﻿   Table of Contents
Title Page
Introduction
Overview
About This Book
AUTISM: EPIDEMIOLOGY AND BASIC SCIENCE
The Increase in Autism Diagnoses. Two Hypotheses. Steven Novella
The Alleged Autism Epidemic. Steven Novella
The CDC is lying to you about vaccines and autism | D Gorski
Autism Prevalence Higher than Thought. Steven Novella. 
Autism Prevalence Unchanged in 20 Years | D Gorski
Autism prevalence: Now estimated to be one in 88, and the antivaccine movement goes wild | D Gorski
Autism prevalence: Now estimated to be one in 68, and the antivaccine movement goes wild | D Gorski
Autism prevalence increases to 1 in 59, and antivaxers lose it…yet again | D Gorski
Latest Autism Data | S Novella
The Early Course of Autism. Steven Novella.
Social Factors in Autism Diagnosis. Steven Novella
Early Intervention for Autism. Steven Novella
A new study reinforces the conclusion that autism is primarily genetic | D Gorski
The genetics of autism. David Gorski.
Fetal Signs of Autism | S Novella
Autism and Prenatal Vitamins. Harriet Hall.
Antidepressants and Autism | S Novella
Epidural Labor Analgesia Not Linked to Autism Says New and Improved Study | C Jones
The Hannah Poling case and the rebranding of autism by antivaccinationists as a mitochondrial disorder. David Gorski
Freeways, autism, and correlation versus causation. David Gorski.
Rainman – Link Between Precipitation and Autism. Steven Novella
Monkey Business in autism research. David Gorski
Peruvian Hamsters and Autism: Cui Bono? Harriet Hall 
“New school” antivax goes old school as Byram Bridle asks if COVID-19 vaccines will drive an “epidemic” of autism | D. Gorski
New Study Finds No Link Between Autism and Acetaminophen Use During Pregnancy | C Jones
Lithium in Tap Water Probably Doesn’t Cause Autism | C Jones
Processed Foods and Autism | S Novella
Glyphosate – The New Bogeyman | S Novella
Well Dr. Stephanie Seneff, 2025 is Over. Did Glyphosate Turn Half of All Children Autistic? | J Howard
Autism Revisited | H Hall
Neurotribes: A Better Understanding of Autism | H Hall
Videos Said to be “Proof” that Nonverbal Autistics Can Communicate by Spelling | H Hall
Does a Common Treatment for Childhood Constipation Cause Autism? | C Jones
Autism and Induced Labor | S Novella
Tylenol and Autism | S Novella
That Trump, RFK, Oz Presser | S Novella
Blaming breast cancer on autism | D Gorski
PETA Embraces Autism Pseudoscience | S Novella
The murder of autistic teen Alex Spourdalakis by his mother and caregiver: What happened? | D Gorski
AUTISM AND VACCINES
David Geier Hired to Study Vaccines and Autism | S Novella
A Checkered History in Vaccine Court: Mark Geier at the VICP 1988-2003 | K Seidel
Science Based Satire: A Sneak Preview Of RFK Jr.’s Vaccine-Autism Study | J Howard
Vaccines Still Not Linked to Autism | S Novella
Vaccines Still Don’t Cause Autism | S Novella
MMR and Autism Rises from the Dead | S Novella
Still No Association Between MMR and Autism | S Novella
Autism Onset and the Vaccine Schedule – Revisited. Steven Novella
Preventing autism? Not so fast, Dr. Mumper… | D Gorski
Antivaccine activists fund a study to show vaccines cause autism. It backfires spectacularly. | D Gorski
The perils and pitfalls of doing a “vaccinated versus unvaccinated” study. David Gorski.
Anti-vaccine warriors vs. research ethics. David Gorski.
The incredible shrinking vaccine-autism hypothesis shrinks some more. David Gorski 
14 Studies Later* Mark Crislip
More On Fourteen Studies. Steven Novella
Welcome back, my friends, to the show that never ends, part II: Generation Rescue, the anti-vaccine propaganda machine, and “Fourteen Studies”. David Gorski
The worst of times for antivaccine believers: Yet another study fails to show any link between the MMR vaccine and autism. David Gorski
Yet another nail in the coffin of the myth that the MMR vaccine causes autism.David Gorski
Terrible Anti-Vaccine Study, Terrible Reporting. Steven Novella.
Autism and Vaccines: Responding to Poling and Kirby. Steven Novella
J.B. Handley and the anti-vaccine movement: Gloating over the decline in confidence in vaccines among parents. David Gorski
The curious case of Poul Thorsen, fraud and embezzlement, and the Danish vaccine-autism studies. David Gorski.
Autism prevalence increases to 1 in 38, and antivaxxers blame vaccines without using the word “vaccine” | D Gorski
Torturing mice, data, and figures in the name of antivaccine pseudoscience | D Gorski
Antivaxxer Steve Kirsch unknowingly identifies the fatal flaw of an antivax “report” from the McCullough Foundation | S Novella
CDC WHISTLEBLOWER
Did a high ranking whistleblower really reveal that the CDC covered up proof that vaccines cause autism in African-American boys? | D Gorski
The “CDC whistleblower saga”: Updates, backlash, and (I hope) a wrap-up | D Gorski
Vaccine Whistleblower: An antivaccine “exposé” full of sound and fury, signifying nothing | D Gorski
Vaccine Whistleblower: BS Hooker and William Thompson try to talk about epidemiology | R Najera
Review of Vaccine Whistleblower: A Legal Perspective | D Reiss
Dr. Edward Livingston On Vaccines & Autism: “Because of Public Skepticism, it is Not Settled Science” | J Howard
ANDREW WAKEFIELD
The Lancet retracts Andrew Wakefield’s article. Steven Novella.
The fall of Andrew Wakefield. David Gorski.
The General Medical Council to Andrew Wakefield: “The panel is satisfied that your conduct was irresponsible and dishonest” David Gorski.
Antivaccine hero Andrew Wakefield: Scientific fraud? David Gorski
“Piltdown medicine” and Andrew Wakefield’s MMR vaccine fraud. David Gorski.
Andrew Wakefield after 25 years: Paving the way for COVID-19 quacks and antivaxxers | D Gorski
The Pathological Optimist: More hagiography than documentary about Andrew Wakefield | D Gorski
VAXXED and the Tribeca Film Festival: How Robert De Niro learned the hard way about Andrew Wakefield and the antivaccine movement | D Gorski
Reviewing Andrew Wakefield’s VAXXED: Antivaccine propaganda at its most pernicious | D Gorski
Andrew Wakefield, the MMR, and a “mother warrior’s” fabricated vaccine injury story | D Gorski
Brian Hooker and Andrew Wakefield accuse the CDC of scientific fraud. Irony meters everywhere explode. | D Gorski
The Woo Boat, or: How far Andrew Wakefield has fallen | D Gorski
WWTI Doctors, Trump Based Medicine, and the “Vindication” of Andrew Wakefield | J Howard
AUTISM AND MERCURY
Mercury in vaccines as a cause of autism and autism spectrum disorders (ASDs): A failed hypothesis. David Gorski
Mercury emissions from coal-burning power plants and autism. Is there a correlation? David Gorski
The final nail in the mercury-autism hypothesis? David Gorski
Prenatal Mercury and Autism | Science-Based Medicine
Antivaccine happenings ten years time ago | D Gorski
Mercury Must Be Bad – If Not in Vaccines, In Teeth. Harriet Hall
AUTISM TREATMENTS
Should We Study Chelation for Autism? Steven Novella
Chelation Therapy for Autism is Quackery | S Novella
Chemical castration of autistic children leads to the downfall of Dr. Mark Geier. David Gorski
Chemical castration for autism: After three years, the mainstream media finally notices. David Gorski.
David Geier, Mail Order Pharmacist | K Seidel
Big Trouble in Little Pharma | K Seidel
The Long Med Con: The Self-Styled Expertise and Expansive Invoices of Mark & David Geier |K Seidel
Autism One: The yearly antivaccine autism “biomed” quackfest begins. David Gorski.
Naturopathy vs. Science: Autism | S Gavura
CEASE therapy for autism: Homeopathic quackery and “self regulation” by naturopathic boards | D Gorski
The antivaccine movement and “autism biomed” versus “outgrowing” autism | D Gorski
Blame and magical thinking: The consequences of the autism “biomed” movement | D Gorski
The autism “biomed” movement: Uncontrolled and unethical experimentation on autistic children. David Gorski.
Is there no end to unscientific treatments for autism? Peter Lipson
The North Carolina Board of Medical Examiners, Dr. Rashid Buttar, and protecting the public from practitioners of non-science-based medicine. David Gorski
Ivermectin is now fast becoming the new MMS | D Gorski
Dubious stem cell trials for autism and the darker side of quackademic medicine | D Gorski
CEASE therapy for autism: Homeopathic quackery and “self regulation” by naturopathic boards | D Gorski
“Dr. Amy” Yasko’s Autism Protocol: Unproven, Complicated and Expensive | J Bellamy
Bleaching away what ails you | D Gorski
Premature Claims for Neurotrophic Factors | S Novella
Luc Montagnier and the Nobel Disease | D Gorski
For-profit stem cell clinics, universities, and “pay-to-play” clinical trials for autism | D Gorski
Facilitated Communication Rears Its Ugly Head Again | S Novella
NYT Article on Rapid Prompting Method | S Novella
The Telepathy Tapes – More FC Pseudoscience | S Novella
Preying on the Vulnerable: Electrodiagnostics, Bach Flower Remedies, and Sound Therapy for Autism, ADHD, and Learning Problems | H Hall
GcMAF and the life and death of an autism quack | D Gorski
Medical marijuana as the new herbalism, part 4: Cannabis for autism | D Gorski
A journey to alternative and integrative medicine apostasy | D Gorski
Stem Cell Therapy for Autism | S Novella
AUTISM, VACCINES & THE MEDIA
The Media and Vaccines. Steven Novella 
When “investigative reporting” becomes anti-vaccine propaganda. David Gorski
Steven Higgs: Another antivaccine reporter like Dan Olmsted in the making? David Gorski.
Mothering magazine: Peddling dangerous health misinformation to new mothers. David Gorski.
Anti-vaccine propaganda from Sharyl Attkisson of CBS News . David Gorski 
Jenny McCarthy, Jim Carrey, and “Green Our Vaccines”: Anti-vaccine, not “pro-safe vaccine” David Gorski
In Jenny McCarthy’s own words. David Gorski
Welcome back, my friends, to the show that never ends: The Jenny and Jim antivaccine propaganda tour has begun. David Gorski
The anti-vaccine movement strikes back against Dr. Paul Offit. David Gorski.
Autism’s false prophets revealed. David Gorski 
The effective wordsmithing of Amy Wallace. David J Kroll
J.B. Handley versus vaccine science. Again. Not surprisingly, J.B. loses. | D Gorski
J.B. Handley of the anti-vaccine group Generation Rescue: Misogynistic attacks on journalists who champion science. David Gorski.
J.B. Handley, Generation Rescue, and attacks on critics. David Gorski
2009: Shaping up to be a really bad year for antivaccinationists. David Gorski
Anti-vaccine warriors vs. research ethics. David Gorski
Trust in science and vaccines continues to decline. Why? | D. Gorski
Sharyl Attkisson and CBS News: An epic fail in reporting on the murder of autistic teen Alex Spourdalakis | D Gorski
Bad Documentary Review: Family Shots | B MacBeth
Move over, Christopher Shaw, there’s a new antivaccine scientist in town | G Gorski
Anti-anti-vax: Getting to the gist | S Gavura
Science-Based Medicine Reviews: Vaccines, and Autism
A Critical Guide for the Health Practitioner and Consumer 
2025 Edition

Executive Editor Steven Novella MD
Managing Editor David Gorski MD PhD
Series Editor Mark Crislip MD

   Introduction 
Steven Novella
The world of health care is becoming an increasingly complex and challenging place. The internet is changing the way we generate and access information, and health information is one of the most popular uses of the internet. It represents an unprecedented democratization of information and opinion. 
While there are many advantages and benefits to such information access, there are also many challenges to health professionals, regulators, academics, and consumers. There is a proliferation of health related products and services, with many provocative health claims. Regulations are generally not keeping up, and often have been watered down, in the face of this onslaught of claims and products. 
The consumer is left with an overwhelming array of health claims, many of which challenge and even directly oppose the traditional experts and institutions. 
The mission of Science-Based Medicine (SBM) is to be a source of reliable information and analysis to help navigate the wild west of health information on the internet and elsewhere. The authors who contribute to this series of e-books are all physicians and other health care professionals who have a great deal of experience educating the public about complex medical issues. We especially take on controversial issues and try to expose pseudoscience and fraud wherever possible.
The Philosophy of Science-Based Medicine
The philosophy of SBM, at its core, is simple: Safe and effective health care is critical to everyone’s quality of life; so much so that it is generally considered a basic human right. Therefore, health care products and services that work and are safe are better than those that do not work or are unsafe. 
The best method for determining which interventions and health products are safe and effective is, without question, good science. Therefore it is in everyone’s best interest for health care to be systematically evaluated by the best science available.
Too often the nature of science itself is misunderstood or misrepresented to the public. Science is not an arcane and privileged discipline. By its very nature it is meant to be transparent and public. Science is nothing more than a systematic and careful use of evidence and logic to evaluate factual claims. And good science possesses certain virtues that are not unique to science but generic to all intellectual endeavors: fairly accounting for all available evidence, using valid and internally consistent logic, using unambiguous concepts and language, proper use of statistics, being quantitatively precise and accurate, and above all being honest.
And yet there are numerous and powerful influences in society that strongly appose the scientific basis of medicine. Driven by some combination of ideology or the desire for profit they wish to eliminate standards of science in health care, or (often under the guise of “health care freedom”) create a double standard in which unscientific methods and products can thrive unchecked. Others simply lack the training or knowledge to achieve minimal standards of quality for scientific medicine. And even the best traditions of scientific medicine can benefit from more critical analysis.
Recognition of the need for careful scientific analysis in medicine partly stems from a recognition that it is very difficult (almost impossible) to reliably assess treatments anecdotally. Human perception, memory, and cognition are prone to a host of flaws, weaknesses, and biases that will tend to mislead us, especially towards conclusions that we wish to be true. Placebo effects, confirmation bias, and simple statistics can make any intervention seem effective, even when they are worthless or harmful. 
Science-Based Medicine vs Evidence-Based Medicine
Within the practice of medicine there is already a recognition of the need to raise the standards of evidence and the availability of the best evidence to the practitioner and the consumer – formalized in the movement known as evidence-based medicine (EBM). 
EBM is a vital and positive influence on the practice of medicine, but it has its limitations. EBM tends to focus on clinical trial results to the exclusion of scientific plausibility. The focus on trial results (which, in the EBM lexicon, is what is meant by “evidence”) has its utility, but fails to properly deal with medical modalities that are highly implausible, or seem to defy well-established findings in science.
All of science describes the same reality, and therefore it must (if it is functioning properly) all be mutually compatible. Collectively, science builds one cumulative model of the natural world. This means we can make rational judgments about what is likely to be true based upon what is already well established. This does not necessarily equate to rejecting new ideas out-of-hand, but rather to adjusting the threshold of evidence required to establish a new claim based upon the prior scientific plausibility of the new claim. Failure to do so leads to conclusions and recommendations that are not reliable, and therefore medical practices that are probably not safe and effective.
The SBM Series
This is why the authors of this series strongly advocate for science based medicine – the use of the best scientific evidence available, in the light of our cumulative scientific knowledge from all relevant disciplines, in evaluating health claims, practices, and products. 
Some of the articles here will analyze individual studies, and explore the strengths and weaknesses of their methods, separating what the study really tells us from how it may be represented in the media. Other articles will summarize what many studies tell us about a specific medical question. 
We will also explore health information on the internet, separating out which information is reliable from that which is misleading, erroneous, or possibly even fraudulent. Likewise we will critique mainstream media coverage of health topics, giving the reader specific tools for to critically analyze health information for themselves.
Other articles will explore topics related to health regulation and academia. Regulations have struggled to keep up with the rapidly changing health care market place, with critical gaps that leave the health care consumer responsible for their own protection. Academic institutions themselves, long the defenders of high standards of scholarship in all fields, including medicine, have been infiltrated by promoters of pseudoscientific belief systems. The result is that there is no longer any single reliable guarantee of scientific integrity. 
The SBM series of e-books is organized by topic, such as acupuncture, chiropractic, homeopathy, and many others. The books are collections of essays, not intended to be a systematic reference, but rather to explore the various scientific issues related to each topic. The goal is to give the reader critical thinking skills and a deeper understanding of, not just the current findings of science, but the process of science, specifically how it relates to health care and the topic of each book. 
Science-based medicine can serve as your pocket guide through the wilderness of health information.

   Overview: Vaccines
Vaccines are generally considered to be the most successful public health intervention ever devised. And yet there have been opponents of vaccines ever since there have been vaccines. So-called antivaccinationists have claimed over the years that vaccines do not work, despite the overwhelming evidence that they do. They often spread misinformation about vaccine, such as the notion that vaccines weaken the immune system, when in fact they work by strengthening the immune response against the target infection.
In recent years the antivaccine movement has focused on the claim that vaccines are linked to neurological injury, and specifically to the neurological disorder autism, now referred to as autism spectrum disorder (ASD). However the scientific evidence overwhelmingly shows no correlation between vaccines in general, the MMR vaccine specifically, or thimerosal (a mercury-based preservative) in vaccines with ASD or other neurodevelopmental disorders.
The primary argument made for an association between thimerosal and ASD is that the rate of diagnosis of ASD has been steadily increasing since the early 1990s. At that time also the routine vaccine schedule was increasing, resulting in an increasing total dose of thimerosal. The antivaccinationists then assume causation from correlation to blame rising ASD rates on thimerosal.
However, by 2002 thimerosal was completely removed from the routine vaccine schedule, and now remains only in some flu vaccines. The total dose of thimerosal exposure is far below 1990 levels, before ASD diagnoses began to rise. Antivaccinationists predicted that ASD rates would fall dramatically in the years following the removal of thimerosal from most vaccines – but rates have continued to rise without even the slightest change in the rate of increase. This is a powerful refutation of the thimerosal-autism hypothesis, and has been replicated in other countries.
Further, the best epidemiological evidence suggests that the rise in the diagnosis rate of ASD is an artifact of broadening the definition of autism, diagnostic substitution, and increased surveillance. Therefore there isn’t really an autism “epidemic” just a change in the definition and efforts to make the diagnosis.
Undaunted, the antivaccinationists have changed their claims to blame any number of “toxins” in vaccines. However, their claims have no scientific validity.


As of 2025, there are over 5000 essays on the Science Based Medicine website. I do no know about you, but I find it difficult to find any post I wrote, much less one written by another contributor. 
So I have updated the books and include almost all the articles through 2025. The volumes are

CAM Concepts
Chiropractic
COVID 
Critical Thinking
Diet and Nutrition
Ethics and CAM
Herbs, Supplements, and Diet
Homeopathy
Infections and Immunity
Law and CAM
Media and Internet
Medicine, Public Health, Dentistry and Pediatrics
Miscellaneous CAM
Naturopathy
Neurology and Psychiatry
Placebo
Quackademic Medicine
Regulation. FDA and FTC
SBM or EBM
Stem Cells, Genetics, AI and Gender
Supplements, Vitamins and Herbs
Vaccine & Anivax
Vaccines and Autism
Vaccines and Preventable Infections

The articles are roughly organized by publication date and topic. Many articles will be in multiple volumes as an essay of, for example, chiropractic and law will be found in both the chiropractic volume and the law volume.
You may find the organization a bit odd. I do. But 5000 plus articles are difficult to organize and I have more to do in my retirement than work of these volumes.
Still, if you find I have missed a nentry or some glaring error, drop me a note and I will fix it for the next edition.

About the authors
Steven P. Novella, MD – Founder and Executive Editor Science Based Medicine.
Founder and currently Executive Editor of Science-Based Medicine Steven Novella, MD.
David H. Gorski, MD, PhD – Managing Editor. Science Based Medicine.
Mark A. Crislip, MD. Editor, Science Based Medicine Guides. 
He did he editing of all the volumes so is to blame for any mistakes.
As to all the other contributors, if you are interested click on the ‘Link’ at top of each essay to go the SBM site, where further information about each author can be found.
A Note On References

The chapters in this book were originally blog entries at ScienceBasedMedicine.org.
Blog and web pages lend themselves to hyperlinks to sources and references that are tedious to translate into footnotes for this ebook.
Under the title of each essay is a hyperlink, cleverly titled ‘Link’, to the original blog entry with all the hyperlinks and references, as well as the comments to the blogs, which often have interesting and thoughtful insights by our readers, as well as some curious comments by the not so thoughtful.
Graphs, tables and links to videos are not in included these essays due to issues of copyright and permission. However, thanks to the ‘Link’, the graphics are a click away.
Thanks for reading the site.
Mark Crislip 


   Autism: Epidemiology and Basic Science

   The Increase in Autism Diagnoses. Two Hypotheses
Steven Novella
Link
A new study sheds more light on the question of what is causing the recent increase in the rate of diagnosis of autism. Professor Dorothy Bishop from the University of Oxford studied adults who were diagnosed in 1980 with a developmental language disorder. She asked the question – if these people were subjected to current diagnostic criteria for autism, how many of them would be diagnosed today as having autism? She found that 25% of them would. (Bishop 2008)
is epidemiological question has been at the center of a controversy over whether or not there is a link between vaccines (or the mercury-based preservative, thimerosal, that was previously in routine childhood vaccines) and autism. The primary evidence for this claim put forward by proponents of a link is that the number of diagnoses of autism increased dramatically at the same time that the number of vaccines routinely given to children was increasing in the 1990′s. They are calling this rise in autism an “epidemic” and argue that such an increase requires an environmental factor, which they believe is linked to vaccines.
That the number of new autism diagnoses is dramatically increasing is generally accepted and not a point of debate. The historical rate of autism is about 4 per 10,000 and the more recent estimates are in the range of 15-20 per 10,000 (30-60 per 10,000 for all pervasive developmental disorders of which autism is one type). (Rutter 2005) The controversy is about what is causing this rise in diagnoses. There are two basic hypotheses: 1) That the true incidence of autism is rising due to an environmental cause, 2) That the rise in incidence is mostly or completely an artifact of increased surveillance and broadening of the definition of autism. These two hypotheses make specific predictions, and there is much evidence to bring to bear on their predictions – this recent study only being the latest.
The confusion about the epidemiology of autism is one common to scientific medicine. Whenever historical comparisons are made it is possible that changing definitions and practices over time will distort those comparisons. This is why medical scientists are often reluctant to change nomenclature (disease names) and definitions – doing so immediately renders the literature obsolete. All subsequent literature must now have a footnote. But the progress of our understanding of biology and disease makes such changes unavoidable.
In the 1990′s the diagnosis of autism was changed to autism spectrum disorder (ASD) – the new name reflecting the changing concept of autism to include a broader spectrum of symptoms, including much more subtle manifestations. In particular a diagnostic entity known as Aspergers syndrome, which is essentially a subtle manifestation of autism features, was classified as part of ASD. Any time you broaden a category the number of individuals that fit into that category is likely to increase.
Autism researcher Eric Fombonne found that:
Recent epidemiological surveys of autistic disorder and other PDDs have heightened awareness of and concern about the prevalence of these disorders; however, differences in survey methodology, particularly changes in case definition and case identification over time, have made comparisons between surveys difficult to perform and interpret. (Fombonne 2005)
In addition to the broadening of the diagnosis, the social and medical network supporting ASD dramatically increased. There has been increased efforts at surveillance – scouring the community for hidden cases of autism. Further, parents have become much more accepting of the diagnosis, which may partly be due to the fact that is some states the label with facilitate access to special services. And clinicians have become more knowledgeable of ASD so are better able to make the diagnosis, even in subtle cases.
Rutter, in order to test this latter hypothesis that increased diagnostic rates were due largely to changes in diagnosis and surveillance, reviewed literature that contained sufficient information to assess true historical rates of autism. He found that applying modern criteria to these historical records yields similar rates of diagnoses: 30-60 per 10,000. Taylor did a similar review and found the following:
The recorded prevalence of autism has increased considerably in recent years. This reflects greater recognition, with changes in diagnostic practice associated with more trained diagnosticians; broadening of diagnostic criteria to include a spectrum of disorder; a greater willingness by parents and educationalists to accept the label (in part because of entitlement to services); and better recording systems, among other factors. (Taylor 2006)
Another prediction that flows from the second hypothesis is that if we compare apples to apples – meaning if we look at the same community and apply the same diagnostic methods that were used in the past as documented in a published study, then the incidence should be the same. In other words – if we control for any changes in the diagnostic criteria and surveillance methods the incidence of autism should be stable over time. Chakrabarti and Fombonne did exactly that, comparing the incidence of autism in 2002 (looking at a cohort of children born between 1996-1998) to the same population using the same methods as a previous study looking at the cohort of children born between 1992-1995. They found:
The rate in this study is comparable to that in previous birth cohorts from the same area and surveyed with the same methods, suggesting a stable incidence. (Chakrabarti 2005)
If the broadened diagnosis hypothesis is true than it must also be true that as other diagnoses shifted over to autism they would decrease as autism numbers increased. This is exactly what Jick et al found when they reviewed a cohort of boys with and without autism. What was previously diagnosed as language disorder is now being diagnosed as autism, with a corresponding decrease in non-specific language disorders. Shattuck found the exact same effect, so called “diagnostic substitution,” when he studied the prevalence of disabilities among children in US special education from 1984 to 2003. He found that in locations where the prevalence of autism had increased there was a corresponding decrease in the prevalence of other disabilities. (Shattuck 2006)
This brings us to the current study by Bishop et al. They looked at adults who were diagnosed as children with a developmental language disorder. Applying current diagnostic criteria they found that a quarter of them (12) would have been diagnosed today with ASD. This also fits the hypothesis that diagnoses have been shifting over to autism from other developmental disorders over the past two decades. The authors, however, caution that the number of subjects in their study was small and therefore it is difficult to extrapolate from this to the general population.
It should also be noted that all of this research, while supporting the hypothesis that the rise in autism diagnoses is not due to a true increase in the incidence but rather is due to a broadening of the definition and increased surveillance, does not rule out a small genuine increase in the true incidence. A small real increase can be hiding in the data. There is no evidence upon which we can conclude, however, that true autism rates are increasing.
Of course the implications of this are profound. If there is no autism epidemic, if there is a “stable incidence” of autism over recent decades, then this alone is powerful evidence against the vaccine hypothesis – and in fact removes the primary piece of evidence for a vaccine-autism connection. Just as a true increase in incidence would have called out for an environmental factor causing autism, the lack of any increase argues strongly against any environment factor – especially when this is combined with the copious evidence for multiple genetic factors as the ultimate cause(s) of ASD.
References:
Bishop DV, Whitehouse AJ, Watt HJ, Line EA. Autism and diagnostic substitution: evidence from a study of adults with a history of developmental language disorder. Dev Med Child Neurol. 2008 Mar 31
Chakrabarti S, Fombonne E. Pervasive developmental disorders in preschool children: confirmation of high prevalence. Am J Psychiatry. 2005 Jun;162(6):1133-41.
Fombonne E. Epidemiology of autistic disorder and other pervasive developmental disorders. J Clin Psychiatry. 2005;66 Suppl 10:3-8.Click here to read
Jick H, Kaye JA. Epidemiology and possible causes of autism. Pharmacotherapy. 2003 Dec;23(12):1524-30.
Rutter M. Incidence of autism spectrum disorders: changes over time and their meaning. Acta Paediatr. 2005 Jan;94(1):2-15.Click here to read
Paul T. Shattuck. The Contribution of Diagnostic Substitution to the Growing Administrative Prevalence of Autism in US Special Education. PEDIATRICS Vol. 117 No. 4 April 2006, pp. 1028-1037
Taylor B. Vaccines and the changing epidemiology of autism. Child Care Health Dev. 2006 Sep;32(5):511-9.Click here to read

   The Alleged Autism Epidemic
Steven Novella
Link
It is without controversy that the number of autism diagnoses being made is on the rise. In 1991 there were about 6 cases per 10,000 births, and in 2001 there were about 42. This number continues to rise at about the same rate.
The cause of this rise, however, is very controversial. There are basically two schools of thought: 1 – that true autism rates are on the rise, and 2 – that the measured rise is an artifact of increased surveillance and a broadening of the definition. I wrote previously about this very controversy, in which I concluded that the expanded diagnosis hypothesis is much better supported by the evidence.
Now, a new study published last week in the journal Epidemiology is being presented by proponents of the epidemic hypothesis as support for their view. A closer look, however, reveals that this study does not support the epidemic hypothesis and adds little to the overall literature on this question.
Background
Prior studies generally support the contention that autism rates are rising due to changes in diagnosis and surveillance. (see my list of references below) For example, Taylor, after reviewing the evidence, wrote in 2006:
The recorded prevalence of autism has increased considerably in recent years. This reflects greater recognition, with changes in diagnostic practice associated with more trained diagnosticians; broadening of diagnostic criteria to include a spectrum of disorder; a greater willingness by parents and educationalists to accept the label (in part because of entitlement to services); and better recording systems, among other factors. (Taylor 2006)
Also, in an excellent review of this question, Gernbacher, Dawson, and Goldsmith pointed out that the DSM-III, the diagnostic manual for mental disorders published in 1980, required six specific criteria for the diagnosis of autism, while the 1994 DSM-IV had 16 less-specific criteria, out of which any 8 would qualify for the diagnosis. They further pointed to the increased practice of giving autism as an additional diagnosis to individuals who were also diagnosed with mental retardation or Down’s syndrome, for example.
In that same article the authors critically analyze a study looking at the same data as the current study, the MIND Institute of California. They conclude:
In this article we have detailed three reasons why some laypersons mistakenly believe that there is an autism epidemic. They are unaware of the purposeful broadening of diagnostic criteria, coupled with deliberately greater public awareness; they accept the unwarranted conclusions of the M.I.N.D. Institute study; and they fail to realize that autism was not even an IDEA reporting category until the early 1990s and incremental increases will most likely continue until the schools are identifying and serving the number of children identified in epidemiological studies.
They are referring to the fact that careful epidemiological studies indicate that the true incidence of autism is higher than what is being reported by service centers in the various states, and there is great disparity among the states. The numbers of diagnoses made by these centers is approaching the probable true number, following increased surveillance, changes in reporting methods, and a significant broadening of the diagnosis. There is therefore no reason to conclude that the true number of autism cases is increasing.
This is a fascinating epidemiological question – and one with huge implications. If autism rates are truly static, that would be compatible with the majority opinion that autism is dominantly a genetic disorder. If there is a true dramatic rise in the incidence of autism, then that strongly suggests an environmental cause or trigger.
As an aside, we need to avoid the false dichotomy of genetic vs environmental. Even if autism is dominantly genetic, as the evidence suggests, the effects of gene products ultimately interact with the environment. Complex genetic disorders, such as a neurodevelopmental disorder, are going to have environmental influences.
A “trigger”, on the other hand, means that the genes just set the stage, but the disorder does not manifest unless the environment pulls the trigger. This could be an infection, toxin, coexisting disease, or (for neurodevelopmental disorders) the social and cultural environment.
For further background on this discussion I should also mention that at present the majority opinion is that the epidemiological evidence does not demonstrate a true rise in autism rates, but a small true rise could be hiding in the data and has not been ruled out.
I take pains to make these points because critics of the mainstream opinion often attack oversimplified straw men, while scientists working on this question tend to have and express appropriately nuanced opinions.
The UC Davis Study
This new epidemiological study, which must be put into the context of all the other studies on this question, looked at the California database of autistic children. They wanted to specifically test the “increased surveillance and diagnostic range” hypothesis, so they looked at autism rates by age. They found that younger age at diagnosis only accounts for a 12% increase in the diagnostic rates. Meanwhile, autism diagnosis rates have increased by 500-600% since 1991.
They then controlled for two further specific variables. First they eliminated all children who were not born in California. This was meant to eliminate children who were brought into California in order to receive services. They also looked at the severity of the symptoms and concluded that the “inclusion of milder cases” resulted in a 56% increase in diagnoses. So in total they could explain only about a 68% increase in autism diagnosis, which is about 10% of the total increase.
They conclude:
Autism incidence in California shows no sign yet of plateauing. Younger ages at diagnosis, differential migration, changes in diagnostic criteria, and inclusion of milder cases do not fully explain the observed increases. Other artifacts have yet to be quantified, and as a result, the extent to which the continued rise represents a true increase in the occurrence of autism remains unclear.
And yet in the press release for this study lead author Irva Hertz-Picciotto is quoted as saying:
“It’s time to start looking for the environmental culprits responsible for the remarkable increase in the rate of autism in California,”
The disconnect between the appropriately conservative conclusion in her paper and her statements to the media is interesting. This probably reflects the fact that peer-reviewed papers have to pass tight scrutiny, and so she could not get away with over-interpreting her results. But to the media she let her true biases be known.
The key to putting this study into context is the phrase “other artifacts”. This study did not control for all possible artifacts resulting in higher diagnosis rates. Specifically, it did not address surveillance, which is likely the dominant factor. It also did not control for shifting diagnosis, diagnostic substitution, and dual-diagnosis. In other words, 20 years ago a child may have been diagnosed with a non-specific speech disorder, and today they would be diagnosed with autism. This specific form of diagnostic substitution was found by Bishop in 2008.
Another factor is that physicians, teachers, and parents have increased awareness not only of the symptoms but of the autistic label. How many parents who notice that their child is socially withdrawn are going to seek out services or medical attention?
This study did nothing to assess these potentially huge factors. So what this study really did was account for 10% of the increase in autism diagnosis. But it did not show anything about the other 90%, nor rule out the leading contenders for diagnostic artifact.
The Vaccine Connection
Of course, the anti-vaccine crowd can be counted on to grab hold of this study, cherry pick it from the other studies whose conclusions they don’t like, and overinterpret the results. David Kirby has already done so over at the Huffington Post. He wrote a piece last week titled: UC DAVIS STUDY: “Autism is Environmental” (Can We Move On Now?) He wants to declare premature victory and “move on,” even when, officially, the study authors had to admit that the question is “unclear.”
He writes:
Autism is predominantly an environmentally acquired disease, the study seems to conclude. Its meteoric rise, at least in California, cannot possibly be attributed to that shopworn mantra we still hear everyday, incredibly, from far too many public health officials: It’s due to better diagnosing and counting.
Compare that to the actual conclusions of the study. I wonder if Kirby read past the press release.
And, of course, Kirby wants to bring this all back to vaccines.
(It is important to keep in mind that almost every child born in 2000 would have received many vaccines that contained the mercury preservative thimerosal, which was not completely phased out of most – but not all – childhood vaccines until at least 2003.)
Even if it were ultimately found that autism rates are truly rising, and that this rise was due to an environment factors – vaccines would still be a very poor candidate. There is already sufficient independent evidence against a significant link between vaccines and autism. If vaccines were causing a 5-6 fold increase in autism that would be a huge signal the studies to date would have picked up.
Also, Kirby fails to mention that the same database used in this latest study is the one that showed that after thimerosal was removed from the childhood vaccine schedule autism rates continued to rise without any change – pretty much destroying the thimerosal hypothesis he clings to.
As usual the most mindless aspect of Kirby’s commentary is his casual and self-serving assumption of moral and intellectual superiority, even over dedicated medical researchers. He writes:
Now, it’s always been easier and more reassuring to tell ourselves that autism was almost purely genetic, that it was always with us at the rate of 1 in 90 men (1 in 60 in New Jersey) and that, gee, weren’t doctors doing a great job these days of recognizing and diagnosis this disorder.
This pathetic groupthink has helped create hugely lopsided funding priorities in autism, where genetic studies get lavishly funded, while environmental ones are lucky to even pick up the dollar scraps left behind.
It is cheap and easy to portray and hard-won consensus built upon years of research and evidence as “groupthink.” Also, Kirby appears to have insufficient familiarity with the real world or medical research to understand that grants are not earned and careers not made by following the herd. There are many researchers tackling these tough questions from many angles and perspectives. Young researchers hoping to find a niche for themselves are more likely to question dominant beliefs.
In fact, while I disagree with Hertz-Picciotto in her bottom line interpretation of the evidence, I think it is a very healthy thing for researchers with a minority opinion to challenge the majority. This happens all the time. But, of course, the burden is on her to make her case.
Kirby insists that the scientific mainstream disagrees with him, not because maybe they understand the research better, but because they are afraid of the truth. They want to avoid any research that could ultimately point back to vaccines. But this is just conspiracy-mongering self-righteous nonsense. And it is a huge non-sequitur.
The notion that scientists disagree with someone because scientists are generally unimaginative and afraid of the truth is huge red flag. This is the mantra of the crank.
Conclusion
This latest study is interesting, but was too limited in scope to significantly alter the evidence as a whole. I would not be surprised if some small portion of the increase in autism diagnoses were due to environmental factors. But I don’t think current evidence lends much support to this notion either. The current state of evidence strongly suggests that the dominant reason for the increase in numbers is due to changes in diagnostic behavior.
There are many similar epidemiological questions in the world of medicine. I am content to let the chips fall where they may, and will gladly alter my opinion as new evidence comes in. The same does not appear to be true for the Kirby’s of the world. The autism question in particular is mired in a fake controversy promulgated by an ideological anti-vaccine movement that causes no end of mischief.
References:
Hertz-Picciotto, Irva a,b; Delwiche, Lora a. The Rise in Autism and the Role of Age at Diagnosis. Epidemiology. 20(1):84-90, January 2009.
Bishop DV, Whitehouse AJ, Watt HJ, Line EA. Autism and diagnostic substitution: evidence from a study of adults with a history of developmental language disorder. Dev Med Child Neurol. 2008 Mar 31
Chakrabarti S, Fombonne E. Pervasive developmental disorders in preschool children: confirmation of high prevalence. Am J Psychiatry. 2005 Jun;162(6):1133-41.
Fombonne E. Epidemiology of autistic disorder and other pervasive developmental disorders. J Clin Psychiatry. 2005;66 Suppl 10:3-8.Click here to read
Jick H, Kaye JA. Epidemiology and possible causes of autism. Pharmacotherapy. 2003 Dec;23(12):1524-30.
Rutter M. Incidence of autism spectrum disorders: changes over time and their meaning. Acta Paediatr. 2005 Jan;94(1):2-15.Click here to read
Paul T. Shattuck. The Contribution of Diagnostic Substitution to the Growing Administrative Prevalence of Autism in US Special Education. PEDIATRICS Vol. 117 No. 4 April 2006, pp. 1028-1037
Taylor B. Vaccines and the changing epidemiology of autism. Child Care Health Dev. 2006 Sep;32(5):511-9.Click here to read
Morton Ann Gernsbacher, Michelle Dawson, and H. Hill Goldsmith, Three Reasons Not to Believe in
an Autism Epidemic; Current Directions in Psychological Science. 2005 14(2)

The CDC is lying to you about vaccines and autism
The CDC webpage about vaccines and autism now misrepresents the science and lies to the public about vaccines and autism. It’s just part of HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s continuing war on vaccines.
David Gorski on November 24, 2025
Link

The CDC is lying to you about vaccines and autism
The CDC is lying to you about vaccines and autism.
The CDC is lying to you about vaccines and autism.
If it bothers you that I sound, for the moment, like an antivax website c.2008 or an antivax Facebook or Twitter account c. 2015—or an antivax Tik Tok or X influencer just a week ago, just be aware that last Wednesday or Thursday, a mere five days ago, the next shoe dropped when it comes to Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.‘s continuing war on vaccines. That’s because, on November 19, 2025, the CDC updated its webpage about one of the central antivax claims dating back to the 1990s, the false claim that vaccines cause autism, a claim that originated in efforts in the 1990s by barristers to sue vaccine manufacturers on behalf of parents of autistic children that culminated in Andrew Wakefield’s fraudulent 1998 Lancet case series linking the MMR vaccine to autism. Here’s what I mean. Take a look screenshots of the last version of the webpage saved in the Internet Archive’s Wayback Machine before the change (an archive of the page when it was last updated on December 31, 2024 captured on October 11, 2025) and the webpage as it appears today:
CDC on vaccines and autism before November 19, 2025.
CDC on vaccines and autism since November 19, 2025.

Let’s compare. First, here are the CDC’s key points about vaccines and autism before November 19:
    • Studies have shown that there is no link between receiving vaccines and developing autism spectrum disorder (ASD).
    • No links have been found between any vaccine ingredients and ASD.
Both of these are true, and the page goes on to describe why they are true, as well as to look at supporting evidence that neither vaccination nor any vaccine ingredient has been associated with an increased risk of autism in large, well-designed, well-executed epidemiological studies. It is a point that we here at SBM have discussed more times than I can remember going back to the very beginning of this blog in 2008 and that I myself have discussed going back to early 2005 on my not-so-super-secret other blog, in particular how antivaxxers publish bad science and misrepresent the scientific literature to try to cast doubt on that. Indeed, I just wrote such a post about a recent misleading and terrible “report” claiming that a link is plausible a mere two weeks ago. (More on that later, as it is relevant to the CDC’s rewriting of its webpage on vaccines and autism.)
Now, here are the CDC’s misleading key points that lie to you about vaccines and autism:
    • The claim “vaccines do not cause autism” is not an evidence-based claim because studies have not ruled out the possibility that infant vaccines cause autism.
    • Studies supporting a link have been ignored by health authorities.
    • HHS has launched a comprehensive assessment of the causes of autism, including investigations on plausible biologic mechanisms and potential causal links.
You might wonder why the first heading still reads, “Vaccines do not cause autism.” The new webpage explains:
The header “Vaccines do not cause autism” has not been removed due to an agreement with the chair of the U.S. Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions Committee that it would remain on the CDC website.
Yes, as part of the deal that garnered him critical support for his nomination, RFK Jr. promised Sen. Bill Cassidy, the physician-politician and chair of the Senate HELP Committee who betrayed his Hippocratic oath twice, first to send RFK Jr.’s nomination for HHS Secretary to the full Senate and then to vote for his confirmation, that the CDC webpage continue to say that vaccines don’t cause autism. Of course, what has really happened is that RFK Jr. has broken his pledge not to change CDC messaging on vaccines and autism because he put an asterisk next to the statement that vaccines do not cause autism and then added all sorts of antivax propaganda after it. Truly, when I consider Sen. Cassidy’s cowardly and perfidious betrayal and his ongoing attempts to “control” RFK Jr., I’m reminded of this cartoon:
Poor Sen. Bill “Charlie Brown” Cassidy! He took Robert “Lucy” Kennedy Jr.’s reassurances that he wouldn’t turn the CDC into an antivax propaganda agency at face value. What a trusting fool!
Let’s take these points on one at a time. Why start with the last point? Because it’s one part of the strategy by which RFK Jr. has been preparing the way to force the CDC to pivot to messaging that, at the very least, will ignore three decades worth of scientific evidence failing to find a hint of a whiff of a correlation between infant and childhood vaccination and autism risk in favor of bad science by ideologically motivated antivaxxers claiming a link to falsely portray a link as at least plausible or, at worst, proclaim that the aforementioned bad science by ideologically motivated antivaxxers claiming a link demonstrates that there is a link. Here are key components the strategy designed to cast doubt on vaccines:
    • Falsely argue that the science showing no link between vaccines and autism is uncertain and that therefore a link is still scientifically plausible.
    • Bolster the deceptive claim that a link between vaccines and autism is plausible through wild speculation about biological mechanisms.
    • Falsely argue that vaccines are inadequately tested clinically and epidemiologically; e.g., through the deceptive claim that vaccines aren’t tested against “saline placebo.”
    • Manufacture evidence through bad science that vaccines are actually associated with autism.
I’ll start with the last CDC talking point (“HHS has launched a comprehensive assessment of the causes of autism”), because I’ve written about it before and it’s fairly quick. Then I’ll discuss the other two points, how antivaxxers are now gloating and proclaiming victory, and where this all fits in when it comes to RFK Jr.’s ongoing efforts to eliminate all vaccines. (And, yes, the elimination of vaccines in the US is his endgame, no matter how many times he lies and claims that he doesn’t want to take away people’s vaccines or that he’s all about “personal choice,” “informed consent,” and “health freedom,” and falsely reassures people that they will be able to be vaccinated (and to vaccinate their children) if they desire.
Again, let me emphasize to you: The CDC is lying to you about vaccines and autism, and this change in CDC messaging is part of a strategy to sow doubt and fear about vaccines in order to allow him to succeed in taking away your vaccines.
“HHS has launched a comprehensive assessment of the causes of autism”? More like the same ol’ same ol’ repackaged and made official policy
My first reaction to this statement was that it was typical of the way cranks and quacks misrepresent science. How? Basically, it frames its new “comprehensive assessment” as though it were something new, as though scientists hadn’t been diligently researching the causes and potential treatments for autism for, quite literally, decades and already know that autism is largely genetic. Moreover, antivaxxers like RFK Jr. are so focused on vaccines as The One True Cause of autism that they ignore the simple fact that arguably the single most-studied potential cause of autism has been—surprise!—vaccines. And guess what? Numerous large, well-designed studies from different countries and different designs have failed to find an association between childhood vaccination and an increased risk of autism. Let’s move on, though, to what, exactly, RFK Jr.’s “comprehensive assessment of the causes of autism” is likely to entail and who will be doing the “research.”
Regular readers (and anyone paying attention to RFK Jr.’s “stewardship” of HHS probably remember that in April he launched an effort to find the causes of autism and, remarkably, promised to have results by September. In the meantime, he hired a veritable rogues’ gallery of antivaxxers to work on this question, starting with (as far as we know) David Geier, the son half of the father-son quack duo who blamed the mercury in the thimerosal preservative that used to be used in several childhood vaccines until around 2001 for an autism epidemic and ran a quack clinic and mail order pharmacy that claimed to treat autism with chelation therapy and puberty blockers, with David Geier being prosecuted for practicing medicine without a license. Unsurprisingly, Dr. Mark Geier (recently deceased) was a frequent expert witness for complainants to the Vaccine Court back in the day. Evidence of Mr. Geier’s “skills” at epidemiological research came from his violating the protocol approved by the institutional review board overseeing his proposed use of Vaccine Safety Datalink data to look for links between vaccines and autism in 2003. Now he’s likely to do the same, just as an official employee of the NIH.
Joining Geier was Mark Blaxill, a longtime antivax activist with no medical training who was also hired at the CDC as a senior advisor. Author of The Age of Autism: Mercury, Medicine, and a Man-Made Epidemic with fellow antivaxxer and blogger Dan Olmsted, Blaxill served for a long time on the board of directors of the group of the antivax group SafeMinds and had a penchant for Holocaust analogies referring to vaccination and autism. One of its most famous publications was an article entitled Autism, A Novel Form of Mercury Poisoning, published in 2001—in Medical Hypotheses, naturally. Blaxill was also associated with another antivax group, Generation Rescue, and wrote prolifically for its blog, Age of Autism, a frequent source for my blogging “inspiration” back in the day. There, Blaxill wrote posts like There’s a Funny Thing About Evidence: More Support for Autism-Mercury Link whose misinformation, bad science, and pseudoscience I routinely used to lovingly deconstruct years ago.
That’s not all. Another antivax hire was Dr. Tracy Beth Høeg, who was hired as a top advisor to Dr. Marty Makary, who is currently FDA Commissioner, who had also become famous as a “COVID-19 contrarian” and slipped further and further into COVID-19 vaccine “skepticism” as the pandemic wore on. Working for Dr. Makary is also Dr. Vinay Prasad, an oncologist and COVID-19 “contrarian” who eventually turned to parroting antivax talking points and is now in charge of the FDA committee responsible for approving and regulating vaccines and biologics. In addition, don’t even get me started on what RFK Jr., did with the CDC Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP). There, he fired all the experts on the committee, replaced them with antivaxxers and antivax-adjacent or -sympathetic new members, resulting in a clown car of a spectacle as ACIP incompetently tried to roll back current vaccine recommendations and made an incoherent mess of recommendations for COVID vaccines. Interestingly, this effort has failed to satisfy RFK Jr.’s most vehement supporters, and the most that RFK Jr.’s new effort to prove that vaccines cause autism came up with in September was a highly dubious claim that acetaminophen use during pregnancy is associated with autism. (It’s not.)
So what is HHS going to do under RFK Jr.? According to the newly rebranded antivax CDC webpage:
HHS will evaluate plausible biologic mechanisms between early childhood vaccinations and autism. Mechanisms for further investigation include the impacts of aluminum adjuvants, risks for certain children with mitochondrial disorders, harms of neuroinflammation, and more.
Regular readers will recall that all of these “plausible biological mechanisms” are actually not so plausible. Indeed, a lot of them are based on what I like to call “biobabble” or “immunobabble,” names that I came up with in homage to “technobabble,” a term used to describe a lot of the futuristic science-y sounding dialogue about physics, biology, and other sciences in Star Trek: The Next Generation and later series. (Public health scientist Jess Stier and colleagues amusingly coined a term for the same phenomenon, “antivaccine Mad Libs.”) Basically, antivaxxers love to do the same sort of speculative handwaving about biological mechanisms behind autism that they think they can relate to vaccines, using the sort of language that real scientists immediately recognize as fancy sounding scientific bullshit.
Indeed, this brings me back to the report that I mentioned in the introduction. Known as the McCullough Foundation Report, it was published in late October and widely debunked by many, including myself, for exactly this sort of speculative handwaving based on interpretations of basic science findings that have consistently failed to be demonstrated in clinical and epidemiological studies to be applicable in humans to the neurodevelopmental mechanisms that lead to autism. It’s a longtime antivax technique, and there are a number of “tells” in the paragraph above that let me know that this is what the CDC is doing now, in particular invocation of mitochondrial disorders (shades of Hannah Poling and Andrew Zimmerman in 2008!), adjuvants like aluminum (which do not cause autism), and use of the term “neuroinflammation.” These were “mechanisms” featured prominently in the McCullough Report.
In other words, this research effort being carried out by HHS agencies such as the National Institutes of Health and the CDC is nothing more than using antivax pseudoscientific ideas as the basis to design research programs to manufacture bogus scientific data to support the idea that vaccines cause autism.
“The claim ‘vaccines do not cause autism’ is not an evidence-based claim”? Wrong.
Let’s circle back to first new CDC talking point, namely that the claim “vaccines do not cause autism” is not an evidence-based claim “because studies have not ruled out the possibility that infant vaccines cause autism.” This is a complete misrepresentation or intentional misunderstanding of how evidence-based medicine—and science in general—works. It is not my intention here to relitigate the mountains of scientific evidence this century that have failed to find conclusive—or even convincingly plausible—scientific, epidemiological, or clinical evidence that infant vaccines detectably increase the risk of autism, much less cause autism. I’ve discussed that evidence and antivax attempts to attack it more times than I can remember. There are many good reasons why the statement that vaccines do not cause autism is considered very strong science by the scientific community, sufficiently strong that most scientists studying autism and vaccines consider the issue to have been scientifically settled, at least pending new and compelling evidence suggesting a link, evidence that antivaxxers can never seem to produce. Indeed, a large chunk of posts on this very blog are deconstructions of the sort of bad science that antivaxxers routinely produce to try to “prove” that vaccines cause autism; e.g., this study in 2017.
Instead, let’s address the bogus argument that the claim that “vaccines do not cause autism” is not evidence-based, specifically because “because studies have not ruled out the possibility that infant vaccines cause autism.” It’s an argument that is often weaponized in favor of alternative medicine quackery, such as the scientific conclusion that homeopathy is physically impossible. What I like to say in response to such arguments about homeopathy is that science can never absolutely prove a negative. That’s just not how science works. However, after a certain point, the weight of scientific studies reaches a point where the odds that the negative finding is incorrect becomes so small as to be, for all practical purposes, functionally and statistically indistinguishable from zero.
Such has long been the scientific status of, for example, homeopathy, with the added bonus that the mechanisms proposed by homeopaths for homeopathy to “work” would, if true, require that huge swaths of long-settled physics, chemistry, and biology be not just wrong, but spectacularly wrong. Similarly, the evidence from large studies looking for links between infant vaccination and autism have failed to detect an increased risk of autism attributable to vaccination or to specific ingredients in vaccines, such as thimerosal (which is no longer in childhood vaccines and hasn’t been in vaccines for close to a quarter of a century) or aluminum salts used as adjuvants. I will conceded that biological mechanisms proposed by antivaxxers for vaccines to cause autism are not quite as fantastical as the claimed mechanisms behind homeopathy, but they’re still incredibly implausible. (Does anyone remember “molecular mimicry” and “homologous recombinaltion tiniker“?)
This is where the twin strategies of casting doubt on existing evidence because studies haven’t examined every possible scenario. As Matthiew Facciani put it on Threads:


View on Threads


View on Threads


View on Threads
I mean, seriously: Do dogs cause autism?
This is all, of course, basically a rephrasing of what I’ve long written, but in simpler terms, which is why I quoted it. Again, the weight of evidence that fails to find even a hint of a whiff of an association between infant and child vaccination and increased autism risk is enormous, so enormous that, even though we can never prove that the chances that vaccines cause autism in anyone is truly zero, we can conclude from the evidence that this chance is so small that it is, for all intents and purposes, functionally indistinguishable from zero. That is what the science shows, and that is why scientists say that vaccines do not cause autism.
Think of the change in wording on the CDC webpage on vaccines and autism as being very similar in intent to the frequent claim by RFK Jr. that most childhood vaccines have never been subjected to randomized controlled clinical trials versus a saline placebo, a claim that RFK Jr.’s antivax propagandist bud Del Bigtree was touting this weekend on X, the hellsite formerly known as Twitter:
Tell me you don’t understand the science and ethics of clinical trials and what constitutes an appropriate control without telling me you don’t understand the science ands ethics of clinical trials and what constitutes an appropriate control. https://t.co/9GHMPG89eQ
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) November 22, 2025
No, Del, it is you who are antiscience, not to mention in favor of
experiments that would violate medical ethics, specifically the
Declaration of Helsinki and the Belmont Report.
I’ve discussed in depth why this claim is deceptive. I’m not going to discuss why in detail here because I’ve already discussed it multiple times, most recently here (where I described why the “no saline placebo” claim is deceptive nonsense that doesn’t show that vaccines are unsafe) and here (where I discussed how RFK Jr.’s HHS has deceptively weaponized and misapplied the principles of evidence-based medicine, ignoring medical ethics, to cast doubt on vaccines and justify making influenza and COVID-19 boosters much more difficult to approve.
Again, what RFK Jr. is about is not science. It is not about medicine or public health. It’s about spreading doubt about the safety and efficacy of vaccines as a prelude to regulating them out of existence in the US. It’s no different than the “toxins” gambit antivaxxers used to love to employ back around 2008, blaming formaldehyde (present in trace amounts in some vaccines) and the like for autism. Every time a study exonerated one vaccine ingredients, antivaxxers would shift to others to blame for autism. I used to like to say that “aluminum is the new mercury” because, after studies increasingly exonerated mercury in vaccines as a cause of autism, antivaxxers just shifted to blaming aluminum adjuvants. Either that, or they shifted to “too many too soon,” the “hypothesis” that it is the overall vaccine schedule that “overloads” the infant immune system and somehow causes autism. Basically, every time science falsifies an antivax “hypothesis” or shows that a proposed scientific mechanism by which antivaxxers claim that vaccines cause autism, they easily and seamlessly shift to another, more elaborate hypothesis or mechanism that is more difficult to falsify. Indeed, citing unfalsifiable hypotheses is an antivax specialty, as noted by Kristen Panthagani:
After three decades of research into the topic, with shifting rumors and scientists doing more and more research trying to keep up, the rumor has still not been satisfied. Now the rumor’s demands have shifted again — “but have you studied every vaccine ever?” “What about the entire childhood vaccine series altogether?” If scientists spend the next ten years painstakingly performing these giant studies, the rumor would likely shift yet again — “ok but you added more vaccines to the childhood vaccine schedule, have you checked the updated childhood vaccine schedule?” “What about this vaccine and this specific subtype of autism? “What about parents who got the COVID vaccine?” “What about moms who got multiple vaccines during pregnancy?” “What about these specific vaccine ingredients during pregnancy?” “You’ve only done observational studies looking into these 17 questions, where are the randomized controlled trials?” We could go on and on forever like this, creating unending list of questions and demands.
This is what antivaxxers do. It’s what they’ve been doing ever since I started really paying attention to them two decades ago.
As noted in an NPR article on the change in the CDC webpage:
“The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention website has been changed to promote false information suggesting vaccines cause autism,” said Dr. Susan J. Kressly, president of the American Academy of Pediatrics, in a statement. “Since 1998, independent researchers across seven countries have conducted more than 40 high-quality studies involving over 5.6 million people. The conclusion is clear and unambiguous: There’s no link between vaccines and autism.”
And:
“The new statement shows a lack of understanding of the term ‘evidence,'” the Autism Science Foundation said in a statement the organization provided to NPR, adding, “No environmental factor has been better studied as a potential cause of autism than vaccines.”
Quite so. The single most-studied environmental factor as a potential risk factor for or cause of autism is undeniably vaccines, and the studies have consistently come up negative for a detectable association dating back nearly three decades. The way antivaxxers have gotten around that simple fact about the science is by continually misrepresenting the evidence base and shifting the goalposts when science falsifies one of their fanciful hypotheses.
“Studies supporting a link have been ignored by health authorities”
I realize now that I should have dealt with this claim sooner, because, really, it’s fairly obviously bullshit. Scientists haven’t “ignored” studies supporting a link between vaccines and autism. They’ve read them, evaluated them, and recognized them as poorly designed and executed studies that do not demonstrate what antivaxxers claim that they demonstrate. Moreover, as I’ve frequently argued, scientists would not have persisted in doing study after study after study looking for links between vaccines and autism, persisting in doing more studies long after the vast preponderance of evidence had long ago shown that the likelihood of ever finding such a link was functionally no different than zero, were it not in service of a hopeless attempt to reassure hard core antivaxxers that vaccines do not cause autism. I can’t help but also mention that, every time such studies are published, antivaxxers are not reassured and instantly do their damnedest to cast doubt on each study, even if they have to attribute dubious methodological shortcomings to each study in order to convince themselves. Again, I’ve written about such attacks more times than I can remember over the last 20 years.
This HHS claim that the “studies are being ignored” is, at its heart, basically nothing more than the central conspiracy theory of the antivaccine movement, namely that the “evidence is out there” that vaccines cause autism by “They” (a cabal of scientists, physicians, Big Pharma, the CDC, the FDA, etc.) are “covering up” the real data and evidence. In essence, this statement is nothing different from what RFK Jr. wrote over two decades ago in Deadly Immunity, when he proposed a conspiracy theory that the CDC really did have the evidence that the mercury-containing preservative thimerosal that used to be in several childhood vaccines was the cause of the “autism epidemic” and convened a meeting at the Simpsonwood Conference Center in suburban Atlanta in 2000 to find a way to cover it up. It’s no different from the more recent “CDC whistleblower” conspiracy theory that claimed that the CDC had evidence that vaccines were associated with a higher risk of autism in African-American boys but had “covered it up.” As I like to say, all science denial, antivax vaccine denial included, is a conspiracy theory.
As Dr. Peter Hotez put it:
Attacking scientists as dishonest and corrupt comes straight out of the anti-vaccine playbook, said Peter Hotez, MD, codirector of the Texas Children’s Hospital Center for Vaccine Development, who also helped develop an affordable, unpatented COVID-19 vaccine.
“This is how the wellness influencer industry works,” Hotez said. “It’s not enough to push the snake oil. You have to discredit mainstream biomedical science and portray scientists as public enemies or cartoon villains, and that’s what Kennedy’s seeking to do.”
Now the antivax arch-conspiracy theorist RFK Jr. is in charge of HHS, and the CDC is well on its way to becoming, as we had feared after RFK Jr. bent the knee to Donald Trump in the lead-up to the 2024 election, an antivax propaganda outfit.
The CDC is lying to you and is no longer reliable
Unsurprisingly, antivaxxers are beside themselves with joy and celebration with the change in messaging on vaccines and autism from the CDC. For example:
🚨 BREAKING: CDC reverses 30 years of denial.

The CDC website admits the claim “Vaccines do NOT cause autism” was never evidence-based.

Studies have NOT ruled out infant vaccines as a cause of autism.

Evidence has been ignored.

HHS has opened a full investigation into… pic.twitter.com/o9sXInYBE7
— Children’s Health Defense (@ChildrensHD) November 20, 2025
CHD, as you recall, is an antivax organization founded by RFK Jr. Elswhere, here are some samplings of the rejoicing from around the antivax influencer crankosphere:
    • The CDC Fold on Autism & Vaccines — What I’ve Been Saying for 25 Years (Sherri Tenpenny).
    • BREAKING: CDC Finally Admitted They Cannot Claim Vaccines Do Not Cause Autism (Lioness of Judah Ministry).
    • Where Does the CDC’s Dishonesty Come From? Is a new era at last is dawning at the CDC? (A Midwestern Doctor, whom I like to call A Midwestern Quack).
    • CDC Retracts 30-Year Falsehood “Vaccines Don’t Cause Autism” Weeks After the McCullough Foundation’s Landmark Autism Report (Nicholas Hulscher). Note: I don’t think it was a coincidence that the McCullough Foundation report was released a mere four weeks before this change to the CDC website. Indeed, I think that the report was intended to provide the justification by throwing up all sorts of dubious proposed scientific mechanisms (a.k.a. antivax Mad Libs) to give the impression of bolstering the claim that we can’t say that vaccines do not cause autism.
    • CDC’s Autism Reversal: Inside the Collapse of a 25‑Year Public Health Narrative (James Lyons-Weiler, because of course JLW is there to regurgitate antivax talking points).
I could provide many more examples, but I think you get the idea. The gloating and rejoicing on the antivax side are truly epic. It also makes me wonder if the growing dissatisfaction with RFK Jr. expressed by antivaxxers over their perception by ardent antivaxxers that he hasn’t done much on vaccines also prodded him to make this change.
I never thought I’d be writing these words, much less repeating them several times in a single post, but the CDC is lying to you. It can no longer be considered a reliable source of information about vaccines. Nor, depressingly, am I alone in concluding that:
Instead of a global leader in science, the CDC has devolved into “a propaganda machine for RFK Jr.’s fixed, immutable, science-resistant theories,” said Paul Offit, MD, an infectious disease specialist at Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia and co-inventor of the rotavirus vaccine. “The CDC is being weaponized to promote RFK Jr.’s anti-vaccine point of view. So why should you trust it?”
Many public health experts who spoke to CIDRAP News sounded sorrowful.
“Today is a tragic day for public health, for the US government,” said Michael T. Osterholm, PhD, MPH, director of the University of Minnesota’s Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy (publisher of CIDRAP News). “Ideology has replaced science as the means for addressing life-saving research and best practices that save lives.”
Many physicians worry that the CDC’s new message will dissuade parents from vaccinating their children.
That is, of course, exactly RFK Jr.’s intent. Meanwhile, those who remain behind at CDC are increasingly demoralized and traumatized as the describe the changes to the CDC webpage as “embarrassing” and “horrifying”:
While they declined to be identified for fear of retaliation, they all said that they and their colleagues were shocked and dismayed by the misinformation put forth on the new page. “It’s horrifying, it’s embarrassing, it’s scary, it’s heartbreaking—it’s all of those things,” said a staffer at the CDC’s Injury Center. “To see our agency being used to spread lies and misinformation is a gut punch,” a CDC communicator with the National Center for Immunization and Respiratory Disease wrote in a message. “People will be harmed by this—parents will decide not to vaccinate their kids because of false information, and kids will get sick and die as a result.”
Another longtime CDC employee who works in communications said, “The best way I can put it is it feels like we’re on a hijacked airplane.”
This is, of course, the intent, to make CDC scientists and staff who try to stand up for vaccine science feel so demoralized and hopeless that they leave, so that they can be replaced by antivax-compliant “scientists.”
As for my statement that we can no longer trust the CDC for reliable information on vaccines under RFK Jr.:
When asked if the CDC was still a reliable source of public-health information, the employees said that most of the public-facing information remained unchanged. A critical problem was that there didn’t appear to be a good way for the public to discern the difference between accurate and politicized messaging. “I don’t know how they would distinguish that,” the Chronic Center staffer said. “There’s not a disclaimer saying posts were approved by political appointees and not by career scientists, so I don’t know.”
“It’s really easy from inside the agency to know what is real information and what has just been added there for political reasons,” added the longtime communications staffer. “But I can see that it would be really hard if you’re outside the agency to know the difference.”
Again, that’s the intent. It’s all coming from the CDC, the remaining reliable information and the ideological antivax propaganda. I can tell the difference, but how on earth is the average person without scientific training going to be able to tell the difference? Even some doctors who don’t have the experience of two decades of refuting antivax lies that I have accumulated might have difficulty telling the difference in some cases.
As I have been warning, RFK Jr. is coming for your vaccines. Eliminating vaccines is his endgame. It’s always been his endgame. What he’s done with ACIP and the FDA are just steps along the way. This change to a major CDC webpage on vaccines and autism is yet another part of RFK Jr.’s ultimate plan to eliminate vaccines.
And Sen. Bill Cassidy bears huge responsibility putting RFK Jr. in a position where he can potentially achieve his aim.
    • 

   Autism Prevalence Higher than Thought
Steven Novella 
Link
Over the last 20 years the prevalence of autism (now part of autism spectrum disorder, ASD) has been increasing. The medical community is largely agreed that this increase is mostly due to expanding the diagnostic category and greater efforts at surveillance. There remains some controversy over whether or not these factors explain all of the measured increase, or if there is a small real increase hidden in there as well. But largely – we are finding more children with ASD because we are casting a wider net with smaller holes.
If this is true, then we do not yet know what the true prevalence of ASD is. There must be a pool of undiagnosed children out there. Eventually the measured prevalence will hit the ceiling of the true prevalence (unless, of course, we expand the definition further) – but where is the ceiling?
That is the question researchers recently set out to answer, and they did so with a comprehensive 5 year study conducted in South Korea. The results surprised even them:
Results: The prevalence of ASDs was estimated to be 2.64% (95% CI=1.91–3.37), with 1.89% (95% CI=1.43–2.36) in the general-population sample and 0.75% (95% CI=0.58–0.93) in the high-probability group. ASD characteristics differed between the two groups: the male-to-female ratios were 2.5:1 and 5.1:1 in the general population sample and high-probability group, respectively, and the ratios of autistic disorders to other ASD subtypes were 1:2.6 and 2.6:1, respectively; 12% in the general-population sample had superior IQs, compared with 7% in the high-probability group; and 16% in the general-population sample had intellectual disability, compared with 59% in the high-probability group.
The previous estimate of autism prevalence was 1% of the population, or about one child in 100. This study found a prevalence of 2.64%, or about one child in 38 – more than twice the previous estimate. They came upon their higher measurement by taking a thorough survey of the general population. Previous studies have looked at high probability groups – children receiving special services or who have already been diagnosed. This study went into the general population and did a thorough survey for undiagnosed cases. Therefore there is a vast untapped pool of potential ASD diagnoses out there.
The results above also indicate that children with undiagnosed ASD in the general population had less intellectual disability than those in the recognized high probability group. They were also less likely to be male and less likely to have classic autism rather than a more subtle variant than the high probability group – which is not surprising. In other words, the undiagnosed children in the general population met the diagnostic features to be considered on the spectrum, but were largely functioning well in mainstream classrooms. In some cases parents were in denial about their child’s condition, in other cases the parents simply had no idea. In South Korea there is apparently still some stigma attached to the diagnosis.
While the authors conclude that their results indicate the need for still better detection of ASD, many of the undiagnosed children would likely not require or even benefit from special services. Although some would, and of course it would be desirable to capture all of those children.
While 2.6% is a high number for any such disorder, it is not out of line with other common mental disorders such as anxiety, depression, or ADHD. Of course these questions always bring up the very relevant issue of where to draw the line between “normal” and “disordered.” As I discussed recently, categorizing brain function is tricky business. Any identifiable psychological or neurological trait seems to vary at least along the classic bell-curve. You can therefore take any trait and declare two standard deviations to either side as the cut-off for “normal” (a standard practice in much of medicine) and declare those at the fringes to have one or another disorder. That would result in 5% of the population being abnormal.
But it takes more than being at the tails of the bell curve to be considered as having a disorder. The definition also requires that the identified traits are associated with (and plausibly cause) some dysfunction or negative outcome. In the case of ASD the disorder is a lack of social ability (not just learned skills, but the raw neurological hardwiring that underlies our ability to socialize). Interestingly, the current measured rate of 2.64% is almost exactly two standard deviations to the left of the curve (the other 2.5%, making a total of 5%, is the cutoff to the right of the curve – those with high social ability, which is generally not considered a disorder).
Since many of the children captured in the current study seemed to be doing fine, it is possible that the current definition of ASD is simply capturing the left two standard deviations of human variability along the bell curve of social ability. Perhaps the definition is therefore too broad, and needs to be tied more closely with some measure of disability. That is a subject for future research.
The bell curve hypothesis also can be used to support those in the “neurodiversity” community. They argue that ASD is just what I described – normal human neurological variation. I agree with this view to some degree, and I think the data above support that. However – when you get out far enough to the left side of the bell curve you do get to the point where dysfunction is undeniable. At some point it is useful to consider a neurological phenomenon to be a disorder. Children with low social ability (even if they make up for it in other ways) tend to have difficulty in school, with making friends, and later in life functioning in the work environment. No matter what you choose to call it, it is useful to identify children who can benefit from programs to help them compensate for their lack of social ability.
Also – we cannot assume that ASD is simply everyone more than two standard deviations to the left of the bell curve. It is possible that the actual curve is not a pristine bell-shape but is bi-modal, representing one hump of normal human variation, and then another hump at the low end of social ability that represents a theoretically definable separate population. This second hump might represent those with one of a group of genetic variants that leads to what we recognize as autism. This is almost certainly true, as children with autism have a higher incidence of intellectual impairment and seizures, suggesting a neurological disorder and not just normal variation. There is also increasing evidence of genetics links to autism.
Further – the low end of the bell curve of normal variation would blend imperceptibly into the second hump of autism disorder. At present the diagnosis of ASD is based entirely on clinical features, making it difficult to separate out different underlying causes. (As I stated above, we can make subtype distinctions based upon associated neurological conditions, but this is still a clinical inference rather than a distinction based upon known cause.)
As neuroscience advances, h0wever, it may become possible to tease out the current mixed bag of clinical ASD by identifying specific underlying genetic or neurological conditions. We may undo the lumping of all these children into one ASD spectrum by identifying subtypes by either their genetic profile, or perhaps their neurological function as examined by functional MRI scanning or a similar functional scan. We are already making significant progress in this area, but this is still an area ripe for further research.
Conclusion
This study adds an interesting data point to the whole picture of ASD. If correct, then the theoretically upper limit of ASD prevalence is about 2.6% of the population, more than twice the previous estimate. It also indicates that when you undergo a program of thorough searching, you will find more diagnoses. No one can reasonably think that the true prevalence of ASD suddenly doubled.
While it doesn’t prove that the steady increase in ASD diagnoses over the last 20 years was due to increased surveillance, it does support that hypothesis by showing the potential of just looking harder. Those children with ASD were always there, they were simply not identified.

Autism Prevalence Unchanged in 20 Years
Steven Novella on September 10, 2014
Link
That there is an “autism epidemic” is taken as a given by those who feel autism has a dominant environmental cause. The Age of Autism blog, for example, bills itself as a, “Daily Web Newspaper of the Autism Epidemic.” The term “epidemic” also implies an environmental factor, such as an infection.
The epidemiology of autism and autism spectrum disorder (ASD) has never supported the conclusion that there is an autism epidemic. There is no doubt that the number of autism diagnoses has increased in the last two decades, but the evidence strongly suggests this increase in an artifact of how autism diagnoses are made, and not representative of a true increase.
Adding to this data, a newly published study looks at autism and ASD prevalence worldwide: “The epidemiology and global burden of autism spectrum disorders“. They found:
In 2010 there were an estimated 52 million cases of ASDs, equating to a prevalence of 7.6 per 1000 or one in 132 persons. After accounting for methodological variations, there was no clear evidence of a change in prevalence for autistic disorder or other ASDs between 1990 and 2010. Worldwide, there was little regional variation in the prevalence of ASDs.
In 1990, according to this study, the prevalence was 7.5 per 1000 – not significantly different than 7.6 in 2010. How do we square this data with those from the CDC and other sources that imply an increase in the measured prevalence (whether real or artifact)? The CDC, for example, reports the US prevalence of ASD in 2000 as 1 in 150, and in 2010 as 1 in 68. The authors of the new study explain that using administrative data, such as reporting and special education needs, is highly problematic:
Our study aimed to overcome these limitations by capturing prevalence data from a range of sources that used comprehensive case-finding strategies and by using covariates to adjust for sources of systematic bias. After adjusting for variable study methodology, our models show that the prevalence of ASDs seems to have remained relatively stable over the past 20 years.
It’s always better to have rigorous and consistent study methodology up front, rather than correcting for such limitations with statistical adjustments at the back end. Every adjustment potentially adds a degree of freedom that itself can bias the outcome. However, when the study methods are variable you have no choice. I am not a statistician, so I cannot directly evaluate the methods used in this study. I leave that to other statisticians. So far, it has passed peer-review, and we’ll see how it holds up going forward.
No one study is ever definitive, but the results conform to other studies that have looked at autism prevalence or incidence and attempted to control for differences in methods of capturing diagnoses. A 2006 review by Taylor, for example, found:
The recorded prevalence of autism has increased considerably in recent years. This reflects greater recognition, with changes in diagnostic practice associated with more trained diagnosticians; broadening of diagnostic criteria to include a spectrum of disorder; a greater willingness by parents and educationalists to accept the label (in part because of entitlement to services); and better recording systems, among other factors.
In other words, several studies have found that there is increased surveillance for autism, a broadening of the diagnostic criteria, and an increased willingness to seek out and accept the diagnosis by parents and educators. Further, when you control for these variables, the adjusted autism prevalence is stable over time.
A 2013 study looked at patterns of autism diagnosis in California. They found that autism diagnosis tends to cluster in neighborhoods with increased diagnostic resources:
We identify birth and diagnostic clusters of autism in California that are independent of individual-level autism risk factors. Our findings implicate a causal relationship between neighborhood-level diagnostic resources and spatial patterns of autism incidence but do not rule out the possibility that environmental toxicants have also contributed to autism risk.
Such epidemiological studies are often appropriately cautious in their conclusions, stating that they cannot rule out other factors, such as environment or a real increase in the number of autism cases. Such studies, however, do not provide evidence for either a real increase or any environmental factors. Rather, autism diagnoses seem to correlate best with awareness of autism and resources for diagnosis and services.
This and other studies have also found that the increase in diagnoses occurs mainly among children who are higher functioning, meaning they have more subtle signs of autism, and not very much among lower functioning children with autism. This makes sense in the context of increased surveillance and broadened diagnostic criteria.
A relatively stable prevalence of autism also is consistent with independent lines of evidence, including recent evidence suggesting that the brain changes seen in autism occur within the womb. A prenatal onset of autism would eliminate any postnatal environmental factors. This is also consistent with the many studies that demonstrate that autism is dominantly a genetic disorder.
Finally, despite many premature claims and attempts to link autism to specific environmental factors (most notoriously vaccines), the evidence ultimately does not support any connection. It is easy to find spurious correlations when sifting through large data sets, as the graph below humorously illustrates. Most such correlations, however, do not pan out when looked at critically.
Conclusion
This latest study showing a stable autism prevalence between 1990 and 2010 is in line with a consilience of scientific evidence showing that autism is mostly genetic, has its onset prenataly, and that the apparent increase in prevalence is largely due to diagnostic substitution, increased surveillance, greater acceptance, and broadening of the diagnostic criteria.
Given all of this it is still possible that there is a real increase hiding in the data, although it must be small. It is further possible that there are environmental risk factors that affect the development of autism. Increasing parental age has been suggested as a factor, and this deserves further study. At present, however, there is no data clearly pointing to any specific environmental factor.

Autism prevalence: Now estimated to be one in 88, and the antivaccine movement goes wild
David Gorski on April 2, 2012
Link
Editor’s Note: Some of you might have seen this before, but it’s an important (and timely) enough topic that I figure it’s worth exposing to a different audience. It’s been updated and edited to style for SBM. Enjoy.
If there’s one thing that I’ve learned that I can always—and I do mean always—rely on from the antivaccine movement, it’s that its members will always be all over any new study regarding vaccines and/or autism in an effort to preemptively put their pseudoscientific spin on the results. It’s much the same way that they frequently storm into discussion threads after stories and posts about vaccines and autism like the proverbial flying monkeys, dropping their antivaccine poo hither and yon all over science-based discussions.
In any case, antivaxers are also known for not respecting embargoes. They infiltrate their way into mailing lists for journalists in which newsworthy new studies are released to the press before they actually see print and then flood their propaganda websites with their spin on the studies, either attacking the ones they don’t like or trying to imprint their interpretation on ones on which they can, all before the skeptical blogosophere—or even the mainstream press—has a chance to report. So it was late last week, when vaccine-autism cranks jumped the embargo on a CDC study that announced new autism prevalence numbers. This is nothing new; it’s the antivaccine movement’s modus operandi, which makes me wonder why the various journals don’t shut off the flow. The study, of course, was announced in press conferences and a number of news stories. No doubt by now many of you have seen them. The stories I’ve seen thus far have focused on the key finding of the CDC study, which is that the prevalence of autism in the U.S. has risen to approximately 1 in 88, a finding reported in the CDC’s Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report.
This is how the CDC came up with the new prevalence:
The Autism and Developmental Disabilities Monitoring (ADDM) Network is an active surveillance system that estimates the prevalence of ASDs and describes other characteristics among children aged 8 years whose parents or guardians reside within 14 ADDM sites in the United States. ADDM does not rely on professional or family reporting of an existing ASD diagnosis or classification to ascertain case status. Instead, information is obtained from children’s evaluation records to determine the presence of ASD symptoms at any time from birth through the end of the year when the child reaches age 8 years. ADDM focuses on children aged 8 years because a baseline study conducted by CDC demonstrated that this is the age of identified peak prevalence. A child is included as meeting the surveillance case definition for an ASD if he or she displays behaviors (as described on a comprehensive evaluation completed by a qualified professional) consistent with the American Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual-IV, Text Revision (DSM-IV-TR) diagnostic criteria for any of the following conditions: Autistic Disorder; Pervasive Developmental Disorder–Not Otherwise Specified (PDD-NOS, including Atypical Autism); or Asperger Disorder. The first phase of the ADDM methodology involves screening and abstraction of comprehensive evaluations completed by professional providers at multiple data sources in the community. Multiple data sources are included, ranging from general pediatric health clinics to specialized programs for children with developmental disabilities. In addition, many ADDM sites also review and abstract records of children receiving special education services in public schools. In the second phase of the study, all abstracted evaluations are reviewed by trained clinicians to determine ASD case status. Because the case definition and surveillance methods have remained consistent across all ADDM surveillance years to date, comparisons to results for earlier surveillance years can be made. This report provides updated ASD prevalence estimates from the 2008 surveillance year, representing 14 ADDM areas in the United States. In addition to prevalence estimates, characteristics of the population of children with ASDs are described, as well as detailed comparisons of the 2008 surveillance year findings with those for the 2002 and 2006 surveillance years.
The bottom line is that in the cohort born in 2000 approximately one in 54 boys and one in 252 girls living in the ADDM Network communities were identified as having an autism or ASD diagnosis. One thing that we should be clear on right here because it’s right in the report is that ADDM Network sites do not make up a nationally representative sample, which means that these prevalence numbers can’t be generalized to the whole U.S.
Before I dig into the report a bit more and discuss the reaction of the antivaccine movement to it, let’s first note one thing that you will not (and I did not) see in the various hysterical reactions to the study that I’ve seen thus far. You will not see any of the usual suspects emphasize mercury in the thimerosal preservative that used to be used in vaccines in the context of the report (although one does foolishly mention it, see below). The reason is obvious. If autism prevalence is still rising (or even if it’s staying the same), it’s yet another death blow to the hypothesis that mercury in vaccines causes autism. After all, thimerosal was removed from nearly all pediatric vaccines back in 2001, but the process began in 1999 after the CDC and the American Academy of Pediatrics’ vaccine advisory committee advised that thimerosal be removed from childhood vaccines. By 2000 the process was under way. If mercury in vaccines were a cause of autism, we’d expect to start to see a decline in autism prevalence. Even if the cause of this apparent increase in autism prevalence is better detection, broadening of the diagnostic criteria, and increased awareness, this report is not good news for those who believe that mercury in vaccines cause autism.
Now that that one point is out of the way, let’s see what the various antivaccine groups are saying about the report. For instance, the Canary Party, which seems to be tightly affiliated with Generation Rescue and the antivaccine crank blog Age of Autism, jumped the gun the day before the report was released and declared:
This week, the Canary Party expects CDC to announce a new autism prevalence rate of 1 in 88. As boys are diagnosed with autism at four times the rate of girls, this translates to 1 in 48 boys. That new rate would be an increase from the previous 1 in 110 reported two years ago by the CDC’s ADDM (Autism Developmental Disabilities Monitoring) Network. This would only be the latest uptick in the autism rate reported by CDC, as the disorder was diagnosed in 1 in 10,000 in the 1960s, and the rate was virtually zero before 1930.
This first paragraph reveals a depth of ignorance that surprises me even from antivaccinationists. There’s a reason that autism prevalence was “virtually zero” before 1930, and that’s because autism wasn’t defined as a distinct clinical entity until 1943, when Leo Kanner published his seminal paper describing the characteristics of autism. While it’s true that the word “autism” was used as early as 1911, when Eugen Bleuler, a Swiss psychiatrist, used the term to refer to one group of symptoms of schizophrenia, the word has meant different things throughout the years, which is why such historical comparisons are almost meaningless before the early 1990s. Ironically, this little bit of history gives me the lead-in to introduce the biggest question about this newly reported prevalence statistic: Is this a “real” increase in autism and ASD diagnoses, “real” meaning that biologically there is a real increase; i.e., it can’t be explained by reasons other than biology? Or is it the increase in autism and ASD diagnoses due to improved diagnosis, screening, and awareness? The antivaccine movement has put all its money on a real increase. The reason is simple. Without a “real” increase in autism prevalence, there is no vaccine-autism hypothesis because in that case there isn’t even correlation to confuse with causation. You can see this in Ginger Taylor’s list or rhetorical questions:
How did we go from one in 10,000 children born 50 years ago being diagnosed with autism to 1 in 88 diagnosed today? Why do the Centers for Disease Control refuse to call the avalanche of autism diagnoses in the U.S. anything more than an “urgent public health concern?” Why is the federal agency downplaying a national emergency with special wording created just for autism – Urgent Public Health Concern – a label that is not used to describe any of the thousands of other disorders and conditions the agency tracks? When dozens of published research papers and multiple congressional hearings have shown that the primary causes of autism are environmental, and include vaccines and their components, why has CDC failed to offer any advice to new parents on how to decrease the chance of a child developing autism? Why has CDC chosen not to even attempt to identify which children are the subset vulnerable to these environmental exposures so that they can be handled with greater care?
Note that “environmental exposure” is code for “vaccines” among antivaccinationists. If that isn’t clear to my regular readers by now, it never will be. The above paragraph makes it as clear as clear can be. SafeMinds echoes the same theme in its press release:
    • Growth in autism rates this dramatic can only be driven by environmental factors.
    • The majority of cases of autism are caused by environmental exposures coming before and/or after birth. This makes them preventable. Until we do a better job of eliminating the soup of toxic pollution our children are exposed to, increases in prevalence like this will likely continue. Autism has been associated with mercury, pesticides and air pollution.
This is a complicated issue, as you might imagine, as various bloggers, such as Steve Novella, have pointed out. However, this part is relatively simple. The antivaccine movement assumes that the huge increase in diagnoses indicates a real increase in the prevalence of autism. They do this because the vaccine-autism hypothesis needs an “autism epidemic” in order to claim correlation between vaccines and autism, as tenuous and biologically implausible as the correlation might be. The more its members can gin this up as some sort of “public health emergency,” the better the chance they can convince the credulous that there is an autism “epidemic.” It might. It might not. What is being almost willfully ignored here is the simple fact that the number of diagnoses of a condition does not necessarily accurately reflect the “true” prevalence in a given population. This is particularly true for a condition like autism and ASDs, where the diagnostic criteria are not nearly as “hard” as in other conditions. In fact, you can see just what I’m talking about if you look at the reaction of the antivaccine movement to the proposed DSM-5, which in its current form tightens the diagnostic criteria for autism and ASDs. You might remember a couple of months ago that the antivaccine crankosphere was in a real lather over the proposed changes, claiming they are a “conspiracy” to hide the autism epidemic (and thus, of course, to exonerate vaccines as its cause) by changing the diagnostic criteria. (Whenever diagnostic criteria are tightened, usually the number of diagnoses for the condition covered by those criteria decreases.) Add to that the fact that there are now a lot of government benefits that depend on a diagnosis of autism or ASD, and there are lots of reasons why the antivaccine movement needs to spin this report to its purpose.
To try to put the results in context, the CDC published an accompanying commentary from the director of NIMH, Thomas Insel, that describes why these results do not necessarily indicate a “true” increase in autism in the population and why it could very well just mean we’re picking up more autism. After invoking a study from South Korea with a high autism prevalence, as well as a British study that found a pretty constant prevalence among all age ranges, suggesting that prevalence hasn’t changed much over the last 50 or 60 years, comparing it to a California study that concluded that only 26% of the increase can be accounted for by better awareness and detection, Insel writes:
This takes us back to the central question: has the number of children with ASD increased or not? Total population epidemiological studies suggest much or all of the increase is due to better and wider detection. Studies of administrative and services data suggest that better detection cannot fully explain the profound and continuing increase. Are we seeing more affected or more detected? The question is vitally important, but there is not one, simple answer just as autism is not a single, simple disorder.
Antivaccinationists argue that increased diagnosis and screening alone can’t explain such a large increase in genetic diseases; hence, autism is not a genetic condition but rather due to environment (cough, cough, vaccines). However, they are quite wrong in the premise behind their argument. If there’s a single rule I’ve learned over the last couple of decades, it’s that whenever a mass screening programs for a condition is undertaken, more people will acquire that diagnosis—sometimes many, many more. For example, let’s look at cancer, specifically breast cancer, since that’s what I know best in medicine. I did a talk a while back part of which addressed this very issue; so I had to look up the data. Specifically, I looked at ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS), which is a premalignant precursor of breast cancer. Basically, it’s cancerous cells that haven’t broken out of the breast ducts yet. Back in the early 1900s, DCIS was rare because by the time it grew large enough to be a palpable mass, it almost always had become invasive cancer. Enter mammography. Now, thirty years or so after mass mammographic screening programs began, DCIS is common. Indeed, approximately 40% of breast cancer diagnoses are in fact DCIS. Indeed, a recent study found that DCIS incidence rose from 1.87 per 100,000 in the mid-1970s to 32.5 in 2004. That’s a more than 16-fold increase over 30 years, and it’s pretty much all due to the introduction of mammographic screening. Think of something like hypercholesterolemia. Fifty years ago, it was an uncommon diagnosis. Changes in diagnostic criteria and screening have lead to an explosion in diagnoses, with large proportions of the population being on statins. Heck, as I pointed out just the other day, before the 1920s doctors didn’t routinely measure systolic/diastolic blood pressure ratios; so there were few, if any, cases of hypertension because doctors weren’t looking for it.
In other words, if you don’t look for something, you won’t find it, and if you do look for something, you will find a lot more of it than you expected. It is quite possible that that is what’s happening with autism, but such a narrative doesn’t fit into the vaccine-autism idea. The antivaccine movement needs an increasing apparent autism prevalence. It needs it so bad that SafeMinds will even post hysteria like this:
The prevalence of autism is rising at about 12% a year. That means:
    • The number of children with autism will double every 6 years.
    • In 5 years, autism could affect 1 in 50 children or 1 in 31 boys.
    • There will be at least one child with autism in every classroom in America.
    • Let’s consider what that means in numbers of children affected:
    • Approximately 4 million babies are born each year in the United States. That means that each year, at current rates, 45, 454 children will be diagnosed with autism. That also means:
    • In 5 years, if we don’t find a cause and rates continue to increase, 80,000 children per year will be diagnosed with autism. How many children have to be affected before our country takes action? 5 percent? 10 percent?
    • Can anyone with a conscience claim that this isn’t an epidemic?
    • SafeMinds believes that most cases of autism are preventable and treatable. We demand action to protect our children.
This is fear-mongering, pure and simple. It also assumes that autism prevalence can continue to increase exponentially. No condition or disease can do that; incidence and prevalence always eventually level out and reach an equilibrium. If they didn’t, then sooner or later 100% of a population would be affected. In any case, pay special attention to the last bullet point. This is in reality an appeal to divert scarce research dollars away from scientifically promising avenues to the scientifically discredited vaccine-autism hypothesis (indeed, later in the press release, SafeMinds states emphatically in its press release that vaccine studies “cannot be taken off the table.” To support this assertion, SafeMinds trots out a hoary host of antivaccine tropes, including the Poul Thorsen gambit, the “no studies” (that I like) gambit, the “too many too soon” gambit, and several others. Amusingly, SafeMinds even trots out the mercury gambit, even though, as I described above, if anything the CDC report should put the final nail in the hypothesis that mercury in the thimerosal preservative in vaccines causes autism. The Canary Party’s press release echoes many of the same antivaccine tropes, particularly the spurious claim that vaccines safety is inadequately tested.
In fact, the antivaccine movement is going all out. For example, the Canary Party is taking advantage of the press given to autism episodes today, World Autism Day, to hold a press conference demanding “action.” What “action” do they demand? Well, here’s a sample of its announcement of the press conference, which is to be streamed live:
The organizations call for three urgent action steps:
     1.  Secretary Sebelius should declare a national health emergency and order the NIH and CDC to shift their research focus to prevention efforts, especially investigation of long overlooked environmental factors.
     2.  The Government Accounting Office should initiate a study of past research funding that has ignored environmental causes. We need to understand whether this was the result of lobbying to avoid possible liability that might be uncovered with examination of environmental triggers.
     3.  The U.S. House of Representatives Government Reform Committee should initiate promised hearings as soon as possible on the failure of federal health agencies in appropriately responding to this epidemic. It has been about ten years since this Committee examined the role of the federal authorities in the autism epidemic.
We can think of no other instance of any comparable epidemic that has gone on so long without Congressional oversight. Grassroots organizations represented at the press conference: Age of Autism, AutismOne, Autism Action Network, Autism File, The Canary Party, Center for Personal Rights, The Coalition for Safe Minds, Elizabeth Birt Center for Autism Law and Advocacy, Focus Autism, National Autism Association, Talk About Curing Autism.
Interesting that Generation Rescue isn’t listed as supporting the press conference. Neither is Barbara Loe Fisher’s NVIC. Maybe they recognize a loser when they see one, although Age of Autism is for all intents and purposes a wholly owned subsidiary of . In any case, notice the harping on “environmental” factors. Remember what I’ve said many times before. In antivaccine lingo, “environmental factors” is code for “the vaccines done it,” and antivaccinationists are milking these CDC numbers for all they’re worth.
So is the “real” prevalence of autism and ASDs increasing? Damned if I know. I do, however, know that, even if it is, it’s not an “epidemic” any more than DCIS is an “epidemic.” Diagnostic substitution, increased screening and awareness, all topped off with strong incentives to place the diagnosis of autism or ASD on children contribute to an apparent skyrocketing autism prevalence. In reality, as the South Korean and British studies strongly suggest, if there is a “real” increase, it’s probably a relatively small one. Show me strong evidence of a “real” increase, and I’ll change my mind. Failing that, finally I also know that the antivaccine movement is so invested in the concept of an “autism epidemic” because it supports its delusion that vaccines cause autism that no study and no amount of data will ever convince them otherwise.

Autism prevalence: Now estimated to be one in 68, and the antivaccine movement goes wild
David Gorski on March 31, 2014
Link
There used to be a time when I dreaded Autism Awareness Month, which begins tomorrow. The reason was simple. Several years ago to perhaps as recently as three years ago, I could always count on a flurry of stories about autism towards the end of March and the beginning of April about autism. That in and of itself isn’t bad. Sometimes the stories were actually informative and useful. However, in variably there would be a flurry of truly aggravating stories in which the reporter, either through laziness, lack of ideas, or the desire to add some spice and controversy to his story, would cover the “vaccine angle.” Invariably, the reporter would either fall for the “false balance” fallacy, in which advocates of antivaccine pseudoscience like Barbara Loe Fisher, Jenny McCarthy, J. B. Handley, Dr. Jay Gordon, and others would be interviewed in the same story as though they expressed a viewpoint that was equally valid as that of real scientists like Paul Offit, representatives of the CDC, and the like. Even if the view that there is no good evidence that vaccines are associated with an increased risk of autism were forcefully expressed, the impression left behind would be that there was actually a scientific debate when there is not. Sometimes, antivaccine-sympathetic reporters would simply write antivaccine stories.
I could also count on the antivaccine movement to go out of its way to try to implicate vaccines as a cause of the “autism” epidemic, taking advantage of the increased media interest that exists every year around this time. Examples abound, such as five years ago when Generation Rescue issued its misinformation-laden “Fourteen Studies” website, to be followed by a propaganda tour by Jenny McCarthy and her then-boyfriend Jim Carrey visiting various media outlets to promote the antivaccine message.
Fortunately, over the last three or four years, the media have become noticeably—and appropriately—much more dismissive of antivaccine pseudoscience. This seems to have occurred in the wake of Andrew Wakefield’s humiliation at being struck off (i.e., had his medical license revoked) in the U.K. and then having his infamous 1998 case series that started the fear mongering over a nonexistent link between the MMR vaccine and autism retracted by The Lancet based on evidence that he committed scientific fraud.
The antivaccine movement aside, there remains a temptation among scientists and government agencies to release the results of new studies having anything to do with autism either during the last week of March or the first week of April, all, of course, to take advantage of the publicity of Autism Awareness Month. So it was last week, when beginning on Thursday I sensed a disturbance in the antivaccine crankosphere force, with the antivaccine blog Age of Autism rerunning various posts by Mark “Not A Doctor, Not A Scientist” Blaxill and other AoA denizens from 2009. The reasons were obvious. The CDC was going to release the latest autism prevalence data on Thursday. The antivaccine crankosphere has been busily spinning those numbers since Thursday, which means it’s time to address those numbers here.
Autism prevalence in the United States, 2014
The CDC’s latest autism prevalence numbers was published in the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (MMWR) in a report entitled Prevalence of Autism Spectrum Disorder Among Children Aged 8 Years — Autism and Developmental Disabilities Monitoring Network, 11 Sites, United States, 2010. This is the sixth survey reported from data gathered from the Autism and Developmental Disabilities Monitoring (ADDM) Network. The ADDM is an active surveillance system in the US designed to provide estimates of the prevalence of autism and autism spectrum disorders (ASDs), as well as other characteristics, of children aged eight years whose parents live in eleven ADDM sites.
The goals of the ADDM are:
     1.  To obtain as complete a count as possible of the number of children with ASD in multiple surveillance areas.
     2.  To report comparable population-based ASD prevalence estimates from different sites every 2 years and to evaluate how these estimates are changing over time. To study whether autism is more common among some groups of children than among others.
     3.  To provide descriptive data on the population of children with ASD.
The concept is simple; unfortunately the implementation is not. The report describes how surveillance is conducted at ADDM sites:
ADDM surveillance is conducted in two phases. The first phase consists of screening and abstracting comprehensive evaluations performed by professional providers in the community. Multiple data sources for these evaluations include general pediatric health clinics and specialized programs for children with developmental disabilities. In addition, most ADDM Network sites also review and abstract records of children receiving special education services in public schools. The second phase involves review of all abstracted evaluations by trained clinicians to determine ASD surveillance case status. A child meets the surveillance case definition for ASD if a comprehensive evaluation of that child completed by a qualified professional describes behaviors consistent with the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition, Text Revision (DSM-IV-TR) diagnostic criteria for any of the following conditions: autistic disorder, pervasive developmental disorder–not otherwise specified (including atypical autism), or Asperger disorder. This report provides updated prevalence estimates for ASD from the 2010 surveillance year. In addition to prevalence estimates, characteristics of the population of children with ASD are described.
Why did the investigators choose age 8 as the benchmark, the age at which they would examine prevalence? As is explained later in the report, it’s because the baseline ASD prevalence study conducted by the CDC’s Metropolitan Atlanta Developmental Disabilities Surveillance Program (MADDSP) in 2003 demonstrated that this is the age of peak prevalence. How can that be? The authors of that study speculated that it was possible at the time that the lower rates in 9- and 10-year olds might have reflected the use of narrower diagnostic criteria for autism before the DSM-IV and the increased availability of educational and health services for children with autism in the 1990s. More specifically, prevalence rates in that study between the ages of 5 and 8 didn’t significantly vary from each other; so the investigators chose the oldest age in that range, in order to capture the highest prevalence rate. To that, I also wonder whether, as I pointed out multiple times before, the observation that some children lose their ASD diagnosis as they grow and develop had anything to do with it. Be that as it may, this is the system, and that’s how the estimates come about.
Last time the CDC reported these numbers, which was in 2012, they found that autism prevalence was 1 in 88. The antivaccine movement went wild. This time, in 2014, the CDC estimates that 14.7 per 1,000 eight year olds (1 in 68) have a diagnosis of an ASD. As Autism-News-Beat points out, this new estimate is 30% higher than the estimate from 2012. (It should be noted that this prevalence number comes from 2010 data.) It’s hard not to mention at this point that it’s very hard to blame this increase on vaccines given the stability of vaccination rates overall in the US. Let’s just put it this way: The increase in prevalence numbers is not a compelling piece of evidence that vaccines are the cause of an “autism epidemic,” no matter how much antivaccinationists try to convince you otherwise.
So what could be going on?
Making sense of the numbers becomes easier if you start looking at more than just the overall number of 1 in 68, or even the estimate that 1 in 42 boys and one in 189 girls living in ADDM Network communities were identified as having ASD in 2010. After all, we’ve known for a long time that boys are considerably more likely to be diagnosed with an ASD than are girls, and these numbers confirm that. So let’s look at more of the details:
Non-Hispanic white children were approximately 30% more likely to be identified with ASD than non-Hispanic black children and were almost 50% more likely to be identified with ASD than Hispanic children. Among the seven sites with sufficient data on intellectual ability, 31% of children with ASD were classified as having IQ scores in the range of intellectual disability (IQ ≤70), 23% in the borderline range (IQ = 71–85), and 46% in the average or above average range of intellectual ability (IQ >85). The proportion of children classified in the range of intellectual disability differed by race/ethnicity. Approximately 48% of non-Hispanic black children with ASD were classified in the range of intellectual disability compared with 38% of Hispanic children and 25% of non-Hispanic white children. The median age of earliest known ASD diagnosis was 53 months and did not differ significantly by sex or race/ethnicity.
Next, if you look at Table 2 in the CDC report, you’ll find a huge variation in the prevalence reported, ranging from 5.7 per 1,000 in Alabama (1 in 175) to 21.9 per 1,000 in New Jersey (1 in 46). Here are the data summarized in a graph:
I noticed something about this graph immediately. Look at the colors of the data points. either dark or light. Notice the dark-colored points represent sites that relied primarily on data from healthcare sources, while the light-colored points represent sources that had access to educational records throughout all or most of their surveillance area? Why is that important? Simple: Notice how all the sites that only relied on data from healthcare sources (Alabama, Wisconsin, Colorado, and Missouri) report prevalence rates below the prevalence rate for all the sites combined. Only one (Missouri) had error bars that encompassed the overall prevalence rate for the entire ADDM Network. Now notice that the sites that had access to educational records (Georgia, Arkansas, Arizona, Maryland, North Carolina, Utah, and New Jersey) all reported prevalence rates that were either at or above the overall prevalence for the network. To me this is a red flag that at least some of the variability in the autism prevalence numbers has to do with the intensity of surveillance and the intensity of screening in various states. Frequently, this is mischaracterized dismissively by antivaccinationists as a huge straw man they like to call “increased awareness,” but in reality it’s a lot more than that, as I’ll discuss later. In the meantime, let’s move on.
Another red flag indicating that much of what is driving the changes in autism prevalence numbers is likely to be something other than biology is the wide disparity between autism prevalence as diagnosed in non-Hispanic Caucasians and in African-Americans as apposed to the much lower prevalence as diagnosed in Hispanics. Indeed, non-Hispanic white children were approximately 30% more likely to be identified with ASD than non-Hispanic black children and were almost 50% more likely to be identified with ASD than Hispanic children. This sort of disparity is far more likely to be due to differences in screening and diagnoses than to biology. Now couple this with observations in the report regarding ASD diagnoses as related to diagnoses of intellectual disability. The authors noted that in previous reports, from 2002 to 2008, the greatest increases in ASD prevalence were noted in Hispanic children, non-Hispanic black children, and children without co-occurring intellectual disability. The first two suggest that Hispanic and non-Hispanic black children are likely to be “catching up” with Caucasian children in terms of access to diagnostic services, while the increases in children without intellectual disability is interpreted thusly:
The much higher prevalence of ASD without co-occurring intellectual disability among white children appears to explain much of the variation in ASD prevalence estimates between different racial/ethnic groups. Among white children, the prevalence of ASD without intellectual disability was nearly double the prevalence among either black children or Hispanic children (OR = 1.8, p<0.01 for both comparisons). Conversely, the prevalence of ASD with co-occurring intellectual disability was similar among white children and Hispanic children but significantly higher among black children than among both of these groups. This suggests that in these seven sites, the significant white-to-black and white-to-Hispanic prevalence ratios were primarily driven by higher prevalence of ASD without intellectual disability among white children, and the significant black-to-Hispanic prevalence ratio was primarily driven by higher prevalence of ASD with co-occurring intellectual disability among black children.
In other words, more children without intellectual disability are being diagnosed with ASD. In the past, these children likely would not have been diagnosed with ASD—or with anything at all. Now they are being diagnosed. As Emily Willingham put it:
From the data, it looks like a lot of sociocultural factors enter into the values. Given the huge variability from site to site and the ethnic differences, recognition and service availability are probably factors. Dr. Boyle referred repeatedly to the evolution of our understanding of autism and used the large percentage of children included in these values who have average to above-average intelligence as an example of that. Unlike numbers from a decade ago, these values include children who previously might not have been recognized as autistic.
And Rachel Dornhelm:
For one thing, the prevalence seems to vary in different communities and among children of different races. The CDC found white children are far more likely to be identified with autism, even though scientists don’t believe the rates are truly different between whites, Hispanics or blacks.
That means that the discrepancy lies in the diagnosis and services available in different communities.
This is very likely true. As was pointed out in the analysis posted at the Thinking Person’s Guide to Autism, Richard Grinker studied ASD prevalence rates in South Korea and estimated that 1 in 38 children had ASDs there. In a news report about the study, Grinker pointed out that the reason the rates he found were so high was likely because in-person evaluations were performed for any child suspected of having an ASD and two-thirds of the cases of ASD identified in the study were “in mainstream schools, unrecognized, untreated.” If the estimates in the South Korean study are more accurate, prevalence rates for ASDs, which are clearly still underdiagnosed, can be expected to continue to increase for some time, until they finally level off at somewhere approximating the “true” prevalence rate. The study’s message, according to autism researcher Bennett Leventhal, is that “if you really go look carefully among all children everywhere, you find that things are far more common than you previously expected.” This is true not just of ASDs, but of pretty much every medical condition that has ever been screened for. If you don’t look for it, you won’t find it. If you do, you will, often at a much higher rate than you would ever have guessed.
I like to go back to an example I use time and time again. I use it time and time again because it’s about as good an example as I can find. Antivaccinationists like to use the argument that increased diagnosis and screening alone can’t explain such a large increase in a “genetic” disease. Thus, to them, autism can’t possibly be due to a genetic condition. Rather, it must be due to “environment”—cough, cough, vaccines, cough cough. However, as I believe to be worth repeating, they are quite wrong in the premise behind their argument.
If there’s a single rule I’ve learned over the last few years of looking into topics such as mammography, PSA screening for prostate cancer, or ultrasound screening for thyroid cancer, it’s that whenever a mass screening program for a medical condition—any medical condition—is undertaken, more people will acquire that diagnosis—sometimes many, many more. For example, let’s look at cancer, specifically breast cancer, since that’s what I know best in medicine.
I did a talk a while back in which I addressed this very issue; so I had to look up the data. Specifically, I looked at ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS), which is a premalignant precursor of breast cancer. Basically, it’s cancerous cells that haven’t broken out of the breast ducts yet. What percentage of DCIS lesions progress to full-blown invasive cancer is not fully known, but it’s clear that some can and that some remain indolent, never endangering the life of the patient. Back in the early 1900s, DCIS was a rare diagnosis because by the time such lesions grew large enough to be a palpable mass, they almost always had become invasive cancers. (We can argue about whether only the lesions that progressed to cancer would grow large enough to produce a palpable mass or not; it’s quite possible that that’s largely the case.) Enter mammography. Now, thirty years or so after mass mammographic screening programs proliferated, DCIS is a very common diagnosis. Indeed, approximately 40% of breast cancer diagnoses are in fact DCIS. A recent study found that DCIS incidence rose from 1.87 per 100,000 in the mid-1970s to 32.5 in 2004. That’s a more than 16-fold increase over 30 years. Does anyone think that the “true” incidence of DCIS rose by 16-fold? Certainly I don’t. We have no evidence that would suggest that it increased by even two-fold. No, the increase in incidence of DCIS is nearly all due to intensive screening for cancer through the use of mammographic screening.
Think of something like hypercholesterolemia. Fifty years ago, it was an uncommon diagnosis. Changes in diagnostic criteria and screening have lead to an explosion in diagnoses, with large proportions of the population being on statins. Heck, before the 1920s doctors didn’t routinely measure systolic/diastolic blood pressure ratios; so there were few, if any, cases of hypertension because doctors weren’t looking for it. Even over the last decade, prevalence of hypertension has increased (for instance, in Canada). Perhaps a better marker for hypertension diagnoses is the percentage of adults who have been prescribed antihypertensive medications, which has skyrocketed since 1950. Of course, over that time, the definition of what constituted “hypertension” has changed markedly, to lower and lower diastolic and systolic pressures. Amusingly, various denialists lambaste such broadening of diagnostic criteria to claim that hypertension is an “engineered” epidemic, while denialists of another stripe (antivaccinationists) take advantage of the broadening of the diagnostic criteria for autism/ASDs in the 1990s to link the entirely predictable increase in ASD prevalence to their favorite bogeyman, vaccines.
Once again, definitions of medical conditions matter. They can have a huge influence on prevalence rates observed. Moreover, if you don’t look for something, you won’t find it, and if you do look for something, you will find a lot more of it than you expected. It is quite possible that that is what’s happening with autism, but such a narrative doesn’t fit into the vaccine-autism idea. The antivaccine movement needs an increasing apparent autism prevalence.
The antivaccine movement reacts
Predictably, based on the intense “preparation” by blogs like AoA, I wasn’t surprised to see that the antivaccine movement was ready to pull out the same sorts of histrionic reactions to this CDC report as it did to the CDC report two years ago. Predictably, SafeMinds denied that, well, I’ll let SafeMinds say it:
Katie Weisman of SafeMinds stated, “Broader criteria and awareness cannot account for this magnitude of increase. The federal government continues to spend millions of dollars ineffectively and ‘potentially duplicatively’ according to a recent GAO report. We need to identify environmental triggers for autism, prevent them, and develop effective treatments.”
Never forget that in anti-vaccine-speak, “environmental triggers” is a code word for vaccines. Weisman is also attacking a straw man, which is the straw man I alluded to earlier. The issue goes far beyond “broader criteria and awareness.” It involves both broader criteria and intensity of screening for developmental disorders, including ASDs. “Awareness” is too vague a term. Specifically, what likely accounts for the increased prevalence of ASDs includes a combination of broader diagnostic criteria, diagnostic substitution (i.e., conditions that formerly weren’t diagnosed as ASDs now fall under the the diagnosis of an ASD), and increased screening and concomitant availability of services.
If you don’t believe me when I say that “environmental triggers” is a code term for “vaccines,” just take a look at SafeMinds’ followup, Top Ten Things to Know about the CDC Report on Autism Prevalence. It’s a mix of self-reported weaknesses of the CDC report, such as the point that the ADDM sites were not selected to be representative of the US population and that ADDM sites change over time, making direct comparisons over time problematic. Of course, one can’t help but note that SafeMinds has no trouble assuming that the comparison between 2012 and 2014 (or 2010 and 2014) is perfectly valid, that autism prevalence really has increased 30% over two years, and that the difference couldn’t possibly be influenced by differences in ADDM sites. In any case, here come the antivaccine points:
Inaccurate Information Regarding Thimerosal Exposure: Thimerosal was not completely removed from vaccines in 2002. The concerns regarding the use of mercury (thimerosal) in infant vaccines surfaced in July of 1999 and it took several years for manufactures to alter their production process to remove or reduce thimerosal content. Vaccines that were being made during these transition years that contained thimerosal continued to be released with 2 year expiration dates, which means children in this report were still receiving thimerosal containing vaccines. Infants in high risk categories were also recommended to receive flu vaccines with mercury starting at 6 months of age and annually thereafter. In addition, the CDC Advisory Committee for Immunization Practices recommends that all pregnant women receive flu vaccines during pregnancy of which the vast majority contained mercury. The fetus accumulates mercury at higher levels than the mother and exposure to mercury during pregnancy is documented to cause neurological harm. Therefore it is impossible to report that there is no association between mercury in vaccines and autism prevalence.
The problem, of course, is that this study never said anything at all about thimerosal and autism. That’s not what it was designed to do. We have plenty of other studies that did look at that question to tell us that thimerosal in vaccines is not associated with autism. Nice straw man, though.
Of course, if it’s not thimerosal in vaccines, it must be the vaccines themselves, right? At least, so sayeth SafeMinds:
Given that the ADDM researchers had access to medical records, a valuable opportunity to evaluate immunizations, adverse reactions, and the development of autism has been ignored. We have had two decades of lost opportunities, which shows no sign of changing. The paper states,” Other topics of interest focus on socioeconomic indicators as well as perinatal risk factors such as timing of conception, weight gain during pregnancy, parental age, and interpregnancy interval.” The CDC failed to mention the many other factors which studies are showing increases autism risk, including air pollution, pesticides, proximity to toxic release sites, and medications such as acetaminophen and anti-depressants. While the CDC/HHS continue to tell the public that there is no link between vaccine injury (and exposure to mercury) and the onset of autism, a study conducted by EBCALA[3] and published in the peer-reviewed Pace Law Review confirmed that the government has compensated at least 83 families in the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program whose child suffered a vaccine induced brain injury resulting in the onset of autism.
In other words, SafeMinds is criticizing the CDC for not examining the hypothesis that they want the CDC to examine, a hypothesis that has been thoroughly discredited, citing a highly dubious “study” by a lawyer about legal claims whose conclusions were easily refuted and which was unethically carried out without institutional review board approval.
Meanwhile, AoA ramped up the nonsense with a series of truly silly Facebook memes. Perhaps the silliest of them all is this one:
To this, I reply, using my own specialty as an example: How could doctors in the 1970s have missed so many cases of DCIS? How could doctors in the 1950s have thought that the best treatment for breast cancer was a radical mastectomy? How could doctors in the 1960s not have realized how useful chemotherapy was for certain cancers? Medical science advances. The way I treat breast cancer now is actually significantly different than what I did 15 years ago, and how I treat it as my career is near to winding up in 15 years will likely be significantly different from how I do it now. The same is increasingly true of how it is diagnosed and characterized, given the rapid development of molecular medicine techniques being used to characterize tumors. Compared to 15 years ago when they did, today most women don’t have all the lymph nodes under their arms removed. Lots of them have chemotherapy first instead of after surgery. We do fewer mastectomies. There are new, targeted therapies. We can predict better who does and doesn’t need chemotherapy. For instance, as recently as ten years ago, a lot of women with node-negative estrogen receptor-positive cancers got chemotherapy based solely on the size of their tumors. Now, thanks to a 21-gene assay, we can much more accurately separate the women with such tumors not likely to benefit from chemotherapy from those who are and treat each accordingly.
My god, man! Those oncologists ten years ago must have been a bunch of idiots to have subjected so many women so unlikely to benefit to such toxic chemotherapy!
See what I’m getting at?
Of course, I love that scene from Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home, but, even as amusing as it is, it still annoys me to some extent, and that’s the assumption that doctors practicing in the past were somehow less intelligent, more ignorant, or even somehow “barbaric,” simply because they used techniques that we now know today to be inferior to what we have now. Doctors do the best they can with the medical and scientific knowledge of the times. The reason we still use chemotherapy, for instance, is because we haven’t (yet) found something that works better with lower toxicity.
The way we diagnose autism now and how we screen for it is different than it was 20 or 30 years ago, and arguably our understanding of it has greatly improved. That the autism prevalence rate from 10 or 20 years ago was much lower than it is now has nothing to do with pediatricians from 20 years ago being “a bunch of idiots” who “missed” so many autism diagnoses. It’s just that our understanding of autism and ASDs has evolved, as is the case with many medical conditions. Lots of what I learned in medical school 26 years ago is now obsolete. Lots of what I learned in residency 18 years ago is obsolete. Lots of what I learned in fellowship 15 years ago is now obsolete. Medical science advances and evolves, and physicians have to be continually learning to evolve with it. People who make arguments like this assume that all autism is the most serious kind, with obvious flapping, stimming, and other behaviors that define the most severe cases of the condition. Diagnostic criteria have broadened markedly since then.
Contrary to the hysteria over the numbers coming from the antivaccine crowd and, I should add, the rather clueless reporting that I’ve seen that stops at mentioning the 30% increase in ASD prevalence over two years and doesn’t delve into the nuances, these numbers do not represent a crisis. They do not represent evidence in support of a link between vaccines in autism. They don’t even really suggest a link between environment and autism. That’s not what this study was intended to do. What they do mean is that medicine is getting better at defining what autism is and diagnosing it and that there is still a ways to go, particularly in underserved communities and among underserved minorities. That’s why I agree with Shannon Des Roches Rosa. It’s time to keep calm and think critically, something antivaccinationists are unable or unwilling to do.
Now I just wonder if in 2016, I’ll have to do another post entitled Autism prevalence: Now estimated to be one in [insert next CDC report’s number here], and the antivaccine movement goes wild.

Autism prevalence increases to 1 in 59, and antivaxers lose it…yet again
Autism Awareness Month isn’t as full of news stories about autism with false balance between science and antivaccine pseudoscience advocates as it was in years past. Every few years, though, when new autism prevalence figures are released, we can count on antivaxers losing it. 2018 is just such a year.
David Gorski on April 30, 2018
Link
It’s odd to me that it’s already the last day of April and somehow I haven’t written about autism or the antivaccine movement. In a way, that omission strikes me as a good thing, not because I don’t still care about these topics intensely. Rather, it’s a reflection of a salutary change I’ve perceived over the last several years that makes making a big deal about the antivaccine movement around April 1 less necessary than I once believed it to be. Back in the old days (say, 2005-2010, which encompass the days before Science-Based Medicine was founded, when my only blog outlet was my personal blog), I dreaded April 1. No, I didn’t dread it because of the lame April Fools jokes and articles that that date inevitably brings every year. Rather, I dreaded it because it was the first day of Autism Awareness Month and I knew that the antivaccine movement would go into overdrive to promote the scientifically discredited idea that vaccines cause autism, as well as the myriad forms of antivaccine quackery that flow from antivaccine pseudoscience. I also knew that, inevitably, the press would be full of stories about autism riddled with false balance between science and the fringe views of antivaxers. Indeed, mainly on my not-so-secret other blog, I lost track of the number of examples of journalistic false balance I’ve written about, not just in April but year round.
Beginning around 2010 or 2011, though, the yearly ritual of deconstructing horrible media stories chock full of false balance became less frequent. I attribute this decline mainly to the full revelation of the scientific fraud committed by Andrew Wakefield, the man who, more than anyone else, was responsible for launching the modern day fear of the MMR (measles-mumps-rubella) vaccine as a cause of autism, pseudoscience that has had horrific consequences in terms of MMR uptake and has had pernicious effects even 20 years later, with massive measles outbreaks ongoing in Europe. It was in 2010 that the UK General Medical Council stripped him of his medical license and his 1998 Lancet case series was retracted. Soon after, he was fired from his position as medical director of Thoughtful House, a quack “autism biomed” clinic and ended up declining to the point where he was a featured speaker on a conspiracy cruise, although, sadly, last year he was the featured subject of a documentary that, by “not taking sides,” took his side. Worse, for the last two years he’s been riding high in the antivaccine underground, thanks to his antivaccine propaganda film VAXXED. As a result, referring to Andrew Wakefield’s “discredited research” and scientific fraud has become a shorthand to dismiss the antivaccine movement, and that’s how many stories these days dismiss the antivaccine movement. I wish that realization that antivaccine pseudoscience is not worthy of being mentioned for “balance” had come about as a result of science rather than Wakefield’s disgrace, but pro-science advocates take their small victories where they can get them.
One thing that does still happen every two or three years during Autism Awareness Month that can still require a response from science-based medicine advocates, however, is the CDC’s report on the prevalence of autism, which has been rising steadily for the last couple of decades. So it was on Thursday that the CDC issued a press release, “Autism prevalence slightly higher in CDC’s ADDM Network“, about its report, Prevalence of Autism Spectrum Disorder Among Children Aged 8 Years — Autism and Developmental Disabilities Monitoring Network, 11 Sites, United States, 2014. Not surprisingly, the antivaccine movement pounced on this report, which showed a modest increase in prevalence since the last CDC report in 2016, as proof that it must be the vaccines, because to antivaxers it’s always—always—about the vaccines. But is it? Of course not. However, as usual, unpacking the data is far more complicated than antivaxers like to make it sound.
The CDC report on autism prevalence – 2018
Before discussing the CDC report’s findings, it’s important to recap what the Autism and Developmental Disabilities Monitoring (ADDM) Network is, as it’s been a few years since I’ve written about its results. In brief, the Children’s Health Act authorized the CDC to monitor the prevalence of autism spectrum disorder (ASD) in multiple areas of the United States, a charge that led to the formation of the ADDM Network in 2000. The CDC notes that since that time it has funded grantees in 16 states, tracks ASD in metropolitan Atlanta, and represents the Georgia site collaborating with competitively funded sites to form the ADDM Network.
The goals of the ADDM are:
    • To provide descriptive data on classification and functioning of the population of children with ASD.
    • To monitor the prevalence of ASD in different areas of the United States.
    • To understand the impact of ASD in U.S. communities.
To accomplish these goals, the CDC set up the ADDM as an active surveillance system that provides estimates of the prevalence of ASD among children aged 8 years whose parents or guardians reside within 11 ADDM sites in the United States (Arizona, Arkansas, Colorado, Georgia, Maryland, Minnesota, Missouri, New Jersey, North Carolina, Tennessee, and Wisconsin), as well as other characteristics, of children aged eight years whose parents live in the ADDM sites. This age was chosen because the baseline ASD prevalence study conducted by the Metropolitan Atlanta Developmental Disabilities Surveillance Program (MADDSP) suggested that this is the age of peak prevalence. The ADDM is the largest population-based program to monitor autism (with more than 325,000 children in the sites under surveillance, or 8% of the US population aged 8 in 2014) and the only autism tracking system that examines health and education records. In other words, in the world of autism, the ADDM is a Big Deal, as are the periodic CDC reports on the data from the network.
Here is how the ADDM ascertains cases:
ADDM is an active surveillance system that does not depend on family or practitioner reporting of an existing ASD diagnosis or classification to determine ASD case status. ADDM staff conduct surveillance to determine case status in a two-phase process. The first phase of ADDM involves review and abstraction of children’s evaluation records from data sources in the community. In the second phase, all abstracted evaluations for each child are compiled in chronological order into a comprehensive record that is reviewed by one or more experienced clinicians to determine the child’s ASD case status. Developmental assessments completed by a wide range of health and education providers are reviewed. Data sources are categorized as either 1) education source type, including evaluations to determine eligibility for special education services or 2) health source type, including diagnostic and developmental assessments from psychologists, neurologists, developmental pediatricians, child psychiatrists, physical therapists, occupational therapists, and speech/language pathologists. Agreements to access records are made at the institutional level in the form of contracts, memoranda, or other formal agreements.
It’s actually far more complex than that. For instance, certain education and health records were missing for certain children, including records that could not be located or whose retrieval would be impractical or too costly; so sensitivity analyses had to be carried out to determine whether these missing records would have an effect on case ascertainment. Another example includes the statistical tests that need to be done to provide confidence intervals and to determine prevalences in different racial groups. A total of 53,120 records for 42,644 children were reviewed from health and education sources. Of these, the records of 10,886 children met the criteria for abstraction. This represented 25.5% of the total number of children whose source records were reviewed and 3.3% of the population under surveillance. Of the records reviewed by clinicians, 5,473 children met the ASD surveillance case definition.
The 2018 report covers the year 2014, which includes the cohort born in 2006. Its key findings include that:
    • Autism prevalence has increased to 16.8 per 1,000 (one in 59) children aged 8 years
    • Estimated prevalence of ASD was highest in New Jersey (29.3 per 1,000 or 1 in 34.1) compared to each of the other ten sites
    • ASD prevalence was 26.6 per 1,000 boys (one in 37.6) and 6.6 per 1,000 girls (one in 151), for a prevalence ratio of 4.0.
    • Male-to-female prevalence ratios ranged from 3.2 (Arizona) to 4.9 (Georgia)
    • Estimated prevalence among white children (17.2 per 1,000) was 7% greater than that among black children (16.0 per 1,000)
    • Estimated prevalence among white children was 22% greater than that among Hispanic children (14.0 per 1,000)
    • Estimates for Asian/Pacific Islander children ranged from 7.9 per 1,000 (Colorado) to 19.2 per 1,000 (New Jersey) with wide confidence intervals.
The accompanying press release notes:
The latest estimate of 1.7 percent (1 in 59) is higher than the previous ADDM estimate released in 2016, which found a prevalence of 1.5 percent or 1 in 68 children. Some of the change in prevalence could be due to improved autism identification in minority populations – although autism is still more likely to be identified in white children than in black or Hispanic children. This identification is important, because children identified early with autism and connected to services are more likely to reach their fullest potential.
“Autism prevalence among black and Hispanic children is approaching that of white children,” said Stuart Shapira, M.D., Ph.D., associate director for science at CDC’s National Center on Birth Defects and Developmental Disabilities. “The higher number of black and Hispanic children now being identified with autism could be due to more effective outreach in minority communities and increased efforts to have all children screened for autism so they can get the services they need.”
So, basically, ASD prevalence increased approximately 20% from 2012 to 2014. However, autism identification in minorities like African-Americans and Hispanics is improving, although it is diagnosed more frequently in white children.
There are, of course, several weaknesses with the ADDM estimates, as is the case with all large epidemiological studies. First, the areas that the ADDM covers are not necessarily representative of the rest of the US, and even the areas chosen in each ADDM area are not necessarily representative of the state as a whole. There are also limitations in the medical and educational records in terms of the information available. For instance, some children might have had earlier diagnoses that were not recorded in the records examined. Finally, comparisons with results from earlier ADDM surveillance years were not always restricted to a common geographic area, which led the authors to point out that “inferences about the changing number and characteristics of children with ASD over time should be made with caution” and that “although study methods and geographic areas of coverage have remained generally consistent over time, temporal comparisons are subject to multiple sources of bias and should not be misinterpreted as representing precise measures that control for all sources of bias.” In other words, when the increase in autism prevalence is modest, as it is in this report, one must interpret the data with caution, as there might in fact be significant less (or more) of an increase than is reported.
The bottom line is that, as has been observed in previous reports, this year’s CDC estimate for autism prevalence based on the ADDM has increased, albeit modestly. For instance, in 2012, the estimate of ASD prevalence in the year 2008 was 11.3 per 1,000 (one in 88), and in 2014 the estimate for 2010 was 14.7 per 1,000 (1 in 68). This increase really shouldn’t be too surprising, as it has been widely believed that autism diagnoses have been underreported for a long time. Likely we’re catching up and getting closer to the “true” prevalence of the condition. But what does this all mean? First, I’ll discuss what it doesn’t mean.
Antivaccine groups react
In 2016, as in 2014, as in 2012, as in 2010 (and, I’m sure, but don’t remember) every two years going back to the beginning of the ADDM, when the CDC reported its estimate for autism prevalence, the antivaccine movement tried its very best to blame vaccines. I noticed something different in 2018. For once, nowhere in the press releases from the usual antivaccine suspects were vaccines explicitly mentioned. (Oddly enough, even the first post by the antivaccine blog Age of Autism mentioning the study that didn’t just regurgitate another blog’s post doesn’t mention vaccines, although the commenters immediately did.) For instance, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s World Mercury Project (a group dedicated to fear mongering over mercury in vaccines as a cause of autism and health problems) didn’t mention vaccines once in its post CDC Still Paralyzed by Autism Epidemic: Report Shows One in 59 Children in the US Now Affected:
Yesterday, the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) released the latest autism spectrum disorder (ASD) prevalence estimate from its Autism and Developmental Disabilities (ADDM) network. Among children born in 2006, in the 11 states included in the report, ASD prevalence at age eight was one in 59 children. In the early 1980s, only 35 years ago, the rate of autism was about one in 5000. That means that autism is about 85 times more common in today’s middle schoolers than it was in their parents. That is why nobody who grew up back then knew a child with autism but today everyone does.
The CDC report might as well be saying that one in 59 children has a hangnail for all the concern CDC expresses, when in fact, this is a public health disaster that will have repercussions for generations. At what point is the CDC going to admit that this disaster requires action? The largest amount by far of research dollars spent on determining causation has been directed towards genetics. “Genes don’t cause epidemics, environmental toxins do,” said World Mercury Project chair Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. “Why is the CDC doing nothing to identify the environmental toxins responsible for the most cataclysmic epidemic of our era?”
Even though vaccines are not mentioned, the above is a common antivaccine trope, particularly the part about how nobody who “grew up back then” knew a child with autism. In that, I like to point out that I took care of teens with autism when I worked in a group home one summer back in the early 1980s. I also like to point out that “environmental toxins” is antivaccine code for—you guessed it!—vaccines. To be fair, antivaxers don’t limit themselves only to vaccines as a potential cause of autism, but, make no mistake, any list of “environmental toxins” produced by antivaxers as causes for autism in essence consists of twenty entries of “vaccines” (or thimerosal), followed by everything else. Also in fairness, I actually do agree with the World Mercury Project that the US doesn’t spend enough on autism research. More importantly, the government doesn’t spend enough on autism services. None of that means that vaccines cause autism.
Elsewhere, Talk About Curing Autism (TACA), a group that promotes the idea that vaccines cause autism, as well as advocates dubious “biomedical” treatments (i.e., quackery) to “cure” autism notes:
The increase in prevalence rate cannot be explained by better diagnosis alone. Some have suggested that autism is just being better diagnosed today versus years ago and that many cases of intellectual disability are now being coded as autism. This would also assume that the experts diagnosing autism before did not know what they were doing. This is NOT TRUE. Autism is the only disorder dramatically on the rise while mental retardation or intellectual disability, Down syndrome and cystic fibrosis remain relatively the same.
It’s a common straw man argument that misrepresents the actual arguments being made as to how the “true” prevalence of autism probably hasn’t changed much in decades but diagnoses of autism have increased dramatically to use terms like “better diagnosis.” What is really meant is increased screening. I’ll return to an example I use so often: ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS), a form of breast cancer. Well, actually, whether it’s really cancer or not is debatable, but it can clearly often be a precursor to cancer, although the percentage of DCIS lesions that progress to cancer isn’t precisely known. Be that as it may, before 1975 DCIS was a very uncommon diagnosis. Now it is very common. Indeed, back in the early 1900s, DCIS was rare because by the time it grew large enough to be a palpable mass, it almost always had become invasive cancer. Now, nearly forty years after mass mammographic screening programs became prevalent, DCIS is a common diagnosis. Indeed, approximately 40% of breast cancer diagnoses are DCIS, and a recent study found that DCIS incidence rose from 1.87 per 100,000 in the mid-1970s to 32.5 in 2004. That’s a more than 16-fold increase over a 30 year period, and it’s pretty much all due to the introduction of mammographic screening. This sort of thing should not be surprising to doctors, but apparently sometimes it is.
Unlike the case for autism, the diagnostic criteria for DCIS remained pretty stable over that 30 year period. Pathologists in the 1970s and pathologists in the 2000s would likely agree on what constitutes DCIS, which makes it particularly striking how, if you look for a disease or medical condition more intensely, you will always find more of it—often a lot more. Always. If this principle works for something that is diagnosed by an objective test, namely a biopsy, how much more so is it likely to be for a condition that has no unequivocal biochemical or tissue test to nail down the diagnosis, like autism, particularly for a condition whose diagnostic criteria has changed considerably over the last 25 years to be more inclusive? This brings up diagnostic substitution, in which diseases or conditions are classified differently now than they were 30 years ago, such that, for example, some children who might have been classified as mentally retarded 30 years ago receive an ASD diagnosis now. There is actually a fair amount of evidence for such a phenomenon, in which the decrease in diagnoses of intellectual disability are nearly completely offset by the increase in diagnoses of ASDs. There’s also the issue of whether we’re discussing administrative prevalence (diagnosis from school records of children receiving services) versus medical diagnoses of autism. (Hint: The two aren’t the same, and administrative prevalence is often higher, because the diagnosis of ASD is a basis for school-based services.)
None of this means that doctors 30 years ago didn’t know what they were doing. Diagnostic criteria were different, and there were nowhere near the resources in schools to identify potential cases.
A 13-year old “has more of a clue” than the CDC
None of this stopped the antivaccine propaganda blog Age of Autism from publishing a post by Cathy Jameson in which she uses her thirteen year old boy as an example of someone who “sees what experts can’t”:
Willem matter-of-factly added, “Well, we know what causes autism.”
Glancing back at his brother, I said, “Yep. We do,” and then added, “And you know what, Willem?”
“What, mom?” he asked.
“You know a heck of a lot more than some adults do,” I said proudly.
He said, “That’s good…but that’s kinda sad too, you know.”
“I know,” I told him. “It’s actually a little pathetic. Not about you knowing more – that’s going to help as you and brother get older. But the other people? It’s ridiculous how they’ve mislead the public about the rise in autism and what we know to be a cause of it.”
Looking back at his sisters, he said, “Yeah, they’d rather we celebrate it than make it stop.”
“Yep. That’s called turning a blind eye,” I said, “and I have a feeling that’ll continue to happen.”
He agreed.
Willem’s an insider looking out at what the world refuses to see—that vaccines can result in autism and that autism is here to stay. Since he knows that and since he sees the real-live struggle his brother lives through daily because of autism, he has every right to feel as frustrated as I do.
My 13 year-old has more of a clue than our paid government ‘experts’ do. If they ever fully understood just how much of a crisis autism is, I’d hope that the public would begin to pitch in a little bit more than know to do now.
Meanwhile, a website that is so extreme as to border on fake news, Big League Politics, is claiming that there was some sort of controversy and cover-up in the CDC that delayed the release of the report. The site claims that, rather than using the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition, Text Revision (DSM-IV-TR), the 2018 report was going to use DSM-5, the newest version, which changes the diagnostic criteria for ASD. Of course, a clear reading of the text of the report shows that this is not the case and that the DSM-IV-TR served as the basis for case ascertainment. It is, however, true that the CDC does plan to phase out the use of the DSM-IV-TR with the 2016 numbers, to be published in 2020, but that’s only appropriate, given that the DSM-5 was released in 2013. I can see an argument for using the DSM-IV-TR for 2014 for the last time, but beyond that I have a hard time justifying it. Of course, antivaxers will likely argue that the change is being made to mask increases in autism prevalence, particularly if autism prevalence doesn’t continue its upward trend when the 2016 prevalence is published in 2020.
The autism epidemic that isn’t
One of the central narratives of the antivaccine movement is that we are in the midst of an “autism epidemic,” which I’ve sometimes heard called an “autism tsunami.” This narrative is essential to the idea that vaccines cause autism because of the expansion of the vaccine schedule in the 1990s that antivaxers blame for the “epidemic” that’s occurred over the last 25 years. Basically, no autism epidemic, no vaccine causation. Antivaxers know this. Unfortunately, what they either don’t know or refuse to acknowledge is that an increase in diagnoses of a condition is not necessarily the same thing as a true increase in prevalence. An increase in diagnoses without a true increase in prevalence (on a biological basis) can occur through, for example, changing of the diagnostic criteria over time or increased screening. My favorite example of the latter is, of course, DCIS, but there are others. For example, increased screening with ultrasound has led to a massive increase in the number of diagnoses of thyroid cancer, the vast majority of which are almost certainly overdiagnosis. Actually, there are issues with changing criteria for the diagnosis of thyroid cancer too. Indeed, diseases for which the prevalence is increasing often involve both increased screening and changes in the diagnostic criteria.
Another example is hypertension. Before the 1920s doctors didn’t routinely measure systolic/diastolic blood pressure ratios; so there were few, if any, cases of hypertension because doctors weren’t looking for it and didn’t know how to easily measure it. Even over the last decade, prevalence of hypertension has increased (for instance, in Canada). Perhaps a better marker for hypertension diagnoses is the percentage of adults who have been prescribed antihypertensive medications, which has skyrocketed since 1950. Of course, over that time, the definition of what constituted “hypertension” has changed markedly, to lower and lower diastolic and systolic pressures, as evidence showed that treating lower blood pressures could prevent premature death, although that trend appears to have leveled off. Amusingly, various denialists lambaste such broadening of diagnostic criteria to claim that hypertension is an “engineered” epidemic. And don’t even get me started on hypercholesterolemia.
So is the increase in autism prevalence “real” (as in an increase in the frequency of the neurobiological entity known as autism in the population) or is it an artifact of increased screening for school services, widening diagnostic criteria, and diagnostic substitution? There’s actually a fair amount of evidence that “true” autism prevalence has been fairly steady for decades. In other words, definitions of medical conditions matter. They can have a huge influence on prevalence rates observed. Moreover, if you don’t look for something, you won’t find it, and if you do look for something, you will find a lot more of it than you expected. It is quite possible that that is what’s happening with autism, but such a narrative doesn’t fit into the vaccine-autism idea. The antivaccine movement needs an increasing apparent-autism prevalence. If there’s no “autism epidemic,” there’s no way that vaccines cause autism. Over the years, there has been quite a bit of evidence that the “true” prevalence of autism has been fairly stable for quite some time. For instance, one study examined autism prevalence using stable diagnostic criteria between 1990 and 2010 and found “no clear evidence of a change in prevalence for autistic disorder or other ASDs between 1990 and 2010. Worldwide, there was little regional variation in the prevalence of ASDs.” Steve Novella has summarized several of these studies.
About a year ago, I took note of a new study out of Australia looking at the same criteria. It basically relies on one of my favorite sayings, namely that the harder you look for a medical condition the more of it you will find. Actually, it uses a corollary of that maxim, namely that, when you look for a condition and diagnose more of it (i.e., cause its apparent prevalence to increase), many of those cases will be milder cases. So, just as mammographic screening led to an increase in diagnosis of smaller tumors and premalignant DCIS, screening for prostate cancer led to milder cases of prostate cancer being diagnosed, and screening for hypertension led to milder cases of hypertension being diagnosed, if the increase in prevalence in autism is due to the broadening of the diagnostic criteria plus increased screening, we’d expect that the average severity of cases diagnosed would decline with time.
None of this rules out an increase in the “true” prevalence of autism over the last few decades, but the increasing consensus is that the evidence does rule out a massive increase. What is most likely happening is that we’re getting better and better at finding and diagnosing autism, including milder cases, to the point where the apparent prevalence of autism (i.e, the number of diagnoses) is starting to converge on the “true” biological prevalence of autism as it is defined today.

Latest Autism Data
Steven Novella on February 11, 2026
Link

In April of 2025, HHS secretary RFK Jr. stated:
“The autism epidemic is running rampant,” said U.S. Health and Human Services (HHS) Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. “One in 31 American children born in 2014 are disabled by autism. That’s up significantly from two years earlier and nearly five times higher than when the CDC first started running autism surveys in children born in 1992. Prevalence for boys is an astounding 1 in 20 and in California it’s 1 in 12.5.”
This remains the official position of the HHS and is stated on their website. RFK went on to describe how devastating autism is, saying that:
“These are kids who will never pay taxes, they’ll never hold a job, they’ll never play baseball, they’ll never write a poem, they’ll never go out on a date. Many of them will never use a toilet unassisted.”
The problem is – he is making a basic error, which is shocking for someone in his position and the resources that come with it. RFK is using data for autism spectrum disorder (ASD) as if it applies to people with profound autism. These are, however, clearly two distinct entities, even though they are both classified under the broad umbrella of “autism.”
Profound autism refers to people who are non-verbal, minimally verbal, or who have an IQ <50. In other words, they have profound intellectual disability, and by any reasonable definition are disabled. A 2023 study found that 26.7% of 8-year olds with ASD had profound autism, which means that 73.3% did not. Many of those with non-profound ASD have subtle manifestations only, are not disabled, and lead productive lives. Many of them consider themselves to be “neurodiverse”, with a different set of strengths and weaknesses from those who are more neurotypical. Some may still need some services and accommodations, but that hardly makes them “disabled”.
Anti-vaxxers like RFK Jr have been using the increasing number of children identified with autism (which is the accurate way to refer to such statistics) to raise the alarm about an “autism epidemic”. However, as we have documented here many times, there is no reason to conclude that there is an actual autism epidemic – it does not exist.
What the data show is that over the last 30 years there are at least three factors that contribute to an increase in the number diagnosed, even without a true increase in incidence. First, the definition has been broadened (hence the term “spectrum”), and has absorbed other diagnoses, such as Aspergers Syndrome and pervasive developmental delay. Sometimes this is referred to as diagnostic substitution.
Second, surveillance efforts have increased dramatically. More children are getting formal testing for autism, for example. Autism diagnoses also tend to follow the availability of services for children with autism. Generally speaking, if you look for something more, you will find it more.
Further, having an autism diagnosis is now considered much more socially acceptable, with less associated stigma, than in the past. This correlates with greater community awareness of the diagnosis and the services available. The bottom line is that 30 years ago many children who today would be diagnosed with ASD would have just been considered “odd”, not formally tested, not identified or diagnosed, and not provided any services or accommodations. Many others would have been given alternate diagnoses. These factors combined are capable of explaining the rise in autism diagnoses. In other words – there is no true epidemic.
If we focus on profound autism we see a different picture. There has been some diagnostic substitution, with many non-specific disorders now categorized under the autism umbrella, but the other factors have not been as significant. As a result, the incidence of profound autism has increased much less than ASD as a whole. According to one recent study:
“In 2000, about 27 of every 10,000 children within the network had profound autism, and 39 in 10,000 had non-profound autism, the team found. And although prevalence increased for both groups over the next 16 years, that of non-profound autism did so more rapidly — reaching 143 per 10,000, compared with 46 per 10,000 for profound autism.”
The demographics of profound autism are also different than non-profound ASD. ASD has generally been considered a diagnosis of white boys, but this is partly an artifact of how the diagnosis is made. ASD is about three times more common in boys than girls, but this has lead to many girls being underdiagnosed, and the disparity has narrowed as the diagnosis has increased. Similarly, the diagnosis has increased more dramatically in minority populations, suggesting that they were previously more underdiagnosed than white populations.
By contrast, profound autism is more common in certain minority populations, and more common in girls, it is associated with lower socio-economic status (unlike ASD) and neurological conditions such as seizures. It really seems to be a different entity from ASD. What more subtle rise we have seen in profound autism can likely be explained by greater awareness and diagnostic efforts in previously underserved minority populations, where the diagnosis is more common.
With all this data in mind the incredible deception of RFK Jr. comes more clearly into focus. He is claiming an autism epidemic (which itself is not real) based on data for non-profound ASD, and then talks as if this data applies to profound autism, which it does not. He then promised to find the root cause of his imaginary epidemic – by September of 2025. Remember that?
Of course, this pledge was based on his faulty understanding of what autism is, and his false assumption, amounting to a conspiracy theory, that the true cause is environmental. He had nothing, so he had to invent some cause so he could claim victory. That is where the “Tylenol causes autism” claim came from, but this is also not based on science.


   The Early Course of Autism
Steven Novella
Link
Understanding the natural history of a disease is an important framework to have. It not only is critical for prognosis, but also informs us about diagnostic and screening strategies, is important to assessing interventions, and provides clues to causation.
There has been much debate about the early course of autism, specifically the earliest age at which autism may be detected. At present scientific evidence suggests that autism is dominantly genetic, and so researchers expect that there may be early signs of autism even in infancy. Traditionally, however, autism is not diagnosed until age 2-3, when parents bring their children to medical attention, or when signs are detected on routine well-child visits or in day-care.
Retrospective studies, largely involving review of home movies, have suggested that autism can be diagnosed as early as 6-12 months, suggesting that parental report is not an adequate screen because subtle signs are hard to detect without rigorous observation.
Now a group has published the first prospective study to address this question. They followed 25 children who were later diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) (22 of which were high risk) and 25 low risk children who were later determined to have typical development (TD). They found:
These results suggest that behavioral signs of autism are not present at birth, as once suggested by Kanner, but emerge over time through a process of diminishment of key social communication behaviors. More children may present with a regressive course than previously thought, but parent report methods do not capture this phenomenon well. Implications for onset classification systems and clinical screening are also discussed.
More precisely, they carefully assessed the children, counting instances of eye contact and smiling, for example, and found that there were no statistically significant differences between the groups at 6 months, but that almost all measures were reduced in the ASD group by 12 months.
The study is rigorously designed, and its primary weakness is that it is a bit small. The authors also acknowledge that future studies should utilize longer periods of recorded observation. I would add that more frequent assessments between 6 and 12 months would help specify when the earliest divergence takes place. Replication of the study is therefore desirable.
But what these results indicate is that clear signs of autism emerge between 6 and 12 months of age. Further, social skills tend to be regressive in ASD between 6 and 18 months of age. It was previously thought that social regression was less common in ASD, but this study suggests it is the rule, not the exception. Meanwhile, language skills did not regress in this study, they continued to improve in the ASD group, just on a slower curve than the TD group.
Further the study documented that the parents generally did not recognize the social regression between 6 and 18 months. The authors refer to the well-known phenomenon of telescoping in which patients or family members will recall the onset of symptoms as being much more recent than they actually were.
Prior studies using home movies have shown that signs of autism can be detected between 8-12 months. A study looking at head circumference found statistical differences prior to 12 months. And one study looking at movements found differences between 4-6 months. So it seems the consensus of current evidence is that objective and detectable signs of autism emerge between 6-12 months. This study does not support detection prior to 6 months, but other studies do suggest this might be possible.
This study has implications for diagnostic categories of autism (specifically distinguishing regressive forms of autism from non-regressive forms, since most of the ASD children in this study showed social regression). It also is very informative regarding screening strategies. It suggests no utility to screening children prior to 6 months of age. Further, since ASD children continued to separate from TD children through 3 years of age, screening for ASD should not stop at 2 but continue to at least 3.
The authors, however, do not discuss one very significant implication of this study (although an implication already raised by prior studies demonstrating early signs of ASD) – the observation made by many parents that ASD symptom onset correlates with certain vaccinations. Many children are diagnosed between the age of 2 and 3, during the height of the childhood vaccine schedule. This lends itself to the assumption of correlation and causation on the part of some parents. The phenomenon of telescoping, whereby memories of time contract, will tend to reinforce this false correlation.
What this and other studies show is that not only is the assumption of causation fallacious, the observation of correlation is likely flawed as well. The true onset of autism in most ASD children likely began a year or two prior to the vaccines that are blamed as the cause.
This point was made most dramatically by the Cedillo case – one of the test cases brought before the Autism Omnibus court alleging vaccine injury causing autism. Cedillo’s parents alleged that their child developed autism as a result of a combination of the MMR vaccine and thimerosal from other vaccines. In courtroom testimony, however, experts were able to show with home movies that Cedillo showed clear signs of autism as an infant, prior to ever receiving the MMR vaccine.
The current study adds nicely to the growing consensus that the true clinical onset of ASD is between 6 and 12 months of age. Whether or not there are biological markers of ASD prior to that remains to be seen, but is not unlikely. Early and fairly uniform onset is consistent with genetic causes of ASD, rather than environmental causes.
Addendum:
As several commenters have pointed out, I erred when I wrote that “Many children are diagnosed between the age of 2 and 3, during the height of the childhood vaccine schedule.” What I meant to convey was that this time period is still within the childhood vaccine schedule, and therefore it is likely that when parents first notice the signs of autism their child would have been recently vaccinated by chance alone. The point remains, however, that many parents blame their children’s autism on vaccines they received after the true onset of symptoms.
Here I was thinking primarily of the MMR vaccine, the first to be blamed for autism (thanks to Andrew Wakefield). As you can see from the vaccine schedule, the first MMR vaccine in the series is scheduled for 12 months – after most children already have detectable signs of autism. This is why I used the Cedillo case to reflect this point.

   Social Factors in Autism Diagnosis
Steven Novella
Link
There is no question that the incidence and prevalence of autism are on the rise. Starting in the early 1990s and continuing to today, there has been a steady rise in the number of children diagnosed with autism. Prior to 1990 the estimates of autism prevalence were about 3 per 10,000. The most recent estimates from the CDC and elsewhere now have the number at about 100 per 10,000, or 1%.
The burning question is – why are the rates increasing steadily? There are those, particularly in the anti-vaccine community, who conclude that the increase in prevalence is a real biological effect – an epidemic – and is evidence for an environmental cause (which they believe is vaccines, even though the scientific evidence does not support this position). However, the evidence strongly suggests that the rising prevalence of autism is largely an artifact of broadening the diagnosis and increased surveillance.
It should be noted that the data cannot rule out a small true increase in autism prevalence. Some hypothesize that increasing maternal and paternal age are contributing to the incidence of autism, but I will leave that question for another post.
A new study now adds significant support to the surveillance hypothesis – Ka‐Yuet Liu, Marissa King, and Peter S. Bearman from Columbia University, publishing in the American Journal of Sociology, report that the risk of being diagnosed with an autism spectrum disorder (ASD) correlates with social proximity to another family with a child with an ASD diagnosis. For those interested in this topic, the full paper is worth a read. While it gets technical at times, the authors do an excellent job of reviewing this topic in detail.
To summarize their key points – they begin by reviewing the history of the autism diagnosis. They point out that historically, in the 1950s and 60s, the diagnosis of autism was stigmatized by psychogenic theories of causation (the infamous “refrigerator mothers”). But then:
With hindsight, we can recognize that autism was increasingly destigmatized through the mobilization efforts of Bernard Rimland and the National Society for Autistic Children (NSAC), whose work refuted psychogenic theories of autism and set the stage for the research program that would identify autism as a neurological disorder (Dolnick 1998).
Therefore, prior to the 1970s parents actually mobilized their resources to avoid an autism diagnosis, and instead to seek a diagnosis of mental retardation (MR). This was not only to avoid stigma – the diagnosis of MR was attached to more public resources, while autism was left out in the cold. Then, this situation began to flip. Increasingly after 1990 ASD lost its stigma and became increasingly attached to access to public resources. Parents then began marshaling their resources to obtain an ASD diagnosis, rather than an MR diagnosis.
Liu et al discuss that this interpretation of the history of ASD makes a number of predictions, and they sought to test those predictions. They are not the first to do so, and others have demonstrated (which they review) that as ASD diagnoses increased there was diagnostic substitution – other related diagnoses, such as MR, decreased. Autism prevalence has increased uniformly in all age groups. If an environmental cause was at work, younger age groups should have disproportionately increased. When the same diagnostic criteria are applied autism incidence is largely stable over time. Increasing caseloads of ASD correlate with times when the diagnostic criteria are expanded.
The study authors now go further – looking at the pattern of ASD diagnoses sociologically. They hypothesized that if the increasing rate of ASD is due to sociological, rather than biological, factors then proximity should play a role. That is exactly what they found – a child who lives 250 meters from another child who has been diagnosed with autism is 42% more likely to be diagnosed, and if they live between 250 and 500 meters of another child, they have a 22% increased chance of being diagnosed. Basically, being close to a family with an ASD child provides access to information that allows other parents to more efficiently mobilize their resources to seek an ASD diagnosis.
This matters because obtaining an ASD diagnosis is not always easy or automatic. Many ASD children, on first presentation to a pediatrician, are not diagnosed. Some doctors are more likely to make the diagnosis than others. And school systems may delay diagnosis as well. Parents who therefore pursue a diagnosis more aggressively are more likely to get it.
Of course, an infectious agent would also spread through proximity, so they tested this possibility by looking at specific features that should differ. For example, the sociological spread hypothesis predicts that the proximity effect should be greatest at the milder end of the spectrum. More clear cut cases are likely to be diagnosed regardless of parental resources or effort, while milder cases will be highly dependent on these factors. They found that the proximity effect existed only among the milder end of the spectrum, and was absent for more severe children. They also found that the effect obeyed school districts – so proximity across a school district demarcation did not confer increased chance of having an ASD diagnosis. Further, they found that children with an ASD diagnosis had similar referral sources to other ASD children with proximity.
All of this points to the fact that parents obtain information from other parents in their neighborhood about which doctors to see, what questions to ask, and how to interface with the school system most effectively to obtain an ASD diagnosis and the increased services that come with it.
Conclusion
This study adds powerful evidence to the conclusion that the increasing incidence of autism is largely due to sociological factors rather than a true increase in the incidence of autism. This does not rule out a true increase also hiding in the data, but rather demonstrates that sociological factors are a significant contributor. This study must also be put into the context of the many other studies supporting the conclusion that the dramatic increase in ASD is due largely to increased surveillance and expanded diagnosis.
I was also not previously aware of the extent of the effect that social stigma has played. Previously parents avoided an autism diagnosis and sought an MR diagnosis, while today the situation is reversed, and the evidence shows the diagnostic substitution we would expect to be the result.
Another prediction of the sociological hypothesis is that eventually autism incidence should level off – once diagnoses are saturated. We are probably getting close to that point now.
All of this also means that scientists are justified in focusing their research efforts on characterizing the genetic risks and causes of ASD. Further, calls for a shift in emphasis to environmental causes based upon the premise that there is an autism epidemic are not valid in light of this research. This does not mean that environmental contributors should not be explored – it is often practical to cover all the bases in medical research – but a significant shift in resources is likely not justified.

   Early Intervention for Autism
Steven Novella
Link
Many parents of children with autism have expressed to me their dismay that the anti-vaccine lobby is sucking all the oxygen out of the room for autism awareness. They feel that just being a parent of a child with autism makes others assume that they are anti-vaccine. They also worry that resources and attention are being diverted from promising legitimate research because of all the attention being paid to the failed vaccine hypothesis.
So it is good to occasionally focus on mainstream autism research to show that progress is being made, despite the unfortunate anti-vaccine sideshow.
A recent study published in the latest issue of Pediatrics shows that early intervention in toddlers with autism can have significant benefits. The study is a randomized controlled trial of the Early Start Denver Model compared to conventional treatment in 18-30 month old children with a diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder (ASD). The study is a reasonable size for this kind of intervention – 48 children were randomized – and this is sufficiently powered to get statistical significance. But it should be noted this is still a smallish study and replication to confirm the results is welcome.
Another potential weakness is that the control group was “referral to community providers for intervention commonly available in the community.” Therefore the control group was not standardized and it’s possible this group was sub-optimally treated. Further, while the groups were randomized they were not blinded.
The results of the study are quite robust:
Compared with children who received community-intervention, children who received ESDM showed significant improvements in IQ, adaptive behavior, and autism diagnosis. Two years after entering intervention, the ESDM group on average improved 17.6 standard score points (1 SD: 15 points) compared with 7.0 points in the comparison group relative to baseline scores. The ESDM group maintained its rate of growth in adaptive behavior compared with a normative sample of typically developing children. In contrast, over the 2-year span, the comparison group showed greater delays in adaptive behavior. Children who received ESDM also were more likely to experience a change in diagnosis from autism to pervasive developmental disorder, not otherwise specified, than the comparison group.
The results of this study are plausible and encouraging, and hopefully will lead to further studies to confirm the results.
The concept behind ESDM is this (from the EarlyDevelopment Studies Lab website):
Autism impedes this process of child learning and adult scaffolding, in several ways. Children with autism are less attentive to other people and so miss many learning opportunities by watching. Young children with autism have impaired communication skills, so they have difficulty learning from the communications that adults provide. Young children with autism also have difficulty imitating others, and so miss opportunities to learn by copying what others do. Young children with autism may not be quite as flexible in their play skills as others, and may enjoy repeating favorite actions with objects, rather than generating new play ideas and learning through discovery, and this limits their learning. And finally, young children with autism may not find social experiences as inherently rewarding as other children, which can result in reduced time in interactions of all sorts. Since interactions are a primary learning opportunity for toddlers, fewer interactions mean fewer learning opportunities.
The ESDM is designed to make learning for young ASD toddlers more fun, dynamic, and child-directed rather than repetitive. The purpose is to compensate for the specific areas of difficulty of ASD children.
While not a “cure” if these results hold up ESDM can be a very effective early intervention for children with ASD. It highlights the potential benefit of early detection and intervention programs.
It also brings to mind the broader context (which is relevant to many neurological diseases and disorders) that at times focus on finding a cure might overshadow research and even clinical attention paid to interventions that improve quality of life and mitigate the impact of a disorder. Finding a cure is, of course, always the long term goal. But we have to be realistic in recognizing that for many complex disorders it is a very long term goal. Meanwhile there is much that can be done to significantly improve outcome, and these types of interventions should not be neglected simply because they are not a “cure.”
Patients and families need to recognize that often there is much that can be done, and they should not neglect medical attention under the false belief that “nothing can be done” simply because a cure does not exist yet. Sometimes, even clinicians need to be reminded of this fact.
Also, research priorities should reflect a reasonable balance between searching for a cure and improving outcomes in the meantime. Grassroots advocacy groups that raise funds for clinical research, in my opinion, often over-emphasize research that has the potential to find a cure in the short term, and may in fact slow overall research progress by upsetting the balance between various kinds of research (basic, therapeutic, and symptomatic).
So it is good to see a solid symptomatic trial like this one get attention, and to remind people that we can make a significant difference with science-based interventions in the lives of children with ASD, even if we don’t fully understand the disorder or know how to cure it.

A new study reinforces the conclusion that autism is primarily genetic
Last week, the largest epidemiological study of its kind was published and concluded, once again, that autism is primarily due to genes and that the environmental component of autism risk is much smaller. Not surprisingly, once again antivaxers didn’t want to hear that message.
David Gorski on July 22, 2019
Link

The key belief of the modern antivaccine movement over the last two decades has been that vaccines either cause, contribute, or predispose children to autism. Although this particular belief is generally believed to have originated in 1998 with the publication of disgraced physician and scientist Andrew Wakefield’s case series of 12 children that reported an association between vaccination with the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine and autism and was published in The Lancet , the idea predates Wakefield’s fraudulent publication. After all, a lawyer paid Wakefield handsomely to do “research” that he could use to sue vaccine manufacturers on behalf of parents of children with autism. Wakefield’s case series was ultimately retracted due to findings of scientific fraud and Wakefield’s medical license taken away, but it didn’t matter. The idea that vaccines cause autism is the most prevalent antivaccine misinformation that fuels the movement, and Wakefield still milks it, having produced with Del Bigtree an antivaccine propaganda movie disguised as a documentary, VAXXED.
The idea is not just limited to the MMR vaccine, either. Another strain of antivaccine belief attributes autism to the mercury in the thimerosal preservative that was used in many childhood vaccines until 2001, while others claim it’s “too many too soon,” and still others blame DNA fragments in vaccines crossing the blood-brain barrier and causing neuroinflammation. Many are the vaccines blamed for autism, and many are the bogus proposed biological mechanisms by which vaccines supposedly “cause autism”, but in the end it’s always about the vaccines. Always. Antivaxers deny that autism has a major genetic components, and, even when they do conceded a genetic component, try to divert to claiming that it’s a “genetic susceptibility” to “vaccine injury” that is responsible for autism, not primarily genetics.
All of this is why antivaxers generally lash out whenever a study comes out that reports a large genetic component to autism and autism spectrum disorders. This happened just last week, as the largest study of its kind, encompassing five countries and two million subjects was published last week and concluded that autism spectrum disorders are 80% reliant on inherited genes. Before I get to the study itself, here’s how it was reported in WebMD:
The findings could open new doors to research into the genetic causes of autism, which the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention now says affects 1 in every 59 U.S. children.
It might also help ease fears that autism is caused by maternal factors — a mother’s weight, mode or timing of delivery, or nutrient intake, for example. The new study found the role of maternal factors to be “nonexistent or minimal.”
Instead, “the current study results provide the strongest evidence to our knowledge to date that the majority of risk for autism spectrum disorders is from genetic factors,” said a team led by Sven Sandin, an epidemiological researcher at the Karolinska Institute in Stockholm, Sweden.
The new study might help dampen public interest in supposed — but unproven — “environmental” causes of autism, such as vaccines. Long-discredited, fraudulent data linking childhood vaccination with autism is still widely cited by the “anti-vaxxer” movement.
I fear that last part is pretty much wishful thinking. Whenever a new study provides evidence for a genetic cause of autism, antivaxers tend to double down and attack the study. Will this study withstand the attacks? Scientifically, probably (as I’ll explain in a moment), but in the vaccine PR wars? Who knows?
Genes, not environment, are the primary driver of ASDs
The study under discussion, “Association of Genetic and Environmental Factors With Autism in a 5-Country Cohort“, was published online in JAMA Psychiatry on July 17 by a multinational group of researchers led by Sven Sandin, an epidemiologist at the Karolinska Institute in Stockholm, Sweden. The investigators set the stage in the introduction thusly:
Autism spectrum disorder has both genetic and environmental origins. Research into the genetic origins of ASD has consistently implicated common and rare inherited variation (heritability). However, evidence shows that there are other, noninherited, genetic influences that could be associated with variation in a trait.3 Given the prenatal origins of ASD, an important source of such genetic influences could be maternal effects.4 The term maternal effects is used to describe the association of a maternal phenotype with ASD in offspring (ie, the noninherited genetic influences originating from mothers beyond what is inherited by the offspring). Maternal effects have been associated with a substantial proportion of the variation in several traits associated with ASD, including preterm birth5 and intelligence quotient.6 Research on nongenetic origins has frequently pointed to a role for environmental exposures unique to different family members (nonshared environment), an example of which is cesarean delivery.7 In contrast, contribution from environmental exposures that make family members similar (ie, shared environment), has been uncertain.8
A meta-analysis of twin studies estimated heritability to be in the range of 64% to 91%,8 and 3 population-based studies from Sweden recently estimated the heritability of ASD to be 83%,9 80%,4 and 66%.10 Among those earlier heritability calculations from twin and family studies (eTable 1 in the Supplement), a single study has estimated maternal effects,4 reporting modest, if any, contribution to ASD. Estimates of the contribution of shared environment range from 7% to 35%,8 but multiple studies estimate the contribution to be zero.4,9,11,12 Thus, although the origin and development of ASD has been investigated for half a century, it remains controversial.
I can’t help but note here that, although there is controversy, most of the estimates cited fall within a fairly narrow range, which makes me think that how much genetics contributes to the development of ASDs is really not that controversial. Be that as it may, I do feel obligated to briefly discuss one point here before I dig into the meat of the study, and that’s to answer the question, “What do we mean by ‘genetic’?” The general public, given how these sorts of issues are reported, often tends to think that “genetic” means that there is a single gene (or a handful of genes) responsible for a trait, disease, or condition. That is, of course, very simplistic. While there are traits and diseases that can be determined by a single gene, most complex traits depend upon many genes and can be affected by many variants of those genes. What studies of this sort estimate is how much autism susceptibility is due to heritability. The other thing that you need to know is that, for purposes of this sort of model, maternal and environmental factors that impact autism risk are basically everything else that is non-heritable. We’ll come back to this point later.
So here’s what the investigators did. They examined the medical histories of more than two million children born in singleton births in Denmark, Finland, Sweden, Israel, and Western Australia between 1998 and 2012. For Sweden, Finland, and Western Australia, investigators included all births between January 1, 1998, and December 31, 2007, while for Israel they included all births between January 1, 2000 and December 31, 2011. All were tracked for a diagnosis of ASD from birth up to December 31, 2014, in Sweden; December 31, 2013, in Denmark; December 31, 2012, in Finland; December 31, 2014, in Israel; and July 1, 2011, in Western Australia. Children were followed until age 16. Denmark, Finland, Sweden, and Israel provided clinically ascertained diagnoses from national patient registers while the data from Western Australia was obtained from a government provided service and benefits register with clinically ascertained autism diagnoses. Of the cohort, 22,156 went on to be diagnosed with an autism spectrum disorder, for a prevalence in the group of 1.1%. Data were analyzed from September 23, 2016 through February 4, 2018.
As you might expect, the authors used Generalized Linear Mixed Effect Models (GLMM) to estimate genetic and environmental effects on the risk for ASD and autistic disorder (AD), using the three-generational data sources in the databases examined to construct families that vary by genetic relatedness and therefore are informative for genetic modeling. These included full siblings and cousins related through their mothers (maternal parallel cousins [mPCs]), or cousins of other relationships. To be honest, I’m not a statistician, which places the nitty-gritty of the statistics mostly beyond me. (If a statistician wants to chime in in the comments, I try never to be too proud do learn something. As Harry Callahan said in Magnum Force, “A man’s got to know his limitations.”)
The key findings of the study were as follows:
    • The median (95% confidence interval) ASD heritability for the whole cohort was estimated to be 80.8% (73.2%-85.5%).
    • For the Nordic countries combined, heritability estimates ranged from 81.2% (73.9%-85.3%) to 82.7% (79.1%-86.0%).
    • Country-specific heritability estimates ranged from 50.9% (25.1%-75.6%) (Finland) to 86.8% (69.8%-100.0%) (Israel).
    • Maternal effect was estimated to range from 0.4% to 1.6%, and in all models used the 95% CI interval included zero, meaning that the estimates for maternal effects were not distinguishable from zero, leading the authors to conclude that there was no support in their models for a significant contribution from maternal effects. (The term maternal effects is used to describe the association of a maternal phenotype with ASD in offspring; i.e., noninherited genetic influences originating from mothers beyond what is inherited by the offspring). The authors note that maternal effects have been associated with a substantial proportion of the variation in several traits associated with ASD, including preterm birth and intelligence quotient.)
    • Estimates of genetic, maternal, and environmental effects for autistic disorder were similar with ASD.
The authors did a variety of sensitivity analyses to determine if changing their inputs had a major effect on the estimates, and the estimates remained pretty solid. The authors note the following strengths in their study:
The major strength of this study is the use of multiple large population-based samples with individual-level data in 3-generation pedigrees. Our data were based on prospective follow-up and health systems with equal access. This approach, following all participants from birth using population registers, avoids bias owing to self-report and retrospective collection of data and reduces selection biases owing to disease status or factors such as parental education. In addition to providing exceptional statistical power, the study directly addresses the concern of lack of replication in research findings31,32 replicating results across 5 countries and health systems.
And limitations:
Our study has several limitations. Despite its large overall sample size, the effective sample size for individual countries was limited by the low prevalence of ASD. Misspecification is another potential limitation. The first potential misspecification arises from the possible violation of the assumption of independence between genetic and environment. If this correlation is not specifically included in the model, its components will mostly be incorporated into the estimate of genetic variance component, potentially biasing the heritability estimate. The direction of the bias will depend on the sign of the covariance between genetic and environmental factors.36 The second misspecification arises from plausible gene-environment interactions that were not modeled and could also bias the heritability estimate. The direction of bias will depend on whether the environmental component is familial and whether the trait is multifactorial.36
Of course, in the case of autism and ASDs, what those “plausible gene-environment interactions” might be is rather unclear. Of course, predictably, antivaxers latched on to that one issue, as you will see. Before I get to that, though, let’s look at the accompanying editorial, “The Architecture of Autism Spectrum Disorder Risk: What Do We Know, and Where Do We Go From Here?” by Amandeep Jutla, Hannah Reed, and Jeremy Veenstra-VanderWeele, which notes:
The study by Bai et al1 elegantly summarizes and confirms, using the largest data set to date, a key truth about ASD’s risk architecture: the disorder is strongly heritable, with environmental factors, although important, contributing relatively less to its variance than genetic factors. Where do we go from here?
One clear next step is to disentangle ASD’s heritability into components that can be identified in ever-growing molecular genetic data sets. The most robust data in ASD implicate de novo copy number variants and rare, de novo single-nucleotide variants in at least 99 genes,6 many of which are involved either in synaptic signaling or regulating expression of other genes, which suggests convergent pathways. Importantly, in a twin study, these noninherited (de novo) variants would be shared by a monozygotic twin pair but not dizygotic twins and would therefore contribute to an estimate of genetic risk. In a family study such as this one,1 these de novo variants are not captured in the estimate of genetic risk because they are not shared between nontwin family members. These rare mutations would instead land in the remaining variance not accounted for by either inherited genetic or shared environmental risk.
Of course, if it is true that de novo (new noninherited) gene variants play a significant role in the pathogenesis of autism and ASDs and, in this analysis, would show up in the nonshared environmental risk component, then it’s possible, even probable, that the genetic contribution to ASD was actually underestimated in this study. Jutla et al also note:
The contribution of the environment to ASD risk appears to be much smaller than the contribution of genetics, yet potential environmental risk factors often receive disproportionate attention from the public and the media, even when (as in the case of vaccine fears) they are debunked. Perhaps this is because environmental risk factors, at least in principle, are modifiable. Even with a smaller contribution to risk, it is worthwhile to enrich understanding of environmental risk factors, which remain relatively understudied.10 Some identified risk factors, such as preterm birth or birth complications,4 are already targets of public health efforts for other reasons. Others, such as a shortened interpregnancy interval or an infection during pregnancy,4 may also be modifiable if the underlying risk mechanisms can be better understood.
Ironically, one of those potentially modifiable environmental factors is congenital infection with rubella, which greatly increases the risk of autism in the child and is, ironically enough, preventable with vaccination of the mother with MMR. In any event, here’s the problem with the assertions above. To antivaxers, the top “environmental risk factors for autism” = vaccines, vaccines, vaccines, vaccines, vaccines, and then everything else. (Actually, perhaps I should have repeated “vaccines” ten times instead of five.) Indeed, I’ve said in the past that one additional harm caused by the antivaccine movement other than depressing vaccine uptake and thus making various populations susceptible to outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases, is that their fanatical belief that vaccines cause autism (1) has diverted funding and research effort to repetitive studies looking at correlations between vaccines and autism and (2) might have made researchers more reluctant to study potentially plausible environmental risk factors for autism because of the association with antivaccine pseudoscience and, of course, the inevitable attacks on them when they find potential environmental risk factors for autism that antivaxers don’t like (anything not vaccines).
A final issue noted in the editorial is that, although the population studied was geographically diverse, it was not as ethnically diverse as one would like. In addition, the smaller sizes of the Israeli and Australian populations studied hamper a clear understanding of whether contributions to ASD risk may differ geographically, leading as they did to higher variability in the estimate of the genetic contribution to ASDs and autism in those countries. I thus agree that it’s unlikely that the estimates for genetic risk will become much more precise with additional family studies, but I also agree that it “would be useful for the findings to be replicated in non-Western or more ethnically diverse countries”.
Antivaxers counterattack
Not surprisingly, antivaxers do not like this study. The reason they don’t like it is because it is practically gospel among them that autism and ASDs are not primarily genetic conditions, but rather caused mainly by environment, specifically vaccines, although they frequently obfuscate by attributing the conditions to vaccines and “other environmental influences” and “toxins”. Also not surprisingly, first out of the gate (that I could find, anyway) to attack the study was James Lyons-Weiler. We’ve met him before when he tried to attribute the death of a teenage boy to Gardasil. The sad thing is that Lyons-Weiler was once an actual reputable scientist (or at least not, to my knowledge, a disreputable one) who during his pre-antivaccine career directed two different bioinformatics cores, one at the University of Massachusetts in Amherst and the other at the University of Pittsburgh, the latter of which closed in 2014. Since then, he’s gone all-in on antivaccine pseudoscience, even going so far as to form an institute he dubbed the Institute for Pure and Applied Knowledge (IPAK), which is about as arrogant-sounding a name for an institute as I’ve ever heard. IPAK isn’t just into antivaccine “science”, but that does seem to be its primary focus compared to others. Since then, Lyon-Weiler’s been battling it out with Leslie Manookian for the title of Most Antivaccine, appearing on antivaccine panels with Del Bigtree, Gayle DeLong, Sherri Tenpenny, and Toni Bark, and, it appears, helping antivaccine pediatrician Paul Thomas carry out a “vaxxed vs. unvaxxed” study.
Lyons-Weiler thus knows a lot, and he really should know enough to know that the complaints he has about the study are mostly irrelevant, save one, which was explicitly and openly acknowledged by the study’s authors. However, something about going antivaccine leads once competent scientists to embrace analyses that in their past lives they would have recognized immediately as nonsense. None of that stopped Lyons-Weiler from entitling his blog post “Yet Another Highly Unethical and Socially Irresponsible “Genes-Only” Study Fails to Show that Autism is 80% “Genetic”” and run with it. Oddly enough, he harps mainly on the WebMD article that I discussed above, rather than the actual study:
The article skips over the fact that the newest, latest study, like the prior studies, fails to actually measure the contribution of a single environmental factor. While the article rails against “anti-vaxxers”, the study ignores the vaccination status of those involved in the study. The mantra of so many studies never showing association has be tempered with a mature, responsible and realstic interpretation in the context of how those studies were conducted: restricted to one vaccine (MMR), and then there is this:
I found it amusing that he repeated one of his criticisms of autism-gene studies twice. As for the Bonferroni correction, I’m not sure why he’s harping on that in the context of the Generalized Linear Mixed Effect Models. The Bonferroni correction is used for much simpler models than this. Actually, the whole thing is rather confused, a list of things that he thinks studies should do (Bonferroni correction) and that they do that he doesn’t like (analyze the data repeatedly until the effect “goes away”). Of course the latter of those two examples reveals shocking statistical ignorance, as quite frequently, raw data reveal an effect that turns out to have been spurious when adjustments are appropriately made for confounding factors. Apparently, like Brian Hooker, Lyons-Weiler prefers the simplicity of the raw, unadjusted analysis that doesn’t control for confounders and provides false positive associations between vaccines and autism.
Next up, Lyons-Weiler asks a question all scientists love: “Why didn’t you study and measure what I think you should have studied and measured?” Here’s what I mean:
Their entire methodology is based on familial correlations. In the current study under consideration, no exposure levels to pesticides, medical exposures in utero, smoking history, nothing environmental was measured. And yet somehow the study authors pretend they can estimate the % liability from environmental factors. How do they pretend to achieve such a feat?
This is just a diversion. Remember, if you accurately estimate the percentage of risk that is genetic, then whatever’s left over must include the environmental risk factors. You don’t have to measure exposure to each and every potential environmental risk factor.
Lyons-Weiler does make one valid criticism, but, as is his wont, he drives off the cliff of ridiculousness with it and fails to note that the authors themselves listed this as a limitation of their study, namely that there could be interactions between genetics and environment. Naturally, he assumes that these interactions would overwhelm the genetics component:
And if the interaction term “(Genetics + Environment)” is more highly significant than “Genetics” or “Environment“, a reasonable interpretation would be that we cannot interpret genetics in a vacuum, that the significance of many ADK risk alleles must be modified by environmental factors. If during model selection, G or E is significant, but then in the full model G x E is significant, we attribute liability to both G and E working together.
Of course, the problem is that we don’t know the size of this term, and it would have to be pretty darned large to push the genetics-only risk factor down to the second or third most important risk factor. We have no good evidence that this is likely, and, if you click on the review article cited, you’ll find that the examples cited by Lyons-Weiler are all supported by small studies, the largest of which had only 408 subjects. It’s wishful thinking to believe that these potential examples are going to overshadow the contribution of genetics to overall risk of autism and ASDs.
Lyons-Weiler then continues:
There are over 850 genes that have been determined to contribute to ASD risk – and not one of them explain >1% of ASD risk individually. Most of these are Common Variants – meaning they are ancient – as in, they pre-date both the ASD epidemic (and yes, there is an epidemic) and vaccination.
Here, he appears to be either falling prey to the simplistic idea that there must be “a” gene for autism or counting on the likelihood that antivaxers reading his screed won’t know that complex conditions and traits are often impacted by many genes, any one of which has little effect. Surely he knows this if he ran bioinformatics cores until 2014, and if he didn’t then he shouldn’t have been running those cores.
Now here’s the part that made me laugh out loud:
The study ignores the fact that environmental factors can impact genes, proteins and biological pathways in a manner that is identical to the effects of genetic variation. This is called Phenomimicry – a term so cool I wish I had invented it. Examples of Phenomimicry are known in science relevant to ASD.
Phenomimicry, if it exists, would indeed be a cool biological phenomenon, but basically here Lyons-Weiler is speculating wildly, pulling something out of his nether regions and using its lack in the study as a cudgel without telling us any plausible scientific rationale why the study authors should have even considered phenomimicry. It’s also a term that, as far as I can tell from Pubmed and Google, is only used by one person, Dorothy V.M. Bishop and is not a generally accepted concept. A PubMed search turns up only one article by Bishop using the term and Googling only turns up mainly articles referring to Bishop’s article.
Lyons-Weiler gives up the game not long after that:
It is highly unethical – and socially irresponsible – for “Genes-only” studies to be conducted that claim to rule out environmental factors. All “Yet Another Highly Unethical Genes-only Study”s – YAHUGS – should be replaced with fully and correctly specified models – that means measuring and studying both vaccination patterns and genetics.
See what I mean? To antivaxers “environmental risk factors” = vaccines, first and always. Whatever the strengths and weaknesses of the current study, the reason Lyons-Weiler doesn’t like it is because it doesn’t consider vaccines (why should it, given the mountains of epidemiological evidence that show no association between vaccination and autism risk?) and concentrated on genetics. Remember that.
The genetics of autism
None of this is to say that this and all the other studies examining the genetics of autism are without problems. Autism and ASDs represent a spectrum of neurodevelopmental disorder impacted by many genes. Teasing out which genes and combinations of genes are most important in determining autism risk is incredibly difficult, as is the case for any complex multigene condition. I’ll even concede that sometimes scientists go too far in touting gene association studies. However, this study was not a gene association study, but rather the largest study to date to estimate how much of the risk of autism is genetic. As such, it produced an estimate that is in line with previous estimates and strengthens the scientific conclusion that autism is mainly heritable, with an effect on risk due to environment that is much smaller and, however large it actually is, not due to vaccines.

   The genetics of autism
David Gorski
Link
Autism and autism spectrum disorders (ASDs) actually represent a rather large continuum of conditions that range from very severe neurodevelopmental delay and abnormalities to the relatively mild. In severe cases, the child is nonverbal and displays a fairly well-characterized set of behaviors, including repetitive behaviors such as “stimming” (for example, hand flapping, making sounds, head rolling, and body rocking.), restricted behavior and focus, ritualistic behavior, and compulsive behaviors. In more mild cases, less severe compulsion, restriction of behavior and focus, and ritualistic behaviors do not necessarily preclude functioning independently in society, but such children and adults may have significant difficulties with social interactions and communication. Because ASDs represent a wide spectrum of neurodevelopmental disorders whose symptoms typically first manifest themselves to parents between the ages of two and three, the idea that vaccines cause autism and ASDs has been startlingly difficult to dislodge and has fueled an anti-vaccine movement, both here in the U.S. and in other developed nations, particularly the U.K. and Australia. This movement has been stubbornly resistant to multiple scientific studies that have failed to find any link between vaccines in autism or the other favorite bogeyman of the anti-vaccine movement, the mercury-containing thimerosal preservative that used to be in many childhood vaccines in the U.S. until the end of 2001. Add to that the rising apparent prevalence of ASDs, and, confusing correlation with causation, the anti-vaccine movement concludes that vaccines must be the reason for the “autism epidemic.”
In reality, autism and ASDs appear to be increasing in prevalence due to diagnostic substition, better screening, and the broadening of the diagnostic criteria that occurred in 1994. Autism prevalence does not appear to be rising, at least not dramatically, at all, as the prevalence of ASDs, when assessed carefully, appears to be similar in adults as it is in children. If the true prevalence rate of autism and ASDs has increased, it has not increased by very much. In reality autism appears to have a major and probably predominant genetic component, and several scientific studies over the last few years have linked autism with various genetic abnormalities. Not surprisingly, given the varied presentation and severity of ASDs, these studies have not managed to identify single genes that produce autism or ASDs with a high degree of penetrance (probability of causing the phenotype if the gene is present). Indeed, one can argue that the state of current evidence is that ASDs are due to multiple genes, perhaps dozens or hundreds. Again, this is not surprising given the heterogeneity of ASD severity, presentation, and symptoms.
One of the more surprising studies supporting a genetic basis for autism appeared to much fanfare in Nature last week. The study by Pinto et al, looks at the functional impact of global rare copy number variation in autism spectrum disorders. Its results are rather surprising in that the large team of investigators (studies of this type take a lot of people to carry out) found that it may be relatively uncommon copy number variations in various genes that lead to the phenotype of autism or ASDs.
Before you can understand what this paper found, you need to know what copy number variation is. In basic genetics and biology classes, many of you probably learned, depending on how long ago you took the courses, that we have two copies of each gene, one on each chromosome, one inherited from the father and one inherited from the mother. The exception is that men have a Y-chromosome instead of a second X chromosome and therefore have only one copy of genes on the X and Y chromosome, the X-linked genes inherited from the mother, the Y-linked genes inherited from the father. Of course, nature is seldom quite so neat, and now that we have powerful tools for sequencing the entire genome and probing its entire DNA to seek out anomalies, we’re finding that things aren’t quite so simple. (Sometimes I marvel that we ever did think things to be that simple.) It turns out that there is considerable variation in the copy numbers of some genes in normal people. This is due to the rare duplication or deletion of a stretch of chromosome during replication. Such errors can leave a person with, for example, one copy on one chromosome and two on another. Although these events are rare for individual stretches of chromosomal DNA, over time and over many generations they can lead to some genes having several. Moreover, there appear to be “hot spots” in various chromosomes that are more prone to duplications or deletions than other regions of DNA.
Because I’m a cancer surgeon and biologist, I’m mostly familiar with variations in gene copy number associated with cancer, and there are many of these. Duplications and amplifications of stretches of DNA are practically the sine qua non of cancer. Often in cancer the amount of gene product in the form of protein that a given gene makes is proportional to the copy number. For instance, in breast cancer, there is a stretch of DNA known as the 8p11-12 amplicon. Basically, it’s a stretch of DNA on the p arm of chromosome 8 that is commonly amplified in breast cancer. This region of chromosome 8 is under active study, and there appear to be a number of candidate oncogenes there. One consequence of our learning about such amplified regions is that a formerly popular (about 30 years ago) and somewhat simplistic idea that single oncogenes would explain carcinogenesis, an idea that was later supplanted by a less simplistic but still too simple idea of multistage carcinogenesis in which a series of mutations in key oncogenes led to cancer. Now we understand that it is many genes that cause cancer. Whole networks of genes are usually perturbed, and, although there are commonalities in many of the networks purturbed among different cancers, the specifics can vary widely from cancer to cancer.
Cancer is one extreme, though, and obviously ASDs are not cancer (or, more appropriately, cancers, given that cancer is not just one disease). ASDs do, however, appear to require multiple genetic changes in order to manifest themselves. Although CNVs are associated with many diseases and conditions, the abnormalities in are not as dramatic or numerous as they are in cancer. In the study under discussion, Pinto et al undertook an a survey of as many CNVs as they could identify in autistic children. Basically, they genotyped 1,275 children with ASD and 1,981 neurotypical controls and compared the frequency of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) according to the following scheme:
schema
It’s not necessary for you to understand in detail what SNPs are. Basically they are variations in single nucleotides within a gene that are useful because by examining them scientists can estimate CNVs and other genetic variants in various genes. This allows the performance of what is known as a genome wide association study (GWAS), which can look at genetic variation over the entire genome, which is what Pinto et al did using a technique that can look for SNPs in 1.2 million loci per sample. Genetic variations that are more common in people with a disease are said to be associated with that disease. GWAS can be very powerful, but, like much of modern genomic medicine, these studies produce incredible amounts of data, with all the attendant difficulties, both computational and scientific, in interpreting what all the associations that are found may or may not mean.
As the authors note in their introduction, previous attempts at GWAS for autism have identified candidate genetic loci at 5p14.1 and 5p15.2. However, variations in these loci can only account for a relatively small percentage of the heritibility of ASD, hence the desire to examine the entire genome in a large number of children with ASD.
What Pinto et al found was this:
The autism spectrum disorders (ASDs) are a group of conditions characterized by impairments in reciprocal social interaction and communication, and the presence of restricted and repetitive behaviours1. Individuals with an ASD vary greatly in cognitive development, which can range from above average to intellectual disability2. Although ASDs are known to be highly heritable (~90%)3, the underlying genetic determinants are still largely unknown. Here we analysed the genome-wide characteristics of rare (<1% frequency) copy number variation in ASD using dense genotyping arrays. When comparing 996 ASD individuals of European ancestry to 1,287 matched controls, cases were found to carry a higher global burden of rare, genic copy number variants (CNVs) (1.19 fold, P = 0.012), especially so for loci previously implicated in either ASD and/or intellectual disability (1.69 fold, P = 3.4 × 10-4). Among the CNVs there were numerous de novo and inherited events, sometimes in combination in a given family, implicating many novel ASD genes such as SHANK2, SYNGAP1, DLGAP2 and the X-linked DDX53-PTCHD1 locus. We also discovered an enrichment of CNVs disrupting functional gene sets involved in cellular proliferation, projection and motility, and GTPase/Ras signalling. Our results reveal many new genetic and functional targets in ASD that may lead to final connected pathways.
One interesting finding was that 5.7% of the CNVs discovered appeared not to be inherited; i.e., they were de novo, meaning, basically, new CNVs. More important, though, was the bioinformatic and systems biology analysis of the CNVs. If there’s one thing that the Human Genome Project has taught us it’s that single genes are rarely that important in disease. Usually, it’s genes that encode for various proteins in discrete functional classes and intracellular signaling pathways, something that can be analyzed by systems biology and network analysis, something I’m increasingly having to do for my cancer research. The result are “bubble diagrams,” which map out various networks and network “hubs” that are important in differences observed between normal and the condition being studied. To come up with such maps and pathway identification requires large numbers of specimens, terrabytes of computer storage space, and a lot of processing power, power that didn’t exist until this decade. In Pinto et al, such an analysis led to the identification of potential new pathways whose function in ASDs may be abnormal compared to the control group. These pathways are mapped out in the following illustration:
pathways
Candidate pathways for ASD identified by this method included genes involved with the cytoskeleton and microtubules, as well as genes involved in cell projection and motility, all of which are involved in cell migration. Other candidate pathways included genes involved in cell adhesion. It is not difficult to imagine how defective or altered migration and adhesion of neurons might result in the creation of abnormal neural pathways and thus result in the differences in cognition and behavior observed in ASDs. Of course, I’m putting things very simply. Even if this is true and these pathways are involved in ASDs, we know so little about how neural networks result in cognition and behavior that it will take a very long time and a lot of work to figure out exactly why and how abnormalities in these pathways result in ASDs. The same is true of other potential pathways implicated by these studies. These include GTPase and ras signaling pathways, as well as other kinase pathways. It’s not necessary for the lay reader to understand the full significance of these pathways. I don’t even know the full significance of these pathways in neurons, although I am familiar with them in cancer. Rather, it’s necessary only to know that they are involved in the transmission of signals from protein receptors on the cell surface into the cell, with the result being a number of processes, such as proliferation, migration, and the transmission of signals between neurons, among others.
Almost as important as the candidate pathways implicated by this study that clearly need further study to validate whether they are truly involved in the pathogenesis of ASDs or not are the pathways that were not implicated. One of the major claims of the “autism biomed” movement, the group of quacks who claim that they can treat autism with all manner of woo ranging from chelation therapy to various antioxidants and supplements, is that there are significant defects in pathways involved in countering the effects of oxidative stress, particularly pathways that result in glutathione production. (Glutathione is one of the major scavengers of reactive oxygen species–a.k.a. free radicals–in the cell.) Such claims were prominently featured by the lawyers for the complainants in the Autism Omnibus. Treatments allegedly targeting “detoxification” pathways involving “Glutathione, Cystathionine, Homocysteine, Methionine” figure prominently on the website of many a quack and are a favorite among the “vaccines cause autism” crowd. Don’t ask me how “vaccine injury” somehow causes oxidative stress sufficient to “cause autism.” Anti-vaccine “scientists” have long and convoluted pseudoscientific explanations that are implausible and unconvincing.
Guess what? Not a single one of the common “detoxification” or oxidative stress pathways implicated in ASDs by the “autism biomed” movement showed up in the analysis of the SNP data by Pinto et al. Big surprise, there. Well, not really. Of course, the fact that Pinto et al failed to find any of these pathways in ASDs in their analysis will no doubt be seized upon as “proof” that their analysis is hopelessly flawed. Just you wait. It’s coming. Because everything old is new again when it comes to the anti-vaccine movement I predict that Mark Blaxill will resurrect the same sorts of dubious criticisms of autism genetics studies that he made in this post from a year ago about an autism genetics study that predated Pinto et al:
But if the de novo CNV theory was plausible at one level, it was absurd at another. The genetic mutations the theory proposed (because this was the best the available evidence could support) were completely non-specific. The copy variants were spread widely (even randomly) over the genome, the theory went. No individual mutation was responsible for autism, just the unhappy presence of the wrong one. And these non-specific mutations were not only widely spread, they were virtually undetectable in the infant: no dysmorphic features; generally normal birth and (in many cases development); and the beautiful children we so often see affected by autism.
In other words these CNVs were a case of immaculate mutations.
And it was the perfect new project for the genetics research community. A wide open field of research opportunities. Lots of new money. And a chance to explain past failure away as part of the inexorable march towards genetic understanding.
Ah, yes. Likening science to religion. It’s a favorite canard of cranks of all stripes, be they anti-vaccinationists, creationists, alt-med promoters, 9/11 Truthers, and Holocaust deniers. I’ve heard anti-vaccine zealots refer to “Vaccinianity“; creationists refer to the “Church of Darwin“; and Holocaust deniers refer to “Holocaustianity” (warning: source is a French Holocaust denial website), among others. The intent is obvious: Try to paint the science detested as being faith-based rather than science-based.
The other favored attack, as those of you who read my post earlier today know, is to claim “conflicts of interest,” even when there aren’t any by any reasonable definition of the term. Although Blaxill hadn’t tried his hand at a pseudoscientific deconstruction of this study as of Sunday afternoon, John Stone over at the anti-vaccine propaganda blog Age of Autism has already pulled this gambit. In a post entitled Scherer of Nature Autism Gene Study Fails to Disclose Pharma Funding As Competing Interest, Stone opines:
Prof Stephen Scherer who is the senior author of the autism gene study launched in Nature last week holds the ‘GlaxoSmithKline-CIHR Pathfinder Chair in Genetics and Genomics at the Hospital for Sick Children and University of Toronto. The title used to be ‘GlaxoSmithKline-CIHR Endowed Chair”, GSK being one of the defendant companies in the UK MMR litigation.
Mr. Stone is clearly ignorant of just what an endowed chair is. Basically, a company or wealthy donor gives a university a lot of money, and the university sets up an endowed chair using that money. The interest and dividends from the fund used to set up the chair are put at the disposal of the holder of the chair to do research and scholarship as he or she sees fit. The reason such chairs are desirable is because an endowed chair gives a researcher a reliable supply of funding without the need to write grant proposals or a department chair a source of funds for various projects that doesn’t have to come out of the departmental budget. It often allows a researcher to do more exploratory work or a department chair to engage in various research and educational activities by doling out funds from the chair to his faculty, for example, to support pilot projects by young faculty. Once an endowed chair is set up, the donor usually has no say over who gets the chair or how the money for the chair is spent. Claiming that Professor Scherer’s holding the GSK chair at his institution is an insurmountable COI that needed to be reported is, quite simply, ridiculous to anyone in academia who knows what an endowed chair is. Clearly, Mr. Stone does not although one commenter going by the ‘nym of Werdna does try to set Mr. Stone straight. It’s a rare thing indeed on AoA for a commenter to take a blogger to task like that, something that usually only happens when an AoA blogger makes a mistake so egregious even for some AoA readers.
Equally ridiculous is Mr. Stone’s lack of understanding of what a corresponding or first author is on a biomedical research paper:
While Prof Scherer’s departmental colleague Dalila Pinto is listed as lead author of the paper Scherer is listed as ‘correspondence author’ and he identifies himself as ‘senior author’ in Kevin Leitch’s LeftBrain/RightBrain blog.
Here’s a hint for Mr. Stone. The lead author of the paper is an honor usually reserved for the person who had the most to do with designing and doing the research. Most of the time the first author is the person who actually wrote the manuscript. On the other hand, the corresponding author of a scientific paper (at least a biomedical paper) is usually the author listed last or near last. More importantly for Mr. Stone’s criticism, the corresponding author and the senior author are nearly always one in the same, namely the author in whose laboratory and using whose funding the research described in the paper was performed. That’s it. That’s all those terms mean. There’s no inconsistency there. The terms are interchangeable. Mr. Stone would do well to learn a little bit about what he speaks before embarrassing himself so.
I’d be happy to educate him.
Mr. Stone’s follies aside, no doubt when Blaxill or whoever at AoA decides to attack Pinto et al shows up to do it, he’ll repeat the same breathtaking combination of ignorance and binary thinking that he did a year ago. As a pre-emptive rebuttal, I’ll cite popular science blogger P.Z. Myers, who put it well when he pointed out that these things are very complicated. So did Pinto et al:
Our findings provide strong support for the involvement of multiple rare genic CNVs, both genome-wide and at specific loci, in ASD. These findings, similar to those recently described in schizophrenia, suggest that at least some of these ASD CNVs (and the genes that they affect) are under purifying selection. Genes previously implicated in ASD by rare variant findings have pointed to functional themes in ASD pathophysiology. Molecules such as NRXN1, NLGN3/4X and SHANK3, localized presynaptically or at the post-synaptic density (PSD), highlight maturation and function of glutamatergic synapses. Our data reveal that SHANK2, SYNGAP1 and DLGAP2 are new ASD loci that also encode proteins in the PSD. We also found intellectual disability genes to be important in ASD. Furthermore, our functional enrichment map identifies new groups such as GTPase/Ras, effectively expanding both the number and connectivity of modules that may be involved in ASD. The next step will be to relate defects or patterns of alterations in these groups to ASD endophenotypes. The combined identification of higher-penetrance rare variants and new biological pathways, including those identified in this study, may broaden the targets amenable to genetic testing and therapeutic intervention.
The problem is that none of this sort of research is easy, and none of it is likely to result in effective treatments for ASDs very soon. Autism quacks and anti-vaccine zealots, however, can’t accept this. Again, like Blaxill, they demonstrate binary thinking. If a study doesn’t find a single, clear-cut gene or small set of genes causing autism or ASDs 100% of the time, then to them almost invariably the study is crap, autism is not genetic in origin, and vaccines (or other “environmental factors”–not vaccines, you know, nudge, nudge, wink, wink) cause autism. They also seem completely oblivious to developmental biology. It bothers them that a child with ASD appears normal at birth and then only manifests symptoms between the ages of 2 and 4. Anti-vaccine zealots who attack genetic linkage studies will frequently point this out as though this observation is a slam dunk argument against a genetic etiology for autism. Development proceeds, however, according to predictable, sequential steps that are under genetic control, and genetic variations and abnormalities can have a profound impact on development that may not manifest itself until previous parts of the developmental program are complete. For example, Tay-Sachs disease is one of thoes rare diseases for which a single gene is the known cause. Babies with Tay-Sachs usually appear normal at birth and develop normally for the first six months of life. Then the neurologic deterioration begins. There are also a number of inborn errors of metabolism that don’t manifest themselves at birth. In other words, it’s not unusual for purely genetic diseases to exhibit delayed manifestation of symptoms. Otherwise, why would we need to test for phenylketonuria (PKU) shortly after birth?
Antivaccine zealots also seem unable to understand that most chronic diseases and conditions with a strong genetic component are due to changes in activity of multiple genes, sometimes many genes. Due to functional redundancy in our cells, there are also often multiple abnormalities that can produce similar phenotypes; it is therefore not surprising that there might be many different gene abnormalities that contribute to ASDs. Systems biology gives us the tools to start to understand these exceedingly complex processes, as Pinto et al did in the study under discussion and as my collaborators try to do for cancer. The problem is that biology is really complex. Frustratingly to those waiting for treatments, it is far more complex than even scientists realized before the Human Genome Project and the dawn of genomic medicine.
While it is possible–even likely–that there is an environmental component to ASDs, the evidence to date has not convincingly implicated any, except for, ironically enough given how anti-vaccine zealots believe that the MMR vaccine causes autism, maternal rubella infection while the fetus is still in utero, as a cause of autism. Moreover, as P.Z. pointed out, no transient exposure or exposures to an external agent (such as a vaccine) is known to be able to produce such a consistent pattern of gene duplications and deletions in human cells like the sets detected in Pinto et al. Thus far, the preponderance of evidence points to primarily a genetic cause for autism and ASDs, and Pinto et al is another solid study supporting a genetic basis for autism. It also suggests potential cell signaling pathways that might be abnormal in autism and thus targets for therapeutic intervention. That’s all we can ask of such a study. It does not rule out an environmental component, although this study is not consistent with vaccines as an etiology of autism. More importantly, it has failed to provide any validating evidence for the frequently claimed abnormalities touted by autism biomeddlers, abnormalities allegedly targeted by all manner of quack nostroms, from chelation therapy to antioxidants to hyperbaric oxygen to “detoxification.”
Now remains the hard work of validating and replicating these findings and then figuring out which pathways can be targeted for therapy. What I’m afraid of now is that the quacks will look at the pathways identified by Pinto et al and try to come up with new pseudoscientific “biomed treatments” for autism based on these results, after (of course) “showing” how vaccine “injury” can create these same CNVs in children. It wouldn’t surprise me if I were to see this sort of “science” presented at Autism One next year.
On the other hand, maybe not. For quacks to try to use the results of Pinto et al to “treat” autism, they’d first have to accept the results of the study.
REFERENCE:
Pinto, D., Pagnamenta, A., Klei, L., Anney, R., Merico, D., Regan, R., Conroy, J., Magalhaes, T., Correia, C., Abrahams, B., Almeida, J., Bacchelli, E., Bader, G., Bailey, A., Baird, G., Battaglia, A., Berney, T., Bolshakova, N., Bölte, S., Bolton, P., Bourgeron, T., Brennan, S., Brian, J., Bryson, S., Carson, A., Casallo, G., Casey, J., Chung, B., Cochrane, L., Corsello, C., Crawford, E., Crossett, A., Cytrynbaum, C., Dawson, G., de Jonge, M., Delorme, R., Drmic, I., Duketis, E., Duque, F., Estes, A., Farrar, P., Fernandez, B., Folstein, S., Fombonne, E., Freitag, C., Gilbert, J., Gillberg, C., Glessner, J., Goldberg, J., Green, A., Green, J., Guter, S., Hakonarson, H., Heron, E., Hill, M., Holt, R., Howe, J., Hughes, G., Hus, V., Igliozzi, R., Kim, C., Klauck, S., Kolevzon, A., Korvatska, O., Kustanovich, V., Lajonchere, C., Lamb, J., Laskawiec, M., Leboyer, M., Le Couteur, A., Leventhal, B., Lionel, A., Liu, X., Lord, C., Lotspeich, L., Lund, S., Maestrini, E., Mahoney, W., Mantoulan, C., Marshall, C., McConachie, H., McDougle, C., McGrath, J., McMahon, W., Merikangas, A., Migita, O., Minshew, N., Mirza, G., Munson, J., Nelson, S., Noakes, C., Noor, A., Nygren, G., Oliveira, G., Papanikolaou, K., Parr, J., Parrini, B., Paton, T., Pickles, A., Pilorge, M., Piven, J., Ponting, C., Posey, D., Poustka, A., Poustka, F., Prasad, A., Ragoussis, J., Renshaw, K., Rickaby, J., Roberts, W., Roeder, K., Roge, B., Rutter, M., Bierut, L., Rice, J., Salt, J., Sansom, K., Sato, D., Segurado, R., Sequeira, A., Senman, L., Shah, N., Sheffield, V., Soorya, L., Sousa, I., Stein, O., Sykes, N., Stoppioni, V., Strawbridge, C., Tancredi, R., Tansey, K., Thiruvahindrapduram, B., Thompson, A., Thomson, S., Tryfon, A., Tsiantis, J., Van Engeland, H., Vincent, J., Volkmar, F., Wallace, S., Wang, K., Wang, Z., Wassink, T., Webber, C., Weksberg, R., Wing, K., Wittemeyer, K., Wood, S., Wu, J., Yaspan, B., Zurawiecki, D., Zwaigenbaum, L., Buxbaum, J., Cantor, R., Cook, E., Coon, H., Cuccaro, M., Devlin, B., Ennis, S., Gallagher, L., Geschwind, D., Gill, M., Haines, J., Hallmayer, J., Miller, J., Monaco, A., Nurnberger Jr, J., Paterson, A., Pericak-Vance, M., Schellenberg, G., Szatmari, P., Vicente, A., Vieland, V., Wijsman, E., Scherer, S., Sutcliffe, J., & Betancur, C. (2010). Functional impact of global rare copy number variation in autism spectrum disorders Nature DOI: 10.1038/nature09146

Fetal Signs of Autism
More evidence that ASD is a developmental disorder that begins in the womb.
Steven Novella on April 6, 2022
Link

Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is a neurological condition considered a developmental disorder that appears in the first two years of life. Clinically it can be diagnosed by around 18 months, but is often not formally diagnosed until later. ASD is typified by difficulty with communication and social interaction, restricted range of interests, and repetitive behaviors. It is considered a spectrum because there is a wide variation in symptoms.
ASD has been caught up in a controversy because of false and now thoroughly debunked claims that it may be caused by vaccination, such as the MMR vaccine. The CDC recommends all children get their first dose of MMR at 12-15 months, and a second at 4-6 years old. The correlation between the timing of the first dose and the onset of recognizable symptoms of ASD likely lead some parents to falsely conclude that the two were causally related, feeding the myth that the MMR vaccine causes autism.
The pre-existing anti-vaccine movement immediately focused on this claim, which was given a huge boost from a fraudulent and now retracted study by the infamous Andrew Wakefield. The MMR-autism “hypothesis” (which is being generous) was soon thoroughly discredited by scientific evidence. The anti-vaccine movement, not deterred by facts, morphed their claims to focus on mercury-containing thimerosal (which the MMR vaccine does not contain). This claim died at the slings of scientific evidence as well. Most dramatically, thimerosal was removed from the standard vaccine schedule in 2001, with any lingering doses used or discarded certainly by 2002 or 2003. The anti-vaccine movement predicted this would precipitate a dramatic drop in autism diagnoses. Scientists predicted it would not. It didn’t. Diagnostic rates continued to rise in the same pattern, likely caused by expanded diagnosis and surveillance. The thimerosal hypothesis was dead.
The anti-vaccine movement, undeterred by evidence, morphed their claims into simply “vaccines” were the cause of autism, without specifying a specific vaccine or ingredient. This gives them the ability to maintain their anti-vaccine claims, while constantly evading new evidence.
However, there is another scientific angle from which to approach the question of vaccines and autism – what is the true cause of ASD, and when does it truly first appear? Over the last few decades, despite the false controversy over vaccines, researchers have been learning a great deal about the genetic causes of ASD. There are many genes now associated with ASD, genes that code for brain-specific proteins. This does not rule out an environmental influence, but at its core ASD appears to be a multifactorial genetic disorder.
Further, there is the question of when ASD is first manifest. Formal clinical diagnosis has to wait until children are old enough to clearly display behavioral signs of ASD, which again begins around 18 months. If ASD is mostly or entirely genetic and developmental, however, then there should be more subtle signs of the disorder at a younger age. As soon as researchers started looking, they started to find changes in behavior and head circumference detectable between 6-12 months, 8-12 months, and even 4-6 months in one study. Of course, if ASD is present at 4-6 months, then later vaccines cannot be the cause.
If ASD is mostly genetic, however, evidence should go back even further, to the womb. The first such evidence was published in the NEJM in 2014. Researchers examined the brains of children with ASD who died. The autopsies revealed patches of disruption in the normal 6-layer structure of the cortex. These layers form early in development, and the changes seen had to occur during that phase of brain development, which puts the onset of ASD in early fetal development.
There is also more direct evidence. A study from January 2022 found an association between ultrasonography fetal anomalies (UFAs) and a later diagnosis of ASD, compared to their neurotypical siblings and age-matched general population controls. Further, the number of UFAs correlated with the severity of symptoms of ASD.
A more recent study used MRI scans to examine the brains in utero of children with and without a later clinical diagnosis of ASD. This study allowed for a more detailed examination of fetal brains than ultrasound. They found:
The insula/insular lobe showed statistically significantly larger volume in ASD than that in all three control groups in the lobar comparison. In the regional comparison, the ASD group had statistically significantly larger amygdala, hippocampal commissure, and insula compared to the non-ASD controls with neurological and non-neurological comorbidities.
These finding correlate with features of the ASD brain in adults, so this is likely not a random fluke.
We now have multiple studies that convincingly demonstrate that ASD is a neurodevelopmental disorder that manifests mostly in late gestation. There are strong genetic correlates, but the environment of the womb appears to also play a role. However, this consensus of evidence is incompatible with the notion that childhood vaccines play any role in ASD.

   Autism and Prenatal Vitamins
Harriet Hall
Link
Science has found no evidence that vaccines cause autism; but the true cause(s) of autism have not yet been determined. So far the available evidence has pointed towards a largely genetic cause with possible interaction with environmental factors. A new study supports that interpretation. It also supports previous evidence that autism is triggered prior to birth, rather than at the time of vaccinations.
Schmidt et al. published a study in Epidemiology on May 23, 2011, entitled “Prenatal Vitamins, One-carbon Metabolism Gene Variants, and Risk for Autism.” It was a population-based case control study of 566 subjects comparing a group of autistic children to a matched control group of children with normal development. They looked at maternal intake of prenatal vitamins in the 3 months before conception and the first month of pregnancy, and they looked for genotypes associated with autism. They found that mothers who didn’t take prenatal vitamins were at greater risk of having an autistic child, and certain genetic markers markedly increased the risk. There was a dose/response relationship: the more prenatal vitamins a woman took, the less likely she would have an autistic child. There was no association with other types of multivitamins, and no association with prenatal vitamin intake during months 2-9 of pregnancy.
They had a large sample size, and they tried to eliminate confounders. They looked for these potential confounders of the association between prenatal vitamin intake and autism: child’s sex, birth year, parent-reported race/ethnicity, family history of mental health conditions, paternal age at child’s birth, maternal age at child’s birth, education, prepregnancy body mass index (BMI) category, cereal intake from 3 months before through the first month of pregnancy, cigarette smoking, alcohol consumption, and residence with a smoker during the period 3 months before pregnancy to delivery. Only maternal education and the child’s year of birth proved to be confounders. They adjusted for these two factors in their analyses. A weakness of their study is that it depends on patient recall long after the fact. Also, it did not attempt to gather any diet information.
Mothers of children with autism were less likely to report taking prenatal vitamins (odds ratio 0.62). Having certain genotypes increased the odds that a vitamin-omitting woman would have an autistic child. Children with the COMT 472 AA gene were at increased risk of autism. If their mothers took prenatal vitamins, the odds ratio for the risk of autism was 1.8; if their mothers didn’t, the odds ratio jumped to 7.2. This suggests that the maternal-fetal environment can magnify the effects of a child susceptibility gene. There was an association with certain maternal genes as well: those odds ratios went as high as 4.5.
The association was robust. The authors think there are plausible biological explanations. Folate and other B vitamins are critical to neurodevelopment. Iron could be involved. The gene variants were within one-carbon metabolism pathways; methylation mechanisms may be responsible.
The authors speculate as to why multivitamins did not have the same effect. Prenatal vitamins typically contain more iron, vitamins B6 and B12, and twice as much folic acid (800 mcg) as multivitamins (400 mcg).
In their summary, the authors say:
Our data suggest that supplementation with prenatal vitamins before pregnancy and during the first month of pregnancy might protect against autism, particularly in genetically susceptible individuals. Additionally, COMT genotype may contribute to an elevated risk for autism, especially in offspring of unsupplemented mothers. This evidence for gene-by- environment interaction effects in autism etiology could help explain variations in previous findings across genetic studies. Whether similar interactions exist for susceptibility genes in other pathways, particularly those epigenetically regulated through methylation, remains to be explored. More research is warranted to replicate the findings, explicate potential mechanisms, and explore interactions with other autism candidate genes.
This is fascinating stuff. It confirms that certain genotypes are associated with autism and that environmental factors can interact with genetics to increase risk. We still need to pin down what it is about prenatal vitamins that prevents autism better than other multivitamins. Is it the folic acid? Is it a subset of the ingredients, or the whole mixture?
We should never blindly accept the results of a first study. These findings will have to be confirmed by other studies. Meanwhile, should we take action? We already recommend folic acid supplements for women who might become pregnant, and we recommend prenatal vitamins during pregnancy. I can’t see any downside to recommending prenatal vitamins in the pre-conception period for any woman who is likely to become pregnant. Some advisors (for instance the Mayo Clinic) were already recommending this practice even before the new study came out.
How will the anti-vaccine contingent react to this new study? It was convenient and satisfying for parents to be able to blame vaccines and accuse the evil medical establishment of causing their children’s autism. Now will those parents accept that at least part of the responsibility lies with their own genetic contributions and the mother’s actions prior to pregnancy? That’s not as palatable a thought, but it’s more realistic.

Antidepressants and Autism
Steven Novella on December 16, 2015
Link

A new study looking at the correlation of antidepressant use during pregnancy and the development of autism spectrum disorder (ASD) has been making headlines. While the results are likely significant, they are not as worrisome as the headlines may suggest.
The study: strengths and weaknesses
Overall the study design is solid. They followed 145,456 singleton full-term infants for a total of 904,035.50 person-years of follow-up. That is the strongest aspect of the study, its power. Typically when you capture large numbers you have to trade-off detail of information. As Lincoln might have said, you can capture a lot of information about a small number of people, or a small amount of information about a large number of people, but it is difficult to capture a lot of information about a large number of people.
The use of databases, especially in socialized countries, does help. In this case they used the ongoing population-based cohort, the Québec Pregnancy/Children Cohort. One compromise, however, is that they followed whether or not the mother filled a prescription for an anti-depressant. They did not capture whether or not the mother actually took the medication.
They counted as statistically significant any result in which the p-value was <0.05 and the 95% confidence interval (CI) did not cross 1.0. They did not correct for multiple comparisons, which does tend to exaggerate the statistical significance when multiple comparisons are made.
The results: A slight increase in the absolute risk of autism
In the mainstream media the results of the study have been widely reported as “Antidepressants during pregnancy increase risk of autism by 87%.” Whenever you see a percent change in risk the first question you need to ask is whether or not this is an absolute or relative risk.
If the risk of a disease increased from 5 to 10% that would equal a 5% increase in absolute risk and a 100% increase in relative risk. Often the relative risk is reported because it seems more dramatic.
In this case the 87% is obviously a relative risk, which equals an absolute risk of 0.87% (an increased risk from 1% to 1.87%, with a 95% CI of 1.15-3.04). That does not make as shocking a headline. But let’s dive a bit deeper.
The increased risk of developing ASD was for exposure in the second and third trimester only, not for exposure during the first trimester or in the year prior to getting pregnant (which had no statistically significant difference).
This is interesting because a 2011 study (although much smaller) found an increased risk of ASD from SSRI antidepressants in the year before delivery, with the strongest signal in the first trimester.
While we’re discussing previous studies, a 2015 systematic review found that for SSRIs:
The pooled crude and adjusted odds ratios of the case-control studies were 2.13 (95% CI 1.66-2.73) and 1.81 (95% CI 1.47-2.24) respectively.
These results are reasonably consistent with the current study. The current study also found no risk from other classes of antidepressants, just from SSRIs.
What does this change? Not much!
The current large study, added to the previous systematic review, does show a consistent increase in risk of developing ASD for mothers who use SSRI antidepressants specifically from 1% to 1.8-2.0%. These studies are correlational and alone do not establish cause and effect.
The current study controlled for confounding factors, including depression itself, as best they could. That SSRIs taken during pregnancy cause a modest increase in risk of ASD is plausible, however, and is a reasonable assumption to make for the purpose of clinical decision-making until further data sheds additional light on the question.
This is not a dramatic change in current practice. Antidepressants are already considered category C in pregnancy, which means:
Animal reproduction studies have shown an adverse effect on the fetus and there are no adequate and well-controlled studies in humans, but potential benefits may warrant use of the drug in pregnant women despite potential risks.
The current studies are observational, and not considered well-controlled, so I don’t think the category will change. Even if they are changed to category D, which means human trials show a risk, both categories allow for use in pregnant women if the benefits outweigh the potential risks.
There are recognized risks to untreated depression in pregnancy. Depressed mothers do not take as good care of themselves, may turn to drinking or smoking, and make seek less prenatal care.
As with all of medicine, decisions consider risk vs benefit (including the risk of not doing something). In this case pregnant women and their doctors need to consider the overall risk of not treating depression with medication vs the modest increased risk from the medication. For mild depression the risks of medication are probably not worth it, but for severe depression it probably is. Where to draw the line is a judgement call.
I do hope the reporting of this study does not cause pregnant women diagnosed with depression to stop their medication without consulting their doctors. The decision should be made with a full understanding of the risks on both sides.

Epidural Labor Analgesia Not Linked to Autism Says New and Improved Study
A new and improved study investigating a potential link between epidural analgesia during labor and autism found no connection. That’s great news for mothers and babies.
Clay Jones on April 30, 2021
Link

The development of safe and effective epidural analgesia, a process that began in the mid-19th century, was a marvel of modern medical achievement. First implemented for reduction of pain during surgical procedures, it initially used intermittently injected cocaine as the anesthetic agent. It took a few decades before it was introduced into obstetrical practice, which was a huge improvement over chloroform but still far from ideal. Sorting out the ideal depth of the injection for each indication and synthesizing less toxic agents would eventually improve the safety and reliability of the procedure considerably, but there were even more advancements on the horizon.
It wasn’t until the 1930s that the use of continuous infusions into the epidural space came into practice, which improved the reliability of pain control throughout a potentially lengthy labor. On January 6th, 1942 at the Marine Hospital in New York, continuous epidural analgesia was used during childbirth for the first time when a woman with rheumatic heart disease required an emergency C-section. Currently epidural analgesia is the most common form of pain control during labor, and involves a combination of drugs that provide fast pain relief with the ability to maintain that relief for the duration of childbirth. There are few side effects for mother, even fewer for baby, and serious complications are rare.
The use of epidural labor analgesia (ELA), which involves the injection of an anesthetic and/or analgesic agents into the space between the inner surface of the vertebral column and the outer surface of the membrane covering the spinal cord in order to provide pain reduction or numbness distal to the site of injection, is not without controversy. This post is not going to serve as an all-encompassing discussion of the history of the pushback against pain control during labor, which is replete with misogyny and pseudoscience. Rather I’m going to focus on one particular concern that has come up in recent years: a potential link between epidural labor analgesia and autism.
In late 2020, the Journal of the American Medical Association published a study that found a 37% increase in the relative risk of autism in children who where “exposed to epidural analgesia” during a vaginal delivery. There was intense skepticism and the relevant medical societies and associations responded:
Importantly, in this study many of the details about the course of these deliveries are not available. There are multiple other possible causes of autism that the study does not address.
The joint statement further points out the lack of plausibility that epidural analgesia would increase the risk of autism:
Additionally, while the authors speculate about mechanisms (like maternal fever) that could explain a link between epidural pain relief and autism, none of these are plausible or confirmed in the analysis. Epidural analgesia involves administering small amounts of dilute local anesthetics and opioids into the mother’s epidural space. Very low levels of these drugs are transferred to the infant, and there is no evidence that these very low levels of drug exposure cause any harm to an infant’s brain.
Low plausibility combined with a positive yet inadequate study is a common pattern discussed on the pages of SBM. Unfortunately, this is also a combination that frequently finds itself covered excitedly by journalists of varying quality, with the end result of a worried public. In order to answer this question more definitively, and hopefully put fears to rest or guide new patient care recommendations depending on the outcome, a study that better addressed the many potential confounding factors was needed. Earlier this month that’s exactly what we got.
Also published in JAMA, the new study found no association between ELA and autism. This time there was an improved “accounting for maternal sociodemographic, preexisting, pregnancy-related, and birth-specific factors”, which means that the results are much more likely to be accurate. Here is a solid piece on the situation (not just because I contributed) by Tara Haelle, who consistently does excellent work covering healthcare topics.
Although we have learned a great deal about autism over the decades, there remain plenty of questions yet to be answered. We don’t know with certainty the totality of factors that might contribute to a child receiving the diagnosis. That being said, we know it is largely genetic in origin and any evidence showing an environmental trigger would need to be compelling for it to change the way we approach pain control during labor.
Now for the elephant in the room. Why was this investigated at all? Is this an example of researchers throwing random crap against a wall just to see what sticks? Probably. It happens a lot. People are desperate to find modifiable risk factors for autism. This isn’t one. Hopefully this doesn’t turn into another zombie belief that returns every few years to scare women into foregoing adequate pain control during labor.

   The Hannah Poling case and the rebranding of autism by antivaccinationists as a mitochondrial disorder
David Gorski
LInk
Regular readers of this blog may have noticed that I seem to have taken on the role of the primary vaccine blogger of this little group of bloggers trying desperately to hold the forces of pseudoscience and magical thinking at bay in the face of powerful forces trying to “integrate” prescientific belief systems with science- and evidence-based medicine, a process that would be unthinkable in just about any other field of applied science, such as aeronautics or the physics used in engineering, just as creationists try to “integrate” religion with biology. Although I do have a strong interest in the antivaccination movement in general and the claim that vaccines, or the mercury in the thimerosal preservatives that was in many childhood vaccines in the U.S. until late 2001 or early 2002 (when they were taken out) are a major cause or contributor to autism, such had not been my intention. When I started here on SBM, I had intended to be a lot more diverse. Indeed, I had even had another topic entirely in mind for this week’s post, but, as happens far too often, news events have overtaken me in the form of a story that was widely reported at the end of last week. It was all over the media on Thursday evening and Friday, showing up on CNN, Larry King Live, the New York Times, and NPR. It happens to be the story of a girl from Georgia named Hannah Poling whose case before the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (VICP), which had originally part of a much larger proceeding known as the Autism Omnibus in which nearly 5,000 parents are petitioning the VICP for compensation based on the claim that their children’s autism were caused by vaccines, was settled by the government. This settlement was based on the observation that Poling had a rare genetic mitochondrial disease that may have been exacerbated by a series of vaccines that she had, after which, among many other problems, Hannah regressed and developed some autism-like symptoms and then months later a seizure disorder. Instantly, it was being trumpeted all over the Internet, blogosphere, and media that the government had “admitted” that vaccines cause autism. One particularly excitable antivaccinationist named Kent Heckenlively (whom we’ve met before), even went so far as to foreshadow the propaganda blitz that was to come as he wrote on the antivaccine blog Age of Autism a full week before this news blitz began:
It’s official. The sky has fallen. The fat lady has sung. Pigs are flying.
[...]
In a settlement, the settling party tries to admit as little as possible. It’s like what I imagine the settlement claim against Bill Clinton in the Paula Jones case must look like. Nowhere in the document does he admit to dropping his pants in a hotel room and asking her to kiss it. It likely says something along the lines of he concedes they were in a hotel room together, they were alone, and something happened which formed the basis of her law suit.
But we all know what happened there. And we know what this settlement means.
The government just dropped its pants.
One thing this shows us is just how the blogosphere can be bubbling with information that lets one predict a public relations blitz like this. The mainstream press seemed to have been totally blindsided by this story, but if reporters had only been checking the right blogs, they would have known about it a full week before, if not longer. In any case, since Thursday, there has been a very well orchestrated public relations campaign to frame this settlement as the government “admitting” that vaccines cause autism. It’s not, as I will try to explain, but framing it that ways has thus far been a very effective PR strategy for antivaccinationists. In my nearly three years of following this topic, I thought that I had never seen anything like it before.
But I had.
This case is nothing more than a demonstration that everything old is new again and that, no matter what the science says, it’s always all about the vaccines, the claims of antivaccinationists otherwise notwithstanding, as I will now show. What we are seeing now, as we did a few years ago, is the rebranding of autism as a condition in order to serve the purposes of the antivaccination movement.
Please indulge me for a moment as I step back to provide a bit of background. I first became interested in the antivaccination movement in 2005. Before that time, in my meanderings on the Usenet newsgroup misc.health.alternative, I had seen some posts claiming that vaccines caused autism (not to mention just about every other chronic condition or malady under the sun). However, I hadn’t paid much attention to it. In the spring of 2005, a journalist named David Kirby wrote a book called: Evidence of Harm: Mercury in Autism and the Autism Epidemic: A Medical Controversy. In this book, he reported on a small but vocal group of parents and “scientists” who claimed that a preservative in vaccines called thimerosal (ethyl mercury) was the cause of the huge increase in autism diagnoses since the early 1990s, a phenomenon that these autism activists like to refer to as an “epidemic” (or, more crassly, a “tsunami” or even a “holocaust“). In reality, the true reason for the huge increase in autism prevalence over the last 15 to 20 years is because of the broadening of the diagnostic criteria for a diagnosis of autism or autism spectrum disorder (ASD) beginning in the early 1990s resulting in widespread diagnostic substitution.
The second shock that got me interested in this issue came in June 2005, with the publication of an article called Deadly Immunity simultaneously on both Salon.com and Rolling Stone. The article was a a pièce de résistance of confusing correlation with causation, cherry picking sources and quote-mining from sources to misrepresent them, and conspiracy-mongering to tell a false story of the Centers for Disease Control attempting to cover up the “fact” that mercury in vaccines causes autism. Meanwhile, antivaccination group Generation Rescue was stating explicitly that “childhood neurological disorders such as autism, Asperger’s, ADHD/ADD, speech delay, sensory integration disorder, and many other developmental delays are all misdiagnoses for mercury poisoning.” (You will note that I used Archive.org to pull up an old version of the GR webpage; it no longer says that. More on why later.) Meanwhile, antivaccinationist sympathizer Don Imus was inviting David Kirby and Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. on his show to spread their message across the airwaves. At one point, as I recall, Don Imus wanted to host a “debate” between Kennedy or Kirby and a defender of vaccines. I don’t recall if it ever happened, because I don’t listen to Imus, but a more hostile environment for a scientist defending vaccines would be hard to imagine.
Fast forward two years to spring 2007. In the intervening time, science had not been kind to the claim that the mercury in thimerosal in vaccines causes or contributed to autism. Indeed, I’ve discussed in detail the reasons why science has come to reject the hypothesis that mercury in vaccines (or, for that matter vaccines) cause or contribute to autism, referring to it as a failed hypothesis. However, in spite of that, a large legal action known as the Autism Omnibus, in which just under 5,000 parents are seeking compensation under the VCIP for their autistic children based on the claim that vaccines were a cause or major contributor to their children’s autism was moving forward. One thing that has to be understood about the VCIP is that it was created in response to fears that vaccine manufacturers would abandon the vaccine business due to liability concerns (a legitimate fear) and that it designed to compensate any injury that could be attributed to vaccines, with a standard of evidence that is a legal, not a scientific standard that’s been likened to “50% and a feather.” These two points are both very important to remember when you hear vaccine opponents trumpeting the Poling case as “proof” of vaccines causing autism. Another thing that’s very important to remember is that the Autism Omnibus is not a court proceeding in the usually understood sense of the term. The adjudicators are called Special Masters and are judges trained in vaccine issues, and the parents can still sue if the ruling goes against them. Moreover, given the volume of cases, the Special Masters decided to hear a small number of “test cases” to test the claim upon which the claims for compensation are based: that some combination of mercury and vaccines triggered autism in these children. In essence, the plaintiffs were asked to choose their most convincing cases and present them. The rulings on these test cases will, as I understand it, then determine if the remaining parents are entitled to continue and will provide precedents upon which to rule on future cases. Thus far, the test cases have not been going well, with plaintiffs’ attorneys generally preferring to tug on the heart strings and present dubious “authorities” to testify on their behalf, while government witnesses demolished nearly every plaintiff scientific claim. This may not matter, however, as the Daubert standard, which for regular court cases sets fairly strong standards on the allowability of expert testimony and the qualification of experts who testify, does not apply for the Omnibus.
Finally, it’s important to understand that apparently Hannah Poling was to be one of these test cases.
Why Poling was removed from the case and settled separately is not known. However, nearly a full week before the media “tsunami” regarding the government concession hit (sorry, I couldn’t resist; I suspect that Mark Crislip is starting to have an effect on me), David Kirby wrote about the “concession” on that repository of antivaccinationism, The Huffington Post, in which he gloated about the ruling and asked “nine questions,” while the Age of Autism published the entire text of the concession and David Kirby did the same on The Huffington Post. Where Kirby got the text of the ruling he isn’t saying precisely (and, make no mistake, it was almost certainly Kirby who got his hands on it), but it’s not clear that it was entirely legal for whoever gave it to him to do so or for him to publicize what should have been a sealed court document about the case of a minor. Be that as it may and since the parents (one of whom was a neurology resident at the time of Hannah’s deterioriation) are now showing up on Larry King Live and all sorts of other media outlets, the cat’s out of the bag and there’s no reason for me not to excerpt relevant parts of the ruling to explain what happened:
At seven months of age, CHILD was diagnosed with bilateral otitis media. Pet. Ex. 31 at 20. In the subsequent months between July 1999 and January 2000, she had frequent bouts of otitis media, which doctors treated with multiple antibiotics. Pet. Ex. 2 at 4. On December 3,1999, CHILD was seen by Karl Diehn, M.D., at Ear, Nose, and Throat Associates of the Greater Baltimore Medical Center (“ENT Associates”). Pet. Ex. 31 at 44. Dr. Diehn recommend that CHILD receive PE tubes for her “recurrent otitis media and serious otitis.” Id. CHILD received PE tubes in January 2000. Pet. Ex. 24 at 7. Due to CHILD’s otitis media, her mother did not allow CHILD to receive the standard 12 and 15 month childhood immunizations. Pet. Ex. 2 at 4.
According to the medical records, CHILD consistently met her developmental milestones during the first eighteen months of her life. The record of an October 5, 1999 visit to the Pediatric Center notes that CHILD was mimicking sounds, crawling, and sitting. Pet. Ex. 31 at 9. The record of her 12-month pediatric examination notes that she was using the words “Mom” and “Dad,” pulling herself up, and cruising. Id. at 10.
At a July 19, 2000 pediatric visit, the pediatrician observed that CHILD “spoke well” and was “alert and active.” Pet. Ex. 31 at 11. CHILD’s mother reported that CHILD had regular bowel movements and slept through the night. Id. At the July 19, 2000 examination, CHILD received five vaccinations – DTaP, Hib, MMR, Varivax, and IPV. Id. at 2, 11.
According to her mother’s affidavit, CHILD developed a fever of 102.3 degrees two days after her immunizations and was lethargic, irritable, and cried for long periods of time. Pet. Ex. 2 at 6. She exhibited intermittent, high-pitched screaming and a decreased response to stimuli. Id. MOM spoke with the pediatrician, who told her that CHILD was having a normal reaction to her immunizations. Id. According to CHILD’s mother, this behavior continued over the next ten days, and CHILD also began to arch her back when she cried. Id.
On July 31, 2000, CHILD presented to the Pediatric Center with a 101-102 degree temperature, a diminished appetite, and small red dots on her chest. Pet. Ex. 31 at 28. The nurse practitioner recorded that CHILD was extremely irritable and inconsolable. Id. She was diagnosed with a post-varicella vaccination rash. Id. at 29.
Two months later, on September 26, 2000, CHILD returned to the Pediatric Center with a temperature of 102 degrees, diarrhea, nasal discharge, a reduced appetite, and pulling at her left ear. Id. at 29. Two days later, on September 28, 2000, CHILD was again seen at the Pediatric Center because her diarrhea continued, she was congested, and her mother reported that CHILD was crying during urination. Id. at 32. On November 1, 2000, CHILD received bilateral PE tubes. Id. at 38. On November 13, 2000, a physician at ENT Associates noted that CHILD was “obviously hearing better” and her audiogram was normal. Id. at 38. On November 27, 2000, CHILD was seen at the Pediatric Center with complaints of diarrhea, vomiting, diminished energy, fever, and a rash on her cheek. Id. at 33. At a follow-up visit, on December 14, 2000, the doctor noted that CHILD had a possible speech delay. Id.
To make a long story short, “CHILD” (whom we now know to have been Hannah, thanks to the PR blitz) regressed and continued to have ear infections. She was seen by Dr. Andrew Zimmerman, a pediatric neurologist, who diagnosed her as having: “encephalopathy [that] progressed to persistent loss of previously acquired language, eye contact, and relatedness” or “regressive encephalopathy with features consistent with an autistic spectrum disorder, following normal development.” He also noticed features consistent with a mitochondrial disease and had Hannah undergo a neurogenetics evaluation. Ultimately, she was diagnosed with a disorder of her mitochondria due to a point mutation in the gene for the 16S ribosomal RNA (T2387C). The conclusion was:
Medical personnel at the Division of Vaccine Injury Compensation, Department of Health and Human Services (DVIC) have reviewed the facts of this case, as presented by the petition, medical records, and affidavits. After a thorough review, DVIC has concluded that compensation is appropriate in this case.
In sum, DVIC has concluded that the facts of this case meet the statutory criteria for demonstrating that the vaccinations CHILD received on July 19, 2000, significantly aggravated an underlying mitochondrial disorder, which predisposed her to deficits in cellular energy metabolism, and manifested as a regressive encephalopathy with features of autism spectrum disorder. Therefore, respondent recommends that compensation be awarded to petitioners in accordance with 42 U.S.C. § 300aa-11(c)(1)(C)(ii).
So what does this mean? First, one thing that it doesn’t mean, contrary to all the P.R. over the last few days, is that the government has conceded that vaccines cause autism. It hasn’t, and science doesn’t support that contention even if it did. Mitochondrial disorders of the sort suffered by Hannah are genetic in nature and rare, an estimated 5.7 individuals per 100,000 worldwide, and, as described well in this New Scientist article, the subset of these disorders that cause autism-like symptoms is even more rare. It is also known that children with mitochondrial disorders are prone to encephalopathy in response to stress or fever that can cause them to regress. The source of this stress can often be an infection, such as a cold or normal childhood illness, that results in a fever. The reason is that the mitochondria are the “batteries” or energy sources of the cell, and mitochondrial diseases can lead a child to be “energy challenged,” so to speak. Because neurons have such a high constant resting energy requirement, stressors like fever deplete the neurons of energy. Moroever, mutations in the same gene that Hannah had a mutation in are incredibly rare. According to Salvatore DiMauro, an researcher who studies mitochondrial diseases, only four other cases are known. It is also important to see what is really meant about this diagnosis. Kevin Leitch, a prominent autism blogger, compared the actual DSM-IV diagnostic criteria for ASDs with what is known about Hannah and found that only three of the behaviors described in the ruling appeared to match up with criteria for ASDs (poor eye contact, poor relatedness, and fixating on fluorescent lights during the examination). Of course, it’s entirely possible that there were other aspects of this diagnosis that have yet to be reported, but, even so, what was really diagnosed was a regressive encephalopathy that had some features of ASD. It may have been exacerbated by the fever that occurred in the wake of the series of vaccines described; it may have been exacerbated by the girl’s recurrent bouts of otitis media. Either way, the government decided that the temporal course of vaccination and regression was close enough that under the law “compensation is justified.”
Another aspect of this question is that it has indeed been noted that mitochondrial diseases may be more prevalent in children with autism or ASDs (the highest estimate of which is here), but it is not at all clear if mitochondrial diseases have anything to do with the “run-of-the-mill” (if you’ll excuse the term) variety of autism and ASD that is commonly diagnosed or whether the apparently higher level of mitochondrial disease noted in some studies of children with ASD is an epiphenomenon. As our fearless leader here at Science-Based Medicine said in an interview in the New Scientist:
“It’s not surprising that mitochondrial function is abnormal,” says Steven Novella, a neurologist at Yale University. “With neurodegenerative disorders almost any marker of cell health will be worse than in controls.” Without more research, he adds, it is impossible to say whether the mitochondrial problems are the cause of the disease or its by-product…Those who argue otherwise, are “making multiple assumptions that are not established”, Novella warns.
In fact, mitochondrial disorders are not benign diseases. Children who have them almost invariably also have other serious (and characteristic) health problems due to their mitochondrial dysfunction. Moreover, the question of vaccinating versus not vaccinating is quite clear-cut–but not in the direction Kirby and other antivaccinationists would have you believe. A person whose friend has a child with mitochondrial disease showed up at the Autism Vox blog and said:
FYI…vaccines ARE recommended for children with mito!!!! Some are advised to avoid a shot, ONLY if a history of bad reactions exists (which holds true for the general population). My friends whose children have mito ALL vaccinate their children and are mortified by people who opt to not give shots to their kids because of quack science (vaccines=autism). Those un-vaccinated children put my child and my friend’s children at risk for contracting serious diseases. Diseases that most certainly would land a child with mito in the ICU & possibly kill them.
Go here: http://www.umdf.org/site/c.dnJEKLNqFoG/b.3616911/apps/s/content.asp?ct=4211851 and read. I will also add, it is HIGHLY unlikely that a child with autism has mito, especially if that child has never been hospitalized, doesn’t have severe health issues, eats on their own, there is no muscle-wasting, vision impairment, heart defects, etc. Read more about mito at umdf.org & see how autism doesn’t equal mito, and how this case has nada to do with what Kirby is fighting for!
Kevin Leitch’s guest blogger SL has rounded up more information on the severity of mitochondrial disorders and the need to vaccinate children who have them.
The bottom line is that it is fever from any source, be it a vaccine reaction or, more commonly, an infection that can exacerbate mitochondrial disorders and provoke encephalopathy. Moreover, because of the confounding factor of multiple ear infections, it’s not 100% clear that Hannah’s vaccinations even caused her regression, although it is certainly possible. None of this, of course, has stopped antivaccinationists from taking this ball and running with it as far as they can as though it were some sort of bombshell admission from the government that it had been wrong all along.
I rather suspect that the reason is that even the most die-hard among them now realizes that the previous tactic of blaming mercury for autism is increasingly a losing proposition, given the science and the number of studies now that have failed to find a link. Consequently, as a buildup to the Poling press conference on Thursday, the antivaccine blogs, particularly the Age of Autism, were in full gloat mode, with Kent Heckenlively writing more posts like the one at the beginning of this article, David Kirby showing up on the Don Imus show making statements about how the government wouldn’t “allow the parents to speak” (actually, the only ones who aren’t allowed to speak are the doctors who examined and diagnosed Hannah) and being coy about where he got the settlement papers and CNN, Deidre Imus doing her usual antivaccination act on her husband’s show, and comedienne and former Playboy Playmate Jenny McCarthy (now turned antivaccinationist) writing articles and trying to organize protests demanding that the head of the CDC resign (this, apparently, to follow up her previous call for a demonstration in June at the headquarters of the CDC in Atlanta). Indeed, I distinctly remember hearing a long story on this case on NPR on the ride into work on Friday, walking through the clinic area on the way to the elevators and seeing it on CNN, and topping it off by hearing about it on the news on Friday night. It was truly surreal, and, for someone dedicated to science-based medicine, a threat to my blood pressure. Worse, this settlement is not even a real “bombshell” admission. As Arthur Allen, author of Vaccine: The Controversial Story of Medicine’s Greatest Lifesaver (an excellent book that I highly recommend, by the way), points out in an article for The Washington Independent, the Poling case is by no means the first case in which the VCICP paid out compensation for “autism-like” symptoms after vaccination:
I have since learned that the 934 families paid out more than $800 million since 1990 by the vaccine court included several with injuries that resulted in “autism-like symptoms.” At least a few of these cases involved tuberous sclerosis complex, a rare genetic condition in which tumors pop up in the brain and other organs, sometimes causing severe mental disability. Like mitochondrial disease, tuberous sclerosis can occur in the form of a regression in a normal-seeming child—and has been known to follow a shot. A senior court official tells me that a handful of TSC kids awarded by the court were, for all intents and purposes, autistic—though no one called it autism.
This media circus about the Poling case appears to be little more than a carefully orchestrated PR campaign by antivaccination groups funded by people with deep pockets, like Generation Rescue founder J. B. Handley, a wealthy investment banker, and now apparently the newest recruit to the cause, Jenny McCarthy. Moreover, it is very likely that the reason the Poling case was dropped as a test case from the Autism Omnibus is because it is so unusual and atypical. If it weren’t, don’t you think that the plaintiffs’ lawyers would have been chomping at the bit to have it included as a test case that would give them the “in” they need to gain compensation for nearly 5,000 parents?
I do.
All of this brings me back to my original point. What we are witnessing here is something that we witnessed before in 2005: the “rebranding” of autism. Oddly, Kim Stagliano, the editor of the Age of Autism blog, showed me this in no uncertain terms in a post she published on the day of the Poling press conference:
Is Miss Hannah Poling patient #1 in the new paradigm for “The disorder formerly known as autism?” Perhaps we’lll come up with a really funky sign like Prince did? Was Hannah misdiagnosed with autism, when she actually had a mitochondrial disorder that was triggered by her childhood vaccines? If so, there may be tens of thousands of children who have been misdiagnosed. That opens up rather a large can of wigglers, doesn’t it?
It might if it were true (for one thing, mitochondrial disorders are genetic disorders, many with maternal inheritance because they are due to mutations in mitochondrial DNA; they are not “triggered” by vaccines), but what really struck me about Stagliano’s observation is that we have indeed seen this all before. Remember how at the beginning of the article, I pointed out that the antivaccination group Generation Rescue used to say that autism is a “misdiagnosis” for mercury poisoning? It no longer says that now. Indeed, if you look at the Generation Rescue site now, what you will see is this:
We believe these neurological disorders (“NDs”) are environmental illnesses caused by an overload of heavy metals, live viruses, and bacteria. Proper treatment of our children, known as “biomedical intervention”, is leading to recovery for thousands.
Autism isn’t a “misdiagnosis for mercury poisoning” anymore, it would appear. It’s been rebranded again. First, we see the zealots back away from the claim that “it’s the mercury, stupid” when scientific evidence failing to find a link between mercury in vaccines becomes overwhelming. Instead, we now see an attempt to link all sorts of “toxins” to vaccines. Now, with the revelation that the government settled a case where vaccines may have exacerbated an underlying mitochondrial disorder and led to an encephalopathy with some features of regressive autism, antivaccinationists now think they have a new “brand” for autism. No longer is it a “misdiagnosis for mercury poisoning.” Now it’s a “misdiagnosis for mitochondrial disorders.” However, as has been explained on Steve Novella‘s blog and elsewhere, the government settlement in this case says nothing about any but possibly a very, very few children, and even about them it does not say that vaccines do more harm than good. Moreover, the claim isn’t even a winner as far as obtaining compensation, given how unusual Hannah’s condition is. Indeed, this “rebranding” of autism as a “mitochondrial disorder” drives home that the idea that vaccines cause autism is the incredible shrinking hypothesis. It’s gone from concrete claims three years ago that mercury or vaccines cause nearly all cases of autism to a lot of speculation based on one highly atypical case, a far cry from previous incriminations against vaccines as the cause of an “autism tsunami.” We shouldn’t forget that. It’s gone from a claim of causation due to vaccines for nearly all autistic children to tortured interpretations of a single case of a rare mitochondrial disorder. Even if mitochondrial disorders are not an epiphenomenon in autism but rather a cause of some forms of ASD, it is unlikely that they would account for more than a very small number of cases every year, too few to contribute much to the overall total. Like mercury, mitochondrial disorders are not The One True Cause of autism. We shouldn’t forget that, either. The goalposts have been moved, and they continue to move, because it is all about the vaccines.
The take-home lesson from this attempt to rebrand autism as a mitochondrial disorder is that everything old is new again. A few years ago, antivaccinationists in the U.S. tried to rebrand it as “mercury poisoning” due to vaccines while ignoring the far larger sources of mercury in the environment when considered cumulatively, such as the diet. When that rebranding withered in the face of science failing to find a link between vaccines and autism, they pivoted on a dime and without missing a beat are now trying to rebrand it as a mitochondrial disorder. What’s forgotten in all of this is that the commonality is, as it always is for antivaccinationists, vaccines. No matter what new causation hypotheses for autism they come up with, no matter what new discoveries in genetics and physiology are made about the pathophysiology of autism, there’s one thing you can predict: Antivaccinationists will try to torture the science into making it all about vaccines, just as they have always done, and that there will be a new round of autism quackery based on mitochondrial disorders.
27 responses so far
27 Responses to “The Hannah Poling case and the rebranding of autism by antivaccinationists as a mitochondrial disorder”
# overshooton 10 Mar 2008 at 11:01 am
Not as big a rebranding as you might expect.
Watching the triumphalist traffic you might think that the mitochondrial disorder jog is the new direction, but I don’t see it as being more than a case of grabbing headlines to connect vaccination -> brain damage.
The broader moves from the antivaccinationist “think tanks” appears to be headed in the direction of blaming aluminum. It’s an easier replacement, since it’s still “metal injected into the baby” and has the benefit of all the headlines about aluminum and Altzheimer’s.
The trial balloons on aluminum have been up for a while now, and it seems to have more staying power than mitochondrial disorders do. I suspect that this is because the general public (much less the most receptive to the antivaccinationist message) aren’t familiar with “mitochondria.” Aluminum? That’s something they all know.

   Freeways, autism, and correlation versus causation
David Gorski
Link
I have a love-hate relationship with epidemiology.
, I love how epidemiology can look for correlations in huge sample sizes, sample sizes far larger than any that we could ever have access to in clinical trials, randomized or other. I love the ability of epidemiology to generate hypotheses that can be tested in the laboratory and then later in clinical trials. Also, let’s not forget that epidemiology is sometimes the only tool available to us that can answer some questions. Such questions generally involve hypotheses that can’t be tested in a randomized clinical trial because of either ethical concerns or others. A good example of this is the question of whether vaccines cause autism. For obvious ethical reasons, it’s not permissible to perform a randomized clinical trial in which one group of children is vaccinated and one is not, and then outcomes with respect to neurodevelopmental outcomes, such as autism and autism spectrum disorders, are tracked in the two groups. The ethical concern with such a study, of course, is the potential harm that would be likely to come to the unvaccinated control group, children who would be left unprotected against common and postentially deadly communicable diaseases.
On the other hand, epidemiology is one of the messiest of sciences, and epidemiological studies are among the most difficult in all of science to perform truly rigorously. The number of factors that can confound are truly amazing, and as a result, it’s very, very easy for an epidemiological study to detect apparent correlations that are either spurious or appear much stronger than the “true” correlation. There can be confounding factors beneath confounding factors wrapped in more confounding factors, the relationships among which are not always apparent. Not infrequently, a condition can appear to be correlated with, for instance, an environmental factor, but in reality that environmental factor and the condition both correlate with a third, unknown confounder. Worse, epidemiologists know that correlation does not necessarily equal causation, but the general public, for the most part, does not, which is why, when anti-vaccine activists, for instance, point out to a rising autism prevalence and then point out that autism prevalence started rising around the same time the vaccine schedule was expanded, to the average layperson the argument sounds compelling. As a result, the design of an epidemiological study is paramount in order to account for or minimize such factors. That’s why I always said I can’t be an epidemiologist. Even though I was very good at math in college, the statistics still made my brain hurt, and I don’t have the patience for the messiness of trying to account for all the possible confounding factors.
However, for all their strengths and flaws, epidemiological studies are an integral part of science-based medicine. They are used to identify predisposing factors to diseases and conditions, environmental contributors to disease, and adverse reactions to drugs, among many other useful pieces of data. That’s why, from time to time, I like to examine epidemiological studies, particularly if they’re epidemiological studies that are getting a lot of press.
The use and abuse of autism epidemiology studies
For instance, studies like this one described in a story in the Los Angeles Times on Friday entitled Proximity to freeways increases autism risk, study finds: More research is needed, but the report suggests air pollution could be a factor:
Children born to mothers who live close to freeways have twice the risk of autism, researchers reported Thursday. The study, its authors say, adds to evidence suggesting that certain environmental exposures could play a role in causing the disorder in some children.
“This study isn’t saying exposure to air pollution or exposure to traffic causes autism,” said Heather Volk, lead author of the paper and a researcher at the Saban Research Institute of Children’s Hospital Los Angeles. “But it could be one of the factors that are contributing to its increase.”
Another news story describes the study thusly:
Story link: MyFoxLA.com
Naturally, the anti-vaccine crank blog Age of Autism is expressing interest in this study. The interview, of course, is truly execrable, particularly the bubble-head host saying “some people” think it’s the MMR, as though the anti-vaccine movement who demonize the MMR as a cause of autism have the slightest clue what they are talking about, and mentioning Jenny McCarthy as though she were anything other than a bad actress with a Google University education that led her to believe that vaccines caused her son’s autism.
Before I get to the study itself, one thing I always wondered about is why anti-vaccine groups are so keen on buying every study that purports to show an environmental component that might predispose to autism. Naturally, they often manage to related it back to vaccines, as they tried to do when there was a bad study purporting to show a link between proximity to power plants whose emissions contained mercury and autism. At least with that study, the potential relationship was fairly obvious in that a large contingent of the anti-vaccine movement still blames mercury in the thimerosal used in childhood vaccines vaccines as a preservative (in the U.S., at least) until the end of 2001. True, the chemical form of mercury in the environment is different than thimerosal, with different implications for toxicity and metabolism, but to the anti-vaccine mercury is mercury is mercury, and it’s equally evil.
Personally, I suspect that the reason anti-vaccine groups glom onto any study that purports to identify an environmental contributor to autism is guilt by association. If, “reason” anti-vaccine activists, this pollution or pesticides are implicated as a cause of autism, then maybe vaccines do too, and they aren’t so crazy after all for saying so. I’m sure regular readers of this blog can see the flaws in that logic. Also, many anti-vaccine activists are also advocates of a wide variety of “autism biomed” quackery, which can range from chelation therapy, to supplements, to hyperbaric oxygen chambers, and even to stem cell quackery. If pesticides, chemicals, environmental pollutants, or whatever can be implicated as a cause or contributor to autism, each new “cause” opens up a new panoply of “autism biomed” quackery to be tried.
So let’s get to the meat of the study itself.
The CHARGE study, proximity to freeways, and autism
My usual loghorreic introduction complete, let’s take a look at the study itself. It’s by a group of investigators from the University of Southern California, and its lead investigator was Heather Volk, the woman who appeared on the above FOX News segment, and the title of the article is Residential Proximity to Freeways and Autism in the CHARGE Study. Conveniently, the anti-vaccine crew at Age of Autism has posted an actual PDF of the study. One of these days, they’re going to get into trouble for doing that, but for now it allows anyone who doubts my analysis to go straight to the source. Let’s take a look at the abstract, for those of you who don’t want to read the whole paper:
Background: Little is known about environmental causes and contributing factors for autism. Basic science and epidemiological research suggest that oxidative stress and inflammation may play a role in disease development. Traffic-related air pollution, a common exposure with established effects on these pathways, contains substances found to have adverse prenatal effects.
Objectives: To examine the association between autism and residence proximity, during pregnancy and near the time of delivery, to freeways and major roadways as a surrogate for air pollution exposure.
Methods: Data were from 304 autism cases and 259 typically developing controls enrolled in the Childhood Autism Risks from Genetics and the Environment (CHARGE) Study. The mother’s address recorded on the birth certificate and trimester specific addresses derived from a residential history obtained by questionnaire were geo-coded and measures of distance to freeways and major roads were calculated using ArcGIS software. Logistic regression models compared residential proximity to freeways and major roads for autism cases and typically developing controls.
Results: Adjusting for sociodemographic factors and maternal smoking, maternal residence at the time of delivery was more likely be near a freeway (≤309 meters) for cases, as compared to controls (odds ratio (OR), 1.86, 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.04-3.45). Autism was also associated with residential proximity to a freeway during the third trimester (OR, 2.22, CI, 1.16- 4.42). After adjustment for socio-economic and demographic characteristics, these associations were unchanged. Living near other major roads at birth was not associated with autism. Conclusions: Living near a freeway was associated with autism. Examination of associations with measured air pollutants is needed.
There are a number of problems with this study, as you might imagine. First off, in epidemiological terms, it’s rather small for a study of this nature. On the other hand, it does have the strength that each child was examined individually for various factors; in other words, individual-level data were used rather than ecological (group-level) data, the latter of which has a huge tendency to result in false positives. Worse, there are a number of inconsistencies in the results, but in particular one glaring confounding factor that apparently failed to be taken into account, at least as far as I can tell.
First, let’s look at the anomalous findings. The main finding of this study is that being within 309 m of a freeway was associated with a barely statistically significant odds ratio of being diagnosed with an autism spectrum disorder of 1.86 (95% confidence interval: 1.03 to 3.45, Table 2). As noted in the abstract, autism was also correlated with residential proximity to a freeway during the third trimester (OR, 2.22, CI, 1.16-4.42). Note that the confidence interval almost encompasses 1.0. For purposes of this study, freeways were defined as U.S. interstate highways or state highways. You might also wonder why 309 m was chosen as the distance cutoff. I wondered that too when I first read news accounts of this study. My first thought was that 309 m was equivalent to 1,000 ft., and so it is–approximately. However, it’s not close enough to explain why 309 m was chosen as the cutoff, given that 309 m equals 1,013.8 ft., and 1,000 ft. equals 304.8 m. On the surface, it looked like a bit of the old data dredging to find a distance that gives a “significant” result. However, this is how the manuscript described the rationale for choosing the distances:
We examined the distribution of distance from the nearest freeway among subjects in our study and determined exposure cut-points to define the closest 10% (<309m), subsequent 15% (309m-647m), and following 25% (647m-1419m) as exposure groups. The remaining 50% (>1419m) served as the reference group in our analysis. Living within 309m of a freeway at birth was associated with autism (odds ratio (OR) 1.86, 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.04-3.45). This association was not altered by adjustment for child gender or ethnicity, maximum education in the home, maternal age, or maternal smoking during pregnancy (Table 2). When we categorized our distance measure into deciles, only the top 10% corresponding to the <309m category above, showed evidence of an increased autism risk compared to those living farthest from the freeway (lowest decile, >5,150m) (unadjusted OR=2.48, 95%CI 1.17-5.39).
Now, here’s the anomaly. This very same study failed to find any correlation with living near what is defined as a “major road,” specifically a state highway, interstate highway, or major arterial. This was true even though the distances from a major road of the closest 10%, 25%, and 50% in this study were 42 m, 96 m, and 209 m, respectively, all much closer. If pollution is the common factor that accounts for the observation of a relative risk for being diagnosed with autism of 2-fold greater than in children farther away from freeways, then these results are meaningless without knowing the levels of pollution at 42 m from a major road compared to 309 m from a freeway. The authors try to explain this anomaly away by doing some hand waving about the higher traffic volumes carried by Southern California freeways, which might well be true, but proximity matters. If proximity to a freeway is a surrogate for exposure to pollution (or a certain subset of pollutants), is it so unreasonable to expect that being more than seven times closer to a major road compared to a freeway would result in exposure to as much pollution? I don’t know the answer to this, although this sort of data is known. For instance, it’s known that resuspension by Los Angeles Interstate 405 significantly increases atmospheric particle numbers and metal concentrations but that both return to urban background levels through dry deposition within 100–150 m of the highway (Sabin et al., Atmos Environ 2006;40:7528–7538).
One thing’s for sure, though. The fact that the investigators didn’t see even a hint of a correlation between autism and a similar measure to proximity to freeways makes me wonder very strongly whether this is simply nothing more than a finding that popped up in multiple comparisons due to random chance alone.
Let’s, for argument’s sake, however, assume that this isn’t the case. Let’s assume that the data are the data, and the correlation found appears not to be due random chance alone, at least using the data and techniques used in this study. I stil see a big problem: a confounding factor that wasn’t controlled. for. True, the authors did try to control for all the usual confounders in autism studies: child sex, ethnicity, level of education in the home, maternal smoking, maternal age, and preterm delivery. (One notes that they didn’t control for paternal age, which, as recent studies have shown, appears to correlate with an increased risk of autism.) But what did they fail to control for? If you remember my deconstruction of Dr. Raymond F. Palmer’s study that claimed to link proximity to mercury-emitting power plants to an increased risk for autism. Do you remember what that was? No reason to expect that you should, given that my post is over two and a half years old, but the criticism of Palmer’s study applies equally well here. Moreover, Joseph explicitly listed a number of complaints about Palmer’s study and demonstrated that the correlation that Palmer found disappeared once population density was accounted for. Why is this important? Urban and suburban regions with much denser populations tend to have more screening and intervention programs for autism and thus a higher rate of diagnosis. If we take a look at the distribution of CHARGE study subjects from the Sacramento Valley catchment area, it can be seen that they are scattered throughout central California. I couldn’t find an equivalent map for the Los Angeles basin catchment area.
The reason why controlling for population density and urbanicity is so important was well explained by Thomas A. Lewandowski in criticizing the Palmer study:
Lastly, the authors found that the most important determining factor for autism prevalence in their study was whether the child lived in an urban, suburban, or rural area. For example, residence in an urban school district resulted in a 473% higher rate of autism compared to rural districts. Similar findings have been reported by others (e.g., Deb and Prasad, 1994). The urbanization effect is nearly 8 times stronger than the effect suggested for mercury but is given relatively little discussion and is not even noted in the abstract. Since levels of many pollutants (including mercury) would be strongly correlated with urbanization/industrialization, this also leads one to question the mercury-autism association the authors report…Certainly a host of environmental and social variables associated with urbanization could be investigated as possible factors in autism. Alternatively, an increased tendency for diagnosis in urban localities could explain at least part of the increased incidence.
Urbanicity is also associated with proximity to Interstate freeways, although, to be fair, it is also associated with proximity to major roads. The denser the population, the more freeways and roads.
Another question that came up as I read this study was a simple one: How many total associations were the authors looking for in their data? Remember, the CHARGE study is looking for environmental factors that modulate autism risk, as described in this review article about the study published in 2006, coauthored by one of the study under discussion:
To structure the search for etiologic factors, we are beginning with known neurodevelopmental toxicants and hints from the immunologic evidence. Additionally, physiologic differences that might provide clues about susceptibility and mechanisms are being examined through characterization of metabolic, immunologic, and gene expression profiles, as well as genetic polymorphisms. Figure 1 shows five broad classes of exposures of interest: pesticides, metals, persistent pollutants with known or suspected neurodevelopmental or immunologic toxicity, medications and other treatments, and infections. Exposures from both the prenatal and early childhood periods are being investigated, with data primarily from three sources: a) extensive interviews with parents; b) laboratory analysis of xenobiotics in blood, urine, and hair specimens; and c) prenatal, labor and delivery, neonatal, and pediatric medical records.
This is represented in a figure:
In other words, the current paper is a report of a subset of analyses from a much bigger study.
The bottom line
Given that this published study is part of a much larger study looking at a lot of factors, there’s always the danger that the reported finding is nothing more than an anomalous result that can be attributed to random chance alone. Such findings are quite common when multiple comparisons are made; indeed, as the number of comparisons rises, so does the chance of finding a fluke correlation that mathematically is statistically significant but is in reality merely random chance in action. In other words, if investigators were looking for 100 different associations and found this one, it would be a different thing than if they were looking for only five and found this one. Without knowing the number of associations authors were looking for at the beginning without having to go to various other papers describing the study, it’s hard to judge whether this one correlation (autism prevalence with proximity to freeways either at birth or during the third trimester, which, let’s face it, correlate closely with each other, given that most expectant mothers don’t want to change residences when they are near the end of their pregnancy) means anything at all. My guess is that it probably does not; I would find the data more convincing if there were included actual measurements of pollutants compared to proximity to freeways and major roads, along with an analysis that shows that pollutants up to 309 m away from a freeway are still much higher than pollutants a mere 42 m from a major road. It would also have been a lot more convincing if there were a geographic effect consistent with the direction that the prevailing winds blow.
Epidemiological studies of clusters of conditions or diseases are fraught with false positives, so much so that there is even a name for the particular fallacy that all too many investigators fall prey to when looking for such clusters: The Texas sharpshooter fallacy. The fallacy is named for the apocryphal Texas sharpshooter who fired a bunch of bullets into the side of a barn and then drew a circle around the area where most of the bullets hit, calling that circle the bullseye. Similarly, epidemiologists look at the geographical location of subjects with a particular condition or disease, and then try to “draw a circle” around them that fits in with what they are looking for. If that’s what happened here, then the CHARGE investigators, believing that pollution might be a contributor to autism, tried to “draw the circle” near freeways and major roads, found one statistically significant result, and then concluded that proximity to freeways is a risk factor for autism, the implication of which (to the investigators) is that pollution is a predisposing factor to autism. I can’t help but note in looking at these results that it is is already known from a study earlier this year that in California autism cases tend to cluster in areas with high populations of more affluent, educated people, who, not surprisingly, tend to live in more affluent communities with good school services, special education, and autism screening and intervention programs.
This approach of examining geographic clusters is nearly always fallacious because (1) the cluster is usually the result of random chance or (2) there may be other reasons for the clustering. Personally, I suspect option #2, with the other reason for the clustering being the unaccounted-for confounding factor of urbanicity. In all fairness, the authors do mention in the discussion that their result might be due to “random chance or bias.” Also, in various interviews, Volk did say that their work needs to be replicated (although not, as far as I saw, that their results are likely to be due to random chance or an uncontrolled-for confounding factor). However, missing from most news reports was a level of skepticism about a study finding in essence only one barely statistically significant result among several.
One can’t help conclude that, if this association were true, then, as AutismNewsBeat pointed out, we would expect autism prevalence to have started its upward trend back in the late 1950s, after the passage of the Interstate Highway Act and the subsequent explosion of construction of interstate freeways. As we all know, however, this explosion didn’t actually begin until the early 1990s, which is the reason why anti-vaccine groups seized upon vaccines as the One True Cause of autism. Such are the hazards of confusing correlation with causation. I don’t think that that’s what the authors are necessarily doing here, but I do think they are doing a disservice to the public by not adequately trying to squash the misunderstandings about studies of epidemiological clusters.

   Rainman – Link Between Precipitation and Autism
Steven Novella
Link
A new study published in the Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine shows a positive correlation between counties in California, Oregon, and Washington with greater precipitation and a higher incidence of autism. While the results of this study are interesting, it needs to be put into proper context. Also of note, the authors had presented early results from this data previously.
Correlation is not Causation
This type of study is a correlational study, which means it asks whether or not there is a statistical correlation between two variables – in this case the rate of autism and the amount of precipitation. This type of data is extremely useful to medical science, but it has known limitations, which can be summarized by the statement that correlation is not causation.
I often see this principle used to dismiss correlation data entirely, but that is not the correct approach. Correlation, rather, needs to be considered in the proper context. When A correlates with B there are various possible interpretations: the correlation is a statistical fluke (coincidence); A causes B, B causes A, or both A and B correlate with another variable C, and there can be a variety of causal relationships among the three (or more) variables which would cause A to track with B.
Therefore, finding a correlation is a way to generate several hypotheses which can then be tested by further observations or research. That, in my opinion, is the best way to view correlational data – as a beginning step to help generate hypothesis. But they should not be used to reach firm conclusions.
It should also be noted that further correlations can be used to test various causal theories, and if multiple correlations all triangulate to a single causal hypothesis that can lead to a fairly confident conclusion – even in the absence of other evidence. For example, smoking correlates with certain types of lung cancer. There are no prospective studies in humans to establish that smoking causes lung cancer, but we can be confident that it does because the correlation holds up no matter how you choose to look at it. If smoking causes cancer (as opposed to other causal hypotheses stemming from the correlation) then we predict that increased duration of smoking increases risk of lung cancer, that stopping smoking decreases risk, that smoking unfiltered is more risky than filtered, etc. Each of the predictions turns out to be true, supporting the smoking causes lung cancer hypothesis.
Rain and Autism
I was immediately interested in how the authors of this study came by the notion that rain might correlate with autism rates. In their older publication they mention that they thought of it as a way to test the hypothesis that TV watching may be an environmental trigger for autism, and that increased precipitation correlates with greater TV watching. In their most recent publication they explore various other causal hypotheses.
For example, they discuss that increased rain leads to more time spent indoors. While this may lead to increased TV watching, it also leads to an increase in all indoor activities. It also leads to increased exposure to the indoor environment, and decreased exposure to the outdoor environment. Therefore there may be some indoor trigger or outdoor protective element.
The rain itself may be involved. Increased rain may increase exposure to atmospheric toxins.
The authors also raise the possibility that increased precipitation correlates with decrease sun exposure, which could lead to relative Vitamin D deficiency, which is the actual trigger for autism. I actually find this the most plausible scenario. Relative vitamin D deficiency has been linked recently to increased risk of a variety of neurological disorders, and has lead to an increase in the recommended daily allowance of Vitamin D for children.
But what the study does not discuss are those causal hypotheses that no one has yet considered (obviously because no one has considered them). This is always the primary weakness of pure correlation – there are so many variables that it is nearly impossible to anticipate them all.
Here is an example from an unrelated field. The research on the possible protective effects of alcohol and heart disease has been largely epidemiological (i.e. correlation). Many studies showed that those who drink a little every day are healthier than those who do not drink at all. It was not considered for many years after this data started to come out, however, that the group that does not drink at all contains ex-drinkers, who are unhealthy as a consequence of their prior alcohol abuse. That may seem like an obvious point now, but it was missed for a long time.
It therefore seems possible, even likely, that there can be a complex causal relationship hiding in this apparent correlation between rain and autism.
We won’t know until further studies are done. The authors of this study concluded:
These results are consistent with the existence of an environmental trigger for autism among genetically vulnerable children that is positively associated with precipitation. Further studies focused on establishing whether such a trigger exists and identifying the specific trigger are warranted.
This is the exactly correct way to word this conclusion – the results are consistent with an environment trigger (but do not prove that one exists), and the results warrant further research (but cannot be used to form reliable conclusions). We can now base predictions on various causal hypotheses stemming from this study as a guide to future research. Something interesting may ultimately come out of this.
Conclusion
Autism remains a poorly understood neurological entity, although it is an area of active research and we have a great deal of information upon which to base our thinking about autism. It is clear that there is a huge genetic component to autism, but it is also probably not a strictly genetic disorder (or, more likely, set of related disorders). While there is no clearly established environmental factor, most such disorders result from an interplay of genetics and environment.
I suspect, however, that the environment of the womb is the dominant environmental factor. Recent research is finding that subtle signs of autism are detectable earlier and earlier in an infants life. The environment of the infant may play a role in expression, but I am not convinced that any post-natal factors trigger autism in children that would otherwise not display any features. This latest study may be providing a clue (if the correlation itself holds up to replication) of a post-natal factor, but right now we are in the wild speculation phase of thinking about these results.
What is clear is that more research is warranted.

   Monkey business in autism research
David Gorski
Link
I get e-mail.
Sometimes the e-mail is supportive. Other times, as you might imagine, given some of my posts, it is anything but. On Friday afternoon, I happened to notice an e-mail from an “admirer” of mine that said something like this:
You are a complete jack-ass.
- Generation Rescue
Appended to the e-mail was a link to this article on the Age of Autism blog.
Generation Rescue, as you may recall, is an organization that promotes the idea that vaccines cause autism, and this e-mail almost certainly came from the founder and head of GR, a man named J.B. Handley. In case you don’t know who he is, Handley is a man who is, even by the standards of antivaccinationists, incredibly boorish and possessed of a bull-in-a-china shop manner that alienates even some potentially sympathetic people, although parents who believe that vaccines cause autism seem to love him. He is also quite–shall we say?–flexible in his notions of how vaccines cause autism. Until about a year ago, the Generation website stated unequivocally:
Generation Rescue believes that childhood neurological disorders such as autism, Asperger’s, ADHD/ADD, speech delay, sensory integration disorder, and many other developmental delays are all misdiagnoses for mercury poisoning.
About a year ago, it changed to:
We believe these neurological disorders (“NDs”) are environmental illnesses caused by an overload of heavy metals, live viruses, and bacteria. Proper treatment of our children, known as “biomedical intervention”, is leading to recovery for thousands.
The cause of this epidemic of NDs is extremely controversial. We believe the primary causes include the tripling of vaccines given to children in the last 15 years (mercury, aluminum and live viruses); maternal toxic load and prenatal vaccines; heavy metals like mercury in our air, water, and food; and the overuse of antibiotics.
The kind interpretation is that GR was changing its hypothesis given that the data being published consistently and strongly refuted the myth that mercury in vaccines somehow cause autism. In reality, though, it’s fairly clear that GR was pivoting effortlessly to a hypothesis that not only was nearly completely unfalsifiable but also allowed GR to continue to blame vaccines for autism, which is what it’s really about. More recently, as I have pointed out before, antivaccinationist rhetoric has also pivoted even further and equally as effortlessly to blame unspecified “toxins” or “combinations of toxins” in vaccines. Be that as it may, having felt the love, I have to admit that Mr. Handley sure does know how to charm a guy. When he draws my attention to some abstracts so politely, abstracts that he clearly considers to be very important evidence, how can I refuse to take a look? After all, Mr. Handley himself apparently very much wanted to point me in the direction of these three abstracts, and it would be downright churlish of me to deny him and refuse to look at the studies with as open a mind as possible.
Besides, I was curious; after I had received Mr. Handley’s e-mail, I asked around and found that other believers of the claim that vaccines cause autism had been sending precisely this same link describing precisely these same three abstracts to other bloggers who frequently write about autism and vaccines and who also share my conclusion that the science just doesn’t support the idea that vaccines somehow cause autism. In addition, the article linked to was written by Dan Olmsted, a very credulous reporter who claims that the Amish don’t vaccinate and don’t get autism when they do both and who conveniently couldn’t find a special needs clinic in the heart of Amish country that treats Amish with some forms of autism. Although not quite as endearingly overwrought in his rhetoric as Kent Heckenlively‘s verbiage, Mr. Olmsted’s articles are usually still instructive as excellent lessons in how not to interpret scientific studies. So onward, we go! Here’s Mr. Olmsted:
The first research project to examine effects of the total vaccine load received by children in the 1990s has found autism-like signs and symptoms in infant monkeys vaccinated the same way. The study’s principal investigator, Laura Hewitson from the University of Pittsburgh, reports developmental delays, behavior problems and brain changes in macaque monkeys that mimic “certain neurological abnormalities of autism.”
The findings are being reported Friday and Saturday at a major international autism conference in London.
Although couched in scientific language, Hewitson’s findings are explosive. They suggest, for the first time, that our closest animal cousins develop characteristics of autism when subjected to the same immunizations – such as the MMR shot — and vaccine formulations – such as the mercury preservative thimerosal — that American children received when autism diagnoses exploded in the 1990s.
The first thing I noticed here before even reading more is just how much antivaccinationists have “sculpted,” if you will, their “hypothesis” (if you can call it that). No longer do they write about “it’s the mercury, stupid” or how “autism and autism spectrum disorders are all all ‘misdiagnoses for mercury poisoning.’” They’ve now added the new wrinkle of blaming vaccines in general and the “vaccination schedule” for….well, it’s not entirely clear what, although they do clearly believe it’s bad and frequently go on and on about “too many, too soon.” That brings us to the second thing that I noticed, which is that they are no longer claiming that vaccines “cause” autism. They are touting this study as showing that vaccines somehow induce behavioral and brain changes that mimic “certain neurological abnormalities of autism.” Couple that with their efforts to imply that there are so many out there with a rare mitochondrial disorder that makes them susceptible to being turned autistic by vaccines, and I marvel at how fluid antivaccinationists are in their use of language, as long as it can be somehow twisted into implying that vaccines cause autism.
I’m not going to discuss Olmsted’s commentary on these abstracts any more because Olmsted has demonstrated unequivocally time and time again that he wouldn’t know a good scientific study if it bit him in his hindquarters. Besides, in response to tweaking over at the Autism Blog, the editors of AoA kindly posted the actual text of all three abstracts that were presented at the International Meeting for Autism Research (IMFAR). Why bother with a secondhand description colored with biased commentary when I can cut through his obfuscation and go straight to the source? The three abstracts were:
     1.  Pediatric Vaccines Influence Primate Behavior, and Amygdala Growth and Opioid Ligand Binding, Friday, May 16, 2008: IMFAR. L. Hewitson , Obstetrics, Gynecology and Reproductive Sciences, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA B. Lopresti , Radiology, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA C. Stott , Thoughtful House Center for Children, Austin, TX J. Tomko , Pittsburgh Development Center, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA L. Houser , Pittsburgh Development Center, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA E. Klein , Division of Laboratory Animal Resources, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA C. Castro , Obstetrics, Gynecology and Reproductive Sciences, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA G. Sackett , Psychology, Washington National Primate Research Center, Seattle, WA S. Gupta, Medicine, Pathology & Laboratory Medicine, University of California – Irvine, Irvine, CA D. Atwood , Chemistry, University of Kentucky, Lexington, KY L. Blue , Chemistry, University of Kentucky, Lexington, KY E. R. White , Chemistry, University of Kentucky, Lexington, KY A. Wakefield , Thoughtful House Center for Children, Austin, TX.
     2.  Pediatric Vaccines Influence Primate Behavior, and Brain Stem Volume and Opioid Ligand Binding, Saturday, IMFAR. A. J. Wakefield , Thoughtful House Center for Children, Austin, TX C. Stott, Thoughtful House Center for Children, Austin, TX B. Lopresti , Radiology, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA J. Tomko , Pittsburgh Development Center, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA L. Houser , Pittsburgh Development Center, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA G. Sackett , Psychology, Washington National Primate Research Center, Seattle, WA L. Hewitson , Obstetrics, Gynecology and Reproductive Sciences, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA.
     3.  Microarray Analysis of GI Tissue in a Macaque Model of the Effects of Infant Vaccination, Saturday, May 17, 2008 IMFAR. S. J. Walker , Institute for Regenerative Medicine, Wake Forest University Health Sciences, E. K. Lobenhofer, Cogenics, a Division of Clinical Data E. Klein , Division of Laboratory Animal Resources, University of Pittsburgh, A. Wakefield, Thoughtful House Center for Children, Austin, TX L. Hewitson , Obstetrics, Gynecology and Reproductive Sciences, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA
But before I dive in, readers should understand that these three abstracts were poster presentations. In the biomedical field, poster presentations are the lowest form of “publication” of one’s data, with the highest being publication in a good quality, high impact, peer-reviewed journal. Indeed, several meetings that I go to fairly regularly accept nearly every abstract that is submitted as a poster. It is from this pool that reviewers decide which abstracts are good enough and/or interesting enough to be oral presentations. That’s not to say that many posters, especially at AACR (a meeting I attend almost every year), aren’t excellent. Many are very impressive, but that’s because, at least at the AACR meeting, the ratio of posters to presentations is quite high (which is why it would be foolish of me to disparage posters in general, given that I personally have presented several posters at various meetings, including AACR). Few abstracts make the cut to be oral presentations, though, relatively speaking. That being said, I do notice that the standards IMFAR appears to subject posters to do not seem to be anything resembling rigorous peer-review. Thus, given that these are only abstracts being submitted as posters, I consider them less seriously than I would an oral presentation and much less seriously than a research article in a good, high-impact peer-reviewed journal. More importantly, the publication of these abstracts as full papers in such a journal would also allow me to examine in detail the methodology, which is only sketchily described in these abstracts. So, even though they are not full scientific papers, discussing these posters is justified because clearly anti-vaccine activists are touting them as some sort of compelling evidence that Vaccines Are Evil Baby-Destroying Weapons of Mass Destruction.
So, on to the abstracts themselves! The first thing that became apparent when I read the abstracts is that they really all appear to describe aspects of one study, the results of which have been split into three different abstracts. In the science biz, this is known as divvying up one’s data into MPUs (minimal publishable units). It’s an unfortunately common practice, but not in and of itself necessarily an indicator of bad science. Because all too many granting agencies and tenure committees seem to be better bean counters than judges of quality and significance when examining a researcher’s publication record, lots of researchers do it. However, we as scientists do tend to look askance at the practice when it is done too blatantly, especially if duplicate or replicative data is included with the MPUs to pad them.
What next leaps to mind in looking at the abstracts themselves is that there are 13 monkeys in the “vaccine” group and only three in the control group. The authors do not explain or justify why there are such unequal numbers of subjects in the two groups or why they didn’t simply assign eight monkeys to each group. Doing so would have required the same number of animals. Similarly, there is no mention of how the monkeys were assigned to one group or the other (randomization, anyone?), whether the experimenters were blinded to experimental group and which shots were vaccine or placebo, whether the monkeys were weight- and age-matched, or any of a number of other controls that careful researchers routinely do when setting up animal experiments. Considering these factors, right off the bat from the small numbers (particularly with only three monkeys in the control group), I can fairly safely conclude that the study almost certainly doesn’t have the statistical power necessary to find convincing evidence of an effect of vaccination on any of the parameters measured. Let’s put it this way. I do experiments with mouse tumor models, and if I put such a large mismatch in terms of the number of controls relative to the experimental group, I would be highly unlikely to get any results I could have any confidence in.
On the other hand, maybe it’s a good thing that there weren’t more monkeys in the study, given the questionable ethics of subjecting infant monkeys to so many repeated procedures in the service of a dubious hypothesis. This concern does not even take into account the number of injections given to the monkeys as vaccines or placebos. Let’s take a look to see what I mean:
    • From Pediatric Vaccines Influence Primate Behavior, and Amygdala Growth and Opioid Ligand Binding: “Amygdala growth and binding were measured serially by MRI and by the binding of the non-selective opioid antagonist [11C]diprenorphine, measured by PET, respectively, before (T1) and after (T2) the administration of the measles-mumps-rubella vaccine (MMR).” In other words, these monkeys were subjected to repeated PET scans and MRIs. That means they had to be restrained and anesthetized each time these studies were done.
    • From Microarray Analysis of GI Tissue in a Macaque Model of the Effects of Infant Vaccination: “Infant male macaques were vaccinated (or given saline placebo) using the human vaccination schedule. Dosages and times of administration were adjusted for differences between macaques and humans. Biopsy tissue was collected from the animals at three time points: (1) 10 weeks [pre-MMR1], (2) 14 weeks [post-MMR1] and, (3) 12-15 months [at necropsy]. Whole genome microarray analysis was performed on RNA extracted from the GI tissue from 7 vaccinated and 2 unvaccinated animals at each of these 3 time points (27 samples total).” So these same monkeys were also subjected to at least two colonoscopies as infants. At least, I assume it was colonoscopies; the abstract doesn’t say.
That’s a lot of procedures and injections for these poor infant monkeys to undergo for what appears to be an experiment in which the distribution between control and experimental groups is such that the study is highly unlikely to produce meaningful results. Where on earth was the University of Pittsburgh’s IACUC? (IACUC at our institution requires us to justify the number of animals requested with a statistical power analysis or, in the cases of preliminary experiments, with a strong scientific rationale for the number requested.) I can’t help but wonder whether these experiments were unnecessarily painful. Worse, these monkeys were clearly euthanized at a very young age, which strikes me as particularly unethical unless there is a really good reason. Primates are not mice.
Ethics and animal treatment aside, let’s get back to the studies. After all, you never know. They may actually be decent science after all in spite of the problems with the allocation of research animals; we have to judge the studies on their methodology, data analysis and conclusions and whether their conclusions are justified by the data. True, this is hard to do from just abstracts (and not particularly informative or quantitative abstracts at that!), but fairness demands that we give the investigators the benefit of the doubt, at least for the moment. Moreover, there is sufficient information in the abstracts to allow some fairly firm conclusions about the quality of these studies.
Once again, perhaps the most critical variable that isn’t discussed is whether proper blinding was used. Someone named Kelli Ann Davis, who acts as though she has inside information, claims that it was. I have my doubts. Of course, perhaps the investigators and caregivers were blinded, but where they correctly blinded? Proper blinding of investigators is particularly important for behavioral studies, but it’s also important for any sort of imaging study or examination of histopathology of biopsies. For behavioral studies, the investigators absolutely needed to be blinded to which monkeys had received placebo and which had received vaccine, both when administering the injections and especially when observing and measuring behavior. Similarly, the radiologists who interpreted the MRI scans had to be blinded as to which scans came from which group, as did the pathologists who interpreted the biopsy results; otherwise subtle (and not-so-subtle) biases can creep in and affect the results. Moreover, it’s unclear whether a saline injection is an adequate placebo for vaccination. Saline injections don’t hurt very much; some vaccines can. This problem alone could potentially account for differences in behavior. If the monkeys receiving vaccines hurt more, they might become more afraid and withdrawn.
Here’s another question that I had: How long is the life expectancy and developmental time to maturity of these monkeys? In other words, were the investigators scaling down the time between injections proportionally to the difference in development between humans and these monkeys? So I looked it up. Rhesus Macaque monkeys live around 25 years and males reach sexual maturity by around four years of age, approximately 1/4 of the time it takes humans males to reach sexual maturity and one third of the lifespan of an average human male. That means, if I interpret correctly the methodology claiming to “adjust for age” that these monkeys could have received a lot of shots in a really short period of time.
Another issue is that it is not clear how many different behaviors were examined in total, and many of the behaviors reported as being different between the vaccinated and unvaccinated monkeys are not particularly “autistic”-seeming. In any case, given the extremely small sample size, it is not at all surprising that there were positive findings just by chance alone. Indeed, just to satisfy my curiosity, I took a very simple model, in which the examination of a single trait in the monkeys was a “yes-no” question and then ran a Fisher’s Exact Probability test for a control group of 3 in which zero exhibit the trait and the experimental group of 13, in which I modeled different numbers of monkeys exhibiting the trait and checked resulting the p-value. To achieve statistical significance at the usual p=0.05 level, 10/13 of the vaccinated monkeys, or 77%, would have to exhibit a given trait, with none of the control monkeys exhibiting it. That’s a huge number, and that’s for a hypothetical trait that is a noncontinuous variable with two possible values; i.e., a “yes-no” question, as in “yes, the monkey exhibits that behavior” or “no, the monkey does not exhibit that behavior.” If we start looking at traits that rely on quantitative measurements of a behavior, in other words a continuous variable such as behavior frequency, then a control group of three is clearly totally inadequate; even a relatively small variance would make it very difficult to achieve statistical significance for any trait other than by random chance. The differences would have to be quite large and the variances, particularly in the control group, quite small.
Finally, let’s look at the microarray. I’ve actually done gene expression profiling before using microarrays and am experienced with PCR and quantitative real time PCR. I can’t say I’m an expert at cDNA microarrays, but I’ve picked up a few principles over the years. Let’s see what the investigators say about this study in the last abstract:
Whole genome microarray analysis was performed on RNA extracted from the GI tissue from 7 vaccinated and 2 unvaccinated animals at each of these 3 time points (27 samples total).
Results: Histopathological examination revealed that vaccinated animals exhibited progressively severe chronic active inflammation, whereas unexposed animals did not. Gene expression comparisons between the groups (vaccinated versus unvaccinated) revealed only 120 genes differentially expressed (fc >1.5; log ratio p<0.001) at 10 weeks, whereas there were 450 genes differentially expressed at 14 weeks, and 324 differentially expressed genes between the 2 groups at necropsy.
One thing that leaps right out at me immediately is the question of why on earth specimens from only slightly more than half of the vaccinated monkeys and only two out of the three unvaccinated monkeys were evaluated. What happened to the other specimens? No explanation is given for why specimens from all the monkeys weren’t studied. This alone makes me suspicious of the results. Why were samples from six vaccinated monkeys and one unvaccinated monkey not used?
The second thing that leaps right out is the cutoff the investigators were using for identifying differnetially expressed genes. It’s not entirely clear from the abstract, but they appear to have used a cutoff of a 1.5 times increase or decrease in the level of a given gene’s transcript. In other words, a gene qualifies as being “differentially expressed” if its messenger RNA (mRNA) level in the vaccinated group is at least 1.5 times control or less than 1/1.5, or 0.67 times its level in the unvaccinated group. If I’m interpreting correctly how they did this, that’s a pretty loose standard for deciding on whether a gene is differentially expressed in the vaccinated group or not, especially in a first pass experiment with very low sample numbers. Let’s put it this way: In one of the microarray experiments I did, all the genes of interest that I looked at had ratios of over 6, and one had a ratio of over 200, which, not surprisingly, really got our attention. Although sometimes we will accept 1.5-fold differences, in general in doing a microarray experiment, on the first try we ignore any gene with less than a two-fold change, and we prefer to see three-fold or greater changes in expression levels of the messenger RNA. This is especially true when one uses a log ratio to calculate each gene’s relative expression level, given that the log ratio is prone to large changes due to error at low expression levels. This would be particularly true in a dataset that includes only two control samples, which is the absolute minimum number that any sort of statistics can be done on and totally inadequate for an experiment like this, except as a very preliminary and exploratory study. The selection of this liberal cutoff strongly suggests to me that the investigators might have been trying to pad the number of differentially expressed genes. Of course, it is possible that the investigators were referring to a true log ratio of 1.5 (i.e., a 21.5-fold change, or 2.8-fold change), which they may very well have been doing). This would still be fairly liberal for an experiment with only two samples in the control group. Remember, cDNA microarray expression profiling looks at thousands of genes at the same time; without truly rigorous statistics, there will be dozens (if not hundreds) of false positives if no correction is made for multiple comparisons. That’s one reason why in microarray experiments it is absolutely critical to verify any “positive” findings for genes that are up- or downregulated by doing at minimum:
    • Reverse transcriptase quantitative real time PCR
    • Western blot or immunoprecipitation to verify that the difference observed in the mRNA level is also seen at the protein level (assuming, of course, a suitable antibody is available)
Indeed, in the aforementioned experiment that I did, we used the microarray as a discovery tool and then validated several of the genes that were interested in that were indicative of inhibition of a signaling pathway using several different modalities.
Did the authors validate any of the genes they found with differential expression levels using these techniques? I see no mention that they did. If they didn’t, their results mean very little, except perhaps for genes with differential expression with a ratio of greater than 10 (a very small number, I’d bet). Once again, cDNA microarray experiments are tricky and often prone to producing false positives in terms of finding genes that are differentially expressed between a control and a test group. Any findings must–and I can’t repeat this enough–must be validated, or at the very least changes in mRNA levels a subset of the genes must be validated by other techniques, particularly when there are so few replicates upon which to do statistics. Another curious thing about this abstract is that the investigators only report in the abstract raw numbers of mRNA transcripts that were up- or downregulated; usually investigators report a few of the specific genes that were most differentially regulated and the ratio by which they were different. All they say is that they are genes consistent with “inflammation,” but that could mean a lot of things, and we don’t diagnose inflammation through the use of cDNA microarrays. Also, in a time course experiment like this, it would be of great interest to know if it was the same genes that were elevated, whether they were continuing to increase or whether they peaked and came back down. If there is no consistent pattern, chances are that what the investigators were observing was noise. Raw numbers of genes going up or down mean little. The identities of the genes, how much they go up and down, and the pattern are all what matter.
Overall, judging from the abstracts so helpfully provided by AoA, I am, alas, underwhelmed. These three studies appear to be nothing more than Hornig v.2.0, except this time with monkeys. I suppose it’s possible, albeit unlikely, that the science in the actual study will turn out to be better than what is represented in the abstracts. For that, we will have to wait for the actual papers to be published–if they ever are published, which is by no means certain, given what I can glean of the quality (or, more correctly, the lack thereof) of the science presented in these abstracts. If anyone actually attending IMFAR and saw the posters, I’d love to hear your account of what was actually reported. Please post it in the comment or e-mail me.
Finally (and I saved this for absolutely last because I wanted to address the substance of the abstracts first without being accused of basing my criticism primarily on ad hominem attacks), who did this experiment? One name stands out: Andrew Wakefield. Yes, it’s the same Andrew Wakefield whose incompetent science (particularly in the area of dealing with RNA and doing PCR!) done with huge conflicts of interest led to a scare that caused MMR vaccination rates to plummet in the U.K. ten years ago. In addition, a blogger named Kev informs us a bit about some of the other authors:
The primary author seems to be Laura Hewiston of Pittsburgh University. She is registered on that page as a DAN! Doctor. She (I think its the same person) also appears here (see 953) and here.
Also listed as an author according to AoA is one AJ Wakefield. Enough said about that!
Lastly, is Steve Walker who did a poster presentation at an IMFAR in the past (can’t recall which one) which also appeared to offer support for the MMR hypothesis. Oddly, that poster presentation never made it into any kind of peer reviewed journal.
Also oddly enough, Hewiston appears to have a background in primate research and has presented multiple times at the meeting of the American Society of Primatologists, an observation that makes me wonder how she got roped into these studies. Apparently she has an autistic son, and that may be coloring her decisions. Unfortunately, Dr. Hewitson wouldn’t be the first researcher whose personal brush with autism led her down the path of questionable science. It appears that such may be the case with her.
Indeed, having learned that she has an autistic son, I really, truly wanted to give Dr. Hewitson the benefit of the doubt as I read these abstracts, assuming that perhaps her love of her son was affecting her scientific judgment and that she might not know what she was getting into when she collaborated with Andrew Wakefield. Sadly, I then discovered what seems to be a very serious and apparently undisclosed conflict of interest, as a commenter has informed me. Not only is Dr. Hewitson married to Dan Hollenbeck, a regular contributor to the Age of Autism website (which would not in and of itself be a major conflict of interest), but she and her husband are listed as litigants in the Autism Omnibus proceedings (see #437):
437. Laura Hewiston and Dan Hollenbeck on behalf of Joshua Hollenbeck, Dallas, Texas, Court of Federal Claims Number 03-1166V
If this conflict of interest was undisclosed, it is in violation of the policies of INSAR about presentations at IMFAR and conflicts of interest:
INSAR requires authors to disclose their sources of contributed support (commercial, public, or private foundation grants, and off-label use of drugs, if any). INSAR also requires authors to signify whether there may be a real or perceived conflict of interest. Any potential for financial gain that may be derived from reported work may constitute a potential conflict of interest.
Note that the instructions say “any” potential financial gain and “…real or perceived conflict of interest”! I’d say that being a plaintiff in a massive legal action being heard before the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program that alleges that vaccine injury, specifically some combination of mercury and other factors (I’m never quite clear which) caused autism in the litigants’ children qualifies as a rather major conflict of interest, wouldn’t you? This conflict of interest is not listed on the AoA posting of the abstracts, which means either that AoA left it out when republishing the abstracts or Dr. Hewitson did not report them to INSAR when submitting or finalizing the abstracts. The first possibility would not surprise me, as AoA is a font of misinformation in service of antivaccination ideology; the second possibility saddens me, because, if true, it would indicate that an apparently once talented researcher has taken a major step down the road to academic and professional ruin. I really hate to see that.
But it goes beyond even that. Kev has also figured out that not only is Dr. Hewitson married to Dan Hollenbeck, but that Dan Hollenbeck works for Dr. Wakefield at Thoughtful House as Director of Information Technology and that his website FightingAutism.org is also part of Thoughtful House. Kev sums things up quite well:
So, here we are with three poster presentations from a woman who has an autistic son, affiliated with DAN!, is married to the Thoughtful House IT guy (who also happens to be on the Board of Directors of SafeMinds) and these afore-mentioned poster presentations are also co-authored by Andrew Wakefield. I wonder just how impartial this science can be?
It’s hard not to answer: Not very.
Again, I find it very sad to see an apparently once-promising young researcher fall to these levels, but it’s irritating as well because of the double standard involved. Indeed, the reaction of antivaccination activists will be instructive. They often lambaste, for instance, Dr. Paul Offit, a staunch defender of the vaccine program, because he has in the past received grants and consulting fees from vaccine manufacturers. It is not at all a bad thing to point out potential conflicts of interest and ties to big pharma, although it is unfortunate that antivaccinationists go overboard with such venom and vitriol bordering on calls for violence. However, Dr. Offit has never tried to hide this potential conflict of interest, as far as I’m aware, and that’s key. Undisclosed conflicts of interest are far more damaging to science than disclosed ones, because once a conflict is disclosed skepticism can be ratcheted up appropriately. Undisclosed COIs hide the knowledge necessary to judge how much skepticism is appropriate. In any case, I wonder whether the crew at AoA will be as harsh on Dr. Hewitson as they are on Dr. Offit and any other vaccine scientist who has ever had ties with a pharmaceutical company now that they have been informed of her multiple conflicts of interest. Somehow I doubt it.
Unfortunately, this discovery about Dr. Hewitson goes a long way towards answering the question: Why are these particular abstracts being touted now by antivaccinationists? In other words: Cui bono? The answer is probably two-fold. First, the Autism Omnibus is up and running again. Thus far, the plaintiffs haven’t done so well in terms of supporting science; they certainly desperately need more “ammunition” in the form of studies, no matter how poor quality they are. Taken together, these observations suggest that litigants in the Autism Omnibus may be producing data and studies to be used in favor of the litigants but obfuscating the origins of that data. Taken together, along with the questionable treatment of the animals in this study, these observations lead me to conclude that not only are these studies almost certainly bad science, but they are bad science in the cause of winning the Autism Omnibus. Lastly, ex-Playmate and comedienne-turned-antivaccinationist activist Jenny McCarthy, along with Generation Rescue and other antivaccinationist groups, will be descending upon Washington, DC on June 4 for a protest rally, and this study is useful to them. True, abstracts had to be submitted to IMFAR months ago, but McCarthy had been talking about a protest at the CDC late last year before changing plans earlier this year to a march on Washington. In any case, even if the original intent wasn’t to boost the efforts to blame “toxins” in vaccines for all sorts of evils, the way these abstracts are being distributed now, even to those of us most likely to be skeptical about any research claiming to support the contention that vaccines cause autism, suggests plans for a publicity campaign based on these studies. probably in concert with McCarthy’s march. Look for them to be featured prominently on signs and in speeches there.
I will conclude this lengthy post by taking this opportunity to thank Mr. Handley profusely. If he hadn’t sent me such a gloating e-mail, I might never have learned of these abstracts or bothered to review them. He led me to this analysis of the bad science and conflicts of interest behind this research, and I sincerely hope that his fellow travelers in the antivaccination movement will accord him all the accolades he deserves for it. I never could have done written this post without him.

   Peruvian Hamsters and Autism: Cui Bono?
Harriet Hall 
Link
Some people are very invested in the idea that thimerosal in vaccines causes autism. They have looked and looked, but have been unable to find enough credible evidence to convince the scientific community. Thimerosal was removed from US vaccines several years ago, and you might have thought that would end the debate. It didn’t. The spotlight has shifted to other countries that still use thimerosal-preserved vaccines, such as Peru.
Anti-vaccine activist David Kirby said,
If thimerosal is one day proven to be a contributing factor to autism, and if U.S. made vaccines containing the preservative are now being supplied the world over, the scope of this potential tragedy becomes unthinkable.
The anti-vaccine website Age of Autism accuses US policy of
[making]…Kirby’s nightmare suggestion a reality. U.S. vaccine manufacturers have continued to ship thimerosal containing vaccine formulations all over the world, in effect offering a defiant double standard of mercury risk for infants from rich countries as compared to poor countries.
They accuse the US of keeping its own children safe while callously endangering children in other countries. Actually, the decision to remove thimerosal from vaccines in the US was a bend-over-backwards-cautious political decision rather than one based on evidence of harm. The vaccines used in Peru are not evidence of any evil plot, much less a US plot. The World Health Organization (WHO) and its Latin American partner the Pan American Health Organization (PAHO) decided to retain thimerosal as a vaccine preservative because of economic considerations and because they did not find evidence that it was harmful.
The Age of Autism website is making much of a new Peruvian study in hamsters that allegedly supports the thimerosal/autism link. The abstract is available in English, but the full article is in Spanish. Critics demanded an English translation to allow for proper peer review, only to be told they were prejudiced against Spanish and that the report had been peer reviewed. One critic thought “the fact that there is no formal translation of this report into any language that I am aware of makes it obvious that the report is no good – otherwise the scientific community would be falling over themselves to translate it.” I don’t think that’s a valid inference, but anyway it would be nice to be able to read the whole paper, not just the English abstract.
No problem. I’m fluent in Spanish. I read it. The research was not in my field of expertise, but it looked quite reasonable as far as I could tell. I don’t think it really matters whether the study is flawed, because even if its results are impeccable I’m not impressed that they tell us anything that would link thimerosal to autism.
The abstract says
The administration of thimerosal in doses equivalent to vaccines content was associated with low corporal weight, low encephalon weight and smaller stature in postnatal hamsters. Neurotoxic effects were also produced at encephalic level, at hippocampus (regions CA1, CA3, DG), cerebral cortex and cerebellum (Purkinje cells and granuloses cells) with decrease in neuronal density, neuronal necrosis, axonal dismyelinization and gliosis.
A US study in 2004 showed that only certain strains of mice were susceptible to thimerosal, and the findings in those mice were very different from the hamster findings.
Autoimmune disease-sensitive SJL/J mice showed growth delay; reduced locomotion; exaggerated response to novelty; and densely packed, hyperchromic hippocampal neurons with altered glutamate receptors and transporters. Strains resistant to autoimmunity, C57BL/6J and BALB/cJ, were not susceptible. These findings implicate genetic influences and provide a model for investigating thimerosal-related neurotoxicity.
A similar US study on those SJL/J sensitive mice was published in 2008. It used a dose 10 times higher and found that
results do not indicate pervasive developmental neurotoxicity following vaccine-level thimerosal injections in SJL mice, and provide little if any support for the hypothesis that thimerosal exposure contributes to the etiology of neurodevelopmental disorders.
So of the 3 studies in small critters, one showed no effects at 10 times the dose, and the two that did show effects didn’t show the same effects. For instance, one showed a decrease in neuronal density, the other showed densely packed neurons. They did both show growth delays (weight and height), but that is not characteristic of autism; and the other hamster and mouse findings do not coincide and do not match known findings in autism.
Animal studies are always problematical. The effects on hamsters may be very different from the effects in humans. There is no adequate animal model of autism.
The Peruvian study is not listed on PubMed, which does list many journals in other languages and provides English abstracts. It was published in an in-house journal, a publication of the Peruvian medical school where the research was done. Their articles are reviewed by an in-house editorial board, not sent out for external peer review.
Studies in non-English speaking countries are statistically more likely to be positive (i.e., there is a greater chance that published reports are false positives). Scientific standards may not be as high, and negative results are less likely to be published. I don’t think Peru does a whole lot of medical research; this is the first study I have ever read from that country.
The review of the literature in the introduction to the study is biased. It misrepresents the state of the evidence for and against thimerosal. It cites a series of papers as evidence that thimerosal causes autism, but every one of them is by the discredited anti-vaccine activists Geier and Geier. The many credible studies showing no correlation are barely mentioned in passing. It seems obvious that the authors of this paper have an agenda: to show that thimerosal should be removed from vaccines in Peru.
They do not make it clear that the decision to remove thimerosal from American vaccines had nothing to do with any documented dangers, but was a precautionary measure to reduce total mercury burden from all sources “just in case.”
Their bias is also shown by their comments, “While it is true, it is very difficult to extrapolate these findings to other animal experimentation groups and over human beings, our results, as the multiple scientific evidence recently published about thimerosal, clearly indicates the toxic nature of this substance at the same dose and the same chronology as human immunizations; therefore we suggest the employment of alternative preservatives in vaccines, especially those intended to pregnant women, neonates and small children based in the prevention and precaution principles of all medical interventions.”
The best scientific studies usually end with a statement to the effect that “if” their findings are confirmed, it “might” mean thus and so. These folks seem to me to have gone beyond the science into recommending social policy. And they have not considered whether there might be any downside to demanding alternative preservatives.
If the thimerosal hypothesis were correct, the rate of autism would be rising faster in Peru than in the US. I don’t think anyone has tried to determine if that is true. Without that kind of data, conclusions based on animal experiments are nothing but speculation.
So what do we have? One study showing thimerosal is bad for hamsters in a way that doesn’t match the findings in autistic children. One study showing thimerosal is bad for one strain of susceptible mice, but in a different way that also doesn’t match the findings in autistic children. Another mouse study contradicting the first one, showing 10 times as much thimerosal is not bad for mice, even the most susceptible strains of mice. That sure doesn’t add up to much. We may have learned something about hamsters, but we haven’t learned anything about humans or autism.
I think the Peruvian experiment may have been a waste of hamsters. PETA wouldn’t approve. But then PETA wouldn’t approve of the Peruvian policy towards guinea pigs, either: they let them run free on the dirt floor of their kitchens, then snatch them up and cook them as needed. I tasted “cui” when I visited a village in the Andes – it was pretty good.
After reading this study, I couldn’t help but ask, “Cui bono?”
(That’s Latin for “who benefits?” and also for “Does the guinea pig taste good?”)

“New school” antivax goes old school as Byram Bridle asks if COVID-19 vaccines will drive an “epidemic” of autism
Wakefield redux? Antivax scientist Byram Bridle just took the “new school” antivax movement old school by implying that COVID-19 vaccines might cause an “epidemic of autism.” Everything old is new again, sort of.
David Gorski on January 22, 2024
Tweet

Sometimes there are topics that just demand that I write about them. So it was over the weekend, as I was perusing my usual sources looking for suitable topics to write about today and found one that grabbed my attention to the point where I immediately knew that I had to abandon the topic that I had already tentatively chosen for today, putting it off for another day (or perhaps my not-so-secret other blog) and focusing on this. I will freely admit that part of the reason I knew I had to write about this was because it so clearly vindicated what for me had started out as a bit of a quip that I had started repeating in the early months after the mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines from Pfizer and Moderna first rolled out in those heady days of early 2021, namely that the only reason antivaxxers weren’t claiming that COVID-19 vaccines could cause autism was because they were not being administered to young children. As the age range for the COVID-19 vaccines got younger and younger, I predicted that antivaxxers would soon be blaming them for autism, but that it might take a few years because autism spectrum disorders are usually not diagnosed until a child is around 3 years old and the characteristic behaviors start to manifest themselves to the point where the parents become concerned. Leave it to Byram Bridle to vindicate my prediction with a post over the weekend on his Substack entitled Will COVID-19 Shots Drive an Epidemic of Autism?, albeit not in the way that I expected. He did, however, echo a common variant of an old antivax claim that vaccines cause autism by adding the blurb If Yes, Those Who Coerced Pregnant Women to Take modRNA Shots Will Be Responsible For It.
It all very much reminded me of something I said on X, the platform formerly known as Twitter, the other day:
Byram Bridle returns! (He never really went away)
You might remember Dr. Byram Bridle, associate professor and viral immunologist in the Department of Pathobiology in the Ontario Veterinary College at the University of Guelph, from the early days of the COVID-19 vaccine rollout nearly three years ago. I first wrote about him in June 2021, when he claimed to have “discovered” a “secret” Japanese study that showed that the Pfizer vaccine’s biodistribution included the ovaries (among other organs), ignoring the facts that the study was not “secret” and was a fairly standard biodistribution study in which huge doses of the vaccine were injected intravenously in mice in order to determine where the drug might go, no matter how small the quantities. (Remember, vaccines are not injected directly into the bloodstream, much less at doses anywhere near what the study used.)
At the time, I also took note of Dr. Bridle for videos like this:
Basically, Dr. Bridle (mis)represented himself as a “provaccine” scientist who made this startling admission (tellingly, quoted by Mike Adams):
In short, the conclusion is we made a big mistake. We didn’t realize it until now. We saw the spike protein was a great target antigen. We never knew the spike protein, itself, was a toxin and was a pathogenic protein. So, by vaccinating people, we are inadvertently inoculating them with a toxin, and in some people this gets into circulation. And when that happens in some people, it can cause damage, especially with the cardiovascular system. I don’t have time, but many other legitimate questions about the long-term safety there for this vaccine. For example, with accumulating in the ovaries, one of my questions is, “will we be rendering young people infertile, some of them infertile?” So, I’ll stop there.
Yep, it’s the “vaccines are going to sterilize our womenfolk” gambit all over again, an antivax gambit that started right around the time that COVID-19 vaccines were granted emergency use authorization (EUA) in December 2020. It’s a very old antivax trope that dates back decades, which is why I was not surprised to see it rear its ugly head again applied to the new mRNA-based vaccines. How old is it? Well, as a matter of coincidence, a peer-reviewed article co-authored by Tara Smith and me accepted for publication in Vaccine just hit the journal’s website late last week. (That’s the first good thing that’s happened to me in 2024.) In the article, we discuss how this trope goes back at least to the 1990s and why it’s a nonsensical conspiracy theory.
But back to Dr. Bridle, given that this time he is not fear mongering about COVID-19 vaccines “sterilizing the womenfolk.” During the last three years, he has diversified his antivax propaganda; for instance, by sarcastically fear mongering about mRNA in breast milk, credulously accusing “Them” of “suppressing” data supposedly showing that ivermectin works against COVID-19 (it doesn’t), parroting the antivax line about “adulteration” of mRNA-based vaccines with plasmid DNA (which is a big nothingburger), and showing up at all sorts of conspiracy theorist antivax conferences and panels. Basically, as much as he claims to be “not antivax,” by his words and actions Dr. Bridle has demonstrated himself to be very much antivax indeed, right up to amusingly whining about how provaccine scientists (like Timothy Caulfield) and advocates “won’t debate him.”
COVID-19 vaccines and autism?
Based on his history, it should come a surprise to no one that Dr. Bridle finds a study done in rats very persuasive support for the contention that prenatal exposure to COVID-19 vaccines will cause autism. It should also come as no surprise given the long history (some of which I myself have documented here) of antivax scientists doing dubious studies of vaccines or vaccine ingredients, like the mercury-containing preservative thimerosal back in the day when thimerosal-containing vaccines were demonized as The One True Vaccine Cause of Autism, at least here in the US. Dr. Bridle’s post also reminded me of a number studies cited by antivaxxers to claim that “immune activation” due to prenatal exposure to, say, Tdap vaccines during pregnancy can hugely increase the risk of autism in the child after birth. (They don’t.) So, right off the bat, we know that Dr. Bridle is resurrecting old antivax misinformation and just applying it to COVID-19 vaccines.
Let’s look at his “concerns” about the study before I discuss the study itself, to see how the study is being spun:
I just finished reading a peer-reviewed scientific article that has been electronically published ahead of the print version. The findings have caused me considerable concern. The paper is entitled “Prenatal Exposure to COVID-19 mRNA Vaccine BNT162b2 Induces Autism-Like Behaviors in Male Neonatal Rats: Insights into WNT and BDNF Signaling Perturbations“.
Of course, the findings caused Dr. Bridle “considerable concern.” He’s antivax, which leads him to this statement:
Sadly, we should have had this comprehensive understanding and then conducted a fully informed risk-benefit analysis before hundreds of thousands of pregnant women were inoculated. But, maybe that is just my crazy way of thinking.
Funny how antivaxxers will seize upon a single study in rats as reason for incredible concern and ignore the clinical data that we have from huge numbers of people vaccinated during pregnancy whose sum total has failed to find evidence adverse maternal or fetal effects from vaccinating pregnant individuals with the COVID-19 vaccine but has produced a growing body of data demonstrates the safety of such use. (There’s even data that the vaccine administered during pregnancy might provide some immunity to the baby as well.) Yeah, a single rat study is going to overturn all that clinical data, because…reasons.
Yes, Dr. Bridle airily dismisses all the existing evidence thusly:
The published studies looking at this have largely been flawed and biased. Ever-emerging evidence proves that the harms of the shots have been substantially underestimated in all people. The only question is by how much? Worse, the studies done during pregnancy have focused most heavily on the women, and less so on the babies. In many cases, babies were followed for only a hand-full of weeks following their birth. This is much too short. And evaluations of these babies have been overly superficial. A classic trick when it comes to the research and development of novel medical interventions is this: one can make a product appear quite safe if one does not look very hard for harms.
Got that? That’s standard antivax conspiracy patter claiming that the only reason “They” don’t find vaccine harms is because “They” don’t look very hard. I swear, I can’t even remember the first time I heard that antivax trope because it was so long ago, nor can I remember the number of times I’ve heard the conspiracy theory that “They” are “suppressing evidence” of harms that antivaxxers so desperately want to attribute to vaccines.
Let’s look at the study now.
COVID-19 vaccines and autism…in rats?
The study in question was published a couple of weeks ago in a journal that I’ve never heard of before, Neurochemical Research, and entitled Prenatal Exposure to COVID-19 mRNA Vaccine BNT162b2 Induces Autism-Like Behaviors in Male Neonatal Rats: Insights into WNT and BDNF Signaling Perturbations. The journal itself, I found, has a respectable impact factor for a specialty journal (4.4.14 in 2023-4); so it’s not the typical crap journal that I usually see these sorts of studies in. It’s also garnered an Altmetric score of 2,757 as of yesterday, which is very high, in the 99th percentile, and has been accessed 44K times. As for the investigators, I am not familiar with any of them, but they are Turkish and come from Izmir Katip Celebi University, Istinye University, Afyon Kocatepe University, and Demiroğlu Bilim University, and the first (and corresponding author) is someone named Mumin Alper Erdogan, who last October also published a study in Journal of Neuroimmune Pharmacology entitled Prenatal SARS-CoV-2 Spike Protein Exposure Induces Autism-Like Neurobehavioral Changes in Male Neonatal Rats.
This latter study is different in that Erdogan injected pregnant rats with either saline, large amount of aluminum hydroxide adjuvant (150 μg/kg, which is within the range commonly recommended for preclinical rodent models), or a large amounts of spike protein (40 μg/kg!) plus a large amount of aluminum adjuvant and then tested the litters of mice for various behavioral traits used as models of autistic behavior, as well as immune markers thought to be associated with autism. Again, I was struck at how large the dose of spike protein was, microgram quantities in rodents that only weighed around 220 g, compared to the typical 70,000 g adult male human. This study was sold as indicating that COVID-19 infection during pregnancy could increase the risk of autism in the offspring of the pregnancy, finding:
At P50, we conducted behavioral analyses on these mature animals and performed MR spectroscopy. Subsequently, all animals were sacrificed, and their brains were subject to biochemical and histological analysis. Our findings indicate that male rats exposed to the spike protein displayed a higher rate of impaired performance on behavioral studies, including the three-chamber social test, passive avoidance learning analysis, open field test, rotarod test, and novelty-induced cultivation behavior, indicative of autistic symptoms. Exposure to the spike protein (male) induced gliosis and neuronal cell death in the CA1-CA3 regions of the hippocampus and cerebellum. The spike protein-exposed male rats exhibited significantly greater levels of malondialdehyde (MDA), tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-α), interleukin-17 (IL-17), nuclear factor kappa B (NF-κB), and lactate and lower levels of brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) than the control group. Our study suggests a potential association between prenatal exposure to COVID-19 spike protein and neurodevelopmental problems, such as ASD. These findings highlight the importance of further research into the potential effects of the COVID-19 virus on embryonic and fetal development and the potential long-term consequences for neurodevelopment.
My first question, of course, was why there was no spike protein alone group, because such a group would help figure out whether the immune system needed to be more stimulated, as with an adjuvant, for this effect to be observed. Still, my eyebrow was raised when I read this passage:
In light of the growing body of research indicating a connection between SARS-CoV-2 infection and neurological symptoms, we conducted a study to examine the potential impact of a synthetic version of the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein on the development of autism spectrum disorder (ASD) in offspring born to mothers exposed to the protein during pregnancy.
And, later:
In light of the growing body of research indicating a connection between SARS-CoV-2 infection and neurological symptoms, we conducted a study to examine the potential impact of a synthetic version of the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein on the development of autism spectrum disorder (ASD) in offspring born to mothers exposed to the protein during pregnancy.
Why the synthetic version? Why not compare to viral infection itself? Why such huge doses? Maybe I’m overly suspicious, but I get the feeling that this study was done in order to lay the groundwork for doing the study being promoted by Dr. Bridle that purports to show a link between the vaccine and autism after prenatal exposure to the vaccine. However, I’ll just take the Erdogan and the authors at their word for the moment that their intent was to study the neuroinflammatory effects of spike protein from infection as a potential promoter of neurodevelopmental disorders like autism spectrum disorders. The reason? Motivation doesn’t matter. Results do. Also, relevance matters, and these studies, as you will see, are not particularly relevant to the questions to which Dr. Bridle thinks they are very relevant.
Let’s move on to the study that so “concerns” Dr. Bridle, who opines later in his post:
I have two boys, so I became very familiar with babies a bunch of years ago. Let’s face it, the bulk of a baby’s early life consists of crying, drinking/eating, pooping/peeing, and sleeping. There is simply not a lot to evaluate when it comes to harms to babies that would manifest as behavioural issues. It is not unusual for babies to seem unhappy and uncomfortable on a regular basis. In other words, one cannot be confident in declaring an absence of a disorder in newborns and even toddlers. For example, I have heard that failing to make eye contact can be a potential sign of autism in young children. Obviously, such an observation cannot be made in a baby; they don’t start making consistent and intentional eye contact for quite some time. So, be very careful when you hear people declaring that there is no evidence of harm to children born to mothers that received the COVID-19 shots. There simply has not been enough time to properly evaluate this.
I like to point out that signs of ASD are often detected in children less than two and can be detected in infants as young as age 6-12 months, sometimes even as young as 3 months. When it comes to ASDs, Dr. Bridle simply doesn’t know what he is talking about here. There is even evidence that signs of autism can be detected in utero as early as mid-gestation. A little humility is in order here. For instance, I know that I am not an expert in neuroscience, autism, or neurodevelopment. I do, however, know from my many years combatting antivaccine misinformation claiming that vaccines cause autism that the signs of autism are detectable much earlier than antivaxxers commonly argue.
Not that that stops Dr. Bridle:
If COVID-19 shots administered to pregnant women can cause neurological harms in their developing babies, including alterations that lead to things like autism, it is almost certain that these could not be identified within the first six weeks. Humans need to gain certain abilities to interact with the world around them before health care professionals can properly assess for evidence of complex disorders. My goodness, some harms aren’t noticed until adolescence if hormonal changes are required to unveil them. This means there is the potential for harms to babies born to mothers that were coerced into getting the COVID-19 shots that we are still unaware of.
No one ever said that we could evaluate in a mere six weeks whether COVID-19 vaccines affect pregnancy outcomes. Again, though, he doesn’t know what he’s talking about here. You don’t have to wait until adolescence to see the signs of ASDs! Again, in some cases, the signs of ASDs can be detected in infancy. His entire argument is just an excuse to invoke the “no long term safety studies” gambit beloved by antivaxxers.
Let’s get to the study, though.
It’s a fairly straightforward study design, although not necessarily a straightforward study. Erdogan’s justification is:
While the mRNA vaccines have exhibited exceptional efficacy in forestalling severe COVID-19 manifestations and curtailing viral transmission, it is of paramount importance to scrupulously investigate the potential neurological ramifications associated with the spike protein itself and with the immune response it induces [16, 17]. Gaining a comprehensive understanding of the implications of spike protein-induced neuroinflammation, along with its impact on synaptic plasticity and overall brain development, will bolster our knowledge of the long-term effects of COVID-19 infection and its vaccination [18].
In this study, our primary objective is to delve deeply into the existing literature and data concerning the potential relationship between COVID-19 mRNA vaccines, spike protein-mediated reactions, and the genesis of neurodevelopmental disorders, focusing on autism.
And:
Through a detailed analysis of these carefully selected parameters, we aim to provide a clearer picture of this pressing area of research and offer directions for subsequent investigations [19, 20].
Is it that pressing a direction of research, though? Is it really? Current clinical evidence in hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of pregnant humans and their offspring have not raised a safety signal of neurodevelopmental disorders linked to the vaccine.
Dr. Bridle cites a reference indicating that many cases of ASD are not diagnosed before the age of 3 and some are not diagnosed until age 5, which is true enough, but not entirely relevant, not that that stops Dr. Bridle:
Here is the problem: Children born to mothers that were coerced into taking COVID-19 shots have not yet reached the age of three. We must now wait another 1.5 years, at least, and likely two or more years to accrue data from enough children to determine whether harms have been caused.
Yes, but there are a lot of children born to those vaccinated against COVID-19 during pregnancy who are getting quite close to 3 years of age, and, again, there are even more who are two years old and still more who are 12 months old. There’s nothing magic about being three years old. It’s more like an average. Lots of children are diagnosed earlier than that, and lots are diagnosed later than that. Although it is still early, with COVID-19 vaccines having only been authorized during pregnancy less than three years ago US, it’s not so early that safety signals for neurodevelopmental disorders in children born after having been exposed to the vaccine in utero through vaccination during pregnancy would not be starting to appear. It’s also a shame, because Erdogan has also published some interesting work in areas in which I’m interested, such as the role of ion channels in cancer. (I wonder if I met him in London in 2015, when I gave a talk at a conference on that topic.)
So how was the study carried out? In brief:
Two cohorts of female rats were randomly assigned to the following treatment groups: Group 1 or the 0.9% NaCl Saline Group (n = 7) and Group 2 or the COVID-19 m-RNA Vaccine BNT162b2 Group (n = 8). Throughout the experiment, the behavior and physical well-being of all animals were meticulously monitored daily. To facilitate the mating process, three female rats were cohabitated with a single male rat for a period spanning two to three days during the estrus phase. The presence of white vaginal plaque in the female rats was used as an indicator of successful mating. After this occurred, the male rats were removed from the enclosures.
After the mating, the rats were then treated thusly:
Rats belonging to Group 1 were administered 1 ml/kg of 0.9% NaCl saline intramuscularly on the thirteenth day of gestation. Simultaneously, rats in Group 2 received a dosage of 30 µg/Rat of the COVID-19 m-RNA Vaccine BNT162b2 intramuscularly on the same day of pregnancy.
Let me first note that this is the full human dose of the Pfizer vaccine administered to rats whose average weight was only 220 ± 10 g. I realize that most people outside of the US are familiar with metric, but for nonscientists understand in the US I’ll just say that this is the equivalent of ~7.8 oz, less than half a pound. I’ll also note that even Dr. Bridle was forced to recognize this problem and try to handwave it away:
Pregnant rats received the same dose as what is given to pregnant women. Some will try to argue that this represents, on a per body weight basis, a higher effective dose. It might, but we don’t have proof of this. How drugs work can vary across species. There are examples where tiny rodents like mice could tolerate doses of drugs that were toxic in people.
Of course, that argument goes both ways, too. Many are the effects seen in rodent models due to drugs or other toxins that do not translate to people, although that doesn’t stop Dr. Bridle from arguing:
This research was conducted in rats. Pre-clinical studies like these are used to predict what might happen in humans. Sometimes the predictions are close. Sometimes the phenomena do not translate into people at all. And sometimes things are worse in people.
He also tries to hand wave why things might be worse in people:
The authors assume that much of the toxicity to the rats is mediated by the spike protein that the modRNA shots get cells in the body to manufacture. However, what they fail to acknowledge is that rats express the low-affinity receptor for the spike protein, unlike humans that express the high-affinity receptor. This means that the spike can only bind weakly to rat cells, but strongly to human cells. As such, I suspect that most of the harm observed in the rats might have been due to inflammation mediated by the lipid nanoparticles and/or immune responses against the spike proteins. If the spike proteins could contribute to the toxicity, then matters could be much worse in hosts with cells expressing high-affinity receptors, which would include people.
This is what we in the biz like to call JAQing off, “just asking questions” designed to lead the listener towards, in this case, the antivax viewpoint being promoted on Dr. Bridle’s Substack posts that the COVID-19 mRNA vaccines are dangerous during pregnancy (actually, that they’re just plain dangerous, regardless of pregnancy status, gender, race, age, etc.).
To continue in that theme, Dr. Bridle argues:
Further, the rats in this study were given a single dose, whereas pregnant women can receive up to two doses. The only way to know for sure is, unfortunately, to wait and see how the global human experiment pans out.
We’re already seeing that. The vaccines are safe and effective, albeit, thanks to mutation and the arrival of the Delta, Omicron, etc. variants and their ability to escape immunity from infection or vaccination against prior variants, they are less effective than they were three years ago.
Getting back to the study again, I note that there was no significant difference between the number of offspring per litter and no neonatal deaths among the litters in either group. Beginning on day 50 after birth (reset to day 1 for purposes of when the tests were administered), the rats born to Group 1 (controls) and Group 2 (vaccinated) were subjected to a number of behavioral tests:
Open Field Test: This initial assessment took place on Day 1. Serving as both a measure of general locomotor activity and anxiety, it also acclimated the rats to a testing environment. Novelty-Induced Rearing Behavior: On Day 4, the rats were evaluated for their vertical explorative behaviors in a novel setting. Three-chamber Sociability and Social Novelty Test: Administered on Day 7, this assessment provided insights into the rats’ sociability and their preference for social novelty. Their prior acclimation to the testing conditions by this point ensured accurate insights. Rotarod Test: On Day 10, the rats underwent this test to evaluate their motor skills and endurance. This physically demanding test was placed last in the sequence to minimize any fatigue or stress impacts on the outcomes of the earlier behavioral assessments.
One thing I noticed right away is something I frequently notice basic scientists failing to do when evaluating the results of rodent experiments, namely doing their observations under double-blind conditions, such that the evaluators do not know which group each rat being tested comes from. They state that they used an “artificial intelligence-based behaviour analysis system and software,” but the link to the system didn’t go anywhere yesterday. One can argue that some of the tests, such as the three-chamber test in which the rat decides between a chamber with no other rat and a “stranger” rat or between a chamber with a known rat and a “stranger” rat in which the test subject’s inclinations to be with one or the other are measured, don’t necessarily need to be double-blinded, but I will argue that all immunohistochemistry tests need to be double blind, even if a computer-aided counting system is used. The reason is that there is some subjectivity in all immunohistochemistry, and, in this case:
Systematic random sampling was employed to maintain uniformity across sections and minimize sampling bias. Counting was facilitated by an image analysis system (Image-Pro Express 1.4.5, Media Cybernetics, Inc., USA) to ensure accuracy and consistency. To ensure objectivity, neuronal counts were independently verified by two trained observers, with any discrepancies discussed and resolved to achieve a consensus count.
See why I think double-blinding would have been nice here?
In addition, several cytokines and immune system factors were measured by PCR from tissue harvested from the hippocampus of the rat brains.
In any event, key findings of the study included:
    • Differences in WNT gene expression and brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) in vaccinated rats, both male and female.
    • A substantial decrease in neuronal counts in critical brain regions, indicating potential neurodegeneration or altered neurodevelopment
    • Male rats reportedly demonstrated “pronounced autism-like behaviors, characterized by a marked reduction in social interaction and repetitive patterns of behavior.”
    • Male rats also demonstrated impaired motor performance, evidenced by reduced coordination and agility.
Here’s Table 4, showing some of the difference:
Sex	Male Groups	Female Groups
Groups	% 0.9 NaCl Saline Male Group	COVID-19 m-RNA Vaccine BNT162b2 Male Group	% 0.9 NaCl Saline Female Group	COVID-19 m-RNA Vaccine BNT162b2 Female Group
Brain IL-17 level (pg/mg protein)	109.7 ± 6.9	112.09 ± 3.8	128.6 ± 4.5	118.9 ± 3.8
Brain BDNF level (pg/mg protein)	806.8 ± 33.4	680.7 ± 27.6 #	773.6 ± 25.4	628.9 ± 24.9 *
Brain TNF-alpha level (pg/mg protein)	94.6 ± 0.3	92.09 ± 4.4	111.3 ± 4.1	104.3 ± 4.5
Brain IL-1 level (pg/mg protein)	22.7 ± 1.01	19.6 ± 0.5	22.7 ± 0.4	21.9 ± 0.9
     1.  Results were presented as mean ± SEM. Statistical analyses were performed by one-way ANOVA. # p < 0.001, different from % 0.9 NaCl Saline Male Group and * p < 0.001, different from % 0.9 NaCl Saline Female Group. For male rats, a significant decrease in brain BDNF levels was evident in the vaccinated group (F(1, 36) = 10.24, p < 0.001), suggesting a specific impact of the vaccine on neurotrophic factors. Similarly, for female rats, brain BDNF levels were significantly lower in the vaccinated group as compared to controls (F(1, 36) = 11.67, p < 0.001), reinforcing the potential influence of the vaccine on neurotrophic signaling
I am familiar with the role of WNT signaling (a molecular pathway that transmits extracellular signals to the nucleus to turn on and off sets of genes that modulate its effect) in cancer, but less so in the brain. The simple version is that WNT signaling is important in neurodevelopment and that impaired WNT signaling can result in various neural impairments, and some research implicates it in the development of ASDs. As for BDNF, it too is important in neurodevelopment, and there is research implicating abnormalities in BDNF signaling with ASDs.
Also, there was noted to be a difference in neuron counts in the hippocampus:
Sex	Male Groups	Female Groups
Groups	% 0.9 NaCl Saline Male Group	COVID-19 m-RNA Vaccine BNT162b2 Male Group	% 0.9 NaCl Saline Female Group	COVID-19 m-RNA Vaccine BNT162b2 Female Group
Neuronal Count CA1	71.8 ± 3.5	54.5 ± 1.3 #	68.5 ± 1.9	66.1 ± 0.8
Neuronal Count CA3	43.6 ± 1.7	30.2 ± 1.1 #	42.2 ± 1.3	39.1 ± 1.1
Purkinje Count Cerebellum	21.9 ± 1.4	13.5 ± 0.9 #	19.8 ± 0.6	18.3 ± 0.9
     1.  Results were presented as mean ± SEM. Statistical analyses were performed by one-way ANOVA. # p < 0.001, different from % 0.9 NaCl Saline Male Group. For the male groups, significant decreases in neuronal counts were observed in the CA1 (F(1, 36) = 23.45, p < 0.001), CA3 (F(1, 36) = 28.37, p < 0.001), and Purkinje cell count in the cerebellum (F(1, 36) = 34.12, p < 0.001) regions, indicating a robust effect of the vaccine. Conversely, the female groups did not show significant differences between treated and control groups in the CA1 (F(1, 36) = 3.21, p = 0.081), CA3 (F(1, 36) = 4.78, p = 0.034), and Purkinje cell count in the cerebellum (F(1, 36) = 5.52, p = 0.024)
Let’s for a moment just accept these results as accurate, the way Dr. Bridle did. Let’s say that the findings of differences in cytokine profiles and neuronal counts between the offspring of vaccinated and unvaccinated rats, , as well as the behavioral differences observed, were accurately measured. What does this mean?
Before I answer that question, I can’t help but mention that I’m glad actually perused the references cited in the study and came across this reference, buried among multiple citations to support a claim:
Erdogan cited Stephanie Seneff and Peter McCullough? Uh-oh. Maybe I was too kind…
Yikes. And uh-oh…again:
No wonder Dr. Bridle likes this study. The authors have cited two of the worst antivax papers I’ve ever seen about COVID-19 vaccines whose authors include one of the worst “new school” antivaxxers (McCullough) and one of the worst “old school” antivaxxers (Seneff).
I take back what I said above when I questioned whether I was being too suspicious of this paper. When you cite two Stephanie Seneff papers, you deserve the suspicion that I had, and it isn’t surprising to me that Dr. Bridle likes this paper. If anything, I was probably not suspicious enough about Erdogan, particularly given the conclusion made by him and his coauthors:
Given the public health significance of understanding the effects of COVID-19 vaccination, especially during pregnancy, comprehensive studies are vital. These should weigh the benefits and potential risks of vaccination, focusing on ensuring optimal neurodevelopmental outcomes. Our findings underscore the importance of continued research in this domain to guarantee the safety and well-being of all individuals, especially those who are pregnant and their offspring.
In summary, this study provides valuable insights into the effects of the COVID-19 mRNA BNT162b2 vaccine on the WNT pathway and BDNF levels, particularly in relation to neurodevelopmental outcomes. The observed male-specific vulnerability and the convergence with existing literature support the involvement of these molecular pathways in neurodevelopmental disorders. However, further research is warranted to validate these findings in human populations and to unravel the complex mechanisms underlying the observed effects. The ultimate goal is to ensure the safety and well-being of individuals receiving COVID-19 vaccination, particularly during pregnancy, while minimizing potential risks to neurodevelopment.
More of a favorite antivax gambit, namely “we need more research.” It’s a gambit used no matter how massive the evidence base against an antivax claim is, such as the old claim that vaccines cause autism.
I deconstructed in depth that paper on G-quadruplexes nearly two years ago! As for the paper on “human genome integration,” I didn’t discuss that paper in particular, but did discuss many times how the claims that the mRNA vaccine can “integrate” into the genome is nonsense. No wonder Dr. Bridle and other antivaxxers like this study!
Relevance, ignored by antivaxxers like Dr. Bridle
The question one has to ask when confronted with a study like this is one of relevance to humans. Even Dr. Bridle recognizes this issue, as he spends considerable verbiage trying to dismiss criticisms based on whether this study is even relevant to what happens in humans while JAQing off in order to make you think that we must treat the results as relevant even though there are a lot of reasons not to, as well as a large amount of data from epidemiological studies of the use of COVID-19 vaccines during pregnancy.
Enter the pandemic’s wrongest man, Alex Berenson, echoing Dr. Bridle’s nonsense about this study:
Naturally, like Dr. Bridle, Mr. Berenson trumpeted this on his Substack in an article entitled URGENT: Giving mRNA Covid vaccines to pregnant rats caused brain changes and autism-like behavior in their young, a new study shows, with the conspiratorial tagline: Naturally, the disturbing finding – which was published in a respected, peer-reviewed journal last week – didn’t come from American scientists and a sarcastic conspiratorial comment in his post:
(Luckily Pfizer did a ton of work to make sure this wouldn’t be problem in humans. Oh, they didn’t? Hey, everyone makes mistakes.)
Again, it’s all about the fear and doubt about the vaccines and ignoring all the human evidence out there:
The study coved only about 40 rats, and it does not prove the vaccines cause autism or similar brain changes in the children of vaccinated pregnant women.
But it does show – again – that the jabs can cause powerful inflammatory and autoimmune responses with unknown consequences, and that their long-term risks have barely been studied.
Mr. Berenson is also ready with an excuse that antivaxxers have been making for two decades:
But neither governments nor vaccine companies have shown any inclination to do that work. And so even if autism diagnoses notably rise in the next few years, proving the mRNAs are responsible will be next to impossible.
Actually, it would be quite possible, in the very same way that doctors studied the vaccine schedule and tried to correlate it with autism diagnoses for the last 30 years and have failed to find a link. It’s just that antivaxxers won’t accept those results. They didn’t accept them for the childhood vaccine schedule, and they won’t accept them for COVID-19 vaccines.
Again, Mr. Berenson is JAQing off, just like Dr. Bridle. Again, it is very much unclear how relevant a model can be in which a dose of vaccine relative to animal body weight so much larger than what is administered to humans and the physiology of pregnancy is so different. One can also question how relevant the behavioral models are to human autism. For example, the three-chamber test has a definite drawback:
To test a mouse’s social interest, researchers place it in a cage that has two side chambers, one of which holds another mouse. Mice normally prefer to investigate the mouse rather than spend time in the empty space. Some of the autism mouse models spend as much or more time in the empty cage, which researchers take to be an indication of social deficits.
But this test relies on an artificial scenario, in which the new mouse is caged and cannot initiate social contact, says Paylor. Tellingly, the FMR1 and NLGN3 rat models both ignore social play, but act normally in the three-chamber test.
“Having a barrier between animals may completely alter the way animals normally interact, and certainly in young rats it prevents rough-and-tumble play behavior,” says Paylor.
I also note that the rats in the Erdogan study were not pups. They were 50 days old and had reached maturity, which is rather late to have been studying the rats. Indeed, one could question why the behavioral part of the study was even designed the way it was when there are rat models that can examine behaviors more relevant to ASDs. I get it. The three-chamber model used is fairly simple and straightforward, but it’s not particularly relevant, particularly not with mature rats.
I could go on and on and on, but I think one of the most telling things I noticed was the reappearance in the comments of Mr. Berenson’s post of an old “friend,” J.B. Handley, founder of Generation Rescue and old school “mercury in vaccines causes autism” leader who’s been fairly quiet for quite a few years. Amusingly, he’s annoyed at Mr. Berenson for previously not having been willing to consider this:
Alex: Your unwillingness, to date, to consider the childhood vaccine schedule’s role in the autism epidemic has been very frustrating for people like me who otherwise conisder you a hero. I hope this revalation helps you re-consider that somehow, magically, the childhood vaccines cause no problems…If you are looking for a mechanism of action, Cal Tech’s Paul Patterson proposed a very clear one more than a decade ago: immune activation events in the brains of babies during critical periods of brain formation. These simmering brain infections can be caused my many different antagonists, but man-made nanoparticle aluminum (the kind found in vaccines that isn’t found in nature) is an obvious culprit, becuase lymphocytes transport it to the brain and the body cant excrete it. There’s likely something similar happening with the mRNA shots that hit the brains of the baby rats, perhaps it’s the spike protein.
I was amused. Mr. Berenson is not sufficiently antivax for old-school antivaxxers, although apparently Dr. Bridle is.
As I wrote at the beginning this post, there is nothing new under the antivax sun. Every antivax claim made about COVID-19 vaccines has a precursor from the beforetime. Also, as I said above, it is nearly inevitable that “new school” antivaxxers who became antivax because of COVID-19 vaccines will over time become become just antivax. As it becomes clear that there is no increased risk of neurodevelopmental disorders like ASDs in children born to individuals vaccinated during pregnancy, the focus will shift (is likely already shifting) to blaming COVID-19 vaccines given to 6 month olds for autism. Same as it ever was.

New Study Finds No Link Between Autism and Acetaminophen Use During Pregnancy
A new study designed to better account for hidden confounding factors has found no link between acetaminophen use during pregnancy and the risk of neurodevelopmental conditions in childhood.
Clay Jones onA pril 12, 2024
Link

Countless news cycles have been spent discussing potential causes of autism and other neurodevelopmental disorders, many (most?) of which have historically involved unfairly and unscientifically blaming mothers. Several rounds in more recent years have been dedicated to acetaminophen, a popular fever and pain medication commonly known by the name brand Tylenol in the United States. This has left many parents confused and anxious over the decision to take what is generally considered to be a safe* medication for fever or aches and pains during pregnancy when other options, such as NSAIDS, have potential for causing serious problems.
To be fair, there have been several studies showing a potential link between use of this medication during pregnancy and adverse neurodevelopmental outcomes in children. In 2021, Nature Reviews Endocrinology published a Consensus Statement supported by 91 “scientists, clinicians and public health professionals from across the globe” that called the safety of acetaminophen into question:
We recommend that APAP should be used by pregnant women cautiously at the lowest effective dose for the shortest possible time. Long-term or high-dose use should be limited to indications as advised by a health professional. Packaging should include warning labels including these recommendations. Given the high prevalence of APAP use by pregnant women, the public health implications of use reduction might be substantial.
https://www.nature.com/articles/%20s41574-021-00553-7
This is a bit more of an aggressive stance than what has been taken by the FDA or the American College of Obstetrics and Gynecology (ACOG). But it isn’t as if ACOG has been telling pregnant women to cram handfuls of acetaminophen down their gullets indiscriminately. In fact, here is their response to the Consensus Statement:
ACOG and obstetrician-gynecologists across the country have always identified acetaminophen as one of the only safe pain relievers for pregnant individuals during pregnancy. This consensus statement, and studies that have been conducted in the past, show no clear evidence that proves a direct relationship between the prudent use of acetaminophen during any trimester and fetal developmental issues.
Neurodevelopmental disorders, in particular, are multifactorial and very difficult to associate with a singular cause. The brain does not stop developing until at least 15 months of age, which leaves room for children to be exposed to a number of factors that could potentially lead to these issues.
The authors are not recommending anything counter to what is already done by obstetrician-gynecologists when prescribing acetaminophen for a given clinical condition. ACOG’s clinical guidance remains the same and physicians should not change clinical practice until definitive prospective research is done. Most importantly, patients should not be frightened away from the many benefits of acetaminophen. However, as always, any medication taken during pregnancy should be used only as needed, in moderation, and after the pregnant patient has consulted with their doctor.
https://www.acog.org/news/news-articles/2021/09/response-to-consensus-statement-on-paracetamol-use-during-pregnancy
In 2022, the inevitable lawsuits began piling up. These efforts targeted Johnson & Johnson, the manufacturer of Tylenol, but also companies that sell generic formulations like CVS, Walgreens, and Walmart. By October of that year, more than 500 of these lawsuits had been clumped together into one large federal multi-district litigation (MDL). In December of 2023, the judge presiding over the Tylenol MDL issued a ruling that appeared to signal an imminent dismissal:
Cote, in a 148-page ruling, found that none of the five expert witnesses proposed by the plaintiffs had offered a sound scientific methodology to support their opinion that Tylenol’s active ingredient, acetaminophen, could cause autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).
“Instead, the unstructured approach adopted by the plaintiffs’ experts permitted cherry-picking, allowed a results-driven analysis, and obscured the complexities, inconsistencies, and weaknesses in the underlying data,” she wrote.
https://www.reuters.com/legal/lawsuits-claiming-tylenol-causes-autism-lack-scientific-support-judge-finds-2023-12-19/
Just last month, however, Judge Cote allowed testimony of a new expert introduced by plaintiffs and the defense has until July to object. And there are also hundreds of potential state lawsuits waiting in the wings, so things might still get ugly. But a new study out of Sweden has provided the best evidence to date on this issue, and the Johnson & Johnson legal team is likely feeling much better about their chances right now.
The study, which was run by researchers at the Karolinska Institute and Drexel University and published in JAMA earlier this week, looked at associations of acetaminophen use during pregnancy with the risk of autism, ADHD, and intellectual disability in children. Researchers looked at the medical records of about 2.5 million Swedish children born between 1995 and 2019, which also included prenatal data. And, quite importantly, this is a cohort study with matched sibling control analysis that is more capable of accounting for potentially confounding variables than any previous investigation.
Again, the sibling controls are the key to why this study is more reliable. They looked at exposures and outcomes in sibling pairs with the same biological parents, meaning that they had similar genetics and environments, and this included many instances where a mother used acetaminophen with one pregnancy but not during the other. This additional layer of analysis revealed that there was no evidence of higher risk.
One interesting finding illustrates the potential for finding associations that can be misleading. In the study, parents with neurodevelopmental disorders were more likely to have used acetaminophen during pregnancy. Parents with autism, for example, are more likely to have children with autism because it is highly heritable:
It is estimated at least 50% of genetic risk is predicted by common genetic variation and another 15-20% is due to spontaneous mutations or predictable inheritance patterns. The remaining genetic risk is yet to be determined.
https://www.uclahealth.org/news/new-genetic-clues-uncovered-largest-study-families-with
The arrow of causality is much more likely to travel through the DNA shared with a developing fetus than through exposure to a medication. Acetaminophen use during pregnancy was also more prevalent with mothers in a lower socioeconomic class or who had psychiatric or neurodevelopmental conditions. We say that correlation does not equal causation a lot, mostly because it is true, and it looks like earlier studies were likely fooled by hidden confounding factors.
*Acetaminophen when taken in excessive amounts, usually but not always in the setting of an intentional overdose, can be extremely toxic and result in permanent liver failure and even death. Appropriate dosing, however, is extremely safe and has fewer potential side effects of concern than other pain and fever reducers such as ibuprofen and aspirin, especially in children. It is, in fact, the only safe OTC medication for these purposes in young infants.

Lithium in Tap Water Probably Doesn’t Cause Autism
A recent study found an association between lithium in tap water and a diagnosis of autism in Danish children. Is it time to turn off the tap and grab the bottled water? Not so fast.
Clay Jones on April 14, 2023
Link

As you read this post, I will be gallivanting around Italy and pretty much acting like I own the place. And I will definitely be trying this Italian food that people are always talking about. So just a quick post today. Divertitevi!
Can the water you drink while pregnant increase your child’s risk of autism?
I think readers will agree that mothers don’t have enough to worry about these days. Thankfully they can now add autism to the list of things that are their fault. Obviously I’m kidding, both because this isn’t something they should be worrying too much about but also because this is far from the first time that mothers have been implicated. In fact, people have attempted to blame mothers for autism for decades*.
A study run by researchers from Yale and UCLA was published in JAMA Pediatrics earlier this month that attempted to uncover a link between naturally occurring lithium in drinking water and the risk for autism. And though they did not claim that lithium exposure in drinking water causes autism directly, they did conclude that an association is possible:
Estimated maternal prenatal exposure to lithium from naturally occurring drinking water sources in Denmark was associated with an increased ASD risk in the offspring. This study suggests that naturally occurring lithium in drinking water may be a novel environmental risk factor for ASD development that requires further scrutiny.
I’m confident that in certain circles the results of this study will be wielded clumsily, despite the limitations that I will discuss shortly. It certainly wouldn’t be the first time that people eager to have an environmental factor to blame have latched on to preliminary findings. Some charlatans have even made careers out of it. But the major media coverage of this study has actually been good about calling for people to not jump to conclusions.
The researchers used data from Denmark, a country that is as loved for its appreciation of all things hygge as it is for the comprehensive nature of their public health records. Denmark also keeps excellent track of trace metals and other contaminants in their water supply and has one of the lowest rates of bottled water consumption in Europe. They are all that and a bag of Lego®! Who knew?
The study authors analyzed lithium levels in public waterworks in Denmark that provide drinking water to half the population. They were even able to match individual mothers to the source of their homes’ tap water during pregnancy. Using the nationwide database of patients with psychiatric disorders, they identified children born between 1997 and 2013 and compared 8,842 kids with an autism diagnosis to 43,864 without the diagnosis. They also controlled for a number of potentially confounding variables, such as maternal age, smoking during pregnancy, location, socioeconomic status, air pollution levels, and child’s sex.
After statistical analysis, they found that the risk of being diagnosed with autism increased with lithium levels in the drinking water:
Every IQR increase in estimated geocoded maternal exposure to natural source of lithium in drinking water was associated with higher odds for ASD in offspring (OR, 1.23; 95% CI, 1.17-1.29). Elevated odds among offspring for ASD were estimated starting from the second quartile (7.36 to 12.67 μg/L) of estimated maternal exposure to drinking water with lithium and the OR for the highest quartile (more than 16.78 μg/L) compared with the reference group (less than 7.39 μg/L) was 1.46 (95% CI, 1.35-1.59).
So as lithium levels increased, so did the risk of an autism diagnosis. When compared to the lowest quartile of recorded lithium levels, lithium levels in the second and third quartiles were associated with a 24-26% higher risk of autism. In the group of children potentially exposed to the highest lithium levels, the risk was 46% higher compared to the lowest quartile. There were, of course, some limitations in the analysis.
Our study also has several limitations. First, this registry study lacks information on dietary and lifestyle factors, including habits of water consumption. This study did not measure the actual sources of water the mothers consumed and did not consider childhood exposure.
They also raise the possibility of other trace elements, such as iodine, that could have contributed to neurodevelopmental problems. Iodine levels do often track with lithium levels in natural sources of water. In my opinion, however, that is an unlikely confounding variable because though hypothyroidism can be caused by excess iodine exposure, and hypothyroidism can cause developmental problems, it is screened for in Danish newborns.
This could be a situation not unlike the classic correlation between ice cream and drowning risk. It would be helpful in this case to have had actual blood levels of lithium in these mothers, or even a potential mechanism of action to increase the plausibility of the study findings. As it stands, we don’t even really know how lithium works in people with psychiatric disorders such as bipolar disorder and depression let alone how it could harm neurodevelopment. Which brings up another potential problem with the study.
People with certain psychiatric disorders are treated with lithium and sometimes these people are pregnant. Lithium as a prescribed medication, which would result in much higher levels in the blood of a pregnant person than from drinking water, has been around for a long time and there is actually a decent amount of safety data that has looked at the potential impact on the developing fetus. Cardiac defects, though still not common, are the problem we worry about the most. There is less data on long term neurodevelopment, but what we have has been reassuring.
Conclusion: Don’t throw the tap water out with the lithium?
Lithium in drinking water is not regulated in the United States, and there are no established standards for how much is safe. Within the past two years, however, it has begun to be monitored more closely. Most of the data on adverse outcomes related to exposure come from people taking lithium as a medication and the amount ingested in drinking water and food (cereals, potatoes, tomatoes, cabbage) is a fraction of that.
Still, we don’t know what causes autism, though there is clearly a large genetic component as demonstrated in studies of twins. It is likely the result of a combination of genetic and environmental factors leading to a variety of changes in the brain that we have given the autism label, and it is definitely possible that exposure to lithium in drinking water played a role in some children with the diagnosis. This study is interesting, and it should be followed up.
In the meantime, I don’t see this as a reason for pregnant people to panic or to avoid tap water entirely. But I also wouldn’t hold it against someone who chooses to do so, although not everyone has the means to live off of bottled water for several months. And, of course, there is often plenty of lithium in bottled water as well. So they would need to do their homework. And because few things in health, and life, are simple and straightforward, there have also been studies linking lithium in drinking water to improved psychiatric outcomes in adults.
Arrivederci!
*The asshole that popularized so-called “refrigerator mothers” as the cause of autism was an abusive fraud.

Processed Foods and Autism
Reports of a “link” between processed food and autism highly misrepresent the actual findings of an in-vitro study.
Steven Novella on July 3, 2019
Link
A new study is making the rounds in the media, with unfortunate but typical misrepresentation. This is partly due to media hype, but I think some of the responsibility goes back to the study authors. The title is: “Propionic Acid Induces Gliosis and Neuro-inflammation through Modulation of PTEN/AKT Pathway in Autism Spectrum Disorder”. I cannot figure out, from reading the study, why those last four words are in the title. Sure, that is the speculation that derives from the data, but the data has nothing directly to do with autism, as we will see. The effect, however, was dramatic. Here are some headlines:
Forbes: “Spike In Autism May Be Linked To Preservative In Processed Foods, Study Suggests”
Medical News Today: “Could processed foods explain why autism is on the rise?”
UPI: “Processed foods may lead to autism, study says”
Business Standard: “Researchers draw link between processed foods and rise in autism”
None of those headlines are fair or accurate. After reading those headlines you may be surprised to learn that the study did not involve children with autism, the risk of autism, or really anything to do with autism. The study, rather, looked at the effects of propionic acid (PPA) on neurons (brain cells) cultured in a dish:
We investigated the effect of Propionic acid (PPA), a short-chain fatty acid (SCFA) and a product of dys-biotic ASD gut, on human neural stem cells (hNSCs) proliferation, differentiation and inflammation.
They found that when the cells were exposed to high levels of PPA this promoted neural stem cell growth, increased the ratio of glial cells to neurons, decreased neurite outgrowth, and increased neural inflammation. These are also features seen in the brains of children with autism. Of course, this is one study and it needs to be replicated to see if this effect is robust, but let’s assume for now that the methods and results are valid. The real question is – how to interpret the results.
As we often point out as SBM, it is a long way from an in-vitro study to a clinical implication, and this applies for either treatment effects or risks. A dish of cultured cells is not an organism. Organisms are complex dynamic homeostatic living things. You cannot extrapolate directly from the petri dish to the animal. At best these in-vitro studies suggest a possibility that would then need to be confirmed in animals. The authors do acknowledge this, and the need for follow up animal study to show if the possible effect they are seeing is relevant in a whole live animal.
But even then we are not done, because rats and mice are not people. We would then need to do epidemiological studies in people, for example studying whether the diet of pregnant women, specifically relating to the amount of PPA, affect the risk of autism in their children. We cannot expose pregnant women to PPA for ethical reasons, but you can also do an experimental study in which you randomize pregnant women, or women who are trying to become pregnant, to a diet low in PPA. Only then, really, will we know if there is a “link” between PPA in the diet and risk of autism. That won’t end the scientific questioning either, as we need to answer many subquestions about dose, other confounding factors, vulnerable populations, and mechanism of action. At best the current study shows a potential mechanism of action IF an actual link is discovered – but it does not establish a link.
There are many ways in which these in-vitro finding will not translate to actual risk in humans. First, PPA is normally found in the gut of humans. So, does the amount of extra PPA consumed in processed foods significantly affect the amount of PPA in the GI system? Does this translate into changes in blood levels, and the levels that cross the placenta, and therefore concentrations in the developing fetus? Are those differences, if any, sufficient to cause biological changes? If any link in this chain is broken, the effects seen in-vitro will not translate to people. Most of the time, the vast majority, effects seen in-vitro do not directly translate to people.
Of course, most people will read the headlines, and not the study, and would not appreciate the distinctions made above in any case.
As an aside, the reporting accepts without challenge the premise that autism rates are increasing. As we have discussed many times, the rise in autism diagnoses is at least partly due to increased surveillance and recognition. We are diagnosing it more, but that does not mean the true incidence is increasing. It’s hard to know exactly, but if we look at all the evidence it seems likely that true rates are stable. There is definitely an increase in surveillance, diagnostic substitution, and a broadening of the definition. If we compare different age cohorts, however, using the same diagnostic criteria, the rates seem stable. But I will grant this is still a bit of an open question, but at the very least much of the apparent rise is an artifact and not real.
Another aspect of the question addressed in this study is the broader question of the apparent link between the GI system and autism. In the last two decades there has been increased evidence for an actual link. For example, there does seem to be a subset of children with ASD who have gastrointestinal symptoms that are sensitive to diet. Some of these children have been found to have specific species of bacteria in their gut microbiome not seen in people without ASD. This does not establish the arrow of cause and effect, but it is intriguing and deserves further research.
That is basically where we are with the current study as well. This is interesting, it deserves further research, and it may fit in with the broader picture of a gut-brain connection in autism, which is also preliminary and deserves further research. In fact the broader issue of a gut-brain connection in general is interesting but needs further research. I am hopeful that in 20-30 years we will actually have interventions based on altering the gut microbiome for certain neurological diseases, but that is likely the time frame we are dealing with.
But for now we are in the preliminary scientific stage, where hype and misleading headlines rule, while firm scientific conclusions, and even less so, interventions, are not yet here.

Glyphosate – The New Bogeyman
Steven Novella on December 31, 2014
Link


There is an ideological subculture that is motivated to blame all the perceived ills of the world on environmental factors and corporate/government malfeasance. Often this serves a deeper ideological drive, which can be anti-vaccine, extreme environmentalism, or anti-GMO. The latest environmental bogeyman making the rounds is glyphosate, which is being blamed for (you guessed it) autism.
Glyphosate is the active ingredient in the herbicide Roundup. It has been widely used for about 40 years, and with the introduction of GM crops that are Roundup resistant, its use has increased significantly in the last 20 years. It has therefore become a popular target for anti-GMO fearmongering.
Glyphosate is one of the least toxic herbicides used. It inhibits the enzyme 5-enolpyruvylshikimic acid-3-phosphate synthase which interferes with the shikimic pathway in plants, resulting in the accumulation of shikimic acid in plant tissues and ultimately plant death. The enzyme and pathway do not exist in animals, which is why toxicity is so low. Still, chemicals can have multiple effects and so toxicity needs to be directly measured and its epidemiology studied.
A systematic review published on 2000 found:
Experimental evidence has shown that neither glyphosate nor AMPA bioaccumulates in any animal tissue. No significant toxicity occurred in acute, subchronic, and chronic studies.
and
Therefore, it is concluded that the use of Roundup herbicide does not result in adverse effects on development, reproduction, or endocrine systems in humans and other mammals. For purposes of risk assessment, no-observed-adverse-effect levels (NOAELs) were identified for all subchronic, chronic, developmental, and reproduction studies with glyphosate, AMPA, and POEA.
As pesticides go, glyphosate has very low toxicity, and any dose a person is likely to get exposed to is well below the safety limits. A 2012 review looking specifically at reproductive and developmental effects found:
In conclusion, the available literature shows no solid evidence linking glyphosate exposure to adverse developmental or reproductive effects at environmentally realistic exposure concentrations.
This includes exposure of farm workers spraying glyphosate, as the chemical is very poorly absorbed through the skin.
A 2011 review of epidemiological studies looking at the association of glyphosate and all non-cancer health outcomes concluded:
Our review found no evidence of a consistent pattern of positive associations indicating a causal relationship between any disease and exposure to glyphosate. Most reported associations were weak and not significantly different from 1.0.
And a 2012 study looking at cancer outcomes:
Our review found no consistent pattern of positive associations indicating a causal relationship between total cancer (in adults or children) or any site-specific cancer and exposure to glyphosate.
In short, there is no evidence for any significant glyphosate toxicity. It breaks down quickly in soil, and can get into ground water, but environmental levels are orders of magnitude lower than accepted safety limits.The current article spreading fears about glyphosate cites the work of Stephanie Seneff, making a clear argument from authority:
For over three decades, Stephanie Seneff, PhD, has researched biology and technology, over the years publishing over 170 scholarly peer-reviewed articles. In recent years she has concentrated on the relationship between nutrition and health, tackling such topics as Alzheimer’s, autism, and cardiovascular diseases, as well as the impact of nutritional deficiencies and environmental toxins on human health.
Seneff, however, has not actually performed any research into glyphosate. She is “a Senior Research Scientist at the MIT Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence Laboratory.” She is also an anti-GMO activist. That does not mean she is wrong – it just means it is misleading to cite her as a researcher and authority. She has published only speculations and gives many presentations, but has not created any new data.
The dramatic claim she is currently making, the one prompting many scary headlines, is that “Half of All Children Will Be Autistic by 2025.” This is not based on any new research. It is simply a naïve extrapolation of current trends indefinitely into the future – which is always dubious. Seneff is also naively equating correlation with causation. Here is her big evidence:
She then assumes correlation is causation – this is the same error the anti-vaccine ideologues make when looking at thimerosal and autism (although conveniently ignore the lack of correlation after the removal of thimerosal from the routine childhood vaccine schedule). The graph below, however, nicely demonstrates that correlation is not necessarily due to causation.
Seneff makes many other dubious claims as well:
Dr. Seneff points out, however, that our gut bacteria do have this pathway, and that’s crucial because these bacteria supply our body with crucial amino acids.
This is pure speculation. There is no evidence that glyphosate has any adverse effect on gut bacteria, or that such effects are linked to any disease.
She makes further claims based purely on correlation as well, including blaming glyphosate for celiac and gluten sensitivity.
The article also repeats a common anti-GMO claim, that wheat in the US is routinely sprayed with glyphosate just prior to harvest. There is never any source given for this claim, and a careful investigation reveals that it is untrue.
Conclusion: Seneff is not credible when discussing glyphosate
Dr. Seneff gives every indication of being an anti-GMO ideologue. She is not a biologist, but rather is a computer scientist, and yet she is being presented as an expert. She has also not conducted any original research, but is spreading fears about glyphosate based on pure speculation, bad science and bad logic.
Meanwhile, numerous published systematic reviews show clear evidence that glyphosate has very low toxicity. More careful study when it comes to any agent being used as heavily as glyphosate is always welcome. Science is complicated, and it is always a good idea to consider factors that may have been previously missed. However, failure to show any adverse effect from glyphosate in epidemiological studies is very reassuring. Given its widespread use, any adverse effect must be tiny or non-existent to be missed by the evidence we have so far.
The evidence, however, will not stop ideologues from cherry picking, misusing evidence, presenting pure speculation as if it were evidence, assuming causation from correlation, and generally fearmongering about a safe chemical in order to grind their ideological axe.

Well Dr. Stephanie Seneff, 2025 is Over. Did Glyphosate Turn Half of All Children Autistic?
Failed predictions are a key feature of pseudoscience, and much of my writing has documented instances of credentialed academies making bold, confident declarations, only to act like they never happened when reality intruded into their fantasy.
Jonathan Howard on December 26, 2025
Link

A big date has arrived. Those of us who have been following pseudoscience for some time will remember that way back in 2014, MIT computer scientist and American Loon #2234 Dr. Stephanie Seneff, predicted that “half of all children will be autistic by 2025“. The culprit, in her opinion, would be glyphosate, an herbicide initially manufactured by Monsanto for genetically engineered crops. As you can imagine, an MIT scientist using the buzzwords autism, Monsanto, and GMOs made quite the splash in the wooisphere back then. It was very big deal at the time.
Well, 2025 is over, and we can now check in with Dr. Seneff’s prediction. Brace yourself. It turns out that no, glyphosate did not turn half of all children autistic.
However, I would like to use this occasion to make a prediction of my own- Dr. Seneff will never admit error. To do so would violate the fundamental code of disinformation influencers. Deliberate amnesia is central to their project, and they often act aggrieved and offended whenever anyone reminds them of their past predictions. How dare you remember the thing I said!
Predictably, instead of reflecting, apologizing, and retreating from public commentary as someone with integrity would do, Dr. Seneff has seamlessly moved on to claiming that vaccines will cause 50% of children and 80% of boys to be autistic by 2032. It’s always onwards to the next thing.
Stephanie Seneff: "If we continue vaccinating kids as we have been by 2032, 1 in 2 children will have autism–and 80% of the boys will have it." https://t.co/4v81HTyn1B
— Tamlyn JJ (@TamlynJJoy) February 27, 2023
h/t Dr. Christopher Hickie
She’s hardly alone in this regard. Failed predictions- both of catastrophes and better days ahead- are a key feature of misinformation, and much of my writing has documented instances of similarly credentialed academies making bold, confident declarations, only to act like they never happened when reality intruded into their fantasy. A smattering of examples are:
    • Dr. John Ioannidis April 17, 2020: Acknowledging for the fact that the epidemic is still evolving, and we cannot be sure whether we will hit even higher peaks in the future, although this doesn’t seem to be the case, at least for the European countries, and it seems to be that even in the US, in most states we’re very close to the peak, if not past the peak, the risk is something that should be manageable as opposed to the panic and horror stories that are circulating about.
    • Dr. Martin Kulldorff May 2020: Daily reported COVID-19 cases has dropped to half in Stockholm, where herd immunity will arrive first, while it is currently flat in the rest of Sweden.
    • Dr. Sunetra Gupta May 2020: The epidemic has largely come and is on its way out in this country.
    • Dr. Jay Bhattacharya July 2020: There’s some places where I think we’ve reached herd immunity.
    • Dr. Vinay Prasad February 2021: This NYTimes story on Jan 24th “Vaccines alone won’t end pandemic” Did not age well (as of Feb 18). It was completely off, and just another squeeze of fear Enough with these models They have often been erroneous.
    • Dr. Monica Gandhi February 2021: We are just facing like complete dawn of hope and light and love. Like it’s gonna be so great. It is getting so great…I think that may be a little soon, but we will get to herd immunity and it will all fall away. It will all fall away. All this anguish, all this yelling at each other, all this politicization, all this depression, it will fall away.
    • Dr. Lucy McBride March 2021: I’ve been yearning for an end to the pandemic. Now that it’s here, I’m a little afraid.
    • Dr. Marty Makary May 2021: Most of the country is at herd immunity.
    • Dr. John Mandrola, June 11, 2021: It appears to me that we have crushed COVID by simply vaccinating susceptible adults. Why not wait for more data before extending these novel therapies to young people?
And though I never put it into writing, I can now reveal a failed prediction of mine- I honestly thought more people, especially “leaders” of American medicine, would have cared about all this. Instead, they ignored or praised MAHA doctors, and as a result of their indifference and enabling, Kennedy is in charge and taking a wrecking ball to things today with promises, assurances, and predictions of a health utopia just around the corner.
I don’t know what 2026 will bring, but I predict that most of it will be very bad, and unlike the doctors I write about, I will admit it if I am wrong.


Autism Revisited
Is there an autism epidemic? Why was autism rare in the past? This book tries to answer those questions with a historical and sociological approach and suggests deinstitutionalization was a key factor.
Harriet Hall on January 1, 2019
Link

Is the autism epidemic due to more awareness and better diagnosis, or to diagnostic substitution? Is it due to something that has changed in our environment? Is there really an autism epidemic? Gil Eyal et al., the authors of the book The Autism Matrix: The Social Origins of the Autism Epidemic wonder if we have been asking the wrong questions. They think a more profitable question is “Why was autism rare in the past?” They think a historical and sociologic approach reveals the answer, and they think deinstitutionalization is a key factor.
They argue that “our practices for representing and intervening in childhood disorders are no longer constrained by the opposition between retardation and illness, but proceed as if they can ignore it.” The boundary between mental retardation and mental illness has been blurred. Autism is defined as a mental disorder in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM), but psychiatry and biomedicine have no effective medical treatments to offer; treatment has fallen into the hands of paraprofessionals, educators, and parents, and many of the treatments they use were originally developed to treat mental retardation or brain injuries. One whole institutional matrix of practices has given way to another.
The diagnostic criteria are a mess. Children in the autism spectrum demonstrate deficits in social interaction, verbal and nonverbal communication, and repetitive behaviors and interests. About a third of them are also diagnosed with mental retardation, but those on the Asperger’s end of the spectrum may have above-average IQs, and there are “idiot savants.” Many are concurrently diagnosed with epilepsy, hyperactivity, emotional disorders, and learning disability. The heterogeneity makes research difficult. In DSM-II autism was classified under childhood schizophrenia. In DSM-III (1980) it was classified under Pervasive Developmental Disorders. The diagnostic criteria were relaxed, and in DSM-IV (1994) head-banging and self-mutilation were no longer mentioned. In DSM-5 (2013) the diagnosis of “autism spectrum disorders” included autism, Asperger syndrome, pervasive developmental disorder not otherwise specified (PDD-NOS), and childhood disintegrative disorder. Rather than using science to direct diagnosis and clinical practice, DSM simply reflected current practice. The chief of child psychiatry at the National Institutes of Mental Health said, “I’ll call a kid a zebra if it will get him the educational services he needs.”
Autism has become protean. It can mean one thing and its opposite at the same time: profound mental retardation and near-genius abilities, hyper-sensitivity and hypo-sensitivity, aloofness and over-attachment, flat affect and combustible tantrums. Autism can be considered a developmental disorder positioned somewhere between mental illness and retardation. There is a “window” in which interventions might influence neural pathways; no such window exists in mental retardation. Autism provides flexibility for experts to postpone the medical diagnosis of social destiny (whether the child will function independently in society).
Some observers rejected the idea of autism as a unitary disease entity and saw it as “overlapping, concurrent, and deeply intertwined with all the other developmental disabilities – mental retardation, cerebral palsy, epilepsy, speech and language delays, learning disabilities.” Others thought autism was a symptom, not a syndrome.
The diagnosis of mental retardation had nothing to do with IQ. It was a legal and social concept that justified locking up those who were “socially incapable,” some of whom had higher IQs than some socially capable individuals. Parents were glad to have their children classified as autistic because there was less stigma attached to that diagnosis.
The book investigates the puzzle of variation in autism rates. The rate of designation of autism by school boards to provide services is 22 times higher in Maine than in Oklahoma. In Norway, the prevalence is 5.2 in 10,000; across the border in Sweden, it is 72.6 in 10,000. In Oregon, children are qualified as autistic for special education services if they simply demonstrate “impairments in social interaction.” Two questions must be answered: why is autism increasing but not learning disabilities or other disorders, and why now? After autism was named in 1943, it took 48 years for the numbers to start rising. As autism numbers rose, special education enrollments showed a corresponding decrease in mentally retarded or developmentally delayed; so there was clear evidence of diagnostic substitution.
For many years, doctors encouraged parents to commit very young children to institutions for the mentally retarded, out of concern for the well-being of the middle-class family. Eventually there was a push-back against the establishment doctors, as society recognized the value of retarded existence and came to believe that the middle-class family, in partnership with the state, was best for early detection and intervention. Parents became activists and children were de-institutionalized. The goal became “normalization” of behavior, with family, residential, educational, and work arrangements adapted to the needs and abilities of the individual child, whether mentally retarded or autistic or something else entirely. Parents became co-therapists, and a new network of (supposed) expertise emerged.
Early in the history of autism, parents were blamed as “refrigerator mothers.” Then the stress of raising an autistic child was recognized and parents were treated with psychotherapy. Then parents were considered experts who best understood their child and could translate for them; they assumed the role of therapists.
Autism therapies upset the boundaries between established and alternative medicine, between illness and retardation, and between expert and layperson. Defeat Autism Now! (DAN!) and similar organizations weaved in and out of science, went back and forth between medicine, alternative medicine, and the market. They blended therapy, parenting, and advocacy, and they glued new symptoms onto the autism spectrum.
Many parents are “therapy omnivores,” eclectically combining whatever they think works for their child. An Internet survey identified 111 different therapies. “Speech therapy was the most commonly reported intervention, followed by visual schedules, sensory integration, and applied behavior analysis. In addition, 52% of parents were currently using at least one medication to treat their child, 27% were implementing special diets, and 43% were using vitamin supplements.” There is little or no scientific evidence to support most of the treatments being used. Rather than controlled studies, they rely on collecting “n of 1” reports from parents. This potluck approach undermines science. Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled studies are the gold standard; among autism activists, scientific rigor is subordinated to the “silver standard” of clinical efficacy (= testimonials). That’s a dangerous approach, because development is delayed, not absent. These children tend to improve over time, and it’s easy to falsely attribute the improvement to whatever treatment they tried last. Even well-educated, highly intelligent people have succumbed to the post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy. The account by James Laidler is well worth reading. He and his wife were both physicians, yet they managed to thoroughly fool themselves about the dietary and other treatments they used on their two autistic sons.
The book doesn’t deny the existence of autism, but it says, “the recent rise in autism diagnoses represents not an epidemic, but a change in the institutional conditions under which we perceive and treat childhood disorders…The very category of autism emerged in the interstice between mental retardation and mental illness.”
Conclusion: diagnosis and treatment of autism are deeply flawed
Whether or not you accept the premises of the book, the categorization of autism is blurry, as evidenced by the constant changes in each subsequent iteration of the DSM. Perhaps it would be better to avoid diagnostic labels entirely and to simply ask what each child’s handicaps and skills are and what we can do to help them. But unfortunately we rely on labels to authorize the provision of special educational and other services.
The book is full of facts and ideas that are well worth thinking about. But it is not an easy read. I found it dense, repetitive, slow going, and sometimes I struggled to understand. I could not recommend it for most readers, but it would be valuable for those with a special interest in autism.

Neurotribes: A Better Understanding of Autism
Harriet Hall on December 22, 2015
Link

What is autism? What causes it? Is it genetic? Is it a consequence of something in our environment or lifestyle? What’s an “idiot savant” or an “autistic savant”? What happens when autistic children become adults? Why are so many of their parents scientists, academics, and engineers? If your grandfather’s Uncle Fred was a socially inept inventor with a lot of strange quirks, do you think he might have been autistic? Is autism really becoming more prevalent, or are we just getting better at diagnosing it? What’s happening with these people and what can be done to give them a better life?
Sorry to burden the list of recommended reading with yet another book, but if you are on the autism spectrum, if you know anyone who is autistic, if you think there is an epidemic of autism, if you think vaccines or environmental toxins cause autism, or if you are just interested in autism and want to understand it better, you will benefit from reading this new book by Steve Silberman: NeuroTribes: The Legacy of Autism and the Future of Neurodiversity. You will walk away from the book with new insights and a new appreciation of the “neurodiverse.”
The history of autism
Silberman provides the most complete history of autism I have seen, and he makes it fun to read. He covers many of the main players like Kanner, Asperger, and Bettelheim, telling details about their lives that make them come alive. He describes how difficult it was to resolve different views of what constituted autism and to reach a consensus about what to call it. He describes the struggle to get meaningful diagnostic criteria into the DSM (The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders).
If you think autism is a new phenomenon, this book will make you think again. He gives many historical examples of people who were clearly on the autism spectrum, and he explains why most autistics would have been off the radar in the past. In the first chapter he gives us extensive details about the life of Henry Cavendish (1731-1810), a phenomenally productive scientist who discovered hydrogen and measured the mass of the Earth, but a seriously weird guy. He was socially inept and remarkably eccentric; he dressed in old-fashioned clothes and had fixed routines like taking exactly the same walk every day and eating the same food over and over. He was so upset by accidentally encountering a housemaid on the stairs in his house that he had a separate set of stairs built for his servants so it wouldn’t happen again. He was every bit as Sheldonish as Sheldon Cooper on The Big Bang Theory.
Silberman gives chilling details about how autism was treated in the past. Autistic children were labeled as hopelessly retarded or schizophrenic and were locked away for life in institutions, with no attempt whatsoever to educate them. Psychoanalysts made bizarre interpretations of their behavior (one thought a boy’s obsessive turning of doorknobs meant he wanted to have sex with his mother). Parents were blamed for causing the children’s troublesome behaviors by being too cold or demanding; they were labeled “refrigerator mothers.” Mothers who had jobs or intellectual interests were demonized. Children who couldn’t talk were seen as willfully refusing to talk. Children were physically punished to extinguish unwanted behaviors. Among other atrocities, electroshock therapy was tried.
Public awareness rises
The movie Rain Man was instrumental in raising public awareness of autism; he gives fascinating details about how that film came about. Temple Grandin provided a highly visible example of how an autistic child could learn, compensate, get a PhD, and make significant contributions in their chosen field. Parents and autistics themselves started banding together for support. Those who found face-to-face interactions difficult found a supportive community on the Internet.
As awareness of autism began to rise, parents found that with intensive early interventions, many of these children could overcome the worst of their handicaps, improve their language and social abilities, and even be enrolled in public schools. Laws were passed to ensure these children had access to educational and therapeutic services.
But at the same time, pernicious rumors spread about vaccines, and all kinds of quackery abounded. Some doctors (and some non-doctors) promised to cure autism with a regimen of diets, supplements, and other unproven interventions, even chelation and chemical castration. Silberman does a masterful job of cutting through the nonsense.
Neurodiversity is a good thing
The best thing Silberman does is to put a positive spin on autism. He sees autistics as different rather than as defective. Autism is many things; autistics are actually more different from each other than from neurotypicals. Autism may just be an exaggeration of traits we all have. There is a wide spectrum, and most of us can identify some autistic-like tendencies in ourselves. Some of the characteristics that define autism are also characteristics that make people successful in a wide range of endeavors. The child who spends hours lining up his toy cars just so may grow up to apply the same degree of fixation, dedication, effort, persistence, and total concentration to solving a problem in his chosen field of work. Some autistics have unique abilities in math, art, or other areas. Temple Grandin gives her autism the credit for her ability to design humane livestock facilities; she thinks in images rather than in words and is able to “think like a cow.” She has said she would not support curing autism because “The world needs all kinds of minds.”
Autistics can be thought of as a neurodiverse tribe. Instead of making them conform to our neurotypical world, we can try to accommodate their differences and create an environment for them that will allow them to thrive and contribute to society. Silberman gives many suggestions as to how that can be accomplished. He gives numerous examples of how parents have adapted to the needs of their autistic children rather than making the children adapt to the rigid expectations of society. Sometimes a behavior initially seen as negative can be encouraged and utilized for positive accomplishments.
Conclusion: “A brilliant and sparklingly humane book”
        ◦ We are daily confronted with bad news about terrorist attacks, the idiocies of presidential candidates, and celebrities who have proclaimed themselves experts, and pseudoscientific misinformation in the media about everything from vaccines to evolution. In a world with all of those discouraging trends, this book is a welcome ray of clarity, sanity, and optimism about autism. It won the Samuel Johnson Prize, the UK’s most prestigious award for non-fiction, and one review called it a “brilliant and sparklingly humane book.” I agree; I highly recommend it.

Videos Said to be “Proof” that Nonverbal Autistics Can Communicate by Spelling
The father of nonverbal autistic child believes videos constitute proof that other children with autism can communicate by by pointing to letters on a board held by a facilitator to spell out words. He is wrong.
Harriet Hall on March 29, 2022
Link


I get a lot of email inquiries about questionable treatments, and when I explain that there is little or no science behind them, my explanation is usually accepted with thanks. Recently I had a different experience: the inquirer wanted to argue with me. The father of a non-verbal autistic son, he had watched videos for Spelling to Communicate (S2C) and he believed they constituted proof that S2C worked.
In the S2C program, autistic children who don’t communicate verbally are taught to communicate by pointing to letters on a board held by a facilitator. I answered the email inquiry with a link to what Steven Novella had written about it, where he pointed out that this was just a new version of facilitated communication that was also subject to the ideomotor effect, and there is no evidence that the clients are actually doing the communicating.
The inquiring father begged to differ. He had watched videos where the autistic person had not only learned to communicate by spelling but had demonstrated knowledge that allowed him to beat his family at Trivial Pursuit. I found this hard to accept. Spelling is often difficult for non-autistic people. How could someone with autism be so good at it, and how could they have known information that allowed them to answer Trivial Pursuit questions that other family members could not answer? It simply didn’t make sense to me.
I tried to show him why these videos were not acceptable as evidence. I failed. I pointed out that when S2C didn’t work, no video would be made. I pointed out that videos can be faked; we have no way of knowing if the person is really autistic or is even a real person. How do we know he’s not just an actor? I pointed out that videos were essentially testimonials, which are not acceptable as evidence. I don’t go by testimonials or anecdotes, but by published peer-reviewed scientific studies with appropriate controls. I did everything I could think of to explain the need for good science. He was unimpressed. He had watched the videos and they proved to him beyond any doubt that S2C worked.
He offered to enroll his son in the program and provide me with updates on his progress that would surely convince me. I explained that that would just be more testimonials that couldn’t possibly convince me. He called S2C an evidence-based method that had helped hundreds of people become articulate spellers. He insulted me by saying I had not watched the video (I had!) and that science dissuades people from trying anything new (not true! Science only asks that claims be properly tested, and asks that new treatments be tried in the context of a controlled study to find out whether they work.) We ended up essentially agreeing to disagree.
I felt sorry for him. He could not be objective. He needed to believe his son had a rich mental life that he could learn to share with others. There are plenty of treatments for autism that are evidence-based and have been proven to help; focusing on a bogus treatment may mean denying his son treatments that might really help.
The whole interchange was an exercise in failed communication. We were speaking different languages with different meanings of the words “proof” and “evidence.” What could I have done better? Was I foolish to try to have a discussion with a person who values video testimonials over scientific studies? I ended up wondering why he had asked for my opinion in the first place. What did he expect I was going to say?

Does a Common Treatment for Childhood Constipation Cause Autism?
Clay Jones on January 16, 2015
Link

Last week an article published by the New York Times entitled “Scrutiny for Laxatives as a Childhood Remedy” made the rounds. The article raised the question of a possible link between the use of a popular over-the-counter laxative, PEG (polyethylene glycol) 3350, and neurological or psychiatric problems in children. This wasn’t the first time this particular journalist wrote a piece on this topic, however. In 2012, she wrote about the popularity of the treatment among pediatricians despite a lack of FDA approval for use by children, a fact which applies to many if not most of the drugs commonly prescribed by pediatricians. 
PEG 3350, perhaps more commonly known as Miralax or by one of many similar generic product names, has long been known to potentially result in loose stools or even frank diarrhea with excessive dosing, as well as abdominal cramping. But both of the New York Times articles mention the fact that there have been a number of anecdotes blaming PEG 3350 for a variety of non-gastrointestinal symptoms, with varying degrees of plausibility in my opinion. They also point out that many of these unproven anecdotes were made via the FDA Adverse Event Reporting System (FAERS).
The FAERS can provide pivotal post-marketing surveillance. It can generate hypotheses, thus allowing the FDA, researchers, and healthcare professionals in the trenches, to hone in on potential toxicities not picked up during clinical trials because of low prevalence, delayed onset, or some other unexpected variable. But like the VAERS, the federal vaccine specific reporting system, the FAERS has significant limitations such that data mined from it should be used cautiously. Now the FDA is funding research at Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia that will specifically address these concerns.
The word autism wasn’t used in these articles, but that is the leap being made by many in the lay community. I’ve already been asked about this by a number of parents, and they are worried. Just search “miralax AND autism” on the Googles or your search engine of choice. I’m not surprised folks are worried considering some of the information available online, like this terrifying nonsense from Gutsense.org:
Adding insult to injury, after getting nuked with an abdominal CT scan to “diagnose” constipation and, then hooked on MiraLAX by the very doctors expected to protect her health, she may end up autistic and cancer-prone for the rest of her life.
You can conveniently order their “Colorectal Recovery Program” for $119.95 in order to avoid and/or repair the damage from these synthetic chemicals. Here is a good rebuttal of the Gutsense post. I’ll cover some of the same ground, and go into more detail about childhood constipation and why we need drugs like PEG 3350, but it’s a good read nonetheless.
Constipation is an extremely common, and often underrated problem in kids, and many children use the remedy in question for acute episodes or for long-term prevention. Some children, my daughter being one of them, have required weeks, months and even years of daily dosing at some point in their lives. So if PEG 3350 is harmful, many children might be affected. Of course there are significant harms that can result from poorly-managed constipation also.
I can’t possibly explain in complete detail such a complex topic as childhood constipation, as it has many causes and a variety of management approaches. But before discussing the potential dangers of PEG 3350, I would like to at least give a solid basic overview of the problem and how it presents in the bulk of children as a functional condition unrelated to any anatomic or biochemical derangement. And it is a problem. One which is extremely under-appreciated. Warning: I’m going to say poop a lot.
What is constipation and why is it so common in children?
Simply put, constipation is defined as trouble with defecation, with having stools that are hard to pass or infrequent fitting the bill for older kids and adults. But as younger children develop, what is considered normal in regards to the frequency and consistency of stools changes – so there must be some fluidity to the definition. We can’t just lump all kids into the same group. It is not uncommon for a parent to believe that their perfectly healthy child is constipated because of an inaccurate understanding of the range of normal stooling patterns and behaviors.
True constipation is very common though, with as many as a third of children affected at any given time, and related complaints from kids and caregivers are the impetus for 3-5% of pediatric sick visits. These complaints cover a lot of ground, ranging from nervous mothers worried about infrequent bowel movements, to severe abdominal pain and the need for inpatient or even surgical management, to significant psychosocial sequelae. The most common presentations, however, involve bowel movements that are hard and uncomfortable, and cramping abdominal discomfort. But trust me, there are piles of additional potential problems associated with untreated constipation.
Mild to moderate constipation occurs throughout childhood, likely as a result of poor dietary choices/options resulting in a less-than-optimal intake of fruits, vegetables and fiber, with incidence tending to peak during the preschool years. It has spikes at three distinct periods of development: the introduction of solid foods during infancy, toilet training and starting school. The most severe cases of functional constipation, which again implies that there is not something structurally or biochemically amiss such as a spinal cord lesion or cystic fibrosis, tend to occur in the setting of purposeful withholding of stool.
Why would a child purposefully hold his poop in? There are actually a number of reasons, and it doesn’t always begin as intentional withholding. An understanding of why a child would do this helps to explain why we see increased incidence of constipation at certain periods of development.
Kids who are afraid to have a bowel movement will actually do whatever they can to not have a bowel movement, including all manner of muscular contortions. These behaviors can be quite impressive and mimic other issues. I once had parents worried about unusual seizure activity or other problem with the nervous system because their horribly constipated toddler would frequently drop whatever he was doing and writhe on the ground with his legs crossed like scissors.
Here is how this can happen. If a child with mild to moderate constipation, or just bad luck, develops a small but very painful tear in the anal tissue, something called a fissure, they might begin to associate pooping with pain. If they are yelled at or punished for having an accident during potty training, they might begin to associate emotional discomfort with pooping. Sometimes kids will refuse to use the bathroom at school because of anxiety or because the toilets are nasty, or they may be unable to even reach the bathroom because of overly-strict school policies on bathroom breaks.
Once the pattern of holding stools in has begun, whether voluntary or not, it can become a vicious cycle. The longer that a child withholds, the larger and harder the accumulated stool becomes, and the likelihood that subsequent bowel movements will be painful increases. Painful defecation in turn leads to more intentional withholding, or to the initiation of intentional withholding in kids who simply weren’t allowed to go at school or had worsening constipation simply because of a poor diet. As the process continues, stool can become impacted and a host of new difficulties can begin to occur. In addition to the sequelae discussed above, chronic severe constipation can also lead to voiding dysfunction with resulting urinary tract infections as well as bedwetting.
Impaction of stool can even lead to fecal incontinence, and I’ve had a few families present with complaints of diarrhea completely unaware that their child was severely constipated. As the mass of stool in the rectum enlarges, the normal functioning of the nerves that signal the need to defecate or delay defecation is impaired because of constant stretching. These children also may lose the ability to even produce enough pressure to move stool from the rectum into the anal canal, thus purposeful withholding of stool can eventually become automatic. At this point, the child may be unaware when the leading edge of hard stool emerges enough to soil their underwear, and liquid stool from above the impaction can leak around the blockage and pass through the anus uncontested.
How is constipation in kids diagnosed?
The official diagnosis of constipation is based on the Rome III criteria, an international consensus for functional gastrointestinal disorders, although in practice we tend to use more of a clinical gestalt, for better or worse. With either approach, a number of factors come into play: stool frequency, hardness, size, fecal incontinence, purposeful retention, and pain with passing stools. To diagnose a child over four years of age, the Rome III criteria require two months of at least two of the previous factors being an issue (one month for infants and toddlers). Treatment should generally begin long before a child might fit this criterion, and prevention should be discussed even earlier than that.
Use of strict criteria like this can be helpful but doesn’t replace clinical skill because they don’t take into account the range of normal stooling behavior or the complexity of information gathering. A parent can usually tell me how many dirty diapers they might change each week but not how often their 7-year-old poops. And good luck getting the kid to tell you anything about frequency and consistency of stool. Even teenagers will often respond with “I don’t know.” Kids will frequently not even localize pain in any way other than “my stomach hurts.”
If parents don’t know that something is a helpful clue, they may not point it out. They may not realize, for example, that “skid marks” observed when doing the laundry are probably not because Timmy doesn’t wipe well enough, or that the “weird thing he does sometimes” is withholding behavior. And I’ve encountered many families that joke about their toddler’s “man-sized toilet cloggers.” Without asking the right questions, sometimes in a variety of ways, all that some parents of chronically and even severely constipated children might offer up is “he complains about his tummy and he’s missed a lot of school lately.”
How is constipation in children managed?
The first and most important step in managing childhood constipation is recognizing that it is a problem that needs management in the first place. Many kids with severe constipation that eventually require inpatient treatment spent months with unrecognized mild-to-moderate symptoms. Despite the fact that pediatric interns generally learn early on in training to respect constipation while managing their first hospital “clean out“, we still often drop the ball and fail to provide appropriate anticipatory guidance and early intervention.
Prevention is the key, so discussing diet and bowel habits should be a standard part of well-child visits. Particular focus should be given to the high risk transitional periods I mentioned earlier. Parents can ensure that their infant’s diet includes adequate fiber and water as they start solid food intake at around 6 months of age, and hopefully they will continue to model and provide a healthy diet containing plenty of fruits and vegetables. Excessive intake of cow’s milk beyond what is required for nutrition is unfortunately common in toddlers and can also lead to constipation.
The common approach to toilet training can be overly aggressive for many children, potentially leading to failure, frustration and withholding behaviors. It should be delayed until a child is developmentally ready and should never involve punishment for accidents. Unfortunately, pushing potty training is often hard to avoid for working parents when preschools and daycare facilities require it.
As kids age and go off to school, parents should be counseled to maintain a working knowledge of their child’s bathroom failures and successes. They should be on the lookout for any difficulties pooping at school and make sure that children have time and are encouraged to go at home. I usually recommend at least 15 minutes, twice a day, for potty time. Sometimes a reward system can help. And diet remains an important factor as children grow as well, with fiber, fruits and vegetables being a key component of normal bowel movements and future health.
But what about when a child presents with signs or symptoms of constipation? The earlier it is recognized and treatment begun, the more successful management tends to be. In many instances, dietary intervention is all that is necessary, particularly when the constipation is mild to moderate.
Infants can be given fruit juices or purees that contain sorbitol, which pulls water into the lumen of the intestines and softens stools, and higher fiber cereals can be given in place of the more typical rice variety. Older kids can simply increase their intake of fruits and vegetables, which is frequently a lot easier said than done. These interventions don’t always work, and tweaking the diet by adding fiber and fluid is usually not enough when children come in with severe constipation, withholding, or incontinence. But it is still important as a means of preventing future occurrences.
For significant short-term constipation in children over 6 months of age, the best treatment on the market is PEG 3350. Like sorbitol, polyethylene glycol is osmotically active. It pulls water into the gut and softens the stool. Furthermore it is the iocane powder of pharmaceutical interventions, being completely without taste, smell, color, or texture when mixed in liquid, and it can be mixed in anything. PEG 3350 is extremely easy to dose and it’s relatively inexpensive since becoming over-the-counter a few years ago. It is recommended by the overwhelming majority of pediatricians and pediatric gastroenterologists, and has an excellent safety record even with use over months to years. Another benefit to PEG 3350 is that it isn’t habit-forming like stimulant laxatives, which can play a role in management but tend to be avoided when possible.
Another major component of constipation management is disimpaction, frequently in the form of suppositories in young infants and enemas in older children. Sometimes surgical disimpaction is even necessary, but thankfully it rarely gets to that point. The reason that this aspect of treatment is so important, particularly in severe cases of impaction, is because treating from above, so to speak, can actually makes things worse if the blockage is not removed.
I have admitted more kids than I can count for severe constipation who have failed outpatient management. Inpatient management involves the administration of a slow-but-steady infusion of PEG 3350 via a tube placed into the stomach through the nose, but only after one or more enemas has removed the impacted fecal mass. Sadly, although quite rare, there are kids out there with such severe, persistent constipation that they have required surgical placement of a tube into their colon for ease of administering laxative solutions at home in order to avoid frequent hospitalizations.
Management of severe constipation is usually thought of as a marathon as opposed to a sprint. Children usually come in having had issues for months to years, and it can take as long for them to return to having soft and comfortable bowel movements. For one thing, changing a child’s diet sounds easy on paper but it can be a challenge for parents who find themselves with a picky toddler or who are in need of dietary interventions themselves. Also, as I mentioned earlier, chronic impaction can impair the ability to evacuate stool even when it is softened. Thus it is extremely common for children to become constipated and symptomatic recurrently, which is why so many remain on PEG 3350 for so long. It just takes time for things to reset.
Does PEG 3350 increase the risk of autism or any other neuropsychiatric symptoms?
PEG is an extremely versatile compound with different chemical properties depending on the form used. It can be found in use in a variety of industries, one of which is in the formulation of various medications. It has been used in some drugs to reduce toxicity and slow clearance from the blood so that the dosing interval can be spaced out. One example is PEG-interferon alfa, a medication for hepatitis C. PEG is also used in the production of liquid medications and soft capsules, as a lubricant in eye drops, and as a base for ointments.
It has a wide range of uses in biological research and industry. It is used in rocket fuel, paintball rounds, and to preserve historical objects recovered from underwater. You can even find it in toothpaste and as an anti-foaming agent in food. Frankly I’m surprised that the Food Babe hasn’t gotten around to PEG yet.
PEG is produced by putting ethylene oxide in a big pot with water and ethylene glycol. I think maybe there is an incantation said over the pot and an acid or base is used as a catalyst, but the incantation is the key in producing a polymer of identical ethylene glycol subunits. What has everyone upset about PEG 3350 is the fact that its production involves ethylene glycol, which is a major component of antifreeze and tastes great, making it a common cause of poisoning in kids. So if you learn nothing else from this post, please keep your antifreeze out of the reach of young children.
Ethylene glycol is used in the production of PEG 3350, but PEG 3350 isn’t ethylene glycol, perhaps because of the incantation used during production, or maybe even science. Ethylene glycol toxicity is serious, potentially resulting from ingestion of just a few milliliters in small children and manifesting as alcohol poisoning with symptoms like altered mental status, rhythm disturbances of the heart, and kidney injury. Treatment is available if recognized quickly enough, but it can be fatal. Ethylene glycol poisoning is similar to autism in the way that mercury poisoning is. In other words, it isn’t. It also isn’t really similar to the anecdotal reports of behavior changes and movement disorders reported to the FDA.
We actually already have an understanding of what happens to PEG in the body. We have a good grasp of how much is absorbed depending on the molecular weight and how it is metabolized. We even have data on whether or not it is broken down into ethylene glycol and potentially able to wreak havoc on the brain, heart and kidneys. We know, for instance, that of the PEG 3350 ingested by humans less than 10% is absorbed and none of it is broken down into individual ethylene glycol monomers. Yes, this wasn’t specifically studied in children but there is no reason at all to think that a child would metabolize PEG into antifreeze while an adult wouldn’t.
What is adding fuel to the fire, in addition to the very questionable FAERS data, is that the FDA apparently did find some ethylene glycol in some test batches a few years ago. But follow-up testing of a larger sample size in 2013, involving five different manufacturers, didn’t reproduce those results. Taking into account what we already know about PEG, the untrustworthy nature of FAERS data, and the long track record of safety in clinical use in children, I believe that this is a non-issue.
But, and I mean this, I understand why the FDA is doing what they are doing. I don’t think it is completely unreasonable to investigate further and hopefully answer this question once and for all. Of course even if the results of the additional research on the safety of PEG 3350 in kids are reassuring, the damage has already been done. It will always be a concern for some parents, particularly parents of children who have already been diagnosed with autism.
Constipation is common in all kids, but it is even more prevalent in children with autism. It makes sense to me that children who may have nutritional and/or sensory issues might be predisposed to problems with defecation and have an increased risk of withholding behaviors. I hate to think that because of implausible concerns about the safety of such an effective treatment there may be children who will have poorly-managed constipation which might exacerbate other behavioral problems. There are other laxatives that can be used, they just aren’t as good.
Ultimately, however, I will follow the science where it leads. Despite the fact that I am highly skeptical of these concerns regarding PEG 3350, and that I will continue to recommend its use in the meantime, I will drop it in a heartbeat should I be wrong. That is, after all, the essence of science-based medicine.

Autism and Induced Labor
Steven Novella on August 14, 2013
Link
A recently published epidemiological study in JAMA Pediatrics looked at the association between induction and enhancement of labor and the risk of autism. The researchers found a positive association, especially with males. The study has been variously reported in the popular press with causal interpretations not justified by the data.
The study itself is very robust – the authors looked at 625,042 live births, including 5,500 children with a diagnosis of autism. They found:
Compared with children born to mothers who received neither labor induction nor augmentation, children born to mothers who were induced and augmented, induced only, or augmented only experienced increased odds of autism after controlling for potential confounders related to socioeconomic status, maternal health, pregnancy-related events and conditions, and birth year. The observed associations between labor induction/augmentation were particularly pronounced in male children.
Although this is a large study, it is one study, and so the correlation needs to be independently confirmed. But if we assume the correlation is accurate, the next question is – what is the arrow of causation? Observational studies can only indicate an association. By themselves they cannot prove causation, although multiple observational studies may be able to triangulate to the most likely causal interpretation.
There are always three generic interpretations when A is associated with B: A causes B, B causes A, or C causes both A and B.
In the case of this study, either inducing/augmenting labor triggers autism in some children, children with autism are more likely to require induced labor, or some other factor(s) is a risk factor for both developing autism and needing to induce or augment labor. This current study does not contain data that can differentiate among these possibilities.
We can, however, explore plausibility. Inducing and augmenting labor includes a variety of generally safe procedures and medications. An unknown medication side effect, however, is always possible. Anything that adds stress to a newborn can also plausibly be a trigger for autism.
Twin studies and other genetic studies suggest that autism has a large genetic predisposition, but that genes are not 100% of the causal factors for autism. It may be that we simply do not yet have the full genetic picture. But it is also likely that the environment in the womb interacts with the genetic predisposition in determining the development of autism.
The environment of the womb could include delayed delivery, which results in induction, or some other factor that delays delivery. It is therefore plausible that either the delay in delivery itself, some other factor that delays delivery, or the procedures used to induce or augment labor when delivery is delayed can (separately or together) be an environmental trigger in genetically susceptible children.
It is also plausible that children who will become autistic may also be slow to deliver – that the delayed delivery is a symptom of, rather than a cause of, autism.
Evidence is mounting that autism begins in the womb, and not just from genetic evidence. Several studies, although individually small, have all shown that children with autism have significantly more brain cells, especially in their frontal cortex.
Other studies indicate that people with autism have abnormal networks in the brain, and specifically there is a deficit of connectivity between different parts of the brain, especially interhemispheric connectivity (the two sides of the brain do not talk to each other as robustly as a typical brain).
Clinically, the features of autism appear to be present starting at about 6 months. Such early presentation of clinical features is consistent with autism being a congenital disorder (i.e. present at birth).
Further, the specific changes in the autistic brain that research so far is demonstrating – changes in neuron number and connectivity – are the kinds of changes that occur during fetal development.
Conclusion
While there is still room for much further research, all the information we have at this time suggests that autism is something that occurs as the fetus is developing the womb, is primarily genetically determined, but may also be determined by factors present in the environment of the womb. The latest study identifies delivery as another possible factor, but it is not clear what role it is playing, and delayed delivery may simply be another symptom or marker of the underlying cause(s) of autism.
All of this is incompatible, of course, with theories about environmental triggers that cause autism in children older than 6 months. The MMR and other vaccines come to mind.

Tylenol and Autism
Steven Novella on September 10, 2025
Link
Earlier this year, HHS secretary RFK Jr. predicted that, “By September, we will know what has caused the autism epidemic and we’ll be able to eliminate those exposures.” Scientists have been researching autism for decades, including what factors are driving changes in diagnostic patterns. Promising such a major breakthrough in just six months is beyond ridiculous, and strongly implies that RFK Jr. thinks he already knows the answer.
What is that answer? He gives a clue in his statement – “those exposures”. RFK thinks that autism is dominantly caused by environmental exposures, despite mountains of evidence that autism is dominantly genetic. There are likely some contributing environmental factors, but they are not “the cause” of autism. We also know what RFK thinks is the king of evil environmental exposures – vaccines. This is why is quickly put together a bogus autism-vaccine study, almost certain to produce the results he desires.
But other environmental exposures are not off the hook, and any “big pharma” target is fair game. Recently the WSJ reported that RFK plans to claim that autism is linked to exposure to acetaminophen (Tylenol) during pregnancy. Well, it’s September, so I guess he feels he has to announce something. So let’s review what the science says about a potential link.
RFK has shown, over and over again, that he has no idea how to properly interpret the medical literature. He uses scientific evidence as the proverbial drunk uses a lamppost – for support rather than illumination. As regular readers here know, preliminary evidence is often all over the place, and also tends to favor false positives. You need careful analysis of research methodology, confounding factors, patterns of replication, detection of p-hacking, etc. in order to come to a reliable conclusion. Or – you can just cherry pick the inevitable studies that support your political agenda.
Sometimes, researchers will helpfully do this kind of analysis for you, with a high quality systematic review. That is, in fact, the entire point of a systematic review, and the good ones will cover all the factors I listed above. Better yet is looking at multiple systematic reviews to see if there is a solid consensus.
In the case of a potential link between Tylenol use in pregnancy and the risk of autism or other neurological developmental disorders (like ADHD), there are some preliminary studies showing a possible small risk, while others do not. This is a job for a good systematic review, and fortunately we have a recent high quality review to look at. The data came from the Swedish national database, which is extremely useful for such research. The review includes data on 185,909 children. They found a very small increased risk of neurodevelopmental disorders with Tylenol use in pregnancy, however this link disappeared when they did a sibling control analysis:
“Sibling control analyses found no evidence that acetaminophen use during pregnancy was associated with autism (HR, 0.98 [95% CI, 0.93-1.04]; RD, 0.02% [95% CI, -0.14% to 0.18%]), ADHD (HR, 0.98 [95% CI, 0.94-1.02]; RD, -0.02% [95% CI, -0.21% to 0.15%]), or intellectual disability (HR, 1.01 [95% CI, 0.92-1.10]; RD, 0% [95% CI, -0.10% to 0.13%]). Similarly, there was no evidence of a dose-response pattern in sibling control analyses. For example, for autism, compared with no use of acetaminophen, persons with low (<25th percentile), medium (25th-75th percentile), and high (>75th percentile) mean daily acetaminophen use had HRs of 0.85, 0.96, and 0.88, respectively.”
They conclude that earlier studies showing a possible link “may have been attributable to familial confounding.” In the end there is no link between Tylenol use in pregnancy and risk of autism, ADHD, or other neurodevelopmental conditions.
To understand this data a bit better, it is important to know that this is observational data. It is not ethical to expose subjects to a potential risk to see what happens. Therefore, we cannot randomize mothers to either take or not take Tylenol during pregnancy. We can just look at see what happens if mothers decide on their own to take it. This is an ethical way to gather data, and also allows for the collection of massive amounts of data (because you can just look at records or collect data, without having to carry out an elaborate experiment).
However, as we have pointed out here often, this also allows for the possibility of confounding factors. For example, what if mothers who have a fever for some reason are both more likely to take Tylenol and to have a child with a neurodevelopmental disorder? Researchers can try to correct for potential confounding factors.
With autism research, if you are looking at an environmental factor, it is standard procedure to control for genetic risk. One way to do that is with sibling control analysis. In order for an environmental factor to be considered a real and independent risk factor for autism, it must survive controlling for genetic risk, such as through sibling control analysis. In this systematic review, the potential link with Tylenol did not survive this analysis.
What this means is that there is very likely no link at all between Tylenol use in pregnancy and risk of autism, ADHD or neurodevelopmental disorder. Of course, data never proves a zero risk – it can only set limits on the potential size of the risk. So the scientific way of saying this is – the risk is below the threshold of statistical detection for existing data. But that data is now pretty robust, so any remaining potential risk is negligible.
We also have to recognize that untreated fever and pain during pregnancy is not risk free. In medicine, anything you do – or do not do – carries some risk. This is why all risk assessment is actually a risk vs benefit assessment. There very likely can be unintended consequences of scaring expectant mothers from treating pain or fever during pregnancy, with a risk that is somewhere between negligible and zero.
But that, of course, is RFK’s specialty – scaring people away from effective treatments with negligible risks based on his gross misreading of the scientific literature. We can expect more shenanigans to come.
    • 

That Trump, RFK, Oz Presser
Steven Novella on September 24, 2025
Link
Yes, we have to talk about that press conference with Trump, RFK Jr and Dr. Oz., which some are characterizing as the absolutely worst firehose of medical misinformation coming from the White House in American history. I think that is fair. This was the presser we knew was coming, and many of us were dreading. It was worse than I anticipated.
I wrote a few weeks ago about the leaked plans for RFK to link Tylenol and autism, so this press conference was anticipated. It did give us an opportunity to get ahead of some of the misinformation. I suspect much of this stems from RFKs previous promise that in six months he would find the cause of autism so that we can start eliminating these exposures – six months is September. This was an absurd claim given that there has been and continues to be extensive international research into autism for decades, and absolutely no reason to suspect any major breakthrough in those six months. Those of us following RFK’s career knew what he meant – he believes he already knows the causes, that they are environmental (hence “exposures”) and include vaccines.
So Kennedy had to gin up some big autism announcement this month, and there is always plenty of preliminary or inconclusive research going on that you can cherry pick to support some preexisting narrative. He just had to find some ongoing research about an environmental link to autism, and acetaminophen fit the bill. The bottom line is, there is no established cause and effect and two really good reasons to doubt one exists: lack of a dose response curve, and when you control for genetics, any association vanishes.
But Trump had a different take:
The president on Monday repeatedly issued strong warnings that flew in the face of the recommendations of leading medical groups: “Don’t take Tylenol. Don’t take it. Fight like hell not to take it.” He urged pregnant women to “tough it out” when in pain, except in rare instances, such as a dangerously high fever.
He also said he saw no downside to not taking it. But Trump, as he acknowledged, is not a doctor, which is why he shouldn’t be giving medical advice from the White House lectern. There are potential downsides to not treating pain or fever in a pregnancy. Such decisions are always a matter of risk vs benefit, but non-experts tend to see only risk, and fail to consider the risk of not treating. Standard medical practice is already to use Tylenol (and any other drug) during pregnancy only when needed, in minimal dose and for the shortest duration. But it is important to treat pain and fever, which can present risks to the pregnancy as well. It’s a balance, which takes medical knowledge and clinical judgement (neither of which Trump or RFK have).
They also wanted to use the news conferenced to announce a newly FDA approved treatment for autism – leucovorin. Taken in isolation, this is just weird – why would the president and HHS secretary make such an announcement? Obviously this is just propaganda, trying to create the impression that they are doing something about autism, even though neither of them or their policies have anything to do with this. Leucovorin may be a legitimate treatment, but only for a small subset of those with autism who have a folate metabolism disorder. It’s really a treatment for cerebral folate deficiency, one of the manifestations of which may be autism.
But more concerning – the FDA just gave approval for leucovorin for CFD without any new evidence. There was no new study, just a review of prior studies. The evidence is generally considered to be preliminary. All of this makes the timing – right before RFK’s big September deadline – highly suspicious. Others have also noted that Dr. Oz, who was standing with Trump and RFK, holds a position in a company that produces leucovorin, but this can be a coincidence.
It’s pretty obvious what is going on here. RFK needed something to announce in September regarding autism, so he or his flunkies scraped the literature for anything they can present as an identified exposure risk and a possible treatment. Nothing else really explains the timing of these two announcements, especially given that the exposure (while more research is always nice) is largely debunked, and the treatment is narrow and preliminary.
All this is just more evidence that we are experiencing a new version of Lysenkoism – the dramatic politicization of science. The FDA, NIH, and CDC are now just arms of Trump’s propaganda machine, not independent scientific organizations looking after the health of Americans.
But all of this is likely not the worst of it. Trump, apparently, decided to have one of his off-script rambling riff sessions – and his target, to the horror of the medical community, was vaccines. He said, “This is based on what I feel,” and “They pump so much stuff into those beautiful little babies, it’s a disgrace.” He went on to repeat anti-vaccine talking points, specifically that the MMR vaccine is not safe and that it should be split up into individual shots, that children get too may vaccines too quickly and they should be spaced out, and again suggested a link between vaccines and autism.
All of this is debunked nonsense. This is a pattern with Trump and a reason for extreme concern – he feels he can substitute his gut feelings for the consensus opinion of experts. His advice, if followed, is dangerous. There are good reasons why the vaccine schedule is what it is (again, it is the optimal evidence-based balance of risk vs benefit). Delaying vaccines leaves children susceptible to infectious disease for longer. There is currently no substitute for the MMR in the US, and no evidence for any increased risk of the combined vaccine. His advice, given with the bully pulpit of the presidency, is dangerous pseudoscience.


Blaming breast cancer on autism
David Gorski on November 9, 2014
Link


Gayle DeLong has been diagnosed with what she refers to as “autism-induced breast cancer”. She’s even given it an abbreviation, AIBC. Unfortunately, as you might be able to tell by the name she’s given her breast cancer, she is also showing signs of falling into the same errors in thinking with respect to her breast cancer as she clearly has with respect to autism. As a breast cancer surgeon, regardless of my personal opinion of DeLong’s anti-vaccine beliefs, I can only hope that she comes to her senses and undergoes science-based treatment, but I fear she will not, as you will see. Her brief post announcing her diagnosis and blaming it on autism, however, does provide what I like to call a “teachable moment” about cancer.
We’ve met DeLong before on this blog. For instance, she published an execrably bad study that—of course!—tried to link vaccine to autism and failed miserably, despite doing some amazing contortions of analysis, combining diagnoses willy-nilly, all in the service of the discredited vaccine-autism hypothesis. As I said at the time, it just goes to show that someone who is an associate professor of economics and finance shouldn’t be doing epidemiological research. As I also described at the time, if the sorts of analytical techniques she used in her study are acceptable in the world of economics and finance, no wonder our economy has been so screwed up for so long. Another time, DeLong wrote a broadside against the regulatory machinery that oversees vaccine development and safety that was full of the usual antivaccine misinformation, tropes, and pseudoscience and hugely exaggerated perceived “conflicts of interest” among the various parties.
So it’s not surprising that DeLong latches on to dealing with her autistic children as the cause of her cancer:
I have autism-induced breast cancer (AIBC). While I am not absolutely certain that the 1.9 centimeter lump that grew in my left breast is the result of the stress of raising two autistic children, all indications point in that direction. There is virtually no cancer in my family, I eat organically, I exercise, I’m a good weight. OK, so I live in the toxic dump known as New Jersey, but that is the only other major risk factor. No, the drop in cortisol levels whenever one kid’s school calls or the other kid has a public “flare up” is enough for the cancer to take root.
First of all, it’s very telling to me that she blames her breast cancer diagnosis on having to take care of her autistic children as the root cause of her breast cancer. The implication, of course, is that her decision to vaccinate her children is what led to their autism and her breast cancer. Be that as it may, notice how DeLong is very emphatic in proclaiming her healthy lifestyle bona fides and that there’s “no cancer in my family.” It’s a very common misconception about breast cancer (indeed, nearly all cancer) that it must be familial. In the case of breast cancer, while it’s true that there is a familial component and that there are genes, such as BRCA1 or BRCA2, that, when mutated, result in an enormously elevated lifetime risk of breast cancer compared to women without them, the simple fact is that only around 10-15% of breast cancer cases have a familial or genetic component. That means around 85% of breast cancer cases are what we in the biz call “sporadic.” That basically means “we can’t identify a specific cause.” True, there are well-characterized risk factors for breast cancer, such as age, early menarche, late menopause, nulliparity, and others, but the magnitude of the risk increase due to these factors is way less than, say, a strong family history (i.e., a first degree relative with breast cancer) or an identified cancer-predisposing mutation in BRCA1.
Of course, people don’t like the concept of “sporadic” cancer, mainly because humans crave explanation. The default assumption is that everything must happen for a reason and there must be a cause for every disease or cancer. Perhaps the most emphatic statement of this that I’ve encountered thus far comes from (who else?) über-quack Mike Adams when he heaped contempt on the idea of sporadic disease as “spontaneous disease.” He did this in the context of a story four years ago when America’s quack, Dr. Mehmet Oz, followed recommended care and underwent screening colonoscopy to look for polyps and was shocked that he actually had some:
Dr Oz even seems to think he has a perfect health record, saying, “I have done everything right. I don’t have any family history, and yet I’m high risk now.” His personal physician, meanwhile, is implying that even though Dr Oz’s “healthy” diet was perfect, it wasn’t enough to prevent colon polyps, and therefore you might get them too. (And therefore everybody should get screened…)
This led Adams to bloviate:
Colon polyps, in other words, appear without any cause! Mainstream medicine, you see, believes in the theory of “spontaneous disease” that “strikes” people at random.
Sort of like disease voodoo.
No matter what you do, they say, you can’t be totally sure that you’re disease free. Therefore, you need all their disease screening protocols, mammograms, and CT scans (which irradiate your body and can actually cause cancer, by the way).
What a bunch of nonsense. As any real scientist knows, everything that happens in our universe has a cause. It’s a cause-effect universe, and unless you’re God or can magically change the laws of the universe, you can’t alter the laws of cause and effect.
So if you develop colon polyps, there is a cause for it, and that cause is without question related to the foods you’re consuming, because that’s what is in contact with your small intestine, large intestine and colon. (It’s not the only factor, but it’s the primary factor.)
This is exactly the sort of thinking DeLong is exhibiting. It’s understandable, particularly when you’ve been diagnosed with a potentially life-threatening disease. Indeed, it’s quintessentially human. We all want to know why, and our default is to assume that there must be a cause. It’s also wrong. At least, it’s wrong in the sense that while, yes, there are causes of breast cancer (or colon polyps or whatever), they are often highly multifactorial and can’t be placed into a simple “box” of diet, lifestyle, or failing to do the “right” thing. This whole idea feeds into magical thinking (which I’ve seen voiced before many times) that every disease can be prevented, if only you would do the right thing. The dark side of such thinking, of course, is the opposite assumption, which goes something like this: If every disease has a definite non-inherent (i.e., non-genetic) cause, such as crappy diet, then it’s the victim’s fault, in part or in whole, for getting sick. We’ve seen this same thinking from Bill Maher before as well when a few years ago he attacked the flu vaccine and proclaimed that the “soil” matters much more than the seed; i.e., if you live a healthy lifestyle and eat a healthy diet, your “soil” won’t be conducive to the flu virus and you won’t get the flu. This reached a ridiculous extreme when Maher proclaimed that he was so healthy that he wouldn’t get flu even if exposed in a closed-in space like an airplane, leading Bob Costas to snort, “Oh, come on, Superman!” Sometimes this thinking goes beyond even Maher’s, in that cancer or other diseases are blamed on “psychic trauma” or some other psychological factor. This idea is at the very heart of the quackery known as German New Medicine or its variant Biologie Totale. The attraction of such ideas is obvious: They give the illusion of control, that you as a cancer patient can cure yourself if only you will it enough and act on that will. The dark side of this idea is an even worse version of what I just described. Now, it’s not only your fault for being sick because you didn’t live a “good” lifestyle, but you’re sick because you either lack the will not to be sick or you secretly want to be sick.
As for the idea that stress can cause cancer, even the National Cancer Institute proclaims the evidence that stress can cause cancer to be “weak,” further pointing out that there is “no strong evidence that stress directly affects cancer outcomes.” Indeed, the evidence with respect to stress and cancer is at worst conflicting, at best quite negative, with the occasional study hyped in dubious outlets like the <cite.Daily Mail being proclaimed as evidence that stress causes cancer, but a recent meta-analysis of 116,000 people, found no significant correlation between stress and bowel, lung, breast or prostate cancers. So, despite it being a very common and intuitively seemingly-reasonable idea that stress and cancer are linked, they almost certainly are not, at least not as far as causation. That’s not to say that chronic, unrelenting life stress is a good thing for your health, but evidence strongly suggests that it doesn’t increase the risk of cancer. So, while it’s understandable that DeLong might think the stress of her raising two autistic children is the cause of her breast cancer diagnosis, she’s wrong about that. What’s more disturbing to me is how she views her children’s autism as the cause of her cancer to the point of even calling it “autism-induced breast cancer” and giving it an abbreviation AIBC.
Even worse is how she views autism itself as being as bad as cancer. Actually, I get the distinct feeling she views it as worse than cancer, given the title of her post “The Lesser of Two Evils: Breast Cancer and Autism“. Look at her comparison between how cancer is viewed and her perception of how autism is viewed:
So, I speak from experience when I say Stage 1 breast cancer has nothing on autism. The differences are vast and significant. Unlike autism, no one is telling me to “celebrate” my cancer. No one is telling me that cancer is “just a different way for cells to grow.” People have told me that we’ve always had cancer, but no one is using that is an excuse for not doing anything about it. No one is blaming me (or my mother) for my cancer. Unlike a person with autism, society does not say my cancer is my fault. Another difference is that in three years, I’ll either be dead or cured. Autism is not tangible, so it neither exists concretely nor definitely leaves the body. Although cancer could do to me what autism did to Avonte Oquendo, the chances of dying from a tumor that I treat properly are small and growing smaller.
First off, unless DeLong’s cancer is a certain subtype called triple negative (and even then not entirely), it’s not true that in three years she’ll be cured or dead. Such a binary outlook! Estrogen receptor-positive [ER(+)] tumors can recur 5, 10, 15, and even 20+ years later, and the treatment for ER(+) tumors involves Tamoxifen or an aromatase inhibitor for at least five years. Indeed, trends based on clinical research showing better results are moving towards the recommendation of ten years of anti-estrogen therapy to reduce recurrence risk. Triple negative tumors, while more aggressive at the outset, tend not to recur after five years, usually recurring within three years, but they certainly can recur later. More offensive is her explicit likening of autism to cancer, in which she proclaims that “no one is telling me that cancer is ‘just a different way for cells to grow.’” This suggests to me that she views her autistic children as cancers or at least their autism as bad as any cancer, hence her resentment at the neurodiversity movement that seeks to destigmatize autism.
Avonte Oquendo, by the way, was a teenage boy with autism who walked out of his school to go missing and whose remains were found months later. In other words, DeLong makes the connection between her view of cancer and her view of autism even more explicit: Both to her are killer diseases, but there is a difference. Her cancer is potentially curable.
Finally, if there’s one similarity we see between antivaccine thinking and other quackery, it’s made explicit by DeLong:
However, one major similarity exists between breast cancer and autism: the “wisdom” of the experts. The standard of care for cancer includes popping this sucker out of my breast, and I’m fine with that. However, I’m more than a bit uneasy about the radiation treatment that the surgeon has recommended post-op. Taking a sledge hammer to my breast may indeed kill the cancer, but what about the organ that lies directly under my breast, my heart? If 10 or 20 years from now I develop a heart condition – which is also unheard of in my family – would it be the result of the radiation or just bad stuff happening to good people? The cancer experts don’t care; after all, the cancer didn’t return! Except that sometimes (often?) cancer does return, perhaps because radiation can cause cancer? And don’t get me started about chemo! I didn’t question the established wisdom concerning vaccines, and my kids have autism. I won’t repeat that mistake. I’ll look for alternatives, weigh the options, and determine the best path for me. Amazing how a little pain in the breast can turn one into a huge pain in the derrière.
So her magical thinking with respect to vaccines is leading to magical thinking with respect to her cancer. I find it rather odd many times how patients often have no problem with surgery for their cancer but have so much trouble with other options. Of course, “cutting out” the tumor makes intuitive sense, so much so that I’ve not infrequently had patients show up in my clinic expecting that I would be doing just that that very day. In the old days, surgery alone was it, too; it’s the oldest and most reliable treatment for early stage breast cancer.
I’m assuming that the surgeon recommended a lumpectomy/partial mastectomy because DeLong has a stage I cancer (clinically, at least) and he’s recommending radiation. What DeLong doesn’t understand is that there’s a reason for the radiation. If she undergoes lumpectomy and doesn’t follow it up with radiation, the local recurrence rate (the chance of her tumor recurring in her breast near the surgery site) is 30-40%. With radiation, it’s in the range of 5-8%. That’s a huge difference. Of course, as I’ve described in many of my analyses of breast cancer testimonials going right back to the very beginning of this blog and beyond, in which women undergo surgery but refuse chemotherapy and radiation, it’s still more likely than not that the tumor won’t recur, but a roughly one in three chance of recurrence are not odds that I would be willing to take, particularly when the risk of serious heart impairment due to “collateral damage” from the radiation is so low when modern techniques are used. She’s also quite incorrect that radiation oncologists “don’t care” if she gets radiation-induced cardiac disease because “the cancer is gone.” They care very, very much. An enormous amount of research over the last three decades has gone into developing techniques that minimize the risk of heart damage.
The other question is chemotherapy. If DeLong has a stage I tumor, then it’s quite possible she might not even need chemotherapy! If her tumor is not HER2(+) but is ER(+), and she doesn’t have any positive lymph nodes, what will be recommended is Tamoxifen if she’s premenopausal or an aromatase inhibitor if she is postmenopausal. If she’s triple negative (negative for ER, progesterone receptor, and HER2), chemotherapy will be recommended, as it will if she’s node positive regardless of markers. If she’s HER2(+), chemotherapy with Herceptin or one of the newer anti-HER2 agents will be recommended. In any case, the benefit of chemotherapy in early stage breast cancer tends to be relatively low as an absolute percentage; so it’s quite possible to refuse chemotherapy and do fine. The veritable plethora of “I refused chemotherapy and I’m fine” breast cancer testimonials that I’ve analyzed over the years attests to that. It’s just that DeLong should understand that if she refuses recommended chemotherapy she is increasing her risk of recurrence and death due to cancer. In early stage breast cancer, that increased risk might only be a few percent, but she needs to understand now that if she refuses chemotherapy and does well, it will be because of the surgery that removed her tumor and (if she accepts it) the radiation that reduced the risk of local recurrence, not due to any “alternative” treatments she ends up choosing to use after surgery.
What I fear we’re seeing right here is the beginning of yet another alternative breast cancer cure testimonial. DeLong will likely have surgery and then refuse radiation and chemotherapy. Assuming she doesn’t have any positive lymph nodes (which might or might not turn out to be true), the odds are more likely than not that she’ll probably be OK, but her survival and failure to recur, assuming that’s what happens, will be due to surgery and a lot of luck to have dodged the 30-40% chance of local recurrence. Her odds could be so much better if she just accepted everything modern oncology has to offer for treating breast cancer, and her survival and lack of recurrence. Our locations on opposite sides of the divide over vaccines notwithstanding, I sincerely hope she does just that, because I hope that she does not become this kind of breast cancer testimonial.

PETA Embraces Autism Pseudoscience
Steven Novella on May 28, 2014
Link
PETA (People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals) has a history of (as the old saying goes) using science as a drunk uses a lamppost – for support rather than illumination. In that way they are typical of ideological groups. They have an agenda, they are very open about their beliefs, and they marshal whatever arguments they can in order to promote their point of view.
Favoring information that supports our current beliefs is a cognitive bias common to Homo sapiens, but ideology tends to take this simple bias to a new level. It can lead to the systematic distortion or denial of science, and render belief systems immune to logic and evidence.
PETA provides us with a nice example of how having an ideological agenda can motivate an individual or a group to embrace dubious science. In an article currently on their website, and making the rounds in social media (this is repeating a claim from at least 2008, but the current article is undated), the group warns: Got Autism? Learn About the Link Between Dairy Products and the Disease. They claim:
The reason why dairy foods may worsen or even cause autism is being debated. Some suspect that casein harms the brain, while others suggest that the gastrointestinal problems so often caused by dairy products cause distress and thus worsen behavior in autistic children.
Saying that “how” dairy harms the brain is being debated implies “that” dairy harms the brain is accepted and not being debated. This is misleading. It is not accepted that dairy harms the brain or is in any way linked to autism, and the evidence is largely against it.
Gluten-free and casein-free diets for autism have been around for decades. They are based largely on the anecdotal observation that children with autism can experience a worsening in behavior when they consume gluten (a protein in wheat and other grains) or casein (a protein in milk and other dairy products). Parents will sometimes try to place their children on a gluten-free or casein-free diet, and some report improvement in behavior.
Such observations are a reasonable basis for a hypothesis, but not a conclusion. Behavior in children, especially those with the challenge of autism, can be unpredictable. Unpredictable and variable symptoms lend themselves to confirmation bias, with a strong tendency to lead to the anecdotal experience that whatever is being looked for is real. For example, many parents believe that sugar makes their children hyperactive, when this is simply not true.
Such uncontrolled observations need to be confirmed by blinded observations. These studies have been done for both gluten-free and casein-free diets. A 2008 Cochrane review of these studies concluded:
Current evidence for efficacy of these diets is poor. Large scale, good quality randomised controlled trials are needed.
A more recent review from April 2014 came to a similar conclusion:
We observed that the evidence on this topic is currently limited and weak.
The pattern of evidence reveals that the methodologically poor studies, ones that are liable to confirmation bias, show some effect, but the properly blinded studies tend to show no effect. For example, a 2010 study (although small) observed children with autism on a gluten-free and casein-free diet, and then challenged them with either gluten, casein, or placebo in a blinded manner. There was no difference in behavior observed. A recent 2014 study also showed no association between dairy and behavior in autism.
As an aside, when such studies are pointed out, the emotional argument is sometimes made that we are “attacking mothers” or “criticizing parents.” This is a diversion, however. Our only point is that parents are humans and are subject to the same cognitive biases that we are all subject to. Being a parent does not magically render someone immune to bias. We need controlled and blinded observations so that we can differentiate between a real effect and self-deception. When an effect disappears under proper blinding, the most likely conclusion is that the phenomenon is not real but is an artifact of observational bias.
Given current evidence, that is the best conclusion we can come to regarding the effects of gluten and casein on autism. The evidence for any effect on behavior is weak and likely not real. There is also no credible evidence to suggest that casein plays a causal role in autism. The evidence is overwhelming that autism is a genetic disorder. Clinical signs are evident at least by 6 months of age, if not sooner, and there is evidence that the developmental processes leading to autism begin in the womb. Despite this, the PETA article concludes:
It isn’t surprising that dairy products may worsen this disease, considering that milk has already been strongly linked to cancer, Crohn’s disease, and other serious health problems. Anyone who wants to alleviate or avoid the devastating effects of autism should give cow’s milk the boot and switch to healthy vegan alternatives instead.
PETA claims that “milk has already been strongly linked to cancer.” That is their summary of the evidence. Now let’s read the conclusion of a 2011 systematic review of the published evidence:
For most cancers, associations between cancer risk and intake of milk and dairy products have been examined only in a small number of cohort studies, and data are inconsistent or lacking. Meta-analyses of cohort data available to date support an inverse association between milk intake and risk of colorectal and bladder cancer and a positive association between diets high in calcium and risk of prostate cancer.
(This May 2014 systematic review comes to the same conclusion.) So milk, if anything, has a protective effect for colon and bladder cancer, while high calcium diets (not necessarily from dairy, but milk is high in calcium) increase the risk of prostate cancer. For all other cancers the jury is still out. Milk therefore might reduce cancer risk in women, and probably also in men, as long as you limit your total calcium intake.
There is also not a “strong” association with Crohn’s. There is preliminary evidence at best. One study of the incidence of Crohn’s in Japan found an increase in incidence after the introduction of a more Western diet, including meat and dairy, and reduction in rice consumption. There are too many variables here to make any conclusions about dairy specifically. There is also preliminary evidence that a bacterium found in cow’s milk may be linked to Crohn’s. Crohn’s is still a poorly understood disease and there is no clear evidence that dairy is playing a causative role.
It’s not even clear if people with Crohn’s need to limit their dairy intake. There are no blanket recommendations for patients with Crohn’s. A recent study found no association between dairy intake and symptoms, suggesting that there is no need to restrict dairy. Some patients with Crohn’s may also have lactose intolerance, and this can be difficult to diagnose because of the overlap in symptoms, so a lactose-free trial period is often recommended. However, eliminating dairy can cause nutritional deficiencies, such as low calcium, and so this needs to be done with care.
Conclusion
There is no evidence that dairy products cause autism, and the current evidence (while weak) does not support the conclusion that dairy has an adverse effect on behavior in children with autism. Further, dairy has a complex relationship with cancer risk, and is as much a benefit as a potential risk factor. There is also not a strong link between dairy and Crohn’s, although some preliminary evidence warrants follow up.
PETA, however, has launched a campaign warning the public about the association between milk and autism, throwing in claims that it is “strongly” linked to cancer, Crohn’s, and other unnamed diseases.
This is clearly, in my opinion, a campaign of fear mongering based upon a gross distortion of the scientific evidence. The purpose is to advocate for a vegan diet, which fits their ideological agenda. They are likely aware that it is easier to spread fears than to reassure with a careful analysis of the scientific evidence.

The murder of autistic teen Alex Spourdalakis by his mother and caregiver: What happened?
David Gorski on June 16, 2013
Link
Editor’s note: This is an extra “bonus” post. Basically, it’s a revised version of a post I did at my not-so-super-secret-other-blog last week. The issue, however, has disturbed me so much that I felt it appropriate to post it to SBM as well. Fear not. There will be a new post by yours truly on Monday.
Sometimes, in the course of blogging, I come across a story that I don’t know what to make of. Sometimes, it’s a quack or a crank taking a seemingly science-based position. Sometimes it’s something out of the ordinary. Other times, it’s a story that’s just weird, such that I strongly suspect that something else is going on but can’t prove it. So it was a few months ago when I came across the story of Alex Spourdalakis, a 14-year-old autistic boy who became a cause célèbre of the antivaccine crank blog Age of Autism.
I first noticed the story in early March when perusing AoA and came across a post by Lisa Goes entitled Day 19: Chicago Hospital Locks Down Autistic Patient. In the post was a shocking picture of a large 14-year-old boy in a a hospital bed in four-point restraints. He was naked, except for a sheet covering his genitals. A huge gash was torn in the bedsheet, revealing the black vinyl of the hospital bed beneath. The boy’s name, we were informed, was Alex Spourdalakis. Further down in the post was another, equally shocking, picture of Alex that, according to Goes, showed severe dermatitis on Alex’s back due to the hospital sheets. The photos shocked me for two reasons. First, if the story was as advertised (something always to be doubted about any story posted at AoA), for once I thought that I might be agreeing with Goes and thinking that AoA was actually doing a good thing, as disconcerting as that possibility was to me. Second, however, I was extremely disturbed by the publication of such revealing photos of the boy. Undoubtedly, Alex’s mother must have given permission. What kind of mother posts pictures like that of her son for all the world to see? Then there appeared a Facebook page, Help Support Alex Spourdalakis, which pled for readers to help the Spourdalakis family.
As I said, something just didn’t seem right at the time.
Now I know that something most definitely wasn’t right, but I still can’t yet figure out what was wrong at that time three months ago. What is wrong now is that a little more than a week ago Alex was brutally murdered by his mother and caregiver, stabbed to death, in fact. The murder was carefully premeditated and quite gruesome:
Convinced that Alex Spourdalakis’ severe autism was growing worse, his mother and caregiver allegedly planned for at least a week to kill the River Grove teenager and themselves.
But the alleged murder plot initially went awry last weekend when the stocky 14-year-old didn’t succumb to an overdose of his prescription medications.
After waiting for several hours, Dorothy Spourdalakis, fatally stabbed her 225-pound son four times with a kitchen knife, then cut his wrist so deeply she nearly severed his hand, Cook County prosecutors said Wednesday.
His caregiver, Jolanta Agata Skrodzka, later stabbed the family cat with the same knife, then washed the utensil and put it back in a butcher’s block, prosecutors said.
Their suicide pact never succeeded: Both women took drug overdoses, then locked themselves in the bedroom with the slain teenager.
They were found semi-conscious inside the second-floor apartment on Sunday afternoon when Alex’s father and uncle came to check on the teen, prosecutors said as the women appeared in court to face first-degree murder charges.
More details are described in this Chicago Tribune story about the murder. Dorothy Spourdalakis and Alex’s caregiver Jolanta Agata Skrodzka had apparently discussed the plan to kill Alex using an overdose of prescription sleeping pills and explained why they did it in a letter. Apparently they killed the cat because they didn’t want it to end up in a shelter after they committed suicide. We also learned that police had been to the house several times to assist with transporting Alex to doctors’ appointments because “he was big and strong and unwilling to go to the doctor.”
Over the last three months, as I occasionally read articles and posts about Alex Spourdalakis, going back to March, I increasingly got the distinct impression that there was more going on that met the eye. Now, on the one hand, Lisa Goes might have been right. That has to be conceded. But while I occasionally looked at stories about Alex on AoA, they just didn’t seem to pass the “smell test” to me. Something, it seemed to me, was being left out. Neither did a lot of the claims being made about the care Alex was receiving strike me entirely credible. At the very least, it was very clear that a highly biased, one-sided version of events was being presented. For instance, Goes claimed that Alex was kept in four-point restraints 24 hours a day at two different hospitals, Gottleib Hospital and Loyola University Medical Center (LUMC), for 19 days:
According to her, at 14 years of age, Alex has a diagnosis of severe autism and cognitive impairment. He is non-verbal. In October of 2012, Alex began to suffer neurological events that prevented a healthy sleep cycle. He was awake for many hours at a time. Agitation and aggression ensued as a result of sleep deprivation. During this time, symptoms and behaviors that were indicative of severe gastrointestinal distress developed as well. A cycle of constipation, diarrhea and formed bowel movements surfaced and became a chronic problem. On February 16th at 5:00 am, with the assistance of police and paramedics, Dorothy took her inconsolable and highly-distressed non-verbal child to Gottlieb Hospital in Melrose Park, Illinois.
Because of Alex’s physical aggression, he was placed in locked restraints. At that time, Dorothy did not know the ER would be their home for the next several days, as Alex lay naked, in locked restraints, suffering bouts of violent vomiting, severe constipation and diarrhea. Neither she nor Alex bathed for the next 13 days while hospital staff and administrators attempted to devise a plan to care for Alex. “He was given Colace for his constipation and sometimes it would take security staff and nurses more than 15 minutes to arrive to help unshackle him so he could use the bathroom,” Dorothy explained. “Alex would scream as best he could when he knew he was going to have a vomiting episode, but security took several minutes to respond so Alex would lay in his own vomit, waiting to be released by a representative of security. He would be wiped down and returned to the same restraints.”
Sure, it was possible that the boy was being abused so horribly, first at Gottleib Hospital and then at LUMC, but the story as presented struck me as implausible, although at the time I had no way of refuting or confirming the increasingly lurid stories being posted at AoA about Alex. For one thing, there are very strict laws these days about patient restraint, particularly when it comes to children. The last time I ever had to order four-point restraints was over 14 years ago, back when I moonlighted as a trauma attending in, yes, the Chicago area, the same metropolitan area where Alex lived and died. Before that I sometimes had to deal with the restraint of patients when as a resident I rotated on the trauma services at the hospitals where I trained. Sometimes patients with head injuries or severe intoxication would be violent and require restraint. There was always a strict protocol that we followed, even back then. My understanding is that the protocols have only gotten more strict. Restraining a patient, particularly a minor, is not something that is undertaken lightly, nor should it be. To believe the AoA account, we have to believe that a severely autistic teenaged boy would be kept in the emergency room for several days (also very, very unlikely) and put in restraints in an abusive fashion at not just one but two different hospitals, continuing after Alex was transferred from Gottlieb Hospital to Loyola University Medical Center on February 28. Actually, it was three different hospitals, because later Alex was shown in four-point restraints at Lutheran General Hospital during his last admission in May. More on that later.
Also missing from these stories was a clear and cogent explanation of why Alex was ever admitted to Gottleib Hospital and then transferred to LUMC in the first place. It’s mentioned in some places that Alex was “inconsolable, highly-distressed and suffering bouts of violent vomiting, severe constipation and diarrhea.” I had to look for clues to explain it, and, I must admit, I still remain puzzled. Certainly, these Change.org petitions demanding that LUMC provide what Ms. Spourdalakis considers to be “standard medical treatment,” which to her included gastroenterology. Peppered through various reports were indications that Alex had multiple allergies and GI issues. Having observed a fair amount of autism quackery on the Internet, these terms were huge red flags to me that strongly suggested the possibility that Ms. Spourdalakis was heavily into “autism biomed.” Another hint as to what might have been really going on comes from reports of a care plan conference on March 12. Allegedly (we only have one side of the story given that the hospital and doctors are bound by HIPAA privacy law not to discuss the case), if Ms. Spourdalakis failed to agree completely to the care plan Alex would be placed in the care of the Illinois Division of Family and Children Services (DFCS).
Elsewhere, I found references to demands that LUMC consult with an “Autism Medical Specialist to ensure Alex’s dietary needs were met to ensure his food allergies and intolerance’s were not aggravating any underlying gastrointestinal or other medical conditions that may also cause adverse behaviors”, which sounded suspiciously like an autism biomed quack. In this post, Lisa Goes described a visit to LUMC with Jeanna Reed of Autism Is Medical, whose website if chock full of standard antivaccine and “autism biomed” tropes, such as a section on mitochondrial disorders, banners asking if autism is vaccine injury, and the like. It’s actually a pretty bare-bones website with lots of bugs, but the intent is clear. Besides, it’s obvious (to me, at least) that Lisa Goes is antivaccine, given that she has been a regular at the (Not-So) Thinking Moms’ Revolution. Indeed, in the very same post, Lisa Goes unwittingly portrayed Jeanna Reed as ranting and haranguing Alex’s doctors with pleas to read quack studies and claims that “many of these children present with bowel disease and mitochondrial dysfunction. He could have GERD, duodenitis, esophagitis, ulcers in the small intestines, colitis. How can we know if we don’t test?” This was pure autism biomed rhetoric, leavened with the arrogance of ignorance. When one of the doctors referred to autism as a “mystery,” Goes totally lost it, yelling, “No! No! It’s not. It’s a medical illness that causes bad behavior. All you have to do IS READ*!”
Such is the arrogance of ignorance that leads antivaccinationists to lecture physicians.
Based on what was in retrospect in plain sight on the antivaccine blogs, it’s hard for me not to suspect at least a little bit that Dorothy Spourdalakis was subjecting Alex to “autism biomed” treatments, that she came to know Ms. Reed and thereby spread her story to the wider autism biomed movement at large. If my suspicions are ultimately revealed to be true through police investigation of the murder and in the upcoming trial of Alex’s mother and caregiver, it would certainly explain a lot. Certainly, it would explain why Lisa Goes and AoA rallied to Alex’s cause so enthusiastically. It would also explain why the hero of the autism biomed movement himself, Andrew Wakefield, visited Alex during Autism One and posted to YouTube on the Autism Media Channel a video making an appeal for Alex:
Note that, in this incredibly creepy video (is it just me, or does Wakefield look creepier and creepier each time I see him?), Wakefield stated that Alex was scheduled to go to long term psychiatric care in 72 hours, as if that were the worst fate imaginable for him. He appealed for funds to allow Alex to be transferred to a facility where he would “get the care he needs.” What that facility is, Wakefield does not say. What also isn’t clear is why Alex was back in the hospital again. I say “back in the hospital” because on March 23 his mother published a post on AoA announcing that Alex was being discharged from LUMC. She thanked everyone at AoA, but she also revealed her antivaccine proclivities:
It is during times like this we as a family realize our full potential. We know no one will help us unless we help ourselves. The continued abuse, medical neglect, discrimination and ignorance have to stop. Vaccines have maimed too many already and there are many more to come. The CDC’s latest stats confirm that. We are not going away, nor are we giving up. My son Alex is just one of millions of children and adults who no longer will be silenced.
We as a group have been deceived and lied to long enough. Our children have paid and are continuing to pay the ultimate price because of greed. The health care system has failed terribly. It is our responsibility to continue to bring about change.
Please continue to follow Alex on his journey toward better health. Allow us to be a part of your lives. Our strength will continue to come from everyone and anyone who would like to continue with us. Alex will hopefully get the medical testing he needs but was denied until now. So much needs to happen in order for us ensure his recovery and I still need so much help! Please continue to follow my team of helpers for updates and fundraising efforts. I cannot tell you how much I appreciate and value every single one of you who have gotten us to this place. Thank God for the internet and facebook!
To me, this was the strongest suggestive evidence that Ms. Spourdalakis had likely been subjecting Alex to autism biomed treatments. The language was pure “autism recovery”-speak. The antivaccine sentiment was there. So was the conspiracy-mongering against conventional medicine and big pharma. In another story, I learned that another antivaccinationist and advocate of “autism biomed,” Polly Tommey of the Autism Media Channel, was involved with the Spourdalakis case, and Ms. Spourdalakis claimed that all Alex needed was “something simple, in the country, where he can run around, get the treatment that he needs so he can get better.” For some reason, however, in May Alex was back in the hospital. When the new reports of Alex in the hospital started coming out, even AoA denizens and supporters wondered what had happened, for instance, on the Facebook post announcing Andrew Wakefield’s appeal. The response from Jeanna Reed:
He’s back in the hospital. The sad truth is that this will be what is left, the only path…unless we start to treat the MEDICAL conditions, provide an appropriate treatment plan and support the families while doing it. A VERY TALL ORDER but one that has to become the norm. Alex does NOT belong in a psychiatric facility. Sadly, this is the only option so many face when all of the above is not available. We did our very best to try and help them, and will continue to do what we can but it’s not enough. We know so many who (if given the opportunity) could heal. So complicated…at the minimum PRAY for them and again realize this could be any one of our children.
I don’t know about you, but if I had seen this at the time it was actually published instead of now, knowing the ultimate outcome, I would have still found the language ominous. In any case, not long after Wakefield’s appeal, Alex was released from the hospital. Andrew Wakefield provided a statement to the Daily Mail after Alex’s death explaining what happened and covering his posterior in the process:
On Sunday May 26, members of the Autism Media Channel (AMC) went to the Lutheran General Hospital in Park Ridge, Illinois. There we visited the late Alex Spourdalakis, his mother Dorothy, and his Godmother. Alex was in four-point restraint and apparently refusing to eat or drink.
His mother was beyond exhaustion and despair. The main reason for her despair was the prospect of Alex being sent to a long-stay psychiatric hospital and heavily medicated with behavior-altering drugs drugs [sic] without any treatment of his underlying medical problems.
AMC issued an appeal on Alex’s behalf to protect him from this fate. We did not, at any stage, advocate for his release from the Lutheran General Hospital.
The following day Dorothy informed us that the hospital could find nowhere that would take Alex and that his insurance carrier had refused to pay for any further inpatient care at the Lutheran General Hospital.
It appears that, as a consequence, he was discharged from that hospital despite his precarious position and that of his carers. It is our opinion that Alex’s tragic death reflects the abject failings of a medical system that has no effective answer to the autism crisis.
In the interests of complete openness, I should point out right now that I used to work part time as a trauma attending at Lutheran General Hospital from 1997 to 1999. It was how I made some extra money while I was a surgical oncology fellow at the University of Chicago. (Chicago is an expensive city to live in, and I didn’t make that much as a fellow.) LGH was a fine hospital then, and I have no reason to think that anything’s changed. Be that as it may, do I detect the stench of self-justification from Wakefield? He’s desperately trying to cover his posterior, but his fetid flatus of blame-deflection leaks out anyway. It’s what he does. Even so, if what Wakefield says is true, it does point out another aspect of this tragedy, namely support for parents with children with special needs.
That being said, what’s also utterly despicable is the reaction of the denizens of AoA and other antivaccinationists to the news of the murder of Alex Spourdalakis. For instance, it is not infrequent to see antivaccinationists blame—of course!—vaccines for Alex’s death, the apparent underlying “logic” being that if he hadn’t become autistic because of vaccine injury then none of this would ever have happened. Such “logic” prevails in the comments of AoA posts about Alex’s death, such as this one and this one. For instance:
Though I can’t support the choice these two women made, it isn’t hard to imagine the desperation and hopelessness they were engulfed in. To watch your precious child suffer for so many years and then endure what this past spring brought for them. They fought and fought the beast head on and felt the hatred against them. It isn’t hard to imagine that they were exhausted. All of this happening in America no less.
No, these two women were, as far as I can tell, offered help but refused it because it was standard conventional therapy. From what I can tell from various blog and Internet articles, they appear to have subjected Alex to biomedical quackery and were unhappy that if Alex were transferred to a psychiatric hospital’s long-term care ward he would no longer be able to receive “autism biomed” treatments. Time and investigation by the authorities will tell if that was the case. Whether that is what happened or not, I nonetheless reject the “logic” of such antivaccinationists such as it is, that only makes sense only if you accept the pseudoscience claiming that vaccines cause autism. While one can sympathize with a parent facing the task of caring for a severely autistic child who is very large, very strong, and very difficult to control, as Jo Ashline says, autism is not an excuse to kill your child, ever. As one blogger put it:
So one of the reasons I’m really pissed off is because of the usual [eye rolling] “Oh, he’s in heaven now”. My favorite is the thing that one of the groups that was intended to work towards getting Alex out of the hospital was a letter to Alex in heaven suggesting that he thank his mother for stabbing him in the chest. [Sarcastic eye rolling] “Thank you so much for brutalizing me, it’s my favorite”. Because now, you see, he’s in heaven, which I don’t think exists. And he doesn’t have autism.
Harsh? Yes. But it rings true. The entire narrative of the autism biomed movement is that autism “stole” the parents’ “real child” away from them. Since the idea that vaccines cause autism is basically holy writ for the autism biomed movement, that means vaccines “stole” the real child away by making him autistic. Parents who try to “recover” that “real” child are thus viewed as heroic, rather than abusive, because they’re willing to do whatever it takes to defeat the scourge of autism (and vaccines) in order to rescue the “real” child within. One can’t help but wonder whether what was really happening was that DFCS was going to put Alex into a conventional long term care facility because his mother clearly couldn’t handle him anymore and was treating him with autism biomed. Unfortunately, it appears from what we know right now that Alex’s mother seems to have thought that he would be better-off dead than not being given access to what she viewed as “curative” treatments for autism. Events and evidence from the investigation and trial might prove that initial assessment incorrect, but for now it seems to fit with what we know. Was Alex collateral damage in this never-ending war by antivaccinationists against autism? Although what we know now suggests that this might be the case, we just don’t know yet. We’ll have to keep an eye on the results of the investigation into Alex’s murder to find out.
In the meantime, watching the denizens of the antivaccine crank blog AoA hold candlelight vigils for Alex is very hard to take, as they rant about how the medical system failed Alex. Maybe it did (that remains to be seen), but what Lisa Goes and Andrew Wakefield did themselves certainly didn’t help Alex either.

   Autism and Vaccines

David Geier Hired to Study Vaccines and Autism
Steven Novella on March 26, 2025
Link

If you are already tired of hearing about RFK Jr. being the Secretary of Health and Human Services (HHS), buckle in. I get it – it can be exhausting. Don’t we already know everything we need to about what a medical crank he is? While SBM will not neglect the many topics that we cover, we certainly consider it a high priority to be a watchdog on someone who is at least in the running for the worst cabinet appointment in American history. As David Gorski correctly observed, this is an “extinction level event” for Federal health policy.
And he is turning out to be every bit as awful as we predicted, from downplaying a measles outbreak on his watch, to touting an ineffective treatment, all while remaining silent while his boss unravels a regulatory system meant to protect the public from actual toxins and poisons. Whatever environmentalist cred RFK had from his earlier career is now completely obliterated.
During his confirmation hearing, Senator Bill Cassidy, a Republican and a physician, generally considered the last hope of blocking RFKs confirmation, asked RFK if he thought vaccines cause autism. RFK responded that if he see scientific evidence showing that vaccine are safe he will accept it.
This was a transparent lie. RFK has had decades to review the ongoing research, and he has, and he has already cherry picked and distorted his way to his desired conclusion. More evidence will not change a flawed process. He relies on fatally flawed or even fraudulent studies, nit picks legitimate research, mischaracterizes what the evidence says, and essentially engages in extreme motivated reasoning to get to the conclusion that supports his narrative.
lt is therefore no surprise that RFK has made it an early priority of his time as HHS secretary to relitigate the question of a link between vaccines and autism. First – there is no scientific or medical reason to do another such study. There is extensive high-quality scientific research showing a lack of any link between any vaccine or vaccine ingredient and autism.
Having said that, as a general rule I am not opposed to doing more research to establish safety (whether for a medical intervention, food ingredient, or environmental substance). More information is generally better, and proving a negative (and therefore what is “necessary”) is always a relative thing. For example, here is a study from 2019, a national cohort study in Denmark, which concluded: “The study strongly supports that MMR vaccination does not increase the risk for autism, does not trigger autism in susceptible children, and is not associated with clustering of autism cases after vaccination.”
But context here is important. Is an additional study feasible, cost effective, ethical, and useful? The Danish study opportunistically used a large national registry. Why not look at data we already have to bolster reassurance for the safety of vaccines?
This is very different from the context of RFK Jr. proposing that the CDC conduct yet another study of a potential link between vaccines and autism. RFK has not demonstrated the need for such a study. Antivaxxers generally cite “public skepticism” as a reason – but of course, they are the ones generating that public skepticism by distorting and lying about the existing evidence.
Also, how would the study be done? As we have pointed out numerous times, a placebo-controlled study is not practical or ethical. You cannot withhold proven treatments from study subjects. Any such study would have to be observational, which is subject to potential confounding factors. It is reasonable to do observational studies (like the Danish study), because they can still be useful and have certain advantages, such as the ability to capture large amounts of data.
But what database of information would the CDC use to perform an observational study in the US? One potential candidate is VAERS – the vaccine adverse event reporting system. Unfortunately, this is a voluntary reporting system that is not systematic or filtered and is an extremely noisy database. As David likes to say, antivaxxers have been “dumpster diving” in the VAERS database for years, producing terrible studies with pre-determined conclusions.
Any study using VAERS or a similar source of observational data would have to be extremely rigorous, as bulletproof as possible, and as objective as possible so as not to put any thumbs on the scale to determine the outcome. Who can RFK Jr find to head such a study? Well, just as Trump found the worst possible person to head HHS, RFK Jr has apparently found the worst possible person to head such a study – David Geier.
David Geier is not a doctor or a scientist (and in fact was charged with practicing medicine without a license). He often works with his father Mark Geier, who is a doctor. The pair have a history of publishing horrible fatally flawed studies of vaccines. They are the kings of the “dumpster divers”. They have also promoted dubious treatments for their fake causation.
The choice of Geier to analyze the data in a new study looking for a link between vaccines and autism makes it perfectly clear what RFK Jr. goal is in pushing for such a study. It is not to build or shore up the consensus (which doesn’t need shoring up). It is not to gather data that is higher quality or more reliable than existing data. If that were the goal then you would tap someone who has extreme qualifications, who could assemble a team of the best and brightest, and whose objectivity is beyond question.
Tapping David Geier tells us everything we need to know – this is a hit job. In my opinion, Geier has zero credibility in the scientific community due to his long history of crankery in this area. He is not qualified as is evidenced by a long history of shoddy science and discredited conclusions.
As a result there is no possible outcome here that would be helpful. The scientific and medical communities will not take the results of Geier’s analysis seriously, as it is almost certain to be riddled with errors and poor methodology. The antivax community does not base their beliefs on scientific facts, so any such study will either reinforce their existing beliefs or will be summarily dismissed.
It seems pretty clear that the study itself and whatever outcome it produces will simply become more anti-vaccine fodder. It will be used to undermine public confidence in vaccines and be used to worsen the health and safety of Americans. With RFK Jr and David Geier in charge there is no other plausible outcome.

A Checkered History in Vaccine Court: Mark Geier at the VICP 1988-2003
A not so expert “expert”
Kathleen Seidel on May 27, 2025
Link
In light of HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s recent appointment of David Geier to conduct a study of autism and vaccines—a role that could negatively impact vaccine uptake throughout the United States—an exploration of the sources of Mr. Geier’s purported expertise to conduct such a study is in order. Given David Geier’s lifelong professional association with his father, the late Dr. Mark Geier (d. March 20, 2025), a review of Dr. Geier’s career in vaccine-injury litigation is a good place to start.
In the discussion below, I will show that David Geier’s scientific mentor and lifelong co-author was a self-taught “expert” who:
    • Had no specialized training in neurology, pediatrics, developmental pediatrics, epidemiology, biostatistics, immunology, rheumatology, or toxicology;
    • Repeatedly testified on subjects in which he had no academic training or clinical experience;
    • Offered his services to VICP petitioners in spite of multiple findings by VICP special masters that his testimony was worthless;
    • Validated parents’ belief that their disabled children were permanently injured by vaccines even when contemporaneous medical records showed that they were not;
    • Offered speculative testimony that often bore no relation to the facts of a case;
    • Could not read an EEG, a CT scan, or a magnetic resonance image, but claimed to do so in more than one case;
    • Cited to outdated textbooks in order to buttress his expert opinions;
    • Cited to studies that supported his opinions, but disregarded those that did not;
    • Cited to animal studies to support his assertions about the effects of vaccines on humans;
    • Switched his scientific arguments in midstream, contradicting his prior testimony;
    • Made assertions “as a physician” that he knew were not scientifically supportable;
    • Routinely offered subjective belief and unsupported speculation in his testimony;
    • Employed analyses that were unreliable and ungrounded in scientific methodology and procedure; and
    • Played “fast and loose” with scientific facts and literature.
Caveat lector (Reader Beware)
This is a long post in which I quote from forty different rulings between 1989 and 2003 in cases in which Mark Geier served as an expert witness. I have redacted the names of the people whose disabilities are discussed. I have not cluttered the text with case numbers and reporter citations. Although this may seem like old news, these rulings are well worth considering afresh, since they point to the quality (or lack thereof) of David Geier’s “scientific” mentorship.
In the Beginning…
Prior to 1988, the only legal remedies available to those who believed that they or a family member had sustained a vaccine injury involved suing vaccine manufacturers—a costly, lengthy, cumbersome, adversarial process. During the 1970s and 1980s, dozens of lawsuits were filed against vaccine manufacturers, including Connaught, Lederle, Eli Lilly, Wyeth, Parke-Davis, and Merrell-Dow. Most of these suits alleged harm from the diphtheria-pertussis-tetanus (DPT) vaccine, and many resulted in substantial jury awards. As a result, many vaccine manufacturers abandoned the market, and the price of many vaccines and liability insurance skyrocketed.
Dr. Mark Geier for the Plaintiff
Among the attorneys and expert witnesses who initiated and benefited from this wave of litigation was Maryland native Dr. Mark Geier. Dr. Geier had earned his PhD in genetics in 1973 and his M.D. degree in 1978, both from The George Washington University. In the years that followed, he completed a one-year internship in obstetrics, worked for a time at NIMH and at Maryland Medical Laboratory, and taught several courses at Johns Hopkins University. In 1980, he formed both Molecular Medicine, Inc. and Genetic Consultants of Maryland, the former a medical lab and the latter an obstetrics and genetic counseling practice (which offered, among other services, sex selection).
Between 1971 and 2000, Dr. Geier co-authored approximately three dozen articles and letters to journals, six of them on potentially toxic components of vaccines. Although it is unclear how he originally became involved with vaccine injury litigation, by his own count, between 1985 and 1989 he would consult or testify in over sixty civil cases (including one before the Supreme Court of Canada), routinely asserting that the DPT vaccine was “unreasonably dangerous,” and that it had caused a “toxic encephalopathy” resulting in permanent brain damage. He first offered testimony about the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine in the 1992 case Coffelt v. HHS, and would testify in seven more MMR cases between 1998 and 2006.
He Did His Own Research
Unlike most scientific experts-for-hire, Dr. Geier’s understanding of vaccines came not from any formal education in a medical specialty, prior experience in developing vaccines or diagnosing vaccine injuries, or clinical or laboratory experience, but from his independent review of the literature on the subject.
For a time, Dr. Geier succeeded in monetizing his autodidactic avocation on a grand scale. Although at the beginning his testimony was often deemed admissible and probative, his tendency to offer opinions outside the areas of his expertise, to speculate, and to disregard clinical and scientific evidence that countered his conclusions led to increasing skepticism on the part of the jurists who came to know him best: the special masters and judges who consider cases brought before the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (VICP).
The New Testimonial Arena
The National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act of 1986 authorized establishment of the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program, which commenced operations on October 1, 1988. The no-fault program was intended to stem the loss of manufacturers from the vaccine market due to the onslaught of litigation in which Dr. Geier was a frequent participant, and to provide a speedier, less adversarial means of compensating individuals who were demonstrably injured by vaccines. The establishment of the VICP created a new forum for the evaluation of vaccine-injury claims where attention could be focused on medical facts and evidence rather than questions of blame and liability, and where compensation could be awarded relatively quickly to those able to establish that they met the criteria.
From its inception in October 1988 through the end of 1989, 172 vaccine-injury petitions were filed, and 22 cases were adjudicated. Each petition alleged vaccine injuries that occurred prior to the establishment of the Program, some as far back as 1950.
Auspicious Beginnings
In October 1988, Mark Geier would make his first appearance at a VICP hearing, with Vienna, Virginia attorney Clifford Shoemaker serving as petitioners’ counsel. In the years that followed, he would provide services to petitioners in over ninety VICP cases.
Although the Vaccine Act charged the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) with responding to vaccine-injury claims, the funding and staffing to carry out this statutory responsibility was not in place until July 1990. The testimony of petitioners and their experts therefore went unopposed during first year and a half of the Program’s existence. Each of the eleven VICP cases in which Dr. Geier testified in 1989 and for which published decisions are available resulted in a determination of eligibility, and an award of compensation. By the end of June 1990 that number had risen to nineteen.
Positive Reviews
Every published decision in cases where Dr. Mark Geier testified during his first, uncontested year and a half of Vaccine Court involvement describes him as an obstetrical geneticist who had comprehensively reviewed the literature on vaccines (see, e.g., Siegfried v. HHS and Seman v. HHS). In all but three of these cases his was the only medical expert testimony provided. During this period, judges and special masters found him to be:
    • “credible and convincing” (Special Master David A. Gerard, Bailey v. HHS)
    • “well qualified” (Special Master George Hastings, Ionescu v. HHS)
    • “prepared to speak authoritatively on the subject of adverse reactions to DPT vaccines” (Judge Bohdan Futey, Ciotoli v. HHS)
    • “qualified to testify as a medical expert in this case” (Chief Special Master Gary Golkiewicz, Meredith v. HHS, Tafoya v. HHS, Berning v. HHS)
In Pusateri v. HHS, Special Master E. LaVon French described Dr. Geier as “the author of numerous publications in his field… [who] has performed extensive research on the results of endotoxins in commercial vaccines,” and determined that “his testimony is entitled to considerable weight.”
Special Master Paul T. Baird was more circumspect in his evaluation of Dr. Geier’s qualifications to offer expert testimony in the fields of neurology and toxicology. Two of his 1989 decisions included the caveat:
Although Dr. Geier’s uncontested testimony is not entitled to as much weight as would be the testimony of a neurologist or some other professional experienced in treating persons affected by neurotoxins, it is generally consistent with the guidance provided in § 14(b) of the Act and does satisfy the requirement of § 13(a)(1) of the Act that the court may award compensation only if a petitioner’s claims are substantiated by medical records or medical opinion. (Siegfried v. HHS, Seman v. HHS)
Familiarity Breeds Suspicion
From mid-1990 forward—once HHS began to scrutinize vaccine-injury claims and solicit outside experts to assess their plausibility—increasing numbers of VICP decisions discussed the limitations of Dr. Geier’s expertise, the increasingly speculative nature of his testimony, and the often-significant distance between his testimony and the facts of a given case.
Mr. Baird issued the first published decision dismissing a VICP case in which Dr. Geier testified. In Chronister v. HHS (1990), petitioners alleged that their child’s disability and death resulted from the DPT vaccine. The court found that their recollection of the timing of events differed from contemporaneous medical records—a lapse not deemed perjurous, but rather a “likely and understandable” error “colored by their desire to find an explanation.” That desire to find an explanation received a helping hand from Dr. Geier.
Petitioner states in the fee petition that she “brought her claim based on her ‘motherly intuition’ as to the events preceding her son’s seizures and cerebral palsy, and upon the opinion of causation she received from a highly recognized medical expert, Mark R. Geier, M.D.” Clearly, ‘motherly intuition’ is insufficient by itself to provide a reasonable basis for a claim… In this case, the parents’ testimony provided the necessary support for Dr. Geier’s opinion.
One more 1990 case in which Dr. Geier testified, Grant v. HHS, resulted in an award to the petitioner. Four others were dismissed by the end of the year.
Dr. Mark Geier stated that as a result of his review of the medical records, and after hearing the testimony of Mrs. Tucker, it was his opinion that there was no evidence of any cause for C‘s seizures other than an adverse reaction to the DPT vaccine. The speculative nature of the evidence concerning compensable damages in this case provides an inadequate basis for an award of compensation. (Tucker v. HHS, Special Master French)
While Dr. Geier was qualified in this and many other cases as an expert on DPT, he is not a neurologist… Dr. Geier’s conclusion that the March 5, 1982, episode was a seizure is simply not in keeping with the weight of the evidence. (Lehmann v. HHS, Special Master Denis Hauptly,)
On cross-examination, Dr. Geier testified that pediatric neurologists are normally the ones who determine that a child has a particular neurological disease. He also testified… that he would refer a child with staring to a neurologist to make a diagnosis…. Dr. Geier did not testify that seizures occurred and did not even claim competence to make such a diagnosis. (Beck v. HHS, Special Master Baird)
Dr. Geier was asked if his opinion would change if there was a diagnosis of autism. Dr. Geier stated that such diagnosis is not ‘against his opinion’ but admitted that the question was “getting to the borderline of [his] area of expertise.” (Waddell v. HHS, Special Master French)
This last statement is particularly notable given that fifteen years later, Mark and David Geier would announce that puberty in autistic children is “a ticking time bomb,” and that even though Dr. Geier had never previously worked with children, let alone autistic children, they had already begun trying out a “totally experimental treatment” on a handful of autistic children in order to remove “testosterone sheets” from the brain. But that is another story.
No Seat at the Table
The Vaccine Injury Table is a list of vaccines, adverse effects, and the time period for first symptom or manifestation of onset or of significant aggravation after vaccine administration that would qualify a petitioner for compensation under the VICP.
In his July 1991 ruling in Daly v. HHS, Mr. Golkiewicz, who would go on to serve as Chief Special Master during the Omnibus Autism Proceeding, cautioned:
This court is inclined to not allow Dr. Geier to testify before it on issues of Table injuries. Dr. Geier clearly lacks the expertise to evaluate the symptomatology of the Table injuries and render an opinion thereon…. The court admonishes Dr. Geier to reconsider his role, from an ethical and moral standpoint, as a witness under this Program. Several petitioners have lost cases solely on the little weight given to Dr. Geier’s opinion in those cases and tremendous duplication in expert fees is resulting from petitioners seeking second opinions after being informed of the serious deficiencies in Dr. Geier’s experience.
Mr. Golkiewicz would reiterate his reservations in his July 1992 decision in Jensen v. HHS:
Dr. Geier admittedly has no expertise in diagnosing Table injuries. The court also has serious reservations regarding his expertise on DPT related matters. While Dr. Geier is more familiar than most with the DPT medical literature, because of his lack of clinical practice, he is unable to relate the literature to the injured person. Therefore, Dr. Geier’s usefulness as an expert is limited to his review of the medical literature. The court sees this expertise of limited value. Furthermore, in this matter, the court is troubled by Dr. Geier’s testimony. Without any current literature or clinical experience to support him, Dr. Geier espouses a theory that the endotoxin contained in DPT causes DPT injuries and, in this case, caused J’s HUS [hemolytic uremic syndrome]. Dr. Geier consistently renders opinions in areas where he lacks expertise, with limited medical record support, and little or no support from the medical literature or the relevant medical community.
Grasping at Diagnoses
Over time, special masters who had grown familiar with Dr. Geier’s courtroom style became increasingly less inclined to give credence to his opinions.
“Dr. Geier has no clinical experience and the value of his testimony, especially in the face of treating pediatricians and pediatric neurologists, is severely limited.” (Thelen v. HHS, 1991, Special Master Golkiewicz)
“Dr. Geier knows a lot about the DPT vaccine, but… knowledge about DPT does not render one better able to diagnose a seizure, shock collapse or an encephalopathy.” (McClendon v. HHS, 1991, Special Master Baird)
“Dr. Geier, in my view, strained to find something that was simply not there.” (Chapman v. HHS, 1991, Special Master Hastings)
“Other than petitioner’s expert, Dr. Mark Geier, an obstetrical geneticist, no expert who has ever testified before me has ever linked shock collapse, a vascular event, with seizures or encephalopathy, a neurological event.” (Mills v. HHS, 1992, Special Master Wright)
“The court finds Dr. Geier’s arguments unpersuasive and speculative at best.… Dr. Geier simply fails to provide a rational basis for ignoring the IOM’s 1991 report rejecting a causal relation between DPT and afebrile convulsions and the IOM’s subsequent 1994 follow-up report.” (Salmond v. HHS, 1999, Special Master Golkiewicz)
Although originally sympathetic in her assessment of Dr. Geier, by mid-1992, Ms. Wright came to similar conclusions as her colleagues. In her June 1992 decision in Summar v. HHS, she wrote:
I ultimately perceived the testimony of petitioners’ experts in this case—Dr. Mark Thoman and Dr. Mark Geier—to be of very limited value… After reviewing the testimony of each in a number of cases over the past three years, I have simply found the testimony of each to be of very little persuasive value in case after case. I thus recommend against use of such witnesses before me in future Program cases.
Credibility Wanes
Dr. Geier’s increasing difficulty in persuading the court to adopt his interpretations of petitioners’ circumstances is documented in a series of decisions from 1992 and 1993. In his March 1992 decision in Yeoman v. HHS, Special Master Richard Abell made note of a significant diagnostic error:
Seizures are neurological events, and Dr. Geier is a geneticist, not a neurologist… Dr. Geier provided an excellent example of his limited neurology training and background during the hearing. Dr. Geier consistently referred to the events following the first vaccination… as petit mal seizures. Both Dr. [Marcel] Kinsbourne and Dr. [Joel] Herskowitz, pediatric neurologists, testified categorically that this terminology was incorrect.
That month, recently-appointed Special Master Laura Millman remarked on similar lapses in one of the earliest VICP cases alleging injury from the MMR vaccine, Saia v. HHS.
Petitioner’s own medical expert cannot distinguish between measles and measles vaccine as the cause of M’s encephalopathy. This inability would be harmless if respondent had provided no evidence of a factor unrelated… But respondent has provided such evidence… It then becomes incumbent upon petitioner to refute respondent’s evidence by a preponderance of her own evidence. This she failed to do, despite Dr. Geier’s insouciant comments about the legal consequences of his inability to state that measles vaccine is more likely than not the cause of M’s encephalopathy… Dr. Geier never discusses the significance of onset time in his conclusory affidavits, a peculiar omission considering that onset of measles and fever is crucial to disposition of this case. Perhaps because Dr. Geier’s expertise is in DPT vaccine, not measles vaccine, and in genetics and obstetrics, not neurology or pediatrics, his omission is understandable. His lack of medical knowledge, however, does not avail petitioner.
Three months later, she would be more cursorily dismissive in her opinion in Ormechea v. HHS:
[Dr. Geier’s] testimony is based on his self-generated expertise in DPT-vaccine injuries. Because Dr. Geier has made a profession of testifying in matters to which his professional background (obstetrics, genetics) is unrelated, his testimony is of limited value to the court…. His specialty has nothing to do with his avocation which is testifying in DPT matters. I cannot give his opinion any credence.
Dismissing the Dedicated Contrarian
The lack of support within the scientific community for Dr. Geier’s opinions on vaccines and his disregard for scientific evidence that contradicted his hypotheses were addressed at some length by Special Master Abell in his June 1992 decision in Aldridge v. HHS (1992):
Petitioner’s medical expert, Dr. Geier, is an obstetrical geneticist, not a neurologist. … His expertise in DPT-related injuries stems from his study of the relevant literature, rather than medical training or participation in studies. I would term this an academic rather than professional pursuit…. Dr. Geier’s testimony is necessarily only a summary of the medical literature on DPT reactions.
Dr. Geier opined that J suffered an encephalopathy and that the literature supported his thesis. He based his findings on some 22 studies, the most recent of which is from the mid-80s, and the strongest of which is the British National Child Encephalopathy Study [NCES]. This study does not conclude that DPT causes encephalopathy, but merely suggests it. No reputable American medical association endorses this thesis. In fact, both the Society of Pediatric Neurology and the American Association of Pediatricians have official positions contrary to Dr. Geier’s theories on DPT encephalopathy. The theories espoused by Dr. Geier are not those of a majority of the medical community. This court finds that the most credible report on this topic is the 1991 Institute of Medicine Report. This report does not lend support to Dr. Geier’s theories… Dr. Geier admitted that his theory on a presumed lowering of the blood brain barrier has not been medically proven. His postulations on the synergistic workings of toxins and endotoxins likewise are speculative… In summary, Dr. Geier provided a number of mechanisms by which DPT could have damaged J’s central nervous system. He did not, however, provide any positive evidence that any of these mechanisms actually occurred in this case.
Mr. Abell then voiced his concern regarding Dr. Geier’s citation to older versions of medical textbooks to support his opinions about the plaintiffs’ condition—opinions that were not supported in subsequent editions.
…Additionally, when referring the court to medical literature in an attempt to rule out infection as a cause of J’s encephalopathy, Dr. Geier cited two outdated editions of medical textbooks that allegedly indicated that a DPT encephalopathy would be accompanied by elevated cell counts in the cerebrospinal fluid. The current editions of these textbooks do not support this claim. Dr. Geier relied on a section discussing a reaction to smallpox vaccine rather than DPT vaccine to prove this same point. I find it disquieting that a witness whose expertise depends entirely on review of medical literature would fail to consider, fail to have available and fail to cite the current authority. Were Dr. Geier an attorney, he would fall below the ethical standards for representation. The undersigned is of the opinion that it is cheek at best for a medical expert to quote from an outdated text, and, if he must do so for whatever reason, it is at best negligent if not a fraud on the court to fail to state ab initio. To intentionally rely on outdated medical texts as authority for a given position approaches the disingenuous… His credibility, and therefore his testimony, suffers as a result of his lack of candor or preparation by directing the court to questionable authority in support of his position. (emphasis added)
Opine Away, Skills Be Damned
Dr. Geier was unable to interpret diagnostic imaging, as Judge James Turner noted in Sumrall v. HHS (1991):
Dr. Geier never examined or treated A, has never treated a seizure disorder, and cannot read an EEG, a CT scan, or a magnetic resonance image.
That did not prevent him from offering whatever “expert” opinion his clients might require. In Aldridge v. HHS (1992), this meant purporting to interpret a CT scan:
Dr. Geier opined that an April 14 1983 CT scan report, which stated that the “findings are most consistent with infarction complicating bacterial meningitis,” was also compatible with endotoxin damage and pertussis toxin damage.
In Marascalco v. HHS (1993), he opined on an MRI and disregarded the interpretation of a neurologist:
Dr. Geier opined that C experienced seizures within three days after her first and second DPT vaccinations…. Dr. Geier stated that, in forming his opinion, he reviewed C’s entire medical record. Indeed, Dr. Geier referred specifically to C’s May 1, 1990 MRI record…. Dr. Geier did not address Dr. Seidel’s conclusion that C’s MRI fell ‘within the spectrum of polymicrogyria.’
To Procure & Defend
Notwithstanding the increasing numbers of rulings critical of Dr. Geier’s testimony, by the end of 1992 petitioners’ attorneys had offered him as an expert in over fifty VICP proceedings. His business was derived primarily from those who made the Vaccine Program their primary professional milieu, above all Clifford Shoemaker, who would become treasurer of the antivaccine organization, National Vaccine Information Center. (In 2008, he would be sanctioned for filing an abusive subpoena against this author, and disbarred in 2020 after raiding a disabled client’s fiduciary account.)
In October 1992, Special Master John Edwards issued one of his first public comments on Dr. Geier’s testimony. His ruling in Einspahr v. HHS specifically addressed the attorneys responsible for putting Dr. Geier on the stand over and over again.
Dr. Geier’s speculative testimony is essentially worthless to a special master. Yet, all petitioners’ counsel and Dr. Geier waste an inordinate amount of time by presenting this testimony in Program cases. All petitioners’ counsel are on notice that the special master will no longer allow Dr. Geier to offer his speculative testimony about pertussis toxin or endotoxin until Dr. Geier is able to apply the various theories to the particular case.
In spite of Mr. Golkiewicz’s warning in Daly v. HHS, Mr. Shoemaker offered Dr. Geier as an expert in a December 1992 hearing before the same special master. Rejecting the expert testimony presented by the petitioner in Ultimo v. HHS, Mr. Golkiewicz wrote:
Dr. Geier is unqualified to testify on Table injuries, and although Dr. Geier is qualified to discuss the state of medical literature regarding DPT vaccinations, Dr. Geier due to his lack of clinical practice is unqualified to relate the findings of the literature to the facts of a given case. Even if Dr. Geier’s affidavit was considered it would be of no help to petitioner. Dr. Geier found a Table case based upon the onset within 3 days… The facts did not support this timing of onset. Dr. Geier does state in characteristic unsupported fashion that, “It is my opinion, even if D’s first seizures appeared 4 days following his DPT shot, that it is more likely than not that D’s current neurological condition which includes his residual seizure disorder and brain damage were the result of his second DPT shot that the received 12/6/62.” No support is given for this statement. Accordingly, it deserves and receives no weight.
In his July 1993 decision in Marascalco v. HHS, Mr. Edwards offered a damning assessment of Dr. Geier’s analysis and candor, homing in on his disregard for inconvenient portions of the petitioner’s medical records.
The special master rejects specifically Dr. Geier’s testimony. In the special master’s view, Dr. Geier’s September 1990 affidavit in this case was seriously intellectually dishonest. It is absolutely clear that Dr. Geier quoted selectively from C’s medical records. In his September 1990 affidavit, Dr. Geier stated that C’s May 1990 MRI “suggests a remote insult to brain development.” However, the same MRI record indicates also that the “remote insult to brain development” is “within the spectrum of polymicrogyria.” Dr. Geier… admitted that he does not possess the expertise to diagnose a condition such as polymicrogyria. Nevertheless, in September 1990, Dr. Geier stated that in his opinion, extensive medical tests—including C’s May 1990 MRI scan—did not identify any “provable cause for C’s condition other than the DPT shots which she received.
Yet, the diagnosis of polymicrogyria was not definitively excluded as a cause for C’s condition until early 1992—more than one year after Dr. Geier executed his September 1990 affidavit. Thus, the special master finds that Dr. Geier ignored portions of C’s medical records in forming his opinion in this case. The special master concludes that Dr. Geier’s September 1990 affidavit is nothing more than an egregious example of blatant, result-oriented testimony… The special master finds that Dr. Geier’s baseless September 1990 affidavit in this case undermines wholly his credibility as a witness.
Humans Are Animals, but…
In her 1993 decision in Haim v. HHS, Special Master Millman addressed in depth the impact of the Supreme Court decision in Daubert v. Merrell-Dow Pharmaceuticals on the admissibility of expert testimony in the VICP, and trained her sights on the ubiquitous Mark Geier:
Dr. Geier’s testimony is based mainly on the NCES [British National Child Encephelopathy Study] and secondarily on a theory of endotoxin “poisoning” of animals. The court holds that Dr. Geier’s testimony does not reach the level of evidentiary reliability that Daubert requires because it is not based upon scientific validity, valid methodology, peer review or testing, and more than minimal support within the scientific community.
Dr. Geier’s expertise as a doctor in the fields of genetics and obstetrics is of no relevance to the issues in the case…. The only relevancy Dr. Geier’s testimony has to the court is as a scientist who, according to Dr. Geier, is familiar with both epidemiology and animal testing. Dr. Geier testified that… he did not know to a scientific degree of certainty that more likely than not DPT caused N’s seizure. Dr. Geier testified that the most likely cause of N’s illness cannot be determined scientifically. The reason undoubtedly that he so testifies is that he cannot as a scientist give validity to the NCES and the toxin theory. Therefore, Dr. Geier offered his opinion that DPT caused N’s condition as a physician, not as a scientist.
This is legal legerdemain which in essence challenges the court to discern why Dr. Geier switches from physician to scientist for the purpose of discussing the basis of his opinion (the NCES and the toxin theory in animal testing), and then back from scientist to physician for the purpose of discussing his level of certainty regarding causation. Dr. Geier may be clever, but he is not credible. Unless the NCES and the toxin theory are based on principles and methodology that are scientifically valid, his conclusions are irrelevant to this court.
Dr. Geier has sloughed over fundamental scientific principles to offer as the second basis for his causation opinion the results of animal testing. The IOM categorically rejects any interpolation of animal studies in the context of attributing causation of neurologic illness to DPT vaccine…. Dr. Geier’s reliance on animal testing as a basis of his opinion on causation in fact is less than candid and not persuasive to this court.
In both the epidemiologic and animal testing areas, Dr. Geier’s testimony fails the Daubert criteria. Dr. Geier has made a career of testifying in cases involving “long-onset” encephalopathy following DPT vaccine. In light of the clear language of Daubert, no other court should be without the tools with which to dissect Dr. Geier’s testimony and to recognize its frailty. Dr. Geier’s testimony is not reliable, or grounded in scientific methodology and procedure. His testimony is merely subjective belief and unsupported speculation.
New Century, Old Concerns
Throughout the mid- to late 1990s, VICP decisions frequently mentioned Dr. Geier’s habit of relying solely on parent reports as the basis for his diagnoses and prognoses, his disregard for contemporaneous medical records in forming his opinions, and his reliance primarily on the NCES to support his “toxic encephalopathy” hypotheses.
“Furthermore, petitioners’ medical experts who testified in the case, Drs. Geier and Mauk, each based their diagnosis on information provided by the petitioners, particularly Mrs. Epstein.” (Epstein v. HHS, Judge Marian Blank Horn, 1996)
“Dr. Geier’s thesis of a toxic invasion of brain cells is not borne out by the pathology (the coroner did not identify brain edema) and the clinical signs (R’s fontanelle was flat).” (Cox v. HHS, Special Master Millman, 1997)
“Dr. Geier based his opinion on the assumption that D had experienced the seizures described by the petitioners. Although Dr. Geier concluded that D experienced seizures, he based his opinion exclusively on the statements of the petitioners. Because of this, his opinion cannot constitute a “medical opinion” to corroborate petitioners’ claim as required by § 300aa-13(a)(1) of the Vaccine Act.” (Lett v. HHS, Judge James Turner, 1997)
“Dr. Geier relies totally on the affidavits of Mr. and Mrs. Muller and E. Muller to establish a temporal association for on-Table significant aggravation.” (Muller v. HHS, Special Master Millman, 1998)
“Dr. Geier in this case has failed to persuade me that his general causation theory is valid…. Dr. Geier in this case spent relatively little time discussing any specific medical literature beyond the 1991 and 1994 IOM Reports, the original NCES, and the 1993 NCES follow-up study.… In my view, Dr. Geier in this and other cases has simply failed to demonstrate that sufficient evidence exists to support his general causation theory. He has failed to point to particular studies, beyond the NCES, and to explain how they support his theory.” (Lewis v. HHS, 1999, Special Master Hastings)
“Dr. Geier simply fails to provide a rational basis for ignoring the IOM’s 1991 report rejecting a causal relation between DPT and afebrile convulsions and the IOM’s subsequent 1994 follow-up report.” (Salmond v. HHS, 1999, Special Master Golkiewicz)
“Dr. Geier’s affidavit gives no basis other than the NCES and the IOM for his opinion on causation.” (Grady v. HHS, 2000, Special Master Millman)
By the turn of the century, Dr. Geier had failed to rehabilitate his reputation, but continued to offer his services to VICP petitioners. In his 2000 decision in Platt v. HHS, Special Master Hastings expressed his dismay at Dr. Geier’s midstream abandonment of his original theory regarding the petitioners’ injuries, which cast doubt on the veracity of his testimony throughout.
During the proceedings before Special Master Wright, Drs. Geier, Bellanti, and Shoham all explained that a major reason for their conclusion that S’s chronic pancreatitis was vaccine-caused was their view that whatever caused that first episode of a person’s pancreatitis was probably the cause of any ensuing chronic pancreatitis. Dr. Geier even indicated that if S in fact suffered from preexisting pancreatitis, his opinion would be different. Yet on remand, Drs. Bellanti and Geier have abandoned, without explanation, their previously-stated view that the cause of a person’s first episode of pancreatitis is likely the cause for any ensuing chronic pancreatitis. Instead, they now assert that it was the vaccination, not the cause of S’s first pancreatitis episodes, that resulted in the chronic pancreatitis. This abrupt change of direction was not only unconvincing, but, to be frank, makes me doubt very much that either expert was actually offering a candid opinion of the case in the testimony before me.
In his 2001 decision in Raj v. HHS Special Master Golkiewicz remarked:
Dr. Geier is wholly unqualified to testify concerning the two major issues in this case.… Concerning the Table encephalopathy issue, the undersigned, in Salmond, found Dr. Geier unqualified to testify… because he is neither board certified nor has formal training in pediatrics and pediatric neurology. Concerning the infantile spasms issue, Dr. Geier admitted at trial that he has no experience treating or diagnosing seizure disorders. The court found both experts to be non-objective advocates whose testimony played fast and loose with the facts and literature.
Special Master Millman’s December 2002 decision in Bruesewitz v. HHS documents considerable lapses in attention by the petitioners’ expert:
Dr. Geier confuses H’s case with someone else’s because he refers to her death and subsequent autopsy. H is still alive.
Regarding Dr. Geier, the specialist in genetics and forensic medicine, his affidavits and report are not credible. First, being a board-certified geneticist and forensic medicine specialist does not qualify him to diagnose neurological diseases and offer an opinion as to how doctors who do specialize in neurology define “encephalopathy.“
In his discussion of DPT causing seizures, Dr. Geier refers in his second affidavit to the IOM’s Adverse Effects of Pertussis and Rubella Vaccines (1991), but significantly omits the IOM’s conclusion that DPT does not cause afebrile seizures. H had afebrile seizures.
The Stealth Witness
By 2003, Dr. Geier’s status with the VICP special masters had sunk so low that in Thompson v. HHS, Clifford Shoemaker filed his response to statement by an expert for HHS lacking any indication of its source. The secrecy surrounding the submission failed to impress Special Master Millman.
On January 29, 2003, respondent filed Dr. Snyder’s response to [plaintiffs’ exhibits]. On February 28, 2003, petitioners filed an unsigned response to Dr. Snyder’s analysis. Not only did this response have no signature, but also there was no letterhead or printed name to indicate who had written it.… The undersigned issued an Order dated March 17, 2003 that petitioners had either to refile this response with the signature of the author or to file the author’s name…. On March 28, 2003, petitioners filed Dr. Mark Robin Geier’s statement that he had written the previously unsigned response to Dr. Snyder’s analysis.
…If the undersigned were to accept the statements of Dr. Geier, petitioner’s “stealth witness,” filed unsigned and unacknowledged as “A Reply to Dr. Russell Snyder’s Comments”, the gist of Dr. Geier’s comments is that statistical significance is unimportant since the court needs a standard of only more likely than not to rule for petitioners. Dr. Geier fails to understand that the undersigned accepts data which are persuasive to individuals in the field at issue (epidemiology, here) in order to accept their conclusions.
…Intellectual rigor is missing from Dr. Tornatore’s testimony and the stealth witness Dr. Geier’s submission after trial. They both posit causation based on the speculation that there are more cases of infantile spasms out there than the NCES and other researchers detected and that, in any event, since the undersigned is looking only for a preponderance of the evidence, statistical significance should not even be relevant here. But it is relevant since professionals in the field of epidemiology rely upon statistical significance in order to reach valid, credible conclusions.
…Frankly, petitioners’ counsel knew it was wrong to submit Dr. Geier’s report after the hearing. That is why he submitted it without any indication of who wrote it. When the undersigned ordered that either the author submit his name or petitioners refile the exhibit with his name, petitioners’ counsel telephoned to inquire if it was sufficient to satisfy the Order if he filed a statement from Dr. Tornatore that he agreed with the report. This was not sufficient and, thus, Dr. Geier emerged from the shadows to proclaim his handiwork.
Neither Dr. Tornatore nor Dr. Geier is qualified to testify about infantile spasms, and their testimony is filled with speculation that is directly contrary to the conclusions reached in well-respected and numerous epidemiologic and medical studies ranging over two decades.
Special Master Millman ruled that the petitioners were ineligible for compensation, and noted that Dr. Geier’s testimony did nothing to further their claim.
To be continued…
In subsequent posts, I will discuss David Geier’s career as a co-author with Mark Geier of numerous journal articles purporting to demonstrate an association between vaccines, autism and other developmental and neurological conditions, and as an aspiring consultant in VICP cases.
This essay is adapted and expanded from my 2008 Neurodiversity Weblog post, The New Testimonial Arena, which was part of the series Vaccine Court Chronicles.


The Journal of Predetermined Conclusions
We Told You So: Vaccines Cause Autism And So Many Other Really Bad Things
Authors: David Geier, Brian Hooker, Ph.D., Del BigTree, Callie Means, Sherri Tenpenny, D.O., Suzanne Humphries, M.D. Bob Sears M.D, Larry Pavelsky M.D., Kelly Brogan M.D., Stella Immanuel M.D, Simone Gold M.D, Pierre Kory M.D, Peter Doshi MPH, Joseph Fraiman M.D. Joseph Ladapo M.D., Joseph Marine M.D., Martin Kulldorff M.D. Allison Krug MPH, Tracy Beth Hoeg, M.D., Joe Mercola D.O. Jay Bhattacharya, M.D., Christiane Northrup, M.D. and Vinay Prasad M.D, MPH, for the WTYS-I Investigators
Published November 16, 2025 J Pre Con 2025;392:1155-1167 DOI: 10.1056/JPVoa2412006 VOL. 382 NO. 12 Copyright © 2026
Background
Despite Saint Wakefield’s definitive study and incontrovertible testimony from parents who have done their research on vaccines, the myth that the MMR doesn’t cause autism persists.
Methods
The Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD) is a collaborative project between CDC’s Immunization Safety Office and healthcare organizations across the United States. To prove that vaccines cause autism (duh!), a self-controlled risk interval design was used to determine the relative risk of each outcome in a risk window after vaccination compared to unvaccinated controls, whose parents clearly love them more. We included children (aged 1–4 years) who received ≥ 1 dose of MMR from January 1, 2010–December 31, 2021. Pre-specified outcomes were identified by diagnosis codes and our intuition.
Clinically serious outcomes evaluated include scrumpox, mortification, the shakes, witchpox, bloody flux, greyscale, monkey fluxpox, dropsy of the brain, bad blood, consumption, black worm fever, chalkstones, blackwater fever, cramp colic, crotch rot, flux of humour, grocer’s itch, kuru, grandular fever, the horrors, King’s evil, lockjaw, milk leg, quinsy, scrofula, the shakes, softening of the brain, lumpism, swamp sickness, jake leg, worm fit, white swelling, winterthistle fever, wandering womb fever, jail fever, Dum-Dum fever, dipsomania, drapetomania, the staggers, the vapours, and autism. All serious outcomes underwent independent medical record review by investigators who were fair and unbiased. You can totally trust us.
Results
During the study period, 963,327 MMR doses were administered to sweet, innocent children who will never be the same. Mean age of vaccinees was 1.8 years; 55.8 % were female; 12.2 % of doses were administered simultaneously with ≥ 1 other horrible vaccine. Serious outcomes occurred with an incidence ≥ 563,000 per 100,000 doses for each outcome assessed. Outcomes that were significantly more common in the vaccinated cohort included flux of humour, bloody flux, the vapours, crotch run, grocer’s itch, grandular fever, the horrors, King’s evil, lockjaw, milk leg, quinsy, scrofula, the shakes, softening of the brain, and autism. Some variability was observed by sex and age group.
Autism was more significantly common in vaccinated boys named Billy with brown eyes born on a Tuesday in Duluth, Minnesota compared to unvaccinated girls names Crystal-Lee with hazel eyes born on a Wednesday in Mobile, Alabama (63.0% vs. 24.2%; relative rate, 1.37; 95% confidence interval, 1.04 to 1.81; P=0.03). This wasn’t something we found by slicing up the data in every way imaginable. Unvaccinated children with natural immunity were obviously happier and healthier. You could tell which kids had been vaccinated just by looking in their cold, dull eyes.
Conclusion
Serious outcomes after MMR vaccination were super common. Vaccines cause autism and many other horrible things. We totally told you so, and only Pharma $hills would disagree. No further research is needed. Subscribe to our monetized social media content, buy our supplements, and send all your money to Children’s Health Defense.


Vaccines Still Not Linked to Autism
Steven Novella on May 21, 2014
Link
Myths tend to be persistent and require periodic maintenance debunking. The anti-vaccine movement arguably can credit its recent increase in effect to successfully spreading fears that vaccines in general, and particularly either the MMR vaccine (mumps, measles, and rubella) or the vaccine preservative thimerosal, are linked to autism. This claim was never based on legitimate science, and over the last 15 years has been overwhelmingly repudiated by multiple independent lines of scientific evidence.
It is easier to spread fears than it is to reassure anxious parents with abstract scientific data, but still we must try. It also seems that giving people information is not an effective way to change their opinions or their behavior. But at the very least I hope to better inform those who are already on board with the science-based approach, and perhaps we can reach the occasional person on the fence who is simply misinformed and open to changing their mind.
A new meta-analysis seems like a good opportunity to remind the public that vaccines are safe and effective, and that they are not linked to neurodevelopmental disorders. The study is: “Vaccines are not associated with autism: An evidence-based meta-analysis of case-control and cohort studies,” by Taylor, Swerdfeger and Eslick, is published in the journal Vaccine. They found: 
Five cohort studies involving 1,256,407 children, and five case-control studies involving 9920 children were included in this analysis. The cohort data revealed no relationship between vaccination and autism (OR: 0.99; 95% CI: 0.92 to 1.06) or ASD (OR: 0.91; 95% CI: 0.68 to 1.20), or MMR (OR: 0.84; 95% CI: 0.70 to 1.01), or thimerosal (OR: 1.00; 95% CI: 0.77 to 1.31), or mercury (Hg) (OR: 1.00; 95% CI: 0.93 to 1.07). Similarly the case-control data found no evidence for increased risk of developing autism or ASD following MMR, Hg, or thimerosal exposure when grouped by condition (OR: 0.90, 95% CI: 0.83 to 0.98; p = 0.02) or grouped by exposure type (OR: 0.85, 95% CI: 0.76 to 0.95; p = 0.01).
Of course, it is impossible to prove a negative, but those p-values, confidence intervals, and odds ratios are all very reassuring. This is, collectively (and that’s the point of a meta-analysis), a large body of evidence showing a complete lack of association between autism and ASD with vaccines in general, with the MMR vaccine in particular, or with thimerosal or mercury.
Autism/ASD
Part of the fear that there is some environmental cause for autism comes from the steady increase in the incidence of diagnoses over the last 20 years. According to the CDC, in 2000 the prevalence of autism was 1 in 150, and in 2010 it had increased to 1 in 68. One reason we track the incidence (new cases per year) and prevalence (how many cases exist at one time) of diseases is as a warning system to alert us to a potential new risk. It is perfectly reasonable to ask questions about this increasing prevalence, which certainly suggests an environmental cause.
However, one reasonable question to ask is this – is the increase in the number of diagnoses being made due to an actual increase in the incidence of the disorder, or is it due to diagnostic definitions and behavior? I discussed this question previously at length. The short answer is that much of the increase in the number of diagnoses can be explained by a broadening of the definition, increased surveillance, and diagnostic substitution.
The data is not sufficient to rule out the conclusion that a subset of the increase is due to a real increase in incidence, but neither has a real increase been definitively demonstrated. It’s possible that it’s all an artifact of diagnosis.
Further, there is copious and increasing scientific evidence that autism is primarily a genetic disorder. Twin studies show a large genetic component. Autism is linked to many individual gene mutations, duplications, and deletions. Not surprisingly, the many specific genes linked to autism are involved in brain development – precisely the genes you would think would be involved in this kind of disorder. At this point there is no question that autism is predominantly a group of complex genetic disorders affecting the organization and connections of the neurons in the brain. This does not by itself rule out an environmental factor – environment can modify the expression and implications of specific genetic changes. The role of environmental factors, however, is certainly diminished by the apparent predominant role of genetics.
The final point to make about autism is that recent research has demonstrated that it can be diagnosed at younger and younger ages, if we look carefully. Several studies show that signs of autism can be detected as early as six months of age, and preliminary data suggests this may be possible as early as two months. Even more significant is a recent study suggesting that the brain changes found in autism must begin in early fetal development – in the womb.
To summarize, evidence suggests that the true incidence of autism is not increasing (although a small increase cannot be ruled out), that it is dominantly genetic (although an environmental factor cannot be ruled out), and that autism is already present in very young children and likely has its roots in early fetal development, before any vaccines are given. These lines of evidence all argue strongly against any association of autism with vaccines.
MMR and thimerosal
The MMR vaccine and thimerosal have been the key targets of the anti-vaccine movement, although their real focus is to blame vaccines in general. The MMR scare was triggered by the now-infamous Lancet study (since retracted) by the discredited researcher Andrew Wakefield. This story has been told multiple times here and elsewhere. To summarize, Wakefield’s small and preliminary study was found to also be likely fraudulent. Subsequent research has not found any link between the MMR vaccine and autism.
As the MMR story was crashing and burning, the antivaccine movement latched onto another boogeyman in the guise of thimerosal, a mercury-based preservative in some vaccines (although never in the MMR). Targeting thimerosal had the advantage of allying the antivaccine movement to the anti-mercury movement and some extreme environmentalists (most notably, RFK Jr.). The thimerosal scare was also given a boost by the book Evidence of Harm by David Kirby.
In the early 2000s, Kirby and other antivaccinationists argued that the increasing exposure to thimerosal in the vaccine schedule was the true cause of the apparent rise of autism rates. The last 14 years, however, have definitely disproven this “hypothesis.” Multiple studies have failed to show any correlation between thimerosal exposure, mercury exposure, or mercury excretion and the risk of developing autism. There is simply no link.
But the final nail in the coffin came as a result of the removal of thimerosal from the routine vaccine schedule around 2001. By 2002 children in the US were no longer receiving vaccines with added thimerosal as a preservative as part of the routine schedule. Some multi-dose flu vaccines still contain thimerosal, but these are optional, and most flu vaccines given in the US don’t contain thimerosal. Thimerosal is also still used in the manufacturing process of some vaccines, and so trace amounts may remain in the final product.
This, of course, gives deniability to dedicated antivaccine ideologues. But the undeniable truth is that exposure to thimerosal through vaccines was dramatically reduced around 2002 – to trace amounts for most children. At that time Kirby and others predicted that autism rates would plummet, confirming their claim that thimerosal was the cause of the apparent increase in rates. This is the one point on which we agreed – if thimerosal was a significant risk factor for the development of autism, and in fact was the cause of the increase in diagnosis rates, then those rates should plummet within 4-7 years following the removal of thimerosal from the vaccine schedule by 2002.
It has now been 12 years and autism rates have not plummeted. In fact, there has not been the slightest blip in the steady rise of diagnosis rates over the last decade. Removing thimerosal from the routine vaccine schedule has had zero detectable effect on the diagnosis of autism.
This is the absolute final nail in the coffin of the failed thimerosal/mercury hypothesis of autism. Only the motivated reasoning of the most dedicated antivaccine ideologue can deny this simple fact.
Conclusion
The recent meta-analysis is just icing on the cake of the body of scientific evidence that fails to demonstrate any link between vaccines in general, MMR, or thimerosal with autism or ASD. Scientific research also gives us many independent reasons to doubt such a link.
There is no scientific controversy here. As much as ideologues hate to hear this – the science is settled. This, of course, does not stop dedicated ideologues from fearmongering with false claims and pseudoscience in order to promote their agenda.

Vaccines Still Don’t Cause Autism
Update: The evidence continues to show no link between vaccines and autism.
Steven Novella on August 22, 2018
Link

There is no evidence linking any vaccine or vaccine ingredient, or the childhood vaccine schedule, to the risk of developing autism or any neurodevelopmental disorder. But an alleged connection remains a persistent myth, propagated by the anti-vaccine movement. We have not written about this for a while so I thought I would check in on the data to see if there were anything new.
The exact claims of anti-vaxxers have shifted over the years, starting with the MMR vaccine, then thimerosal (a mercury-containing preservative), then just vague toxins, or “Too many, too soon” or perhaps it’s aluminum, or whatever – but it has to be something in the vaccines. The most prominent claim, however, that still is popular among antivaxxers is the notion that thimerosal is linked to autism.
The most compelling evidence against a link between thimerosal and autism is the fact that thimerosal was removed from the childhood vaccine schedule in the US in 2002, and this did not result in the predicted decline in autism diagnoses. Antivaxxers did make this prediction. David Kirby, who wrote Evidence of Harm, popularizing the thimerosal-autism claim, predicted that autism rates would plummet, which would prove the connection. He and others promoting this claim looked anxiously over the autism incidence rates as they came in, pointing excitedly at any downward fluctuations.
But the predicted decline never happened. I and others who thought the evidence did not support a connection made a very different prediction – that autism incidence would continue to rise until it reached its true level (I will explain this further below), and then would level off. That is essentially what is happening.
Antivaxxers not willing to give up on good propaganda started making increasingly absurd rationalizations. One I heard just a few years ago was that pediatricians were still using the thimerosal-containing vaccines they had in stock. However, thimerosal-containing vaccines in the schedule (it’s still in some flu vaccines) were phased out by 2002. Even if every pediatrician stocked up on these vaccines for the full shelf life of two years, that would have extended their use to 2004 (and to be clear, this is not what happened, but even if we take this extreme case).
As the years ticked by and autism rates did not plummet, the thimerosal hypothesis was looking worse and worse. Anti-vaxxers were persistent, however. They kept waiting for the predicted decline, like Linus waiting for the Great Pumpkin, but it never occurred. They tried to argue for more and more of a delay, but every year their strained arguments got less and less plausible.
This year the CDC published their autism incidence statistics, which include data through 2014. The rates ticked up a little bit again from the previous estimates covering through 2012. Incidence rose from 14.6/1000 to 16.8 (or 1 in 59 children).
So we now have data for 12 years following the complete removal of thimerosal from the vaccine schedule and no decline in autism diagnoses. There is also more recent state data (not yet compiled nationally) showing no decline even through 2018 (that’s 16 years). If thimerosal were contributing to the number of cases of autism, we should definitely be seeing some effect by now.
In essence, by removing thimerosal from the vaccine schedule we conducted a natural experiment, with a very clear outcome. This experiment has been replicated in many countries around the world, and in fact world-wide use of thimerosal has been steadily declining for the last 20 years, without any correlated decrease in autism.
So – is there any one left who still clings to the thimerosal-autism claim despite this slam-dunk evidence for a lack of a correlation? Of course there is. In a 2017 interview, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. argued that thimerosal in flu vaccines was the culprit.
Healthline: It seems your main concern is the flu shot, which is given to children and pregnant woman. Is that your focus?
Kennedy: It’s being given to children at 6 months and it’s being given to pregnant women. So, today the exposure a child suffers is probably the greatest in history. If you give a flu shot to a woman who is one or two months pregnant, that child could be getting thousands of times of exposure levels to mercury.
Let’s look at the numbers. Total thimerosal dose to infants and young children peaked at 187.5 micrograms of thimerosal (not including flu vaccines, which are optional). The argument from antivaxxers was, as the thimerosal dose increased, so did autism diagnoses. Well, then, as the thimerosal dose decreased, so should autism diagnoses, which we now know did not happen. Multi-dose flu vaccines contain about 25 micrograms of thimerosal. So even if a child received a flu vaccine with thimerosal every year, they would not total the dose in the previous vaccine schedule for 7 years.
But remember – that 187.5 micrograms was in addition to any flu vaccines. No matter how you slice it, total thimerosal dose was decreased. There is also good evidence that mercury from thimerosal is cleared within days, and does not accumulate over years, so it doesn’t make sense to total the dose over years. Further, signs of autism are present as early as six months of age.
All of this is why Kennedy and others focus on the flu vaccines given to pregnant mothers. I don’t know what he is referring to with the “thousands of times” claim, or what he is comparing it to. In any case – this has been studied also, and there is no link between maternal flu shots and autism.
Further still, only the fraction of flu shots that are given from multi-dose vials contain thimerosal. Shots given from single-dose vials and live virus vaccines do not contain thimerosal. The percentage of flu shots with thimerosal has been declining, and for this latest flu season only about 14% of flu vaccines produced contained thimerosal. Also, some states, like California, have banned thimerosal-containing flu vaccines, so the total dose of thimerosal for children in those states is zero.
So really it is completely absurd for Kennedy and others to claim that autism rates have not declined because of flu vaccines, and every year such claims get even more ridiculous.
So why, then, are autism rates increasing? There are a number of reasons, and we have explored them here before. It is a combination factors, including diagnostic substitution, increased surveillance, and broadening the diagnosis. The CDC attributes the recent increase to more diagnoses among minorities, who remain underdiagnosed compared to Caucasians. This is due to increased awareness and diagnostic efforts, often linked to services.
It is also possible that increasing maternal or paternal age is causing a real increase in autism incidence, but that is only part of the total increase.
We will keep tabs on the data, on any new significant published research, and keep reminding the public that the vaccine schedule is safe, it is closely studied and monitored, and there is no credible link to autism or any neurodevelopmental disorder.

MMR and Autism Rises from the Dead
Steven Novella on September 4, 2013
Link
One of the tactics of snake-oil salesmen is to fearmonger about mainstream medical practices so as to scare potential customers into their clutches. A common target of such fearmongering is vaccines. Vaccine are an easy target – they are generally required by the government to some degree, and involve sticking small children with needles and injecting them with a cocktail that parents often don’t understand in detail.
While vaccines are of clear benefit, no one argues that they are risk free. There are rare serious complications. For this reason the US established the NVIC – National Vaccine Injury Compensation program. This is funded by a small tax on each vaccine, and is designed to compensate families of children who have a possible reaction to vaccines, bypassing the slow and costly regular court system. The NVIC works well.
The goal of the NVIC is not to determine scientifically if there is a link between a particular vaccine and a particular side effect. That is determined by the scientific community. Rather, the NVIC’s charge is to determine if “compensation is appropriate” in specific cases. They also give the benefit of the doubt to the families.
In many cases families do not have to prove that a vaccine caused a specific injury, only that their child had a certain medical outcome within a specific time frame of being vaccinated. Further, certain outcomes are considered “table injuries,” meaning that all the family has to do is establish that the child has the condition and the onset was within a certain window after getting a vaccine, and then compensation is automatic.
What this means is that there is a steady stream of families being compensated by the NVIC as a matter of course, even if there isn’t a single actual vaccine injury. Children get vaccinated, and children get sick, and sometimes these two things happen in sequence by chance alone. There is likely also rare reactions to vaccines, and there is no way to separate these two groups, so the NVIC just compensates everyone.
The NVIC, however, provides a constant source of raw material for vaccine fearmongers. Social media and the internet also mean that these cases can be passed around over and over again, rising from the dead even after they have been repeatedly explained by more sober sources. Most people don’t let pesky facts get in the way of a good story.
The usual suspects, such as Natural News, are again pushing the story of Ryan Mojabi (anti-vaccine reporter David Kirby exploited this case earlier in the year). Ryan developed encephalitis within 5-15 days after the MMR, and has permanent neurological injury as a result. This is a table injury, and so was deemed “appropriate for compensation.” Natural News, however, is reporting that:
…but the federal government’s kangaroo “vaccine court” has once again conceded, albeit quietly, that the combination measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine does, indeed, cause autism.
No they didn’t. They did not even rule that the MMR causes Ryan’s injury, only that compensation is appropriate under their rules. Further, Ryan did not have autism. He had encephalitis (inflammation of the brain) which caused brain injury. This can cause symptoms which superficially might resemble autism (to a non-expert), but it’s not autism.
Natural News is further reporting this as a vindication of Andrew Wakefield, when it is nothing of the sort. Wakefield’s faked science remains utterly discredited.
Also absent from the fearmongering articles are the real facts surrounding encephalitis, measles, and vaccines.
Childhood encephalitis is most often caused by viral infections. The real question with regard to vaccines is this – is there any statistical association between vaccines and the risk of encephalitis? The answer to that question is probably no. A review of cases from 1998-2008 in California, for example, found no association at all between encephalitis and any childhood vaccine.
Further, there is a decreased risk of encephalitis among those vaccinated with MMR – because measles can cause encephalitis. Evidence shows that the incidence of one type of encephalitis, SSPE (subacute sclerosing panencephalitis) dropped sharply after the introduction of the MMR vaccine, and subsequent cases were mostly in the unvaccinated.
Conclusion
There is no clear evidence that vaccines increase the risk of encephalitis. In fact, they clearly decrease the risk of encephalitis caused by the infections they prevent. There is a net and very large advantage to being vaccinated in terms of encephalitis risk, even if we assume that cases of encephalitis occurring after vaccination were caused by the vaccination. We know statistically this cannot be true in all cases, and it is possible that it is true in no cases.
There is also sufficient evidence to show that vaccines do not cause autism. Further, encephalitis, while possibly causing brain injury, does not cause autism.
Despite all of these facts, some antivaccinationists continue to exploit individual cases of the NVIC compensating encephalitis as a table injury as an alleged admission that vaccines cause autism. Every link in this chain of argument is false.

Still No Association Between MMR and Autism
Steven Novella on April 22, 2015
Link


A new study published this week in JAMA, “Autism Occurrence by MMR Vaccine Status Among US Children With Older Siblings With and Without Autism”, puts one more nail in the claim that the MMR is associated with autism.
You may wonder why, after years and multiple studies showing no association between the measles-mumps-rubella vaccine (MMR) and autism spectrum disorder (ASD) there would even be a need for such a study. The authors explain:
Despite research showing no link between the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine and autism spectrum disorders (ASD), beliefs that the vaccine causes autism persist, leading to lower vaccination levels. Parents who already have a child with ASD may be especially wary of vaccinations.
The study is a retrospective cohort study involving 95,727 children with older siblings. They looked at whether or not the older sibling had a diagnosis of ASD, whether or not they were vaccinated with MMR, and whether or not they themselves developed ASD. They found:
MMR vaccination rates (≥1 dose) were 84% (n = 78 564) at age 2 years and 92% (n = 86 063) at age 5 years for children with unaffected older siblings, vs 73% (n = 1409) at age 2 years and 86% (n = 1660) at age 5 years for children with affected siblings. MMR vaccine receipt was not associated with an increased risk of ASD at any age. For children with older siblings with ASD, at age 2, the adjusted relative risk (RR) of ASD for 1 dose of MMR vaccine vs no vaccine was 0.76 (95% CI, 0.49-1.18;P = .22), and at age 5, the RR of ASD for 2 doses compared with no vaccine was 0.56 (95% CI, 0.31-1.01; P = .052). For children whose older siblings did not have ASD, at age 2, the adjusted RR of ASD for 1 dose was 0.91 (95% CI, 0.67-1.20; P = .50) and at age 5, the RR of ASD for 2 doses was 1.12 (95% CI, 0.78-1.59; P = .55).
Children with older siblings with ASD were less likely to be vaccinated, presumably because of parental fear of an association. The results clearly show, however, no association between the MMR vaccine and the risk of developing ASD, for children with or without an older sibling with ASD.
This study directly addresses the claim by some in the anti-vaccine movement that vaccines may trigger autism in susceptible individuals. This was little more than special pleading, however, after evidence showed no overall link between MMR and ASD.
In January 2015 a smaller case-control study looked at early MMR and thimerosal exposure among children with ASD and without and found no difference. (A cohort study, like the one above, looks at different groups and then assesses whether or not they develop a disease. A case-control study compares those with the disease to those without for some possible risk factor.)
A 2014 systematic review found:
There is strong evidence that MMR vaccine [sic] is not associated with autism.
Overall they found that serious side effects from the vaccine were extremely rare.
A separate 2014 systematic review and meta-analysis concluded:
Findings of this meta-analysis suggest that vaccinations are not associated with the development of autism or autism spectrum disorder. Furthermore, the components of the vaccines (thimerosal or mercury) or multiple vaccines (MMR) are not associated with the development of autism or autism spectrum disorder.
The evidence at this point is overwhelming – every way this data has been crunched the same answer emerges, there is no link between vaccines in general, thimerosal, or the MMR specifically, with autism or ASD.
While further study is not necessary, every study does increase our confidence significantly. However, we are beyond the point where, from a scientific point of view, spending further resources to ask and answer the same question is dubious at best. In fact, it can be considered a waste of limited research resources. This is not a small thing, as any researcher desperate for funding can tell you.
This is part of the damage of the anti-vaccine movement, and proponents of pseudoscience in general. Society is best served if our limited research resources are spent to maximal effect, improving the science and practice of medicine, and our understanding of science in general.
I think it can be reasonably argued that all research resources spent on “alternative” medicine, or chasing wild conspiracy theories or crank ideas, represent a massive inefficiency, slowing the rate of scientific progress. Such research is justified, as is the current study, by addressing popular opinion, rather than scientific plausibility or prior probability. “Popular” opinion often means a vocal minority.
I am not saying we should never do such research. Medicine is an applied science, and sometimes we need to provide research to address a public, rather than a scientific, concern. But it should be recognized that research is probably a fairly ineffective means of addressing such concerns. Anti-vaxxers are unlikely to be swayed by new evidence, just as conspiracy theorists are immune to evidence. Likewise, CAM proponents never abandon treatments because research shows they are ineffective (I have yet to see a counter-example, and have an open challenge to anyone who can point to one).
It seems to me that if we are going to spend limited resources to study a question in order to reassure a public concern, then we should endeavor to ascertain whether or not the concern is eased by the research. History indicates that it largely isn’t. One possible solution to this dilemma is to tie such research funding to specific regulatory measures.
For example, the government could fund research into CAM treatments, but only if those treatments are properly regulated, so that the research results can be implemented rather than ignored. Research into vaccine safety (above and beyond what is scientifically necessary) can be tied to laws removing vaccine exemptions if those vaccines are found to be safe.
In addition to having a regulatory environment in which the results of this research will actually be used, we should not rely on research as the only means of addressing public non-scientific beliefs and concerns. Improved education and outreach is another approach, which means that scientists and academic institutions need to get more proactive in managing public scientific literacy and understanding of specific issues, like vaccine safety.
Without proper regulation and outreach, research dollars into answered questions or unlikely treatments are thrown down a black hole and utterly wasted. Add this to the list the next time someone asks, “what’s the harm?” with regard to pseudoscience.

   Autism Onset and the Vaccine Schedule – Revisited
Steven Novella
Link
This week on Science-Based Medicine I wrote an article (The Early Course of Autism) about a new study looking at the onset of autism symptoms, showing that most children who will later be diagnosed with autism will show clear signs of autism at 12 months of age, but not 6 months. This is an interesting study that sheds light on the natural course of autism. I also discussed the implications of this study for the claim that autism is caused by vaccines.
Unfortunately, I made a statement that is simply wrong. I wrote:
Many children are diagnosed between the age of 2 and 3, during the height of the childhood vaccine schedule.
First, this was a vague statement – not quantitative, and was sloppily written, giving a different impression from the one I intended. I make these kinds of errors from time to time – that is one of the perils of daily blogging about technical topics, and posting blogs without editorial or peer-review. Most blog readers understand this, and typically I will simply clarify my prose or correct mistakes when they are pointed out.
However, since I often write about topics that interest dedicated ideologues who seek to sow anti-science and confusion, sometimes these errors open the door for the flame warriors. That is what happened in this case.
J.B. Handley, writing at Age of Autism, saw my error as a way to demonize me before his enthralled mobs – and he dives into his task with gusto – although without much care or attention to detail himself, as we will see. Handley also is clearly not interested in what the science actually says, only in grabbing a propaganda opportunity.
First, to clarify the facts, here is the childhood vaccine schedule from the CDC. As we can see, the majority of vaccines are given prior to the age of 2, many in fact at or before 12 months. While “height” is a vague term, it is certainly inaccurate in this case. Before I explore this issue further, however, let me address the other factual claim made in that statement.
I wrote that “many children are diagnosed between the ages of 2 and 3. About this statement Handley writes:
Firstly, the last time I checked, the average age of diagnosis for a child with autism was somewhere between 3-4 years of age, not 2-3.
In fact, the average age of diagnosis is 3.1 years (although to be fair other studies give the average at 3.6 – there is some regional variation). This is “somewhere between 3-4 years of age” but Handley’s point is still incorrect. I did not write that the average age was between 2 and 3 but that many children are diagnosed between 2 and 3, which is certainly true if the average age at diagnosis is 3.1. In his exuberance, Handley simply got this wrong.
I don’t expect him to make a correction, however. The last time he attacked me, he make a rather amateurish mistake, confusing incidence and prevalence, and used his error as the basis of his criticism. He never admitted or commented in any way on his gross error.
But onto the substance of his latest attack. The point that I was trying to make, which I did in fact clarify later in my post, is that when parents attempt to date the onset of their child’s autism they typically will date the onset later than the true onset. As we now know, from multiple studies, true clinical onset (biological onset is likely earlier) is between 6 and 12 months. Parents may not notice this onset until much later, and formal diagnosis is later still. This diagnosis happens within the childhood vaccination schedule, so it is likely that parents will have some recent vaccine to point to when looking for factors that seem to correlate with the onset of autism.
That was my point – a point that I and many others have made previously. By pushing earlier the true clinical onset of autism this study adds to evidence against the involvement of later vaccines. It is true that many vaccine are given in the first year of life, and of course this study by itself does not let all vaccines off the hook – nor did I say that it does.
But I did discuss one vaccine in particular – the MMR vaccine. MMR has received more attention than any other vaccine as a potential cause of autism, thanks to the now-discredited work of Andrew Wakefield. The first dose of MMR is given at a minimum of 12 months of age, with the second dose being given between 4 and 6 years. Certainly this study is relevant to the claim that MMR is a significant cause of autism
There is much evidence to support the conclusion that there is no correlation between MMR and autism. It should be obvious that this study is further evidence against a correlation. If most children with autism show signs by 12 months, then a vaccine which is not given prior to 12 months cannot be to blame. This was not obvious to Handley, however. He wrote:
In fact, between the ages of 2 and 3, children receive all of 2 vaccines, accounting for 5.5% of the vaccines they receive, while a full 70%, including MMR, come in their first 12 months of life, perfectly matching the time when this new study reported the beginning of a regression into autism!
Wrong, Handley. The MMR does not come “in their first 12 months of life.” At the very earliest it comes AT 12 months, which obviously cannot be responsible for symptoms that are present by 12 months. Maybe Handley was just sloppy in his choice of words (but it is odd that he went out of his way to mention MMR by name). Or maybe he is guilty of all the things of which he falsely accused me. This is certainly the same kind of error I made, although more specific. My error was inadvertent and I have readily admitted my mistake and am taking great pains to correct it. Let’s see how Handley responds when this error is pointed out to him.
The bottom line is that this study does in fact add to the body of evidence against an association between MMR and autism, because of the timing of the onset of autism.
Handley also takes exception to my point that parents may not accurately observe and remember when the onset of their child’s symptoms were. He makes one obvious point – that onset is not a moment in time but a process. I agree – but never implied otherwise. But even for diseases and disorders of insidious onset, there usually is a relatively brief period of time when the patient or family member really notices it – and that is when they date the onset.
I have the experience of actually seeing and diagnosing patients, reviewing their histories and comparing them to documented evidence in some cases. So I, like other experienced clinicians, understand this phenomenon well. For example, I see many patients with dementia, like Alzheimer’s disease, and they or their family will often date the onset of symptoms at a point in time some months prior to presentation, often anchored to a specific event (a phenomenon actually known as “anchoring”). But when I probe for specific details, it is apparent that there were signs of dementia for 1-2 years prior to the family’s dating of the onset. Or, I may have the benefit of a documented exam or history, clearly showing onset prior to the memory of those giving the history.
Handley seems naive to all of this, and rather he is content to grossly mischaracterize my point as calling parents “dumb,” which, of course, I never did. This is because Handley’s purpose, in my opinion, is not to meaningfully explore the evidence, but to demonize scientists and physicians with whom he disagrees. Read the comments to his blog and you will see that his attempts at demonizing me and others are quite successful in the echochamber of his followers. He wrote:
Further, this notion by Novella that we parents are “telescoping” is simply the ridiculous introduction of a new and confusing term to try and explain away the chorus of tens of thousands of parents all screaming the same thing about what happened to their kids.
The authors of this study itself applied the concept of “telescoping” or dating autism onset as more recent that it really was. I simply used their term, which they in turn took from the literature. It is a well-described concept, not invented by me or this study’s authors – people remember events in the past as being more recent than they actually were. For Handley’s purposes, however, he wants to characterize a well-known and scientifically established psychological phenomenon as being equivalent to calling people stupid, or spinning reality.
I also showed that this phenomenon is absolutely relevant to the question of vaccines and autism, using the Cedillo case as an example. The Cedillos believed that their child acquired autism after receiving the MMR vaccine. However, home movies reviewed in the court case brought before the Autism Omnibus shows signs of autism in the first year – prior to the first MMR vaccine.
Further, Handley is now trying to argue that this new study supports a correlation between vaccines and autism. In fact, it does nothing of the sort. It does all but eliminate MMR, varicella, and Hep A as having any potential role in autism, as these vaccines all come after the onset of autism in most cases. Handley, if he were being intellectually honest, should admit this, but he doesn’t, and very dishonestly implies that MMR specifically is still a potential cause.
Average age of diagnosis of autism is about 3.1 years of age, and when that was the best information we had to go on the anti-vax movement argued that this showed a correlation with vaccines. Then clinical studies showed that the diagnosis could be reliably made between age 2-3 years of age, but that’s OK, that still correlates with vaccines. Now we know the age of clinical onset is between 6 and 12 months, and Handley is saying this still correlates with the vaccine schedule.
Since the HepB is given at birth, and other vaccines at 1-3 months, moving the diagnosis of autism up even further would still correlate with some vaccines. Since Handley is willing to blame any vaccines, regardless of type (live virus or otherwise) and ingredients (thimerosal or not) no age of onset would disprove his cherished vaccine hypothesis.
There is also nothing about the vaccine hypothesis that led anyone in the anti-vaccine camp to predict that the true age of onset of autism is earlier than it is being diagnosed, and certainly not to within 6-12 months of age. So Handley is just retrofitting – declaring whatever evidence there is as supporting his position.
Finally, Handley pulls the “pharma shill” gambit on me as part of his smear campaign. He trots out an accusation he has made before, portraying my association with the ACSH as being sinister. As I have already explained, my association with the ACSH is limited to me agreeing to advise them on areas of my expertise. That’s it. I have, in fact, performed zero work for them. I have had no contact with them, other than them sending me their public material, and I have never received any kind of remuneration from ACSH. I have corrected Handley on this before, so I know that he knows what he is writing is wrong, and he has failed to correct his errors.
Further my associations with the pharmaceutical industry are minimal – a couple lectures and consultations for nominal fees years ago (and nothing ever to do with vaccines). I have never received a dime from any company to express an opinion on a scientific topic, or write a particular blog or article. I suppose that Handley believes my many hours of work producing podcasts and blogs and promoting science and skepticism is all an elaborate smokescreen for shilling for industry, all without receiving a dime for my efforts, which makes me the worst shill ever.
Actually, I don’t suppose that at all. Rather I think that Handley knows that what he is writing is pure BS, especially since I have called him on it before, and openly challenged him to produce a shred of evidence to support his false accusations. But Handley knows the narrative of the anti-vaccination movement – everyone who denies that vaccines are evil are themselves evil shills for even more evil industry.
Conclusion
In the end, all that matters is the science, which clearly shows that there is no association between vaccines and autism. This one study has minimal implications for an alleged connection, except that it clears the most often implicated vaccine – MMR. It also supports other evidence that the onset of autism is earlier than many parents observe and much earlier than formal diagnosis, which calls into question any casual observations about the timing of onset to any potential triggers.
In my first article on this topic I was sloppy in that one sentence about the vaccine schedule – an error I have now corrected. But that error did not affect the relevant points I made in the rest of the article, which I have also amplified here.
J.B. Handley thinks he has scored some points for his side by jumping on my error, but he has only shown himself, once again, to be a propagandist with no regard for science, accuracy, or even common decency.

Preventing autism? Not so fast, Dr. Mumper…
David Gorski on August 26, 2013
Link
Dug the Dog strikes again, as he did three weeks ago. I had a couple of ideas for a post this week, but none of them were time-sensitive or timely. Then, over the weekend, I saw a post on the antivaccine crank blog Age of Autism by Dan “Where are the Autistic Amish” Olmsted entitled Weekly Wrap: Another Medical Practice with a Sane Vaccine Schedule – and No Autism. Given the tendency towards a—shall we say?—lack of accuracy of Olmsted’s previous reporting, it’s no surprise that he’d latch on to this study. I’m also seeing it appear around other antivaccine websites. I had gotten wind of it late last week, a few of my readers having sent it to me but hadn’t decided yet whether to blog about it. Then it appeared on AoA. Thanks, Dan.
So let’s see how this study is being spun by the antivaccine movement:
When we at Age of Autism talk about ending the epidemic, the “to do” list seems almost overwhelming – funding a vax-unvaxed study, getting mercury out of flu shots, proving the HepB shot is nuts, wresting control of the agenda from pharma, fixing Vaccine Court (this time in the good sense of “fix”), establishing that biomedical treatments help kids recover, and on and on.
But there’s a shortcut to all this, and it goes straight through pediatricians’ offices. The evidence is growing that where a sane alternative to the CDC’s bloated vaccine schedule is offered, and other reasonable changes adopted, autism is either non-existent or so infrequent that it doesn’t constitute an epidemic at all.
The latest example comes from Lynchburg, Va., and the pediatric practice of Dr. Elizabeth Mumper. She noticed a frightening rise in autism in the 1990s. Concerned that vaccines and other medical interventions might be playing a role – concerned in other words that SHE was playing a role — Mumper changed course.
Fewer vaccines. Fewer antibiotics. No Tylenol. Breast-feeding. Probiotics. Good, pesticide free diets.
Since then, hundreds more children have been seen in her practice, Advocates For Children. But no more autism.
In essence, this study is being spun to imply that doing all of these things will eliminate autism, or at least dramatically decrease its prevalence.
You can see one thing just from this description that makes me doubt this study, and that’s something very simple: Changes in too many variables being tested at once. Even if Dr. Mumper’s study shows what she claims it shows (and what Dan Olmsted advertises it as showing), there’s no way of knowing which, if any, of these things was responsible for the changes observed. I could say this quite easily before I even read the study. Fortunately, all of you can read along, because Mumper’s study is available online for all. Or maybe unfortunately, because, as you might expect, it’s not a very good study. Its hypothesis is diffuse and unclear, and it’s based on dubious science. Its methodology isn’t so hot either. Let’s take each in turn.
First, though, I have to make a general observation about this paper. That general observation is that it’s very sloppily put together. One notices that there are only 52 references listed, even though citations number up to over 100 in the text. It really does look as though the reference list is incomplete or wrong, as just a brief perusal showed me citations that do not appear to relate to the text in which they are being cited. For instance, after a sentence mentioning fecal transplants, Mumper cites references 35 to 37, none of which has anything to do with fecal transplants. One paper is about the consolidation of memory in the amygdala, while the others are about neurocognition in schizophrenia and impaired inhibitory control in children with ASDs. That’s just one example. To me it looks as though the wrong reference list might have been printed, or that Mumper didn’t bother to make sure that the citation numbers match the references.
Mumper starts with standard “autism epidemic” exaggerations and misinformation, in which she states in the very first paragraph that during the time she has been a practicing pediatrician the prevalence of autism has increased from 1 in 5,000 in 1975 to as high as 1 in 50 in 2013. As we’ve pointed out here many times before, the increase in the reported prevalence of autism and autism spectrum disorders (ASDs) is almost certainly accounted for by three things: (1) the broadening of the diagnostic criteria for ASDs in the early 1990s; (2) diagnostic substitution, in which conditions that were formerly classified as something else are reclassified as an ASD; and (3) intensive screening programs. We’ve noted that recent studies examining adult cohorts for ASDs using current-day criteria have produced estimates of autism prevalence similar to what is being reported in children now (for example, this one). Not surprisingly, antivaccinationists don’t like these studies. They also don’t like it when I point out that screening for a medical condition—any medical condition—will result in an apparent increased prevalence of that condition, as previously subclinical and undiagnosed cases are discovered. My favorite example of this is ductal carcinoma in situ, a precancerous condition in the breast whose incidence and prevalence have skyrocketed, largely thanks to mammographic screening programs, which I explicitly compared to autism and ASD prevalence. The bottom line is that, although we can’t rule out a modest increase in the true prevalence of ASDs, there almost certainly is no “autism epidemic.” Worse, from the view of antivaccinationists, if there is no “autism epidemic,” then vaccines almost certainly can’t be a significant cause of or contributor to autism.
Mumper then goes on to cite several papers that are either dubious, don’t support the vaccine/”toxin” hypothesis, or are unrelated, starting with various papers that claim a correlation between ASD prevalence and airborne pollutants. I’ve discussed at least a couple of these papers before, such as this one looking at mercury emissions from coal-burning power plants and this one claiming a correlation between proximities to freeways and ASD prevalence. Virtually every one of these studies that I’ve ever read suffer from one of the same flaws: The ecological fallacy or inadequate controlling for major confounders, in particular urbanicity and access to services. Mumper also tries to link breastfeeding to decreased ASD prevalence, but even she has to admit that there’s no evidence. In any case, I don’t know any scientist or pediatrician who would argue that breastfeeding is in general not good for babies (quite the contrary); so I’m not sure why she has focused on breastfeeding. Actually, upon further thought, I rather suspect that I do know. She tries to relate breastfeeding to the almost certainly nonexistent entity known as autistic enterocolitis, presenting in Table I gut biopsy results from 21 children in her practice with autism and noted that 13 had evidence of lymphoid nodular hyperplasia. Of course, there would be significant selection bias here, as presumably only children with GI symptoms would undergo colonoscopy and ileal biopsies. (At least, I hope that’s the case; it’s not as though certain practitioners who practice “autism biomed” haven’t been known to be a little quick to biopsy autistic children for questionable indications.) Then it was a community pathologist who examined the specimens; we have no idea if he was skilled in pediatric GI pathology. As Wakefield has taught us (thanks to Brian Deer), it’s very easy to mistake normal lymphoid nodule development for inflammation.
Next up, Mumper cites studies suggesting that probiotics during pregnancy and infancy result in less irritable bowel disease, allergic rhinitis, asthma, and various other disorders. All of this might or might not hold up to further scrutiny, but it’s really not related to autism and ASDs. None of this stops Mumper from trying to relate these studies to ASDs through the “immunological actions” of probiotics. To say that this is speculation is to be kind. That’s what it is at best: Speculation. At worst, it’s completely unfounded speculation. And so it goes. Mumper goes on and on about nutritional factors that might or might not be related to ASDs, the use or overuse of antibiotics, the claim that acetaminophen might be related to ASDs when given after vaccination. It’s all terribly thin gruel upon which to build a study.
Then, of course, there’s the vaccine issue. In justifying looking at vaccines, Mumper cites the tired, old familiar litany of bad science and pseudoscience:
The CDC and AAP have issued statements that vaccines are not associated with the risk of autism and that there are epidemiologic studies suggesting no causal role.58-60 Under immunization as a result of parental perceptions of vaccine safety remains a primary concern of the American Academy of Pediatrics.61 As a result, primary care physicians are taught ways to address parents’ vaccine concerns, take opportunities to vaccinate, and use recall methods to catch patients up on vaccines.62 Despite having one of the most aggressive vaccination policies in the developed world, specifying 22 vaccine doses for a total of 12 diseases by 1 year of age,63 the United States had higher infant mortality rates in 2009 than 33 other nations.64
Notice that the numbering of all the references cited starts at 58. The reference list only goes up to 52. I know, I know. I’m repeating myself. But I had to keep looking at it again and again, because I couldn’t believe that such a blatant error was made and had to keep going back to look at the paper and its reference list. In any case, I couldn’t look up the references cited in the passage above. I could, however, guess at what reference 64 might have been. I bet it was this execrably bad study, or another by the same authors. Reading the next paragraph, I realize that it almost certainly was one of those horrible studies by Neil Z. Miller, because Mumper mentions his name:
In 2009, five of the 33 nations with the lowest infant mortality rates required 12 vaccine doses, the least amount, while the United States required the most vaccine doses. Using linear regression analysis of unweighted mean infant mortality rates, Miller calculated a statistically significant high correlation between increasing number of vaccine doses and increasing infant mortality rates (r = 0.992 p value 0.0009).64 Correlation does not equal causation. But since the United States spends more money per capita on medical care than the rest of the industrialized world,65 it seems prudent to examine all possible contributions to the relatively poor health of our most vulnerable citizens – children.
Yup, Miller’s cherry-picked data dredging is definitely one of Mumper’s citations.
But enough of the unconvincing rationale for this study, what, exactly, did Mumper do? Well, she basically describes her strategies for “preventing” autism in her practice, which include:
     1.  Minimizing environmental toxicant exposures. What this means, apparently, is “avoidance of pesticides and herbicides during pregnancy, feeding children and pregnant women a whole food diet that is as organic as possible, and using less toxic ‘green’ cleaning products in the home in hopes of preventing some cases of neurodevelopmental disorders and in the knowledge that it seems to be safe and reasonable anticipatory guidance for all children.” That’s all very nice, but based on little or no evidence.
     2.  Maximizing breastfeeding prevalence. Again, I’m not sure that any pediatrician would argue with trying to encourage breastfeeding.
     3.  Recommending probiotics. This is done, of course, based on the flimsiest of evidence.
     4.  Nutritional counseling. To Mumper this means “1) pre-natal vitamins containing folinic acid, ideally in the active form such as 5 methyl- tetrahydrofolate, 2) eating locally grown organic fruits, vegetables and protein as much as possible 3) avoiding processed foods, preservatives, monosodium glutamate, aspartame, nitrites and 4) avoiding mercury containing fish.” None of this is bad, although there’s no evidence that organic fruits and vegetables are of any higher nutritional value than regularly farmed produce. There’s also no good scientific evidence that any of this correlates with autism.
     5.  Antibiotic stewardship. No one is likely to argue that minimizing antibiotic exposure is a bad thing, but I’d also be concerned that Mumper doesn’t use antibiotics when they are actually indicated. Nor is there any good scientific evidence that antibiotic exposure has a causative or predisposing relationship with autism.
     6.  Minimizing use of acetaminophen. Again, few would argue that we should use lots of acetaminophen, but, again, there is no good evidence that use of acetaminophen correlates with autism/ASDs or its complications or comorbid conditions.
     7.  Allowing/implementing a modified vaccine schedule. Here’s the tropes come in. Dr. Mumper’s schedule is basically a variant of the delayed vaccination schedule based on the “too many too soon” trope. (See below.)
So, here’s the vaccine schedule advocated by Dr. Mumpers (click to embiggen):
Now, let’s compare Dr. Mumper’s schedule to the CDC-recommended vaccination schedule (click to embiggen):
Prominent differences between Dr. Mumper’s proposed schedule and the CDC-recommended schedule are that Dr. Mumper doesn’t give flu vaccines, the hepatitis A or B vaccines, or the rotavirus vaccine. The MMR vaccine is pushed back to age 2, and the varicella vaccine (chickenpox) is pushed back to age 5. My initial guess was that the only reason Dr. Mumper requires the varicella vaccine is because it’s required in Virginia to enter school. In fact, this whole vaccine schedule strikes me as being the bare minimum to meet the Virginia state requirements for vaccines required to enter school or day care.
So what’s the bottom line? Mumper basically selected these patients:
Patient SelectionInclusion criteria were: 1) all general pediatric patients born in 2005 or later; 2) presented for well child care prior to 2 months of birth and 3) followed until at least the age of 2 years and 2 months. Totally 294 patients qualified for the inclusion criteria and have been selected in the current research.
They were treated according to Dr. Mumper’s procedures listed above, and this is what Dr. Mumper found:
In the current research, there are no new cases of autism out of the 294 cases recognized and recorded, resulting in 0% prevalence of ASD. Based on the CDC background risk of autism of 1 in 50 for the cohort born around 2005 we would expect to have about 6 new cases of autism in our practice. We calculated our statistics using a Chi-squared test with 1 degree of freedom. Using the CDC autism rate of 1 in 50 reported in 2013 (but based on surveys of eight year old children), the expected rate for our 294 patients starting in 2005 would be 5.88 children with autism. Zero new cases of autism would occur by chance 1.4% of the time (p-value 0.014, significant at 0.05).
That’s it. That’s Mumper’s finding. That’s all there is to this paper. It’s a retrospective study with no control group that claims that she found no cases of ASDs in her practice since 2000 (but doesn’t have a patient number for the period between 2000 and 2005) and has found no new cases in the 294 patients followed in her practice from 2005 to 2013 from under two months of age at least to two years.
Just to check further into this, I took my handy dandy statistics program and played around with some numbers. Encouragingly (I suppose), when I ran a chi-squared test on Mumper’s numbers comparing them against a 1 in 50 prevalence reported earlier this year, I got a p-value of 0.0143. Of course, given that Dr. Mumper’s sample size is so small, it doesn’t take much for her “statistically significant” result to drop from statistical significance. For example, if I insert the autism prevalence of 1 in 88 from last year’s CDC study, the p-value jumps up to 0.071, no longer statistically significant. Given that last year’s study and this year’s study used different methodologies, it isn’t clear which figure is closer to the true prevalence of ASDs. Nor is the latest study evidence of an “autism epidemic,” but rather evidence that we are getting better at not missing any cases. In any case, playing around with different numbers, I found that the autism prevalence at large has to be at least 1 in 77 to make Dr. Mumper’s results statistically significant compared to the general prevalence of ASDs. I also found out that if she found just one case of ASD, the p-value would jump to 0.043, which would barely be statistically significant and is close to what Dr. Mumper reported in this case (0.042), which reassured me that I chose numbers for the control group similar or identical to what she chose. Two cases in Dr. Mumper’s practice would cause that p-value to skyrocket to 0.108.
Not surprisingly, Mumper reports that, after her paper was reviewed, one child was referred on suspicion of autism based on expressive language delay, but no diagnosis has been made. This brings up another issue (besides the fragility of her “results”). In a retrospective study like this, the control group has to be chosen to be as close as possible to the observation group, and Dr. Mumper just didn’t do this. The apparent prevalence of ASDs can depend on the availability of services (which is one reason why urban/suburban populations often appear to have more ASDs), screening, and socioeconomic factors. Dr. Mumper didn’t even attempt to compare the prevalence of ASDs in her practice to that of the surrounding area. For instance, in 2011, the prevalence of autism/ASD in Virginia was reported to be 0.8%. I realize that the more recent numbers are much higher and that the prevalence is increasing in Virginia, as it is for the rest of the country, but the latest figures that I could find for Virginia show a lower prevalence rate. The point is that we have no idea whether the number Dr. Mumper chose is a valid one to compare her practice to. That’s the problem with retrospective studies using existing prevalence as a control. They rarely tell us anything, particularly with such small numbers.
That is, of course, the very problem with small numbers. An N of 294 is way too small to make any hard and fast conclusions. Indeed, reading this paper I was amazed at how small the number was. An active pediatrician should have more than 37 new infant patients a year over nearly eight years. That’s less than one a week. Even if we take into account that all of these patients were seen before two months and followed at least until age 2 years, that’s still a small number for a pediatrics practice. One wonders how her practice can survive on those numbers. Be that as it may, what we have here is a dubious set of observations based on no clinical prior plausibility looking at a vaccine schedule that is based in no science and seems tailored to meet the minimum requirements of the Virginia school system’s vaccine requirements. On the other hand, given that Dr. Mumper appears to spend most of her effort treating children with developmental disorders with “autism biomed”, perhaps well baby visits are a small part of her practice. Then there’s the issue of the age range studied. The age range at which autism and ASDs are most commonly diagnosed is over the age of two; so how did Dr. Mumper assure that she captured all the diagnoses after age 2?
And did I mention that the center where these observations were made, the Rimland Center, appears to be, to my observations, a wretched hive of “autism biomed” quackery? Just take a look at its offerings: hyperbaric oxygen, reflexology, DAN! protocol treatments (that’s “Defeat Autism Now!” for those who aren’t familiar with “autism biomed”), gluten-free, casein-free, special carbohydrate diets, and more. All of this is consistent with the DAN! protocol, which includes pretty much every form of autism quackery known to quacks under its rubric, including chelation therapy, hyperbaric oxygen, and a wide variety of other quackery, such as Bioset supplementation, and Diflucan to “get the yeast out.” It’s no wonder that I’ve described “biomed” treatments like the DAN! protocol as uncontrolled and unethical experimentation on autistic children. It’s not for nothing that autism biomed has been referred to as an “autism cult.”
Finally, there’s Dr. Mumper herself. It’s not surprising that such a bad study would come from Dr. Mumper, as she is a vaccine-autism true believer to the point that she is cited in Whale.to and has presented at the yearly antivaccine quackfest Autism One and, most recently, at the 2013 Biomedical Conference. Also of note, Dr. Mumper has had her testimony dismantled in front of the Vaccine Court as one of the expert witnesses for the plaintiffs in the Autism Omnibus hearings.
In the end, Dr. Mumper’s study tells us a whole lot of nothing. Certainly, it is no evidence that doing what Dr. Mumper advocates doing has any effect whatsoever on the risk of developing autism in infants. The study will, however, be trotted out (as it has already been) as “evidence” that if we’d only decrease the number of vaccines, encourage breastfeeding more, decrease antibiotic usage and indulge in various unscientific interventions, we could virtually eliminate autism. It is evidence of nothing of the sort. Amusingly, however, this study is unlikely to be embraced by the hard core antivaccinationists. Why? Because even the decreased number of vaccines in Dr. Mumper’s proposed vaccine schedule are too many vaccines. (Just look at some of the amusing and depressing antivaccine comments after Dan Olmsted’s post.) To such antivaccinationists, one vaccine is one vaccine too many.

Antivaccine activists fund a study to show vaccines cause autism. It backfires spectacularly.
David Gorski on October 5, 2015
Link


Having written about pseudoscience and quackery continuously for over a decade and having engaged in conversations about it online for over 15 years, I’ve come to recognize a number of traits that are virtually the sine qua non of quacks and pseudoscientists and their believers. Obviously, one of them is a severe case of the Dunning-Kruger effect, a tendency of those with low expertise in a topic to overestimate their expertise and express far more confidence in their conclusions than warranted while those with high expertise know enough to know how much they don’t know about a topic and thus tend to express more uncertainty and caveats. Basically, the Dunning-Kruger effect describes how unskilled individuals express an illusory superiority, mistakenly believing their knowledge, competence, and ability to be much higher than it really is.
As a result of the Dunning-Kruger effect, coupled with other cognitive shortcomings suffered by all human beings (but seemingly amplified in believers in quackery and pseudoscience) that lead them to believe in pseudoscience, such as confusing correlation with causation, motivated reasoning, and the like, believers in pseudoscience are often so absolutely rock-solid in their beliefs that they are virtually impossible to reason with. It is incredibly difficult to change their minds, and disconfirming evidence often causes them to dig in all the more deeply to defend their beliefs. Not uncommonly, this leads them to commission studies designed to support their beliefs. But what happens when such a study does not actually support their belief? What happens when such a study backfires spectacularly and not only fails to support their belief, but emphatically so? Skeptics were re-treated to just such a spectacle last week when SafeMinds and other antivaccinationists were burned by a study they funded (subscription required):
Between 2003 and 2013, SafeMinds provided scientists from the University of Texas Southwestern School of Medicine, the University of Washington, the Johnson Center for Child Health & Development and other research institutions with approximately $250,000 to conduct a long-term investigation evaluating behavioral and brain changes of baby rhesus macaques that were administered a standard course of childhood vaccines. (The National Autism Association, another organization that has questioned vaccine safety, also provided financial support for this research.) The latest paper in the multiyear project was published Monday in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS). In it, the researchers concluded that vaccines did not cause any brain or behavioral changes in the primates.
Astute readers will recognize that I’ve written about similar papers before reporting that pediatric vaccines cause changes in behavior and/or brain structure in macaque monkeys. Specifically, way back in 2008, I noted the initial report of this ongoing study, first when preliminary results were reported as a poster presentation and then later another publication from the same group published in 2009. Steve Novella and a certain well-known friend of the blog have also described how poor experiments published from these studies in 2010 were, the latter of whom cited several other major criticisms of the study, not the least of which was some reporting of changes in the size of a part of the brain known as the amygdala that were…hard to believe. There were also a lot of issues with the control group chosen.
Basically, these abstracts and papers reported the results of an ongoing study looking at infant vaccines in macaque monkeys to see if there was an effect on socialization or changes in brain anatomy, the key hypothesis seeming to be that thimerosal-containing vaccines cause autism. (The investigators even added thimerosal to some of the vaccines because they weren’t being made with thimerosal anymore!) You can read the links I cited just now if you want the gory details; suffice to say that these were not good studies and not particularly good evidence that vaccines cause autism, as shown by the fact that homeopaths loved the study, and ultimately the paper examining hepatitis B specifically was withdrawn. Yet these reports were flogged for quite a while by the antivaccine movement as proof positive primate data that vaccines are Evil.
Fast forward to 2015. Now we have a much larger, much better study. It’s even by the same people. And guess what? It’s as negative as negative can be. No wonder SafeMinds and other antivaccinationists are unhappy. Let’s take a look.
Three dozen dead monkeys later, vaccines still don’t cause autism
One of the limitations constraining those of us who do human subjects research is that ethical considerations often prevent us from designing our clinical trials in what would be, from a strictly scientific standpoint that ignores all other considerations, in the most methodologically rigorous way. For example, we can’t intentionally infect human beings with known inocula of deadly bacteria in order to cause a reproducible severity of disease to be treated with a new antibiotic. Also, leaving aside that such a study would be impractical from a purely practical standpoint given that it would take decades, we can’t ethically do a randomized, controlled study of smoking versus no smoking and then assess differences in the incidence of heart disease, lung cancer. Yet, from epidemiological studies, we do know that tobacco smoke does cause lung cancer, heart disease, chronic lung disease, and other cancers.
Similarly, from an ethical standpoint we can’t do a randomized, controlled clinical trial of a “vaxed versus unvaxed” group because it would leave the control group of children unprotected against vaccine-preventable diseases. There would be no clinical equipoise. Some antivaccinationists have begun to accept this reality—grudgingly—and started to propose epidemiological “vaxed-unvaxed” studies, of course without realizing how difficult it would be to control for confounders and how many subjects would be needed. (Hint: More unvaccinated children than probably exist in the US.)
One way to try to get answers when you can’t use humans is to use animals. Indeed, that is traditionally how drug and toxicity studies have been done. However, this approach has problems as well, because, depending on the animal model and the disease, the relevance of such experiments can be questioned. One way to try to maximize the relevance to human physiology is to use nonhuman primates, but such experiments are incredibly expensive to do and must be held to very high ethical standards given how human-like they are.
Here’s where the monkey study by Gadad et al. in PNAS, that has so riled antivaccinationists, comes in. Entitled “Administration of thimerosal-containing vaccines to infant rhesus macaques does not result in autism-like behavior or neuropathology“, it examines the effect of the infant vaccine schedule on macaque monkeys. Oddly enough, Laura Hewitson is one of the authors. Remember that Hewitson was a key player in doing the previous awful studies, one of which listed Andrew Wakefield as a co-author. She is now the Research Director of the Johnson Center for Child Health and Development, which is what Andrew Wakefield’s old quack clinic, the Thoughtful House Center for Children, became after he was given the boot by its board of directors in the aftermath of his losing his UK medical license and seeing his 1998 Lancet paper implicating the MMR vaccine retracted. Her history and current position just make the results of this study even more delicious.
Unfortunately, part of the justification for the current study were the previous monkey studies that purported to show a link between vaccines and neurodevelopmental disorders. Indeed, so bad were those previous studies that personally I consider this study to be highly unethical, given that there is no compelling evidence to justify subjecting 79 macaque monkeys to a bunch of injections and killing 36 of them to dissect their brains, all in the service of testing the long discredited hypothesis that vaccines cause autism or other neurodevelopmental disorders. The University of Washington IACUC, which approved this study, should be ashamed of itself. Ethically, the study is a travesty. It was also a waste of a lot of money, again, because this question did not need to be studied yet again. Despite the lack of a compelling scientific rationale for the study, it was nonetheless done, and done competently; so we have to consider its results which—surprise! surprise!—were completely negative. Let’s take a look at the details.
The design was quite simple. There were 79 infant macaque monkeys subjected to six different vaccination schedules: (i) Control (n = 16), in which animals received saline injections in place of vaccines; (ii) 1990s Pediatric schedule (n = 12), in which animals received vaccines following the pediatric schedule recommended in the 1990s; (iii) 1990s Primate (n = 12), in which animals received vaccines recommended in the 1990s but on an accelerated schedule; (iv) thimerosal-containing vaccines (TCV, n = 12), in which animals received all TCVs but no MMR vaccines following the accelerated schedule; (v) MMR (n = 15), in which animals only received the MMR vaccine but no TCVs following the accelerated schedule; and (vi) 2008 (n = 12), in which animals received vaccines recommended in 2008 but on an accelerated schedule. Infants were assigned to a peer group of four animals, with multiple study groups being tested each year for neurodevelopmental outcomes.
The investigators then assessed social behavior, with testing being carried out by a social tester blinded to the experimental group. The testers were well-trained and experienced; they were also tested for reliability and used standard testing methods:
Infants underwent testing as follows: from birth to 20 d, infants were assessed for the development of neonatal reflexes and perceptual and motor skills; from postnatal day 14 to ∼3.5 mo of age, infants were examined for the development of OCP; from ∼3 to 6 mo of age, animals underwent discrimination learning assessments; from ∼5 to 8 mo of age, animals were assessed for learning set development; and from 30 d to 12 mo of age, animals underwent assessments of behavior before group living. These developmentally appropriate tests are measures of neurodevelopment, learning, cognitive abilities, and social behavior in young macaques (45). At ∼13 mo of age, animals were transferred to juvenile caging where they were group housed (n = 4 males per group) with animals from within their peer group for the duration of the study. All subsequent behavioral data were collected while animals were in their home cage.
Behaviors were defined as passive, exploring, playing, sex, aggression, withdrawal, fear-disturbed, rock-huddle-stop-clasp (strong clasping/grasping of another monkey without play behavior, or self-clasping with arms, legs, hands, or feet, without locomotion and no active inspection of own or other’s body), and stereotypy (repetitive body movements, with or without locomotion, requiring three or more consecutive, repetitive movements). It might be a cliché, but there were no statistically significant differences detected in any of the behaviors measured in any of the experimental groups.
Then, at the conclusion of the experiment, brains from monkeys in the control (N=12), 1990s (N=12), and 2008 groups (N=8) were sectioned for histological and immunohistological examination. The authors examined the brains for neuropathology in parts of the brain previously shown in humans to have changes in autism: the cerebellum, hippocampus, and amygdala. Try as they might to find differences, Gadad et al. failed to find any differences between controls and either of the two vaccinated groups examined. There were no changes in the neurons in these regions. There were no changes in protein levels. Basically, there were no differences from control in the two experimental groups in the volume of the cerebellar hemispheres, the number or density of Purkinje cells in the cerebellum. There was no difference in the size of the Purkinje cells. Western blots (a means of detecting proteins with antibodies) failed to find differences in certain Purkinje-cell associated proteins calbindin, GAD-67, and proteins that are markers for different cell types, such as Iba1 (a microglial marker) and GFAP (astrocyte marker). Again, these were all negative. Gadad et al. measured these proteins up, down, right, left, and sideways (so to speak), but failed to find any differences.
Why, you might ask, didn’t Gadad et al examine the brains from the monkeys in the other experimental groups? The authors justify this decision thusly:
The neuroanatomical analyses were first performed in brains from the 1990s Primate and 2008 groups, as animals in these groups received the highest amount of EtHg exposure (1990s Primate) or the most extensive vaccine exposure (2008). Because no neuronal differences were found in either of these vaccine groups compared with the control group, no additional vaccine groups were fully studied.
This is a reasonable compromise to keep the number of monkeys euthanized as low as possible. If the groups that received the most extensive thimerosal exposure and the highest vaccine exposure showed no detectable differences in brain structure in regions relevant to autism pathophysiology, then there really isn’t a good reason to kill the rest of the monkeys to look at their brains. Even with that compromise, 36 monkeys paid for this information with their lives (16 control + 12-1990s schedule, and 8-2008 schedule) and brains while the rest received at least unnecessary injections and other interventions. Basically, this study’s results are inconsistent with the three main “hypotheses”—though after all the disconfirming data calling them “hypotheses” really is doing them too much honor—that thimerosal-containing vaccines, MMR vaccines, or “too many [vaccines] too soon” cause autism. Each hypothesis is represented by an experimental group.
It’s utterly ironic that so many antivaccinationists funded this study, as noted in the acknowledgements:
We thank the following for their generous financial support: The Ted Lindsay Foundation, SafeMinds, National Autism Association, and the Johnson and Vernick families. This work was also supported by WaNPRC Core Grant RR00166 and CHDD Core Grant HD02274.
It’s depressing to see that the Washington National Primate Research Center, the Center on Human Development and Disability, and the University of Washington contributed wasted funds to this unethical study.
SafeMinds is, of course, highly antivaccine. It’s particularly amusing to see SafeMinds get burned funding a study to show that vaccines cause autism when they’ve been burned before for being involved with such a study. I’m referring, of course, to the study published in 2007 in the New England Journal of Medicine by Thompson et al. (yes, that William Thompson) that failed to find a correlation between thimerosal-containing vaccines and neurodevelopmental disorders. As you might recall, Sallie Bernard of SafeMinds was on the advisory committee for the study. Why invite an antivaccine activist to be on such a committee? I don’t know. Perhaps the misguided idea that you should keep your friends close and your enemies closer. (That didn’t work out so well for Jon Snow.) Be that as it may, when Thompson et al. didn’t show what SafeMinds and antivaccinationists wanted it to show, she immediately pulled criticisms out of her nether regions to try to discredit it, to be followed by other antivaccine groups.
Here we go again, same as it ever was.
Antivaccinationists respond
So how did antivaccine activists react to the study they had helped fund? Did they accept the results and start to wonder whether they might have to start rethinking their previous views about vaccines and autism? (That’s what real scientists and those who are science-based in their outlook would do.) Come on, this is SafeMinds we’re talking about! Of course it did nothing of the sort! Predictably, SafeMinds did exactly what it did in 2007 when Thompson et al. didn’t turn out the way it had hoped going in. It immediately went on the attack:
SafeMinds, the nonprofit that funded the research, is not happy with the results. Representatives from the group say the findings contradict both an earlier pilot study and interim progress reports the organization received from the researchers.
Naturally, no such attack would be complete without insinuations of scientific fraud:
SafeMinds also believes that the research team behind the new PNAS study may have cherry-picked their data. SafeMinds Director Lyn Redwood, a registered nurse, says she received an email in 2013 from the researchers reporting a “statistically significant” 11 percent reduction in certain types of hippocampal cells in the vaccine groups. But she says the authors did not include these findings in the new paper.
Redwood, of course, is not a scientist, and it shows. Many are the times that preliminary analyses in a scientific study look as though they will find a positive result. Many are the times that the positive result disappears as more and more of the subjects are analyzed and more measurements completed. Many are the times that scientists have been disappointed because of this phenomenon, so tantalized by a seemingly positive result only to see it disappear. Redwood seems not to understand this; she seems not to understand that a two year old progress report describing promising preliminary analyses does not matter one whit if those preliminary analyses didn’t pan out. In this case they didn’t. Laura Hewitson, who by working with Andrew Wakefield on one of the preliminary studies used to justify this study showed that at that time she was very much leaning antivaccine, appears to have pulled back from the pseudoscience and become much more scientific. She even tries to school Redwood in the very point I just made:
Dr. Laura Hewitson, director of research for the Johnson Center for Child Health & Development, an adjunct associate professor in the Department of Psychiatry at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, a lead researcher on project and co-author on all four papers, says that at the time that email was sent, it was also made clear to SafeMinds “that the data should be treated as preliminary until all of the animals had completed the study.” She added that none of the study’s procedures changed once her team moved from the pilot program to a larger sample.
And to explain to Redwood basic things like blinding to experimental group so important in studies where humans are making measurements:
She added that all of the researchers, technicians and behaviorists involved in collection and analysis of data did not know which of the monkeys were in the vaccine groups or the control group. The researchers also implemented a “chain of custody” protocol once the data were collected, in which they reviewed chronological documentation that shows the control, transfer and analysis of all data sets. Hewitson says that her team used an independent statistical consultant for all data analysis, and that two additional outside investigators from two other academic institutions confirmed their findings.
“As you can see, we have done everything possible to ensure the integrity of the data. My co-authors and I stand by our published findings,” she says. “The comprehensive nature of the current study underscores why the findings from the pilot study should be interpreted with an abundance of caution, given the small number of animals included.”
One notes that this is much more rigorous than the protocols used in the pilot studies. I (and others) have previously pointed out that pilot studies are often positive, but those positives are usually due to small numbers of subjects and less rigorous methodologies, and tend to disappear with larger, more rigorous studies. This is exactly what happens with acupuncture and homeopathy studies; it is what appears to have happened with this study.
Elsewhere, antivaccinationists have taken to Twitter to claim things like:
@EMcCra2 @doritmi more on methodology. Apparently weight for the monkeys was averaged, based on an assumed 6.3:1 ratio, and thus dosing was
— Master Muppet ™ (@rblotnicky) October 3, 2015
@EMcCra2 @doritmi lowered 6.3 times from the 1990shot. Also didn’t take into account differences in human birth weight. The study assumed
— Master Muppet ™ (@rblotnicky) October 3, 2015
@EMcCra2 @doritmi all human infants that provided the 6.3:1 difference were born on time, at same weight, w/ zero genetic factors considered
— Master Muppet ™ (@rblotnicky) October 3, 2015
This is, of course, an utterly ridiculous objection when you read the supplemental data and methods section in the paper, which lays out in considerably detail exactly how doses were adjusted for the monkeys:
EtHg [thimerosal] content of primate vaccines was determined by first averaging the weight ratios for human infant boys: male infant primates across the six time points of vaccine administration. The average weight ratio was 6.3:1. The EtHg content in each pediatric vaccine was then divided by 6.3 to determine the dosing of EtHg for each primate vaccine. This method provided a similar dosing of μg EtHg/kg body weight for infant boys and primates.
Included is a table of the vaccine schedule that describes how the dosing was determined. It lists the weight ratio between human baby boys and infant macaques at the different time points where vaccines are administered. This ranges from 4.5 to 7.5, meaning that human infants weigh from 4.5 to 7.5 times what infant macaques weigh at the same time point. So basically at some ages, the macaques received somewhat more thimerosal than human babies on a per weight basis, while at other ages they received less. Since at no time is the difference more than 29% and given that the very idea behind the mercury militia’s belief that thimerosal causes autism is that the thimerosal content far surpasses the toxic threshold, it’s unlikely that averaging would have had any significant effect. Finally, given that no one has shown any genetic risk factors for vaccine injury leading to autism (mainly because vaccines do not cause autism), how could the investigators possibly know how to consider genetic risk factors in this study? They can’t. If they had found differences in neurodevelopmental correlates in one of the vaccinated groups, that would have been a topic for another study.
A particularly amusing response comes from Sallie Bernard of SafeMinds, who can’t seem to restrain herself from attacking science that SafeMinds was involved in when it doesn’t show what she thinks it should show:
But Sallie Bernard, president of SafeMinds, says she would at least like to see a re-analysis of the newest data. “We feel that embedded within these data sets there are animals that have potentially an adverse reaction to this vaccine schedule that would mirror what happens in human infants,” she says. “The majority who get vaccines are fine, but we believe there is a subset that have an adverse reaction to their vaccines. By looking at the raw data, not data in aggregate, we may be able to identify the subgroup that had that reaction.”
Ironically, one of the complaints that I’ve heard about the study from antivaccinationists is that the numbers are too small. If that were true, then doing subset analysis is a fool’s errand, because if the number of subjects in the experimental groups was too small to detect a statistically significant difference in the overall groups, it’s almost certainly too small to detect anything meaningful in subgroup analyses. Be that as it may, it is a general principle in doing studies of this type, either animal experiments or human clinical trials, that subgroup analyses, unless they are pre-specified in the protocol, is far more likely to mislead than illuminate. Indeed, whenever I see clinical trials in which post hoc subgroup analyses are done, I know it’s a (likely) futile attempt to salvage a positive result out of a negative study. That’s exactly what Sallie Bernard wants to do here. It’s also hilarious, in light of her accusation against the researchers of “cherry picking data,” that cherry picking data from the raw data set is exactly what Bernard is proposing here, although she’s certainly too scientifically ignorant to realize it.
As for a “reanalysis” of the monkey data, I’m sure Brian Hooker is salivating at the opportunity, given what he did with previous vaccine trial data.
Why do scientists keep doing these unethical, wasteful studies?
One of the arguments for studying the question of whether vaccines cause autism over and over and over again is that enough negative studies will ultimately convince antivaccine parents that vaccines are not dangerous and do not cause autism. I’ve argued again and again that such is not the case. This is yet another example demonstrating just that.
Dr. Paul Offit, after listing all the studies that have failed to find a correlation between vaccines and autism, alluded to a similar same concern in an accompanying editorial, although he was nowhere near as blunt as I have been because, well, that’s the way he rolls. Characteristically, he refrained from calling this macaque study unethical and a waste of money and tried to find something good about this waste of money and primates:
One could reasonably wonder whether it is necessary to continue to spend more money chasing this fruitless, dead-end hypothesis. However, the constant drumbeat of negative studies has made a difference. Unlike 10 y ago, the media no longer covers the vaccine– autism controversy by telling both sides of the story when only one side is supported by the science; for the most part, they have chosen perspective over false balance. Legislators are also stepping up; both California and Vermont recently eliminated their philosophical exemptions to vaccination.
I will admit that Dr. Offit has a point, nor am I in any way arguing that there isn’t value in negative studies. No one, least of all I, would dispute that negative studies can be very useful. As useful as such studies can be when evaluating issues like whether vaccines cause autism, a question—and reasonable scientists can disagree over the answer to this question is—remains: At what point can we say that enough is enough, that the question being studied has been settled to a sufficient degree of certainty that it is no longer worth spending large sums of money on and killing three dozen intelligent primates to ask and answer the question yet again? An animal study like this might be considerably less expensive and complex than large epidemiological studies, but it’s still an animal study. Human epidemiological studies, on the other hand, are much more expensive and require controlling for confounders that don’t need to be controlled for in the highly controlled world of animal studies.
Sadly, I must disagree with Dr. Offit here. The relentless drumbeat of negative studies about vaccines and autism has probably played much less of a role in how the press has changed its tune in the way it covers vaccine-autism pseudoscience to a far less credulous one than Dr. Offit credits it with. In fact, as much as it pains me to do so, I argue that this turnabout has far more to do with the recent discrediting of the chief architect of the MMR-autism scare, Andrew Wakefield. As much as I really, really wish it were the science alone that finally turned the tide and persuaded reporters and much of the general public that vaccines do not cause autism, I really do believe that was less of a factor than Wakefield’s utter disgrace and discrediting. From my perspective, seeing Wakefield lose his medical license, be dismissed as the medical director of the quack clinic he used to run in Texas, have his Lancet paper that launched the MMR scare retracted, and be shown to have been a scientific fraud practicing what Brian Deer so aptly called “Piltdown medicine” probably played a far greater role in changing public perception. Add to that the string of outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases that culminated in the Disneyland measles outbreak early this year. These things, more than anything else, were likely what shifted public opinion. That’s why it’s my opinion that, barring new compelling evidence that demands that we study the question further, studies such as this one are unnecessary.
In the abstract, studies like this one do have value—to a point. Given the evidence we have and what we already know about the relationship between vaccines and autism (namely that there isn’t one), however, I really have to question the very necessity for such a study. Sure, it shows what every other well-designed study asking whether vaccines, be they thimerosal-containing or not, are associated with autism, but surely the investigators should have known before they started that that’s what it would show. Worse, it’s changed no minds among antivaccine activists. They dismiss it as an animal experiment and continue to call for either an experiment even more unethical than this one (a randomized trial of “vaxed versus unvaxed”) or an epidemiological study of “vaxed versus unvaxed” children that they can dismiss because it’s an epidemiological study prone to all of the confounders that epidemiological studies are prone to.
This brings us back to how I started this post. One of the arguments for studies like this is that negative studies will change minds. They will not. They might give some reassurance to parents who were already open to being reassured about vaccines, but they have zero effect on people like Sallie Bernard and Lyn Redwood. They are true believers, and if a study is negative, even one that they funded, it must be because there was incompetence or scientific fraud. It can’t possibly be because vaccines don’t cause autism.
At least I can hope that after this study no more primates need die in the service of a dead, discredited hypothesis. A bigger challenge will be preventing children from dying because belief in this discredited hypothesis leads parents to not vaccinate their children against deadly diseases.

   The perils and pitfalls of doing a “vaccinated versus unvaccinated” study
David Gorski
Link
The anti-vaccine movement is nothing if not plastic. It “evolves” very rapidly in response to selective pressures applied to it in the form of science refuting its key beliefs. For instance, when multiple studies looking at the MMR vaccine and autism failed to confirm the myth that the MMR causes autism or “autistic enterocolitis,” most recently late last year, it was not a problem to the anti-vaccine movement. Neither was it a major problem to the movement when multiple studies similarly failed to find a link between mercury in the preservative thimerosal that used to be in most childhood vaccines and is no more (except the flu vaccine) and autism. No problem! Andrew Wakefield is alleged, based on strong evidence, to have falsified his data alleging a link between the MMR vaccine and “autistic enterocolitis”? Fuggedabouddit! The anti-vaccine movement simply pivoted neatly, de-emphasized points that the evidence was so clearly against that even they couldn’t spin it to a positive anymore, and found new bogeymen. These days, it’s the “toxins” (such as formaldehyde and the latest antivax bogeyman, squalene), and “too many too soon” (a gambit given seeming respectability by Dr. Bob Sears and Dr. Jay Gordon, apologists for and supplicants to the anti-vaccine movement both.
However, there is one trait of the anti-vaccine movement that, however its camouflaging plumage may evolve, never, ever changes. It is as immutable as believers say that God is. That trait is that, whatever other claims, the anti-vaccine movement makes, at its core it is always about the vaccines. Always. No matter how often science fails to find a link between vaccines and autism or vaccines and whatever other horreur du jour the anti-vaccine movement tries to pin on vaccines, no matter how many studies do not support the viewpoint that vaccines cause autism, no matter how much the anti-vaccine movement tries to deny and obfuscate by saying that it is not “anti-vaccine” but rather “pro-safe vaccine,” at its core the anti-vaccine movement is about fear and loathing of vaccines. Always. When inconvenient science doesn’t support their views, anti-vaccine activists either ignore the science, distort the science, or launch ad hominems against the people doing the science or citing the science. And, as I said before, the claims of the anti-vaccine movement evolve. Never again will the anti-vaccine movement make the horrific mistake of yoking itself to a hypothesis that is as easily testable as the hypothesis that mercury in vaccines causes autism. The claim that mercury in vaccines causes autism predicted that, if thimerosal were removed from vaccines or reduced to pre-”epidemic levels” of the early 1990s, then autism rates should plummet. Thimerosal was removed from nearly all childhood vaccines (the sole exception being some flu vaccines), reducing infant mercury exposure from vaccines to levels not seen since the 1980s; yet autism rates continue to rise. This is about as resounding a refutation of the hypothesis that mercury in vaccines is a major cause or contributor to autism that even the anti-vaccine movement has backed away from the pure claim, which has now evolved to unnamed “environmental toxins,” either in concert with mercury or with other nasty things, as being the Real One True Cause of Autism.
It’s evolution in action. These new claims are much “fitter” because they are much harder to falsify through scientific research, epidemiology, and clinical trials.
To understand the persistence of the myth that vaccines cause autism, we must consider the myth underlying it, namely the myth of the “autism epidemic.” It is certainly true that the number of autism diagnoses has been increasing at a seemingly inexorable rate ever since the early 1990s. At around the same time, multiple new vaccines were introduced to the schedule. Also around the same time (namely 1994), the diagnostic criteria for autism and autism spectrum disorders were greatly broadened. Also, throughout the 1990s and the 2000s, more resources were invested in screening children for autism. As is the case with other conditions or diseases, the more you screen for something the more you will find, often the less severe cases that would have been missed otherwise. In any case, a combination of diagnostic substitution, increased awareness, increased screening, and increased support services that brought revenue to school districts to help autistic children account for the vast majority, if not all, of the increase in autism prevalence over the last 20 years or so. As Joseph puts it:
Nevertheless, it appears that when ASD is screened thoroughly in a population, or when there’s a lot of awareness and good ascertainment, prevalence is found to be closer to 1%. This is not new. The following is what Lorna Wing and David Potter said on the subject as early as 1999.
Indeed, recent NCSH data do not show any evidence of an “autism epidemic.”
However, the key to the myth that vaccines cause autism is the observation that autism prevalence has increased rapidly since the early 1990s, and that was around the same time when the vaccination schedule was expanded to include more vaccines. Of course, as I’ve pointed out before, this is a classic case of confusing correlation with causation, and, as I’ve also pointed out before, one could point to a number of other things that happened in the 1990s that correlate with increased autism diagnoses. For example, the first easy-to-use web browsers were first introduced in the early 1990s, leading to an astonishingly rapid growth of Internet use outside of universities and work environments. Using the same sort of logic as anti-vaccinationists use, we could just as easily blame the Internet for the “autism epidemic”! In any case, thanks to the human tendency to confuse correlation with causation and desire to have an explanation for anything we consider scary, the myth that vaccines cause autism persists among even highly intelligent people who should know better. Indeed, one person at a recent skeptical meeting I attended was clearly very suspicious of vaccines and not so clearly reassured by what fellow SBM blogger Peter Lipson and I explained. Consistent with the persistence of this myth, refutations of the contention that vaccines cause autism are usually either met with denial or the classic false dichotomy, “Well, if vaccines don’t cause autism, what is causing this huge increase in autism?” as if vaccines were the only plausible option.
Thus, I think, was born the “too many too soon” gambit, in which the anti-vaccine movement, so wedded to the idea that vaccines must cause autism, have latched onto the idea that somehow it’s the “overvaccination” or “too many vaccines.” According to this idea, somehow excessive “immune stimulation” or injection of “toxins” that is leading to and “epidemic” of autism, asthma, and a huge variety of other ailments and conditions.
This “too many too soon” chant has lead to a demand by the anti-vaccine movement that the government conduct a large study of “unvaccinated” versus the “vaccinated” children to compare them for health outcomes and, especially, the prevalence of autism. The expectation, of course, on the part of the anti-vaccine movement is that such a study would show that unvaccinated children are far healthier and don’t suffer from nearly the same rate of autism. I don’t think that people like J.B. Handley realize how risky their gambit is. Such a study would have a very high risk of torpedoing virtually everything the anti-vaccine movement has been working toward in terms of promoting their message of fear about vaccines as being somehow credible (or at least not unreasonable) and based on science (more on that later).
None of these concerns has stopped the drones over at the happy home for anti-vaccine propagandists (Age of Autism) from busily promoting the idea of a “vaxed versus unvaxed” study and, as is their M.O. for any critics, harshly disparaging anyone who dares to point out the difficulties and lack of scientific rationale for such a study, the latest target being Tom Insel of the Interagency Autism Coordinating Committee (IACC), who recently testified in front of Senator Tom Harkin’s comittee (yes, that Tom Harkin).
The misunderstanding and misrepresentation of epidemiology being trotted out to justify this study are astounding. For example, last week on AoA, a mechanical engineer named Catherine Tamaro tried to lecture scientists on statistics and the difference between observational versus experimental studies using quotes from a statistics textbook. She began:
After reading Katie Wright’s summary of the August 3 Senate Committee on Appropriations’ hearing on autism (HERE), I would like to comment on Dr. Insel’s testimony to Senator Harkin on why a study comparing vaccinated vs. unvaccinated children has not been done to date. Dr. Insel claimed that such a study would be “unethical” because, as he apparently envisions it, the study would entail dividing a large cohort of newborns into two groups, vaccinating one cohort but not the other through age two, and then comparing outcomes. This is just a bit disingenuous and I would like to explain why.
Of course, Ms. Tamaro is either ignorant or disingenuous herself in that some anti-vaccine advocates do indeed call for just such a study, even going so far as to demand a randomized, double-blinded study. J.B. Handley himself has attacked people who correctly call demands for such a study “unethical.” Apparently Ms. Tamaro isn’t aware of the strain running through the anti-vaccine movement that does want just such a study, or she herself is being even more disingenuous than she accuses critics of being. Tamaro then continues:
Research studies are divided into two categories, observational studies and experimental studies. An observational study observes individuals and measures variables of interest but does not attempt to influence the responses. (The “epidemiological” studies to which Dr. Insel refers are actually observational studies.) An experimental study, on the other hand, deliberately imposes some treatment on individuals in order to observe their responses; the purpose of an experiment is to study whether the treatment causes a change in the response.
This paragraph just goes to show how a little knowledge is a dangerous thing. There are many flavors of “observational” studies, with varying degrees of power to detect differences and varying degrees of ease with which confounders are accounted for. These include cohort studies (both retrospective and prospective), cross sectional studies, longitudinal studies, and case series. All have their strengths and weaknesses, and the studies of vaccines and autism have used several kinds of methodology. Not that that sways Tamaro:
All studies done to date investigating a correlation between vaccinations and autism have been observational studies, but no observational study has been done comparing the prevalence of autism diagnoses in a vaccinated human population compared to an unvaccinated human population. When Dan Olmsted points out that he has identified large populations of unvaccinated children in the United States and asks why a study has not been done on them, he is actually asking why an observational study has not been done. When Senator Harkin asks Dr. Insel why a study has not been done on vaccinated vs. unvaccinated American children, he too is actually asking why an observational study has not been done to date. Dr. Insel, however, chooses to respond by saying that an experimental study would be required in order to resolve the issue.
Tamaro may have a bit of a point about Insel choosing the easiest to attack, but she is doing the same thing by ignoring the fact that there have been calls from the anti-vaccine movement for experimental studies, which, of course, would be highly unethical because they would leave large numbers of children completely unvaccinated and thus vulnerable to vaccine-preventable diseases. In any case, here’s where Tamara goes right off the deep end:
I would like to point out the epidemiological similarity between smoking/lung cancer and vaccines/autism. Smoking has been proven to cause lung cancer, yet not a single experimental study on humans was ever done – all of the human studies proving that smoking causes lung cancer were observational. The experimental studies were performed on research animals only. Attached at the end of this letter is a lesson taken verbatim from an introductory course in college statistics describing how the connection between smoking and lung cancer was made.
There have been lots of experimental studies on research animals of vaccines trying to show a link between vaccines and autism. I’ve written about some of them right here, and other bloggers have discussed them in detail as well. For example, there was the infamous Mady Hornig “rain mouse” study, in which she claimed that thimerosal at the doses infants received, adjusted for size, caused autistic symptoms. Both Prometheus and Autism Diva enumerated the numerous flaws and ethical lapses in that experiment. Then there was the more recent (and even more unethical) Laura Hewitson experiment looking at vaccinated and unvaccinated Macaque monkey infants. I was appalled at how badly designed and grossly unethical that experiment was, not to mention at the enormous undisclosed conflicts of interest of the investigators. The problem, of course, is that there is not yet a good animal model of autism. If there were, you can bet that there would be a huge amount of research using animal models. It’s not because the NIH is unshakably opposed to animal research on vaccines and autism. Rather it’s because such research is inherently not particularly useful or feasible absent a good animal model or two. Moreover, the history of such research (i.e., Hornig and Hewitson) is not exactly cause for optimism, given how badly done these studies were.
In addition, the tobacco comparison is a favorite canard of anti-vaccinationists (for instance, Dr. Jay Gordon). Certainly, it was primarily epidemiological studies that showed that smoking causes cancer. While she is correct to say that an experimental (i.e., randomized, blinded) study is not always necessary to provide sufficient evidence of causation to conclude that there is causation, she’s picked the wrong example for a number of reasons. For smoking and cancer, the association is very strong, stronger than almost any environmental toxin and cancer that I can think of off the top of my head. Smoking results in a ten-fold increased risk of lung cancer. Such a high magnitude of increased risk is generally not that hard to detect with an epidemiological study of even fairly weak design, as long as there are sufficient numbers and the condition is not extremely uncommon. But more importantly, what Ms. Tamara either doesn’t know or fails to acknowledge is that the very same sorts of studies that identified smoking as a huge risk factor for lung cancer and cardiovascular disease are the same sorts of studies that have failed to find an association between either thimerosal and autism or vaccines and autism. For example, it was a case control study by Sir Richard Doll that was credited with first detecting the link between smoking and lung cancer (although actually Nazy doctors discovered the link with a case control study two decades before Sir Doll did).
In any case, Ms. Tamara is also wrong when she says that a study of the vaccinated and unvaccinated has never been undertaken. First, there have been studies looking at who the unvaccinated are and where they live. One study published in Pediatrics in 2004 found that:
Undervaccinated children tended to be black, to have a younger mother who was not married and did not have a college degree, to live in a household near the poverty level, and to live in a central city. Unvaccinated children tended to be white, to have a mother who was married and had a college degree, to live in a household with an annual income exceeding $75 000, and to have parents who expressed concerns regarding the safety of vaccines and indicated that medical doctors have little influence over vaccination decisions for their children. Unvaccinated children were more likely to be male than female. Annually, 17 000 children were unvaccinated.
In other words, there are a lot of difficult confounders to control for, and the number of unvacccinated children is small, further complicating epidemiological studies. Ironically enough, Generation Rescue itself tried to do it. It was a very bad study, really no more than a phone survey, and its results were amusing in that they found that the highest rates of autism were in the so-called “partially vaccinated” children. The clear implication of the study was drolly described by Kevin Leitch:
There’s no getting away from this. This is a disaster for Generation Rescue and the whole ‘vaccines cause autism’ debacle. Generation Rescue’s data indicates that you are ‘safer’ from autism if you fully vaccinate than partially vaccinate. It also indicates that across the spectrum of autism, you are only 1% more likely to be autistic if you have had any sort of vaccination as oppose to no vaccinations at all – and thats only if you are male. If you are a girl you chances of being on the spectrum are less if you have been vaccinated! Across both boys and girls, your chances of being on the spectrum are less if you have received all vaccinations.
I can only conclude that Ms. Tamara is also quite naive in that she clearly has no clue just how much money and how many children an observational study of the vaccinated versus unvaccinated would require to do properly, much less how tricky it would be to control for confounders, given that the unvaccinated vary in significant ways from the vaccinated. Skeptical blogger extraordinaire Prometheus tells the tale. First, he points out how few completely unvaccinated children there are to study, perhaps around 50,000 in the entire U.S., in the 3-6 year old age cohort that would be most fruitful to do a study looking at autism incidence in the vaccinated and unvaccinated. Prometheus then explains:
Let’s say – for the sake of argument – that we decide that a 10% difference in autism prevalence is enough to convince the skeptics that vaccines might cause autism and that a less than 10% difference will convince the believers that vaccines don’t cause autism. [I know, the latter assumption is pure fantasy.]
Well, plugging those numbers in – along with the current 1 in 150 autism prevalence – we find that we need over 360,000 children in each group to detect a 10% difference (you can try it yourself here). Unfortunately, that is more than the total number of unvaccinated children in the US, so that’s not going to happen.
What can we get with our “sample” of 49,652 unvaccinated children? If we manage to include each and every unvaccinated child in the US in the study, we could detect a 26% or more difference in autism prevalence.
Of course, it’s not even remotely practical to expect to get 100% of the unvaccinated children in the country into a study. How more about a practical number – say, 10% of them? That would allow us to detect a 70% or greater difference – about a three-fold difference in autism prevalence between the fully vaccinated and unvaccinated groups.
Does anyone here think that parents who fervently believe that vaccines cause autism would accept negative results from a study that’s only powered to detect a three-fold difference in autism rates between the vaccinated and unvaccinated as sufficiently reassuring to accept the current vaccination as safe? Prometheus was right when he said that a study powered to find a 10% difference would probably not sufficiently reassure them. Given the religious fervor with which the anti-vaccine movement clings to the myth that vaccines cause autism, I doubt that it would accept a negative result from a study powered to detect a 1% difference in autism rates as sufficiently reassuring to abandon its fear. Moreover, as Prometheus tells us, even the study described above would be inordinately expensive and difficult to do. So he did a “back of the napkin” calculation of what a more feasible study could accomplish:
Finally, let’s “run the numbers” on a more practical study – one where we are able to enroll 500 unvaccinated children and 5000 fully vaccinated controls matched for age, sex, socioeconomic group, geographic location, urban vs rural vs suburban setting and race.
This study – which would still be very difficult and expensive to do – would only be able to detect a more than 15-fold difference in autism prevalence between the two groups. It could detect as little as a 7-fold difference, but only if we were willing to accept a beta error (chance of erroneously saying there is no difference when there is a difference) of over 50%.
I doubt this would “satisfy” the vaccines-cause-autism believers if the results were negative.
I can’t help but note that the study described by Prometheus would probably fail to find the well-known increased risk of lung cancer and heart disease due to smoking, the more so since the incidence of lung cancer in nonsmokers is considerably lower than 1 in 150, which is how many children are estimated to be autistic. Remember, the relative risk of lung cancer due to smoking is on the order of ten-fold.
The only way to get around the problems inherent in designing a study with sufficient numbers of unvaccinated children of sufficient power to detect a difference in autism prevalence between the unvaccinated and vaccinated children small enough to reassure most parents that vaccines do not cause autism would be to expand the study to multiple nations. Of course, doing such a study would be even more enormously expensive, take several years, and, because funding for autism research is pretty much a zero sum game, would divert huge amounts of money from more promising research to chasing down a highly implausible hypothesis that has virtually no credible empirical support behind it, either from basic science, epidemiology, or other evidence, certainly nowhere near enough evidence to justify such a huge expenditure and effort. Alternatively, as Prometheus points out, we could look at dose-response models:
Of course, we wouldn’t have to just look at unvaccinated vs fully vaccinated with this study, which is a large part of its superiority. We could look at a dose response of vaccination - to see if it really is “too many” – as well as the age at youngest vaccination – to see if it really is “too soon”. In fact, a few studies have already looked at those issues and found that there is no difference between the autistic and non-autistic groups. I suspect this is the reason the folks pushing to “put on a study” want to look at vaccinated vs unvaccinated – they hope that the numbers will be different (or, at least, not as definitive) the other way round.
In fact, I rather suspect that the smarter among the anti-vaccinationists know all the problems inherent in doing a study of vaccinated versus unvaccinated children. Certainly the government does, hence its reluctance to spend all sorts of money chasing a highly improbable hypothesis. (If only it would apply that reasoning to NCCAM!) In reality, the “vaccinated versus unvaccinated” gambit is just that–a gambit. The leaders of the anti-vaccine movement probably know that doing a study with sufficient power and numbers to exclude even a modest risk of autism due to the current vaccine schedule is so expensive and impractical that it would probably never be done and that smaller studies that are feasible will have too little power to reassure those who believe that vaccines cause autism that vaccines are in fact safe. Why do it then? It keeps the troops fired up thinking that there is some huge conspiracy to prevent such a study because of the fear of its results or that the government just doesn’t care enough about autistic children to do such a study.
On the other hand, antivaccinationists should be very careful what they ask for. They may just make enough of a pain of themselves to get it. True, getting the resources necessary to do a study the like of what Prometheus described intially would monopolize autism research funding for years, but the anti-vaccine movement doesn’t really care about that, because it’s always been all about the vaccines more than helping autistic children. Worse, if the government ever did spend the money on such an enormous study and it was resoundingly negative, it’s easy to predict that it would make no difference. As they have done before for other large studies, anti-vaccinationists would discount the results and cry bias. Still, if the government caves and decides to do such a study, it is up to us in the scientific community to make sure that it’s done by no one but the best epidemiologists, in other words, that it’s a proper study that correctly controls for confounders and can answer the question being asked, not the dubious study custom designed to have the maximal chance of a false positive result, which is of course what the anti-vaccine movement really wants.

   Anti-vaccine warriors vs. research ethics
Published by David Gorski
Link
Three weeks ago, the anti-vaccine movement took a swing for the fences and, as usual, made a mighty whiff that produced a breeze easily felt in the bleachers. In brief, a crew of anti-vaccine lawyers headed by Mary Holland, co-author of Vaccine Epidemic: How Corporate Greed, Biased Science, and Coercive Government Threaten Our Human Rights, Our Health, and Our Children, published a highly touted (by Generation Rescue and other anti-vaccine groups, that is) “study” claiming to “prove” that the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (VICP) had actually compensated children for autism. As is typical with such “studies” generated by the anti-vaccine movement, it was bad science, bad law, and just plain bad all around. The authors intentionally conflated “autism-like” symptoms with autism, trying to claim that children with neurological injury with “autism-like” symptoms actually have autism. Never mind that there are specific diagnostic criteria for autism and that, if the children actually had autism, many of them would have been given a diagnosis of autism. Never mind that what they were doing was akin to claiming that all patients with “Parkinson’s-like symptoms” have Parkinson’s disease. (Hint: They don’t.) Never mind that all they did was to demonstrate a prevalence of autism spectrum disorders among the VICP-compensated children that was clearly within the range of what would be anticipated if there were no relationship between vaccines and autism. Never mind all that. This was Holland’s big chance, but it went over like the proverbial lead balloon. No one bit, other than FOX News.
The study rapidly faded into the obscurity it so richly deserves, in spite of mighty efforts by Generation Rescue, SafeMinds, and the likes of Ginger Taylor to keep it alive and use it as a rallying point to persuade legislators to pass anti-vaccine-friendly legislation. You could feel the frustration in its backers as Holland’s study, into which groups like Generation Rescue had apparently poured their hopes of being vindicated, crashed and burned.
However, there’s one aspect of this study that I didn’t discuss. In fact, I thought of it as I read it, but I wasn’t sure. What I (and others) have noticed is that there was no statement in the article that approval had been obtained from the relevant institutional review boards (IRBs) to do human subjects research. For those not familiar with what an IRB is, an IRB is a committee that oversees all human subject research for an institution. It is the IRB’s responsibility to make sure that all studies are ethical in design and that they conform to all federal regulations. Basically, IRBs are charged with weighing the risks and benefits of proposed human subject research and making sure that
risks are minimized and that the risk:benefit ratio, at least as well as it can be estimated, is very favorable;
to minimize any pain, suffering or distress that might come about because of the experimental therapy; and
to make sure that researchers obtain truly informed consent.
During the course of a study, regular reports must be made to the IRB, which can shut down any study in its institution if it has concerns about patient welfare.
Of course, I know this all because I happen to be involved in human subjects research. It’s part of what I do while doing research in breast cancer. Clinical trials are obviously human subjects research. After all, their very purpose is to test a new drug or treatment on human subjects in order to determine if it works. However, human subjects research encompasses a lot more than just clinical trials; in fact, it encompasses almost any research study that involves either human subjects or human subjects’ protected health information (i.e., medical charts). Basically, any human subject experimentation requires approval by a properly constituted IRB. There is no documentation in Holland et al that IRB approval had been obtained, either from the for NYU (given that Mary Holland is a research scholar at the NYU School of Law) and/or Pace University, given that Pace Law School is cited as having “provided significant research support for this study” in the footnotes of the paper:
Mary Holland, Research Scholar and Director of the Graduate Legal Skills Program, NYU School of Law; Louis Conte, independent investigator; and Robert Krakow and Lisa Colin, attorneys in private practice. Pace Law School provided significant research support for this study.
Autism News Beat and Sullivan are already all over this issue, but I thought I’d throw in a bit from my perspective, given that I actually have to work with IRBs and, before my career is over, will probably be roped into serving on an IRB. In any case, as is true of any researcher who is involved in human subjects research, I had to undergo specific training regarding the “rules of the road,” so to speak, as a requirement of being an investigator on any study involving human subjects research.
How is human subjects research defined? According to 32 CFR 219.102(d), research means “a systematic investigation, including research development, testing, and evaluation, designed to develop or contribute to generalizable knowledge,” and according to 32 CFR 219.102(f) a human subject is defined as ” living individual about whom an investigator (whether professional or student) conducting research obtains data through intervention or interaction with the individual, or identifiable private information.”
Under these criteria, I believe that the Pace study clearly qualifies as human subjects research. First of all, as poorly designed as the study was, it was clearly intended as a systematic investigation designed to contribute to generalizable knowledge and testing a hypothesis, namely that autism is associated with vaccine-induced brain injury. The authors claim to have found data in the VICP-compensated cases indicating that there is a higher incidence of autism in these children. Never mind that they found nothing of the sort, they set out to test that hypothesis and their methods were designed to support it. Moreover, as Autism News Beat pointed out, members of the Elizabeth Birt Center for Autism and Legal Advocacy (EBCALA) administered the Social Communication Questionnaire (SCQ) to the parents or caregivers of 22 children. This clearly makes the parents who answered the questionnaire (and their children) human subjects, as identifiable protected health information about the children is being solicited and used to test their hypothesis.
To be fair, I have to point out that there are types of studies that are exempt from full IRB approval. In fact, there are six categories of so-called “exempt” studies. I frequently use category four, which involves the use of already existing clinical information that has been de-identified. I also note that this particular exemption involves research that does not involve interacting with living humans about their health information; rather, these sorts of studies tend to involve chart reviews or the examination of human tissue specimens that have already been collected. Be that as it may, there is one potential exemption that EBCALA might claim. First, number two:
Research involving the use of educational tests (cognitive, diagnostic, aptitude, achievement), survey procedures, interview procedures or observation of public behavior, unless:
information obtained is recorded in such a manner that human subjects can be identified, directly or through identifiers linked to the subjects; and
any disclosure of the human subjects responses outside the research could reasonably place the subjects at risk of criminal or civil liability or be damaging to the subjects financial standing, employability, or reputation.
Unfortunately for Holland et al, the first “unless” probably kills this exemption. The information they obtained was obtained in a manner such that the human subjects can be identified. The second “unless” might or might not kill the exemption; I note that both criteria are used to decide whether an exemption is not permissible. However, even if this research could potentially be considered exempt – and I highly doubt that a reputable IRB operating within the law and the Common Rule would find it exempt, particularly since IRBs are charged with taking special care to protect human subjects considered to be vulnerable, such as children, and that the survey is in fact a screening/diagnostic tool, making the results protected health information – it should also be noted it is not the investigators who get to decide whether a protocol is exempt or not and therefore whether a protocol requires IRB evaluation and approval. Period. Investigators do not have the power to determine whether their research falls under one of these exempt categories; only the IRB can make that determination, usually in an expedited review that determines whether a potentially exempt protocol meets the standards of one of the categories that are exempt from full IRB approval. It’s right there in the rules:
Only the IRB may determine which activities qualify for an exempt review. Investigators do not have the authority to make an independent determination that research involving human subjects is exempt and must contact the IRB concerning the status of proposed research or changes in ongoing research.
Also note that the research cannot begin until after IRB approval is obtained.
Personally, unlike the case with the Geiers, my guess is that as lawyers Holland et al were simply ignorant that what they were doing constituted human subjects research and that’s why they didn’t bother with a little thing (to them) like obtaining IRB approval before doing their study. Indeed, when Autism News Beat inquired at Pace Law School about whether the EBCALA study had IRB approval, this is what he was told:
When asked if the Pace study had IRB approval, Pace Law spokesperson Lauren Rubenstein referred the question to the study’s co-author, Louis Conte. In an email, Rubenstein wrote “Louis Conte has told me that there was no human subjects research in this study.”
Which reveals Conte’s utter cluelessness about human subjects research. Investigators interacted with the parents of these children, administering a questionnaire to them for purposes of looking for data to support their hypothesis. It’s human subjects research until judged otherwise–by an IRB, not by Conte, Holland, or any of the other of the merry band of anti-vaccine lawyers who put this travesty of a study together. Not surprisingly, attempts to get Conte to respond to e-mails regarding IRB approval of the study were not returned.
Of course, ignorance of the law is no excuse; as lawyers the authors of Holland et al should know. I also find it rather hard to believe, whether or not they were ignorant of federal law and regulations regarding human subjects research, that at some point either Holland and her coauthors weren’t made aware somehow by someone that what they were doing constituted human subjects research under federal law. Surely someone must have realized this, given that questionnaires about protected health information were being administered to living human beings. If they did not, then, quite frankly, I find the level of incompetence and lack of concern about basic ethical standards that every investigator in the U.S. who engages in human subjects research knows as basic information because they are required to know them and abide by them as part of ethics and the law.
This lack of concern about such niceties of the ethical treatment of human subjects is nothing new in anti-vaccine studies. Andrew Wakefield demonstrated it with his callous treatment of children at a party, whom he basically bribed for blood samples and whose fear he made light of. The Geiers père et fils demonstrated it when they created an IRB to oversee their own research, sat on that IRB themselves with Dr. Geier himself chairing the committee (a massive conflict of interest), and packed it with their anti-vaccine cronies.
There’s one more “out” that Holland et al might try for, and that’s to say that their research was not federally funded and is therefore not covered by the Common Rule. However, most universities that accept federal funding for research agree to be bound by the Common Rule for all research carried out by their faculty, students, and trainees. Even if Holland et al tried to justify their failure to obtain IRB approval this way and argue that they are not legally bound to follow the Common Rule, their failure to obtain IRB approval for their study and submit to IRB oversight is a massive ethical failing. I characterized Holland et al as evidence that that when the anti-vaccine movement can’t win on science, it will appeal to the law. It also appears that when it can’t win on ethics, it will appeal to the law as well.
While Holland et al tout “unanswered” questions about autism and the VICP, the only question I have is: Will Pace University and NYU will investigate how such a study could be performed without its investigators obtaining the requisite IRB approval? Or will they sweep this massive ethical (and possibly legal) breach under the rug and hope it goes away.

   The incredible shrinking vaccine-autism hypothesis shrinks some more
David Gorski
Link
Just when I thought I was out… they pull me back in.
Michael Corleone in The Godfather, Part 3
I hadn’t planned on doing two vaccine posts with such a short interval between them, but all too often, as the they say in the weakest of the Godfather movies, I get pulled back in again. So, after noting last week that 2009 was shaping up–fortunately–to be a very bad year for antivaccinationists, I should have expected a counterattack from the antivaccine fringe. Indeed, the only thing that surprised me after the twin blows of the revelations about scientific fraud on the part of the originator of the claim that the MMR vaccine causes autism, Andrew Wakefield, and the resounding defeat of the first three test cases of the Autism Omnibus proceedings, was that it took longer than I had expected. True, a group had formed, proclaiming that “we support Dr. Andrew Wakefield.” Also true, the antivaccine activists at the Age of Autism have been working overtime to attack the Autism Omnibus as being hopelessly rigged. Indeed, our “old friend” Dr. Jay Gordon has even likened attempts to refute antivaccine pseudoscience to tobacco companies’ P.R. and astroturf campaigns back in the 1950s through 1980s to cast doubt on the strong scientific and epidemiological evidence showing that cigarettes cause lung cancer.
But those contortions of science, epidemiology, law, and logic were merely a warmup for the real counterattack. On February 25, Generation Rescue purchased this full page ad in USA Today:
Unfortunately, the advertisement above was only the beginning. Generation Rescue managed to team up the chief progagandist for the antivaccine movement, David Kirby, along with Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., whom I have discussed before for his total support of the antivaccine movement. The question then becomes: Where would these two team up to spread their message against vaccines? Do you even have to ask?
Their twin articles appear on that repository of all things antivaccine, The Huffington Post, under the title Vaccine Court: Autism Debate Continues. As I will explain, these twin articles represent yet another example of what I have at times referred to as the “incredibly shrinking vaccine-autism hypothesis.”
Let’s take a look first at the article by RFK, Jr., Another Autism Case Wins in Vaccine Court:
The New York Times joined the government Health Agency (HRSA) and its big pharma allies hailing the decisions as proof that the scientific doubts about vaccine safety had finally been “demolished.” The US Department of Health and Human services said the rulings should “help reassure parents that vaccines do not cause autism.” The Times, which has made itself a blind mouthpiece for HRSA and a leading defender of vaccine safety, joined crowing government and vaccine industry flacks applauding the decisions like giddy cheerleaders, rooting for the same court that many of these same voices viscously derided just one year ago, after Hannah Poling won compensation for her vaccine induced autism.
But last week, the parents of yet another child with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) were awarded a lump sum of more than $810,000 (plus an estimated $30-40,000 per year for autism services and care) in compensation by the Court, which ruled that the measels-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine had caused acute brain damage that led to his autism spectrum disorder.
Yes, it’s the Hannah Poling case all over again, except this time the antivaccine movement is not rebranding autism as a mitochondrial disorder. What it is trying to rebrand autism as again, you will see in a moment. In the meantime, RFK, Jr. spins and twists:
The family of 10-year-old Bailey Banks won their case quietly and without fanfare in June of 2007, but the ruling has only now come to public attention. In the remarkably clear and eloquent decision, Special Master Richard Abell ruled that the Banks had successfully demonstrated that “the MMR vaccine at issue actually caused the conditions from which Bailey suffered and continues to suffer.”
Bailey’s diagnosis is Pervasive Developmental Disorder — Not Otherwise Specified (PDD-NOS) which has been recognized as an autism spectrum disorder by CDC, HRSA and the other federal health agencies since at least the 1990s.
PDD-NOS is indeed one of the conditions that fall under the category of disorders known as autistic spectrum disorders (ASDs) and is thus considered an ASD. The ruling concluded that, in the case of Bailey Banks, the MMR had caused a condition known as acute disseminated encephalomyelitis (ADEM). Here is the passage that RFK, Jr. quotes in his HuffPo article:
The Court found that Bailey’s ADEM was both caused-in-fact and proximately caused by his vaccination. It is well-understood that the vaccination at issue can cause ADEM, and the Court found, based upon a full reading and hearing of the pertinent facts in this case, that it did actually cause the ADEM. Furthermore, Bailey’s ADEM was severe enough to cause lasting, residual damage, and retarded his developmental progress, which fits under the generalized heading of Pervasive Developmental Delay, or PDD [an autism spectrum disorder]. The Court found that Bailey would not have suffered this delay but for the administration of the MMR vaccine, and that this chain of causation was… a proximate sequence of cause and effect leading inexorably from vaccination to Pervasive Developmental Delay.
This is not an exact quote of what Special Master Richard Abell’s ruling. Note the term “an autism spectrum disorder” in brackets. There’s just one problem. PDD is not an autistic spectrum disorder. Let’s look at the very beginning of the Special Master’s ruling:
On 26 June 2002, the Petitioner filed a petition for compensation under the National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act of 1986 (Vaccine Act or Act)2 alleging that, as a result of the MMR vaccination received on 14 March 2000, his child, Bailey, suffered a seizure and Acute Disseminated Encephalomyelitis (“ADEM”),3 which led to Pervasive Developmental Delay (“PDD”), a condition from which he continues to suffer (the “Petition”).
Note the difference. The claim in the ruling is not that ADEM led to pervasive developmental disorder, not otherwise specialized (PDD-NOS). The ruling is about pervasive developmental delay (PDD). The difference is more than a matter of semantics, as Kev points out. PDD is not the same thing as PDD-NOS. In fact, the ruling itself makes this point very, very clear in one of its footnotes:
Pervasive Developmental Disorder, Not Otherwise Specified (PDD-NOS) is a ‘subthreshold’ condition in which some – but not all – features of autism or another explicitly identified Pervasive Developmental Disorder are identified. PDD-NOS is often incorrectly referred to as simply “PDD.” The term PDD refers to the class of conditions to which autism belongs. PDD is NOT itself a diagnosis, while PDD-NOS IS a diagnosis. The term Pervasive Developmental Disorder – Not Otherwise Specified (PDD-NOS; also referred to as “atypical personality development,” “atypical PDD,” or “atypical autism”) is included in DSM-IV to encompass cases where there is marked impairment of social interaction, communication, and/or stereotyped behavior patterns or interest, but when full features for autism or another explicitly defined PDD are not met.
In fact, PDD-NOS is a subset of PDD, but there are other forms of PDD. This is what RFK, Jr. says about it:
Bailey’s diagnosis is Pervasive Developmental Disorder — Not Otherwise Specified (PDD-NOS) which has been recognized as an autism spectrum disorder by CDC, HRSA and the other federal health agencies since at least the 1990s.
It’s not. Read the decision. Granted, the terms PDD and PDD-NOS seem to be used almost interchangeably and sloppily so, but latching on to that doesn’t “prove” anything. In fact, if you read through the ruling, you’ll also see that even the facts of the case do not represent the slam dunk that RFK, Jr. seems to think they do. Indeed, the Special Master even acknowledges that and feels the need to justify his decision:
Despite their accord on certain factual predicates contained in Bailey’s medical records, there is, unsurprisingly, a pronounced conflict between the parties as to the following issues: whether a biologically plausible link exists between ADEM and pervasive developmental delay (PDD) in a direct chain of causation, whether Bailey did in fact suffer from ADEM, and ultimately whether the administration of the MMR vaccine to Bailey actually caused ADEM which would then cause PDD that currently besets Bailey today.
Note that Special Master Abell referred to PDD as “pervasive developmental delay.”
I’ll grant you (and even the antivaccine movement) that Abell seems to flip back and forth between using PDD to mean pervasive developmental delay or PDD-NOS in a confusing manner, trying to explain himself in the footnotes and failing. My point is not that Bailey Banks doesn’t have PDD-NOS. Rather, it is that the antivaccine fringe reads far more into the terminology than is warranted. Reading the entire judgment, whatever neurological disorder Bailey has, I consider it arguable whether Bailey actually has an ASD. He very well might have PDD-NOS; he might not. In fact, the title of the ruling should tell you how sure Special Master Abell was that the MMR caused Bailey Banks’ autism: Non-autistic developmental delay; Acute Disseminated Encephalomyelitis; Expert Credibility; Evidentiary Reliability; Scientific Validity; Burden of Proof; Causation in Fact; Proximate Causation.
More importantly, even if Bailey does have PDD-NOS, the chain of causality gets more strained when we consider ADEM. For one thing, it’s not even entirely clear that Bailey actually had ADEM, as the testimony in the case reveals. However, clearly something happened; so, for the sake of argument, let’s say for the moment that he definitely did suffer a vaccine-induced incident of ADEM. Here’s where the problem comes in: There’s close to no scientific literature to support an epidemiological or pathologic link between ADEM or PDD (or PDD-NOS, for that matter). Basically, the ruling is best read as saying that in this case MMR probably (i.e., with a 51% or more probability) caused Bailey’s ADEM, a rare condition after vaccination that is compensable, and that Bailey’s ADEM further might have resulted in PDD or PDD-NOS. That’s a lot different than RFK, Jr.’s confident assertion that this case is a slam-dunk indication that the Vaccine Court has accepted the general principle that vaccines can cause autism. Such nuances undermine the antivaccine spin on the case, however; so they can’t be mentioned.
What I find more troubling, however, is this statement in Special Master Abell’s ruling, quoted by David Kirby in his article:
In response, Respondent’s expert stated that, although ADEM may result in “permanent neurological sequelae,” nevertheless “all the medical literature is negative in that regard;” however, soon thereafter, he corrected this statement by clarifying, “I can find no literature relating ADEM to autism or [PDD].” Tr. at 84-85. It may be that Respondent’s research reveals a dearth of evidence linking ADEM to PDD, but that is not the same as positive proof that the two are unrelated, something Respondent was unable to produce. Therefore, the statement that “all the medical literature is negative” is incorrect.
I have one request of anyone who fervently believes that the Vaccine Court is overwhelmingly biased against the petitioners who bring cases before it. Read the above paragraph. Then read it again. Then read it over and over. That single paragraph tells you all you need to know about the true attitude and “bias” of the Vaccine Court, which most definitely are not what Kirby represents them as. The above paragraph reveals a Special Master of the Vaccine Court bending over backwards to give the petitioner’s experts the benefit of the doubt even in the absence of any positive peer-reviewed medical literature supporting the petitioner’s hypothesis of causation for the vaccine injury claimed. Abell even appears to be chiding the government’s expert witness for being too particular about actually requiring some evidence published in the peer-reviewed journals to back the petitioner’s claim that the MMR caused ADEM, which resulted in PDD-NOS. Moreover, Abell’s statement above that the observation that there is a “dearth of evidence linking ADEM to PDD, but that is not the same as positive proof that the two are unrelated” suggests that he think that science can ever “positively” prove a negative. It cannot; it can only suggest probabilities. In any case, the Special Master appears to be going beyond even that. He appears to be looking for a reason to reject the Respondent’s defense.
Now don’t get me wrong. Special Master Abell’s misunderstanding of how science works aside, for the most part, as a matter of public health policy this bias of the Vaccine Court towards granting petitioners’ claims is probably a good thing. After all, if we as a society are going to require mass vaccination programs of our children, even though the benefits far outweigh the risks, there are small risks, and there will always be a small number of adverse events. Children who suffer an adverse event deserve to be compensated in an expeditious fashion. Indeed, the Vaccine Court was set up to do just that by streamlining the compensation process. Given that Bailey had a reaction close enough to his vaccination that the law considers it likely that the vaccination caused it as a matter of law, it is probably not unreasonable that the Vaccine Court decided to compensate him. But, please, let’s not confuse a legal ruling with science. As I pointed out when I discussed the recent rejection of the claims of causation by the first three test case petitioners in the Autism Omnibus, I was pleasantly surprised that, in the instance of the Omnibus at least, the law got the science right. Far too often, it does not. The rulings and litigation over silicone breast implants that bankrupted Dow-Corning in the 1990s come to mind.
To boil it all down, the antivaccine movement is doing nothing other than what it did in the Hannah Poling case, attempting to “rebrand” autism. RFK, Jr. and David Kirby are throwing people a big red herring. What the court admitted is that Bailey’s seizures occurred soon enough after the MMR to be considered a vaccine injury and accepted that his neurologic problems could be the result. It did not “admit that vaccines cause autism” any more than it did in the Hannah Poling case. Indeed, it bent over backward to give the petitioner every opportunity to come up with a concept of how vaccines might contribute to autism and argue it, primarily based on the relatively close temporal proximity. It even in essence ignored testimony that there was no convincing evidence in the peer-reviewed medical literature linking ADEM to PDD. I did the PubMed searches myself, and there really isn’t much of anything.
David Kirby, characteristically, is a bit more careful–and, of course, weaselly–about the issue. Clearly he is the smarter and cleverer of the two. What Kirby does is to throw Andrew Wakefield under the bus, metaphorically speaking, at least as far as how he claimed that MMR caused autism:
Is vaccine-induced ADEM (and similar disorders) a neurological gateway for a subset of children to go on and develop an ASD? That question will now become subject to debate. Thousands of parents have reported similar reactions and symptoms following vaccination, yet they lack radiological proof of ADEM or related disorders in the form of an MRI. Meanwhile, most children with autism do not present with myelin damage, but many do test positive for antibodies to myelin basic protein (MBP).
But what were these reactions? Kirby described them earlier:
Most cases of ADEM (80%) are in children. Symptoms usually appear within a few days to a couple of weeks. They include: headache, delirium, lethargy, seizures, stiff neck, fever, ataxia (incoordination), optic nerve damage, nausea, vomiting, weight loss, irritability and changes in mental status.
I know of thousands of parents who witnessed many of these same symptoms afflict their children shortly after vaccination, most typically the MMR. Did these children with autism also suffer initially from ADEM or some subclinical version of the disorder? We may never know (physical signs like myelin damage are transitory).
This is yet another “I’m just asking” gambit by David Kirby, the same sort of rhetorical prestidigitation he performed for the Hannah Poling case, connecting condition after condition without any firm scientific evidence that a connection is warranted, each connection getting more tenuous as he continues. He’s also playing a subtler game that that in that he is implicitly attributing all sorts of nonspecific neurological symptoms to “regressive autism” without specifically saying that that’s what he’s doing.
Let’s look at it this way. Again, let’s go beyond what we conceded to the antivaccine movement for the sake of argument. Let’s concede that, in the case of Bailey Banks, MMR caused ADEM, which then lead to PDD-NOS or even full blown autism, exactly as David Kirby and Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. are claiming. Here’s the problem. ADEM occurring after vaccination is very rare–so rare that, epidemiologically, it has been very difficult to determine whether it’s even correlated with a vaccine at all. For example, this study looking at post-marketing adverse events from vaccines in Japan reported the total estimated incidence of serious neurological incidents, including ADEM, encephalitis or encephalopathy, and Guillain-Barré syndrome, after vaccination as being in the range of 0.1-0.2 per million immunization practices. That’s incredibly rare. Fellow SBM blogger Dr. Lipson has pointed out that the incidence of ADEM after measles and some other viral infections is 5,000 to 10,000 times higher than after vaccination, on the order of 1 in 1,000. In other words, even in the worst case scenario and granting every single link between vaccines, ADEM, and ASDs that David Kirby and RFK, Jr. speculate about, the risk of a child’s suffering a bout of ADEM after getting the measles is several orders of magnitude higher than it is after MMR vaccination–if there even is an elevated risk of ADEM after MMR vaccination at all! By David Kirby’s and RFK, Jr.’s own arguments, vaccination with MMR is vastly safer and vastly less likely to result in neurological sequelae than not vaccinating.
Of course, Kirby has a ready answer for this:
ADEM is said to be rare, but the disorder may be grossly under-diagnosed (or misdiagnosed). Even the government’s chief witness against Bailey’s case testified that he sees patients with ADEM “on a fairly regular basis.
Note the cleverness, so pathognomonic of Kirby’s writing style. ADEM itself may not be incredibly rare, but ADEM associated with vaccination is very rare and much more common after at least one of the diseases that vaccination prevents. At the end of the article, Kirby repeats the sentiment:
People will argue that ADEM is rare; that vaccines “only” caused PDD in Bailey; and that this was a legal and not scientific decision. The problem is we don’t know how prevalent ADEM is because we never looked; while “PDD” is interchangeable with “ASD” in the language of public health. And, the three cases that lost were also “legal” decisions.
This is just plain incorrect. Scientists and doctors have looked. There are numerous epidemiological studies and post-marketing surveillance studies looking for neurological sequelae after vaccination, be it with MMR or any other childhood vaccine. These studies just haven’t found what Kirby wants them to find. I strongly suspect that Kirby’s definition o which is why his definition of “look” is to do CT scans and MRIs on every child brought to the emergency room with any complaint at all after vaccination. Also remember that Bailey underwent an MRI because he had a seizure associated with fever.
I have on occasion referred to the vaccine-autism hypothesis as the “incredible shrinking causation hypothesis.” This tag-team assault by two luminaries of the antivaccine movement is yet more evidence of just how puny this hypothesis has become. Remember, the original claim of the antivaccine movement was not that a couple of very rare conditions predispose a child to vaccine injury, which predisposes them to developing autism. It was not that vaccines might cause autism in one or even two in a million children. No! It was that vaccines are a major cause, if not the main cause of an alleged “autism epidemic” that has been going on since the mid-1990s. Of course, the real cause of the apparent increase in autism diagnoses appears to be largely due to diagnostic substitution and the broadening of the diagnostic criteria for autism, but to antivaccine advocates, correlation must equal causation, and the increase in autism diagnoses correlated roughly with an increase in the number of vaccines in the recommended childhood vaccine schedule.
In the case of the discredited hypothesis that the mercury in the thimerosal preservatives in vaccines causes autism, Generation Rescue, for example, before its shifting of the goalposts declared autism to be a “misdiagnosis for mercury poisoning” due to vaccines. After the science became so overwhelming that even antivaccine activists had a hard time blaming autism on thimerosal anymore, GR describes autism in much vaguer terms:
We believe these neurological disorders (“NDs”) are environmental illnesses caused by an overload of heavy metals, live viruses, and bacteria. Proper treatment of our children, known as “biomedical intervention”, is leading to recovery for thousands.
The cause of this epidemic of NDs is extremely controversial. We believe the cause includes the tripling of vaccines given to children in the last 15 years (with unstudied ingredients like mercury, aluminum and live viruses); growing evidence also suggests that maternal toxic load and prenatal vaccines, heavy metals like mercury in our air, toxic ingredients in our water, pesticides; and the overuse of antibiotics are also implicated. Generation Rescue’s mission is to support continued research on causative factors and treatment approaches for NDs.
So what do we have now from the antivaccine movement, now that the thimerosal hypothesis has been discredited scientifically and Andrew Wakefield’s MMR work has been thoroughly repudiated? Vague ideas about “toxins” in vaccines. I want to emphasize it again: What we now see now is truly the incredibly shrinking hypothesis. By latching onto a rare mitochondrial disorder as the “linking factor” between vaccines and autism last year and now latching onto a very rare possible complication of vaccination, ADEM, as a “gateway” to autism, using only a questionable legal ruling and in essence no science, Kirby and Kennedy are showing just how small the vaccine hypothesis for autism has become. Even if such a link exists between the MMR and ADEM and autism and is ultimately scientifically confirmed (unlikely) it could not possibly account for very many cases of autism–just as mitochondrial disorders couldn’t account for very many cases. Moreover, even more so than neurological complications in children with mitochondrial disorders, neurological complications due to ADEM are more likely to occur in the unvaccinated because measles is more likely in such children. Science, facts, and reason notwithstanding, look for a lot of very bad “science” to pour out of the “labs” of Thoughtful House, Mark and David Geier’s basement, and Boyd Haley’s lab, wherever that may be these days.
I also find it rather convenient that the antivaccine movement seemingly forgot all about this particular ruling. After all, the ruling was originally issued in 2007 and Kathleen Seidel even blogged about it and other similar rulings nearly a year ago. One wonders why Generation Rescue waited until now to trot it out. Coincidence? I think not. Here’s what I think, and I believe I have good reason behind my thinking: Pre-Autism Omnibus ruling, even the antivaccine movement considered the Banks case thin gruel, too thin to make much of a stink about. Indeed, if that weren’t the case, the Banks case would almost certainly have received major hype when its ruling was originally announced a year and a half ago. I also don’t buy the argument that this ruling was “hidden.” The antivaccine movement is very aware of rulings made by the Vaccine Court, as they are always looking for a ruling to use. Now, post-Autism Omnibus ruling and Andrew Wakefield revelations, the antivaccine movement needs something to distract people from the drubbing they’ve taken scientifically and legally. So they pull an old ruling out of the closet, tart it up a bit using their post-Poling spin skills, and send it flouncing down the runway in the hope that it impresses.
And if that doesn’t work, RFK, Jr. in his own inimitable fashion cranks up the paranoia:
Although the vaccine court is mandated to fairly serve the victims of vaccine injuries, their primary purpose and raison d’etre is to protect the vaccine program and vaccine makers. Damages are doled out from a 75-cent tax on every vaccine sold and not from the vaccine makers. “You can understand why special masters, burdened with their duty to protect vaccine programs, might be unwilling to make the direct causal link between autism and vaccines,” Krakow observed. “If you ask the big question and answer it in the affirmative, there is a sense that it will damage the vaccine program irreparably.”
Vaccine Court judges are equipped with a draconian armory of weapons deployable against plaintiffs intent on proving the causal connection between vaccines and autism. Jury trials are prohibited. Damages are capped; awards for pain and suffering are strictly limited and punitive damages banned altogether. Vaccine defenders have an army of Department of Justice attorneys with virtually unlimited resources for expert witnesses and other litigation costs. Plaintiffs, in contrast, must fund the up front costs for experts on their own. In a cultural choice that clearly favors defendants, vaccine court gives overwhelming weight to written medical records which are often inaccurate — over all other forms of testimony and evidence. Observations by parents and other caretakers are given little weight.
I have one question for David Kirby and RFK, Jr.: If the proceedings of the Vaccine Court are so rigged against the petitioners, why is it that the U.S. government pays their legal fees, win or lose? Readers may or may not have heard of a certain lawyer named Clifford Shoemaker, who abused the subpoena process to punish Kathleen Seidel. What caused him to go after Kathleen Seidel with legal thuggery? What led him to take abusive retaliatory legal action was Seidel’s revelation of just how much money he had made from representing Vaccine Court petitioners. In fact, the Vaccine Court goes beyond paying legal fees, even for those who lose. As Kathleen Seidel has explained, the law guarantees payment of attorney’s fees and costs incurred by petitioners in presenting a claim to the Vaccine Court, as long as the claim is brought in good faith and the costs are deemed reasonable and necessary.
Particularly odd to me is RFK, Jr.’s rant that the court gives overwhelming weight to written medical records. What on earth else is the court supposed to give the most weight to when considering medical-legal claims? Humans are very prone to confusing correlation with causation, as well as confirmation bias, and the tendency to subconsciously adjust memories to conform to beliefs. Medical records may indeed be fallible, but eyewitness testimony is even more fallible. Indeed, the Michelle Cedillo case shows that, given how the parents insisted that her neurological problems started after her vaccine. Videotapes made by her parents before she was vaccinated and before her neurologic symptoms manifested themselves to her parents showed that her abnormalities were pre-existing. Experts could see the early signs; her parents didn’t know what to look for and did not.
Finally, to cap off the advertisement in USA Today and the tag team crankfest of David Kirby and RFK, Jr., Generation Rescue pulls out all the stops, trotting out–yes, you guessed it!–Jenny McCarthy and Jim Carrey. Check out this press release:
“It was heartbreaking to hear about Bailey’s story, but through this ruling we are gaining the proof we need to open the eyes of the world to the fact that vaccines do, in fact, cause autism,” said Jenny McCarthy, Hollywood actress, autism activist, best-selling author and Generation Rescue board member. “Bailey Banks’ regression into autism after vaccination is the same story I went through with my own son and the same story I have heard from thousands of mothers and fathers around the country. Our hope is that this ruling will influence decision and policy-makers to help the hundreds of thousands of children and families affected by this terrible condition.”
Chiming in immediately after is her boyfriend:
Jim Carrey, Hollywood legend and Generation Rescue board member, reacted to the news, “It seems the U.S. government is sending mixed messages by telling the world that vaccines don’t cause autism, while, at the same time, they are quietly managing a separate ‘vaccine court’ that is ruling in favor of affected families and finding that vaccines, in fact, were the cause. For most of the autism community the question is no longer whether vaccines caused of their child’s autism. The question is why is their government only promoting the rulings that are in favor of the vaccine companies.”
No, Jim, the question is why you and Jenny think your Google University education and personal anecdotal experience trumps science, epidemiology, and the accumulated knowledge based on mountains of epidemiological and scientific evidence, and why you think that a legal ruling on science decides science.
I could go on, so much misinformation is there, especially in RFK, Jr.’s article, where he complains to high heaven about how plaintiffs’ attorneys supposedly can’t get access to the Vaccine Safety Datalink. Likely this is another one of RFK, Jr.’s exaggerations, but even if it weren’t, I’d have to wonder if, assuming the court may be indeed reluctant to give plaintiff’s attorneys access to the VSD, this reluctance has anything to do with concerns about the confidential medical information under HIPAA for the millions of medical records contained in that database. Or perhaps it is knowledge of how Mark and David Geier once tried to alter file extensions and merge datasets, very possibly to match names with cases. True, they denied it, but as Kathleen Seidel wrote:
To justify their attempt to merge datasets, they refer to the absence of direct identifiers in patient records, apparently unaware or dismissive of the well-documented fact that aggregation of indirect identifiers (such as race, sex, birthweight, APGAR, maternal age, gestation, and date of vaccination) would compromise the confidentiality of private health information. Modern data mining software heightens the risk that patient confidentiality might be compromised by statistical researchers, hence the proliferation of guidelines for the conduct of such research.
Of course, legitimate researchers can get access to the VSD. Even lawyers for petitioners for the Vaccine Court can get access. Indeed, numerous studies have looked at the VSD data on vaccines, none finding any correlation between vaccines or thimerosal in vaccines and neurodevelopmental disorders. If the antivaccine movement had any scientists other than crank scientists, it could do studies using the VSD data too. All it takes is a protocol that can be approved by an IRB.
What we are seeing here is desperation. The leadership of the antivaccine movement sees the writing on the wall. Study after study have failed to find even a whiff of a link between mercury and autism or vaccines and autism. The Vaccine Court, which, as the Banks case shows, is about as petitioner-friendly as can be, has recently conclusively ruled against the vaccine-autism hypothesis. The hero of the antivaccine movement has been revealed for the world to see as not just a dishonest man in the pay of lawyers suing vaccine manufacturers and hiding his conflict of interest, not just an incompetent scientist, but as an outright scientific fraud. They know that, in the reality-based world, the last nails are being driven into the coffin of the vaccine-autism hypothesis, which, zombie like, keeps pounding on the lid of the casket to try to loosen them and get out.
Science does not support them; so all that is left is spin and P.R. 

   14 Studies Later*
Mark Crislip
Link
First off, I have deliberately not read the entries on Fourteen Studies by fellow bloggers on SBM. I wanted to go through the information on the site myself. So if some of the information is repetitive, sorry.
Second, in the interest of openness and transparency, I will state my conflicts of interest up front: none. I have not talked to a drug rep in at least 20 years. Outside of a trip to San Francisco as a fellow, paid for by the company who was funding a drug study my boss was participating in, I have accepted no gifts or money of any kind from big (or little) pharma since I was a medical student. Nothing. I don’t even eat the pizza at conferences (1).
Third, I am a hospital based adult Infectious Disease doctor. I make zero money from vaccines. In fact, I only make money if people get sick with infections. For my bottom line, giving vaccines to prevent disease is counter productive to my bottom line.
Why 14 studies?
Fouteen Studies is child (8) of Generation Rescue, one of the autism organizations that, among other things, promotes a link between vaccines and autism. The web site opens with Amanda Peet, my favorite actress (2), who generated a brouhaha when she suggested that vaccines were safe. As the top of the home page of fourteenstudies.org quotes:
“Fourteen studies have been conducted (both here in the US and abroad), and these tests are reproducible; no matter where they are administered, or who is funding them, the conclusion is the same: there is no association between autism and vaccines.”
Fourteen Studies refers to Ms. Peet as “Spokesperson for Sanofi Aventis, a vaccine manufacturer.” They imply she is a shill for big pharma. As best I can tell she is a spokesman for Vaccinateyourbaby.org, a site by Every Child by Two.
Every Child By Two (ECBT) was founded by former First Lady Rosalynn Carter and former First Lady of Arkansas Betty Bumpers in 1991 as a result of the measles epidemic that killed nearly 150 people.
I am convinced. Whenever I think of Rosalyn Carter, I think evil incarnate. Don’t you?
Ms. Peet is a spokesman for Vaccinate Your Baby, which gets support from the vaccine maker sanofi pasteur.
Every Child By Two’s Vaccinate Your Baby campaign is made possible through an unrestricted, educational grant from sanofi pasteur (9).
However:
Amanda Peet is generously volunteering her time to support this cause and does not receive compensation for her time and effort.
Anyone besides me think this is cheesy? But this site is more about implying financial impropriety and bias, than evaluation of science. Anyone mind if I continue the theme of being a financial shill?
The papers discussed at Fourteen Studies like the Vaccinateyourbaby.org website, have some openness and transparency. Both at least let you know where the funding comes from (4).
Generation Rescue, like the Age of Autism website, is rife with advertisements yet nowhere can I find a statement of any financial conflicts of interest they might have. It is a small thing, but in the interest of openness and transparency, it would be nice to know how much they take in from advertisements, on line sales and speaking fees. Generation Rescue is a tax exempt charity, but I cannot find their financial statement on line. It would help put their position into context, at least as far as financial bias goes. Maybe its nothing. Maybe it is a dollar a year, like what Apple pays Steve Jobs. Jobs appears to be doing OK. Maybe they make a good living from the proceeds.
Fourteen Studies often in its criticisms links to other sites that also do not mention any potential financial conflicts of interest. Which they probably don’t have. We all blog out of the intrinsic goodness of out hearts, after all. But when someone asks “Amanda Peet, How Much Are They Paying You?” on a web page with 12 sponsors and advertisers of autism treatments, the moral high ground slumps into the Marianas Trench.
(A later in the day addendum. I found the 990′s. The founders of GR are paid nothing. They spend the 400K a year they take in mostly on market research and advertising. No research. A breakdown of the source of income is not available).
What they do at the Fourteen Studies is rate each study (and there are more than 14 studies) with the following criteria, each worth up to 10 points: “Asked the Right Question,” “Conflict of Interest,” “Ability to Generalize,” and “Post-Publication Criticism.” 40 points would be the highest possible score. The highest score two studies received was a 5. Several received negative numbers suggesting either that those doing the scoring either did not know how to apply their own criteria, do not know how to correctly add together 4 positive numbers, or that the whole scoring system is bogus.
They say “We ranked all of the studies on a forty point scale.” Who the ‘we’ is who are doing the scoring is not mentioned. In each of the studies evaluated on the website, you know who did the work. Not fourteen studies. Transparency and accountability do not appear to be the strong suit of this site.
The first click to take you to the 14 studies gives a list of the studies and the only flaw they mention is the conflict of interest in each study. I have written before on this blog about the perils of funding and the results of clinical trials. It is not a trivial issue, but is, in and of itself, not a reason to dismiss a study. In the end the study has to rise and fall on the merits of its science and its reproducibility. Key concept. Reproducibility. The more a study is reproduced, the more reliable its underlying premise and the results.
The page does give the impression that there is a widespread, well funded, conspiracy between researchers, industry and government to suppress the truth about the side effects of vaccines.
Which is not true. As we all know that the REAL widespread, well funded, conspiracy between researchers, industry and government is suppress the truth about the Kennedy assassination. And man made global warming. And the Trilateral Commission. And the Holocaust. And UFO’s. And Big Foot. And Homeopathy. And Fluoridation. And the Loch Ness Monster. And and and and…
High quality studies take time and money to complete and are not easy to do. Someone has to do them, and the only people with the resources to fund biomedical research are the government and industry. Funding bias is a two edged sword, so if we look at the studies in peer reviewed, high impact journals funded by Generation Rescue we find, well, I can’t find any published studies Generation Rescue has funded. But if they do fund a published study that shows a link between autism and vaccines, by their own standards it will be suspect. Unless they are good guys, and so, as good guys, are resistant to funding bias. Of course, everyone thinks they are the good guy. Except me. I am totally prone to be influenced (1).
There is a page on the website called “Our Studies,” but they are not “their studies” because Generation Rescue is responsible for the studies, but because they support Generation Rescue’s position. That is the approach of Fourteen Studies: A good study is one that supports a vaccine/autism connection and a bad study is on that contradicts the connection. If, in the end, reality does not support your position and you do not change your opinion based on reality, then all you are left with is being a crank. I suspect that Generation Rescue is destined for crankdom.
None of “their studies”, save the Lancet MMR article by Wakefield, are high impact journals. Two studies were funded by Cure Autism Now Foundation. Does that invalidate them? Two are partially funded by the NIH? I thought the government were the Bad Guys. One (besides Wakefield’s) is by researchers who testify as experts on the damage caused by vaccines. Many do not mention conflicts of interest at all. Thanks to an apparent disregard for copyright/intellectual property (5), you can download all the references yourself from the fourteen studies website. Not that I would encourage you to do that. I got my copies through my hospital’s library.
In residency (and sometime beyond if you practice in a teaching hospital as I do) you have to suffer though, I mean, participate in Journal Club. In Journal Club an article is chosen and then carefully analyzed line by line. You look carefully for the strengths and weaknesses of the paper to learn how to read a paper critically. The one take home from years of participating in Journal Club is that all studies have flaws. All of them. Our studies and their studies are have flaws and bias. That is why most studies need to be repeated and all studies need to be taken in context. Clinical trials are messy and an individual study is rarely definitive.
Lets do a modified Journal Club with the 14 (actually 19) studies. These are all downloadable from Fourteen Studies, again, not that I suggest you violate copyright laws.
1) “Safety of Thimerosal-Containing Vaccines: A Two-Phased Study of Computerized Health Maintenance Organization Database”
Pediatrics, Thomas Verstraeten, MD (November 2003)
They gave it a 3. Their main issue with the paper was the politics and bias behind it. What about the science?
In this study they looked at HMO records of 124,170 infants for associations between neurodevelopemental disorders and thimerosal exposure. They then reevaluated the same disorders on another 16,717 children in another HMO. They found different associations between neurodevelopemental disorders and thimerosal exposures at the two HMO’s. And when it came to autism and attention deficit disorder, there were no increased risks that they could determine.
The discussion is a sober and reasonable evaluation of the potential confounding issues in the study that make it difficult to make a definitive statement that thimerosal does not cause autism. It is also one of those studies that makes your brain hurt trying to wrap your brain around it. In the conclusion they say “Although the lack of consistency between the 2 phases argues against a thimerosal effect, we believe that additional investigation is required.” It is typical of the calm, considered discussions found in all fourteen studies of the limitations of the study in question.
It is an article that demonstrates how difficult it is to tease out risk from a single exposure in a large population using epidemiology studies. The website suggests what is needed is a study that compares autism rates in vaccinated vrs unvaccinated children. Given the benefits of vaccines, such a study could never be ethically done. To deliberately randomize children to not getting vaccines would be immoral to do and impossible to get past an IRB.
That study will be possible in the future, thanks to the anti-vaccine and alternative vaccine schedule proponents. We will be able to compare disease, death and autism rates in vaccinated and unvaccinated populations. I predict that the unvaccinated group may have a slightly higher autism rate. If autism is mostly genetic, families where vaccines are not given due to prior autism cases will have more cases of autism when compared to vaccinated groups.
Where fourteen studies sees ethical malfeasance, I see a typical epidemiologic study. Messy, but helpful. It is one brick in the wall.
2) “Thimerosal and the Occurrence of Autism: Negative Ecological Evidence from Danish Population-Based Data”
Pediatrics, Kreesten M. Madsen, MD (September 2003)
According to fourteen studies, who gave it a 1, “Written by a Danish vaccine company, the study made a mockery of the data, a problem the authors themselves warned of. And, the CDC engineered the entire study. This one goes beyond useless, it was fraudulent to run the numbers this way, and they knew it.”
In this study they look at autism rates in Denmark during the use of thimerosal and after it was removed from the vaccines. The rates of autism diagnosis were stable during the thimerosal era and increased once thimerosal was removed. Suggesting that thimerosal is not associated with the development of autism (and maybe protective? (6)).
The mockery and fraud? I can’t mockery or fraud in the study. They recognise the confounding factors that both the criteria for diagnosis and the ability to find cases changed during the study period and may be a confounding variable.
I thought a nice study, and, for a retrospective epidemiologic study, fairly clean.
3) “Continuing Increases in Autism Reported to California’s Developmental Services System”
Archives of General Psychiatry, Robert Schechter, MD (January 2008) They gave it a 1.
“The entire study is based on the false premise that children’s vaccines no longer contain mercury. ” Not true. The premise was that mercury exposure declined over time.
This study looked at the prevalence of autism from 1995 to 2007. From 1999 to 2001, when most of the thimerosal was removed from the vaccine schedule, From 1995 to 2007 autism rates rose. Again, demonstrating that thimerosol is protective?
Another relatively clean and compelling epidemiologic study. The “Bad” studies that show an no association between vaccines and autism are all messy, as life is messy. They are several logs better than “Our” studies. The best study, a randomized, prospective, blinded trial can never ethically be done.
4) “Neuropsychological Performance 10 Years After Immunization in Infancy With Thimerosal-Containing Vaccines” Pediatrics, Alberto Eugenio Tozzi, Patrizia Bisiacchi (February 2009). A negative 2. It is concerning that the those at Fourteen studies can take a 0 to 10 scale and, after adding 4 positive numbers, get a negative number. Next thing you know, they will say a study that demonstrates no association between a vaccine and autism actually shows such an association (11). They gave it a negative two due to “such extreme fraud”
In medicine, there is a dose response curve. More drug, more effect, less drug, less effect. The assumption, reasonable outside of the world of homeopathy, is that if groups of kids who get less thimerosal (62.5 mcg) are compared to kids who had more thimerosal, (137.5 mcg), there should be a less toxicity in the group that received less thimerosal.
Not so in this study. There was (mostly) no difference in the two groups.
“Nearly 70% of the invited subjects participated in the neuropsychological assessment (N = 1403). Among the 24 neuropsychological outcomes that were evaluated, only 2 were significantly associated with thimerosal exposure. Girls with higher thimerosal intake had lower mean scores in the ﬁnger-tapping test with the dominant hand and in the Boston Naming Test.”
And the association could have been due to chance as often happens in studies that look at multiple endpoints. Natural noise in biologic outcomes results in the occasional outlier looking significant. It is why studies need to be reproduced.
The Italians had only one autism case in the study, so, while interesting on the potential for other neurotoxicities from thimerosal, it does not directly address the issue of autism. But extreme fraud? Nope. I can’t find any. I half expect Fourteen studies to say “The CDC is infested with Vaccinationists. I have here in my hand a list of 205—a list of names that were made known to the Secretary of Health as being members of the Vaccinationist Party and who nevertheless are still working and shaping policy in the CDC (9).”
5) “Autism and Thimerosal-Containing Vaccines: Lack of Consistent Evidence for an Association”
American Journal of Preventive Medicine, Paul Stehr-Green, DrPh, MPH (August 2003). A zero score.
In this study they “compared the prevalence/incidence of autism in California, Sweden, and Denmark with average exposures to Thimerosal- containing vaccines.”
They found that as the use of thimerosal declined, the rates of autism rose in all three areas. The Swedes have much less autism than the US, whether real or diagnosed, I cannot say, but the results are as compelling as epidemiologic data gets. And there is a pattern in the studies.
6) “Thimerosal Exposure in Infants and Developmental Disorders: A Prospective Cohort Study in the United Kingdom Does Not Support a Causal Association” Pediatrics, John Heron and Nick Andrews, PhD (September 2004). This study received a -4, the worst score and worst addition in the group. Why the low score?
They looked at 14,000 kids, when they received a vaccine, then calculated the amount of thimerosal they received, and were “compared with a number of measures of childhood cognitive and behavioral development covering the period from 6 to 91 months of age.” They did not specifically look at autism.
Annoying for Fourteen studies, and perhaps the real reason it received a -4, is the explicitly stated result that the exposure of thimerosal was beneficial:
“Contrary to expectation, it was common for the unadjusted results to suggest a beneficial effect of thimerosal exposure. For example, exposure at 3 months was inversely associated with hyperactivity and conduct problems at 47 months; motor development at 6 months and at 30 months; difficulties with sounds at 81 months; and speech therapy, special needs, and “statementing” at 91 months.”
So mercury is good for you? I doubt it. It demonstrates the difficulties in retrospective epidemiologic studies, that occasionally the data has what are probably not real results. To be believed, it need to be reproduced.
How about adverse effects from thimerosal? No.
“We could find no convincing evidence that early exposure to thimerosal had any deleterious effect on neurologic or psychological outcome when given according to an accelerated schedule.”
Anyone besides me noticing a pattern here? Epidemiologic studies, all coming at a problem from a different angle, all with the same result. Of course, the same result is what you would expect from a high level conspiracy.
7) “Early Thimerosal Exposure and Neuropsychological Outcomes at 7 to 10 Years”
New England Journal of Medicine, Thompson WW et al. (September 27, 2007). Highest score with a 5 out of 40. No one, not even Fourteen studies, would dis the NEJM. It is not that different from study 4 that received a -2.
They looked at “1047 children between the ages of 7 and 10 years and administered standardized tests assessing 42 neuropsychological outcomes. (We did not assess autism-spectrum disorders) ” and how much thimerosal they received in vaccines. They found that mercury exposure in vaccines was probably not a neurotoxin.
“The weight of the evidence in this study does not support a causal association between early exposure to mercury from thimerosal containing vaccines and immune globulins administered prenatally or during infancy and neuropsychological functioning at the age of 7 to 10 years. The overall pattern of results suggests that the significant associations may have been chance findings stemming from the large number of statistical tests that we performed. “
“Association Between Thimerosal-Containing Vaccine and Autism”
Journal of the American Medical Association, Anders Hviid, MSc (October 2003). A score of 1.
The study looked at all children born in Denmark from 1990 and 1996 and found no difference in the rates of autism in kids vaccinated with vaccines that contained thimerosal and those that were vaccinated with vaccines that did not contain thimerosal.
As best they could tell, no relation between thimerosal and autism. They also found that as the use of thimerosal declined, the rates of autism increased.
The data was reanalyzed by Safe Minds on the assumption that cases of autism were lost and if that was factored in, autism rates declined when thimerosal was removed. The authors disagreed with this approach, and, in an exchange in the letters sections of JAMA (curiously not mentioned at 14 studies) said they checked with the source of the data, that the numbers used were not prevalence measurements, and that cases were not lost, invalidating the analysis of Safe Minds (3).
9) “Mercury concentrations and metabolism in infants receiving vaccines containing thimerosal: A descriptive study”
The Lancet, Michael Pichichero, MD (November 2002). Rated zero.
An interesting study that looked at mercury levels in children who received thimerosal containing vaccines and compared it to mercury blood levels in children who received thimerosal free vaccines. The mercury in the blood of the vaccine children was about twice that of controls, but well with in what is considered safe. And 12 of the samples in the vaccine group had no detectable mercury. It does not address the issue as to whether near homeopathic blood levels of mercury are associated with autism, but is an interesting basic science. I would, as mentioned above, expect a dose response effect of mercury and, if the levels after vaccine are low to undetectable after vaccine, I would be skeptical, on the basis of basic pharmakotoxicity, that mercury is a cause of autism.
Fourteen studies take? “One of the sillier studies ever performed, and the lead author is a vaccine patent-holder, no less. Absurd that this study appears on lists of studies exploring the relationship of vaccines to autism, as it doesn’t even address the topic. More absurd is the author’s complete misunderstanding of how mercury is excreted from the body.”
I can’t see why this is silly. If you are to understand how ethylmercury is toxic, in part you need to understand its pharmakokinetics, how it is excreted and where it goes in the body. Which is what this study investigated and reported. Based on the critics, I imagine they would only be satisfied if brain biopsies were done to measure mercury level in the CNS. If you think the return of polio is ok, probably a brain biopsy would not be so bad (12).
10) “Thimerosal and Autism?” Pediatrics, Karen Nelson, MD (March 2003). Rated zero.
A nice review that concludes, based on 60, yes 60 (when I count postive numbers, I get a postive number), which, in my world of numbers, is greater than 14, papers that there is no link between thimerosal and autism.
11) “Lack of Association Between Rh Status, Rh Immune Globulin in Pregnancy and Autism”
American Journal of Medical Genetics, Judith H. Miles and T. Nicole Takahashi (May 2007). Another zero.
Looks at whether Rh Immune Globulin, which contains thimerosal, is associated with autism. It isn’t. While not a vaccine, it is a mercury exposure, and does concern the issue as to whether or not thimerosal is toxic.
That’s the 11 articles that address thimerosal and autism. A very compelling series of articles that, when taken as a whole, are convincing that there is no relation between mercury and autism. I had read the articles piecemeal before, but, like evolution, when read in total, are an excellent argument that thimerosal is not associated with autism.
Lets move on to the 7 articles concerning MMR and autism
Wakefield had a study published in Lancet titled ” Ileal-lymphoid-nodular hyperplasia, non-specific colitis, and pervasive developmental disorder in children,” that has had some issues.
This study demonstrated that “Onset of behavioral symptoms [autism] was associated, by the parents, with measles, mumps, and rubella vaccination [MMR] in eight of the 12 children, with measles infection in one child, and otitis media in another…We identified associated gastrointestinal disease and developmental regression in a group of previously normal children, which was generally associated in time with possible environmental triggers.”
The response of fourteen studies is that “This relatively straightforward conclusion, that the MMR may in fact be related to autism, set off a worldwide controversy and a mini-industry of bogus scientific reports trying to refute the idea that MMR and autism are related. You will see many of the studies below.”
If true, the Wakefield needs to be reproduced, if not true, that also needs to be determined. The first study that looked at high dose steroids and sepsis showed benefit. Multiple subsequent studies (or should I say a mini-industry of bogus scientific reports trying to refute the idea that steroids were helpful) showed harm and no benefit. A typical and annoying feature of the medical literature is differing results. It is why it is important to consider both biologic plausibility and the results of the preponderance of studies.
The following studies, unlike the Wakefield study, are bogus. Hm.
12) “Lack of Association Between Measles Virus Vaccine and Autism with Enteropathy: A Case-Control Study”
PLoS One, Mady Hornig, Thomas Briese T, et al. (September 2008). Rated 1.
The secret to believable medical information is reproducibility. Cold fusion died because no one can reproduce it. So an association between MMR and autism will have to be reproduced to be compelling.
They tried, in part, to repeat the Wakefield study, They did not get the same results. “However, it made one critical distinction from the Wakefield approach: it didn’t recruit for the subset of children with autism who regressed after MMR vaccination.” Evidently, neither did Wakefield.
“The sample was an age-matched group of US children undergoing clinically-indicated ileocolonoscopy. Ileal and cecal tissues from 25 children with autism and GI disturbances and 13 children with GI disturbances alone (controls) were evaluated by real-time reverse transcription (RT)-PCR for presence of MV RNA in three laboratories blinded to diagnosis, including one wherein the original findings suggesting a link between MV and ASD were reported. The temporal order of onset of GI episodes and autism relative to timing of MMR administration was examined. We found no differences between case and control groups in the presence of MV RNA in ileum and cecum. Results were consistent across the three laboratory sites. GI symptom and autism onset were unrelated to MMR timing.”
This study had the advantage over the Wakefield study in that the data was not made up or falsified.
13) “MMR Vaccination and Pervasive Developmental Disorders: A Case-Control Study” The Lancet, Liam Smeeth, MRCGP, Eric Fombonne, MD (September 11, 2004). Rated a 2.
In medicine, if you want to see if there is a risk of disease in a population, you do a case control study. The two groups differ in (hopefully) one variable. In this study they compared “1294 cases and 4469 controls were included. 1010 cases (78·1%) had MMR vaccination recorded before diagnosis, compared with 3671 controls (82·1%) before the age at which their matched case was diagnosed.”
They could find no association between the MMR and autism. Fourteen studies argues that the MMR causes regression of autism, which was not the point of the study, and therefore the study is no good because it looked at the ‘wrong’ question. It is an easy and typical criticism throughout Fourteen studies: the study looked for and found no association using a given methodology. The study is no good because it didn’t look at the information Fourteen studies thought it should. Given that most studies try for a narrow focus, there will always be a component not evaluated. A common straw man argument throughout the website.
Within the context of the study, it is reasonable to conclude that the MMR is not associated with developing autism.
14) “Pervasive Developmental Disorders in Montreal, Quebec, Canada: Prevalence and Links With Immunizations”
Pediatrics, Eric Fombonne, MD (July 2006). Another issue with addition, it is rated -2.
The negative number may come from the finding that “The prevalence of pervasive developmental disorder in thimerosal free birth cohorts was significantly higher than that in thimerosal-exposed cohorts (82.7 of 10 000 vs 59.5 of 10 000).” Curious we now have several studies that showed thimerosal to be protective. Ouch.
To add insult to injury, they also found
“Pervasive developmental disorder rates significantly increased when measles-mumps-rubella vaccination uptake rates significantly decreased. In addition, pervasive developmental disorder prevalence increased at the same rate before and after the introduction in 1996 of the second measles-mumps-rubella dose, suggesting no increased risk of pervasive developmental disorder associated with a 2–measles-mumps-rubella dosing schedule before age 2 years.”
Now I feel like Truedeau. The vaccination information THEY don’t you to know: MMR and thimerosal are protective for developing autism.
They derived this information looking at 27,000 kids, 180 of whom had a pervasive developmental disorder, including autism and comparing rates of autism (which went up) with thimerosal and MMR use (both of which went down).
15) “No Evidence for a New Variant of Measles-Mumps-Rubella-Induced Autism”
Pediatrics, Eric Fombonne, FRCPsych (October 2001). A one rating.
Their insightful analysis of the article starts “What is it with Eric Fombonne and Pediatrics? ” I do not think they approve of Fombonne. Next they will accuse him for something he didn’t do (11). Not a sign of compelling science analysis and they do not give a reason for the 1 rating, the link takes one to another site for analysis. Suggesting again a mini-industry of bogus scientific ratings trying to refute the idea that MMR and autism are not related.
This study, with small numbers, compared 96 children with MMR and autism to data from other studies of children with autism before and after an MMR. Not the most compelling of methodological design (more cases are always better, especially if looking for very rare events) and looked to support 6 hypothesis:
“1. Childhood disintegrative disorder might have become more frequent;
2. The mean and distribution of age at which parents become concerned has changed and is closer to the mean immunization age than in children who were not exposed to MMR;
3. Regression in the development of children with autism has become more common;
4. The age of onset of symptoms for autistic children with regression clusters around the immunization date and is different from that of autistic children without regression;
5. Children with regressive autism may have distinct symptom and severity profiles; and
6. Regressive autism is associated with gastrointestinal symptoms, and children with regressive autism may exhibit increased frequency of inflammatory bowel disorders. “
Their data comparisons did not support any of the above. Not the most convincing data set, but in the context of the above studies, ok conclusions.
16) “No effect of MMR withdrawal on the incidence of autism: a total population study”
Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, Hideo Honda, Michael Rutter. A five.
Highest score in the group. Why?
“We gave this study our highest score because it appears to actually show that MMR contributes to higher autism rates.”
The key phrase in the whole site. Data that supports their position is good, data that doesn’t is bad. What makes a study good is not its methodology or its rigor, but if it supports vaccines casing autism. Bass Ackwards thinking.
The position that vaccines cause autism is determined, then you look for data that supports the position. When you read the studies, they do not support the position that the MMR is associated with autism.
It is doubly odd in that the paper’s conclusion is that
“The MMR vaccination rate in the city of Yokohama declined significantly in the birth cohorts of years 1988 through 1992, and not a single vaccination was administered in 1993 or thereafter. In contrast, cumulative incidence of ASD up to age seven increased significantly in the birth cohorts of years 1988 through 1996 and most notably rose dramatically beginning with the birth cohort of 1993.”
Remember reference 4? Foreshadowing.
In Yokohama they gave ZERO MMR’s after 1993. Zip. The result?
Kind of hard to argue that MMR leads to autism when autism rates continue to increase after no more MMR is given. One explanation link as to why black is really white leads to ’404 not found error,’ the other links to a web page where, as best I can gather, they argue that the MMR withdrawal lead to a decrease in autism because there was actually an increase in autism due to increase in the use of Japanese encephalitis and single measles vaccines. Which demonstrates that the increased autism rates that followed MMR removal were a decline in autism rates. I may have that wrong. Read it and let me know. Maybe the 404 site explained it better.
17) “Measles Vaccination and Antibody Response in Autism Spectrum Disorders”
Archives of Disease in Childhood, Gillian Baird (February 2008). Rated a one, they must have become distracted in the MMR section as they do not give a breakdown of how the score was derived for the last five studies.
They looked at antibody to measles as a result of MMR in autism cases and controls and found no correlation. This one study adds little to the data. It supports the lack of correlation between MMR and autism, but the last study is far more compelling.
18) “Neurologic Disorders After Measles-Mumps-Rubella Vaccination”
Pediatrics, Annamari Makela, MD (November 2002). Another zero without reason.
This study looked at 535, 544 children for neurologic events after MMR. It was more to look at encephalitis and meningitis, which were not increased as a result of the vaccine. Autism was not also seen, but, as legitimately pointed out (the one and only legitimate sentence in the whole web site) “it used “hospitalizations” as a criteria for finding children with autism.” Not a good way to find autism cases, I agree.
The last paper in the group,
Association of Autistic Spectrum Disorder and the Measles, Mumps, and Rubella Vaccine”
Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine, Eric Fombonne, FRCPsych (July 2003) is a structured review of 28 papers that fails to demonstrate a relationship between the MMR and autism.
This is really odd. Their ‘headline’ is “Fombonne again.”
But the authors of this reference are Kumanan Wilson, MD, MSc, FRCP(C); Ed Mills, DPH; Cory Ross, MSc, DPH, CHE; Jessie McGowan BMus, MLIS; Alex Jadad MD, DPhil, FRCP(C). I cut and pasted it from the reference.
For posterity’s sake, here is a screenshot before they change it:
Are they even reading the damn articles?
The full title of the article is “Association of Autistic Spectrum Disorder and the Measles, Mumps, and Rubella Vaccine
A Systematic Review of Current Epidemiological Evidence.”
The key words, left out by Fourteen studies, are ” Systematic review.” For those who do not have to read the medical literature (bold added by me),
“Systematic reviews are scientific investigations in themselves, with pre-planned methods and an assembly of original studies as their “subjects.” They synthesize the results of multiple primary investigations by using strategies that limit bias and random error. These strategies include a comprehensive search of all potentially relevant articles and the use of explicit, reproducible criteria in the selection of articles for review. Primary research designs and study characteristics are appraised, data are synthesized, and results are interpreted.”
“A systematic review involves the application of scientific strategies, in ways that limit bias, to the assembly, critical appraisal, and synthesis of all relevant studies that address a specific clinical question. (7)”
A well done Systematic review is more that a review, it is a valuable, if less than perfect, way to evaluate a literature that tries to correct for bias and for variation in study methodologies.
Finally, if you want another excellent (free) review, try Vaccines and Autism: A Tale of Shifting Hypothesis.
I read over 100 or so journal articles a month just for my Infectious Disease podcast. Plus those I read for patient care, for general interest, for the blogs. They are of variable quality, from the ground breaking to the incomprehensible. The ‘bad’ references on the fourteen studies site are by and large pretty good, especially given the methodologic, logistic and ethical problems in doing large epidemiologic studies.
In medicine, as in all of science, no single study is definitive. Epidemiologic studies in medicine are particularly messy, and researchers never do a perfect study. I am always impressed with the ingenuity and hard work on the part of epidemiologists to get good information out of complicated and incomplete data sets. You have to read all the studies in context of biologic plausibility, the flaws in a given study, reproducibility, and, yes, the financial bias of the researcher.
I would like to thank the Fourteen studies for their website. Anyone who takes the time to read all the articles will come away convinced of the safety of both thimerosal and the MMR vaccine, especially in contrast to the quality of ‘our’ studies that purport a causation. The moving target of the cause of autism appears to be shifting to aluminum and too much too soon. I’m skeptical on biologic plausibility grounds. I am as certain as I can be (i.e. I am one, preferable more, high quality studies in a high impact journal from changing my mind) that the vaccines, both separately and together, are many logs safer than the diseases they prevent.
Now I get to read the other blog entries on the topic. About time.
References
*I love the movie 28 Days Later and its sequel. Something about fast, mindless, infected zombies running amok, producing more mindless zombies with the resultant body count appeals to me. I didn’t care for Shawn of the Dead, which didn’t work as either a comedy or a zombie movie for me. But do read World War Z if you are a zombie fan.
(1) Not that I do not want to sell my soul. I do. I just set the price higher than most want to pay.
(2) In the spirit of transparency, I will admit she isn’t. A review of the Internet Movie Database suggests I have never seen her perform, but most movies I see are with my 11 year old and are animated.
(3) JAMA letters Vol 291, No 2, page 181
(4) Not enough for my taste, but I am a crank on the topic. I think everyone should have to list, in dollar amounts, all direct and indirect (travel, food etc) support they receive if they give CME accredited lectures or publish in journals
(5) I can’t download the Lancet references with paying first. I doubt the publishers will complain as it would look like they are in cahoots with Big Pharma to suppress information.
(6) I don’t really think that. It is what the data would suggest, but I can’t really see the plausibility.
(7) http://www.annals.org/cgi/content/full/126/5/376
(8) A child evidently vaccinated against reality.
(9) They do not capitalize their title, very hip edgy. For a drug company. To be really Web 2.0 it needs a random capital and a vowel removal: snoFi psTeur.
(10) Modified from Joseph McCarthy, US Senator.
(11) A literary device called foreshadowing.
(12) “I do believe sadly it’s going to take some diseases coming back to realize that we need to change and develop vaccines that are safe. If the vaccine companies are not listening to us, it’s their f___ing fault that the diseases are coming back. They’re making a product that’s s___. If you give us a safe vaccine, we’ll use it. It shouldn’t be polio versus autism.” http://www.time.com/time/health/article/0,8599,1888718,00.html

   More On Fourteen Studies
Steven Novella
Link
Recently my co-blogger David Gorski wrote an excellent analysis of the latest propaganda effort from the anti-vaccine crowd – a website that attempts to deconstruct the fourteen studies most often cited to argue for a lack of association between vaccines and autism. As David pointed out, there are many more than 14 studies which demonstrate this, and no credible studies showing that there is any correlation. David covered some of the 14 discussed studies, and today I will discuss one more.
On that anti-vaccine propaganda site J.B. Handley begins his introduction with this logical fallacy:
Of all the remarkable frauds that will one day surround the autism epidemic, perhaps one of the most galling is the simple statement that the “science has spoken” and “vaccines don’t cause autism.” Anytime a public health official or other talking head states this, you can be assured that one of two things is true: they have never read the studies they are talking about, or they are lying through their teeth.
Of course this is a false dichotomy, or forced choice. I personally know of many people, including myself and David, who have both read all the studies and are telling the truth about our opinions that they do not support a link between autism and vaccines. It seems to be inconceivable to Mr. Handley that an informed professional could honestly disagree with his opinions – such is the nature of fanaticism.
It is also remarkable that Handley himself quotes many professional, expert, and advisory bodies who also have read the studies and concluded that they overwhelmingly support the conclusion of a lack of correlation between vaccines and autism – including the Centers for Disease Control, the American Academy of Pediatrics, The American Medical Association, the Institute of Medicine, and the March of Dimes. Handley casually and self-servingly assumes that all of the professionals in these organizations are incompetent or they are lying.
And keep in mind what it would mean to lie on this issue – Handley believes that many doctors who have chosen the career path of public health are deliberately condemning millions of children to autism simply to avoid admitting past error, because they cannot face the horrible truth, or to receive their Big Pharma kickbacks. It’s no wonder their rhetoric often becomes hysterical – they really believe this is going on. For some reason it is easier for them to believe this astounding horrible claim than even consider the possibility that perhaps they have misinterpreted the science and that trained experts who have dedicated their lives to understanding the science may know better. This is what we call the “arrogance of ignorance.”
I wish to add that there are also many scientist and physician bloggers who have also taken the time to analyze the data and agree with the consensus opinion of no link. We have no dog in this hunt. David and I, for example, do not prescribe vaccines in our practice, we do not work for pharmaceutical companies, we are not involved in litigation – we have none of the conflicts of interest typically cited to discredit otherwise valid studies or opinions. Our only personal stake in this issue, as science bloggers, is our reputations, which are based upon honest and transparent analysis. We have nothing to gain and everything to lose if we are dishonest or sloppy on this issue.
You also cannot legitimately argue, as many often attempt to, that we are just protecting the status quo or that we are doing this as a favor to our colleagues. We have taken up the task of criticising our colleagues and the status quo whenever we feel it is appropriate. We are in the business of ruffling feathers. Our only stake is in defending something we firmly believe in – science-based medicine.
But the anti-vaccine fanatics simply assume we must be hiding some conflict of interest, or that we are simply incapable of seeing the Truth. That is the paranoid behavior of a cult.
With David’s post for background on the methods used, I will add to his analysis one more of the studies in question.
Madsen 2003 Danish Study
Madsen et al evaluated autism rates in Denmark from 1971 – 2000. From 1961 – 1970 children received 400 micrograms of thimerosal. From 1971-1992 they received 250 micrograms of thimerosal. After 1992 all thimerosal was removed from childhood vaccines in Denmark. The study identified 962 children with autism over this period. They found that from 1970 to 1990 there was no change in the incidence of autism. After 1990 autism rates began to increase, which was attributed to expanding diagnosis and surveillance. These numbers generally match the experience in other Western nations.
The authors conclude that there was no association in their study between thimerosal dose and autism rates. This is the same as the experience so far in the US – thimerosal was removed by 2002 and yet autism rates continued to rise without a blip.
The “fourteen studies” site gives this study a score of 1 on their rigged scale. There main criticism is that in 1994 outpatient records were used in addition to inpatient records to assess autism incidence. By itself this is a legitimate criticism, but it does no invalidate the study as they suggest. This is a potential weakness of retrospective studies – researchers are somewhat dependent on the consistency of methods used over the years in study. The authors of this study were completely up front about the changing methods over time and the potential impact on their data.
But anti-vaccine critics miss a couple of very important points. First, if thimerosal were a significant contributor to autism rates then we would expect (as with all toxins) a dose response effect. In 1970 the dose of thimerosal in the Danish vaccine schedule was reduced from 400 to 250 micrograms. This did not result in a decrease in autism rates 3-7 years later as one would predict from the thimerosal hypothesis. Autism rates were stable during this time, and there are no concerns about altering methods of diagnosis or counting during this time.
Second – Madsen and his co-authors were well aware of the effects of altering counting methods in their study. Therefore they did the following:
In additional analyses we examined data using inpatients only. This was done to elucidate the contribution of the outpatient registration to the change in incidence. The same trend with an increase in the incidence rates from 1990 until the end of the study period was see.
So they did a reasonable assessment of the effect of adding outpatient to inpatient records on their data by looking at the inpatient data alone, and they found the same trend. This completely invalidates the criticism of this study by the anti-vaccine crowd, which is premised on the fact that the increasing rates of autism after 1990 were due to the addition of outpatient records.
The bottom line is that this study shows no correlation between changing doses of thimerosal and autism rates. It does reveal an increase in autism rates beginning in the early 1990s resulting from expanded diagnosis and surveillance. It is interesting that the anti-vaccine critics use that very fact to argue that this study is not valid. Yet otherwise they deny that increasing autism rates are due to these factors because it is their claim that the increase in autism rates were due to vaccines. They therefore directly contradict themselves.
In addition to a lack of correlation between thimerosal and autism, this study supports the conclusion that the rise of autism rates in the 1990s and beyond are due to changes in the definition of autism and efforts to make the diagnosis in the population. That is the common element between Denmark and the US. Exposure to thimerosal and the vaccine schedule differed between these two countries, and yet autism rates were similar. Thimerosal and vaccines are not the common element in the rise of autism diagnoses – definition and surveillance are. So this data becomes much more powerful evidence against a link between autism and vaccines when it is considered in the context of US data.
The “fourteen studies” website declares:
Where is the truth? Like everything else in life, the devil is in the details.
It is indeed.

   Welcome back, my friends, to the show that never ends, part II: Generation Rescue, the anti-vaccine propaganda machine, and “Fourteen Studies”
David Gorski
Link
I hadn’t planned on writing about the antivaccine movement again this week, so soon after having had to subject myself to yet another round of Jenny McCarthy on Larry King Live and a truly execrable Generation Rescue “study.” I really hadn’t. For one thing, there’s just so much nonsense laid down by antivaccinationists these days that it’s utterly impossible for one blogger to keep up with it all. I could write about them every single day and still not counter the sheer mass of pseudoscience, misinformation, and general ignorance that antivaccine activists spout each and every day, and because this is Autism Awareness Month lately the misinformation has been coming particularly fast and furiously. Sometimes, however, there arrives a bit of misinformation that is so egregious that it requires some response, regardless of how burned out on the topic I might be; so I guess I’ll just have to suck it up and plunge into the morass again.
The reason is that, in retrospect, I now realize that the Jenny and Jim antivaccine propaganda tour was clearly merely phase I of Generation Rescue’s April public relations offensive. In rapid succession last week, courtesy of J.B. Handley, the founder of Generation Rescue, who in order to have a couple of famous faces fronting his organization has allowed himself to be displaced, so that Generation Rescue has now been “reborn” as Jenny McCarthy and Jim Carrey’s Autism Organization (the better to capitalize on her D-list celebrity yoked to Jim Carrey’s formerly A-list (but rapidly plunging) celebrity), announced Generation Rescue’s latest initiative in a post on its antivaccine blog Age of Autism entitled Fourteen Studies? Only if you never read them.:
For me, it all started when Amanda Peet said the following in her “apology” to calling parents parasites:
“Fourteen studies have been conducted (both here in the US and abroad), and these tests are reproducible; no matter where they are administered, or who is funding them, the conclusion is the same: there is no association between autism and vaccines.”
And, don’t think Amanda Peet is alone, the mantra comes fast and furious from all sides…
These comments were driving me nuts. I’d read a majority of the studies they were referring to, I knew how bad they were, and I also knew that most journalists couldn’t even find the studies being referred to, because most weren’t even on the web!!
Several hundred hours of work later, Generation Rescue is pleased to introduce a website with a very simple purpose: to tell the truth. You will find every study in its entirety and a whole lot more right here:
www.fourteenstudies.org
Before I dive in, let me just point out right here and right now that J.B. Handley wouldn’t be able to recognize good science if it bit him on the posterior. Ditto bad science, because he simply does not have an understanding of the scientific method or the methodology involved that would allow him to distinguish good from bad science. His well-known arrogance of ignorance leads him to be very confident that he knows as much or more than the pointy-headed scientists, whom he clearly despises and for whom he clearly has little but contempt, and can thus judge the quality of complicated epidemiology and basic science, but he clearly does not. That’s why Mr. Handley’s claim that he recognized these studies to be bad science by reading them made me chuckle heartily. After all, Mr. Handley’s proven time and time again that he doesn’t understand science, the scientific method, or epidemiology, and I find the picture that pops into my mind of Mr. Handley poring over epidemiological and scientific studies, carefully making note of the methodology and picking out the flaws almost as outlandish as Jenny McCarthy’s transformation from an “Indigo Mom” to a “warrior mom” for autistic children. That’s because J.B. also understands nothing about clinical trials and especially the ethics of clinical trials, one particularly egregious example of which I should someday post about. Be that as it may, right off the bat, I knew that this “Fourteen Studies” initiative was likely to be more of the same. The claim that it took “several hundred hours of work” is probably true, but, given the results, but it clearly wasn’t time and money well spent, at least on an intellectual level. Whether it was time and money well spent in terms of producing effective propaganda remains to be seen.
Taking a general view of the Fourteen Studies, I note that it’s divided broadly into what I can’t help but refer to “studies antivaccinationists hate” (because they are for the most part large, well-designed epidemiological studies that found no association between thimerosal and autism or vaccines and autism) and “studies antivaccinationists like.” Of this latter category, the studies listed that I recognize include some small preliminary studies (which are more prone to false positives), more than a fair amount of cluelessness (the Generation Rescue “vaxed versus antivaxed” phone survey, which I’ll discuss more later), the incompetent (pretty much anything by Andrew Wakefield or Mark and David Geier), or execrable (anything published in the vanity Medical Hypotheses, which discourages the publication of data and will publish virtually article as long as it presents a provocative and speculative hypothesis, making it a “what if?” speculative journal and not a serious research journal , or the crank journal, the Journal of American Physicians and Surgeons (JPANDS), whose penchant for antivaccine pseudoscience I’ve discussed in depth before on this very blog). Heavy hitters in the world of vaccine or autism science, these are not. (Hint: If you want to be taken seriously in the world of medical science, don’t cite JPANDS. Really. Don’t. Doing so is a deal breaker. Also, citing articles from Medical Hypotheses as though they were evidence of anything other than the author’s speculative flights of scientific fancy shows more cluelessness than anything else.)
I also recognize that a lot of these criticisms are the same old dubious, exaggerated, and/or fallacious criticisms of these studies that have been floating around in antivaccine circles for a long time. I recognize them because I have read nearly all of these articles myself, both the ones Generation Rescue likes and the ones it doesn’t like, over the years, and I have seen these “criticism” True, I’m more familiar with some of these studies than others, but in fact I have even blogged about some of them, here and elsewhere. (I will link to such posts where appropriate.) In essence, what I plan to do is to set the stage by discussing the overall intellectual dishonesty that underpins Fourteen Studies and then take a few (I hope) well-chosen examples to illustrate this intellectual dishonesty. Over the coming days, it is my hope that some of my fellow SBM bloggers will take on other examples, explaining the fallacies behind the “critiques” and why the “studies antivaccinationists like” are, by and large, not very good and/or do not show what antivaccinationists think they show.
We do this because we realize that the Fourteen Studies website is going to metastasize all over the web. That is clearly Mr. Handley’s intent; he saw what he feared to be an effective public relations gambit from scientists and physicians, and he couldn’t let that go unanswered. To him, it’s not about the science, but winning the P.R. war. That’s why we know that antivaccinists will be referring journalists to it, if they have not already begun to do so. We also predict that antivaccine parents will be planting printouts of it in front of their pediatricians in order to try to persuade them that the evidence base supporting the consensus that vaccines do not cause autism is hopelessly corrupt and weak. We realize that this is exactly the purpose of Generation Rescue’s new website, which is why we believe that there should be as many rebuttals on the web to which people can be referred as possible. In fact, it is my hope that our readers will help us out by deconstructing some of the studies in the comments, and that readers who happen to be bloggers will join in this effort by applying some evidence-based criticism to the site. Unfortunately, here at SBM can’t afford to spend the hundreds of hours that Generation Rescue spent on this website in order to counter the misinformation there. We do not have the time, nor do we have the money to pay someone to do it, as Generation Rescue apparently does.
“RANKING” CRITERIA THAT GUARANTEE THE OUTCOME
First, let’s take a look at how Generation Rescue “ranks” these 14 studies. This alone should show you more than anything else why this site is propaganda, not science. Whoever put it together first ranked the studies on a scale of 40 points, made up of four 10-point subscales. The first of these subscales is described thusly:
Asked the Right Question (0-10 points):
Did the study actually contemplate the real world example of a parent vaccinating their child with 5 or more vaccines and then seeing a regression into autism afterward? Did it contemplate something close to that which could be helpful and generalized? A perfect question received a 10, a study that didn’t even contemplate the question at hand received a zero.
See what I mean? This is, of course, not the “right question” at all, other than in the minds of antivaccinationists who have already made up their minds about the answer. This is, in essence, an appeal to anecdotal evidence (“contemplate the real world example”) framed in the most “dramatic” way possible, full of inflammatory language about “five or more vaccines.” The right question is, rather, whether or not there is an association or correlation between autism and vaccination. Also, note how vague and subjective this scale is. What determines how close to the “right” question a hypothesis will be ranked, apparently, is whether it sounds good to the Generation Rescue antivaccinationist who ranked it. Certainly there do not appear to be anything resembling objective criteria, which are essential for any sort of scale like this. I also note with some amusement that one of the studies included as “Our Studies” on this website, namely a 2006 study by Raymond Palmer looking at whether proximity to coal-fueled power plants is associated with increased prevalence of autism, would get a zero on this scale, as it didn’t even look at vaccines at all! It was also a really crappy study, as I discussed extensively a few months ago during a deconstruction of Palmer’s followup study. At least Generation Rescue could have cited Palmer’s 2008 followup study instead, which, while not very good at all, was at least not as spectacularly awful as his 2006 study, which didn’t even bother to try to control for some very obvious confounders. Apparently asking the “right” question doesn’t really matter to Generation Rescue if J.B. Handley likes the answer.
Next, Generation Rescue lists:
Conflict of Interest (0-10 points):
We considered a scientist employed by a vaccine maker or a study sponsored by a vaccine maker to have the highest degree of conflict, with a public health organization (like the CDC) to be the second-worst. A conflict free study would receive a 10, a study rife with conflicts as low as zero.
This one really annoyed me, because I’ve discussed on at least a couple of occasions how rife with conflicts of interest are many of the “studies” used by antivaccine advocates to support their point of view. For example, the grossly incompetent “study” by Generation Rescue that I discussed last week and that is featured on Fourteen Studies was commissioned and performed by an organization whose raison d’être is to convince lawmakers and the public that vaccines cause autism and that “biomedical treatments” targeted at “vaccine injury” can cure autism. If that’s not a conflict of interest, I don’t know what is. The same is true of an awful study of vaccination in monkeys by Laura Hewitson (which I blogged about several months ago and that Generation Rescue widely promoted, but apparently decided to leave off of its latest propaganda initiative even though it would get a 10 out of 10 on “asking the right question” by Generation Rescue’s definition. (Maybe the criticisms stung.) After all, Laura Hewitson is not only married to antivaccine hero Andrew Wakefield’s IT director but she and her husband are complainants in the Autism Omnibus proceedings, which led me and others to wonder at the time if their “monkey study” was in fact done explicitly to provide more ammunition for the test cases under consideration by the Vaccine Court at the time.
Finally, let’s not forget Mark and David Geier, both of whom have much invested in the concept that mercury in vaccines causes autism and advocate, in essence, chemical castration with Lupron as a “treatment” for autism to help “free” the mercury from testosterone and allow it to be chelated more effectively. In fact, they took conflicts of interest to whole new levels undreamt of by even the most cynical, greedy, and amoral big pharma executive when they specially created an IRB and stacked it with their cronies in order to approve “studies” of their Lupron therapy. Any of their studies would get a zero on this the conflict of interest scale. Heck, they’d get negative scores! And all of this doesn’t even count Andrew Wakefield, who was shown by Brian Deer not only to have been an incompetent scientists, but in the pocket of trial lawyers suing vaccine manufacturers for “vaccine injury.” Worse, these are undisclosed conflicts of interest, whereas any conflict of interest listed in the “fourteen studies” was disclosed right there on the manuscript. In marked contrast, it took Brian Deer years to dig up Andrew Wakefield’s blatant conflicts of interest; Kathleen Seidel’s digging to unearth the Geiers’ abuse of the IRB process; and the digging of several bloggers to figure out Laura Hewitson’s undisclosed conflict of interest in being a plaintiff in the Autism Omnibus. If there’s one rule of thumb in medical research, it’s that undisclosed conflicts of interest correctly raise far more suspicion of bias than disclosed ones do.
Cleverly, Generation Rescue disingenuously inoculates itself from charges of picking studies with huge conflicts of interest by narrowly defining a conflict of interest the way that it wants to: As an investigator’s only being affiliated with a vaccine maker or the CDC. (Because, you know, antivaccine warriors can’t possibly ever have a conflict of interest.) Then, to guarantee that every study that it doesn’t like has an irretrievable “conflict of interest,” even if there is no pharmaceutical company connection, Generation Rescue appears to consider the mere fact of the lead investigator working for the NIH to be a severe conflict of interest. That is what is listed as the sole conflict of interest for Dr. Karen Nelson, who wrote a review article on thimerosal and autism. If that’s not enough to guarantee a “conflict of interest” for all of these “fourteen studies,” Generation Rescue also appears to define the mere fact of being funded through grants from the CDC, NIH, American Academy of Pediatrics, or the Canadian Institutes for Health Research. Scientists who have had NIH grants (such as myself) or grants from any of these other organizations know just how ridiculous considering that funding source to be a horrific conflict of interest is. After all, such grants are in general competitive grants awarded after rigorous peer review, and the NIH, for example, exercises almost no control over how researchers funded through it do their work, other than enforcing federal regulations on animal and human subjects welfare by refusing to disburse funds until the appropriate approvals are in place.
Next up, Generation Rescue ranks the ability to generalize and post-publication criticism:
Ability to Generalize (0-10 points):
This was a measure of the robustness, replicability, and usefulness of the study. Where possible, we looked to experts to help us gauge this ranking. The more robust, replicable, and broadly applicable, the higher the score.
Post-Publication Criticism (0-10 points):
Was the study widely accepted in the scientific community, or was it the subject of extreme criticisms from many sources? The closer to widely accepted, the closer to 10 points.
One wonders why Generation Rescue didn’t always look to experts to gauge this ranking. After all, neither J.B. Handley, Jenny McCarthy, nor Jim Carrey are scientists. In fact, they have shown time and time again that they are clueless about science. Any conclusion by them or the other antivaccine warriors at Generation Rescue on the generalizability of a study would be highly suspect even giving them every benefit of the doubt. As part of this propaganda effort, forget it. Also, one can’t help but note that the “experts” Generation Rescue does find happen to be antivaccinationists like Boyd Haley, the former chairman of the Department of Chemistry at the University of Kentucky whose academic career imploded as a result of his having delved too deeply for too long into mercury and vaccines pseudoscience (as well as “toxic teeth” amalgam pseudoscience), or Mark Geier, whose protocol that uses Lupron to treat autism is, in my considered opinion, dangerous quackery. In other cases, the “experts” are nothing more than some of J.B. Handley’s fellow antivaccine activists with no special scientific or medical training: Sallie Bernard of SafeMinds or Deirdre Imus–or even J.B. Handley himself. Such are Generation Rescue’s “experts”! Clearly, the talent pool of “experts” at Generation Rescue is not particularly deep. One wonders why Generation Rescue didn’t draft Jim Carrey or Jenny McCarthy to do a critique of one of these articles.
Also, it’s extremely disingenuous of Generation Rescue to rank these studies on “post-publication criticism” because it is the antivaccine movement, including Generation Rescue, that accounted for the vast majority of criticisms of these articles (most were not particularly controversial among scientists). Indeed, the antivaccine movement encouraged criticism at every turn. In most cases, Generation Rescue is conflating criticisms based on ideology with scientific criticisms, which is how they keep the vaccine/autism manufactroversy alive. One can’t help but note again that, if post publication criticism were a major criterion by which Generation Rescue’s favored studies should be judged, Andrew Wakefield’s 1998 Lancet study was disavowed by 10 of its original 13 authors and ultimately utterly repudiated by the scientific community–and deservedly so! Yet there it is on the “Our Studies” page of Fourteen Studies. Apparently only criticism by the antivaccine movement counts as a negative to Generation Rescue. Criticism by scientists? Apparently not so much.
ON TO SOME OF THE “FOURTEEN STUDIES”
Mady Hornig’s 2008 study
Even though it was obvious from the start that this website is every bit as much propaganda as the Green Our Vaccines rally in Washington, DC last year, still I wanted to see what Generation Rescue said about some of the studies. So I picked a few that I am quite familiar with. First, off, I noticed that Mady Hornig’s study from last fall that tried to replicate Andrew Wakefield’s original Lancet study that implicated the MMR vaccine in the pathogenesis of “regressive” autism and enterocolitis. You might remember this one too. You might also recognize that all Generation Rescue did was to regurgitate old attacks by Andrew Wakefield, SafeMinds, and the National Autism Association on it. You may also recall that I blogged about this study shortly after it was published and showed you why these criticisms were, scientifically speaking, a load of horse hockey. Suffice it to say, they have not aged well.
The 2009 Italian study
Another study included on the list is an Italian study that came out this year by Tozzi et al, which was published in the February issue of Pediatrics and entitled Neuropsychological Performance 10 Years After Immunization in Infancy With Thimerosal-Containing Vaccines. The study was done in Italy, and one of its great advantages is that the amount of thimerosal to which the infants were exposed was actually known, unlike many epidemiological studies, where sometimes the dose of thimerosal (and therefore mercury) has to be estimated or inferred from the vaccine schedule at the time.
The reason is that the children studied were children who had taken part in a randomized study of two different diptheria-tetanus-acellular-pertuss (DTaP) vaccines, one that contained thimerosal and one that did not:
In 1992-1993, 15,601 healthy, 2-month-old infants were enrolled in the Italian Trial on Pertussis Vaccines. 18-20 In this trial, infants were selected from the general population in 4 of Italy’s 20 regions (Fig 1) and were assigned randomly to receive, under double-blind conditions, 3 doses of 1 of 4 vaccines, 2 of which were DTaP vaccines from 2 different manufacturers. One DTaP vaccine contained 50 μ g of thimerosal (or 25 μ g of ethylmercury) per dose, and the other was thimerosal-free (2-phenoxyethanol was used as preservative). The 3 doses of DTaP vaccine were administered at 2, 4, and 6 months of age. To comply with Italy’s vaccination schedule, all children also received 3 doses of hepatitis B virus vaccine (child formulation), each of which contained 25 μ g of thimerosal (or 12.5 μg of ethylmercury), at 2, 4, and 12 months of age, and a fourth dose of diphtheriatetanus vaccine, which contained 50 μg of thimerosal (or 25 g of ethylmercury), at 11 months of age…Therefore, in the first 12 months of life, the cumulative intake of ethylmercury, the mercury metabolite of thimerosal, was 137.5 μg for the children who were assigned randomly to receive the DTaP vaccine that contained thimerosal (“higher intake group”) and 62.5 μ g for those who received the thimerosal- free DTaP vaccine (“lower intake group”).
Ten years later, the children from this study living in the Veneto Region were studied. 1,403 children (697 belonging to the high thimerosal group and 706 belonging to the low thimerosal group) were recruited and subjected to a battery of eleven neurodevelopmental tests that produced a total of 24 neuropsychological outcomes to assess their development. The results were unsurprising and very much like the results of a study of thimerosal-containing vaccines as a risk factor for neurodevelopmental disorders other than autism that was published a year and a half ago. Most outcome measures showed no difference between the low and high thimerosal group, and the ones that did were small and entirely compatible with random chance due to multiple comparisons.
I knew at the time exactly what antivaccine activists would probably say when and if they get around to attacking this study, and, in fact, that’s basically the criticism on Fourteen Studies. (Most depressingly, Generation Rescue even reprints J.B. Handley’s scientifically illiterate criticism of the study.) In any case, the main criticism is that there was not a control group receiving no thimerosal. True enough. The authors themselves make that very point. However, if thimerosal in vaccines were associated with autism, one would not expect that it would be different than any other toxin associated with an abnormality, disease, or condition in that it would be expected that the chance of autism or neurodevelopmental disorders would increase with increasing dose.
The second argument that I thought advocates would try to make but that Generation Rescue actually did not make is that the dose-response curve for mercury and autism has a plateau, and that plateau is below 62.5 μg, hence the lack of difference between the two groups. There’s just one problem with that argument. An exposure to 62.5 μg, to which the low exposure group was exposed, corresponds to roughly the total dose of mercury in thimerosal to which American infants were exposed in 1989–before the alleged “autism epidemic.” Even if mercury does indeed cause autism and there is indeed a plateau in the dose-response below a dose of 62.5 μg, that would not be consistent with the antivaxers’ other pet claim, that an autism epidemic started in the 1990s because of the increasing amount of thimerosal exposure due to vaccines. That couldn’t have happened if a dose of thimerosal less than 62.5 μg maxed out the risk of autism, because 62.5 μg below the baseline exposure before the alleged “autism epidemic” started. The two claims (that of an autism epidemic in the 1990s due to increasing amounts of thimerosal in vaccines versus that of an effect that maxes out before a 62.5 μg cumulative dose of mercury from thimerosal) are mutually contradictory. I suppose antivaccinationists could postulate a threshold effect that doesn’t occur until a dose above 137.5 μg. Unfortunately for them, then they would have the problem of how long they ranted that any mercury was toxic and any mercury was unacceptable, not to mention the–shall we say?–inconvenient epidemiological evidence that autism rates did not plummet back to 1980s levels after 2001, which was when thimerosal was removed from most childhood vaccines and mercury exposure from vaccines plummeted to well under 62.5 μg.
Finally, the most ironic thing about this study is the question of why autism prevalence was so low among the Italian population studied. Of course, as Generation Rescue points out, all of the subjects received at least 62.5 μg mercury from their vaccines; so by antivaccinationist logic there should have been a much larger prevalence of autism, particularly among the Italian children who received 137.5 μg mercury. There wasn’t. The prevalence was much lower than in the U.S., which also rather undermines the claims Generation Rescue made in its recent “vaccines by nation” nonsense. So much for “mercury poisoning,” at least in this case.
The 2008 Schechter study
Antivaccinationists really, really hate this study because it looked at a very specific prediction that naturally follows from the hypothesis that mercury in the thimerosal preservative in vaccines was a major cause of the “autism epidemic.” I say “was” because by early 2002, thimerosal had been removed from the vast majority of vaccines, and this allows the testing of the hypothesis. Specifically, the prediction is that, if thimerosal in vaccines was indeed a major cause of autism, autism incidence should have plummeted within a few years after it was removed. This study showed that there is no evidence that the apparent rise in autism is even plateauing yet in California. In a truly fun bit of additional irony, this study even uses the California Department of Developmental Services (CDDS) database, to which David Kirby has often referred as a good way of looking at whether autism rates have started falling since thimerosal was removed from most vaccines. He has also since been moving the goalposts as to when he would expect autism rates to begin falling if the thimerosal hypthesis is true, going first from 2005 to 2007 and, most recently, to 2011.
In order to ask the question of whether autism rates had declined, Schechter and Grether examined data for clients with active status reported from January 1, 1995 to March 31, 2007. Using careful statistical analyses, they used two approaches to measure the occurrence of ASD during this period. The second approach, in which ASD prevalence was determined in the 3 to 5 year old cohort, is perhaps the most informative. It shows a continuing increase in autism prevalence without even a blip or decrease in the rate of increase after 2002. Indeed, showing the skill of some bloggers to analyze the same data, the money figure in the paper (Figure 3) looks almost exactly the same as the graph prepared in early 2007, a continually increasing curve since 1995. This result is not only consistent with multiple other published and unpublished studies, including the famous (or, if you’re an antivaccinationist, infamous) Danish and Canadian studies, but it is about as unambiguous evidence as can be obtained from a database like the CDDS database. Indeed, despite the known limitations of the use of this database, it is an excellent example of proponents of a “mercury injury” hypothesis of autism being “hoisted by their own petard,” so to speak. Even more amusingly, one of the criticisms of the study was written by Deirdre Imus, who has been known to regularly lay down some of the more–shall we say?–easily refuted antivaccinationist canards, all cloaked in “concern for the children,” is one of the “experts” refuting this study, while Boyd Haley wrote a long rant that is mostly a non sequitur.
The complaints about this study from antivaccinationists can be boiled down to one: That mercury hasn’t been completely eliminated from childhood vaccines. In other words, even though mercury has been removed from all mandated childhood vaccines other than the flu vaccine (and there are thimerosal-free versions of the flu vaccine available), leaving only trace thimerosal in the current set of vaccines, according to antivaccinationists that’s not enough. To them, mercury is just that toxic, and even the trace levels left in the vaccines are enough to keep the “autism epidemic” moving in a steadily upward direction. This is an utterly fallacious criticism for exactly the same reasons the criticisms of the Italian study listed above are similarly fallacious. Once again, remember that the “mercury hypothesis” states that an “autism epidemic” began in the late 1980s/early 1990s after the government expanded the number of mandated vaccines containing thimerosal. A consequence of that claim is that we should expect late 1980s/early 1990s levels of autism to be associated with a certain dose of mercury in vaccines, which, as you remember, was approximately 60-75 μg in 1989–by antivaccinationist Mark Blaxill’s own estimates! With now thimerosal removed from all vaccines save the flu vaccine (which many children still don’t get anyway), all that is present in the total vaccine dose received by children is a level of mercury less than what children received in 1989. So, in the world of antivaccinationists, lowering the level of total mercury received in vaccines by children to a level lower than what children received 20 years ago (before the “autism epidemic”) is still too toxic. (Consistency has never been the antivaccine movement’s strong suit.) Unfortunately, by the antivaccinationists’ own arguments, if the graph that Mark Blaxill likes to show represents not just correlation but causation, the dose-response curve for mercury must be such that the level in 1989 resulted in a relatively low level of autism; therefore, lowering it to levels below those seen in 1989 should result in a dramatic decrease in autism rates–again, using the mercury militia’s own numbers.
It didn’t. Stick a fork in the mercury-thimerosal-autism hypothesis. It’s quite done.
Thompson et al, 2007
This study did not specifically look at autism, but was the first publication of a larger study looking at neurodevelopmental outcomes after vaccination using data from the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD) database, a massive database overseen by the CDC and maintained through several large HMOs that collects data on vaccination outcomes. The first publication, Thompson et al, looked at whether there were adverse neurodevelopmental outcomes other than autism that could be identified as being correlated with thimerosal-containing vaccines. A second study looking specifically at autism using the VSD is in the works.
The authors found weak associations between thimerosal and developmental outcomes that were most consistent with being due to chance. It is true that there were some negative correlations found that achieved statistical significance. However, when running 42 tests, it would be shocking if there were not a few anomalous associations. What makes the study authors confident that the findings are anomalous is that they were divided roughly equally in both directions, good and bad. It is true that there were some negative correlations found that achieved statistical significance. When running 42 tests, it would be shocking if there were not a few anomalous findings. What makes the study authors fairly confident that the findings are anomalous is that they were divided roughly equally in both directions, good and bad. Consequently, if antivaccinationists are going to insist that the correlation, for example, with increasing mercury exposure and poorer performance on the GFTA-2 measure of speech articulation test is real and due to likely causation, then it must also accept the findings of a beneficial association between mercury and identification of letters and numbers on the WJ-III test, as there is no scientific reason to reject it. Even Autism Speaks, one of the “guest commentators” in Fourteen Studies, concedes this but tries to latch onto these few findings as being somehow significant.
Another important aspect of this study is that Sallie Bernard of SafeMinds, was a panelist on the consulting board that helped design this study. She pulled out when the results weren’t what she had been hoping for and has been criticizing the study ever since, up to and including being one of the “guest commenters” on this article for Generation Rescue. Her complaint is the most ridiculous of all, specifically that the study
comprised children who were least likely to exhibit neuropsychological impairments. Specifically, children with congenital problems, those from multiple births, those of low birth weight, and those not living with their biological mother were excluded. The sample was skewed toward higher socioeconomic status and maternal education — factors that are associated with lower rates of neurobehavioral problems and higher intervention rates and that were not measured.
Ms. Bernard is too scientifically illiterate to realize that that’s because the hypothesis being studied was that mercury in vaccines is associated with neurodevelopmental problems in normal children. Remember, in virtually all of the testimonials about regressions after vaccines, parents insist that their child was absolutely, positively normal before those horrible pediatricians pumped them full of those nasty, toxic, autism-causing vaccines. In fact, this study was looking at exactly the “right question.” Also (and arguably more importantly for the study design) children with congenital problems and of multiple births or of low birth weight have a higher baseline level of neurodevelopmental problems. Including such children would have (1) made it difficult to determine whether thimerosal actually was associated with neurodevelopmental difficulties because the effect size could well be dwarfed by the baseline levels of neurodevelopmental disorders in this population and (2) introduced confounders that would have been very difficult to control for in the final statistical analysis.
In any case, Ms. Bernard is being intellectually dishonest to an extreme. She participated in the design of the study but never criticized its design until after its results contradicted her expectations. Does anyone think she would have had a problem with this study if it had come back less resoundingly negative, with even a bit of wiggle room? Such is the intellectual dishonesty of the antivaccine movement and a major reason why it was always a bad idea for the government to include antivaccinationists in the the decision-making process about anything in the name of “inclusion” and the hopes that if they had a stake in the outcome they would be more constructive. The government hoped to shut up antivaccinationists by including them on such panels; it should have realized that they would turn on the government as soon as it didn’t get its way or as soon as scientific studies in whose design they participated failed to yield the results craved by the antivaccine movement.
AN EXAMPLE OF “GOOD” VACCINE STUDIES, ACCORDING TO GENERATION RESCUE
Before I conclude, I was curious to note what Generation Rescue apparently considers to be “good” studies. I already mentioned some of the awful studies, such as those by Andrew Wakefield or Mark and David Geier, that Generation Rescue likes. One study from 2009 included on the list is one I haven’t seen before, and I may well write about it on its own, as it makes a provocative but, in my opinion, ultimately highly doubtful conclusion.
One constant refrain of antivaccinationists is that there should be a study of “unvaccinated” versus “vaccinated” children. Never mind that they never quite state the hypothesis that such a study would study and sometimes even suggest utterly unethical studies, such as a randomized double-blind, placebo-controlled study. Such a study, although methodologically rigorous, would be completely unethical because it would leave the control group unprotected against vaccine-preventable diseases. Nonetheless, that doesn’t stop Generation Rescue from listing as number two its utterly risible and badly executed telephone study from 2007.
Kevin Leitch did an excellent job of deconstructing the numerical shenanigans in the poll that lead GR to boldly claim things like:
All vaccinated boys, compared to unvaccinated boys:
    • Vaccinated boys were 155% more likely to have a neurological disorder (RR 2.55)
    • Vaccinated boys were 224% more likely to have ADHD (RR 3.24)
    • Vaccinated boys were 61% more likely to have autism (RR 1.61)
Older vaccinated boys, ages 11-17 (about half the boys surveyed), compared to older unvaccinated boys:
    • Vaccinated boys were 158% more likely to have a neurological disorder (RR 2.58)
    • Vaccinated boys were 317% more likely to have ADHD (RR 4.17)
    • Vaccinated boys were 112% more likely to have autism (RR 2.12)
(Note: RR means “relative risk,” which in this poll is the ratio of the percentage of the condition of interest in the group of interest to the percentage found in the control population, in this case the allegedly “completely” unvaccinated.)
I’m not going to go over the same ground that Kevin Leitch so ably covered when the poll first came out, specifically the numbers. Kevin did a good job with the details showing that the “finding” are not nearly as impressive as they are represented to be. Particularly amusing is the observation that, for several of the groups, the “partially vaccinated” (whatever that means; it’s not defined) had apparently higher numbers of parents reporting autism or ASD but with parents of fully vaccinated children reporting numbers the same or lower than the unvaccinated, leading him to drolly observe:
There’s no getting away from this. This is a disaster for Generation Rescue and the whole ‘vaccines cause autism’ debacle. Generation Rescue’s data indicates that you are ‘safer’ from autism if you fully vaccinate than partially vaccinate. It also indicates that across the spectrum of autism, you are only 1% more likely to be autistic if you have had any sort of vaccination as oppose to no vaccinations at all – and thats only if you are male. If you are a girl you chances of being on the spectrum are less if you have been vaccinated! Across both boys and girls, your chances of being on the spectrum are less if you have received all vaccinations.
Of course, what the results actually suggest is a reporting bias in the phone survey in which parents whose children developed autism or an ASD and who believed vaccines might have been responsible stopped vaccinating, thus falling into the “partially vaccinated” group. Kevin’s also kindly converted the locked PDF with the raw data supplied by J. B. Handley into an Excel spreadsheet that allows more easy analysis of the figures. Some commenters ran some statistical tests on the raw data for various groups. Not surprisingly, the results were not statistically significant in nearly all cases. I looked at a few groups myself and did a few chi squared tests, and I failed to find any statistically significant differences either. I will admit that I did this only to sample the data; I have better things to do with my time than an exhaustive analysis.
Given that background, I’d like to step back a bit and look at the big picture. This phone poll is fatally flawed as a medical study for several reasons. First, note how there are now more diagnoses being looked at. Given Generation Rescue’s previous concentration on autism almost exclusively, I found it striking that ADD and ADHD were in the mix. In one row, ADD, ADHD, autism, and ASDs were all combined into one group, even though there is no etiological or logical reason to do so. Generation Rescue refers to this as “neurologic” diagnoses, but then why did the survey limit itself to just the above? After all, mental retardation is a neurological diagnosis. Seizure disorders are neurological diagnoses. It makes very little sense.
In reality, the whole enterprise was nothing more than one huge case of doing multiple comparisons and seeing if anything shakes out. Remember, at the 95% confidence level there’s still a 5% chance that any seemingly “positive” result that is found is in reality due to chance alone. The more groups looked at and compared, the more chances of a spurious result that isn’t “real.” There are statistical methods for controlling for multiple comparisons, but there’s no evidence that I can find that they were done for this poll. My best guess is that this survey was nothing more than a sloppily conducted fishing expedition where they didn’t even bother to control for multiple comparisons. Moreover, doing what is in essence subgroup analysis is dubious when only around 6% of the children (a reassuring figure, actually) were totally unvaccinated, as it makes the numbers of unvaccinated in many of the subgroups too small to be statistically useful (not that that stopped Generation Rescue from slicing and dicing the group any which way it could to extract more probably spurious “correlations”). I’m not even entirely convinced that the 991 unvaccinated children supposedly identified by this poll represent a big enough sample. Moreover, the poll concludes that there is no increased risk of autism or other ASDs in girls due to vaccination, which makes me wonder if J. B. will change his tune and urge girls, at least, to be vaccinated.
Another problem with the poll is how the vaccinated group was divided into “partially vaccinated” versus “fully vaccinated.” For one thing, the definition of “fully vaccinated” would not be the same in all age groups, given that the recommended vaccination schedule changes periodically based on new recommendations from the CDC and the American Academy of Pediatrics. Second, “partially vaccinated” would encompass a huge range of possibilities, from children who only received one or two recommended vaccinations to those who received all but one. It’s an almost meaningless distinction, particularly in a phone survey. The only sort of study for which separating the vaccinated into two groups like that might be useful is one in which investigators can review the vaccination records of the subjects polled and know who got exactly what vaccines. No doubt J. B. was hoping to find some sort of dose-response curve, with increasing levels of neurologic diagnoses as one goes from unvaccinated, to partially vaccinated, to fully vaccinated. That makes it all the more hilarious that the results show in many groups equal percentages of diagnoses in the unvaccinated and fully vaccinated groups, with the peak percentages reported being in the partially vaccinated group and suggests that the real comparison that should have been made was one that wasn’t: between the completely unvaccinated and patients who had gotten any vaccines (partially vaccinated + fully vaccinated). Of course, again, this also suggests a reporting bias, where parents who think their children’s problems stem from vaccines stop vaccinating. Or it could just be spurious. What it does suggest is that there is a serious problem with the poll.
The biggest problem, however, that makes me doubt this survey is the questionnaire and how the study was conducted. J. B. makes a big deal about how their methodology “mirrored” the methodology that the CDC used to establish estimates of autism prevalence. The two are only superficially comparable. The CDC used very simple methodology:
The surveys were independently conducted but both were conducted during the same time period, 2003 to 2004. Both were based on a nationally representative sample of non-institutionalized U.S. children and in both surveys parents or guardians of the sampled children were asked about a range of different health issues.
Autism prevalence was estimated from the question asking parents if they were ever told by a doctor, or other health care providers, that their child had autism.
Leaving aside that Generation Rescue doesn’t describe how their sample was chosen, what measures were taken to make sure it was representative, and what the response rate was, compare this to the questionnaire that Generation Rescue tried to get parents to answer. Here’s a sample:
5) If this child has ever been diagnosed with asthma, juvenile diabetes, autism, Asperger’s Syndrome, ADD, ADHD, or PDD-NOS, press 1 (continue to next Q)
Otherwise, press 2 (skpt to closing language “B”)
6.) OK, then, let’s go through each condition one at a time.
Has this child been diagnosed…
With Asthma?
Yes, press 1
No, 2
Not sure? 3
7.) With Juvenile Diabetes?
Yes, press 1
No, 2
Not sure? 3.
8.) With Autism?
Yes, press 1
No, 2
Not sure? 3.
9.) With Asperger’s?
Yes, press 1
No, 2
Not sure? 3.
10.) With ADD?
Yes, press 1
No, 2
Not sure? 3.
11.) With ADHD?
Yes, press 1
No, 2
Not sure? 3.
12.) With PDD-NOS?
Yes, press 1
No, 2
Not sure? 3.
PDD-NOS? How many parents know what PDD-NOS is? (It’s pervasive developmental disorder, not otherwise specified, by the way.) I didn’t know what a PDD-NOS was until I became interested in the vaccine-autism hysteria. The only parents who are going to know what that is are the ones whose child has a diagnosis. Heck, even though most parents know what autism is, a lot of parents don’t know what Asperger’s is unless their child has it.
Moreover, the CDC study produced estimates of autism prevalence that were consistent with previous studies. In contrast, J. B.’s survey produced estimates of autism and ASDs of 3% in the aggregated data. That’s 1 in 33, approximately 5 times more prevalent than the usually cited estimate of 1 in 166 or 1 in 150. This, too, suggests reporting bias, where parents who have a child with autism or an ASD will be more likely to complete this survey. Moreover, SurveyUSA is known for asking very concise questions that have been known in the past to produce divergent results using automated telephone polls, which have a number of problems, not the least of which is a much lower response rate than traditional polls. Again, the issue of reporting bias comes up. That’s not to say that it’s not possible to do accurate polls with automated technology, but asking about health problems is difficult, leading me to take any such poll done looking for correlations between vaccines and anything with a huge grain of salt. Moreover, no evidence about response rates or how many parents responded “not sure” for each question is presented, nor is any evidence to show that the sample chosen is representative. In any case, Prometheus has done an excellent job discussing how a true “vaccinated versus unvaccinated” study could be done with both a reasonable degree of scientific rigor and ethically as well. Unfortunately, it would take a minimum of 20,000 children:
A study of autistic children in the 3 – 6 year age range would need over 683,000 children in each group to detect a 10% difference in vaccination level. It would need nearly 22,000 in each group to detect a 50% difference. With a predicted number of 110,000 autistic children in that age range, that is a sizeable fraction of all autistic children.
A more manageable study – one with 10,000 children in each arm (which is still a HUGE study!) – would only be able to tell the difference between the national average of 0.3% unvaccinated in the non-autistic group and 0.1% unvaccinated in the autistic group (at the specified levels of confidence). If the difference is smaller than that, the results would be considered negative (i.e. that there is no effect of vaccination). For reference, a study with 1,000 children in each arm would show statistical significance (at our specified level of confidence) only when the autistic group was below 0.01% unvaccinated or above 1.7% unvaccinated.
Of course, we wouldn’t have to just look at unvaccinated vs fully vaccinated with this study, which is a large part of its superiority. We could look at a dose response of vaccination - to see if it really is “too many” – as well as the age at youngest vaccination – to see if it really is “too soon”. In fact, a few studies have already looked at those issues and found that there is no difference between the autistic and non-autistic groups. I suspect this is the reason the folks pushing to “put on a study” want to look at vaccinated vs unvaccinated – they hope that the numbers will be different (or, at least, not as definitive) the other way round.
This would, of course, be a massively expensive study to do as well and would funnel more research money to dubious studies of highly unlikely hypotheses.
CONCLUSION
Given that Generation Rescue paid $200,000 to do its poll, if I were J.B., I’d be asking for my money back. On the other hand, compared to how much money Generation Rescue is raking in hand over fist, thanks to Jenny McCarthy, who’s been hitting the pro wrestling circuit, doing celebrity poker events with Lance Armstrong, holding fundraisers with Hugh Hefner and Britney Spears and making numerous appearances to raise money for Generation Rescue, I’m guessing that these days $200,000 is pocket change. Moreover, only J.B. knows how much money was spent on the Fourteen Studies website, but I’m guessing it was quite a bit. The slickness of the website, coupled with all the TV appearances, and celebrity fundraisers, all of which coopt the message of “autism awareness” and conflate it with the antivaccine activist agenda, bespeak large amounts of money flowing into the antivaccine propaganda effort. Wouldn’t it be wonderful if Generation Rescue actually spent its money on real research, instead of propaganda like the Fourteen Studies website?
Don’t hold your breath waiting for that to happen.
That’s because, unfortunately, it’s not about science, evidence, or reason to Generation Rescue. It never has been; it is not now; and it never will be. No, it’s all about winning, which means that the evidence showing that vaccines are not associated with autism must be attacked, because the AAP, CDC, and Paul Offit are the “bad guys.” That’s why this Fourteen Studies website is nothing more than pure propaganda; indeed, it’s every bit as much propaganda as Jenny and Jim’s media tour to promote McCarthy’s latest paean to antivaccine pseudoscience and autism quackery or the “Green Our Vaccines” march last spring. I also note that there are far more than “14 studies” showing no association between vaccines and autism. Indeed, Mady Hornig cited twenty just looking at MMR and autism alone. That defenders of vaccines have chosen “fourteen studies” as a talking point was not a good idea; it was a strategy that made a website like Fourteen Studies possible. That, alas, was a failing of scientists as communicators.

   The worst of times for antivaccine believers: Yet another study fails to show any link between the MMR vaccine and autism
David Gorski
Link
THE BEST OF TIMES
It was the best of times (for antivaccinationists). It was the worst of times (for antivaccinationists). It was the age of wisdom (definitely not for antivaccinationists). It was the age of foolishness (definitely for antivaccinationists). It was the epoch of belief (for antivaccinationists).
Such is the time we live in, my apologies to Charles Dickens, even though he is long dead.
Let’s face it. If we ignore the science, it is, alas, indeed the best of times for antivaccinationists. I’ve lamented the rise of non-science-based fearmongering among the antivaccine brigade before many times. Indeed, I’ve lamented how the influence of ignorant, unscientific dolts like Jenny McCarthy spouting nonsense about vaccines has already resulted in the resurgence of vaccine-preventable diseases such as measles in areas of the U.S. to the point where I’m not along in fearing that the bad old days will soon return, just as Andrew Wakefield’s litigation- and money-driven “studies” suggesting that the MMR was somehow responsible for autism and GI problems linked with autism resulted in the measles going from being conquered in the U.K. 14 years ago to being declared endemic again there, all because of the fear stoked in parents by bad science, paranoia, and anti-vaccine fearmongering.
Truly, it is the best of times for antivaccinationists, or so it seems from a superficial view.
THE WORST OF TIMES
For all the success antivaccinationists have had on the propaganda and public relations front, however, all is not well. If one concentrates solely on the science and nothing but the science, this golden age of antivaccine activism is also without a doubt the worst of times for antivaccinationists. Study after study over the last two years have provided strong evidence that vaccines do not cause autism or any of the other dreaded consequences attributed to them by antivaccinationists. For example, numerous studies have failed to find even a hint of a correlation between the most evil (in the minds of antivaccinationists) preservative used in some vaccines, thimerosal, and autism. Indeed, numerous studies have failed to find a link between vaccines in general and autism or other neurodevelopmental disorders. In fact, the drumbeat of studies coming out that fail to find a link between either thimerosal-containing vaccines and autism or vaccines in general and autism (or, for that matter, vaccines and the dire consequences attributed to them by anti-vaccine activists) is becoming so routine as to be monotonous.
It’s a monotony that I like–and that you should like too.
You’d think that the pseudoscientists who are so utterly convinced that it absolutely, positively has to be the vaccines causing autism (and that if it isn’t vaccines causing autism they must be causing some horrible chronic health problem or other) would have gotten the message by now. You would, of course, be wrong, because to them science is besides the point. It doesn’t matter that the pace of these studies appears to be accelerating. Somehow, some way, no matter how many studies fail to find a link between vaccines and autism or other complications, antivaccine activists would have us believe that nonetheless vaccines must be the Root of All Evil, or at least all autism.
YET ANOTHER NAIL IN THE COFFIN
Last Thursday, yet another study failing to find a link between MMR and autism, this time out of Columbia University, was released. Even better, the first author on the study is Mady Hornig, who became a hero of the mercury militia a three years ago with her infamous “rain mouse” study, in which she performed experiments of dubious ethics on some very unlucky lab mice and proclaimed the results “evidence” that thimerosal caused autism. She was even a common speaker at mercury militia–excuse me, I mean National Autism Association (NAA) –events, along with hard core antivaccinationists Boyd Haley, Richard Deth, Mark Blaxill, Jeff Bradstreet, and others, as well a speaker for FAIR Autism Media, along with Mark and David Geier, Thomas Burbacher, Boyd Haley (again), Andrew Wakefield himself, and many others. The paper reporting her study is even hosted on the NAA website, as well as that of SAFEMINDS. Unfortunately, her experiments were anything but evidence supporting a link between thimerosal and autism, just as these endorsements imply.
This latest study makes me think that perhaps Dr. Hornig, contemplating her descent into antivaccine pseudoscience, may have had a “come to Jesus” moment and is trying to regain her scientific mojo (although I’ll only really believe that when I see her give up trying to show that thimerosal causes autism using the aforementioned “rain mouse” model). Either that, or she figured out that flirting with the band of pseudoscientists and ideologues making up the antivaccine movement is the surest way to kill her scientific career deader than dead and thereby end up working in the basement of her house like Geier, père et fils. In other words, perhaps she decided that tenure and a continued scientific career meant more to her than the momentary notoriety and adulation that came her way from her brief stint as one of the darlings of the mercury militia.
Let’s hope so, anyway.
Whatever the case, Dr. Hornig has done a study with W. Ian Lipkin as the senior author published in PLoS ONE entitled, Lack of Association Between Measles Virus Vaccine and Autism with Enteropathy: A Case-Control Study. Before I get to the study itself, let’s look at the news report:
CHICAGO (Reuters) - Scientists who tried to replicate a study that once tied a measles vaccine with autism said Wednesday they could not find any link and hope their study will encourage parents to vaccinate their children to combat a rash of measles outbreaks.
Parents’ refusals to have their children vaccinated against measles have contributed to the highest numbers of cases seen in in the United States and parts of Europe in many years.
Measles kills about 250,000 people a year globally, mostly children in poor nations.
I love it when a mainstream news article lays out the price of antivaccination pseudoscience right from the beginning. The beauty of this study is that it tried to replicate the original study done by Andrew Wakefield. As you may recall, ten years ago, Wakefield published a paper in The Lancet describing a series of children with regressive autism and gastrointestinal complaints. He described intestinal abnormalities, including reactive lymphoid hyperplasia in the ileum, and the parents of several of these children reported the onset of symptoms temporally related to the MMR. This led to the hypothesis that the MMR was associated with autism and GI complaints, and what later followed were additional papers that purported to find measles RNA in the gut of autistic children. These results were spun by antivaccine advocates as “evidence” that the MMR vaccine was associated with gut abnormalities and autism.
Thus was born the MMR scare in the U.K., a scare that, a decade later, has resulted in the resurgence of the measles in there to the point that it has become endemic again a mere 14 years after having been declared under control. Sadly, he had lots of help from the press, which published credulous inanities about this link, regardless of how shoddy the science was (and shoddy it was indeed).
Basically, the design of the Hornig study study was pretty simple, and, better yet, it was an intentional attempt to replicate the research of Andrew Wakefield using rigorous methodology. The design was a case control study in which children with autism and GI problems were compared to children with GI problems and no autism for a number of parameters, including MMR vaccination and the presence of measles virus RNA in the gut of children who underwent endoscopy. The overall approach was to determine whether children with autism and GI symptoms were more likely to have detectable measles virus RNA in the gut. The result?
Zero correlation. Nada. Zip.
One out of the 25 autistic children in the study had detectable measles virus RNA present in their biopsies, while one out of the 13 children without autism also had detectable measles virus RNA present. There was not even a hint of a statistically significant difference between the groups, nor was there a correlation between the timing of the MMR vaccination and the onset of autism or GI symptoms. Basically, this study was negative, and represents some pretty strong evidence against the contention that MMR causes autism or chronic GI problems. So strong was the evidence that even committed antivaccine zealot Rick Rollens grudgingly admitted it in a back-handed way:
“No longer can mainstream medicine ignore parents’ claims of clinically significant GI distress,” said Rick Rollens, a parent and autism research advocate.
He commended the researchers for their work but said, “This study by itself does not exonerate the role of all vaccines.”
Sound familiar? It’s just like the thimerosal shuffle. As studies come out exonerating thimerosal as a cause of autism, antivaccinationists invoke other “toxins,” sometimes going to ridiculous contortions to do it. Because, you know, it’s absolutely, postively, got to be something in the vaccines. It’s the same thing here. The MMR has been exonerated as a cause of autism, but Rollens knows that it’s just absolutely, positively got to be some vaccine or other that causes autism, even if it’s not the MMR.
One observation that came out of this study is that there does appear to be a correlation between GI complaints and regressive autism. Neither are associated with the MMR, but they are associated with each other. This is certainly an observation that should be followed up with further study; what this study contributes is that it frees researchers to stop wasting precious research dollars studying the hypothesis that MMR causes autism. It doesn’t. Between a previous study by Baird et al and the current one, among others, the science is quite clear that there is no link between MMR and autism.
THE “EXONERATION” OF ANDREW WAKEFIELD? NOT!
The reaction to this study by the antivaccine contingent is instructive. There are two main reactions, the ridiculous and the even more ridiculous. To understand just the ridiculous, you first need to know that this study had one very interesting aspect to its design. All the samples were sent to three different laboratories for analysis, completely blinded so that the labs didn’t know which experimental group each patient was in, and tests of concordance were done, to verify that the three labs agreed. Prior to the beginning of the study, the three labs were tested with positive and negative controls. So what? You might reasonably ask. Let’s go back to a discussion of the Autism Omnibus last year, where polymerase chain reaction (PCR) expert Stephen Bustin examined John O’Leary’s laboratory, where the the reverse transcriptase PCR (RT-PCR) was performed to detect measles RNA. Bustin demolished the methodology of that laboratory demonstrating conclusively that the “postives” detected were all false positives made possible by plasmid contamination, as Kevin Leitch has discussed.
The O’Leary laboratory was one of the three labs used in this study, and Dr. O’Leary was one of the authors.
Let’s put it this way. The day the study came out, a little birdie told me that David Kirby himself was one of the reporters who called into a teleconference about this study held the day before its release and that he asked a lot of questions about the O’Leary lab. (Note added after publication: The press conference can be found here.) I’ve also heard rumblings from the antivaccination underground that the talking point will be that this study is a “two-edged sword” in that it supposedly the fact that the O’Leary lab performed competently now somehow exonerates its horrible performance several years ago. It doesn’t. Bustin’s deconstruction of the methodology in use at the O’Leary lab at the time was devastating, demonstrating a level of incompetence beyond belief. What is far more likely is that O’Leary was forced to clean up his act and tighten up lab discipline in order to be included as one of the labs in this study. The same little birdie also told me that Kirby asked questions about the Michelle Cedillo case, which is in essence a non sequitur, because part of the claim in her case is that thimerosal was contributory to autim, and there has never been any thimerosal in the MMR. However, apparently Cedillo’s biopsy samples were also processed by Dr. O’Leary’s lab, and Kirby seems to think that maybe this study could therefore be used to support her test case in the Autism Omnibus. Again, don’t fall for that line; it’s virtually certain that Dr. O’Leary must have cleaned up his act. Remember, his lab was tested before it was allowed to process real patient samples from this study.
While David Kirby has not yet posted one of his typical obfuscation-laden feats of verbal prestidigitaion to criticize this study, that doesn’t mean that other anti-vaccine advocates haven’t jumped into the ring. Perhaps Kirby realizes just how silly such criticisms sound from a scientific standpoint and has decided for once to stay silent. Unfortunately, others are more than happy to leap into the fray to embarrass themselves, including Andrew Wakefield himself.
THE FASTEST WITH THE LEASTEST
Predictably, the Wendy Fournier of the National Autism Society was first off the mark with her criticism, and a truly laughable bunch of nonsense it is. Amusingly, she starts out by calling this a “CDC study.” Actually, it’s a study out of Columbia University, Massachusetts General Hospital and Harvard University, Trinity College in Dublin, and the Measles, Mumps, Rubella, and Herpesvirus Laboratory and the Branch National Center for Immunization and Respiratory Diseases at the Centers for Disease Control, and its funding came from CDC grant U50 CCU522351 to the AAP and by National Institutes of Health awards AI57158 (Northeast Biodefense Center-Lipkin), HL083850, and NS47537. Predictably, Fournier wants to make this sound like a conspiracy of some sort or imply conflict of interest. Of course, she neglects the fact that investigators Mady Hornig and John O’Leary, among others, were until this study heroes of the antivaccine movement. Some “conspiracy”!
Fournier’s “complaints” are predictably lame:
The CDC study was designed to detect persistent measles virus in autistic children with GI problems. The assumption being if there is no measles virus at the long delayed time of biopsy, there is no link between autism and MMR. But NAA says this underlying assumption is wrong. The questions should have been: Do normally developing children meeting all milestones have an MMR shot, develop GI problems and then regress into autism? Do they have evidence of measles and disease in their colons compared to non-vaccinated age and sex matched controls
Point one: The study didn’t just look at the presence of measles virus in the gut. It also looked at the timing of MMR vaccination compared to a number of health parameters. Indeed, the authors analyzed not just whether MMR preceded symptoms but did statistical modeling of how long the interval between vaccination and symptoms was. The answer was that there was no correlation. Of course, Fournier’s whine is nothing more than an example of the old crank adage: “If you don’t like the answer, change the question.” This is, in essence, nothing more than a form of moving the goalposts.
Point two: Does Fournier know how impractical her demand for checking non-vaccinated age- and sex-matched controls is? She clearly knows nothing about clinical research or medical ethics. Colonoscopy is an invasive procedure. Not only does it require general anaesthesia in small children, but there is a small but real risk of serious complications. It’s not a procedure to be done without a firm indication, which is what the investigators did. They selected children for whom colonoscopy was indicated based on their clinical presentation and symptoms. Doctors can’t just go around doing colonoscopies and gut biopsies on “control” children. In addition, even if she meant that the controls with GI problems should have been free of exposure to the MMR, that is a methodological obstacle that would be very difficult to overcome, given how few children of that age have not received the MMR, and if ths hypothesis being studied is that MMR is causative for autism, autistic enterocolitis, or enterocolitis itself, looking for correlation between receiving MMR before the onset of symptoms is a valid methodology to pursue to test that hypothesis. Of course, an understanding of medical ethics was never the strong suit of antivaccinationists.
Neither are statistics, as Fournier demonstrates:
In the current CDC study, only a small subgroup of children was the correct phenotype to study. From page 7, “Only 5 of 25 subjects (20%) had received MMR before the onset of GI complaints and had also had onset of GI episodes before the onset of AUT (P=0.03).” The other 20 autistic children in the study had GI problems but the pathology developed before the MMR vaccine. Additionally, the controls all received the MMR vaccine and had gastrointestinal symptoms. The controls should have been free of exposure to vaccine measles in order to make a comparison relevant for purposes of causation.
This analysis was the one of the major points of the study, the point being that there was no difference, statistically speaking, between the number of children in the autism plus GI complaints and the GI complaints alone group, indicating that there was no association between having the MMR vaccination before the onset of symptoms and the development of symptoms. As for her complaint that all the controls received MMR and had GI symptoms, see my previous response. It applies here, too. The only grain of truth is that this study wasn’t all that large. It did, however, include four times the number of patients that Wakefield’s original study did, and it was far, far more rigorous in design and execution, including excellent blinding. Also, for reasons mentioned before, no study of this type is ever likely to achieve high numbers because it requires an invasive procedure. In any case, the study had more than adequate power for the questions answered and accrued enough patients to have highly statistically significant results.
The weakest of all, however, is this:
Inflammatory bowel disease in the absence of MMR RNA does not mean that MMR shot didn’t precipitate the GI disease and didn’t precipitate autism. A similar example would be rheumatic fever where the infection is cleared quickly but damage to the heart and/or brain last a lifetime.
Talk about moving the aforementioned goalposts! Remember, the hypothesis being tested was Andrew Wakefield’s hypothesis, which was that somehow the persistence of the measles virus in the guts of children vaccinated with the MMR live virus vaccine contributed somehow to autism and “autistic enterocolitis,” not that the MMR contributed to autism or autistic enterocolitis via some sort of rheumatic fever-like mechanism. The concept was that persistent measles virus in the gut somehow resulted in inflammation and increased gut permeability. Now that this study has provided strong evidence falsifying that hypothesis, antivaccinationists like Fournier are moving the goalposts yet again. If it’s not the persistence of the measles virus from vaccines in the gut that causes autism, then it must be some other mechanism, because to the antivaccinationist it absolutely, positively has to be the vaccines. They just know it, and no amount of evidence will ever sway them to think otherwise.
BUT WHAT DOES ANDREW WAKEFIELD THINK OF ALL THIS?
Of course, given that the Hornig et al study is the proverbial shot across the bow of Andrew Wakefield’s S.S. MMR-Autism, it would be shocking if the grandfather of MMR fearmongering himself didn’t take offense and decide to fire off a shot back himself, because, once again, to the antivaccinationist, it absolutely, positively, has to be the vaccines that somehow, some way cause or contribute to autism. It just has to be, don’t you know? Dr. Wakefield’s response posted to his Thoughtful House website is exactly as predicted in that he tries to spin this study as an exoneration of his work. (Brian Deer has done a nice description of Thoughtful House here.) But first Wakefield pulls out the false equivalence gambit:
A study published yesterday in the Public Library of Science One (PLOS1), an on-line journal, failed to find evidence of measles virus in the intestinal tissue of 24 children with autistic regression and gastrointestinal symptoms. The findings contrast with those published in 2002 in which researchers from Ireland and the UK found measles in 75 of 91 biopsies from autistic children with GI inflammation, and in only 5 of 70 samples from non-autistic children(1). The children with autism in the 2002 study developed gastrointestinal symptoms and autistic regression after the MMR vaccine.
Unfortunately, for Wakefield, the reason Hornig et al‘s results contrast so markedly with his in his 2002 followup to his infamous 1998 Lancet study is because Dr. O’Leary’s Unigenetics Laboratory was so incompetent, its facilities so contaminated with plasmid containing measles virus sequences, that virtually all of its positives were false positives. In this, the testimony of PCR expert Stephen Bustin during day 8 of the Autism Omnibus proceedings is quite instructive. Back in 2002, no results derived from the polymerase chain reaction in Dr. O’Leary’s laboratory could be trusted. None. Just because sometime in the six year interim since then Dr. O’Leary has apparently cleaned up his lab’s act and his lab can do the PCR assay for measles now does not exonerate it for its sloppiness and incompetence in 2002. Not that Dr. Wakefield doesn’t try to spin it exactly that way in his first of three points:
In the study published yesterday, conducted by three independent laboratories, only 5 of the 25 children developed these symptoms after the MMR vaccine and therefore, only these five are comparable to the 2002 study. This new study confirmed that results from the laboratory of Professor John O’Leary (one of the collaborators on the new study, and senior author of the 2002 study) were correct, and identical to the results obtained by the laboratories of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and Dr. Ian Lipkin of Columbia University.
No, the results confirmed nothing, and Wakefield is doing nothing more than disingenuously trying to make the study’s numbers sound lower by zeroing in on one subgroup of subjects. Never mind that the whole point was that the same percentages of childen in each group developed symptoms after the MMR vaccine, which was a major finding of the study. Nonetheless, Dr. Wakefield forges on:
In that this new study affirms the reliability of Professor O’Leary’s laboratory and therefore of his previous findings, a major impact upon the current hearings in vaccine court is likely, wherein the government’s defense relies largely on the claim that Professor O’Leary’s finding of measles in the intestinal biopsy of Michelle Cedillo (a child with severe autism and epilepsy) was unreliable. The historical reliability of the measles assay used in Professor O’Leary’s laboratory is now confirmed.
I’ll give Wakefield credit. He’s slick. He also reveals a clever, albeit obviously desperate gambit to try to make the best of a very bad situation for him. It won’t work, though. As Kevin Leitch points out, Michelle Cedillo’s samples were run in 2002 and Stephen Bustin didn’t inspect Dr. O’Leary’s lab until 2004. As I’ll repeat again: Just because Dr. O’Leary apparently can get it right now does not exonerate him for his lab’s ineptitude prior to 2004. According to the methodology of Hornig et al, before any patient samples from the study were tested for the presence of vaccine strain measles sequences, all three laboratories correctly identified the true negative and true positive samples sent to them for analysis as a test of their methodology. If Dr. O’Leary hadn’t cleaned up his lab’s act, it is virtually certain that his lab would have produced some false positives. Wakefield seems incapable of realizing this, or at least he hopes his readers won’t. Predictably, some of them, like longtime antivaccine activist Barbara Loe Fisher and the crew at that repository of antivaccine propaganda and autism quackery, Age of Autism, lapped it up anyway.
Wakefield’s second point is an argument that the linkage between MMR and autism is an open question. It isn’t, at least not anymore. Hornig et al is only the latest of a long line of studies over the last several years that have failed to find a link. It is also the latest of attempts to replicate his results. All have failed, other than Wakefield’s group or groups affiliated with Wakefield. Add all of that to the evidence for incompetence of the laboratory where the biopsy specimens from his studies were analyzed by PCR, and in serious scientific circles the hypothesis that MMR causes or triggers autism or autistic enterocolitis is about as dead as a hypothesis gets. The entire continued kerfluffle over the MMR vaccine is nothing more than a manufactroversy.
Finally, Wakefield concludes with one of the most blatant examples of rewriting history and shifting the goalposts I’ve seen in a long time:
Dr. Wakefield comments, “The search for the ‘footprints’ of measles virus in the intestine is merited, based upon the previous findings and the intestinal disease that is commonly found in these children. This new study rules out only one possibility – that the measles virus must remain for the long term in the intestine. We need to consider that the MMR vaccine can cause autism as a hit-and-run injury, but not necessarily leave the measles virus behind.”
Time travel back about six years to the conclusion of the infamous Uhlman et al paper, which was the followup to Wakefield’s original Lancet study in which PCR for measles virus was first described:
We describe an association between persistent MV infection and ileocolonic lymphonodular hyperplasia and ileocolitis in children with developmental disorder.1 The molecular data indicate the presence of MV genomes in 75 of 91 affected children with the disorder compared with five of 70 control children.
Wakefield also then went on to make an analogy between persistent measles virus infection as an immunological trigger for enterocolitis with autism and how persistent HIV infection causes AIDS. As recently as February, in response to the last study failing to find a link between MMR and autism, Wakefield was still making this sort of argument; i.e., that a persistent measles infection was the trigger. Even if Wakefield’s original idea were that MMR was a “hit-and-run” injury, the Hornig et al study is still strong evidence to refute such a concept, as pointed out in its conclusion:
ASDs comprise a wide range of endophenotypes that may represent different routes to pathogenesis. The work reported here eliminates the remaining support for the hypothesis that ASD with GI complaints is related to MMR exposure. We found no relationship between the timing of MMR and the onset of either GI complaints or autism. We also could not confirm previous work linking the presence of MV RNA in GI tract to ASD with GI complaints.
In other words, this study was about more than whether measles virus could be detected in the guts of autistic children with GI complaints. It also doesn’t absolve Andrew Wakefield for his litigation-driven, conflict-of-interest-riddled, shoddy research.
THE BEST OR WORST OF TIMES?
I realize that I wrote a lot about this particular study. It could be argued that I engaged in massive overkill, but it’s overkill with a point. (Besides, overkill is what I do best, almost as well as my co-blogger Kimball Atwood.) This study was even more important than typical studies over the last few years that have failed to find a correlation between the MMR vaccine and autism for one simple reason: It was explicitly designed to attempt to replicate Andrew Wakefield’s results. It was also highly rigorous in both looking at any potential correlation between MMR and gastrointestinal symptoms or MMR and autism in children with gastrointestional complaints. Not only was no correlation found between epidemiological measures, but Hornig et al found no differences between case and control groups in the presence of measles virus RNA in the colon or terminal ileum. Although the study is relatively small, it is sound. When added to our previous body of knowledge and previous studies, it’s one more nail in the coffin of the MMR-autism hypothesis.
None of that, of course, matters to anti-vaccine activists, because science is irrelevant to them. It exists only to be either abused or cherry-picked to serve their preexisting fervent belief that vaccines do far more harm than good or, in extreme cases, represent a conspiracy to control the human population. (I kid you not.) They dismiss all studies that fail to find a link between vaccines and autism or other conditions, or, failing that, move the goalposts, so utterly convinced are they that vaccines are a plot to poison our children. And they’ve gotten good at it. However, that wasn’t enough. It took a far more sustained propaganda effort with a catchy slogan, plus the good fortune to have sucked a not-too-bright D-list celebrity into their orbit and get her to organize and front marches on Washington. From a propaganda standpoint they’re flying high. However, from a scientific standpoint they haven’t been any lower. As study after study comes out failing to find a link between vaccines and autism or all the horrible other consequences blamed on them, it’s getting harder and harder for them to make a case that isn’t obviously based on blatant pseudoscience.
As vaccination rates are threatened and vaccine-preventable diseases come roaring back, let us all fervently hope that times get as bad for antivaccinationists from a propaganda standpoint as they are from a scientific standpoint. If they don’t, our children will be in for a world of hurt, and so will we.
REFERENCE:
1. Mady Hornig, Thomas Briese, Timothy Buie, Margaret L. Bauman, Gregory Lauwers, Ulrike Siemetzki, Kimberly Hummel, Paul A. Rota, William J. Bellini, John J. O’Leary, Orla Sheils, Errol Alden, Larry Pickering, W. Ian Lipkin, Mark R. Cookson (2008). Lack of Association between Measles Virus Vaccine and Autism with Enteropathy: A Case-Control Study PLoS ONE, 3 (9), 1-8 DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0003140

   Yet another nail in the coffin of the myth that the MMR vaccine causes autism
David Gorski
Link
Arguably, the genesis of the most recent iteration of the anti-vaccine movement dates back to 1998, when a remarkably incompetent researcher named Andrew Wakefield published a trial lawyer-funded “study” in the Lancet that purported to find a link between “autistic enterocolitis” and measles vaccination with the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) trivalent vaccine. In the wake of that publication was born a scare over the MMR that persists to this day, 11 years later. Although peer reviewers forced the actual contents of the paper to be more circumspect, in the press Wakefield promoted the idea that the MMR vaccine either predisposes, causes, or triggers autistic regressions. Even though over the next several years, investigations by investigative journalist Brian Deer revealed that not only was Wakefield’s research funded by trial lawyers looking to sue vaccine manufacturers for “vaccine injury” when he did his research (for which he is now being charged by the U.K.’s General Medical Council with scientific misconduct), but during the Autism Omnibus trial testimony by a world-renowed expert in PCR technology showed that he was incompetent. Even worse for Wakefield, in February 2009 Brian Deer published a news expose based on strong evidence that Wakefield may very well have falsified data for his Lancet paper.
None of this mattered. Andrew Wakefield still enjoys a cult of personality among the anti-vaccine crowd that no revelation seems able to dislodge, even the revelation that at the time he was both in the pay of trial lawyers and working on his study, Andrew Wakefield was also applying for a patent for a rival measles vaccine. Indeed, the anti-vaccine propaganda blog Age of Autism bestowed upon him last year its “Galileo Award” as the “persecuted” scientist supposedly fighting for truth, justice, and anti-vaccinationism against the pharma-funded or brainwashed minions of the “Church of the Immaculate Vaccination.” In the meantime, MMR uptake rates in the U.K. have plummeted over the last decade, far below the level needed for herd immunity, to the point where, last year the Health Protection Agency declared measles to be once again endemic in the U.K., 14 years after the local transmission of measles had been halted.
Since Wakefield’s study was released, a number of studies have shown that there is no epidemiologically detectable link between vaccination with MMR and autism, including one by a researcher who once appeared to be a believer in the idea that vaccines are somehow linked with autism, Mady Hornig. Hornig actually tried very hard to replicate Wakefield’s 1998 Lancet study, only this time with more children, and she found no link between MMR and autism using methodology similar to Wakefield’s. None of these studies has had any effect on the anti-vaccine movement, except to motivate them to circle the wagons even more, as J.B. Handley of Generation Rescue did when he launched a website called Fourteen Studies, whose purposes are to launch fallacious and pseudoscientific attacks on studies failing to find a link between vaccines and autism (often involving accusations of being a “pharma shill”), to promote the lousy science that gives the appearance of supporting the hypothesis that there is a link between the MMR vaccine and autism, and then slime anyone who points out how deceptive their attacks were.
Now, yet another study has been released studying whether there is a link between MMR vaccination and autism. Yet another study has failed to find a link between MMR vaccination and autism. Yet another study is all set to be attacked by Generation Rescue and the anti-vaccine movement. The sad and sordid history of reactions of the anti-vaccine movement to studies that do not support its belief in the unsinkable rubber duck of a myth that vaccines cause autism. This study was published online in The Pediatric Infectious Disease Journal by a group from Department of Epidemiology and Preventive Medicine, Jagiellonian University, Collegium Medicum, Krakow, Poland (a Polish group, my people!) and entitled Lack of Association Between Measles-Mumps-Rubella Vaccination and Autism in Children: A Case-Control Study. It’s yet another nail in the coffin of the myth that the MMR causes or contributes to autism. Indeed, this study not only shows that MMR vaccination is not associated with autism but that it may even be protective against autism. True, for reasons I will discuss shortly, I doubt that that latter interpretation is true, but there’s no doubt that this study is powerful evidence against the view that there is an association between MMR and autism. Unfortunately, I fear that all the nails in my local Home Depot would not be enough to keep the zombie of this pseudoscience from rising from its grave yet again.
Here’s the abstract of the paper:
OBJECTIVE: The first objective of the study was to determine whether there is a relationship between the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccination and autism in children. The second objective was to examine whether the risk of autism differs between use of MMR and the single measles vaccine.
DESIGN: Case-control study.
STUDY POPULATION: The 96 cases with childhood or atypical autism, aged 2 to 15, were included into the study group. Controls consisted of 192 children individually matched to cases by year of birth, sex, and general practitioners.
METHODS: Data on autism diagnosis and vaccination history were from physicians. Data on the other probable autism risk factors were collected from mothers. Logistic conditional regression was used to assess the risk of autism resulting from vaccination. Assessment was made for children vaccinated (1) Before diagnosis of autism, and (2) Before first symptoms of autism onset. Odds ratios were adjusted to mother’s age, medication during pregnancy, gestation time, perinatal injury and Apgar score.
RESULTS: For children vaccinated before diagnosis, autism risk was lower in children vaccinated with MMR than in the nonvaccinated (OR: 0.17, 95% CI: 0.06-0.52) as well as to vaccinated with single measles vaccine (OR: 0.44, 95% CI: 0.22-0.91). The risk for vaccinated versus nonvaccinated (independent of vaccine type) was 0.28 (95% CI: 0.10-0.76). The risk connected with being vaccinated before onset of first symptoms was significantly lower only for MMR versus single vaccine (OR: 0.47, 95% CI: 0.22-0.99).
CONCLUSIONS: The study provides evidence against the association of autism with either MMR or a single measles vaccine.
Indeed it does. It’s worth talking a bit about the methodology of the study. First of all, this is a case control study, which means that it’s retrospective and therefore not randomized. On the other hand, it was a case control study by Sir Richard Doll that was the first outside of Nazi Germany (whose scientists, oddly enough, had found evidence linking smoking to lung cancer more than two decades before the Surgeon General issued his report in 1964) to find an association between tobacco smoking and lung cancer, a finding that was subsequently followed up in cohort studies and found to be valid. Be that as it may, case control studies, instead of prospectively following a population over time, study a population of patients who already have a disease or condition and then try to identify factors associated with the development of that condition. Basically, this involves picking a control population that is equivalent to the study population, and this is how the investigators did it:
Subjects were identified using general practitioner records in the Lesser Poland (Małopolska) Voivodeship in Poland. The sample population of this study included children aged 2 to 15 years diagnosed with childhood or atypical autism, classified according to ICD 10-criteria as F84.0 or F84.1, respectively. Every diagnosis of autism was made by child psychiatrist. Dates of these diagnoses were recorded in general practitioners files. Cases with uncertain diagnosis of autism, secondary to disease state or trauma, were excluded. Two controls were selected for each affected child, individually matched by year of birth, gender, and physician’s practice. The first 2 children visited the physician after the time of the autistic child visit who met entry criteria served as controls.
This is a reasonable strategy to use to pick the control group, as it means that the children would be coming from the same pediatric practices as the autistic children and would be about as comparable as it is possible to make them in this sort of trial design. Another strength of this study is that it used physician reporting for vaccination history and the age at which each autistic child was first diagnosed, rather than relying on parents’ reporting, which is prone to serious confirmation bias. True, the parents were also asked when they first suspected their child’s symptoms might be related to autism, and their knowledge and beliefs regarding the cause of autism, but vaccination was not mentioned in order to avoid biasing the parents’ answers. Cases of autism were then analyzed and considered to have been vaccinated if they received the MMR prior to the onset of autistic symptoms. Controls were considered vaccinated if they had received the MMR before the age of onset of their matched case controls. Finally, the authors corrected for other potential risk factors for autism, including mother’s age, education, gestation time, medications during pregnancy perinatal injury, and the APGAR score of the child at birth. Those that appeared significant in univariate analyses were then subjected to multivariate analysis.
The money tables are Table 3 and Table 4:
What’s surprising about these results is that the multivariate analysis found a relative risk (RR) of autism for children vaccinated with any vaccine before the onset of autistic symptoms of 0.65 and 0.28 for children vaccinated before their “official” diagnosis of autism. When looking at the single vaccine for measles or the trivalent MMR vaccine, both appeared to be protective against autism, but the MMR appeared to be considerably more protective than the single shot measles vaccine. (This comparison could be made because the Polish national health service only covered the single dose measles vaccine and not the MMR until 2004, meaning that before 2004 parents who wanted the MMR vaccine had to pay extra.) Indeed, this study evne found that for children vaccinated with MMR before their diagnosis of autism the RR = 0.17, suggesting a six-fold decreased risk of autism in children vaccinated with MMR!
Is this really true? Is MMR vaccination really that protective against autism? Probably not. An effect of that magnitude would very likely been picked up in one or more of the large population-based studies that failed to find a correlation between vaccines and autism. There is also one shortcoming in this study is that it only looked at autistism and not other pervasive developmental disorders; however there is ample other evidence that MMR is not associated with PDDs other than autism, and the original claim of the anti-vaccine movement was that MMR causes autism. So how to explain such a result? One possibility is simply random chance, given that the sample size, although reasonable, is not that large. Another possibility is that there is a confounder that wasn’t adequately controlled for. Whatever the case, here’s one thing to remember about retrospective studies in general. They often find associations that later turn out not to hold up under study using prospective studies or randomized trials or, alternatively, turn out to be much weaker than the retrospective study showed. They do not so often find a result that is exactly the opposite of hypothesis tested for. In other words, when such a study is used to look for a positive association between a factor and a specific condition or disease, it is quite uncommon to find a negative association, particularly one this strong. One possible reason for this seeming protective effect observed was discussed by the authors:
The decreased risk of autism among vaccinated children may be due to some other confounding factors in their health status. For example, healthcare workers or parents may have noticed signs of developmental delay or disease before the actual autism diagnosis and for this reason have avoided vaccination.
I have speculated before that a study of “vaccinated” versus “unvaccinated” children could be similarly confounded by parents who have one autistic child, become convinced that vaccines caused it, and therefore don’t vaccinated subsequent children that they might have. The main point to remember is that, even though this study is not compelling evidence that MMR is protective against autism, at the very least, the Polish study is strong evidence against a positive correlation between vaccination with MMR or single vaccination against measles and the development of autism. It is yet another pebble in the mountain of evidence that vaccination with MMR is not associated with autism or “autistic enterocolitis.”
It’ll be fun to see how long it is before Handley adds this study to his “Fourteen Studies” website and renames it “Fifteen Studies.” Of course, at the rate studies failing to support Generation Rescue’s cultish clinging to the unsinkable rubber duck of a belief that vaccines cause autism, Handley will have to rename his site every few months at least, and either I or one of my partners in crime here at SBM will have to slap down yet another scientifically ignorant attempt at discrediting each new study.
On and on it goes. Meanwhile, autistic children pay the price for quackery related to anti-vaccine beliefs, and normal children face the resurgence of vaccine-preventable diseases, thanks to the efforts of anti-vaccine cranks like J.B. Handley, Jenny McCarthy, Jim Carrey, Barbara Loe Fisher, and the rest of the vaccine denialists.

   Terrible Anti-Vaccine Study, Terrible Reporting
Steven Novella
Link
One of my goals in writing for this blog is to educate the general public about how to evaluate a scientific study, specifically medical studies. New studies are being reported in the press all the time, and the analysis provided by your average journalist leaves much to be desired. Generally, they fail to put the study into context, often get the bottom line incorrect, and then some headline writer puts a sensationalistic bow on top.
In addition to mediocre science journalism we also face dedicated ideological groups who go out of their way to spin, distort, and mutilate the scientific literature all in one direction. The anti-vaccine community is a shining example of this – they can dismiss any study whose conclusions they do not like, while promoting any horrible worthless study as long as it casts suspicion on vaccines.
Yesterday on Age of Autism (the propaganda blog for Generation Rescue) Mark Blaxill gave us another example of this, presenting a terrible pilot study as if we could draw any conclusions from it. The study is yet another publication apparently squeezed out of the same data set that Laura Hewitson has been milking for several years now - a study involving macaque infants and vaccinations. In this study Hewitson claims a significant difference in brain maturation between vaccinated and unvaccinated macaque infants, by MRI and PET analysis. Blaxill presents the study without noting any of its crippling limitations, and the commenters predictably gush.
The first (and really only) thing you need to know about this study is that it involves 9 vaccinated monkeys and 2 controls. That’s right – just 2 controls. The fact that Hewitson bothers to do statistical analysis on such a small set of subjects is laughable. Let’s keep in mind that most pilot studies turn out to be wrong – they are called pilot studies because they are intended to point the way to further research, not as a basis for any conclusions. Serious researches recognize that pilot studies are shots in the dark – and that counts even for good pilot studies, which this is not.
If the outcome were something hard and dramatic – like survival vs death, then 2 subjects would be a reasonable pilot study. But in this case Hewitson is doing a somewhat tricky measurement of brain volume changes over time and binding of opioid ligands in the amygdala. It is also worth noting that there were originally 4 controls, but one was eliminated due to improper protocol. We never learn what happened to the third monkey, we are just told there is data on two controls. This kind of missing data, especially when the overall numbers are so pathetically low, is very concerning.
She is also making multiple analyses (another red flag by itself), which means she can compare multiple variables looking for any difference. Then she invokes the sharpshooter fallacy and declares any change she does find to be clinically meaningful. So while there is no difference in brain volume or amygdala volume between exposed and unexposed monkeys, she finds differences in the change over time. We don’t know if still other variables were looked at and not reported – this is another weakness of pilot studies and why follow up studies replicating the specific effects reported are necessary before any conclusions can be drawn.
As further evidence of looking for any difference then declaring that the outcome of interest, we can look back to Hewitson’s 2008 reporting of her monkey data, in which she wrote:
“Compared with unexposed animals, exposed animals showed attenuation of amygdala growth and differences in the amygdala binding of [11C]diprenorphine.”
But in the current study she finds increased amygdala growth in exposed monkeys:
Not surprisingly, given the different maturational trajectories in exposed vs. unexposed animals, (unexposed decreasing and exposed increasing) there was a statistically significant interaction between exposure and time on total amygdala volume (Wald χ2=10.93; P=0.001). However, there were no significant main effects on total amygdala volume of either exposure (Wald χ2=0.75; P=0.39) or time (Wald χ2=1.14; P=0.29).
So which is it? Reading the results of the current study, especially in light of previous publications, gives the overall impression of a random scatter of data with incredible cherry picking in order to make the argument that there are any meaningful results at all.
Taken by itself, this is a worthless study. The numbers of subjects is too small to do any meaningful analysis. The results are all over the place, and not even consistent with prior publications by the same authors. The analysis is also far-fetched. Hewitson argues that both thimerosal-containing vaccine and MMR (which does not contain thimerosal) contribute to the alleged brain changes she is reporting. While the word “autism” does not appear in her report, Blaxill is concluding in his reporting that these brain changes are the same as those found in autism (an absurd conclusion given how non-specific these changes are, even if real, which cannot be concluded from this study). The anti-vaccine agenda is now clear – they get to have their cake and eat it too. They can now argue that an interaction between thimerosal and MMR cause or contribute to autism, through completely independent mechanisms, apparently.
To put this study further into context, this research is being conducted by the Thoughtful House Center for Children – Andrew Wakefield’s home after he was essentially kicked out of the UK and subsequently struck off. Wakefield’s name, however, does not appear anywhere on the current study, although he was listed as final author on previous publications from the same research. Apparently his name has become too toxic for the Thoughtful House.
The current study also appears in a obscure journal, Acta Neurobiologiae Experimentalis – which dedicated an entire issue to publishing dubious research on autism. The same issue includes two articles by the father and son Geier team – other vaccine and autism researchers who are off in their own world and whose research cannot be replicated.
Conclusion
This current study, as well as the entire macaque research program by Hewitson, is a good example of terrible research. The subject numbers are far too small for any meaningful statistics, and the outcomes being followed are numerous and tricky with a random scatter of results not even consistent between different publications of the same research.
What we have is far worse than ideological reporting and spinning of the scientific research – apparently we have the ideological conduction of research in the first place. This is similar to the research program of Benveniste on homeopathy.
In general it is a good rule to be suspicious of research that seems to be unique to one researcher or research team and is out of step with the broader research community. Unfortunately, such research contaminates the literature and is easily exploited to confuse the media and the public who often do not distinguish crank research from legitimate science.

   Autism and Vaccines: Responding to Poling and Kirby
Steven Novella
Link
In response to my NeuroLogica blog post on Monday, David Kirby wrote a response in the Huffington Post and Dr. Jon Poling (father of Hannah Poling) wrote an open letter to me, placed in the comment section and posted at Age of Autism. It seems only polite that I respond to their kind attention.The primary focus of my original post (which I further developed yesterday) was that the media is focusing too much attention on what celebrities and politicians are saying about the controversy surrounding the discredited notion that vaccines are a significant cause of autism. Over the past year Jenny McCarthy (now joined by her boyfriend Jim Carrey) has become the major spokesperson for a movement that, at its core, is anti-vaccine and is dedicated to the scientific opinion that vaccines are toxic and cause autism. Recently actress Amanda Peet joined the fray, professing her belief that vaccines are safe, are not associated with autism, and that parents who do not vaccinate their children are “parasites” for depending on other parents who do. (She later apologized for that remark, calling it “divisive”.)
While I appreciate Amanda Peet’s support, I feel strongly that scientific questions should be handled by the scientific community. Celebrities are great when they support causes – but when they second guess the scientific community and decide to advocate for their own scientific conclusions, they are more likely to cause harm than good.In that post I also took David Kirby to task for criticizing Amanda Peet, saying that her position is against the “medical establishment.” Kirby used a very dubious chain of logic to come to that conclusion – relying heavily on the opinions of politicians and ambiguous cases and failing utterly to make the case that the medical establishment, or any consensus of scientific medical opinion, finds any credibility in the supposed link between autism and vaccines.
My Involvement with this Issue
Before I respond directly to Kirby and Poling I want to review my personal involvement with this controversy. Not because it is relevant (only the scientific evidence is relevant) but because my critics often try to make it relevant, usually by making false assumptions about me. So I want to just set the record straight, satisfy any curiosity, and also make this my formal disclosure of any potential conflicts.
I am an academic neurologist in the clinical educator tract at the Yale University School of Medicine. I am an adult neurologist (not a neurosurgeon) with specialties in general neurology and neuromuscular disease. My duties are primarily teaching and clinical with some clinical research thrown in.
I do not participate in autism treatment, diagnosis, or research. I am not affiliated in any way with the Yale Child Study Center or autism research at Yale. I do not speak for Yale or autism research at Yale in any regards. I do not prescribe or research vaccines. I do not work for or have any financial interest in any pharmaceutical company or any corporation that has a vested interest in the vaccine program. I have never worked for the government or any regulatory agency. I am not involved in any legal cases involving autism or vaccines.
My first involvement with this controversy was several years ago when I was invited to write a review article for the New Haven Advocate. This was an outgrowth of what I consider to be my primary academic activity – educating the public about science and science-based medicine. This is something I have been doing for over a decade, starting with the New England Skeptical Society, a non-profit educational organization I started with some colleagues to promote science and reason. My activities have evolved over the years and now include a popular science podcast (the Skeptics Guide to the Universe) and this blog.
After several months of reading and literature review, I decided that at that time (2005) the evidence did not support a link between vaccines in general, the MMR vaccine specifically, or thimerosal in vaccines with autism or any neurodegenerative disorder. I did not begin my investigation with that conclusion. My goal was to accurately reflect the current state of the scientific evidence. As an outspoken scientific skeptic, my reputation is not based upon any particular scientific conclusion. Rather it is based upon dedication to the process of science – using valid logic and fairly accounting for all available evidence.
So for me the only thing that mattered was getting the science right. If I honestly thought the evidence supported a link between vaccines and autism I would have promoted that conclusion. This would have actually worked out much better for me and my career – becoming an early advocate for a minority and highly controversial position that I thought was correct and would eventually be vindicated would have worked very well for me. As it turns out I supported the boring consensus position and was largely ignored outside of skeptical circles. Oh well.
David Kirby
In 2005, as part of my research, I read David Kirby’s book, Evidence of Harm, in which he promoted the conclusion the thimerosal probably does cause autism and that the government is essentially engaged in a cover up of this fact. This conclusion was premised in part on the belief that we are in the midst of a true autism epidemic – that true autism rates are increasing rapidly (the evidence, however, supports the conclusion that the apparent increase is due largely to an expanded diagnosis and increased surveillance). At the time I also interviewed David Kirby for several hours by phone. We both agreed that our respective positions were destined for a definitive test – for thimerosal had been removed by the beginning of 2002 from all vaccines in the routine child vaccine schedule. If thimerosal were a significant cause of autism then autism rates should plummet by 2007. If not then they would continue to rise until they plateau at the true rate. Well, it’s 2008 and autism diagnosis rates have continued to rise without a blip. This fact alone rules out thimerosal as a significant contributor to autism rates (as always – really just as a point of logic – an effect too small to be detected by the available data cannot be ruled out).
David Kirby, however, refused to admit the undeniable implications of this data. He has since moved on to other hypotheses linking vaccines and autism- just as speculative and lacking in data.
In my recent blog post I criticized Kirby for his recent Huffington Post piece – specifically that he is desperately trying to portray the public controversy over an alleged association between vaccines and autism as a legitimate scientific controversy. Yet to make his case he cites politicians and regulators – not scientists. Further he cites the fact that the IACC (the Interagency Autism Coordinating Committee) expressed interest in exploring the vaccine-autism issue. But it turns out this interest came from Lynn Redwood – a member of Safe Minds, a group promoting the idea of a link between vaccines and autism. She was included to give voice to this minority opinion. Now Kirby is using that politically-motivated inclusion to argue that scientists are taking the controversy seriously.
Kirby now takes this self-referential strategy one step further. First he writes:
I write my Huffington Post blogs in order to spark debate and commentary from other quarters about what has become — like it or not — the biggest medical controversy of our time: the potential link between vaccine ingredients and autism.
In that sense, my last piece, “Amanda Peet vs. the Medical Establishment,” has done its job.
Reaction was predictably swift and furious to this opinion essay — and that’s what blogs are: this is not news reporting.
Let me dissect this a bit. He is saying that the purpose of his blog entry was not to report or inform, but to spark debate and commentary. Does that mean we are not meant to trust the information in his blogs? Are they intended only to provoke and not inform? While I agree that blogs are largely opinion pieces, the distinction from reporting is not clean. Often blogs will report news or summarize evidence. Opinions are often based upon a factual premise – you cannot then hide from misinformation and poor facts by claiming it’s all just opinion.
Kirby is also claiming that the autism-vaccine question is the “biggest medical controversy of our time.” I disagree, but I am also not sure how to objectively measure such a thing. As a side note – notice how he wrote: “potential link between vaccine ingredients and autism” – vaccine ingredients. Without ever admitting defeat on the thimerosal issue, he has quietly shifted his claim over to “vaccine ingredients”. What ingredients are those, I wonder?
What Kirby is primarily doing here is exactly the same thing that the Discovery Institute (an anti-evolution group) tries to do with intelligent design (ID) and evolution. They promote the idea of a scientific controversy of evolution and ID where none exists. They then use propaganda and political mechanisms to create a public and political controversy. They then present the public controversy they manufactured as if it were a scientific controversy, and then scream for academic freedom to “teach the controversy.” Meanwhile they desperately claim that there must be something wrong with evolution or else why would there be such a controversy.
Kirby and the anti-vaccination crowd have created a false controversy over vaccines and autism. They then promote this controversy as if it were a legitimate scientific controversy. They then demand that their claims be investigated, that they are represented on the IACC, and they sue the government over alleged vaccine injury – and claim that the resultant controversy they manufactured is evidence for a legitimate scientific controversy and that they should therefore be taken seriously. There must be something to this controversy we manufactured because there’s a controversy – it’s nothing more than an elaborate and deceptive self-fulfilling prophesy.
Kirby is now using a strategy also familiar to the ID crowd – say something scientifically outrageous, and then use the backlash of scientific outrage to say – well at least I got them talking about it and taking the controversy seriously. Mission accomplished. It’s just more self-fulfillment.
What is lacking in the case of ID and the anti-vaccination movement is an actual scientific controversy, or reliable scientific evidence to challenge the current consensus of opinion.
For further self-reference, Kirby writes:
Now, Hannah’s father, Dr. Jon Poling, a respected neurologist and clinical assistant professor of the Department of Neurology, Medical College of Georgia, has responded to Dr. Novella, including his, “criticizing the journalism of Mr. David Kirby.”
A copy of Dr. Poling’s letter to Dr. Novella is posted at what ABC News.com called “the popular blog, Age of Autism.”
It makes for some good reading, from deep inside the medical establishment!
It is misleading for Kirby to refer to Dr. Jon Poling as being “deep inside the medical establishment.” Sure, he is a neurologist, but he is hardly a disinterested expert. He is, as Kirby points out, Hannah’s father. This means that he was involved in suing the vaccine compensation program on the claim that vaccines triggered his daughter’s neurological condition. In this case he is acting more as a member of the anti-vaccine movement than the medical establishment.
For the record, I don’t think it’s accurate to characterize me as part of the medical establishment either. As I pointed out above, I am not involved in autism research or any organization dealing with autism or vaccines. I am simply an individual academic educator distilling this information for the public. But this is a small and not very relevant point.
Also Kirby might be just being facetious, as he claimed he was in his original post about the “medical establishment.” That gives him the ability to make his point – the medical establishment is fighting amongst itself over this real controversy – without being held accountable to the details.
Dr. Jon Poling
Dr. Poling has published an open letter (his second to me) on the Age of Autism website – a site dedicated to the failed mercury hypothesis of autism. He begins:
Your assertion that the scientific question of Autism etiology belongs to the medical community rather than Hollywood Stars is correct. I also agree that Hollywood opinions are more likely to be broadcast to millions because of their position in the media. This heightened awareness is nothing but a positive thing for the million families struggling with this difficult, and all too common, disorder. Jenny McCarthy is an Autism Mom looking for answers and rattling some cages—good for her. Amanda Peet is a new mom who believes in the importance of vaccines to protect her baby—good for her too. Don’t attack the moms, listen to them.
Heightened awareness is not always a positive thing, if it’s awareness of misinformation. What Jenny McCarthy has done is spread demonstrable misinformation (like the false claim that vaccines contain antifreeze) which has served to confuse the public. Unscientific propaganda distracts from real science and real solutions. Misinformed parents, hoping for answers, have been lured by false claims of the so-called “mercury militia” to risky and likely ineffective treatments, like chelation therapy. Hysteria over vaccines has lead to increasing numbers of parents choosing not to vaccinate their children – with resultant outbreaks of preventable diseases, like measles. This threatens herd immunity – which means that vulnerable populations, and even the vaccinated, are at increased risk (because vaccines are not 100% effective).
Dr. Poling is saying, essentially, that public misinformation, risky and ineffective treatments, false hope, and unnecessary outbreaks of preventable disease is all good – as long as it raises awareness.
He then tries to defend McCarthy, and criticize me, with the mommy gambit. This was tried before by RFK Jr. who tried to deflect skepticism towards the dubious claims of the mercury militia as an “attack on mothers.” McCarthy’s status as a mom, even of a child who may have autism, does not exempt her opinions from scrutiny, and does not remove from her the obligation to use her celebrity status responsibly.
He continues:
In criticizing the journalism of Mr. David Kirby, you wrote:
“He refers again to the Hannah Poling case, a girl with a mitochondrial disorder who developed a neurodegenerative disorder with “features of autism” after getting a fever from vaccines.”
Actually—Hannah has diagnoses of DSM-IV Autism (by JHU/KKI psychology) and mitochondrial disorder (by two metabolic experts). The only ‘degeneration’ that occurred (along with 6mos of total growth failure) after 18mos of NORMAL development followed vaccination and nothing else! Of course, any ‘scientist’ can obviously point out that temporal correlation in a single case never proves causation. Rule number one of pediatrics though is “LISTEN TO THE MOM.” Are 10s of thousands of autism moms over the last decade suffering from mass hysteria induced by Hollywood? Not likely.
I was quoting the summary of the case in the Autism Omnibus decision – “features of autism.” I am still not convinced that Hannah Poling has a condition on the autism spectrum, as opposed to a broader neurological disorder that has features that overlap with autism – enough to meet some of the DSM-IV criteria. The case report also listed many symptoms that are not symptoms of autism. But as even Dr. Poling admits, this is part of the problem of trying to reach any reliable conclusion from a single case.
Dr. Poling emphasizes that his daughter had “NORMAL” development until 18 months of age. Assuming this is true, that only means the she had a regressive neurological disorder – nothing exotic or unusual there. Many neurological disorders known to be genetic are regressive – children develop normally for a while and then lose ground. This by itself is not evidence for any sort of trigger, such as vaccines.
He then reiterates his mommy gambit non sequitur, this time presuming to preach to me about clinical wisdom. Listening to mothers (and all family members, for that matter) is about information gathering – not about scientific conclusions. Parents know their children and are sensitive to changes – but that does not mean they are equipped to scientifically interpret them. Any good clinician listens to patients and family members – but also knows that there is a huge tendency to over-report. This is because people do not instinctively know what information is important and what is coincidence, they have a tendency to see patterns even where they don’t exist, and they report a great deal of misleading or just unrelated information. It’s the clinician’s job to sort through that – to find the signal in the noise. Dr. Poling is telling me to listen to the noise.
He then finishes with a straw man – that the only alternative explanation is that 10′s of thousands (not sure how he came by that number or what specifically he is referring to) of moms are suffering from mass hysteria. The true alternative hypothesis – the one actually favored by the scientific consensus – is that the observation of mothers (and fathers, for that matter, but I guess fathers are not as emotionally appealing as mothers) is accurate, the mistake is in assuming causation from correlation. Autism is frequently diagnosed around the age that many vaccines are given. This does not mean that vaccines cause autism. We need controlled or epidemiological data to test that hypothesis – and the evidence strongly suggests that the correlation is coincidence – not causation.
Dr. Poling then writes (again quoting me):
“This special case – which is not a case of autism being caused by toxins in vaccines – says nothing about the broader vaccine-autism debate.”
The only thing unique about my little girl’s case is the level of medical documentation—5 to 20% of patients with ASDs have mitochondrial dysfunction. Many other cases where mitochondrial testing is WNL is because “we never looked” not because the testing would be “within normal limits.” Most mitochondrial experts will tell you that the dots of autism and mitochondrial disorders are strongly connected.
Dr. Poling is saying that his daughter’s case is not unique – that it is typical and therefore is does say something about a broader vaccine-autism connection. Hannah Poling’s history has many features that are not typical of autism – like a history of otitis media with frequent fevers, seizures, and what sounds like a rare encephalitis that probably did result from vaccines. Even if we put her mitochondrial mutation aside – this is not a typical case of autism.
Dr. Poling also makes specific claims about the association of autism and mitochondria – which is not surprising as this is now one of the favored hypotheses of the anti-vaccine crowd, now that their mercury hypothesis has failed. He does not reference his “5-20%” figure for autistic children with mitochondrial dysfunction. The highest figure I could find was 7.2%. I admit I am not familiar enough with this literature to know for sure if there is other published data showing it is more prevalent, but reviews of the literature give figures more in the 5% range.
But more important than the exact figure is what it means. Right now the answer is that no one knows. Autism is not a single disease, it is a complex of diseases with various causes. It may be that one of those causes is mitochondrial dysfunction. The anti-vaccine crowd are now seizing upon this to argue that vaccines are triggering autism in a population made susceptible by mitochondrial dysfunction. But this is pure speculation – a hypothesis, not something that can be concluded from any data. It is also possible that some forms of mitochondrial dysfunction cause autism without a trigger, or that there are a host of environmental triggers. Perhaps any fever can trigger regression, and therefore vaccines may even have a protective role by decreasing overall infections. Maybe we should be vaccinating children with mitochondrial diseases more, not less.
Much is unknown, but at present there is no evidence (beyond two isolated cases of which I am aware, Hannah Poling being one) that links vaccines to mitochondrial dysfunction and autism.
About the case he writes:
“The case was settled (not judged in Poling’s favor, but settled) because both sides realized it was a special case that could not be extrapolated to other vaccine-autism cases.”
The case was not settled, it was conceded by medical representatives of Sec HHS. We are obviously pleased with the HHS decision to concede our case, but we had NOTHING to do with the concession. This was a unilateral decision from HHS (recall that HHS is the respondent, rather than the vaccine maker, as manufacturers have blanket liability protection afforded by the Vaccine Injury Program established in 1986) I will not speculate on the obvious question—why concede? Hannah’s case was positioned to set precedent as a test case in the Omnibus Autism Proceedings for potentially thousands of other cases.
OK – I’m not a lawyer and I don’t want to get caught up in legal jargon. This is also not a normal court of law, so I am not sure if “settled” even applies to such hearings. I was referring to the fact that the case was removed as a test case – it was not decided as a test case. The HSS agreed that “compensation was appropriate” – they specifically did not concede, as Dr. Poling implies, that vaccines were actually responsible for Hannah Poling’s autism. What the HHS did not do was rule that this case sets a precedent for any other case. It seems that Dr. Poling is suggesting that the Autism Omnibus cheated – they removed a case they knew would set a precedent they apparently did not want. But wasn’t the whole point of the test cases to be test cases?
My interpretation (and that of many others) of the HHS ruling was that the Hannah Poling case is too complex and unique to be a test case, but because there is so much uncertainty they erred on the side of compensation – without conceding that vaccines caused autism in this case.
He continues:
With regard to the science of Autism, I have no argument with the assertion that a single case does not prove causation of a generalized autism-vaccine link. What the case does illustrate though is a more subtle point that many physicians cannot or do not want to comprehend (ostensibly because vaccines are too important to even question). Autism is a heterogeneous disorder defined by behavioral criteria and having multiple causes. Epidemiological studies which have not found a link between autism and aspects of vaccination do not consider the concept of autism subgroups. Indeed, in a heterogeneous disorder like Autism, subgroups may indeed be ‘vaccine-injured’ but the effect is diluted out in the larger population (improperly powered study due to inability to calculate effect size with unknown susceptible subpopulation).
At least we agree that this one case cannot prove a causation between vaccines an autism. But isn’t that the whole question? Trying to rescue the conclusion he appears to want, Dr. Poling then pulls the “you can’t handle the truth” gambit. I really love this one – yeah, if vaccines are causing harm I (as an academic neurologist with no direct ties to vaccines at all) want to just hide my head in the sand. Please, Dr. Poling, spare us your condescension. Apparently what I cannot admit is that: “Autism is a heterogeneous disorder defined by behavioral criteria and having multiple causes.” Gee, that sounds familiar – where have I encountered that concept before.
Well, a year ago I wrote in a blog entry on autism:
First it needs to be understood that ASD is likely not a single disease but rather a groups of diseases possibly with various underlying causes.
Again – I am not an autism expert. I am just distilling the consensus of opinion of experts – who seem to have no problem recognizing that autism is a group of disorders, not a single disorder. I don’t expect Dr. Poling to have read every blog entry I have ever written on autism, but if I easily gleaned that from the autism literature, why didn’t he. It seems he was just assuming whatever was convenient for him to assume about his fellow physicians.
His next statement is technically true – that studies designed to look for an effect in an entire population may not be powered to find those effects in a much smaller subgroup. But I have been reading the literature long enough to recognize this as a juicy post-hoc rationalization. In other words – this is what proponents always say after the evidence doesn’t support their contentions. It’s true – but it doesn’t mean there is an effect in a subgroup – it just means we cannot rule out effects that are smaller than the data is capable of showing. This is universally true – by itself it does not rescue data from being negative. At best it means that you can generate a new hypothesis (a subgroup effect) after the old one has been rejected (no effect in the entire group). But all you have now is an untested hypothesis – speculation, not evidence.
After some more speculation, Dr. Poling descends further into condescension:
Definition: Autism is a heterogeneous systemic disorder with primary neuropsychiatric manifestations due to complex genetic and gene-environmental interactions likely affecting synaptic plasticity early in childhood development. This new theory of Autism is rapidly replacing the ‘old guard’ dictum that Autism is a genetically predetermined developmental brain disorder of synaptic formation/pruning that is set in motion prenatally. By the ‘10 year rule of science,’ your time is about up!
Time is up for what, exactly? Is Dr. Poling assuming that I am part of some alleged “old guard” that doesn’t recognize that genes interact with their environment. Does he forget that I am a neurologist, like he (we even went to the same medical school). I treat ALS – guess what is the leading hypothesis of the causes of ALS (which, like autism, is a group of diseases with various causes) – that it is a complex interaction of genetics and environment. What about multiple sclerosis – a complex interaction of environment and genetic predisposition. I have not been in neurology long enough to remember a time when this was not the leading hypothesis as to the cause of many neurological disorders.
Genetic phenotypes interact with their environment – sure. The question is, what is the relative contribution from genes and environment, and what is the interaction. This is a question that autism researchers have asked themselves (even though they cannot comprehend such things, according to Dr. Poling). For example there have been twin studies that specifically ask what the relative contribution of genes and environment is to the risk of developing autism. The conclusion of this one study is: “Genetic structural equation modeling showed that the overlap between AQ and WB and SOC was mainly due to genetic effects.” This means when they looked at twins and non-twin siblings, shared genetics was more of a predictor of overlapping autism traits than shared environment.
This is hardly the final word, and yes this is a very complex topic that requires further research. Subgroup analysis – sure, sounds good. My point is that researchers are asking the very question Dr. Polings suggests they are not, and also that the evidence is pointing in the direction of strong genetic influences in autism. I have no problem with researchers exploring hypotheses about specific environmental triggers of specific genetic abnormalities in subgroups of autism – research away. I would not even be surprised if such research yielded fruit.
My position, rather, is that we cannot conclude from current evidence that there is a specific causal link between vaccines and autism. Further, any such potential link is likely to only be relevant to a minority of autism cases as existing evidence rules out a moderate or larger association between vaccines and autism. Finally – none of this rescues the thimerosal hypothesis as the explanation for an autism epidemic. Dr. Poling admits that they are now nibbling around the edges of autism – not proposing a possible explanation for a major cause of autism. The fact that there was no measurable effect on the incidence of autism after the removal of thimerosal rules out a significant effect for thimerosal by any mechanism.
This includes the article that Dr. Poling references on altered calcium homeostasis. He says that in the discussion the authors speculate about thimerosal as a possible trigger. This type of speculation does not derive from the data – it’s just speculation. Further, as I just pointed out, it doesn’t matter what mechanism is proposed for an effect from thimerosal, the data already rules out a significant effect.
He concludes:
Thank-you Dr. Novella and his band of skeptics for continuing the debate.
No problem, Dr. Poling. Me and my merry band of skeptics will now return to Sherwood Forest. In all seriousness – more skepticism is exactly what Dr. Poling and his side need. Skepticism is just good science.
It’s interesting that Dr. Poling finishes with Kirby’s debate gambit – as if the debate justifies it’s own existence. At least that brings this discussion full circle.
Conclusion
Existing evidence supports the conclusion that autism spectrum disorder – while a collection of disorders of differing causes, is dominantly genetic. There is no evidence to support vaccines or thimerosal as a significant contributor to autism. Proponents of an autism-vaccine link have been steadily retreating from negative data falsifying their claim. They are now focusing on small subgroups of autism with possible genetic and environmental factors – but at present have nothing more than speculation to implicate vaccines even in this drastically reduced role.
Meanwhile there are groups and individuals presenting to the public unsubstantiated claims that vaccines are unsafe and cause autism. These unproven claims are leading some parents to unproven and dubious therapies. It is also leading some parents to forgo immunization, threatening herd immunity and already resulting in outbreaks on preventable diseases.
David Kirby and Dr. Poling want the debate to continue – and not just in the laboratory and the clinic, among scientists who can parse the subtleties of the data – but in public where fear-mongering and misinformation are easy to spread. According to them, it’s all good.

   J.B. Handley and the anti-vaccine movement: Gloating over the decline in confidence in vaccines among parents
David Gorski
Link
UPDATE, 4/25/2011: I can’t resist pointing you to a hilariously misguided attack against me that proves once again that, for the anti-vaccine activists, it’s all about the ad hominem. Clifford Miller, a.k.a. ChildHealthSafety, was unhappy that I showed up in the comments of Seth Mnookin’s post complaining about J.B. Handley’s attacking him solely based on his having once been a heroin addict, an addiction that Seth managed to beat. In response, Miller writes. Not only was he unhappy about a post of mine that was over a year old, but he regurgitated Jake Crosby’s fallacious pharma shill gambit that he used against me last summer. Thank you, Mr. Miller, for, in your utterly irony challenged manner, proving my point that to the anti-vaccine movement it’s all about the ad hominem. You did it better than I ever could. Now, back to my post.
One of the key talking points of the anti-vaccine movement is to repeat the claim, “I’m not ‘anti-vaccine.’” Indeed, one of Jenny McCarthy’s favorite refrains has been “I’m not ‘anti-vaccine.’ I’m pro-safe vaccine,” or “I’m ‘anti-toxin.’” In doing so, the anti-vaccine movement tries very hard to paint itself as being made up of defenders of vaccine safety, as if the Centers for Disease Control (CDC), the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), and all the regulatory agencies don’t support safe vaccines. Many are the times that we have seen examples of this particular denial, both on this blog and elsewhere. For which specific anti-vaccine activists this is self-deception, delusion, or outright lie is a complicated question, but one thing that is clear to me is that the very existence of this talking point demonstrates that, at least for now, being anti-vaccine is still viewed unfavorably by the vast majority of people. If it were not, there would be no need for vaccine conspiracy theorists to use this particular line over and over again. Also, if the rhetoric from the anti-vaccine movement didn’t demonize vaccines so viciously as the One True Cause of autism, asthma, and a variety of other conditions, diseases, and disorders, leaders of the anti-vaccine movement wouldn’t be so anxious to assure us at every turn that, really and truly, they aren’t “anti-vaccine.” Oh, no, not at all.
Unfortunately for them, their rhetoric and activities betray them. For one thing, the anti-vaccine movement is not monolithic. There are indeed anti-vaccine zealots who are not afraid to admit that they are against vaccines. Many of them showed up to Jenny McCarthy’s Green Our Vaccines march on Washington two years ago with signs bearing slogans such as “Danger: Child Vaccine (Toxic Waste)”; “We found the weapons of mass destruction”; “Stop poisoning our children”; and, of course, “No forced vaccination! Not in America!” In the run-up to that march, I lurked on several anti-vaccine discussion forums, and I saw first hand how the organizers of the march were trying to keep people with these signs in line and less visible, not so much because they don’t agree with them but because they promoted the “wrong” message. In this, they remind me of political parties trying to rein in their most radical elements.
Among these groups, Generation Rescue has supplanted the former most influential anti-vaccine group, the National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC). It has achieved this largely through somehow attracting a scientifically ignorant washed-up model, actress, and comedienne named Jenny McCarthy who, most recently before having a son diagnosed as being on the autistic spectrum had been promoting “Indigo Child” woo on her IndigoMoms.com website, complete with a “quantum prayer wheel” invented by William Nelson, inventor of the quackalicious EPFX-SCIO. Back in 2007, just prior to the release of her first autism book, Louder Than Words: A Mothers’ Journey in Healing Autism, McCarthy’s “indigo” website disappeared from the web in a futile attempt to send it down the memory hole, but thankfully The Wayback Machine knows all. In any case, thanks to Jenny McCarthy and, at least as much to her boyfriend, the massively more famous Jim Carrey, Generation Rescue has been tranformed from an ignored fringe anti-vaccine group to a famous and influential fringe anti-vaccine group with all sorts of ins among the Hollywood elite, just as it’s been tranformed from just Generation Rescue to Jenny McCarthy and Jim Carrey’s Autism Organization – Generation Rescue.
Its increasing fame and influence notwithstanding, Generation Rescue has been playing the “pro-safe vaccine” game for at least five years now. Indeed, J.B. Handley himself, founder of Generation Rescue, wrote just last year:
I have vaccinated my children. I encourage others to vaccinate. But when I question vaccine safety, or rather the lack thereof, I’m called “anti-vax” by people like you.
Tell me, how am I anti-vaccine? How am I endangering other people by encouraging them to read up on vaccine injuries. How am I endangering them by giving them as much information as possible in the hopes that their children will not have the same reaction as my son?
Of course, in the five years since I first learned of J.B. Handley, during which time I’ve been following his exploits, I have never once heard him say or seen him write anything that encouraged parents to vaccinate, that expressed anything other than regret or anger at having vaccinated his children and, apparently in his view, caused their autism, or that said anything good about vaccines at all. Quite the contrary, in fact. Last year, for example, J.B. Handley began April, which is Autism Awareness Month, by releasing a truly incompetent attempt at a “study” and then launching Generation Rescue’s deceptive Fourteen Studies website. All the while, I have seen J.B. paint himself as a guardian or watchdog of vaccine safety time and time again, while using familiar denialist tactics of sowing fear and doubt; misinterpreting, cherrypicking, or misrepresenting existing science; highlighting bogus science like that of Andrew Wakefield and Mark and David Geier; and demonizing his opponents, the last of which he is particularly talented at.
Consistent with this, it would appear that J.B has finally let his “I’m not anti-vaccine” mask drop. Last week, Handley laid down an unusually candid bit of his typical braggadocio about a recent study that appeared in the journal Pediatrics about parental attitudes towards vaccination. Tellingly, he entitled it Tinderbox: U.S. Vaccine Fears up 700% in 7 years, in which he gloated about having been responsible for the increasing mistrust of vaccines among parents. Since Handley prominently mentions yours truly, I felt that a bit of a friendly rejoinder was in order.
J.B. Handley starts off his post by boasting:
With less than a half-dozen full-time activists, annual budgets of six figures or less, and umpteen thousand courageous, undaunted, and selfless volunteer parents, our community, held together with duct tape and bailing wire, is in the early to middle stages of bringing the U.S. vaccine program to its knees.
Cue the “Star Wars” music, with a rag-tag band of rebels fighting off an evil galactic empire. Citing the study (Freed et al), which found that 25% of parents surveyed believe that vaccines “can cause autism in healthy children” and that 60% of mothers agree or strongly agree that “I am concerned about serious adverse effects of vaccines,” Handley then gloats by congratulating his people:
Community, prepare to take a bow, America is listening.
I can’t help but make three points here. First, I’m not sure why anyone would want to “take a bow” for spreading misinformation based on ignorance, outright pseudoscience, and paranoid conspiracy theories about vaccines because it has started to have some traction among the public. In my book, that’s nothing to be proud of at all. Second, if J. B. Handley is “not anti-vaccine,” why on earth would he think it’s a good thing that, if the study he cites first is to be believed, parents are becoming more afraid of vaccines, so much so that he blusters and brags about his “success” in his typical fashion? J.B. clearly believes he and his ilk are the responsible for a huge increase in fear and doubt about vaccines and goes so far as to take the credit for it in the name of the “autism community” and lays out his anti-vaccine belief very clearly in a typically testosterone-laced style. Third, although the survey does raise some cause for concern, it is not as bad for supporters of science-based medicine and good for the anti-vaccine movement as Handley tries to paint it. Before I get to explaining why, let’s first note the full reason that Handley is gloating:
Taking a very different approach from the average journalist, I started doing some of my own research, and came across this study, Parental Vaccine Safety Concerns, Results from the National Immunization Survey, 2001-2002.
I was floored.
I remember 2001-2002. My son was born in 2002. I’d barely heard of autism. I’d heard the faintest whispers about vaccines causing autism, but wrote it off as hippy-conspiracy stuff. Not surprisingly, the 2001-2002 report, unlike the 2009 report, does not even mention the word “autism.”
And, in 2001-2002, what percent of parents expressed any concerns about the safety of vaccines? Seven. 7%. Less than 10. Five plus two. A full 93% of parents said vaccines were “completely safe.” In fact, the 2001-2002 study was exceptionally proud of the “low prevalence of vaccine safety concerns.”
What a difference seven years has made. Folks, the U.S. vaccine program literally has its hair on fire. 56% of parents today are concerned about the serious adverse effects of vaccines, and 60% of moms. 56% of parents is an 8-fold, or 700% increase from 2001-2002.
That’s right. J.B. Handley is taking credit on behalf of the movement he leads for cranking up hysteria about vaccines, concluding, “Parents, you can now take a bow. It’s way worse than we thought.”
Well, yes and no. You’ll see why this is a typical bit of J.B. Handley hyperbole in a minute. On the other hand, it is very difficult to argue that fear and loathing of vaccines haven’t increased during the last decade or so. This increase in mistrust of vaccines is particularly evident in the United Kingdom, where Andrew Wakefield’s shoddy, trial lawyer-purchased, incompetent, and possibly even fraudulent 1998 Lancet study linking the MMR vaccine to bowel problems in children, coupled with the aid of the credulous media, both witting and unwitting, has driven down MMR uptake in the U.K. to far below the level necessary for herd immunity. This decline in MMR uptake rates has predictably resulted in measles incidence skyrocketing over the last decade to the point where it has become endemic again. Although it took 12 years, the results of Wakefield’s malfeasance finally came home to roost last month, when, in rapid succession, Wakefield was found guilty of research misconduct by the U.K. General Medical Council, saw his Lancet paper retracted by The Lancet‘s editors, saw his infamous “monkey study” withdrawn by NeuroToxicology, and was then forced to resign from Thoughtful House by its board of directors, led, ironically enough, by Jane Johnson, heiress to the Johnson & Johnson pharmaceutical fortune. If 2009 was a bad year for the anti-vaccine movement in many ways, 2010 looks to be potentially as bad, starting with the latest ruling from the Vaccine Court against the second batch of test cases, one year after the first batch also failed.
All of the above developments, and more, have led the anti-vaccine movement in general and J.B. Handley in particular to lash out, and I see this latest bit of braggadocio as part of that lashing out. I was particularly amused by this passage:
Referring again to the 2009 Pediatrics report that “current public health education campaigns on this issue have not been effective,” I am pleased to lay the blame for that on four people: Dr. Paul Offit, Dr. David Gorski, Amanda Peet, and Ms. Alison Singer. The data clearly shows that the efforts of these four to stem the tide of public opinion away from vaccines has been a miserable failure.
I must say, there’s nothing like being mentioned in the same sentence with Dr. Paul Offit, Alison Singer, and Amanda Peet as defenders of the vaccination program to give a nice little boost to one’s ego! And J.B. even called me “Dr.,” something he often apparently intentionally avoids doing! Seriously, I’m profoundly honored that in J.B.’s mind I deserve to be viewed as being on the same level. Think about it. Here I am, an itty-bitty blogger. Well, not exactly itty-bitty. This blog has a healthy and respectable traffic, as does my other, more infamous blog, so much so that to my shock when I traveled to St. Louis a couple of weeks ago the Skeptical Society of St. Louis thought enough of me to arrange an impromptu get together on short notice at a local bar. Even so, to compare my feeble efforts to combat the anti-vaccine movement to those of Paul Offit, who has been a vaccine researcher for decades and made real scientific and medical contributions to eliminating infectious disease, is ridiculous. To compare me to Amanda Peet, who has many orders of magnitude more name recognition that I have, either under my real name or my more infamous pseudonym, does seem a stretch, as does comparing me to Alison Singer, who was forced out of Autism Speaks because she doesn’t share the belief that vaccines cause autism and ended up forming a new autism charity called the Autism Science Foundation. Unrealistic or not, ridiculous or not, being considered to be on par with such people puts me in very good company indeed, although, in the words of Wayne and Garth from a couple of decades ago, “I’m not worthy, I’m not worthy!”
In comparison, all I’ve done is to have been a persistent thorn in J.B. Handley’s side through my blogging for the last five years about the vaccine pseudoscience promoted by Generation Rescue (and later Age of Autism), written one relatively popular blog, edited another popular group blog, and participated in a panel discussion about the anti-vaccine movement at TAM7 last year. All of these are worthy activities, but I can only conclude that it is a measure of J.B.’s fixation with me that he would be deluded enough to include me in such a list. Whatever influence I’ve garnered through my personal blog and, with the help of my cobloggers,though SBM is on the order of several thousand readers. That influence is not even close to being of the same order of magnitude as that of the mainstream media or of someone like Jim Carrey or Jenny McCarthy, which makes “blaming” me for whatever failure there has been in combatting the tide of misinformation spread by various anti-vaccine organizations rather silly. I also wonder why J.B. didn’t also target Steve Novella, who’s done at least as much, if not more, than I, as he’s done in the past.
Perhaps this is why:
Did Hollywood cast this guy as a villain? He’s perfect! Of course, Offit found Amanda Peet, who let the world know we were all parasites (anyone hear from her lately?). Go online to get the other side, and your likely to find Dr. Gorski’s blog, where a dozen anonymous commentators echo Dr. Gorski’s venomous invective – just the thing to build trust with a new mommy! The newest entrant, Ms. Peet’s replacement, is Ms. Singer, who looks like she stepped out of the morgue to take each interview and tell everyone that vaccines are safe and we all barely exist. Keep talking, Ms. Singer, keep Paul Offit on your board, and keep publicizing the “National Immunizations Conference” on your “autism science” website.
I’ll admit that my other persona is a tad more–shall we say?–blunt (insolent, even!) than I am when I write for SBM, but to hear J.B. complain about “venomous invective” nuked my irony meter. Generation Rescue and its propaganda arm Age of Autism specialize in “venomous invective,” particularly against Paul Offit and anyone else who opposes its anti-vaccine agenda. After all, this is the same man who launched personal attacks on Steve Novella that can only be viewed as more than venomous. This is the same man whose misogynistic attacks on Amy Wallace, a journalist who wrote an excellent article on the anti-vaccine movement, made him infamous throughout the science-based blogosphere. This is the same man who periodically blasts away at me1,2,3 whenever I get under his skin too much. This the same man whose blog posted a Photoshopped picture of Steve Novella, Amy Wallace, Paul Offit, and Trine Tsouderos sitting around the table for a Thanksgiving feast, the main course of which was a baby, as shown by this screenshot taken from my computer around the time the post showed up:
That was so over-the-top that even AoA ended up deleting it after a firestorm of criticism. I can’t compete with venom like that even if I wanted to, and I don’t want to.
But let’s get to the study touted by Handley. It did indeed show that 25% of parents polled think that vaccines can cause autism in healthy children, a disturbingly high rate, but, quite honestly, much lower than I feared it would be when I first heard about the story. However, what Handley neglects to mention is that, despite the 54% of parents expressing concern about serious adverse events due to vaccines, 90% of parents agreed that “getting vaccines is a good way to protect my child(ren) from disease” and that 88% agreed that “generally I do what my doctor recommends about vaccines for my child(ren).” These responses suggest that, although more than half of parents express concern about adverse events, most of these same parents don’t find the worries they have about vaccines compelling enough to refuse vaccination. In other words, they have heard about the concerns, most likely thanks to anti-vaccine groups and activists like Generation Rescue and J.B. Handley, but the concerns haven’t “stuck” enough to make them refuse vaccination. Unfortunately, J.B. Handley and his ilk are certainly doing their best to change that.
More disturbing is the finding that nearly 1 in 8 parents have refused certain vaccines for their children, with newer vaccines being more likely to be refused than older vaccines. This figure suggests to me that the “too many too soon” propaganda of Generation Rescue and others, and the “alternative vaccination schedules” touted by people like Drs. Bob Sears and Jay Gordon may be gaining traction. How much of that can be attributed to the propaganda of the anti-vaccine movement is impossible to say for sure, but certainly other factors are at play, including a general trend of questioning medicine more, along with the rise of the Internet, which has allowed people with no particular expertise in a topic to attend “Google U.” and conclude that they know more about a topic than researchers who have studied an issue all of their lives. While it’s true that science does advance and scientific consensuses do change, they do so through data, experimentation, and clinical research, not through conspiracy theories and misrepresentation of science. Moreover, changing public opinion has nothing to do with the validity of a position. Many more people believe in ghosts than in the scientifically discredited idea that vaccines cause autism. That does not mean ghosts exist.
In the end, I have to wonder whether the anti-vaccine movement has reached its high water mark in terms of public influence and J.B.’s gloating is a tad premature. After all, the last year or so has been very bad for him and his organization. Before 2009 started, study after study have failed to find a link between vaccines and autism or thimerosal and autism, many of which we’ve collected right here. In February 2009, strong evidence showing that Andrew Wakefield had committed scientific fraud came to light, and that was followed by a ruling against the first three Autism Omnibus test cases. A series of excellent reports by Trine Tsouderos and Pat Callahan of the Chicago Tribune demonstrated the depths of autism quackery driven largely by anti-vaccine ideas, while exposes of the anti-vaccine movement came fast and furious from Chris Mooney for DISCOVER (Why Does the Vaccine/Autism Controversy Live On?) and Amy Wallace for WIRED (An Epidemic of Fear: How Panicked Parents Skipping Shots Endangers Us All), leading to the aforementioned misogynistic attacks against Amy Wallace and a recent hilarious invocation of the “pharma shill” gambit against Chris Mooney. Since 2010 began, not only has Andrew Wakefield been completely discredited that he was forced to resign from Thoughtful House, but the Vaccine Court ruled against the second set of test cases. Meanwhile, later this year Paul Offit is scheduled to release a book about the anti-vaccine movement that paints it in a very unfavorable light. Increasingly, people are (correctly, in my estimation) viewing Jenny McCarthy as a dangerous loon abusing her celebrity.
I’ve been very critical of the AAP and CDC before. I and many others have been sounding the alarm against the anti-vaccine movement for at least five years now, and the AAP and CDC remained tone deaf to the growing vaccine denialism movement fronted by J.B. Handley and, since 2007, Jenny McCarthy and Jim Carrey. To me, it seemed that it wasn’t until 2009 (2008, to be generous) that health authorities in the U.S. seemed to wake up to the threat. So, since 2002, the anti-vaccine movement had the playing field to itself by and large. Now it does not. I may be the eternal optimist in this (either that, or I’m bipolar, cycling between extremes of pessimism and optimism), but for the first time since 2005, the year I first started paying attention to vaccine issues in a big way, I sense a positive shift in the national zeitgeist against the anti-vaccine movement. That’s one reason why I consider it important to mention two things. First, the questionnaires for this survey were administered in January 2009. Second, I’ve sensed this change most strongly beginning in late 2008/early 2009, and accelerating in early 2010, meaning that this survey could indeed represent the high water mark of mistrust of vaccines. I also note that the spectacular flameout of Andrew Wakefield in January and February, in particular as evidenced by the retraction of his 1998 Lancet paper, has seriously hurt the anti-vaccine movement, and don’t think they aren’t feeling it.
I do have to thank Mr. Handley though. His article did do more for my already inflated ego than anything since finding out at TAM7 that I’m not just an itty-bitty blogger anymore. I also thank him for laying it on the line: The goal of the anti-vaccine movement is to spread fear and doubt about vaccines among parents, to “bring the U.S. vaccine program to its knees,” as J.B. so aptly put it. Now that we know that, we know that, for all the disclaimers of “I’m not anti-vaccine” notwithstanding, J.B. Handley and Generation Rescue are anti-vaccine to the core.
ADDENDUM:
I can’t resist pointing out a perfect case of crank magneticism by an AoA commenter who left a doozy of a comment after the post above that amused me greatly:
First off Keebler count me in the quarter that denies the 18th century evolution theory that even the theorist decried before his death as he turned to God. His theory was just a 4 centuries removed from the 14th century world is flat group.
Also count me in the group that says global warming is Horse Sh– and the students paper it is based on, the emails that exposed the conspiracy of lies and the revelation that Al Gore used photos from a Hollyweird movie did not have anything to do with my firm conclusion. Anybody who is even remotely aware of the weather man/woman and the accuracy of their predictions clearly knows that the weather cannot be accurately predicted from Monday to Wednesday with any consistency therefore to take the word of these same people that the planet will be warmed significantly from CO2 from SUV’S and cars is beyond laughable. As any grade schooler can tell you the earth has more water than land, almost 72%, and the greatest emission of green house gases is from the ocean, God sort of planned it that way and you can take for granted that he is a wee bit smarter than you are ok genius.
Also Keebler the hysteria from people like you screaming that the glaciers are melting and that this will cause floods all over the world is nothing short of histrionics spawned by true ignorance, you see according to Archimedes principal, another high school physics tid bit, when an object displaces water, like ice does, even if it melts the water level does not rise because of the volume displaced by the ice is equal to it’s volume when melted.
By the way, water is the ONLY substance that when solid is less dense than when it is a liquid. If this were not true then the plants in the bottom of lakes, rivers and oceans in cold areas would die and not make oxygen and the fish would die and then we would eventually die. Again God planned it that way and when you know everything because you actually created everything it works really well.
Finally the vaccine scam will come to an end. Physicians and surgeons everywhere outside of pediatrics and psychiatry are telling people not to vaccinate. I stand straight up and tall and look parents in the eye and tell them not to vaccinate and give them my card and tell them to tell their pediatrician to call me if he has the guts to.
Evolution denial, anthropogenic global warming denial, and vaccine denial, all in one comment! Truly, we have the crank trifecta!
Less amusing is this:
After this scam comes to an end, and it most certainly will come to an end because ALL SCAMS COME TO AN END. I personally am hoping it is through mob violence so I can get my licks in. I am going to have all of these ass wipe fraudulent studies along with the pictures of the authors printed on toilette paper of my choice, with raised lettering( so it catches more fecal material when I clean myself) on double ply paper because I want to be real comfortable when these “peer reviewed” articles and their authors from Pediatrics, Elsevier the CDC and the New England journal of Medicine do their real job. I am certain they will be great at it and that this is what their true purpose in life is.
When J.B. talks about “venomous invective,” perhaps he should look at his own blog. Nowhere do I ever advocate (or even just hope for) “mob violence.”

   The curious case of Poul Thorsen, fraud and embezzlement, and the Danish vaccine-autism studies
David Gorski
Link
If there’s one thing about the anti-vaccine movement, it’s all about the ad hominem attack. Failing to win on science, clinical trials, epidemiology, and other objective evidence, with few exceptions, anti-vaccine propagandists fall back on attacking the person instead of the evidence. For example, as I’ve noted numerous times, Paul Offit has been the subject of unrelenting attacks from Generation Rescue and other anti-vaccine groups, having been dubbed “Dr. Proffit” and accused of being so in the pocket of big pharma that he’ll do and say anything for it. I personally have been accused by Jake Crosby of a conflict of interest that isn’t, based on conspiracy mongering and an utterly brain dead argument (which is much like every other argument Jake likes to make on this issue). Steve Novella, Paul Offit, Amy Wallace, Trine Tsouderos, and others were portrayed as cannibals sitting down to a Thanksgiving feast of baby. Meanwhile, anti-vaccine luminaries invoke the pharma shill gambit with abandon and try their best to smear journalists who write about how anti-vaccine views are endangering herd immunity, journalists such as Trine Tsouderos, Amy Wallace, Chris Mooney, and Seth Mnookin, to name a few.
Sometimes, however, for whatever reason karma, fate, God, or whatever you want to call it smiles on anti-vaccine activists, dropping a story into their laps that allow them to indulge the worst of their tendencies towards ad hominem attacks and seem superficially credible. So it was about a year ago when an financial fraud investigation was being undertaken in the case of Poul Thorsen, a Danish investigator who had contributed to two large Danish studies, one of which failed to find an association between the MMR and autism in the immediate wake of Andrew Wakefield’s falsified data suggesting such an assocation and one of which failed to find an association between mercury in the thimerosal preservative in vaccines and an increased incidence of autism. At the time longstanding anti-vaccine propagandist Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. tore into Thorsen with abandon before he was even indicted or charged (he was only under investigation at the time) as though, even if he actually did commit fraud, such fraud invalidated the two large studies regarding MMR and autism and thimerosal and autism with which he had been involved. Did it?
To find out, let’s hop into our SBM TARDIS and go back in time about a year, in order to see the genesis of this manufactorversy that AoA is currently flogging. Let’s look at the case of Danish investigator Poul Thorsen as it developed.
Thorsen in 2010: Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. parties like it’s 2005
It was back in March 2010. Andrew Wakefield had just had his 1998 Lancet paper retracted by the editors in the wake of his having lost his medical license in the U.K. as a result of his research misconduct. Just when times seemed darkest for those who promote the scientifically discredited notion that vaccines cause autism, a miracle occurred! So great was the miracle that it enticed Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., who for quite some time before had actually been pretty quiet about vaccine/autism issues, to let himself be pulled out of storage, dusted off, and sent once again to tilt at mercury windmills. Not unsurprisingly, he reappeared on that bastion of anti-vaccine pseudoscience, The Huffington Post, and the title of his post was Central Figure in CDC Vaccine Cover-Up Absconds With $2M. In what appeared to be a coordinated attack, the anti-vaccine group Generation Rescue‘s blog Age of Autism was promoting RFK, Jr.’s article and adding a few of its own with titles such as Poul Thorsen’s Mutating Resume by the not-so-dynamic duo of Mark Blaxill and Dan Olmsted and NBC 11 Atlanta Reports: Vaccine Researcher Flees with $2M, featuring this news report:
These were among the earliest reports about Poul Thorsen. So what was going on? Let’s look at RFK’s article and how he started it:
A central figure behind the Center for Disease Control’s (CDC) claims disputing the link between vaccines and autism and other neurological disorders has disappeared after officials discovered massive fraud involving the theft of millions in taxpayer dollars. Danish police are investigating Dr. Poul Thorsen, who has vanished along with almost $2 million that he had supposedly spent on research.
Thorsen was a leading member of a Danish research group that wrote several key studies supporting CDC’s claims that the MMR vaccine and mercury-laden vaccines were safe for children. Thorsen’s 2003 Danish study reported a 20-fold increase in autism in Denmark after that country banned mercury based preservatives in its vaccines. His study concluded that mercury could therefore not be the culprit behind the autism epidemic.
But was Thorsen really the driving force behind the Danish vaccine-autism studies that the anti-vaccine movement hates so much? I had been paying close attention to the vaccine-mercury-autism manufactroversy for nearly five years then, and I had never heard of him, although I had heard of one of his coauthors. If Thorsen was so important to the pro-vaccine movement, you wouldn’t have known it from the two studies that the mercury militia was hoping to discredit by turning up its propaganda machine to 11 about Thorsen’s possible criminal behavior. Those papers were:
Madsen KM, Hviid A, Vestergaard M, Schendel D, Wohlfahrt J, Thorsen P, Olsen J, Melbye M. A population-based study of measles, mumps, and rubella vaccination and autism. N Engl J Med. 2002 Nov 7;347(19):1477-82.
Madsen KM, Lauritsen MB, Pedersen CB, Thorsen P, Plesner AM, Andersen PH, Mortensen PB. Thimerosal and the occurrence of autism: negative ecological evidence from Danish population-based data. Pediatrics. 2003 Sep;112(3 Pt 1):604-6.
It is the Pediatrics paper that the mercury militia appeared to be concentrating mostly on because it directly deals with thimerosal in vaccines. But look at the citations above for both papers anyway. Do you notice something? Look where Thorsen’s name is in the list of authors in both studies. Notice that it is not first, nor is it last. This is important because author order matters in scientific and medical studies. In straight science studies, the two most important authors are usually the first author and the last author. The last author is usually the senior author in whose laboratory the work was done, while the first author is the person whose project the work represents and who was the primary author of the manuscript. In medical papers, as in Pediatrics or NEJM, the author list usually signifies the relative contribution of each author to the article, the first being the most important and the last being the least important. In both types of articles, there is always designated one author who is the corresponding author. In scientific papers, the corresponding author is almost always the last author; in medical papers it is usually the first author. The corresponding author is responsible for answering inquiries about the study and, way back in the age before PDF files, used to be the author to contact to request reprints. Not only that, the corresponding author is generally considered to be the primary author for the paper.
Notice something else?
That’s right. Poul Thorsen was not the first author for either of these studies. He was not the last author, either. He was not the corresponding author; that would be Kreesten M. Madsen, MD, who was corresponding author on both the NEJM and Pediatrics papers. As it turns out, Thorsen was safely ensconced in the middle of the pack of co-authors. That’s why, when RFK, Jr. referred to the Pediatrics study as “Thorsen’s study,” he had to be either grossly ignorant or intentionally misleading (Take your pick.) Anyone who knows anything about how the scientific literature works would be able to spot that immediately just by looking at the abstracts of these articles. Trust me, if studies this large really were Thorsen’s babies his name would not have been relegated to fourth or sixth on the list of authors. Basically, Thorsen’s position in the author lists of these two papers indicated that, whatever leadership position he may have held at Aarhus University and in its vaccine studies group, he clearly was not the primary contributor for these studies.
Not that that stopped the mercury militia from going out of its way to paint him as such, referring to him as a “central figure.” At the time, I had to tip my hat to RFK, Jr. his language throughout his article is truly Orwellian, a propaganda masterpiece of prestidigitation of language and innuendo. Here are just a few examples of perfectly loaded phrases sprinkled throughout the article, all designed to suggest concealment and conspiracy:
    • …”built a research empire…”
    • “…failed to disclose…”
    • “…has disappeared…”
    • “…damning e-mails surfaced…”
    • “…culprit behind…”
    • “…leading independent scientists have accused CDC of concealing the clear link between the dramatic increases in mercury-laced child vaccinations.”
    • “…safe to inject young children with mercury…”
    • “…CDC officials intent on fraudulently cherry picking…”
RFK, Jr. also parroted anti-vaccine talking points about the study that were hoary back when David Kirby first published the mercury militia Bible, Evidence of Harm, talking points like:
His study has long been criticized as fraudulent since it failed to disclose that the increase was an artifact of new mandates requiring, for the first time, that autism cases be reported on the national registry. This new law and the opening of a clinic dedicated to autism treatment in Copenhagen accounted for the sudden rise in reported cases rather than, as Thorsen seemed to suggest, the removal of mercury from vaccines. Despite this obvious chicanery, CDC has long touted the study as the principal proof that mercury-laced vaccines are safe for infants and young children. Mainstream media, particularly the New York Times, has relied on this study as the basis for its public assurances that it is safe to inject young children with mercury — a potent neurotoxin — at concentrations hundreds of times over the U.S. safety limits.
Notice how RFK Jr. really, really wanted you to believe that the Danish studies are the primary foundation upon which the science exonerating MMR and thimerosal-containing vaccines as a cause of autism rests, the be-all and end-all of the epidemiology studying thimerosal-containing vaccines, when in fact there are multiple studies and lines of evidence, of which the Danish studies are but a part. Also notice how he conflated a study’s being weak with its being fraudulent. The two are entirely different concepts, and it is entirely possible for a study to be poorly designed and executed without even a whiff of fraud. Be that as it may, the Danish studies, although they have weaknesses inherent in a retrospective design, are actually pretty darned good studies. As I said before, RFK’s whine in the passage above is the parroting of a hoary criticism of the Danish studies cribbed straight from anti-vaccine sites. The criticism goes like this. Anti-vaccine propagandists argue that because, beginning in 1994, outpatient records were used in addition to inpatient records for case ascertainment in Denmark for purposes of these studies, the whole set of studies must be crap. As Steve Novella pointed out, this change was not chicanery, and in fact Madsen et al tried to test whether the change in case reporting by doing this was significant. Here is a quote from Madsen et al:
In additional analyses we examined data using inpatients only. This was done to elucidate the contribution of the outpatient registration to the change in incidence. The same trend with an increase in the incidence rates from 1990 until the end of the study period was seen.
In other words, Madsen et al considered the possibility that adding outpatient records to inpatient records beginning in 1994 might change the results. They tested for that possibility and determined that the addition of outpatient cases did not change the trend of increasing autism diagnoses. Again, RFK, Jr. was either grossly ignorant of the facts or consciously distorting. (Take your pick–again.) The same was true of J.B. Handley when he repeated the same misinformation, and and of Ginger Taylor when she also repeated the same fallacious argument.
Here’s what was going on. In the wake of debacle the implosion of Andrew Wakefield represented, the anti-vaccine movement needed a distraction—badly—and they needed it fast. It would have been even better if the distraction were one that they could spin to make it look as though there were some dark corruption at the heart of the vaccine science. Like manna from heaven, about a year ago Dr. Thorsen’s case dropped seemingly from the sky. Never mind that it makes absolutely no difference to the science exonerating vaccines or thimerosal in vaccines as a cause of autism whether Thorsen is a criminal and thief or not. It was convenient propaganda, even though there is abundant evidence that Thorsen was not a major player in the Pediatrics and NEJM publications reporting the Danish studies.
Fast forward to 2011: The indictment of Poul Thorsen for fraud
As we have seen, in the wake of the commencement of an investigation of Poul Thorsen for fraud and embezzlement of CDC grant money, it was not surprising that the anti-vaccine movement struggled mightily to elevate him to being the prime mover and shaker of the Danish studies. The reason was obvious: They wanted to discredit “inconvenient” studies that did not support their belief that mercury in vaccines causes autism. It was an ad hominem attack, plain and simple, because the primary argument was not against the data or the studies, but against the man. It’s a form of poisoning the well or guilt by association. It’s the same thing as if I were to point to physicians who have defrauded Medicare or insurance companies and argue that all science-based medicine is thus somehow suspect. Unfortunately, this sort of tactic frequently works–which is why propagandists without moral qualms about smearing their opponents frequently use it.
It’s also why, when I saw this article a couple of weeks ago, I knew that it wouldn’t be long before Age of Autism and other anti-vaccine minions would be swarming. After all, in January the BMJ had published the rest of Brian Deer’s expose of Andrew Wakefield’s research fraud, showing his actions to be even worse than we had suspected. The anti-vaccine movement needed another distraction, and the indictment of Poul Thorsen was a convenient one, which is why it wasn’t long before the anti-vaccine blog Age of Autism was on the case after Thorsen had been indicted. Since then, Thorsen has been a regular feature on AoA (up to and including today’s post) and other anti-vaccine blogs and websites. You’ll see why from this news report:
A Danish man was indicted Wednesday on charges of wire fraud and money laundering for allegedly concocting a scheme to steal more than $1 million in autism research money from the Atlanta-based Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
The indictment charges Poul Thorsen, 49, with 13 counts of wire fraud and nine counts of money laundering. The wire fraud counts each carry a maximum of 20 years in prison and the money laundering counts each carry a maximum of 10 years in prison, with a fine of up to $250,000 for each count.
The federal government also seeks forfeiture of all property derived from the alleged offenses, including an Atlanta residence, two cars and a Harley-Davidson motorcycle.
This is how Thorsen is now accused of having done it:
Once in Denmark, THORSEN allegedly began stealing the grant money by submitting fraudulent documents to have expenses supposedly related to the Danish studies be paid with the grant money. He provided the documents to the Danish government, and to Aarhus University and Odense University Hospital, where scientists performed research under the grant. From February 2004 through June 2008, THORSEN allegedly submitted over a dozen fraudulent invoices, purportedly signed by a laboratory section chief at the CDC, for reimbursement of expenses that THORSEN claimed were incurred in connection with the CDC grant. The invoices falsely claimed that a CDC laboratory had performed work and was owed grant money. Based on these invoices, Aarhus University, where THORSEN also held a faculty position, transferred hundreds of thousands of dollars to bank accounts held at the CDC Federal Credit Union in Atlanta, accounts which Aarhus University believed belonged to the CDC. In truth, the CDC Federal Credit Union accounts were personal accounts held by THORSEN. After the money was transferred, THORSEN allegedly withdrew it for his own personal use, buying a home in Atlanta, a Harley Davidson motorcycle, and Audi and Honda vehicles, and obtaining numerous cashier’s checks, from the fraud proceeds. THORSEN allegedly absconded with over $1 million from the scheme.
If Thorsen is convicted, I have no problem saying unequivocally that he should go to prison for a long time. As was pointed out in this Reuters story about the indictment, research dollars are a precious commodity. In fact, with the recent budget battles and cuts in Washington, government research grants haven’t been this hard to come by for 20 years, and there’s no sign of improvement in the situation in sight; it will likely be several years before things get better, if they ever get better at all. So, I’m as angry as anyone to see a researcher abuse research funds by, if the indictment is correct, buying a home and a Harley-Davidson motorcycle. Of course, having had to deal with the bureaucracy at my university and cancer institute that oversees my grants, I really don’t understand how it is even possible to buy a house and a Harley using grant funds. Every major expenditure (for me, at least) is closely tracked and matched to the approved budget. I can’t even envision how, even if I wanted to try to misuse large sums of my grant funds, I could even find a way to do it. I really can’t. To me, if Thorsen really did abuse his research funds this way, it points to a serious accounting and oversight problem in his university that allowed such chicanery to occur.
Be that as it may, reading between the lines I do find one bit of information that might explain some things about the Danish studies. Madsen was the first and corresponding author, but it’s pointed out that Thorsen became principal investigator of the CDC grant in 2002. That doesn’t help AoA at all, though. I went and looked up the two articles again and noticed something interesting that I hadn’t really paid attention to before.
The NEJM article lists its funding sources as:
Supported by grants from the Danish National Research Foundation; the National Vaccine Program Office and National Immunization Program, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; and the National Alliance for Autism Research.
This article was, however, published in November 2002. Given that it takes months, sometimes even a year or more, for a manuscript to go from submission to publication, this work had almost certainly been completed and was in the publication pipeline before Thorsen took over as principal investigator of the CDC grant. The Pediatrics paper, which was published after Thorsen went back to Denmark, lists its funding thusly:
The activities of the Danish Epidemiology Science Centre and the National Centre for Register-Based Research are funded by a grant from the Danish National Research Foundation. This study was supported by the Stanley Medical Research Institute. No funding sources were involved in the study design.
That’s right. The Pediatrics thimerosal study was not even funded by the CDC! Even if it were, given that large epidemiological studies take years to carry out, it probably was in the last leg of its analysis when Thorsen showed up anyway. Even worse for the “guilt by association” crowd, all of the fraudulent charges to the grant are alleged to have occurred between 2004 and 2008, as described above–well after the Danish studies were published.
Of course, none of this stops AoA from opining:
We have written several articles about Dr. Poul Thorsen (4th from the left in the back row with his CDC colleagues), whose research known as “The Danish Study” is quoted extensively to “debunk” the autism vaccine connection. The mainstream media was silent when he disappeared. Here are some of the posts we’ve run on the topic along with today’s article in the Atlanta Bizjournals below. Will they give Thorsen “the Wakefield treatment” now, or have they been given their marching orders to look the other way?
Of course, not noted by the author is that Thorsen has already been treated far more harshly than Wakefield ever was! He’s been indicted on criminal charges; all that happened to Wakefield is that he was struck off the register of licensed UK physicians, and then only after a ridiculously long (two and a half year) hearing by the British General Medical Council. He just had a couple of his papers retracted, the most prominent of which being the Lancet paper from 1998 for which strong evidence was found that he had falsified data. In the meantime, he had moved to Texas to make big bucks applying his woo to autistic children, at least until the scandal led even his friends kick him out of the practice. Thorsen faces decades in prison if convicted of these crimes. My guess right now is that Thorsen is praying for “the Wakefield treatment.” It was so much less harsh than what he faces if he is convicted of defrauding the federal government. My other guess is that Thorsen would gladly take the “Wakefield treatment” over the possibility of 20+ years in a federal prison.
Not long after AoA, the anti-vaccine group Autism Action Network (formerly known as A-CHAMP) also piled on. If you read this “action alert,” you’ll notice the clever linking of Thorsen’s indictment for defrauding the federal government of research funds with baseless criticism of the two main Danish studies that provide strong epidemiological evidence that failed to find a link between the MMR vaccine and autism or thimerosal in vaccines and autism. It doesn’t matter that Thorsen’s alleged fraud didn’t even occur until at least a year after the publication of the thimerosal study.
Then, of course, the anti-vaccine group Safeminds had to weigh in with its own press release. Sallie Bernard, unfazed by reality and science, stares bravely into the abyss that was once what little credibility she has, and insists that “many biological studies support a link between mercury and autism, but these Danish studies have been used to suppress further research into thimerosal. With clear evidence of Dr. Thorsen’s lack of ethics, it is imperative to reopen this investigation.” And there you have it, the clearest and most honest statement of the intent of the anti-vaccine movement. In essence, all they want is any excuse they can find to try to demand “more studies,” even as the hypothesis that vaccines cause autism continues to pine for the fjords. Like Polly, however, it is still an ex-hypothesis, while, like Frankenstein, Bernard thinks she can infuse life into the dead. (I do so love to mix metaphors when it suits my purpose.) However, instead of using electricity from lightening Bernard uses nonsense like this:
In addition, internal emails obtained via FOIA document discussion between the Danish researchers and Thornsen which acknowledge that the studies did not include the latest data from 2001 where the incidence and prevalence of autism was declining which would be supportive of a vaccine connection. The emails also include requests from Thornsen to CDC asking that the agency write letters to the journal Pediatrics encouraging them to publish the research after it had been rejected by other journals. A top CDC official complied with the request sending a letter to the editor of the journal supporting the publication of the study which they called a “strong piece of evidence that thimerosal is not linked to autism”.
The latter accusation above is just plain silly, as this link shows. Basically, it’s a letter of support from the CDC for the Danish thimerosal article, and there’s nothing there in any way incriminating. I do find it odd, however, that clearly the second page of the letter is missing, which makes me wonder why that is. The e-mails already say who signed the letter. As for the e-mails about the data from 2001, it’s impossible to tell exactly what the correspondents are saying. There are only two brief e-mails, and much text is redacted with black marker, that consist of an exchange between Marlene Lauritsen, who’s second author on the paper, and Kreesten Madsen, the first author. It’s cryptically mentioned that the incidence and prevalence are “still decreasing in 2001,” but the sentence immediately following it is redacted. Most of Madsen’s reply to this e-mail is also redacted.
In other words, the e-mails tell us little or nothing. More importantly, as Sullivan has shown by listing the studies rejecting the vaccine-autism hypothesis on which Thorsen is a co-author, you could eliminate every study with which Thorsen was associated, and the literature refuting the hypothesis is only reduced slightly.
Finally, of all the reactions to the study, there is one that made me laugh out loud when I read it. I’m talking about Katie Wright:
Who would make serious health care decisions based upon the work of a thief and a fraud.
Come on CDC, you cannot be serious.
Given that Wright and the many AoA followers have routinely made health care decisions based upon the work of Andrew Wakefield, who, while not a thief, was clearly a scientific fraud, I posit that Wright owes me a new irony meter. She blew mine up again–melted that sucker into a pool of gurgling plastic, rubber, and copper wire so that it’s now sputtering pathetically on my desk. Yet Wright and her fellow travelers defend Wakefield to the death metaphorically speaking, with J.B. Handley, for example, even going so far in this weekend’s New York Times Magazine as to liken him to “Nelson Mandela and Jesus Christ rolled up into one” and Michelle Guppy, coordinator of the Houston Autism Disability Network, darkly threatening a reporter, “Be nice to him [Wakefield], or we will hurt you.”
Double standard? You be the judge.
Conclusion
To a certain extent, I understand the assertion of “once a cheat, always a cheat.” I understand that the lead author (Madsen) and Thorsen’s other co-investigators might now want to check over Thorsen’s contribution to the two papers (as relatively small as it appears to be compared to the other authors), even for the paper whose work was not funded by the CDC at all and therefore has zero financial dependency on the CDC. That’s normal caution. However, normal caution is most definitely not what these attacks by Safeminds and AoA are about. They’re about the denialist technique of spreading FUD (fear, uncertainty, and doubt) about vaccines. Let’s just put it this way. Let’s say the anti-vaccine movement’s wet dream about Thorsen came true and it was somehow discovered that his science was also falsified and that, further, his fraud was enough to call the conclusions of every study for which Thorsen was a co-author in doubt. Even in that highly unlikely scenario, in which both studies were somehow completely discredited as a result of Thorsen’s financial chicanery with grant funds, it would not be nearly enough for scientists to call into question the scientific consensus that neither the MMR nor thimerosal are associated with an increased risk for autism. The reason is that there’s so much other evidence that is consistent with the Danish studies and similarly shows that neither the MMR nor thimerosal in vaccines is associated with autism.
What AoA, Safeminds, and other denialists refuse to understand is that science is rarely, if ever, a matter of a scientific consensus being based on one study, two studies, or a handful of studies. A scientific consensus is based on examining all the evidence from all relevant studies, deciding which studies are most methodologically powerful, and then synthesizing it all into a conclusion. Contrast this to how the anti-vaccine movement treats its “brave maverick doctors” like Andrew Wakefield, Mark Geier, Rashid Buttar, et al, and the difference between real science and anti-vaccine pseudoscience couldn’t be clearer.
ADDENDUM: I can’t resist pointing you to a hilariously misguided attack against me that proves once again that, for the anti-vaccine activists, it’s all about the ad hominem. Clifford Miller, a.k.a. ChildHealthSafety, was apparently unhappy that in the comments of Seth Mnookin’s post complaining about J.B. Handley’s attacking him solely based on his having once been a heroin addict, an addiction that Seth managed to beat, I dared to criticize J.B. for an ad hominem attack. In response, Miller fired off a counterattack. Not only was he unhappy about a post of mine that was over a year old, but he regurgitated Jake Crosby’s fallacious pharma shill gambit that used against me last summer.
Thank you, Mr. Miller, for a hearty chuckle and for, in your utterly irony challenged manner, proving my point about the anti-vaccine movement and ad hominem attacks better than I ever could.

Autism prevalence increases to 1 in 38, and antivaxxers blame vaccines without using the word “vaccine”
The CDC updated its estimates for the prevalence of autism spectrum disorders. Predictably, antivaxxers blame the increasing prevalence of ASDs reported, particularly in Black children, on “environmental factors,” which is antivax code for, “Vaccines are to blame.”
David Gorski on March 27, 2023
Link

Many years ago, long before the COVID-19 pandemic upended everything and turbocharged the antivaccine movement beyond anything any of us had ever seen or predicted, the central conspiracy theory of the antivaccine movement (as I like to call it) was that vaccines caused autism, and the CDC and FDA were covering up the evidence. In retrospect, that version of the central conspiracy theory seems almost quaint compared to the current version centered around COVID-19 vaccines (particularly mRNA vaccines), in which antivaxxers claim that these vaccines are killing, sterilizing, and inducing “turbo cancers” in millions, but the CDC and FDA (plus, Anthony Fauci) covered up the evidence that was apparently so obvious that experts missed all the signals that people with no training in medicine, epidemiology, or vaccinology could find. Back then, after having been a blogger for a couple of years, I had come to dread April, at least when it came to antivaccine misinformation. The reason was simple. April is National Autism Awareness Month, and I could always count on the antivaccine movement to ramp up its misinformation linking a combination of the MMR vaccine, “too many vaccines too soon,” and mercury from the thimerosal preservative that used to be used in a number of childhood vaccines before 2001 as the cause for the “autism epidemic.” Sure, often the vaccines were not the only thing blamed for rising autism prevalence. Often processed foods, wifi, and a number of other supposed “causes” were thrown in as well, but always at the center of causes that conspiracy theorists blamed for the increasing prevalence of autism were vaccines.
You might think that this whole strain of antivaccine “thought” (if you can call it that) might have disappeared to insignificance, with the rise of “new school” antivaxxers focused mainly on COVID-19 vaccines. However, as I’ve described a number of times, there is increasingly little daylight between “old school” MMR/thimerosal-autism antivaxxers and “new school” COVID-19 antivaxxers, as the latter have started repeating exactly the same tropes as the former and started to generalize their fear of COVID-19 vaccines to all vaccines. As I perused my feeds of antivax websites and blogs and came across an article by Cynthia Nevison on Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s website entitled In New Autism Report, CDC Again Fails to Address Root Causes, I had flashbacks to 15 years ago and couldn’t help but think that antivaxxers were partying like it was 2009. (I admit that I couldn’t find a way to slip 1999 into this quip and so had to settle for a decade later. No one ever said that I could be as funny as Clay Jones or Jonathan Howard.) I also recognized that name as someone whom I had first encountered in 2012, when she co-opted the language of scientists and skeptics to liken “autism epidemic denialists” to climate science deniers who refuse to accept the science of anthropogenic climate change characterized by global warming. At the time, she was an atmospheric research scientist at the University of Colorado, but in the meantime she appears to have become a full-time crank.
The reasons my thoughts went this way was because, in antivax-speak, “root causes” always mean vaccines, primarily at least. However, changing times do lead to changing language. For example, I couldn’t help but immediately notice how Nevison cleverly never actually uses the words “vaccine” or “vaccination” anywhere in her article and also now echoes attacks on public health organizations like the CDC for being too “woke” in that the blurb for her article states:
In its latest autism report, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention continues to focus on equity, rather than causation, even though the new prevalence numbers have turned the equity argument upside down.
Of course, RFK Jr., being RFK Jr., and The Defender, being The Defender, the game had been given away the day before in an article by Brenda Baletti entitled 1 in 36 Kids Have Autism, CDC Says — Critics Slam Agency’s Failure to Investigate Causes. In this case, “critics” mean antivaxxers, and “causes” again mean vaccines, plus a lot of other “environmental” factors, but, make no mistake, Baletti is talking mainly about vaccines:
As autism rates skyrocketed among U.S. children over the past several decades, along with concern among parents, much research has turned to investigate the role of environmental risk factors in compounding underlying diverse genetic factors.
Environmental risk factors include metals like aluminum and mercury in vaccines, glyphosate exposure, use of acetaminophen during pregnancy and infancy, heavy metals in baby food and other organic environmental pollutants.
Studies also link industrial chemicals, such as lead, arsenic, copper, selenium, iron and magnesium, to the disorder.
Seeing this narrative, I remembered that it’s been five years since I last wrote about autism prevalence and how the antivaccine movement tries its hardest to blame its increase on vaccines. That’s why I think an update is definitely in order.
Times change, but the antivax autism narrative doesn’t
Going back over my posts on this blog and my not-so-super-secret other blog, I found that antivaxxers were flipping out over vaccines as a cause of autism in 2018 (when the CDC reported autism prevalence was reported to be 1 in 59), in 2014 (when the CDC reported autism prevalence was reported to be 1 in 68), and in 2012 (when the CDC reported autism prevalence was reported to be 1 in 88). So did our founder Steve Novella, who wrote in 2009, 2011, and 2014 about how true autism prevalence has almost certainly been unchanged over the last two or three decades.
Rising autism prevalence dating back to the 1980s has, ever since the myth that vaccines cause autism arose in the 1990s, fueled an antivaccine narrative that there is an autism “epidemic,” which in some cases has even been called a tsunami, an intentional comparison with a devastating natural disaster that sweeps away everything. At the same time, any scientific pushback against the claim that vaccines are the cause of increasing autism prevalence would be attacked as “denial.” It is a narrative that continues, with longtime antivaccine activist Mark Blaxill having pontificated on it in an interview after he’d somehow managed to publish an article with Toby Rogers and, yes, Cynthia Nevison in a bottom-feeding peer-reviewed journal less than two years ago.
Each time the CDC releases new figures for autism prevalence, along with its analysis of those figures (publications that almost always show up near the end of March, just in time for Autism Awareness Month), antivaxxers regurgitate the same argument: “Autism prevalence is still skyrocketing! It must be environmental factors (translation: vaccines, pollution, high fructose corn syrup, heavy metals, but mostly vaccines), but the CDC is ignoring these potential causes. In fairness, no one rules out environmental contributors to autism development that can alter the risk; it would be irresponsible to do so for a condition that is as multifactorial as autism. However, the evidence, as summarized by Steve and me (and many others) is that, by far, the largest contributor to autism is genetic, a conclusion that continues to be reinforced by more recent studies, to the point that signs of autism have been detected in the fetus, with the contribution of environmental factors being estimated to be between 7%-35%, but possibly as low as zero.
Which brings us to the CDC report and how autism prevalence can still be increasing even if the condition is primarily heritable; i.e., genetic. To set the stage, I will simply repeat something that I have repeated many times. Autism prevalence is referring to the fraction of children in the population given a diagnosis of a condition known as autism. As I have also discussed many times. many conditions are underdiagnosed, and that was almost certainly the case with autism decades ago continuing into recent years, but less so.
The CDC report and the antivax reaction
As the it has done periodically for a number of years now, on Friday the CDC published a report in MMWR, Prevalence and Characteristics of Autism Spectrum Disorder Among Children Aged 8 Years — Autism and Developmental Disabilities Monitoring Network, 11 Sites, United States, 2020. As is also usually the case, the report covers up to around two or three years ago, because that’s how long it takes the data to mature into usable statistics. As the CDC does when it publishes these figures, it used data from Autism and Developmental Disabilities Monitoring (ADDM) Network, an active surveillance program that provides estimates of the prevalence of ASD among children aged 8 years.
Before I discuss the results, I’m going to stop a moment to point out a phrase: Active surveillance. We often discuss the difference between passive and active surveillance systems when discussing the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database, a passive surveillance system, compared to systems like the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD), an active surveillance system. The difference between an active and passive surveillance system is that, in contrast to passive surveillance systems that rely on reports generated by healthcare workers and other sources (in the case of VAERS anyone can report), active surveillance systems are set up to monitor for a diagnosis. In the case of the VSD, the electronic health records (EHRs) of a number of large healthcare systems are monitored to look for associations between vaccination and adverse events, diseases, and health conditions. In the case of ADDM:
In 2020, there were 11 ADDM Network sites across the United States (Arizona, Arkansas, California, Georgia, Maryland, Minnesota, Missouri, New Jersey, Tennessee, Utah, and Wisconsin). To ascertain ASD among children aged 8 years, ADDM Network staff review and abstract developmental evaluations and records from community medical and educational service providers. A child met the case definition if their record documented 1) an ASD diagnostic statement in an evaluation, 2) a classification of ASD in special education, or 3) an ASD International Classification of Diseases (ICD) code.
In this study, children included in the report were born in 2012 and lived in surveillance areas of the 11 sites during 2020. Using a definition of autism spectrum disorders (ASDs) described in depth in the article, the authors then estimated the prevalence of ASDs and then:
Prevalence was calculated as the number of children with ASD per 1,000 children in the defined population or group. Overall ASD prevalence estimates included all children with ASD from all 11 sites. Prevalence also was stratified by sex and by race and ethnicity using both the U.S. Census postcensal population estimates as well as the National Center for Health Statistics postcensal bridged race denominators. The Wilson score method was used to calculate 95% CIs. Pearson chi-square tests were used to compare proportions, and the Mantel-Haenszel (Woolf) test of homogeneity compared prevalence ratios across sites. Permutation tests were conducted to test differences in medians. Cochran Armitage tests were used to detect trends in prevalence across SES tertiles. Prevalence estimates with a relative SE >30% (and ratios calculated from those estimates) were considered to have limited statistical precision and were suppressed. Statistical tests with p values <0.05 and prevalence ratio 95% CIs that excluded 1.0 were considered statistically significant. R software (version 4.2; R Foundation) and additional packages were used to conduct analyses (12).
The report also divided cases into children who had an ICD code for an ASD diagnosis only, those who had eligibility for school services without a diagnosis, and those who had a diagnosis. The key findings of the study were:
    • For 2020, one in 36 children aged 8 years (approximately 4% of boys and 1% of girls) was estimated to have ASD. These estimates are higher than previous ADDM Network estimates during 2000–2018.
    • For the first time among children aged 8 years, the prevalence of ASD was lower among White children than among other racial and ethnic groups, reversing the direction of racial and ethnic differences in ASD prevalence observed in the past.
    • Black children with ASD were still more likely than White children with ASD to have a co-occurring intellectual disability.
A bit more detail about the first two findings:
For 2020, across all 11 ADDM sites, ASD prevalence per 1,000 children aged 8 years ranged from 23.1 in Maryland to 44.9 in California. The overall ASD prevalence was 27.6 per 1,000 (one in 36) children aged 8 years and was 3.8 times as prevalent among boys as among girls (43.0 versus 11.4). Overall, ASD prevalence was lower among non-Hispanic White children (24.3) and children of two or more races (22.9) than among non-Hispanic Black or African American (Black), Hispanic, and non-Hispanic Asian or Pacific Islander (A/PI) children (29.3, 31.6, and 33.4 respectively). ASD prevalence among non-Hispanic American Indian or Alaska Native (AI/AN) children (26.5) was similar to that of other racial and ethnic groups. ASD prevalence was associated with lower household income at three sites, with no association at the other sites.
Now let’s see how Nevison spins these results. Again, she doesn’t mention vaccines at all, but if you remember that “environmental factors” or “non-genetic factors” are code terms for vaccines you’ll get the intended message. Remember, like most antivaxxers, Nevison denies being antivaccine. Vaccines are just one of many potential genetic factors that she’s considering. In this case, though, you have to be aware of her history dating back to at least 2012 to know what she is about in her article, although the fact that she published it on the website of a longtime leader of the antivaccine movement is also a hint.
Race and autism, according to antivaxxers
The CDC report found that for the first time ASD prevalence was lower among non-Hispanic White children and children of two or more races than among non-Hispanic Black or African American (Black), Hispanic, and non-Hispanic Asian or Pacific Islander (A/PI) children. In the past, this was not true, and the lower ASD prevalence among Blacks, for instance, was attributed to less access to screening, health care, and services that led to an under-ascertainment of cases among some minorities. In other words, the difference in prevalence between white and Black children was a reflection of racial disparities. There is diagnostic substitution, a phenomenon in which children who would have been diagnosed with something other than ASD (or not diagnosed with ASD at all) are now being diagnosed with ASD.
Citing both the current report and another report by the CDC published on the same day that looked at early identification of ASD in four-year-olds, Nevison argues:
Yet one of the most notable features of both new ADDM reports is the rapid rise in ASD prevalence among racial minorities relative to white children, who historically have had the highest prevalence.
For example, in 2004, the mean Hispanic to white ASD ratio was 0.67 nationwide for children born in 2004.
In the new reports, the mean Hispanic to white ASD ratio is 1.3 for 8-year-olds and 1.8 for 4-year-olds. The mean U.S. Black to white ASD ratio is 1.2 for 8 year-olds and 1.6 for 4-year-olds.
Figure 1 below illustrates how strikingly these racial differences in ASD prevalence have shifted over time. Meanwhile, absolute prevalence continues to climb for all racial groups, albeit more slowly for whites.
She even provided this figure:

How does one interpret a graph like this? First, one notes that there are no error bars. If there were, the results would look a lot less impressive, although the p-values for the prevalence ratios were statistically significant in Table 3. Now let’s see how Nevison spins this result:
The media coverage of the ADDM reports for birth years 2006 and 2008 primarily attributed increasing overall ASD prevalence to better diagnosis among Black children.
The media went so far as to imply that the overall increased rate of ASD was hopeful news because it indicated that Blacks were “catching up” to whites and achieving diagnostic equity — the hope being that their diagnosis would afford them earlier and better access to services.
The apparent underlying assumption was that there is a natural genetic level of ASD in the population, which is reflected in white prevalence, and that all races and ethnicities will eventually stabilize at that level thanks to improved outreach and screening.
The new ADDM report recognizes that, “For the first time … the prevalence of ASD was lower among White children than among other racial and ethnic groups, reversing the direction of racial and ethnic differences in ASD prevalence observed in the past.” However, the authors neglect to acknowledge that this reversal undermines the hopeful interpretation of previous ADDM data and effectively turns the equity argument on its head.
First of all, although Nevison does get the underlying assumption correct that there is likely a “natural genetic level of ASD in the population,” notice how she mischaracterizes it as being reflected in the prevalence in white children. There is no reason to assume that the same sorts differences in prevalence among different racial and ethnic groups that we observe for diseases with a large genetic component (e.g., various cancers, cardiovascular diseases) would not also be likely in a heritable condition like autism. In other words, there is no a priori reason to assume that the “natural genetic prevalence” (not an epidemiological term, but I’ll use it because it’s what Nevison uses) of ASDs would be the same in Blacks as in whites. Moreover, you can’t really even assume that there is a true difference based on one set of data. It could be that in 2 years the prevalences will be indistinguishable. In any event, whatever other factors might be influencing this increase in autism prevalence in Blacks and Hispanics, observing underserved minorities “catch up” in prevalence is actually likely an indication that these groups are finally getting access to screening and services that white children have long taken for granted.
Unsurprisingly, antivaxxers are having none of this. For example, at SafeMinds an old antivax warrior Sallie Bernard dismissed the possibility that the increase in ASD prevalence observed among Black children in the latest report is due to better ascertainment thusly:
That does not explain why their rate is higher than white children. As a group, no racial or ethnic minority here gets better assessment and diagnosis than white children, so to explain the disparity in the rate now as due to better assessment for minorities is just ludicrous.
Note the assumption there. Assessment and diagnosis do not have to be “better” in order to produce this result in a single year’s study, particularly if the actual prevalence in Black children is actually higher than it is in white children. At the very least, more temporal data points are needed even to conclude that ASD prevalence among Black children is indeed higher than it is among white children.
Next, Nevison takes on the third observation, that Black children with ASD are more likely to have a diagnosis of intellectual disability:
Instead, the report adds that, “Black children with ASD were still more likely than White children with ASD to have co-occurring intellectual disability” — as though this were a reassuring line of continuity from past reports.
However, the disparity in the rate of co-occurring intellectual disability, which is nearly twice as high among Blacks compared with whites, was an overlooked and unmentioned thorn that didn’t fit with the optimistic “catching up” interpretation of the birth year 2006 and 2008 reports.
In the new birth year 2012 ADDM report, more than 60% of the 8-year-olds diagnosed with ASD nationwide have either severe (IQ
Unsurprisingly, Nevison neglects to mention a big caveat described as a limitation in the study:
Finally, the surveillance case definition of intellectual disability is not the same as a clinical diagnosis; IQ measurements in young children might lack stability and children might not ultimately receive a diagnosis of intellectual disability.
Also, there could well be other reasons for this. Indeed, in the other take on these studies by Baletti, the other possibility is acknowledged only to be dismissed:
Black children with autism were far more likely than white children to have a co-occurring intellectual disability, which the report said might stem from “underascertainment of ASD among Black children without intellectual disability.”
This is, of course, a perfectly reasonable possible explanation that needs to be considered and investigated, but antivaxxers dismiss it out of hand. Bernard, of course, tries to spin this as slam-dunk evidence for an “environmental”—cough, cough, vaccines!—cause of autism:
Now they’ve diagnosed that Black children have such a high rate of intellectual disability and borderline intellectual disability. That’s a group of people with autism that have the toughest time in life. For families, it’s so hard. And so they absolutely need more attention.
“But it doesn’t explain the social determinants of health. For that, we need environmental justice. You have to ask what are they exposed to?
Meanwhile, Toby Rogers, who is both antivaccine and transphobic, predictably spins a conspiracy theory, in which “they” are keeping The Truth from you:
The unwillingness of the CDC to even ask why these numbers are increasing is a massive ‘poker tell’ that they know but are prohibited from talking about it.
Two high-quality, multi-million dollar studies in California (Byrd et al., 2002; Hertz-Picciotto and Delwiche, 2009) both concluded that better awareness, changes in diagnostic criteria and earlier age of diagnosis only explain a small fraction of the rise in autism.
Cherry pick studies much, Toby? Steve Novella discussed at least one of those studies and its flaws back when it was published, noting that the study itself came to rather conservative conclusions that Picciotto liked to spin in press interviews as slam-dunk evidence that there must be some unidentified environmental contributor to autism and ignore studies that show that the vast majority of increases in ASD prevalence (which, when you come right down to it are differences in the proportion of children in a given population who receive an ASD diagnosis) have been driven by changes in diagnostic criteria, screening, and public awareness.
Before I conclude, I will, as I have done a number of times, answer the argument from incredulity that antivaxxers often invoke, in which they claim that changes in diagnostic criteria and/or screening can’t possibly result in such large increases in a diagnosis.
DCIS, redux
Let me return to an example I use so often whenever I encounter antivaxxers claiming that “better diagnosis” or “more screening” can’t possibly explain a huge increase in prevalence of a condition or disease: ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS), a form of breast cancer. Well, actually, whether it’s really cancer or not is debatable, but it can clearly often be a precursor to cancer, although the percentage of DCIS lesions that progress to cancer isn’t precisely known. Be that as it may, before 1975 DCIS was a very uncommon diagnosis. Now it is very common. Indeed, back in the early 1900s, DCIS was rare because by the time it grew large enough to be a palpable mass, it almost always had become invasive cancer. Now, nearly forty years after mass mammographic screening programs became prevalent, DCIS is a common diagnosis. Indeed, approximately 40% of breast cancer diagnoses are DCIS, and a recent study found that DCIS incidence rose from 1.87 per 100,000 in the mid-1970s to 32.5 in 2004. That’s a more than 16-fold increase over a 30 year period, and it’s pretty much all due to the introduction of mammographic screening. This sort of thing should not be surprising to doctors, but apparently sometimes it is.
Unlike the case for autism, the diagnostic criteria for DCIS remained pretty stable over that 30 year period. Pathologists in the 1970s and pathologists in the 2000s would likely agree on what constitutes DCIS. The same is true for other conditions. Indeed, thyroid cancer comes to mind, a disease for which increased screening with ultrasound has led to a massive increase in the number of diagnoses of thyroid cancer, the vast majority of which are almost certainly overdiagnosis. Actually, there are issues with changing criteria for the diagnosis of thyroid cancer too. Indeed, diseases for which the prevalence is increasing often involve both increased screening and changes in the diagnostic criteria.
Another example is hypertension. Before the 1920s doctors didn’t routinely measure systolic/diastolic blood pressure ratios; so there were few, if any, cases of hypertension because doctors weren’t looking for it and didn’t know how to easily measure it. Even over the last decade, prevalence of hypertension has increased (for instance, in Canada). Perhaps a better marker for hypertension diagnoses is the percentage of adults who have been prescribed antihypertensive medications, which has skyrocketed since 1950. Of course, over that time, the definition of what constituted “hypertension” has changed markedly, to lower and lower diastolic and systolic pressures, as evidence showed that treating lower blood pressures could prevent premature death, although that trend appears to have leveled off. Amusingly, various denialists lambaste such broadening of diagnostic criteria to claim that hypertension is an “engineered” epidemic. And don’t even get me started on hypercholesterolemia.
Increasing numbers of diagnoses ≠ increasing number of people with a given condition or disease
I’d like to conclude once again by emphasizing that the increasing prevalence of a condition really means an increase in the number of people given a diagnosis associated with that condition, not necessarily a “true” increase in the prevalence of the condition. If you look for a disease or medical condition more intensively, you will always find more of it—often a lot more. Always. If this principle works for something that is diagnosed by an objective test, namely a biopsy, how much more so is it likely to be for a condition that has no unequivocal biochemical or tissue test to nail down the diagnosis, like ASDs, particularly for a spectrum of disorders whose diagnostic criteria has changed considerably over the last 30 years to be more inclusive?
None of this rules out an increase in the “true” prevalence of autism over the last few decades, but the increasing consensus is that the evidence does rule out the sort of massive increase that antivaxxers claim and then blame on vaccines. What is most likely happening is that we’re getting better and better at finding and diagnosing autism, including milder cases, to the point where the apparent prevalence of autism (i.e, the number of diagnoses) is starting to converge on the “true” biological prevalence of autism as it is defined today and that we might just be starting to see the sorts of differences in that “true” prevalence attributable to race, gender, and ethnicity that we see for many medical conditions and diseases, no vaccines needed as a “root cause” to explain.

Torturing mice, data, and figures in the name of antivaccine pseudoscience
In September, antivaccine “researchers” Christopher Shaw and Lucija Tomljenovic published a study claiming to link aluminum adjuvants in vaccines to neuroinflammation and autism. Naturally, the antivaccine movement pointed to it as slam dunk evidence that vaccines cause autism. It’s not. In fact, not only is it bad science, but it might well be fraudulent.
David Gorski on October 30, 2017
Link

[Editor’s note: I am currently at CSICon. Consequently, even though I’ve written about this study elsewhere before, I think it’s good to revise, update, and repurpose the saga for SBM, given the way it shows how antivaccine “researchers” work. Also, I wanted to have a reference to this in SBM.]
For antivaxers, aluminum is the new mercury.
Let me explain, for the benefit of those not familiar with the antivaccine movement. For antivaxers, it is, first and foremost, always about the vaccines. Always. Whatever the chronic health issue in children, vaccines must have done it. Autism? It’s the vaccines. Sudden infant death syndrome? Vaccines, of course. Autoimmune diseases? Obviously it must be the vaccines causing it. Obesity, diabetes, ADHD? Come on, you know the answer!
Because antivaxers will never let go of their obsession with vaccines as The One True Cause Of All Childhood Health Problems, the explanation for how vaccines supposedly cause all this harm are ever-morphing in response to disconfirming evidence. Here’s an example. Back in the late 1990s and early 2000s, antivaxers in the US (as opposed to in the UK, where the MMR vaccine was the bogeyman) focused on mercury in vaccines as the cause of autism. That’s because many childhood vaccines contained thimerosal, a preservative that contains mercury. In an overly cautious bit of worshiping at the altar of the precautionary principle, in 1999 the CDC recommended removing the thimerosal from childhood vaccines, and as a result it was removed from most vaccines by the end of 2001. (Some flu vaccines continued to contain thimerosal for years after that, but no other childhood vaccine did, and these days it’s uncommon to find thimerosal-containing vaccines of any kind.)
More importantly, the removal of thimerosal from childhood vaccines provided a natural experiment to test the hypothesis that mercury causes or predisposes to autism. After all, if mercury in vaccines caused autism, the near-complete removal of that mercury from childhood vaccines in a short period of time should have resulted in a decline in autism prevalence beginning a few years after the removal. Guess what happened? Autism prevalence didn’t decline. It continued to rise. To scientists, this observation was a highly convincing falsification of the hypothesis through a convenient natural experiment, although those who belong to the strain of antivaccine movement sometimes referred to as the mercury militia still flog mercury as a cause of autism even now. Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. is perhaps the most famous mercury militia member, although of late he’s been sounding more and more like a run-of-the-mill antivaxer.
Which brings us to aluminum. Over the last few years, there have been a number of “studies” that remind me of the pseudoscience published by Mark and David Geier on mercury and autism back in the day, which have led to embarrassment of two researchers who have become the darlings of the antivaccine movement, whose previous studies and review articles have been discussed before. Yes, I’m referring to Christopher Shaw and Lucija Tomljenovic in the Department of Ophthalmology at the University of British Columbia. Both have a long history of publishing antivaccine “research,” mainly falsely blaming the aluminum adjuvants in vaccines for autism and, well, just about any health problem children have and blaming Gardasil for premature ovarian failure and all manner of woes up to and including death. Shaw was even prominently featured in the rabidly antivaccine movie The Greater Good. Not surprisingly, they’ve had a paper retracted, as well.
Actually, make that two. Their most recent study is to be retracted. I’ll get back to that in a moment. First, I think it’s worth looking at why the study is so bad, as well as why and how it was retracted. It’s a tale of either extreme carelessness, outright scientific fraud, or both.
Torturing mice in the name of pseudoscience
Before looking at the study itself, specifically the experiments included in it, let’s consider the hypothesis allegedly being tested by Shaw and Tomljenovic, because experiments in any study should be directed at falsifying the hypothesis. Unfortunately, there is no clear statement of hypothesis where it belongs, namely in the introduction. Instead, what we get is this:
Given that infants worldwide are regularly exposed to Al [aluminum] adjuvants through routine pediatric vaccinations, it seemed warranted to reassess the neurotoxicity of Al in order to determine whether Al may be considered as one of the potential environmental triggers involved in ASD.
In order to unveil the possible causal relationship between behavioral abnormalities associated with autism and Al exposure, we initially injected the Al adjuvant in multiple doses (mimicking the routine pediatric vaccine schedule) to neonatal CD-1 mice of both sexes.
This was basically a fishing expedition in which the only real hypothesis was that “aluminum in vaccines is bad and causes bad immune system things to happen in the brain.” “Fishing expeditions” in science are studies in which the hypothesis is not clear and the investigators are looking for some sort of effect that they suspect they will find. In fairness, fishing expeditions are not a bad thing in and of themselves—indeed, they are often a necessary first step in many areas of research—but they are hypothesis-generating, not hypothesis confirming. After all, there isn’t a clear hypothesis to test; otherwise it wouldn’t be a fishing expedition. The point is that this study does not confirm or refute any hypothesis, much less provide any sort of slam-dunk evidence that aluminum adjuvants cause autism.
Now, let’s look at the paper’s shortcomings before—shall we say?—issues were noted regarding several of the figures (to be discussed in the next section).
Moving along, I note that this was a mouse experiment, and, pre-retraction, antivaxers were selling Shaw’s paper as compelling evidence that vaccines cause autism through their aluminum adjuvants causing an inflammatory reaction in the brain. Now, seriously. Mouse models can be useful for a lot of things, but, viewed critically, autism is not really one of them for the most part. After all, autism is a human neurodevelopmental disorder diagnosed entirely by behavioral changes, and correlating mouse behavior with human behavior is very problematic. Indeed, correlating the behavior of any animal, even a primate, with human behavior is fraught with problems. Basically, there is no well-accepted single animal model of autism, and autism research has been littered with mouse models of autism that were found to be very much wanting. (“Rain mouse,” anyone?) Basically, despite the existence of many mouse strains touted to be relevant to autism, almost none of them are truly relevant.
The assumption behind this study was that immune changes in the brain of mice will be relevant to immune activation in the brains of autistic humans. That is an assumption that hasn’t yet been confirmed with sufficient rigor to view this study’s results as any sort of compelling evidence that aluminum adjuvants cause autism—even if they do cause inflammatory changes in mouse brains. Yes, the authors included this important-looking diagram describing how they think immune system activation causes autism:In the end, though, as impressive as it is, the relevance of this chart to autism is questionable at best, as is the relevance of this study.
So let’s look at the mouse strain chosen by the investigators, CD-1 mice. Basically, there’s nothing particularly “autistic” (even in terms of existing mouse models purported to be relevant to autism) about these mice, which are described in most catalogues of companies selling them as “general purpose.” Basically, the authors used them because they had used them before in previous studies in which they reported that aluminum injections caused motor neuron degeneration (nope, no autism) and another crappy paper in the same journal from 2013 purporting to link aluminum with adverse neurological outcomes. That’s it.
As for the experiment itself, neonatal mice were divided into two groups, a control group that received saline injections and the experimental group received injections of aluminum hydroxide in doses timed such that they that purportedly mimicked the pediatric vaccine schedule. Looking over the schedule used, I can’t help but note that there is a huge difference between human infant development and mouse development. Basically, the mice received aluminum doses claimed to be the same as what human babies get by weight six times in the first 17 days of life. By comparison, in human babies these doses are separated by months. In addition, in human babies, vaccines are injected intramuscularly (in a muscle). In this study, the mice were injected subcutaneously (under the skin). This difference immediately calls into question the applicability of this model to humans, even if you accept the mouse model as valid. The authors stated that they did it because they wanted to follow previously utilized protocols in their laboratory. In some cases, that can be a reasonable rationale for an experimental choice, but in this case the original choice was questionable in the first place. Blindly sticking with the same bad choice is just dumb.
So what were the endpoints examined in the mice injected with aluminum hydroxide compared to saline controls? After 16 weeks, the mice were euthanized and their brains harvested to measure gene expression and the levels of the proteins of interest. Five males and five females from each group were “randomly paired” for “gene expression profiling.” Now, when I think of gene expression profiling, I usually think of either cDNA microarray experiments, in which the levels of thousands of genes are measured at the same time, or next generation sequencing, in which the level of every RNA transcript in the cell can be measured simultaneously. That doesn’t appear to be what the authors did. Instead, they used a technique known as PCR to measure the messenger RNA levels of a series of cytokines. Basically, they examined the amount of RNA coding for various immune proteins in the brain chosen by the authors as relevant to inflammation. The authors also did Western blots for many of those proteins, which is a test in which proteins are separated on a gel, blotted to a filter, and then probed with specific antibodies, resulting in bands that can be measured by a number of techniques, including autoradiography or chemiluminescence, both of which can be recorded on film on which the relevant bands can be visualized. Basically, what the authors did wasn’t really gene expression profiling. It was measuring a bunch of genes and proteins and hoping to find a difference.
There’s an even weirder thing. The authors didn’t use quantitative real time reverse transcriptase PCR, which has been the state-of-the-art for measuring RNA message levels for quite some time. Rather, they used a very old, very clunky form of PCR that can only produce—at best—semiquantitative results. (That’s why we used to call it semiquantitative PCR.) Quite frankly, in this day and age, there is absolutely zero excuse for choosing this method for quantifying gene transcripts. If I were a reviewer for this article, I would have recommended not publishing it based on this deficiency alone. Real time PCR machines, once very expensive and uncommon, are widely available. (Hell, I managed to afford very simple one in my lab nearly 15 years ago.) These days, any basic or translational science department worth its salt has at least one available to its researchers.
The reason that this semiquantitative technique is considered inadequate is that the amount of PCR product grows exponentially, roughly doubling with every cycle of PCR, asymptotically approaching a maximum as the primers are used up.It usually takes around 30-35 cycles before everything saturates and the differences observed in the intensity of the DNA bands when they are separated on a gel become indistinguishable. That’s why PCR was traditionally and originally primarily considered a “yes/no” test. Either the RNA being measured was there and produced a PCR band, or it didn’t. In this case, the authors used 30 cycles, which is more than enough to result in saturation. (Usually semiquantitative PCR stops around 20-25 cycles or even less.) And I didn’t even (yet) mention how the authors didn’t use DNAse to eliminate the small amounts of DNA that contaminate nearly all RNA isolations. Basically, the primers used for PCR pick up DNA as well as any RNA, and DNA for the genes of interest will be guaranteed to contaminate the specimens without DNAse treatment. Yes, you molecular biologists out there, I know that’s simplistic, but my audience doesn’t consist of molecular biologists.
Now, take a look at Figures 1A and 1B as well as Figures 2A and 2B. (You can do it if you want. The article is open access and, for reasons unclear to me, has not yet been removed from the journal website.) Look at the raw bands in the A panels of the figures. Do you see much difference, except for IFNG (interferon gamma) in Figure 1A? I don’t. What I see are bands of roughly the same intensity, even the ones that are claimed to vary by three-fold. In other words, I basically am very skeptical that the investigators saw much of difference in gene expression between controls and the aluminum-treated mice. In fairness, for the most part, the protein levels as measured by Western blot did correlate with what was found on PCR, but there’s another odd thing. The investigators didn’t do Western blots for all the same proteins whose gene expression they measured by PCR. Of course, they present primers for 27 genes, but only show blots for 18 (17 inflammatory genes plus beta actin, which was used as a standard to normalize the values for the other 17 genes).
I also questioned the statistical tests chosen by the authors. Basically, they examined each gene separately and used Student’s t-test to assess statistical significance. However, in reality they did many comparisons, at least 17, and there’s no evidence that the authors controlled for multiple comparisons. If one chooses statistical significance to occur at p < 0.05 and compares 20 samples, by random chance alone at least one will be different. Add to that the fact that there is no mention of whether the people performing the assays were blinded to experimental group, and there’s a big problem. Basic science researchers often think that blinding isn’t necessary in their work, but there is a potential for unconscious bias that they all too often don’t appreciate. For example, the authors used Image J, free image processing software developed by the NIH. I’ve used Image J before. It’s a commonly used app used to quantify the density of bands on gels, even though it’s old software and hasn’t been updated in years. Basically, it involves manually drawing outlines of the bands, setting the background, and then letting the software calculate the density of the bands. The potential for bias shows up in how you draw the lines around the bands and set the backgrounds. As oblivious as they seem to be to this basic fact, basic scientists are just as prone to unconscious bias as the rest of us, and, absent blinding, in a study like this there is definitely the potential for unconscious bias to affect the results. In fairness, few basic science researchers bother to blind whoever is quantifying Western blots or ethidium bromide-stained DNA gels of PCR products, but that’s just a systemic problem in biomedical research that I not infrequently invoke when I review papers. Shaw and Tomljenovic are merely making the same mistake that at least 90% of basic scientists make.
But let’s step back and take the authors’ results at face value for a moment. Let’s assume that what is reported is a real effect. In the rest of the paper, the authors present evidence of changes in gene expression that suggest the activation of a molecular signaling pathway controlled by a molecule called NF-κB and that male mice were more susceptible to this effect than females. (Just like autism!) Funny, but I know NF-κB. I’ve published on NF-κB. I had an NIH R01 grant to study how my favorite protein affected NF-κB. True, I ended up abandoning that line of research because I hit some dead ends. True, I’m not as familiar with NF-κB as I used to be. But I do know enough to know that NF-κB is easy to activate and very nonspecific. I used to joke that just looking at my cells funny would activate NF-κB signaling. Also, NF-κB activation is indeed associated with inflammation, but so what? What we have is an artificial model in which the mice are dosed much more frequently with aluminum than human infants. Does this have any relevance to the human brain or to human autism? who knows? Probably not. No, almost certainly not.
Also, the mouse immune system is different from the human immune system. None of this stops the authors from concluding:
Based on the data we have obtained to date, we propose a tentative working hypothesis of a molecular cascade that may serve to explain a causal link between Al and the innate immune response in the brain. In this proposed scheme, Al may be carried by the macrophages via a Trojan horse mechanism similar to that described for the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) and hepatitis C viruses, travelling across the blood-brain-barrier to invade the CNS. Once inside the CNS, Al activates various proinflammatory factors and inhibits NF-κB inhibitors, the latter leading to activation of the NF-κB signaling pathway and the release of additional immune factors. Alternatively, the activation of the brain’s immune system by Al may also occur without Al traversing the blood-brain barrier, via neuroimmuno-endocrine signaling. Either way, it appears evident that the innate immune response in the brain can be activated as a result of peripheral immune stimuli. The ultimate consequence of innate immune over-stimulation in the CNS is the disruption of normal neurodevelopmental pathways resulting in autistic behavior.
That’s what we call in the business conclusions not supported by the findings in a study. On a more “meta” level, it’s not even clear whether the markers of inflammation observed in autistic brains are causative or an epiphenomenon. As Skeptical Raptor noted, it could be that the inflammation reported is caused by whatever the primary changes in the brain are that result in autism. Cause and effect are nowhere near clear. One can’t help but note that many of the infections vaccinated against cause way more activation of the immune system and cytokines than vaccination.
So what are we left with?
Basically, what we have is yet another mouse study of autism. The study purports to show that aluminum adjuvants cause some sort of “neuroinflammation,” which, it is assumed, equals autism. By even the most charitable interpretation, the best that can be said for this study is that it might show increased levels of proteins associated with inflammation in the brains of mice who had been injected with aluminum adjuvant way more frequently than human babies ever would be. Whether this has anything to do with autism is highly questionable. At best, what we have here are researchers with little or no expertise in very basic molecular biology techniques using old methodology that isn’t very accurate overinterpreting the differences in gene and protein levels that they found. At worst, what we have are antivaccine “researchers” who are not out for scientific accuracy but who actually want to promote the idea that vaccines cause autism. (I know, I know, it’s hard not to ask: Why not both?) If this were a first offense, I’d give Shaw and Tomljenovic the benefit of the doubt, but this is far from their first offense. Basically, this study adds little or nothing to our understanding of autism or even the potential effects of aluminum adjuvants. It was, as so many studies before, the torture of mice in the name of antivax pseudoscience. The mice used in this study died in vain in a study supported by the profoundly antivaccine Dwoskin Foundation.
Enter fraud?
Not long after Shaw’s paper was published, serious questions were raised about the figures in the paper. To understand the problem, you need to know that after a PCR reaction is run, the PCR products (DNA fragments amplified by the PCR reaction) are separated by placing them in an agarose gel and running an electrical current through it. This gel electrophoresis works because DNA migrates towards the positive electrode and, once it solidifies, agarose forms a gel that separates the DNA fragments by size. The gel can then be stained with ethidium bromide, whose fluorescence allows visualization of the bands, which can be assessed for size and purity. Photos of the gel can be taken and subjected to densitometry to estimate how much DNA is in each band relative to the other bands.
To measure protein, Western blots work a little differently. Basically isolated cell extracts or protein mixtures are subjected to polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) with a denaturing agent (SDS). Again, like DNA, protein migrates towards the positive electrode, and the gel forms pores that impeded the process, allowing separation by size and charge. The proteins are then transferred to a membrane (the Western blot) and visualized by using primary antibodies to the desired protein, followed by a secondary antibody with some sort of label. In the old days, we often used radioactivity. These days, we mostly use chemiluminescence. Blots are then exposed to film or, more frequently today, to a phosphoimager plate, which provides a much larger linear range for detecting the chemiluminescence than old-fashioned film. Just like DNA gels, the bands can be quantified using densitometry. In both cases, it’s very important not to “burn” (overexpose) the film, which pushes the band intensity out of the linear ranger) or to underexpose them (noise can cause problems). It’s also important how the lines are drawn around the bands using the densitometry software and how the background is calculated. More modern software can do it fairly automatically, but there is almost always a need to tweak the outlines chosen, which is why I consider it important that whoever is doing the densitometry should be blinded to experimental group, as bias can be introduced in how the bands are traced.
So why did I go through all this? Hang on, I’ll get to it. First, however, I like to point out to our antivaccine “friends” that peer review doesn’t end when a paper is published. Moreover, social media and the web have made it easier than ever to see what other scientists think of published papers. In particular, there is a website called PubPeer, which represents itself as an “online journal club.” More importantly, for our purposes, PubPeer is a site where a lot of geeky scientists with sharp eyes for anomalies in published figures discuss papers and figures that seem, well, not entirely kosher. It turns out that some scientists with sharp eyes have been going over Shaw and Tomljenovic’s paper, and guess what? They’ve been finding stuff. In fact, they’ve been finding stuff that to me (and them) looks rather…suspicious.
One, for instance, took figure 1C of the paper and adjusted the background and contrast to accentuate differences in tones:It was immediately noted:
     1.  A clear and deliberate removal of the Male 3 Control TNF result. This isn’t an unacknowledged splice, as there is no background pattern from a gel contiguous with either band, left or right.
     2.  Removal of the left half of the Male 1 Control IFN-g. Dubious also about Male 3 Control IFN-g, as the contrast highlight shows boxing around the band.
     3.  What appears like an unacknowledged splice in ACHE blot, between AI Animal 2, Control Animal 3
Comparing this representative blot to the densitometry accompanying it, they score from 5 independent experiments IFN-g fold change from control to AI, relative to actin, as on average 4.5, with an SEM ranging from ~2.7 to 6.5. This seems too good to be true.
Look at the band. It’s the second from last band. It looks as though the band has been digitally removed. There is an obvious square there. The edges are clear. Now, this could be a JPEG compression artifact. Indeed, one of the commenters is very insistent about reminding everyone that compression artifacts can look like a square and fool the unwary into thinking that some sort of Photoshopping had occurred. However, I do agree with another of the PubPeer discussants this is enough of a problem that the journal should demand the original blot.
On this one, I’ll give Shaw and Tomljenovic the benefit of the doubt. (Whether they deserve it or not, you can judge for yourself.) That might be a compression artifact. Other problems discovered in the gels are not so easily dismissed. For instance, there definitely appears to be the ol’ duplicated and flipped gel bands trick going on in Figure 2A:Spotting these takes a little bit of skill, but look for distinctive parts of bands and then look to see if they show up elsewhere. It’s also necessary to realize that there could be multiple different exposures of the same band, such that the same band can appear more or less intense and mirror-imaged. You have to know what to look for, and I fear that some readers not familiar with looking at blots like these might not see the suspicious similarities, even when pointed out. Still, let’s take a look. There are more examples, for instance, these two bands in Figure 4C:
And Figures 4B and 4D, where bubbles on the gels serve as markers:You can look at the rest of the PubPeer images for yourself and decide if you agree that something fishy is going on here. I’ve seen enough that I think there is. Others noted that Shaw and Tomljenovic have engaged in a bit of self-plagiarism, too. Figure 1 in the 2017 paper is identical (and I do mean identical, except that the bars in the older paper are blue) to a paper they published in 2014. Basically, they threw a little primary data into one of their crappy review articles trying to blame “environment” (i.e., vaccines) for autism, this one published in 2014 in OA Autism. Don’t take my word for it. Both articles are open-access, and you can judge for yourself, at least as long as Shaw’s most recent paper remains in press.
And that’s still not all. Let’s take a visit to our scaly friend, Skeptical Raptor, where he notes that The Mad Virologist and the Blood-Brain Barrier Scientist jointly analyzed the paper and found:
But there are six other key points that limit what conclusions can be drawn from this paper:
     1.  They selected genes based on old literature and ignored newer publications.
     2.  The method for PCR quantification is imprecise and cannot be used as an absolute quantification of expression of the selected genes.
     3.  They used inappropriate statistical tests that are more prone to giving significant results which is possibly why they were selected.
     4.  Their dosing regime for the mice makes assumptions on the development of mice that are not correct.
     5.  They gave the mice far more aluminum sooner than the vaccine schedule exposes children to.
     6.  There are irregularities in both the semi-quantitative RT-PCR and Western blot data that strongly suggests that these images were fabricated. This is probably the most damning thing about the paper. If the data were manipulated and images fabricated, then the paper needs to be retracted and UBC needs to do an investigation into research misconduct by the Shaw lab.
Taken together, we cannot trust Shaw’s work here and if we were the people funding this work, we’d be incredibly ticked off because they just threw away money that could have done some good but was instead wasted frivolously. Maybe there’s a benign explanation for the irregularities that we’ve observed, but until these concerns are addressed this paper cannot be trusted.
I note that they go into even more detail about the problems with the images that have led me (and others) to be suspicious of image manipulation, concluding:
These are some serious concerns that raise the credibility of this study and can only be addressed by providing a full-resolution (300 dpi) of the original blots (X-ray films or the original picture file generated by the gel acquisition camera).
There has been a lot of chatter on PubPeer discussing this paper and many duplicated bands and other irregularities have been identified by the users there. If anyone is unsure of how accurate the results are, we strongly suggest looking at what has been identified on PubPeer as it suggests that the results are not entirely accurate and until the original gels and Western blots have been provided, it looks like the results were manufactured in Photoshop.
I agree. Oh, and I agree with their criticism of the use of statistics. I even brought up their failure to control for multiple comparisons, but Shaw and Tomljenovic also used a test that is appropriate for a normal distribution when their data obviously did not follow a normal distribution.
The retraction
Not surprisingly, the journal that published this turd of a paper, The Journal of Inorganic Biochemistry, received a lot of commentary and complaints, all of which clearly had an effect. Basically, as I mentioned above, the editor of the journal decided to retract the paper. Not surprisingly, Shaw is making excuses:
Shaw, a professor at UBC’s department of ophthalmology, said he and the lab ran their own analysis of the figures in question after seeing allegations from PubPeer on Sept. 24. He said he requested a retraction from the journal within two days and notified the university.
“It appears as if some of the images in mostly what were non-significant results had been flipped,” Shaw told CBC on Thursday. “We don’t know why, we don’t know how … but there was a screw-up, there’s no question about that.”
Shaw said the lab can’t confirm how the figures were allegedly altered because he claims original data needed for comparison is no longer at the UBC laboratory.
“We don’t think that the conclusions are at risk here, but because we don’t know, we thought it best to withdraw,” the researcher said.
Asked how the seemingly wonky figures weren’t caught before publication, Shaw said it was “a good question.”
Indeed it is. Too bad Shaw doesn’t have a good answer to that good question. Actually, in fairness, he does have part of point here:
“We were always under the impression that, based on our viewing of the original data a couple years ago and our subsequent analysis of these data, that everything was fine,” he said. “One double-checks this at various stages in the process, but by the time you’ve looked at them enough times and done the various analyses on them, you do tend to believe they’re right.
“When you look at these kinds of [data], unless you look at them under very, very high power and magnify them 20 times — which no one does, by the way — you would not necessarily see that there was anything untoward,” the professor said.
No, it was not necessary to look at the figures under high power to catch the image manipulation. Certainly, the PubPeer denizens who found the image manipulation needed such tools to see the problems with the various images, just trained eyes. On the other hand, as a researcher myself, I can understand how, looking at the same figures over and over again, one tends to miss things about them. It’s not a valid excuse however. Neither is this:
Shaw claims the original data is in China, with an analyst who worked on the paper.
The professor claimed the analyst told him the data are “stuck there.”
“It’s like ‘the dog ate my homework.’ What are you going to do?”
He noted that, even if the original data are recovered, he thinks “this paper is dead” for credibility reasons.
This is, of course, appalling. For example, the NIH requires that the raw data be kept by the principal investigator for ten years. True, Shaw’s study was not funded by the NIH, but rather by a the antivaccine Dwoskin Foundation, but his university does require investigators to keep the raw data with them for at least five years, which means that the data should have been kept at least until 2018.
Amusingly:
Reached by email on Friday, co-author Tomljenovic said she agreed to the retraction but said she “had nothing to do either with collecting or analyzing any of the actual data.” She declined further comment.
Then why was she a co-author? Maybe she helped write some of the antivaccine boilerplate for the introduction. Meanwhile, Dan Li has apparently lawyered up. I wonder why. Naturally, Shaw is throwing the “pharma shill” moniker around hither, thither, and yon:
In response to the criticisms from scientists online, Shaw was dismissive.
“Anti-vaccine” researcher is an ad hominem term tossed around rather loosely at anyone who questions any aspect of vaccine safety. It comes often from blogs and trolls, some of which/whom are thinly disguised platforms for the pharmaceutical industry… Anyone who questions vaccine safety to whatever degree gets this epithet.
My view: I see vaccines as one of many useful medical interventions. Prophylactic medicine in all of its forms is great, and vaccination is a way to address infectious diseases with the goal of preventing them. But, much like other medical interventions, vaccines are not completely safe for all people, nor under all circumstances.
In follow-up questions, Shaw said that if future data does not support a link between autism and aluminum, he would reconsider his hypothesis and research.
Sure he will. Sure he will. Of course, I was not surprised at his invocation of the pharma shill gambit. It’s what antivaxers do when criticized. Also, there’s a difference between “questioning vaccine safety” and doing so based on pseudoscience and, indeed, contributing to that pseudoscience by carrying out bogus studies of one’s own designed to demonstrate that, for example, Gardasil causes death and premature ovarian failure and aluminum adjuvants cause autism, as Shaw and Tomljenovic have done extensively. That’s what makes them antivax, not “questioning” vaccine safety.
Shaw did say one thing that (I hope) turns out to be true:
Shaw said he’s likely finished working on papers concerning vaccines after this retraction.
“I’m honestly not sure at this point that I want to dabble in [vaccines] anymore,” he said. “We have some projects that are ongoing that have been funded that we feel duty-bound to complete that are on this topic. Frankly, I doubt if I will do it again after that.”
We can only hope, but I’d be willing to bet that Dwoskin Foundation money will continue to support Shaw; that is, unless the foundation decides that even Shaw is too discredited for its purposes and finds another pliable scientist to do its dirty work of demonizing vaccines.
Whatever happens, this incident does help to illustrate that science can work. Peer review might have failed, allowing this paper to be published, but post-publication peer review did work, leading to its retraction.

Antivaxxer Steve Kirsch unknowingly identifies the fatal flaw of an antivax “report” from the McCullough Foundation
Hilariously and without realizing it, antivaxxer Steve Kirsch nailed the essence of why a recent antivax “report” by the McCullough Foundation is nonsense. It’s basically a very old tactic for misrepresenting science repackaged for “new school” antivaxxers.

David Gorski on November 10, 2025
Link

One advantage to having studied antivax rhetoric and techniques used by deniers of vaccine safety and efficacy for so long is that I’m now so familiar with the patterns and tactics that I see them right away. So it was when I saw the same old arguments used by antivaxxers to portray the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine as ineffective and dangerous recycled and repurposed for COVID-19 vaccines basically as soon as the vaccines were released to the public in December 2020. That included the eugenicist thinking behind claims that COVID-19 is only dangerous to those who are already chronically ill (i.e., “unfit”) to begin with, as well as claims that you might have thought unique to mRNA-based vaccines, such as the lie that mRNA vaccines “integrate” with your DNA to cause all sorts of diseases. (Hint: Antivaxxers got there long ago making the same claim about HPV vaccines.) These were the thoughts as I encountered a “report” published a couple of weeks ago on a preprint server by the McCullough Foundation, McCullough Foundation Report: Determinants of Autism Spectrum Disorder. Antivaxxers have been flogging it as though it were actual “gold standard science,” even though the report was immediately recognizable as yet another example of cherry picking and biased presentation that includes horrendous antivax “science” to “prove” that vaccines cause autism. True, the McCullough Foundation claimed that the causation of autism was “multifactorial,” but it also falsely concluded that “combination and early-timed routine childhood vaccination constitutes the most significant modifiable risk factor for ASD.” Indeed, if you want to know how bad the report is, just note that the godfather of the 21st century antivax movement, Andrew Wakefield, is a coauthor, along with “new school” antivaxxers like Peter McCullough.
The report concludes:
The totality of evidence supports a multifactorial model of ASD in which genetic predisposition, neuroimmune biology, environmental toxicants, perinatal stressors, and iatrogenic exposures converge to produce the phenotype of a post-encephalitic state. Combination and early-timed routine childhood vaccination constitutes the most significant modifiable risk factor for ASD, supported by convergent mechanistic, clinical, and epidemiologic findings, and characterized by intensified use, the clustering of multiple doses during critical neurodevelopmental windows, and the lack of research on the cumulative safety of the full pediatric schedule.
No, this is only true in an antivax funhouse version of science. Unsurprisingly, the McCullough Foundation is trumpeting its report as “proof” that the safety of the vaccine schedule has not been adequately studied and that vaccines are the single largest contributor to autism:
For decades, the causes behind the relentless rise in autism have been hotly debated. Some claim it’s due to better diagnosis or changing definitions; others point to environmental stressors and genetics. Yet until now, no comprehensive analysis has ever examined all potential factors—genetic, environmental, immunologic, and iatrogenic—together within a single scientific framework.
The McCullough Foundation’s landmark report, Determinants of Autism Spectrum Disorder, represents the most exhaustive synthesis ever conducted on the causes of autism. Drawing from over 300 peer-reviewed studies across epidemiology, clinical medicine, toxicology, immunology, and molecular biology, this analysis provides an authoritative, data-driven evaluation of how vaccination and other determinants contribute to autism risk.
By comparing the strength, direction, and biological plausibility of every major proposed risk factor, this landmark report delivers unprecedented clarity: autism is a multifactorial neurodevelopmental disorder—but one major, modifiable factor stands out above all others.
Combination and early-timed routine childhood vaccination emerges as the single most significant driver of autism risk, supported by convergent mechanistic, clinical, and epidemiologic evidence.
This conclusion challenges long-standing assumptions and underscores the urgent need for a full reassessment of the U.S. childhood vaccine schedule—now administered in greater volume and frequency than at any point in history.
Meanwhile, Children’s Health Defense, the antivax organization founded by our current Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy Jr., is beside itself with joy that Andrew Wakefield is back, baby, and back with a vengeance:
The report also marks the return of researcher Dr. Andrew Wakefield to scientific research and publication. In 1998, Wakefield published a paper in The Lancet identifying a possible association between the MMR vaccine and autism.
Wakefield’s paper initially didn’t generate controversy. But in 2011, The Lancet’s editors “bowed to pressure to retract Wakefield’s paper,” even though its contents had not been proven to be erroneous.
Hulscher said Wakefield’s co-authorship of the report “marks an important restoration of scientific integrity.”
“His return represents a reawakening of open scientific inquiry into one of the most pressing health crises of our time. It also signals that independent researchers are no longer intimidated by censorship or character assassination from the vaccine industry and its institutional allies,” Hulscher said.
Holland said the retraction of Wakefield’s paper and the lack of subsequent studies by mainstream scientists examining a possible link between vaccines and autism are examples of “draconian censorship.”
Jablonowski said it was fitting that Wakefield co-authored the report, as he “paid a high price for his scientific integrity,” which served as “a warning to others who dared to be curious enough to study vaccinations and their deleterious outcomes.”
There is not an eye roll emoji that rolls its eyes hard enough to be a fitting reaction to the passage above. Andrew Wakefield, of course, sparked what became 21st century iteration of the antivax movement with his fraudulent 1998 Lancet case series and has been consistently disgraced since then. (In 2016, he was even a headliner on a conspiracy cruise.) Indeed, in response to his scientific fraud, the UK’s General Medical Council concluded about Wakefield in 2010, “The panel is satisfied that your conduct was irresponsible and dishonest” Before the pandemic, Wakefield had even been reduced to the level of fear mongering about a “sixth extinction” (humans) that will be caused by the MMR vaccine supposedly selecting for deadly variants of measles. (I kid you not.) Still, Wakefield did pave the way for the wave of “new school” antivax grifters who have proliferated since the COVID-19 pandemic started over five years ago.
Of course, whenever such a review is carried out, the devil is always in the details, beginning with literature search strategies, weighing the strength of studies included, and interpreting the evidence. That’s why, unsurprisingly, all the handwaving in the 82-page report (with “supplemental material”!) about “other genetic predisposition, neuroimmune biology, environmental toxicants, perinatal stressors, and iatrogenic exposures” converging “to produce the phenotype of a post-encephalitic state” serve primarily as window dressing designed to make the “conclusion” that vaccines are the most powerful cause of autism seem reasonable. It’s not.
Now here’s the hilarious thing. Now that it’s two weeks after the report was published, I thought that perhaps I had waited too long, especially given that there have been excellent deconstructions of the bad science, misrepresentation of science, and pseudoscience in the report. (I also like how Jess Stier referred to the report as “anti-vaccine Mad Libs.”) As a result, rather than dive into the weeds (too much, at least), I thought I’d spend more time on the premise of the “analysis” undertaken by this “study” or “report” as being consistent with longstanding antivax techniques of misrepresenting science, although it is, of course, impossible for me not to point out some of the major flaws, because, hey, it’s me.

You’ll never guess who inspired me to do this post, even though after two weeks I thought that perhaps my time had passed to write much about this report.
McCullough Foundation’s “mechanisms” of autism causation. It looks really science-y, doesn’t it? The funny thing here is that, unlike past antivax claims that vaccines are the be-all and end-all of autism causation, this image appears to weight vaccines as only 25% of causation. Seriously, these guys need a better graphic artist, although I can’t rule out that this is just AI slop.
Moreover, if you want to get an idea of just how bad this paper is, take a look at Figure 2 from the report:
Where have we seen charts like this before, going back at least 20 years?
Holy spurious correlations, Batman! Seriously, if you’re going to include a graph from an antivax organization illustrating the usual antivax claim that correlation means causation, you do not deserve to be taken seriously. After all, we have 25+ years worth of large, well-designed studies showing no correlation between vaccines and autism when rigorously controlled for confounding variables.
Steve Kirsch almost gets it…almost
Regular readers of this blog will be familiar with Steve Kirsch, although I haven’t written about him in a while, at least not here. Before the pandemic Kirsch was one of two independent inventors of the optical mouse in the 1980s. After that, he started several companies, examples including the search engine Infoseek in the 1990s as well as Frame Technology Corp. (which was purchased by Adobe in 1995) and a company making a spam filter (Abaca) in 2005, becoming quite wealthy over the years. Relevant to COVID-19, early in the pandemic Kirsch founded the COVID-19 Early Treatment Fund (CETF) in order to fund research into off-label treatments for COVID-19 using existing drugs already having FDA approval for other diseases. He donated $1 million himself and solicited donations from others. It actually wasn’t a bad idea. The problem, however, is that Kirsch didn’t seem to understand how clinical research works and what the failure rate is for testing repurposed drugs for pretty much anything, which made it unsurprising that things started going horribly wrong with Kirsch descending into COVID-19 misinformation and conspiracy theories, in the process becoming what the MIT Technology Review once called a “misinformation superspreader.” It is not an exaggeration to say that it didn’t take Kirsch long to go down a very deep rabbit hole of conspiracy theories and pseudoscience about COVID-19 and then the mRNA vaccines against COVID-19. Basically, Kirsch reacts to disconfirming data by denying it and doubling down, a pattern that I’ve see in him over and over again.
I'm currently blind in one eye from a subretinal hemorrhage (SRH); with your help, it won't be permanenthttps://t.co/r6HWIo9iOY
— Steve Kirsch (@stkirsch) July 27, 2024
Before I discuss how Kirsch inadvertently nailed the key problem with the McCullough Foundation report, I must point out that I do feel some empathy for him, as last year he suffered a major health issue. Last year, he suffered a subretinal hemorrhage that resulted in major vision loss in one eye, caused, according to him, “either a central serous retinopathy (CSR) that burst (which started when I was under a lot of stress with all the work I was doing), or dry age-related macular degeneration (AMD) that progressed to wet AMD.” Unsurprisingly, he’s been attracted to quackery, such as claims that DMSO drops might restore his vision, although in fairness he hasn’t tried it, as far as I can tell, and remains somewhat skeptical. More interestingly to me, he has actually wondered in an August 2024 video whether taking The Wellness Company’s “Spike Detox” formula might have contributed to his subretinal hemorrhage, even referring to it as an “expensive lesson” to check the contraindications, the “expensive lesson” being the loss of vision in one eye:
The lesson that I learned is if you take any supplements, be sure you know why you’re taking the supplements, and don’t take supplements you don’t need. So always look for counterindications for anything that you’re taking… [41:10] This thing happened to me. And I’ll people know to be careful, to be careful about anything you put into your body. I don’t care if it’s a vaccine or a supplement or a drug. Make sure you really understand the interactions. And make sure that all of your specialists know what you’re taking, so that you can look for things that are probably not going to provide you any benefit whatsoever, and would only contribute downside risk. Because I think that the—I was on the Peter McCullough protocol, which I think is a great protocol, ! mean it’s highly highly effective for preventing blood clots, and for eliminating any blood clots that you might have. It turned out that wasn’t my problem. Because I was just taking it thinking that, you know there was no harm in taking it. But because I had a retinal condition and because for whatever reason my doctor didn’t realize that I was taking these three supplements, my retinal bleed was the mother of all retinal bleeds. And the first thing that happened when I ran into my – the first surgeon that I saw, he said what blood thinners are you on? And I said I’m not on any blood thinners but I think I know what you’re talking about.
Oddly enough, this isn’t bad advice, for the most part. I’ve written about the Spike Detox Formula (which consists mostly of an enzyme called nattokinase) before and how it is quackery being peddled by The Wellness Company, for which Dr. McCullough serves as Chief Scientific Officer and spokesdoctor. While I highly doubt that this supplement was the cause of Kirsch’s subretinal hemorrhage, I do not doubt that it is antivax COVID-19 quackery, which makes it odd to me that Kirsch is so enthusiastic about the McCullough Foundation report.
That digression aside (seriously, I’m starting to think that I have more and more in common with Molly Conger and her digressions on her podcast), let’s take a look at what Kirsch says about the McCullough Foundation Report in a Substack entry called New McCullough autism paper: Vaccines are the single largest contributor to the risk of autism. Naturally, his tagline for this Substack is, “No surprises. Of course, this paper will be ignored, censored, and ‘fact checked.'” Again, the ironic thing is that Kirsch hits the nail on the head regarding the fatal flaw of this report without even realizing that he’s done so. Let’s begin.
After summarizing the report and saying, “In short, it’s the vaccines,” Kirsch decides that he has to tell his readers what is superior about this report compared to the decades’ worth of studies, meta-analyses, and systematic reviews that conclude that vaccines do not increase the risk of being diagnosed with autism, calling it a “meta-collection” of “roughly 100 – 150 citations on non‑vaccine factors (e.g., prenatal infection, maternal age, pollution) and another ≈ 130 papers on vaccination or excipients” that were “then merged…into thematic tables.” (Hint: This is not the way you do systematic reviews.)
Amusingly, this leads Kirsch to correctly identify that different methods can lead to different conclusions:
The divergence arises from both methodology and interpretive framework.
a. Different Inclusion Rules
    • Lancet/NIH ACE use Cochrane‑style systematic filters: randomized or large registry studies with double‑blinded outcome assessment.
→ Low‑power or non‑replicated mechanistic papers, uncontrolled case‑series, and ecologic correlations are excluded.
    • McCullough review includes broad evidence — mechanistic animal work, cell data, case reports, and re‑analyses of disputed datasets — giving heavy weight to biological plausibility even when statistical demonstration is weak.
    • Hence: different evidence hierarchies → different conclusions.
Yep! Kirsch nailed it! If you use a different evidence hierarchy that includes, along with randomized, double-blind studies, and large registry studies, low quality evidence such as non-replicated mechanistic papers, uncontrolled case-series and ecological correlations, and in vitro cell culture work that has never been shown to apply to in vivo models, you’re going to come to different conclusions! Here’s the thing. For any common disease or condition, there will always be hundreds, if not thousands, of lab-based studies in cell culture that propose mechanisms of etiology, of how the condition is caused. Inevitably, many of them will be red herrings or dead ends and won’t lead to an actionable understanding of the biology of how the condition or disease state is caused or how it can be treated. By design, the McCullough Foundation Report dilutes the high quality preclinical, clinical, and epidemiological science with much lower quality preliminary reports, uncontrolled observations, and the like, all in order to be able to conclude that vaccines cause autism.
Kirsch is so close to understanding this, but unfortunately he seems to see this feature (and not a bug) of the McCullough method as a good thing, as you can see in his next bullet point:
b. Interpretive Approach
– Lancet/NIH treat correlation ≠ causation; they require population‑level replication before causal language.
– McCullough interprets overlapping mechanistic signals (immune activation, metal toxicity, mitochondrial deficit) as causal chains even without direct cohort confirmation.
Once again, what Kirsch is basically saying is that, contrary to what the Lancet/NIH method demanded, McCullough accepts lower quality, unreplicated, and uncontrolled evidence as causative without any actual rigorous evidence of causation. Moreover, if you peruse the list of 308 references, you’ll find just how low quality some of the evidence cited is. For example, reference #7 is Wakefield’s retracted 1998 Lancet case series! Also included are articles and studies from a panoply of antivax “scientists” about whom I’ve written much over the years, in some cases going back two decades both here and at my not-so-super-secret other blog, including David Kirby, Andrew Zimmerman, Mark and David Geier, Brian Hooker, Christopher Shaw and Lucija Tomljenovic, James Lyons-Weiler, Gary Goldman, Christopher Exley, Catherine DeSoto and Robert Hitlan, Sallie Bernard and Lynn Redwood, Stephanie Seneff, Gayle DeLong, Mary Holland (an antivax lawyer), Theresa Deisher, Helen Ratajczak, Mark Blaxill and Boyd Haley, and Anthony Mawson. They even included a citation (#281) of an article by Robert O. Young, one of the quackiest quacks about whom I’ve ever written, a mail-order trained naturopath who doesn’t believe in germ theory, denies that sepsis is caused by bacterial infection, thinks that viruses are “molecular acids,” and claims that cancer is in reality too much acid in the body, that cancer is an acidic liquid, and that that tumors are the body’s natural defense of walling off “spoiled” tissue. They even cite multiple articles from Peter McCullough and his antivax authors citing themselves (e.g., John Leake and Nicholas Hulscher) and the rabidly antivax org Children’s Health Defense, including an infographic entitled Vaccines Can Cause Autism! (Indeed, Figure 2 comes from the infographic.)
That’s what I would call a failure of selection criteria for studies to be cited and discussed in the review. Of course, it’s intentional. These quack studies are cited along with legitimate studies as though the quack studies are just as valid and cast doubt on the findings of rigorous scientific studies. That’s the point.
Again, Kirsch comes so close to getting it…without getting it:
c. Selection Bias & Data Weighting
The McCullough group weights:
    • in‑vitro data showing neuronal toxicity of ethyl‑Hg or Al;
    • ecological trends (autism incidence vs. vaccine dose counts);
    • clinical case series of “regressive autism after vaccination.”
Mainstream commissions discount those sources as uncontrolled and biologically non‑comparable to real pediatric exposure levels.
Notice the wording, “Mainstream commissions dismiss.” Kirsch doesn’t get it while almost getting it. Mainstream scientists do not count such data as compelling because they are, in fact, from uncontrolled studies and often using doses of compounds that aren’t comparable to real pediatric exposure levels. As for studies showing neuronal toxicity of ethyl mercury or aluminum, the concentrations used are basically always much higher than what could be expected or achieved even in the bloodstream of an infant, basically because the amount in vaccines is so tiny (or was so tiny in the case of ethyl mercury, given that thimerosal, the preservative containing it, was mandated to be removed from childhood vaccines in 1999 and was removed by early 2002).
Moreover, if there’s one rule about biological plausibility, it’s that any mechanism or toxicity observed in cell culture that doesn’t translate to humans in well-designed epidemiological studies or randomized controlled trials is incredibly unlikely to be important. For example, there is a passage in the McCullough Report (pp. 29-30 in which the authors discuss the different pharmacokinetics (the rates at which a drug level increases and then the drug is eliminated from the body) of ethyl and methyl mercury to try to imply that ethyl mercury is actually more toxic than methyl mercury (which is known to be toxic). Even if this were all true, as a practical matter it isn’t relevant to the question being asked. Large, well-controlled epidemiological studies consistently show that exposure to ethyl mercury in thimerosal in vaccines at the cumulative dose that infants received even when the most thimerosal-containing vaccines were included in the vaccine schedule, is not associated with a higher risk of autism. Mercury in vaccines at the doses used then did not cause autism, and, given that mercury was removed from almost all childhood vaccines nearly a quarter century ago, mercury in vaccines does not cause autism now. It’s now a moot point.
Then, of course, once again Kirsch is impressed by ecological data and uncontrolled case series, seemingly more than well-designed large epidemiological studies that appropriately control for confounders. In this, he sounds very much like Brian Hooker, who while giving a talk on his “reanalysis” of a large study that failed to find a correlation between MMR vaccination and autism, said:
So I reanalyzed the dataset using what is a very, very simple statistical technique. I think that in statistics simplicity is elegance. And I’m not really that smart; so I like to do simple, easy things rather than much more intellectually challenging things. So I did the simplest, most straightforward analysis, which is a Chi Squared analysis…
Here’s a hint: In statistics and epidemiology, the simplest analysis is often not the correct analysis, and, boy, was this the case for Hooker’s reanalysis of the DeStefano et al dataset! He didn’t control for simple confounders. He did a crappy statistical analysis. He botched the analysis in pretty much every way possible. And Kirsch—as well as, apparently, McCullough, Wakefield, and the rest of his antivax co-authors—is more impressed with “simplicity.” Of course, it is a common antivax conspiracy theory that appropriate correction for confounders that causes a correlation between vaccines and autism to disappear in dataset is a conspiracy in which “they” are covering up a link.
Indeed, in my first post that ever went viral, I deconstructed all the misinformation and conspiracy mongering shortly after, as did others, who noted that the entire Simpsonwood transcript was not at all consistent with any effort to “cover up” a link between mercury and autism, but rather included a debate about how best to deal with confounders in a study by Verstraeten et al. (Of course, to antivaxxers, any adjustment for confounders that eliminates a link between vaccines and whatever bad health outcome that they attribute to vaccines is always a “coverup,” not science doing what science is supposed to do and being rigorous.) Years later, I referred to this as the Simpsonwood conspiracy theory and, sometimes, part of the central conspiracy theory of the antivaccine movement, in which They (the CDC, government, FDA, medical profession, big pharma, and who knows who else—aliens, possibly) “know” that vaccines cause autism but actively work to cover up any incriminating evidence.
Finally, Kirsch notes:
They agree on
Both camps agree on advanced parental age, premature birth, maternal infection, and high inflammation markers as consistent ASD risk factors.
Both accept a role for mitochondrial and redox biology in some subgroups.
Yes, and no. It’s the way that antivaxxers “accept a role for mitochondria and redox biology in some subgroups.” Does anyone remember all the redox pseudoscience and woo that came out of the Hannah Poling case, where antivaxxers claimed that mitochondrial disorders plus vaccines equals autism from c.2008-2012?
As for the rest:
They differ solely on iatrogenic exposures
Mainstream bodies see no epidemiologic signal once bias is controlled.
The McCullough report emphasizes uncontrolled subpopulation findings.
The difference arises from how each group defines valid evidence and how strictly they apply epidemiologic causal criteria.
I actually can’t argue with that. Antivaxxers like McCullough have a predetermined outcome that they seek to find evidence for that lets them support that outcome—or at least lets them seem to support that outcome to people without a background in clinical or epidemiological research. They are therefore quite willing not to define “valid evidence” or apply “epidemiological causal criteria” very strictly at all. “Mainstream bodies” don’t see any epidemiological signal once bias is controlled for, and that is the very reason why antivaxxers like McCullough, Wakefield, and Kirsch value evidence that is uncontrolled, or at least much less well-controlled than standard epidemiological rigor normally demands.
Whom do you believe?
When you come right down to it, it all boils down to a single question, at least according to Steve Kirsch: Whom do you believe? Here’s how he puts it:
The million dollar question: Which is more likely to be correct?
It depends on which evidence bases you value more.
When you go to an AutismOne Conference, and the speaker asks the parents, “How many of you believe your child’s autism was linked to vaccines?” and nearly every hand in the room goes up, that’s a little hard to explain.
No, it’s not. Not really particularly given that Autism One is an antivax conference. Think about it. The vast majority of parents who are willing to pay to travel to the suburbs of Chicago to attend such a conference will, at the very least, lean in the direction of believing that vaccines caused their child’s autism. Having studied and written about the conference dating back nearly two decades, I know that the vast majority of attendees are fervent antivax true believers looking for ammunition to support their belief and treatments based on the dubious science used by the presenters at the conference.
Indeed, those of us who’ve been paying attention long enough know that Autism One actually tries very hard to keep skeptics and reporters not aligned with the antivax cause, particularly skeptics and reporters who might write news stories and critical blog posts about the talks and “science” presented there. Indeed, in 2011, Jamie Bernstein, Vice President of the Women Thinking Free Foundation and a vaccine advocate, registered for Autism One along with Ken Reibel, in order to see what the antivaccine movement was saying there. That’s not all, as Liz Ditz wrote in 2011, a number of reporters and those not aligned with the antivax movement who tried to attend Autism One and report on its proceedings have been ejected. Indeed, the organizers called the police on Bernstein and Reibel, who were escorted out by security guards. I’d be willing to bet that Steve Kirsch doesn’t know this history, but I do, having followed it for decades.
No, it’s not difficult at all to explain why damned near every single parent of an autistic child (or of autistic children) who attended Autism One believes that vaccines caused their children’s autism in some way.
In the end, Kirsch is almost correct without actually being correct. He notes that the McCullough Report mixes low quality preliminary preclinical studies, epidemiological observations not corrected for confounding, and uncontrolled case series with “mainstream” evidence that values controlling for confounders, confirming mechanistic observations from preclinical cell culture and animal studies with clinical and epidemiological studies in humans, and, in general, scientific, epidemiological, and clinical rigor over anecdotal experience. Don’t get me wrong. Uncontrolled case series and mechanistic studies in preclinical models can be good for generating hypotheses, but those hypotheses must be tested confirmed in larger, more rigorous human studies. Moreover, many of the preclinical studies cited have been tested in more rigorous human studies and been found to be wanting. McCullough and his coauthors likely know, but refuse to accept, that simple fact. They can thus weave all sorts of mechanistic speculations—which I like to refer to as “biobabble,” as a nod to the famous term about some Star Trek technology, “technobabble”—with low quality clinical and epidemiological data to paint a picture of plausibility that seems compelling if you don’t have a strong background in science.
One final thought I had. What Kirsch is proposing might, on its surface, seem to be science-based medicine (SBM). After all, we have long argued that basic and preclinical science findings should be included in any evaluation of a medical treatment or causation claim, particularly for alternative medicine. Here’s the difference. What SBM proposes is to use basic science findings to increase scientific rigor. In other words, we like to point out that homeopathy is physically impossible, that, for homeopathy to be true, huge swaths of well-established scientific findings in physics, chemistry, and biology would have to be not just wrong, but spectacularly wrong. In other words, we propose that what we know about science will primarily cast doubt on fantastical claims. In contrast, what Kirsch seems to be doing is to argue that all sorts of preliminary and contradictory basic science and preclinical data should be brought in to cast doubt on well-founded clinical and epidemiological findings by claiming that, even though we don’t find a hint of a whiff of a suggestion in datasets and large, well-designed clinical trials and epidemiological studies that vaccines increase the risk of autism, some study in which mercury or aluminum is put into the culture medium of neurons in a dish at a high concentration causes toxicity should cast doubt on all of that. I hope you can see the difference.
In the end, your answer to Kirsch’s final question—which evidence bases you value more—determines whether you have a scientific mindset or not. If you value high quality evidence and understand the hierarchies of rigor in scientific evidence, you have a scientific mindset. If you do not, you are more like Steve Kirsch or Peter McCullough—or are at least likely to be susceptible to the kinds of misinformation they spread.


CDC Whistleblower

Did a high ranking whistleblower really reveal that the CDC covered up proof that vaccines cause autism in African-American boys?
David Gorski on August 25, 2014
Link
[Editor’s note: I realize this post might look familiar to some, although it has been tweaked and updated. Grant deadline Tuesday, meaning no time to produce original content up to the standards of SBM that you have come to expect. At the same time, I figured I had to contribute something this week. Hopefully this update on a certain bit of antivaccine posturing will do. Fear not, though. Harriet will take my Monday slot, and we have a very special guest post for you on Tuesday. I’ll be back at it, same day and time, same Bat channel, next week.]
The antivaccine movement and conspiracy theories go together like beer and Buffalo wings, except that neither are as good as, yes, beer and Buffalo wings. (Maybe it’s more like manure and compost.) In any case, the antivaccine movement is rife with conspiracy theories. I’ve heard and written about more than I can remember right now, and I’m under no illusion that I’ve heard anywhere near all of them. Indeed, it seems that every month I see a new one.
There is, however, a granddaddy of conspiracy theories among antivaccinationists, or, as it’s been called, the central conspiracy theory of the antivaccine movement. That conspiracy theory postulates that “they” (in the U.S, the CDC) have known for a long time that vaccines cause autism, but “they” are covering it up. In other words, the CDC has, according to this conspiracy theory, been intentionally hiding and suppressing evidence that antivaccinationists were right all along and vaccines do cause autism. Never mind what the science really says (that vaccines do work don’t cause autism)! To the antivaccine contingent, that science is “fraudulent” and the CDC knew it! Why do you think that the antivaccine movement, in particular Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., went full mental jacket when Poul Thorsen was accused of financial shenanigans (i.e., fraud) with grant money from the federal government? It was a perfect story to distract from the inconvenient lack of science supporting the antivaccine view that vaccines cause autism. More importantly, from the antivaccine standpoint, it was seen as “validation” that the CDC studies failing to find a link between autism and vaccines were either fraudulent or incompetently performed. Why? Because Thorsen was co-investigator on a couple of the key studies that failed to find a link between the MMR and autism, antivaccinationists thought that his apparent financial fraud must mean that he committed scientific fraud. They’re the same thing, right? Well, not really. There were a lot of co-investigators, and Thorsen was only a middle author on those studies.
Enter William Thompson, a.k.a. the “CDC whistleblower,” or, if you’re on Twitter, the #CDCwhistleblower. There has been a new development sufficiently bizarre as to catch my attention, but first, since it’s been a while, here’s the mandatory recap.
Recall, back in August, that biochemical engineer turned antivaccine activist and epidemiologist wannabe, published a study, recently retracted, that basically provided strong evidence that Andrew Wakefield was wrong about the MMR vaccine being associated with autism. When I first saw Hooker’s study, even I recognized how utterly incompetently it was carried out, and I’m not even an epidemiologist or statistician. After all, it’s pretty obvious that data collected for a case control study should not be analyzed as a cohort study, but that’s just what Hooker did. When I first read the study, I was actually not as hard on it as I should have been. The more I’ve read, and the more I’ve found out, the more I’ve realized just how badly done it was. Contrary to what Hooker apparently believes, simplicity is not beauty in statistics, particularly when you fail to control for obvious confounders and analyze data incorrectly. The result was a “finding” that there was a 3.4-fold increased risk of autism associated with MMR in African-American boys. Never mind that the numbers of this subgroup were tiny and the data incorrectly analyzed. Never mind that the rest of the data were negative as negative could be for even a whiff of a hint of a correlation between vaccines and autism for any other subgroup and that the vast majority of the leaders of the antivaccine movement are your basic affluent white people who never showed much in the way of an interest in the problems of African-American children before. Suddenly, this finding was being likened to the Tuskegee syphilis experiment by Andrew Wakefield himself!
This incompetent study was the result, allegedly, of discussions between Hooker and a senior psychologist at the CDC named William Thompson. For reasons that are still not clear, Thompson, a co-author on an important study by DeStefano et al, confided in Hooker, who, betraying his confidences, recorded much of what he said, an action whose legality is unclear given that it’s unclear where all of these recordings were made (one party or two party consent states). Hooker then teamed up with Andrew Wakefield to cherry pick bits to make it sound as though Thompson were confessing to some horrible crime of data manipulation to hide this “bombshell” result reported by Wakefield. Thus was born the “CDC whistleblower,” who featured prominently in the video likening DeStefano et al and the “coverup” to the Tuskegee syphilis experiment. Later, Thompson released as statement through his lawyer characterizing the whole problem over DeStefano et al as being a scientific disagreement. Nonetheless, a new conspiracy theory was born: The “CDC whistleblower,” complete with its own hashtag on Twitter, #CDCwhistleblower. Thompson has said nothing publicly since then, and the mainstream media has basically ignored the story other than an interview with Ronan Farrow of MSNBC that basically trashed the claims of the antivaccine movement.
So, after two months of relentlessly trying to get the mainstream media to pay attention and utterly failing, Andrew Wakefield and Brian Hooker had to try something new. Last Wednesday, that something new dropped into the antivaccine blogosphere with a massive plop that no one heard outside of the echo chamber confines of sites like the antivaccine crank blog Age of Autism. For instance, everyone’s favorite hysterical antivaccine blogger Kent Heckenlively proclaims it as “The Hammer Falls!”:
Dr. Brian Hooker, Dr. Andrew Wakefield, and attorney James Moody announced today they have sent a complaint by Federal Express to Dr. Harold Jaffe, Associate Director for Science at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, as well as Dr. Don Wright, Acting Director of the Office of Research Integrity at the Department of Health and Human Services, claiming research misconduct in the 2004 paper, “Age at First Measles-Mumps-Rubella Vaccination in Children with Autism and School-Matched Control Subjects: A Population-Based Study in Metropolitan Atlanta,” which was subsequently published in the journal, Pediatrics.
The allegations are horrifying, not just for the millions of families who deal with autism on a daily basis, but for the picture it paints of a government agency, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), devoid of any shred of scientific integrity or what we once used to call “honor” in this country.
If these claims are shown to be true, we will be looking at nothing less than the greatest crime committed in the history of our republic, and a dark page in science which will be remembered for centuries to come.
Let’s just say that Heckenlively is prone to a little…hyperbole. I mean, seriously. For the sake of argument, as a thought experiment, let’s imagine for the moment that every allegation flowing from the fever dream conspiracy theory that is the #CDCwhistleblower is true. In that case, does Heckenlively really believe that this “crime” was worse than, say, slavery? The internment of Japanese-Americans in the early days of World War II after the bombing of Pearl Harbor? The real Tuskegee syphilis experiment? This is worse? It just goes to show how out of touch with reality these people are. But, then, this is Kent Heckenlively we’re talking about here. Reality and Mr. Heckenlively haven’t been on the same planet for at least a decade, not to mention that this is Brian Hooker and Andrew Wakefield making an accusation of scientific fraud. In what bizarro world does Andrew Wakefield, the ultimate scientific fraudster himself, accuse anyone, much less CDC scientists, of scientific fraud? Then there’s Hooker, who is the most incompetent epidemiologist wannabe I’ve seen aside from his young Padawan Jake Crosby and whose big foray into epidemiology broke records in speed of retraction. Even more hilariously, his article was retracted from a new journal. It was so toxically bad that even a new journal, scrambling to establish itself and attract quality submissions, couldn’t afford not to retract it. Pot, kettle, black, anyone?
The result of these delusional accusations is a 34-page letter to the Dr. Harold Jaffe, CDC Associate Director for Science, and Dr. Don Wright, Acting Director, ORI, along with an appendix. It’s a painful slog to read through, particularly given that it doesn’t discuss much that I haven’t already covered in detail before here and here (not to mention on my not-so-super-secret other blog). That’s not to say that there aren’t any new revelations, but most of them have little or nothing to do with the attacks on the science based on methodology, which have been covered, discussed, and dissected here and on other blogs until it was quite clear that Hooker had no clue how to do an epidemiological study and went into his “study” with a preconceived notion of what it should show.
The core of this complaint is found in this early paragraph:
We write to report apparent research misconduct by senior investigators within the National Immunization Program (NIP), Battelle Memorial Institute at the Centers for Public Health Evaluation (CPHE), and the National Center on Birth Defects and Developmental Disabilities (NCBDDD), and to request an immediate investigation.
The Analysis Plan dated September 5, 2001 [Exhibit 2] set forth the objective of the research reported in the above-titled article, to compare ages at first MMR vaccination between children with autism and children who did not have autism, and to test the hypothesis that age of first MMR vaccination is associated with autism risk.
The research team, headed by Dr. Frank DeStefano, MD., (NIP) including Dr. William Thompson Ph.D., (NIP) Dr. Marshalyn Yeargin-Allsopp, MD (NCBDDD), Dr. Tanya Karapurkar Bashin (CPHE), and Dr. Coleen Boyle, Ph.D., (NCBDDD) (collectively referred to by Dr. Thompson as “The Group”) found statistically significant associations between the age of first MMR and autism in (a) the entire autism cohort, (b) African-American children, and (c) children with ‘isolated’ autism, a subset defined by The Group as those with autism and without comorbid developmental disabilities.
We’ve heard this before, albeit not exactly in this way. The central charge is that the investigators altered the research plan after the study was under way. The charge basically goes this way. The CDC planned a case control study examining the age of receiving the MMR vaccine and whether it correlated with an increased risk of autism using data from the Metropolitan Atlanta Developmental Disabilities Surveillance Program (MADDSP). Seeing a result they didn’t like, they allegedly altered the plan in order not to report the “inconvenient” result that the MMR resulted in a 3-fold increased risk of autism among African-American boys. Explaining from scratch why this is BS would take a post of truly Gorski length in and of itself. Fortunately, Wakefield and Hooker couldn’t keep their mouths shut. Wakefield had to go and make a video outlining the charges before he sent this letter to the CDC:
The video came out about two weeks days ago, and I actually thought of blogging it at the time, but I was a bit burned out on the whole #CDCwhistleblower thing. So I let this antivaccine cup pass for a change. Fortunately, Matt Carey took it on more than a week ago, and that makes my job easier. Matt’s post is worth reading in its entirety, but the Cliffs Notes version is as follows. In the video, Wakefield zeros in on a single sentence that says “The only variable available to be assessed as a potential confounder using the entire sample is child’s race.” Based on that, and allegedly confirmed by Thompson during conversations with Hooker, Wakefield and Hooker claim that “decisions were made regarding which findings to report after the data was collected,” further claiming, “Thompson’s conversations with Hooker confirmed that it was only after the CDC study coauthors observed results indicating a statistical association between MMR timing and autism among African-Americans boys, that they introduced the Georgia birth certificate criterion as a requirement for participation in the study. This had the effect of reducing the sample size by 41% and eliminating the statistical significance of the finding, which Hooker calls a direct deviation from the agreed upon final study protocol – a serious violation.’”
I discussed this aspect in my original post, namely how doing this was not the scientific fraud claimed, but at the time I didn’t have access to the original research plan. In any case, notice that that one sentence doesn’t even really mean that the investigators deviated from the plan, as race was always planned to be examined as a potential confounder for the whole group. As Carey put it:
There are two interesting points in the above. First, the sentence Mr. Wakefield highlights doesn’t say what he claims. The only variable available to be assessed as a potential confounder using the entire sample is child’s race. The plan doesn’t say that they will test and report race. Consider the context: this is a section of the plan called “statistical analysis”. Put in context with the entire paragraph, this sentence is clear: the full dataset is limited because it only has one variable available.
The CDC didn’t deviate from the plan when they didn’t report on race for the total sample because that was never in the plan.
Exactly. More importantly, Wakefield and Hooker are cherry picking. (So what else is new?) As Carey points out, the analysis plan doesn’t include a call to report on race separately in the total sample (the group without the birth certificates), and the CDC “approved analysis plan” did include analysis of a subset with birth certificate data. Use of birth certificate data to look for confounders was always an option in the plan. For example:
For the children born in Georgia for whom we have birth certificate data, several sub-analyses will be carried out similar to the main analyses to assess the effect of several other potential confounding variables.
And:
3) Analyses examining Gender Effects
Males are at substantially higher risk for autism and may be more vulnerable to the exposure associated with the MMR vaccine. We will analyze males and females separately and replicate the main objectives of the primary analyses as well as examine the potential confounders available from Georgia birth certificates.
In the complaint, Wakefield and Hooker even misquoted the analysis plan, as Carey also points out. The plan states, “The only variable available to be assessed as a potential confounder using the entire sample is child’s race.” The complaint quotes this as, “The only variable that will be assessed as a potential confounder using the entire sample will be the child’s race.” He had also verified that he was examining the same document that Wakefield and Hooker had.
Wakefield also tries to do a bit of statistical prestidigitation by claiming that one of the analyses proposed, analyses of “isolated” versus “non-isolated” autism were not done. “Isolated” autism is autism with no comorbid developmental disabilities, such as mental retardations. As Carey convincingly argues, this subanalysis was done. He even explains how, although the raw, unadjusted analysis appears to show an association between age at MMR vaccination (vaccination prior to 36 months) and autism, the adjusted, final analysis does not. Tellingly, Hooker’s study is praised in the complaint thusly:
Dr. Hooker has approved access to public datasets for the original raw data from the study provided by the CDC. Dr. Hooker was thereby able to repeat the original analyses and confirm The Group’s findings of an excess autism risk in African American children. Dr. Hooker’s reanalysis [Exhibit 4] was rigorously peer reviewed and published.6 Dr. Hooker’s paper was reviewed and approved by Dr. Thompson. Dr. Thompson has also supplied Dr. Hooker with his original data output and subsequent data runs of his analyses.
Funny how Wakefield and Hooker didn’t see fit to mention that Hooker’s study was retracted—and retracted over a week before they sent their letter to the CDC! Wakefield and Hooker owe me a new keyboard again (or I should know better than to drink anything, even water, while reading anything written by these two) for this, as well:
Dr. Hooker is a scientist, Assistant Professor at Redding University, California, an extensively published vaccine safety researcher, and the father of a child with autism. Dr. Wakefield is an academic gastroenterologist by training and a documentary film producer/director with Autism Media Channel. Both have standing to complain. Both have a strong interest in documenting this research misconduct and in securing a remedy for the severe damage it has caused: Dr. Hooker’s son was, as alleged in his petition for compensation to the NVICP, permanently damaged by vaccines. The ethically required and Congressionally – mandated compensation provided by this program has been denied to many children based in part on the misconduct alleged herein. He has also suffered scientific opprobrium for his position on vaccine safety. Dr. Wakefield first proposed a possible link between MMR and autism,7 and specifically, age of exposure to MMR and autism risk.8 Had The Group’s true findings been published as intended,9 well before their actual publication date in 2004, much of the damaged done to Dr. Wakefield’s career and reputation might have been mitigated. Mr. Moody is an attorney with a longstanding interest in the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (NVICP) and an expert in Whistleblower law.
Hooker is an “extensively published vaccine safety researcher”? A PubMed search reveals four publications that might have anything to do with autism or “vaccine safety,” including the retracted one. Subtract the retracted paper and a paper dismissing paternal age as a risk factor for autism (clearly it must be the vaccines, then!), and only two publications that have anything to do with vaccines remain (1, 2). That’s hardly “extensively published.” Of course, Wakefield’s standing in this is dubious at best, too, given that his reputation and career were almost entirely destroyed in England, not the US.
So we know that Wakefield and Hooker are dishonestly cherry picking evidence in their letter, but there’s one bombshell that shocked me and goes a long way towards explaining something that’s always bothered me about this affair: Why? Why did Thompson confide in Hooker? What drove him to it? It turns out that, if Hooker and Wakefield are telling the truth about this (and I really take anything they say with an enormous grain of salt), Thompson was (and presumably still is) prone to anxiety issues (at minimum), depression, and what Thompson calls “delusions,” which first manifested themselves in a big way a decade ago, around the time he was preparing to present the results of this study to the Institute of Medicine and was facing the likelihood of being called to testify in front of a Congressional committee whose chair was notorious for his antivaccine views. After citing an e-mail from Thompson to Julie Geberding, the then-director of the CDC (which I discussed), in which Thomspon expressed anxiety about appearing in front of a Congressional committee, Wakefield and Hooker write:
In the end, Dr. Thompson signed off on The Paper that was published in Pediatrics [Exhibit 1]. However, his name was withdrawn from the roster of those due to present to the IOM on February 9, 2004. In reporting a discussion that he had had with his whistleblower lawyer Thompson stated:
Ya know, I’m not proud of that and uh, it’s probably the lowest point in my career that I went along with that paper and I also paid a huge price for it because I became delusional.24
In his recorded call with Dr. Thompson of 5.8.14, Dr. Hooker pressed the Dr. Thompson on whether he raised his concerns about the omission of significant data with The Group in the days leading up to the IOM meeting.
Dr. Hooker: Did you raise that…did you raise that issue at the time?
Dr. Thompson: I will say I raised this issue…I will say I raised this issue, the uh…two days before I became delusional.
This reference is important: three days before the IOM presentation Thompson – faced with either presenting false data or taking responsibility for the vaccine-autism link in front of potentially hostile parents of autistic children25 – stopped sleeping, and became profoundly depressed and “delusional.” Crucially, he reports no prior history of mental disorder.
Dr. Thompson went on to confirm, to Dr. Hooker, that the DeStefano 2004 paper was the reason for these acute psychological problems.
Dr. Thompson: It is one of the reasons I became delusional because I was so paranoid about this being published.
Citation 24 is claimed to be from a phone conversation between Hooker and Thompson dated May 24, 2014. That was the Saturday of Memorial Day weekend this year. Hmmm. That was also during Autism One. Brian Hooker gave a talk at Autism One on May 23. One wonders if he was still there, one does. Why do I wonder that? Because Illinois has one of the most Draconian laws in the country when it comes to being a “two party” consent state with respect to recording conversations. If Hooker recorded a phone call with Thompson while Hooker was in Chicago, that could be big trouble for him, should Thompson wish to pursue it. That’s a minor consideration, though. The major consideration is that, if this conversation occurred as represented, then Hooker just divulged highly personal medical information that Thompson confided to him, namely that Thompson suffered some sort of mental breakdown, complete with paranoia, delusions, and depression, right before IOM conference ten years ago. This, after having bragged about how he was Thompson’s “confessor,” like a priest. How low can you go? In order to imply that the magnitude of the “crime” Thompson was being forced to be party to was so massive that it led him to some sort of mental breakdown in the days leading up to the IOM conference, Hooker betrayed Thompson’s confidences about a very personal health issue issue.
Oh, wait. This is Brian Hooker and Andrew Wakefield we’re talking about.
It’s now clear to me that Thompson appears to be a bit of a fragile soul, easily rattled. From the sketchy description in Wakefield’s and Hooker’s complaint, he sounds as though he suffered a bout of what sounds like a panic attack or severe anxiety disorder, but I don’t know enough to tell. If that’s the case, though, anxiety disorders can be profoundly crippling and lead to the sort of behavior described. Either way, anxiety disorder or no anxiety disorder, depression or no depression, it’s quite clear that, even at his best, Thompson melts under pressure, and that could explain a lot of his behavior, certainly back in 2003 and 2004 and possibly even this year.
In the end, though, Wakefield’s and Hooker’s complaint is nothing more than a publicity stunt. Their first play, the video likening DeStefano et al and the “coverup” of “vaccines causing autism in African American boys” to the Tuskegee syphilis experiment, Hitler, Stalin, and Pol Pot, failed miserably. For all the Twitter bombing of the #CDCwhistleblower hashtag, the mainstream media barely took notice, and rightly so. There was nothing to see there. Also, as I’ve pointed out many times before, Wakefield’s name is, quite correctly, now so toxic that his involvement with this whole affair virtually guaranteed that no one of any consequence in the mainstream media would take it seriously. If Hooker had written this letter, sent it to the CDC, and publicized it out of the blue, he might have fooled a few credulous mainstream media outlets or reporters into doing a story or two about it in a fairly neutral tone. Making this play now, after having been associated with Wakefield and after all the #CDCwhistleblower nonsense, virtually guarantees that nothing will come of this.
But it sure will rile up the antivaccine base. That’s the point, after all.

The “CDC whistleblower saga”: Updates, backlash, and (I hope) a wrap-up
David Gorski on September 1, 2014
Link

Given that this is a holiday weekend here in the US and that I’m having a bit of a staycation right now, I had thought of simply not posting today or of rerunning a “classic” (if you want to call it that) blast from the past. But the topic I wrote about last week has only festered and grown bigger since Monday; so at the very least I felt obligated to do a post updating you, our readers, on the twists and turns that have occurred in the saga of the so-called “CDC whistleblower.” For those of you familiar with the story (not to mention following my not-so-secret other blog), much of this will be familiar, but, given that this is SBM, I felt that this material should be on record here for your edification and (hopefully) education. I’ll take (more or less) a chronological approach since last Monday and then finish up by trying to put this whole mess into perspective. This is going to be longer than even my usual posts, but I want to be authoritative. So, if you’re very familiar with what’s happened, you might want to skim everything before the “backlash” and “conclusion” sections to fill in what you might have missed. If you’re less than completely steeped in what happened, read every scintillating word!
But first, for those who might be entering this saga right now, let me recap a moment. I’m referring to a conspiracy theory, which has been flogged to death by the antivaccine movement for nearly two weeks now, that there is a CDC whistleblower who has made “devastating” reports that the CDC hid data that showed a 3.4-fold increased risk of autism in African American males, based on an incompetent “reanalysis” of a 10 year old CDC study that found no evidence that children with autism were more likely to have received their first MMR vaccine earlier than neurotypical controls. As I (and others) have discussed, Hooker used howlingly bad statistical methodology (for instance, analyzing case control data as a cohort study and using risibly bad statistical analyses) to torture the data until they confess that vaccines cause autism. As I said at the time, when it comes to data, call Hooker the Spanish Inquisition. Such was the weakness of what he found that, even after forcing the data to sit in the comfy chair for extended periods of time, the most damning “confession” he could get from them was a correlation between age at MMR vaccination and autism diagnoses in one small subgroup: African American males.
Based on this utterly incompetent data torture and Hooker’s apparent budding relationship with a “CDC whistleblower,” Wakefield first made a video in which this “whistleblower’s” voice was electronically altered (not to mention edited into such selective snippets that it was impossible to glean any context from his seemingly-damning statements. This video, released through Andrew Wakefield’s and Tommy Polley’s Autism Media Channel, despicably likened this CDC “cover-up” to the Tuskegee syphilis study, and finished with a flourish of Godwin-y nonsense that included Adolf Hitler (of course!), Pol Pot, and Josef Stalin, implying that the CDC’s “crimes” with respect to this alleged cover-up were just as bad. It was a breathtaking demonstration of pure stupid hyperbole. Then, a few days later, Wakefield replaced the video with the alterations in the “whistleblower’s” voice with his real voice and revealed his real name: William W. Thompson, PhD, a psychologist and senior scientist at the CDC, as well as a co-author of the study being “reanalyzed,” DeStefano et al. Now, on to the update!
The CDC reponds
Remember how last week I wondered why the CDC hadn’t responded yet? Well, on the afternoon of August 26, after having let this mess fester over the weekend plus Monday, the CDC finally did respond with a statement:
CDC shares with parents and others great concern about the number of children with autism spectrum disorder.
CDC is committed to continuing to provide essential data on autism, search for factors that put children at risk for autism and look for possible causes. While doing so, we work to develop resources that help identify children with autism as early as possible so they can benefit from intervention services.
CDC’s study about age at first Measles-Mumps-Rubella (MMR) vaccination and autism, published in Pediatrics in 2004, included boys and girls from different ethnic groups, including black children. The manuscript presented the results on two sets of children:
     1.  All children who were initially recruited for the study, and
     2.  the subset of children who had a Georgia birth certificate.
Access to the information on the birth certificates allowed researchers to assess more complete information on race as well as other important characteristics, including possible risk factors for autism such as the child’s birth weight, mother’s age, and education. This information was not available for the children without birth certificates; hence CDC study did not present data by race on black, white, or other race children from the whole study sample. It presented the results on black and white/other race children from the group with birth certificates.
The study looked at different age groups: children vaccinated by 18 months, 24 months, and 36 months. The findings revealed that vaccination between 24 and 36 months was slightly more common among children with autism, and that association was strongest among children 3-5 years of age. The authors reported this finding was most likely a result of immunization requirements for preschool special education program attendance in children with autism.
The data CDC collected for this study continue to be available for analysis by others. CDC welcomes analysis by others that can be submitted for peer-review and publication. For more information on how to access this public-use dataset please go to the this [sic] webpage.
Additional studies and a more recent rigorous review by the Institute of Medicine have found that MMR vaccine does not increase the risk of autism.
Vaccines protect the health of children in the United States so well that most parents today have never seen first-hand the devastating consequences of diseases now stopped by vaccines.
However, our 2014 measles count is the highest number since measles was declared eliminated in 2000. We do not want to lose any opportunity to protect all of our children when we have the means to do so.
I was actually rather torn by this statement. When I first saw it, it annoyed me. It was so milquetoast, so vague. It didn’t address the heart of the attempt at a manufactroversy, namely what on earth is going on with CDC senior scientist William Thompson, who was represented by Andrew Wakefield and Brian Hooker as having “confessed” to grave malfeasance and fraud with respect to this study using cherry-picked sound bites with no context claimed to be by Thompson himself intermingled with Hooker making all sorts of claims of suppression of the “real” results. On the other hand, this antivaccine manufactroversy hadn’t hit the mainstream press much yet, having at the time been confined to the antivaccine and quack crankosphere. So maybe it wasn’t such a horrible idea not to mention Thompson, Hooker, or Wakefield. Certainly Hooker and Wakefield don’t deserve to be considered on the same level as someone like Thompson, even if he did somehow make the huge mistake of speaking with Hooker. Stick to the science. However, if this is all that the CDC was going to come out with, it boggles the mind that this statement wasn’t released on Friday, when the social media storm first really erupted. In any case, it struck me as too little, too late, but for what it is it does have some positives, particularly the statement that the data continue to be available for analysis and that the CDC welcomes such analyses by others that can be submitted for peer reviewed studies. That hardly suggests a “cover-up.”
On the other hand, I really wish that Frank DeStefano, the lead author of DeStefano et al., hadn’t agreed to be interviewed by antivaccine crank reporter Sharyl Attkisson (remember her?), where he doesn’t come across that impressively. In this case, the CDC is losing the PR war.
Mike Adams and antivaccinationists try the “drip, drip, drip” technique
Meanwhile, Mike Adams, thinking himself some sort of “investigative journalist,” decided that he’d try to get the press’ interest by releasing e-mails and letters in dribs and drabs. First up in Adams’ “leak parade,” most likely fed to him by either Brian Hooker or Andrew Wakefield was a letter from William Thompson to the then-head of the CDC, Julie Gerberding, dated February 2, 2004:

Going along with this letter was this interview with Adams:
First off, can’t antivaccinationists understand that a 3.4-fold increased risk is NOT a 340% increased risk? It’s a 240% increased risk. These people are numerically illiterate. The rest of it is nothing new, nothing that I haven’t discussed before. The only difference is more race-baiting despicableness added to Andrew Wakefield’s and Brian Hooker’s race-baiting despicableness. Oh, and libeling Julie Gerberding. Adams charges that she definitely had been offered a quid pro quo for allegedly having quashed the finding that the MMR vaccine causes autism in African-American children. Oh, and totally misinterpreting Thompson’s letter.
Second, do you see a hint of a conspiracy or desire to cover up data in Thompson’s letter? I don’t. Indeed, as I read this, all I could think of was: Is this the best Wakefield and Hooker have got? What I see in this letter is a scientist begging his boss to respond to an antivaccine legislator’s rabble rousing. In fact, these letters from Rep. David Weldon, MD, to Julie Gerberding can be found online on various antivaccine websites. For instance, here is Weldon’s letter dated October 31, 2003. Here is the second letter, dated January 21, 2004.
If you read Weldon’s letters, you’ll note that they have nothing to do with Destefano et al. They’re both about the Verstraeten study, which is the study at the heart of what has been referred to as the central conspiracy theory of the antivaccine movement (at least in the US) and has been deconstructed in detail. Basically, Weldon, even though he’s a physician, fell for the Simpsonwood conference conspiracy theory, promoted a year and a half later by antivaccine crank Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., hook, line, and sinker. The first letter basically regurgitates the “concerns” being promoted by the antivaccine movement at the time. The second letter turned up the heat, trying to persuade Gerberding to postpone the Institute of Medicine conference until the “concern” about the Verstraeten study had been addressed. As we all know, the IOM conference did go on and the IOM report strongly stated that there was no correlation between the MMR vaccine and autism.
I can understand why Thompson, if this first letter is genuine, was concerned. David Weldon was making hay with the antivaccine underground, which back in 2003 and 2004 hadn’t yet been completely revealed to be the total cranks they are, such that they could be safely ignored. Thompson sounds as though he were concerned that he was being thrown to the wolves without adequate backup, a not unreasonable concern at the time. He sounds as though he were pleading for the CDC to come out more strongly on the science of vaccine safety, disagreeing that letting the science showing vaccines to be safe speak for itself is enough. He was right. Science and medicine communicators are needed, because the antivaccine movement will do everything in its power to make sure that the science doesn’t speak for itself.
The next day, Mike Adams published what he described as “Bombshell email from CDC whistleblower reveals criminality of vaccine cover-up as far back as 2002“:
Taken out of context, it’s rather hard to know what to make of this e-mail. Apparently in 2002, there was a Department of Justice request for documents relating to the MMR vaccine, thimerosal (which, I note, is not in the MMR and never has been), and autism. Asking around, what I gather is that at this time the discovery phase of the Autism Omnibus proceeding was under way, and requests for CDC documents were coming hot and heavy. Whatever was going on, what I see here is not evidence of a cover-up. Quite the contrary! If you read the letter, you’ll see Thompson relating that he had expressed concerns about some of the “sensitive legal issues” regarding what documents he should provide to the DOJ and was told that he should “apply a very broad definition” to the documents to be provided to the DOJ. In other words, it would appear that Thompson went to the CDC expressing concern about these requests and was told to give the DOJ everything. So that’s what he does, spelling out exactly what he means by that: All his agendas, analysis plans, Excel spreadsheets, SAS programs, draft manuscripts, edited manuscripts, and sensitive results from the MADDSP/MMR Autism study (the study that was ultimately published as Destefano et al. and “reanalyzed” incompetently by Brian Hooker). He also said he would be providing any other documents he had related to autism/MMR studies. In other words, he seemed to be saying to the CDC, if you tell me to apply a “broad definition,” I’m going to give the DOJ everything I have. As far as we know, the CDC did not object. If it had and Mike Adams had the “smoking gun” e-mail, you can bet he’d have used it by now, given that this e-mail was “revealed” several days ago.
Most of the issue here appears to be requests for documents from the DOJ, which clearly spooked Thompson, if this letter is any indication. I can understand. If I were an investigator at the CDC and the DOJ were requesting documents from me, I’d be nervous too, particularly after seeing my collaborator raked over the coals in front of the committee of the grandaddy of antivaccine congressional representatives, Dan Burton, as Thompson did Coleen Boyle in 2002. As an investigator in vaccine safety, you don’t expect to be the target of investigations of politically minded antivaccine loons. You expect to do good science and let the science speak for itself. Unfortunately, given the antivaccine movement, anyone who works for the CDC in vaccine safety is a target, something that’s been true for 15 years now.
Mike Adams (and the antivaccine contingent lapping up his stuff) wants you to think Thompson was expressing fear that he and his collaborators had done something wrong. To Adams, it’s always the “cover-up,” whether there is any cover-up or not. I just don’t see that, though. To me, it looks as though it’s probably panic at having the DOJ breathing down his neck and demanding documents. What I see is a plea for help, an attitude of, “WTF? I didn’t sign on for this legal stuff when I became a scientist. Take my name off the manuscript if I’m going to have to put up with this to be part of it.” He then took the step of hiring a personal attorney to protect himself, which is also not an entirely unreasonable step to take. After all, institutional lawyers exist to protect the institution, not the individual. Physicians inherently know this, which is why we don’t generally use hospital attorneys to defend ourselves in malpractice cases. We hire our own. In this case, it looks as though Thompson was simply informing the CDC brass that he was covering his own posterior. In other words, this e-mail is very much of a piece with his previous e-mail. Thompson was freaked out at dealing with the DOJ and didn’t want to take any chances. Barring more information, that’s what it looks like to me.
In other words, the “document dump,” such as it was, orchestrated by Mike Adams with (presumably) Brian Hooker and Andrew Wakefield, was utterly unimpressive. What amazes me today, as it did last week, is just how…mundane…these “bombshell” e-mails are. There’s no real indication of a cover-up. In fact, it sounds as though the CDC ordered its investigators to be maximally open with the DOJ after Thompson asked for guidance. If this is the best Adams, Wakefield, and Hooker can come up with, it’s thin gruel indeed. Meanwhile, antivaccine activists tried to get the attention of the mainstream media through a Twitter party orchestrated by the cringe-inducingly named Thinking Moms’ Revolution that failed.
Two real “bombshells”
Wednesday was an eventful day in that there were two developments. First, in the morning, Hooker’s paper was taken down pending further investigation, with the following notice:
This article has been removed from the public domain because of serious concerns about the validity of its conclusions. The journal and publisher believe that its continued availability may not be in the public interest. Definitive editorial action will be pending further investigation.
As of last night, the same message is there. When I first heard of this, I was conflicted. On the one hand, my position had hardened since I had first analyzed Hooker’s sorry excuse for a reanalysis. Then, I wasn’t completely sure that the paper was as bad as all that. Oh, I knew it was bad, but just how bad had to be further pounded into my head through further thought, further reading, and further analysis over the next few days. So I really thought this paper deserved retraction. On the other hand, I knew that retracting this paper would simply feed the conspiracy theorists of the antivaccine movement in a way that almost nothing else could, and if this removal does end up being the first step towards retraction it will drive the antivaccine conspiracy contingent into even greater heights of frenzy. But then I thought about it. Everything feeds into the conspiracy theories of antivaccinationists. We don’t care about changing their minds, because their minds can’t be changed. What we do care about is persuading the general public, particularly the fence sitters, and a retraction of a scientific paper sends a powerful message to the public about a study.
A great example is Andy Wakefield himself. His reputation was never quite the same after he was struck off as a physician in the UK and then his Lancet paper was retracted. Before that, mainstream news outlets used to routinely interview him about vaccines and autism. Afterward, he was toxic. True, he should have been just as toxic all along, at least as far back as the late 1990s, but for some reason he wasn’t. After his retractions, suddenly he was. Indeed, one can’t help but wonder whether Wakefield’s involvement in this story completely undermined Hooker by guaranteeing that the mainstream media wouldn’t touch this story with the proverbial ten foot cattle prod. Without Wakefield, maybe Hooker would have gotten some traction with major mainstream media outlets over his “reanalysis” and his whistleblower. With Wakefield on board, he got nothing. Indeed, this is one of the uncommon times when the mainstream media should be congratulated for not covering Andrew Wakefield, with only very minor exceptions (and, no, CNN iReports do not count as mainstream news reporting, the efforts of antivaccinationists to claim otherwise notwithstanding).
That changed somewhat after the next major development, but not, in general, to the antivaccine movement’s liking. This next development, was the issuance of a press release by William Thompson through his lawyer, Rick Morgan.
The first thing you have to remember is that this statement was vetted through his lawyer. Consequently, it is relatively content-free, at least as far as some of the more pressing questions. There also appears to be an effort there to straddle the fence a bit, hence Thompson’s saying that he agrees with Hooker that CDC decision-making and analyses should be “transparent.” That’s a statement so generic as to be in essence meaningless. No one—the CDC included—would disagree with that statement. The devil, of course, is in the details. What, exactly, does “transparent” mean?
The next thing that came to mind is this: Thompson very likely destroyed his scientific career, and it’s not because he revealed any scientific fraud. There doesn’t appear to have been any fraud, just a scientific disagreement. Yet, over this disagreement, Thompson has, in essence, apologized (expressed “regret”) not just for himself (which he has every right to do if he thinks he’s done something wrong) but has in essence also apologized for his co-authors too. One wonders whether his co-authors think they’ve done anything that requires such an expression of “regret.” My guess is that the answer to that question is no. So Thompson has turned a scientific disagreement into an insinuation of unethical behavior, based on a dubious accusation, given that I don’t see, even now, how “relevant data” were withheld, given that Destefano et al. analyzed data for all subjects, as I described.
Sure, the CDC won’t fire Thompson or discipline him, but no one is going to want to collaborate with him any more—and understandably so. Certainly, if I were one of his collaborators, I’d drop him like the proverbial hot potato immediately and refuse to work with him further, if only for the reason that I could no longer trust him not to turn an honest scientific disagreement into a major kerfuffle. Make no mistake, his attempt to recast his behavior as a result of a scientific disagreement by saying that “Reasonable scientists can and do differ in their interpretation of information” will fall on deaf ears in the scientific community. After all, he just accused his coauthors, indirectly, of at the very minimum sloppy science in not following the study protocol. Worse, they can’t say anything publicly to counter it, given Thompson’s having lawyered up to assert whistleblower status.
That being said, the antivaccine movement should take no comfort in Thompson’s statement, either. I’ve seen them all over Twitter and Facebook already zeroing in on Thompson’s insinuations, to the exclusion of the rest of the press release. It was enough to have our old buddy J.B. Handley (remember J.B. Handley?) start up a Twitter account:
#CDCWhistleblower scrubbed by lawyers and still ugly, biggest shit-bomb CDC has ever seen http://t.co/pefeWFphzc
— JB Handley (@JBHandleyjr) August 28, 2014
Meanwhile, the commenters are going wild over at the antivaccine crank blog Age of Autism.
Antivaccinationists, however, are quite mistaken in declaring Thompson’s statement to be “vindication.” It is not. For one thing, all we have is Thompson’s word that anything untoward occurred. For another thing, it hasn’t been actually proven that there was any sort of malfeasance or scientific fraud at all, and even Thompson’s statement, although it insinuates less-than-rigorous scientific behavior, does not support an accusation of fraud. Even if it did, accusations are not convictions. Here’s the problem. Antivaccinationists, as is usual, are being very selective in what they believe out of this press release. They trumpet Thompson’s statement about the Destefano et al as “proof” that the “CDC lied.” Yet, they’re completely ignoring the biggest part of the statement: How massively enormous (or enormously massive) a slimeball Thompson just revealed Hooker to be—Wakefield, too. In the statement, Thompson accused Hooker of having recorded him without informing him, a massive violation of the trust Hooker had nurtured between them.
In light of this new information, what do I now think happened? I think I can make a reasonably educated guess now. Both Hooker and Thompson agree that they had many phone conversations over that period of time. Likely, Hooker reeled Thompson in by offering a sympathetic ear and enthusiasm to reanalyze the data, as well as by playing to his ego and view of himself as a wronged warrior for the truth. It didn’t matter much that Hooker, if his “reanalysis” is to be believed, has the statistical and epidemiological skills of a paper cup. The two men obviously hit it off, and Thompson confided more and more with him, while Hooker taped it all without Thompson’s knowledge. Meanwhile, anyone paying attention to the rumblings of the antivaccine underground knew that Hooker had been claiming he had a “whistleblower” on the inside for quite some time now. Ultimately, somehow Wakefield found out and proposed making that video, promising not to reveal Thompson’s identity, a promise he broke. Betrayals within betrayals. Hooker played Thompson by recording him, and apparently Wakefield played Hooker by tricking him into doing that video with a promise not to reveal Hooker’s identity. Either way, Thompson was played, big time.
The backlash
There’s no doubt about it. The antivaccine crankosphere is fired up about this. They’ve been pounding a hashtag they invented, #CDCwhistleblower, for almost a week now. Antivaccine activists are so fired up about this that they’ve lost their usual sense of caution with respect to commenting on pro-science blogs like this one and my not-so-super-secret other blog. As I write this, the number of comments after my first post is fast approaching 1,000, largely because of an unprecedented influx of antivaccine posters. Meanwhile, I haven’t been at the receiving end of such an intense series of attacks by antivaccinationists since four years ago, when Jake Crosby accused me of a nonexistent conflict of interest, resulting in an influx of e-mails and calls to my university’s board of governors, my cancer center director, and my medical school dean trying to get me fired. They failed.
These days, the attacks are coming in the form of a potentially libelous CNN iReport regurgitating Crosby’s charges, and, of course, Twitter attacks galore:
@gorskon @brian_sthecobra @DrChrisNorthrup @RobSchneider We're holding all complicit accountable & heads will roll. The ax is coming down!
— Marsha McClelland (@Mofmars333) August 31, 2014
@JBHandleyjr @gorskon @snopes Gorski & others been working years for pHARMa to hold children in harms way #CDCwhistleblower @RobSchneider
— Marsha McClelland (@Mofmars333) August 31, 2014
@gorskon @brian_sthecobra @DrChrisNorthrup @RobSchneider They're lies? You & others to be named were warned to stop. Time to pay the piper!
— Marsha McClelland (@Mofmars333) August 31, 2014
@gorskon @JBHandleyjr your words and actions will come back to haunt you on your deathbed #CDCwhistleblower
— Blaze (@autismeradicato) August 31, 2014
@gorskon @JBHandleyjr #CDCwhistleblower Many hold rage in our hearts due to this Dr. Gorski.& his several partners in crime @RobSchneider
— Marsha McClelland (@Mofmars333) August 31, 2014
This all sounds rather…threatening. One wonders if Ms. McClelland thinks it’s wise to post such Tweets.
And, of course, J.B. Handley is at it as well:
My take on Dr David Gorski aka Orac #CDCwhistleblower http://t.co/217iIpfMVc — JB Handley (@JBHandleyjr) August 31, 2014
@JBHandleyjr @gorskon @snopes did you see the TV coverage !! Kreipske made audito, finds fraud gets fired http://t.co/Nq7muYbo8y
— Eben Plettner (@EbenPlettner) August 31, 2014
I must be oblivious to what’s going on at my medical school, because I hadn’t heard about this. So I did a little Googling and found the University’s response:
Having now reviewed a copy of the complaint provided to us by the Free Press, our preliminary conclusion is that there is no substance to the suit. For example, five of the six grants discussed by the plaintiff were simply grant applications that the plaintiff himself helped prepare. The applications were never funded, making it impossible for fraudulent spending to have occurred. For the one grant that was actually funded, federal auditors performed an audit and there were no findings or recommendations; the audit was completely clean.
In addition to Wayne State’s own scientific misconduct investigation, this former Wayne State employee was also investigated by the Federal Office of Research Oversight, which imposed a 10-year ban on further grant funding to him by the Veterans Administration. He has challenged his termination from Wayne State three times and the findings of research misconduct by federal agencies multiple times. Each of these challenges has been unsuccessful. During that time, he never once brought these latest allegations of fraud to the attention of anyone in Wayne State’s administration.
In other words, this whole lawsuit sounds quite dubious.
I can say is (1) this is an accusation and has not been proven in a court of law (and really doesn’t look as though it will be) and (2) even in the unlikely event WSU lost this lawsuit, it’s nothing more than the logical fallacy of guilt by association, a type of ad hominem fallacy. If that’s the best J.B. Handley has, he’s pathetic indeed. However, I now expect that I’ll be seeing that story thrown at me a lot, along with Jake’s old discredited post. Others who have spoken out against them have received the same treatment to a degree not seen in a while about anything.
There was a time when such vilification would have bothered me, but I’m used to it now. Indeed, I wear it as a badge of honor. They don’t have anything else, and the intensity of the vitriol directed at me is proportional to my effectiveness in dismantling antivaccine claims.
A reality check: So what was Thompson thinking, anyway?
The biggest unknown in this entire misbegotten saga is William W. Thompson, the “CDC whistleblower.” Over the last week and a half, I’ve wanted to ask him time and time again, “What on earth were you thinking?” Thompson now writes in his statement that he is willing to collaborate with “unbiased and objective scientists” to reanalyze vaccine safety datasets. That’s great. But, if that’s the case, why on earth did he ever contact Brian Hooker? Brian Hooker? Just a cursory Google search of Hooker’s name and the word “vaccine” would have easily revealed to him that Hooker was anything but “unbiased” and “objective” about vaccines. Such a search would have quickly revealed obviously that Hooker is an antivaccine activist working to “prove” that mercury in vaccines causes autism.
Thompson thus failed miserably in even the most cursory due diligence. And now he’s surprised that Hooker betrayed him? Now he thinks that true “unbiased and objective” scientists might want to collaborate with him on vaccine safety issues? Real “unbiased and objective” scientists are going to avoid Thompson like the plague. I don’t know what personal guilt or issues drove Thompson to think that confiding in Hooker was ever a good idea. I’d say he deserved what he is getting, were it not for the fact that the children of the U.S. and possibly the world could well suffer as a result of his ill-advised pseudointellectual dalliance with Brian Hooker. There are mothers out there who will not vaccinate their children with MMR, thanks to Thompson’s ill-advised dalliance with the antivaccine movement. I guarantee it.
Oddly enough, there are some Tweets that ask the key questions about Thompson’s motivations that echoed my own questions:
@gorskon Im gathering opinions from both sides. Im not an expert. Why would a seemingly respectable Dr tank his name&career on a study done
— marcos magaña (@mm3813) August 31, 2014
@gorskon 10 yrs ago? Why would he chose of all people Hooker to tell this to? (When its obvious hooker is not respected in the scientific
— marcos magaña (@mm3813) August 31, 2014
Excellent questions. At first, I thought we were left with two potential explanations. One was that Thompson had gone antivaccine. I don’t think he has, but some selected quotes publicized in which he criticized recommending the thimerosal-containing version of the flu vaccine for pregnant women, stating that it causes tics in children and tics are “autism-like” sure do sound antivaccine. So, although I don’t think he’s gone antivaccine (yet), he’s clearly imbibed at least some of that world view from Hooker. The other possibility was that Thompson had an unresolved scientific disagreement with his co-authors, a “beef,” if you will, that he is now resolving. But if that were the case, then surely there must have been better ways to resolve that than cozying up to an antivaccinationist who has been trying to get first Rep. Darrell Issa (R-CA) and then Rep. Bill Posey (R-FL) to hold hearings looking into a vaccine-autism link.
Friday, I was made aware of a possible third reason.
Based on some of my previous posts over at the not-so-secret other blog, I was unexpectedly contacted by Rick Morgan, William Thompson’s lawyer, who wanted to speak with me. So I gave him my number, and he called me on Friday. It was a brief, but very strange conversation. Morgan didn’t tell me much, but I didn’t expect him to, although he stated that he understood that I thought Thompson either had a beef with his co-investigators or had gone off the deep end. However, he wanted to “plant a seed” that maybe—just maybe—there might be another explanation, that this had been torturing Thompson all these years and he just had to do something because he couldn’t take it anymore.
And maybe that is true. I have no way of knowing. I do know that, whatever his motivation, Thompson had done horrible damage and almost certainly endangered African American children to suffer from measles who might not have contracted it otherwise.
Assuming that what Mr. Morgan told me in that brief, cryptic conversation is true, it just goes to show how a guilty conscience, whether justified or not, can drive a man to do some really stupid things. Make no mistake, there is no doubt that what Thompson did was incredibly naive and/or stupid. Maybe his conscience was torturing him for a decade. Again, who knows?
That thought led me to another thought, though. The central conspiracy theory of the antivaccine movement states that scientists and bureaucrats at the CDC are involved in a massive cover-up of The Truth, undeniable scientific evidence that vaccines cause autism, all done in the service of big pharma. Now think about Thompson again. If what Morgan says is true, then Thompson’s conscience has been torturing him over a relatively minor scientific disagreement in which he didn’t really believe, based on the data presented in DeStefano et al., that there was a true correlation between MMR vaccination and autism, but he did believe that further studies should be done. Now his conscience has led him to ruin his scientific career and reputation over just that.
Now imagine if there had been a real conspiracy to suppress compelling evidence indicating that vaccines cause autism. In that case, there wouldn’t just be a single man torturing himself over decisions made, as Thompson, if we believe Morgan, apparently has. It would be men and women at every level of the CDC. If the CDC couldn’t “keep Thompson quiet” over this, if Thompson was willing to risk destroying his career over a small subgroup analysis with almost certainly spurious results that weren’t followed-up on when he thought they should be, imagine what would happen if real data demonstrating a strong link between vaccines and autism had been covered up. There would be Bill Thompsons crawling out of the woodwork everywhere, beginning not long after the cover-up began.
And that, my friends, is why the entire CDC whistleblower conspiracy theory is so incredibly implausible. Indeed, it reads like a bad movie script.

Vaccine Whistleblower: An antivaccine “exposé” full of sound and fury, signifying nothing
Antivaccine lawyer Kevin Barry has published a book containing what are allegedly the transcripts of telephone conversations between “CDC whistleblower” William Thompson and biochemical engineer turned incompetent antivaccine epidemiologist Brian Hooker. Suffice to say, the transcripts do not show evidence of a massive coverup at the CDC of evidence that vaccines cause autism.
David Gorski on August 24, 2015
Link

Life’s but a walking shadow, a poor playerThat struts and frets his hour upon the stageAnd then is heard no more: it is a taleTold by an idiot, full of sound and fury,Signifying nothing.
– Shakespeare’s Macbeth, Act 5, Scene 5

I don’t review books that often. The reason is simple. My posts for this blog sometimes take as much as a several hours to write (particularly my more “epic” ones that surpass 5,000 words), and I usually don’t have the time to add several more hours to the task by reading an entire book. Also, by the time I’ve read a book I might want to review, weeks—or even months—have often passed, and a review is no longer of much interest to our readers anyway. Fortunately, Harriet does an admirable job of reviewing books for us.
Today, I’m making an exception for a book hot off the presses. The main reason is curiosity, because the book is about a topic that I’ve blogged about three times here and several times more for my not-so-super-secret other blog, and I really wanted to find out more about what was going on. I didn’t expect to find out what really happened, because I knew from the beginning that the book, Vaccine Whistleblower: Exposing Research Fraud at the CDC by an antivaccine lawyer named Kevin Barry, would be highly biased. However, as I found out a few weeks ago, the book promised four complete transcripts of telephone conversations between the “CDC whistleblower,” a Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) psychologist named William W. Thompson who has been a co-investigator on important CDC studies since the late 1990s.
Given my rather public skepticism about the particulars of Thompson’s story, I was quite surprised when my request to Barry’s publicist for a review copy of Vaccine Whistleblower was enthusiastically answered in the affirmative, thus giving me time to read the e-book before it was released. I also sent a copy of the book to a law professor familiar with the saga, Dorit Reiss, to write a legal perspective (also being published on SBM today) which is why I will say little about this aspect of the book in my discussion. In addition, René Najera has examined the book from a statisticians’ standpoint.
#CDCWhistleblower: Essential background
Thompson’s rather implausible “revelations” that the CDC covered up data showing a link between the MMR (measles-mumps-rubella) vaccine and autism in African American boys birthed the whole “CDC whistleblower” phenomenon almost exactly a year ago. Before I review the book, let me briefly describe the “scandal” that spawned the book.
Thompson was an author on several pivotal papers examining whether vaccines cause autism. All of the studies were negative, of course, but to antivaccine activists that just adds to the conspiracy. Basically, almost exactly a year ago, Thompson was featured in a short film by Andrew Wakefield as a “whistleblower” who had “confessed” to a biochemical engineer named Brian Hooker that for one of the studies for which he had been a coauthor in 2004 (Destefano et al.) investigators had “covered up” a correlation between MMR vaccination and autism in African-American males and had not followed the protocol as written. He based his claim of a cover up on a truly incompetently done “reanalysis” of Destefano et al., which he later touted for its “simplicity,” apparently not realizing that simplicity in statistical analyses of epidemiological data is not a virtue. Suffice to say, the original correlation was based on small numbers and disappeared when proper corrections for confounders were made. Not surprisingly, Hooker’s reanalysis was ultimately retracted.
None of this has stopped Hooker and Wakefield from trying to make hay about this “CDC Whistleblower” scandal or antivaccinationists from swarming Twitter on the #CDCWhistleblower hashtag. Just last month, Rep. Bill Posey (R-Florida), who appears to be taking up the antivaccine mantle left behind when Rep. Dan Burton retired, got up on the floor of the House to speak during the Morning Hour, a time when Representatives can basically say what they want for a few short minutes, and demanded an investigation into the CDC. He even went so far as to quote Thompson thusly:
All the authors and I met and decided sometime between August and September ’02 not to report any race effects for the paper. Sometime soon after the meeting, we decided to exclude reporting any race effects, the co-authors scheduled a meeting to destroy documents related to the study. The remaining four co-authors all met and brought a big garbage can into the meeting room and reviewed and went through all the hard copy documents that we had thought we should discard and put them in a huge garbage can. However, because I assumed it was illegal and would violate both FOIA and DOJ requests, I kept hard copies of all documents in my office and I retained all associated computer files. I believe we intentionally withheld controversial findings from the final draft of the Pediatrics paper.
It was the first statement, albeit unverified, from Thompson in quite some time, and it was also a serious accusation of major scientific misconduct on the part of his co-authors and former coworkers at the CDC. If this statement were to be verified as having come from Thompson (oddly enough, it appears nowhere in Vaccine Whistleblower) and I were one of his co-authors, I’d consider myself as having been defamed. Thompson himself has been silent—at least publicly—since last summer, when this whole kerfuffle erupted, and probably wisely so. Whatever his motivation, he has caused considerable damage with his foolishness in having trusted Brian Hooker. Or so I had thought. It turns out, if Vaccine Whistleblower is any indication, that Thompson was actually an enthusiastic participant in bringing about this scandal. Indeed, he appears to have turned antivaccine in such a way that he distinctly reminds me now of Andrew Wakefield, albeit without the charisma and hunger for the spotlight but with at least as much anger, resentment, and narcissism. You’ll see what I mean soon enough, but here’s a taste. At one point, Thompson accuses drug companies of “hyping” measles outbreaks and the failure to eradicate polio, describing them as a “never-ending thing where the press loves to hype it and it scares people and how “it scares the crap out of people when they hype those two types of outbreaks.”
Yes, Thompson has gone full antivax.
The setup
Vaccine Whistleblower is a rather short book designed to showcase the transcripts of four telephone conversations recorded—legally, Barry is quick to point out multiple times—between Brian Hooker and William Thompson on May 8 (Transcript #1), May 24 (Transcript #2), June 12 (Transcript #3), and July 28, 2014 (Transcript #4). The first two conversations are rather brief (around 5,000 words each), while the last two are quite long (over 8,000 words each).
Barry begins with a Foreword by, of all people, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. Right away, all I can say is: Way to go, Mr. Barry! If you want to portray yourself as being “not antivaccine,” as you say in the book so many times, there’s no better foreword writer to pick than RFK, Jr.! Hilariously, RFK, Jr. begins his Foreword by declaring again, as he did on The Dr. Oz Show, that he is “fiercely pro-vaccine”:
I have always been fiercely pro-vaccine. I had all six of my children vaccinated. I believe that vaccines have saved millions of lives and that broad vaccine coverage is desirable. To achieve those goals, we need safe vaccines, transparent and reliable science, and an independent regulatory agency. The extraordinary revelations in this book by CDC insider and whistleblower Dr. William Thompson prove that, unfortunately, we have none of these.
RFK, Jr.’s declaration is risible in the extreme.
It’s also apparent that these four transcripts were carefully selected. I base this conclusion on two observations. First, in the transcripts, Hooker and Thompson pal around as though they’ve been buddies a long time. For example, in Transcript #4, before anything of substance is recorded, the reader is treated to three and a half painful pages of Hooker and Thompson bantering about Hooker’s new iPhone 5s, Thompson’s family vacation in Chicago (where his kids played drum and guitar in a blues camp), and Hooker’s vacation near Mt. Shasta and the drum and bugle corps he enjoyed watching, which ended with his tale of hitting a deer, complete with a description of the gore flying back at them as semis hit the deer again and again. Clearly these passages are included to emphasize that Thompson and Hooker had become best buds, and it works. I’ve changed my opinion of Thompson. He wasn’t duped; Hooker was duped after he told Wakefield about the transcripts of his phone conversations. Thompson himself was all in.
The other observation is that the first contact between Hooker and Thompson was in November 2013, earlier than I had thought. It’s not clear who reached out first, but it’s clear from the gist of the transcripts that Thompson had been planning long before that to “go rogue” and that his colleagues didn’t trust him—with good reason, it turns out. Also, RFK, Jr. states in his foreword that there were “over thirty conversations with Hooker” in which “Thompson disclosed in great detail the CDC’s tricks for executing the fraud.” So why were just these four chosen for publication in Vaccine Whistleblower? Inquiring minds want to know, particularly given that these four conversations actually don’t reveal that much. If, as is presumably the case, these are the best Hooker could come up with, I wonder about the rest. It’s not as though the book was so long that he couldn’t have included a couple of more or omitted the pointless hundreds of words’ worth of dull pleasantries between Hooker and Thompson to make room.
Be that as it may, May 2014 is, according to the May 24 transcript, when Thompson was becoming concerned enough about his situation at the CDC that he engaged Frederick M. Morgan, Jr. of Morgan Verkamp, a lawyer specializing in whistleblower claims, who is representing him pro bono and issued the last known public communication by Thompson in the form of his statement dated August 27, 2014. It thus appears that, even if Andrew Wakefield hadn’t “outed” Thompson a year ago, it probably wouldn’t have been too long before he went public, particularly given that Hooker wanted him to and news of his existence had begun to percolate through the antivaccine underground. Indeed, at the time of the phone conversations documented in Vaccine Whistleblower, he had already long been in contact with Rep. Posey, pushing him to investigate and providing him with “100,000 pages” of…it’s not exactly clear what.
Predictably RFK, Jr. links Thompson’s “revelations” with his claims of CDC malfeasance and conspiracy mongering about a study looking at thimerosal-containing vaccines and autism and the CDC conference in which the data were discussed that ten years ago formed the basis of his abysmally antivaccine pseudoscience article, “Deadly Immunity“. It’s a lot of the same ol’, same ol’, as RFK, Jr. seems incapable of thinking up a new antivaccine schtick. Similarly, disgraced antivaccine chemist Boyd Haley shows up to write a preface in which he touts his “extensive study of this issue over many years” to claim that thimerosal-containing vaccines are dangerous.
Revisionist scientific history I: Thimerosal, vaccines, and tics, oh, my!
The first time through the book, I wondered why on earth the preface and the foreword both featured antivaccine activists who are all about mercury in vaccines. After all, what originally vaulted Thompson into the “CDC whistleblower” status were his accusations of scientific malfeasance against his former colleagues over a study from 2004 examining whether the MMR vaccine was associated with autism in African American boys, which, I noted, was the only subgroup where an effect was found. That’s why I originally characterized Hooker’s “reanalysis” of the DeStefano et al. data, purged of all those pesky statistical techniques designed to correct for confounders, as proving Andrew Wakefield wrong in his assertion that the MMR vaccine was correlated with an increased risk of developing autism. Getting a “positive” result in African-American boys required small numbers of this subgroup (which the study had) and ditching corrections for confounders that produce a spurious correlation, as I’ve discussed before. Even so, I was surprised at how little emphasis, relatively speaking, was given to DeStefano et al. in the transcripts chosen to be included in Vaccine Whistleblower. Maybe it’s because, as Jim Frost described, there’s just no there there. Emily Willingham agrees, and Matt Carey sees creative editing in Posey’s quoting of Thompson.
Far more discussion occurred between Thompson and Hooker over a study on which Thompson was the first author. Even more astonishingly, these transcripts show that Thompson doesn’t even know how to interpret his own data, which were quite clear. The study I’m referring to is a 2007 study published in The New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) by Thompson et al. entitled “Early Thimerosal Exposure and Neuropsychological Outcomes at 7 to 10 Years.” It’s a study that, as RFK, Jr. takes pains to point out, Dr. Paul Offit characterized as “wonderful” and “definitive.” And so it is, but that doesn’t stop Thompson from now reinterpreting it in the wrong way.
It also doesn’t take long for the first inkling to appear in the transcripts that Thompson has gone antivaccine. This exchange occurs in Transcript #1 early on:
Dr. Thompson: I just think there has to be a mantra. The mantra should be, “We know thimerosal causes tics.” That’s been demonstrated. That’s been demonstrated in the big studies. And just keep saying that, “We know thimerosal causes tics.” ‘Cause the CDC never said that thimerosal doesn’t cause tics. The CDC always says thimerosal doesn’t cause autism. You have to take it off that. You have to take it off that. And I really do think it’s a public relations campaign. But I also have to say these drug companies and their promoters, they’re making such a big deal of these measles outbreaks and they are now, they’re making a big deal that polio is coming back and polio comes back all the time in third world countries. It’s like a never- ending thing where the press loves to hype it and it scares people. It scares the crap out of people when they hype those two types of outbreaks. I think as they teach you at the CDC, you have to stay on message. And the message I think to start getting out and then you wouldn’t have the press jumping on you saying, “Well vaccines don’t cause autism.” If you said, “Yeah, that’s true, but vaccines do cause tics.” And then eventually, eventually you could get the message over to oh tics are like five times as common among kids with autism.
Dr. Hooker: Right, it’s about four times, but, yes, absolutely.
Dr. Thompson: I do think that it’s staying on message with something different than autism because the press and everyone, you know, Jenny McCarthy, all those people. You bring up autism and vaccines you just get hammered. Who’s the company that, who sponsored one of your groups?
Dr. Hooker: Oh, Chili’s.
Dr. Thompson: Yeah, Chili’s just got fried. They just completely got fried.
Yes, you read that right. Immediately after the “Hello, how are you?” pleasantries, we see Thompson coaching a biochemical engineer turned antivaccine warrior on how to properly sell an antivaccine message. Forget about autism (for now), Thompson says. That’s too toxic, too associated with kooks like Jenny McCarthy. Instead, say that vaccines cause tics and go from there! It’s rather ironic how Thompson, after complaining how people working for the CDC “have to stay on message,” immediately provides Hooker a message to counter what he dismisses as the CDC message. Then Thompson complains about how Chili’s got “fried.” Most readers probably don’t remember this event, but in 2014 Chili’s came under fire for having scheduled a day to donate 10% of the day’s proceeds to the National Autism Association, which is, of course an antivaccine group posing as an “autism advocacy” group. Indeed, the NAA has explicitly stated on its website that one of its core beliefs is that vaccines can cause autism.
But is Thompson correct about thimerosal-containing vaccines acting as a cause of tics? The answer is no. However, before I get to how Thompson is now misinterpreting his own study, let me briefly touch on other articles that Thompson cited as evidence that thimerosal-containing vaccines cause tics. The first is what is commonly referred to as the Italian study:
Dr. Thompson: …And you can point to that Italy study (Tozzi et al. 2009) and just look at the means and the means are quite different in that study for tics. I really do think that study actually supports the idea. And then the other thing about the Italy study, the Italy study was the only randomly assigned study and it was a much smaller exposure so if you find something in there and they found two positive effects, right, if I’m recalling correctly, so again, ya know, a study that is randomly assigned, it’s the only study I know where there was random assignment and you found two negative associations where it was increased likelihood of maternal, I mean, verbal IQ and I can’t remember the other one. But tics, I’m telling you, if my recollection is correct, tics were significant in earlier drafts of the paper.
Really? Let’s go to the tape, so to speak and see what Tozzi et al. really concluded. This particular study was clever in that it took advantage of an existing randomized study of two different diphtheria-tetanus-acellular-pertussis (DTaP) vaccines, one that contained thimerosal and one that did not. This produced two groups of children who had been randomized, one whose vaccine schedule contained a cumulative intake of ethylmercury, the mercury metabolite of thimerosal, of 137.5 μg for the children who were assigned randomly to receive the DTaP vaccine that contained thimerosal (“higher intake group”) and 62.5 μg for those who received the thimerosal- free DTaP vaccine (“lower intake group”).
Ten years later, the children from this study living in the Veneto Region were studied. 1,403 children (697 belonging to the high thimerosal group and 706 belonging to the low thimerosal group) were recruited and subjected to a battery of eleven neurodevelopmental tests that produced a total of 24 neuropsychological outcomes to assess their development. The results were unsurprising. Most outcome measures showed no difference between the low and high thimerosal group, and the ones that did were small and entirely compatible with random chance due to multiple comparisons.
Oddly enough, the investigators did not control for multiple comparisons in their statistical analysis. I have no idea why they didn’t (they didn’t really explain), but they didn’t. They did, however, point out that for 78 different univariate statistical tests between all the outcome measures of all the tests (some outcome measures were tested by more than one test, and separate tests were done for males, females, and the entire sample), by random chance alone they would expect four “statistically significant” associations by univariate analysis. They found two. Girls had slightly lower scores in a measure of motor function, the finger-tapping test with the dominant hand, and a language test, the Boston naming test. As the authors described it, the differences were very small and of doubtful clinical relevance. My guess is that these apparent associations would probably disappear if a correction for multiple comparisons were applied. Moreover, only one case of autism was found, and that was in the group with the lower thimerosal dose. As for tics, the study reported that motor tics were observed for 2.56% of patients in the lower thimerosal intake group and 2.91% of patients in the higher intake group (RR: 1.13; 95% CI: 0.60–2.13; p = .744, Fisher’s exact probability test) and that phonic tics were detected for 0.43% of patients in the lower intake group and 0.87% of patients in the higher intake group (RR: 2.04; 95% CI: 0.51–8.13; P = .338, Fisher’s exact probability test). In other words, it was not statistically significant; so Thompson is reduced to insinuating that the effect was statistically significant in earlier drafts of the paper. This reminds me very much of David Kirby’s distortions about how another study exonerating thimerosal, Verstraeten et al., started out with a positive association between thimerosal and autism but that it disappeared in later drafts.
The Tozzi study is not without weaknesses. For instance, there was no control group who received no thimerosal. However, if thimerosal in vaccines were associated with autism, one would not expect that it would be different than any other toxin associated with an abnormality or condition. One would expect that the chance of autism or neurodevelopmental disorders would increase with increasing dose. Another criticism that antivaccine advocates made was to claim that the thimerosal dose-response curve has a plateau, and that plateau is below 62.5 μg, hence the lack of difference between the two groups. There’s just one problem with that argument. An exposure to 62.5 μg, to which the low exposure group was exposed, corresponds to roughly the total amount of mercury in vaccines to which American infants were exposed in 1989–before the alleged “autism epidemic.” Even if mercury caused autism and there was a plateau in the dose-response below a dose of 62.5 μg, that would not be consistent with antivacinationists’ other pet claim, that an autism epidemic started in the 1990s because of the increasing amount of thimerosal exposure due to vaccines. That couldn’t have happened if a dose of thimerosal less than 62.5 μg maxed out the risk of autism, because 62.5 μg is below the baseline exposure before the alleged “autism epidemic” started.
Revisionist scientific history II: Thompson misinterprets his own study
The other study that Thompson harps on in the transcripts is one by John Barile at the CDC published in 2012. Here’s what he says about it:
Dr. Thompson: It’s going to take two or three years, right. They tell me, they’re two and a half years behind, and they actually said with Posey thing treat it as a FOIA because he’s not the head of a committee. So, I just, again, you gotta come up with a different message where you won’t get hammered and they can’t deny it. Right? The only thing I know for sure, is that I can say that pretty confidently, vaccines cause tics. We replicated that. The Barile article replicated that and showed that once you took into account the number of tests and reduced them down to constructs, the one thing you couldn’t get to go away was the tic effect.
Dr. Hooker: Was the tic effect, right. I agree. And I’m even using that in my son’s vaccine court case, because he has tics and so, we have that. It’s been confirmed in several studies, not to mention your study and then the Barile study that was the reanalysis from 2012. And I’ll go back and look at those means on Tozzi as well.
Thompson is also listed as a co-author on Barile’s study. A word of explanation regarding authorship is in order here. Thompson is last author, which usually signifies the corresponding author, the senior author who was the one overseeing the research. However, the article lists John Barile as the corresponding author, which means that Thompson, listed last, was deemed the author who contributed the least to the study. The study itself is a reanalysis of Thompson’s own 2007 NEJM study that he is now misinterpreting. So it’s not unreasonable here to discuss the Thompson 2007 study. This is a study that pointedly did not look at autism but rather at other neurodevelopmental outcomes. Basically, it was a cohort study that studied children from four HMOs that participate in the CDC’s Vaccine Safety Datalink. A total of 1,047 children between the ages of 7 and 10 were evaluated with a battery of standardized tests assessing 42 different neuropsychological outcomes and these outcomes were correlated with exposure to mercury, estimated from prenatal maternal exposures to thimerosal-containing vaccines and exposures after birth.
As Steve Novella and a friend of the blog explained at the time, for some reason the investigators chose not to adjust for multiple comparisons. It is thus not surprising that they found some statistically “significant” exposures. One of these adverse associations was between thimerosal and tics in one HMO population and between thimerosal and language delay in another. Here’s where Thompson goes off the rails, taking a page from antivaccine activists like Sallie Bernard and David Kirby, Thompson cherry picks the negative association and ignores the positive. Why does this matter? Simple. By examining 42 neurodevelopmental outcomes and not correcting for multiple comparisons, Thompson made it virtually certain that a handful of the outcomes would be “statistically significantly positive.” Consistent with random chance, some of these were positive (as in mercury is protective against an adverse neurodevelopmental outcome) and some were negative. As a blogger other than Steve or me put it so aptly at the time:
The CDC study looked at 42 different outcomes, and determined multiple confidence intervals in each case, since different levels of exposure were tested. In total, I understand there were over 300 confidence intervals. Consequently, assuming the null hypothesis is correct, you should expect that an RR of 1.0 will be outside the 95% confidence interval in over 15 measures. What the study found was that in 12 measures there was an apparent protective factor, and in 8 measures there was an apparent risk factor. This is completely consistent with the null hypothesis. Therefore, the conclusion of the study, namely that the results of the same do not support a causal association between thimerosal-containing vaccines and neurological outcomes, is absolutely the correct conclusion.
Exactly. If you accept that thimerosal “causes” tics, then you have to accept that it also increases IQ. There is no basis to accept one correlation and reject the other. The most parsimonious explanation is that this study found no differences not attributable to random chance.
So what did Thompson do? He reanalyzed the data, with the help of John Barile, and published it in a pediatric psychology journal using “measurement models to assess more efficiently the associations between thimerosal exposure and theoretically meaningful neuropsychological constructs using a subset of the outcomes from the original study” and items “primarily based on the previous studies that found significant associations between methylmercury exposure and neuropsychological outcomes.” In other words, they got rid of all the other comparisons by organizing “25 of the measures into the following theoretical constructs based on expert opinion and previous literature: general intellectual functioning, verbal memory, fine motor coordination, executive functioning, behavior regulation, tics, and language.” By torturing the data this way, they found one statistically significant association between exposure to thimerosal-containing vaccines and the presence of tics among boys but not among girls. They concluded that “given that the association between thimerosal and tics has been replicated across several different studies, it may be informative to consider additional studies examining these associations using more reliable and valid measures of tics.” The problem is that those previous studies were not particularly convincing, and neither is this one, particularly given that the effect was only seen in boys. In the transcript, Thompson is even quite blatant when he explains why he chose to publish his reanalysis in a psychology journal:
Dr. Thompson: …And here is the other thing, is you gotta get it out of the medical journals, you gotta move it to the psychology journals. I don’t know if you saw but the Barile article got published in a psychology journal. It wasn’t actually, it was like Pediatric Psychology.
Dr. Hooker: It was the Journal of Pediatric Psychology, I saw that.
Dr. Thompson: Right, but if you get it out of the medical world and into the psychology world, you are not going to get as much bias from the medical establishment that has such a strong hold over these medical journals.
Dr. Hooker: Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. I’m not as well traveled in that realm. Is the Journal of Pediatric Psychology a good one to look at?
Dr. Thompson: It’s a great journal. It is a very good journal. We got great reviews from that journal. I’ll tell you. They actually made us [unintelligible] our discussion. They actually said, why are you downplaying the association with tics? So, actually made [UI] . . .
In other words, he looked for a sympathetic journal with a relatively low impact factor (2.472). Next, I predict, he’ll be publishing in bottom-feeding pay-to-publish journals.
Inside politics and “persecution” at the CDC
One thing that becomes apparent reading this book is that Thompson, like Barry, has a definite agenda. He also doesn’t think very much of his colleagues at the CDC. Interestingly, despite Rep. Posey’s use of an alleged quote by Thompson accusing his co-authors on DeStefano et al. of destroying data, no such statement is found in the book. Instead, however, on many occasions, Thompson expresses concerns that he’ll be labeled as “mentally ill” or “crazy” by the higher-ups at the CDC. For example, in Transcript #2, there is this exchange:
Dr. Thompson: Well I [laughing], Brian, this is where you and I don’t know each other very well and I . . . Here’s what I struggle with, is I struggle with saying anything that isn’t in writing that can’t be backed up. Here’s my fear okay? Let’s say you go public with anything okay? Whatever and then it becomes clear that you got information from call me. And then people will immediately say, “Well, he’s mentally ill and why would you believe anything that he says, it’s just hearsay.”
Dr. Hooker: How do people know about your business? Why do they know about ya know . . . It’s really none of their business your mental state or whether you’re quote-unquote mentally ill or not.
Dr. Thompson: I know but it will become, it will become, that will be the way they undermine me.
It’s hard for me not to point out here that Thompson’s “allies” Brian Hooker and Andrew Wakefield have already basically thrown him under the bus with respect to whether he suffers from any form of mental illness. They even alluded to this when they wrote a letter to the CDC demanding an investigation of Thompson’s allegations, quoting Thompson as saying that he had become “delusional” in a conversation dated May 24, 2014. When I went back to look at their letter, I noticed that that’s the same date as Transcript #2 in Vaccine Whistleblower, and there is no mention of that transcript. There are, however, two notations of “edited due to sensitive personal information” in this transcript, specifically:
Dr. Thompson: I know, maybe, maybe not, but I’m saying what he [Thompson’s whistleblower lawyer] and I agreed to. This is a lawyer that was reading through these documents that had never seen them before. And I basically was telling this guy I was complicit, and I went along with this, we did not report significant findings. Ya know, I’m not proud of that and uh, it’s probably, it’s the lowest point in my career that I went along with that paper. [Edited due to sensitive personal information.]
Thompson was quoted in Hooker and Wakefield’s letter as saying:
Ya know, I’m not proud of that and uh, it’s probably the lowest point in my career that I went along with that paper and I also paid a huge price for it because I became delusional
The match between the last sentence of the first quote and the first sentence of the last quote tell me I found the right place. There is another example as well.
As I said at the time, how low can Wakefield and Hooker go? In order to imply that the magnitude of the “crime” Thompson was being forced to be party to was so massive that it led him to some sort of mental breakdown, Hooker betrayed Thompson’s confidences about a very personal health issue. Barry, at least, left this part and another quote about Thompson’s having been delusional out of his book. I have no idea what Thompson’s mental state was or is (and deem it irrelevant for the purpose of assessing his veracity and credibility), but it’s odd that he fears that the CDC might paint him as mentally ill to discredit him but willingly cozied up to people who have already painted him as mentally ill when it suited their purpose.
Be that as it may, what comes through loud and clear in all of the transcripts is Thompson’s utter contempt for and fear of his former co-authors and colleagues, as well as other people in the government. He’s also a bit of a misogynist, referring to a woman at one point as being “like a twenty-five-year-old bimbo that they have do their dirty work.” Time and time again, he unloads to Hooker about how he fears that they will collude to deny anything he claims and turn it into his word against theirs, the presumption being that their word will be what is believed. He claims that the CDC “watered down” DeStefano et al and his own NEJM study when, even by his own account, what happened sounds like the normal give and take that goes on in the multiple layers of approval that any study done by a government agency has to go through before it is approved for submission for publication. He even brings up Poul Thorsen being suspected of committing fraud with CDC research grants, a man that antivaccinationists like to portray as being somehow “central” to the CDC’s studies that failed to find a link between vaccines and autism, when in reality he is anything but and those of us who oppose antivaccinationists would be more than happy to see him face justice. It’s just another place where Thompson sounds just like an antivaccine activist.
He and Hooker even talk about how Mark and David Geier tried to do what needed to be done when they tried to go beyond the IRB and merge Vaccine Safety Datalink datasets and lamenting how it’s not possible any more to do what they tried to do. Amusingly, though, Hooker points out that “it doesn’t really do me any favors to publish with the Geiers.” Given the Geiers’ history of atrociously unethical science in the name of blaming thimerosal for autism and Mark Geier’s history of having his medical license revoked, that has to be the understatement of the year!
Perhaps the most telling part of this whole exchange is here:
Dr. Thompson: Yeah, it’s all there. Um, but I’ve never looked at it yet. But I could actually go into the database right now and do a frequency count on things. But, I’m not going to do anything like that right now. I’m just really trying to sort this all out. I’m trying to, ya know I’m being in trouble because I’m blowing up and stuff like that and I’m getting really agitated and I just have to settle down.
Dr. Hooker: Right, you had mentioned on I think on a previous voicemail something about maybe taking a leave of absence or um or uh putting in for a new assignment.
Dr. Thompson: Yeah, I was considering getting detailed out of the branch. The downside to that is I would no longer have access to this type of information that I am sharing with you. I’m learning more and more. As I ask more and more, I’m learning more and more. I am, these people are like in one big bubble, they uh and their bubble is getting smaller and smaller.
So, on May 24, 2014, Thompson admitted to Hooker that the only reason he’s sticking around his branch of the CDC even though everybody there had come to distrust him (as well they should!) was to have access to information that he could funnel to Hooker, such as the existence of the SEED project, a dataset that contains the health records of 1,200 children, 800 of whom are confirmed autistic, with complete vaccination records. Thompson was also royally ticked off about the lack of use of this resource:
Dr. Thompson: So, um, what’s amazing, now this is what’s going to be shocking to you, it shocked the crap out of me. They have ya know six different sites interviewing data and um they all put in proposals to do studies. So far there is about sixty proposals in, um, for people ready to do studies. Not a single one of them looks at vaccines, not one! [laughing] So, I, well, I ripped into these people this week. And I’m like, “These vaccine studies have to be done. This is the largest case-control study you could ever do. They’re all objectively identified as kids with autism. You have the vaccine records.”
So, assuming this is true, Thompson is outraged that, of all the sixty proposals for studies using SEED project data thus far submitted, none of them looks at vaccines? If that’s not an indication that he’s become antivaccine, I don’t know what is! Let’s just put it this way: Did it ever occur to Thompson that the reason there are no proposals for studies using the SEED data that examine vaccines is because, from a strictly scientific standpoint, there is no interest in vaccines as a cause of autism or other neurodevelopmental disorders. The reason for that is simple. It’s been studied to death, and there is no credible evidence to support the hypothesis that vaccines (or just thimerosal-containing vaccines) cause autism. Like any good antivaccinationist, William Thompson cannot accept the science.
In fact, so antivaccine has William Thompson become that he and Brian Hooker gleefully trash other antivaccine groups for betraying the cause. Sallie Bernard, for instance, comes in for particularly harsh criticism, with Hooker dismissing her as a “double agent.” Mady Hornig, who produced the widely derided “autistic mouse” is disparaged by Hooker as “shacking up” with Ian Lipkin, whom Thompson chimes in to dismiss as an “arrogant dick,” even though they were married at the time. Of course, Hornig later did a study that tried to replicate Andrew Wakefield’s case series in The Lancet and failed to find a correlation between MMR and autism. How fast antivaccine heroes fall when they embrace science!
Kevin Barry’s agenda
I see little reason to write extensively about the rest of the book, the chapters that Kevin Barry wrote to fill it out to a measly 172 pages, counting the foreword by RFK, Jr., the preface by Boyd Haley, and Barry’s “executive summary” of the four transcripts. However, these still must be briefly discussed. This book is, if nothing else, intended as antivaccine propaganda, in which a former member of the hated “other side” recants and changes sides. Barry clearly wants to use Thompson to attack the vaccine program and to use Thompson as a motivator to prod antivaccinationists to agitate for political action and investigations into vaccine safety. That’s why the last three chapters of the book are dedicated to using Thompson’s betrayal of the CDC and science to demand that the President act:
The entire vaccine program is under the Executive Branch. It’s long past time for presidential leadership to take the issue of vaccine safety seriously. If President Obama won’t do it, then the next president must clean out the Immunization Safety Office and replace everyone but Dr. Thompson. Ideally, the replacements should do their best to resist unethical behavior, resist omitting significant data, and not lying in the first place.
Barry also demands that Congress “schedule hearings, issue subpoenas, and compel testimony under oath” and asserts:
As Dr. Thompson indicates, the lack of accountability must end. The White House, Congress, and the press need to hold CDC accountable for the lies and deception regarding vaccine safety over the past fifteen years. The same applies to the American Academy of Pediatrics—the nation’s pediatricians have also been deceived.
The funny thing is, nothing in Vaccine Whistleblower actually demonstrates this. All we have are the words of a very angry man, William Thompson, who clearly has been nursing a grudge against his former colleagues since at least 2003 and is willing to make accusations without significant evidence at them. All we have from this very angry man are a highly select number of transcripts, only four out of over 30, in which this bitter man makes his accusations. It’s all very one-sided, and unfortunately the CDC, probably because Thompson has lawyered up with one of the best whistleblower attorneys in the country, is being painfully vague and discreet in its response:
CDC is aware that employee Dr. William Thompson has raised concerns regarding an article he co-authored that was published in 2004 in Pediatrics. Consistent with CDC’s existing policies and procedures, the agency, through its Office of the Associate Director for Science (ADS), and in coordination with the HHS Office of Research Integrity, is reviewing these concerns. The agency will provide further information once the review is completed.
The bottom line is that this book is nothing more than propaganda, and deceptive propaganda at that. The sad thing is that a formerly reputable scientist, William Thompson, provided the grist for the propaganda because he apparently has an ax to grind against his former co-investigators. In any other organization besides a government organization, Thompson would have been fired a long time ago for incompetence and being a troublemaker, and he would have deserved it. Instead, Thompson has kept his job and is, of necessity, treated with kid gloves.
As for Barry’s book, it is propaganda, nothing more. What’s worse is that it isn’t even very good propaganda. It’s hard to read, and hits the reader over the head with its message, which isn’t even earned based on the thin gruel that the four transcripts provide. Indeed, if there was one impression of Thompson that I got from reading all the transcripts, it was of narcissism. Therein lies the comparison to Andrew Wakefield. As I read Thompson’s complaint, what came through loudest was his unshakable belief that he is right and everyone else at the CDC is wrong, that the only reason anyone could disagree with him is because they’re indoctrinated or bought off. To him his colleagues are not just wrong but incompetent, ideologically blinded boobs who are out to destroy him.
In fact, I can’t help but wonder if we are seeing a new Andrew Wakefield being born and if his name is William Thompson. I’m just thankful that, unlike the real Andrew Wakefield, the “CDC whistleblower” appears to be retiring and publicity-shy, preferring to act behind the scenes. Unfortunately, he can do a lot of damage to the vaccine program just the same.

Vaccine Whistleblower: BS Hooker and William Thompson try to talk about epidemiology
René Najera on August 24, 2015
Link


Here we go again with the whole “CDC Whistleblower” thing, this time with a book about the recorded conversations between Brian J. Hooker and William Thompson. Well, not the whole conversations, of course. If they were to release the whole conversations, we might get the truth, and the truth always gets in the way of the antivax crowd. Instead, we get an edited transcript of the conversations between those two in which, according to them and the book’s editors and authors, there is some sort of massive cover-up at all levels of science, government, and public health. What’s the cover-up? As usual, vaccines are evil and whatnot.
I’m not going to review the whole book for you because Dr. Gorski has already done so, and Dorit Reiss has discussed the legal aspects of what is discussed in the book. You can go read his review and/or Prof. Reiss’ analysis and then come back, or stay here and read what I have to say about the failed attempts at epidemiology from both BS Hooker and Thompson.
Let’s start by reviewing BS Hooker’s credentials. He is a bioengineer and chemical engineer, not an epidemiologist, despite what the author of the book wants you to believe:
With the publication of Kevin Barry’s Vaccine Whistleblower: Exposing Autism Research Fraud at the CDC, any claims of credibility for the CDC’s science has collapsed. Barry built his book upon four legally taped conversations between CDC senior vaccine safety scientist Dr. William Thompson and Simpson College professor and epidemiologist, Dr. Brian Hooker.
Later in the book, in the transcript of one of the conversations between BS Hooker and Thompson, BS gets a list of things he needs to do to earn an “honorary” degree in epidemiology. Among those things was to look at some of the earlier studies that Thompson had coauthored. And BS did. He would go on to write a flawed paper that I critiqued here and ended up being retracted, as I told you about here. That paper alone should tell you everything you need to know about BS Hooker’s epidemiological understanding, but the transcripts given to us by his camp in the form of the book really reveal his ignorance.
So let’s go through the calls we have transcripts for and pick at the epidemiological and biostatistical missteps that Thompson suggests for BS Hooker. 
The first transcript
In the first call we have a transcript for, Thompson tells BS to look at a study from Italy — and a reanalysis of that study — and see that there is an association between thimerosal in vaccines and tics. No, not autism, but tics. And both studies caution against concluding that it was the thimerosal because of the methodology and biologic plausibility of this. Also, the Italian study invited suBSects to participate, leading to a 70% participation rate. What the other 30% would have contributed is unknown. This is a huge source of bias and something that we should all watch out for.
Still, BS Hooker agrees to look at those studies and use them for his court case:
Dr. Thompson: The only thing I know for sure, is that I can say that pretty confidently, vaccines cause tics. We replicated that. The Barile article replicated that and showed that once you took into account the number of tests and reduced them down to constructs, the one thing you couldn’t get to go away was the tic effect.
Dr. hooker: Was the tic effect, right. I agree. And I’m even using that in my son’s vaccine court case, because he has tics and so, we have that. It’s been confirmed in several studies, not to mention your study and then the Barile study that was the reanalysis from 2012. And I’ll go back and look at those means on Tozzi as well.
Dr. Thompson: Look at the means. Look at the means, they’re very close. You could do a simple t-test and see they’re very close to significance. The other thing I wanted to ask you.
Yeah, they may be “very close to significance,” but that means nothing when you look at the entirety of the evidence. The authors tell us in those papers that there is bias, and that we must not jump to conclusions based on other factors, like biological plausibility. Still, Thompson and Hooker want to latch onto these studies and make something of them. Pretty par for the course for a couple of antivaxers.
Later in the first transcript, they discuss the numbers that led BS Hooker and his followers to cry out that African American males were more likely to get autism from vaccines than others in the group analyzed in the DeStefano paper. What is funny to me is that they discuss how drilling down into the data and splitting the cases and controls like they were doing leads to small numbers of cases and controls being compared:
Dr. Hooker: Okay, and one of the things I did find in this weird um, when I use the thirty-six-month cut-off for African American males, I only had seven cases in the after thirty-six months. Okay, so the cohort was getting small. So, I had like seven cases and I can’t remember how many controls. Obviously, the lion’s share of the cases were for individuals who got the MMR before thirty-six months. Now I, when I, I wanted to correct for low birthweight. So I threw out low birthweight. But what I found was that in my cases after, in the cases of individuals that got the MMR after thirty-six months, I wasn’t throwing out low birthweight, I was throwing out individuals that didn’t have birthweight reported at all. So you basically look at that and it is essentially saying it is the birth certificate cohort. Does that make sense? Let me, I can explain it one other way. When you look at the data and you look at African American male cases of autism, there are seven cases. There are four cases that did have a birth certificate and were normal birth weight and the remaining three cases didn’t have a birth certificate so they didn’t have birth weight at all.
That right there is a huge source of bias. When you compare five people here and six people there, even if you pick them at random, you’re going to find some differences that are big between the two groups. You need larger sample sizes to make sure that what you are seeing continues to be true on average and in the long run. It’s basic epidemiology, but Thompson and Hooker continued down that path, even as they recognized that these low numbers could be criticized and could be a problem.
As BS Hooker said:
Bill, I am not an epidemiologist by training.
And it shows.
The second transcript
In the second call we have a transcript for, Thompson seems horrified at the idea that no research group within and outside CDC wants to do an autism-vaccine study. Perhaps because that horse is dead and needs no more beatings?
Dr. Thompson: We’re going to have twelve hundred kids with autism as part of this uh study, um, with all their medical records and all their vaccine records abstracted. So, um, what’s amazing, now this is what’s going to be shocking to you, it shocked the crap out of me. They have ya know six different sites interviewing data and um they all put in proposals to do studies. So far there is about sixty proposals in, um, for people ready to do studies. Not a single one of them looks at vaccines, not one!
They probably don’t want to do a study like Thompson wants because the issue has been settled every which way before, because it is a huge waste of resources to look at autism and vaccines again.
In that same second transcript, there is a discussion about confidence intervals that needs to be noted. Thompson says this:
Dr. Thompson: You see that the strongest association is with those without mental retardation. The non-isolated, the non-mentally retarded, the effect is where you would think that it would happen. It is with the kids without other conditions, without the comorbid conditions. And the, ya know, honestly, I looked at those results, I had not gone through these hard copy papers, I don’t think I have ever gone through them since 2004 and I came across them, and I’m like “Oh my God” and this is 0.97 to 16 and it’s not statistically significant but odds ratio is 8 and if we would have added one more suBSect it probably would have been significant. I’m just looking that and I’m like. “Oh my God. I cannot believe we did what we did.” But we did. It’s all there. It’s all there. I have handwritten notes.
A confidence interval is the range of results that you will see 95 times out of 100 if you repeat the study many times. If your value includes 1.0, then there is a better than 5% chance that you will see no effect. Generally, you want confidence intervals to be nice and tight and not include 1.0. When you get a confidence interval that includes 1.0, you cannot rely on the results as being statistically significant. Now, did you catch that part about adding one more suBSect? Was Dr. Thompson suggesting that the results be manipulated some way? Or was he wishing that there were more suBSects in the study so the confidence interval wouldn’t be as wide and include 1.0?
Either way, the confidence interval could have shifted the other way to include 1.0 and more values under 1 than seen here. Then what? But, again, true to the antivax way, Dr. Thompson seems to wish that the results show what he wants them to show.
The third transcript
The third transcript is mostly about wishing that the data had gone the other way and confirmed the biases that BS Hooker and Thompson have about vaccines. They wish that non-African Americans had an association like the one seen in African American kids (when not adjusted for other factors). And then BS Hooker basically says that autism equals mental retardation, and that those who are autistic but not mentally retarded are the result of an “in vogue” diagnosis:
Dr. Thompson: Well, if you … The kids with mental retardation. …
Dr. Hooker: Right.
Dr. Thompson: … it’s probably, it’s probably unlikely that mercury exposure causes mental retardation.
Dr. Hooker: How well though … If you’ve got … You know, and you, like you said before, you’re not really the person to answer this but, how well do you have those records? Because a lot of times if you have an isolated autism case, you’re going to have mental retardation. I don’t … You know, I don’t know; I’m out in the community; I don’t really know many autistic kids that aren’t mentally retarded.
Dr. Thompson: Oh, I don’t know. I actually don’t know that for sure, but my reading of our own papers, the recent papers, is there’s a huge increase in the number of kids who don’t have mental retardation. That number is going, proportionately is going up.
Dr. Hooker: Right.
Dr. Thompson: So, I still … I still say …
Dr. Hooker: But that could be … Part of that could be a health-care-seeking behavior, because if it’s in vogue to get an autism diagnosis … And I deal with this as a parent all the time. You know, some genius walks up and tries to have a conversation with my kid, and I’ll look at the parent and say, “Oh, my son has autism. He’s non-verbal; he doesn’t speak.” And they’ll look at me and they’ll say, “Yeah, my kid has autism too.” And I’m just like, “What the fuck! Really?” We should be so lucky to have that kind of autism.
Later in the conversation, they try to compare thimerosal exposure to mercury exposure from fish and to lead poisoning… Do these guys even science? And they then dive into the antivaccine conspiracy theories about conflicts of interests (ignoring BS Hooker’s own, of course), hidden agendas, and Big Pharma interference.
In the last conversation in the book, there is more discussion about the papers that pointed to an increased chance of tics in children who got exposed to thimerosal. They try to explain away the lack of statistical significance in the findings and the recommendations to not look too much into the findings because there is an issue with biological plausibility. Yet again, they try to make sense of a world of science that they seem to not understand.
Again, check out the writers on other blogs who are reviewing the book and all of the discrepancies within it. Remember that you’re reading an edited version of conversations between two anti-vaccine people who have a lot to lose if it turns out that vaccines do not cause autism. Read carefully at the parts where they throw associates under the bus, and use some harsh language to describe those with whom they disagree. In essence, read the transcripts critically.
See, if you read the book with a total lack of understanding of what is going on, you might be tempted to think that a researcher at the CDC is actually revealing some pretty messed-up — perhaps even criminal — activities with regards to studies on vaccines and autism. But you know better, you’re more of a critical thinker than the hundreds of people who will read the book and be even more convinced of their own biases about vaccines. If you do end up reading the book, keep in mind the following things:
     1.  Numerous other public and private research groups have found no association between any vaccine and autism. The CDC is not the only agency that looked into it. After Wakefield’s fraud of a paper back in 1998, everyone and their mother looked into vaccines and autism, and 17 years later, no one has found anything credible in terms of evidence that vaccines cause autism.
     2.  BS Hooker has had the paper he worked on based on Thompson’s information thoroughly retracted. His methods didn’t add up, his conclusions didn’t add up, and…
     3.  BS Hooker has a case pending in the vaccine court where he alleges that vaccines caused his son’s autism. He failed to disclose that in his paper (#2 above) and that is a huge conflict of interest. If it is proven that vaccines cause autism, BS Hooker is due to cash in a whole lot. If not, he won’t get what he wants, and with it would go his fame and glory among the antivax camp.
     4.  Vaccines save lives. Period. End of post.

Review of Vaccine Whistleblower: A Legal Perspective 
Dorit Reiss on August 24, 2015
Link


This post addresses some legal issues raised in the Vaccine Whistleblower book. The first part explains whistleblower protections and how Dr. Thompson’s allegations fit into them. The second part addresses Dr. Thompson’s suggestion of an independent research agency. The third part explains why the book’s claim that school mandates violate international human rights is incorrect.
A note on the book: Chapters 1 is an executive summary of Chapters 2-5, the interview transcripts; Chapters 6-12 are the author Kevin Barry’s thoughts on what should be done. (Note that Dr. Gorski has also discussed this book from the perspective of the science.)
Prologue: to set the scene
The “Vaccine Whistleblower Book” has four transcripts of telephone conversations between William Thompson and Brian Hooker, recorded between May 1, 2014 and July 28, 2014.
Hooker has elsewhere stated that these conversations were only four of over thirty conversations between Thompson and Hooker. Hooker asserts these conversations began in November, 2013, and that Thompson initiated the conversations. It is not clear if these four recorded conversations were the only ones during that time frame, or what was discussed in the non-recorded conversations.
William Thompson was a co-author on a number of vaccine-safety studies published by the CDC. The most salient one for this discussion is (hereinafter DeStefano 2004):
DeStefano F, Bhasin TK, Thompson WW, Yeargin-Allsopp M, Boyle C. Age at first measles-mumps-rubella vaccination in children with autism and school-matched control subjects: a population-based study in metropolitan Atlanta. Pediatrics. 2004 Feb;113(2):259-66. PMID 14754936
It is not clear why Thompson became concerned enough to reach out in 2013 about a paper that had been published almost a decade previously.
Part I: Whistleblower protections in the United States:
When a federal employee discloses wrongdoing that he or she has a “reasonable belief” falls into certain categories in the United States, the law protects the employee from retaliation by the agency he or she exposed (or tried to expose). That’s the heart of whistleblower protections. It’s important to remember that both the Whistleblower Protection Act and the Whistleblower Protection Enhancement Act seek to provide broad and strong protections to employees disclosing wrongdoing, and Congress clearly signaled a desire to interpret doubts in the disclosing employee’s favor — though that does not translate into automatic protection.
It’s also important to point out that these protections only come into play if there was alleged retaliation by the agency in response to a disclosure.
An employee does not claim whistleblower status in abstract. An employee discloses information about wrongdoing; then, if the agency retaliates, whistleblower protections provide a remedy to the employee (there are a number of other contexts in which we use the term whistleblower that are less relevant here).
How do these whistleblower protections apply to Dr. Thompson?
Disclose to whom?Dr. Thompson did not go higher up in CDC, to another agency, to the administration, to Congress or the press directly. What he did do is have a long series of phone conversations with a private citizen — Dr. Brian Hooker — in which he complained about his colleagues’ conduct. But that does not negate the protections: they come in to force, with some exceptions that don’t apply here, regardless of to whom the disclosures were made (5 U.S.C. § 2302(b)(8)(A)).
That said, if Dr. Thompson’s goal was to correct wrongdoing, his choice of channel to correct it was strange, to say the least. According to the transcripts, Dr. Thompson only hired legal representation in May 2014, when the possibility of his involvement becoming public was raised (p. 24, chapter 3). So he didn’t have the benefit of legal counsel when he decided to call Dr. Hooker initially. But if you think there is serious wrongdoing in your agency and you want to effectively redress it, is calling an individual that is not only part of the administration but is in many ways an outsider the best way to do so? Dr. Thompson could have hired legal counsel in 2013, or done a Google search on, for example, whistleblower, government and wrongdoing — the first result of which is the Office of Special Counsel whose mandate includes protecting whistleblowers. He could have gone to the press. He could have tried a number of things that would be more effective than calling Dr. Hooker, even if he thought Dr. Hooker had some connections to members of Congress. It may be unfair to criticize Dr. Thompson in hindsight — he may not have thought of this or been well informed on how to report alleged government misconduct — but it is still a strange choice.
Do his allegations fall into protected categories?
In 2012, to broaden protection for whistleblowers, Congress passed the Whistleblower Protection Enhancement Act (WPEA). Relevant to us, section 110 of the Act applies whistleblower protections to scientists that seek to disclose acts they reasonably believe consist of “censorship related to research, analysis, or technical information that cause, or will cause, gross government waste or mismanagement, an abuse of authority, a substantial and specific danger to public health or safety, or any violation of law.” Censorship is defined as: “any effort to distort, misrepresent, or suppress research, analysis, or technical information.” Dr. Thompson claims he saw acts of suppressing research and analysis that could be directly related to the public health, to harm to children. If his belief is reasonable, whistleblower protections would apply to him.
What is reasonable belief, and Did Dr. Thompson have it?
Reasonable belief asks:
whether, given the information available to the whistleblower, a person standing in his shoes could reasonably believe that the disclosed information evidences one of the identified conditions in the statute.
from The U.S. Office of Special Counsel’s Role in Protecting Whistleblowers and Serving as a Safe Channel for Government Employees to Disclose Wrongdoing, drawing on these cases: Fitches v. Dep’t of the Air Force, 82 M.S.P.R. 68 (1999); Gores v. Dep’t of Veterans Affairs, 68 M.S.P.R. 100 (1995)
The information does not have to be true, and the focus is on the whistleblower’s state of mind, not the listener. The whistleblower’s motives — for example, a desire to get even with a co-worker — do not negate the protection and are not directly connected to the reasonableness of the belief.
Given the holes in the facts in the book and my lack of familiarity with the day-to-day realities of the scientific process, I cannot really assess whether Dr. Thompson had reasonable belief that his co-authors engaged in “any effort to distort, misrepresent, or suppress research, analysis, or technical information.” I would assume his belief was sincere, but I don’t know if it was reasonable. All I can say is that there is a good chance that an administrative official or judge that does not have a background in science will, given the intent to make whistleblower protections broad, give Dr. Thompson the benefit of the doubt — if his agency acted against him and whistleblower protections were needed.
So far, there is no indication the CDC acted against Dr. Thompson, so there was no retaliation to trigger the protections in the Act. It’s important to note that if there is reasonable belief by the employee that he is disclosing something that falls under the headings in the act, the agency has a heavy burden to support any action against him. If there is evidence that the disclosure was a contributing factor in the act against the employee, and knowing about the disclosure and the action being close in time to the disclosure can create such a case (as can other types of evidence), the agency:
can avoid liability only if it demonstrates by clear and convincing evidence that it would have taken the same action in the absence of the whistleblowing.
It makes sense, therefore, that the CDC will be very careful not to take actions that could be seen as retaliation against Thompson if they believe his claims could possibly meet the standards in the whistleblower protection acts.
One more point on this deserves addressing. On page 111 Mr. Barry, the book’s author, claims that Dr. Thompson needs to be subpoenaed to testify before Congress because “it is unlikely that his attorney, an expert in whistleblower cases, would allow him to testify unless compelled.” It’s not quite clear why Mr. Barry thinks that. First, Dr. Thompson is an adult; he doesn’t need permission to testify, though he would be wise to listen to the experienced legal counsel he hired. Second, if his goal, as suggested in the transcripts, is to achieve meaningful reform, why wait for a subpoena? As his lawyer, who specializes in these areas, could have pointed out, the OSC can require an investigation by the agency and then make recommendations to Congress and the CDC. Neither is bound by the OSC’s recommendations, but recommendations by a specialized agency focusing on whistleblowing will almost certainly have an impact. And if Congress decided to investigate before the OSC is done, it could. If the CDC wanted to retaliate, whistleblower protection would come into play with or without a subpoena.
Why wait?
The only explanation I can think of is that Dr. Thompson thinks he may be criminally liable for something, and thinks a subpoena would guarantee immunity. It won’t, however. The only situation in which a subpoena would mean immunity is if Dr. Thompson was forced to testify after asserting a Fifth Amendment claim before Congress. Congress can grant immunity, or partial immunity (meaning Dr. Thompson can still be prosecuted, but not using his own testimony), but doesn’t have to, and it’s not an automatic part of a subpoena. These are two separate things.
Part II: Thompson’s suggestions for reform of vaccine safety oversight
On page 69 to the book, Dr. Thompson explains his suggestion for solving the problems he identifies in CDC’s decision making. He says:
It would end this way. That you would end up with an agency like the National Transportation Safety Board. You know, the FAA; then there’d be NTSB. The FAA is responsible for regulating all sorts of things, but then when an accident happens, you bring in the NTSB. So, you would have the equivalent of an NTSB-like organization that would do vaccine safety studies independently.
Dr. Thompson suggests an institutional solution to the problem he identified. Institutional design is a well-accepted — and heavily studied — part of public administration. But both Dr. Thompson’s problem definition and his proposed solution seem simplistic. Dr. Thompson — and the authors of the book — seem to think the problem is that the CDC has complete control over studying and monitoring vaccine safety, which enables the agency to rig results, and that there is a lack of independence (from industry, presumably?) that motivates it to actually do so. Thompson also seems to think a separate agency will solve the independence problem. Neither part is correct.
Vaccine safety monitoring is done by multiple actors
Even in the United States alone, vaccine safety is handled by more than one body, with a complex interaction both at the federal and state level. To give a simplified and partial picture, the FDA regulates licensing of vaccines, including governing clinical trials, pre and post licensure safety and effectiveness studies, labeling, manufacturing quality, and so forth. A CDC advisory committee recommends vaccines that are then approved by the CDC Director for specific populations. Even there, it’s not the CDC staff, but an advisory committee made of experts and a consumer representative, that makes recommendations which the head of the CDC confirms, and recommendations are also made, on that issue, by the American Academy of Pediatrics and the American Academy of Family Physicians. Federal advisory committee are heavily regulated by the Federal Advisory Committees Act, which among other things imposes requirements of transparency. The Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices debates in public and provides detailed, heavily referenced recommendations that are then published (though often a while after they are made): nothing is hidden. The recommendations draw on studies not only from the United States but from the entire world. And those are recommendations: they do not automatically translate into mandates in any state, though they certainly influence the mandates.
In other words, the CDC is not a classic regulatory agency at all. It certainly has an influence on vaccine usage; but it’s not the CDC that can fine manufacturers for wrongdoing or oversees clinical trials. The CDC has additional roles — vaccine distributor; information provision to the public; a role in programs funding vaccines for certain populations; monitoring vaccine usage; and a responsibility for preventing diseases beyond vaccinating alone, for example, via monitoring cases. None of these make it a regulatory agency in the classic sense, and it has not been treated or studied as one.
A large part of the CDC’s role in vaccine regulation is close to NTSB’s role in air safety — research and investigate and recommend after the fact, though Dr. Thompson is right that it is more involved in actually handling vaccines and their influence than NTSB is. But the CDC is still probably closer to NTSB than FAA in this comparison. FDA is the main regulatory agency.
The CDC has a role in monitoring vaccine safety. Part of that role is doing studies. Another is that the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System is partly managed by the CDC. But the CDC is not alone in handling vaccine safety: the FDA has a part in that, as does the Institute of Medicine, a private body. Vaccine safety studies post-licensure (which are massive) are done through the Vaccine Safety DataLink. And the studies and results are collected and analyzed primarily by academic researchers independent of the CDC. Researchers in other countries also do studies, and other governments also monitor vaccines, with the information coming from multiple directions.
The diffusion of responsibility between several actors prevents each single actor from completely controlling the information on vaccine safety. The fact that many studies are done abroad also limits the ability of the CDC to control the information. Why would creating one specialized agency guarantee more accountability than a variety of actors that can check each other?
Independence and its feasibility
The second concern those promoting the CDC whistleblower story have is that the CDC’s personnel is too involved with industry in some way — a claim certainly made by Mr. Kennedy in his forward (p. xix) and by Mr. Barry himself (p. xxi and 6). It may be that this is part of Dr. Thompson’s concern.
If that’s what is on his mind, Dr. Thompson should ask himself where members of NTSB come from. According to the board’s website there are currently four members of the board. One previously served with the FAA, one has served with both the CDC and the American Automobile Association; the third was a professional pilot for three decades and worked in regulatory affairs in US Airways; and the fourth had a long career with an airplane manufacturer. The last two, in other words, came from industry, and the Chair came from the FAA.
Reality check: in a specialized area, the majority of people involved in regulation and policy would often have served in more than one role and moved between the players. That’s because their expertise will be sought out. Specialized training takes a long time and is then often sought out by different actors. And often experts have to get hands-on experience somewhere, and in a specialized field the options are limited. And you often want the people regulating to have a mixture of theoretical knowledge and hands-on experience in the area.
You do not want people with no background in air safety having the major say in regulating it or investigating accidents, because lack of expertise, however good the intentions, can easily lead to bad results in a technical area that have real safety implications. For exactly the same reason you do not want people who do not understand infectious diseases and the vaccines that prevent them having the main say on regulating or monitoring them, because they will get it wrong, potentially with very, very bad results. Experts can get it wrong too — but hopefully, much less often. Is there a risk of corruption? Of course. That’s why we want multiple actors and divisions of labor, as well as mechanisms of accountability in place. That’s why you want to think about designing incentives. But you will not be able to get rid of interconnections between the players in a specialized field. Not going to happen, not without sacrificing expertise and knowledge, again, with potentially much, much worse consequences.
Thinking that you can create a magically independent agency to regulate vaccine safety and populate it with people that know what they are doing but do not have connections to industry or other government agencies involved with vaccines is simply unrealistic.
Even if there was extensive evidence of corruption and wrongdoing of the CDC — and the book has not provided that — creating another agency is no panacea, and has very real costs, monetary and in terms of the coordination that will need to happen with that agency. Some more sophisticated thought would be needed to truly analyze what, if any, are the problems with CDC and how to solve them.
Part III: School Mandates and Human Rights
On pp. 128-129 (Chapter 11: First Principles and Moral Courage), Barry argues that freedom from vaccination — and in that case explicitly the freedom of a parent to refuse vaccination for her child — is a human right. This is not the first time we have heard that argument — it was made by Ms. Holland in her article in the book Vaccine Epidemic, chapter 1. Here, as there, it’s used as an attack on school mandates, claiming they violate informed consent. The twist added in Vaccine Whistleblower is to base the opposition on what Barry interprets Dr. Thompson to have disclosed. The passage reads:
If a state is going to force its judgment on a citizen or a parent regarding vaccination (a preventative medical intervention), the safety studies supporting those vaccines must be rock solid. According to Dr. Thompson, the studies are anything but rock solid. The quality of vaccine safety studies is insufficient to support mandatory vaccination.
Given what Dr. Thompson has disclosed, parents should not be removed from the decision-making regarding the health of their children. Parents know their own children’s and their own family’s health history better than their pediatricians and their elected representatives. Parents also know their religious beliefs and their personal relationships with God better than pediatricians, their elected representatives, and employees of their school districts.
The initial premise is incorrect in several ways; and the additional claim also doesn’t hold water.
Whose rights?
First, while I would agree that generally an adult of sound mind should not be forced physically to undergo any medical procedure, including vaccination, though there may be consequences to such refusal (such as quarantine or limiting access to some jobs), the protections do not apply in the same way to children — who do not have a choice either way. This discussion is not about bodily autonomy — which is why the comparison to rape made by anti-vaccine activists is not just reprehensible but incorrect. The question here is the extent of parental rights to make medical decisions for their child.
The view that parents have a human right to refuse vaccination for their children is problematic. Parents usually have a right to make medical decisions for their child — but that right is not, and for some time has not been, absolute — and that’s a good thing. Children are no longer property of their parents, to break and use as the parents will. Modern thinking raises three reasons to support the rights of parents to make those decisions (for a more complete discussion, see “The Rights of the Unvaccinated Child: The Legal Framework“).
First and most important, a child is — generally correctly — considered cognitively unable to make those decisions. Someone has to make them for the child, and in most circumstances it’s the parent who stands as the child’s agent, and makes decisions for the child, since usually the parent can be trusted to represent the child’s best interests.
Second, the parent usually has the responsibility to cover costs of treatment and to deal with the child in many ways. With such responsibility should come the power to make decisions that fit the family’s means and abilities.
Third, we respect privacy of the family and its autonomy, and want to minimize government interference in it. Most iterations of the “my child, my choice” argument seem to emphasize the third reason — but that is, clearly, much weaker than the first.
The main reason to give parents rights is because we hope and believe that usually parents will be the best person to protect the child’s interests. The child is an autonomous being, and children have rights. Parental rights are already limited and regulated by the state. Parents cannot starve or abuse the child. Parents cannot, in California, leave a young child unattended in a car. There are already clear limits on parental powers over a child’s welfare. Given the dramatic imbalance between the risks of vaccinating and the risks of not vaccinating, the state has the authority to step in in this area, too.
If anything, the human right at issue here is the child’s right to health, the right to be protected against preventable diseases via the simple, safe precaution of vaccinating. Not the right of the parent to deprive their child from such protection because they subscribe to anti-vaccine misinformation.
Indeed, in Prince v. Massachusetts, the seminal case about the limits of religious rights when it comes to children’s welfare, the Supreme Court, in a statement that wasn’t part of the ruling but has been incredibly influential, based its support of forced vaccination in part on that:
[a parent] cannot claim freedom from compulsory vaccination for the child more than for himself on religious grounds. The right to practice religion freely does not include liberty to expose the community or the child to communicable disease or the latter to ill health or death.
Prince v. Massachusetts, 321 U.S. 158, 166–67 (1944)
And in another case from New York, a court found not vaccinating against measles, during an outbreak, can amount to medical neglect. (In re Christine M., 595 N.Y.S.2d 606, 616 (N.Y. Fam. Ct. 1992)).
To be clear, my view is that as long as dangerous diseases are reasonably under control in the United States, as long as the threat is not immediate, the state usually should not intervene and force vaccinating. But that’s not because the state does not have authority to intervene. It’s because parental rights, for the reasons above, matter, and where we can respect them without irreversible harm to the child, we should. We have other ways to increase immunization rates besides forcing unwilling parents to vaccinate, and as long as rates of non-vaccination are kept low, herd immunity can protect children. We should avoid the most extreme step unless the child is at immediate risk.
But the state can and should use other means to increase rates, to protect all children and others who may be harmed by disease — including, perhaps especially, children whose parents deny them vaccines.
School mandates are not force vaccinating
Furthermore, school mandates are not “force vaccinating”. Yes, it can seem intrusive and hard to parents who find homeschooling very difficult. But there is a difference in the degree of state intervention and the level of coerciveness. Contrary to some of the language we have heard, school immunization mandates do not mean anyone will be coming to the house of parents with a gun and force vaccinating, or throwing parents in jail. It’s just not direct coercion.
Even if we acknowledge parental rights to refuse vaccination in most circumstances, that does not mean they have a corresponding right to send that child to school unvaccinated and risk other students’ health. School immunization mandates are a traditional public health policy in the United States, dating back to the 19th century, and they have been upheld by every court, state or federal, that ruled on them, because even the strongest formulation of parental rights does not give a parent a right to impose the risk of disease they choose for their own child on others or their children. Your child is not the only one at school; low vaccination rates make schools less safe for others; and a parent does not have a right to make that choice for other parents and their children.
School mandates and Dr. Thompson’s claims
As to the claim that Dr. Thompson’s allegation are an argument against mandates — first, it’s not clear that Dr. Thompson’s claims undermine even the 2004 paper, as Dr. Gorski’s review of the book demonstrates. Second, the 2004 paper is not the only one on MMR, and is not actually a “principal” one, in spite of the book’s claims; even for MMR, it’s one of many studies — and a small, localized study, with substantially less power than, for example, the large scale Danish or Finnish studies. Third, even if the alleged connection had power, and if the 2004 paper was the only or principal paper on MMR, it would be relevant, at most, for African American boys who received the MMR between 18-36 months: so if an African American boy was not vaccinated on time, the solution is simple: vaccinate after the age of 36 months, where no correlation was found. It certainly does not support the wholesale exemption of children from immunization mandates, something that would increase the risk of disease in schools.
Contrary to the author’s claims, the transcripts do not negate the science examining if there’s a link between MMR and autism, or vaccines and autism generally. They are not an argument against school immunization mandates — a traditional policy, aimed at making schools safer.

Dr. Edward Livingston On Vaccines & Autism: “Because of Public Skepticism, it is Not Settled Science”
Will new studies cause large numbers of anti-vaxxers to say “Wow. It turns our vaccines don’t cause autism after all. I’ve been wrong the whole time.”?
Jonathan Howard on March 9, 2025
Link
There’s people who disagree that the world is round. People still think Elvis is alive.
Dr. Bill Cassidy, a Republican Senator from Louisiana, has permanently cemented his reputation as a spineless jellyfish who caved to pressure and voted to confirm RFK Jr. Now that it’s too late, he is futilely trying to erase his shameful legacy by making accurate but impotent pro-vaccine statements whenever possible. According to news reports about the confirmation hearing of Dr. Jay Bhattacharya:
In one contentious exchange, Senator Bill Cassidy of Louisiana, the committee’s Republican chairman, lamented that Dr. Bhattacharya had stopped short of saying the question of whether vaccines cause autism had been resolved. “It’s been exhaustively studied,” said Mr. Cassidy, a doctor and fierce supporter of vaccination. “The more we pretend like this is an issue, the more we will have children dying from vaccine-preventable diseases.”
Dr. Bhattacharya responded that more research was needed as long as American parents were concerned enough not to vaccinate their children. “My inclination is to give people good data,” he said.
To that, Mr. Cassidy suggested that there already was good data, and that “precious limited taxpayer dollars” could not be devoted to every last fringe theory.
“There’s people who disagree that the world is round,” he said. “People still think Elvis is alive.”
Though generations of medical students should study Dr. Cassidy as a cautionary tale who betrayed medical ethics and let children suffer in exchange for political power, in this instance he is exactly right.
Science is only settled when everyone is convinced that a hypothesis is proven to be true.
One person who agrees with Dr. Bhattacharya, however, is Dr. Edward Livingston, a former deputy editor of JAMA. I previously discussed how Dr. Livingston wrote a robust defense of Dr. Bhattacharya and the Great Barrington Declaration despite not knowing or even caring about what it said. In his latest defense of Dr. Bhattacharya, Dr. Livingston said:
Interesting that some Senators criticized @DrJBhattacharya for saying he would fund research at the @NIH to show that vaccines do not cause autism. The critics argued that this was ‘settled science.’ Yes, there is compelling evidence against the vaccine-autism relationship. However, a large swath of the public do not believe it. Because of public skepticism, it is not settled science. There is a need for further research intending to convince the public regarding vaccine safety. It is not good enough to say “I am a scientist at a prestigious university, and you should believe what I say because of who I am.” That does not work anymore, especially after the pandemic when science’s reputation took a big hit…
He also added, “science is only settled when everyone is convinced that a hypothesis is proven to be true.”
It’s hard to know where to begin with something like this, but I think it’s important to understand what’s so wrong about calling for more research into the relationship between vaccines and autism.
First, there isn’t just “compelling evidence against the vaccine-autism relationship.” There is overwhelming evidence vaccines don’t cause autism and people have worked hard to curate this material (Vaxopedia, Skeptical Raptor). Conversely, there’s no evidence that vaccines cause autism. We are in this situation only because of a one dishonest doctor. As Skeptical Raptor wrote:
Over the over 20 years since the retracted paper was first published, Mr. Andy Wakefield, fraud extraordinaire, has continued to propagate the myth about vaccines and autism. But in case it is not clear, nothing in Wakefield’s original paper has any credibility, that’s why it was retracted. Moreover, Wakefield has provided no evidence whatsoever to support his claims.
If you want to read all about Wakefield’s despicable deceit (and unethical study design), you can read it here, here, and here, a series of articles written by award-winning journalist Brian Deer and published in the British Medical Journal (now known as BMJ), a respected peer-reviewed publication. Mr. Deer has even written a book detailing his investigation of Wakefield and his fraudulent research called, “The Doctor Who Fooled the World: Science, Deception, and the War on Vaccines.”
Dr. Livingston wants us to keep chasing after the myths started by this fraudulent research.
Second, no one defends vaccines by saying “I am a scientist at a prestigious university, and you should believe what I say because of who I am.” Dr. Livingston made that up to spread doubt and mistrust about scientists. He implies these jerk scientists, who don’t really exist, are to blame for vaccine hesitancy, not blogs like Sensible Medicine, which published glowing tributes to RFK Jr. such as Why Doctors Should Learn to Stop Worrying and Love MAHA.
In reality, vaccine-experts don’t make empty arguments from authority. They share the overwhelming evidence that vaccines don’t cause autism. Dr. Peter Hotez wrote a book titled Vaccines Did Not Cause Rachel’s Autism, for example, and under the direction of Dr. Paul Offit, the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia uses plain language to discuss the flaws in Wakefield’s “studies”, present studies that disprove the vaccines/autism myth, and discuss what the actual causes of autism might be. Dr. Livingston is willing to conjure imaginary jerk scientists out of thin air while simultaneously ignoring the many actual scientists and doctors who do a great job of explaining vaccine-safety to the public, often at great personal cost.
Third, if the the phrase vaccines don’t cause autism is not “settled science” then what is in medicine and who deputized Dr. Livingston to makes these determinations? Dr. Livingston feels that what is and what is not “settled science” should be determined by public opinion, not by evidence, and that as long as a critical mass of people hold a false belief, that means the science itself is “not settled”. Dr. Cassidy was right that there are people who think the world is flat. According to Dr. Livingston, however, haughty astronomers are to blame for this, and the shape of the earth is not “settled science.” It requires “further research”.
Fourth, although almost no topic in medicine has been researched more than vaccines, Dr. Livingston believes further research will “convince the public regarding vaccine safety.” Even though Dr. Livingston rightly recognizes that anti-vaxxers don’t believe the existing data, in his imagination this “further research” will magically succeed in changing minds of anti-vaxxers while countless other studies from around the world have failed. Dr. Livingston claims that more studies will cause large numbers of anti-vaxxers to say “Wow. It turns our vaccines don’t cause autism after all. I’ve been wrong the whole time.” As those of us who have been paying attention to it know, anti-vaccine sentiment isn’t driven by a lack of research, but rather by a lack of trust and conspiracies. Indeed, the one time RFK Jr. shared accurate information about vaccines, he too became part of the conspiracy. He hasn’t encouraged vaccines since then.
Anti-vaxxers are often angry and vocal, but fortunately they are still a small minority. For now, thankfully most parents still vaccinate their children. Yet, Dr. Livingston feels extreme anti-vaccine voices should set the national research agenda. He feels we are beholden to them in some way, and we must address their “skepticism”. For their sake, we need to repeat studies that have already been done many times before, even though they all show the same thing. Other research projects can take a back seat so that we can once again generate evidence to cater to a minority of people, many of whom are not persuadable with evidence.
Obviously, repetitious studies on vaccines and autism will be a waste of time and money that won’t move the needle at all. We don’t have to let anti-vaxxers hijack our research priorities. Given that doctors believe “settled science” should be determined by a popularity contest, perhaps a better use of resources would to to invest in basic scientific literacy and education.
Finally, Dr. Livingston wasn’t entirely wrong to say that “science’s reputation took a big hit” during the pandemic. However, that is because merchants of doubt portrayed dedicated vaccine-scientists as arrogant bullies who refuse to present data to the public. Though he could have praised the scientists who gave us life-saving COVID vaccines in record time, Dr. Livingston instead glorified Fox News celebrities like Dr. Bhattacharya who misled the public throughout the pandemic. Although there are countless examples, Dr. Bhattacharya said that we “basically” had herd immunity in May 2021 and that vaccines were a perfect panacea that had “defanged” pandemic. Rather than admit his errors and retreat into obscurity, Dr. Bhattacharya encouraged mistrust in frontline doctors, blaming them, not the virus, for unpopular mitigation measures. Meanwhile, he earned $12,000 posting on X last year. More recently, Dr. Bhattacharya has begun to stoke distrust about routine vaccines, as Walker Bragman detailed in his article Trump Pick for NIH Director: Vaccines May Cause Autism, Alternative Schedules Okay. Instead of sharing these examples and explaining how they led to mistrust, Dr. Livingston censored them in his homages to Dr. Bhattacharya.
US CDC Plans Study Into Vaccines and Autism, Sources Say
Unfortunately, Dr. Livingston will probably get his wish. According to the article US CDC Plans Study Into Vaccines and Autism, Sources Say:
The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention is planning a large study into potential connections between vaccines and autism, two sources familiar with the matter told Reuters, despite extensive scientific research that has disproven or failed to find evidence of such links. It is unclear whether U.S. Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr, who has long promoted anti-vaccine views, is involved in the planned CDC study or how it would be carried out.
This is a dangerous moment. With mendacious anti-vaxxers like RFK Jr. and Dr. David Weldon in charge, there is little doubt what this “study” will “discover” and what the effects will be. When vaccine-rates fall even further and once-vanquished diseases continue to return, we can point the finger at doctors who called for “further research,” while denigrating scientists and the extensive research they have already done.

   Andrew Wakefield

   The Lancet retracts Andrew Wakefield’s article
Steven Novella
Link
In 1998 Andrew Wakefield and 11 other co-authors published a study with the unremarkable title: Ileal-lymphoid-nodular hyperplasia, non-specific colitis, and pervasive developmental disorder in children. Such a title would hardly grab a science journalist’s attention, but the small study sparked widespread hysteria about a possible connection between the mumps-measles-rubella (MMR) vaccine and autism spectrum disorder (ASD).
The study itself has not stood the test of time. The results could not be replicated by other labs. A decade of subsequent research has sufficiently cleared the MMR vaccine of any connection to ASD. The lab used to search for measles virus in the guts of the study subjects has been shown to have used flawed techniques, resulting in false positives (from the Autism Omnibus testimony, and here is a quick summary). There does not appear to be any association between autism and a GI disorder.
But it’s OK to be wrong in science. There is no expectation that every potential finding will turn out to be true – in fact it is expected that most new finding will eventually be found to be false. That’s the nature of investigating the unknown. No harm no foul.
Andrew Wakefield, however, was apparently guilty of more than just getting it wrong, or even of being a sloppy scientist. He has been the subject of an ethics investigation by the General Medical Council who recently concluded that:
The General Medical Council ruled he had acted “dishonestly and irresponsibly” in doing his research.
David Gorski has the full report on the GMC ruling, which I will not repeat.
What is also at issue, however, is the integrity of the published peer-reviewed medical research. Again – there is not the expectation that peer-reviewed research will always get the answer right. In fact, the published research stands as an important record of error – the blind alleys, red herrings, false correlations, and erroneous conclusions that are part of the history of science.
However, error should not include scientific fraud, or science that is thoroughly misrepresented. One aspect of the transparency demanded by science, and increasingly an issue, is disclosure of potential conflicts of interest. This is the issue that first got Wakefield in hot water with the Lancet – the journal that published his original research. Wakefield was being paid as an expert by lawyers who were suing over alleged vaccine injury. In fact some of the children in the study were the children of parents who were suing. This is a massive conflict of interest.
When this came to light the Lancet responded by contacting the co-authors of the article and essentially asking them if they still stand by the results of the study. Ten of the original 12 authors of the study retracted their support for the study and its interpretation. In 2004 the Lancet published a retraction. However, it was only a partial retraction, and the study remained as part of the published literature.
In the wake of the GMC ruling, however, the Lancet has once again reviewed the study and concluded that there is now sufficient evidence of wrongdoing on Wakefield’s part to print a full retraction. Here is the entire text of the article:
Following the judgment of the UK General Medical Council’s Fitness to Practise Panel on Jan 28, 2010, it has become clear that several elements of the 1998 paper by Wakefield et al are incorrect, contrary to the findings of an earlier investigation. In particular, the claims in the original paper that children were “consecutively referred” and that investigations were “approved” by the local ethics committee have been proven to be false. Therefore we fully retract this paper from the published record.
This should be the final nail in the coffin of this controversial and harmful study. Coming 12 years after the original paper, after just about every element of the research and its findings have been refuted, the Lancet retraction almost seems unecessary. But it is necessary and important. As the retraction indicates – it removes this dubious research from the published record.
While we can all celebrate this move, I also believe it highlights the need for scientific journals to have a lower threshold in retracting published studies that are found to be fraudulent, or are so flawed either ethically or scientifically that they should never have been published in the first place.
The process of editorial and peer-review is not perfect, and given the number of papers that are published there is no way to keep dubious, even fraudulent, research from slipping past the goalies. But peer-review does not stop when a paper is published – in fact that is when it begins in earnest. So it is common for serious problems with a paper to be discovered only after they are published. When this happens, the journal editors should be willing to admit error and correct their mistakes.
An example of the importance of correcting the published record is the Cha/Wirth/Lobo study conducted at Columbia University and published in the Journal of Reproductive Medicine in 2001. The study alleged to find that intercessory Christian prayer doubled the success of in-vitro fertilization. However, Rogerio Lobo, presented as the lead author, later acknowledged that he had nothing to do with the conduction of the study. His name was removed from the authors list in 2004.
But much worse than that, Daniel Wirth, who is not an MD and is not affiliated with Columbia University and who seems to be most responsible for the study results, was indicted by a federal grand jury and pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit fraud. (See this excellent article by Bruce Flamm for all the details.) Essentially this study was conducted by a paranormal researcher with the resume of a con-artist.
And yet, the Journal of Reproductive Medicine has refused to admit error and retract the paper. It remains listed on PubMed, without any hint that the study has been seriously called into question.
They have published a clarification by the third author, Kwang Cha, who is digging in and defending the paper, writing:
This deliberate design constraint made it impossible for Mr. Wirth to have played any role in manipulating or altering the data.
I find it very difficult to believe that manipulation was “impossible.” I think Dr. Cha overestimates the ability to protect against deliberate fraud, and underestimates the cleverness of those who choose to commit fraud. Cha would have us believe that it is more likely he proved the efficacy of a miraculous intervention than that someone guilty of fraud may have committed fraud.
While this study has been scientifically discredited, it remains part of the published record and continues to be cited by supporters of the efficacy of prayer.
Conclusion
I applaud the Lancet for finally retracting the Wakefield study and removing it from the published record. It should not, however, have taken this long.

   The fall of Andrew Wakefield
David Gorski
Link
I must admit, I never saw it coming.
At least, I never saw it coming this fast and this dramatically. After all, this is a saga that has been going on for twelve solid years now, and it’s an investigation that has been going on at least since 2004. Yes, I’m referring to that (possibly former) hero of the anti-vaccine movement, the man who is arguably the most responsible for suffering and death due to the resurgence of measles in the U.K. because of his role in frightening parents about the MMR vaccine.
I’m referring to the fall of Andrew Wakefield
Wakefield has shown an incredible ability to avoid the consequences of his actions, so much so that, as recently as the end of 2009, what has happened to him over the last month or so would have been almost unthinkable to me. No, I’m not referring to Wakefield’s having been found guilty by Britain’s General Medical Council of grossly unethical behavior with respect to his conduct while carrying out the “research” (and I use the term loosely) that resulted in his trial-lawyer funded, incompetent, and quite likely scientifically fraudulent 1998 Lancet paper. It was the study that launched the most recent (an possibly most virulent) iteration of the anti-vaccine movement, led to dramatically decreased MMR vaccination rates in the U.K., and launched a thousand quacks in the form of the “autism biomed” movement, which has in essence made autistic children the victims of unregulated and sometimes dangerous experimentation all in the name of trying to “cure” them of their autism. The price autistic children have paid for Wakefield’s pseudoscience is horrific enough, but the potential price that thousands of children, both autistic and neurotypical, are paying and will likely continue to pay in terms of suffering from vaccine-preventable diseases, will probably be even worse.
As I’ve pointed out before, I was quite happy when the British GMC told it like it is, so to speak, and found Wakefield guilty of research misconduct and in no uncertain terms called him “irresponsible and dishonest.” I was not surprised that the GMC had ruled against Wakefield; I was, however, surprised at the vehemence of the ruling and that it took three years after revelations by investigative journalist Brian Deer for the GMC to convene proceedings against Wakefield. Ironically, it was after those revelations, described in a Sunday Times investigative report and a TV news documentary on the U.K.’s Channel 4 entitled MMR: What They Didn’t Tell You, that Andrew Wakefield himself demanded the GMC investigation to “clear his name.” On February 23, 2004, the day after Brian Deer’s article Revealed: MMR research scandal that Andrew Wakefield himself was quoted as saying:
Serious allegations have been made against me in relation to the provision of clinical care for children with autism and bowel disease, and the reporting of their disease. It has been proposed that my role in this matter should be investigated by the GMC. I not only welcome this, I insist on it and I will be making contact with the GMC personally.
Be careful what you ask for, I always say.
As I pointed out, the verdict of the GMC alone was not enough to bring about Andrew Wakefield’s fall. Indeed, I’d consider it, to use baseball parlance, strike one. Or, to mix metaphors as I am wont to do at times just for the heck of it, it could be viewed as the first piece of rock or ice to start falling from a mountainside, triggering more rocks to fall and ultimately leading to an avalanche that buried Wakefield. The second strike (or second rock, to continue my habit of mixing metaphors) occurred less than a week later, when the editors of The Lancet finally did the right thing. True, it took them six years after revelations of Wakefield’s conflicts of interest in the form of payments from trial lawyers and his having applied for a patent on a vaccine to compete with the MMR plus his research misconduct in the form of having performed medically unnecessary invasive procedures such as lumbar punctures and colonoscopies on autistic children were first brought to light by investigative journalist Brian Deer, but at least they finally did the right thing. They retracted Wakefield’s 1998 Lancet article from the scientific literature. That doesn’t even cover the revelations from nearly exactly a year ago, once again revealed by Brian Deer, that Wakefield was not only in the pocket of trial lawyers who wanted to sue vaccine manufacturers to the tune of £435,643 in fees, plus £3,910 expenses but he may well have committed scientific fraud in how he carried out his Lancet study.
From my perspective, the editors should have retracted Wakefield’s study back in 2004, when ten of the original thirteen authors retracted their support for the article and its interpretation. At the time, Andrew Wakefield and Peter Harvey refused to to retract. If the the editors had had any guts back then, they would have retracted the paper then and there. It would have been the right thing to do. After all, the editors all but admitted that Wakefield had violated The Lancet‘s rules on disclosure of conflicts of interest. Come to think of it, if Andrew Wakefield and Peter Harvey had had one iota of honor, they would have retracted the paper themselves, as honorable scientists do when serious flaws are brought to light. Not surprisingly, Wakefield did no such thing, because he is not an honorable man. Moreover, it should be noted that the involuntary retraction of a scientific paper by the editors of a journal is a very rare thing, particularly by a journal as high profile as The Lancet.
Wakefield’s dishonesty and lack of honor aside, up to this point, up to the two strikes against Wakefield, his supporters continued to rally around him. Two months earlier, the anti-vaccine National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC) had invited Wakefield to be its keynote speaker at its annual pseudoscientific conference, even going so far as to award him its Humanitarian Award. Then, in the weeks leading up to the expected GMC verdict at the end of January, the anti-vaccine propaganda blog Age of Autism ramped up its praise of Andrew Wakefield, even likening him to Galileo and the GMC to the Inquisition. As they say, to claim the mantle of Galileo, it isn’t enough to be “persecuted” for your views. You have to be right. Andrew Wakefield was anything but right. AoA also published a whole series of posts by John Stone and Martin Walker trying to discredit the GMC in advance of the expected ruling, along with pure idiocy published by Mark Blaxill. There was even a defense of “that paper” by Andrew Wakefield himself, plus a new “study” published in a new autism vanity journal claiming to have replicated Wakefield’s findings. Clearly, the crew at AoA was pulling out all the stops.
As I pointed out three weeks ago, the anti-vaccine movement continued to circle the wagons after the GMC ruling, but the defenses of Andrew Wakefield and attacks on his critics continued even after the Lancet retraction. The most bizarre of these came, courtesy of–who else?–Generation Rescue. In rapid succession, GR’s spokescelebrities Jenny McCarthy and Jim Carrey released a statement, soon followed by the founder of GR, J.B. Handley. The message? Well, here’s what Jenny and Jim said in a statement entitled, appropriately enough A Statement from Jenny McCarthy & Jim Carrey: Andrew Wakefield, Scientific Censorship, and Fourteen Monkeys (mirrored on the Generation Rescue website):
Dr. Andrew Wakefield is being discredited to prevent an historic study from being published that for the first time looks at vaccinated versus unvaccinated primates and compares health outcomes, with potentially devastating consequences for vaccine makers and public health officials.
It is our most sincere belief that Dr. Wakefield and parents of children with autism around the world are being subjected to a remarkable media campaign engineered by vaccine manufacturers reporting on the retraction of a paper published in The Lancet in 1998 by Dr. Wakefield and his colleagues.
But what was the study that the nefarious Vaccine Illuminati were going so far to squelch? Take a guess:
Behind the scenes, the pressure to keep the work of Dr. Wakefield and his colleagues from being published is immense, and growing every day. Medical journals take extreme risk of backlash in publishing any studies that question the safety of the vaccination program, no matter how well-designed and thorough the research might be. Neurotoxicology, a highly-respected medical journal, deserves great credit for courageously publishing the first phase of this vaccinated monkey study.
Yes, it’s the execrable unethical waste of primates to the cause of pseudoscience that I’ve blogged about twice before under the titles Monkey Business in Autism Research and Monkey Business in Autism Research, Part II. The excellent skeptical blogger Prometheus also deconstructed the study in A “Made for Court” Study? Read those posts if you want the gory details. Suffice it to say, that once again Wakefield was pushing bad, bad science, and, unfortunately, had managed to fool the hapless and apparently naive reviewers and editors at NeuroToxicology to publish the first part of his study. J.B. Handley added to this conspiracy theory vibe, apparently while trying to channel Cuba Gooding, Jr. and Tom Cruise in Jerry McGuire by repeating “Show me the monkeys!” eleven times in the course of his post. Even David Kirby launched his own bit of dissembling nonsense on that repository of all things quackery, The Huffington Post, in a post entitled The Lancet retraction changes nothing.
I thought so, too, David, at least in terms of the lionization of Andrew Wakefield by the anti-vaccine movement, but it turns out I may be wrong, as we shall see, but it took one more thing to change everything. But what was that one more thing, that strike three, that beginning of the real avalanche that buried poor Andy?
It happened one day after J.B. Handley’s “show me the monkeys” cry (or, at least, it was noticed one day later), making me think that Handley knew something was coming. That something arrived when NeuroToxicology withdrew Wakefield’s previously accepted “monkey business” paper. Not surprisingly, the lunatic fringe of the anti-vaccine movement viewed this as still more evidence that there was some sort of conspiracy theory against Wakefield. Topping off the conspiracy-fest, Ginger Taylor drew an elaborate chart of the nefarious forces in a post she called Anatomy of a witch hunt, leading a certain friend of this blog to ask, “But what about the Illuminati and David Icke’s reptilians?” While rational people could but shake their heads in disbelief, believers reacted to the charge of conspiracy theory correctly leveled against them by lamely claiming that the American Revolution started out as a conspiracy.
Meanwhile, the reaction of AoA was, surprisingly, much more subdued and delayed. So, surprisingly, was the reaction of the very same organizations that had so defended Wakefield, such as SafeMinds. Editorials defending Wakefield still showed up on AoA, and Mark Blaxill even managed to get a pro-Wakefield editorial published in USA TODAY, but they didn’t mention the withdrawal of Wakefield’s NeuroToxicology study. This presaged something I never would have expected. On Wednesday evening, a message appeared on the Yahoo! Thoughtful House Group:
Dr. Wakefield has resigned from Thoughtful House
The needs of the children we serve must always come first. All of us at Thoughtful House are grateful to Dr. Wakefield for the valuable work he has done here. We fully support his decision to leave Thoughtful House in order to make sure that the controversy surrounding the recent findings of the General Medical Council does not interfere with the important work that our dedicated team of clinicians and researchers is doing on behalf of children with autism and their families. All of us at Thoughtful House continue to fight every day for the recovery of children with developmental disorders. We will continue to do our very best to accomplish our mission by combining the most up-to-date treatments and important clinical research that will help to shape the understanding of these conditions that are affecting an ever-increasing number of children worldwide.
Jane
Jane, in case you weren’t aware, is Jane Johnson. Yes, that Jane Johnson, as comment from Liz Ditz pointed out and provided some relevent background, first from 2008:
In 2007 alone, Thoughtful House saw 1,500 new patient requests — or about 60 percent of the center’s current total patient load — and almost a 50 percent increase in new patient requests in the last six months, says Anissa Ryland, director of operations. Thoughtful House’s funding, which comes largely from foundations and private donors, has also been rising steadily in the last two years. From 2005 to the end of 2007, the nonprofit saw a 48 percent increase in private donations and an 84 percent increase in donations from foundations and trusts, Ryland says. In the past two years, the nonprofit raked in $5.5 million in donations.
And then from Kristina Chew:
A number of celebrities and “prominent central Texans” are supporters of Thoughtful House. Former Dell Inc. executive Charlie Ball and his wife, Troylyn, are among the founders of Thoughtful House; their son has “struggled with physical and developmental problems.” The co-managing director of Thoughtful House’s board is Jane Johnson of New York, part of the family of the Johnson & Johnson health care products and services company. Johnson (who co-authored Jepson’s book, Changing the Course of Autism) and her husband, Chris, donated $1 million to lay the groundwork for Thoughtful House in 2004:
Naturally, I can’t resist suggesting that, given that a heiress of the Johnson family of the Johnson & Johnson pharmaceutical and health products company is a founding donor of Thoughtful House when it was established in 2004 and sits on its board of directors, that, by Jake Crosby’s logic on Age of Autism, Wakefield has clearly been a minion of big pharma at least since 2004. Given how often AoA fequently calls Dr. Paul Offit “Dr. PrOffit” and Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. calls him a “biostitute,” perhaps the science-based community should start calling Andrew Wakefield the same thing.
Now here was a bombshell. At first, I wasn’t even sure whether to believe it was true. After all, since its founding in 2004, Andrew Wakefield has been the face of Thoughtful House, and it was his fame that attracted patients. Few people have heard of Drs. Arthur Krigsman or Bryan Jepson, but everybody knows Wakefield, at least in the autism “biomed” circles. My guess at the time was that Wakefield’s notoriety due to the recent one-two punch of his having had an unfavorable ruling by the GMC followed by the retraction of his 1998 Lancet paper might have become a problem for Thoughtful House in that it might have brought unwanted attention from the Texas Medical Board and other local authorities. Add to that the retraction of the very last shred of Wakefield’s apparent (to anyone beside those who pay attention to his story) scientific credibility, his monkey study, and it’s possible that saner heads wanted Wakefield gone. It turns out that it was true. Wakefield was toast. On February 18, the day after the cryptic announcement appeared, Andrew Wakefield’s name disappeared from the list of Thoughtful House staff, as did his defense of his Lancet article published after the GMC ruling. On Friday, the news was confirmed by mainstream news sources. Then yesterday, Brian Deer reported:
Five days later [after the GMC ruling], the Lancet retracted Wakefield’s research. “It was utterly clear, without any ambiguity at all, that the statements in the paper were utterly false,” Dr Richard Horton, the journal’s editor, told The Guardian. “I feel I was deceived.”
The following day, Dr Joan Marie Cranmer, editor of the specialist journal Neurotoxicology, told her New York publisher that she would withdraw a new Wakefield paper, already released online, which also claimed to incriminate vaccines.
It’s understood that Cranmer “took another look at the paper” in the light of a GMC finding of research dishonesty, but a spokesman for the publisher, Elsevier, declined to comment. “It would be inappropriate to go into a lot of detail,” he said.
The Neurotoxicology decision is believed to have been the last straw at Thoughtful House, a centre founded in 2005 by the rich parents of developmentally-challenged children. The clinic was set up to enable Wakefield to continue activities which in October 2001 saw him fired from a London research position, and which eventually led to the GMC charges.
Within two days of Wakefield’s resignation, it was announced that Dr. Krigsman was also leaving Thoughtful House:
Re: Dr. Krigsman
Dr. Krigsman’s decision to relocate his clinical practice to a facility outside Thought House reflects his belief that the complexities inherent in a referral-based practice can be best addressed by his working independently. We will continue to refer patients for GI evaluations when appropriate, and we look forward to continuing to work with Dr. Krigsman on research projects. We are grateful to Dr. Krigsman for his dedication to Thoughtful House and for the work he does on behalf of the children we serve.
Just to be clear, this is official.
Jane
It looks as though a purge was under way at Thoughtful House, most likely instigated by Jane Johnson. Adding to the impression that Wakefield’s departure from Thoughtful House was not voluntary is this:
In further brief comment on the departure, Jane Johnson, a Thoughtful House board member and also executive director of the US Defeat Autism Now organisation of alternative practitioners, said that those who knew Wakefield “will not find it implausible” that he quit for the good of the centre.
Observers say that the doctor may now be the victim of a domino effect, which threatens to see him lose his fellowship of the UK’s Royal College of Pathologists, which he obtained in 2001 on the basis of a submission of his publications, and even potentially spark the collapse of a new celebrity-led American anti-vaccine movement.
So, in a period of time encompassing January 28, which is when the GMC decision was first announced, to February 17, which is when Wakefield was apparently forced to resign from his position at Thoughtful House, all the accumulated pseudoscience, dishonesty, conflicts of interest, and incompetent research finally caught up with Andrew Wakefield and reduced Thoughtful House from three practitioners of autism woo to just one. It was a breathtaking fall to those of us who have been following the case for years. So slimy and slick has Wakefield been that I had honestly thought that he could weather even the GMC ruling plus the Lancet and NeuroToxicology retractions. I was wrong. It was three strikes that sent Andy back to the dugout.
So what now?
Clearly, the retractions of Wakefield’s 1998 Lancet and his 2009 NeuroToxicology papers were the last nails in the coffin of whatever zombie of Wakefield’s scientific respectability remained to shamble about and eat the brains of hapless and unsuspecting journal editors. Those two developments guarantee that for the foreseeable future Wakefield will almost certainly not be able to fool a respectable journal into accepting one of his manuscripts again. He will thus be relegated to publishing in crank journals like JPANDS and Medical Veritas. The stream of seemingly respectable “research” would thus dry up and further compromise Thoughtful House’s ability to raise cash and attract patients not belonging to the anti-vaccine fringe–which is almost certainly why Wakefield had to go. In light of this development, I see a clinic in central America or someplace with similarly lax regulation of medical clinics in Wakefield’s future. Or maybe someplace as close as Tijuana. He could even still live in the U.S. and commute across the border.
Or maybe not. Autism pseudoscientists and quacks are nothing if not, as James Randi would put it, unsinkable rubber ducks. Wakefield is down, but I wouldn’t count him out–unfortunately. After several days of utter silence, Age of Autism’s very own Dan Olmsted published an interview with Wakefield in which Wakefield states that he will “move on to a new phase of leadership in the autism community” after leaving Thoughful House and going on the offensive to answer the GMC’s ruling. Never mind that it had been nearly four days after his resignation and two days since the mainstream press had started reporting on his departure. In that context, Wakefield’s announcement comes as anticlimactic at best.
The only question that I have remaining is this: Who would want Andy now? My top two guesses would be a position with either Generation Rescue or SafeMinds, the two premier organizations promoting autism pseudoscience these days. I fear we won’t have too long to wait for the answer promised us in his Age of Autism press release.

   The General Medical Council to Andrew Wakefield: “The panel is satisfied that your conduct was irresponsible and dishonest”
David Gorski
Link
BACKGROUND
In my not-so-humble opinion, the very kindest thing that can be said about Andrew Wakefield is that he is utterly incompetent as a scientist. After all, it’s been proven time and time again that his unethical and scientifically incompetent “study” that was published in The Lancet in 1999 claiming to find a correlation between vaccination with MMR and autistic regression in autistic children with bowel symptoms was at best dubious science and at worst fraudulent. For one thing, as investigative journalist Brian Deer found, Wakefield was in the pocket of trial lawyers, who were interested in suing vaccine manufacturers, to the tune of £435,643 in fees, plus £3,910 expenses beginning even before his infamous “study” started accruing patients. Even though the study itself used the typical careful and relatively neutral language that we all expect from scientists, Wakefield himself was not nearly so circumspect. In a press conference announcing the Lancet study, he said:
He told journalists it was a “moral issue” and he could no longer support the continued use of the three-in-one jab for measles, mumps and rubella.
“Urgent further research is needed to determine whether MMR may give rise to this complication in a small number of people,” Dr Wakefield said at the time.
And so began one of the most contentious health stories of this generation.
Wakefield’s Lancet paper, even interpreted as sympathetically as possible, concluded nothing that justified such language. Yet his rhetoric, along with sensationalistic and credulous British journalists, ignited a firestorm of fear over the MMR that has not yet subsided now, over a decade later. Vaccination rates plummeted in the UK, and measles, a disease once thought to be under control, has surged back and become endemic again. It is a feat that Jenny McCarthy and Jim Carrey appear to be trying to replicate right here in the U.S. with their wonderfully Orwellian-named Green Our Vaccines activism and ceaseless promotion of anti-vaccine messages.
More recently, at the Autism Omnibus hearings, we learned from a world expert in the polymerase chain reaction, Dr Stephen Bustin, that the techniques used in the laboratory running PCR on the clinical specimens from Wakefield’s clinical trial were so shoddy, so devoid of routine controls necessary in any PCR experiment, that the measles sequences reported as amplified in Wakefield’s followup to his Lancet study were false positives derived from plasmids with measles sequences in them contaminating the laboratory. Then, in late 2008, Mady Hornig and colleagues at Columbia University published an attempted replication of Wakefield’s study. They failed. There was no association between vaccination with MMR and autistic regression, nor could Hornig find any evidence that measles in the gut was any more common in the autistic children studied than in the neurotypical controls. This study was particularly devastating to Wakefield because it was carried out by a researcher who had previously been sympathetic to the myth that vaccines cause autism, as evidenced by her infamous “rain mouse” study and, even more close to home, using the same laboratory that had performed Wakefield’s PCR, which had apparently cleaned up its act in the years following its work on Wakefield’s specimens.
When it comes to the science, there is no doubt. No reputable scientist has been able to replicate Wakefield’s findings, and there is a remarkable convergence and agreement of findings of major studies looking for a correlation between MMR vaccination and autism: There ain’t one. Indeed, closing out 2009 was the publication of yet another study that failed to find any correlation between MMR and autism, or, as I put it at the time, yet another nail in the coffin of the myth that the MMR vaccine causes autism. Andrew Wakefield’s repeated claims that the MMR can cause or “trigger” autism in some children is deader than dead as a scientific hypothesis and without a basis in scientific or clinical evidence. True, Wakefield tried to counter with a horribly unethical and badly designed primate study that seemed custom-designed to be used in court rather than in the court of scientific inquiry. It didn’t help and only made Wakefield’s Thoughtful House, Wakefield’s Fortress of Solitude in Texas to which he retreated in the wake of the revelations about his conduct, look even worse. Even a credulously “balanced” TV story by NBC news and Matt Lauer couldn’t hide the dubiousness nature of what goes on there.
Of course, while the science refuting Wakefield’s pseudoscience and evidence showing Wakefield to be incompetent and unethical continued to roll in, a little less than a year ago, it got even worse for him. Brian Deer reported that Wakefield very well may have engaged in scientific fraud in the “research” (and I do use the term loosely) that led to the publication of his Lancet paper in 1999. Through it all, the General Medical Council began an inquiry into whether Andrew Wakefield behaved unethically in the “research” that resulted in his 1999 Lancet report. It should be pointed out that the investigation of the GMC began before Deer’s latest revelation of potential fraud; rather it was far more concerned with how Wakefield ran his study and recruited patients. Nonetheless, the revelations nearly a year ago about Wakefield’s playing fast and loose with research methodology could not help but contribute to the sense that the Good Ship Wakefield had been torpedoed below the water line and was taking on water fast.
As the investigation and hearings wound on seemingly endlessly for two and a half years, Wakefield’s supporters intermittently waged an increasingly histrionic and ridiculous propaganda offensive to try to preemptively discredit the GMC’s findings. As it became clear that finally after all this time the GMC was on the verge of announcing its ruling, I noticed that the anti-vaccine crank blog Age of Autism was ramping up an increasingly bizarre and unhinged last minute propaganda campaign, complete with reposting a hilariously inapt post by Mark Blaxill comparing Wakefield to Galileo and the GMC to the Inquisition, complete with references to Stalin and Mao (I suppose I should be relieved that Blaxill refrained from playing the Hitler card); a defense of “that paper” by Wakefield himself; claims that parent witnesses had been “silenced” at the GMC hearings; and a whole series of posts by John Stone trying to discredit the GMC.
And then on Thursday, the GMC ruled.
ANDREW WAKEFIELD: “IRRESPONSIBLE” AND “DISHONEST”
The general findings in the GMC’s ruling should have come as no surprise at all to anyone who had been following Wakefield’s activities, as I have been for the last five years, although I must admit I was pleasantly surprised by the lack of weasel words in it. On Thursday, the BBC reported:
Dr Andrew Wakefield’s 1998 Lancet study caused vaccination rates to plummet, resulting in a rise in measles — but the findings were later discredited.
The General Medical Council ruled he had acted “dishonestly and irresponsibly” in doing his research.
No kidding. Here is a sentence from the actual GMC report:
In reaching its decision, the Panel notes that the project reported in the Lancet paper was established with the purpose to investigate a postulated new syndrome and yet the Lancet paper did not describe this fact at all. Because you drafted and wrote the final version of the paper, and omitted correct information about the purpose of the study or the patient population, the Panel is satisfied that your conduct was irresponsible and dishonest.
The Panel is satisfied that your conduct at paragraph 32.a would be considered by ordinary standards of reasonable and honest people to be dishonest.
That’s about as plain a statement of Wakefield’s mendacity as I can imagine. In fact, I’m very surprised that the GMC report was so blunt. But wait, there’s more, as described in this BBC news report:
The verdict, read out by panel chairman Dr Surendra Kumar, criticised Dr Wakefield for the invasive tests, such as spinal taps, that were carried out on children and which were found to be against their best clinical interests.
The panel said Dr Wakefield, who was working at London’s Royal Free Hospital as a gastroenterologist at the time, did not have the ethical approval or relevant qualifications for such tests.
The GMC also took exception with the way he gathered blood samples. Dr Wakefield paid children £5 for the samples at his son’s birthday party. Dr Kumar said he had acted with “callous disregard for the distress and pain the children might suffer.”
He also said Dr Wakefield should have disclosed the fact that he had been paid to advise solicitors acting for parents who believed their children had been harmed by the MMR.
Two of Dr Wakefield’s former colleagues at the Royal Free were also ruled to have broken guidelines.
Professor John Walker-Smith and Professor Simon Murch both helped Dr Wakefield carry out the research.
The complete 143 page report can be read here. It is truly a damning document. While it cleared Wakefield of some charges, it found that Wakefield was in breach of managing public finances, that the funds he controlled were not used for their intended uses, and that, most shocking of all, he performed procedures on a child for research purposes without the approval of his Ethics Committee. Having found that some of the most damning allegations made against Wakefield are true, the GMC will now deliberate over what sanctions will be indicated. These can range from a rebuke to the stripping of Wakefield’s medical license from him (or, as the British put it, his being “struck off”). Of course, given that Wakefield has moved to Austin, Texas, there to form Thoughtful House, an institution dedicated to the practice of what many, including myself, consider to be autism quackery based on anti-vaccine beliefs, even if the GMC does ultimately strip Wakefield of his medical license very likely it would have little or no significant effect on his practice. After all, Wakefield does not treat children himself. He can’t. He does not have a Texas medical license. Wakefield’s partner Dr Arthur Krigsman is the one doing colonoscopies on autistic children for what appear to be questionable indications, as was portrayed in the aforementioned NBC special with Matt Lauer, and his other partner Dr Bryan Jepson treats them with DAN! protocols.
Indeed, well do I remember one part of the Lauer special in particular. Specifically, it was the part where Lauer asked for Wakefield’s anecdotal experience about whether these children “get better.” Wakefield, of course, responded in the affirmative. (Never mind that what Lauer should have asked Wakefield is whether he has data from randomized controlled clinical trials to support his belief that autistic children “get better” at Thoughtful House. He doesn’t.) Moreover, pretty much every child undergoing endoscopy at Thoughtful House (85%, according to Dr Krigsman) ends up with a diagnosis of “autistic enterocolitis,” which is, as far as science can tell, almost certainly a nonexistent syndrome given that autistic children do not appear to exhibit bowel complaints at a higher frequency than neurotypical children. In the case of Tom Kasemodal, the autistic child whose endoscopy was featured in the NBC report, Dr Krigsman was hard-pressed to find grossly visible abnormalities during the procedure. (“Mild or softer findings,” he said about Tom.) Of course, on pathology, Thoughtful House pathologists apparently found “mild inflammation.” And what did Krigsman prescribe? Lots of supplements, daily laxatives, and periodic colon cleansing. Can you imagine subjecting an autistic child to laxatives and colon cleanses? How do you get a severely autistic child to cooperate for a “colon cleanse”? I have no idea, and I don’t want to think about it.
If the NBC report with Matt Lauer is any indication, apparently such is the “medicine” practiced at Thoughful House, and I must emphasize that the GMC ruling will almost certainly do absolutely nothing to stop it. As when he was at the Royal Free Hospital in North London, Wakefield bills himself as a “researcher” and does not practice clinical medicine, at least not on the surface of it, although the NBC special sure made it look to me as though he participates as a consultant in the care of the autistic children brought to Thoughtful House. If the GMC were to “strike off” Wakefield from the rolls of licensed physicians, it would at least be a further moral victory in addition to the ruling itself, but Thoughtful House would still exist and, under Wakefield’s leadership, still be subjecting autistic children to the sorts of therapies shown on the NBC report and who knows what else.
ANDREW WAKEFIELD, “BRAVE MAVERICK DOCTORS,” AND A CULT OF PERSONALITY
In the decade since his Lancet paper began the movement that led to the resurgence of measles in the U.K., Andrew Wakefield has become a hero to the movement dedicated to the discredited idea that vaccines cause autism. He is the prototypical “brave maverick doctor” and don’t need no steeenkin’ science to know that he’s “recovering” autistic children. Evidence of this is everywhere; so I’ll pick and choose. Perhaps the most obvious manifestation of the Wakefield cult of personality is the nausea-inducing website We Support Dr Andrew Wakefield. I first became aware of this website last year after Brian Deer’s revelations regarding the likely scientific fraud committed by Andrew Wakefield came to light. Consistent with its defense of Wakefield then, on the day that the GMC’s findings were announced, the website declared it a “sad day for the future of our children” and further declared:
The General Medical Council’s (GMC) verdict today concerning Dr Andrew Wakefield brings together autism organizations across the United States who stand united in support of him, unequivocally renounce the GMC’s findings, and demand an investigation into possible conflicts of interests at the GMC. We further challenge the U.K. and U.S. governments to offer grants for gold standard research into why so many children with autism have gastrointestinal pathology, as well as any links between this pathology and the symptoms of autism, before all of the children of the world are affected.
Today’s verdict by the General Medical Council epitomized their negligence in respecting all of the sound scientific studies worldwide replicating the findings of Dr Andrew Wakefield. In the United States we will continue to fund studies replicating Wakefield’s work. We will focus more heavily on helping to educate the British public about the dangers of the MMR. We will look with renewed vigor into possible misconduct by the GMC. And, most importantly, we will continue to recover children from autism thanks, in large measure, to Dr Wakefield’s pioneering work. We have witnessed and applaud the sustained courage and dignity of Dr Andrew Wakefield. He has stood by the children, and we will stand by him.
This statement is signed by AutismOne (which I’ve discussed before), the Autism Research Institute, Generation Rescue (big surprise there, given that GR has already declared its support for Andrew Wakefield in no uncertain terms and, in the lead up to the GMC’s findings, tried its best to demonize GMC and cast doubt on the legitimacy of the entire proceeding), SafeMinds, Schafer Autism Report, Talk About Curing Autism (TACA), Unlocking Autism. In other words, organizations supporting the scientifically discredited vaccine-autism link are all lining up to support this statement. Notice how the statement alleges conflicts of interest and misconduct on the part of the GMC without any actual evidence of such COIs. Also notice how it declares that other researchers have “replicated” the findings of Andrew Wakefield. Of course, that is true if you count the dubious and researchers associated with Wakefield himself, but no reputable researchers have been able to replicate his findings. Most recently, as I pointed out above, a sympathetic researcher named Mady Hornig, who had previously published research seemingly supporting a link between thimerosal and autism, failed to replicate Wakefield’s results. Finally, notice how, despite numerous studies supporting the safety of the MMR and its lack of association with autism or bowel complaints in autism, these organizations continue to cling to the belief that the MMR is “dangerous” and vow to “educate” the public about the “dangers” of the MMR vaccine.
Consistent with previous reactions to criticisms of the anti-vaccine movement or one if its leaders, some of these organizations are also going on the attack, painting themselves as the underdog being persecuted for speaking truth to power. For instance, here’s what the TACA wrote:
The most frightening aspect of these GMC findings is the silencing effect it could cause to scientist and researchers. These verdicts now prove that researchers who stumble upon science that is controversial have to worry about losing their licenses and careers.
Consistent with the persecution complex that the anti-vaccine movement has, yesterday AoA contributor Martin Walker tried with some truly Bulwer-Lytton-worthy writing and incredibly heated rhetoric to show just how much reason has checked out among Wakefield’s defenders:
As the recitation of the crimes of Dr Wakefield came to an end, it appeared as if Dr Wakefield, had in the mid nineties, been some kind of inhuman Nazi experimenter practicing on children in the heart of England; an overlooked human vivisector who stalked a large North London hospital committing serious crimes with the two other criminals in his firm, invisible to his colleagues and unseen by the hospital administration.
It’s actually funny that Walker would mention Nazis. It was Nazi experimentation, among other things, that led to the Helsinki Declaration, the Belmont Report and the Common Rule in the US, and all the other protections for human subjects involved in clinical research. These rules are quite strict, although some would argue whether they’re even strict enough. They prevent atrocities like the Tuskegee syphilis experiment. They are the same rules that Wakefield flouted.
Undeterred by reality, Walker then likens the ruling to a knight’s jousting (and you don’t have to guess who’s the Black Knight):
Today I know will be one of those times that signify a dark night of the soul, for defendants, parents and campaigners alike. This afternoon the defendants will be knocked from their horses by rib smashing lance blows, on the ground they will lie dazed and have to figure whether it is right or even possible to remount and continue the battle. Parents will contemplate the bleak landscape of their children’s illness without any treatment and with open skepticism from medical practitioners from whom they seek help. Activists and campaigners like myself will have to face the melancholic prospect of either continuing the campaign or slipping away to support apparently more equitable battles.
This particular battle is a post-modern struggle, one in which the most powerful forces, multinational companies, reshape the world hand in hand with governments. This is a struggle from which parents and citizens have been expunged. A blind struggle, in an age where all the ties between governments and citizens have been severed, where it is no longer possible for citizens to have any real effect on either the processes of industrial science or of national politics.
It’s a post-modern struggle alright, just not in the way that Walker means.
Perhaps the most over-the-top conspiracy-packed “defense” of Andrew Wakefield comes from Mark Blaxill, published on the anti-vaccine crank blog Age of Autism and entitled Naked Intimidation: The Wakefield Inquisition is Only the Tip of the Autism Censorship Iceberg. All the hallmarks of a persecution complex and crankery are there.
Claims that the GMC finding was designed to “intimidate” those “brave maverick scientists”? Check:
The GMC proceeding is a frightening and thoroughly modern form of tyranny. It makes you shudder to think what Stalin or McCarthy might have accomplished if their public relations had been more skillful and better organized.
The extremity of the GMC’s verdict — all three men guilty on all counts — lays bare any pretense that the British medical establishment cares one whit about the welfare of its patients. Let’s put in perspective the actions at issue here. No children were harmed and no parent or guardian has complained about the care these three men provided. In fact, the procedures involved were routine, the resulting treatments standard and the careful attention to gastrointestinal illness in autistic children has recently been endorsed by a consensus statement published in the journal Pediatrics (no friend of the autism community). Considered in this light, the GMC hearing process stands exposed for what it is. It was not about medical standards. It was not about evidence. It was not even civilized. It was, rather, a naked exercise in intimidation, a fateful moment of moral decision in which the medical industrial complex exposed its ruthless, repressive essence. They are a frightening bunch and their conduct here raises issues well beyond autism.
The only thing frightening about this case is how much Andrew Wakefield got away with and how long it took for him to be exposed as the unethical fraud he’s been shown to be by Brian Deer, the GMC, and numerous other sources. It should also be noted that Wakefield was not found “guilty on all counts,” although he was found guilty on several of the most egregious counts. Blaxill really should read the whole report.
Attacks on peer review? Of course, they’re there too:
Since the National Institutes of Health (NIH) hold a virtual monopsony (“a sole or predominant buyer” in a particular market) on scientific research in the United State, NIH grant reviews are one prominent place where researchers can be effectively intimidated. One scientist, who authored a sensitive, previous publication, when asked to join in the effort to draft a review paper, demurred with the following explanation.
I have had two rejections of NIH grants in the last two weeks. This is most remarkable, in that the grants were not deemed good enough to even be scored. In my X years on the faculty, I have never had an unscored grant. Moreover, in one grant it is clear that there is a personal vendetta ongoing. This is not totally surprising but nonetheless disturbing. I am not ready to throw my career away, and I don’t look at how Andy Wakefield has handled such problems as a good model for me. It is vital that the science of this problem get out, and this is where I want to focus my attention. Therefore, I have decided that I do not want my name on [this new review publication], for I don’t need more persecution right now, and as good as the paper is (and I think it is extraordinary), it is not going to be a definitive scientific publication. I am enclosing a section I wrote-some of this is already included-feel free to use any of it.
If an intrepid researcher goes so far as to submit a paper for publication, that’s where the more overt forms of censorship can enter in, all in the guise of “peer review.” Admittedly, rejection at the point of peer review is a common part of science, but the autism problem is especially radioactive and is a place where I have seen the unmistakable cold hand of censorship take many forms: some unwelcome research can be headed off at the pass, with journal editors making clear that papers on certain autism topics are unwelcome and won’t even be sent out for review; or unwelcome papers can be sent to anonymous reviewers the editor knows to be hostile to the topic of environmental influences;
Let’s see: I just found out on Friday that not only was a revision of a paper I wrote still not deemed acceptable for publication in the journal to which I submitted it, but I also found out that I didn’t get a grant I really wanted that I had thought I had a good chance of getting. That’s academia and biomedical science. It happens all the time (although I can’t recall having had such a one-two body blow to my ego in one day). The latter case is somewhat apt in that the reviewers praised my proposed experimental design as being excellent but were skeptical of the primary hypothesis itself. Obviously, I must be too close to The Truth about breast cancer and how to treat it, and the breast cancer industry is trying to “silence” me! (Yeah, yeah, that’s what I’ll tell myself.) In any case, the complaint that “I’ve never had a grant not scored” is not indicative of “censorship.” The amount of money available for the NIH to fund grants compared to the number of grants submitted fell precipitously between 2003 and 2009. Lots of senior researchers who had never had a grant found to be “not worthy” of being given a numeric score (which indicates that the study section deemed it to be in the bottom half–or even bottom 60% — of the grants being ranked and therefore possessing no chance of being funded that round) have suddenly had grants coming back unscored. (Join the club and stop whining, those of us in the trenches ruefully respond!) In these tight fiscal times, that’s just reality. In this sort of environment, though, it’s easy for scientists to tell themselves that they’re the victim of groupthink whether there’s anything to it or not.
However, Blaxill had more in store for me. He completely shattered yet another of my irony meters when he wrote his conclusion:
The GMC verdict, that honest scientists like Andy Wakefield have “failed in their duty”, makes a mockery of the value of civil debate in an open society.
The medical industrial complex is closing ranks. It’s time for responsible citizens — health consumers and principled scientists alike — to raise their voices in opposition.
No, the anti-vaccine movement has made a mockery of civil debate in an open society. Its reflexive reaction to attack the messenger when criticized is legendary. Journalists have been the victims of it. Our fearless leader Steve Novella has been a victim of it. Paul Offit has been nearly continuously a victim of such bile and harassment, up to and including frivolous lawsuits. Sometimes, it gets incredibly vicious, as when AoA represented Paul Offit, Steve Novella, and journalists Trine Tsouderos and Amy Wallace as sitting down to have a Thanksgiving feast, the main course of which was a dead baby. I myself have been harassed similarly on many occasions.1,2,3,4,5,6,7
I suppose that’s the definition of “civil” debate from the anti-vaccine movement.
THE CULT OF ANTIVACCINATIONISM
As I have pointed out on numerous occasions before, both here and elsewhere, the anti-vaccine movement has much in common with cults. It believes, despite all scientific evidence, that vaccines cause autism and many other chronic health conditions. Its adherents see themselves as the keeper of a hidden truth that “they” don’t want you to know about, a “truth” that it desperately wants everyone to know. No facts, no science can sway them, and when one of their prophets is found to have behaved unethically, to have had massive conflicts of interest, and possibly even to have falsified research, it’s all part of a plot by The Man to keep them down.
That is why, as necessary as it is for the GMC to have ruled against Andrew Wakefield, I know that it will not stop him from plying his trade on children in Texas, and I especially know that it will only feed his cult of personality by adding martyr to his list of attributes in their eyes. It will not stop him from raking in money hand over fist. Even videos like this showing Wakefield joking over children fainting and throwing up as he prepared to draw blood from them after bribing them to agree to it won’t change that:
Yes, that is laughter and joking, and that is one incident that led the GMC to declare Andrew Wakefield’s “callous disregard” for children. That is the real Andrew Wakefield.
When will the madness end? I fear that it will only end when vaccine-preventable diseases return to the point where every parent fears them again. No, it’s more than that. Vaccine-preventable diseases are already returning. That’s why I fear it will only end when they return to the point where the fear of disease is more intense than the fear of the vaccine-autism bogeyman. In the meantime, while Third World countries clamor for life-saving vaccines and Bill Gates pledges $10 billion to bring vaccines to the world, here in the developed world we have men like Andrew Wakefield feeding an irrational fear of vaccines that threatens to reverse all the progress of the last few decades.
Maybe 20 years from now, we’ll need the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation to be pledging billions of dollars to bring vaccines to us.

   Antivaccine hero Andrew Wakefield: Scientific fraud?
David Gorski
Link
Pity poor Andrew Wakefield.
Actually, on second thought, Wakefield deserves no pity at all. After all, he is the man who almost single-handedly launched the scare over the MMR vaccine in Britain when he published his infamous Lancet paper in 1998 in which he claimed to have linked the MMR vaccine to regressive autism and inflammation of the colon, a study that was followed up four years later with a paper that claimed to have found the strain of attenuated measles virus in the MMR in the colons of autistic children by polymerase chain reaction (PCR). It would be one thing if these studies were sound science. If that were the case, then Wakefield’s work would have been very important and would have correctly cast doubt on the safety of the MMR. Unfortunately, they were not, and, indeed, most of the authors of the 1998 Lancet paper later withdrew their names from it.
Over the next decade, aided and abetted by useful idiots in the media, by British newspapers and other media that sensationalized the story, and the antivaccine movement, which hailed Wakefield as a hero, Wakefield managed to drive MMR vaccination rates in the U.K. below the level of herd immunity, from 93% to 75% (and as low as 50% in some parts of London). As a result Wakefield has been frequently sarcastically “thanked” for his leadership role in bringing the measles back to the U.K. to the point where, fourteen years after measles had been declared under control in the U.K., it was in 2008 declared endemic again.
Worse, this fear was based on the worst science imaginable. First, no scientist not associated with Andrew Wakefield has ever been able to replicate his work. Second, as was exposed by U.K. reporter Brian Deer, not only was Wakefield paid big bucks by trial lawyers seeking to sue vaccine manufacturers for “vaccine injury” to do his studies on autistic children, a conflict of interest he never revealed and that had to be exposed through Deer’s investigations, but months before he published his Lancet paper Wakefield had applied for a patent on a an allegedly safer single measles vaccine that could succeed best if the safety of the MMR were called into doubt. Even after all of this came to light, leading to Wakefield’s correctly being dragged in front of the General Medical Council for charges of scientific misconduct. Even after this, he still enjoys a cult of personality that I can’t figure out, and is often portrayed as being “persecuted” by the British medical establishment. Third, was revealed at the Autism Omnibus proceedings when PCR expert Stephen Bustin testified about the shoddy methods at the laboratory used to do the PCR on the colon biopsies. In brief, the laboratory used was set up such that cross contamination between the plasmids used to maintain the measles virus sequences and the area where the PCR was done. PCR is very sensitive; if there is contaminating plasmid sequence, it is very easy to amplify and detect it even when there is nothing in your samples. Indeed, I’ve experienced this very problem on occasion in my own lab. Unfortunately, in the case of Wakefield’s research, no controls were done to make sure that contamination was detected in the negative controls. Finally, Wakefield’s results were roundly refuted in an attempt to replicate his work that was published last year. As you can see, Wakefield’s work and ethics are about as bad as it gets.
Or so I thought, until readers started sending me this article published in The Times, again by Wakefield’s nemesis Brian Deer. Holy crap. If only a fraction of the allegations in this article are true, not only is Wakefield an unscrupulous and incompetent scientist but he’s a scientific fraud as well:
The doctor who sparked the scare over the safety of the MMR vaccine for children changed and misreported results in his research, creating the appearance of a possible link with autism, a Sunday Times investigation has found.
Confidential medical documents and interviews with witnesses have established that Andrew Wakefield manipulated patients’ data, which triggered fears that the MMR triple vaccine to protect against measles, mumps and rubella was linked to the condition.
The research was published in February 1998 in an article in The Lancet medical journal. It claimed that the families of eight out of 12 children attending a routine clinic at the hospital had blamed MMR for their autism, and said that problems came on within days of the jab. The team also claimed to have discovered a new inflammatory bowel disease underlying the children’s conditions.
However, our investigation, confirmed by evidence presented to the General Medical Council (GMC), reveals that: In most of the 12 cases, the children’s ailments as described in The Lancet were different from their hospital and GP records. Although the research paper claimed that problems came on within days of the jab, in only one case did medical records suggest this was true, and in many of the cases medical concerns had been raised before the children were vaccinated. Hospital pathologists, looking for inflammatory bowel disease, reported in the majority of cases that the gut was normal. This was then reviewed and the Lancet paper showed them as abnormal.
The complete story reveals behavior on the part of Wakefield that leaves me just shaking my head in disbelief. It’s simply unbelievable.
Let’s step back a minute. The original Lancet paper examined the cases of twelve children with autism and other neurodevelopmental disorders. In the paper, it was reported that in 8 of the 12 children with regressive autism the onset of developmental changes closely followed MMR vaccination and in one of the 12 it followed measles infection. Moreover, colonoscopy showed colon abnormalities “ranging from lymphoid nodular hyperplasia to aphthoid ulceration.” In 11 children, biopsy histology showed patchy chronic inflammation in the colon. The conclusion was that there was an apparent association between MMR vaccination and a syndrome of regressive autism and inflammatory bowel changes. Even though the paper’s tone was more tentative than one would have thought given the furor it launched and even though it stated that the authors “did not prove an association between measles, mumps, and rubella vaccine and the syndrome described,” Wakefield promoted his results to the media as though he had definitely found a link between the MMR vaccine and a syndrome consisting of regressive autism and inflammatory bowel disease. Thus was launched the scare that caused a thousand cases of measles (in 2008) that could have been avoided and caused many autistic children to be subjected to invasive procedures they didn’t need, sometimes at the cost of serious complications.
If the latest information is true, however, Wakefield is guilty of more than shoddy science and unreported conflicts of interest. He is guilty of scientific fraud and falsifying the medical reports of these children. For example, take Child 11, whose father requested a second set of testing on his child’s biopsy specimens:
MR ELEVEN’S taxi dash was a small ride in his desperate quest to find an answer for his son’s condition. Today, Child Eleven is much improved: at 17, he is a terrific scholar, although too nervous to drive.
The extra tests on his biopsies produced striking results. His father asked the cancer institute to look for the measles virus, which lay at the heart of Wakefield’s concerns over the vaccine. According to a theory that underpinned the project, this virus in MMR was the cause of bowel disease, which then did damage to children’s brains.
“It took a big fight to get the information,” said Mr Eleven. “They told me there was no measles virus. I had the tests repeated three times at different labs in the US, and they all came back negative.”
This struck a different note from what Wakefield suggested when describing his research to the world.
“We would not have presented this paper to The Lancet had we not undertaken extensive virological studies already,” he told the 1998 press conference.
Of course, this anomaly could simply have been due to the aforementioned incompetence of the lab that Wakefield used to test his specimens for MMR strain measles virus, with its procedures guaranteed to produce false positives. Unfortunately, there’s more. A lot more. Take Child One:
In the paper this claim would be adopted, with Wakefield and his team reporting that Child One’s parents said “behavioural symptoms” started “one week” after he received the MMR.
The boy’s medical records reveal a subtly different story, one familiar to mothers and fathers of autistic children. At the age of 9½ months, 10 weeks before his jab, his mother had become worried that he did not hear properly: the classic first symptom presented by sufferers of autism.
This is an incredibly common story among parents who believe that vaccines caused their child’s autism. Many vaccines are scheduled to be given during the same time that children often show the first behavioral alterations associated with autism, and it is not uncommon either for such changes to occur within a few weeks of a vaccination by random chance alone, nor is it uncommon for parents to remember incorrectly that the child’s symptoms started soon after a vaccine when they did not. Indeed, it is not uncommon at all for experts to be able to detect the subtler signs of autism on videotapes of babies before the parents noticed and before the child received the vaccinations for which parents blame the condition. Unfortunately, human memory is fallable, and it easily relates events that are not closely related, particularly in response to other information or preexisting beliefs. This happens all the time with vaccines and autism, where numerous epidemiological studies have failed to find an association between either mercury in thimerosal-containing vaccines and autism, between MMR and autism, and between vaccines in general and autism.
And Child Two:
This was Child Two, an eight-year-old boy from Peter-borough, Cambridgeshire, diagnosed with regressive autism, which, according to the Lancet paper, started “two weeks” after his jab.
However, this child’s medical records, backed by numerous specialist assessments, said his problems began three to five months later.
And the list goes on:
Only one was a girl, Child Eight, aged 3, from Whitley Bay, Tyne & Wear. She was reported in the journal as having suffered a brain injury “two weeks” after MMR.
Her medical records did not support this. Before she was admitted, she had been seen by local specialists, and her GP told the Royal Free of “significant concerns about her development some months before she had her MMR”.
Child Six, aged 5, and Child Seven, aged 3, were said to have been diagnosed with regressive autism, with an onset of symptoms “one week” and “24 hours” after the jab respectively.
But medical records show that neither boy was “previously normal”, as the Lancet article described all the children, and that both had already been hospitalised with brain problems before their MMR.
Child Six received his vaccine at the age of 14 months, but had twice previously been admitted with fits.
Child Seven was given his at the age of 20 months but, again, problems already showed.
In other words, one of two things happened, neither of which is flattering to Wakefield. Either he took the history from parents, for whom confirmation bias could easily have led to remembering incorrectly that their child’s behavioral changes were noted shortly after the MMR rather than before it or months later, in which case Wakefield was incompetent for not having examined the medical records. Alternatively, Wakefield did examine the medical records and lied about them in the Lancet paper. Take your pick.
In fact, I might have been willing to give Wakefield somewhat of the benefit of the doubt, viewing the discrepancies between the medical records and what he reported in the Lancet paper as being yet more evidence of his shoddiness and incompetence rather than malice, were it not for the major discrepancies between what Wakefield said about the histology of the biopsy specimens in the paper. The Lancet paper described a uniform pattern of patchy inflammation, but apparently what Wakefield reported does not jibe with what the pathologists saw:
“The uniformity of the intestinal pathological changes and the fact that previous studies have found intestinal dysfunc-tion in children with autistic-spectrum disorders, suggests that the connection is real and reflects a unique disease process, ” the Lancet Paper explained of the “syndrome”.
Yet pathology records of samples taken from the children show apparent problems with this evidence. The hospital’s consultants who took biopsies from the children’s colons concluded that they were not uniform but varied and unexceptional.
For Child Eight, the pathology report said: “No abnormality detected”, while the Lancet paper said: “Nonspecific colitis”. This pattern was repeated for two of the other children, Nine and Ten.
The most striking change of opinion came in the case of Child Three, a six-year-old from Huyton, Merseyside. He was reported in the journal to be suffering from regressive autism and bowel disease: specifically “acute and chronic nonspecific colitis”. The boy’s hospital discharge summary, however, said there was nothing untoward in his biopsy.
Not happy with the readings of the pathologists, apparently Wakefield’s research team met for a “research review” of the biopsy specimens. This in and of itself is not unusual. However, it is unusual that the research team overturned the original readings of so many of the specimens. As Brian Deer put it:
It was not an unusual move for a group of specialists to reconsider the evidence upon which their research was relying. It was nevertheless striking that their conclusion was that 11 of the children’s bowels were in fact diseased when their colleagues had found no abnormalities in at least seven of the cases.
Quite frankly, such conduct beggars the imagination. It’s about as unethical as it gets. But it’s all of a piece with Andrew Wakefield’s behavior. After all, as I pointed out before, he was in the pocket of a lawyer named Richard Barr seeking to sue vaccine manufacturers for “vaccine-induced” autism before he undertook his research. Not only that, but Barr was affiliated with the antivaccine group Jabs, and Wakefield apparently concocted his new “syndrome” after at least some consultation with Barr. But perhaps the most unethical, at least from a human research standpoint, was that the patients recruited to his study were not anything resembling a random or neutral sample. As pointed out by Brian Deer, the parents of these children heard through word of mouth about Wakefield. Add to that the fact that Wakefield subjected these children to unnecessary invasive medical procedures, and then incompetently analyzed the specimens obtained from them for measles virus to produce a virtually preordained result, even if it took scientific fraud to do it, and you see what I mean. Given such a level of ideological blindness that seems to think his cause so just that good science and ethics are optional in pursuit of it, a lack of concern over blatant conflicts of interest, and an appallingly inflated opinion of himself that he is seems to believe that he is actually a persecuted Galileo, is it any surprise that Wakefield may have stooped so far as to falsify research results in his campaign?
Not to me, it isn’t.
Sadly, none of this will matter to antivaccinationists, who view Wakefield as exactly that–a persecuted scientific hero. Although I have yet to see any response from antivaccine blogs like like Age of Autism, I’m sure that they’ll wax ridiculous about what a great doctor and man Wakefield is and how it’s big pharma and its minions who, frightened by the implications of Wakefield’s work, are working hard to demonize him and suppress his “science.” Unfortunately for their reality-challenged world view, sometimes things are as they appear, sometimes there really is no conspiracy, and sometimes a rat is a rat.
And Wakefield is most definitely a rat. A rat who caused thousands of cases of measles and at least one death.

   “Piltdown medicine” and Andrew Wakefield’s MMR vaccine fraud
David Gorski
Link
Pity poor Andrew Wakefield. Well, not really. I tend to view what’s happening to him yet again as the chickens coming home to roost.
Let’s put it this way. 2010 was a terrible year for him, and 2011 is starting out almost as bad. In February 2010, the General Medical Council in the U.K. recommended that Wakefield be stripped of his license to practice medicine in the U.K. because of scientific misconduct related to his infamous 1998 case series published in The Lancet, even going so far as to refer to him as irresponsible and dishonest, and in May 2010 he was. This case series, thanks to Wakefield’s scientific incompetence and fraud, coupled with his flair for self-promotion and enabled by the sensationalistic credulity of the British press, ignited a scare about the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine in which, afraid that the MMR vaccine causes autism, parents in the U.K. eschewed vaccinating their children in droves. As a result, vaccination rates plummeted far below the level necessary for herd immunity, with the entirely predictable result of massive measles outbreaks in the U.K. Measles, which as of the mid-1990s had been declared under control by British and European health authorities, came roaring back to the point where in 2008 it was declared once again endemic in the British Isles. In a mere decade and a half, several decades of progress in controlling this scourge had been unravelled like a thread hanging off a cheap dress, all thanks to Andrew Wakefield and scandal mongers in the British press.
True, Wakefield had long since moved to Texas, the better to be the founding “scientific director” of a house of autism woo known as Thoughtful House. Thus, the removal of his license to practice had little practical import (or effect on his ability to earn a living), or so it seemed at the time, given that Wakefield did not treat patients and hauled in quite the hefty salary for his promotion of anti-vaccine pseudoscience. Fortunately, karma’s a bitch, and, as a result of the GMC’s action, in short order The Lancet retracted Wakefield’s 1998 paper; Wakefield was pushed out of Thoughtful House; and his latest attempt to “prove” that vaccines cause autism in an animal study was also retracted. Investigative reporter Brian Deer’s investigation finding that Andrew Wakefield had committed scientific fraud in carrying out his Lancet study joined prior findings that Wakefield had been in the pocket of trial lawyers (to the tune of £435 643, plus expenses) seeking to sue the vaccine industry at the time he carried out his “research” and the allegations by renowned PCR expert Stephen Bustin during the Autism Omnibus as to how shoddily Wakefield’s other research was carried out. Finally, the mainstream media started to back away from its previous embrace of Wakefield and his claims. As a result, for a while at least, Wakefield was reduced to lame appearances at sparsely attended anti-vaccine rallies last spring.
The rest of the story
As bad as the findings were that Wakefield had committed scientific fraud, it turns out that it was even worse than the original reports indicated. A few hours ago, the British Medical Journal (BMJ) published an analysis of the scientific fraud committed by Wakefield, fraud that journalist Brian Deer likens in an accompanying editorial to the Piltdown Man. The articles are:
How the case against the MMR vaccine was fixed by Brian Deer
Wakefield’s article linking MMR vaccine and autism was fraudulent (editorial by BMJ editors Fiona Godlee, editor in chief, Jane Smith, deputy editor, Harvey Marcovitch, associate editor).
Piltdown medicine: The missing link between MMR and autism by Brian Deer.
And here is CNN reporting on the story last night:
Even better, Deer’s article is part one of a planned two-part series, the next part of which will look at Wakefield’s business plans and how he came to be fired. Basically, these latest two articles will grind to dust any remaining “scientific resepctability” Wakefield might have enjoyed. Actually, it grinds it to even finer dust–nanoparticles that disappear into the air–given that Wakefield’s reputation had already been pulverized quite thoroughly last year by the GMC. Deer begins, as he began one of his news stories before, with the testimony of a parent of one of the 12 children that Wakefield included in his study:
Mr 11, an American engineer, looked again at the paper: a five page case series of 11 boys and one girl, aged between 3 and 9 years. Nine children, it said, had diagnoses of “regressive” autism, and all but one were reported with “non-specific colitis.” The “new syndrome” brought these together, linking brain and bowel diseases. His son was the penultimate case.
Running his finger across the paper’s tables, over coffee in London, Mr 11 seemed reassured by his anonymised son’s age and other details. But then he pointed at table 2–headed “neuropsychiatric diagnosis”–and for a second time objected.
“That’s not true.”
Child 11 was among the eight whose parents apparently blamed MMR. The interval between his vaccination and the first “behavioural symptom” was reported as 1 week. This symptom was said to have appeared at age 15 months. But his father, whom I had tracked down, said this was wrong.
“From the information you provided me on our son, who I was shocked to hear had been included in their published study,” he wrote to me, after we met again in California, “the data clearly appeared to be distorted.”
Then Deer describes exactly how Wakefield rigged his study under the pay of trial lawyers to appear to suggest a link between MMR vaccination and autism. For instance, before Wakefield ever undertook his infamous study, he and a solicitor named Richard Barr had claimed to have identified a new syndrome consisting of bowel inflammation and regressive autism and aimed to show a temporal association between MMR vaccination and the onset of first symptoms. Unfortunately, Child 11′s case was a disappointment, as his discharge summary from the Royal Free Hospital, which showed that the boy’s regression began two months earlier than claimed in Wakefield’s paper and a month before he had ever received his MMR vaccine. Deer also describes Child 2, whose parents were the first to have approached Wakefield, sent by the anti-vaccine group JABS. This boy appeared in numerous news reports and was one of the four “best cases” used by Barr in a lawsuit. The boy’s mother’s story was vague and she wasn’t clear on how long it was between the child’s vaccination and the onset of his symptoms.
But that’s not all. The more the paper was investigated, the more anomalies were found. For example, only one child clearly had regressive autism, and three of nine described as having regressive autism did not. In fact, none of these three even had a diagnosis of autism at all! There were other anomalies as well. Several of the children clearly had preexisting conditions. For example, all twelve children were described in the paper as “previously normal,” but at least two of them clearly had developmental delay and facial dysmorphisms noted before they were vaccinated with the MMR. All twelve children taken together did not support the existence of a syndrome of bowel problems and regressive autism, at least not the syndrome as described in Wakefield’s paper. Deer summarizes how Wakefield “fixed the link” between MMR and regressive autism with enterocolitis:
The Lancet paper was a case series of 12 child patients; it reported a proposed “new syndrome” of enterocolitis and regressive autism and associated this with MMR as an “apparent precipitating event.” But in fact:
    • Three of nine children reported with regressive autism did not have autism diagnosed at all. Only one child clearly had regressive autism
    • Despite the paper claiming that all 12 children were “previously normal,” five had documented pre-existing developmental concerns
    • Some children were reported to have experienced first behavioural symptoms within days of MMR, but the records documented these as starting some months after vaccination
    • In nine cases, unremarkable colonic histopathology results–noting no or minimal fluctuations in inflammatory cell populations–were changed after a medical school “research review” to “non-specific colitis”
    • The parents of eight children were reported as blaming MMR, but 11 families made this allegation at the hospital. The exclusion of three allegations–all giving times to onset of problems in months–helped to create the appearance of a 14 day temporal link
    • Patients were recruited through anti-MMR campaigners, and the study was commissioned and funded for planned litigation
As Brian Deer so aptly puts it, Wakefield “chiseled” the data, “falsifying medical histories of children and essentially concocting a picture, which was the picture he was contracted to find by lawyers hoping to sue vaccine manufacturers and to create a vaccine scare.” The discrepancies between the case reports as described in Wakefield’s Lancet paper and the actual medical records are anything but random; all are in the direction of suggesting a link between the MMR and Wakefield’s as yet unverified syndrome of regressive autism and enterocolitis. The cases that were selected appear not to have been random, sequential patients but were rather recruited specifically through anti-vaccine activists and trial lawyers. Moreover, as Deer puts it
Moreover, through the omission from the paper of some parents’ beliefs that the vaccine was to blame, the time link for the lawsuit sharpened. With concerns logged from 11 of 12 families, the maximum time given to the onset of alleged symptoms was a (forensically unhelpful) four months. But, in a version of the paper circulated at the Royal Free six months before publication, reported concerns fell to nine of 12 families but with a still unhelpful maximum of 56 days. Finally, Wakefield settled on 8 of 12 families, with a maximum interval to alleged symptoms of 14 days.
Between the latter two versions, revisions also slashed the mean time to alleged symptoms–from 14 to 6.3 days. “In these children the mean interval from exposure to the MMR vaccine to the development of the first behavioural symptom was six days, indicating a strong temporal association,” he emphasised in a patent for, among other things, his own prophylactic measles vaccine, eight months before the Lancet paper.
Yes, that’s exactly what Deer has found. When the time frame between vaccination and the onset of symptoms was too long to be useful for suggesting a link between MMR and regressive autism with enterocolitis, Wakefield systematically removed subjects whose parents blamed the MMR for their children’s autism until the time frame between vaccination and onset of symptoms in the remaining subjects was a much more impressive 14 days. There is no innocent explanation possible for the systematic and numerous discrepancies between the medical record and Wakefield’s paper, as the editors of the BMJ point out in their accompanying editorial:
The Office of Research Integrity in the United States defines fraud as fabrication, falsification, or plagiarism. Deer unearthed clear evidence of falsification. He found that not one of the 12 cases reported in the 1998 Lancet paper was free of misrepresentation or undisclosed alteration, and that in no single case could the medical records be fully reconciled with the descriptions, diagnoses, or histories published in the journal.
Who perpetrated this fraud? There is no doubt that it was Wakefield. Is it possible that he was wrong, but not dishonest: that he was so incompetent that he was unable to fairly describe the project, or to report even one of the 12 children’s cases accurately? No. A great deal of thought and effort must have gone into drafting the paper to achieve the results he wanted: the discrepancies all led in one direction; misreporting was gross.
The antivaccine movement circles the wagons again
The degree of falsification and the number of discrepancies were breathtaking in their audacity and contempt for reviewers and Wakefield’s own collaborators, ten of whom retracted their names from the study back in 2004, when strong evidence of a serious conflict of interest on Wakefield’s part was first unearthed by Deer. The chutzpah Wakefield demonstrated in his fraud was truly breathtaking. So is the chutzpah he continues to exhibit today with his denials. Even after this report and all the stories reporting on it, Wakefield continues to deny that he has done anything at all wrong and blames the criticisms leveled against him on conspiracies. In reality, given the way the anti-vaccine movement has begun to circle the wagons to defend Wakefield yet again, it’s tempting to claim that this is a conspiracy. Personally, I consider it a conspiracy of utter cluelessness. For one example, check out this video of J.B. Handley:
Yes, Handley’s regurgitating antivaccine favorites like the “tobacco science” mischaracterization, touting Wakefield’s “monkey business” study (which he neglects to mention was withdrawn), and defending Wakefield. I will say one thing, though. Handley actually managed to keep himself from having one of his characteristic outbursts, although it was obvious that he was on the verge of one of his typical rants. Perhaps he’s had some media training since his last appearance on The Doctors or Larry King’s show.
For another example, check out this defense of Andrew Wakefield by the anti-vaccine National Autism Association, which makes the astonishingly ludicrous claim that the BMJ article is “yet another attempt to thwart vaccine safety research.” The anti-vaccine crank blog Age of Autism naturally reposted the NAA’s counterattack.
One of the NAA’s claims in its press release is that Wakefield’s study has been “repeatedly confirmed,” and the NAA cites five studies that allegedly confirm Wakefield’s fraudulent results. However, as Just the Vax and Sullivan show, these studies do not represent independent confirmation of anything. One of them was by a close associate of Wakefield; one is a case report of an adult autistic with enterocolitis; and none of the rest confirm Wakefield’s results either. Yet, every time a story pops up showing that Wakefield committed scientific fraud, Wakefield defenders in the anti-vaccine movement dutifully trot out the same five studies, as though any of them were independent confirmation of his work, while anti-vaccine activists launch ad hominem attacks against BMJ editor Fiona Godlee and regurgitate old attacks on Brian Deer. Particularly off-base is the NAA’s claim that somehow, by laying bare Wakefield’s clear cut and vile scientific fraud, the BMJ is interfering with “vaccine safety research.” No, it’s revealing a dangerous scientific fraud, nothing more.
“Piltdown medicine”
So egregious was Wakefield’s fraud that Deer likens it in an accompanying blog post to “Piltdown medicine,” making this direct comparison to the infamous “Piltdown Man” hoax:
The Piltdown contrivance involved the pre-arranged “discovery” of features brought together to be sensationally “found.” A piece of skullcap was human, a partial jaw was an orangutan’s, and a tooth was a chimpanzee’s, filed down. They were stained with chemicals and, to fabricate a temporal link, were buried with flint tools in datable gravel near the tiny village of Piltdown, East Sussex.
Some would suggest that their proximity was a matter of chance, but the odds of this would have taxed an astronomer. “That two different individuals were present,” one of the scientists who unmasked the fraud explained later, “a fossil man, represented by a cranium without a jaw, and a fossil ape, represented by a jaw without a cranium, within a few feet of each other and so similar in colour and preservation, would be a coincidence, amazing beyond belief.”
And so it was with Wakefield, eight decades after the Piltdown discoveries. Amazing beyond belief. For skullcap read “developmental disorders”, for the jaw “enterocolitis”, and for the tooth “parental complaints about MMR”. Bring them together at one hospital, with a 14-day temporal link, and another assemblage was “found”.
This is a very apt analogy. The more we find out about how Wakefield put together his case series for The Lancet, the more it becomes obvious that he calculatingly put together a fraud every bit as elaborate and planned as the Piltdown Man hoax. It might not have taken as long for Wakefield’s fraud to come to light. Although there were suspicions that not everything was as it appeared as early as within the first year after Wakefield’s case report, it was not until 2004 that serious allegations came to light of Wakefield’s conflict of interest. These allegations ultimately led to the GMC hearing that began in 2007 and the findings of scientific fraud announced nearly a year ago. Now, here it is, thirteen years later, and only now is the full story being told.
What I can’t figure out–I mean, really, really can’t figure out–is why the anti-vaccine movement continues to cling to Wakefield’s tattered “science” and lionize this fraud as a hero. Surely the more sober and intelligent members of the anti-vaccine mvoement (they do exist, believe it or not) must realize by now that Wakefield has become a huge liability. This was best demonstrated last year, when, after years of doing nothing about him, as soon as the GMC found Wakefield had committed scientific fraud, in short order The Lancet retracted his paper, Thoughtful House fired him, and his “monkey business” paper, which was to be his “comeback” as far as scientific respectability goes, was also retracted. Wakefield is now very much like the Black Knight in Monty Python and the Holy Grail, who, having had his arm hacked off by King Arthur declares it to be “just a flesh wound.” After hacking off all but the Black Knight’s left leg, the Black Knight keeps taunting Arthur, who retorts, “What are you going to do, bleed on me?” and finally, unable to take any more, cuts off the Black Knight’s last leg.
This article by Brian Deer is the last swing of the sword that hacks off Wakefield’s last limb.
Unfortunately, like the Black Knight, not realizing that, scientifically he’s been utterly discredited, Wakefield fights on. Worse, he is still feted by the anti-vaccine movement. Right now, he’s in Jamaica as part of a “vaccine safety” conference whose list of speakers is chock full of anti-vaccine activists.
For Wakefield, even 13 years later, fraud pays.

Andrew Wakefield after 25 years: Paving the way for COVID-19 quacks and antivaxxers
It was 25 years ago yesterday that Andrew Wakefield launched the modern iteration of the antivaccine movement.In doing so, he laid down a template that antivax quacks today still follow.
David Gorski on February 27, 2023
Link

Has it really been 25 years, a whole quarter of a century?
I must admit that this is an anniversary that snuck up on me. I had been intending to write about an entirely different topic when I sat down with my laptop yesterday, but then I saw an article pop up in my Google Alerts from Katherine Fidler entitled ‘Dishonest and irresponsible’: 25 years on from Andrew Wakefield’s claims against the MMR jab, and I knew I had to acknowledge this unfortunate “anniversary” somehow,” given that yesterday was the quarter century anniversary of the press conference at which Andrew Wakefield announced the findings of his execrably bad 12 patient case series that first linked the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine to “associated gastrointestinal disease and developmental regression in a group of previously normal children.” It is true, of course, that year before, the UK General Medical Council had stripped Wakefield of his license to practice medicine—he was “struck off,” a delightfully British way of putting it—with GMC concluding that “there was a biased selection of patients in The Lancet paper” and that Wakefield’s “conduct in this regard was dishonest and irresponsible.”
After that, one might think that the rigorous documentation by Brian Deer of Andrew Wakefield’s scientific fraud should have been the final nail in the coffin of Wakefield’s reputation. One would be wrong. Even after Deer, who referred to The Lancet case series as “Piltdown medicine” ultimately documented Wakefield’s fraud and how the study had been “fixed,” if you will, unfortunately that was 13 years after the study’s publication and the damage had already been done. From 2011 until the emergence of a novel coronavirus nine years later, to antivaxxers Wakefield was the pre-eminent “brave maverick doctor”; that is, until a new generation of grifters forged in the chaos of a deadly global pandemic arose.
An anniversary of misinformation that will live in scientific infamy
The new generation of antivaxxers, quacks, and grifters that has arisen since COVID-19 spread throughout the world in 2020 is why I immediately switched topics to discuss Wakefield on this unfortunate anniversary. He arguably laid down the basics template that antivax quacks are now following and expanding upon in the age of COVID-19. Moreover, yesterday and tomorrow are days of infamy and failure that science-based physicians should never, ever let The Lancet and its Editor-in-Chief at the time, Richard Horton, forget. Unbelievably, a quarter century on, Horton is still editor of The Lancet, even though he should have been sacked no later than immediately after Brian Deer’s exposé revealed the magnitude of his failure.
Let’s take a look back at Wakefield’s original case series and industry of antivax quackery and disinformation that it spawned. Then I will discuss Wakefield’s unfortunate continuing relevance to COVID-19 antivaxxers. Right up front, I will conceded that, for reasons that I cannot understand, Wakefield failed to be as prominent among “new school” antivaxxers as he was among the “old school” before the pandemic. I rather suspect that sheer numbers could be part of the reason why, unlike some other “old school” antivaxxers—e.g., Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., Stephanie Seneff, Sherri Tenpenny, Ty Bollinger, Rashid Buttar, Kelly Brogan, Joe Mercola, Erin Elizabeth, and some of the rest of the “Disinformation Dozen“—who have managed not only to remain relevant but to increase their stature through embracing COVID misinformation, compared to his stature in the antivaccine movement prepandemic, Andrew Waekfield has not been a huge presence, certainly not the towering figure of disinformation that he was for the 22 years before SARS-CoV-2 arrived who directed one of the most influential antivax movies ever, VAXXED, in 2016, had a hagiographic “documentary” made about him, and was once likened by J.B. Handley, founder of Generation Rescue, the group for which Jenny McCarthy became the figurehead for a few years back in the late aughts, to “Nelson Mandela and Jesus Christ all rolled up into one.”
Even so, Wakefield hasn’t been completely supplanted. For example, Wakefield has promoted nonsense about mRNA COVID-19 vaccines “permanently altering your DNA” and has been showing up more frequently on the podcasts and social media of “new school” antivaxxers like Steve Kirsch, a tech bro who has now imbibed deeply of every COVID-19 antivax conspiracy theory in existence and then occasionally gone beyond them, even as he takes the crank love of bogus debate challenges to new and ridiculous “heights.” Moreover, as I argued in 2021, Geert Vanden Bossche’s conspiracy theory that COVID-19 vaccines will lead to “escape mutant” variants that could mean the end of humanity was clearly patterned on Wakefield’s 2019 unsupported and deceptive claim that measles variants, selected for by MMR, will lead to a sixth mass extinction.
First, though, let’s let Kathleen Fidler remind us how it all started:
Scientists aren’t always right. In fact, most will tell you they spend their days trying to prove themselves wrong. Only when they can’t – many times over – can they be close to sure.
However, in the case of former doctor Andrew Wakefield, a dangerous dose of overconfidence – coupled with undisclosed financial incentives – led to a damaging public health scare, the effects of which are still being seen in 2023.
It was 25 years ago today that a crowd of media assembled in the atrium of London’s Royal Free Hospital to hear the shocking and provocative results of a study by Wakefield and his 12 research colleagues. They said, following research into 12 children – 11 boys and one girl, there was a link between the combined measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine, and a new syndrome causing both bowel disease and autism.
That a vaccination designed to protect infants from a trifecta of serious childhood diseases could lead to a lasting neurological disorder was an allegation of immense concern to parents across the country, and soon, around the world.
In the years following publication of the study in renowned medical journal The Lancet – and sustained media coverage – vaccination rates fell, as parents felt forced to choose between protecting against potentially life-threatening viruses or autism.
It was a decision no parent ever wants to make – or should have to. Especially as it wasn’t true.
To be honest, I think that Fidler is being way too generous here in referring to Andrew Wakefield as a scientist. Maybe he was at one time, but by that fateful day in February when he he began is string of appearances on multiple media outlets promoting his fear mongering about the MMR vaccine, he had long ceased to be anything resembling a scientist. Similarly, the idea that vaccines somehow caused autism was not Wakefield’s invention. As reported by Brian Deer, in fact Wakefield had accepted funding from antivax lawyers intending to sue pharmaceutical companies for “vaccine-induced autism.” As Fidler notes:
As a researcher at the Royal Free Hospital focusing on gastrointestinal disorders, Wakefield believed he had discovered a link between measles and Crohn’s disease, a chronic form of inflammatory bowel disease. That research later pivoted to asking whether measles vaccinations were also a risk factor in developing the condition.
This work brought him to the attention of a lawyer, Richard Barr, who was acting for a number of parents who believed the MMR had caused their children to develop autism. Working in tandem, the pair arranged for 12 children – from as far afield as the US – to be referred for assessment at the Royal Free as part of a study into the effects of MMR.
Each child was subjected to a number of intensive and invasive procedures – later determined by the General Medical Council to be unnecessary – including spinal taps and colonoscopies.
Worse, patients were recruited through anti-MMR campaigners, and the study was commissioned and funded for planned litigation. Indeed, a barrister named Richard Barr paid him to produce evidence that he could use in lawsuits against vaccine manufacturers for “vaccine-induced autism” even as he had developed a measles-only vaccine that he hoped could compete against the MMR:
Unknown to Mr 11, Wakefield was working on a lawsuit,7 for which he sought a bowel-brain “syndrome” as its centrepiece. Claiming an undisclosed £150 (€180, $230) an hour through a Norfolk solicitor named Richard Barr, he had been confidentially 8 put on the payroll two years before the paper was published, eventually grossing him £435,643, plus expenses.9
Curiously, however, Wakefield had already identified such a syndrome before the project which would reputedly discover it. “Children with enteritis/disintegrative disorder [an expression he used for bowel inflammation and regressive autism10] form part of a new syndrome,” he and Barr explained in a confidential grant application to the UK government’s Legal Aid Board11 before any of the children were investigated.12 “Nonetheless the evidence is undeniably in favour of a specific vaccine induced pathology.”
The two men also aimed to show a sudden-onset “temporal association”—strong evidence in product liability. “Dr Wakefield feels that if we can show a clear time link between the vaccination and onset of symptoms,” Barr told the legal board, “we should be able to dispose of the suggestion that it’s simply a chance encounter.”13
The rest of Deer’s exposé reported how Wakefield had manipulated the data and the parents’ reports to produce a more convincing temporal association between the 12 subjects’ initial symptoms, particularly given that some of them had had evidence of symptoms before they received the MMR. (You can read Deer’s report for the details.) I like to remember one thing, too, when reading this assertion by Brian Deer:
Drawing on interviews, documents, and properly obtained data, collected during seven years of inquiries, we show how one man, former gastroenterology researcher Andrew Wakefield, was able to manufacture the appearance of a purported medical syndrome, whilst not only in receipt of large sums of money, but also scheming businesses that promised him more. His was a fraud, moreover, of more than academic vanity. It unleashed fear, parental guilt, costly government intervention, and outbreaks of infectious disease.
Remember, this was published in The BMJ, which is published the UK, a nation with very plaintiff-friendly libel laws. You can bet that it was all extensively documented and vetted by The BMJ‘s lawyers before publication. As an aside, seeing The BMJ‘s bravery in publishing this 12 years ago compared to The BMJ‘s embrace of COVID-19 disinformation-spreaders like Paul Thacker and its now longtime senior editor Peter Doshi depresses me, leading me to ask, “WTF happened?” Let’s just say that The BMJ has gone way downhill over the last 12 years.
The BMJ‘s decline aside, it didn’t take long for the fear that MMR causes autism to cause MMR uptake in the UK and Europe to plummet, with the return of massive measles outbreaks. Fortunately, the MMR fear mongering didn’t have quite as marked an effect in the US, although over here fear mongering based on the false hypothesis that mercury in the thimerosal preservative used in childhood vaccines until around 2001 was a major cause of autism.
In any event, after his being struck off in 2010 and Deer’s documentation of the fraud at the heart of his Lancet case series, Wakefield went the only route that he could and became even more of an antivax campaigner and conspiracy theorist. For example, in 2014 he popularized the “CDC whistleblower” conspiracy theory claiming that the CDC had “hidden” evidence that MMR caused autism. Two years later, the “CDC whistleblower” conspiracy theory became the basis of the antivax documentary VAXXED that he made with Del Bigtree. On can obviously see the parallels in the age of COVID-19, with COVID-19 and antivax propaganda movies having come fast and furious, beginning with Plandemic in 2020 and continuing to movies like Died Suddenly. Meanwhile, Wakefield had movies made about him like The Pathological Optimist, which basically portrayed him as the brave maverick doctor who stuck to his guns in face of criticism and sanctions by the medical community.
Wakefield pioneered much the template used by COVID quacks
As 2022 dawned, I noted how everything old is new again and there is nothing new under the sun when it comes to COVID-19 quackery and antivax quackery. Of course, if you consider only the details of the claims made by quacks and antivaxxers about COVID-19, that’s not entirely true, but if you look at the broader narratives of antivaxxers it most certainly is. Basically, every antivax narrative about COVID-19 fits into the common antivax narrative themes that existed before the pandemic, and Andrew Wakefield helped amplify nearly all of them. This is all the more impressive given that in 1998 social media didn’t exist and the Internet, in particular the World Wide Web, was still in its infancy and Wakefield relied primarily on old media, in particular the UK tabloid press, to spread his message.
Another part of the antivax template that you have to have to be an effective quack is an “alternative” to current vaccinations. You might recall that at first Wakefield had his own separate measles vaccine and mostly only demonized the combined MMR vaccine. You might also recall that, like any good quack, Wakefield had a dubious component in that vaccine, which he tried to patent. Specifically, Wakefield was going to use something called transfer factor in his new vaccine to “boost immunity.” Basically, transfer factor is pure quackery thought up by Hugh Fudenberg. For those of you who haven’t heard of him before, the late Hugh Fudenberg was a collaborator and co-inventor with Andrew Wakefield. Dr. Fudenberg also happens to have been involved in some very dubious “treatments” for autism that led to some problems with his medical license.
Does any of this sound familiar? Let’s take a look. In the early aughts, Wakefield left the UK and moved to Texas, where in 2005 he co-founded Thoughtful House Center for Children, which was a quack clinic in which he served as Medical Director and, although he didn’t treat patients himself, developed “protocols” to treat autism and “autistic enterocolitis” based on the concept that they were caused by MMR vaccine “injury.” There, an American gastroenterologist Dr. Arthur Krigsman did what Andrew Wakefield could not do because he did not have a Texas medical license, namely treating children with autism with quackery for “gut issues” and performing colonoscopies. Interestingly, after Brian Deer’s reporting on Wakefield’s fraud, Wakefield and Krigsman both left Thoughtful House, Wakefield not voluntarily, Krigsman, well, it’s not so certain. In any event Thoughtful House was a quack clinic in which Krigsman treated autistic children with “autism biomed” with Wakefield’s “guidance” (given that he couldn’t legally provide direct medical treatment to anyone) based on the idea that MMR vaccine and other vaccines cause autism and “autistic enterocolitis.”
Wakefield’s fingerprints are all over the current crop COVID-19 quacks. Just take a look at, for example, American’s Frontline Doctors (AFLDS), none of whom were ever really frontline, but all of whom were into the selling of all manner of quackery, including an ivermectin telehealth prescription mill and then later degenerated into legal wrangling between quacks and grifters over control of the organization. Then there’s arguably the most famous group of COVID-19 quacks, Front Line COVID-19 Critical Care Alliance (FLCCC). I haven’t written much about FLCCC here, although I’ve discussed this group much more elsewhere. Basically, FLCCC is a group of quacks co-founded by Dr. Pierre Kory promote ivermectin, although the FLCCC promotes more than just ivermectin. For instance, FLCCC promotes protocols such as the I-MASS protocol, touted as an “in-home” treatment protocol for COVID-19 that involves vitamin D3, melatonin, aspirin, a multivitamin, a thermometer, and an antiseptic mouthwash. Another FLCCC protocol is I-MASK+, which is promoted as an outpatient treatment protocol and involves ivermectin, zinc, melatonin, various vitamins, and fluvoxamine. The FLCCC’s most “advanced” protocol is MATH+, a hospital treatment protocol that involves—of course!—ivermectin, plus zinc, fluvoxamine, and a bunch of other vitamins and supplements, along with steroids and anticoagulants. None of these protocols has anything resembling solid evidence from randomized clinical trials to support it. Reading through these protocols, I get very much a Wakefieldian autism biomed vibe, as FLCCC throws everything but the kitchen sink at COVID-19.
Like Wakefield and other autism biomed quacks who sought to cure autism by “detoxing” vaccine injury, FLCCC also has a protocol to treat “postvaccine syndrome,” because of course it does. It even includes a lot of old school antivax “treatments” for autism and “vaccine injury”:
First Line Therapies(Not symptom specific; listed in order of importance)
    • Intermittent daily fasting or periodic daily fasts
    • Ivermectin
    • Moderating physical activity
    • Low-dose naltrexone
    • Nattokinase
    • Aspirin
    • Melatonin
    • Magnesium
    • Methylene blue
    • Sunlight and Photobiomodulation
    • Resveratrol
Probiotics/Prebiotics/Adjunctive/Second-Line Therapies(Listed in order of importance)
    • Vitamin D (with Vitamin K2)
    • N-acetyl cysteine
    • Cardio Miracle™ and L-arginine/L-citrulline supplements
    • Omega-3 fatty acids
    • Sildenafil (with or without L-arginine- L-citrulline)
    • Nigella sativa
    • Vitamin C
    • Spermidine
    • Non-invasive brain stimulation
    • Intravenous Vitamin C
    • Behavioral modification, relaxation therapy, mindfulness therapy, and psychological support
Third Line Therapies
    • Hyperbaric oxygen therapy
    • Low Magnitude Mechanical Stimulation
    • “Mitochondrial energy optimizer”
    • Hydroxychloroquine
    • Low-dose corticosteroid
Intravenous vitamin C? Vitamin D? “Mitochondrial energy optimizer”? Hyperbaric oxygen? Regulars probably remember all of these showing up in autism biomed quackery at one time or another. Similar to other autism quacks, FLCCC has of late branched out and billed its quackery as able to treat other conditions.
Wakefield also pioneered the use of patients who thought they had been injured by vaccines (or, in the case of autistic children, their parents) as weapons against attempts to hold him accountable. We saw it at his GMC hearings. We saw it in the reaction of his followers and fans. However, this was not unique to Wakefield, of course. Stanislaw Burzynski had been doing this since the early 1990s. He also perfected the art of playing the persecuted genius, suffering because he is supposedly so brilliant and far ahead of his peers.
Even so, if I had to think of one thing that Wakefield “pioneered” that we’ve seen more than anything else during the pandemic, it’s the weaponization of bad scientific studies. None of what I mentioned above, the quackery, the grift, the self-portrayal as the persecuted genius, the use of the media of the time to promote his quackery, was truly unique. However, his Lancet case series was truly the original template that antivaxxers quickly imitated to churn out bad study after bad study over the years to demonize vaccines and tout their quackery, occasionally, like Wakefield, managing to publish in a highly reputable journal. In the age of the pandemic, arguably more quacks than ever are publishing more papers than ever in an attempt to produce the next one with Wakefield-level influence to grift on.
Indeed, one thing that did not surprise me about the pandemic is just how many “old school” antivaxxers quickly pivoted to become COVID-19 conspiracy theorists and then, when COVID-19 vaccines arrived, COVID-19 antivaxxers. Many of them profited more than ever before. (Joe Mercola, Del Bigtree, and RFK Jr. immediately come to mind.) What did surprise me is that Wakefield was not one of them. Sure, he did seem to try, but it didn’t seem to resonate the way that his fear mongering about MMR vaccines and autism did. I can only speculate that perhaps this is because 25 years ago Wakefield was indeed a “pioneer” of antivaccine fear mongering and quackery, as well as of using the scientific literature to promote pseudoscience and misinformation. Now, he is just one of many, some of whom have far surpassed him. I also suspect that his arrogance got in the way and that he couldn’t conceive of not being able to garner attention easily. Moreover, his idea about MMR resulting in ever more deadly variants of measles was clearly a major inspiration of the many antivax variants claiming that COVID-19 vaccines will cause ever more virulent COVID variants.
Whatever the reason for the disconnect, there is no doubt that Wakefield was trailblazer in the antivaccine world. Unfortunately, that means he is a pioneer in causing unnecessary death on a mass scale.

The Pathological Optimist: More hagiography than documentary about Andrew Wakefield
The Pathological Optimist is a recently released documentary by Miranda Bailey about Andrew Wakefield that I got a chance to see. In interviews and in the film’s promotional materials, Bailey takes great pains to emphasize that she “doesn’t take a side” about Wakefield. Unfortunately, her film demonstrates that, when it comes to pseudoscience, “not taking a side” is taking a side, and that a film’s bias is often more evident in what is not shown and told than in what is.
David Gorski on October 9, 2017
Link

Quacks have discovered that a couple of the most effective tools out there to influence opinion are videos and documentaries. Videos, of course, can be made on the cheap and posted to YouTube, then later sold, either online or in DVD form. An excellent example of one such quack video series is Ty Bollinger’s The Truth About Cancer. Of course, videos like this do not have the cachet of actual documentaries, and there has been a cornucopia of these promoting quackery too. I’ve written about several of them, such as The Beautiful Truth (promoting Gerson cancer quackery), Burzynski The Movie: Cancer Is Serious Business and its sequel Burzynski: Cancer Is A Serious Business, Part 2 (both promoting Stanislaw Burzynski’s antineoplaston cancer quackery), The Greater Good (promoting antivaccine quackery), Simply Raw: Reversing Diabetes in 30 Days (overblown claims for vegan diets), and, of course, VAXXED: From Cover-up to Catastrophe (more antivaccine quackery, this time from Andrew Wakefield himself). Of course VAXXED made a lot of news last year because Robert De Niro bypassed the normal judging process to show it in the Tribeca Film Festival, of which he is a co-founder. When the film list for the festival was released, the uproar, both from the press and filmmakers, was so intense that De Niro was forced to pull the movie from his festival. At least we learned that De Niro is antivaccine.
Speaking of VAXXED and Andrew Wakefield, what happens when a legitimate, generally respected filmmaker takes on a topic related to the antivaccine-movement? It’s something I’ve never dealt with before, but now I have the opportunity to do so. Such a film is a different kettle of fish entirely from the sort of propaganda films listed above. In the case of those films we know the filmmaker is not only biased but making the film to promote the quack or quackery featured. In contrast, when a legitimate filmmaker with a decent track record decides to take on a topic like Andrew Wakefield, we don’t know that and hope for a compelling, accurate documentary. In this case, I’m referring to the recently released movie The Pathological Optimist, which is portrayed as a “balanced” portrait of Andrew Wakefield, who basically inspired modern iteration of the antivaccine movement through his fraudulent science linking vaccines to autism in the late 1990s.
Here’s the trailer:
Here’s how the film’s website describes the film:
Who is the man behind the most highly controversial, intensely debated topics in modern medicine? In THE PATHOLOGICAL OPTIMIST, director Miranda Bailey brings us a character study of Dr. Andrew Wakefield, one of 13 co-authors of a notorious 1998 paper in the UK medical Journal The Lancet, but who became the very public face of what has come to be known as “The Anti-Vax Movement.” An expat from Britain who currently resides in Austin, Texas, Wakefield allowed Bailey and her team to follow him and his family for five years beginning in 2011 as he fought a defamation battle in the courts against the British Medical Journal and journalist Brian Deer. The results of that case – and the self-reflection, pronouncements, and observations of Wakefield, his legal team, wife, and his children – create a complex and incisive look at one of our era’s most fear-provoking and continuously provocative figures. THE PATHOLOGICAL OPTIMIST takes no sides, instead letting Wakefield and the battles he fought speak for themselves.
The “take no sides” claim sends up huge red flags for me. My retort to this is that, when it comes to pseudoscience, “not taking a side” is taking a side, the side of giving that pseudoscience far more believability and stature than it deserves. It’s also utter nonsense to claim that “letting Wakefield and the battles he fought speak for themselves.” If there’s one misconception about documentaries, it’s that they are (or should be) objective. They’re not. A documentary filmmaker has a story to tell, and that story is very much colored by how she chooses to frame it, what she decides to show (and, equally importantly, not to show), what order scenes are shown in, who is interviewed and who isn’t, and even the music and narration used. Bailey’s film no more “lets Wakefield and the battles he fought” speak for themselves than Wakefield’s VAXXED is an objective portrait of a CDC “conspiracy.” It is how Miranda Bailey chose to tell Wakefield’s story. Indeed, it’s hard not to note that the only people directly interviewed for the film are Andrew Wakefield, his family, and his supporters. All criticism of Wakefield comes in the form of grainy archival footage from TV news interviews, which Wakefield or one of his supporters gets to answer.
How do I know this? I’ve seen the movie. If there’s one thing that strikes me most about it is that it taught me that bias in a film is at least as evident, if not more so, in what the director chooses not to show and tell than in what she does show and tell. Overall, The Pathological Optimist is basically Wakefield’s side of the story, with occasional archival footage of Brian Deer, Paul Offit, Bill Gates, The Lancet editor Richard Horton, and a few others from TV appearances attacking Wakefield, but not enough to demonstrate that Wakefield is, as is his wont, laying down heaping helpings of misinformation designed to present him as the Brave Maverick Doctor persecuted by The Man for telling an “inconvenient truth.” The end result is that Bailey leaves out a lot of context and Wakefield ends up coming off far more favorably than unfavorably, his key claims mostly unrefuted. That’s because, if you don’t know the context behind many of Wakefield’s claims, you’ll tend to take what he says and how Bailey presents the events portrayed in the film at face value. If you don’t know who several of the Wakefield supporters interviewed are and what they do, you’ll take their claims at face value as well.
Wakefield the man, as portrayed in the film
The Pathological Optimist begins with rather fawning shots of Wakefield heading out to do yoga, with a voiceover in which Wakefield points out that a charge of scientific fraud is a death sentence to a scientist’s career (usually true) and claiming that the media in the UK didn’t pay much attention to Brian Deer’s BMJ report that Wakefield had committed scientific fraud was largely ignored in the UK but hyped in the US. I can’t personally speak to the veracity of this claim, given that I live in the US, but I can say that I do remember quite a few news articles coming out of the UK about the article at the time and that readers who do live in the UK tell me that this claim is a load of fetid dingo’s kidneys. As Wakefield does yoga, archival news footage of Dr. Paul Offit and Bill Gates criticizing Wakefield’s fraud is shown. Cue the credits while Andy does yoga, followed by an interview with him as he drives home. Next comes the introduction of Wakefield’s frivolous libel lawsuit through Wakefield looking over one of his filings. Thus is the tone of the movie set, as the movie is framed around Wakefield’s libel suit against Brian Deer and The British Medical Journal (BMJ) in Texas, which—spoiler!— ignominiously never got off the ground when a Texas appeals court ruled it didn’t have jurisdiction. It’s a rather weak frame, given that relatively little screen time is devoted to it compared to multiple other aspects of Wakefield’s history. Of course, it was a weak case, too, far more a vehicle for Wakefield to raise money than having any real chance to succeed.
Those who have been following Wakefield’s career will, if they see this movie, likely feel a rising tide of bile welling up in the back of their throats as they watch. There are lots of shots of Wakefield and his family clearly designed to portray him as a devoted family man. One near the beginning of the film shows him making breakfast for his teenaged children before school and standing in the door with a cup of coffee wistfully watching them leave. There’s another scene of him sitting in the stands watching his son at rugby practice after having driven him there. Elsewhere, Wakefield speculates that the worst disadvantage that his children have is having him as a father. (I probably have to grant him that.) Late in the film, we learn from a scene of his wife Carmel O’Donovan walking through the grounds of the Wakefield estate with her daughter that Wakefield likes to take out his frustrations by chopping wood. Indeed, the last scenes of the film feature Wakefield in a tank top chopping underbrush and wood, interspersed with news reports about the backlash over VAXXED being accepted into the Tribeca Film Festival. The film closes with a shot of Wakefield surveying the enormous pile of chopped branches that he had created over the years. I suppose there’s a metaphor in there somewhere.
Money is a theme that surfaces repeatedly in the film. Wakefield and his wife frequently lament about not having any money because the “persecution” has made him unemployable. Yet they’re repeatedly shown living in a rather impressively large and beautiful house with extensive land surrounding it. True, there is one scene where Carmel tells her youngest daughter about Andrew’s and her plans to sell the house and move into smaller digs after she leaves for college. She notes that only two of the Wakefield children still live there and explains that her parents did the same thing when she left for university. Not surprisingly, we’re never informed whether the Wakefields ever actually did sell their house. As far as I know, they’re still living there. So where does Wakefield’s money come from? Who knows? I’ve often wondered that. In the film, we see him in several scenes fundraising for his legal fund, but where the income that keeps him and his family in that large house comes from, we never learn. We are, however, treated to multiple shots throughout the film of Wakefield’s adoring fans fawning over him. One can almost understand why near the end of the film Wakefield compares himself to Nelson Mandela in his belief that he will be vindicated.
Speaking of Wakefield’s wife, Carmel is featured in several scenes. In one, she talks about how difficult it was for her to raise four children alone in the UK for four years after Wakefield had moved to Austin to run the “wholistic autism clinic” Thoughtful House. She relates an anecdote about how jet lag totally wipes Wakefield out. Basically, after being a single mother for so long, she looked forward to her husband coming home to England so that he could watch the kids a while, only on his arrival to find him nearly nonfunctional due to jet lag. In another segment, she is shown childishly mocking the judge overseeing Wakefield’s libel suit, Amy Clark Meacham, as flipping her hair like a teenaged girl. Later Carmel attacks Meacham as biased because her husband is a lobbyist for the pharmaceutical company. In still another scene, she refuses to say anything about Wakefield’s leaving Thoughtful House after he was struck off by the GMC and his Lancet paper retracted, citing a nondisclosure agreement. (Wakefield was almost certainly fired after his being struck off and having his paper retracted made him someone that not even a quack clinic like Thoughtful House wanted to be associated with.)
At least a two of the scenes are so obviously staged to make Wakefield appear sympathetic that the only reaction from someone who is familiar with Wakefield’s history is an intense desire to barf. For instance, early in the film, Wakefield is shown driving his son to rugby practice and asking him if he thinks his dad’s a “bad guy.” What on earth is a teenaged boy supposed to say in response to a question like that from his father, particularly while on camera? Of course, he says he doesn’t think his dad is a bad guy. He also responds that he doesn’t believe the bad things he hears about his father but does believe the good things. Later in the film, we see a conversation between Wakefield and his mother in which she tells him that all his father, who was apparently too ill when the interview was filmed to travel to Texas, has ever wanted was for his son to be vindicated and exonerated before he dies and how his father had had a very difficult time with all the negative press coverage of Wakefield. We also learn that Wakefield never really explained to his parents why he left the Royal Free Hospital, and we’re treated to an emotional scene of Wakefield apologizing to his mother for that lapse.
In fairness, there is at least one segment where Wakefield doesn’t come off well at all. It is the part of the film describing the infamous birthday party incident. Those familiar with Wakefield’s history will recall that at his son James’ 10th birthday party, Wakefield decided it would be a good time to get some blood samples for normal controls for a study, offering the children £5 each to let a nurse draw their blood. Of course, such a practice is highly unethical; yet Wakefield, his wife, and his son James are all shown defending it. James claims it was fun and that the children were fighting to be first in line to get their blood drawn. Wakefield claims multiple times that what he did was ethical, even while admitting that he didn’t have the approval of an ethics board to do what he did. A video of him joking about it is then shown. This is a video that can be found on Brian Deer’s website, but it was also widely broadcast in the UK at the time it surfaced. (The film implies that Deer was the only source publicizing the video.) In it Wakefield jokes that two children passed out and one threw up all over his mother. Worse, the audience laughed. He also then contended that this is a market economy and that the kids would be asking for £10 next year. James and Carmel both claim that Wakefield was wrong, that nothing like that happened at the party, and basically excused it all as a misguided attempt at humor. I also can’t help but note that Wakefield said more than that at his talk and that it was actually far worse than what Bailey portrays.
Even so, despite that segment, The Pathological Optimist paints a portrait of Wakefield that is far more positive than not. Sure, you do get the feeling that he’s obsessed with conspiracy theories, mainly because he frequently claims that big pharma, the British medical establishment, and the US press are out to get him. Yes, we do see the birthday party incident, albeit with excuses from his son and wife. But the rest shows a devoted father, a persistent scientist adored by mothers of children with autism and other health issues, and someone willing to suffer rather than admit he was wrong. All the while Bailey basically lets him tell his side of the story (mostly) unanswered.
Which brings us to the next section.
A misleading portrait by omission
I started out this post by mentioning how the bias in a documentary can often be detected by what is omitted more than by what is shown. However, to know what is omitted requires a knowledge of the subject of the film, which is why omission is such a powerful technique. After all, it’s safe to say that relatively few people know a lot about Wakefield’s history, which means that they won’t know the context that was omitted in so many places in the film. There are so many examples, that it’s hard to decide what to include, lest this post balloon to a length even longer than my usual logorrhea. A few examples do stick out, however.
Early in the film, Wakefield claims that his now-retracted 1998 Lancet case series has been “scrutinized unlike any article in the history of science,” which may or may not be true. (I vote for not true, but hyperbole can be allowed.) Then we see his legal team pulling a play straight from the Wakefield playbook and pointing to a single sentence in the paper:
We did not prove an association between measles, mumps, and rubella vaccine and the syndrome described.
Yes, it’s true. The paper itself did say that. However, after you’ve been in the science biz a while, you come to recognize statements that are almost certainly there not because the author wants them to be there but because the reviewers of the manuscript forced the author to include them in the revised manuscript if they wanted their paper published. The above passage strikes this surgical scientist as being just one of those statements demanded by reviewers. One reason is that it sticks out like a sore thumb from the rest of the discussion; it caught my attention when I read it because it didn’t jibe with the rest. Moreover, Table 2 in the paper explicitly tries to link MMR vaccination to subsequent autistic regression and bowel symptoms. What the paper is trying to show is very clear, that one disclaimer notwithstanding, and those who know how to read scientific and medical journal articles can recognize that. Reinforcing that impression is what Wakefield writes later in the manuscript:
If there is a causal link between measles, mumps, and rubella vaccine and this syndrome, a rising incidence might be anticipated after the introduction of this vaccine in the UK in 1988.
And
We have identified a chronic enterocolitis in children that may be related to neuropsychiatric dysfunction. In most cases, onset of symptoms was after measles, mumps, and rubella immunisation. Further investigations are needed to examine this syndrome and its possible relation to this vaccine.
Now, it is true that later Wakefield is briefly shown in an interview from what looks like the 20 minute video the Royal Free Hospital released around the time the Lancet paper was published, but it is not until much later in the film. What is shown right after Wakefield’s lawyer honing in on that one sentence is Wakefield giving talks to antivaccine groups about how the MMR vaccine causes autism. In any case, the context was not provided immediately, and it should have been. Anyone who’s followed Wakefield knows that that video was a doozy, with Wakefield making a number of claims about how he thought a link between MMR and autism needed to be urgently investigated. Parents got the message Wakefield was laying down then. He implied it in the paper, but he said it explicitly in many appearances after the paper was published. Wakefield was telling British parents that the MMR could cause autism. Oh, sure, he qualified it with enough weasel words to appear cautious, but basically recommended that parents get single vaccines, rather than the trivalent vaccine (MMR), because the MMR was somehow not as safe, because he thought that it could autistic regression. It’s all there, and it’s all clear. It worked, too, aided and abetted by the sensation-mongering credulous British press.
Elsewhere in the film, Wakefield takes issue with Brian Deer’s claim that he had a patent for a competing measles vaccine, as reported by Brian Deer. And indeed he did file such a patent. Deer has a copy on his website. The patent is for a “combined vaccine/therapeutic agent” that is safer and can treat inflammatory bowel disease as well. In that patent, he also states that he has “found that regressive behavioural disorder (RBD) is associated with measles, mumps, and rubella (MMR) vaccination.” In any case, in the film, Wakefield makes a massive straw man of what Deer reported, claiming that his MMR-autism claims were all a scam intended to discredit the MMR so that he could bring his own single measles vaccine to market and thereby bring down the pharmaceutical companies. Of course Deer’s claims were more modest and nuanced. For instance, we know Wakefield was paid by a lawyer to undertake research to link MMR to autism. So there’s one motivation. We also know that he did indeed have a patent for his own MMR vaccine, which by no coincidence claimed that this new vaccine could also to treat inflammatory bowel disease.
Wakefield then goes on to cite how he was going to use something called transfer factor in his new vaccine to “boost immunity.” Sounds benign, right? Yet somehow Bailey neglected to point out another very important aspect of Deer’s reporting on this patent. Basically, transfer factor is pure quackery thought up by Hugh Fudenberg. For those of you who haven’t heard of him before, the late Hugh Fudenberg was a collaborator and co-inventor with Andrew Wakefield. Dr. Fudenberg also happens to have been involved in some very dubious “treatments” for autism that led to some problems with his medical license. In November 1995, the South Carolina Medical Board concluded that Fudenberg was “guilty of engaging in dishonorable, unethical, or unprofessional conduct,” and he was fined $10,000 and ordered to surrender his license to prescribe controlled substances (narcotic drugs). His medical license was also placed on suspension. In March 1996, he was permitted to resume practice under terms of probation that did not permit him to prescribe any drugs. His medical license expired in January 2004; and in March 2004, he applied to have it reinstated. However, after a hearing in which the Board considered a neuropsychatric report issued in 2003, Fudenberg agreed to remain in a “retired” status and withdrew his application for reactivation of his license.
Later, Dr. Fudenberg ran a nonprofit “research” organization called Neuro Immunotherapeutics Research Foundation that sold dubious remedies for autism. He also charged $750 per hour for “review of past medical records,” $750 per hour for “determining what new tests need to be ordered; ordering of new tests; evaluation of new tests,” and $750 per hour for “determining which therapy will work and which will not; discussing this with patient along with an in-depth study of past medical history to determine what makes a patient better or worse.” If you look at Fudenberg’s PubMed publication list, you’ll find that there is nothing after around 1989 other than review articles, speculative articles in Medical Hypotheses, plus a fair number of publications on his “transfer factor” in low impact journals such as Biotherapy. Looking at the list, a knowledgeable person can tell right about when Dr. Fudenberg started to descend into fringe medicine, sometime between 1985 and 1989.
In any case, the specific dubious autism treatment with which Dr. Fudenberg was involved is the use of something called “transfer factor” to make a combined measles vaccine and autism “cure.” The method of making these so-called “transfer factors” is bizarre in the extreme and involves injecting mice with measles, extracting and processing white blood cells, injecting the result into pregnant goats, milking the goats after kid-birth and turning the product into capsules for autistic children. In a patent application (based in part on the infamous Lancet paper) obtained by Brian Deer, Wakefield represented a vaccine/therapy for “MMR-based” autism using transfer factor as potentially a “complete cure” for autism or for “alleviation of symptoms.”
Oh, and Fudenberg liked to claim that the flu vaccine causes Alzheimer’s disease.
Another closely-related example of misinformation by omission involves how the film treats the case of John Walker-Smith, who was a co-investigator with Wakefield in his 1998 Lancet paper. Prof. Walker-Smith was also struck off the British medical register (lost his medical license) along with Wakefield for, like Wakefield, research fraud. Unlike Wakefield, Walker-Smith appealed. More than that, he actually won his appeal and was reinstated. Bailey lets Wakefield portray the fact that Walker-Smith was exonerated by the British General Medical Council as a slam dunk reason that he should be exonerated too. It wasn’t. Basically, Walker-Smith prevailed because he convinced the Council that he didn’t believe he was doing research, but rather routine clinical care of the children in the Lancet case series. In actuality, the ruling was rather contradictory in that the ruling acknowledged that what Walker-Smith did could be reasonably viewed as research, but exonerated him because it could also be viewed as therapeutic:
The panel made no express finding on this issue and cannot have appreciated the need to do so. It was not helped by the premise upon which the GMC’s case was founded. There was a good deal of evidence, to which I refer in greater detail below, that Professor Walker-Smith and his team were undertaking what any reasonable body of medical practitioners would categorize as research – but also that he intended and genuinely believed that what he was doing was solely or primarily for the clinical benefit of the children. When such an issue arises, a panel will almost always have to determine the honesty or otherwise of the practitioner.
In other words, the ruling, as muddled and demonstrating a poor grasp of medical ethics, says nothing about Wakefield, nor does it exonerate him. After all, Wakefield clearly knew he was doing research. Yet Bailey makes a big deal of how Walker-Smith’s exoneration was “underreported.”
It’s also mentioned in the film that the Vaccine Court “admitted” in a case that vaccines cause autism. I wasn’t sure what case was being referred to in the film, but fortunately she tells us in an interview:
It seemed like every 6 months or so something big was going to come out and turn Andy’s life around. Some story would finally show the world that they were wrong to take away Andy’s license. For example while we were filming him a child named Hannah Poling and her family were awarded over a million dollars for vaccine induced autisim [sic] in a US court. This was a big deal in the Wakefield supporter communities because the media was shouting at them that vaccines don’t cause autism and that anyone who thinks or says they do is a quack. Yet our own US government admitted it in this case. Andy and the people around him thought this would be big news and change the media’s opinion about them. . . but nothing happened. It was crickets.
That’s because the Vaccine Court did not “admit” that vaccines cause autism in the Hannah Poling case. I note that in the same interview Bailey says that she’s “not saying that because Walker Smith was exonerated that Wakefield should have been, but surely it is big news completely blacked out in the same US media that so fervently reported on Andrew’s fraud in the BMJ in 2011 and continues to do so to this day.” Note the disingenuous comparison. Somehow, I don’t believe her disclaimer that she doesn’t think that Walker-Smith’s exoneration means that Wakefield should have been exonerated too, and only someone sympathetic to Wakefield would think that Walker-Smith’s exoneration should be big news on par with Brian Deer’s reports of Wakefield’s fraud.
Of course, I can’t help but note that in her film’s portrayal of how VAXXED was accepted and then eliminated from the Tribeca Film Festival last year, Bailey neglects to mention that Robert De Niro bypassed the usual selection committees and abused his position as founder of the festival to include VAXXED in his festival. Instead, she portrays the uproar and De Niro’s subsequent decision to cut VAXXED from the Tribeca Film Festival as yet more of the seemingly irrational persecution of Wakefield.
Bias is as bias does
Clearly, The Pathological Optimist has a point of view, and that point of view is obviously sympathetic to Andrew Wakefield. A particularly telling example was reported in Jezebel in an article by Ellie Shechet entitled “How Not to Make a Documentary About Vaccines.” If there is a subtle framing in the film that lets you know whose side the filmmaker is on, it’s Bailey’s treatment of Brian Deer, who is frequently portrayed as the antagonist and at one point shown being jeered down by Wakefield supporters as he tries to comment on Wakefield’s losing his medical license.
Shechet first notes that the only people who speak directly to the camera in Bailey’s movie are Wakefield and his family: Wakefield, his wife, his children, his brother, two of his lawyers, a few fans at his book signings, and a supporter of Wakefield’s who believes her son became autistic immediately after receiving the MMR vaccine. I also can’t help but notice that that mother is Jennifer Larson. What we are not told about her is that she is a wealthy woman who’s become an influential antivaccine activist and political donor who has used her money to try to influence Congress to hold hearings on vaccines and autism. In the film, she’s portrayed as nothing more than a mother who believes that vaccines caused her son’s autism, and Wakefield is portrayed as the kindly champion who admires the boy’s art. All of this was in the context of a segment showing how antivaccine protestors rallied near the University of Wisconsin when Brian Deer was invited to speak to the journalism school there in 2012. Antivaxers demanded that Wakefield be allowed to appear to rebut Deer’s charges and lamented that there was “no debate.” Wakefield, ever the publicity hound, obligingly showed up for the spectacle. In The Pathological Optimist, this incident is framed entirely as a fear on Deer’s and UW’s part of a “debate.”
In any case, at the end of the film shortly before the credits, we see this:

It turns out that that Wisconsin incident was very important, because that’s the pretext that Bailey’s team used to reach out to Deer, who notes that in September 2012 he got an email from Gabriel Geer asking if he’d be willing to be interviewed while he was in Wisconsin. Deer responded:
So, forearmed against the unethical, in September 2012, I responded to the email from Geer. “Forgive me for being somewhat cautious,” I wrote, “but I have seen what has happened in the field of Aids denialism, where people have cooperated in good faith with documentary makers only to find themselves presented in unexpected and unfair contexts.”
I alluded to the Golding scam, and added: “In the UK, where I’ve made films, we normally tell participants things like the names of the producers, the drift of the project and the context within which the participant might feature. So I would really need a better idea of what you had in mind.”
I can think of other examples, too, such as Richard Dawkins being misled about the nature of the anti-evolution film Expelled! when interviewed and Paul Offit (as well as other pro-vaccine doctors and scientists) being misled on the nature of the antivaccine film The Greater Good (which Miranda Bailey loved, by the way, citing a glowing review by über-quack Joe Mercola).
Deer exchanged e-mails, during which Bailey’s team described the genesis of the project and how it was to be about the “MMR controversies.” Deer then discovered:
What I didn’t know then, but I do know now, is that whoever wrote that email was lying. They weren’t making a film “about the MMR controversies”. For the previous 19 months, they had been working with Wakefield, filming with him in staged and choreographed sequences, as he pursued a vexatious and hopeless gagging lawsuit against me and the British Medical Journal.
And:
I’m not just featured in “The Pathological Optimist”. The structure of the film is essentially a series of replies to video snips featuring me. A few-second clip from CNN, for example, will be screened to begin a false account from Wakefield, melding lengthy public relations sequences (including dogs, children, and breakfast tables) with sly interviews in which Bailey and her people feed him opportunities to fool the audience.
It’s a glorification of the former doctor, and a highly motivated, personal attack on one individual: me.
I’m not quite sure the attack was that personal, but Deer’s quite correct that the structure of the film was basically a series of answers by Andrew Wakefield to charges made by Deer in his well-documented reporting, all with no evidence other than that Wakefield said it. It’s not just Deer, though. A certain friend of the blog features in the film as well. At around a third of the way through the film, Wakefield is seen perusing posts about him, and this 2012 post is shown. As Wakefield peruses it, he says:
I’m looking at bullshit from a guy who calls himself Orac who doesn’t have the cojones [note: mispronounced] to put his name to his website. Every other word is garbage. It’s just wrong. It’s offensive to me to actually be on this website; so if you don’t mind I’m going to get off it.
Trust me. Orac’s life is now complete. It is unlikely that he will have a more satisfying experience in blogging than knowing that he pissed off Andrew Wakefield. I know. Also, given that Orac’s real identity is about the worst kept secret on the Internet (and was in 2012) Wakefield and/or Bailey almost certainly intentionally declined to mention it so that they could disingenuously use the “anonymous cowardly attacker” gambit against Orac. In any event, right after this, Wakefield makes fun of Seth Mnookin’s appearance as he clicks on a link to an article by the Good Thinking Society announcing that Wakefield had beat out Prince Charles for the Golden Duck Lifetime Achievement Award for his contribution to quackery. Ultimately, he dismisses his critics by saying:
It’s fascinating what people waste their time doing when they’ve really got nothing to contribute to society whatsoever.
Obviously, I don’t in any way mean to say that this little swipe against Orac and the Good Thinking Society is in any way as relentless or bad as the pointed attempts to refute and cast aspersions on Brian Deer throughout the movie. I mention it mainly because the movie does at times get just this petty. (Also, because Orac loves it that something he wrote irritated Wakefield this much.)
Finally, to bring it all back around to my original point in closing, remember how I said that a film’s bias can be identified at least as much by what it decides not to show as by what it does show? Shechet zeroes right in on this. Noting that when she asked Bailey “if they’d reached out to anyone else who could provide a counter-argument to various things Wakefield and others say throughout the film,” Bailey responded that the style of documentary she was aiming for was cinéma vérité, which would make such counterarguments difficult to weave in:
“Once the style of the film found itself, which was not the style of, you know, a news show—once it was clear that it was a character study about this figure in history, then it felt like, when you’d have those things, they weren’t attached to the character study and it seemed like a messy concept,” Bailey told me.
“I’m not a newsperson, I’m not there to show a balanced—I’m not Fox News, I don’t need to do interviews. Interviews are boring, also.”
If interviews are so “boring, why did Bailey include so many of them with Wakefield, his family, and his ardent supporters? Inquiring minds want to know.
It gets worse, though. Here’s more of Bailey justifying her style:
I gather that your question to me is really wanting me to answer why I didn’t show interviews of other people who can tell me that Wakefield is a fraud, and a charlatan etc. Well, that information is already out there. It’s in every piece of news we read about him. If you are familiar with the story you already know all of that. I wanted to show you what you haven’t seen which is inside his life living with these charges.
This is, of course, complete and utter nonsense. Shechet drolly counters that the “expectation that a viewer would come to the documentary with extensive foreknowledge isn’t really a fair one, or one likely to result in clarity.” No kidding.
She also nails it again:
You can refute some of his statements, and question him about his discrepancies, and show news footage of Anderson Cooper reaming him on CNN, but the decision to physically focus this documentary entirely within Andrew Wakefield’s perspective, giving him and his family an opportunity to repaint himself as wronged and his research as ethical when there is quite a lot of evidence to the contrary, is an odd one, given the stakes of the subject matter.
Remember what I said about omission, folks. Miranda Bailey is either lying or deluding herself when she asserts that The Pathological Optimist “takes no sides.” Of course it does, and the side it takes is unequivocally Wakefield’s. It couldn’t be otherwise. Does anyone really think that Wakefield would have given Bailey—or any filmmaker—such close access to him and his family for five years if he had any doubts whatsoever that the result would be anything other than a film that allows him unfettered opportunity to argue his position more or less unrefuted and paints him as the brave doctor only in it “for the children”? Of course he wouldn’t. If you look at the film’s website, you’ll see that he’s even appearing with Bailey for Q&A sessions after some screenings:
Join me TODAY at the @laemmle Santa Monica for Q&A w/ Dr. Andrew Wakefield @ director @mirandambailey following #ThePathologicalOptimist! pic.twitter.com/W0bDlXWUpU
— Scott Mantz (@MovieMantz) October 8, 2017
Indeed, in the closing credits, Bailey makes it clear just how much she identifies with Wakefield. Partway through the credits, there is text stating that the “director of this documentary received an e-mail from her lawyer asking her to call him.” After this, as the rest of the credits continue to roll, we hear a recorded phone call between Bailey and her lawyer in which her lawyer says that he was chatting with Bailey’s agent and that they both have “concerns” about the film she was making, specifically how this might affect her and whether she should “continue to go forward with it in light of what’s been going on with his [Wakefield’s] documentary and the backlash and all.” He goes on to warn that that controversy could transfer to Bailey and affect her career and reputation. He ends by saying “Can you handle that?” No answer is given. We reach the end of the credits, which is obviously her answer to her lawyer’s question.
I fear that this film will be far more damaging than VAXXED. After all, VAXXED never pretends to be anything but a vehicle for Wakefield to try to rehabilitate his reputation. In contrast, The Pathological Optimist is made by a real filmmaker who’s been successful in topics unrelated to vaccines, which means that the mainstream media and filmgoers will take it a lot more seriously than VAXXED could ever be taken.

VAXXED and the Tribeca Film Festival: How Robert De Niro learned the hard way about Andrew Wakefield and the antivaccine movement
Disgraced antivaccine doctor, Andrew Wakefield, managed to pull another fast one. His antivaccine propaganda film, VAXXED, was mysteriously accepted for a screening at the Tribeca Film Festival. It turns out that TFF co-founder Robert De Niro had pulled some strings. The well-deserved backlash provides yet another example of how Andrew Wakefield discredits everything he touches.
David Gorski on March 28, 2016
Link


One of the disadvantages of only doing one blog post a week here at Science-Based Medicine is that sometimes stuff happens at too fast a pace for me. If something happens on Tuesday, by the time Sunday rolls around and it’s time for me to do my weekly post, it’s often old news, too old to bother with. That’s why it’s a good thing that I have my not-so-super-secret other blog, where I can keep up with such events. On the other hand, the advantage of a once-a-week posting schedule is that there are times I can look back at a story that evolved over the last week and, instead of blogging about it in daily chunks, I can put together a post that tells the whole story and puts it in context. Something like that happened last week. The beauty of it is that I played a major role in bringing the story to public consciousness, followed the story as it evolved, and now can provide a fairly complete recounting. Or so I hope.
First, however, let’s take advantage of another good thing about waiting to blog about a story, namely getting to see the reactions of quacks to what happened. No one can do it better than everybody’s favorite all around quack, crank, and all-purpose conspiracy theorist Mike Adams, who greeted me yesterday morning with this headline: VAXXED film pulled from Robert De Niro’s Tribeca Film Festival following totalitarian censorship demands from pharma-linked vaccine pushers and media science trolls. What on earth is Adams talking about, you might wonder? In case you haven’t been following the news, here’s a link to the New York Times story on the same incident: “Robert De Niro Pulls Anti-Vaccine Documentary From Tribeca Film Festival.” Basically, the 2016 Tribeca Film Festival selected an antivaccine documentary directed by Andrew Wakefield for screening and then thought better of it after a major uproar and a whole boatload of bad press.
I’ll deal with Adams’ post a bit later because it’s so hilariously nutty but also because it is basically the propaganda line that antivaccinationists are putting on this PR debacle brought about by Andrew Wakefield and Robert De Niro. (I never thought I’d use those two names in the same sentence.) Let’s go back a week and see what I mean.
The Tribeca Film Festival announces it will screen Andrew Wakefield’s antivaccine propaganda “documentary”
Film lovers among our readers are probably already familiar with the Tribeca Film Festival, as it’s one of the largest and most prestigious film festivals on the yearly calendar. Founded in 2002 by Jane Rosenthal, Robert De Niro, and Craig Hatkoff, the festival has grown into a major film juggernaut, and thousands of films are submitted each year for consideration. So it was with considerable surprise when last Monday I noted several announcements, discussions on Facebook, and gleeful Tweets and blog posts by antivaccine activists about how Andrew Wakefield’s antivaccine propaganda film, Vaxxed: From Cover-up to Catastrophe, had been selected for a screening at the Tribeca Film Festival. Here’s why.
When last we left Andrew Wakefield, hero to the antivaccine movement, he was a headliner on the Conspira-Sea Cruise, a cruise filled with conspiracy theorists, crop circle chasers, cranks, quacks, and antivaccine activists. It was a huge come down from his formerly exalted position as chief spokesman and “scientist” for the antivaccine movement, a position he enjoyed for many years before he was struck off (i.e., had his medical license stripped from him) in the UK and later had his scientific fraud documented so thoroughly by investigative reporter Brian Deer. Since then, it’s all been downhill, and, although his followers like to claim that he’s been done wrong and exonerated, he’s been neither. In January, it looked as though Wakefield had hit bottom, having been reduced to giving talks to adoring conspiracy cranks on the same podium as crop circle chasers. The only cranks missing were Bigfoot hunters. It was an incredibly appropriate venue for him, although no doubt he didn’t think so.
Regular readers might remember in the stories about Andrew Wakefield’s most excellent cruise adventure, such as the one by Anna Merlan, that Wakefield screened a documentary that he had been working on. It was going to be about the latest conspiracy theory coming out of the fever swamp of antivaccine pseudoscience, the so-called “CDC Whistleblower” William W. Thompson. Thompson, as you recall, is the CDC scientist who complained to Brian Hooker, a biochemical-engineer-turned-incompetent-antivaccine-epidemiologist, that the analysis of important study done by his colleagues at the CDC in 2004 and him (DeStefano et al) was manipulated to hide a real positive result correlating MMR vaccination with autism in African-Americans. As I said at the time, Hooker’s “reanalysis” of the DeStefano et al study basically proved Andrew Wakefield wrong in that, other than for a very small subgroup, there wasn’t a hint of a whiff of a whisper of a positive correlation between the MMR vaccine and autism, and the one seemingly positive result was almost certainly spurious. It was only because of Hooker’s utter incompetence at epidemiology and statistics that he foolishly inferred an actual result from his “reanalysis.”
Because this story seemed to confirm what I like to call the central conspiracy theory of the antivaccine movement, namely that the CDC or other government agencies “knew” that vaccines cause autism but hid it from the people, the so-called “CDC whistleblower” conspiracy theory was born. Unfortunately, it has legs, too, as it was in August 2014 when Andrew Wakefield and Brian Hooker “outed” Thompson in a horrific video that compared this alleged CDC “coverup” to the Tuskegee syphilis experiment. Since then, #CDCwhistleblower has become a very common hashtag on Twitter, where antivaccine activists have pounded this conspiracy theory relentlessly to amplify their message. Of course, only antivaccine activists are not “sheeple.” Only they know The Truth.
And, as of less than a week ago, that “Truth” was going to get a screening at the Tribeca Film Festival.
Vaxxed: A conspiracy theory propaganda film masquerading as a documentary
Basically, you can tell from the trailer alone that this is what Wakefield’s movie is about. You can also tell just how bad it is:
The film is described thusly on the Vaxxed website:
In 2014, biologist Dr. Brian Hooker received a call from a Senior Scientist at the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) who led the agency’s 2004 study on the Measles-Mumps-Rubella (MMR) vaccine and its link to autism. The scientist, Dr. William Thompson, confessed that the CDC had omitted crucial data in their final report that revealed a causal relationship between the MMR vaccine and autism.
Over several months, Dr. Hooker records the phone calls made to him by Dr. Thompson who provides the confidential data destroyed by his colleagues at the CDC. Dr. Hooker enlists the help of Dr. Andrew Wakefield, the British gastroenterologist falsely accused of starting the anti-vax movement when he first reported in 1998 that the MMR vaccine may cause autism. In his ongoing effort to advocate for children’s health, Wakefield directs this documentary examining the evidence behind an appalling cover-up committed by the government agency charged with protecting the health of American citizens. Interviews with pharmaceutical insiders, doctors, politicians, and parents of vaccine-injured children reveal an alarming deception that has contributed to the skyrocketing increase of autism and potentially the most catastrophic epidemic of our lifetime.
The trailer, as you might expect, is a greatest hits of “CDC Whistleblower” conspiracy nonsense, beginning with a hilariously inept reenactment of Brian Hooker receiving his first phone call form William Thompson, after which “medical journalist” Del Bigtree starts bloviating about how Thompson told Hooker that the his coauthors, Frank DeStefano et al, had committed scientific fraud in its analysis of the data for their study. Of course, we all know now that nothing of the sort happened and that Thompson never accused his coauthors of fraud, although he sure did make it sound as though there was something not quite on the up and up about the way they analyzed their data. Unfortunately, conspiracy-friendly journalists ate it up. Meanwhile Hooker’s “reanalysis” was so bad that the paper reporting it was retracted, even by a new journal.
Particularly deceptive is a segment that occurs around 1:22 in the trailer, a cartoon that depicts a large syringe with green liquid in it in surrounding a girl with a Teddy Bear, clearly meant to represent a vaccine, presumably the MMR given the whole focus on the “CDC Whistleblower.” The animation is clearly meant to imply that the vaccine is toxic. Why is this deceptive? In the context of his “reanalysis” of the CDC dataset facilitated by Thompson, among Caucasian girls, even Brian Hooker couldn’t torture the data to make them “confess” to a correlation between vaccinating girls and an increased risk of autism. So why didn’t Wakefield choose to put an African-American boy in the syringe? After all, when Brian Hooker tortured the data, all he could get them to confess to was a correlation in a subset of African-American boys? Perhaps Wakefield knows his audience well and therefore considered the image of the white girl with a Teddy Bear more palatable for a trailer than that of an African-American boy.
True, later in the trailer children of all races are shown, but that seems to be just a means to imply that Hooker’s results are generalizable beyond African-American boys. Even if they were real results (which they are not), based on sound statistical analysis (Hooker’s statistical “analysis” was anything but sound), Hooker found no link in any other subgroup besides one group of African-American boys. Basically, the filmmaker is making a blatantly obvious attempt to take a single result from an incompetent “reanalysis” of DeStefano et al and suggest to the audience that the results apply to all children.
Later, to my surprise, Dr. Jim Sears shows up at around the 2:00 mark, thus shattering any of his claims that he isn’t antivaccine yet again. (Usually it’s “Dr. Bob” Sears who’s spewing the antivaccine misinformation.) After all, you don’t appear in a movie directed by Andrew Wakefield saying that Wakefield was right after all if you have a shred of scientific knowledge—or dignity—left or if you are not at least antivaccine-sympathetic, if not outright antivaccine. Sears is followed by Rep. Bill Posey (R-FL), whose swallowing of the misinformation promoted by Hooker and Thompson helped perpetuate the whole “CDC whistleblower” urban myth. He’s rapidly followed by Stephanie Seneff, someone with no expertise in epidemiology who thinks she can do autism epidemiology. Hilariously (to me), she claims that, if we extrapolate current trends, by 2032 80% of boys will be autistic. What’s particularly silly is that Seneff isn’t even an MMR crank. She’s a GMO crank, the author of a risibly bad paper blaming autism on glyphosate and another blaming it on aluminum adjuvants.
Finally, it’s interesting to consider others involved in the film. For example, there is Del Bigtree, who produced Vaxxed. It turns out that he also has produced a number of episodes and segments of The Doctors, which could explain how Jim Sears was roped into appearing in Vaxxed. I couldn’t help but notice, though, that Sears appears not to be a principal “doctor” any more on The Doctors. His name is no longer on the show’s website, although he has appeared in two episodes in 2016. But that’s not all. There was another unexpected surprise in the cast. I’m referring to Sharyl Attkisson, former CBS correspondent and die-hard antivaccine believer, as has been documented many times going back to 2007. Her connection to Wakefield dates back at least as far as 2008, but she is most “known” in antivaccine circles for her utterly dishonest reporting of the murder of an autistic teen named Alex Spourdalakis. She’s still at it, too.
Tribeca responds to the backlash
It’s clear that Vaxxed is an utter crankfest of a movie, far more antivaccine propaganda than any attempt at a serious treatment of a subject, which is why it’s not surprising that there was such an uproar among scientists, physicians, and skeptics when its selection was announced. At first, the organizers of the Tribeca Film Festival seemed to be taken aback by the controversy. Its first response was:
Tribeca, as most film festivals, are about dialogue and discussion. Over the years we have presented many films from opposing sides of an issue. We are a forum, not a judge
“We are a forum, not a judge.” Let’s examine that assertion for a moment. It’s a common excuse made by, for example, reporters for “telling both sides” about scientific issues. Here’s the problem. This sort of attitude might make sense for social and political issues, but science is different, because in science, unlike the case in social or political issues, there is very often a right answer, and, more importantly, there are very often answers that are clearly wrong based on science. (Guess which category Andrew Wakefield’s views fall into?) You can have all the “dialogue and discussion” you want about a scientific topic, such as the question of whether vaccines cause autism, but at the end of the day there is a correct answer based on science. Within a very small margin of error, the existing scientific evidence strongly supports the conclusion that vaccines do not cause autism, and it’s not as though this question hasn’t been studied many, many times. Indeed, we’ve discussed the issue on this blog many, many times.
Let’s look at this another way. The question of whether or not vaccines cause autism is very much like other scientific questions, questions such as: Did the diversity of life arise through undirected evolution?
There are people who believe that the diversity of life did not arise through undirected evolution. They are called creationists or intelligent design creationists. Creationists believe God created all creatures in their original form, which hasn’t changed. Some young earth creationists believe the earth is only 6,000 years old. Intelligent design creationists, in contrast, believe that living organisms evolve, but that their evolution is somehow “directed,” that there is a “designer” (cough, cough, God) directing that evolution. Of course, from a scientific standpoint, none of these are scientific controversies. There is no science involved in their claims; in fact, science refutes their claims, as it does for the claims of believers in antivaccine pseudoscience. Would the Tribeca Film Festival organizers select a film by, for instance, Ken Ham claiming that the earth is only 6,000 years old and that evolution is a sham? Would they do it for the sake of “dialogue and discussion” as part of a “forum”? Would the Tribeca film festival screen the anti-evolution film the dishonest Expelled! No Intelligence Allowed or a film like it? Somehow I doubt it. Yet they have just done the equivalent by letting Andrew Wakefield use the imprimatur of their festival screen his conspiracy- and pseudoscience-laden film.
I can see the organizers retorting that, sure, maybe the science is against Wakefield, but what about the whole “CDC whistleblower” conspiracy, which is what the movie appears to be mainly about. As has been written so many times before, there’s just no “there” there to that story. It’s worse than that, though, particularly with respect to this movie.
Just how worse this “documentary” was, was documented by Matt Carey, who did a masterful job of demonstrating how Wakefield deceptively edited recorded statements from William Thompson (a.k.a. the “CDC whistleblower,” the scientist who was critical of a 2004 study that failed to find a link between the MMR vaccine and autism, the same study tortured by Brian Hooker to appear to show a greatly increased risk of autism in a subset of African-American males) to give a very different impression than the actual transcripts give. You really should read all of Matt’s post, but the CliffsNotes version is that Wakefield spliced two statements by Thompson together to make it sound as though Thompson was introducing himself to Hooker and then stating that he had “great shame” now because he knew Hooker had a son with autism, all as a prelude to alleging that the CDC had committed scientific fraud when in fact Thompson never really said anything of the sort. In reality, the statements were phone conversations much later in the Hooker-Thompson relationship, and Thompson, although complaining about a disagreement in methodology in the study never accused his colleagues at the CDC of scientific fraud. In fact, he even said:
The fact that we found a strong statistically significant finding among black males does not mean that there was a true association between the MMR vaccine and autism-like features in this subpopulation.
Thompson just wanted more research, or at least that’s all he’s ever said in any public statements or any of his phone calls with Hooker that have been published.
So basically, what we had mid-week was a film selection for the Tribeca Film Festival that was causing increasing consternation both among science advocates and filmmakers. Indeed, filmmaker Penny Lane wrote an epic Open Letter to the Tribeca Film Festival that she posted on her Facebook page that explains exactly why Vaxxed is different from other documentaries that take a controversial stance on a contentious issue and just why Tribeca’s defense was so disingenuous:
Here is the problem with your statement: it assumes that Vaxxed is just like any other film taking on an unpopular, controversial or provocative subject. It is not. There is a big difference between advocacy and fraud, between point of view and deception. For you to claim there is no difference, and for you to screen this film, perpetuates Wakefield’s fraud.
Exactly.
Robert De Niro confesses
As the week progressed, I kept asking myself: How on earth did a film as fraudulent as Vaxxed manage to get accepted for screening at the Tribeca Film Festival, complete with a Q&A afterwards? Those who’ve followed the story might also recall that elsewhere I speculated, based on Andrew Wakefield’s having bragged to the faithful that Leonardo DiCaprio was promoting his film, even though later he denied that he had ever said such a thing. Of course, it’s not as though Hollywood in particular and the film making community in general isn’t full of people with antivaccine views. Consequently, other possibilities that I considered included either that one or more of the people tasked with selecting films for the festival had greased the wheels, or even one of the Tribeca Film Festival’s founders, such as Robert De Niro himself, had done so, noting that De Niro has an autistic child and has been involved with at least one Autism Speaks event, appearing with Suzanne and Bob Wright, as well as their daughter Katie.
To my surprise, my latter speculation turned out to be correct, as I learned when Tribeca did the classic Friday afternoon PR dump with this statement from Robert De Niro himself:
Grace and I have a child with autism and we believe it is critical that all of the issues surrounding the causes of autism be openly discussed and examined. In the 15 years since the Tribeca Film Festival was founded, I have never asked for a film to be screened or gotten involved in the programming. However this is very personal to me and my family and I want there to be a discussion, which is why we will be screening VAXXED. I am not personally endorsing the film, nor am I anti-vaccination; I am only providing the opportunity for a conversation around the issue.
I couldn’t believe that it actually was De Niro who got Vaxxed into Tribeca. In any case, I couldn’t help but think that if Robert De Niro and his wife Grace wanted to help their autistic child, “dialogue” generated by a propaganda film directed and written by a known scientific fraud whose UK medical license was revoked featuring a viewpoint trumpeting a long-discredited idea that MMR causes autism grafted onto a conspiracy theory about the CDC “covering up” the evidence that vaccines cause autism that has no basis in fact is not a good way to go about this.
Out of curiosity, I couldn’t help but try to figure out what film set my source had seen De Niro on. To answer this question, the most obvious things to do to try to figure this out are (1) see if De Niro had shot a film in Texas during the last decade or so, particularly near Austin, which is where Wakefield lives and (2) see if De Niro had ever done a movie with known antivaccinationists, particularly supporters of Wakefield. So I did. Regarding the latter, the first hit of a Google search about films made in Austin with Robert De Niro pulled up Machete. Being somewhat of a connoisseur of bad movies, I remembered enjoying this violent cheesefest of a film, particularly the character played by De Niro, a hilariously racist and corrupt Texas state senator. I also remembered something about the director of the movie, Robert Rodriguez, namely that he and his wife had provided Wakefield with a blurb for his book, Callous Disregard:
Meeting Dr. Andy Wakefield changed our lives and . . . we are forever grateful. His wise and measured advice about vaccinations helped us dodge a bullet . . . Our fourth son [had] multiple allergies and repeated infections . . . We now fully realize [he] would have been a victim of immune overload had we followed the regular vaccine schedule . . . [He] is [now] bright and healthy . . . This book provides a terrifying insight into what has been happening behind the scenes as efforts redouble to silence Dr. Wakefield . . . It is a wake-up call to those who think [he] is anything other than a modern day hero fighting for all of our children.
—Robert Rodriguez and Elizabeth Avellán, Troublemaker Studios, Austin, Texas
Let’s see. A movie filmed in Austin in which Robert De Niro was one of the stars? Check. A movie whose director and his wife are very antivaccine and tight with Wakefield? Check. Yes, I could well be wrong about this, but at this point I don’t think I need to look any further for how Robert De Niro’s wife probably met Andrew Wakefield. This looks like the most likely film set over the last decade where Wakefield would be allowed to show up and where De Niro was starring. Of course, if it wasn’t Rodriguez who introduced De Niro’s wife to Wakefield, it could have been any number of antivaccine actors, actresses, or filmmakers. Hollywood is rife with them.
If it was indeed Rodriguez and his wife, what happened after that, who knows? I can only speculate that De Niro’s wife Grace Hightower either introduced De Niro to Wakefield or, at Wakefield’s urging (and you know it had to be at Wakefield’s urging, as I highly doubt that Hightower or De Niro would volunteer to do this unbidden) lobbied her husband to show it. Given that Hightower is of African-American and Blackfoot descent herself, she might well have been more susceptible to the message that the CDC was covering up data showing that the MMR vaccine can cause autism in African-American boys. I further speculate that De Niro might have done this against his better judgment, given that the movie was scheduled for the last day of the festival, opposite a lot of award ceremonies.
Unfortunately, barring someone involved (other than Wakefield, of course) talking, we can never know for sure. My speculation could be totally off-base, but circumstantially it sure strikes me as reasonable.
A surprise decision
As angry as I was at him, as of Saturday I actually did still kind of feel sorry for Mr. De Niro. He wouldn’t be the first person conned by Wakefield on the basis of he and his wife having an autistic child, and his decision to intervene to bypass the normal selection process for Wakefield was producing disastrous consequences for him and his festival. In the wake of his press release, all manner of articles appeared, with titles such as “Robert De Niro just broke my heart“, castigating De Niro for having let Wakefield use his respected film festival as a vehicle to promote his antivaccine pseudoscience and conspiracy theories. Pretty much all the press Tribeca was receiving as of Saturday morning was bad press about screening Vaxxed. Meanwhile, ever their own worst enemies, the flying monkeys of the antivaccine movement had descended upon the Tribeca web page for Vaxxed, there to fling their poo of pseudoscience and nastiness so unhinged that surely it must have had an effect. Indeed, the last time I checked the total number of comments was over 2,000, and the crazies were truly out in force, including John Scudamore, the man responsible for Whale.to, one of the oldest and largest repositories of pseudoscience and quackery on the whole Interent. That, and Holocaust denial and anti-Semitism in the form of that old anti-Semitic forgery The Protocols of the Learned Elders of Zion. It’s a shame the page is now gone, because antivaccinationists are their own worst enemies, and it was amusing to behold. No doubt this influx had an effect on De Niro as well, as no rational, intelligent person could look at the sorts of things they were saying and not conclude that these people are total loons.
I say this was a surprise decision, given how resistant the culture among film makers is to anything that appears to be “censorship,” but maybe I shouldn’t have been. The only way to stop the bleeding due to De Niro’s self-inflicted wound was to issue this press release, which was done on Saturday afternoon:
My intent in screening this film was to provide an opportunity for conversation around an issue that is deeply personal to me and my family. But after reviewing it over the past few days with the Tribeca Film Festival team and others from the scientific community, we do not believe it contributes to or furthers the discussion I had hoped for.
The Festival doesn’t seek to avoid or shy away from controversy. However, we have concerns with certain things in this film that we feel prevent us from presenting it in the Festival program. We have decided to remove it from our schedule.
Interesting. It sounds as though De Niro never actually watched the film before okaying its inclusion in the Tribeca Film Festival and, with the help of people who actually knew something about vaccines and autism, realized that he’d been conned and was horrified. I wonder if “we have concerns with certain things in this film that we feel prevent us from presenting it in the Festival program” really means, “Oh, my god, how could I possibly have okayed a film this badly made and this obviously full of pseudoscientific nonsense and conspiracy theory claptrap?”
The name Wakefield should have been enough to tip him off.
No, this is not “censorship”
So in the end, science won this battle, with De Niro essentially admitting his error (without actually saying he made a mistake or apologizing—baby steps I guess) and having taken a step towards reclaiming the reputation of the Tribeca Film Festival by yanking Vaxxed. But it’s a victory I feel ambivalent about. Before I explain why, I can’t help but point out that I don’t feel the least bit ambivalent about reactions of the antivaccine fringe, like Mike Adams’ article and rants like this:
Yet De Niro discovered that even declaring yourself to be pro-vaccine isn’t enough to appease the vaccine totalitarians. The mere granting of any public platform to this explosive document is very nearly a crime in the eyes of the corrupt, fraudulent vaccine industry and all its arrogant zealots.
As more pressure was brought against De Niro for defending the free speech of what might be one of the single most important documentaries of our modern age, he caved. He pulled the film from Tribeca, participating in the censorship that was demanded by the vaccine totalitarians. The film’s page on Tribeca was also memory holed — it used to be found at this link — and De Niro felt compelled to issue a follow-up statement today that appeases the demands of the vaccine fundamentalists.
Earlier in the week, the “Media Editor” at that wretched hive of scum and quackery Age of Autism, Anne Dachel, had voiced similar cries of “censorship” over articles attacking the Tribeca Film Festival for including Vaxxed in its lineup.
Let me spell it out one more time for Ms. Dachel and Mr. Adams:
Criticism ≠ “censorship”
And:
Freedom of speech ≠ freedom from criticism
I hate this gambit, because it is so clueless.
Let’s take a look at what happened here. Robert De Niro, for whatever reason, made a huge mistake, choosing to bypass the regular selection process for the Tribeca Film Festival to include what even the trailer reveals to be a dishonest film that manipulates quotes from its subject, William Thompson, and promotes a dangerous pseudoscientific idea. Of course, the Tribeca Film Institute is a private corporation; it had the right to choose to screen any film its organizers wanted to screen. It could use any criteria and process that its organizers deemed appropriate. It could have, if it so desired, taken 3″ x 5″ cards with the name of each film entered into a big bowl and draw them at random or just had Robert De Niro, pick whatever he wanted the festival to show if that’s what it had wanted to do. There’s nothing any of us could do about that directly. Those of us on the pro-science side were also quite cognizant that in any film festival screening hundreds of films selected from thousands of submissions, there will be occasional—or even not-so-occasional—pieces of cinematic crap that slip through. Vaxxed, as said by Penny Lane, “smells” different than the run-of-the-mill bad movie that sometimes gets selected for film festivals, even ones as prestigious as Tribeca or Sundance.
What we could, should, and did do was to criticize and question the selection. We also had every right to start asking organizers of the Tribeca Film Festival how such a piece of scientific and cinematic dreck could have been selected. None of those of us writing critical articles called for “censorship.” The worst that we called for were (1) an accounting by the organizers of the festival for how this film was selected and (2) for skeptics to attend the screening in order to draw attention to the lies in the film and, quite frankly, to make Andy and his fellow filmmakers sweat with some uncomfortable—but polite!—questions that poke holes in the claims made in the film.
Seeing these criticisms, Robert De Niro first tried to defend his decision through the classic technique for dealing with bad PR, the Friday afternoon press release, and then the next day decided to reverse himself and pull the film. Why? In retrospect it is obvious that De Niro had no idea what he was doing when he agreed to have Vaxxed screened at Tribeca, because he clearly did not foresee the backlash. I’m sure that, motivated by his experiences with his autistic child, he thought he was doing a good thing that might help others with autistic children. That’s how Wakefield gets you.
Still, in a way I’m a bit disappointed. De Niro had made a horrible decision, but, once the decision had been made, I really didn’t expect it to be unmade. It would have been great to have some skeptics be among the first to see the movie in a venue that Wakefield could not completely control. I expect now that Vaxxed will probably see its first showing at an antivaccine quackfest like Autism One. Meanwhile, antivaxers like Mike Adams will portray this as yet more evidence of a “conspiracy” to suppress their viewpoint and will use it to fire up their followers. That’s why I’m not sure if this is a victory or not.
Whether this decision is a victory for science or not, Robert De Niro is now learning a painful lesson. He’s now finding out the hard way why those of us who’ve studied him say that Andrew Wakefield discredits anything he touches. That now includes the Tribeca Film Festival.

Reviewing Andrew Wakefield’s VAXXED: Antivaccine propaganda at its most pernicious
Antivaccine “hero” Andrew Wakefield has recruited Del Bigtree to help him make a movie about the “CDC whistleblower” manufactroversy and anti vaccine conspiracy theories in general. The results are so ham-fisted that they would make Leni Riefenstahl shout, “Zu viel!” (“Too much!”)
David Gorski on July 11, 2016
Link
I’ve finally seen it. I’ve finally seen Andrew Wakefield and Del Bigtree’s “documentary” VAXXED: From Cover-up to Catastrophe, and I didn’t even have to pay to see it! Now, having watched Wakefield and Bigtree’s “masterpiece,” I can quite confidently say that it’s every bit as accurate and balanced a picture of vaccine benefits and risks as Eric Merola’s two movies about the quack Stanislaw Burzynski and his Second Opinion: Laetrile at Sloan-Kettering are about cancer and cancer research, The Beautiful Truth is about the Gerson protocol for cancer, Simply Raw: Reversing Diabetes in 30 Days is about diet and diabetes, Expelled! No Intelligence Allowed is about evolution, and The Greater Good is about…vaccines! Of course, based on what I knew of the story, saw of the VAXXED trailer (which deceptively edited together statements by William Thompson), and have discussed about the efforts of Andrew Wakefield, Del Bigtree, and Polly Tommey to use VAXXED as a tool in a publicity campaign to try to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt (FUD) about vaccines using the “CDC whistleblower” conspiracy theory (about which a primer can be found here), I shouldn’t have been surprised, but I was actually surprised (slightly) at the manipulative depths to which this film sinks.
On the plus side, its production values are better than those Eric Merola’s films (although I, with no experience, could probably make a film with better production values than Merola), but that just makes it somewhat more effective propaganda. In my review and discussion of the movie and its claims, I will discuss the claims made by Bigtree and Wakefield as well as the movie as a movie. Unfortunately, there is so much misinformation in this 91 minute documentary that I will only be able to hit the “high” points without going far, far beyond even a Gorski level of logorrhea in this post. Worse, there is a considerable amount of dishonest framing, in which actual facts and events are presented in a deceptive manner to tell a distorted narrative. Before that, though, let’s meet the key players.
ADDENDUM May 19, 2023: The film has been posted to Rumble, for anyone to watch and judge how accurate my characterization is:
Dramatis personae
There are a lot of people featured in VAXXED. Some, like Andrew Wakefield, Del Bigtree, Brian Hooker, Sheila Ealey, and Polly Tommey, are featured extensively, some only briefly. It’s a rag tag bunch of vaccine-autism pseudoscientists, parents who sincerely but mistakenly believe their children were rendered autistic by the MMR vaccine, and a couple of TV doctors. A more complete list can be found here, but the main players are:
The star
Andrew Wakefield: Andrew Wakefield is the director of VAXXED and, as regular readers know, a British gastroenterologist who in 1998 published a 12-patient case series in The Lancet that claimed to have found a correlation between the MMR vaccine, autism, and bowel disease. Given the amount of screen time he gets and how much the narrative keeps circling back to him, Wakefield is undeniably intended as the star and central character in VAXXED, even though the story is purportedly about Brian Hooker and William Thompson, the “CDC whistleblower”. It was Wakefield’s case series that launched the antivaccine fear mongering about the MMR vaccine that led to MMR uptake plummeting in the UK and the resurgence of measles in the UK and Europe. Ultimately, the General Medical Council in the UK stripped Wakefield of his medical license for research misconduct; his Lancet paper was retracted; and he has since been reduced to doing conspiracy ocean cruises along with crop circle mavens, other antivaccine luminaries, and New World Order conspiracy theorists. Clearly, directing a film in which the director is a major part of the story is rather a massive conflict of interest, and, not surprisingly, much of VAXXED regurgitates the lies and misinformation that Wakefield has been spouting for the last 18 years, while Wakefield’s critics are portrayed in the most unflattering way possible or only in passing. Basically, a major theme of VAXXED is how the CDC whistleblower’s revelations exonerate Andy Wakefield and his “finding” that the MMR causes autism.
Also starring
Del Bigtree: Del Bigtree is the producer of VAXXED and is also featured a great deal in the movie. (The producer and director, both showing up a lot on camera? Who’da thunk it?) It is unclear why a television producer and filmmaker with no relevant background in medicine or science is so heavily featured, although I do admit to having laughed out loud when he bragged about having been a producer of “the best medical talk show in the world” (The Doctors). Let’s just put it this way: The Doctors is only slightly less quacky than The Dr. Oz Show but even more vapid. (Just check out its segment on vaccines from a few years back if you don’t believe me.) The IMDB tells me that Bigtree produced 30 episodes of The Doctors between 2010 and 2015 and was a field producer for two. He also produced some segments for The Dr. Phil Show. These are hardly the qualifications I’d expect for someone to competently tackle a topic like this. Like Wakefield, Bigtree also makes the story about him by opining about how he had to make this movie because the mainstream press wasn’t covering the CDC whistleblower, and the two seem to have a mutual admiration society bordering on a bromance going on.
Brian Hooker: Brian Hooker is a biochemical engineer who now fancies himself an epidemiologist. He is introduced as a scientist who’s published extensively. Unfortunately, the vast majority of those publications have nothing to do with vaccines or autism and the ones that do are terrible. The best example of this is his 2014 Translational Neurodegeneration paper containing his “reanalysis” of William Thompson’s data, which was ultimately retracted by the journal editor. (So Hooker and Wakefield share something in common!) He is portrayed as a “brave” scientist delving into secret CDC data (it’s not so secret) with the help of William Thompson to find what “they” didn’t want him to find.
William Thompson: I’ve written so much about William Thompson over the last two years that I’m getting tired of it. However, he is a key player in that he was a co-author on the 2004 DeStefano et al paper that failed to find a link between the MMR vaccine and autism. Wakefield and Bigtree try to use Thompson’s words contrasted with the negative result published in DeStefano et al as slam-dunk evidence that the CDC “covered up” data showing that vaccines cause autism in African-American children. In a fit of payback to his colleagues, Thompson had multiple conversations with Brian Hooker alleging scientific misconduct at the CDC. Unfortunately for him, Thompson did not know that Hooker secretly recorded several of these conversations. The transcripts of Thompson’s conversations with Hooker (and why they don’t show what antivaccine activists claim they show) are discussed in detail here. Thompson also gave a large number of documents to Rep. Bill Posey (R-FL), a number that is sometimes claimed by antivaxers to be “100,000 documents” but in reality was far fewer. A detailed discussion of the documents Thompson gave to Rep. Bill Posey (R-FL) can be found here, here, and here. On the other hand, all my writings and delving into how Thompson became the “CDC whistleblower” were an enormous help to me in seeing through the utter BS that VAXXED lays down in so many of its scenes, because VAXXED is basically the story of the CDC whistleblower through the lens (if you’ll excuse the term) of Andrew Wakefield. Thompson is never seen on screen, other than by the occasional stock photo, which is understandable given that nothing has been heard from him since August 2014. However, inexplicably, I couldn’t help but notice, as others did, that whenever Thompson speaks, this graphic of an undulating computer-generated line over a document appears on screen, with occasional key words and phrases popping out. It’s very strange indeed:

Co-starring: The parents
The parents, contrary to what the filmmakers want you to think, really aren’t given top billing in VAXXED. They do, however, share co-starring roles:
Polly and Jon Tommey: Polly Tommey is the editor of the magazine The Autism File, which peddles antivaccine pseudoscience and quack “autism biomed” treatments. Better known in England than the US, she has also worked closely with Wakefield on the Autism Media Channel (e.g., the deceptively told story of the murder of autistic boy Alex Spourdalakis). She and her husband have an autistic son whose autism they blame on the MMR, and that is what drove her into the antivaccine camp. No mention is made in the movie that she has been a longtime collaborator with Andrew Wakefield. In the movie, she is presented just as another parent who believes her son’s autism was caused by vaccines and now works for vaccine safety. In reality, she is as antivaccine as Wakefield. Some of the most exploitative footage of autistics used in VAXXED are of her son.
Sheila Ealey: Sheila Ealey is an African-American woman who believes her son’s autism was caused by an inadvertent double-dose of MMR administered at 13 months. Her story has a lot of holes in it in that she claims his medical records were stolen from her evacuated apartment in New Orleans and that her lawsuit was thrown out because of Merck’s machinations. These days, she’s been appearing with Wakefield and Bigtree when they do appearances in communities that are predominantly African-American, like Compton. Her story emphasizes how her daughter, who did not get the MMR is an accomplished pianist and doing very well. Here is one segment featuring her:
Vaxxed Clip: Sheila Ealey, African American mother of Temple, describes how her son reacted to the MMR vaccine from Cinema Libre Studio on Vimeo.
Mark Blaxill: Mark Blaxill is an antivaccine activist associated with SafeMinds. His penchant for twisting science is well known. For inexplicable reasons he keeps showing up in the film, even though, he too has no scientific credentials to speak of.
There are also several other parents whose children are briefly featured, including one whose child is shown seizing in an (intentionally) uncomfortably long shot taken from home video.
Also appearing: The doctors and scientists
Besides Brian Hooker, three other scientists and “autism experts” are featured:
Doreen Granpeesheh: I had never heard of Doreen Granpeesheh before, but she shows up early in the movie as an autism expert. On her first go-around, she appears reasonable in discussing how autism is diagnosed, although she does repeat oft-debunked antivaccine tropes about an “autism epidemic.” Later in the movie, she starts to let her antivax quack flag fly, opining about how autistic children are autistic because their “detoxification” is defective. (Remember, a lot of quack “autism biomed” therapies and concepts of “vaccine injury” blame impaired “detoxification” for autism.) She is the founder of The Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD) but also worked at Thoughtful House back when Andrew Wakefield was the director. No mention is made of this prior connection.
Luc Montagnier: Winner of a Nobel Prize in Medicine (which he is shown receiving in VAXXED) for discovery of the virus that causes AIDS, Luc Montagnier has of late become the foremost example of what I like to call the “Nobel Disease“; namely, a tendency for scientists who win the Nobel Prize to descend into crankery and quackery. Of late, he’s been publishing studies that seem to endorse homeopathy, appearing in an HIV/AIDS denialist film saying that HIV can be cured with supplements and diet, and presenting his work at the yearly autism biomed quackfest known as Autism One. Clearly, Wakefield and Bigtree wanted him in VAXXED because his Nobel Prize adds scientific status to the antivaccine misinformation they present.
Stephanie Seneff: Stephanie Seneff is on staff at MIT and an expert in computer science, but for some strange reason is often presented as an expert on biomedical science, even though her only training in biology is a bachelor’s degree from decades ago. She can’t seem to make up her mind whether it’s GMOs or vaccines that will ultimately make every child autistic, but that doesn’t stop Wakefield from showing her repeating her risibly stupid claim that 50% of all children and 80% of all boys born in the year 2032 will be autistic. This claim is based on extrapolating current incidence trends in an exponential fashion and is about as ridiculous as claims get but is treated in the movie as a dire warning that we must “do something” (presumably stop vaccinating).
Del Bigtree also recruits two of the physicians from his old talk show The Doctors to help. More on that later.
Bookending VAXXED: The Disneyland measles outbreak
Now that we know the who, let’s move on to the what. VAXXED begins with a pre-credits montage of news reports about the Disneyland outbreak and its aftermath. The outbreak, as you remember, started around the Christmas holidays in 2014 and persisted for months into 2015. It also focused the nation’s attention on the problem of low vaccine uptake and the influence of the antivaccine movement, whose prominent members went into veritable contortions of logic and science to argue that the measles isn’t serious and the story was overblown. The montage features reporters and pundits blaming the outbreak on low vaccine uptake. There’s a clip in which Surgeon General Dr. Vivek Murthy refers to Andrew Wakefield’s long-discredited 1998 Lancet case series claiming to link the MMR vaccine to GI problems in autistic children, which Murthy quite correctly blames for launching the most recent iteration of the antivaccine movement, and one in which California Senator Dr. Richard Pan argues for the bill he co-sponsored last year, California SB 277, which ultimately passed and has eliminated nonmedical exemptions to school vaccine mandates in California. VAXXED even includes a clip from the Penn and Teller’s Bullsh!t episode about the antivaccine movement and of President Obama stating how the vaccine-autism link has been debunked, to add to a clip by Dr. Murthy saying the same thing.
The reason I spent so much verbiage on the first two minutes or so of the film is to try to help you understand where Wakefield and Bigtree are coming from. The first segment on the Disneyland measles outbreak sets the stage. Wakefield, who directed the film, clearly hates scientists so routinely describing how his work has been “debunked” and at least in part wants to use VAXXED as a vehicle for his vindication. Those not familiar with Wakefield might not realize this, but I recognized it from the first minute of the film and Wakefield’s choice to begin using the Disneyland measles outbreak and experts referring to his 1998 case series as having been debunked. Also, this montage segues to a shot of fingers typing on a keyboard, meant to represent CDC scientist turned “CDC whistleblower” William Thompson. The scene is dark; the contrast is high; and the voiceover is ominous. Thompson is quoted as saying “we lied about the scientific findings” and that the “CDC can’t be trusted to police itself.” Also, the Disneyland measles outbreak serves as bookends to the movie, as Wakefield and Bigtree circle back to the story in the last 15 minutes of the movie, portraying it as being used by the CDC and big pharma as a tool to sell vaccines and crush the CDC whistleblower conspiracy theory.
It’s only after this that the title of the movie is shown, accompanied with a rather puzzling view of a syringe shooting out what looks like blue exhaust and lifting off like a rocket, behind which the letter X appears, later turning into the word “VAXXED.” Vaccines as missiles? Vaccines spewing pollution? I don’t know what this image is supposed to convey, but clearly it’s meant to be just as ominous as the voiceover quoting William Thompson’s words. The intent is clarified by the next image of a reenactment of Brian Hooker picking up his phone to answer an unexpected call from William Thompson. Soon after, Hooker tells the story of how his son regressed into autism two weeks after his 15 month shots. It’s a dramatic story, a story very similar to the stories of many parents who fervently believe that vaccines caused their child’s autism based on temporal correlation. Thus, the narrative is framed: Parents suffering through what is portrayed as the horrors of autism wronged by the CDC which, according to the “CDC whistleblower” covered up data showing a link between vaccines and autism.
This is a device that is used relentlessly throughout the film: interviews with parents who believe that vaccines made their child autistic interspersed with home video footage of their low functioning autistic children contrasted with earlier home video showing those same children looking happy and normal before vaccines. The message couldn’t be less subtle. Worse, the shots of the autistic children are frequently nakedly exploitative, showing them at their worst. At times, the parents tear up as they tell their story. Basically, this movie uses emotional manipulation at its most naked. Indeed, it is a plea—nay, a scream—to believe the anecdotal evidence of these attractive, suffering parents over science. Wakefield and Bigtree then provide a highly slanted selection of data. It’s also a powerful reinforcement of a particularly odious narrative known as the “lost child,” in which the child is portrayed as perfectly normal until vaccines took that normal child away and made him autistic.
Oh, and Wakefield is vindicated. (Remember, this movie is, more than anything else, about Wakefield.) Indeed, the movie beats the viewer over the head later with Wakefield defending his retracted paper, with the clear message that the “CDC whistleblower” vindicates Wakefield, who is portrayed throughout the entire movie as the “brave” defender of children and vaccine safety advocate. Much of the first 40 minutes or so of the movie features Wakefield repeating the same lies he’s been repeating for 18 years about how he came to want to investigate vaccines and autism (a parent called him out of the blue) with no mention of how he accepted large sums of money from a barrister looking to sue vaccine manufacturers. As Kathy at VaccinesWork notes, Wakefield’s 1998 case series is treated as totally legitimate, with no mention of why it was retracted or that Wakefield had his medical license stripped from him. Wakefield recounts how he recommended the monovalent measles vaccine instead of the trivalent MMR, neglecting to mention that he had a patent on a competing monovalent measles vaccine. Basically, everything he says in this segment portrays Wakefield as a man willing to sacrifice all for his beliefs and vaccine safety and his detractors as motivated by ideology, greed, or part of the conspiracy between big pharma and the CDC. Oddly enough, the movie doesn’t mention Brian Deer. Maybe it’s because Brian Deer ripped the cover off the whole rotten edifice that was Wakefield’s MMR scam and exposed it to the light of day.
I wonder why. (I know, sarcasm.)
The first holes in Brian Hooker’s autism narrative
Hooker’s story is dramatic and very similar to many stories of regression into autism after vaccination. It is also, as Matt Carey explains, a story that’s full of holes. I don’t mean to imply by this that Hooker is lying. Rather, human memory is malleable and parental recollection, when compared to objective records, is often shown to be incorrect. In this case, we have the records of Hooker’s case before the Vaccine Court, for which a claim of vaccine injury was denied, to compare to what Hooker says in the film. I urge you to read Carey’s post and Dorit Reiss’ analysis of Hooker’s case. Hooker states in VAXXED:
Two weeks after his 15 month vaccines, then he lost all language. He lost all eye contact. You would pick him up and he would just hang limp.
Yet according to court records, his son was seen by his pediatrician 19 days after his vaccination, and no such symptoms were noted, just fever, irritability, and decreased appetite. Moreover, other court records note that the Hookers had reported decreased eye contact as early as 12 months. Of course, there’s no way for a viewer of VAXXED to know this or to be familiar with just how unreliable human memory can be and how easily memories over time come to conform themselves with preexisting beliefs. It is a human trait to which we are all prone. However, if VAXXED represents Hooker’s story in such a slanted fashion, leaving out key pieces of information and presenting his flawed memories as fact, what else does VAXXED get wrong, intentionally or unintentionally?
Brian Hooker’s incompetent “reanalysis” of DeStefano et al
I frequently refer to Brian Hooker as a biochemical engineer (which he is, by training and career) turned incompetent epidemiologist (which is what he demonstrates himself to be with every attempt at analyzing epidemiological data). In VAXXED, Thompson is portrayed as guiding Hooker, as Deep Throat guided Woodward and Bernstein during their investigation of the Watergate break-in, to the data that would reveal the conspiracy for all to see. (It’s just that subtle.) The funny thing is that it is implied on more than one occasion that the dataset used by DeStefano et al was not available to the public and that Thompson was fearful of providing it to Hooker, but then it’s claimed that through a “loophole” in the law through which Thompson guided Hooker, the “classified” dataset could be obtained legally.
Be that as it may, Hooker is an utterly incompetent epidemiologist. He analyzed data intended for a case-control study as a cohort study using “simple” statistical analyses. (Translation: He didn’t bother to control for confounders.) Indeed, he was later featured on a video (now taken down) bragging about the “simplicity” of his statistical analysis, to which I responded: “Here’s a hint. In statistics, simplicity is not beauty, nor is it rigor.” Basically, Hooker tortured the data until they confessed what he wanted them to. No wonder his study was retracted by the editor of Translational Neurodegeneration, the journal that originally published it.
Ironically, Hooker’s reanalysis is portrayed in the movie, as it’s been portrayed all along, as “vindication” of Wakefield’s finding that the MMR vaccine increases the risk of autism. It did not. Basically, it found a significantly increased risk of autism in a small subset (African-American males) of autism that was almost certainly spurious. For every other group, even Hooker’s reanalysis was in line with there being no link between the MMR vaccine and autism. Of course, DeStefano et al is also presented as the be-all and end-all of studies examining whether vaccines are associated with autism, ignoring all the many other studies that have found no link. As I like to point out, even if DeStefano et al were totally discredited, the overwhelming scientific consensus would remain that the MMR vaccine does not cause autism based on many other studies, studies that VAXXED doesn’t mention.
Asks VAXXED: Did the CDC commit fraud?
The answer is “no,” as I’ve discussed time and time again, but, having set their story up in the first half of VAXXED, in the second half of the movie Wakefield and Bigtree then proceed to do their damnedest to convince you that the answer is “yes” with three “exhibits.” All of these will come as no surprise to those who’ve followed the “CDC whistleblower” conspiracy theory, as they are claims that Wakefield and Hooker have been making ever since they first created the CDC whistleblower manufactroversy. The three “exhibits” are:
Exhibit #1: Deviation from the analysis plan
Exhibit #2: Omission of data
Exhibit #3: Destruction of documents
Between roughly the halfway point of the movie and the looping around again to the Disneyland measles outbreak, VAXXED makes each claim in a separate section with the title introducing it. Let’s take a look at these claims individually
Exhibit #1: Deviation from the analysis plan
The first claim attributed to Thompson in this section is that the CDC scientists led by Frank DeStefano deviated from the analysis plan in order to “hide” a statistically significant association between vaccination with MMR and autism in African American children. I’ve discussed this issue before, as has Matt Carey long before VAXXED and in his review of VAXXED. In the VAXXED narrative, CDC scientists didn’t like what they were seeing in the first analysis of the data that later formed the basis of the 2004 paper by DeStefano et al that failed to find a link between MMR and autism. The problem, as previously cited links show, is that the “race effect” was not discovered until after the final analysis plan was locked in, and no changes in the analysis plan were made after that. Moreover, the analysis plan did allow for the analyses that were ultimately performed, as Matt Carey has shown again and again.
VAXXED also claims that the CDC substituted birth certificate data in order to “hide” the association in African-Americans. I’ve discussed that claim in detail before, as have Matt Carey and Reuben. The bottom line is that it’s a smokescreen. The birth certificate analysis was planned, and there were legitimate reasons for it.
Exhibit #2: Omission of data
The next seemingly damning claim made by Wakefield and Bigtree is that the CDC omitted data in the final published version of DeStefano et al. This claim was first trotted out in film form in a video made by Autism Media Channel (remember Wakefield and Tommey?) Specifically, it is claimed that there was a strong association between MMR and “isolated autism.” What is “isolated autism”? In VAXXED, it’s autism without developmental delay. In the movie, it’s “just autism” and “nothing but autism”; i.e., completely normal kids with no hint of autism or autism spectrum disorders who didn’t show any signs of autism until 18 months. The claim is that the CDC conspired to omit data showing a shockingly high relative risk of “isolated autism” in children vaccinated earlier. It sounds convincing if you don’t know a lot about the issue. Indeed, if I were unschooled in the whole CDC whistleblower conspiracy theory, I would have been puzzled about how to explain it. Fortunately, Matt Carey is way ahead of me. First, he shows that DeStefano et al didn’t “hide” the result. It’s in Table 4 of the paper. What DeStefano et al did was similar, but not identical, to what Hooker claimed to have done. Instead of “isolated autism,” DeStefano et al examined autism without mental retardation:
If you want to say, “well autism without MR isn’t the same thing as ‘isolated autism’, consider this: the answer is basically unchanged from what Mr. Wakefield claims was “omitted”. Take a look at the table: in the total sample, the group without MR has basically the same result as was supposedly hidden. Odds ratio 2.45 (compared to 2.48), with confidence interval from 1.20 to 5.00 (compared to 1.16 to 5.31). Which is to say: the CDC published the result that Mr. Wakefield claims was hidden.
Smoke. Mirrors. Wakefield. Hooker.
This result is 10 years old. And no one, not Wakefield, Not Hooker, not anyone in the real advocacy community has made a big deal out of it until now. I do not profess to understand how Mr. Wakefield nor Mr. Hooker think, but here’s one reason why most people haven’t considered this “autism without MR” result a big deal: this is a raw data result. A result unadjusted for any possible confounders. The adjusted result, also highlighted in the figure above, shows a confidence interval that spans 1. In other words, there’s no suggestion of a real effect when one does a full analysis.
Which of course shows us why people do full analyses. Sometimes associations change when one controls for other factors. Sometimes associations get stronger. Sometimes they go away. Sometimes things that appear to not be associations are shown to be associations.
Yes, Hooker does love his “simple” analyses. Unfortunately, in epidemiology and statistics, “simple” usually means preliminary and not controlling for confounders. When confounders are appropriate controlled for, an analysis that is not “simple,” and often those initially discovered associations go away.
Exhibit #3: Destruction of documents
The final “exhibit” seems most damning of all, but it’s actually the simplest of all to deal with. When Rep. Posey gave his speech announcing the CDC whistleblower documents a year ago, he read a statement allegedly by William Thompson claiming:
The remaining four co-authors all met and brought a big garbage can into the meeting room and reviewed and went through all the hard copy documents that we had thought we should discard and put them in a huge garbage can. However, because I assumed it was illegal and would violate both FOIA and DOJ requests, I kept hard copies of all documents in my office and I retained all associated computer files. I believe we intentionally withheld controversial findings from the final draft of the Pediatrics paper.
Unfortunately, as Matt Carey and I pointed out, this story is highly unlikely as described. For one thing, as VAXXED mentions, all the remaining co-authors of the study other than Thompson have denied it (which VAXXED portrays as evidence of the conspiracy, of course), but more importantly it’s just not very plausible given government data retention and computer backup policies. There is no evidence that raw data from DeStefano et al were destroyed. Yet VAXXED portrays a frenzied situation in which, after the “race findings,” the co-investigators met weekly to try to figure out a way to make the finding go away and ultimately destroyed raw data.
Indeed, antivaccinationists seemed most displeased when the “CDC whistleblower” documents were released to the public by Carey and other bloggers because examination failed to find evidence of a coverup, no matter how much antivaccine-sympathetic journalists like Ben Swann tried to make them. We did learn from the documents that Thompson seemed to be a troubled employee back around 2004, as he complained about being placed on administrative leave for “inappropriate and unacceptable behavior in the work place.”
The Doctors attack
Perhaps the unintentionally hilarious scene in VAXXED occurs near the end of the movie, right after the story circles back to the Disneyland measles outbreak. After portraying the outbreak as a tool used by the CDC and pharma to silence those who “question” vaccines and stir fear to sell more vaccines, Bigtree is shown bringing in two of the doctors on The Doctors, Dr. Jim Sears and Dr. Rachel Ross. It’s a scene that is so blatantly scripted, stilted, and fake that most reality show producers would have nixed it as being too obvious. Basically, Bigtree, after establishing that Sears and Ross have supported vaccination (which for Sears is doubtful) and administered vaccines (complete with shots of a pregnant Dr. Ross seeing patients and saying that she follows the CDC recommendations), gives them a set of documents, which he claims include the complaint about the CDC by William Thompson and the reanalysis of DeStefano et al and evidence of the CDC coverup. Shots of Ross and Sears in shock demonstrating acting more appropriate for a Telemundo soap opera follow. (All that is missing is the dramatically appropriate Latin score.) Next follow interviews, in which both state that their faith in the CDC and vaccines has been “shaken.” Dr. Ross in particular states that she will be delaying the MMR for her baby and asks, “What else am I being lied to about?” She even went so far as to write an apology letter featured on the VAXXED website in which she regurgitates antivaccine lies about the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program and the CDC whistleblower and writes, “I apologize from the bottom of my heart to any children and parents that I have unknowingly harmed. I had no idea.”
Truly, I believe that Dr. Ross has no idea. Actually, she clearly has no clue.
What’s painfully hilarious about this whole sequence is how brazen it is. First, family practitioners and pediatricians (indeed, most MDs) are not scientists and lack the background to analyze the reanalysis of DeStefano et al. Second, they were only given one side of the story, with no context upon which to judge the claims made in the documents. Jim Sears, in particular, is the brother of Dr. Bob Sears, who has been discussed many times on this very blog for his antivaccine-sympathetic views and his deceptive vaccine book and lately has been telling California parents how to avoid vaccinating after the passage of SB 277.
I blame Robert De Niro
I realize that documentaries are not necessarily supposed to be in any way “objective.” Indeed, most documentaries have a definite point of view and are trying to convince the audience that that point of view is correct. However, having a point of view, a position if you will, to argue does not give filmmakers like Bigtree and Wakefield license to present their data deceptively or dishonestly, but that’s exactly what they do in VAXXED. They both present antivaccine misinformation and frame correct information in a deceptive way meant to persuade the audience that the CDC whistleblower conspiracy theory is real, that the CDC is covering up evidence that vaccines cause autism, and that vaccines are dangerous. In the process they trot out a large list of the “greatest hits” of the antivaccine movement, such as:
Autism is an epidemic. Nary a mention is made of the effect of changes in diagnostic definitions in the 1990s, better screening, and diagnostic substitution that strongly suggest autism prevalence is likely not increasing.
Vaccines are not tested for safety as rigorously as pharmaceutical drugs (and, oh, Vioxxx…). Wrong. They are tested at least as rigorously as than other drugs.
The vaccine omnibus hearings were defeated by a single “fraudulent study” from the CDC; that is, DeStefano et al, the very study featured in VAXXED as having been revealed as “fraudulent” by William Thompson. Nope. You can also read more here. I also note that one of the children who was a test case used to establish biological plausibility, William Yates Hazlehurst, was shown in video in VAXXED without the audience being informed that this child was one of the test cases and that his parents’ complaint was denied.
There has never been a “vaxxed vs. unvaxxed” study. This is a favorite antivaccine fantasy. First, the question is framed as a randomized study, like a drug study, in which one group receives a placebo. This, of course, would be unethical because one group would be left unprotected. It’s also not true that there hasn’t been a “vaxxed vs. unvaxxed” study. In fact, there have been several. They generally show at least no differences in health and often better health in the vaccinated group. Basically, the claim that there is no “vaxxed vs. unvaxxed” study is a lie, antivaccine propaganda.
Yes, VAXXED is a deceptive bit of antivaccine propaganda, but it’s unfortunately become an influential piece of antivaccine propaganda. For example, Wakefield and Bigtree have actually successfully used VAXXED to win a meeting with powerful Congressmen like Jason Chaffetz (R-UT), who is currently the chair of the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform (Dan Burton’s old committee). Chaffetz met with Bigtree, antivaccine lawyers, and an antivaccine blogger with the ‘nym Levi Quackenboss just a couple of weeks ago, with Chaffetz seemingly promising an “investigation” of the CDC. Meanwhile, Bigtree and Wakefield have teamed with Sheila Ealey to go into African American communities for showings of VAXXED promoting the CDC whistleblower conspiracy theory.
I blame Robert De Niro for a large percentage of the damage VAXXED can potentially do.
Why do I blame Robert De Niro? Recall that De Niro bypassed the selection process of the Tribeca Film Festival, which he co-founded, in order to get VAXXED a showing there. True, the uproar among writers and documentarians over his giving preferential treatment to VAXXED ultimately led De Niro withdraw the film, but the uproar also brought a lot of publicity to the movie. Unlike other antivaccine movies like The Greater Good, which found only a small audience and rapidly faded into oblivion, VAXXED stayed in the news longer than any antivaccine (or even any quack) film I remember. Bigtree, Tommey, and Wakefield launched a nationwide publicity tour, doing Q&A’s after screenings all over the US, sometimes drawing decent-sized crowds. There might even be Congressional hearings (although I remain skeptical until I actually see it happening). Some African-American communities, communities that can least afford a decline in vaccination rates, have become more suspicious of vaccines, thanks to the CDC whistleblower conspiracy theory. There’s almost certainly no way this would have happened if Robert De Niro hadn’t given VAXXED a leg up by inserting it into the 2016 Tribeca Film Festival lineup. Even if there hadn’t been such an uproar that forced De Niro to retreat, VAXXED could still have been marketed as having been selected for screening at the prestigious Tribeca Film Festival.
Thanks, Mr. De Niro. Thanks for making a weak weapon for antivaccine activists much stronger than it had to be.

Andrew Wakefield, the MMR, and a “mother warrior’s” fabricated vaccine injury story
David Gorski on October 13, 2014
Link

As the time came to do my usual weekly post for this blog, I was torn over what to write about. Regular readers might have noticed that a certain dubious cancer doctor about whom I’ve written twice before has been agitating in the comments for me to pay attention to him, after having sent more e-mails to me and various deans at my medical school “challenging” me to publish a link to his results and threatening to go to the local press to see if he can drum up interest in this “battle.” I’ve been assiduously ignoring him, but over time the irritation factor made me want to tell him, “Be very careful what you ask for. You might just get it.” Then I’d make this week’s post about him, even though I wasn’t thrilled with the idea of giving in to his harassment and giving him what he wants.
That’s why I have to thank the ever-intrepid investigative reporter Brian Deer for providing me an alternative topic that is way more important than some self-important little quack and a compelling topic to blog about in its own right. Brian Deer, as you might recall, remains the one journalist who was able to crack the facade of seeming scientific legitimacy built up by antivaccine guru Andrew Wakefield and demonstrate that (1) Wakefield’s work concluding that the MMR vaccine was associated with “autistic enterocolitis” was bought and paid for by a solicitor named Richard Barr, who represented British parents looking to sue vaccine manufacturers, to the tune of over £400,000; (2) Wakefield expected to make over £72 million a year selling a test for which Wakefield had filed a patent application in March 1995 claiming that “Crohn’s disease or ulcerative colitis may be diagnosed by detecting measles virus in bowel tissue, bowel products or body fluids”; and Wakefield’s case series published in The Lancet in 1998 was fraudulent, the equivalent of what Deer correctly characterized as “Piltdown medicine.” Ultimately, these revelations led to Wakefield’s being completely discredited to the point where The Lancet retracted his paper and even Thoughtful House, the autism quackery clinic in Austin, TX where Wakefield had a cushy, well-paid position as scientific director, had to give him the boot. Yes, Wakefield is a fraud, and it’s only a shame that it took over a decade for it to be demonstrated.
As much as I hate how it took discrediting Wakefield the man as a fraud rather than just discrediting his bogus science to really begin to turn the tide against the annoying propensity of journalists to look to Wakefield or his acolytes for “equal time” and “balance” whenever stories about autism and vaccines reared their ugly heads, I can’t argue with the results. Wakefield is well and truly discredited now, so much so that, as I noted, his prominent involvement probably ruined any chance promoters of the “CDC whistleblower” scam ever had to get any traction from the mainstream press.
What is sometimes forgotten is the effect Wakefield’s message has had on parents. These are the sorts of parents who tend to congregate into groups designed to promote the idea that vaccines are dangerous and cause autism, such as the bloggers at the antivaccine crank blog Age of Autism, the equally cranky blog The Thinking Moms’ Revolution, or groups like The Canary Party. It is Wakefield’s message and the “autism biomed” quackery that it spawned that have led to unknown numbers of autistic children being subjected to the rankest form of quackery in order to “recover” them, up to and including dubious stem cell therapies and bleach enemas.
This is the sort of parent that is the topic of Brian Deer’s story in the The Sunday Times yesterday entitled “A warrior mother lost to MMR lies“. (Mother Warriors, remember, was the title of a book by Jenny McCarthy promoting the idea that vaccines cause autism and the biomedical quackery parents of such children use to treat autistic children.) It is the story of a mother who became an acolyte of Andrew Wakefield and how she completely made up the link between vaccination and her child’s autism. Because of what is characterized by Deer as a “pathological conflict with his carers,” an unnamed local brought legal action against the mother and father to allow their autistic son to get the care he required.
Unfortunately, the article is behind a paywall. Fortunately, there is a version of his article, “Wakefield ‘MMR mother’ fabricated injury story“, on Brian Deer’s own website, along with a 45,000 word judgment by High Court judge Mr. Justice Baker that entered the public domain last week from the Court of Protection. A link to the complete text of that judgment is also available on Deer’s website. In order to protect the child’s anonymity, the parents are not named, the mother being referred to as “E,” the father as “A,” and the child as “M.” To continue that protection, given that I know many of our readers are quite knowledgeable about l’affaire Wakefield, some even considerably more so than I, I must insist that there be no speculation about the identities of E, M, or A, and no naming of them. In any case, E is what Deer has dubbed a “Wakefield mother,” Wakefield mothers being forgotten victims of the MMR scare engineered by Andrew Wakefield. The story of E is harrowing reading, and Deer is not unsympathetic:
By any reckoning, “E” is a formidable crusader. She is intelligent, articulate and outwardly confident. She has worked as a health service manager. She is a former school governor and a trained mediator. And, most of all, she is a loving parent. She champions her son “M” – who is autistic and learning-disabled – and for his first 18 years looked after him at home, generally “very well” by all accounts.
In America, she likely would be called a “mother warrior”, a name coined by Jenny McCarthy, an actress. These are women who have concluded that their child’s disorders were caused by vaccines, and will stop at almost nothing to prove “the truth”. In recent years, Britain’s “MMR scare” has been exported to the United States, and such mothers have rallied to networks of websites and conferences, even as infectious diseases have returned.
But “E” is British, a leading disciple of Andrew Wakefield, the former “MMR doctor”, who was struck off the medical register in 2010. He is the man who terrified a generation of young parents, claiming that the triple shot against measles, mumps and rubella causes autism and a novel bowel disease. As my lengthy investigations revealed, while he secretly worked for lawyers and tried to launch his own personal business ventures, he caused vaccination rates to plummet, and triggered outbreaks of measles. The British Medical Journal dubbed his research “an elaborate fraud”.
“E”, I believe, is one of the scare’s forgotten victims. I call them the “Wakefield mothers”. Here is a woman, now in her fifties, who I have met but am forbidden to name. She has appeared at public rallies and in media, with her son. She has protested to government ministers. She has denounced judges, doctors and journalists (including me). She sued a drug company that makes MMR.
It also turns out that what E relates to the authorities (and everyone else) about her child’s development of autism does not jibe with available records and evidence, to the point that the judgment finds it hard not to conclude that “E has fabricated, or at least grossly exaggerated, her account.” The entire judgment is incredibly damning, documenting numerous cases of E recounting health issues that are not supported by available documentary evidence. How did this happen? Was E lying, or is this just another example of how malleable memory is and how a mother, finding what she thinks to be a potential cure, can find her memories unconsciously altered to fit her beliefs, so that she really believes her false accounts are true? Or is it a combination? Let’s look at her story, as related by Deer, and the judgment.
The archetype versus reality
Brian Deer carefully points out how E’s story is an “archetype,” the same sort of story that he’s heard “hundreds of times” since he started investigating Wakefield and that I’ve heard as well many, many times since I first took an interest a decade ago in the antivaccine movement, Andrew Wakefield, and the pseudoscientific myth that the MMR vaccine causes autism. As Deer put it, “It was the template media and lawsuit “Mothers’ Story” that would be recited so many times, by so many mothers over the years, that a reasonable person might assume it was true.” Indeed, the most famous “mother warrior” in the US, Jenny McCarthy, tells a story that fits the archetype. When told by these “mother warriors,” the core story is always the same, although the details can vary considerably. The core story is that the child was perfectly healthy, with no indication whatsoever of neurodevelopmental issues (or, usually, anything at all wrong) until sometime after MMR vaccination. In the case of Jenny McCarthy, she claimed that soon after the shot, “boom—the soul’s gone from his eyes.” McCarthy’s story has mutated and morphed through the years and with other retellings, so much so that it is difficult to tell what really happened. Unfortunately, E’s story about M has also morphed through the years.
I’ve read the entire judgment, and one thing that leaps out is a passage at the beginning. After noting that M was born in July 1989, the chronology used by the judge indicates that “on four dates between September 1989 (when he was aged six weeks) and March 1990 (aged eight months) M received the normal range of inoculations, with no recorded reactions,” and that “Between July and December 1990 there were eight further visits to the GP noted in M’s medical records in which he was reported as suffering from a variety of infections. There is no record of any developmental delay in these notes.” Then:
On 12th January 1991, aged just under 18 months, M was given the measles, mumps and rubella (“MMR”) vaccination. There is no record in his GP notes of any adverse reaction. In fact, there is no report of any adverse reaction to the MMR in any record relating to M for the next nine years. From 2000 onwards, however, M’s parents, and in particular his mother, have given increasingly vivid accounts of an extreme reaction to the injection experienced by M. There are descriptions of M screaming after having the injection, followed by six hours of convulsions, screaming and projectile vomiting. It is the parents’ case that the mother told their GP that he had had a bad reaction to the MMR but was told by him that she was an over-anxious mother and must be imagining it. When E called the GP a second time and said she was calling the emergency services, she was told not to do this, but went ahead because M was going in and out of consciousness. The paramedics and the GP had arrived at the same time, at which point M’s temperature was 104. The GP had told the paramedics to leave. Before going, they had told her that this was a case of meningeal encephalitis. The GP had been verbally abusive to E. The above account, given to Dr. Beck, a psychologist instructed as an expert witness in these proceedings, is similar to that given by the mother to a variety of professionals. She also gave a detailed description of M’s reaction to the MMR in the course of her oral evidence. One note in an “auditory processing assessment report” dated 31st October 2002 records E alleging that, following the MMR, M had remained in, “A persistent vegetative state for six months.”
The judgment (Deer as well) notes multiple inconsistencies in E’s accounts of M’s health problems, which she never linked to the MMR until at least 2000, after news of Wakefield’s case series and claims about the MMR, autism, and “autistic enterocolitis” had begun well and truly circulating in the British press. Ironically, as Deer and the judgment relate, E claimed repeatedly that her son had autistic enterocolitis, even after M had been evaluated by Wakefield’s group. Why is this unusual? The reason is simple; despite the tendency of Wakefield’s group at the time to promote autistic enterocolitis as a real entity and blame it on the MMR, even his group at the Royal Free Hospital didn’t diagnose M with the condition. It’s noted that E and A “have stated that M displayed signs of a severe gut disorder from the time of the MMR vaccine for 10 years until he was assessed and diagnosed at the Royal Free gastroenterology department” even though “there is no record in the GP notes or any other contemporaneous complaint that M had suffered a gut disorder during this 10 year period.” In fact, what M had been diagnosed with was constipation. The hospital notes from 2002, for instance, list E’s diagnosis as “progressive [regressive] autism – constipation.” As High Court judge Mr. Justice Baker’s judgment states:
Throughout the hearing, E insisted that M had been given the diagnosis of autistic enterocolitis or leaky gut syndrome and alleged that some of the Royal Free medical records must be missing. I reject that assertion. I find that not even the Royal Free team, who at that time were leading the way and postulating the link between autism and a form of colitis, found any evidence in 2001 of significant gut disorder in M. In his case no diagnosis of autistic enterocolitis or leaky gut syndrome was ever made.
If even Wakefield’s group at the Royal Free Hospital didn’t diagnose M with autistic enterocolitis, that really ought to tell you something! In any case, what Deer and this judgment recount is that the mother, having discovered Wakefield’s hypothesis, changed her story. Indeed, E filed for compensation in the “class action” lawsuit three months after she obtained an appointment at the Royal Free. Before she learned of Wakefield’s MMR scare, E blamed M’s condition on this:
The first relevant concern was in May 1990, when “M” was aged 10 months. In an account taken later, his parents said that on one night they felt that he had three times “nearly stopped breathing”, turned blue, and from then had difficulties swallowing.
“A clear indication of the trauma his body experienced from this illness was from that time onwards he could not bear his head to be anything other than upright,” said an education service report of the parents’ words, filed in evidence. “If it was moved lower than his shoulders his whole body would go completely rigid. For a time he lacked control over his tongue, until we managed to teach him how to keep it in his mouth.”
This was almost eight months before “M” received MMR, which was given to him in January 1991. And there were no reports of any reactions, or anything related to the shot, in his notes for the next nine years. Meanwhile, “E”, and her husband, “A”, who worked for the fire service, cared for their son, with devotion and love, as paediatricians struggled with the boy’s emerging autism and his significant intellectual delay.
Once E had discovered the dark path of vaccine injury and autism biomed, however, she jumped in, head first, taking her son to a variety of alternative medicine practitioners, garnering a huge number of diagnoses at various times, and treating him with virtually every form of quackery you can think of to which autistic children are subjected. The sorts of health issues reported by E included loss of sensation in M’s hands and feet, seizures, meningitis, leaky gut syndrome, tumors in his gums, “chronic blood poisoning,” bilateral deafness, uncontrollable temperatures, heavy metal poisoning (of course!), a “black shadow sitting on his left sinuses,” stabbing pains in his groin, uncontrollable sneezing, adverse effects of “electromagnetic energies” (against which E wrapped “electronic items in his [M’s] bedroom in tin foil to protect him”), “black grunge oozing from every orifice,” and Lyme disease (also of course). Other diagnoses included, rheumatoid arthritis; heavy metal poisoning (based on an isolated test result when such a diagnosis turns on repeated elevated levels); and a defective blood brain barrier. It gets even worse, though.
When M reached his teenage years and started to demonstrate more difficult behaviors, E blamed his personality change on “an unavoidable personality change” brought about because he was “dominated by testosterone and mercury.” This, as you might recall, is a truly quacky idea promulgated by a father-son team of autism quacks, Mark and David Geier, whose concept was that testosterone somehow “bound” mercury (from vaccines, of course) so that it couldn’t be properly chelated out of the brain. Never mind that the study they relied on for claiming that testosterone could bind mercury reported such binding in hot benzene, whose relevance to the aqueous solution that is human blood and serum is highly dubious, at best. The Geiers’ suggested solution was chelation therapy plus Lupron, the latter of which shuts down sex hormone production quite markedly and is a drug sometimes used for chemical castration.
As repeated several times in the judgment and by Deer, nowhere is there evidence to support any of these diagnoses from reputable medical practitioners, nor does the medical record support a temporal link between MMR vaccination and onset of autistic symptoms (or other symptoms), for that matter. E’s explanation? Those records are missing, doctors didn’t record the stories and incidents that she related to them, and that doctors or someone has removed relevant pages of the medical record. However, the court, after considerable investigation, concluded:
For some time E has alleged that part of M’s medical record is missing. The inference that she invited the court to draw was that pages had been deliberately removed to conceal contemporaneous records of his reaction to the MMR. It is now clear that no part of the records have been removed. One page of the records was missing and copies produced by E and A, but the original record was intact. I am not going to speculate on the reason why the copies produced by E and A are incomplete.
This sort of claim is repeated time after time after time by E, as described in the judgment. Conveniently, all the verifiable medical records that would back up her assertions have gone missing somehow. The implication, of course, is that it’s a conspiracy to discredit her, an implication the judge rejected:
If M had an experienced an extreme reaction to the vaccine, as now alleged, it is inconceivable that E and A would not have sought medical advice and thereafter told all doctors and other medical practitioners about what had happened. As I put it to E in the course of the hearing, there are only three possible explanations for what has happened. The first is that E did give the account to Dr Baird and all the other practitioners at every appointment, but each of them has negligently failed to record it. The second is that she gave an account but all the practitioners have chosen not to include it in their records. That is what E maintains has happened, alleging that the whole of the medical profession is deliberately concealing the truth about the MMR vaccine. The third is that E has fabricated, or at least grossly exaggerated, her account.
Which is more likely? That M’s doctors over the course of nearly a decade failed to document such an important part of his medical history, or that the story about M’s vaccine reaction is not accurate? If the court were to believe the mother, it would have to have concluded that there was “an MMR conspiracy, through which thousands of doctors and scientists (and, more recently, journalists) concealed horrific alleged injuries to children,” a “legal conspiracy, through which judges denied fairness,” and a “local government conspiracy, by which hard-pressed social workers wanted to remove autistic children from their parents.” These are exactly the sort of conspiracy theories I’ve seen time after time since becoming interested in the antivaccine movement. I could write about them every day if I wished.
Of course, once the fake diagnoses are made, can the quack treatments be far behind? In this case, they weren’t. M was subjected to a veritable cornucopia of quackery by E and A. Besides the aforementioned wrapping of electrical equipment in M’s room with tin foil, there was quackery that involved everything from cranial osteopathy, reflexology, oxygen chamber sessions for six hours at a time (it’s not clear if it was hyperbaric oxygen or not), and, of course, lots and lots of supplements and homeopathic remedies. According to the judgment, “the range of biomedical interventions being supplied to M included a probiotic, six vitamin supplements, four mineral supplements, five trace elements, fatty acids, amino acids, enzymes and a range of homeopathic remedies.” One description of a treatment administered on November 11, 2012 states:
M had a cranial osteopathic appointment that focused on the contorted membrane between the two frontal lobes, apparently where both optical and auditory brain stems sit. The twist in his central membrane was significant for most of the treatment to be spent on it and it would appear to have come from M’s head overheating, obviously trying to release body heat.
Then there was reflexology:
He is also benefiting from reflexology twice a week at the moment, as his hands and feet are so pale, freezing cold, rigid and painful. We are giving sips of water in between mouthfuls to help it go down and we are ensuring his bite size is far smaller, but he does seem to be suffering with trapped wind.
All of this doesn’t even include the rigid diets imposed on M to try to cure his apparently nonexistent gut problems. Overall, in the story of M, we see a story I’ve seen all too often, that of parents latching on to vaccines as a cause of their child’s autism and trying to “recover” their child through a wide variety of quackery. These stories appear frequently at blogs like Age of Autism and The Thinking Moms’ Revolution.
Into darkness
The scenario described above would be bad enough if it were completely innocent, but there is more than just well-meaning parents who latched on to the myth that vaccines cause autism as an explanation why their child isn’t normal and embraced quackery in order to try to “recover” their “real” child. Deer states at one point that he had “merely thought that her son’s autism plus Wakefield had so stripped her of trust in almost anyone but charlatans that she had been driven off the rails and round the bend” and, elsewhere, that he had “wondered if the mother was mad” (an offensive way to wonder if the mother had a mental illness that made me really wish he had chosen a different way to say what he meant). He also noted that E’s picture could fit that of “thousands of parents” who are taken in by Wakefield, who, Deer notes, regularly appears at “conferences dominated by quack remedy merchants and crowded with mother warriors who – wrongly blaming themselves for having their children vaccinated – are uniquely vulnerable prey.” This latter observation is, of course, absolutely true. That is how Wakefield operates. He blames autism on vaccines, which leads these parents to feel guilty over their decision to vaccinate and, in their minds, cause their children’s autism. Then he offers them a way to assuage that guilt through “recovering” their “real” child via biomedical quackery.
However, as bad as that is, in some cases, it gets even darker than that. Some parents, apparently E among them, use vaccine injury as a means of control, and that is what the court found:
Although not a criminal case, a litany of misbehaviour runs from page to page in the judgment. “E” subjected her son to unnecessary tests and interventions “and/or lied” about purported illnesses. She behaved in a “devious and destructive” way towards professionals. She denied her son the chance to develop more independence. She allowed the pain and suffering of a dental abscess to go untreated for a year, then planned to send the lost teeth to Wakefield. She made false allegations against social workers, and vexatiously complained to regulators.
In the end, Baker ruled that, not only did she have factious disorder, but a bunch of other disorders as well: “narcissistic personality disorder”, “histrionic personality disorder” and elements of “emotionally unstable personality disorder”. Her legal deputyship status was revoked. “M” would receive a vaccine if a GP advised it. And the mother was told to demonstrate a “fundamental change of attitude”, or face “permanent steps” to restrict her involvement in the future of her much-loved son.
It’s as sad a story as one can imagine, particularly for M. In E’s case, where did the normal malleability and suggestibility of human memory, such that later information and influences can alter our memories such that we “remember” things that that didn’t happen or our memories of incidents are not what really happened, end and E’s factitious disorder begin? Who knows? Who can tell for sure when she was lying, when she really believed her son had various disorders, and what they were? In the end, when trying to safeguard M’s welfare, it really doesn’t much matter. What we do know is that Wakefield’s antivaccine message, coupled with the quackery that it spawned (it’s not for nothing that I like to describe Wakefield’s Lancet paper as the “paper that launched a thousand quacks”) gave E the tools, and she used them. She subjected M to unnecessary tests and quack treatments; she prevented him from becoming more independent; and she even sued a pharmaceutical company. Most bizarrely, she allowed M to suffer for a year with an untreated tooth abscess, planning to deliver the tooth to Wakefield.
None of this helped her son, and the judge concluded:
It is inevitable that, were M to return home, he will be subjected to the same regime as before in which his mother sought to reimpose control over all aspects of his life. Furthermore, it is likely that she would continue to misrepresent his state of health and expose him to unnecessary examinations and treatments. It is inconceivable that M could return home unless E demonstrates a fundamental change of attitude.
And:
This court acknowledges the enormous demands placed on anyone who has to care for a disabled child. Even though such carers are motivated by love – and I accept that both E and A love M and are deeply devoted to him – the burdens and strains on them are very great. Every reasonable allowance must be made for the fact that they love their vulnerable son and want the absolute best for him. Every reasonable allowance must be made for the impact of these burdens and strains when assessing allegations about the parents’ behaviour. However, having made every reasonable allowance for those factors, I find the behaviour exhibited on many occasions, by E in particular, was wholly unreasonable.
The saddest part is at the end, where the judge concludes that unless E and A can demonstrate a “fundamental change of attitude,” the court will have to move to take permanent steps to restrict their involvement in his life.
This whole family, but most of all M, is the sort of victim of Andrew Wakefield who don’t get enough attention.

Brian Hooker and Andrew Wakefield accuse the CDC of scientific fraud. Irony meters everywhere explode.
David Gorski on October 26, 2014
Link

The antivaccine movement and conspiracy theories go together like beer and Buffalo wings, except that neither are as good as, yes, beer and Buffalo wings. (Maybe it’s more like manure and compost.) In any case, the antivaccine movement is rife with conspiracy theories. I’ve heard and written about more than I can remember right now, and I’m under no illusion that I’ve heard anywhere near all of them. Indeed, it seems that every month I see a new one.
There is, however, a granddaddy of conspiracy theories among antivaccinationists, or, as it’s been called, the central conspiracy theory of the antivaccine movement. That conspiracy theory postulates that “they” (in the U.S, the CDC) have known for a long time that vaccines cause autism, but “they” are covering it up. In other words, the CDC has, according to this conspiracy theory, been intentionally hiding and suppressing evidence that antivaccinationists were right all along and vaccines do cause autism. Never mind what the science really says (that vaccines do work don’t cause autism)! To the antivaccine contingent, that science is “fraudulent” and the CDC knew it! Why do you think that the antivaccine movement, in particular Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., went full mental jacket when Poul Thorsen was accused of financial shenanigans (i.e., fraud) with grant money from the federal government? It was a perfect story to distract from the inconvenient lack of science supporting the antivaccine view that vaccines cause autism. More importantly, from the antivaccine standpoint, it was seen as “validation” that the CDC studies failing to find a link between autism and vaccines were either fraudulent or incompetently performed. Why? Because Thorsen was co-investigator on a couple of the key studies that failed to find a link between the MMR and autism, antivaccinationists thought that his apparent financial fraud must mean that he committed scientific fraud. They’re the same thing, right? Well, not really. There were a lot of co-investigators, and Thorsen was only a middle author on those studies.
Enter William Thompson, a.k.a. the “CDC whistleblower,” or, if you’re on Twitter, the #CDCwhistleblower. There has been a new development sufficiently bizarre as to catch my attention, but first, since it’s been a while, here’s the mandatory recap.
Recall, back in August, that biochemical engineer turned antivaccine activist and epidemiologist wannabe Brian Hooker, published a study, recently retracted, that basically provided strong evidence that Andrew Wakefield was wrong about the MMR vaccine being associated with autism. When I first saw Hooker’s study, even I recognized how utterly incompetently it was carried out, and I’m not even an epidemiologist or statistician. After all, it’s pretty obvious that data collected for a case-control study should not be analyzed as a cohort study, but that’s just what Hooker did. When I first read the study, I was actually not as hard on it as I should have been. The more I’ve read, and the more I’ve found out, the more I’ve realized just how badly done it was. Contrary to what Hooker apparently believes, simplicity is not beauty in statistics, particularly when you fail to control for obvious confounders and analyze data incorrectly. The result was a “finding” that there was a 3.4-fold increased risk of autism associated with MMR in African-American boys. Never mind that the numbers of this subgroup were tiny and the data incorrectly analyzed. Never mind that the rest of the data were negative as negative could be for even a whiff of a hint of a correlation between vaccines and autism for any other subgroup and that the vast majority of the leaders of the antivaccine movement are your basic affluent white people who never showed much in the way of an interest in the problems of African-American children before. Suddenly, this finding was being likened to the Tuskegee syphilis experiment by Andrew Wakefield himself!
This incompetent study was the result, allegedly, of discussions between Hooker and a senior psychologist at the CDC named William Thompson. For reasons that are still not clear, Thompson, a co-author on an important study by DeStefano et al, confided in Hooker, who, betraying his confidences, recorded much of what he said, an action whose legality is unclear given that it’s unclear where all of these recordings were made (one party or two party consent states). Hooker then teamed up with Andrew Wakefield to cherry pick bits to make it sound as though Thompson were confessing to some horrible crime of data manipulation to hide this “bombshell” result reported by Wakefield. Thus was born the “CDC whistleblower,” who featured prominently in the video likening DeStefano et al and the “coverup” to the Tuskegee syphilis experiment. Later, Thompson released a statement through his lawyer characterizing the whole problem over DeStefano et al as being a scientific disagreement. Nonetheless, a new conspiracy theory was born: The “CDC whistleblower,” complete with its own hashtag on Twitter, #CDCwhistleblower. Thompson has said nothing publicly since then, and the mainstream media has basically ignored the story other than an interview with Ronan Farrow of MSNBC that basically trashed the claims of the antivaccine movement.
So, after two months of relentlessly trying to get the mainstream media to pay attention and utterly failing, Andrew Wakefield and Brian Hooker had to try something new. Last Wednesday, that something new dropped into the antivaccine blogosphere with a massive plop that no one heard outside of the echo-chamber confines of sites like the antivaccine crank blog Age of Autism. For instance, everyone’s favorite hysterical antivaccine blogger Kent Heckenlively proclaims it as “The Hammer Falls!”:
Dr. Brian Hooker, Dr. Andrew Wakefield, and attorney James Moody announced today they have sent a complaint by Federal Express to Dr. Harold Jaffe, Associate Director for Science at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, as well as Dr. Don Wright, Acting Director of the Office of Research Integrity at the Department of Health and Human Services, claiming research misconduct in the 2004 paper, “Age at First Measles-Mumps-Rubella Vaccination in Children with Autism and School-Matched Control Subjects: A Population-Based Study in Metropolitan Atlanta,” which was subsequently published in the journal, Pediatrics.
The allegations are horrifying, not just for the millions of families who deal with autism on a daily basis, but for the picture it paints of a government agency, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), devoid of any shred of scientific integrity or what we once used to call “honor” in this country.
If these claims are shown to be true, we will be looking at nothing less than the greatest crime committed in the history of our republic, and a dark page in science which will be remembered for centuries to come.
Let’s just say that Heckenlively is prone to a little…hyperbole. I mean, seriously. For the sake of argument, as a thought experiment, let’s imagine for the moment that every allegation flowing from the fever dream conspiracy theory that is the #CDCwhistleblower is true. In that case, does Heckenlively really believe that this “crime” was worse than, say, slavery? The internment of Japanese-Americans in the early days of World War II after the bombing of Pearl Harbor? The real Tuskegee syphilis experiment? This is worse? It just goes to show how out of touch with reality these people are. But, then, this is Kent Heckenlively we’re talking about here. Reality and Mr. Heckenlively haven’t been on the same planet for at least a decade, not to mention that this is Brian Hooker and Andrew Wakefield making an accusation of scientific fraud. In what bizarro world does Andrew Wakefield, the ultimate scientific fraudster himself, accuse anyone, much less CDC scientists, of scientific fraud? Then there’s Hooker, who is the most incompetent epidemiologist wannabe I’ve seen aside from his young Padawan Jake Crosby and whose big foray into epidemiology broke records in speed of retraction. Even more hilariously, his article was retracted from a new journal. It was so toxically bad that even a new journal, scrambling to establish itself and attract quality submissions, couldn’t afford not to retract it. Pot, kettle, black, anyone?
The result of these delusional accusations is a 34-page letter to the Dr. Harold Jaffe, CDC Associate Director for Science, and Dr. Don Wright, Acting Director, ORI, along with an appendix. It’s a painful slog to read through, particularly given that it doesn’t discuss much that I haven’t already covered in detail before here and here (not to mention on my not-so-super-secret other blog). That’s not to say that there aren’t any new revelations, but most of them have little or nothing to do with the attacks on the science based on methodology, which have been covered, discussed, and dissected here and on other blogs until it was quite clear that Hooker had no clue how to do an epidemiological study and went into his “study” with a preconceived notion of what it should show.
The core of this complaint is found in this early paragraph:
We write to report apparent research misconduct by senior investigators within the National Immunization Program (NIP), Battelle Memorial Institute at the Centers for Public Health Evaluation (CPHE), and the National Center on Birth Defects and Developmental Disabilities (NCBDDD), and to request an immediate investigation.
The Analysis Plan dated September 5, 2001 [Exhibit 2] set forth the objective of the research reported in the above-titled article, to compare ages at first MMR vaccination between children with autism and children who did not have autism, and to test the hypothesis that age of first MMR vaccination is associated with autism risk.
The research team, headed by Dr. Frank DeStefano, MD., (NIP) including Dr. William Thompson Ph.D., (NIP) Dr. Marshalyn Yeargin-Allsopp, MD (NCBDDD), Dr. Tanya Karapurkar Bashin (CPHE), and Dr. Coleen Boyle, Ph.D., (NCBDDD) (collectively referred to by Dr. Thompson as “The Group”) found statistically significant associations between the age of first MMR and autism in (a) the entire autism cohort, (b) African-American children, and (c) children with ‘isolated’ autism, a subset defined by The Group as those with autism and without comorbid developmental disabilities.
We’ve heard this before, albeit not exactly in this way. The central charge is that the investigators altered the research plan after the study was under way. The charge basically goes this way. The CDC planned a case control study examining the age of receiving the MMR vaccine and whether it correlated with an increased risk of autism using data from the Metropolitan Atlanta Developmental Disabilities Surveillance Program (MADDSP). Seeing a result they didn’t like, they allegedly altered the plan in order not to report the “inconvenient” finding that the MMR resulted in a three-fold increased risk of autism among African-American boys. Explaining from scratch why this is BS would take a post of truly Gorski length in and of itself. Fortunately, Wakefield and Hooker couldn’t keep their mouths shut. Wakefield had to go and make a video outlining the charges before he sent this letter to the CDC:
The video came out about two weeks days ago, and I actually thought of blogging it at the time, but I was a bit burned out on the whole #CDCwhistleblower thing. So I let this antivaccine cup pass for a change. Fortunately, Matt Carey took it on more than a week ago, and that makes my job easier. Matt’s post is worth reading in its entirety, but the Cliffs Notes version is as follows. In the video, Wakefield zeros in on a single sentence that says “The only variable available to be assessed as a potential confounder using the entire sample is child’s race.” Based on that, and allegedly confirmed by Thompson during conversations with Hooker, Wakefield and Hooker claim that “decisions were made regarding which findings to report after the data was collected,” further claiming, “Thompson’s conversations with Hooker confirmed that it was only after the CDC study coauthors observed results indicating a statistical association between MMR timing and autism among African-Americans boys, that they introduced the Georgia birth certificate criterion as a requirement for participation in the study. This had the effect of reducing the sample size by 41% and eliminating the statistical significance of the finding, which Hooker calls a direct deviation from the agreed upon final study protocol – a serious violation.’”
I discussed this aspect in my original post, namely how doing this was not the scientific fraud claimed, but at the time I didn’t have access to the original research plan. In any case, notice that that one sentence doesn’t even really mean that the investigators deviated from the plan, as race was always planned to be examined as a potential confounder for the whole group. As Carey put it:
There are two interesting points in the above. First, the sentence Mr. Wakefield highlights doesn’t say what he claims. The only variable available to be assessed as a potential confounder using the entire sample is child’s race. The plan doesn’t say that they will test and report race. Consider the context: this is a section of the plan called “statistical analysis”. Put in context with the entire paragraph, this sentence is clear: the full dataset is limited because it only has one variable available.
The CDC didn’t deviate from the plan when they didn’t report on race for the total sample because that was never in the plan.
Exactly. More importantly, Wakefield and Hooker are cherry picking. (So what else is new?) As Carey points out, the analysis plan doesn’t include a call to report on race separately in the total sample (the group without the birth certificates), and the CDC “approved analysis plan” did include analysis of a subset with birth certificate data. Use of birth certificate data to look for confounders was always an option in the plan. For example:
For the children born in Georgia for whom we have birth certificate data, several sub-analyses will be carried out similar to the main analyses to assess the effect of several other potential confounding variables.
And:
3) Analyses examining Gender Effects
Males are at substantially higher risk for autism and may be more vulnerable to the exposure associated with the MMR vaccine. We will analyze males and females separately and replicate the main objectives of the primary analyses as well as examine the potential confounders available from Georgia birth certificates.
In the complaint, Wakefield and Hooker even misquoted the analysis plan, as Carey also points out. The plan states, “The only variable available to be assessed as a potential confounder using the entire sample is child’s race.” The complaint quotes this as, “The only variable that will be assessed as a potential confounder using the entire sample will be the child’s race.” He had also verified that he was examining the same document that Wakefield and Hooker had.
Wakefield also tries to do a bit of statistical prestidigitation by claiming that one of the analyses proposed, analyses of “isolated” versus “non-isolated” autism were not done. “Isolated” autism is autism with no comorbid developmental disabilities, such as mental retardations. As Carey convincingly argues, this subanalysis was done. He even explains how, although the raw, unadjusted analysis appears to show an association between age at MMR vaccination (vaccination prior to 36 months) and autism, the adjusted, final analysis does not. Tellingly, Hooker’s study is praised in the complaint thusly:
Dr. Hooker has approved access to public datasets for the original raw data from the study provided by the CDC. Dr. Hooker was thereby able to repeat the original analyses and confirm The Group’s findings of an excess autism risk in African American children. Dr. Hooker’s reanalysis [Exhibit 4] was rigorously peer reviewed and published.6 Dr. Hooker’s paper was reviewed and approved by Dr. Thompson. Dr. Thompson has also supplied Dr. Hooker with his original data output and subsequent data runs of his analyses.
Funny how Wakefield and Hooker didn’t see fit to mention that Hooker’s study was retracted—and retracted over a week before they sent their letter to the CDC! Wakefield and Hooker owe me a new keyboard again (or I should know better than to drink anything, even water, while reading anything written by these two) for this, as well:
Dr. Hooker is a scientist, Assistant Professor at Redding University, California, an extensively published vaccine safety researcher, and the father of a child with autism. Dr. Wakefield is an academic gastroenterologist by training and a documentary film producer/director with Autism Media Channel. Both have standing to complain. Both have a strong interest in documenting this research misconduct and in securing a remedy for the severe damage it has caused: Dr. Hooker’s son was, as alleged in his petition for compensation to the NVICP, permanently damaged by vaccines. The ethically required and Congressionally – mandated compensation provided by this program has been denied to many children based in part on the misconduct alleged herein. He has also suffered scientific opprobrium for his position on vaccine safety. Dr. Wakefield first proposed a possible link between MMR and autism,7 and specifically, age of exposure to MMR and autism risk.8 Had The Group’s true findings been published as intended,9 well before their actual publication date in 2004, much of the damaged done to Dr. Wakefield’s career and reputation might have been mitigated. Mr. Moody is an attorney with a longstanding interest in the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (NVICP) and an expert in Whistleblower law.
Hooker is an “extensively published vaccine safety researcher”? A PubMed search reveals four publications that might have anything to do with autism or “vaccine safety,” including the retracted one. Subtract the retracted paper and a paper dismissing paternal age as a risk factor for autism (clearly it must be the vaccines, then!), and only two publications that have anything to do with vaccines remain (1, 2). That’s hardly “extensively published.” Of course, Wakefield’s standing in this is dubious at best, too, given that his reputation and career were almost entirely destroyed in England, not the US.
So we know that Wakefield and Hooker are dishonestly cherry picking evidence in their letter, but there’s one bombshell that shocked me and goes a long way towards explaining something that’s always bothered me about this affair: Why? Why did Thompson confide in Hooker? What drove him to it? It turns out that, if Hooker and Wakefield are telling the truth about this (and I really take anything they say with an enormous grain of salt), Thompson was (and presumably still is) prone to anxiety issues (at minimum), depression, and what Thompson calls “delusions,” which first manifested themselves in a big way a decade ago, around the time he was preparing to present the results of this study to the Institute of Medicine and was facing the likelihood of being called to testify in front of a Congressional committee whose chair was notorious for his antivaccine views. After citing an e-mail from Thompson to Julie Geberding, the then-director of the CDC (which I discussed), in which Thomspon expressed anxiety about appearing in front of a Congressional committee, Wakefield and Hooker write:
In the end, Dr. Thompson signed off on The Paper that was published in Pediatrics [Exhibit 1]. However, his name was withdrawn from the roster of those due to present to the IOM on February 9, 2004. In reporting a discussion that he had had with his whistleblower lawyer Thompson stated:
Ya know, I’m not proud of that and uh, it’s probably the lowest point in my career that I went along with that paper and I also paid a huge price for it because I became delusional.24
In his recorded call with Dr. Thompson of 5.8.14, Dr. Hooker pressed the [sic] Dr. Thompson on whether he raised his concerns about the omission of significant data with The Group in the days leading up to the IOM meeting.
Dr. Hooker: Did you raise that…did you raise that issue at the time?
Dr. Thompson: I will say I raised this issue…I will say I raised this issue, the uh…two days before I became delusional.
This reference is important: three days before the IOM presentation Thompson – faced with either presenting false data or taking responsibility for the vaccine-autism link in front of potentially hostile parents of autistic children25 – stopped sleeping, and became profoundly depressed and “delusional.” Crucially, he reports no prior history of mental disorder.
Dr. Thompson went on to confirm, to Dr. Hooker, that the DeStefano 2004 paper was the reason for these acute psychological problems.
Dr. Thompson: It is one of the reasons I became delusional because I was so paranoid about this being published.
Citation 24 is claimed to be from a phone conversation between Hooker and Thompson dated May 24, 2014. That was the Saturday of Memorial Day weekend this year. Hmmm. That was also during Autism One. Brian Hooker gave a talk at Autism One on May 23. One wonders if he was still there, one does. Why do I wonder that? Because Illinois has one of the most Draconian laws in the country when it comes to being a “two party” consent state with respect to recording conversations. If Hooker recorded a phone call with Thompson while Hooker was in Chicago, that could be big trouble for him, should Thompson wish to pursue it. That’s a minor consideration, though. The major consideration is that, if this conversation occurred as represented, then Hooker just divulged highly personal medical information that Thompson confided to him, namely that Thompson suffered some sort of mental breakdown, complete with paranoia, delusions, and depression, right before IOM conference ten years ago. This, after having bragged about how he was Thompson’s “confessor,” like a priest. How low can you go? In order to imply that the magnitude of the “crime” Thompson was being forced to be party to was so massive that it led him to some sort of mental breakdown in the days leading up to the IOM conference, Hooker betrayed Thompson’s confidences about a very personal health issue.
Oh, wait. This is Brian Hooker and Andrew Wakefield we’re talking about.
It’s now clear to me that Thompson appears to be a bit of a fragile soul, easily rattled. From the sketchy description in Wakefield’s and Hooker’s complaint, he sounds as though he suffered a bout of what sounds like a panic attack or severe anxiety disorder, but I don’t know enough to tell. If that’s the case, though, anxiety disorders can be profoundly crippling and lead to the sort of behavior described. Either way, anxiety disorder or no anxiety disorder, depression or no depression, it’s quite clear that, even at his best, Thompson melts under pressure, and that could explain a lot of his behavior, certainly back in 2003 and 2004 and possibly even this year.
In the end, though, Wakefield’s and Hooker’s complaint is nothing more than a publicity stunt. Their first play, the video likening DeStefano et al and the “coverup” of “vaccines causing autism in African American boys” to the Tuskegee syphilis experiment, Hitler, Stalin, and Pol Pot, failed miserably. For all the Twitter bombing of the #CDCwhistleblower hashtag, the mainstream media barely took notice, and rightly so. There was nothing to see there. Also, as I’ve pointed out many times before, Wakefield’s name is, quite correctly, now so toxic that his involvement with this whole affair virtually guaranteed that no one of any consequence in the mainstream media would take it seriously. If Hooker had written this letter, sent it to the CDC, and publicized it out of the blue, he might have fooled a few credulous mainstream media outlets or reporters into doing a story or two about it in a fairly neutral tone. Making this play now, after having been associated with Wakefield and after all the #CDCwhistleblower nonsense, virtually guarantees that nothing will come of this.
But it sure will rile up the antivaccine base. That’s the point, after all.

The Woo Boat, or: How far Andrew Wakefield has fallen
David Gorski on August 16, 2015
Link


File this one under the category: You can’t make stuff like this up. (At least, I can’t.)
Let’s say you’re a diehard all-conspiracy conspiracy theorist and alternative medicine believer (a not uncommon combination). You love Alex Jones and Mike Adams and agree with their rants that there is a New World Order trying to suppress your rights. You strongly believe that vaccines not only cause autism, sudden infant death syndrome, a shaken baby-like syndrome, autoimmune diseases, premature ovarian failure, and even outright death, but are a depopulation plot hatched by Bill Gates and the Illuminati who support his agenda. Heck, you even believe that black helicopters are keeping an eye on those who have discovered this plot. To you, genetically modified organisms (GMOs) are part of the same plot, pure poison and pure evil. And, of course, you just know that there is a cure for cancer—nay, cures for all diseases—out there but those evil pharmaceutical companies are keeping them from the people, the better to bolster their profits, just as they are preventing Brave Maverick Doctors like Andrew Wakefield, Mark Geier, and Sherri Tenpenny from telling the world the truth about vaccines. Heck, you just know that these same nefarious forces are even going so far as to kill vaccine “skeptic” heroes like Jeff Bradstreet (and, of course, make it look like a suicide) and holistic “pioneers” like Nicholas Gonzalez (and make it look like a heart attack).
And you like cruises.
So where do you go when you want to go on a cruise? Normal cruises are filled with people who just want to have a good time and tend to roll their eyes when you regale them with your ideas about how there is a shadowy conspiracy out there that is promoting toxic pharmaceuticals and vaccines and preventing natural cures from being used by the people, while simultaneously promoting GMOs to make people sick so that they think they need more of those pharmaceuticals and vaccines and more pliable so that their New World Order agenda faces less opposition. By the time you get to how they’re also using chemtrails as another means of control, AIDS is not caused by HIV, and Ebola can be cured with homeopathy, in other words, by the time you’ve been on the cruise a couple of days, you’ll find yourself basically shunned, eating alone at dinner, and drinking alone at the bar. When you sit down at a table, everyone suddenly finds a reason to be elsewhere.
Fear not! There is now a cruise for you. See the Conspira-Sea Cruise next January, embarking in Los Angeles and taking you on a cruise through the Mexican Riviera:
Our “Conspira-Sea Cruise and Seminar-at-Sea” takes place right on our luxury cruise ship during our seven-day cruise, in conference rooms on the ship, and during our port calls in Mexico.
During this incredible, mind-blowing, truth-telling, spiritually enriching event, we will do our best to uncover the truth about things conspiratorial, including:
GMOs, Monsanto, bee colony collapse, ecology, global warming, climate change, fracking, HIV, autism, big pharma, medical suppression, vaccinations, flouridation [sic], political corruption, government corruption, forbidden archeology, forbidden religion, Federal Reserve, truth about money, World Bank, IRS, strawman, property title, admiralty law, martial law, Bohemian Grove, Skull and Bones, JFK, cover-ups, September 11, Star Wars agenda, nuclear plants, chemtrails, HAARP, crop circles, IRS, MK-Ultra, Fukashima [sic], NASA, NSA, Bilderbergs, sustainability, military industrial complex, pentagon [sic], Waco, Malaysia 370, Pan Am 103, TWA 800, Gulf Oil Spill, Halliburton, Obama, Ruby Ridge, OK City, Vatican, New World Order, false flags, Montauk, privacy, surveillance, Area 51, Dulce, Project Rainbow, Nazi Bell, Vrill, U.S.S. Eldridge, Iron Mountain, psyops, population mangement [sic], subliminal ads, Nibiru / Planet X, Cointel Pro, technology suppression, entity possession, electoral fraud, identity chips, 2nd amendment, and so much more.
Plus we will explore how to heal ourselves and others, and to attain self-mastery and greater integrity through:
Spirituality, meditation, affirmation, prayer, yoga, manifestation, self-development, holistic health, alternative lifestyles, organic foods, healthy living, wellness, self-sufficiency, prosperity, sustainability, freedom, human rights, discernment, wisdom, awakening, longevity, inner guidance, and inner peace.
The purpose of this cruise is NOT about being a victim of conspiracies. It is about taking back our power from corrupt and greedy institutions, attaining true self-authority, and realizing our genuine Self behind the masks. It is about discovering the truth, taking command of our lives, and attaining genuine inner realization.
This cruise will not only uncover the lies. It will show us the truth. As we dispell [sic] the darkness, and shine the light of wisdom, we enter the true light of consciousness.
When I first saw this link, I really thought that it had to be a joke, a Poe of some sort. There really couldn’t be a cruise like this, could there? Then I looked at the company organizing the cruise, Divine Travels, which advertises itself as a “gateway to spiritual adventures,” and I had to admit that this Conspira-Sea Cruise is legit and fits right in with Divine Travels’ other cruises, which are loaded with woo, such as a tour of Egypt with Cindy Reed, an energy/spiritual healer, a New Age retreat where you can learn “spiritual healing,” and more. In this case, Divine Travels has outdone itself. Look at this preliminary speaker list. There are antivaccinationists, such as Andrew Wakefield, who, hilariously is listed as a “Vaccination & Autism Researcher”; Sherry Tenpenny, who is listed accurately as an “Anti-Vaccine Activist”; and Toni Bark, described as a “Vaccination Whistleblower.” I know Tenpenny and Wakefield’s activities well, but I didn’t remember who Toni Bark is. So I Googled her and quickly found her website—and with it, some serious quackery, including homeopathy, something called “lipodissolve,” links to quack movies like Gary Null’s Silent Epidemic: The Untold Story of Vaccines, and several appearances on The Gary Null Show.
OK, she fits right in, and I did start to remember her when I saw her picture. For some reason, I don’t recall ever having blogged about her before.
But, hey, you say. Antivaccine conspiracy theories just aren’t my thing. No problem! How about alt-med conspiracy theories? In addition to Toni Bark doing double duty on vaccines and general alt-med craziness, one of my “favorite” quacks (and by “favorite” I mean favorite target of mockery), Robert O. Young, the man who thinks all cancer is due to excess acidity and that his “alkaline diet” will cure cancer and all serious diseases, will be there. So will Len Horowitz and Sherry Kane. Horowitz advertises himself as “The King David of Natural Healing” versus “The Goliath of ‘Slash, Burn, and Poison’ Medicine,” while Sherri Kane is a journalist who works with him spreading his message, describing herself as an “investigative journalist, news commentator, psycho-social analyst, and political activist, specializing in uncovering media persuasion and manipulation, conspiracy realities and women’s, children’s, and animal rights issues.” Together, they are collaborating on “Healthy World Organization (HWO) (the alternative to the corrupt World Health Organization), HealthyWorldAffiliates.com, and The 528 Love Revolution advancing the power of the “528 hz” frequency of Love and Healing for a Musical Revolution and Spiritual Renaissance with 528Records.com and i528tunes.com.”
He’s also affiliated Medical Veritas, if you remember that. I sure do, particularly its cancer quackery and HIV/AIDS denialism.
But that’s not all! There are (of course!) anti-GMO activists like Jeffery Smith; HIV/AIDS denialists, such as Robert Strecker; and “holistic healers” like Dale Allen Hoffman and Dr. Dream. But, hey, medicine isn’t your conspiracy topic. For you, there are—of course!—a whole bevy of “spiritual teachers.” But that’s not all. Don’t think other woo has been forgotten! Oh, no! There are “paranormal investigators,” an “earth advocate” and “global alchemist” (whatever that means) named Laura Eisenhower, and near death experience survivors. There’s Nick Begich, conspiracy theorist who believes that HAARP is a form of mind control. If that’s not woo-ful enough for you, they even have a chemtrails researcher named Sharon Schloss, a crop circle maven named Patty Greer, and an astrologist named Helen Sewell. Truly, I’m hard pressed to think of a form of quackery, pseudoscience, or paranormal nonsense. Oh, wait. There’s no cryptozoology, no Bigfoot maven. Well, it’s still early. Maybe they’ll find someone.
Of course, there are testimonials from previous Spiritual Travels cruises, such as:
“The panel of speakers was by far the best attribute of the trip. The speakers covered a wide array of topics… everything from Angel wings to the modern Nazi regime. It was all around enlightenment.”–D.R.M., Wyoming
“Enlightenment” isn’t quite the word I’d use to describe such a cruise.
When it was suggested to me that a skeptic should sign up for this cruise, I pointed out two things that would disqualify me. First, I’d have to waste vacation time. Second, Andrew Wakefield provokes such a visceral response in me that being in his actual physical presence, particularly on a ship, might actually make me physically ill. Come to think of it, the same can be said of Robert O. Young. Also, as people who know me know, although I would certainly be amused by some of these speakers, I am not very good at hiding my contempt for quacks like Wakefield and Young. After all, a skeptic mole would have to be able to avoid getting kicked off the boat!
Still, if there are any intrepid souls willing to do this, maybe a Go Fund Me page would be able to provide the travel and cruise expenses. I’m sure there’d be blogging material for many weeks. Heck, there might even be enough material for a book! In the meantime, I can’t help but feeling some rather intense schadenfreude over how far Andy Wakefield has fallen. It amuses me to no end that he’s now sharing a podium with HAARP mind control conspiracy nuts, paranormal researchers, and chemtrail and crop circle aficionados.

WWTI Doctors, Trump Based Medicine, and the “Vindication” of Andrew Wakefield
Dr. Vinay Prasad seems poised to stop the “too many too soon” approach and start making Andrew Wakefield’s dreams a reality.

Jonathan Howard on October 31, 2025
Link
I think the president is 100% correct.
My last few articles have had a similar theme.
    • In Doctors Who Glorified Trump Have Permanently Tied Themselves to Everything He Does, I discussed Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, who said that Trump is “very pro-science” and that it is “ridiculous slander” to suggest otherwise.
    • In MAHA and the Triumph of Feelings Based Medicine I discussed how Dr. Marty Makary, parroted Trump’s claims about Tylenol and autism and touted leucovorin as a treatment based on “incredible stories.”
    • In Dr. Vinay Prasad Doesn’t Realize He’s The Establishment. It’s His Job to Produce Results for the American Public, Not Fluff Donald Trump, I discussed how Dr. Prasad said Trump was “100% correct” about vaccines.
We Want Them Infected doctors clearly do not want to get on the wrong side of their boss.
I think the president has a deeper point about the evidence to support combination and concomitant administration.
Meanwhile, here’s what Trump is saying today:
Kennedy confirmed this more than just idle chatter in a recent press conference:
Reporter: The president has asked to break up the MMR vaccine into three separate shots. Is that something you’re going to direct ACIP to consider or take action on?
RFK Jr: We’re looking at the feasibility of that now.
Unfortunately, WWTI doctors, specifically Dr. Prasad, seem poised to turn these delusions into reality. In an interview with his fellow disinformation superspreader Bari Weiss titled Trump’s Vaccine Chief on Childhood Vaccinations, Dr. Prasad had this exchange:
Bari Weiss: The MMR has been administered in one single vaccine, for measles, mumps, and rubella, since the early 1970s. The president, in saying that the shot should be broken up, is more than implying that the combined shot is dangerous. Is it?
Vinay Prasad: I believe MMR is an important vaccine. I think the president has a deeper point about the evidence to support combination and concomitant administration. By background, combination vaccines combine two or more into a single vial or shot, while concomitant administration means administering two or more at the same visit. Historically, FDA has had stronger levels of evidence for combination than concomitant administration, but that is changing. We are planning new guidance to raise the bar for concomitant administration, and we have a paper now submitted in a medical journal. Stay tuned.
This is dangerous stuff.  Before someone messes with the vaccine schedule, they better have a very good reason. That’s the medically conservative approach. Combination vaccines are nothing new- even Bari Weiss knew the MMR has been used since the early 1970s- and if someone feels they are unsafe, the burden is on them to prove it, not the other way around.  Since Dr. Prasad feels we need “stronger levels of evidence”, it is his job to generate that evidence.  He is the medical establishment.
This is vindication
Unsurprisingly one person is overjoyed by all this, Andrew Wakefield. He and Trump go way back, and with WWTI doctors in charge, he is taking a victory lap. He recently said:
For three decades, I’ve stood by the principle that we must protect our children by questioning a vaccine schedule that has grown unchecked and untested. President Trump announced a sweeping plan to reform the childhood vaccine schedule. And he did it by adopting the very recommendation I made back in 1998.
That includes splitting the MMR vaccine into individual measles, mumps, and rubella shots… delaying the hepatitis B vaccine until age 12… removing mercury and aluminum… spacing out vaccines, stopping the “too many too soon” approach… and eliminating Tylenol use around vaccination. For the millions of parents whose children were injured, ignored, gaslit, and shamed — this is vindication. But more importantly, it’s hope.
This is about being pro-safety, pro-transparency, and pro-child — and particularly pro the right of parents to choose on behalf of their children. The autism epidemic is real — and it’s time we confronted it with honesty.
We’ll see what Dr. Prasad’s “new guidance” says, but he appears poised to stop the “too many too soon” approach and start making Wakefield’s dreams a reality.
In this administration, you serve not only at the pleasure of the president, but for the pleasure of the president.
We need to be clear that we are witnessing Trump Based Medicine (TBM), where Trump’s deranged ramblings, derived from frauds like Wakefield and cranks like Kennedy, get laundered through esteemed professors from esteemed universities who absurdly claim, “the president has a deeper point about the evidence to support combination and concomitant administration.“
Of course, in the Trump administration, the truth is whatever he says it is. His feelings come first, and no one who works under him can disagree in any way. That includes the doctors serving- tenuously– under his reign. As one sage commenter said here recently:
In this administration, you serve not only at the pleasure of the president, but for the pleasure of the president. And if that means spouting BS until the cows come home, you’ll do it with a smile on your face. Or else you’re out of a job.
They’re right, and a slavish devotion to Trump is now official policy at the HHS. According to an article titled HHS Employees Now Being Measured by Loyalty to Trump’s Policies:
The Trump administration is using a new metric for assessing people’s job performance at the Department of Health and Human Services: whether they “clearly and demonstrably support implementation” of President Donald Trump’s policy agenda.
Tens of thousands of HHS employees have to fulfill four “critical elements” for their annual performance reviews, which take place at the end of the fiscal year. One of those elements, “Faithful Support of Administration of the Law and the President’s Policies,” lays out how workers now have to essentially prove their loyalty to Trump’s policies.
AAP Evidence-Backed Immunization Schedule Reflects Break from CDC Advisers.
At least there is a silver lining to this politicization of science- it’s all obvious and out in the open. WWTI doctors aren’t fooling anyone, and no reasonable person takes them seriously. Could you imagine a pediatrician caring what Vinay Prasad, Marty Makary, or Jay Bhattacharya has to say about vaccines or anything else for that matter?  Of course not. Everyone know they are mindless mouthpieces for their Dear Leader, and medical organizations and large swaths of the country are wisely forming their own guidelines in response. Today, the headlines read: 
    • Trust In Federal Health Leadership Is Failing Under RFK Jr., New Poll Finds
    • 15 Blue Governors’ New Alliance Is Largest Alternative Public Health Coalition Yet,
    • Veering from CDC, ACOG Recommends Maternal Vaccination Against COVID-19
    • AAP Evidence-Backed Immunization Schedule Reflects Break from CDC Advisers
Obviously, WWTI doctors can do a lot of damage moving forward. They can deceive a lot of parents and create devastating regulatory barriers to vaccines. Measles and pertussis are already spreading under their “leadership”, and rather than focusing keeping children healthy, WWTI doctors aim only to spread doubt and mistrust about vaccines. That’s what they do best.
However, amongst their peers, their ultimate fate may be a richly deserved irrelevancy. Their “new guidance to raise the bar for concomitant administration” will be delivered with great fanfare and drama, and though Wakefield will celebrate, doctors who actually care for sick people will know it’s just worthless TBM. And when it comes to making decisions for our patients and families, we will all roll our eyes and simply ignore it.


   Autism and Mercury

   Mercury in vaccines as a cause of autism and autism spectrum disorders (ASDs): A failed hypothesis
David Gorski
Links
One of the most pernicious medical myths of recent years has been the claim, promulgated by a subgroup of parents of autistic children and facilitated by scientists of dubious repute, that somehow the mercury in the thimerosal (ethyl mercury) preservative used in common childhood vaccines in the U.S. until early 2002 causes autism. Although it had been percolating under the radar of most parents and scientists for several years before, this belief invaded the national zeitgeist in a big way in 2005, beginning with the publication of a book by journalist David Kirby entitled Evidence of Harm: Mercury in Vaccines and the Autism Epidemic: A Medical Controversy. The fires of hysteria were stoked even higher by Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., who published a truly twisted and misleading piece of pseudojournalism and pseudoscience published simultaneously in Rolling Stone and on Salon.com entitled Deadly Immunity. Relying primarily on quote-mining of the transcripts of both a conference held Atlanta by the CDC to discuss the question of whether autism is related to thimerosal in vaccines and an Institute of Medicine report on vaccines while simultaneously misrepresenting the results of two studies by Verstaeten et al to paint a false picture of a government coverup, RFK Jr. almost single-handedly managed to stoke fears that vaccines were causing an “epidemic of autism.”
I say “almost” single-handedly, because, unfortunately, he had help. Relying on the dubious research of a variety of investigators, such as the father-and-son team of Dr. Mark Geier and David Geier, whose prodigious output of badly designed studies emanating from a lab in their home in suburban Maryland, done using a rubberstamp institutional review board stacked with friends and cronies to approve the studies, and published for the most part in non-peer-reviewed journals, activists loudly insisted that mercury in vaccines was the cause of most autism. Others claiming to demonstrate this link include Boyd Haley, a chemist from the University of Kentucky, and a few other vocal scientists and advocates, who claim that autism is, in essence, mercury poisoning. Facilitating the dissemination of this message were reporters such as David Kirby, activists such as Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., and media personalities such as Don Imus. Indeed, some activists claimed that some vaccines were “poisoning” our children, even going so far as show photos of autistic children with the label “mercury-poisoned“ underneath them on placards held aloft at protest rallies. They made quite a splash then, and still do to a lesser extent even today. There’s just one problem.
The scientific data, taken in totality, do not support a link between mercury in vaccines and autism. Today yet another important study by Robert Schechter and Judith Grether was released published in the Archives of General Psychiatry entitled Continuing Increases in Autism Reported to California’s Developmental Services System: Mercury in Retrograde1, that utterly failed to support the hypothesis that mercury in vaccines is an etiological factor in autism. It is yet another nail in the coffin of the medical myth that mercury in vaccines causes autism.
Before I discuss this new study in more detail, a bit of background is in order. In response to the FDA Modernization Act of 1997, prior to the hypothesis that thimerosal might cause autism the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) compiled a list of vaccines and how much thimerosal they contained. Thimerosal had been commonly used to prevent microbial contamination of vaccines, particularly multidose vials, since the 1930s. It could be reasonably argued that, given the more lax standards of the time, thimerosal had not been adequately tested before use in humans, but decades of use after that had, as far as could be discerned, revealed only occasional skin hypersensitivity reactions due to this component. By 1999, under the recommended schedule of childhood vaccines at the time, concern was expressed that infants, before six months of age, were potentially being exposed to cumulative doses of ethyl mercury that may have exceeded safety standards. It should be noted that these safety standards were based on an indirect surrogate of ethyl mercury, namely methyl mercury, and largely in the absence of any real data. In July 1999, the American Academy of Pediatrics and the U.S. Public Health Service decided, as a precaution, to recommend that thimerosal be removed as soon as possible from childhood vaccines.
It did not take long for this recommendation to be implemented. By March 2001, all vaccines in the recommended infant vaccination schedule were available in forms that had at most traces of thimerosal left over from the manufacturing process. The last lots of childhood vaccines with thimerosal had expiration dates in 2002. Indeed, as Arthur Allen documented in his recent book Vaccine: The Controversial Story of Medicine’s Greatest Lifesaver, a survey of several hundred medical offices in February 2002 conducted by the CDC found that, of the three pediatric vaccines that contained thimerosal in the 1990s, only 2% of vaccine stock still contained thimerosal. Since then, with the exception of the flu vaccine, no childhood vaccine in the U.S. has contained more than trace amounts of thimerosal. There has been considerable debate over whether the decision to remove thimerosal was undertaken too quickly. True, at the time it seemed like a prudent, cautious step. However, the decision had unintended consequences. One was that it resulted in a temporary shortage of childhood vaccines. More importantly, though, it fed the fears of activists that the mercury in vaccines must really be harmful. After all, if it weren’t harmful, why would the AAP and PHS recommend its removal?
Why indeed? The use of this precautionary measure, which to health officials seemed prudent at that time, as justification for attacking the safety of vaccines is as good an example of how no good deed goes unpunished as I’ve ever seen. Many parents, faced with the enormous challenge of raising autistic children, not unreasonably wondered whether there was something wrong with vaccines in the first place.
The second bit of background information that you need to know is that, over the last couple of decades, the incidence of autism and autism spectrum disorder (ASD) has increased markedly to an estimated 1 in 150 children. Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. and others who believe that mercury in vaccines somehow cause autism have referred to this increase as an “autism epidemic” (or, more offensively, as an “autism tsunami“) and frequently claim that there must be an environmental factor that has led to this increase. Because the symptoms of autism, such as cognitive delay and withdrawal from interaction with parents, often manifest themselves between one and three years of age and because this is the age when children receive the bulk of their vaccines, there is a correlation. However, correlation does not necessarily equal causation. It may, but often it does not. Often the correlation is spurious, unrelated, or related to a common factor. More investigation is always required to determine if an apparent correlation is or is not due to causation. In the case of autism, there is good evidence, most recently published by Paul Shattuck2, that increased awareness and diagnostic substitution since the criteria for a diagnosis of ASD were broadened in 1994 account for the apparent increase in diagnoses of autism, as pointed out by Arthur Allen and Roy Grinker.
Regarding the question of vaccines and autism, for ethical reasons we cannot do a double-blind, randomized, control trial of vaccines with and without thimerosal. However, we can do the next best thing, and, indeed, we now have several good studies since 1999 that do just that. Some of these studies are epidemiological; some are ecological. What allows us to use them to reject the hypothesis that mercury in vaccines is an etiological agent that is either associated with or causes autism is a very simple but powerful prediction that the hypothesis makes. Quite simply, if the hypothesis is true and thimerosal-containing vaccines (TCVs) cause autism (or are even merely a significant contributing factor), we would expect that the removal of thimerosal from vaccines would lead to a rapid decrease in autism incidence and prevalence within 2-5 years.
There have now been several studies that examined this very hypothesis in countries that removed thimerosal from their vaccines before the U.S. did. For example Hviid et al3 reported that autism prevalence in Denmark increased from 1991 to 1996 despite the removal of thimerosal from vaccines, while Madsen et al4 looked at the time period from 1971 to 2000 and concluded that autism diagnoses continued to increase after thimerosal was removed from vaccines. Neither study supported a causal link between TCVs and autism, and they were a prominent part of the dataset that was used by the Institute of Medicine to conclude in 2004 that there was no good evidence to support a link between TCVs and autism. A more recent study by Eric Fombonne5 in Montreal examined 27,749 children born from 1987 to 1998 attending 55 different schools. Cumulative thimerosal exposure by age 2 years was calculated for the 1987-1998 birth cohorts. This exposure ranged from 100-125 μg from 1987 to 1991, 200-225 μg from 1992 to 1995, and then none after 1996, which was when thimerosal was completely removed from vaccines in Canada. The result was that autism, ASD, and pervasive developmental disorder diagnoses continued to increase in all periods, demonstrating no relationship between TCVs and autism or ASDs. Even more recently, a large study6 failed to support a relationship between thimerosal and adverse neurodevelopmental outcomes, a result that led one of the investigators in the study, Sallie Bernard, a proponent of the thimerosal hypothesis, to disavow the study in a case of sour grapes, because it did not show what she had hoped that it would show.
We are now nearly six years out from the near-complete removal of thimerosal from vaccines. Other than the flu vaccine, there is no more than trace thimerosal in any childhood vaccine; overall mercury exposure due to vaccines has not been this low in decades. Consequently this hypothesis can now be tested in the United States. In a deliciously ironic twist, Schechter and Grether1 chose to use a source of data that has frequently been widely abused by advocates claiming a link between TCVs and autism to try to show one where there isn’t one as though the conclusions were foreordained. Although it is probably not, it has even been referred to as the “gold standard” of autism epidemiology by none other than David Kirby. Indeed, this is the very same database in which David Kirby predicted that there should be a noticeable decrease in new diagnoses of autism by 2007 if the thimerosal hypothesis is true and then later shifted the goalposts to 2011 when it became apparent that there has been no decrease. This source is the California Department of Developmental Services (CDDS) database. The CDDS administers a statewide system of regional centers and developmental centers designed to serve people who are substantially disabled because of autism, mental retardation, or other developmental disabilities. It maintains an archive file of client developmental evaluation reports on clients enrolled in the system. Among the strengths of the system are that it is a population-based system representing the most populous state in the U.S. Moreover, the client reporting form was consistent throughout the study period, preventing confounders due to changes in reporting. The weaknesses of the CDDS is that its data is derived from an administrative system that was designed to track enrollment and fiscal data and is not as well suited to measuring the occurrence of developmental disabilities in the population. However, with proper statistical analysis, considerable information can still be gleaned from this data for specific birth cohorts.
In order to ask the question of whether autism rates had declined, Schechter and Grether examined data for clients with active status reported from January 1, 1995 to March 31, 2007. Using careful statistical analyses, they used two approaches to measure the occurrence of ASD during this period. The second approach, in which ASD prevalence was determined in the 3 to 5 year old cohort, is perhaps the most informative. It shows a continuing increase in autism prevalence without even a blip or decrease in the rate of increase after 2002. Indeed, showing the skill of some bloggers to analyze the same data, the money figure in the paper (Figure 3) looks almost exactly the same as the graph prepared in early 2007, a continually increasing curve since 1995. This result is not only consistent with multiple other published and unpublished studies, including the aforementioned Danish and Canadian studies7, but it is about as unambiguous evidence as can be obtained from a database like the CDDS database. Indeed, despite the limitations of the use of this database, it is an excellent example of proponents of a “mercury injury” hypothesis of autism being “hoisted by their own petard,” so to speak. Indeed, Eric Fombonne, in a blistering editorial8 that accompanies this study, agrees:
The particular significance of the study by Schechter and Grether is that it relies on the California Department of Developmental Services database, which has been systematically used by proponents of the thimerosal hypothesis to argue that the rising number of children accessing these services— or the “epidemic” of autism— was linked to the increasing exposure to ethylmercury of US children occurring in the 1990s through the changes in the immunization schedule. To the contrary, the data analyzed by Schechter and Grether9 provide a clear and unambiguous test that shows that the expected decline in autism rates following discontinuation of thimerosal in US vaccines did not occur.
Noting that, “with the exception of studies conducted by a single pair of authors” (with uncharacteristic restraint Fombonne does not name whom he obviously meant, namely Mark and David Geier), all studies done have thus far failed to find a link between TCVs and autism, Fombonne continues:
Despite the accumulation of scientific evidence rejecting these 2 hypotheses linking autism to various components of childhood vaccines, these theories and the practices that accompany them have not faded away. Why? How many more negative study results are required for the belief to go away, and how much more spending of public funds on this issue could even be justified?
He then postulates an explanation that I happen to agree with:
Outside academic circles, powerful advocacy groups developed and started to lobby decision makers to influence decisions about which autism research to fund and even how to conduct it. Unaware of scientific studies, or worse, doubtful of their results, bestselling writers, journalists, and politicians were drawn to embrace conspiracy theories that portrayed vaccine manufacturers and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention as public enemies.15 Law firms saw an opportunity to obtain large financial compensations from the US Vaccine Injury Compensation Court or before local federal courts, the viscous US legal process allowing for fermentation of misconceptions. Exploiting further families’ beliefs and their understandable desire to try everything possible to help their children, charlatans developed alternative (and lucrative) “treatments” for autism, which included chelation therapy, use of a hyperbaric oxygen chamber, and testosterone suppression. All are of unproven efficacy, and many are dangerous.
In other words, it’s all about obtaining compensation for nonexistent “vaccine injury” and “biomedical treatments” for this injury. Never mind that these “treatments” are neither scientifically plausible nor have convincing evidence in the form of well-designed clinical trials to support their efficacy in ameliorating the cognitive delays observed in autistic children. Unfortunately, parents who love their autistic children and desperately want to do something to “make them better” are fertile ground for the blandishments of proponents of these implausible and unproven “therapies.” Some of these treatments, such as chelation therapy, which, it is claimed, will remove the mercury that, according to proponents of the thimerosal hypothesis, is the root cause of autism, have developed into veritable cottage industries that prey on desperate parents. It has even progressed to the point where the Geiers can convince some parents that most autistic children exhibit signs of “precocious puberty” and that the elevated testosterone in such children forms “sheets” that bind mercury and prevent it from being chelated properly. As hard as it is to believe, they then use that claim as a justification for using powerful anti-androgenic drugs such as Lupron on autistic children to treat their autism.
Vaccination is arguably the most effective single public health intervention ever developed. As recently as 50 years ago, for example, our parents and grandparents lived in deathly fear of diseases like polio, which is virtually a thing of the past. Because they are preventative in nature and administered to a very large population of healthy people, vaccines have a very high hurdle to jump as far as safety is concerned, because when an intervention is performed on millions of otherwise healthy people, even a low rate of complications can result in large numbers of injured people. Modern vaccines have achieved that level of safety. Are they completely safe? Nothing in medicine is absolutely, 100% safe. In comparison to the risk of the diseases they prevent and by any reasonable standard, the risks due modern vaccines are extremely low. Moreover, the claims of proponents of an increasingly untenable hypothesis to the contrary, there is no convincing evidence that thimerosal-containing vaccines, or vaccines in general, have anything to do with the etiology of autism. Whatever tiny risk there may be from childhood vaccines, autism and ASDs are not among them. Indeed, even before this study by Schechter and Grether, under the onslaught of studies that all fail to find a link between thimerosal and autism, even David Kirby and those more zealous than him were starting to back away from the hypothesis, invoking hand-waving and vague “environmental toxins” or even going so far as to blame mercury from pollution wafting over from China or, even more ludicrously, mercury from the cremation of bodies with mercury amalgam dental fillings. Meanwhile, in the wake of this study, Mark Blaxill is retreating to saying that “the epidemiological analysis doesn’t prove that thimerosal exposure cannot cause individual cases of autism” and blaming vaccines in general for autism (while also not being able to wait for the embargo to try to put his spin on the matter, by the way).
This study is clearly but one more nail in the coffin of this dying hypothesis. Unfortunately, like Jason in the Friday the 13th movies, the hypothesis that mercury in vaccines is a major cause of autism just refuses to die, no matter how many studies fail to find even a wisp of a link between the two. Just when you think it’s finally, really dead, it has an unpleasant way of being resurrected. That’s why it is not difficult to predict that the usual suspects will refuse to believe it, just as they have refused to believe the studies preceding it.
REFERENCES:
Schechter R and JK Grether (2008). Continuing Increases in Autism Reported to California’s Developmental Services System. Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 65: 19-24.
Shattuck P (2006). The Contribution of Diagnostic Substitution to the Growing Administrative Prevalence of Autism in US Special Education. Pediatrics 117:1028-1037.
Hviid A, M Stellfeld, J. Wohlfahrt, and M Melbye (2003). Association between thimerosal-containing vaccines and autism. JAMA 290:1763-1766.
Madsen KM, MB Lauritsen, CB Pedersen, P Thorsen, AM Plesner, PH Andersen, PB Mortensen (2003). Thimerosal and the Occurrence of Autism: Negative Ecological Evidence From Danish Population-Based Data. Pediatrics 112:604-6.
Fombonne E, R Zakarian, A Bennett, L Meng, D. McLean-Heywood (2006). Pervasive Developmental Disorders in Montreal, Quebec, Canada: Prevalence and Links With Immunizations. Pediatrics 118:e139-50.
Thompson WW, C Price, B Goodson, DK Shay, P Benson, VL Hinrichsen, E Lewis, E Eriksen, P Ray, SM Marcy, J Dunn, LA Jackson, TA Lieu, S Black, G Stewart, ES Weintraub, RL Davis, F DeStefano; Vaccine Safety Datalink Team (2007). Early Thimerosal Exposure and Neuropsychological Outcomes at 7 to 10 Years. NEJM 357:1281-1292.
Parker SK, B Schwartz, J Todd, and LKPickering (2004). Thimerosal-containing vaccines and autistic spectrum disorder: a critical review of published original data. Pediatrics 114:793-804.
Fombonne E (2008). Thimerosal disappears but autism remains. Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 65: 15-6.

   Mercury emissions from coal-burning power plants and autism. Is there a correlation?
David Gorski
Link
On April 30, outside the courthouse in Dallas, a press conference/rally was held. This particular rally was in response to a new study published by a group led by Dr. Raymond F. Palmer in the Department of Family and Community Medicine at the University of Texas Health Science Center in San Antonio, whose conclusion was that autism prevalence correlates strongly with proximity to mercury-emitting coal-burning power plants and other industrial sources of airborne mercury, the implication being that such sources of mercury may be causal or contributory to the development of autism. Unfortunately, the rally was reported by the media as though this study were slam dunk evidence that mercury environmental mercury is a definite contributor to the development of autism. For example, there is some video (also here) from local news sources of the rally, in the first of which it is stated as fact that mercury caused autism in the child featured in the story and in the second of which a mother who thinks that mercury causes autism is quoted credulously. This study has had much less play in the national news, but antivaccination activists, such as the ones at the Age of Autism website, a site whose main theme is that either mercury in the thimerosal preservative that used to be in childhood vaccines before 2002 or vaccines themselves cause autism, both promoted the rally and posted a glowing and credulous take on the study, as did “alternative medicine” and antivaccinationist website NaturalNews.com.
My first thought upon reading of this is that it is yet more vindication of the science showing that the claim that mercury in thimerosal-containing vaccines is a failed hypothesis. After all, as I have predicted time and time again, as the scientific and epidemiological evidence continued to mount that thimerosal is just plain not associated with autism or autism spectrum disorders, even the most diehard adherents to this belief are starting to realize that they were backing a losing horse, especially since thimerosal was removed from all childhood vaccines other than the flu vaccine in 2001, leaving only trace amounts from the manufacturing process and there is no sign that autism prevalence is falling. That’s why lately, their effort has shifted from primarily demonizing mercury to blaming other “toxins” in vaccines, even to the point that their efforts to demonize some ingredient–any ingredient–in vaccines often reaches ridiculous levels of blatant silliness, such as touting sucrose as one of those “toxins.” Indeed, I was puzzled. If environmental mercury is the new cause of autism, then the rationale antivaccinationists use to demonize vaccines and portray their children as “vaccine-damaged” is much less potent. Why on earth would they tout this study, which, even if a good study (and it’s not), would weaken their arguments against vaccines immeasurably and take power away from their whole new propaganda slogan “Green Our Vaccines”? The only reason I could think of is that perhaps they somehow think that if mercury in the environment can be linked to autism that maybe–just maybe–they can convince people that they were right about mercury in vaccines all along. Indeed, this seems to be the sort of tack that David Kirby took a year ago when he started arguing that mercury emissions from coal-burning power plants in China (which do reach California), coupled with mercury emission from crematoria in which cadavers with mercury fillings were burned, were contributing to the continued increase in the autism caseload in California despite the elimination of thimerosal in 2001.
But what does the study say itself? Is it good evidence that airborne mercury from coal-fueled power plants is an important contributor to the development of autism? I will argue no, because the study’s flaws are so innumerable that it is well nigh uninterpretable. For simplicity’s sake, to summarize its findings, I’ll quote a Science Daily press release about it:
A newly published study of Texas school district data and industrial mercury-release data, conducted by researchers at The University of Texas Health Science Center at San Antonio, indeed shows a statistically significant link between pounds of industrial release of mercury and increased autism rates. It also shows–for the first time in scientific literature–a statistically significant association between autism risk and distance from the mercury source.
“This is not a definitive study, but just one more that furthers the association between environmental mercury and autism,” said lead author Raymond F. Palmer, Ph.D., associate professor of family and community medicine at the UT Health Science Center San Antonio. The article is in the journal Health & Place.
Dr. Palmer, Stephen Blanchard, Ph.D., of Our Lady of the Lake University in San Antonio and Robert Wood of the UT Health Science Center found that community autism prevalence is reduced by 1 percent to 2 percent with each 10 miles of distance from the pollution source.
“This study was not designed to understand which individuals in the population are at risk due to mercury exposure,” Dr. Palmer said. “However, it does suggest generally that there is greater autism risk closer to the polluting source.”
The study should encourage further investigations designed to determine the multiple routes of mercury exposure. “The effects of persistent, low-dose exposure to mercury pollution, in addition to fish consumption, deserve attention,” Dr. Palmer said. “Ultimately, we will want to know who in the general population is at greatest risk based on genetic susceptibilities such as subtle deficits in the ability to detoxify heavy metals.”
The new study findings are consistent with a host of other studies that confirm higher amounts of mercury in plants, animals and humans the closer they are to the pollution source. The price on children may be the highest.
Now, let’s take a look at the reasons why I consider this to be a very poor study and equally poor evidence arguing for a link between proximity to coal-burning power plants and industrial sources and autism prevalence. First, you should know that the present study is a followup to a widely-criticized study that Dr. Palmer published in 20061. That study purported to show the same thing but was viewed as uninterpretable for a variety of reasons, with its most glaring flaw being that it failed to control for urbanicity of the populations being studied. Particularly harsh was Thomas A. Lewandowski:
Lastly, the authors found that the most important determining factor for autism prevalence in their study was whether the child lived in an urban, suburban, or rural area. For example, residence in an urban school district resulted in a 473% higher rate of autism compared to rural districts. Similar findings have been reported by others (e.g., Deb and Prasad, 1994). The urbanization effect is nearly 8 times stronger than the effect suggested for mercury but is given relatively little discussion and is not even noted in the abstract. Since levels of many pollutants (including mercury) would be strongly correlated with urbanization/industrialization, this also leads one to question the mercury-autism association the authors report. More detail on the impact of residence would have been helpful. Was one particular urban area (e.g., Dallas, Houston, San Antonio) responsible for the effect? Did the authors explore how data for other chemicals correlated with autism incidence? Certainly a host of environmental and social variables associated with urbanization could be investigated as possible factors in autism. Alternatively, an increased tendency for diagnosis in urban localities could explain at least part of the increased incidence.
Dr. Palmer’s 2006 study found a far larger correlation between urbanicity and autism prevalence than anything that proximity to sources of mercury emission could account for and was so full of holes that even antivaccinationists had a hard time defending it. Indeed, when I went back to look at this study, of which I had previously been unaware, I got the distinct impression that Palmer is a man with an axe to grind. This new study2, clearly carried out to answer that major criticism, does nothing to change my mind. The first thing I noted upon reading the introduction was that Dr. Palmer approvingly cites the infamous “baby hair mercury study” (Holmes et al), and from that I knew right away where he is probably coming from. That particular paper, a favorite of the mercury militia wing of the antivaccinationist movement, was a load of poorly designed garbage bordering on, if not actually, pseudoscience. He also approvingly and uncritically cites the even worse Bradstreet et al study claiming to show that autistic children excrete more mercury in the urine. If you want to get an idea just how bad this study is, consider that it was co-authored with Mark and David Geier. (Say no more.) Where on earth were the peer-reviewers? So let’s look at this study in more depth and decide if it’s worth taking seriously. There are two huge flaws in this study, how autism prevalence was calculated and how urbanicity was controlled for, and a depressingly large number of lesser ones
Autism prevalence and the study hypothesis
Whenever looking at a study, it’s very useful to look at the hypothesis and then decide whether the methods and data analysis are appropriate and adequate to answer the question asked in the hypothesis. Indeed, whenever I write a research paper or a grant, I always include in the introduction a paragraph starting with something along the lines of “we hypothesized that” or “the hypothesis we plan to test is that,” followed by a statement and justification of the hypothesis being tested (or, in the case of a grant, to be tested). Perusing the Palmer et al article, the closest I could find to a statement of hypothesis was this:
The objective of the current study is to determine if proximity to major sources of mercury pollution is related to autism prevalence rates.
Fair enough, as far as the statement goes, although it is somewhat vague. When reading a paper, though, it’s also important to see if the authors’ statement of hypothesis actually jibes with the hypothesis that their methodology is designed to test. Often embedded in the methodology are assumptions that the methodology and analysis must account for, and there’s a glaring disconnect between the simple statement of hypothesis as described in the sentence above and the actual hypothesis that the study was designed to test. First, consider how the study was done. Buried in the Methods secion is a description that is quite revealing. Data from 1998 for 39 coal-fired power plants and 56 industrial facilities in Texas were examined and modeled to see if the distance from these plants of various school districts correlated autism rates in 2002, with this being the rationale:
…it is plausible to postulate that releases during 1998 would have exposure potential for a cohort who was in utero in 1997. If an effect was present, this would be reflected in the 2002 school district records–the age (5 years old) this cohort would be entering the system.
So, from reading the Methods section, I conclude that the real hypothesis being tested, although not stated explicitly in the introduction, appears to be that exposure to mercury in utero contributes to autism, not that infant or childhood exposure to mercury is related to autism prevalence. Why else would the authors have examined mercury emissions and autism prevalence in 1998 and then modeled this against data about special education services for children with autism and ASDs in 2002? Now, the next step is to see if this methodology actually tests the hypothesis. Not surprisingly, there are a number of problems. First among these is that it is quite unclear exactly what data from the Texas Education Agency were used. Apparently Dr. Palmer used some sort of special data set provided by the TEA that is not publicly available. However, the most glaring error, one that in and of itself is enough to sink the study is this:
Total number of students reflects all enrolled students in the districts 2002 school year and was used as the denominator in calculating autism rates.
Later, under the Statistical Methods section, Palmer writes:
District autism data in 2002 were treated as event counts and used as the outcome in a Poisson regression model predicted by pounds of environmental mercury release in 1998, distance to sources of the release, and the relevant covariates. Total number of students enrolled in each district for 2002 defined the rates for each district
Wait a minute! How could this be? Someone correct me if I’m wrong, but doesn’t the model being tested assume that in utero exposure to mercury as assumed by distance from coal-burning power plants in 1997 would correlate with autism prevalence in the five year old cohort entering Texas public schools in 2002? Yet it appears that autism prevalence in 2002 was calculated using the total number of students enrolled that year, not the number of students entering kindergarten; i.e., the number of students who were exposed to the levels of pollution in utero in 1997. If this statement of methodology is accurate (and I have no reason to doubt it), it tells us that Palmer was using figures for autism prevalence (actually numbers of students needing special education assistance for autism or ASDs) in 2002 for all students, K through 12. Since this includes children up to age 18 and since autism is usually diagnosed by age 5, this methodology would necessarily include a large number of autistic children who would already have been diagnosed with autism in 1997, the year for which figures for mercury emissions from power plants and industrial sources were used in the model. In other words, Palmer included in his dataset far more children whose autism, using his own hypothesis, could not possibly have been related to mercury emissions than he did children who might have been susceptible.
This flaw alone, originally pointed out by Michelle Dawson, if I have not missed something, makes the results of this study completely uninterpretable. The correct methodology would have been to compare autism prevalence in the kindergarten (or, if using loose criteria, perhaps the kindergarten through third grade cohort) with mercury emissions. Moreover, the perils of using special educational services data as a surrogate for true prevalence are well known.
Controls for urbanicity
In epidemiological studies, perhaps the most difficult part of study design is to develop methodology that controls for confounding variables. Confounders are commonly variables that are related to both of the variables showing a correlation and that could therefore be the “true” cause underlying a phenomenon. For example, say that a study finds that variable A and variable B are strongly correlated. Let’s for the sake of this example say that as A rises so does B. That may or may not be evidence that A causes B. For example, if there is a third variable (variable C) that causes A to increase and also causes B to increase, then the correlation that we see between A and B is not a cause-and-effect correlation; rather, both are correlated because C causes both of them to rise. Consequently, controlling for C is very important. Unfortunately, in epidemiological studies, there are often many such “C” variables that can confound correlations unearthed by a study.
That’s why the most potent criticism of Palmer’s 2006 study was that he did not try to control for urbanicity. It’s easy to see how urbanicity might be a confounding variable in this study. After all, urbanicity is clearly correlated with proximity to sources of industrial pollution, as well as more awareness of autism and more services for children with autism and their parents. There could also be a wide number of confounders in urbanicity itself as well. Consider that in Palmer’s 2006 study, the effect of urbanicity on autism “prevalence” was several times stronger than that of proximity to mercury-emitting power plants. Palmer hardly mentioned this in his original study, but Lewandowski certainly saw that problem right away. Thus, the question about the current study is whether Palmer adequately addressed this problem and correctly controlled for urbanicity. Here’s how he describes his methodology to accomplish this:
Urbanicity. Eight separate demographically defined school district regions were used in the analysis as defined by the TEA: (1) Major urban districts and other central cities (2) Major suburban districts and other central city suburbs (5) Non-metropolitan and rural school districts In the current analysis, dummy variables were included in the analysis coding Urban (dummy variable 1, and Suburban (dummy variable2), contrasted with non-metro and rural districts which were the referent group. Details and specific definitions of urbanicity categories can be obtained at the TEA website http://www.tea.state.tx.us/data.html.
Blogging at Left Brain/Right Brain, Joseph argues compellingly that Palmer failed to control adequately for urbanicity. His complaints are:
It is too discrete. Within the set of urban districts, some districts will be more urban than others. The same is true of rural districts. Palmer et al. (2008) is effectively using a stratification method to control for urbanicity, but this method is limited, especially considering the paper looks at 1,040 school districts. A better methodology would be to use population density as a variable.
Modeling for distance. The paper models autism rates based on distance to coal-fired power plants. It follows that a control variable should model distance to urban areas rather than urbanicity of each district. Granted, this would not be easy because, as noted, urbanicity is not a discrete measure. But it needs to be noted as a significant limitation of the analysis. Consider school districts in areas designated as “rural” that are close to areas designated as “urban.” Such proximity would presumably provide access to a greater availability of autism specialists than would otherwise be the case.
To support his arguments, Joseph goes to the trouble of doing just such an analysis on similar data from California. He modeled population density versus special education service data for children with autism and ASD and found that the association between autism prevalence and mercury emissions disappears once population density is accounted for. His post is worth reading in its entirety, as he makes a strong case that population density is a better control for urbanicity than the methodology that Palmer used. His analysis is entirely consistent with other published data that show that population density is strongly correlated with autism diagnoses3.
Other flaws
There are also numerous other deficiencies in the design and methodology of the study, as one might expect. Another glaring flaw is that Palmer appears not to have done any tests to see if distance from power plants correlates with some other confounding variable other than urbanicity and wealth. True, he did try to control for urbanicity, mainly because urbanicity correlates so strongly with autism awareness and access to resources, making it not surprising at all that in his earlier study autism prevalence correlated far more strongly with urbanicity than with mercury emissions. It also correlates with population density, many other forms of pollutants such as auto exhaust, and many other potentially confounding variables. Other serious flaws that I found include:
The method for calculating distance from power plants. Basically, Palmer took the geographic center of each school district, measured the distance from that point to the nearest power plant, and then used that distance for every child in the district. Remember, this is Texas we’re talking about. Some of these school districts are quite large. However, Palmer’s methodology averages the distance out for every child in the district.
Moves. The authors appear to assume that no one moves in or out of the district.
No examination of wind effects. The underlying hypothesis here appears to be that mercury carried on the wind is what correlates with autism prevalence. If that were the case, then it would be expected that the effect would be much stronger in school districts that, based on the general direction of the prevailing winds, are downwind from a power plant. Palmer didn’t even consider this variable.
No comparison to other regions. The EPA has produced a very nice map showing the distribution of deposition of mercury on a global basis. It also has another good map that shows mercury deposition in the U.S. from all sources. Texas has few “hot spots,” while in the U.S. the Northeast and Midwest have many and China is one continuous hotspot. If Palmer’s hypothesis is true, it would have been nice of him to include a spot check of autism prevalence rates in a state with a lot of coal burning power plants, such as West Virginia. Also, if his hypothesis is true, he needs to explain why Texas, which has a significant deposition of mercury–particularly in its more heavily populated areas–has about the same autism prevalence (according to educational data from the USDE) as Idaho, which has much less mercury deposition. Palmer would also have to explain why Pennsylvania (which appears to be covered in mercury) has a lower autism prevalence than Minnesota and Oregon. Just looking at autism prevalence data and then comparing it to these two maps would be enough to show that Palmer’s hypothesis is not even plausible, much less supported by data.
Other sources of pollution. Coal-burning power plants emit many more pollutants besides mercury. Remember my discussion of confounding variables above? Palmer didn’t control for whether there were other pollutants that were associated with mercury emissions that might be the real environmental culprit, if environmental culprit there actually is.
Other sources of mercury exposure. Even in airborne mercury, industrial emissions are not the only cause. The EPA states that one third of mercury emissions do not derive from human activity. Palmer also didn’t take into account sources of mercury in the diet; for instance, from fish.
Lewandowski summarized other serious criticisms of Palmer’s 2006 study. Although Palmer tried (unsuccessfully) to answer his most serious criticism (failure to control for urbanicity), the others still stand:
Palmer et al. used county-level (and school district-level) TRI data for mercury as a surrogate measure of mercury exposure. The authors note in their introduction that mercury emitted into the air may be carried many miles before being deposited to soil or water. This is critical. Air modeling analyses indicate that mercury deposition that occurs in the west of the nation (including Texas) is overwhelmingly attributable to Asian or other non-US sources (Seigneur et al., 2004). Texas is a significant source of mercury emissions, but the mercury from these emissions is largely deposited hundreds to thousands of miles to the east. It is therefore highly unlikely that mercury emitted in a particular county or school district can be correlated with air mercury exposures in that locality.
TRI data also do not specify mercury species or the environmental medium to which the mercury is released. The likelihood of human exposure (and resulting toxicity) is highly influenced by these factors. For example, community exposure to inorganic mercury present in coal fly ash shipped to an off-site disposal facility will be zero. Releases to surface water bodies may also have a very different exposure potential than releases to air.
The authors also acknowledge that fish consumption is the primary source of human exposure to mercury. Fish mercury exposures in the general population are primarily associated with ocean caught fish, such as tuna or swordfish (Carrington and Bolger, 2002; Dabeka et al., 2004). Mercury levels in ocean fish are impacted by releases on a continental rather than a county-wide scale. Even for freshwater fish, which may be sources of mercury intake for a limited number of individuals, the mercury will most likely be attributable to distant sources. Local mercury releases (as described by the TRI data) should therefore not be used as a surrogate variable for actual mercury exposure. Because TRI-mercury releases on the county or school-district level are unlikely to be correlated with actual mercury exposures in the same geographic regions, it seems implausible that the observed association between mercury release rates and autism prevalence represents a real biological phenomenon.
All of these are very serious criticisms, and Palmer’s study answers none of them.
No one, least of all I, claims that living near a coal-burning power plant is a Good Thing or in any way perfectly fine for one’s health. EPA regulation or not, such plants still spew pollution into the air, and the adverse effects of industrial pollution on human health are well documented. However, that is not the question that Palmer is attempting to answer. He has made a specific claim, namely that mercury exposure from such power plants and other industrial sources, with proximity to such plants used as a surrogate for exposure, correlates with autism prevalence. It is thus implied that environmental mercury causes or contributes to the development of autism. Unfortunately for Dr. Palmer, the numerous enormous flaws in the methodology of his study undermine that conclusion and clearly show that his conclusions do not follow from his data.
It’s entirely possible that some environmental factor, or factors, may contribute to the development of autism, either on their own or by acting with some genetic susceptibility, but if that is the case with mercury this study is thin gruel to use to support such a hypothesis. In fact, it’s not even that good as a hypothesis-generating study. There’s just too much potential interference from confounding variables that hasn’t been accounted for. I have to wonder about the quality of the peer review of this particular journal. After all, if Joseph and I, neither of whom are epidemiologists and one of whom is not a physician or scientist, can spot the glaring flaws in this study, why couldn’t the peer reviewers?
REFERENCES:
1. PALMER, R., BLANCHARD, S., STEIN, Z., MANDELL, D., MILLER, C. (2006). Environmental mercury release, special education rates, and autism disorder: an ecological study of Texas. Health & Place, 12(2), 203-209. DOI: 10.1016/j.healthplace.2004.11.005
2. PALMER, R., BLANCHARD, S., WOOD, R. (2008). Proximity to point sources of environmental mercury release as a predictor of autism prevalence. Health & Place DOI: 10.1016/j.healthplace.2008.02.001
3. Williams, J.G. (2005). Systematic review of prevalence studies of autism spectrum disorders. Archives of Disease in Childhood, 91(1), 8-15. DOI: 10.1136/adc.2004.062083

   The final nail in the mercury-autism hypothesis?
David Gorski
Link
PROLOGUE: BAD LUCK AND BAD TIMING
Two and a half years ago, very early in the history of this blog, I wrote one of my usual logorrheic (although I prefer the word “comprehensive”) posts entitled Mercury in vaccines as a cause of autism and autism spectrum disorders (ASDs): A failed hypothesis. In that post, I characterized the scientifically discredited notion that the mercury in the thimerosal preservative that used to be in several childhood vaccines was the cause of the “autism epidemic” as “one of the most pernicious medical myths of recent years.” And so it is. I like to characterize the notion that thimerosal-containing vaccines (TCVs) cause autism as the American version of the British myth, popularized by Andrew Wakefield and a sensationalistic British press, that the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine causes autism and “autistic enterocolitis.”
Both notions were based on confusing correlation with causation, aided and abetted by some truly bad science, and both notions have been painfully difficult to dislodge. Indeed, in the case of Wakefield, only now that Wakefield was stripped of his license to practice in the U.K. by its General Medical Council, leading to The Lancet finally doing what it should have done six years ago and retracting Wakefield’s 1998 study that sparked the MMR frenzy in the U.K. and arguably kickstarted the modern anti-vaccine movement, do I sense that journalists are finally “getting” that science does not support the idea that the MMR vaccine causes autism. Andrew Wakefield may be trying to fight back with his book Callous Disregard after his disgrace was complete, basking in the glow of admiration of die-hard anti-vaccine groups, but, for now, at least, Wakefield and his MMR fear mongering are yesterday’s news, and that’s a very good thing indeed–at least for as long as it lasts.
Perhaps it is the fall of Andy Wakefield that has led to an apparent resurgence of the concept that mercury in TCVs somehow causes autism, after having faded into the background after the CDC and AAP recommended that thimerosal be removed from all childhood vaccines in 1999 and the last TCV having expired towards the end of 2001. After all, if the hypothesis that TCVs cause autism had been correct, we should have expected to see a marked decrease in the incidence of autism and autism spectrum disorders (ASDs) within about 5 years of 2002, given that the vast majority of cases of ASDs are diagnosed between the ages of 2 and 5. We have not, and, even though its adherents have kept moving the goalposts back regarding the date that we should start to see a leveling off and drop in the incidence of ASDs, starting with 2005, then 2007, and now, apparently, 2011 (which is only less than four months away, by the way), even Jenny McCarthy’s anti-vaccine organization originally founded by J.B. Handley and his wife, namely Generation Rescue, began demphasizing mercury in 2007, after having stated flatly on its website that autism is a “misdiagnosis for mercury poisoning” for so long. Since then, “too many, too soon” has been the favored propaganda talking point.
Of course, not every crank is ready to abandon the myth that TCVs cause autism. Indeed, tomorrow two mercury militia “heavy hitters” and bloggers for the anti-vaccine propaganda blog Age of Autism, Mark Blaxill and Dan Olmsted, will be releasing a book entitled Age of Autism: Mercury, Medicine, and a Manmade Epidemic. In anticipation, four weeks ago I actually e-mailed the publicist to send me a review copy of Age of Autism. I have yet to receive the book. I wonder why. Be that as it may, it amuses me that the official release of the release of the not-so-dynamic duo of the mercury militia’s book actually will one day after a study that is arguably the last nail in the coffin of the very dead hypothesis that TCVs cause autism was released. Either the great pharma conspiracy is far more conniving and effective than even J.B. Handley thinks, or Blaxill and Olmsted’s luck is just that bad. As I anticipate the conspiracy mongering posts about this bad timing aside, let’s just take a look at this last coffin nail, which is a study by Price et al that was released today in the journal Pediatrics entitled Prenatal and Infant Exposure to Thimerosal From Vaccines and Immunoglobulins and Risk of Autism.
PRELUDE TO PRICE ET AL
The first thing you need to know about this study is that it is the long-awaited follow-up to a study by Thompson et al published in The New England Journal of Medicine in 2007, which I’ve discussed before. Thompson et al was a study that examined in a rigorous fashion whether there is a correlation between TCVs and adverse neuropsychological outcomes other than autism and ASDs. Basically, this was a case-control study of over 1,000 children tested for 42 different neuropsychological outcomes other than autism and ASDs in which children were subjected to various neuropsychological tests and the results correlated to exposure to TCVs during the neonatal period (days 0 to 28) and the first seven months of life. The results were a classic example of in essence random noise. There were a few neuropsychological measures in which lower scores correlated with TCV exposure, and there were a few neurodevelopmental measures in which higher scores correlated with TCV exposure. However, the detected associations were small and almost equally divided between positive and negative effects; in other words, nothing more than would be expected from random noise in the data.
One aspect of this study that was depressing and amusing at the same time was that the input of anti-vaccine–excuse me, “pro-safe vaccine”–groups was solicited during the design of the study. Indeed, Sallie Bernard, president of SafeMinds, was a consultant to the investigators of Thompson et al and participated in the design of the case-control study, despite the fact that she has no relevant background in science, statistics, or clinical trial design! Yes, in the ultimate case of trying to appease those who cannot be appeased and indulging Ms. Bernard’s arrogance of ignorance, apparently the CDC and the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD) team decided to “reach” out to their foes. The result? Sallie Bernard saw the writing on the wall, namely that the study was not showing what she wanted it to show, dropped out of the study, and started attacking it immediately, even jumping the gun on the article embargo in order to post her sour grapes all over the Internet. A blogger by the ‘nym of Interverbal aptly criticized Bernard for this:
Even before this study was released yesterday, there was publicized dissent from advocates from the idea of a mercury etiology of neuropsychological harm. One of them came from a well known advocate, Sallie Bernard, who was invited to be a collaborator in this study. It seems that she was involved in the planning of this study, but the lead author indicated that she withdrew her support after the results began to be circulated.
That is not how science works. If you have a problem with a study design then you dissent before you begin collecting data.
As Joseph aptly put it, sour grapes. As the final draft circulated, qq read it and didn’t like what the results showed. She even went so far as to write a letter to the NEJM listing her complaints, to which the Thompson et al responded, skewering all of her objections quite ably. Bernard’s behavior with respect to her involvement in Thompson et al is one reason why I have come to the conclusion that attempting to “build bridges” to the leaders of the anti-vaccine movement is a fruitless and pointless exercise. That is not to say that we shouldn’t try to build bridges to parents who express fears over vaccines because they’ve heard the message of anti-vaccine leaders like Bernard, but trying to convert or coopt high profile anti-vaccine activists like Bernard is a waste of effort.
The other common reaction of the anti-vaccine movement to this study was to cherry pick all the negative outcomes and ignore all the positive outcomes. Steve Novella caught opportunistic anti-vaccine propagandist David Kirby doing just that at the time of the study. Sadly, this dishonesty continues even today. Indeed, Mark Blaxill himself promoted the very same misinterpretation of Thompson et al just last week. Spin and misinformation promoted by the anti-vaccine movement never truly dies. Once a line of attack is developed, no matter how many times it is soundly refuted by science, it inevitably rises again, much like the zombies in any number of movies that I’ve enjoyed through the years. What that means is that defenders of science-based medicine, in order to outrun the zombies when they inevitably rise again, need to do their cardio.
That, of course, and the double-tap. On the other hand, anyone who’s read my stuff for a while knows that for me the double-tap isn’t enough. I like to deal with anti-vaccine pseudoscience using at minimum a .50 caliber machine gun.
SURPRISE! SURPRISE! THIMEROSAL IN VACCINES ISN’T ASSOCIATED WITH ASDs, EITHER!
When Thompson et al was published three years ago, the authors pointed out that they intentionally did not include autism and ASDs as studied outcomes and that these outcomes would be the topic of a subsequent paper. Price et al is that paper. What one also needs to understand about Price et al and Thompson et al is that these were studies suggested at the time that the CDC and AAP first decided on the precautionary principle to recommend the removal of thimerosal from all childhood vaccines. That it took until 2007 to publish Thompson et al and until now to publish Price et al just goes to show how difficult and time-consuming epidemiological research can be. Finally, given that the data sources and methodology were in essence the same for each of the two studies, we can expect that the anti-vaccine movement will use the same spin and misinformation about Price et al as it did for Thompson et al in order to attack it.
Basically, Price et al is a similar sort of case-control study. A case control study is a type of retrospective trial in which subjects with a certain condition (cases) are matched as closely as possible with subjects without the condition under study (controls), and the two groups compared to look for factors that correlate with the condition. That’s how Thompson et al was performed, and that’s how Price et al was also performed. Being retrospective, such a study can never be as rigorous as a randomized controlled trial or a prospective cohort study. However, given that thimerosal has already been removed from all infant vaccines other than the flu vaccine (and there is a thimerosal-free alternative) and, more importantly, that it would be unethical to conduct a randomized double blind, placebo-controlled clinical trial, this sort of trial is the best evidence that we will be able to come up with.
The specific design of Price et al is summarized in this table (click for a larger version):
design
Basically, the final two groups that were studied consisted of 256 children with ASD and 752 matched controls. One very interesting aspect that looks as though it were almost certainly placed into the experimental design based on concerns of anti-vaccine advocates like Sallie Bernard is a group of children who underwent regression. Basically, the study examined whether there was a correlation between ASD and TCV exposure. It also examined two subsets of ASD, autistic dsorder (AD) and ASD with regression, looking for any indication whether TCVs were associated with any of them. Regression was defined as:
the subset of case-children with ASD who reported loss of previously acquired language skills after acquisition.
Also, when adding up total thimerosal exposure, the investigators also included any thimerosal exposure that might have come prenatally from maternal receipt of flu vaccines during pregnancy, as well as immunoglobulins, tetanus toxoids, and diphtheria-tetanus. In other words, investigators tried to factor in all the various ideas for how TCVs might contribute to autism when designing this study.
So what did the investigators find? I think you probably know the answer to that question. They found nothing. Nada. Zip. There wasn’t even a hint of a correlation between TCV exposure and either ASD, AD, or ASD with regression:
There were no findings of increased risk for any of the 3 ASD outcomes. The adjusted odds ratios (95% confidence intervals) for ASD associated with a 2-SD increase in ethylmercury exposure were 1.12 (0.83–1.51) for prenatal exposure, 0.88 (0.62–1.26) for exposure from birth to 1 month, 0.60 (0.36–0.99) for exposure from birth to 7 months, and 0.60 (0.32– 0.97) for exposure from birth to 20 months.
The last result is a bit of an anomaly in that it implies that exposure to TCVs from birth to 1 month and birth to 7 months actually protects against ASD. The authors quite rightly comment on this result thusly:
In the covariate adjusted models, we found that an increase in ethylmercury exposure in 2 of the 4 exposure time periods evaluated was associated with decreased risk of each of the 3 ASD outcomes. We are not aware of a biological mechanism that would lead to this result.
Of course, two of the most likely explanations for such a paradoxical result would be either that parents of cases, given the genetic component of ASD, might have older children who have already developed ASDs. If these parents have imbibed the anti-vaccine propaganda that is so prevalent, they might be less likely to vaccinate their children according to the recommended schedule. The authors looked for such a correlation between older siblings with ASD and TCV exposure levels and found none. They also asked whether parents of children in the case group may have suspected that their children had an ASD and been influenced in their choice of vaccines by that knowledge, but none of the case children had been diagnosed by 7 months and only a few had been diagnosed by 20 months, which were the two time periods for which cumulative thimerosal exposure was calculated. In light of this, I would tend to interpret this seemingly paradoxical result as meaning, in essence, that there really isn’t even a whiff of a hint of a difference between the two groups.
This study had an additional strength as well, namely that the case and control populations were collected from three managed care organizations (MCOs) that participate in the VSD. Consequently, because of the detailed records maintained by these MCOs, investigators were able to develop a detailed and accurate estimate of total thimerosal exposure from the computerized databases maintained by the MCOs as well as the medical records of the cases, controls, all supplemented by standardized interviews with the parents. In addition, outcomes were measured in clinical settings using standardized assessment tools. In Price et al, the most up-to-date standardized assessment tools used to diagnose ASDs were used to identify cases. In addition, in order to make sure that the controls did not include children with undiagnosed ASD, which would tend to decrease any apparent differences between the groups, controls the lifetime form of the Social Communication Questionnaire was administered as part of the interview with each mother for children who had indications of any neurodevelopmental difficulties. Several children were excluded from the control group in this manner. Finally, the detailed medical records and databases maintained by the MCOs allowed for the detailed determination of and control for many potential confounders. All of these are strengths that were shared with Thompson et al.
So is this study the “last nail in the coffin” of the hypothesis that TCVs cause or contribute to ASDs? Scientifically, I would argue that it’s close, if not actually the final nail. After all, there have been multiple large, well-designed epidemiological studies of varying designs, all of which have come to the same conclusion: There is no detectable correlation between exposure to mercury in vaccines and ASDs. As far as case-control studies go, Price et al is quite good, but it is a retrospective study and the possibility of undetected biases or unidentified confounders can never be completely excluded. Also, it shares one other weakness with Thompson et al, namely a relatively low response rate of around 30%. However, as the authors pointed out in their response to Sallie Bernard, that participation rate was actually higher than predicted as the study was being designed, and it was accounted for in incredible detail in the technical description of how the study was set up
Even though Price et al provides yet another bit of powerful evidence that, as far as science can tell, mercury in vaccines is not a cause of ASDs, I am under no illusion that this study will put this issue to bed once and for all. After all, if Blaxill and Olmsted are still publishing books based on Olmsted’s laughably poorly researched series Age of Autism. Let’s also not forget that Sallie Bernard was an external consultant for Price et al, as well. No doubt she will make her displeasure known soon, and no doubt it will consist of the same already refuted criticisms that she leveled at Thompson et al.
I can think of one criticism of this study that the anti-vaccine movement will level at it. In the methods, the authors state:
Children were excluded if they had the following medical conditions with known links to ASD traits: fragile X syndrome; tuberous sclerosis; Rett syndrome; congenital rubella syndrome; or Angelman syndrome.
Bernard complained that low birth weight children were excluded from Thompson et al (and presumably also from this study), not understanding that the reason for excluding low birthweight children was obvious: Such children are more likely to have neurodevelopmental problems completely independent from any external cause, such as thimerosal. Including preemies and lower birth weight children would only contribute to the background noise and make finding true associations more difficult. Or perhaps she did understand that and picking up false positives from random noise is what she hoped to see. Be that as it may, the same reasons apply for excluding children with medical conditions with known links to ASD traits. Including them would have added random noise to the current study. Anti-vaccine zealots will no doubt claim that the CDC intentionally excluded them because they are more “vulnerable” to “vaccine injury,” but there is no convincing evidence that this is so, and making such a claim is a shifting of the goalposts from the original claim that autism is a “misdiagnosis for mercury poisoning.” Such a hypothesis will probably eventually have to be studied, but it is a relatively implausible hypothesis given the weight of existing evidence. I also wonder if anti-vaccine activists realize just how much of a shrinking of their hypothesis it is to narrow it down to saying that vaccines cause autism only in children with these conditions. Particularly ironic is congenital rubella syndrome, given that maternal rubella during pregnancy is one of the few known external contributors to the development of autism.
CONCLUSION
In the end, it is always frustrating to watch how studies like Thompson et al and Price et al are spun by anti-vaccinationists. Epidemiology is like that, though. It’s virtually impossible to conduct a case-control study like this without there being significant shortcomings in it. The reason is that, unlike a bench experiment, the investigators can never control all the variables. Trade-offs are inevitable, and rarely are there adequate resources to assure sample sizes large enough to be completely bullet-proof or to be able to account for every single potentially confounding variable.
However, if there’s one rule in science-based medicine, it’s that no one study is ever sufficient to confirm or rule out correlations between undesirable outcomes and various exposures. However, as the weight of several studies starts to bear down on the problem, the preponderance of evidence must at some point be acknowledged, because we do not have unlimited resources to keep doing studies to answer the same question over and over and over again and every repeated study uses resources that could be used to study other potential causes and treatments for autism. Price et al happens to be one large and convincing chunk of that evidence, but it is not the only one. It builds on multiple other studies and it fits into the confluence of evidence strongly refuting the hypothesis that mercury in vaccines is a cause of autism.
Not that the die-hard cranks will ever accept that result. Blaxill and Olmsted’s book still stands there, thumbing its nose at science.

Prenatal Mercury and Autism
Steven Novella on July 24, 2013
Link
Mercury in unequivocally a neurotoxin. It is especially damaging to the developing brain. But it’s the dose that makes the toxin, and so a low enough exposure even to something known to be potentially harmful may not be. Further, the body has mechanisms for dealing with toxins, and toxins in the body may not be reaching the cells they can potentially damage in significant amounts. Therefore if we want to know if a potential toxin is actually causing any harm to people we need to do some type of epidemiological study – correlating exposure to possible adverse outcomes. All the studies in petri dishes and with cell cultures just won’t answer the question of harm.
The question of whether or not mercury in vaccines has caused neurological harm, specifically autism, has been largely answered. Numerous studies have shown no association between the amount of mercury exposure from vaccines and the risk of developing autism. A separate mercury-related question, however, is whether or not there is any risk of harm from mercury exposure from seafood. Mercury is methylated by bacteria into methymercury, and through them gets into the food chain in the oceans. Fish that eat other fish then concentrate the mercury in their tissues, and so predatory fish and sea mammals tend to have high concentrations of methymercury.
This has led to some precautionary recommendations, including that pregnant women should not eat tuna or other fish with high mercury levels. This makes sense, but what is the actual risk? The precautionary principle can also cut both ways. Fish contain many high-quality nutrients important for a developing brain, such as polyunsaturated fatty acids. Removing this food source from the diet of pregnant women may have unintended negative consequences.
The best way to address this issue is to look at net clinical outcomes associated with the consumption of seafood. There are a number of studies that do this, and a recently published follow up study adds to the growing evidence-base addressing this question.
Wingaarden et al. recently published the study “Autism Spectrum Disorder Phenotypes and Prenatal Exposure to Methylmercury”. In this study:
We administered the Social Communication Questionnaire to parents of a cohort of 1784 children, adolescents, and young adults. The Social Responsiveness Scale was administered to teachers of 537 cohort subjects at about 10 years of age. Prenatal exposure to methylmercury was measured in maternal hair samples collected at or near the time of birth. Multivariable regression models evaluated the relationship between prenatal methylmercury exposure and ASD phenotypic scores, adjusting for relevant covariates.
The conclusion:
No consistent association between prenatal methylmercury exposure and ASD screening instrument was found, using linear and nonlinear regression analyses.
This is a large and well-conducted study looking specifically at features of autism. Of course, no study can every demonstrate a risk of zero, but the evidence from this and other studies suggests that any such risk must be minimal – too small to show up in the data. The other possibility is that any negative effects of mercury are more than compensated for by the nutritional benefits of eating seafood.
Davidson et al. published a previous study in 2010 in Neurotoxicology, “Fish consumption, mercury exposure, and their associations with scholastic achievement in the Seychelles Child Development Study”. The Seychelles are the “canary in the coal mine” for mercury exposure from seafood. The inhabitants of these islands have a fishing economy and consume about ten times the amount of seafood as Americans and Europeans.
In this study they measured mercury exposure through hair analysis, with an average prenatal exposure level of 6.8 ppm (compared to an average of 1 ppm in the US). They compared prenatal mercury exposure and postnatal exposure (hair mercury levels in infants) with various scales of neurological development and academic performance (the Southern and Eastern African Consortium for Monitoring Educational Quality, the Family Resource Scale, the Henderson Environmental Learning Profile Scale, and standard IQ tests).
In this study they found:
For the subgroup of 215 subjects who participated in the SACMEQ test, there were significant adverse associations between examination scores and postnatal exposure, but only for males. The average postnatal exposure level in child hair for this subgroup was significantly higher than for the overall cohort. These results are consistent with our earlier studies and support the interpretation that prenatal MeHg exposure at dosages achieved by mothers consuming a diet high in fish are not associated with adverse educational measures of scholastic achievement. The adverse association of educational measures with postnatal exposure in males is intriguing, but will need to be confirmed by further studies examining factors that influence scholastic achievement.
In other words, they found no consistent pattern of negative outcomes. They found the typical scatter of results indicative of the random results seen when looking at multiple outcomes. The outlier of postnatal exposure (not prenatal) in males only would have to be independently replicated before it should be considered anything but a random result.
The Seychelles cohort is a resource of information that can be examined in multiple ways. Essentially you have a large cohort of children followed for years with standard measures of IQ and academic performance. Another study, for example, looked at prenatal mercury exposure from dental amalgam fillings and found no association with a negative outcome.
At odds with the evidence from the Seychelles are previous studies of prenatal mercury exposure and IQ from the Faroe Islands. This research has found a relationship between mercury exposure and decreased IQ.
How do we reconcile these differing results? As others have pointed out – the Faroe Islanders get their mercury from whale meat, while inhabitants of the Seychelles get it from fish. It’s not clear why this would cause a difference, but it is a possible factor. The Seychelles have a genetically diverse population, while the Faroe Islands are homogeneously Scandinavian. Overall, the Seychelles data is more robust, especially when the latest study is taken into consideration.
Conclusion
While the data is not unanimous (it rarely is), the bulk of the evidence indicates that prenatal exposure to methylmercury from seafood is not a significant risk for reduced IQ or the development of autism. The data is more compelling for fish than for sea mammals such as whales. This is true even at mercury exposure levels many times that in the US and Europe.
What is the bottom line for pregnant women? The most common recommendation is still to balance the possible risk from mercury with the nutritional benefits of seafood. It is counterproductive to avoid seafood completely out of fears of mercury. It is reasonable to seek out fish that have generally lower mercury levels but still contain the polyunsaturated fatty acids that are beneficial.
A quick guide from the Mayo Clinic advises:
Eat a variety of seafood that’s low in mercury and high in omega-3 fatty acids, such as:
    • Salmon
    • Anchovies
    • Herring
    • Sardines
    • Trout
    • Atlantic and Pacific mackerel
Other safe choices include shrimp, pollock, catfish and canned light tuna. However, limit albacore tuna and tuna steak to no more than 6 ounces (170 grams) a week.
The Seychelles data is very reassuring, however. Any significant risk would have likely been identified in this data.

Antivaccine happenings ten years time ago
David Gorski on March 3, 2014
Link
This is about antivaccine happenings ten years’ time ago. Unfortunately, it’s also about antivaccine happenings now. The reason, and what links the two, is that antivaccine happenings, particularly myths, never seem to die. They just keep coming back over and over again. One myth that’s been recycled since at least 2005 is the one that claims that there’s been a study that has vindicated Andrew Wakefield. Stories pop up every so often that look for all the world as though they’re new claiming that the results of Andrew Wakefield’s original Lancet case series has been replicated. Sadly for Wakefield (and happily for the rest of the world), it’s just not true. I have a Google Alert for vaccines set up, so I see these stories when they pop up periodically. Sometimes they even make an appearance on Facebook and/or Twitter as antivaccine memes.
This time around, what’s happening is not exactly the same thing. The “Wakefield was right” news stories appear to arise organically every so often. I have no idea why. This particular story is one that’s being desperately pushed by antivaccine mavens—again. It’s one that has been desperately promoted dating back to a decade ago, as you will see. Unfortunately, like Jason or Michael Myers in a classic slasher flick, just when you think it’s dead is the time to be vigilant because it’s not. I’m referring to a myth that I’ve been covering on and off for nearly a decade that the Centers for Disease Control (the CDC) has been “hiding evidence” that mercury in vaccines is a major cause of the “autism epidemic.” It’s not true, of course. Indeed, my very first post for this blog lo these six years ago referred to the hypothesis that mercury in the thimerosal preservative that used to be used in childhood vaccines as a failed hypothesis. And so it is—and remains.
None of that prevents a very vocal bunch of cranks from trying very hard to exhume the rotting corpse of the hypothesis, hook it up to steampunk-appearing equipment straight out of a Frankenstein movie and fire thousands of volts of electricity through it to reanimate it. This time around, it’s Brian Hooker, PhD, whom we’ve only met very briefly before on this blog. However, those of you who follow certain other blogs (such as my not-so-secret other blog) have met Dr. Hooker, a biochemist who fancies himself a vaccine expert. He’s also known for having presented at the yearly AutismOne quackfest, along with Tim Bolen, clearly one of the crankiest cranks in existence, as anyone who’s been following issues of antivaccine beliefs and quackery is likely to know.
I must admit that, until now, I had been assiduously avoiding this particular topic. I must confess that the reason was because I was so incredibly tired of this particular line of “reasoning,” such as it is, having first dealt with it nine years ago. Unfortunately (for me, not for you I hope) no one at SBM had taken on this particular claim before, which means that I feel as though I have to. I realize that this is a bit repetitive for people who follow me both here and at my not-so-secret other blog, but I thought the issue important enough to risk more repetition than usual. Let’s just put it this way. I hope that I can write this and that you can just post it in response whenever you see this particular claim/meme pop up on Facebook or wherever. I can only hope that it will suffice for a reasonable period of time in the future, so that I don’t have to revisit this topic again any time soon.
So let’s go back a bit. This particular claim – that the CDC has been “hiding” or “covering up” evidence that in reality the mercury in thimerosal in vaccines really has been causing autism all along – has been all over, in press releases, on SafeMinds, on the “boy wonder” Jake Crosby’s blog, and, of course, on the antivaccine crank blog Age of Autism. The origin of this claim appears to be a document obtained by Brian Hooker, whose “mistreatment” at the hands of SafeMinds and the antivaccine luminaries at AoA led to his becoming the Frankenstein’s monster they could no longer control. I’m referring, of course, to the Brian Hooker whose epic fails when it comes to vaccine science go beyond epic.
Let’s go to the press release, straight from Hooker himself:
Dr. Hooker, a PhD scientist, worked with two members of Congress to craft the letter to the CDC that recently resulted in his obtaining long-awaited data from the CDC, the significance of which is historic. According to Hooker, the data on over 400,000 infants born between 1991 and 1997, which was analyzed by CDC epidemiologist Thomas Verstraeten, MD, “proves unequivocally that in 2000, CDC officials were informed internally of the very high risk of autism, non-organic sleep disorder and speech disorder associated with Thimerosal exposure.”
When the results of the Verstraeten study were first reported outside the CDC in 2005, there was no evidence that anyone but Dr. Verstraeten within the CDC had known of the very high 7.6-fold elevated relative risk of autism from exposure to Thimerosal during infancy. But now, clear evidence exists. A newly-acquired abstract from 1999 titled, “Increased risk of developmental neurologic impairment after high exposure to Thimerosal containing vaccine in first month of life” required the approval of top CDC officials prior to its presentation at the Epidemic Intelligence Service (EIS) conference. Thimerosal, which is 50% mercury by weight, was used in most childhood vaccines and in the RhoGAM® shot for pregnant women prior to the early 2000s.
My first reaction to this claim was a massive, massive yawn. Why is that? Quite simply, I thought I was having an acid flashback to 2005, as this bogus argument dates back at least that far. For example, see this post. It’s not about the Verstraeten study specifically per se, although it does mention it as an example of how successive iterations of data analysis can result in an effect size seen in preliminary analyses shrinking away to nothing as successive, more rigorous analyses are performed. It’s a common thing in science, particularly clinical science. Physicians know it and expect it. We’re not surprised by it. Indeed, we have an instinctive tendency to be skeptical of large effects reported in early studies because we know they often dissipate in later studies and analyses. There’s even a term that’s been coined for one type of this observation, the “decline effect.”
Hooker, determinedly oblivious to such considerations, along with the antivaccinationists who have been hatching all manner of conspiracy theories about the Verstraeten study for the last decade, do not know it and do not expect this natural and common phenomenon in science. So when they see it, their natural inclination is to assume that it must be a conspiracy.
Hence the yawn.
Indeed, my yawn was so intense that when a reader wrote asking me to take this on or point her to a debunking of this particular bit of antivaccine nonsense, I demurred at first. Basically, I said that the whole matter bored me and that if I were to write about the Verstraeten study again it would be far more out of a sense of duty than out of any real interest. After all, I never thought that, nearly nine years after this particular conspiracy theory appeared, thanks to everybody’s favorite antivaccine crank, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., the same misinformation would be reappearing, like some crazed Whac-A-Mole™ that needs to be slapped down yet again. Key to RFK Jr.’s conspiracy theory is the claim that somehow, at a meeting in suburban Atlanta at a conference center known as Simpsonwood, the CDC somehow cooked the numbers to “cover up” evidence that, contrary to CDC assurances, thimerosal in vaccine really was strongly associated with autism. Of course, as explained by Skeptico and myself, RFK, Jr.’s account of what happened at Simpsonwood was shockingly dishonest, as anyone can see for himself if he takes the time to read the entire 286 page transcript.
So what’s got Hooker and his antivaccine buddies’ knickers in a knot? To understand this, you need to understand a couple of things. First, the Simpsonwood conference was all about examining evidence from the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD), a collaborative effort between the CDC’s Immunization Safety Office and nine managed care organizations (MCOs) established in 1990 to monitor immunization safety and address the gaps in scientific knowledge about rare and serious events following immunization to determine if there really was a reason for concern about thimerosal in vaccines. Although the decision had been made in 1999 to remove thimoerosal from childhood vaccines, the decision hadn’t been fully implemented yet, and the CDC wanted to determine whether there was any cause for concern. It was hardly the action of a group that wanted to “cover up” anything, particularly the bit about publishing the entire transcript. None of this, however, prevented antivaccine activists, particularly the branch known as the “mercury militia” for its affinity for the set of antivaccine beliefs associated with mercury in vaccines as a cause of autism, from dreaming up all manner of conspiracy theories, with the CDC meeting in a “secret” location to cackle over the “autism epidemic,” rubbing their hands together gleefully as they plotted to create a generation of autistic children. (I exaggerate, but really only slightly.) Of course, it didn’t help that Verstraeten ultimately left the CDC and went to work for pharma, which only fueled the hype.
Various antivaccine groups, from SafeMinds on, have been filing Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests for well over a decade. Apparently one of Hooker’s numerous frivolous requests finally panned out. Or so he thinks. What he described above in the press release is an abstract presented by four authors, including Verstraeten, at the CDC’s yearly conference in 1999 for the fellows of its Epidemic Intelligence Service. It was a preliminary study, as such abstracts often report, and it reported a relative risk for developing a neurological developmental disorder, comparing the group with the highest exposure to thimerosal at one month compared to no exposure, of 1.8 (95% confidence interval 1.1 to 2.8). In other words, there was a statistically significant difference, but the error bars almost encompassed one. You can get an idea of how preliminary the report is by looking at the 95% confidence intervals for some of the relative risks for some of the conditions reported: autism (RR 7.6, CI=1.8 to 31.5) and sleep disorders (RR 5.0, CI=1.6 to 15.9). These are the preliminary data in which the RR was reported to be 7.6, the original abstract that was said to be “watered down” to a less worrisome abstract to be presented at Simpsonwood. Sounds damning, right?
Wrong.
The Verstraeten VSD study was always intended to be a two phase study, as Emily Willingham and Lindsay Beyerstein reported. They both explain it well, but I think I’ll go to the source, Verstraeten himself, who wrote a letter to the editor of Pediatrics in 2004 about the study:
Did the CDC water down the original results? It did not. This misconception comes from an erroneous perception of this screening study and other epidemiological studies. The perception is that an epidemiological study can have only 1 of 2 outcomes: either an association is found (or confirmed), or an association is refuted. Very often, however, there is a third interpretation: an association can neither be found nor refuted. Let’s call the first 2 outcomes “positive” and “negative” and the third outcome “neutral.” The CDC screening study of thimerosal-containing vaccines was perceived at first as a positive study that found an association between thimerosal and some neurodevelopmental outcomes. This was the perception both independent scientists and antivaccine lobbyists had at the conclusion of the first phase of the study. It was foreseen from the very start that any positive outcome would lead to a second phase. Whereas the original plan was to conduct the second phase as a case-control study, we soon realized this would be too time consuming. The validity of the first-phase results needed urgent validation in view of the large potential public health impact. Did the CDC purposefully select a second phase that would contradict the first phase? Certainly not. The push to urgently perform the second phase at health maintenance organization C came entirely from myself, because I felt that the first-phase results were too prone to potential biases to be the basis for important public health decisions. Health maintenance organization C was the only site known to myself and my coauthors that could rapidly provide sufficient data that would enable a check of the major findings of the first phase in a timely manner.
Because the findings of the first phase were not replicated in the second phase, the perception of the study changed from a positive to a neutral study. Surprisingly, however, the study is being interpreted now as negative by many, including the antivaccine lobbyists. The article does not state that we found evidence against an association, as a negative study would. It does state, on the contrary, that additional study is recommended, which is the conclusion to which a neutral study must come.
In other words, the first part of the study was the screen, to see if there might have been an effect, in which the study was designed to look for associations that, by the design of the study, would need to be, if found, confirmed in the second phase of the study. In this case, it wasn’t. As I said before, this is not an uncommon thing to happen with studies in medicine. Frequently early phases of studies are positive, because they’re designed to look for associations with high sensitivity but with a tendency for a high rate of false positives. Scientists want to see if something might be there. Then they need to test if any associations they find in a first pass-through hold up to scrutiny. In this case the association between vaccines and autism didn’t, and, because of the design of the study, this meant that the study could neither confirm nor entirely refute an association between thimerosal and autism. The conspiracy-mongering RFK, Jr. made it sound as though phase II of the study was tacked on specifically to try to discredit the findings of phase I, but nothing could be further from the truth. Phase II was “baked in,” included in the original design. The only controversial feature was to use an HMO in Massachusetts to crosscheck phase I results, and this was done out of a sense of urgency to get results, not for any nefarious purposes. This happens sometimes; practicality and external exigencies can result in such decisions on the parts of investigators. There was no cover-up, no attempt to whitewash an association.
Of course, no antivaccinationist is ever going to believe that because the source is Verstraeten and because they don’t understand how often studies in medicine start out promisingly positive, only to have associations disappear as more and more confounders are controlled for and more and more rigorous analyses are done.
None of this stops Jake Crosby from attacking Emily Willingham’s analysis in a fashion that really makes me wonder how on earth he graduated from an MPH program, given how lacking in scientific and epidemiologic understanding it is. He engages in the same sort of conspiracy-mongering that Hooker does, only using an e-mail from Verstraeten in which he does what scientists frequently do: Explores different analyses of the data. It even refers to the abstract he had presented.
Of course, since the Verstraeten study, we have multiple other high quality studies that have failed to find a whiff of a hint of an association between thimerosal-containing vaccines and autism. So even if everything Hooker and Crosby says about the Verstraeten study were true, and the CDC did “cover up” a positive study, it wouldn’t matter because it would be an outlier. The fall of the hypothesis that mercury in vaccines causes autism does not depend on the Verstraeten study. It never did. If it were truly positive for an association between thimerosal-containing vaccines and autism, more study would have needed to be done. If it were correctly interpreted as “neutral,” as Verstraeten puts it, more study would have needed to be done. More study was done and it was negative. The antivaccine movement’s obsessive focus on the Verstraeten study is nothing more than a conspiracy theory, and not a very convincing one at that—except, of course, to the antivaccine movement.
In fact, as I’ve known for years and as Emily Willingham summarizes, none of this is even new information! Seriously. It’s not. Look at slide #41 in this PowerPoint presentation by David Kirby, who in 2004 made his name in antivaccine circles by publishing a book, Evidence of Harm, which claimed that mercury in vaccines was the cause of the “autism epidemic. Actually, never mind. I’ll show you the slide:
Notice that it says it was an FOIA (that’s Freedom of Information Act) request that provided the Verstraeten data that reported a relative risk for autism of 7.6 in children exposed to thimerosal-containing vaccines. Everything old is new again.
And again.
And again and again and again and again.
This particular meme isn’t new in 2014. It wasn’t new in 2005. It wasn’t new even a decade ago.
Same as it ever was.

   Mercury Must Be Bad – If Not in Vaccines, In Teeth. 
Harriet Hall
Link
Those of us who are baby boomers or older can remember playing with mercury when we were young. The thermometer broke, and you pushed the little globules around. Or you fooled around with the stuff in science class. My husband says he used to get mercury to flow over the surface of a dime and make it look really shiny. Who knew our old playmate would turn out to be such a bugaboo?
The real dangers of mercury have been recognized. Guidelines have been published to limit exposure. Instructions for safe cleanup of mercury spills are available online. This is good. Other developments are not so good. Scaremongers have demonized mercury and blamed it for everything from autism to Alzheimer’s.
Just when you thought the mercury/autism scare was finally subsiding, another mercury scare has resurfaced. The alarm has been raised (again!) about the mercury in amalgam fillings.
The Consumers for Dental Choice have published an exultant statement claiming “We have won our ten-year battle to get the Food and Drug Administration to comply with the law and set a date to classify mercury amalgam….A 180-degree reversal from FDA’s 30-year policy of protecting mercury fillings… recognizing the serious health concerns posed by amalgam in particular for children and unborn children, for pregnant women, for those with mercury immuno-sensitivity or high mercury body burdens.”
You can read the FDA’s statement for yourself. It gives a rather different impression. They haven’t said they recognize a danger; they are simply calling for public comment during a 90 day period prior to considering a regulatory change to “reclassify” mercury amalgams.
In response to inquiries, the American Dental Association issued this statement on June 5, 2008:
The American Dental Association (ADA) believes the recent settlement between the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the group Moms Against Mercury simply sets a definite deadline (July 28, 2009) for the FDA to complete what it began in 2002—a reclassification process for dental amalgam, a commonly-used cavity filling material. As far as the ADA is aware, the FDA has in no way changed its approach to, or position on, dental amalgam.
Contrary to some assertions, the FDA’s current reclassification proposal does not call for restrictions on the use of amalgam in any particular population group. It merely restates FDA’s ongoing call for public comments on that issue, as well as the findings of the most current scientific studies on amalgam….Presently, FDA has different classifications for encapsulated amalgam and its component parts, dental mercury and amalgam alloy. The FDA’s proposed reclassification, which the ADA has supported since 2002, would place encapsulated amalgam and its components under one classification.
It’s amazing how activists distort the information to make it look like it supports their ideology.
In reviewing the information on the web, I found some interesting tidbits I either hadn’t heard or had forgotten.
Some of you may remember the “smoking tooth” video. If you don’t, you can watch it smoke at this link. They show smoke rising from an old extracted tooth and claim it is mercury in large amounts. When skeptics pointed out that we were probably looking at water vapor, they produced another video to “prove” it was mercury vapor. It made me laugh out loud. Instead of testing the smoke in the video, they did an entirely unrelated test where they used a very sensitive machine to measure traces of mercury coming off a tooth in a patient’s mouth. Why on earth didn’t they just stick the sensor in the smoke? I can only guess it was because the sensor wouldn’t register water vapor.
We know that tiny amounts of mercury are emitted after vigorous chewing, but this exposure is very brief and most of the mercury is exhaled. Sure, you can measure it, but it’s highly unlikely that it has any health effects. We’ve gotten so good at measuring tiny quantities that we’re worrying about all sorts of things that are really insignificant.
In 1990, CBS aired a “60 Minutes” segment that Dr. Stephen Barrett, founder of Quackwatch, has called “the most irresponsible report on a health topic ever broadcast on network television.” Among other things, they claimed a study on sheep had proven the dangers of amalgam fillings, and they featured a woman who said that her symptoms of multiple sclerosis had disappeared overnight after her fillings were removed. Dr. Robert Baratz of the National Council Against Health Fraud is a dentist as well as a doctor; he holds an MD, DDS and PhD. He tried to ward off the disaster:
Two weeks before the 60 Minutes program aired, Dr. Baratz mailed a warning to its producer:
• The Canadian researchers prepared their amalgam with a method that has been obsolete for more than 40 years. The resultant amalgam contained excess mercury and was softer and therefore more easily worn by chewing, especially in a cud-chewing animal such as a sheep.
• The amalgams were placed in opposing teeth, so they would grind against each other. This enhanced the already enhanced rate of release of materials.
• Because rubber dams were not used when the fillings were placed, scrap amalgam was free to enter the sheeps’ mouth and be swallowed.
• The methods used to detect and calculate the amount of mercury absorbed were not valid.
• Although the researchers claimed that body mercury levels rose during the experiment, they had not measured the levels that were present in the beginning. The data actually showed that the animals swallowed a lot of free mercury during the placement of the fillings.
• Their claim of kidney toxicity was based on urinary findings that show just the opposite of what is known to occur in mercury poisoning in humans.
Baratz and at least one other knowledgeable critic also spoke by telephone to “60 Minutes” producer Patti Hassler before the program was aired. But they encountered a stone wall.
To make matters worse, that wonderful sheep study involved only 6 sheep, 2 of which were controls. It was a BA-A-A-A-AD study any way you look at it. (Sorry about the pun).
Dr. Stephen Barrett tried to explain to CBS that the woman’s supposed overnight cure was impossible because removal of mercury amalgam fillings temporarily RAISES mercury levels.
In 1995, Hal Huggins lost his license to practice dentistry. The judge’s conclusions can be read here.
The judge’s report is hair-raising. Huggins had developed indiscriminate tooth extraction into a big industry and was training other dentists. He diagnosed “mercury toxicity” in every patient even if they didn’t have any fillings! He told patients that mercury amalgam fillings caused: tremors, seizures, MS, ALS, Alzheimer’s disease, emotional disturbances, depression, anxiety, unprovoked suicidal thoughts, lupus, scleroderma, rheumatoid arthritis, unexplained heart pains, high and low blood pressure, tachycardia, irregular heartbeat, osteoarthritis, chronic fatigue, “brainfog,” digestive problems, and Crohn’s disease.
Huggins’ ideas are still going strong. There is a Huggins Applied Healing website. On the main page, they list MS, chronic fatigue, ALS, depression, and auto immune diseases as examples of mercury toxicity. Further into the website you can find many more illnesses including “Gulf War Disease” that can be cured by having your fillings removed “properly” by dentists trained in the Huggins method.
Apparently “Dr. Huggins and his team train the individual doctors to practice the Huggins Protocol safely” but he is not involved in the actual treatments. (Remember, he lost his license). The program offers nutritional advice based on Your Ancestral Diet as determined by blood tests. It also offers supplements, acupressure, etc.
I hope the FDA will keep its head, but there is a disturbing precedent. The “precautionary principle” was invoked to remove thimerosal from vaccines. They had not found any evidence that it caused harm, but they wanted to bend over backwards just in case some child might be overburdened by mercury from other sources and the mercury in thimerosal might add to that burden. Their reasoning was not made clear to the public, and the anti-mercury militia claimed it as a victory and an admission that the mercury in vaccines harmed children. They could invoke the same precautionary principle to demand that children (or everyone, for that matter) should never be exposed to one unnecessary molecule of mercury and that mercury amalgam fillings should be abolished. That would be a big mistake. We have every reason to think they are safe, and they offer some real advantages over other types of fillings.
The mercury militia doesn’t seem to understand that toxicity is in the dose, tiny amounts of toxins are harmless, and we can’t make the world a 100% safe place. The precautionary principle is a good one in moderation, but taking it to extremes is likely to do more harm than good.
As of June 5, 2008, the American Dental Association announced, “Based on extensive studies and scientific reviews of dental amalgam by government and independent organizations worldwide, the ADA believes that dental amalgam remains a safe, affordable and durable cavity filling choice for dental patients.”
We ask “cui bono” – who benefits from policies? Dentists could make a lot more money by pulling teeth and replacing fillings. The ADA dentists are acting against their own financial interests and in the interests of their patients, just as they have done in the fluoridation controversy.
Kudos to those who follow the science and not the dollar.
Ten lashes with a wet noodle (that’s a euphemism – I don’t want to use profanity here) to dentists who recommend removing amalgam fillings.

   Autism ‘Treatments’

   Should We Study Chelation for Autism?
Steven Novella
Link
The National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) supports doing a study on the effects of oral chelation therapy in autism. The proposal is highly controversial, is drawing criticism from many scientists, but has popular support among parents who believe this type of therapy might help their children with autism. The proposal raises many questions about the ethics of biomedical research.
Chelation and Autism
Chelation therapy is a legitimate FDA approved treatment for heavy metal poisoning. The drugs used for chelation, such as disodium EDTA, bind to heavy metals so that they can be removed from the body. Chelation drugs can be given either orally or intravenously. The treatment is somewhat risky because it can also remove needed electrolytes, like calcium, from the body or causes shifts in the electrolytes that can cause arhythmias and changes in brain function. There are reported cases of cardiac arrest and death due to chelation.
Chelation therapy has a long history of quackery – not for its intended use but for other uses for which there is no evidence. The classic example of this is the use of chelation therapy to treat atherosclerosis to prevent heart disease. This claim persists despite the utter lack of evidence for efficacy and the fact that all proposed mechanisms have been shown to be flawed or false.
In the last decade the belief that mercury in some vaccines (mercury-containing thimerosal was removed from routine childhood vaccines in the US by 2002) might be linked to autism. The scientific evidence clearly shows this is not the case (as I have discussed in many previous posts). But belief persists despite the evidence, mostly among anti-vaccinationist ideologues. But many earnest parents, just wanting to help their autistic children, have been caught up in the pseudoscience and conspiracy-mongering.
Naturally, belief that mercury causes autism has led to claims that chelating mercury cures autism. There is no evidence for this and there is no basic-science reason to suspect this might be the case. Now proponents of this treatment want the government to sponsor a study based upon their unsubstantiated treatment which in turn is based upon a false belief regarding the cause of autism.
The Ethics of Medical Research
Medical research has always been ethically tricky – it requires giving humans experimental treatments with unknown benefits and risks. But over the last few decades (originally triggered by Nazi abuses) there has been evolving ethical standards for medical research. They include many principals, among them that any experimental treatment must be more likely to help the subjects of the study than to hurt them, prior research must show that the treatment is probably safe – or at least is not highly toxic or dangerous, and there must be a plausible belief that the treatment is likely to work. Further, study subjects must be given full informed consent, and regardless of the treatment being studied they must receive at least the minimal current standard of care. In other words, you cannot withhold proven therapies in order to study unproven ones.
For this reason many consider using chelation therapy for autism to be unethical. There is insufficient scientific justification to believe that it might work, at least not enough to justify the safety concerns. Subjecting children to a risky treatment that probably doesn’t work is certainly ethically dubious.
But proponents of the study cite the fact that many parents are already using chelation therapy for their autistic children. Among them is Dr. Thomas Insel, Director of the NIHM. He is reported as saying:
“So many moms have said, `It’s saved my kids.’”
“This is an urgent set of questions. Let’s make innovation the centerpiece of this effort as we study autism, its causes and treatments, and think of what we may be missing.”
This justification comes up often with so-called alternative medicine – people are using it and they want choices, so we should study it. This turns out to be a very poor justification, however. The National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) was founded on this idea – but a decade of research and hundreds of millions of dollars spent on this precise form of wishful thinking has lead to nothing. All of the NCCAM research has not added one solid treatment to the arsenal of scientific medicine, nor has it convinced CAM proponents to abandon a single failed therapy. That is the very purpose of medical research – to change practice. Research into dubious therapies promoted by those who eschew science-based medicine does not achieve that purpose.
Therefore, such research is a waste. But it is more than a waste – it subjects the people in the study to the risks of medical research without any benefit to society. If the treatments are highly implausible, then the probability is there was no benefit to the subjects themselves either. Such research seems to be all expense and risk and no benefit.
This puts advocates of science-based and ethical medicine in a difficult position, however. It is hard to argue against doing research – more information always sounds like a good idea. Refusal to even research a question can easily be made by fanatics to seem like suppression of the truth. This can turn the public against those who are most sincerely advocating for their rights, ironically. This motivates some, like Insel, agree to do the research – but this is a sucker’s bargain. We have been there before – doing the research accomplishes nothing because the people who need to be convinced are not basing their conclusions on scientific evidence in the first place.
What about all those parents who feel that their children were helped by chelation? Frankly, this is not compelling evidence. Again – we have been there before with similar treatments. Many parents thought their children were helped by psychomotor patterning, but the evidence showed conclusively that they weren’t. The scientific community abandoned the treatment – but the true believers cling to it still, even after three decades.
Children with developmental and neurological disorders will often improve as they age. This background maturing can easily be mistaken for improvement in response to a treatment. There is also the numerous psychological effects that highly motivate parents to believe their children are being helped, even when they aren’t (such as confirmation bias and expense justification). The simple fact is that history has shown that anecdotal evidence is not reliable. If a treatment is plausible it may be enough to justify doing controlled research. But for risky and implausible treatments it is not enough. Otherwise we would be spending hundreds of millions of dollars studying numerous implausible modalities to no end (wait a minute – we are doing just that with the NCCAM).
Doing this kind of questionable research is also risky. With a study of this size there is a real chance of a false positive – that the study results will be positive even if the treatment does not work. If that happens it will embolden the proponents of chelation for autism and lure more children to this dubious treatment. One small study is not enough to settle a scientific question or establish an unlikely therapy – so a false positive study will lead to a larger follow-up study. That means more money, more time, and more children subjected to chelation as part of the experiment.
This all stems from doing research on an ideologically charged question. Ideally medical science should take its time with a question, conservatively interpret existing research, and carefully consider the next step. This is not possible when there are groups outside the scientific medical community essentially kibitzing the science. Regardless of their intentions, this taints the scientific process and leads to confusion. It creates a situation in which the public is likely to overreact to preliminary research – for example by demanding treatments that probably don’t work.
Conclusion
I am with those who say that this research is highly unethical. It is being promoted by a fringe movement that has a history of anti-scientific attitudes. There is no reason to believe that the results of the research will settle anything, and it is very unlikely to be truly positive given what we know about autism. Doing this type of research in the hopes of convincing the ideologues is a fool’s notion. Don’t say I didn’t tell you so.

Chelation Therapy for Autism is Quackery
Chelation therapy for autism is not based on any scientific rationale and what evidence we have shows it does not work, yet it continues to be offered as an “alternative” treatment.
Steven Novella on September 5, 2018
Link

Ten years ago I wrote an article here making the case against doing research into chelation therapy for autism. The case is pretty straight forward – there is no basic science reason to suspect that chelation therapy should be helpful for autism, and no preliminary evidence to suggest that it works. Further, the people promoting or using chelation therapy will not listen to the scientific evidence, and those who listen to scientific evidence already know enough to conclude that chelation therapy is not an appropriate treatment for autism. So what would be the point?
Now, a decade later, the situation has not changed, except that there have been a few studies that had no effect on the use of chelation therapy. A 2015 systematic review found 10 studies of chelation and autism. Nine studies were not controlled, which means that they are essentially useless. There has been only one controlled study looking at chelation therapy for autism, and it was completely negative. The authors conclude:
As such, no clinical trial evidence was found to suggest that pharmaceutical chelation is an effective intervention for ASD. Given prior reports of serious adverse events, such as hypocalcaemia, renal impairment and reported death, the risks of using chelation for ASD currently outweigh proven benefits. Before further trials are conducted, evidence that supports a causal link between heavy metals and autism and methods that ensure the safety of participants are needed.
I agree – there needs to be a rationale, and some assurance of safety, before more clinical trials are warranted. All of this is normal medical science. We test new ideas all the time, and most do not pan out and are abandoned. There was never any good reason to suspect chelation might work for autism, and early adoption has demonstrated it is risky, while the only good clinical study shows it does not work. The story should be over, a footnote in the annals of medicine. But of course, it isn’t.
Chelation therapy uses either oral or intravenous chemical to bind to heavy metals and help remove them from the body. It is a legitimate and approved therapy for heavy metal poisoning. However, there are several unscientific uses of chelation therapy, based on the preliminary or false notion that some condition is caused by heavy metals. The use of chelation for autism derives from the notion that autism is caused by mercury poisoning from thimerosal in vaccines. The vaccine/thimerosal-autism connection has been thoroughly disproven.
Therefore the entire basis of using chelation for autism is false. However, a 2013 study found that half a million children are subjected to this risky treatment in the US for autism each year. Use is not limited to the US, and it is common in Canada and Europe as well. A recent article in the Canadian news outlet, CBC, highlights the problem. They write:
Parents often discuss alternative treatments they’re considering for their children with autism with Anagnostou, and she’s fine with many of them as long as they’re safe and used in conjunction with proven autism interventions. But she draws the line at chelation therapy.
Anagnostou is a pediatric neurologist who treats children with autism. While I agree with her opposition to chelation therapy, I believe she is underestimating the harm of using “alternative” treatments that she considers “safe”. Often that means there is not evidence of direct immediate harm, but this ignores all the indirect harm. There is an opportunity and resource cost to using unproven therapies, and this burden may be massive, especially on families that are already experiencing increased burdens from a chronic condition. This may delay or even replace proven therapies.
Also – using unproven treatments does not occur in a vacuum. The practitioners offering those treatments are part of a culture, a network, and an industry of unscientific treatments. By patronizing them for one treatment that you think is individually benign, you are supporting the entire industry – an industry of quackery. I’m sorry, but there is no such thing as harmless pseudoscience in medicine.
The story gets worse, however. Borden King runs an autism advocacy group. The CBC article reports:
So when Borden King found out that Dr. John Gannage, a physician in Markham, Ont., was offering chelation therapy to children with autism, she called government agencies to try to find out if there were any clear regulations preventing that — and found there weren’t.
“It’s this Wild West,” she said. “There is no law that says that you can’t do these things.”
King was told to contact the appropriate regulatory body, the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario, so she did. They said that Dr. Gannage was in compliance with their policy, stating:
Although the [College] does not take a position on individual therapies or treatments, we have developed policies to guide physician conduct while supporting patient autonomy. If physicians offer complementary treatments to patients, their diagnosis must be based on their clinical assessment, be supported by sound clinical judgment and informed by evidence and a risk-benefit analysis.
If patients have concerns about the care or treatment they’ve received, we encourage them to contact our public advisory service.
Those practice guidelines state:
Patients have the right to make health care decisions that accord with their own values, wishes and preferences. This includes decisions to pursue complementary/alternative medicine either as an adjunct to conventional medicine, or instead of conventional medicine. The Medicine Act, 1991 states that physicians shall not be found guilty of professional misconduct or incompetence solely on the basis that they practice a therapy that is non-traditional or that departs from the prevailing medical practice.
This is partly how the purveyors of pseudoscience and health fraud remain in business – through these very types of regulations. What this regulation essentially says is that there is no science-based standard of care, as long as what you are doing is “alternative”. The standard of care has been successfully erased from medicine. As the response above states, the default now is – if something bad happens, make a complaint (not that anything will happen if you do).
The medical profession has simply rolled over and accepted the eradication of the standard of care, in favor of “patient autonomy” (which is really code for the freedom of purveyors to sell quackery). In my dealings with my colleagues I find that many think this kind of quackery is on the fringe, but they are wrong. This is now fully infiltrated into the mainstream. They just haven’t noticed. When norms slowly shift, it is easy to miss.
Chelation therapy for autism is a good example of the problem with this approach. This is a risky intervention, even with documented deaths, that has no basic science support, and clinical evidence for lack of efficacy. It is offered to desperate parents in a manner that amounts to exploitation. Meanwhile the regulatory infrastructure turns a blind eye because, hey, people apparently want it.
What people actually want are safe effective treatments. They only accept chelation therapy for autism because some medical authorities are telling them this is a good option, while the majority look the other way. This is the legacy of the alternative medicine movement, and the medical profession needs to wake up to this reality or the slide into mainstream quackery will continue.

   Chemical castration of autistic children leads to the downfall of Dr. Mark Geier
David Gorski
Link
One of the most persistent myths is one that’s been particularly and doggedly resistant to evidence, science, clinical trials, epidemiology, and reason. It’s also a myth that I’ve been writing about a long time. Specifically, I’m referring to the now scientifically discredited myth that the mercury-containing thimerosal preservative that used to be in quite a few childhood vaccines causes autism. The myth began in the late 1990s and was later fed by the publication of David Kirby’s book Evidence of Harm, which was basically a paean to various brave maverick doctors who promoted the claim that mercury in vaccines cause autism. Among the “scientists” promoted by David Kirby were the father-son team of Mark and David Geier. Mark Geier is a physician who also has a PhD and represents himself as a medical geneticist; his son David has no medical degree, leading to my wondering from the very beginning how it was that he got away with helping his father evaluate and treat autistic children, in essence practicing medicine without a license.
The Geiers are most infamous for their “Lupron protocol,” which I first learned about back in 2006. As I wrote about it in 2009, when the mainstream media finally noticed the Geiers’ dubious medicine and how they were franchising it to different states, it was chemical castration for autism. The short version is that, somehow some way, Mark Geier got the idea in his head that testosterone contributes to autism. That in and of itself isn’t woo, given that scientists have from time to time hypothesized that very thing. What made the Geiers’ conclusions pseudoscience is their explanation. Basically, Geier claimed that testosterone binds mercury from vaccines, making it more “toxic” to the brain and also making it harder to get rid of the mercury using chelation therapy. Never mind that the only paper showing testosterone binding to mercury did it in benzene (hint: your blood is not benzene) under extreme conditions. What was worse, however, was the Geiers’ “solution” to this problem, which was to add to the autism quackery known as chelation therapy another potentially harmful form of quackery, namely chemical castration using Lupron, a drug that shuts down the production of sex hormones, including testosterone. It’s a drug that’s used to treat metastatic prostate cancer, a treatment that replaced the old treatment for metastatic prostate cancer, namely surgical castration. (Not coincidentally, it’s also used to chemically castrate sex offenders.) Even worse still, the Geiers somehow got away with a highly unethical clinical trial in which they packed the Institutional Review Board overseeing it with their cronies, going merrily on their way offering an unethical “clinical trial” untouched and seemingly untouchable.
Finally, the law acts
For over five years now, I’ve been wondering just how in the world the Geiers got away with such unethical pseudoscience and how they got away with it for so long. I couldn’t figure it out. Not only did they ply their dubious medicine on autistic children, but David Geier appeared to be functioning as a “diagnostician,” somehow fooling the State of Maryland’s Autism Commission into appointing him as a member, even though he completely lacks expertise to be practicing medicine and does not have a medical or clinical degree of any kind. Meanwhile, evidence suggested that the Geiers appeared to be playing fast and loose with insurance companies by making lots of diagnoses of “precocious puberty,” a very uncommon diagnosis. Truly, I wondered what was wrong with the State of Maryland…until last week, when online acquaintances, not to mention some of you started sending me the news that Mark Geier has had his medical license suspended by the State of Maryland, as outlined in this 48-page court order. Kathleen Seidel, as usual, is already on the case as well.
Yes, the Maryland State Board of Physicians has finally acted. All I can say is: It’s about time. Let’s take a look at some of the relevant sections of the order. First, here’s the money section, namely the summary statement, which I cite nearly in its entirety:
The Respondent misdiagnosed autistic children with precocious puberty and other genetic abnormalities and treated them with potent hormonal therapy (“Lupron Therapy” or “Lupron Protocol”), and in some instances, chelation therapy, both of which have a substantial riskof both short-term and long-term adverse side effects. The Respondent’s treatment exposed the children to needless risk of harm.
The Respondent, in addition to being a physician, is certified as a genetic counselor. His assessment and treatment of autistic children, as described herein, however, far exceeds his qualifications and expertise. The extensive and extensive batteries of laboratory studies the Respondent initially orders, many of which he orders to be repeated on a monthly basis, are outside the standard quality of care for a work-up for an autistic patient or to determine the underlying cause of autism. The Respondent failed to conduct adequate physical examinations of any of the patients and in several instances, began his Lupron Protocol based merely on a telephone consultation with the child’s parent and the results of selected laboratory tests he ordered. The Respondent’s omission of a comprehensive physical examination constitutes a danger because his treatment is based on a diagnosis that requires documentation of sexual development beyond that expected for the age of the child. Moreover, his treatment may constitute more of a risk to a child with an underlyingl medical condition.
The Respondent failed to provide adequate informed consent to the parents of the autistic children he treated. In one (1) instance, he misrepresented that his treatment protocol had been approved by a federally approved IRB.
[...]
The Respondent endangers autistic children and exploits their parents by administering to the children a treatment protocol that has a known substantial risk of serious harm and which is neither consistent with evidence-based medicine nor generally accepted in the relevant scientific community.
In the order, Mark Geiers’ numerous other offenses are listed, including his corrupt, crony-packed IRB overseeing his clinical trial, possible insurance fraud (billing insurance companies for services never rendered), failing to obtain informed consent, misdiagnosing children with “precocious puberty” in most egregious ways (such as diagnosing children who did not meet the age criteria for precocious puberty) and writing medical necessity letters based on this mistaken diagnosis, and misrepresenting himself as a geneticist. Basically, regarding this latter charge, Mark Geier claimed to be a geneticist, which is a “physician who evaluates a patient for genetic conditions, which may include performing a physical examination and ordering tests,” even though he is not a medical geneticist; rather, he is a genetic counselor, which is “an individual with a master’s degree who helps to educate the patient and provides an assessment of the risk of the condition recur in the family.” I know genetic counselors. I work with genetic counselors. They don’t diagnose genetic conditions; rather, they counsel patients after either a genetic diagnosis has been rendered or the patient has developed a condition (such as breast cancer at a young age) that might indicated a genetic predisposition to a disease. It turns out that Geier also misrepresented himself as a board-certified epidemiologist when he is not.
Particularly disturbing are the treatments to which Mark Geier submitted children in his care. Case studies described in the report include include a battery of over 40 tests, spironolactone for misdiagnosed hyperaldosteronism, chelation therapy for “heavy metal toxicity,” Lupron, and methyl B12 drops for unclear and undocumented indications. One patient, patient F, a female, was given Femara, an aromatase inhibitor, which is used to treat estrogen receptor-positive breast cancer. It’s used mainly in post-menopausal women to shut down hormone production in the peripheral tissues. (It doesn’t work in premenopausal women because their ovaries make lots of estrogen, far more than the small amount made in peripheral tissues.) The presumed rationale, I have to guess, would be the same as in younger woman with breast cancer, where sometimes it is necessary to shut down ovarian hormone production and then to top it off by shutting down peripheral hormone production. My guess is that Geier somehow thought he needed to shut down not just ovarian sex hormone production in this girl but peripheral production as well. Why, I have no idea, but its profoundly idiotic and potentially harmful, particularly when combined with chelation therapy. Meanwhile, in other patients, Mark Geier proposed adding another anti-androgen drug, Androcur.
The abuse of autistic children was staggering. As a result, the Board made a finding of law:
Based on the foregoing facts, the Board concludes that the public health, safety or welfare imperatively require emergency action in this case, pursuant to Md. State Gov’t Code Ann. § 10-226 (c) (2) (i) (2009 Repl. Vol.).
That’s right, not just action but emergency action. I guess the State of Maryland has a different definition of “emergency,” given that the Geiers have been at this for at least six years, but I’ll take what I can get. At least when finally roused from its torpor, the Maryland State Board of Physicians recognized the Geiers for the threat to autistic children that they are and, as a result, ordered that Mark Geier’s license to practice medicine in the State of Maryland be summarily suspended. As a result, Mark Geier was required to surrender the following to the Board:
    • his original Maryland License D24250
    • his current renewal certificate
    • his Maryland Controlled Dangerous Substance Registration
    • all controlled dangerous substances in the Respondent’s possession and/or practice;
    • all Medical Assistance prescription forms
    • all prescription forms and pads in the Respondent’s possession and/or practice
    • any and all prescription pads on which his name and DEA number are imprinted
Excellent.
I only have a couple of remaining questions. First, what will be the response of the anti-vaccine movement. One thing I’ve noticed over the last couple of years, since the mainstream media first noticed his Lupron protocol is that the anti-vaccine movement seems to have distanced itself from the Geiers. They’re almost never mentioned anymore on Age of Autism these days, even though they used to be regular features there a couple of years ago. They’re not the headliners at the yearly Autism One quackfest anymore; they are, however, still listed as speakers for this year’s quackfest. One has to wonder whether they’ll be quietly disinvited now that Geier has had his medical license yanked, or whether Lisa Sykes will remove the Geiers’ epilogue from her book. Probably not, I’d guess. Most likely the Autism One organizers will see the loss of Mark Geier’s medical license as evidence of his cred as a “brave maverick doctor,” much as Wakefield’s cred remains high in the anti-vaccine movement. Even so, in the several days since the suspension of Geiers’ license became widely known, I’ve seen almost nothing written about them by the anti-vaccine movement, which is in marked contrast to the wailing and gnashing of teeth observed after Andrew Wakefield lost his medical license in the U.K.
Be that as it may, I’m now left wondering how long it will be before the conspiracy theories come out. The most obvious one hasn’t hit the blogosphere yet, at least not as I write this. How long do you think it’ll be before an anti-vaccine loon claims that stripping Mark Geier of his medical license (just like another brave maverick doctor, Andrew Wakefield!) was a plot by the miltiary-industrial-pharma-CDC complex to distract attention from the case of Poul Thorsen. You know it’s coming sooner or later.
Finally, what of the metastatic deposits of Geier père et fils quackery in other states? After all, besides Maryland, the Geiers have spread their clinics to Kentucky, Missouri, Florida, Illinois, and Indiana. Will these states now act to shut down the Geier clinics there, known as ASD Centers, LLC? I know I’ve complained about how long it took the State of Maryland to do the right thing. Even so, I’m glad that the Board there finally acted. It’s time for the medical boards in these other states to do likewise.
Fallout
There was one truly odd aspect about this incident, as long overdue as it was and as happy as I was to learn about it. Basically I learned something else along the way that I hadn’t known. In fact, I was pretty shocked to find this out, and I wanted to know how something like this could possibly have happened. I’m referring to the fact that Mark Geier’s son David Geier had somehow slimed his way onto the State of Maryland Commission on Autism as a “diagnostician.” As I pointed out at the time, David Geier is not a physician and has no qualifications to diagnose or treat autism (or anything other medical condition, for that matter). Not that that’s stopped him thus far; he does it anyway.
By way of the Baltimore Sun, I now learn that part of the fallout in the aftermath of Mark Geier’s humiliation is that, not only is the state trying to get rid of David Geier but people are asking–shall we say?–inconvenient questions about how he was appointed to the Commission on Autism in the first place:
A day after Dr. Mark Geier’s medical license was suspended in Maryland over allegations of putting children with autism at risk, state officials were seeking to remove his son from a state commission that advises the governor on the disorder.
The officials were also struggling to explain why David Geier, who has an undergraduate degree in biology and does not have a medical license, was identified by the Commission on Autism as its “diagnostician.” The commission’s website had listed him as a doctor until Wednesday, which officials said was a clerical error. The commission’s listing also includes the Geiers’ company, ASD Centers LLC, whose website lists a corporate center in Silver Spring but is not registered in Maryland.
“Under the circumstances, we do not believe it’s appropriate for David Geier to serve on the autism commission,” said David Paulson, a spokesman for the state Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, which submitted 19 names to the governor, including David Geier’s, for approval to the panel. “Unfortunately, he declined to resign his commission. … As a result, we are considering the appropriate next steps.”
Leave it to a Geier not to take the hint when not wanted, leading the state to try to get rid of him. Like father, like son, I suppose. However it is a very interesting question. How could someone like David Geier, a man with no qualifications, associated with pseudoscience like the Geiers’ Lupron protocol get on such a panel? While it’s true that he has been caught in the past inflating his credentials, I doubt that explains it. The explanation coming from the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene doesn’t sound particularly convincing:
Paulson said the state was aware of “the controversial nature of David Geier’s views” when he was recommended for the position on the commission, which was formed by the legislature in 2009. But officials were looking for a “diverse” panel.
“Controversial.” You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means. David Geier’s views are most definitely not “controversial,” at least not from a scientific standpoint. They’re demonstrably wrong. They’re pseudoscientific. They’re advocacy of abuse of autistic children. But controversial? Not so much. One potential explanation for David Geier’s presence on the panel has been suggested by Robert Goldberg, author of Tabloid Medicine: How the Internet is Being Used to Hijack Medical Science for Fear and Profit, who asks how an autism quack got on the Maryland autism panel and then tries to answer the question:
Here’s a clue: The Geiers did have their association with John L. Young, MD.
Who is Dr. Young and why might he be connected to David Geier’s appointment?
In 2009, Dr. Young “was the President of the Montgomery County Medical Society, the largest component medical society in Maryland. From 2007 to 2009, he was asked by Maryland Governor Martin O’Malley to serve as a Commissioner for the Maryland Community Health Resources Commission, and in 2009, was appointed by Governor O’Malley to serve on the Board of Regents for the University System of Maryland.”
That information is taken from the website of ASD Centers, which the Geiers set up to peddle Lupron and other dangerous and disproven autism treatments. That’s because John L. Young, MD — founded in 2008 — along with Mark Geier — ASD Centers.
http://www.autismtreatmentclinics.com/Staff.html
And there’s more: The Geiers set up an Institutional Review Board (IRBs are established to review the impact of clinical research on human subjects) to approve their own research, conducted by ASD Centers of course. The IRB called the Institute for Chronic Illnesses turned out to be Mark Geier’s home.
More problematic, John Young was a ‘co-investigator’ with Mark and David Geier in their Lupron research.
Even worse, Young was also a member of the IRB.
http://www.neurodiversity.com/weblog/article/98/
It certainly does look suspicious, doesn’t it?
Whether Dr. Young is the conduit through which David Geier managed to find a seat on Maryland’s autism panel or not, the Geiers have built a virtual “autism biomed” empire in Maryland, Illinois, Indiana, Texas, Florida, New Jersey, Missouri, Kentucky, and Washington based on, in essence, the chemical castration of children. We have to remember that Geier’s only been shut down in one state. True, it’s the state of his current residence, which is huge, but that doesn’t stop the Geiers from simply relocating to one of the other states in which Mark Geier holds a medical license. Heck, if Dr. Geier were to relocate to Virginia, he might not even have to move out of his very large, very expensive home; he could just deal with a longer commute. The problem, as I’ve discussed before, boils down to ineffective state medical boards, many of which are overburdened and hampered by laws that mistake giving doctors due process with viewing a medical license as a right. It’s not; it’s a privilege. In any case, the ineffectual regulation of physicians by many state medical boards have allowed “unconventional” doctors like Rashid Buttar to continue their dubious medicine with impunity, in essence thumbing their noses at the medical establishment.
Which is what the Geiers are still doing in Illinois, Indiana, Texas, Florida, New Jersey, Kentucky, and Washington.
So, how to stop them? In most states, for the medical board to act, there have to be complaints, either from patients or fellow health care professionals. Whether there have been complaints about the Geiers or not, I don’t know, but there should be. Also, a license suspension in one state can trigger an investigation in another state. At the very least, the Mark Geier will have to report it the next time he applies for renewal of his license in the several states in which he is licensed, a convenient list of which has been kindly provided here.
I have two hopes right now. The first, and lesser, of the two is that David Geier will be kicked off of the Maryland Commission on Autism. He should never have been on that panel in the first place, and it would be very, very interesting to find out exactly who pushed for his appointment, given that the competition for the spots on that committee was pretty fierce. I highly doubt that David Geier got a spot on the committee on his merits; almost certainly someone somewhere pulled some strings, possibly Dr. Young. The second, and more important, hope is that the State of Maryland’s action, as long overdue as it may have been, ultimately cascades, and Mark Geier finds himself losing his medical license in each and every state in which he holds one.

   Chemical castration for autism: After three years, the mainstream media finally notices
David Gorski
Link
We’ve written a lot about anti-vaccine zealotry on this blog, as Steve and I take a particular interest in this particular form of dangerous pseudoscience for a number of reasons. One reason, of course, is that the activities of antivaccine groups like Generation Rescue and its spokesmodel since 2007 (Jenny McCarthy, a frequent topic on this blog) have started to frighten parents about vaccines enough that vaccination rates are falling well below that required for herd immunity in some parts of the country. Indeed, McCarthy, at the behest of her handlers in Generation Rescue, serves up a regular “toxic” brew of misinformation and nonsense about vaccines, most recently in a video that was the subject of a post by Val Jones about her unbelievably pseudoscience-laden blather. Truly, it has to be seen to be believed. Meanwhile, Generation Rescue has sent McCarthy on a media propaganda tour for her latest antivaccine pro-quackery book and set up a misinformation-laden propaganda site called Fourteen Studies (blogged about by Steve Novella, Mark Crislip, and, of course, yours truly) in which they attack well-designed studies that have failed to confirm their pet idea that somehow, some way, vaccines must be the cause of autism. And, when their pseudoscience is criticized, the antivaccine movement has a tendency to launch vicious ad hominem attacks, as they recently did against Steve Novella and have done multiple times in the past against me.
However, there is one other consequence of the antivaccine movement, however, and it is at least as important as the public health implications of the potential dimunition of herd immunity caused by the fear mongering of groups like Generation Rescue. That consequence is the cottage industry of “biomedical” treatments to which desperate parents subject their children. Gluten-free diets, chelation therapy (which has caused deaths), hyperbaric oxygen chambers (a recent story described a child getting severely burned when one of these caught fire), autistic children have been subjected to it all. But of all the biomedical woo to which autistic children have been subjected, one form of woo stands out as being particularly heinous. Indeed, I agree with our fearless leader Steve in characterizing it as an “atrocity.”
I’m referring to Mark and David Geier’s favored “treatment” for autistic children, namely a drug called Lupron.
THE LUPRON PROTOCOL
I first became interested in Mark and David Geier around four years ago, around the same time I first became aware of and interested in the antivaccine movement.Dr. Mark Geier is a physician but has no expertise in pediatrics, endocrinology, vaccines, or autism. His son only has a bachelor’s degree in biology; yet he assists his father in his “research” and in essence helps him treat patients, despite his lack of medical training. Together, they are the Batman and Robin of autism woo (the 1960s camp version, not the updated Dark Knight version) going into battle against autism, which–surprise! surprise!–they blame on vaccines. But not just any vaccines. Oh, no. Batman and Robin–excuse me, Mark and David–were there at ground zero of the formation of the mercury militia. Together, they were at the forefront of promoting the now scientifically discredited concept that mercury in the thimerosal preservative that was in childhood vaccines until the end of 2001 causes autism and published many dubious papers arguing that mercury in vaccines caused autism.
Not that the Geiers didn’t put their own personal spin on things. Not at all. In fact, around four years ago, they conjured up a “hypothesis” (my fingers seized up as I typed that, not wanting to dignify their idiotic idea with such a scientific term) that testosterone somehow bound to mercury, making it harder to chelate. They even claimed that testosterone binds to mercury, leading to a complex that can’t pass the blood-brain barrier and keeps mercury in the body, a complex that the quackery known as chelation therapy won’t chelate (more on that later). They claimed that autistic children were really undergoing premature puberty and had too much testosterone, which was binding to mercury and somehow enhancing its toxicity. So what was their solution?
In essence, chemical castration using a powerful anti-sex hormone drug called Lupron.
The Geiers even called it their “Lupron protocol,” and a disturbing number of parents not only fell for this disturbing abuse of autistic children, but they even paid big bucks for it. Even after the revelations of what the Geiers did, I could never figure out, though, since 2006, more than three years ago, is just how. How did they manage to keep subjecting children to a treatment with science so bad that it doesn’t even qualify as junk science? And why didn’t the mainstream media ever notice, even though a small cadre of skeptical bloggers wrote about it repeatedly?
I don’t know, but I do know that finally a major newspaper noticed the Geiers, who operate a makeshift laboratory in the basement of Dr. Geier’s house, complete with a tissue culture hood. Yesterday, the Chicago Tribune ran companion stories entitled ‘Miracle drug’ called junk science and Physician team’s crusade shows cracks.
All I can say is that it’s about time.
I first learned about the Geiers’ Lupron protocol (to my horror) back in Februrary 2006, when I first read blogger Kathleen Seidel’s account of their activities. Somehow, some way, the Geiers have managed to inject autistic children with a powerful drug that suppresses sex hormone production for over three years now. How did this all get started? First, let me explain what Lupron is.
Lupron is the trade name for a drug called leuprolide acetate, a synthetic analog of a hormone known as gonadotropin releasing hormone (GnRH, a.k.a. LH-RH). After causing an initial stimulation of gonadotropin receptors by binding to them, chronic administration of Lupron inhibits gonadotropin secretion, specifically leutenizing hormone (LH) and follicle stimulating hormone (FSH). The end result is the inhibition of the synthesis of steroid hormones in the testes in men and in the ovaries in women. In men, testosterone and androgen levels fall to castrate levels, and in women estrogens are reduced to postmenopausal levels.
This is a drug that doesn’t have very many uses. Perhaps the most common use is in men with metastatic prostate cancer, because prostate cancer is an androgen-dependent tumor. Back when I was a surgical resident, such patients were treated with surgical castration. These days, they are usually put on Lupron or a similar GnRH agonist, and this treatment works quite well to suppress the growth of prostate cancer for a while. Such tumors will inevitably develop androgen-independent growth and become resistant to hormonal suppression with Lupron, but in the meantime chemical castration with Lupron can provide excellent palliation. Another use for Lupron is in women with estrogen-dependent conditions, such as endometriosis and uterine fibroids. One troubling side effect of its use in women is the onset of menopausal symptoms, often quite severe, a problem that sometimes causes women to stop taking it. The other major use of Lupron is during cycles of in vitro fertilization, in which it is used to suppress ovarian function completely in order to allow complete control of hormone levels and ovarian follicle development through the use of hormone injections. Without Lupron or similar drugs, it is very difficult to get multiple ovarian follicles to develop and mature at the same time, allowing the harvest of many eggs.
But we’re not talking about adults here. We’re talking about children. Are there any medically accepted uses of Lupron in children? Yes, but only one: Precocious puberty. Precocious puberty is defined as the onset of secondary sexual characteristics before 8 years old in girls and 9 years old in boys. It can be the result of tumors, central nervous system injury, or congenital anomalies. The package insert for Lupron emphasizes that children should not be treated with Lupron unless they meet the following criteria:
     1.  Onset of secondary sexual characteristics before age 8 in females and age 9 in males.
     2.  The clinical diagnosis must be confirmed by a pubertal response to GnRH (adequate secretion of LH in response to a challenge with injected GnRH) and bone age advanced at least one year beyond chronological age.
     3.  Baseline evaluation has to include: Height and weight measurements; sex steroid levels; adrenal steroid level to rule out congenital adrenal hyperplasia; beta-chorionic gonadotropin (beta-HCG) to rule out a beta-HCG-secreting tumor; pelvic and adrenal ultrasound to rule out a steroid-secreting tumor; and a CT of the head to rule out an intracranial tumor.
Also, precocious puberty is a rare condition. Autism is not. Not that that that stops the Geiers. In any case, in my book, if you’re going to give a potent drug like Lupron to children, a drug that can almost completely shut down the synthesis of both male and female steroid hormones, you’d better have damned good evidence that it’s likely to help to make it worth the risk.
So did the Geiers have good evidence three or four years ago, when they first started pumping autistic children full of Lupron? Take a guess. As pointed out by Kathleen Seidel, the Geiers seemed quite excited about manipulating testosterone levels and were recruiting children for a “clinical trial,” having presented their concept in 2005 at the Autism One conference in Chicago. Prior to that, they had published their idea in a medical journal known as Medical Hypotheses, giving it the patina of respectability. The problem is, Medical Hypotheses is a fringe journal that is not well respected. For one thing, it’s not peer-reviewed. The other reason that it exists to publish “radical” ideas that “conflict with current theory and practice.” Such a speculative journal may serve a useful purpose in the publishing world, but citing speculative articles published in it is not exactly good evidence for anything, other than that
Not surprisingly, the paper was a mess, full of unsupported speculation. Its first flaw was apparent right from the beginning. First, the Geiers implicitly assumed that mercury is the cause of autism and that chelation is the cure. As evidence, they cited the usual suspects, such as the Hornig “rain mouse” study; the Redwood et al study using a model to predict the hair level of mercury due to vaccines (while ignoring the Pichichero et al, which actually measured the levels and showed that mercury levels in infants given thimerosal-containing vaccines according to a standard schedule had blood levels well within what is considered safe); papers studying cultured cells treated with ridiculously high concentrations of thimerosal, concentrations unattainable in humans; and the infamous Boyd Haley study that showed lower levels of mercury in the hair of autistic babies compared to normals, leading him to speculate without evidence that autistics do not secrete mercury as well, leading it to accumulate in the brain. They also cited the Bradstreet article that looked at mercury levels excreted in response to a “challenge” with the chelating agent DMSA and supposedly found that autistic children secrete more mercury than nonautistic children. The problem was, Bradstreet used a nonstandard method of normalizing their mercury concentrations in the urine, didn’t measure total mercury excretion, not to mention that they didn’t match the ages of their groups very well. Worse, their data was so full of scatter that it’s hard to tell how they made any conclusions. (Not surprisingly, this article was published in the Journal of American Physicians and Surgeons, a really crappy journal that’s chock full of antivaccination rhetoric, antifluoridation articles, and an article defending Alan Yurko, an antivaccination activist who was tried for shaking a baby to death but got off by claiming it was the result of vaccines causing encephalitis. Many of the rest of the articles cited had been written by the Geiers themselves, and they ignored important studies that cast serious doubt on any link between mercury and autism. Worse, through it all, the Geiers stated as fact that chelation therapy is effective, when there is in fact no credible evidence suggesting that it is.
As I’ve mentioned before, however, the new twist that the Geiers placed on their mercury madness is the concept that testosterone somehow increases the toxicity of mercury. The way the Geiers came to this concept is rather roundabout. First they cite a paper suggesting that there are increased markers of increased oxidative stress in autistic patients. (To me this begs the question of why there was so much focus on mercury rather than abnormalities in oxidative metabolism in autism. Since then, there has been a lot of such work that has been used to justify all manner of antioxidants and other dietary manipulations. But I digress.) They also presented a paper in which the investigators treated cultured neuroblastoma and glioblastoma tumor cells with high concentrations of thimerosal and show that pretreatment with glutathione (an antioxidant) is protective against thimerosal toxicity. However, the authors themselves state:
Acute high dose exposures to Thimerosal (mmol/L) in cultured cells were used to study mechanistic aspects of Thimerosal toxicity and not intended to mimic exposures of developing brain cells in vivo to Thimerosal in vaccines (nmol/kg).
Little details like that never stopped the Geiers from representing the study as strong “evidence” that defects in oxidative metabolism potentiate thimerosal toxicity as a cause of autism. At best the study shows that very high concentrations of thimerosal are toxic to brain cancer cells and that glutathione can protect these cells.
So how did the Geiers link oxidative metabolism defects observed in some autistics, testosterone, and mercury? Well, if you’re the Geiers, it’s easy. You wave your hands and point out that one of the one enzyme (hydroxysteroid transferase) that modifies a testosterone precursor DHEA to DHEA-S (a sulfate group added) requires glutathione and is inhibited by mercury. Of course the Geiers cite a 30-year old paper and don’t even use the name of the enzyme that I find in the more recent literature, namely DHEA sulfotransferase. In any case, DHEA is the main precursor to androgens like testosterone, and DHEA sulfotransferase adds a sulfate group to it, “shuttling” DHEA away from the pathway to make testosterone by turning it into DHEA-S. DHEA-S is thought to be a “storage” form of DHEA, and DHEA and DHEA-S are freely interconverable. If something prevents DHEA from being converted to DHEA-S, there’s more precursor for testosterone synthesis. Elevated DHEA and DHEA-S levels have been implicated in polycystic ovary syndrome.
This all sounds well and good, but there was no good evidence then that any of this, at least as explained by the Geiers, has anything to do with the pathogenesis of autism, nor is there any evidence now that it does. The abnormalities in oxidative metabolism observed in some autistics may be a cause of autism or they may simply be a consequence of other genetic abnormalities that are responsible for autism. It is not yet possible to know their significance with the current state of our data, but that hasn’t stopped the Geiers from mining this rich vein for pesudoscientific justifications for their Lupron protocol over the last four years.
But if you really want to know how risibly bad the Geiers’ understanding of biochemistry is, consider the “testosterone sheet” nonsense they laid down three years ago, when they were quoted as saying that mercury binds to testosterone and forms “sheets” in the brain, leading to a complex that can’t pass the blood-brain barrier and keeps mercury in the body. This is indeed nonsense on many levels. Besides the fact that there is no persuasive evidence that mercury causes autism in the first place, there is even less evidence that testosterone in any way prevents the elimination of mercury from the body. I can’t help but note that the claim that testosterone binds mercury and prevents it from being excreted was not in the Medical Hypotheses paper, suggesting that it was too far out even for that far out journal. Instead, the Geiers included large figures showing complex pathways of steroid biosynthesis and wildly speculated that the combination of testosterone and decreased glutathione might inhibit the activity of DHEA sulfotransferase. Thus even if mercury were the cause of autism, there would be no biochemical justification for the shotgun approach of using Lupron to suppress steroid hormone synthesis in boys. Remember, Lupron doesn’t just suppress testosterone production; it suppresses both the androgenic and estrogenic pathways.
The Geiers have also liked to cite a paper they published in Hormone Research. The Chicago Tribune article quite nicely pointed out what garbage it was:
To support their theory that a link exists between testosterone, mercury and autism, the Geiers often cite their own paper published in the journal Hormone Research. Their report describes symptoms and lab results for 16 autistic children ages 3 to 10 and finds nearly all have high testosterone.
Experts who read the paper said it is deeply flawed and its conclusions are baseless.
The blood tests the Geiers use as proof of excessive testosterone don’t show that at all, and other data they cite mean nothing, said Paul Kaplowitz, chief of endocrinology at Children’s National Medical Center in Washington, D.C., and an expert on precocious puberty. They also leave out test results that could help show whether the children are in early puberty, he added.
Looking at the tests, Kaplowitz said he asks himself: “Is Dr. Geier just misinformed and he hasn’t studied endocrinology, or is he trying to mislead?”
Another deconstruction of the paper can be found here.
Once again, if you’re going to propose doing something as radical as shutting down steroid hormone synthesis in children, you’d better have damned good evidence to justify it, and the Geiers didn’t then and don’t now. The best piece of clinical evidence that suppressing testosterone might help autistic boys they can muster is a case report in which a 24-year old autistic man exhibiting severe frequent inappropriate sexual behavior who frequently masturbated in public and became sexually aroused around young children was placed on Lupron. Surprise, surprise! His inappropriate sexual behavior decreased markedly. Chemical castration will do that. This case report said nothing about what treating children with Lupron would do. (It also raised some seriously touchy ethical questions.)
It isn’t that there hasn’t been at least some evidence suggesting that abnormal testosterone levels might have something to do autism. Certainly, the high proponderance of males with autism alone could suggest such a linkage. There’s just one problem. Nearly all of the evidence supporting such this link has correlated high levels of prenatal exposure of the fetus to testosterone with autism and autism spectrum disorders. The main proponent of this hypothesis is Simon Baron-Cohen, who has published several papers finding correlations between elevated fetal testosterone and empathy, decreased quality of social relations, gender-typed play, and autism. This has led to Baron-Cohen’s concept that autism is due to an “extreme male brain.” This is a controversial concept in the autism research community, and I can see why. Personally, I found the evidence supporting this concept to be a somwhat shaky after reading several papers describing it. Even so, the concept is probably worth further study. Of course, none of Baron-Cohen’s data provides any real support for the Geiers’ concept that lowering testosterone will help autistics. Nearly all of the evidence implicating testosterone in autism pathogenesis come from correlations with prenatal testosterone levels and markers for high prenatal levels of testosterone. Presumably, treating children several years after birthwould be too late; the brain has already been largely shaped by the prenatal testosterone.
THE CHICAGO TRIBUNE NOTICES THE GEIERS
I had first got wind through some of my online sources that the Tribune might be doing a story on the Geiers a couple of weeks ago. I was skeptical, but apparently the inciting event was the yearly autism quackfest known as Autism One held in Chicago every Memorial Day week. Mark and David Geier be spoke there this year, as they have most years in the recent past. For those not familiar with Autism One, it’s best described as an autism Quackapalooza. Chelation, hyperbaric oxygen, “biomedical” interventions, gluten-free diets, every form of autism woo and quackery that you can imagine is there, all under one roof. But, above, all there is the antivaccine movement. As long as it’s antivaccine, it’s all good, and every luminary of the antivaccine movement, including most of the crew of Age of Autism will be there, probably Tweeting and blogging away. Heck, Jenny McCarthy herself was the keynote speaker in 2009, just as she was in 2008.
Moreover, quackfest that Autism One is, the organizers don’t in the least like skeptics or those who don’t buy into the claim that vaccines cause autism to be there. They don’t like it at all. Indeed, one such skeptical blogger, despite remaining polite but firm in his questions, was expelled last year on a trumped up excuse. Indeed, the irony of the timing, so hot on the heels of Ben Stein’s anti-evolution documentary Expelled!, was not lost on those of us who have corresponded with this particular blogger. This time around, not surprisingly Autism One organizers took measures to prevent skeptics from infiltrating and most especially to prevent anyone not associated with Autism One from videotaping or recording, but what are they going to do if the Trib decides to send reporters?
Be that as it may, I like the chorus of strongly condemning quotes from real scientists studying autism:
Four of the world’s top pediatric endocrinologists told the Tribune that the Lupron protocol is baseless, supported only by junk science. More than two dozen prominent endocrinologists dismissed the treatment earlier this year in a paper published online by the journal Pediatrics.
Simon Baron-Cohen, a professor of developmental psychopathology at the University of Cambridge in England and director of the Autism Research Center in Cambridge, said it is irresponsible to treat autistic children with Lupron.
“The idea of using it with vulnerable children with autism, who do not have a life-threatening disease and pose no danger to anyone, without a careful trial to determine the unwanted side effects or indeed any benefits, fills me with horror,” he said.
Experts in childhood hormones warn that Lupron can disrupt normal development, interfering with natural puberty and potentially putting children’s heart and bones at risk. The treatment also means subjecting children to daily injections, including painful shots deep into muscle every other week.
And:
Specialists in autism, hormones and pharmacology who are familiar with the Geiers’ protocol said it cannot work as they suggest.
“In terms of science, there is nothing suggesting the most basic elements of what they are talking about,” said Tom Owley, director of the Neurodevelopmental Pharmacology Clinic at the University of Illinois at Chicago and a specialist in the treatment of autistic children with medicine. “That there are high levels of mercury in autism — not proven! That they have precocious puberty — not proven!”
I shared Dr. Baron-Cohen’s horror three years ago. So did Kathleen Seidel. So did a number of other bloggers. I didn’t really know, though, just how much money this protocol sucks out of desperate and gullible parents. I knew Lupron is an expensive drug and that insurance won’t pay for it for autism. That’s exactly why, as Kathleen put it, the Geiers found a way to label virtually every child they used the drug on as having “precocious puberty,” even though by definition any girl older than 8 or boy older than 9 cannot have precocious puberty. That doesn’t stop the Geiers from this:
To treat an autistic child, the Geiers order $12,000 in lab tests, more than 50 in all. Some measure hormone levels. If at least one testosterone-related level falls outside the lab’s reference range, the Geiers consider beginning injections of Lupron. The daily dose is 10 times the amount American doctors use to treat precocious puberty.
By lowering testosterone, the Geiers said, the drug eliminates unwanted testosterone-related behaviors, such as aggression and masturbation. They recommend starting kids on Lupron as young as possible and say some may need the drug through the age of puberty and into adulthood.
The cost of the Lupron therapy is $5,000 to $6,000 a month, which health plans cover, Mark Geier said. However, two families told the Tribune that they had trouble getting insurance to pay for the treatment.
This is big bucks. Seriously big bucks. It’s also possibly insurance fraud, because the Geiers claim precocious puberty but in fact are using Lupron to treat autism. Indeed, the way the Geiers do their testing is all but guaranteed to produce in most children the “desired” diagnosis. The reason has to do with multiple lab values. The “normal” range of lab values, by definition, is designed so that 95% of “normal” patients will fall within that range. That means, for any “normal” child and any single given laboratory test, there is by random chance alone a 5% chance that his or her lab value will fall outside the “normal” range. 5% of 50 tests would mean that the average child would be likely to have 2.5 (or, given that these are whole numbers) between 2-3 lab values that fall outside the normal range. And–presto!–that will mean that they have “precocious puberty” and need the Geiers’ Lupron protocol. It’s all bogus (word choice intentional)
In fact, it’s so bad that the antivaccine propaganda blog Age of Autism actually–to my shock!–allowed a post that was critical of the Lupron protocol:
It is of great concern that studies on testosterone and autism are being misinterpreted, leading to the use of therapies aimed at disturbing steroid hormone production in individuals with autism. Currently, many autistic children may be being treated, without proof of safety and scientific and medical evidence of benefit, with a view to reducing their hormonal secretion of testosterone (Lupron Therapy, Spironolactone). The rationale behind advocating these therapies appears to be based on a misunderstanding of autistic behaviours and without systematic laboratory evidence of abnormal testosterone levels.
Word to Mark and David Geier: When the antivaccine cranks at Age of Autism starts attacking you (even if they don’t do it by name and they draft an outsider to write the post), your credibility is seriously shot. So how do the Geiers defend themselves against all these scientists criticizing them? You guessed it! A panoply of the usual excuses used by purveyors of pseudoscience:
    • Don’t knock it till you’ve tried it: Mark Geier responded that these are “opinions by people who don’t know what they are talking about,” saying the pediatric endocrinologists interviewed by the Tribune don’t treat autistic children and have not tried the Lupron treatment.
    • Misrepresenting the work of real scientists: David Geier said prominent scientists support their work and gave as an example Baron-Cohen, the autism expert who told the Tribune that the Geiers’ Lupron treatment filled him with horror.
    • Conspiracy theories: The Geiers also say mainstream medicine condemns them because of their vocal stance that pediatricians, health officials and drug companies are covering up the link between vaccines and autism. “Nobody likes a whistle-blower,” Mark Geier said in an interview.
    • The pharma gambit: The Geiers are not dissuaded by the criticism. Mark Geier said the courts are biased against him and that the medical establishment is more concerned about preserving drug companies’ profits than about protecting children. “There’s no question this will turn out to be true,” Mark Geier said in an interview, referring to the vaccine-autism connection.
And, most despicable of all, the Geiers demonize the very autistic teens upon whom they are plying their quackery:
“With masturbating there is a degree of normal, and then there is autism. Parents will say: ‘He will hump pillows, he will hump your leg,’ ” David Geier told doctors at Eisenstein’s office. He made similar statements on the same visit to about 60 parents of autistic children.
In an autistic teenager, high testosterone will lead to dangerous aggression, Mark Geier said, mentioning an autistic Ohio teen accused of killing his mother. “They are incredibly strong. They can hurt you,” he said. “You have to respect that these kids are on massive testosterone.”
Autistic children with high testosterone are heading down an ominous path, the Geiers said, and likely will end up hooked on psychiatric drugs, institutionalized or jailed.
This is nonsense. Even worse, it’s pernicious nonsense. Unfortunately, it’s exactly the same sort of pernicious nonsense they’ve been pushing since four years ago, when they published their “case report” of the autistic child whose inappropriate sexual behavior abated after he was dosed with Lupron.
Of course, the parents of Geiers’ patients are largely self-selected to believe the woo and have a serious incentive, after sinking thousands of dollars into it, to believe it’s working. And they do provide testomonials, a couple of which were included in the Trib story. It wouldn’t even surprise me if some of them are true. If you shut down a child or teen’s testosterone production, they will likely become more docile and have a decreased sex drive. That doesn’t mean the drug is doing anything at all for the teen’s autistic symptoms or to improve their neurocognitive functioning. Indeed, it could be doing great harm to the child. While Lupron may not be too risky for prepubertal children, giving it to teens can “put puberty on hold,” as one scientist put it, calling it “chemical castration”:
Said Kaplowitz: “You can lower sex drive, yes, but are you going to do that for every autistic [teenage] boy, do a medical castration? … For a year? For their lives?”
Neither Eisenstein nor the Geiers dispute that what they are doing amounts to chemical castration.
Speaking about one teen he put on the drug, Mark Geier said: “I wasn’t worried about whether he would have children when he is 25 years old. If you want to call it a nasty name, call it chemical castration. If you want to call it something nice, say you are lowering testosterone.”
Karl Rove would be proud of Dr. Geier.
In a companion article, another aspect of the Lupron protocol is deconstructed:
Abbott Laboratories, which sells Lupron in the U.S., once applied for a patent with the Geiers through a now-defunct joint venture with another drug company, yet never pursued work with them. A spokeswoman for the North Chicago-based company said there was no scientific evidence to justify further research.
When a pharmaceutical company decides it isn’t interested in pursuing a potentially lucrative new indication for one of its drugs, you know you’re deep into pseudoscience. I will say, though, that Abbott Laboratories should be ashamed of itself. Until now, it has been winking and nodding at the use its product is being put to, even though its scientists know there is no scientific justification for it. Of course, the Geiers had already tried to patent their Lupron protocol once, because, of course, they’re doing this all out of the goodness of their hearts.
Not:
The Geiers’ first Lupron patient, a Virginia boy with severe autism who is now 13, started the treatment about four years ago. Since then, the Geiers have opened eight clinics in six states, including one in Springfield and their arrangement with Eisenstein, which he described as a “franchise” of sorts.
“We plan to open everywhere,” Mark Geier said in February at Eisenstein’s office. “I am going to treat as many as I can.”
Some of the Geiers’ clinics are headed by doctors; a psychiatrist runs the Springfield clinic. But that is not always the case. The clinic in Indianapolis is run by an X-ray technologist who has an autistic child.
In Washington state, the head is a health advocate and documentary filmmaker.
I can’t help but ask: How do the Geiers get away with it? These people whom they’ve hired to run their other clinics are not physicians. They are clearly practicing medicine without a license!
WHAT THE TRIBUNE MISSED
There were only two deficiencies in these articles. The first one almost goes without saying in stories of this type. There was too much of the usual “tell both sides” journalistic construction, in which testimonials were given far more weight than they deserved and the Geiers were extensively quoted. I’ve given up expecting anything other than that from journalists. The other deficiency is that there was no mention of how the Geiers played fast and loose with human research protections in order to ply their quackery. There was no report at all of this in the Trib’s article.
What do I mean? In essence, the Geiers formed their own Institutional Review Board (IRB) to review their own studies and thereby get around federal regulations over human subjects research. The IRB is usually reported as being from an entity formed by the Geiers listed as The Institute for Chronic Illnesses. As Kathleen Seidel first reported, it’s an elusive institute whose address is the same as that of Dr. Mark Geier’s home residence. (It also has a lovely tennis court.) But, elusive or not, The Institute for Chronic Illnesses does have its own IRB, and that IRB is actually registered with the federal government. Leave it to Kathleen’s tenacity to track down through a Freedom of Information Act request some information on this particular IRB. What she found is very disturbing indeed.
In order for you to understand why what Kathleen discovered is so disturbing, a word is in order about just what an IRB is and does (or should be and is supposed to do). I’ve written about the international treaties and U.S. law regulating human subjects before, but not in detail about what IRBs are and do. After the horrors of Nazi medical experimentation and the abuses during the Tuskegee syphilis study right here in the good ol’ USA, it was clear that rules were needed to protect human research subjects from such abuses. A historic document in the development of such rules in the U.S. was the Belmont Report on Ethical Principles and Guidelines for the Protection of Human Subjects of Research finalized on April 18, 1979. This report identifies three essential and fundamental ethical principles for human subject research (respect for persons, beneficence, and justice) that form the basis of all Department of Health and Human Services human subject protection regulations to this day. It is essential reading for anyone doing human subject research in this country. In 1991, these regulations were codified into what is now known as The Common Rule. All institutions doing federally funded research are required to adhere to The Common Rule. Moreover, some states, such as Maryland (where the Geiers have their businesses) require that all human research, regardless of funding source, must conform to the Common Rule.
A key aspect of The Common Rule is the IRB. The IRB is in essence a committee that oversees all human subject research for an institution and makes sure that the studies are ethical in design and that they conform to all federal regulations. Basically, IRBs are charged with weighing the risks and benefits of proposed human subject research and making sure that (1) the risks are minimized and that the risk:benefit ratio is very favorable; (2) to minimize any pain or suffering that might come about because of the experimental therapy; and (3) to make sure that researchers obtain truly informed consent. Once a study is in progress, regular reports must be made to the IRB, which can shut down any study in its institution if it has concerns about patient welfare. Indeed, the IRB at my particular institution is like a bulldog; it’s utterly ruthless in how it deals with researchers. The same is the case at most institutions that receive significant federal funding, and these are the criteria for approving a study:
(a) In order to approve research covered by this policy the IRB shall determine that all of the following requirements are satisfied:
(1) Risks to subjects are minimized: (i) By using procedures which are consistent with sound research design and which do not unnecessarily expose subjects to risk, and (ii) whenever appropriate, by using procedures already being performed on the subjects for diagnostic or treatment purposes.
(2) Risks to subjects are reasonable in relation to anticipated benefits, if any, to subjects, and the importance of the knowledge that may reasonably be expected to result. In evaluating risks and benefits, the IRB should consider only those risks and benefits that may result from the research (as distinguished from risks and benefits of therapies subjects would receive even if not participating in the research). The IRB should not consider possible long-range effects of applying knowledge gained in the research (for example, the possible effects of the research on public policy) as among those research risks that fall within the purview of its responsibility.
(3) Selection of subjects is equitable. In making this assessment the IRB should take into account the purposes of the research and the setting in which the research will be conducted and should be particularly cognizant of the special problems of research involving vulnerable populations, such as children, prisoners, pregnant women, mentally disabled persons, or economically or educationally disadvantaged persons.
(4) Informed consent will be sought from each prospective subject or the subject’s legally authorized representative, in accordance with, and to the extent required by 46.116.
(5) Informed consent will be appropriately documented, in accordance with, and to the extent required by 46.117.
(6) When appropriate, the research plan makes adequate provision for monitoring the data collected to ensure the safety of subjects.
(7) When appropriate, there are adequate provisions to protect the privacy of subjects and to maintain the confidentiality of data.
(b) When some or all of the subjects are likely to be vulnerable to coercion or undue influence, such as children, prisoners, pregnant women, mentally disabled persons, or economically or educationally disadvantaged persons, additional safeguards have been included in the study to protect the rights and welfare of these subjects.
It sounds pretty clear-cut. And, from discussing studies with members of different IRBs, I know that good IRBs take the above guidelines very seriously, almost always erring on the side of being more protective of human subjects. (If you’re interested in learning more about federal human subject research guidelines, check out this course.) Now here’s where it gets even more interesting. The membership of an IRB must be at least five persons according to these guidelines:
a) Each IRB shall have at least five members, with varying backgrounds to promote complete and adequate review of research activities commonly conducted by the institution. The IRB shall be sufficiently qualified through the experience and expertise of its members, and the diversity of the members, including consideration of race, gender, and cultural backgrounds and sensitivity to such issues as community attitudes, to promote respect for its advice and counsel in safeguarding the rights and welfare of human subjects. In addition to possessing the professional competence necessary to review specific research activities, the IRB shall be able to ascertain the acceptability of proposed research in terms of institutional commitments and regulations, applicable law, and standards of professional conduct and practice. The IRB shall therefore include persons knowledgeable in these areas. If an IRB regularly reviews research that involves a vulnerable category of subjects, such as children, prisoners, pregnant women, or handicapped or mentally disabled persons, consideration shall be given to the inclusion of one or more individuals who are knowledgeable about and experienced in working with these subjects.
(b) Every nondiscriminatory effort will be made to ensure that no IRB consists entirely of men or entirely of women, including the institution’s consideration of qualified persons of both sexes, so long as no selection is made to the IRB on the basis of gender. No IRB may consist entirely of members of one profession.
(c) Each IRB shall include at least one member whose primary concerns are in scientific areas and at least one member whose primary concerns are in nonscientific areas.
Well, guess who was on the IRB of the Institute for Chronic Illnesses at the time of their seminal “studies” on testosterone and autism (and, as far as I know, are still on the ICI IRB)? If you’ve clicked on the link to Kathleen’s article you already know, but for those who haven’t done so yet (or who don’t believe in clicking on links), now’s a good time to do so:
Mark Geier, Chair
Affiliated Scientist; MD, PhD; Genetics
David Geier
Affiliated Scientist; BA; Biochemistry
Lisa Sykes
Unaffiliated Non-Scientist; MA; Clergy (Rev. Sykes is a Richmond, Virginia Methodist minister, anti-thimerosal activist, and mother of a participant in Dr. Geier’s study. The clinical data for Patient #1 in the Hormone Research article is identical to data from her son’s medical records, which were displayed at the 2005 and 2006 Autism One conferences.)
Kelly Kerns
Unaffiliated Scientist; RDH; Dentistry (Mrs. Kerns is a Lenexa, Kansas dental hygienist, anti-thimerosal activist, and petitioner in vaccine injury complaints for each of her three autistic children.)
John Young
Unaffiliated Scientist; MD; OB-GYN, Genetics (Dr. Young is Dr. Geier’s business partner in Genetic Consultants of Maryland and Genetic Consultants of Virginia; he, Dr. Geier and various business entities were codefendants in a 1994 medical malpractice lawsuit.)
Anne Geier
Affiliated Scientist; BS; Educator (Mrs. Geier is wife of Dr. Mark Geier and mother of David Geier. She is a ranking member of the U.S. Tennis Association.)
Clifford Shoemaker
Affiliated Non-Scientist; JD; Legal (Mr. Shoemaker is a vaccine injury lawyer, a member of the Vaccine Injury Alliance, and a member of the Omnibus Autism Proceeding Petitioners’ Steering Committee. Dr. Geier has testified on behalf of his clients in Price v. Wyeth et al, Platt v. HHS, Jenkins v. HHS, Lewis v. HHS, Raj vs. HHS, Jefferies v. HHS, and other cases.)
Notice how conveniently every single member of this IRB was either one of the Geiers, an anti-thimerosal activist, a Geier associate, or a lawyer suing on behalf of “vaccine-injured” clients. Anyone want to make a bet about how closely they adhere to the guidelines for human research listed above? It almost doesn’t matter anyway because, as Kathleen pointed out, besides the fact that none of the members of this IRB has any expertise in endocrinology, Mark and David Geier would not be eligible to debate or vote on their own protocols anyway; having them on the IRB is utterly unethical and almost certainly illegal. Ditto Anne Geier, who wouldn’t be eligible to vote because of her relationship to Mark and David, and Lisa Sykes, who wouldn’t be eligible to vote if her child is to be a subject in the research protocol being reviewed. And does anyone really think that any of the other members of this particular IRB has research subject protection as his or her overriding concern?
But it didn’t end there. If the FOIA information that Kathleen has obtained is complete, then it looks as though the research reported under the auspices of this IRB was done before the IRB of The Institute for Chronic Illnesses was even registered with the federal government. It is hard not to strongly suspect that the Geiers were told by someone while submitting their paper that human subjects research had to be approved by an IRB and that no reputable journal would publish such research without a statement to the effect that the research encompassed in the manuscript had been approved by an IRB.
CONCLUSION
After having watched with frustration for over three years how the Geiers have managed not only to continue to subject autistic children to, in essence, chemical castration and have large numbers of parents sufficiently desperate or sufficiently believing in “alternative” medicine that they are willing to pay the Geiers big bucks to submit their children to their “protocol,” I am gratified that the Chicago Tribune did this investigation and wrote this study. True, the reporters didn’t uncover the chicanery the Geiers have been demonstrating for years with the dubious IRB, and I can’t help but be a bit disturbed at this because, as a clinical researcher, I try very hard to hew to the rules and law governing human subjects research and conduct such research ethically.
The Geiers’ saga, in fact, demonstrates a number of things. First, there is the utter lack of medical ethics that would allow them to inject autistic children with a powerful anti-androgen and anti-estrogen drug based on a concept as easy to demonstrate to be without scientific foundation as mercury being bound up in “testosterone sheets.” But more importantly, there is the issue of how on earth our laws and regulations could be so lax that the Geiers could get around them by creating a dubious “Institute,” creating an equally dubious IRB, and then stacking that IRB with true believers and cronies, among them the principal investigator of all of the Geiers’ “studies,” Dr. Mark Geier himself.
The price of antivaccine lunacy is steep and getting steeper. In addition to decreasing herd immunity and endangering those who do not subscribe to their toxic mix of paranoid conspiracy theories and pseudoscience, antivaccine zealots like the Geiers have managed to make a mockery of our system of human subjects protection. Above, all, however, autistic children pay the price for the current antivaccine madness sweeping through our country.
I just hope that the media will increasingly notice. Shining the light of day on this quackery and egregious flouting of human subjects protections is the only chance these children have to be spared from such atrocities.

David Geier, Mail Order Pharmacist
David Geier was in the drug business. What was he selling before the FDA stepped in?
Kathleen Seidel on May 10, 2025
Link
David Geier, cosplaying a scientist.
It is well known by now that HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. has appointed his long-time associate David A. Geier to conduct a study of a possible association between autism and vaccines.
It is well known that David Geier and his father, the late Mark Geier, are “researchers” who claim to have found a causal association between vaccines and autism, and that their work has been widely criticized within the scientific community.
It is also well known that in 2011, the Maryland Board of Physicians summarily suspended Mark Geier’s license to practice medicine and charged David Geier with the unlicensed practice of medicine.
“Egregiously violated basic medical standards”
These charges arose from their promotion of Lupron in combination with chelation drugs as an autism “treatment,” which relied on the hypotheses that autism is a form of mercury poisoning, and that testosterone binds to mercury, thereby making it more difficult to remove. During its investigation, the Board found that Mark Geier
egregiously violated basic medical standards in his treatment of these patients by not evaluating them properly, lying about which drug he was prescribing, and failing to evaluate in any realistic medical way whether his intensive and very expensive treatment was effective.
Additionally, the Board found that Mark Geier
…had parents sign a consent form that falsely implied that he was conducting an experimental protocol approved by an Institutional Review Board when in fact that review board was […] a facade covering the intentions of a group that did not believe that they were bound by federal or state law and had no intention of being so bound.
In due course, Mark Geier’s license to practice was permanently revoked, a decision affirmed by Maryland’s highest court.
“Misleading, evasive and implausible”
A separate investigation found that rather than serving in solely an administrative capacity at his father’s practice, as he had claimed, David Geier diagnosed at least one child, evaluated a parent questionnaire about that child, and selected and ordered laboratory tests for that child, all without Mark Geier’s supervision. The Board found that “David Geier’s testimony was not reliable, and […] he was not a credible witness”; the Board further characterized his and his father’s testimony as “misleading, evasive and implausible,” and stated that they “contradicted each other and the documentary evidence. Often times, their testimony was self-contradictory.” David Geier was subsequently sanctioned and fined $10,000, a decision that was also affirmed upon appeal.
Partner in crime
Additionally in 2013, the license of Mark Geier’s practice partner, Dr. John Ling Young, was summarily suspended following the discovery by the Maryland Board of Physicians that shortly after the suspension of Mark Geier’s license, Dr. Young obtained a permit allowing him to dispense drugs directly to patients, then began to
[write] prescriptions for Lupron and leuprolide for patients of Mark Geier whom he himself had never examined or even met; that he doubled and even tripled patients’ dosages without reviewing their medical records or documenting his rationale for doing so; that one Prior Authorization he submitted cited to diagnoses of ‘central precocious puberty’ and ‘pituitary dysfunction’ that were not supported by the patient’s medical records; that his notes indicated that he would ‘check with David’ before prescribing leuprolide to another patient; and that when questioned about his reasons for increasing Dr. Geier’s patients’ dosages of Lupron after Dr. Geier’s license to practice was summarily suspended, he replied that he ‘was probably just following Dr. Geier’s recommendation.’
Dr. Young’s sole reliance on Mark Geier and his need to “check with David” for guidance in the administration of Lupron to autistic children is particularly concerning. Mark Geier had no training in endocrinology, and no experience in the diagnosis, care or treatment of either autistic children or mercury poisoned patients prior to his involvement in thimerosal litigation, and David Geier’s credentials to offer medical advice were only aspirational—a fact of which Dr. Young, who had known his business partner’s son since infancy, must certainly have been aware.
It is also concerning given the fact that in spite of his apparent inability to make independent decisions about the care of his young patients, in 2006 Dr. Young had advertised that he administered “Lupron injections” to autistic children at his practice. Dr. Young eventually persuaded the Maryland Board of Physicians to allow him to continue practicing in the field of obstetrics and genetic counseling.
Fresh start in the Sunshine State
Little has been written about Mark and David Geier’s activities since their move to Jupiter, Florida in late 2011. The Florida Board of Health had suspended Mark Geier’s license to practice medicine in October 2011 and permanently revoked it in August 2012. This attention from the Florida Board notwithstanding, Mark Geier began to engage in the unlicensed practice of pharmacy almost immediately upon his relocation to the state in December 2011.
According to a complaint issued by the Board in May 2013, on four different occasions between December 30, 2011 and February 2, 2012, Mark Geier compounded lots of leuprolide acetate powder at Prescription Depot, a “community pharmacy,” then dispensed it to 39 patients of three doctors identified only by their initials—initials that happen to correspond to the names of doctors associated with his businesses Genetic Consultants of America and ASD Centers LLC:
Prescription Depot Storefront, Tamarac, Florida 
Google, “Streetview,” digital images, Google Maps (http://maps.google.com),
photograph of 8225 N Pine Island Rd, Tamarac, FL 33321, taken December 2024.
    • J.Y. corresponds to obstetrician John L. Young, of Genetic Consultants of Maryland, Rockville, Maryland; “J.Y.” was responsible for 28 prescriptions;
    • D.C. corresponds to radiologist David A. Clayman, Tamarac, Florida, of ASD Centers LLC in Tamarac, Florida; “D.C.” was responsible for 11 prescriptions; and
    • G.D. corresponds to psychiatrist Georgia Davis, director of ASD Centers LLC in Springfield, Illinois; “G.D.” was responsible for five prescriptions.
A final order in the case was issued in May 2015, with Mark Geier essentially pleading no contest to the allegations. He was reprimanded, fined $1,500, required to reimburse DOH for the cost of the investigation, required to take an ethics course, and barred from applying for a medical license without first undergoing a professional evaluation.
Setting up shop
Former location of DAP Pharmaceuticals, LLC 
Google, “Streetview,” digital images, Google Maps (http://maps.google.com),
photograph of 1408 N Killian Drive, Ste. 210, Lake Park, Florida, 33403, 
taken January 2024
On October 18, 2011—the same month that Mark Geier’s license to practice medicine in Florida was suspended, and shortly before his family’s move to that state—David Geier established a Florida firm called DAP Pharmaceuticals, LLC (FEI #3010166882). In the articles of organization, the firm’s address was identified as 1408 N Killian Drive, Ste. 210, Lake Park, Florida, 33403; its registered agent was identified as Patrick E. Riley of Palm Beach Gardens, and its manager was identified as David A. Geier of Jupiter, Florida. Florida Board of Pharmacy records indicate that neither Patrick Riley nor David Geier hold a license to practice pharmacy in that state.
Import records indicate that on August 7, 2014, two capsule filling machines addressed to Kartzinel Wellness Center—the Jackson, Tennessee practice of Dr. Jerry Kartzinel, who testified in support of Mark Geier at his Maryland license revocation hearing—were delivered from China to David Geier’s Jupiter, Florida address.
Chinese capsule filler with a gross weight of 625kg

Also in 2014, David Geier filed a FOIA with FDA for applications and correspondence about the approval, safety and effectiveness of cyproterone acetate—i.e., Androcur, a testosterone suppressant often prescribed by Mark Geier as part of the “Lupron protocol” that is not FDA approved for sale in the United States. Cyproterone acetate is available in powder form.
FDA Inspection: “Official Action Indicated”
On September 9 and 10, 2019, FDA investigators Vivin George and Jennifer L. Huntington conducted an inspection of DAP Pharmaceuticals LLC’s Lake Park, Florida facility. FDA’s 483 Inspectional Observations report was issued on September 11, 2019. The establishment was characterized as an API repackager, that is, a firm that repackages active pharmaceutical ingredient for dispensing. The report redacted the name of the API, recommended storage conditions and lot numbers. The report lists eight different categories of failure to establish adequate practices and procedures to ensure operational safety.
    • OBSERVATION 1
Failure of your quality unit to ensure that there is stability data to support retest or expiry dates and storage conditions of the API.
Specifically, your firm has failed to perform stability testing to justify the use of the manufacturer’s expiration date for your repackaged (redacted), which is maintained at room temperature. The manufacturer’s expiration/retest dating is based on a storage condition of (redacted).
    • OBSERVATION 2
Failure to test the identity of each batch of incoming production material or appropriately qualify suppliers to rely upon their Certificate of Analysis.
Specifically, your firm has failed to perform at least one test to ensure the identity of the API prior to release for repackaging. In addition, your firm failed to qualify the supplier of (redacted), Lot (redacted), used in the repackaging of (redacted), Lot (redacted).
    • OBSERVATION 3
Failure to prepare and use production and control records for each API batch.
Specifically, your firm has failed to establish master packaging records and labeling used for the repackaging of (redacted). In addition, your firm does not prepare a batch record containing a representative label for each lot of repackaged (redacted).
    • OBSERVATION 4
Failure to establish written procedures describing the receipt, specifications, examination, and release of packaging and labeling materials.
Specifically, your firm has failed to establish procedures describing the receipt, specifications, examination, and release of packaging materials used for the repackaging of (redacted). In addition, your firm has failed to establish written procedures for the examination and release of labeling produced for repacked (redacted).
    • OBSERVATION 5
Failure to provide the manufacturer’s Certificate of Analysis with shipments of repackaged API to your customer.
Specifically, your firm has failed to provide customers a copy of the manufacturer’s Certificate of Analysis (COA) with shipments of (redacted).
    • OBSERVATION 6
Failure to have a quality unit that is independent of production and fulfills quality assurance (QA) and quality control (QC) duties.
For example, the same employees that perform repackaging activities also released batches for distribution. For example, (redacted) was repacked and released for distribution by the same employee. This was observed a minimum of 12 additional times from 01/14/14 to 09/30/15.
    • OBSERVATION 7
Failure to establish a procedure for the training of employees and to ensure training is regularly conducted by qualified individuals and covers, at a minimum, the particular operations that each employee performs and cGMP as they relate to the employee’s functions.
Specifically, your firm has failed to ensure employees are routinely provided training on cGMP and procedures required to perform their duties.
    • OBSERVATION 8
Failure to ensure that your cleaning and sanitization methods for equipment used in the repackaging of API are effective.
Specifically, your firm has failed to provide sufficient evidence that the cleaning and sanitization procedures used to clean dedicated equipment used for the repackaging of (redacted), are effective at eliminating microbial contamination and removes residual cleaning agents.
The DAP Pharmaceuticals inspection was classified as OAI, “Official Action Indicated”—the highest level of noncompliance.
Like father, like son
In its order revoking Mark Geier’s license to practice medicine, the Maryland Board of Physicians found that
Dr. Geier failed to meet basic medical standards for evaluating patients and conducting medical examinations and keeping adequate records of treatments and diagnoses. He failed to conduct an adequate initial evaluation of any of these patients and failed to make an adequate record of an examination for any of these patients. He began treatment often without sufficient information about the patients’ physical condition. In many cases, [Dr. Geier] had no information at all about the Patients’ physical conditions.
The Final Decision and Order in the disciplinary proceeding against David Geier affirmed the pervasive lack of documentation and rigor at Mark Geier’s medical practice:
Genetic Consultants had no approved policies and procedures (and certainly none that were written) for the ordering of laboratory testing by unlicensed individuals. No such policies and procedures are in the record. And the lack of policies and procedures at Genetic Consultants was further established by David Geier’s testimony in the instant case in his response to a question about the seemingly random nature of the initialing and signing of documents at the clinic: ‘It’s a reflection of the way that it just happened. I mean, the answer is that thousands of patients, thousands of charts we’re talking about, there are just times when things happen. I mean, we don’t have a formal protocol in place in the office that says you will do it this way or that way. It’s simply what happened in the course of patient care.’
Taken together, David Geier’s own words, and the DAP Pharmaceuticals 483, reinforce the impression that Mark Geier’s well-documented habits of lax record-keeping, failure to establish internal protocols and procedures and contempt for professional regulation have been passed on from father to son.
DAP Pharmaceuticals LLC was voluntarily dissolved eighteen months after the inspection, on March 2, 2021.
Nonexistent qualifications
This chain of incidents gives rise to numerous concerns, and numerous questions that remain open due to legally mandated redactions in the 483.
David Geier’s qualifications for operating any sort of pharmacy are nonexistent. According to the Maryland Board of Physicians’ charges against him,
[He] never has been licensed to practice medicine or any other health occupation in the state of Maryland or any other State. [He] has a Bachelor’s of Art degree in biology from a Maryland State university. [He] has taken several graduate courses, but has not earned a graduate degree in any specialty or discipline (emphasis added).
His responsibilities in his role as President of DAP Pharmaceuticals, Patrick Riley’s responsibilities and qualifications for managing a pharmaceutical repackager, and the identity, responsibilities and qualifications of any other individuals who might have been employed by DAP Pharmaceuticals remain open questions.
Signs point to yes
Whether Mark Geier was directly involved in DAP Pharmaceuticals’ operations is a question that is likely correctly answered in the affirmative. Both the Florida Department of Health’s finding that he had compounded leuprolide on multiple occasions then dispensed it to numerous patients, and the Maryland Board of Physicians’ finding that Dr. John Young had enabled Mark Geier to continue practicing medicine following the suspension of his license, demonstrate that Mark Geier was determined to continue his pharmaceutical experimentation on the endocrine systems of disabled children in spite of any efforts by professional regulators to stop him, and in spite of criticism of his treatment hypotheses by pediatric endocrinologists, who he asserted “don’t know what they are talking about.”
The fact that the time period during which John Young was found to have written prescriptions to Mark Geier’s former patients corresponds to the time period during which Mark Geier was found to have compounded leuprolide acetate and shipped it to “J.Y.” suggests that the prescriptions written by “J.Y.” were intended for patients of Mark Geier, who he was continuing to treat via his business partner.
Whether DAP Pharmaceuticals ever shipped drugs direct to consumer, or to unlicensed individuals affiliated with ASD Centers, LLC, remain open questions, as does the ultimate destination and intended use of the capsule filling machines addressed to Dr. Jerry Kartzinel at David Geier’s home address.
DAP? TAP?
The similarity of the business name “DAP Pharmaceuticals” to TAP Pharmaceuticals, the now-defunct inventor of Lupron, is another point of interest. In September 2005, TAP and the Geiers jointly submitted an application to patent the “Lupron protocol” that included the fallacious assertion that “mercuric chloride binds and forms a complex with testosterone in subjects,” thereby making mercury more difficult to remove. A revised application submitted in October 2007 omitted this falsehood, and focused instead on the goals of reducing mercury and testosterone levels in autistic children.
However, in a 2008 affidavit filed in the case Sykes v. Bayer, Mark Geier stated that he “was working with the manufacturer of Lupron to set up tests to further evaluate the clinical benefits of Lupron therapy to patients with autistic disorders,” but that publicity surrounding his work “has apparently significantly impacted my relationship with the Lupron manufacturer.” In 2009, a spokesperson for Abbott Laboratories, which took over distribution of Lupron after TAP ceased operations, stated that “there was no scientific evidence to justify further research.”
Just what was that API and who was it aimed at?
Although the identity and source of the API or APIs repackaged by DAP remain unknown, Mark and David Geier’s patents and reports on the pharmaceutical treatment of autistic children primarily discuss drugs that suppress testosterone, with specific focus on Lupron and Androcur. The 483 report implies that a single API was handled by DAP at the time of the inspection. The investigators’ observation that the API was improperly stored at room temperature implies that it was supposed to be refrigerated. If the API was leuprolide acetate, it should have been stored at -20 ± 5°C (-4 ± 41°F). Storing an API at an inappropriate temperature—especially one hotter than recommended—creates significant potential for contamination and degradation; this is a matter of particular concern given the likelihood that the drugs dispensed by DAP were prescribed for administration to autistic children, who are entitled to special protections in research both by virtue of their youth, and by virtue of their disability.
Radical transparency?
Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. called for a new era of “radical transparency” upon his confirmation as Secretary of HHS. If David Geier failed to disclose his sanction by the Maryland Board of Physicians for the unlicensed practice of medicine, or his creation of DAP Pharmaceuticals LLC in whatever CV he might have submitted to HHS prior to being hired by Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. to lead a federally-sponsored investigation into possible associations between vaccines and autism, it would seem imperative to determine why. And if Secretary Kennedy is aware of David Geier’s sanction, of his involvement with DAP Pharmaceuticals, and of the damning inspection that preceded its dissolution, it would seem imperative to elicit why he would conclude that it just doesn’t matter.
Many thanks to Elizabeth Woeckner of CIRCARE for her help preparing this report.
SOURCES
Maryland State Board of Physicians
Maryland Board of Physicians (March 22, 2012). Final decision and order. In the Matter of Mark R. Geier, M.D., License No. D24250. Case Nos. 2007-0803, 2008-0454, 2009-0308, https://www.mbp.state.md.us/bpqapp/Orders/D2425003.222.pdf.
Maryland State Board of Physicians (August 22, 2012). Final decision and order. In the matter of Mark R. Geier, M.D. (License No. D24250). Case Nos. 2007-0803, 2008-0454, 2009-0308, p. 7, https://www.mbp.state.md.us/BPQAPP/orders/d2425008.222.pdf.
Maryland State Board of Physicians (May 16, 2011). Charges under the Maryland Medical Practice Act. In the matter of David A. Geier (unlicensed). Case Numbers 2008-0022 and 2009-0318, https://www.mbp.state.md.us/BPQAPP/orders/GeierCharge05162011.pdf.
Maryland State Board of Physicians (July 30, 2012). Final decision and order. In the matter of David A. Geier (unlicensed). Case Numbers 2008-0022 and 2009-0318, https://www.mbp.state.md.us/BPQAPP/orders/GeierOrder07.302.pdf.
Maryland State Board of Physicians (February 13, 2013). Order for summary suspension of license to practice medicine. In the matter of John L. Young, M.D. (License No. D23121). Case No. 2012-0497, https://www.mbp.state.md.us/BPQAPP/orders/d2312102.133.pdf.
Maryland State Board of Physicians (September 26, 2014). Final decision and order. In the matter of John L. Young, M.D. (License No. D23121). Case No. 2012-0497, https://www.mbp.state.md.us/bpqapp/Orders/D2312109.264.pdf.
Court of Special Appeals of Maryland
Court of Special Appeals of Maryland (May 29, 2015). Opinion. Mark R. Geier v. Maryland Board of Physicians. No. 1095, Sept. Term, 2014, https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/md-court-of-special-appeals/1702533.html.
Court of Special Appeals of Maryland (July 31, 2015). Opinion. David A. Geier v. Maryland Board of Physicians. No. 0709, September Term 2014, https://www.courts.state.md.us/sites/default/files/unreported-opinions/0709s14.pdf.
Florida Board of Medicine
Florida Board of Medicine (October 17, 2011). Administrative complaint. Department of Health v. Mark Robin Geier. Case 2011-07673. License No. ME0103406, https://mqa-internet.doh.state.fl.us/MQASearchServices/HealthCareProviders/LicenseVerification?LicInd=101411&ProCde=1501.
Florida Board of Medicine (April 12, 2012). Settlement agreement. Department of Health v. Mark Robin Geier. Case 2011-07673. License No. ME0103406, https://mqa-internet.doh.state.fl.us/MQASearchServices/HealthCareProviders/LicenseVerification?LicInd=101411&ProCde=1501.
Florida Board of Medicine (August 17, 2012). Final order. Department of Health v. Mark Robin Geier. Case 2011-07673. License No. ME0103406, https://mqa-internet.doh.state.fl.us/MQASearchServices/HealthCareProviders/LicenseVerification?LicInd=101411&ProCde=1501.
Florida Board of Medicine (May 24, 2013). Administrative complaint. Department of Health v. Mark Robin Geier. Case no. 2012-04248. License ME0103406, https://mqa-internet.doh.state.fl.us/MQASearchServices/HealthCareProviders/LicenseVerification?LicInd=101411&ProCde=1501.
Florida Board of Medicine (February 18, 2015). Settlement agreement. Department of Health v. Mark Robin Geier. Case no. 2012-04248. License ME0103406, https://mqa-internet.doh.state.fl.us/MQASearchServices/HealthCareProviders/LicenseVerification?LicInd=101411&ProCde=1501.
Florida Board of Medicine (May 1, 2015). Final order. Department of Health v. Mark Robin Geier. Case no. 2012-04248. License ME0103406, https://mqa-internet.doh.state.fl.us/MQASearchServices/HealthCareProviders/LicenseVerification?LicInd=101411&ProCde=1501.
Florida Division of Corporations
Florida Division of Corporations (accessed April 23, 2025). ASD Centers LLC: Application by foreign Limited Liability Company for authorization to transact business in Florida, https://search.sunbiz.org/Inquiry/CorporationSearch/ConvertTiffToPDF?storagePath=COR%5C2010%5C1119%5C87685971.Tif&documentNumber=M10000005067
Florida Division of Corporations (accessed April 23, 2025). DAP Pharmaceuticals, LLC. https://search.sunbiz.org/Inquiry/corporationsearch/SearchResultDetail?inquirytype=EntityName&directionType=Initial&searchNameOrder=DAPPHARMACEUTICALS%20L110001186750&aggregateId=flal-l11000118675-647e2ed6-6d23-4d51-a3dc-8570c863008e&searchTerm=DAPPETITE%20LLC&listNameOrder=DAPPETITE%20L180000418260.
U.S. Food and Drug Administration
U.S. Food and Drug Administration (September 2024). Closed FDA FOIA log, September 2024, https://www.fda.gov/media/182385/download.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Food and Drug Administration (August 19, 2019). Form FDA 483: Inspectional Observations: DAP Pharmaceuticals, https://www.neurodiversity.net/court/FDA%202019%20-%20DAP%20Pharma%20483%20(FOIA%202025-3642)%20(OCR).pdf.
U.S. Food and Drug Administration (accessed May 6, 2025). Firm Profile: DAP Pharmaceuticals, LLC (FEI Number 3010166882), https://datadashboard.fda.gov/ora/firmprofile.htm?FEIi=3010166882&/identity/3010166882.
World Intellectual Property Organization
TAP Pharmaceutical Products, Inc., Mark R. Geier and David A. Geier (September 13, 2005). WO2006033907: Methods of treating disorders having a component of mercury toxicity. Publication Number WO/2006/033907. World Intellectual Property Organization, https://patentscope.wipo.int/search/en/detail.jsf?docId=WO2006033907&_cid=P22-M91NXS-58917-1.
TAP Pharmaceutical Products, Inc., Mark R. Geier and David A. Geier (October 29,2007). WO2008055112: Methods of treating autism and autism spectrum disorders. Publication Number WO/2008/055112, https://patentscope.wipo.int/search/en/detail.jsf?docId=WO2008055112&_cid=P22-M91NXS-58917-1.

Big Trouble in Little Pharma
The Excruciating Inspection of David Geier’s DAP Pharmaceuticals
Kathleen Seidel on July 1, 2025
Link
In a previous post on Science-Based Medicine, I described the Florida Department of Health‘s sanction of Mark Geier for the unlicensed practice of pharmacy, David Geier’s establishment of DAP Pharmaceuticals LLC, and the 2019 inspection of DAP by the FDA—events that occurred after Mark Geier’s license to practice medicine was suspended by the Maryland Board of Physicians, and after David Geier was charged with the unlicensed practice of medicine. At the time I wrote my post, many questions were left unanswered, since all I had to go on was the FDA’s 483 report, which cited only general categories of concern followed by a brief description of the investigators’ findings.
I have since obtained the long-form Establishment Inspection Report (EIR) from FDA’s first and only visit to DAP between its formation in 2011 and its dissolution in 2021. The EIR provides a complete account of the inspection, inspectors’ interactions with management, and the real-time responses of its Manager, Patrick E. Riley of West Palm Beach, Florida, and its President, David A. Geier of Jupiter, Florida. DAP’s written response, prepared with the assistance of a compliance consultant, describes the actions taken by Mr. Riley and Mr. Geier to cure the deficiencies noted in the 483 report. The significance of these documents is enhanced by Mr. Geier’s recent appointment by HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. to lead a study of possible associations between vaccines and autism.
Filling In the Blanks
The EIR describes an unannounced “surveillance inspection of a non-sterile, prescription active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) repacker.” According to statute, “repacking” is “taking a finished drug product or unfinished drug from the container in which it was placed in commercial distribution and placing it into a different container without manipulating, changing, or affecting the composition or formulation of the drug.” According to the EIR, the only API handled by DAP Pharmaceuticals was leuprolide acetate; as a repacker, DAP presumably measured out powdered leuprolide acetate into smaller containers for distribution to customers.
Since we are told that DAP handled only leuprolide acetate, and since further references to the API are redacted, I have assumed that redacted entries referring to the API refer to leuprolide acetate. Given that leuprolide is an injected drug, I have assumed that redacted entries referring to method of administration refer to injection. And given that manufacturers of leuprolide acetate salts recommend that it be stored at -10 to -25°C, I have assumed that redacted references to proper storage temperature refer to that range.
A Knock and a Phone Call
Former location of DAP Pharmaceuticals,
LLC. Google “Streetview” photograph of
1408 N Killian Drive, Ste. 210, Lake
Park,Florida, 33403, taken January 2024.
The report begins with the arrival of FDA investigators Jennifer Huntington and Vivin George at the DAP’s Lake Park, Florida facility. Although the office was closed, a sign on the door identified the owner and manager as Patrick E. Riley. After the investigators called the contact number provided, Mr. Riley arrived in short order and ushered them into DAP’s offices. DAP did not keep standard business hours.
Mr. Riley told the investigators that DAP was established in 2013 and began operations in 2014. He identified the owners of DAP as David Geier, Mark Geier, and himself, and stated that each were one-third owner of the firm. Mr. Riley was present throughout the inspection, whereas David Geier only appeared via teleconference, and Mark Geier not at all.
A Singular Product & Customer
Mr. Riley claimed that DAP only served a wholesale market and did not distribute leuprolide acetate out of the state of Florida; they were therefore exempt from regulations pertaining to interstate commerce. Throughout the report, investigators refer to “customer” in the singular, implying that the firm had only one customer who was a resident of Florida. (The customer was not identified.) Records provided to the investigators indicated that the most recent batch of leuprolide had been produced and distributed in September 2016, three years prior to the inspection.
The report noted that “the intended use for this API was to produce a sterile [redacted].” The ±40-character redaction is long enough to encompass the phrase “solution for injection by syringe,” the customary means of administering prepared leuprolide acetate. Presumably, DAP’s singular customer was a compounding pharmacist, because only a compounding pharmacist would be trained and legally authorized to convert leuprolide API, a powder, into a sterile solution for injection.
The Silent Partner
According to the report, “Mr. Riley stated that he and Mr. David Geier held equal responsibilities in the day-to-day operations of the firm,” and that “both could receive and release API and repackage and release [leuprolide acetate] for distribution.” Although Mark Geier was identified as one-third owner, Mr. Riley stated that he was not actively involved in the day-to-day activities of the firm.”
Although Mr. Riley informed the investigators that DAP was established in 2013, the firm was actually registered with the Florida Division of Corporations (FDOC) in 2011, with Patrick Riley designated as Registered Agent and David Geier as Owner/Manager. The name of the third owner, Mark Geier, appears nowhere on the registration or any of DAP’s subsequent FDOC filings.
Certificate of Slack Manufacturing Practice
Mr. Riley produced certificates of completion in cGMP training for both himself and David Geier but admitted that neither had received any additional training since December 2012. (Online cGMP courses can be had for as little as $200, and take less than a day to complete.) DAP maintained no documentation of training on the firm’s procedures. Although they had prepared a few Standard Operating Procedures, Mr. Riley confirmed that both he and David Geier were out of compliance with their own Quality Control Unit Responsibilities due to their failure to participate in further cGMP and SOP training. They also failed to document changes in product labeling.
DAP’s records comported with Mr. Riley’s assertion that the firm had not distributed repackaged leuprolide since 2016. Mr. Riley stated that he was not sure whether DAP would continue to engage in that business since there was unspecified “difficulty with the finished product.” There is no further explanation of the nature of those difficulties, or whether “difficult” production batches were destroyed or distributed to their singular Florida customer.
Failure & Ignorance
In their investigation of DAP’s quality control systems, investigators determined that Mr. Riley and Mr. Geier had:
    • Failed to execute a quality agreement with their leuprolide supplier
    • Failed to perform in-house testing or obtain third-party testing upon receipt and prior to repackaging of the API.
    • Failed to perform internal audits
    • Failed to retain samples of either the API or the repackaged leuprolide following preparation of batches.
    • Failed to define their product specifications.
    • Failed to provide documentation, including a Certificate of Analysis, when either their customer or that customer’s representative picked up the repackaged leuprolide.
    • Failed to assign responsibility for quality control and production to different staff members.
When asked whether he performed Annual Product Reviews (APRs), Mr. Riley stated that he did not even know what they were. And neither, apparently, did David Geier, for there were no APRs to be found.
Inside the Labóratóry
The DAP facility consisted of a 480 square feet, two room suite with an office space and a separate, unclassified production room containing an ISO 5 BSC (biosafety cabinet) vertical laminar flow hood, a refrigerator/freezer, a scale, and a HEPA filter.
The freezer contained a bottle of leuprolide acetate dated February 2019; the investigator noted that the temperature of the freezer was higher than that required for safe storage of the API. Although the identity of the supplier of the leuprolide acetate was redacted from the report, a number of firms sell the same product. Millipore Sigma recommends that leuprolide acetate be stored at -10 to -25°C.
Calibration of the scale was not properly documented; although Mr. Riley stated that a third party performed the calibration, the only record consisted of statements from the vendor. The last internally documented calibration occurred in 2014, the year Mr. Riley stated that DAP went into operations, and five years before the inspection.
BSC hood certifications were performed annually by a third party; however, National Sanitation Foundation (NSF)/American National Standards Institute (ANSI) standards call for certifying BSC hoods for pharmacy usage every six months. Additionally, the hood was located in an unclassified, nonsterile room, and was unplugged between uses, contrary to ISO 5 standards.
Not Sterile? Not a Problem!
When DAP’s lack of sterile working conditions was called to his attention, Mr. Riley responded that an ISO 5 environment was not required for repacking the firm’s non-sterile API. The investigator pointed out that while this may be the case, DAP was preparing leuprolide for a specific use. Although that use was redacted, it is reasonable to speculate that the missing word was “injection.”
Low-temperature electron
micrograph of a cluster of E. coli
bacteria. What if some of these
made their way into DAP’s
repackaged leuprolide? 
Photo: USDA, 2005.
The inspector then asked Mr. Riley whether DAP “tested for microbial contamination or bacterial endotoxins after repacking and prior to distribution.” Mr. Riley responded no. Both Mr. Riley (in person) and David Geier (by teleconference) stated that “the customer should [redacted] the drug substance prior to [redacted].” Whatever actions purchasers were advised to take to ameliorate the potential for microbial contamination is left to the imagination. The investigator emphasized the importance of controlling microorganisms and bacterial endotoxins throughout the repackaging process especially since bacterial endotoxins could not be removed by the means recommended by Mr. Riley and Mr. Geier. Mr. Geier then set forth his rationale for his lack of concern for maintaining sterile conditions:
Mr. Geier reiterated that the [leuprolide acetate] they repackage is not labeled as a sterile product and believed they were not responsible for testing for microbial contamination nor bacterial endotoxins.
Maybe Clean, Maybe Not
Mr. Riley’s and Mr. Geier’s cleaning procedures entailed spraying with a cleaning agent (the name of which was redacted), and wiping the space down with a mop prior to repacking. The BSC hood would be turned on, then repacking items were placed into it. Amber jars, caps and spatulas would be rinsed and left to dry.
In spite of several requests by the investigators, Mr. Riley was unable to provide internal studies that he claimed demonstrated the effectiveness of the firm’s cleaning agents. When reminded of this request, David Geier stated that:
he believed the firm was exempt from controlling for microorganisms as the [leuprolide acetate] they repackaged was not labeled as sterile or for sterile use.
When the investigator reminded Patrick Riley and David Geier that they were “responsible for ensuring the control of microorganisms whether or not the drug was sterile,” and reminded them of “the importance of controlling microorganisms and bacterial endotoxins throughout the repacking process especially since bacterial endotoxins are not removed by [their cleaning agent] and the intended use for this drug substance was for [presumably injection],” neither had anything to say.
Trust, but Don’t Bother to Verify
Mr. Riley confirmed to the investigators that neither he nor David Geier performed in-house testing upon receipt of API, and did not send samples to a laboratory for testing; rather, they relied solely on the supplier’s COA. The leuprolide, as delivered, was non-sterile, although the COA indicated that each lot “was tested for bacterial endotoxins.” The inspector noted that DAP had not defined the drug substance specifications; that is, DAP had established no procedures to ensure that the API they received was actually leuprolide, and that it was safe for human consumption.
When asked whether the amber jars and lids used for storage of repackaged leuprolide were sterile, Mr. Riley stated that they were not. The firm had no procedures governing the receipt, specification, examination and release of these packaging materials, and performed no sampling and examination of the jars and lids prior to use. Masks, sleeves, caps and gloves used during the repacking process were also not sterile.
Too Warm a Room
3D medical animation still showing
Staphylococcus Bacteria. What if
some of these made their way into
DAP’s repackaged API? 
Photo: Scientific Animations, 2019.
License: CC-SA-4.0.
When asked by the inspector how they stored the leuprolide after thawing, Mr. Riley stated that it was maintained at room temperature, and that the repacking process took place at room temperature. Once thawed, leuprolide must be kept beneath 25°C/77°F to guarantee stability; however, the firm maintained no logs indicating the temperature at which either thawed or repackaged leuprolide was stored. In fact, DAP did not maintain master batch and packaging records.
As they did with thawed leuprolide, DAP maintained repackaged leuprolide at room temperature, and did not create batch and packaging records for individual lots of repackaged leuprolide. No record was kept of the time either frozen API or repacked leuprolide was kept out of proper storage conditions. DAP relied solely on the manufacturer’s retest date to determine an expiration date for their repacked leuprolide; however, they performed no independent stability testing to justify an expiration date for leuprolide stored at a higher temperature than that recommended by the manufacturer.
Lax Labeling
DAP had also established no procedures for the printing, review and release of labeling, or for documenting changes in labeling. When asked for a representative label for each batch of repackaged leuprolide, Mr. Riley first printed them out, then admitted that the firm maintained no relevant logs and kept no representative hard-copy labels for each batch. Neither had DAP established any procedure for assigning lot numbers.
The Close-Out Meeting
On September 11, 2019, after the inspection was complete, the inspectors convened a close-out meeting with DAP’s management; Patrick Riley attended in person and David Geier by videoconference. The inspectors presented the pair with FDA’s 483 report listing eight objectionable conditions and gave Mr. Riley and Mr. Geier an opportunity to respond.
     1.  Failure of your quality unit to ensure that there is stability data to support retest or expiry dates and storage conditions of the API.
     2.  Failure to test the identity of each batch of incoming production material or appropriately qualify suppliers to rely upon their Certificate of Analysis.
     3.  Failure to prepare and use production and control records for each API batch.
     4.  Failure to establish written procedures describing the receipt, specifications, examination, and release of packaging and labeling materials.
     5.  Failure to provide the manufacturer’s Certificate of Analysis with shipments of repackaged API to your customer.
     6.  Failure to have a quality unit that is independent of production and fulfills quality assurance (QA) and quality control (QC) duties.
     7.  Failure to establish a procedure for the training of employees and to ensure training is regularly conducted by qualified individuals and covers, at a minimum, the particular operations that each employee performs and cGMP as they relate to the employee’s functions.
     8.  Failure to ensure that your cleaning and sanitization methods for equipment used in the repackaging of API are effective.
No Comment
With respect to inspectors’ concerns about DAP’s product labeling procedures, David Geier suggested changing their label to instruct the user to store the repackaged leuprolide at the proper temperature. The inspector responded that freeze/thaw studies would still need to be conducted in order to demonstrate that the thawing process had no effect on its quality or shelf-life. Although Mr. Geier insisted that DAP already had a quality agreement with their supplier, he could not provide any documentation.
When the inspectors expressed their concern about DAP’s lack of production and control records, written packaging, labeling and employee training procedures; their failure to provide Certificates of Analysis with their finished product; and their lack of an independent quality control unit independent of production, neither Patrick Riley nor David Geier asked any questions or offered any comment.
What, Me Worry About Endotoxins?
It was only when the inspectors came to “Observation 8,” noting that DAP had failed to ensure the effectiveness of their cleaning and sanitization methods for equipment used in the repackaging of API, that David Geier rose to justify his and Mr. Riley’s relaxed housekeeping, stating:
he felt the firm was exempt from having to ensure microbes are removed from the environment since the firm repackages a non-sterile drug.
Color-enhanced electron micrograph
showing Salmonella Typhimurium
invading cultured human cells. What
if some of these made their way into
DAP’s repackaged leuprolide? 
Photo: Rocky Mountain Laboratories,
NIAID, NIH, 2002.
The inspector responded that “although the API was non-sterile, the firm was responsible for ensuring microbial contamination is minimized during production especially since [leuprolide acetate] is intended for use as a sterile drug product.” Neither Mr. Riley nor Mr. Geier had anything to say; Mr. Riley simply stated that they would respond in writing to FDA’s Office of Pharmaceutical Quality Operations within fifteen days.
At the end of the close-out meeting, the investigators notified Mr. Riley that the EIR would be reviewed by other FDA staff in order to determine whether official action should be taken; they reminded him of “his responsibility to assure full compliance to all applicable laws and regulations”; and they warned him that “failure to implement appropriate corrections could result in regulatory actions such as an untitled letter, warning letter, regulatory meeting, seizure, or injunction.”
Too Little Too Late
Immediately after the inspection, Mr. Geier and Mr. Riley engaged FDA Compliance Group, LLC to assist them in preparing their response. In a September 25, 2019, letter to FDA, they reasserted that they repacked their last batch of leuprolide in 2016, three years prior to the inspection:
No drug products have been marketed, manufactured, repackaged, sold or distributed by DAP Pharmaceuticals, LLC since September of 2016 … There is no planned production or existing orders for the repacked [leuprolide] or any other drug products. There is no active website, sales or marketing of a drug product on going at this time. Any of our products that were sold in September 2016 or before September 2016 have reached their expiration date and would not be used by any of our customers since they are expired. Since we have not marketed, manufactured, repackaged, sold or distributed any product since September 2016, we will fully implement and train to all proposed FD-483 corrections should we decide to market, manufacture, sell or distribute any of our products in the future.
Mr. Geier and Mr. Riley assured FDA that since the inspection, they had developed or modified Standard Operating Procedures relating to each category of noncompliance:
    • product stability, processing time and freezer temperatures;
    • supplier qualification;
    • master packaging and labeling records;
    • receipt and inspection of packaging materials;
    • production of certificates of analysis for repacked leuprolide;
    • independence of production and QA functions;
    • employee training;
    • and last but not least, cleaning and sanitization of production equipment to prevent microbial contamination.
In every instance, Mr. Geier and Mr. Riley stated that the procedures described “will be fully implemented and training completed, should we decide to market, manufacture or distribute any product in the future.”
They offered no explanation as to why these Standard Operating Procedures were not in place prior to the commencement of DAP’s operations.
DAP Pharmaceuticals LLC was dissolved in March 2021.
A Sordid Enterprise
It is profoundly disturbing (not to mention ironic) to discover that the son of and co-author with a doctor who routinely offered sworn, ostensibly “expert” testimony that the DPT vaccine contained unacceptable levels of endotoxins that resulted in a client’s irreversible neurological damage, would argue that he need not control for microorganisms at his leuprolide repacking facility because the API was labeled non-sterile, even though the finished product was presumably destined for injection into autistic children.
One of the earliest articles co-authored by David Geier with Mark Geier, The True Story of Pertussis Vaccination: A Sordid Legacy? (2002) proclaimed:
Endotoxin is a highly toxic substance. Doctors and scientists take great care to ensure its absence from most medicines, intravenous tubing, syringes, and other medical instruments before using them.
In at least a half dozen papers published between 2002 and 2004, both Mark and David Geier alleged that endotoxins in pertussis, influenza and MMR vaccines had given rise to countless instances of disability and death. In a review article written after they were retained by VICP petitioners’ attorneys to develop scientific evidence implicating thimerosal as a cause of autism, Mark and David Geier speculated that “increased endotoxins levels… may also increase Hg intoxication in the brain.”
However, it would seem from the DAP Pharmaceuticals EIR that endotoxins were only a concern for Messrs. Geier, Geier and Riley when they might potentially be found in someone else’s product.
Missing Information
Given that their task was to inspect DAP’s physical plant and production processes rather than to ascertain its principals’ backgrounds and credentials, the investigators were probably unaware that in 2012, Dr. Mark Geier’s license to practice medicine in that state was revoked following the Maryland Board of Physicians’ finding that he had endangered autistic children in his care through the indiscriminate administration of leuprolide, often in dosages far exceeding those approved by the FDA for the treatment of central precocious puberty. It is also likely that the FDA investigators were unaware that in 2013, the same year that Mr. Riley claimed that DAP was established, co-owner Mark Geier was charged with the unlicensed practice of pharmacy by the Florida Department of Health (DOH).
As noted in my previous article about DAP, Florida Board of Pharmacy records indicate that neither Patrick Riley nor David Geier hold a license to practice pharmacy in that state; additionally, Florida DOH charges against Mark Geier note that Hal Goldman, the Tamarac, Florida pharmacist who allowed Dr. Geier to compound leuprolide at his establishment and was later disciplined for doing so, stated that he himself did not know how to compound.
The Supporting Cast
Mark Geier’s alleged non-involvement in the operations of the firm strains credulity, given his professional investment in the “Lupron protocol,” his purported accumulation of hundreds of autistic patients prior to the suspension of his license to practice medicine in Maryland in 2011, and his determination to continue promoting the “Lupron protocol” as evidenced by his decision to illegally compound the drug for distribution to “J.Y.,” “G.D.,” and “D.C.”.
Following the revocation of his license in 2012, many of his patients were ostensibly transferred to the care of his ASD Centers, LLC colleagues John L. Young of Bethesda, Maryland and Palm Beach Gardens, Florida, who continued to prescribe leuprolide injections to autistic patients entirely at Mark Geier’s direction, and was ultimately disciplined by the state of Maryland for doing so. Other “Lupron protocol” subjects were patients of other associates of the Geiers, four of whom testified in support of Mark Geier during his revocation hearing. These included:
A quack doctor selling remedies from
his caravan. Chromolithograph by T.
Merry, 1889. Photo: Wellcome Library,
London. Licensing: CC-SA-4.0.
    • Pediatrician Mary Norfleet Megson of Richmond, Virginia (who at Autism One 2005 reportedly parroted as fact the Geiers’ baseless hypothesis that lowering autistic children’s testosterone with leuprolide enables “sheaths” of mercury to be “pulled out” through chelation);
    • Psychiatrist Georgia Davis of Springfield, Illinois (who, like Dr. Young, consulted extensively with Mark Geier by teleconference during patient examinations, interpretation of tests, and dosage determinations, and whose initials corresponded to those of a recipient of Dr. Geier’s illegally compounded leuprolide);
    • Radiologist David Clayman of Tamarac, Florida (who was the designated registered agent for ASD Centers, LLC in Florida and another likely recipient of Dr. Geier’s illegally compounded leuprolide); and
    • Pediatrician Jerry Kartzinel of Jackson, Tennessee and Clermont, Florida (whose Orlando-based Kartzinel Wellness Center is listed by Healthgrades as a pharmacy, and whose “particularly unpersuasive” testimony in the Maryland Board of Physicians proceedings against Mark Geier included opinions that “a physical examination of patients is highly overrated,” and that a physician need only “bide by his eye” and “get a gestalt” without the need to document those impressions in a patients’ medical record).
Although each of these doctors claimed expertise on the “efficacy and safety of Lupron for treatment of autistic children,” none possessed any expertise in the field of endocrinology.
Expertise & Disingenuity
Commercially available Leuprolide
Acetate Injection. Not hard to
come by; no need to compound if
you’re not prescribing astronomical
doses of the stuff.
There is little reason for physicians to prescribe or pharmacies to distribute leuprolide acetate manufactured in a manner unapproved by the FDA when FDA-approved preparations are readily available for intramuscular or subcutaneous injection by people who truly have a need for it. There is little reason for a pediatrician, psychiatrist, radiologist, or any other non-endocrinologist to begin treating any child with leuprolide without consulting an endocrinologist. There has never been any reason to administer leuprolide to autistic children not experiencing precocious puberty.
The only people to have recommended it for the treatment of autism are Mark Geier, David Geier, and their similarly unqualified colleagues. Although leuprolide may have helped to lessen aggression in some autistic children, I am aware of no evidence that any board-certified endocrinologist has ever condoned the use of leuprolide as a short-acting psychopharmaceutical; indeed, a 2009 consensus statement by the Lawson Wilkins Pediatric Endocrine Society and the European Society for Paediatric Endocrinology on the use of gonadotropin-releasing hormone analogs [GnRHa] in children notes that although Mark and David Geier had posited “that GnRHa may benefit behavioral symptoms in children with autism, the consensus is that there is no current evidence for GnRHa therapy for this indication.” A 2019 follow-up review offered greater detail:
GnRHa treatment cannot be recommended for autism as there is no validated evidence of efficacy. A single article reported that GnRHa usage in both prepubertal and pubertal children with autism improved behavioral symptoms (e.g., reduced aggressiveness and inappropriate sexual behavior) in the short term. Attempts to replicate these data have not been successful. There is no evidence of any longstanding improvement in patients’ inappropriate behavior or use of such therapy in children with autism. Although GnRH agonists have been used to treat patients with developmental problems (i.e., males who masturbate in public and females unable to care for themselves during menstruation), preventing pubertal progression can be seen, at best, as a temporary measure.
Attempted End Run
It is likely that adverse publicity surrounding the “Lupron protocol” and Mark Geier’s license revocation alerted insurance companies to his and his colleagues’ misdiagnoses of autistic children with “precocious puberty,” “testicular hyperfunction,” “hyperandrogenism” and other convenient, coverage-enabling medical fictions, and made it more difficult for parents to obtain the drug, and to obtain insurance reimbursement for it.
The end of Mark Geier’s career as a practicing physician, the fading of his career as an expert witness, and both Mark and David Geier’s inability to extract income from either the VICP program or petitioners’ attorneys, offered an incentive to find new sources of income. Any desire on the part of Mark Geier’s former patients’ parents or his leuprolide-slinging colleagues to continue their off-label treatment of autistic children with leuprolide offered an incentive to find new sources of injectable leuprolide.
Unanswered Questions
The identity of DAP’s singular customer was not disclosed in the Establishment Inspection Report, and at this point in history could only be revealed by Patrick Riley, David Geier, the customer himself or herself, and any physicians or parents who might have ordered injectable leuprolide directly from that individual.
The Establishment Inspection Report also does not indicate the supplier of the leuprolide API, the API’s wholesale price, or the price of the repackaged API. DAP’s irregular hours and infrequent operation notwithstanding, the acquisition of office space and investment in production equipment suggests that DAP Pharmaceuticals was a profitable operation.
The parents who were persuaded to believe that leuprolide could have a long-term positive impact on their autistic children’s development, that it could make mercury easier to remove from the body, that it could make a child “fall off the spectrum,” or “make the autism virtually disappear,” were tragically, even criminally misled, both by the late Dr. Mark Geier, and by his uncredentialed son.
The Ultimate Target
David Geier, wearing a lab coat, sits at his 
desk beside the family fume hood.
David Geier is neither a physician, nor the aspiring scientist that he appeared to be when, fresh out of college, he began co-authoring articles and attending Congressional hearings with his father, where they broadcast their identical convictions regarding the supposed dangers of vaccines. A decade later, after serving as co-investigator in a prolonged, scientifically unsupportable, profoundly unethical pharmaceutical experiment on disabled children, and after a lengthy investigation by the Maryland Board of Physicians of his father’s practice and his role in it, he was charged with practicing medicine without a license.
After the Geier family relocated to Florida, he and his father co-founded a firm for the express purpose of continuing their human subjects research at the expense of autistic children’s welfare and their parents’ bank accounts, all in support of their grandiose, factually-deficient belief that they had discovered both the cause and the cure for autism.
The leuprolide acetate salts repacked by the principals of DAP Pharmaceuticals were doubtless destined for injection into the bodies of autistic children. Any endotoxins that found their way into the product thanks to David Geier, Patrick Riley and Mark Geier’s sloppy manufacturing practices were doubtless destined for injection into the bodies of autistic children.
The man hired by HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. to validate his pre-existing conviction that autism is a consequence of vaccine injury, but who expressed no concern about the potential for microbial contamination in his own product, will doubtless bring the same twisted sense of ethics to bear on this new research project that he brought to his past promotion of “the Lupron protocol” and his more recent misadventure in the world of Little Pharma.


The Long Med Con: The Self-Styled Expertise and Expansive Invoices of Mark & David Geier
All it takes is a coming-of-age consultancy and you, too, can morph from an average teenage Joe or Josephine to an instant “vaccine expert”
Kathleen Seidel on June 12, 2025
Link
HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s recent hiring of David Geier to reinvestigate possible associations between vaccines and autism gives ample cause to review Mr. Geier’s history as a consultant to vaccine-injury claimants, and as a prolific co-author with his father, the late Dr. Mark Geier, of studies, reviews, letters, and magazine articles that support their disability causation claims.
That history begins at a point when Dr. Geier’s output of scientific journal articles had slowed. During the 1970’s, he had co-authored a dozen papers in the fields of genetics and biochemistry; however, during the 1980’s, only a few papers bore his name. The 1990’s saw a handful of new publications, all on genetic testing save for a letter discussing the rubella vaccine.
In spite of this uptick, near the end of the century Dr. Geier’s career was not so much about conducting studies and publishing scientific papers as it was about running a genetics and obstetrics practice, testifying in vaccine injury cases, and offering commentary on vaccines at public committees and conferences. However, judges and Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (VICP) special masters had grown increasingly critical of the quality of his speculative, often irrelevant testimony. (I discuss this subject in my previous post, “A Checkered History in Vaccine Court: Mark Geier at the VICP, 1988-2003.”)
A Dwindling Store of Evidence
Although the VICP does not strictly adhere to rules of evidence that apply in civil courts, the VICP special masters are nonetheless inclined to apply the principles outlined in Daubert v. Merrell Dow to cases in that venue. Daubert requires that expert opinion be supported by peer reviewed research, but peer reviewed research to support Dr. Mark Geier’s idiosyncratic, litigation-driven opinions on vaccine injury and disease causation was scarce, and the few academic sources upon which he relied were increasingly out of date.
One approach to filling the evidence gap was to DIY. Although during the 1970’s Dr. Geier had published several papers on endotoxins in vaccines, his only other vaccine-related contributions to the scientific literature consisted of two otherwise-unpublished statements made at public meetings of the Institute of Medicine. However, in 1999, he acquired a new apprentice with whom he could jointly generate studies and reviews to buttress his opinions in court, and with whom he could jointly address public meetings and conferences to broadcast those opinions worldwide.
A Pair of Wiser Minds
In 1998, Mark Geier’s son David Geier was a freshman at the University of Maryland-Baltimore County (UMBC); he would eventually choose a major in biology and a minor in history. Although he described himself at least once as a pre-med student, he appears to have taken few pre-med courses. During his college years, David Geier was granted a journalism internship and became a frequent contributor of opinion pieces to the UMBC student weekly, The Retriever. He advocated for gun control and for restricting voting rights to those with demonstrable educational achievement; he predicted interstellar settlement and a new civil war; he recommended that eligible citizens be legally required to vote, and that the United States consider purchasing parts of Canada.
In a September 19, 2000 Retriever editorial, “Americans should take vaccines more seriously,” young Mr. Geier—like his father had before him—donned the mantle of vaccine expert in the absence of any formal education or clinical experience in immunology, neurology or vaccine development, and adopted his father’s “expert” opinions as his own. He characterized prevalent methods of vaccine distribution as a careless business and counted himself and his father among the “wiser minds [who] have begun to truly question the safety and efficacy of such a slipshod method of vaccination, especially considering the fact that vaccines can cause some extremely disastrous side effects in recipients.” He called attention to “my recent research with Dr. Mark Geier in the Journal of Clinical and Experimental Rheumatology” as evidence that the Hepatitis B vaccination often caused “serious immunological disorders,” and cited to a “recent analysis by Mark Geier and myself” as evidence that influenza vaccines are only marginally effective. Mr. Geier opined—like his father had in numerous vaccine-injury cases—that pharmaceutical companies were incapable of adequately testing flu vaccines for efficacy and safety. Like his father had before him, Mr. Geier accused “healthcare professionals and industries” of painting a “wonderful rosy picture” of vaccine safety and encouraged his readers to “know the whole truth” about vaccines.
The essay ended with the biographical note, “David Geier is a junior majoring in biology,” but failed to disclose that the author had also recently become President of a firm offering consulting services to vaccine injury attorneys—a President who was either self-appointed, or, more believably, was elevated to that role by his father.
The Expert’s Apprentice
On August 1, 1999—shortly before David Geier’s sophomore year commenced, and a year before he penned his vaccine editorial—Clifford Shoemaker—a vaccine injury attorney and close professional associate of Mark Geier—prepared the Articles of Incorporation of MedCon, Inc., a Delaware corporation established to “provide medical consulting and other such litigation support for personal injury attorneys.” MedCon’s Directors were identified as Mr. Shoemaker, David Geier and his mother, early childhood educator Anne Geier, and the firm’s principal office as the Geier family home in Silver Spring, Maryland. Although ostensibly a medical consulting firm, MedCon’s Board of Directors did not include anyone with a medical education. The name of Dr. Mark Geier—the only member of the Geier household even remotely qualified to offer medical services—appeared nowhere on the document.
For the next quarter-century, Mark and David Geier presented themselves as one mind and spoke as one mind. From 2000 onward, nearly every paper published by Mark Geier named his son as a co-author; their written output focused primarily on vaccines and vaccine injury. On public forays, they often gave the impression of unanimity. A 2003 profile in Seed Magazine noted that David “finishes his father’s sentences and jumps in to correct him when a detail is omitted during one of the numerous presentations they make together,” and that father and son “live in the house where David grew up and work most nights and weekends on side-by-side computers in the study.” Nearly a decade later, their work-life situation was much the same; as one judge noted, David Geier and Dr. Geier “live in the same home and are together nearly all the time.”
An Instant Professional Affiliation
But even as Mark and David Geier lived their private life at each other’s side and cultivated a unified public image, they also sought to convey the notion that they were intellectually independent from each other. Although David Geier lacked his father’s M.D. and Ph.D.—and until mid-2002, lacked even a Bachelor’s degree—he did have one credential he could display to create an impression of expertise, authority, and intellectual independence: his made-to-order professional affiliation as “President of MedCon, Inc.”
From 2000 through 2005, David Geier would identify himself—or not identify himself, as convenience mandated—as “President of MedCon, Inc.” Every paper co-authored by David Geier and Mark Geier between 2000 and 2005 gave David Geier’s affiliation as “President of MedCon, Inc.,” and Mark Geier’s affiliation as principal or President of his obstetrics and genetics practice, Genetic Centers of America. In none of the Geiers’ published papers did Mark Geier ever disclose any affiliation with MedCon. These disclosures, and the lack thereof, served to convey the unwarranted impression that David Geier’s professional life was somehow separate from his father’s.
This was hardly the case. In fact, MedCon, Inc. served as a vehicle for an ambitious effort to transform David Geier from an average college student to the very picture of a full-fledged contrarian scientist, qualified not by post-graduate education and research or clinical experience, but by apprenticeship to his father, a self-styled expert on vaccine injury and professional purveyor of results-oriented testimony. MedCon, Inc. also served as a made-to-order employer; on his resumes, Mr. Geier included “Researcher at MedCon, Inc.” and “President of MedCon, Inc.” as examples of his scientific employment, notwithstanding the fact that he was purportedly the firm’s founder and President.
In the eyes of those not already wedded to the conclusion that vaccines cause autism, Mark and David Geier’s effort to boost the latter’s status to that of an instant expert was doomed to fail.
New Research & New Clients
David Geier’s new role as Mark Geier’s amanuensis and “President of MedCon, Inc.” enabled Dr. Geier to dramatically boost his output of publications, and to transform the royal “we” into the collective “we” in his papers and public testimony. In their early work together, Geier père et fils would turn their attention first to the hepatitis B and pertussis vaccines, then to vaccines for rubella, anthrax and Lyme disease. They published a series of analyses of data from the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS), a database of adverse event reports submitted by both professionals and laypeople, consistently finding associations between vaccines and whatever might be the topic of their analysis. Then, beginning in 2003, they would shift their focus again, to the mercury-based preservative thimerosal in vaccines.
The Geiers’ reorientation coincided with their new role as consultants to petitioners in the Omnibus Autism Proceeding (OAP), which consolidated growing numbers of VICP claims alleging that children had been rendered autistic by either the MMR or thimerosal-containing vaccines. At the November 2002 3rd International Conference of the National Vaccine Information Center, Mark and David Geier gave a presentation on adverse vaccine reactions and became acquainted with Lyn Redwood, co-founder of SafeMinds, a parent-led organization that promoted the thimerosal-causation hypothesis and advocated for collective litigation. Shortly thereafter, they were solicited by attorneys from the OAP Petitioners’ Steering Committee to evaluate data about thimerosal-containing vaccines. In September 2003, Mark Geier entered into a formal agreement with the PSC to consult and potentially offer expert testimony, at rates ranging from $250 to $500/hour. One year later, that agreement was expanded to include David Geier, with payment of fees to be deferred until the conclusion of the six OAP test cases.
Mark Geier, David Geier and petitioners’ attorneys spent the next few years seeking authorization to access data in the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD), which is comprised of anonymized patient information from participating Managed Care Organizations (MCOs). After many complaints about the inconvenience of passing the scrutiny of the MCOs’ Institutional Review Boards, and many requests to the court to order MCOs to grant petitioners’ “independent experts” unfettered access to patient records, Mark and David Geier were eventually allowed to study the VSD, only to find their permission withdrawn after they attempted implement a plan that (according to Mark Geier) was devised by David “to put their … seven different data bases together to make one.” In 2006, following more appeals by petitioners’ attorneys, a second attempt by the Geiers to analyze multiple datasets simultaneously led to yet another suspension. (I describe these events in greater detail in my post, Senator Hassan Sets Secretary Kennedy Straight.)
In the meantime, Mark and David Geier continued publishing analyses of VAERS data, now in relation to thimerosal-containing vaccines.
Cultivating Litigants & $$$
David Geier’s MedCon, Inc. engaged in both the business of generating evidence to support the claims of vaccine-injury petitioners and soliciting clients for vaccine-injury attorneys. In a 2005 announcement on autismfliers.tripod.com, David Geier encouraged parents of autistic children to file VICP claims by way of his firm:
75 cents from every vaccine goes into $2 Billion dollar program which pays for your child’s lawyer & medical experts. Contact David Geier and the medical-legal consulting firm, MedCon, 301-989-0548. Must file suit within 3 years of diagnosis.
In a 2005 defamation action against the authors of an article that criticized their work, both Mark and David Geier claimed that compensation for services to litigants represented a significant portion of their income, presumably eclipsing Dr. Geier’s income from his obstetrics and genetics practices.
(T)he Geiers dedicate a substantial amount of their time and resources to their role as expert witnesses. … (T)he Geiers are dependent upon the compensation they receive as expert witnesses as a significant source of income.
Where that income was coming from—especially income presumably paid to David Geier—is left to the imagination. Many VICP decisions evaluate Mark Geier’s bills to the court, and either outright deny or reduce his compensation. Although only a handful discuss David Geier, those that do shed abundant light on his lack of qualifications to offer expert research and opinion on medical matters, as well as a willingness to soak the court for personal expenditures that can fairly be called audacious.
An Anonymous Invoice
In her June 18, 2008, fees and costs decision in Carrington v. HHS (Case No. 99-495V)—the first VICP ruling to mention MedCon, Inc.—Special Master Denise Vowell scrutinized a request for nearly $100,000.00 in fees submitted by petitioners’ counsel Clifford Shoemaker, and determined that bills from MedCon were not compensable, due in part to the firm’s appearance as an alias for Mark Geier, and due in part to the fact that while MedCon purported to provide consulting services, the faceless entity delivered no work product to the court.
Perhaps the most difficult matter in this fees and costs application is the amount of compensation requested for Dr. Mark Geier and MedCon, Inc., a combined total of $3,800.00. I am concerned both by the lack of specificity in the bills submitted, as well as the use of medical consultants when no reports or other documents are filed with the court reflecting what role the consultant played in the case.
Invoices from both MedCon and Dr. Geier were submitted with the fees and costs application. The bill format of MedCon is identical to the format of the bills submitted by Dr. Mark Geier as a Medical/Legal Consultant, with the exception of an entry over the heading reflecting Dr. Geier’s name. The bills for Dr. Geier and MedCon are aggregated in the Synopsis of Fees and Costs submitted with the Application for Fees and Costs. I thus conclude that MedCon is a business that is in some way connected with Dr. Geier. [emphasis added]
Given that David Geier’s name appears nowhere in the Carrington decision, Special Master Vowell appears not to have been informed that bills from MedCon pertained to work performed by Mark Geier’s son.
A Hidden Relationship
The special master then expressed her concern that Mark Geier and Mr. Shoemaker had preexisting business relationships by way of a nonprofit organization they had recently founded, the Institute for Chronic Illnesses:
When a client is billed for such consultation, the client is entitled to know what the consultant did, what hourly fee or flat rate of compensation was charged, and why the consultant was required. […] Under fee-shifting statutes, the general rule is that an attorney may not bill the government (or the opposing party) for fees that would not be billed to a private client.
When there are indications that the arrangement between consultant and attorney is not entirely at arm’s length, the issue of consultant fees becomes even more problematic. Public records reflect that petitioner’s counsel is an officer or director of the Institute for Chronic Illnesses, Inc., a charitable organization. One of Dr. Geier’s many published articles identifies his organizational affiliation as the Institute for Chronic Illnesses, Inc.
In light of Special Master Vowell’s expression of concern over Dr. Geier’s and Mr. Shoemaker’s shared membership on a nonprofit board, it is likely that she would have been equally concerned to learn that Mr. Shoemaker was a director of the for-profit MedCon consultancy when he submitted MedCon’s bills to the court.
Bills and time records from Mark Geier and the anonymous MedCon gave Special Master Vowell little indication of the work being performed and the identity of the individual who performed it, and bore little relationship to time records submitted by Mr. Shoemaker.
In the case of Dr. Geier/MedCon, Inc., the situation is complicated by the frequency in which such services are utilized, when little or no information is ultimately filed with the court documenting what was actually done… The invoices in this case are insufficient to explain the relationship of the costs to the prosecution of this petition. … The bill dated March 2, 2002, submitted from MedCon, Inc., claims $400.00 for what is labeled ‘Research’ in one column and ‘Lawyer Consultation’ in another. I have carefully examined the attorney time records submitted, and find only one entry involving this case for any attorney in this firm in all of 2002.… Given the lack of specificity for this bill and the lack of any attorney entry reflecting consultation with MedCon, Inc., or Dr. Geier in the same year, I will not authorize compensation for this $400.00.
The Evidence Fails to Persuade
Although the President of MedCon enabled his father to produce a pile of litigation-driven journal articles, he was unable to enhance their quality. In his February 2009 ruling in Cedillo v. HHS (Case 98-916V), Special Master George Hastings offered his take on studies by the Geiers submitted in support of the contention that autism could be caused by the MMR vaccine.
As noted above, all of the studies that have addressed the MMR/autism causation issue published since the Wakefield article in 1998 have found no association between MMR vaccination and autism, with two exceptions. Both exceptions were studies published by the research team of Dr. Mark Geier and his son David Geier….
After careful consideration, I conclude that the Geiers’ studies cannot be given any weight. Those studies were considered by the Institute of Medicine (IOM) committee that fully studied the entire MMR/causation issue in 2004, and that committee concluded that the studies were so flawed as to be “uninterpretable” and to contribute nothing meaningful (“noncontributory”) concerning the causation issue. The committee noted that the studies were based on databases that themselves had “significant limitations,” and that the studies’ methodologies had “serious methodological limitations.” The committee added that the Geiers’ articles describing the analytical methods were “not transparent” and omitted “important details,” so that it was impossible to evaluate the studies. Other specific points of deficiency in the studies were also discussed. In addition, Dr. [Eric] Fombonne analyzed the Geier studies, and found them to be “seriously flawed in several respects.” None of the expert witnesses for the petitioners vouched for the reliability of the Geier studies. [emphasis added]
In her simultaneously-published decision in the test case, Snyder v. HHS (Case No. 01-162V), Special Master Vowell came to much the same conclusion regarding the Geiers’ 2003 report, A Case-Control Study of Mercury Burden in Children with Autistic Spectrum Disorders, presented to support the argument that autism is a consequence of vaccine-induced thimerosal poisoning. After noting numerous methodological and statistical problems with the study, Special Master Vowell wrote:
Petitioners have failed to demonstrate that children with autism have difficulty excreting mercury, and thus there is no reliable evidence of a mercury efflux disorder or a hypersusceptibility to mercury in children with an ASD diagnosis
It didn’t help that two of the study’s co-authors were already poorly regarded by the court:
I note that two of the co-authors of this study were Dr. Mark Geier and Mr. David Geier. This is not the first occasion in which other researchers have been unable to verify the validity of the Geiers’ statistical analysis. … A number of judges have had similar concerns about Dr. Geier’s work.
In his March 2010 decision in the test case King v. HHS (Case No. 03-584V), Special Master George Hastings had another opportunity to comment on the value of Mark and David Geier’s thimerosal studies. His observations were similar to those in Cedilloregarding their studies of the MMR vaccine:
As explained above, most of the epidemiologic studies that have addressed the thimerosal/autism causation issue have failed to find any association between thimerosal-containing vaccines and autism, but there have been certain exceptions. Those exceptions were studies published by the research team of Dr. Mark Geier and his son David Geier.
After careful consideration, I conclude that the Geiers’ studies cannot be given any weight. A number of those studies were considered by the Institute of Medicine (IOM) committee that fully studied the entire thimerosal/autism causation issue in 2004. … Other specific deficiencies in the studies were also discussed, including the fact that the Geiers incorrectly used several epidemiologic terms and measures
Further, petitioners’ own expert witness concerning epidemiology, Dr. [Sander] Greenland, agreed with the criticisms of the Geier articles, acknowledging that those studies are “deficient in methodology.” And none of the expert witnesses for the petitioners vouched for the reliability of the Geier studies.
In summary, I conclude that all of the Geier epidemiologic studies are not reliable, and cannot be accorded any weight. [emphasis added]
Unfamiliar & Unqualified
Whereas in Carrington, MedCon lost out on only $400 in billables, in Riggins v. HHS (Case No. 99-382-V)—another VICP case in which Clifford Shoemaker served as petitioner’s counsel—David Geier and his father were far more presumptuous. In his June 2009 Fees and Costs Decision in that case, then-Chief Special Master Gary Golkiewicz discussed Mr. Geier’s qualifications and his bills to the court and found both inadequate.
The undersigned is quite familiar with Dr. Mark Geier, but far less familiar with his son David Geier. Petitioner has requested approximately $37,543.75 in costs associated with fees to be paid to David Geier. The undersigned finds petitioner’s request for fees and costs associated with activities performed by David Geier unsubstantiated, and thus unreasonable, and denies the request in total.
The court observed that David Geier had no relevant credentials and no expertise to offer.
As an initial matter, David Geier is not qualified to serve as a consultant on the medical issues presented in the Vaccine Program. To the undersigned’s knowledge, David Geier has not been compensated as a consultant in any prior Program case, and petitioner has not cited any such prior Program compensation. David Geier does not possess any advanced medical or scientific degrees. The only degree David Geier possesses is a Bachelor of Arts in Biology. According to his CV, he has taken graduate level coursework, but does not appear to have finished any program, nor does he appear to be currently enrolled in any graduate program. While David Geier is named as co-author in numerous vaccine related papers with his father, Mr. Geier possesses no advanced degrees or credentials to qualify him for work as a Vaccine Program consultant. The issues in this matter concern medical causation for which Mr. Geier does not have the requisite background and credentials. On this basis alone, petitioner’s request for compensating David Geier is denied. [emphasis added]
Although David Geier sought to buttress his claim for reimbursement with a retainer agreement between a Chicago attorney and MedCon, the court was not impressed.
The undersigned notes that attached to David Geier’s affidavit, as “Exhibit B” is a retainer agreement signed by an attorney in Chicago and David Geier in which the attorney client appears to be retaining the services of MedCon, Inc. (of which Mr. Geier is president) to perform research “involving thimerosal litigation and other related matters” at a rate of $250 an hour. The undersigned does not find this agreement establishes David Geier’s qualifications to serve as a consultant in Program cases. At most, this agreement may demonstrate that someone has agreed to pay MedCon, Inc. to perform research “involving thimerosal litigation and other related matters” at a rate of $250 an hour.
The court was also unmoved by Mr. Geier’s employment history (which at the time consisted primarily of summer jobs and positions at enterprises established by or employing his father).
David Geier, also lists as “scientific employment” his positions in various consulting and research organizations. However, holding these positions alone does not give Mr. Geier the background necessary to qualify him for work as a Vaccine Program consultant.
Two for the Price of One?
Mark Geier and Clifford Shoemaker characterized David Geier’s employment as a consultant in Riggins as something of a bargain.
Petitioner argues David Geier is a qualified consultant and petitioner saved funds by employing David Geier. (“In his consultation with Counsel Dr. Geier would enlist the assistance of David Geier, his son, at a greatly reduced rate than his own, an action which resulted in further savings to counsel, and subsequently, the Program.”)
However, the court determined that both father and son were performing essentially the same work, at the same number of hours.
However, even assuming arguendo that David Geier was qualified to serve as a Vaccine Program consultant, the work performed in this matter by Mr. Geier is duplicative of the work performed in this matter by his father, Dr. Mark Geier. To state that counsel is saving the Vaccine Program money by employing David Geier is simply not established nor is it a credible statement. For virtually every single request for costs for work or travel performed by Dr. Geier, an identically described request is made by David Geier (albeit at a lower rate than his father).
Mr. Shoemaker’s insistence on his right to be compensated for every “expert” he might happen to hire was unavailing.
Petitioner attempts to justify this unreasonable submission for fees and costs for the services of both Dr. Mark Geier and David Geier by arguing “that it is counsel’s prerogative to determine how to prosecute his case.” Within certain bounds, including ethical and reasonableness, that is true, however, it is not counsel’s “right” to be compensated simply because counsel says a charge is reasonable. Attorneys retained by paying clients are not able to make any expenditure they desire. In private litigation, the client’s oversight constrains expenditures. Likewise, petitioners in the Program are not given a “blank check to incur expenses” to be paid by the Vaccine Trust Fund.… The undersigned finds a hypothetical client would find counsel’s request for consulting fees paid to David Geier unjustifiable as he is unqualified, his costs constitute over-billing as they duplicate his father’s charges, and thus the charges are entirely unreasonable. Therefore, fees and costs associated with David Geier are denied in their entirety. [emphasis added]
“An Extreme Example of Error in Billing Judgment”
The Geiers’ bills in Riggins included a preposterous request for nearly $44,000 spent on father-son jaunts to France and Italy in 2005 and 2006, as well as their time in the air.
Another extreme example of counsel’s error in billing judgment is the request by counsel for fees and costs billed by Dr. Mark Geier and David Geier for trips to France and Italy in the summer of 2005 and winter of 2006 respectively, and for Mr. Shoemaker to travel to France with the Geiers in the summer of 2005. These requests represent a complete abdication of billing judgment.
Dr. Geier and Mr. Geier together billed a total of over $20,000.00 to travel along with Mr. Shoemaker to France and meet with various doctors and lawyers to discuss adverse events following the hepatitis B vaccination. Dr. Geier, in his affidavit, and counsel in Petitioner’s Sur-Reply, allege … that this information could only be obtained in “face-to-face” discussions. In addition, Dr. Geier and Mr. Geier together billed $23,690.00 to travel to Italy to attend the 5th International Conference of Autoimmunity.
The undersigned finds petitioner has failed to explain why it was reasonable for the Geiers (and Mr. Shoemaker) to travel to France and Italy, billing and spending in excess of $44,000.00, including $19,175.00 billed as travel time, to talk to other doctors and lawyers about their experiences and research “face-to-face.” … These fees and costs requested for these trips are excessive and not compensable.
The court looked askance at the Geiers’ failure to submit receipts for their travel, and at their commingling of expenses.
Additionally, the Geiers provided absolutely no supporting documentation, such as receipts, to evidence the $9,399.68, they allege they incurred in costs for airline tickets, other transportation costs, parking, hotel, “daily expenses,” food, and conference fees during these trips. By itself, this failure justifies not awarding these costs.… The undersigned notes David Geier’s “costs” while on travel are intermingled with the travel costs of Dr. Geier.
The court found Mark and David Geier’s bills even more unreasonable due to their lack of qualifications to serve as experts in a case involving the hepatitis B vaccine.
Further, there is no explanation of why the Geiers, who are not qualified experts, were taken to engage in conversations with these foreign experts as opposed to qualified experts counsel had retained to opine in [Shoemaker & Associates’] hepatitis B cases…. It is completely unreasonable and extremely inappropriate to bill the Vaccine Fund for the costs of the Geiers traveling to Italy and attending a professional conference that the Geiers were invited to attend as researchers.… Thus, the request is denied.
It appears that the Geiers in this matter incurred significant costs with no oversight…. In summary, the undersigned finds the costs for David Geier’s efforts to be obviously unreasonable as Mr. Geier is not qualified to address the medical issues involved in the Program and his work was duplicative of the efforts by Dr. Geier. Thus, the undersigned denies the request for costs for David Geier in its entirety. [Emphasis added]
Dr. Geier would be awarded only $10,000 for his services as a consultant to the petitioners in Riggins, and David Geier would receive nothing. The decision was eventually affirmed  by the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, which held that “the Special Master’s reduction in the fees awarded for the work of Dr. Geier and refusal to award fees for David Geier was not arbitrary, capricious, or an abuse of discretion.”
Unjustified, Unreasonable & Unobjective
Following the conclusion of the test case King v. HHS (Case 03-584V), the Geiers sought $197,000 in compensation for researching and writing Thimerosal exposure in infants and neurodevelopmental disorders, an article commissioned by the PSC; co-author Heather Young sought $248,636 for her contributions, and collaborator Dr. Robert Hirsch sought $41,000 for his. However, in his December 2010 ruling on fees and costs, Special Master George Hastings concluded that it would not be reasonable for the Program to compensate anyone for any work on the study. He noted that although Dr. Geier had acknowledged his intent “to produce a legitimate scientific work product that would withstand peer review and be published in a scientific journal… even absent the Vaccine Act litigation,”
[Mark and David Geier] already had a long track record of producing data analyses and articles supportive of the theory that vaccines can contribute to causing autism. The mere fact that the PSC lawyers contributed or promised monetary support for another article co-authored by the Geiers, concerning the topic of whether thimerosal-containing vaccines can cause autism, is itself strong evidence that the article was litigation-driven.
He observed that the article “did not add any value to the petitioners’ causation presentation in this case,” citing to the testimony of Dr. Michael Rutter and Dr. Eric Fombonne, both of whom criticized the study’s statistical manipulations and wholesale invention of data. The petitioners’ epidemiology expert Dr. Sander Greenland did not help the Geiers’ credibility with his testimony that their work was “deficient in methodology.”
The special master concluded:
No rational hypothetical paying client of the PSC would have agreed to pay for the production of such a flawed study.
The special master then gave his rationale for not covering the cost of producing an article co-authored by the Geiers, referring to Mark Geier’s custom of offering testimony outside his medical specialty, and citing to his colleagues’ rulings on “the credibility, credentials, honesty, or other aspects of the testimony or opinions of Mark Geier,” and their conclusions that he “is not an honest, candid witness.’” One cited decision noted that “such expressions by special masters were common even in the earlier years of the Program, so that even by the year 2002 it should have been clear that to retain Dr. Geier as an expert was ‘unreasonable.’”
The court held that it would be particularly unreasonable to pay Mark and David Geier to produce yet another study intended to demonstrate a causal association between vaccines and developmental disorders, given the severe criticism of their work by the Institute of Medicine and by both petitioners’ and respondents’ expert witnesses.
Dr. Geier’s attempts at epidemiological studies in this area were so poorly executed that they are completely useless in analyzing the general causation issues.… I find that the fact that Mark Geier and David Geier are two of the three co-authors of the Young-Geier article is another very strong reason for concluding that it would not be reasonable for me to compensate the PSC for the cost of producing that article.
As demonstrated above, the prior epidemiologic efforts of the Geiers in the area of the alleged vaccine causation of autism clearly demonstrate that the Geiers are the very opposite of independent, objective researchers. As also demonstrated, the Geiers do not have appropriate expertise to author epidemiologic studies. And as further demonstrated, adding Drs. Young and Hirsch to the project did not salvage the situation. Given the Geiers’ history, it was quite unreasonable for the PSC to agree to fund a research project with the Geiers as co-authors, even if Drs. Young and Hirsch did have appropriate expertise themselves. And the resulting study in fact turned out to be severely flawed, in ways very similar to the deficiencies of the Geiers’ previous studies in the vaccine-autism area. [emphasis added]
In addition to billing $197,000 for their work on Thimerosal exposure in infants and neurodevelopmental disorders, Mark and David Geier billed approximately $167,000 for general work performed for the PSC between 2003 and 2008. Most of this was also deemed unreasonable. The special master expounded at length about David Geier and his lack of qualifications to render services to the court, either as an “expert” or a consultant, or to bill $200-250/hour for those services.
I am not persuaded that it would be reasonable to provide any compensation for the claimed services of David Geier. His only academic degree is a Bachelor of Arts with a major in biology. He has no medical degree or other graduate degrees. It is the petitioners’ burden to demonstrate that it would be reasonable to pay David Geier at his claimed hourly rates of $200 or $250, or at any other rate, but they have failed to demonstrate that he is qualified to provide valuable expert or consultant services to the PSC…. The petitioners have not pointed to any Vaccine Act case in which a special master has awarded compensation for services provided by David Geier.
As in Riggins, the court smelled the unseemly aroma of double-billing.
Further, I note that in Riggins, the special master concluded, after studying the Geiers’ billing records, that for many meetings or consultations, Mark Geier and David Geier seemed to have billed the same hours; the master found that this amounted to unjustified duplication of effort. I have detected the same phenomenon again and again in the billing records submitted in this case, and I find it to be another reason to deny compensation for the hours billed by David Geier.
Finally, I note that the petitioners have failed completely to offer any evidence as to what might be a reasonable hourly rate for David Geier’s services. This is yet another reason for denying compensation for his services.
In short, it is the petitioners’ burden to demonstrate that it would be reasonable to compensate then for the services provided by David Geier, but they have failed to shoulder that burden in this case.
Special Master Hastings then analyzed invoices submitted by both Mark Geier and MedCon and determined that each pertained to the work of both father and son.
I have closely studied the part of Petitioners’ Application that contains the billing documentation pertaining to the Geiers… A summary of payments made to, or bills received from, “Mark Geier,” totaling $355,431.05, shows disbursements to “Medcon, Inc.,” totaling $9,165.00. “Medcon” seems to be an alternative billing vehicle for the Geiers, under which work by either Geier may be billed. The PSC in its billing records intermingled bills for “Mark Geier” and “Medcon.” Both the bills from “Mark Geier” and the bills from “Medcon” bill the PSC for the work of both Mark Geier and David Geier. [emphasis added]
Faced with nearly a third of a million dollars in invoices from Mark Geier, David Geier and MedCon, Inc., the court awarded $33,130.35—about a tenth of the total bill—to Dr. Geier, and nothing to his research assistant.
A Litany of Unprofessional Conduct
In the Spring of 2011, the Maryland Board of Physicians summarily suspended Mark Geier’s license to practice medicine and charged David Geier with the unlicensed practice of medicine; the decisions were reaffirmed the following summer. The Geiers nonetheless persisted in their efforts to extract compensation from the VICP for their services. In her August 2012 decision in Arango v. HHS (Case 09-318V), Special Master Dee Lord made note of the disciplinary actions that disqualified the Geiers from having any role in the case:
David A. Geier, co-author of [An evaluation of serious neurological disorders following immunization], does not possess any advanced medical or scientific degrees.… On May 16, 2011, the Maryland State Board of Physicians (the ‘Board’) charged David Geier with practicing medicine without a license. On July 30, 2012, the Board concluded that David Geier practiced medicine in Maryland without being licensed and imposed a $10,000 civil fine for the violation.
David Geier is the son of Mark R. Geier, M.D., the other co-author of [An evaluation of serious neurological disorders following immunization]. On April 27, 2011, the Board summarily suspended Dr. Geier’s license to practice medicine in Maryland on the grounds that the public health, safety, or welfare imperatively required such action. Six other states, including California, Indiana, Kentucky, New Jersey, Virginia and Washington subsequently suspended Dr. Geier’s license to practice medicine, pending the outcome of the discipline in Maryland. The State Medical Board of Ohio initiated similar action with respect to Dr. Geier’s pending licensure application based on Maryland’s licensing board suspension, concluding:
[T]hat the public health, safety, and welfare imperatively required emergency action based on the determination that doctor’s treatment for autistic children included exposing children to needless risk of harm resulting from misdiagnoses, failing to conduct adequate physical examinations prior to starting treatment, and treating with therapies not supported by evidence-based studies.
On March 22, 2012, following a lengthy appeals process, the Maryland Board upheld the suspension of Dr. Geier’s license to practice medicine.
I do not give probative weight to any evidence based on the work of the Geiers because they lack appropriate medical credentials and have been found by competent authorities to have engaged in unprofessional conduct. Their work product is not reliable.
The Geiers vs. the PSC
Although Mark Geier and David Geier AKA “MedCon, Inc.” had entered into agreements with members of the Petitioners’ Steering Committee to conduct research that would support their clients’ autism causation arguments, there was no guarantee that the court would compensate them. After the six OAP test cases had closed without Dr. Geier being called upon to testify, the Geiers billed the PSC for nearly $600,000. After their bills were rejected by the court and went unpaid by any of the petitioners’ attorneys, the Geiers filed suit, alleging breach of contract, malpractice and civil conspiracy for fraud.
In her February 2012 ruling in Geier v. Conway, Homer & Chin-Caplan, District Court Judge Rosemary Collyer dismissed the case for lack of jurisdiction and failure to state a claim. Her ruling contained much discussion of Dr. Geier’s amply-documented history as a testifying expert in vaccine cases. With respect to the doctor’s apprentice and President of MedCon, Inc., the court noted that:
The special master declined to provide any compensation for the work of David Geier because he was not qualified to serve as a consultant on medical issues.
Judge Collyer concluded:
Given the reaction of Vaccine Court to the Geiers it is doubtful that the Law Firms were particularly benefitted by the Geiers’ services. … The Court takes judicial notice of the orders by which the Vaccine Court determined the value that the Geiers generated to the Vaccine Court petitioners and compensated the Geiers. The Geiers received compensation for the benefit they conferred.
That benefit was considerably less than they had envisioned.
Shocking & Disreputable
In his 2017 fees and costs decision in Hooker v. HHS, Chief Special Master George Hastings expressed his amazement that the petitioners and their attorney, the ubiquitous Clifford Shoemaker, would offer both Mark and David Geier as experts following the disciplinary actions taken against them.
The court noted that Dr. Geier’s expert report was prepared in November 2007, about 5½ years before it was filed; that it was prepared prior to completion of the OAP test cases; that it expounded autism causation theories which had already been extensively litigated and roundly rejected; and that Dr. Geier’s license to practice medicine had been revoked.
With respect to the petitioners’ expert reports—including one by petitioner Brian Hooker himself, one by David Geier, a supplemental report by Mark Geier, and reports by Janet Kern, Boyd Haley and Dr. Stephen Smith—Special Master Hastings wrote:
I found that the Petitioners’ experts were very poorly qualified, sometimes scandalously so, and very unpersuasive in their reports. I found that Respondent’s expert reports were quite persuasive. I found that Petitioners’ theory of causation, that SRH was injured by the mercury contained in the thimerosal ingredient of one or more of SRH’s vaccinations, was exactly the same theory rejected at extreme length and detail in the petitioners’ “second theory” “test cases” in the OAP. In short, I found absolutely no merit in any of Petitioners’ causation evidence advanced in this case.… I conclude that Petitioners’ entire presentation of expert reports, medical literature, and the filings of Dr. Hooker himself, were so defective that their presentation was, in essence, frivolous. [emphasis added]
Special Master Hastings went on to discuss Mark Geier’s license revocation, and the Maryland Board of Physicians’ findings about the quality of his patient care—patient care in which David Geier participated.
The first expert report filed was that of Dr. Mark Geier, and it was shocking to me that in 2013 any Vaccine Act attorney would rely on Dr. Geier, for several reasons.
First, in King v. HHS, I found that it would be unreasonable for the Vaccine Program to compensate counsel for paying Dr. Geier and his co-authors for writing a medical article.… Further, exhibits filed in this case show that the Maryland State Board of Physicians (“Board”) suspended Dr. Geier’s license to practice medicine on April 27, 2011, and then revoked that license on August 22, 2012. Even more disappointingly, when Petitioners’ counsel filed a curriculum vitae of Dr. Geier on October 4, 2013, the fact that his medical license had been suspended and later revoked was not mentioned.
Further, those exhibits also showed that the Board, in fact, based its actions against Dr. Geier specifically on a review of Dr. Geier’s medical care for multiple patients afflicted with ASDs. Among the many reasons given by the Board for revoking Dr. Geier’s medical license were: a) his failure to meet basic medical standards for evaluating patients and keeping adequate records; b) his prescriptions of risky “chelation” therapy to patients who did not need chelation; c) his administration of medications not approved by the Food and Drug Administration, without obtaining adequate informed consent, and his failure to properly monitor the outcome of such treatments; and d) his willful falsification of his professional credentials. The Board concluded that Dr. Geier had displayed “an almost total disregard of basic medical and ethical standards,” and that, “in plain words, Dr. Geier exploited these patients under the guise of providing competent medical treatment.”
Further, while Dr. Geier has published many medical articles concerning ASDs, the Institute of Medicine has evaluated a number of these articles and concluded that they are riddled with problems, and thus are essentially without any value whatsoever in terms of contributing to the study of the causation of ASDs.
After Special Master Hastings discussed disciplinary actions taken against Dr. Stephen Smith, David Geier took his turn on the rotisserie:
Petitioners’ counsel also submitted as an “expert” report a report from Mr. David Geier, the son of Dr. Mark Geier. However, David Geier, according to his own curriculum vitae, lacks any sort of medical education or training. In fact, his most significant qualification is a Bachelor of Arts degree, with a major in biology. Further, David Geier was a co-author with his father on most of the medical articles described above, found by the Institute of Medicine to be worthless. I also note that in Riggins v. HHS, Special Master Golkiewicz found that David Geier was “not qualified to serve as a consultant on the medical issues presented in the Vaccine Program.” I reached the same conclusion in King v. HHS.
It was shocking to me that Petitioners’ counsel even filed the reports of Dr. Mark Geier, Dr. Stephen Smith, and David Geier, in light of the above-described rejection by the Institute of Medicine of the works of the two Geiers, the complete lack of qualifications of David Geier, and the condemnations of both Dr. Geier and Dr. Smith by the medical boards of their respective states. [emphasis added]
Special Master Hastings noted that the petitioners’ allegations were “strongly contradicted” by their child’s medical records and admonished them that he had already warned that they risked not being compensated if they continued with “their flawed, rejected, and discredited causation theory.” Ultimately, he disallowed most of the fees and costs application—not only the cost of commissioning expert reports by Mark and David Geier, but any time Mr. Shoemaker spent interacting with Dr. Geier.
I will make no award for fees and costs incurred after [August 2011], except for a small amount awarded for filing the fees and costs application…. I will also disallow most of the hours counsel spent interacting with Drs. Geier and Megson. Based on my discussion of Dr. Geier above, I find that all hours spent dealing with that disreputable individual are per se unreasonable. [emphasis added]
Questionably Competent & Scientifically Unreliable
A dwindling number of post-2017 VICP decisions mention either Mark or David Geier. A January 2022 ruling in America v. HHS (Case 17-542V) disparages a citation made by a petitioner’s expert to the Geiers’ 2017 VAERS study, Quadrivalent Human Papillomavirus Vaccine and Autoimmune Adverse Events, and cites to numerous VICP decisions critical of their research.
In his July 2022 decision in Chambers v. HHS (Case 19-140V) current Chief Special Master Brian Corcoran noted with disapproval the inclusion of studies by the Geiers in a meta-analysis of studies of vaccines and autoimmune conditions, commenting both on their methodological failings, and on their authors’ reputation:
I nevertheless note that the Geiers have repeatedly, and over a lengthy period of time, been deemed to be questionably-competent and scientifically-unreliable experts in the Vaccine Program—casting significant doubt on any studies they have authored.
In his January 2024 ruling in Stricker v. HHS (Case 18-56V), Special Master Christian Moran found that the Geiers’ analysis of VAERS data in their 2015 paper, A case-control study of quadrivalent human papillomavirus vaccine-associated autoimmune adverse events “was questionable and its authors were not trustworthy.” (The special master’s ruling was later affirmed by Judge Richard A. Hertling.)
Shell Game by-the-Sea
Beginning in 2006, David Geier replaced the statement of affiliation in his publications from “President, MedCon, Inc.” to the much more humanitarian-sounding “Vice-President of the Institute of Chronic Illnesses.” Although he would never disclose his affiliation with MedCon, Inc. in any other peer-reviewed publication, Mr. Geier’s consultancy remains a going concern. Tax filings of the Institute of Chronic Illnesses indicate that beginning in 2011—the year Dr. Geier’s license to practice medicine was suspended, the year that David Geier was charged with the unlicensed practice of medicine, and the year the Geier family relocated to Florida— père et fils frequently moved funds between their personal and tax-exempt accounts.
Between 2011 and 2023, over $2,670,000 in donations to the Institute from Mark Geier, David Geier, Anne Geier, and their enterprises MedCon, Genetic Centers of America, ASD Centers, and DAP Pharmaceuticals, were counterbalanced by nearly $1,500,000 in Institute disbursements to Mark Geier, David Geier and MedCon for both “professional consulting” and “medical consulting” services. (ICI’s expenses also included a one-time payment of $355,000 to Anne Geier for “professional consulting”; over $176,000 in rent for the nonprofit, which is located in the Geier family’s oceanside palazzo; and $20,000 to the LLC which holds title to the home.)
In early 2020, MedCon, Inc. board member Clifford Shoemaker was disbarred for embezzling funds from a disabled client’s bank account, first by the Virginia Bar Association, then by the U.S. Court of Federal Claims. With Mr. Shoemaker now in enforced retirement, and with Dr. Geier deceased, it is unlikely that David Geier, B.A. will ever seek validation as an “expert” in a vaccine injury case again. But that is, perhaps, a minor issue now that the unqualified, disreputable HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. has elevated his equally unqualified, disreputable friend to a paid position at HHS in order to (as Senator Maggie Hassan aptly put it) “relitigate and churn settled science,” or (as sources at the CDC put it), to “prove corruption” at the CDC, or (as I see it) to carry on his unqualified, disreputable father’s mission of sowing unjustified fear and outrage among parents of disabled children and unwarranted suspicion about vaccines.


   Autism One: The yearly antivaccine autism “biomed” quackfest begins
David Gorski
Link
In the world of the anti-vaccine underground, there is one time of the year that looms large. Over the last few years, this time has generally come right around the end of May, usually coinciding with the Memorial Day weekend and the unofficial beginning of the summer vacation season here in the U.S. I’m referring, of course, to Autism One, which blights one of my favorite cities in the world, Chicago, every year about this time. True, of late Autism One has been metastasizing, most recently to blight the city of Toronto and the very grounds of the University of Toronto itself. As you may recall, last fall, when Autism One descended upon Toronto, I described it as “a conference of believers in two things: (1) that vaccines cause autism and (2) that ‘biomedical’ and CAM/IM therapies can treat and even reverse autism,” and it’s true, but Autism One is more than that. It’s a combination of a networking meeting for the anti-vaccine set, a revival meeting for the cult of anti-vaccinationism and autism “biomedical” therapy, and a trade show for “biomed” treatments for autism, all dressed up to appear to be a legitimate scientific conference.
Of all the fake scientific conferences out there, Autism One in Chicago, which begins today, far eclipses all the others, including even Barbara Loe Fisher’s National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC) conference. Closely aligned with the anti-vaccine propaganda group Generation Rescue and its outlet in the blogosphere Age of Autism (both of which, not surprisingly, have been promoting the conference incessantly), Autism One is the granddaddy of fake academic autism conferences, where anyone who’s anyone in the anti-vaccine “autism biomed” underground goes to see and be seen. It even has a keynote address by anti-vaccine celebrity spokesmodel Jenny McCarthy herself this year, just like the previous two years. This year, however, Autism One has expanded from three or four days to a full week, and it has taken on a note of political activism that was generally lacking in previous conferences. In previous years, Autism One pretty much stayed localized to a hotel near O’Hare, far from the center of the city. This time around it’s still at a hotel near O’Hare, but its organizers plan an anti-vaccine protest rally right smack dab in the middle of Grant Park on Wednesday afternoon. All of this leads me to conclud that this year Autism One’s organizers appear to be cementing the relationship between the autism “biomed” movement, the anti-vaccine movement, and the “health freedom” movement.
A cavalcade of anti-vaccine quackery
First and foremost, Autism One is about two things: “biomedical” quackery to treat autistic children (who are, according to many of the dubious practitioners there, autistic because of “vaccine injury”) and promoting the scientifically discredited idea that vaccines cause autism. In fact, this year, Autism One appears to have taken on the flavor of being in part one big “coming out” party for Andrew Wakefield, who somehow also managed to score an interview with Matt Lauer on Monday. Remember, this is the man whose dubious, incompetent, trial lawyer-funded, and probably fraudulent research back in 1998, aided and abetted by the credulous and sensationalistic U.K. press, not only sparked a hysterical fear of the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine resulting in depressed vaccination rates and the resurgence of the measles in the U.K but is arguably the man most responsible for the very existence of the “autism biomed” movement itself. His shoddy and likely fraudulent research was the inspiration that launched a thousand — nay, thousands! — of “biomed” practitioners (a.k.a. quacks) to prey on autistic children. That’s why I thought it would be a useful exercise to take a look at the list of abstracts (just like a real scientific conference!) and make a few observations.
The first thing I noticed when I looked at the schedule is rather telling. I simply searched for the word “vaccine” and immediately noticed that for an autism conference there sure are a lot of references to vaccines! But what is Autism One telling parents about vaccines? What do you think? Let’s find out.
First up on the list is a speaker named Vicky Debold, who is giving a talk entitled What Parents Need to Know About Vaccine Adjuvants. Ms. Debold is described as:
…affiliate faculty member at George Mason University, Health Administration and Policy Department. She previously worked as a health policy analyst for the US Congress at the Physician Payment Review Commission, the Michigan Health and Safety Coalition, and the Michigan State Commission on Patient Safety. Additionally, she has served as an assistant professor at the University of Michigan and as an associate professor and director of the Health Systems Management Program at the University of Detroit, Mercy. Her doctoral degree is from the University of Michigan (1999) – from both the School of Public Health (Health Services Organization and Policy) and the School of Nursing (Health Systems Administration). She was a University of Michigan Regent’s Fellow and completed a post-doctoral fellowship in health services research at the Michigan Peer Review Organization. Dr. Debold’s son, her only child, experienced serious, long-term health problems following receipt of seven live virus and killed bacterial vaccines at his 15-month well-baby appointment. That event sparked her interest in vaccine safety and chronic childhood illness. In addition to serving as a director and committee member for autism non-profit organizations and as the volunteer director of patient safety and a board member of the National Vaccine Information Center, she is the appointed consumer representative to the Food and Drug Administration’s Vaccine and Related Biological Products Advisory Committee (VRBPAC).
Oh, dear. Not my alma mater! Not the University of Michigan! Isn’t it bad enough that Ann Coulter also graduated from the University of Michigan? In any case, of note Debold is a board member of the anti-vaccine organization NVIC. From her abstract, it looks as though Debold is trying to put a reasonable face on the anti-vaccine movement — at least on the surface. Her abstract sounds pretty reasonable until you hit this:
In addition to producing antibodies, vaccine adjuvants can stimulate the immune system to produce abnormal responses in some individuals leading to autoimmunity and chronic diseases such as rheumatoid arthritis and lupus.
I don’t have high hopes for the scientific accuracy of this talk.
Next up is Dr. Mayer Eisenstein. Dr. Eisenstein, as you may recall, has been mentioned several times on this blog, most recently just last week when it was pointed out that he is part of the team that writes anti-vaccine propaganda for the website Medical Voices Vaccine Information Center, the very same website that’s been dodging responding to Mark Crislip’s excellent takedown of one bit of MVVIC’s anti-vaccine propaganda. Dr. Eisenstein, as you may recall, is the founder of the crunchy “alternative” HomeFirst practice in the Chicagoland area. He is noted for claiming that there is no asthma, allergies, ADHD, ADD or Autism in its unvaccinated children based on zero published peer-reviewed evidence. In fact, Eisenstein himself has said:
Eisenstein stresses his observations are not scientific. “The trouble is this is just anecdotal in a sense, because what if every autistic child goes somewhere else and (their family) never calls us or they moved out of state?”
Yet his claim that he has 35,000 unvaccinated children in his practice and has never seen a case of asthma, allergies, ADHD, ADD, or autism in them is taken as Gospel truth in anti-vaccine circles. This time around, at Autism One, Dr. Eisenstein will be speaking on So You Have Decided Not to Vaccinate – How Do You Qualify for a Valid Legal Vaccine Waiver?, and the abstract reads:
Since vaccine mandates are state determined, vaccine laws may vary from state to state. Before submitting any medical, philosophical or religious exemption documentation, I recommend reviewing your state law to determine which of the waivers are applicable in your state. All 50 states in the U.S. allow for medical exemption to childhood vaccines. With the exception of West Virginia and Mississippi, all states also allow for a religious exemption to childhood vaccines. Currently, 17 states have philosophical exemptions to vaccines.
I will address the following questions: Can I give some of the vaccines and not others? Are there medical contraindications to vaccines? Can the state review and deny your physician’s letter objecting to vaccines? Are the chicken pox and rubella vaccines grown on the cells of aborted fetuses? Is mercury still in vaccines? How do I find a sympathetic doctor?
Of note, Dr. Eisenstein was recently in the news for having been an advocate of Mark and David Geier’s chemical castration protocol for autism, as well as a record of harm and death in his practice. And what do vaccines have to do with autism? In the real world, as far as science has been able to ascertain, nothing. In the fantasy world of Autism One, everything. Meanwhile, no form of quackery is off-limits at Autism One. In fact, there will even be homeopaths speaking there about how to use that quackiest of quackeries, homeopathy, to treat autism and “vaccine injury.” For example, two homeopaths named Cindy L. Griffin, DSH-P, DIHom, BME and Lindyl Lanham, DSH-P, BS Spec Ed, both from the Homeopathy Center of Houston, are collaborating to give two talks, one entitled An alternative approach for vaccine injury, which features homeopathy prominently as one of those “alternative” approaches, and another entitled The Houston Homeopathy Method of Sequential Homeopathy: A Drug-Free Alternative to Biomedical Treatment for Children with Autism.
Apparently even the magical thinking that is homeopathy is not too magical for the organizers of Autism One. And if that’s not enough, there’s a naturopath named Darin Ingels, ND (Not a Doctor) presenting on The Role of Allergy Desensitization in Autism, which makes Dr. Lipson’s post last week most timely, as well as another Not a Doctor, Jennifer Johnson, discussing Lymphatic Therapy – the Missing Piece. Get a load of the abstract:
Jennifer Johnson, ND, will speak on lymphatic therapy and how it is the missing link for autism recovery. She will include how lymphatic decongestive therapy prepares the body to be at its optimum level of detoxification prior to laser energetic detox. Also she will include how lymphatic decongestive therapy works in conjunction with the Zyto as well as how it complements IVIG treatment and chelation. This will be done with a slide-show presentation. This will be followed by a demonstration of the electro-lymphatic drainage machine and there will be time for questions and answers.
“Laser energetic detox”? “Lymphatic decongestive therapy”? IVIG treatment and chelation? Truly, no form of autism pseudoscience is too bizarre for Autism One, be it homeopathy or the woo-iest of woo from naturopaths!
Of particular interest to regular readers of this blog is this talk by Laura Hewitson entitled Primate Models for Testing Vaccine Safety. Having had her (and Andrew Wakefield’s) paper on this study withdrawn before officially appearing in the journal NeuroToxicology in the wake of the judgment of the British General Medical Council having found Wakefield to have committed research misconduct. Regular readers may recall that I deconstructed this study, in which Wakefield and Hewitson subjected infant Macacque monkeys to hepatitis B vaccination spiked with extra thimerosal, twice, once on the basis of a couple of abstracts presented at IMFAR and then once based on the actual manuscript describing the study results. Suffice it to say that this study was, in my not-so-humble opinion, bad science, unethical, and a waste of valuable and sensitive primates, who were all killed at the end of the study to examine their brain and organs, as well as to perform whole genome expression profiling on tissues harvested from the GI tract of the dead monkeys. Dr. Hewitson also failed to disclose on her initial abstracts that her husband worked for Thoughtful House and that she and her husband are the parents of a complainant in the Autism Omnibus petition to the Vaccine Court seeking redress based on “vaccine injury” having caused autism in the children involved. As a result of her association with Wakefield, which led to her descent into pseudoscience, Dr. Hewitson saw her once-promising academic career at the University of Pittsburgh tank and ended up joining Wakefield at Thoughtful House. Now that Wakefield has been fired from Thoughtful House, Hewitson remains there. She who once was the learner has now become the master, at least at Thoughful House, while Wakefield is on the outside looking in. Meanwhile, if your research is discredited scientifically, you can always present it at Autism One, as long as it appears to support the belief that vaccines cause autism.
Speaking of Andrew Wakefield, as I said before, Autism One appears to be his “coming out” party after the disrepute he fell into in the wake of the GMC’s ruling, the retraction of his infamous 1998 Lancet paper, and the withdrawal of his NeuroToxicology paper in which he abused baby monkeys by using them for bad science. First of all, he has a new book out entitled Callous Disregard: Autism and Vaccines—The Truth Behind a Tragedy. The title of a book is a play on this passage from the GMC’s ruling on Wakefield’s research misconduct: “You showed a callous disregard for the distress and pain that you knew or ought to have known the children involved might suffer.” Wakefield no doubt thinks that he’s being cheeky and sarcastic by appropriating those words for the title of his book, but the term “callous disregard” fits Wakefield like a glove. Of course, the book is getting rave reviews from the anti-vaccine crowd, but I have yet to see a review from a skeptic. I’m half tempted to see whether I could score a review copy, but after my attempt to read Suzanne Somers’ paean to cancer quackery last fall I’m not sure that would be such a good idea. You’ll notice that there was no part 2 to that series. My brain had a hard time handling all the misinformation there; it caused too much pain.
So what’s Wakfield up to at Autism One? First, he’ll be appearing on a panel with the editors of the anti-vaccine crank blog Age of Autism, where they will tag team a discussion of “AOA’s mission in the coming year and discuss with Andy how to continue to tell the truth about autism.” I can hardly wait. No doubt it will provide me and my fellow SBM bloggers with copious blogging material for the coming year. Then later he’ll be a keynote speaker, where he will discuss in a talk entitled Autism and the vagrant in the brainstem:
This talk examines the possibility that brainstem injury plays a central role in autism. In light of recent observations of brainstem injury in a primate model of vaccine-associated effects on early neurodevelopment, and an analysis of the scientific literature, it is proposed that, as an epicentric event, damage to the dorsal vagal complex (DVC) of the brainstem may be necessary and sufficient to initiate the central and systemic features of autism, including the many that fall outside the behavioral definition of this condition. Mechanisms by which primary systemic inflammation can cause brainstem damage are presented with reference to the published literature. The talk discusses the anatomical predilection of the DVC for injury resulting form a variety of mechanisms including disruption to the blood supply in the developing brain, environmental toxicity and, via retrograde vagal pathways, intestinal inflammation. Ways of examining this theory are discussed.
So now it’s “brainstem injury” due to vaccines, is it? I thought it was gut injury due to measles virus from MMR. Truly, Wakefield is a man with many dubious ideas.
Perhaps the most intriguing event where Andrew Wakefield will appear occurs on Wednesday. It is at this event where Autism One does us skeptics all a great service by demonstrating even more strongly than Jenny McCarthy’s “Green Our Vaccines” rally two years ago that it is about being “anti-vaccine,” not “pro-safe vaccine.”
The anti-vaccine movement “autism biomed” movement meets the “health freedom” movement
One of the biggest examples of either self-delusion or lying that emanates from the anti-vaccine movement is the oh-so-pious and indignant denials that inevitably follow from its members and leaders whenever someone like me has the temerity to point out that they are, in fact, anti-vaccine. The disingenuously angry denials usually take a form something like this, “I’m not anti-vaccine; I’m pro-safe vaccine.” Another variant is for anti-vaccine activists to claim that they aren’t anti-vaccine at all; they’re just “concerned” that children are getting “too many” vaccines “too soon.” What belies these claims, which can be seemingly reasonable on the surface to the uninitiated, is what happens if you try to pin down someone making them on just what, exactly, it would take to convince them that vaccines are safe as administered. A good way to approach this is to try to ask them to tell you specifically exactly what it would take to convince them to vaccinate their next child. What evidence would convince them? What you’ll almost inevitably find, if you push them, is that the answer to that question is: Nothing! Nothing will convince them. Ever!
On cue, seemingly trying very hard to support my oft-stated belief that “pro-safe vaccine” really equals “anti-vaccine,” and the “autism biomed” movement is in reality all about the vaccines, Autism One comes along to back me up. The reason I say that is that on Wednesday, May 26, associated with the Autism One quackfest, there will be a rally in Grant Park, an “American rally for personal rights.” Perusing the website, you’ll rapidly find out that the manifesto of the rally is about vaccines:
We believe in the rights to life, liberty, and personal security for ourselves and our children.
We demand the universal human rights standard of informed consent for all medical interventions. Compulsory vaccination cannot be legally and morally justified.
We affirm the sanctity of personal space, the right to be left alone, and the freedom to make personal health care decisions guided by the professionals of our choosing.
We invite all people, families and organizations committed to protecting these fundamental rights to stand with us in downtown Chicago on May 26, 2010 at our inaugural rally, and to work with us after the event to support grassroots advocacy, education, and leadership in defense of our personal – individual, parental, legal, moral, religious, civil, and human – rights.
Is it a coincidence that this rally is occurring smack dab in the middle of Autism One? Of course not! Is it a coincidence that, at the same time Andy Wakefield is “coming out” after his humiliation in January and February, as well as the impending loss of his medical license in the U.K. and that part of that coming out (not to mention promotion of his book) involves being the keynote speaker for an anti-vaccine rally? Get a load of the promotional video:
If you wanted yet more evidence that the “pro-safe vaccine” movement is really the anti-vaccine movement, here it is. But, wait!, I hear. It’s an entirely legitimate issue about how much power the government should have to require that children be vaccinated and under what circumstances. So it is. It’s a valid political and philosophical question, but a scientific question, not so much, given that the science is firmly behind the safety and efficacy of vaccines. Moreover, the whole “personal rights” bit is a smokescreen to hide the true nature of the rally: Anti-vaccine to the core. In reality, this “personal freedom” angle is very much the intellectual offspring (I think I just choked on the word “intellectual” in this context) of the “health freedom” movement. As I’ve said more times than I can remember, “health freedom” is in practice rarely anything more than demanding freedom for quacks to ply their trade on their marks without any pesky interference from laws, regulation, or the government.
“Vaccine freedom” is little different at its core. It’s also profoundly deceptive for at least two reasons. First, by “informed consent,” American Personal Rights does not mean real, informed consent, with a science-based discussion of the benefits versus the risks of vaccines (which, by the way, is overwhelmingly in favor of vaccinating being safer than not vaccinating). What such groups really mean is an “informed” consent where parents are “informed” of all sorts of scientifically unsupported and intentionally frightening claims, such as the claim that vaccines cause autism, that they’re loaded with “toxins,” that the don’t work, or that they’re very dangerous, all coupled with a vastly exaggerated estimation of the rate at which true vaccine complications occur, which is very, very low. Second, except for two states, parents already have the freedom to decline vaccines. The only real enforcement point of our vaccination policy is admittance to public schools, virtually all of which require children to be up to date on their vaccines before they can attend. Even with that leverage, in nearly every state, there are mechanisms within the law to claim exemptions from vaccination requirements based on religion or even personal philosophy (17 states have “personal philosophy” exemptions, as Dr. Eisenstein himself points out), the latter of which can be something as simple as saying that the parent has some sort of “philosophical objection” to vaccinating their children. In other words, this is a rally for a right that parents in nearly every state already have.
So why bother? Perhaps some of the literature on the website can tell us. First, let’s take a look at the organizations that are participating in the rally. The participants include a veritable who’s who of anti-vaccine cranks, including Age of Autism, Ginger Taylor, Dr. Sherri Tenpenny, Generation Rescue, the Holistic Moms Network, Medical Voices, Mike Adams, TACA, the Australian Vaccination Network, and many others.
For more evidence, let’s take a look at the suggested slogans for rally signs. I’ve selected a few out of the 100 or so slogans there. There’s lots of “freedom” rhetoric, but there are also quite a few signs that can only be described as pure anti-vaccine:
    • 1% US Kids Autistic But Fully Vaccinated
    • Adults Die From Vaccine Reactions, Too
    • CDC Trades Infectious Disease For CHRONIC – Allergies, Autism, ADHD, Asthma, Diabetes…
    • H1N1 Was a TARP For Pharma
    • I Refuse Forced Vaccines
    • If My Child Is Harmed, You Won’t Pay
    • I’m More Afraid Of The Vaccine Than The Flu
    • My Child Was Murdered By Vaccines
    • No Vaccine Liability! Total Immunity If Vaccine Kills You
    • Schools Are Overrun With Vax-Injured Children
    • Stop Experimenting On Our Kids
    • The Ouch Isn’t What Hurts
    • Too Many Shots
    • Too Many Sick Kids
    • Why Does Our Government Want Us Vaccinated So Bad?
And my favorite, the ever-ominous, “There Are No Safe Vaccines.”
Finally, this particular rally has its very own soundtrack.
The American Rally for Personal Rights is pleased to announce that rally speaker Michael Belkin, will for the very first time ever, be performing songs from his upcoming CD at our rally. In 1998, Michael’s daughter died only hours after receiving a required vaccine, sparked by this intensely personal encounter with the negative effects of government mandated vaccines he began a journey of public service which has included providing testimony before Congress, attending vaccine related regulatory sessions and appearing in countless media reports as a vaccine safety advocate.
His journey has found a new path in The Refusers, a musical tribute to the victims (past, present and future) of the government’s misguided mandatory vaccination policy. Inspired by his previous career as a LA session player and recording artist, Michael has brought infectious elements of funk, gospel, rock, and even a touch of punk to this project. Combining this with his pointed lyrics discussing vaccine issues and government-mandated intrusion into our personal lives, The Refusers embodies, in the great American tradition of protest music, a sound that will be heard around the world. With lyrics like “they can keep their flu vaccine” and “a vaccine needle stole my baby away,” this record will have you on your feet shouting “keep your mandates out of my body”!
You think I’m joking? I only wish I were joking, but I’m not, and neither, apparently, is the “American Rally for Personal Rights” or The Refusers. There are three songs listed there:
     1.  Get Your Mandates Out of My Body
     2.  Vaccine Gestapo
     3.  We Don’t Want Their Flu Vaccine
You can actually download these songs here. If you want an example of how anti-vaccine (not to mention inane) these songs are, here are the lyrics to one of them, “Vaccine Gestapo”:
They have swastikas on their shoulders
They’re such patriotic soldiers
They’re like a militia in Montana
They’re a government agency in Atlanta
Vaccine gestapo! Vaccine gestapo!
Vaccine gestapo! Vaccine gestapo!
They’re a medical military priesthood
Just like Adolf they preach the greater good
Consciencious objectors are just little snot
Why don’t you quit complaining and go get your shots
Vaccine gestapo! Vaccine gestapo!
Vaccine gestapo! Vaccine gestapo!
Can we see your papers
Have you had all your shots?
your papers please, your papers please
Have you had all your shots?
They’re got a one track mind of domination
They say vaccines are your obligation
If a bad reaction turns you into a vegetable,
They’ll sneer and tell you you’re expendable
Vaccine gestapo! Vaccine gestapo!
Vaccine gestapo! Vaccine gestapo!
Vaccine gestapo!
Let’s just put it this way: The Clash’s immortal classic “The Guns of Brixton” or “Police on My Back,” this ain’t.
I didn’t know whether to laugh or cry after I listened to this song. I also kept holding out hope that The Refusers were some sort of mischievous, clever parody of anti-vaccine nonsense. They aren’t. They’re dead serious. As hard as it is to believe, these lyrics are absolutely real and appear to be intended completely sincerely. Truly, the anti-vaccine movement has degenerated to the point where it is impossible to distinguish real from parody. Maybe I’ll claim another law (well, a corollary, anyway) and hereby name it the Gorski Corollary of Poe’s Law:
Without a winking smiley or other blatant display of humor, it is utterly impossible to parody antivaccinationists in such a way that someone won’t mistake for the genuine article.
Songs like this are impossible to parody. What was that again about Andrew Wakefield and J.B. Handley swearing to high heaven that they aren’t anti-vaccine?
Autism One: An anti-vaccine quackfest fused with the “health freedom” movement
It has been said that it’s impossible to reason a person out of a viewpoint that he has not reasoned himself into. The anti-vaccine world view is just such a viewpoint. There is no convincing (or even good) scientific evidence that vaccines cause autism or any of the other conditions attributed to them by the anti-vaccine fringe, and there is good scientific evidence that vaccines are effective at preventing the diseases for which they are designed and very safe. Serious vaccine injuries are not nonexistent, but they are rare. Again, the risk-benefit ratio for vaccines is overwhelmingly in favor of being vaccinated.
Generation Rescue, Age of Autism, and Autism One, as well as other anti-vaccine organizations, try very, very hard to paint their viewpoint as science-based. It is not. The question of whether vaccines cause autism or all the other conditions attributed to them has been extensively studied over the last decade, and the evidence shows that these vaccines are safe, the efforts of the anti-vaccine movement to discredit the research notwithstanding. The best that groups like Generation Rescue can come up with are incompetently performed non-studies, dubious telephone surveys that don’t show what they think they show, and unethical monkey experiments. When scientists and skeptics point out the utter intellectual and scientific vacuity of these “studies” and attempts to discredit existing science, often they are attacked in misogynistic terms (if they are female) or just smeared (if they are Steve Novella, Paul Offit, or others), sometimes to truly despicable extremes.
Unfortunately, the alignment of the anti-vaccine autism “biomed” movement with the health freedom movement is not unexpected. The two fit together perfectly, because the “health freedom” movement vigorously resists all attempts to regulate quackery and dubious supplements, while the anti-vaccine movement, because of its extreme distrust and loathing of vaccines and anything that smacks of a vaccine mandate, can fit its agenda comfortably within that of the supplement hawkers wanting to be able to make whatever health claims they like without any pesky interference from the FDA or FTC.
In the end, it’s not about vaccine “injury.” It’s not about autism. It’s not about science. It’s not even about “health freedom,” really, other than as a convenient political justification for wanting to end vaccine mandates that just happens to use libertarian rhetoric that resonates among many Americans. It’s about “bringing the U.S. vaccine program to its knees.” I know this because J.B. Handley himself, the founder of Generation Rescue and major force behind Age of Autism, tells us this is so.
Autism One and The American Rally for Personal Rights are just more of his propaganda tools to try to accomplish that end.

Naturopathy vs. Science: Autism
Scott Gavura on November 20, 2014
Link

Just when I thought I was out, they pull me back in. My blogging plan was to take a break from my series of naturopathy versus science posts, where I’ve been contrasting the advice from naturopaths against the scientific evidence. From a blogging perspective, naturopathy is a fascinating subject to scrutinize as there is seemingly no end of conditions for which naturopaths offer advice that is at odds with the scientific evidence. From a health care perspective, however, reading the advice of naturopaths is troubling. Naturopaths promote themselves as health professionals capable of providing primary care, just like medical doctors. And they’re increasingly seeking (and obtaining) physician-like privileges from governments. Naturopathy seems to be getting an easy ride from regulators, despite a lack of evidence that shows naturopathy offers anything distinctly useful or incrementally superior to science-based medicine.
Defining the scope of “naturopathic” treatment is difficult. Naturopaths offer an array of disparate health practices like homeopathy, acupuncture and herbalism that are only linked by the (now discarded) belief in vitalism – the idea we have a “life force”. From this philosophy can sometimes emerge reasonable health advice, but that has little to do with the science or the evidence. As long as it’s congruent with the naturopathic belief system, it’s acceptably “naturopathic”. In past posts I’ve looked at the naturopathic perspectives on fake diseases, infertility, prenatal vitamins, vaccinations, allergies and even scientific facts themselves. An advertisement passed to me this week promoted a naturopath who claims to treat pediatric conditions like ADHD and learning disabilities:
The Learning Disabilities Association is pleased to present this Workshop for Parents and Professionals:ADHD and LD NaturallyGuest Speaker: Dr. Joseph SteyrDo you want to know more about natural treatments for ADHD and Learning Disabilities? Dr. Steyr is a Naturopathic Doctor and also has been diagnosed with a Learning Disability since he was a young child. His talk will start with a short introduction to what is Naturopathic Medicine and continue to a discussion of the biology of ADHD/LD. Using that foundation of understanding we will then go over ideas of how nutrition, herbal and homeopathic medicine is used to help support and treat people living with ADHD or LD.
Naturopaths using homeopathy is nothing new (it’s a “clinical science” within their practice), but this bulletin was distributed by the Toronto District School Board, the largest school board in Canada. As a Toronto resident [full disclosure: I have family members in TDSB schools] I’ve always understood that the TDSB was large enough to manage children with special needs and learning disabilities appropriately. It’s a big board with the capacity to offer specialized, focused care. So I was disappointed to see the school board describing homeopathy as “medicine”, and permitting a naturopath to speak. This is especially concerning given that Toronto Public Health notes that some Toronto public schools have up to 40% of students with “exemptions” from the vaccination schedule. Given naturopathy as a practice is antagonistic to vaccination, I wondered if this naturopath shared the perspective of his peers. What I found was troubling. I’ve been reading far too much this week about how how alternative medicine and its purveyors can harm children, so it’s frustrating to see poor thinking about science promoted by academic and charitable organizations that should know better. What’s even more alarming than naturopathy for ADHD and learning disabilities is the naturopathic approach to autism, a condition that naturopaths claim is caused by vaccines, and can be treated with naturopathy.
Autism is a recurrent topic at SBM largely because of the manufactroversy between vaccines and autism, a link that was never based on any credible evidence. Autism is also the unfortunate target of a cornucopia of quackery, all claiming to offer benefit in areas where science-based medicine may not offer satisfactory answers or treatments. The problems with the “naturopathic” approach to autism become clear with an understanding of the science of the disease. Autism can be described as a spectrum of neurodevelopmental cognitive disorders and delays, with variable effects on communication and socialization. There’s no known single cause, and while the disease seems to be strongly influenced by genetics there are a number of factors that are hypothesized to contribute, which include environmental components. While the scientific understanding of autism continues to grow, there are still maddening gaps in the evidence base. There is no cure for autism, but there are evidence-based approaches that can be effective.
Autism biomed
The lack of a “cure” for autism hasn’t stopped alternative medicine proponents from bringing forward their own (unproven) treatments. “Autism biomed” is short for biomedical, and is the umbrella term for the interventions used to “treat” autism medically. There are countless “biomedical” treatments for autism, and they’re offered by alternative (and sometimes conventional) practitioners. What proponents of “autism biomed” treatments always have in common is that they proclaim a superior understanding of autism over “conventional” medicine. And with this special insight comes the confidence that their particular biomed treatments are effective. Their entire perspective on autism as a disease may be quite different. Because they believe autism has external triggers and causes, they see autism as something “done” to a child that can therefore be “undone” with the right treatment: biomed. Consequently it’s not uncommon to see biomed practitioners claim that autism is either curable or highly treatable with their treatments. Biomed treatments can range from mild interventions (like modest dietary changes) to the truly horrific, like chemical castration or bleach enemas. Joseph Steyr, the naturopath noted above, is a proponent of autism biomed. Taking a closer look at his website, his description of biomedical treatment neatly encapsulates the biomed belief system:
The Biomedical Approach believes that environmental triggers (infectious agents, vaccines, foods, pesticides, pollutants/heavy metals) accumulate to a threshold point where Autism starts. These factors can trigger Autism on their own, or in conjunction with genetic susceptibilities. Once Autism begins, untreated triggers and nutrition deficiencies will lead to a worsening of the condition. Starting Biomedical Approach treatments, along with Behavioural therapies, as early as possible increases the chances that Autistic behaviours can be reduced or possibly eliminated. Naturopathic medicine offers many treatment options, from therapeutic diets, herbal (botanical) medicines, vitamin and mineral supplements, to homeopathic remedies, hydrotherapy (waterbased therapies such as foot baths and low‐heat infrared saunas) and (needle‐free) acupuncture.
To biomed purveyors like Steyr, autism is “triggered” by products like vaccines. Other naturopaths hold these same beliefs. Hilary Andrews, a naturopath in Portland Oregon claims:
While the measles-mumps-rubella or MMR vaccine has been strongly linked to the onset of autism, I believe that prior vaccinations also play a cumulative role in this disease. Current vaccination schedules overload very young, fragile immune systems with a huge number of viruses. The number of vaccinations administered to children has more than doubled during the last decade. Today, a child receives approximately 33 doses of 10 different vaccines before the age of six.
To naturopaths, vaccines are yet another “toxin” triggering autism spectrum as well as conditions like food allergies and “nutrient sensitivities”. To detoxify your autistic child, Steyr offers useless but probably harmless treatments like homeopathy and foot baths. He also offers treatments with greater risk for harm, like herbalism or the quackery of hyperbaric oxygen. But Steyr is no rogue naturopath. There is no shortage of naturopaths offering biomedical treatments for autism. A comprehensive list of treatments would be impossible – but here are some of the common treatments promoted by naturopaths:
CEASE therapy
Anke Zimmerman, a naturopath in Victoria, British Columbia, offers Complete Elimination of Autistic Spectrum Expression (CEASE) therapy which uses homeopathy to allegedly rid the autistic child of vaccine toxins. Homeopathy is an elaborate placebo system, with no medicinal effects. Here it is pseudoscience that’s neatly packaged snake oil and promoted to parents of autistic children.
Autonomic response testing
Eugene Quan, a Calgary naturopath claims he can cure autism:
We now know that autism is not a psychological disorder. It is biomedical … viruses, bacteria, candida, parasites, and heavy metals cause the behaviours that lead to an autism diagnosis. Once you remove what is causing the symptoms, you can remove the diagnosis … Dr. Quan at Western Naturopathic in Calgary can help your child become autism-free in 1-2 years. Dr. Quan uses Autonomic Response Testing for clear patient assessments, resulting in successful individualized treatment plans. Dr. Quan guides us through a myriad of options, organ-supportive protocols, the vaccine issues, healing the gut, parasites, mould sensitivity, stemming, seizures, speech issues, tonsils, soul awareness, and biofilm elimination. His approach is making a positive difference in the lives of many children and parents searching for options.
Autonomic Response Testing is a variation of applied kinesiology, where muscles are “tested” to determine “sensitivities” to different products. ART is complete pseudoscience and there’s no scientific evidence that ART or applied kinesiology is anything other than a parlour trick – or in this case, a bogus diagnostic.
Food intolerance testing
Sharon Behrendt, a naturopath in Orleans, Ontario, claims that children with autism are suffering from food allergies:
Many children with ASD have food allergies, due to abnormalities in their digestive and/or immune systems. If food is not broken down and digested, then the partly digested food can pass from the gastrointestinal tract into the bloodstream. The immune system recognizes those foods as foreign to the body, and may launch an immune response to those foods, including brain inflammation. These food allergy reactions are called IgG, or delayed, food reactions, as they can take hours or even a couple of days to occur.
Perhaps not surprisingly, Behrendt wants you to stay away from gluten and milk. She also claims:
Removing allergic foods can result in a wide range of improvements in up to 65% of ASD children, in particular improvements in behavior, focus and concentration.
Citation required. I’ve blogged extensively about how naturopaths do not diagnose or treat allergies according to scientific principles. IgG food testing offered by naturopaths is clinically useless and is not recommended by medical professionals for allergy testing. IgG testing leads to unnecessary and potentially-harmful food restrictions, with no relationship between the IgG test and autism.
Behrendt also recommends juicing (delicious, but medically useless) and B12 injections (useless, unless you’re deficient).
Supplements, supplements, supplements
Marianne Fernance, a naturopath in Brisbane, Australia, recommends detoxification, but also vitamin B12, zinc, and magnesium, as well as essential fatty acids for children with autism. The reality is that many children with autism are placed on (sometimes highly restrictive) diets, which increases the risk of nutritional deficiencies if close attention isn’t paid to nutrient intake. The evidence seems to show that special diets do not work for autism, so unless there is a clear dietary restriction or deficiency, supplementation should not be necessary.
Low-dose naltrexone
Nicola McFadzean Ducharme, a naturopath in San Diego, California, recommends low-dose naltrexone for autism. Steven Novella has a much longer summary of the lack of evidence that supports LDN. In short, LDN is an opiate antagonist, usually used to treat narcotic overdoses by blocking the drug’s action at the cell receptor. When used at very low doses, there’s no convincing evidence it has any established role in the treatment of autism.
Chelation
McFadzean Ducharme also advertises chelation, a common pseudoscientific treatment offered by naturopaths:
Heavy metal toxicity is a key component in many children suffering with autistic-spectrum disorders. Whether through exposure via environmental factors such as contaminated food or water, or vaccinations these toxins are detrimental to your child’s health. The detection of toxicity levels of heavy metals is challenging and sometimes difficult to quantify. Tests such as hair analysis (Great Plains or Doctor’s Data) are a good place to start and can give some useful information with regards to the potential of heavy metal poisoning. However, it is important to realize that hair testing is a screening tool and further diagnostics may be necessary to qualify heavy metal toxicity.
Chelation has legitimate uses when it’s part of a protocol for actual heavy metal poisoning. You don’t diagnose heavy metal poisoning with hair testing, however. The hair testing is simply used to give the provider the impetus to recommend useless treatments. When used by alternative medicine providers, chelation is quackery used to remove fictitious “toxins” in the body. There is no credible evidence that supports the use of chelation in autism. What’s concerning about chelation is that the intravenous infusions are not without risks, and chelating children with autism has caused deaths.
Conclusion: Naturopaths can’t treat autism
Like the other medical conditions they claim to treat, naturopaths do not look at autism in science-based ways. Many seem to place a strong emphasis on environmental factors as causes, sometimes calling out vaccines as contributors. Naturopaths offer an array of pseudoscientific treatments they call “biomedical”, with some practitioners claiming that autism biomed can “cure” autism. The reality of autism biomed is quite different than the vision promoted by practitioners. There are countless autism biomed interventions, but there is one universal feature: There is no convincing evidence that autism biomed treatments have any meaningful therapeutic effects on the features of autism. Autism biomed is anecdote driven experimentation and ultimately health quackery. There is no convincing evidence that naturopathy has anything meaningful to offer for the treatment of autism.

CEASE therapy for autism: Homeopathic quackery and “self regulation” by naturopathic boards
Naturopathy is quackery. If you doubt this, consider that you can’t have naturopathy without homeopathy. What’s even worse is when naturopaths subject autistic children to quackery like CEASE therapy. Expecting any naturopathic regulatory board to investigate quackery in naturopathy is the proverbial fox guarding the henhouse.
David Gorski on May 28, 2018
Link

[Editor’s note: Today is a holiday in the US, and your humble managing editor spent much of it working on a grant, a book chapter, and, all day yesterday in Toledo on family business. As a result, I didn’t have time to produce one of my usual 5,000-word epics. I do, however, have a post that some of you might have seen before (and many probably have not) from my not-so-secret other blog, modified and repurposed for SBM. I’ll be back next week as usual. In the meantime, I’ll be holed up working on a grant and book chapter in my air-conditioned office, given that it’s supposed to go up to 96° F here in my neck of the woods. That’s too much heat for me to venture outside without a damned good reason.]
We here at SBM write about naturopathy a lot because, almost alone among alternative medicine “specialties,” naturopaths think of themselves as real physicians. They aren’t, of course. They are basically cosplaying real physicians, but they really do think that their education, training, and methodology are equal to that of MDs (and, in the US, DOs), even though it’s been discussed many times here and elsewhere why they are not, why naturopathic “accreditation” is a joke, and just how low standards are in naturopathic “medical” schools. I personally have discussed many incidents of naturopathic quackery that are, as much as naturopaths deny it, well within the accepted practice of naturopaths. I’m referring, of course, to treatments like the use of saliva from a rabid dog as an “approved” remedy to treat a variety of conditions, how naturopaths can make even Epsom salts fatal, the horror of what happens when a naturopath tries to treat pertussis “naturally,” or, thanks to lax regulations on compounding pharmacies, a clean kill by a naturopathic quack injecting curcumin intravenously. This latter incident, in particular, resulted not in naturopaths in California trying to clean up their acts but rather in their circling the wagons to defend their profession. It was also a very good illustration of why naturopathic licensure doesn’t protect patients from bad naturopaths because naturopathy is quackery by its very nature. “Licensed naturopaths” are no safer than any other naturopath.
Don’t even get me started on “stuff” naturopaths say when they think no non-naturopaths are listening, or the antivaccine quackery that is at the heart of naturopathy, such that the vast majority of naturopaths being antivaccine. Yes, I know that there are a few who are not (although I point out that even some of those, when tweaked, reveal antivaccine tendencies), but they are vastly outnumbered by the majority who range from moderately antivaccine to rabidly antivaccine. (Maybe that could be treated with a bit of homeopathic Lyssinum)
Given that naturopaths are making yet another effort to achieve licensure in my state of Michigan (and, sadly, having some success at it), I’m likely to be writing more than usual about naturopathic quackery (but I repeat myself) more than usual, the better to build an armamentarium of examples of why naturopathy is not medicine and why it endangers patients. So, when several people Tweeted this story at me, I took interest. So did Jann, who wrote about this legislative alchemy last week, but, since I live in the state, I figured it wouldn’t hurt to add my take on the story:
The College of Naturopathic Physicians is investigating a complaint launched against three B.C. practioners.
The registered naturopaths are said to be offering a treatment known as “CEASE” – Complete Elimination of Autism Spectrum Expression. The idea is largely based on the unscientific claim that Autism is caused primarily by vaccines.
In the treatment, children are “detoxified” using a highly diluted version of the causative agent, or toxin, in order to “purify” the body.
Who are the three naturopaths? Another news story reveals their names:
B.C. naturopaths Anke Zimmermann, Janice Potter and Margret Holland are all certified CEASE practitioners, and the college has acknowledged it is investigating the public complaint against them.
Anke Zimmerman? Hmmm. Where have we heard that name before? Oh, yes, I remember. She’s the naturopath who loves to use homeopathy about whose use of a homeopathic remedy supposedly derived from the saliva of a rabid dog to treat a boy with behavioral issues I wrote about last month. She also uses a homeopathic remedy supposedly derived from gonorrhea. (I swear, you can’t make stuff like this up. At least, I can’t.)
So what is CEASE therapy?
First, for those not familiar with homeopathy, I do need to do a little primer again. (I know, I know, there probably aren’t that many readers not familiar with The One Quackery To Rule Them All, but I do occasionally get new readers, and I don’t want to force them to click a link to learn what homeopathy is.) As I like to say, homeopathy doesn’t really qualify even as pseudoscience given that there’s nothing scientific about it and that in reality it shows far more similarity to sympathetic magic than anything else. In other words, there isn’t even enough of patina of science slathered over the quackery to qualify as pseudoscience. It’s magical thinking, pure and simple, in which homeopaths believe that diluting a remedy makes it stronger, but only if it is shaken vigorously (succussed) between each serial dilution step. Even more magically, they believe that it is possible for a compound that has been diluted many orders of magnitude more than Avagadro’s number, such that it’s exceedingly unlikely that even a single molecule of active substance remains, to have a therapeutic effect. They justify this by claiming that water has “memory” and retains some sort of “imprint” of the substance that it’s been in contact with. Never mind that there’s no evidence that water has “memory” beyond an extraordinarily brief period of time. Homeopaths are impervious to reason.
So CEASE therapy involves homeopathy, which is more than enough to make it quackery. That’s not all, though. It also involves the belief that vaccines are the cause of autism, which they are not. So let’s take a look at CEASE therapy again. It’s an invention/delusion of an actual MD (unfortunately) named Tinus Smits, who “discovered” CEASE:
Dr. Smits discovered in his practice with over 300 cases the foundation of CEASE therapy and came to his hypothisis [sic] of what causes autism. In his experience autism is an accumulation of different causes and about 70% is due to vaccines, 25% to toxic medication and other toxic substances, 5% to some diseases. With isotherapy (see below), a form of homeopathy using the causative substances themselves in homeopathic preparation, the toxic imprints can be erased.
He continues:
The treatment of autistic children and even adults has matured through 300 cases over the last three years and is called CEASE Therapy, which stands for Complete Elimination of Autistic Spectrum Expression. Step by step all asumed [sic] causative factors (vaccines, regular medication, environmental toxic exposures, effects of illness, etc.) are detoxified with the homeopathically prepared, that is diluted and potentized substances that were administered prior to the onset of autism. Currently we use the 30C, 200C, 1M and 10M potencies to clear out the energetic field of the patient from the imprint of toxic substances or diseases.
Of course, a 30C dilution means 30 serial 100-fold dilutions, or a 1060-fold dilution. A 200C dilution means 200 serial 100-fold dilutions, or a 10400-fold dilution. 1M means 1,000C, or a 102,000-fold dilution. You get the idea. Indeed, one can’t help in these situations to point out that Avagadro’s number is approximately 6 x 1023. That means if you dilute a one molar solution of something by approximately 12C (1024), then the solution is highly unlikely to have more than one or two molecules of the substance left. Take the dilution up to 30C, 100C, and beyond, and the odds rapidly become vanishingly small that a single molecule will remain. How small? Well, for a comparison that I frequently use when I’m giving talks that include a section on homeopathy, there are only estimated to be approximately 1080 atoms in the observable universe. Also remember, when Smits says that he’s using these different potencies, what he’s doing is increasing the “potency” at each step by using a more diluted remedy:
The duration of a remedy course depends on the severity of the problems and the reactions of the patient and can vary from 2 weeks to 2 months. Potencies should be repeated until no further improvement is seen before passsing [sic] to the next poetency [sic]. After each course a 1 or 2 week break is applied. The administration is carried out by letting 2 granules melt in the mouth.
So basically Smits is deluded into thinking that he’s using increasingly strong medicine to treat his patients.
What, however, is “isotherapy”? Smits is happy to explain:
Using the causative substances as a homeopathic remedy, their profound toxic effects can be witnessed as the children begin to react to the remedies. The reactions on the isopathic remedies are so characteristic, that there can be no doubt about the existence of a link between the toxins as the cause and the development of Autism as its effects although this is not considered as scientific proof. In this way Dr. Smits discovered, step by step, why autism and other behavioral problems, with their specific developmental problems, have so dramatically increased over the last ten to twenty years. It also became clear that autistic children do not suffer from one single cause but from an accumulation of different causes.
Do tell. So it sounds as though Smits uses vaccines and other “toxins” as the basis for his homeopathic “detoxification.” Of course, inquiring minds want to know: How much of each vaccine is in the starting material? Does he replicate the CDC vaccination schedule and then use some of that as his starting tincture for his homeopathic dilutions? This is about as close to an explanation as Smits comes:
The homeopathic method as applied in the treatment of vaccination damage consists of administering four successive remedies of the suspected vaccine.
I’m guessing Smits must use a lot of MMR. Actually, no he doesn’t. After all, if he’s making such diluted solutions of vaccine he could buy one vial and then use it for decades. Later, he claims:
All autistic children should be detoxified using the homeopathically diluted remedies of the vaccines that have been administered to the child.
And:
Autistic children should never again be vaccinated!
One more time. Vaccines do not, as far as science has been able to tell, cause autism. Many have been the epidemiological studies, and none of the large, well-designed ones have found a hint of a whisper of an association between vaccination and an increased risk of autism. By urging that autistic children never be vaccinated again, he is placing them in danger of infectious disease and turning them into vectors to spread infection.
Of course, homeopathy isn’t the only quackery in CEASE. As any good quack is, Dr. Smits is very much into high dose vitamin C, claiming that it “seems to play an essential role in protecting children against the adverse effects of vaccinations or other stress inducing events.” Whether vitamin C plays a role in protecting against stress-inducing events is still up for discussion, but it surely doesn’t prevent, treat, or cure autism.
Let’s conclude by getting to training. The three naturopaths being investigated are listed as being “certified CEASE practitioners.” Apparently, it means undergoing “training” by one of a few CEASE practitioners who appear to be acolytes of Dr. Smits, such as Kim Kalina. There’s a CEASE Facebook page showing various training sessions, such as:
You get the idea. Show up at a CEASE course, and get a certificate that’s not worth the paper it’s printed on. But what do these courses cover? Here’s one by Kim Kalina herself given last summer:
The course will cover
    • how to individualise, evaluate the need for and accurately apply each of the core components of CEASE – Isotherapy Remedies, Orthomolecular Supplements and the ‘Saturday’ Remedies
    • how to recognise which cases are best suited to CEASE vs Classical Homeopathy
    • the additional case-taking skills, questions and information needed in a CEASE case
    • the key ‘ Saturday’ remedies, potencies and posology indicated in autism cases, as well as other frequently indicated remedies in general CEASE cases – including specific Inspiring Homeopathy, Matridonal and Sarcode remedies.
    • the key Orthomolecular supports needed to support cellular detoxification in various types of CEASE cases, including supplements, vitamins, baths, etc.
    • how to apply and adjust the Isotherapy components of CEASE, including resources for info about drugs, vaccines etc. and extensive vaccine charts Kim has personally developed to enable practitioners to quickly identify which vaccine may need to be cleared based on unique characteristic symptoms of each
    • how to manage CEASE cases – this is perhaps the single most important aspect of the training, and Kim uses several of her own cases (not just autism cases), as well as FAQ’s from clients and practitioners, to take participants through many follow-ups, crises, etc. so that practitioners can learn how to handle the many case management issues that can arise and how to correctly interpret and manage each one
    • how to manage herxheimer reactions – don’t know what these are? This is essential info if you want to use CEASE safely and appropriately!
    • other supports and therapies that are very beneficial in CEASE cases, particularly in the management of these complex cases – specific cell salts, bowel nosodes, flower essences and additional therapies to consider that can help the healing process to unfold much more gently and easily
Such a lot of quackery. I note that, elsewhere, it is revealed that Smits died in 2010 and Kalina is carrying on his “legacy,” such as it is. She is also described as “one of the five approved instructors for the CEASE Organization (the others being in the Netherlands, Germany and Sweden), and brings extensive experience in both teaching and clinical case management to the CEASE community.” Kalina also misuses the concept of the Herxheimer reaction, which is sometimes seen after the initiation of antibacterials for tick-borne relapsing fever due to the release of endotoxin-like products by microorganisms as they die off during antibiotic treatment. It was first described as a reaction to the treatment of syphilis with penicillin and is also seen after treatment of other diseases caused by spirochetes, such as Lyme disease and leptospirosis. Yes, basically, Kalina is claiming that CEASE therapy can cause a “healing crisis” in which the patient gets worse before getting better. This is a common claim among quacks.
So what will happen? It’s noted in one story:
College bylaws prohibit false and misleading advertising, including marketing “likely to create in the mind of the recipient or intended recipient an unjustified expectation about the results which the registrant can achieve.”
The college also forbids naturopaths from advising against vaccination unless there is a “sound, and properly documented, medical rationale for doing so.”
I expect that nothing will come of this complaint against these three naturopaths. After all, if any “board” of naturopathy were actually to enforce standards like the ones above, it would have to take away the license of pretty much every naturopath under its regulatory authority.
Michigan legislators, take note. This is what naturopaths want for Michigan, and, if you pass a naturopathic licensure bill into law, this is what they will get.

The antivaccine movement and “autism biomed” versus “outgrowing” autism
David Gorski on January 21, 2013
Link
A commonly misunderstood aspect of autism and autism spectrum disorders (particularly by antivaccinationists and believers in the quackery known as “autism biomed”) is that autism is not a condition of developmental stasis. It is a condition of developmental delay. Autistic children can and do exhibit improvement in their symptoms simply through growth and development. However, parents who subject their children to “autism biomed” quackery of the sort championed by Jenny McCarthy and others seem to view autism as a condition of developmental stasis. That’s why they so easily and predictably attribute any improvement in their children to whatever quackery du jour they are using on them. It’s also why, in order to determine whether a given intervention in autism has any real effect, randomized controlled trials are required. Indeed, it’s not so difficult to see why, if you take into account the widespread belief that autistic children do not improve, along with parents’ imperfect human memories riddled with confirmation bias, confusing correlation with causation, and other confounders like regression to the mean, so many parents believe that “autism biomed” treatments have actually helped their children. Moreover, improvements observed in autistic children tend to be uneven, with periods of little change interspersed with periods of rapid development. Should such a period of rapid development appear after a “biomed” intervention, guess what gets the credit for the improvement?
But how much improvement is possible? Do autistic children “recover,” and, if they do, how much can they recover? The autism biomed movement is rife with stories of “recovered” children, but often, if you investigate these stories, they turn out to be less than convincing, not unlike the way that alternative medicine cancer “cure” testimonials tend not to be so impressive when examined closely. However, in the case of autism, this isn’t always the case. There are clearly children who lose their diagnosis of autism or ASD, with observations published as far back as 1970, when Rutter reported that 1.5% of adults who had been diagnosed with autism were functioning normally, while 30 years later Sigman et al reported that 17% of autistic children in their group lost their diagnosis and 10 years after that Kleinman et al reported that up to 19% of autistic children “lose their diagnosis.” The reason for this observation is hotly debated, and until fairly recently it was often assumed that these children’s recoveries were in fact not true recoveries but children who were either misdiagnosed or overdiagnosed. Such an assumption made intuitive sense because such an outcome is more likely with children diagnosed with Asperger’s disorder or pervasive developmental disorder, not otherwise specified (PDD-NOS), both of which are categories that resulted from the expansion of the diagnostic criteria for autism. Be that as it may, when you boil it all down, it is estimated that between 3% and 25% of autistic children “lose their diagnosis.” However, few of these studies explicitly address whether the social and communication abilities of these children are fully typical.
Outgrowing symptoms of autism
A recent study might help clarify what degree of recovery is and is not possible. Most of the previous studies before this have been small and did not look specifically at the outcomes people are curious about. Published in The Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry by Fein et al and entitled “Optimal outcome in individuals with a history of autism“, this study got some news coverage last week under titles such as “Some With Autism Diagnosis Can Overcome Symptoms, Study Finds“; “Scientists seek clues in kids who outgrow autism symptoms“; “Some children outgrow autism: study“; “Health Buzz: Can Autism Fade Over Time?“; and “Children ‘may grow out of autism’“. The authors set the stage in their introduction after surveying the literature, some of which I’ve touched on above:
Several tentative conclusions thus seem warranted based on prior research: (a) losing the ASD diagnosis is a possibility for a minority of children and, at least for some children, is not due to misdiagnosis; (b) ‘optimal outcome’ is associated with higher cognitive functioning and somewhat milder initial symptoms; (c) residual difficulties with language, attention, executive or emotional functioning may persist and need to be characterized. Definitively documenting the existence and characteristics of individuals who lose the diagnosis of autism has important implications for understanding the neurobiology of autism, the impact of intervention on functioning, and the mechanisms underlying improvement. Structural and functional imaging of this group may shed light on whether brain anatomy and function have normalized, or whether normal behavior has been achieved through compensatory mechanisms. The current project aims to document a group of such OO individuals, explore possible persistent weaknesses in areas central to ASD, characterize the range of treatments they received, and look for biological characteristics through structural and functional MRI.
Basically, what the authors did was to characterize these children who would be referred to by antivaccinationists as “recovered.” To do this, they identified a group of 34 children who had had a diagnosis of autism/ASD but no longer meet the criteria for the diagnosis, referred to as “optimal outcome” (OO) above. These children were compared with a group of 44 age- and nonverbal IQ-matched children with high functioning autism (HFA) and 34 children undergoing typical development (TD). What makes this study stand out is that the investigators did something very critical. They were very careful to accept only children whose diagnosis had been made by a physician or psychologist specializing in autism before the age of five verified with a written diagnostic report provided by the parents. Then, as a second step to confirm the diagnosis, the investigators took each report, removed language about the diagnosis, summary, and recommendations but leaving descriptions of the child’s behavior. This redacted reporta were then reviewed in a blinded fashion by one of the co-investigators, along with a bunch of “foil” (a.k.a. control) reports from children with non-ASD diagnoses, such as global delay or language disorder. All foils were correctly rejected, and four OO children’s reports were rejected for inadequate documentation of diagnosis. The second screen was to have the child’s current status evaluated, with clinicians with at least 15 years of experience, who reviewed that the child’s Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule (ADOS) scores were below ASD thresholds and that in their clinical judgment an ASD was not present.
The overall schema is summarized below:
Other criteria included that the children in the OO group had to be fully included in regular education classes with no one-on-one assistance and no education services to address autism deficits (e.g., no social skills training) and that scores on another communication-related test had to be at or above a certain level.
So what next? Well, the authors interviewed the parents and tested the children using several measures, with, where knowledge of group could affect scoring, the tests scored by a researcher blinded to what experimental group the children. These measures included ADOS, Autism Diagnostic Interview-Revised (ADI-R); Social Communication Questionnaire (SCQ); Wechsler Abbreviated Scale of Intelligence (WASI); Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales (VABS); Benton Facial Recognition Test; Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals-IV (CELF-IV); and the Edinburgh Handedness Inventory. Sex, age, and handedness didn’t differ between the three groups, but verbal IQ was 7 points lower in the HFA group, compared to the OO and TD groups, where it was in the high-average range.
Losing the diagnosis
The investigators reported a number of observations of their groups. First, communication and socialization ADOS scores didn’t differ between the OO and TD groups, although the authors do note that “seven OO participants were judge to have social functioning mildly affected by nonautism conditions, such as anxiety, depression, or impulsivity” and that they will report a full exploration of the psychiatric functioning of all three groups in a separate study. They also noted that by early history the OO group demonstrated somewhat milder social symptoms than the HFA group but that they did not differ in communication or repetitive behavior symptoms. A small number of OO children demonstrated some weakness in the facial recognition test, but it was not statistically distinguishable from what would be expected in the population at large. Overall, by the measures used, the OO children were for the most part indistinguishable from TD children. It was also reported that the children who fell into the OO group also tended to have slightly milder autism upon diagnosis than the HFA group by the ADI-R and SCQ-Lifetime results. Basically, their social deficits seemed to be less marked. However, their language delay and repetitive behaviors were similar to those of the HFA group, at least within the limitations of recollections an documentation from a decade or more before (the mean ages of the groups ranged from 12.8 to 13.9 years).
Of coure, the biggest limitation of this study is that it says nothing about what percentage of autistic children can achieve the “optimal outcome” of losing their ASD diagnosis about what interventions are most likely to facilitate such improvements. The review article from Helt et al that I mentioned before estimated that between 3% and 25% of children diagnosed with an ASD “lose the diagnosis.” However, the percentage who would have achieved this without intervention is unknown. Clearly, a lot more study is needed.
This most recent study (Fein et al) is in line with a study from last year by Fountain et al, which showed up in some media reports last spring. This study reported that approximately 10% of children diagnosed with autism/ASD by age 3 “bloomed”; i.e., they improved rapidly, to the point that by age eight they were high functioning. Similar to Fein et al, Fountain et al observed that repetitive behaviors don’t seem to change as much and that it’s mainly the social and communication dimensions where huge variability in outcomes is seen. Fountain et al also found these correlates with “blooming”:
Bloomers differ from other children with respect to intellectual disability and socioeconomic characteristics. Among young children with severe autism, those most likely to “bloom” are those without intellectual disability and those with more educated, nonminority mothers. Although we are unable to identify the specific mechanisms through which socioeconomic status affects trajectory outcomes, the intervening variables likely include home and neighborhood environments, quality and intensity of treatment, quality of education, the efficacy with which parents are able to advocate for their children with institutions providing services, and many other factors in various permutations. If this heterogeneity in outcomes is associated with parental and community resources, then equal access to early intervention and treatment resources for less-advantaged children is vital. Although some trajectories may be associated with different etiologic drivers, if etiology alone were driving outcomes, we would be less likely to observe the strong socioeconomic effects unless socioeconomic status was associated with exposure to some biological risk factor for a particular autism subtype.
Not surprisingly (at least not to those of us who have followed the antivaccine movement), it is the autistic children born to the types of parents most likely to be antivaccine (more educated, non-minority, higher socioeconomic status) who are most likely to “bloom,” no “biomed” intervention necessary. That’s why, when evaluating whether an intervention of any kind, be it behavioral, medication, or even “biomed,” “works” in autism, it is essential to have a prospective randomized controlled trial. To see what I mean, I’ll refer you to a blog post that is six years old but still very relevant. It’s by Prometheus and entitled, appropriately enough, Listening to Autism. He begins by pointing out that parents, because they observe their children every day, believe that they understand their autism better than anyone else, even experts. Of course, it’s equally, if not more, likely that they are so close to their children that they can’t be objective and that their lack of objectivity can profoundly color their observations and thus lead them astray (confusing correlation with causation, for instance, or mistaking regression to the mean for real improvement), but few of them ever seem to acknowledge, much less accept, this possibility. Prometheus then goes on to discuss the prototypical example of an autism “biomed” treatment: Secretin.
Secretin: A magic bullet that shot blanks
Secretin first hit the scene in 1998, when it was first reported that a single injection of secretin, used as a routine part of endoscopy, appeared to dramatically improve the language and functions of an autistic child. This reporte led to a lot of excitement, a lot of use of secretin, and a bunch of studies of many varieties, short-term, long-term, case series, and, eventually randomized trials. Many of these studies did not support the initial results. Finally, there was a randomized clinical trial done by Repligen, the company that sells Secretin, that was negative. Today, the scientific consensus, as described in a Cochrane Review and multiple other reviews of the scientific literature, is that secretin does nothing for ASD symptoms and that its use in ASD warrants no further study.
None of this stops the autism biomed crowd from advocating and using secretin. If you go to, for instance, the antivaccine crank blog Age of Autism, you will from time to time find commenters extolling the virtues of secretin long after the science has been settled. Other websites still tout it, as well. Indeed, the Florida branch of the Scientology front group Citizens Commission on Human Rights (CCHR) recently argued that the reason the scientific trials of secretin were negative was because the investigators used a “synthetic” version of secretin, while the “dramatic improvements” came from a “natural version” of the hormone from pigs. In other words, some parents and quacks still swear by secretin, even though the evidence is even clearer that secretin does nothing for autism than it is that vaccines do not cause autism.
Luck, greed, and hope
To explain this, combined the results that I just discussed above with a tale that Prometheus tells, which he calls the Tale of the Lucky Stockbroker:
Long, long ago, a smart fellow decided that he would try to make a lot of money in the stock market. Having watched the market for some time, he realized that the best way to make money on stocks wasn’t to buy and sell them, but to sell expert advice.
Knowing that most people who invested in stocks were wary of advice, he set out to prove to people that he had a special power for knowing when stocks were about to go up or down. He got a list of a ten thousand people who were avid stock traders and sent each of them an e-mail describing his services (and fees) and giving them a “sample” stock pick.
Half of the prospective customers got an e-mail saying that the stock would go up in the next week, and half of them got an e-mail saying that the stock would go down. At the end of the week, the stock he picked had gone down, so he sent another e-mail to the five thousand people who had received the “correct” stock advice.
Half of the five thousand got an e-mail saying that another stock would go up in the next week; half got an e-mail saying it would go down. At the end of the week, he sent out another e-mail to the remaining 2500 would-be customers.
At the end of six weeks, he was down to a little over 150 potential customers, but those 150 has seen him make six correct stock predictions in a row! The last e-mail he sent them was to tell them that they could continue to get these predictions only if they bought a five-year subscription to his service.
There is no claim that autism “biomed” quacks are deliberately doing something like this, although perhaps a few are. However, in effect they are doing something like this. Parents who seem to see results, nearly always due to random chance alone and the human tendency to confuse correlation with causation, will convince themselves that whatever treatment they have chosen is “working.” Given that the very parents who tend to gravitate towards autism biomed treatments tend to be the same parents who blame their children’s autism on vaccines, this should not be surprising. They are already likely to easily confuse correlation with causation. Because children, autistic and non-autistic, develop in “spurts,” it’s very easy to think that a treatment that by chance alone happened to be started right before a period of rapid development, was the reason for the improvement in the autistic child’s symptoms, even if it were homeopathy (i.e., water) that was used. Meanwhile, the parents who don’t see any improvement will drift away from the “treatment,” frustrated that it “didn’t work.” Others lash out at any suggestion that autistic children can “recover” spontaneously or with something other than quackery, for instance, Kim Stagliano of the antivaccine crank blog Age of Autism:
Oh! And did you hear some kids “outgrow” their autism. Yuppers. In the Catholic Church we call that a miracle. When Jenny McCarthy told the media her son had lost his diagnosis she was called a liar. Turns out that the only way to lose the diagnosis is by doing nothing. Jeez, I’m always the last to know… I could be driving that Camaro I’m constantly talking about on Facebook with the money we’d have saved.
I’m not sure why there is such hostility here. My guess is that it’s the implicit conclusion that a significant but unknown percentage of children with autism/ASD can develop rapidly and ultimately fall into the neurotypical group. It doesn’t even much matter, for purposes of the observation that “outgrowing” autism is possible what the mechanism is. The authors propose other possible explanations besides development resulting in brain function that is more neurotypical, for example:
A pressing theoretical question is to what extent brain structure and function have normalized in the OO children. It is possible that effective early intervention plus maturation have resulted in the normalization of pathways and functions or even anatomical structure. Dawson et al. (2012) were able to show EEG evidence of normalization of cortical activation in response to faces versus objects in children receiving Early Start Denver Model intervention for 2 years in early childhood, supporting this possibility. Alternatively, successful intervention may have resulted in compensatory functions, such that overt behavior is normal, but atypical pathways or levels of activation are needed to achieve these behavioral results, as has been shown, for example, in dyslexia by Eden et al. (2004). Structural and functional MRI data were obtained from a subset of each group in the present study and are being analyzed.
More likely, it is a combination of factors. Whatever the case, if anything, Fein et al should provide hope to parents of autistic children by emphasizing that autism is not static and that it should be possible, depending upon the mechanism at work in these children who “grew out of” their autism, to identify science-based personalized strategies to maximize the potential of each autistic children, not to mention the chances that they can eventually function as fully independent members of society living productive lives.

Blame and magical thinking: The consequences of the autism “biomed” movement
David Gorski on February 25, 2013
Link
That the myth that vaccines cause autism is indeed nothing more than a myth, a phantom, a delusion unsupported by science is no longer in doubt. In fact, it’s been many years now since it was last taken seriously by real scientists and physicians, as opposed to crank scientists and physicians, who are still selling the myth. Thanks to them, and a dedicated cadre of antivaccine activists, the myth is like Jason Voorhees, Michael Myers, or Freddy Krueger at the end of one of their slasher flicks. The slasher or monster appears to be dead, but we know that he isn’t because we know that he’ll eventually return in another movie to kill and terrorize a new batch of unlucky and invariably not so bright teenagers. And he always does, eventually.
Unfortunately, the myth has a price, and autistic children pay it when they are unlucky enough to have parents who have latched on to this particular myth as an explanation for why their child is autistic. One price is blame. Parents who come to believe the myth that vaccines cause autism also express extreme guilt that they “did this” to their children, that it’s their fault that their children are autistic. At the same time, they have people and entities to blame: Paul Offit, big pharma, the FDA, the scientific community, pediatricians. As a result, the second price is paid: Their children are subjected to pure quackery, such as “stem cell” injections (which almost certainly aren’t actually stem cells, given the provenance of the clinics that offer such “therapies”) into their cerebrospinal fluid, and what in essence constitutes unethical human experimentation at the hands of “autism biomed” quacks. Meanwhile these same quacks reap the financial benefits of this belief by offering a cornucopia of treatments to “recover” autistic children that range from the ineffective and usually harmless (such as homeopathy) to the ineffective and downright dangerous (dubious “stem cell” injections by lumbar puncture into a child’s cerebrospinal fluid). These treatments drain the parents’ pocketbook and do nothing other than potential harm to the children. These prices are intertwined, and just last week I saw examples of both prices on full display at various antivaccine blogs. Worse, the concept appears to be metastasizing beyond vaccines. As more and more scientific evidence fails to find even a whiff of a hint of a correlation between vaccines and autism, the One True Cause of Autism, which was once vaccines or mercury in vaccines, has become the Many True Causes of Autism, in which vaccines (it’s always the vaccines) mix with pharmaceuticals, pollution, diet, and chemicals to produce autism in a manner that is a lot harder to falsify than the older, all too scientifically testable hypothesis that vaccines cause autism.
“I gave my son autism”
Perhaps the most shocking of the two examples I saw last week was a post promoted in the antivaccine crank blog Age of Autism about a post in another antivaccine crank blog The Thinking Moms’ Revolution (in reality The Not-So-Thinking Moms’ Revolution), entitled How I gave my son autism.
It’s a chilling read, right from the first paragraph, where the blogger, who goes by the ‘nym Mountain Mama, begins by writing about how she was raised Catholic and therefore believes in the concepts of reconciliation and absolution, forgiveness and redemption, introducing her topic thusly:
My spiritual beliefs have evolved and changed over the years, but the idea of forgiveness is still critical to how I walk through life. There are things I have done for which I know God forgives me. However, I’m pretty sure that I will never forgive myself, for my transgressions are embodied in a beautiful seven-year-old who tells me daily that I am “the best Mom in the universe.” I know the truth. And someday, so will he. All of these “unforgivable” actions were done with the best of intentions, but we all know what they say about “good intentions” and “the road to hell.” I am admitting here for all the world to see: I gave my son Autism. I did it. Me. And no one can ever take that away.
See what I mean? See how chilling this is? Mountain Mama is convinced that she and she alone is responsible for her son being autistic. She lives in fear of the day when her son learns of her role in making him autistic, the subtext clearly being that her son will blame her and even come to hate her for having made him the way he is. The other subtext is that Mountain Mama appears to be wondering if God or her son can ever forgive her for the evil that she believes she has done to her son. The expression of guilt at having “caused” one’s child’s autism is something I’ve seen before. Having long perused antivaccine blogs, websites, and discussion forums, I’ve seen innumerable times when parents have blamed themselves for vaccinating their children and vowed never to do it again. What is striking about Mountain Mama’s post is the sheer number of ways that she believes she has caused her son’s autism, beginning with prenatal ultrasounds:
I had at least five while I was pregnant. I was assured that they were completely safe. Heck, you can get them in malls, so I assumed they were pretty benign. Wrong! While I didn’t get ultrasounds in malls, I didn’t research them either. Ultrasounds have, in fact, been implicated in autism among other neurological disorders. While there is no definitive “causal link,” enough has been found to warrant further research and precautionary measures. According to this article, “Research shows populations exposed to ultrasound have a quadrupled perinatal death rate, increased rates of brain damage, nerve cell demylienation, dyslexia, speech delays, epilepsy and learning difficulty.” Sound familiar?
Well, yes, but none of these things are autism. In any case, the article Mountain Mama cites is from a chiropractor webpage that conflates an FDA warning about 4D “vanity” or “keepsake” ultrasounds that can be obtained in clinics in malls and are not done for medical reasons with medical ultrasound. As the FDA warning itself states, unlike medical ultrasounds, which are usually performed in the shortest time reasonable to get the necessary information, these “keepsake ultrasounds” sometimes require an hour to get a video of the fetus. Even though there is no convincing evidence linking prenatal ultrasounds with adverse health outcomes, be they autism, neurological conditions, or premature death. Basically, the FDA warning was an exercise of the precautionary principle based on the principle of “we just don’t know.” Conservatively and wisely, the NIH Consensus Statement on Diagnostic Imaging in Pregnancy states that ultrasound examinations solely to satisfy parental curiosity about the sex of the baby, view the fetus, or for educational purposes “should be discouraged” and that examinations without medical benefits shouldn’t be done, reasonable recommendations for any medical test.
One can argue whether or not the FDA overreacted given the lack of evidence, but it probably did not because it’s a general principle that medical tests should not be done for nonmedical reasons because their use under such situations is all risk and no benefit. From an ethical standpoint, even if the risk is not known or is very, very tiny, one can make an argument that it’s not a good idea to do medical tests when they are definitely not indicated. Certainly, there is not enough evidence to justify self-flagellation by a mother that she caused her child’s autism because she got the recommended prenatal ultrasounds. Indeed, a recent study and review of the literature fail to find evidence of a correlation between prenatal ultrasounds and autism, and the arguments that blame ultrasound examinations for autism boil down to the same sort of arguments used to blame vaccines for autism: The increase in autism diagnoses correlates with the increased use of prenatal ultrasound; i.e., confusing correlation with causation. Moreover, there is a confounder that the people who think ultrasound examinations cause fetal abnormalities always neglect to mention or even consider, and it’s this. Complicated pregnancies usually require more ultrasound examinations, as the obstetrician keeps a much closer eye on them. Complicated pregnancies also have a higher probability of fetal death or neurological abnormalities. If that confounder isn’t carefully controlled for, of course there’s a correlation between the number of ultrasound examinations and adverse outcomes for the child!
The litany of things that Mountain Mama blames for her child’s autism balloons up to nine items, including Lortab/acetaminophen, antibiotics, Pitocin, high fructose corn syrup, C-section, other drugs, and, of course, vaccines, about which she writes:
People, I know what happened to my kid. I KNOW. I watched it. Ginger Taylor has been compiling studies for years that link vaccines to autism. That list has now reached over 60 studies.
Another word – Don’t bother making comments arguing about vaccines. I won’t post them. I am fully aware that there are children with autism who weren’t vaccinated. I am not suggesting that vaccines are SOLELY responsible for EVERY child’s autism. I KNOW, however, that they caused irreparable damage to my son’s immune system which ultimately led to his autism. There. Done.
In other words, don’t bother Mountain Mama with evidence. She don’t need no steeenkin’ evidence, other than that which she cherry picks. I do, however, find it very telling that Mountain Mama would use a list compiled by, of all people, Ginger Taylor as her “evidence.” If there’s a single person who embodies the arrogance of ignorance when it comes to vaccines, is a master of cherry picking studies, and thinks she knows more than real scientists, it’s Ms. Taylor, who is a true believer who attended Jenny McCarthy’s antivaccine “protest” a few years ago and believes that Andrew Wakefield is the victim of a “witch hunt.” Indeed, many of the studies she lists do not show what she thinks they show or have at best a tangential relationship to autism or no relationship to autism at all.
As for the other potential causes, Mountain Mama cites a Medical Hypotheses paper as evidence that there is a link between Augmentin and autism. As is frequently the case with articles in this vanity journal that is not peer-reviewed but is known for publishing all sorts of pseudoscientific nonsense such as HIV/AIDS denialism, antivaccine quackery, and more, the argument boils down to handwaving and speculation about biochemical mechanisms and confusing correlation with causation, along with an uncontrolled “study” allegedly linking Augmentin to autism. This was a “study” so bad that even Medical Hypotheses published a refutation of it that pointed out the nonsensical nature of the claim:
Her non-prospective, non-randomized, uncontrolled “study” of 206 autistic children found that members of her cohort had received 893 courses of amoxicillin/clavulanate and 1587 courses of other antibiotics. Without data on appropriately-matched control children, her data fail the “white shoe test”. Had she found that, of 206 autistic children, 205 wore shoes on a regular basis, and of those, 200 regularly wore a pair of white shoes before age one, would she suspect white shoes cause autism? Suppose further she found 125 students whose white shoes were fastened with Velcro® instead of shoelaces. Would she associate autism with Velcro®? Velcro® would certainly pass Fallon’s “timeline test”: there were very few Velcro® fastened shoes before the 1980s.
I’m so going to remember this analogy. My favorite one is the “CD analogy,” in which I point out that the rise in autism prevalence correlates very nicely with the introduction of CDs in 1985 and how CDs supplanted LPs as the most common medium on which music has been sold. Of course, then we have the difficulty of the last several years, during which MP3 files downloaded from various online services have become the preferred medium for consuming music, but I have a substitute: The “Internet” analogy, in which I point out that the rise in autism diagnoses also correlates very well with the explosion in Internet usage since the early 1990s. The analogies write themselves.
The evidence cited by Mountain Mama for everything else on which she blames her son’s autism is similarly weak. For instance, she also blames her child’s autism on her having to have a C-section to deliver him, citing a single non-peer-reviewed observation on a website as evidence why she feels that way. Now, there is some weak evidence that C-section deliveries might be associated with a higher risk of autism, but it’s pretty weak. Besides, what would Mountain Mama have done otherwise? By her own account, it sounds as though she really needed the emergency C-section.
In the end, the list goes on and on:
I can think of many more things I did wrong that I am sure contributed to my son’s health crisis. I will mention diet, toxic cookware, benzocaine teething gel and toxic building materials but won’t elaborate because at this point, common sense should dictate. I am writing this to try to hit the biggies that people really need to research to make better decisions than I did.
Is there anything Mountain Mama didn’t do to cause her son’s autism? Reading her confessional, it’s hard to think of any. After telling readers not to bother to try to urge her to let go and forgive herself but instead to send it around to everyone they know because:
No child should have to endure what mine has endured. No mother should ever have to experience the kind of torturous guilt I live with every day.
The mistakes I made were, by and large, recommended by healthcare professionals. That is no excuse. My son’s health was MY responsibility. I could choose to follow the recommendations or not. Even a small bit of research would have changed the outcome for my son. There are women, as we speak, who are on the way to the doctor for their second or third ultrasound. There are mothers dosing their babies with acetaminophen before their shots. There are expectant moms being hooked up to Pitocin drips. Some moms are administering unnecessary antibiotics for yet another ear infection and haven’t made the connection that their baby’s immune system is failing. There are also many, many mothers who are hearing the following words for the first time, “Your child has autism.” Help them.
Oddly enough, I agree. No parent should have to live with such guilt. Unfortunately, in Mountain Mama’s case, the guilt is unnecessary, not based on any evidence, and destructive, both to her emotional well-being and to the health of her son. This is the price of the myth that vaccines cause autism. The guilt imposed on parents was bad enough when they believed in only one major cause of autism, vaccines. Now that the list of culprits has expanded in the wake of the discrediting of Andrew Wakefield and the studies suggesting a vaccine-autism link, we see in Mountain Mama an example of guilt due to everything she did before and after her son was born. While it might be a common human reaction to blame oneself when one’s child is not “normal” and has special needs, in the case of Mountain Mama and thousands of mothers like her, the price is a self-blame so intense that it informs everything she does. Unfortunately, it also leads her to the second price paid because of the myth of vaccine causation of autism.
Another medical propaganda film, this time promoting “autism biomed” quackery
Last week, to add to the lovely specter of a new Stanislaw Burzynski movie approaching a mere week from tomorrow, I learned of an antivaccine movie currently in production. I actually learned of it based on an appeal from its producer for money to help her finish it. The “documentary” (in reality an infomercial) Canary Kids: A Film for Our Children, is being touted by the antivaccine quackery propagandists at the antivaccine crank blog Age of Autism. There’s even a trailer:
The makers of this film sure aren’t shy about promoting it—or making hyperbolic claims for it, either:
We live in a media age. It is time for a big media solution. It is time for a ground-breaking, paradigm-shifting film, made by an award-winning director, that will raise awareness in a meaningful and powerful way. A film that connects the dots for people. A film that shows how all children in this country are a part of the autism epidemic. A film that can be seen in theaters across the country.
I present to you, Canary Kids: A Film For Our Children. This is a documentary film that is being funded by us, the parents, the scientists, the writers, the advocates, the people who “get it,” who want everyone else to “get it” too. But we need your help.
I’m beginning to think that it’s a general rule among cranks, “brave maverick doctors,” and quacks that, if you can’t convince scientists and physicians based on high quality scientific and clinical trial evidence, then make a movie! Maybe I’ll call that Gorski’s Law. Oh, wait. I’ve called too many other postulates “Gorski’s Law,” such as “Gorski’s Law” as related to the Pharma Shill Gambit. Maybe I should publish a list of them, along with corollaries, kind of like the Ferengi Rules of Acquisition. Maybe I could call them “Gorski’s Rules of ‘Alternative’ Health.”
My egomaniacal desire for laws and postulates named after me that can be quoted in skeptical wikis aside (much like Mark Crislip’s desire for world-wide media dominance), this movie looks bad. Real bad. As bad as the latest Stanislaw Burzynski hagiography that’s going to be released direct to DVD in eight days. It’s hard to tell, because obviously the Canary movie isn’t done yet, and the purpose of this announcement is to hit up the faithful for money. Using a survey that found that people who watched Food, Inc. actually changed their behavior with respect to the sorts of food they purchased, the makers of this new antivaccine movie state explicitly what their goals are for this movie. They are, quite simply, to do grave damage to public health by undermining confidence in the vaccine program and to promote the quackiest of quackery to be used to “recover” autistic children:
So imagine the statistics coming out upon the release of Canary Kids:
People who watched Canary Kids were more likely to:
    • refuse vaccination and/or question their pediatricians about the safety and efficacy of vaccines
    • refuse antibiotics for their children’s ear infections or viral sore throats
    • eat organic whole foods
    • try homeopathy before pharmaceutical medications
    • replace toxic cleaning and personal care products with safe, green alternatives
    • write their Congressmen about toxic exposures in their communities
Now, that is the kind of change that can stop a health epidemic in its tracks.
No, that’s the kind of change that can cause a health epidemic by decreasing the number of children protected against vaccine-preventable diseases, thus degrading herd immunity and guaranteeing that the incidence of serious childhood illnesses will increase manyfold. It’s also the sort of change that could guarantee that children will die of diseases they don’t have to die from as parents choose quackery like homeopathy before they choose real medications.
This is the sort of change we don’t need.
Fortunately, I doubt that a movie that will obviously not be as slick as Food, Inc will be as influential. The message is also likely to be so heavy-handed that people will likely tune it out as an advertisement, which is what it will be, more or less, specifically an advertisement for autism biomed quackery. It is, however, interesting to me primarily because apparently the movie is going to codify the sorts of things that antivaccinationists have been saying, in which vaccines apparently cause pretty much every chronic disease known to children because, well, vaccines are evil in their eyes. Certainly no science links vaccines with these problems, but science was never the strong suit of people like the makers of this film.
In fact, this film will create a diagnosis that will boil down to “vaccines cause every chronic health problem children experience.” You think I’m joking. Take a look. The name of the condition, according to the film, is “almost autism.” What constitutes “almost autism”? Almost everything. Basically, the filmmakers are trying to suck all parents into believing that their children are part of the “autism epidemic” (that almost certainly is nothing of the sort), whether their children have autism or not. In service of this “rebranding,” they redefine GI problems, asthma, pretty much any behavioral problem, or any chronic problem as “not autism”; i.e., caused by the same things they believe to be causes of autism, including (of course) above all vaccines. The filmmakers are very blatant about admitting that their movie’s message is all about marketing:
What is going to make someone come out to see Canary Kids? Canary Kids is not just about autism. For too long, people not directly affected by autism have looked the other way, because they can’t relate to autism. They don’t know what it is, they don’t see how it impacts them. They may not come out to see a film about autism, but they will come out to see a film about their kids.
Most people don’t understand that the asthma epidemic is directly related to the autism epidemic or that the obesity epidemic is related to the autism epidemic. They don’t yet see that the same environmental factors (pharmaceuticals, vaccines, toxins, diet, etc.) that cause symptoms of autism in one child are the very same environmental factors that cause symptoms of asthma in another.
I don’t know if this tactic is evidence that these people are true believers or truly cynical. It’s probably both, although I don’t know which predominates. Basically, because their message isn’t resonating very much outside of their little collective of vaccine-autism true believers, they’ve decided that the way to reach out is to try to convince parents whose children have any sort of health issue at all that the evil vaccines done it and that their children have “almost autism.” In this, they seem to be appearing to redefine autism to the point of their definition being no definition at all other than any condition their fevered imaginations come to view as being caused by vaccines, regardless of how they do it.
But who is this group that is making this movie? We learn that it’s a nonprofit organization called Epidemic Answers, which until now I had never heard of before. It was formed by a woman named Beth Lambert, whom I had also never heard of before, which just goes to show that, no matter how much I think I know the players in the antivaccine movement, I never quite do. There’s always someone out there attacking vaccines or forming some organization or another whom I don’t hear about until for some reason he or she pops up on my radar. Then, when that happens, I try to find out who the person is and what she stands for.
In the case of Lambert, it’s easy. She bills herself as a former healthcare consultant to pharmaceutical and device manufacturers and teacher. It’s pretty clear that she has no formal medical training, because if she did she would certainly advertise that on her book (yes, she’s written a book), A Compromised Generation: The Epidemic of Chronic Illness in America’s Children. She wrote it with a dietitian named Vicki Kobliner who runs a company, Holcare Nutrition, that touts “gluten-free, dairy free, low allergen, GFCF, SCD, GAPS, FODMAPS, and other appropriate diets” to treat a whole host of conditions. She’s also into “functional” medicine:
Through established scientific research and laboratory testing, functional medicine recognizes that ADHD is associated with imbalances in the levels of micronutrients (or vitamins and minerals used by the body for basic functions), neurotransmitters (necessary brain chemicals), and excesses of heavy metals in the body, among other dysregulated processes. Through diagnostic laboratory testing, clinicians can evaluate a particular patient’s imbalances and look for what might have contributed to these imbalances. For instance, deficiencies in micronutrients in the body (such as zinc, selenium, magnesium) can be explained by looking at the diet and how effectively or ineffectively the body assimilates these nutrients into the gastrointestinal tract.
Sadly, functional medicine is pure pseudoscience, as Wally Sampson has explained. It postulates “imbalances” in hormones and neurotransmitters, oxidation-reduction, detoxification and biotransformation, immune function, inflammation, and cell structure. It’s all so vague that these “imbalances” could mean almost anything, and when practitioners of “functional medicine” refer to them they usually do. Perhaps the most famous practitioner of “functional medicine” is Mark Hyman, known for creating “Ultrawellness,” the very name of which should tell you pretty much all you need to know about functional medicine. Yes, it’s quackery, full of supplements, dietary manipulations, and “detoxification.” “Imbalances” must be measured through a battery of lab tests and corrected with whatever woo functional medicine practitioners can dream up.
So we know where Lambert and Kobliner are coming from, and it is not from anything resembling a science-based perspective. Not surprisingly, she believes that in addition to lifestyle and diet, vaccines and “toxins” from the environment are the root cause of autism and pretty much every other chronic conditions children can develop, as seen in this interview:
This interview is very telling. In it, Lambert describes having a child with what she calls “almost autism,” who had sensory, skin, allergy, and behavioral issues. The funny thing is, apparently her pediatrician didn’t agree that the child had all these problems, because Lambert complains that every time she took her child to the pediatrician he would tell her that her child was fine and developing on-target. One wonders if Lambert was unhappy that her child was only developing “on-target” and was not developing far ahead of his peers. Whatever the reason, Lambert went doctor shopping and found a “Defeat Autism Now!” (DAN!) doctor. As many readers know, DAN! was a name for a set of “autism biomed” quackery, and DAN! doctors were doctors who practice such quackery. They were listed on the registry of the antivaccine autism biomed group “Autism Research Institute,” but the DAN! classification was dropped after 2011, and the ARI no longer maintains a list of DAN! doctors.
And guess what? The DAN! doctor found stuff wrong with her child—a lot of stuff! (Funny how that works, isn’t it?) Completely unsurprisingly, the problems he found were the same as those that DAN! doctors always seem to find in autistic children. Lambert also apparently used an “integrative” physician and dietician to do “comprehensive gut healing protocols,” whatever that means. She basically assembled a team consisting of the DAN! doctor, a woo-loving dietician, a homotoxicologist, a naturopath, and other practitioners of unscientific “medicine.” In other words, she assembled a team of quacks and entrusted them with the care of herself and her children. I realize I’ve written a lot about naturopathy, which is a cornucopia of just about every form of quackery known to humans, but what is homotoxicology? It turns out that it’s a quack discipline concocted by a homeopath, Hans-Heinrich Reckeweg, who believed that disease was the body’s attempt to dispel “toxins” and that homeopathic remedies can be used to correct this.
So what is this movie about? Let’s take a look:
The Canary Kids Film Project will take 7 children with a diagnosis of autism, ADHD, asthma, chronic Lyme or some other amalgamation of chronic (environmentally-derived) symptoms and provide them with free healing and recovery services for the period of 18 months.
The film will document their recovery journey while simultaneously providing an exposé on the factors that contributed to their conditions in the first place. Most importantly, the film will connect the dots for people so that they understand that we are all a part of the autism epidemic: Asthma, ADHD, allergies, Lyme, OCD, SPD, LDs, diabetes, obesity, Crohn’s, colitis, rare autoimmune conditions . . . we are all affected.
So basically, Lambert will take seven children with “with a diagnosis of autism, ADHD, asthma, chronic Lyme or some other amalgamation of chronic (environmentally-derived) symptoms” and subject them to the the full Monty of autism biomed quackery, including “detoxification” and “supplementation” treatment in order to “heal” them. It is indeed pure propaganda. Propaganda for antivaccine views and autism biomed quackery aside, I can’t help but wonder if, in fact, the motivation to produce this film is more than just a desire to sell the world on the idea that vaccines cause autism and all sorts of other health problems (almost autism). It would appear to me that the motivation is primarily to sell autism quackery to a broader audience by making a movie that will be in essence a series of testimonials. Does anyone believe that all seven of these children won’t improve? Of course they will, because the outcome is preordained and there wouldn’t be a movie if they didn’t all (or at least five or six of them) appear to make considerable progress. What a bargain for the mere price of $250,000, which is what Lambert is asking for! Sadly, I have little doubt she’ll get it and ultimately make this movie. Fortunately, on the surface it looks as though it will be so blatant that most people outside the autism biomed bubble will recognize it for the propaganda that it will be.
The price continues to be paid
The concept that vaccines cause autism has been thoroughly refuted from a scientific standpoint, but it lives on in “autism biomed” communities. Whether as a result of the increasing level of scientific evidence refuting the connection between vaccines and autism or for other reasons, the concept of seemingly everything under the sun (but especially vaccines!) as a cause for autism exacts a steep price, both from the psyches and pocketbooks of parents and from the health and well-being of autistic children, who are subjected to innumerable forms of quackery in the quest to “recover” them, as discussed above. This is the sort of price that drives parents to flit from dubious practitioner to dubious practitioner looking for the “cure” that will work. Two other recent examples of this were featured on—where else?—The Thinking Moms’ Revolution blog. In the first post, Denial Land, a woman going by the ‘nym Lionness expresses regret that she let her son have a hepatitis B vaccine and that she agreed to have a flu shot while pregnant, blaming herself for her son’s autism in much the same way that Mountain Mama did.
Then, in a post entitled The Things We Do For Love, a blogger going under the ‘nym Sunshine describes her quest last week to get her child to a new practitioner. She begins by describing walking into the airport one day last week at 2 PM for a flight to St. Louis but being told that the flight was canceled. I’m guessing that her flight’s cancellation most likely had something to do with the same snowstorm that hit Kansas and Missouri so hard it canceled a conference that I was scheduled to speak at, and almost stranded me in St. Joseph’s, MO. It also gave me a lovely taste of sitting several hours in the very crowded Kansas City International Airport as my flight home Friday was progressively delayed by half-hour increments and only got out about seven hours after it had originally been scheduled. If I had been starting out at home on such a journey, I’d simply have canceled. Not Sunshine. Instead of simply turning around and going home to reschedule her son’s appointment in St. Louis, which would have been the most sensible thing to do in such a weather-induced travel emergency, Sunshine finagled a flight through Detroit, which was delayed, causing her to miss her connection, ended up spending the night in Detroit with a “Thinker” (the name members of the “Thinking Moms’ Revolution” apparently call each other), and finally caught a plane that connected through Atlanta to go to St. Louis. At this point she:
Saw practitioner, drew blood, got new protocol, PAID BILL.
And then flew back home, concluding:
4 flights. 2673 miles. 30 hours start to finish. We were in St. Louis for a grand total of 6 hours.
This is what we do for recovery. For healing. For our beautiful kids. All in the name of love.
Remember, during this whole time she had an autistic boy in tow. One can only imagine the stress on the child. I have no doubt that Sunshine loves her son and thinks she was doing all this in the name of love, but I have to wonder how much of her actions are driven by guilt, the same sort of guilt that drives Mountain Mama. Running through four different airports and staying in the home of a stranger to try to get to St. Louis despite a snowstorm, all to see a new practitioner, who is no doubt no more science-based than any previous practitioners she’s taken her son to, are indeed a lot to go through.
She and her son continue to pay the price for a pseudoscientific belief not based in evidence, as do thousands of parents and autistic children.

   The autism “biomed” movement: Uncontrolled and unethical experimentation on autistic children
David Gorski
Link
Ever since I first discovered the anti-vaccine movement, first on Usenet, specifically on a Usenet newsgroup devoted to discussing alternative medicine (misc.health.alternative, or m.h.a. for short) and then later on web and on blogs, there have been two things that have horrified me. First, there are the claims that children suffer all sorts of harm from vaccines, be it being made autistic (with the attendant “autism epidemic” caused by vaccines), suffering neurological damage, immune system damage, and all manner of other adverse consequences. There is no good evidence for these claims (although, as has been documented right here on this very blog time and time again, anti-vaccine activists will trot out all manner of awful studies to support their contentions), but that doesn’t keep useful celebrity idiots like Jenny McCarthy, Jim Carrey, Don Imus, or Bill Maher from repeating the same myths over and over again. Worse, the permeation of society with these myths about vaccines has led to declining vaccination rates and the resurgence of potentially deadly vaccine-preventable diseases. It began first in the U.K. in the wake of Andrew Wakefield’s trial lawyer-funded, incompetent, and possibly fraudulent “research,” and has spread to the U.S., thanks to Jenny McCarthy and her ilk, who won’t take responsibility for their words and actions.
Even worse, the myth that vaccines cause autism has led to ideas. Dangerous ideas, and not because they “challenge” medical orthodoxy. These ideas are dangerous because they have direct consequences for children with autism. These consequences take the form of subjecting children to unscientific treatments that are ineffective at best and harmful at worst, sometimes even life-threatening. Indeed, I have written about case histories in which children were subjected to injections of “stem cells” into their cerebrospinal fluid by lumbar puncture and various other “treatments,” as well as chemical castration in combination with chelation therapy. That latter bit of quackery is something I wrote about years ago, but that the mainstream press only just noticed earlier this year. Better late than never, I guess. Even better than that, though, the same reporting team at the Chicago Tribune that reported on Mark and David Geier’s advocacy of Lupron to treat autistic children back in May. Sadly, the result of that story does not appear to have been actions by the State of Maryland to take away Dr. Mark Geier’s medical license or to go after his son David for practicing without a license. Neither does it appear to have resulted in insurance companies going after them for prescribing an expensive drug for an indication for which it is not appropriate. What it does appear to have done, however, is to inspire the same journalist, Trine Tsouderos, along with another journalist from the Chicago Tribune, Patricia Callahan, to pursue an even bigger target that Mark and David Geier, namely the entire “autism biomed movement,” which is for the most part rank quackery, in the following articles:
    • Autism treatments: Risky alternative therapies have little basis in science
    • Autism treatment: Success stories more persuasive to some than hard data
    • Questionable treatments for children with autism
This is another rare case of excellent reporting on this issue, and I hope that this report (another installment of which was published early this morning after I had written this post) will grab the attention of more reporters and news outlets, leading to shining a light on the dark underbelly of the autism biomed movement.
The aspect of this report that I most like is that Ms. Tsouderos gets it. She understands what I and other critics have been saying all along, namely that the autism biomed movement is almost all pseudoscience and quackery and that much of it “amounts to uncontrolled experimentation on children.” This is a message that has been a hard sell, because most lay people (and, sadly, a lot of doctors) do not understand clinical trials, clinical trial ethics, and why the physicians and “healers” promoting these unsupported therapies are in essence doing uncontrolled, poorly done, and poorly monitored clinical research, whether they recognize that’s what they’re doing or not. The rules and laws built up over decades exist for a reason, to protect patients and human research subjects from harm and risk as much as is possible. Because of their emotional and ideological investment in such therapies, they throw out rules in such a way that they’d find utterly unacceptable if a mainstream scientist or even worse–gasp!–big pharma were to do. The story sets up this concept right from the beginning:
James Coman’s son has an unusual skill. The 7-year-old, his father says, can swallow six pills at once.
Diagnosed with autism as a toddler, the Chicago boy had been placed on an intense regimen of supplements and medications aimed at treating the disorder.
Besides taking many pills, the boy was injected with vitamin B12 and received intravenous infusions of a drug used to leach mercury and other metals from the body. He took megadoses of vitamin C, a hormone and a drug that suppresses testosterone.
This complex treatment regimen — documented in court records as part of a bitter custody battle between Coman, who opposes the therapies, and his wife — may sound unusual, but it isn’t.
Thousands of U.S. children undergo these therapies and many more at the urging of physicians who say they can successfully treat, or “recover,” children with autism, a disorder most physicians and scientists say they cannot yet explain or cure.
But after reviewing thousands of pages of court documents and scientific studies and interviewing top researchers in the field, the Tribune found that many of these treatments amount to uncontrolled experiments on vulnerable children.
Remember how many times Jenny McCarthy has said of her son, “Evan is my science”? Indeed, take a look at this transcript from an interview she did a couple of years ago (sadly, the original video no longer seems to be on the web):
You know, I could in two months turn Evan completely autistic again. I could do it completely through diet. And maybe getting some vaccine boosters. Through diet, I could load him up again with all the things that will aggravate the damage that was done. Right now, what happened now was that I healed him to the point where he got everything back to this baseline level and it stays there like this. But I mess with it at all–boom!
Combine McCarthy’s frequent invocation of the mantra that “Evan is my science” plus the attitude that if she were to stop doing everything combine to demonstrate that this is indeed “experimentation” with therapies, as documented by the Trib (and that have been documented here many other times), that are at best unproven and implausible and at worst ineffective and potentially dangerous:
The Tribune found children undergoing daylong infusions of a blood product that carries the risk of kidney failure and anaphylactic shock. Researchers in the field emphatically warn that the therapy should not be used to treat autism.
Children are repeatedly encased in pressurized oxygen chambers normally used after scuba diving accidents, at a cost of thousands of dollars. This unproven therapy is meant to reduce inflammation that experts say is little understood and may even be beneficial.
Children undergo rounds of chelation therapy to leach heavy metals from the body, though most toxicologists say the test commonly used to measure the metals is meaningless and the treatment potentially harmful.
The justification for using chelation therapy to treat autism is two-fold. First, claim its adherents, children are either “mercury-toxic” or “heavy metal-toxic.” Originally, back in the days when Generation Rescue used to proclaim boldly, “”There is no such thing as autism. Autism is a misdiagnosis for mercury poisoning.” These days, even J.B. Handley has moved the goalposts and now attributes autism to a more vague “overload of heavy metals, live viruses, and bacteria,” due to “the tripling of vaccines given to children in the last 15 years (mercury, aluminum and live viruses); maternal toxic load and prenatal vaccines; heavy metals like mercury in our air, water, and food; and the overuse of antibiotics.” The second rationale is a dubious, unreliable, and unproven diagnostic test in which children are given chelating agents and then the levels of mercury and other metals are measured in urine samples. Surprise, surprise! These levels are virtually always elevated (mainly because that’s what chelation therapy does, binds metals and leads to their excretion in the urine, even in normal children. These “provoked urinary toxic metals tests” are virtually guaranteed to show “elevated” levels of various metals, particularly because often the “normal” ranges used for these tests are based children who have not recently had a chelating agent administered:
Nobody knows what normal results of this test would look like, toxicologists say. There is no accepted reference range. Nonetheless, the lab sends back color-coded charts that show alarming peaks of metals graphed against a meaningless reference range that was calculated for people who had never been given a chelator.
“That is exactly the wrong way to do it,” said Dr. Carl R. Baum, director of the Center for Children’s Environmental Toxicology at Yale- New Haven Children’s Hospital. “There is a whole industry that preys on people’s fears of heavy metal poisoning.”
Though most labs note that the reference range used is for unprovoked results, the apples-to-oranges comparison still can set off panic in parents.
Indeed. It’s inherently deceptive to do medical tests this way. Whether that deception is due to the incompetence of the “biomed” doctors doing them or outright dishonesty probably depends upon the specific practitioner. In any case, study after study has failed to find evidence that elevated mercury or heavy metal levels has any relationship to autism. Moreover, representatives of the labs doing such tests even admit that they’re not clinically validated. Their excuse for not working on clinical trials to validate them? About as lame as it gets:
Toxicologist William Shaw, lab director of The Great Plains Laboratory in Lenexa, Kan., said determining appropriate reference ranges for provoked tests will take more research but noted that it is difficult to get such studies approved by ethics boards and to get parents to enroll their children.
Both Shaw and Johnson of Defeat Autism Now! said the labs are identifying real problems, saying they have seen children benefit from chelation. Johnson also pointed to improved test results.
“Our only bedrock here is the observation by clinicians and parents that their children get better when they are given agents which are known to remove heavy metals from the body,” Johnson wrote in an e-mail.
Except that, as Prometheus has pointed out time and time again, autism is a disorder of developmental delay, not developmental stasis. Autistic children can and do “get better,” a significant fraction of them even so far as to lose their diagnosis and an even large fraction of them improving enough to be able to be productive members of society when they grow up. That’s why anecdotes about autistic children “recovering” after chelation therapy are inherently unreliable, not to mention that there’s no control group against which to compare. Indeed, in an accompanying sidebar, Ms. Tsouderos points out several things that need to be driven home again and again. Anecdotes are inherently unreliable, particularly in a condition that waxes and wanes as much as autism. She emphasizes, as did Prometheus, that 10-20% of children with autism may make so much progress that they become indistinguishable from their peers and “lose” their diagnosis.
Three other points stand out. First is the reaction of a luminary of the autism biomed movement to this story, specifically Dr. Martha Herbert. (We’ve met her before.) I’m rather amused at how she responded to e-mail exchanges about chelation therapy, after pointing out that she supports “biomed” treatments for autism:
In an earlier e-mail she wrote that she would sue the Tribune if she was portrayed as “an uncritical booster and fan of potentially dangerous unorthodox treatments.”
“I’m not defending chelation,” Herbert said in an interview. “I will sue you if you say that.”
That quote’s not going to endear poor Dr. Herbert to the biomed movement at all, I suspect. On the other hand, because she so desperately wants to be the “respectable” face of the autism biomed movement, Dr. Herbert does need to try to protect what’s left of her academic reputation, and supporting obvious quackery like chelation therapy for autism would not help her in that endeavor.
The second point was that it’s really, really easy to become a Defeat Autism Now! (DAN!)-certified biomed practitioner and to be listed as such. First off, you don’t even have to be a physician! You can be a nutritionist, naturopath or a homeopath, chiropractor, or nurse. Then all you have to do is to attend a 13-hour seminar held by the Autism Research Institute, sign a statement agreeing with the group’s philosophy regarding autism, and then pay $250 a year. After that, you, too, can push supplements, give chelation therapy, and promote whatever biomed woo you want to desperate parents!
Finally, it was interesting to see what happened to Dr. Roy Kelly, an ENT doctor turned DAN! doctor whose incompetence and quackery killed an autistic child back in 2005. Unfortunately, his license was only suspended for six months, with two and a half years probation. In my opinion, it should have been permanently revoked because he has proven himself to be practicing outside the standard of care in a way that killed a child. Amusingly, however, he registered as a DAN! doctor a year after having killed an autistic child and continued to be listed until, well, I’ll let the story tell:
Less than a year later, Kerry was added to the registry. In 2008 he voluntarily surrendered his medical license pending criminal charges of involuntary manslaughter in connection with the boy’s death, according to the Pennsylvania Board of Medicine.
Those charges were dropped, but in July of this year the state board suspended his license for six months, with 2 1/2 years of probation, state records show.
Kerry’s lawyer, Al Augustine of Chicago, said there was no proof chelation killed the child and that Kerry agreed to the suspension to avoid the cost and emotional hardship of contesting it.
Defeat Autism Now! continued to list the doctor until Nov. 5, a day after the Tribune inquired about his inclusion.
Johnson said the group had already planned to drop him this month because he had not filled out paperwork on his medical license.
Such are the standards for DAN! doctors. Even worse, that Dr. Kerry only had his license suspended for six months as a result of what looks to me like gross negligence demonstrates the utter ineffectiveness of our system for licensing and monitoring doctors. Another luminary of the autism biomed movement, Dr. Rashid Buttar, in addition to selling autism “biomed” in the form of “transdermal chelation therapy” (sometimes jokingly referred to as “Buttar’s butter”) and even apparently urine injection therapy, provided unproven cancer “cures” for years for many patients, charging huge sums for them. The North Carolina State Medical Board has tried unsuccessfully to strip Dr. Buttar of his medical license. In any case, it does look amusingly not coincidental that DAN! didn’t drop Dr. Kerry from its roles until reporters from the Trib started sniffing around. If only the Pennsylvania State Medical Board were less reluctant to discipline wayward physicians like Dr. Kerry.
Not surprisingly, the autism biomed movement (or, as it is in my opinion, the autism quackery movement) wasted no time striking back. Indeed, within a couple of hours of the Trib story going live on its website, the anti-vaccine crank blog Age of Autism posted a notice to “Tell the Chicago Tribune They Are Wrong.” Instantly, the comments section of the Trib story was flooded with outraged boosters of “biomed” autism therapy. The dogmatism and pseudoscience on display are truly depressing to contemplate. But AoA wasn’t done. Yesterday, Kent Heckenlively, the AoA blogger who hit his daughter’s grandfather up for $15,000 to take his daughter to Costa Rica for dubious “stem cell” injections into her cerebrospinal fluid, next likened the Trib story to “playing the ‘telephone’ game,” complaining that the Trib didn’t take seriously the “studies” that he had referred Ms. Tsouderos to. Of course, real experts had told her the value of those studies, which is basically nil. I will give Mr. Heckenlively credit for melting my irony meter into a dripping, quivering pool of molten metal and rubber by saying that Ms. Tsouderos, “gives the appearance of thinking without actually engaging in the activity.” That statement, better than anything else, sums up the savvier members of the anti-vaccine movement. The less savvy members can’t even give the appearance of thinking, at least not of thinking critically and scientifically.
Autistic children have paid the price. They will continue to pay the price until somehow, some way, science-based medicine, rather than anecdote- and pseudoscience-based medicine can prevail. Autistic children deserve no less than the best scientific medicine that can be brought to bear on helping them to develop and alleviating their symptoms. They most certainly don’t deserve the unethical and uncontrolled experimentation to which far too many of them are being subjected.

   Is there no end to unscientific treatments for autism?
Peter Lipson
Link
If you’ve been a regular reader of SBM or denialism blog, you know that plausibility plays an important part in science-based medicine. If plausibility is discounted, clinical studies of improbable medical claims can show apparently positive results. But once pre-test probability is factored in, the truth is revealed—magic water can’t treat disease, no matter what a particular study may say. So it was with great dismay that I read an email from a reader telling me about parents buying hyperbaric chambers for their autistic children. Let’s review some science.
In Breathing 101, we talked about how the oxygen delivered to your lungs depends on both the percentage of oxygen in the air, and the air pressure. We looked at how diminishing atmospheric pressure, for example at altitude, makes it harder to breathe.
Of course it is also possible to expose people to increased atmospheric pressure, which has therapeutic uses in the form of hyperbaric oxygen therapy (HBOT).
Oxygen delivery to tissue depends on several factors. We already talked about the air itself. Once air gets enters the lungs, most of the oxygen transported to your tissues is carried by the hemoglobin molecules in your red blood cells (under normal conditions). A small amount is directly dissolved in the blood. The amount dissolved in the blood is dependent on (no surprise) the percentage of oxygen and the atmospheric pressure. By increasing the atmospheric pressure from 1 atm (760 torr) to 3 atm, the amount of oxygen dissolved in the blood is enough to meet your body’s needs independent of heme-associated oxygen.
This is a good thing.
For example, up here in the Midwest, we have a lot of cases of carbon monoxide (CO) poisoning during the winter. CO binds to hemoglobin much more strongly than oxygen, so even after victims are removed to a normal environment, they are still asphyxiating.
Carbon monoxide intoxication is one of the primary uses of HBOT. Under pressure, enough oxygen is delivered to the tissues for the patient to survive. Additionally, the increased pressure helps oxygen displace CO so that heme molecules are free to go back to the work of transporting oxygen.
The original use for HBOT was of course “the bends”. When a person (for example a diver) is exposed to high pressures for a long period of time, nitrogen, which is normally not very soluble in blood, dissolves much more readily. When the diver ascends, the nitrogen bubbles are released from the blood into the tissues, causing widespread damage. HBOT can be used to help a diver “ascend” more slowly, so that the nitrogen comes out of solution in a much less damaging fashion.
HBOT can also be used to treat a variety of other conditions that are responsive to increased oxygen tension, such as anaerobic bacterial infections. But hyperbaric chambers are not without risk. Small errors can cause big problems, including death.
Strangely enough, though, you can buy your very own hyperbaric chamber for use in your own home, and parents of autistic children are doing just that.
So why does anyone think that HBOT might be appropriate for the treatment of autism? Is it even plausible? Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is a very broad diagnostic category. Autism is a neurobehavioral disorder of inconsistent severity and unknown cause. There has been some decent research into etiology, and in some cases genetic causes have been implicated. There is no reason to suspect that autism has anything to do with decreased oxygen tension.
As you have no doubt read in this space, autism attracts a wide range of quackery, and HBOT for autism quacks pretty loudly. Whose idea is this, anyway?
All signs point to a guy named Dan Rossignol. Dr. Rossignol is apparently into every form of autism crankery, including mercury poisoning, mitochondrial dysfunction, and oxidative stress (although I can’t imagine that increased PaO2 is an effective treatment for “oxidative stress”). After spending a few minutes looking through his web-based material, I’m starting to think that this guy can give the Geier’s a run for their money.
True to form, Rossignol is a “pioneer” and a “maverick”. He goes where legitimate clinicians haven’t dared. Based on an implausible hypothesis, he (apparently) subjects autistic children to potentially dangerous hyperbaric oxygen therapy. He has published his ideas in the crank-magnet “Medical Hypotheses”, and in BMC Pediatrics, a journal devoted to rapid, “flexible” publication.
Even if his data were to support his nonsensical hypothesis (again, increased O2 to treat oxidative stress??), should we believe it?
Well, someone does, and that someone apparently sells hyperbaric therapy, and not just for autism. They also treat Lyme disease, multiple sclerosis, and cerebral palsy—and anything else you can spell. The site does, however, have a very small Quack Miranda Warning on the left sidebar.
There is an unbroken chain of bad medicine here. Some guy decides that a potentially dangerous treatment might help a protean syndrome. He publishes his ideas in low quality journals. Then, someone sells his treatments uncritically.
HBOT is serious medicine. Off-label use in children with autism isn’t just foolish—it’s dangerous, and should be illegal.
References
Rossignol DA. Hyperbaric oxygen therapy might improve certain pathophysiological findings in autism. Medical Hypotheses. 2007;68(6):1208-27. Epub 2006 Dec 4.
Rossignol DA, Rossignol LW. Hyperbaric oxygen therapy may improve symptoms in autistic children. Medical Hypotheses. 2006;67(2):216-28. Epub 2006 Mar 22.
Rossignol DA, Rossignol LW, James SJ, Melnyk S, Mumper E. The effects of hyperbaric oxygen therapy on oxidative stress, inflammation, and symptoms in children with autism: an open-label pilot study. BMC Pediatr. 2007 Nov 16;7:36.

   The North Carolina Board of Medical Examiners, Dr. Rashid Buttar, and protecting the public from practitioners of non-science-based medicine
David Gorski
Link
One of the most contentious and difficult aspects of trying to improve medical care in this country is enforcing a minimal “standard of care.” Optimally, this standard of care should be based on science- and evidence-based medicine and act swiftly when a practitioner practices medicine that doesn’t meet even a minimal requirement for scientific studies and clinical trials to support it. At the same time, going too far in the other direction risks stifling innovation and the ability to individualize treatments to a patient’s unique situation–or even to use treatments that have only scientific plausibility going for them as a last-ditch effort to help a patient. Also, areas of medicine that are still unsettled and controversial could be especially difficult to adjudicate. Unfortunately, with medicine being regulated at the state level, there are 50 state medical boards, each with different laws governing licensure requirements and standards for disciplining wayward physicians, our current system doesn’t even do a very good job of protecting the public from physicians who practice obvious quackery. The reasons are myriad. Most medical boards are overburdened and underfunded. Consequently, until complaints are made and there is actual evidence of patient harm, they are often slow to act. Also, in my experience, they tend to prefer to go after physicians who misbehave in particularly egregious ways: alcoholic physicians or physicians suffering from other forms of substance abuse; physicians who sexually abuse patients; or physicians who are “prescription mills” for narcotics. These sorts of cases are often much more clear-cut, but most importantly they don’t force boards to make value judgments on the competence and practice of physicians to nearly the extent that prosecuting purveyors of unscientific medicine does.
Dr. Rashid Buttar: Autism and cancer
The reason I’ve been thinking about this issue again is because last Friday it was announced that one of the most dubious of dubious physicians of which I have ever become aware, Dr. Rashid Buttar of North Carolina, was, after many years of practice, finally disciplined by the North Carolina Board of Medical Examiners. Basically, the Board restricted his practice so that he could no longer treat children or cancer patients (more on why those two particular restrictions were imposed below). Once hailed as a hero by antivaccinationists and even once having testified to the Subcommittee on Wellness & Human Rights on autism issues, he is now disgraced.
Dr. Buttar runs a clinic called the Center for Advanced Medicine and Clinical Research, which features on its front page this quote:
“All truth passes through 3 phases: First, it is ridiculed. Second, it is violently opposed, and Third, it is accepted as self-evident.”- Arthur Schopenhauer, 1788-1860.
I can’t resist mentioning that any time I see this particular quote, I know that I’m almost certainly dealing with someone who is far on the fringe, because what one first has to realize about the quote is that non-”truth” never makes it past phase one or two–and rightly so. Right off the bat, we can see that Dr. Buttar has a greatly inflated view of his own importance.
I first became aware of Dr. Buttar around three years ago in the context of his “transdermal” chelation therapy for autism. Regular readers may be aware that the whole concept of “chelation” therapy for autism is based on the scientifically discredited notion that mercury in the thimerosal preservative that used to be used in childhood vaccines until the end of 2001 is a major cause of autism. Based on this highly dubious concept, all manner of methods to “detoxify” these children of the mercury (and other heavy metals) that, according to antivaccinationists, are the cause of autism, have been used on autistic children. Chelation therapy involves using chemicals that can bind to the metal ions and allow them to be excreted by the kidneys, and indeed this is standard therapy for certain types of acute heavy metal poisoning. However, when it is used for coronary artery disease or autism, on a strictly stoichiometric and pharmacological basis, it is extremely implausible. Moreover, it is not without potential complications, including renal damage and cardiac arrhythmias due to sudden drops in calcium levels. Such arrhythmias can and have led to deaths (more later). Despite this extreme implausibility, randomized controlled studies showing that chelation is no better than placebo for cardiovascular disease, and no evidence at all that it does anything at all for symptoms of autism, a veritable cottage industry of chelation therapy for cardiovascular disease and autism has sprung up. With most regimens costing $100 to $150 a treatment and “requiring” 30 to 40 doses, it’s a tidy little profit center for “alternative” physicians.
Dr. Buttar made his name in the autism community by coming up with a form of chelation therapy that did not involve intravenous medication, which led him to be lionized by boosters of the “mercury causes autism” such as Generation Rescue. He took an accepted chelator used for acute heavy metal poisoinging, including mercury, called DMPS, formulated it as a paste or cream, and dubbed it “transdermal” DMPS or TD-DMPS, or, as some wags have dubbed it, “Buttar’s butter.” His main claim is that it’s safer. Of that there is little doubt, but that’s because Dr. Buttar has either utterly refused or been unable to provide even the barest modicum of evidence to suggest that the DMPS is absorbed through the skin and into the bloodstream. That is the most basic question that any science-based physician would ask about any transdermal medicine, and Dr. Buttar’s reactions to such questions is very telling. For instance, Prometheus quotes him:
In answer to questions of whether he has tested to see if his transdermal DMPS (TD-DMPS) drops are, in fact, absorbed through the skin -
No, we haven’t done that. Why would I waste my time proving something that I already know is working innately?
And, in response to being challenged on this point, Dr. Buttar wrote in an e-mail exchange with a supporter of his named Pat Sullivan:
My purpose is not to prove that TD-DMPS is getting through the skin Patrick. I don’t care if it is a placebo, which obviously it isn’t….and our lancet paper
It is a “SAFETY” issue I’m talking about….I don’t care to prove a damn thing to those people that you have been dueling it out with.
In a later e-mail, Dr. Buttar wrote:
You see, first, you would have to actually have to have some type of test developed to actually detect the DMPS in it’s altered form as it is absorbed. That takes money, effort and time. As my friend says, why do it? Let someone who wants to establish biokenetics and half life do that. It is not necessary to do this from a clinical efficacy standpoint. It would be nice to know how it works, but it is irrelevant. It works based on empirical evidence.
So it’s absorption is not an issue for me or for anyone who is a true scientist because the empirical evidence is abundant. Only a pseduo scientist is going to get caught up with levels in serum, which it may not even show, since DMPS is highly neurophillic and may be possibly taken up by the nerves or distributed through the lymphatics…I don’t know and I frankly don’t care since it has no relevance to the clinical side of the house. But you see how absurd it is to simply assume it has to get into the serum? It most likely does, but it may not. The point is, it gets in and it works….and it works better than anything else out there.
Yes, Dr. Buttar “knows” his treatment works, based on his “clinical experience.” He don’t need no steekin’ science, like bothering to show that his drug actually gets absorbed through the skin into the bloodstream. (Never mind that Dr. Buttar has been promising a study since 2004.) This seems quite odd, given that it would in fact be pretty straightforward to document whether the DMPS is getting into the bloodstream and if it is actually chelating heavy metals. Why on earth would he not want to do it? Of course, as we know, the plural of “anecdotes” is not “data,” as Steve Novella has pointed out, and, as Prometheus has pointed out, autism is a syndrome of developmental delay, not developmental stasis, which is why randomized studies with a placebo-control group are so critical. Particularly telling is Dr. Buttar’s statement that he “doesn’t care if it’s a placebo.” Little more needs to be said about his attitude about science, but that hasn’t stopped him from promoting this unproven and dubious therapy for autism for several years now.
More recently, Dr. Buttar developed a new “protocol” for treating autism that involved more than just chelation therapy. It is described here by a parent who saw him for a consultation a couple of years ago:
Every 2 weeks our son will get IV EDTA and ozone (which will be infused in his blood and given via IV) and on the second day he will get minerals. The reason given for ozone is to reduce persistent organics in his system. There is no test being recommended to determine if the child will be a good candidate for ozone. Apparently, some children are seeing good results and Dr Buttar is trying this treatment on older children (greater than 7). Dr Buttar’s office has provided some research on ozone done by a MD researcher in NY whom we spoke with. The immediate reaction of this researcher was that there has not been any study with children while ozone therapy is safe and has been used on millions of people in Europe. The researcher was not aware of Dr Buttar or his protocol on children and said that one needs to establish first if ozone therapy is needed.
There is no biologic plausibility or evidence to support the use of such a regimen. But Dr. Buttar has reportedly gone even beyond this level of dubiousness. As reported by Kevin Leitch, parents on a Yahoo! discussion group about chelation therapy for autism were reporting in 2006 that Dr. Buttar was recommending, well, let Kevin describe it. First, a parent asks:
Have any of your tried, or even heard anything about, doing urine shots to help the immune system? I don’t know much about it yet, but I know you use your child’s own urine, and filter it with special filters, before injecting it into their hip. I’ve heard really good things about it from a friend who tried it.
Here are some answers:
    • “This was recommended by Dr. Buttar’s office for my NT son who has tons of allergies. I believe Dr. Imam in NY does it. It sounded too “out there” for us so we are currently sticking with justchelation for him.”
    • “My grandson went through this beginning in October. It was a once a week treatment for 10 weeks. Before he began, he had lots of allergy problems that would often advance into sinus infection and ear infections. It’s almost April and he has not had one problem since. The only thing that I see is an occasional stuffy nose that lasts only a very short time.”
    • “I only know this was described to me to be a procedure used by Dr. Buttar about a year ago when my son was his patient, but the nurse said it would require an extended stay near the clinic and we live in Texas. We never tried it and moved on to another doctor.”
As Kevin puts it:
Just in case you think you read it wrong, you didn’t. Rashid Buttar and others recommend taking some of the childs urine, filtering it and then injecting it back into them. This is apparently good for the immune system. Yummy.
Yummy, indeed.
Arguably even more egregious is Dr. Buttar’s treatments for cancer patients. Let’s see what Dr. Buttar says on his own website about how he treats cancer:
The standard method of treating cancer is comprised of a combination of chemotherapy, radiation and surgery. However, according to the conventional, traditional medical literature, 75 to 95 percent of all cancers are related to some type of toxicity which results in damage to the immune system. Also, 42 percent of all cancer patients die of malnutrition. Yet, how many doctors treating cancer address nutrition or help repair the immune system? Learn the 5 step treatment approach Dr. Buttar uses in repairing the immune system in conditions such as cancer and AIDS. Then reach your own conclusion.
None of Dr. Buttar’s treatments have been subjected to science or to randomized clinical trials. That doesn’t stop Dr. Buttar from being unbelievably cocky and making totally unrealistic claims to patients with incurable cancer:
Medical board documents don’t name the four patients whose cases are cited. But Stephanie Kenny, a Charlotte mother of three, told The Charlotte Observer she is one of those who complained, on behalf of her husband, Jeffrey Kenny.
After learning that his adrenal cell cancer had returned following surgery, Jeffrey Kenny sought help from Buttar in early 2004. “He said it didn’t matter what kind of cancer anybody had, he could cure it,” Stephanie Kenny said. “He kept reiterating he had a 100 percent success rate.”
And:
Jerry Messina, of Los Angeles, told The Charlotte Observer he also complained to the medical board on behalf of his aunt, Lori Kostin. He said she went to Buttar after three rounds of chemotherapy failed to cure ovarian cancer. The medical board said Kostin paid $10,000 of a $30,000 bill for two months of treatment with IV infusions.
Messina, who did not meet Buttar, said his aunt told him the doctor “treated every type of cancer the same” and bragged about his 100 percent success rate. Two weeks before she died, in November 2004 at age 52, “she just flat out told me `I wish I’d never gone to this Dr. Buttar,’” Messina said. “She felt that her cancer got a lot worse.”
It should be noted that Dr. Buttar claims that he has patients sign a form that “no claim to cure cancer with these therapies has been made.” Be that as it may, anyone, doctor or not, who claims that he or she has a 100% success rate in curing cancers like the ones described above is either deluded or a liar. Period. Not even cancers for which there is a good prognosis and for which we have very effective treatments are cured 100% of the time. Moreover, it is incredibly unethical to make such a claim and then accept tens of thousands of dollars for these treatments. Even worse, like the Gonzalez regimen, Dr. Buttar’s cancer regimen is very onerous for cancer patients to follow. Indeed, one of Dr. Buttar’s patients, a man with prostate cancer who has posted under the pseudonym Cajun Cowboy, summarized his regimen, and it’s incredible. It turns out that Cajun Cowboy was at first a big fan and happy patient of Dr. Buttar, but now he says:
All the information about Dr. Buttar is still on this site but I no longer am one of his patients and I do not recommend him to any one for any reason. If you go to him for treatment BEWARE, BEWARE and read Roger Mason’s books first and go to QuackWatch.org first!
His description of Dr. Buttar’s billing practices is heartbreaking, and Dr. Buttar has been known to go after patients’ estates for uncollected bills. Meanwhile, one of the Board recognized a cardinal sign of questionable medicine:
“Doesn’t it strike you as a little strange that every patient that comes through your door has heavy metal toxicity?” Dr. Art McCulloch, a Charlotte anesthesiologist, asked Buttar’s nurse practitioner, Jane Garcia.
I assume the question was rhetorical, as anyone who has taken the time to study such practitioners knows that giving the same diagnosis and treatment to every patient is practically pathognomonic of quackery.
The reason I’ve gone on so long about Dr. Buttar is first simply to show just how outside of the standard of care Dr. Buttar’s practice of medicine has been. Kathleen Seidel has documented all of the complaints leveled by the NC Board against him, and I encourage everyone to read it. My second purpose is to point out just how powerless the North Carolina Board of Medical Examiners seems to have been for so long. Yes, it is taking action now and has specifically restricted Dr. Buttar’s practice to exclude cancer patients and children (the latter of which should stop his treating autistic children), but Dr. Buttar practiced this way for several years and continued to do so in the many months during which the Board’s proceedings against him ground along. Moreover, it’s by no means clear that the Board’s recommendation against him will stand. Dr. Buttar has deep pockets and can indeed afford to fight this action all the way to the North Carolina Supreme Court. I have no doubt that he will try to do just that. Even worse, even if he loses, his license is not being taken away. He will still be able to practice, just not on cancer patients or children. There’s nothing in the Board’s recommendation that would prevent him from treating patients with cardiovascular disease with his TD-DMPS.
Other practitioners of dubious therapies
If Dr. Buttar were just one example of an “alternative” practitioner who manages to get away with practicing non-science-based medicine that does not help patients and arguably harms them, one might dismiss him as nothing more than an anomaly. However, just in the realm of autism alone, he is not alone. Dr. Roy Kerry, for instance, is an otolaryngologist near Pittsburgh who apparently has given up head and neck surgery and devoted himself to dubious allergy treatments and various “alternative” medical modalities, who killed an autistic child in 2005 with chelation therapy. Yet, despite this, the CDC got it wrong about why this happened, and it took nearly two and a half years before any substantive action was taken. I will give proper credit to the State of Pennsylvania, though, that Dr. Kerry will soon stand trial for negligent homicide, although I can’t resist pointing out that Dr. Kerry still has a license to practice medicine and has continued to see patients since 2005. I have no doubt that if the autistic boy Abubakar Tariq Nadama had not died, Dr. Kerry would still be happily chelating autistic children with no inteference from the government.
If Dr. Buttar and Dr. Kerry are two who actually are being brought to justice for their offenses against medicine, however, more are like the case of Dr. Mark Geier, who has served as an expert witness in numerous lawsuits against vaccine manufacturers. He has had, as far as I know, no actions taken against him by the Maryland Board of Physicians. Describing in detail the number of questionable and unscientific practices that Dr. Geier inflicts on autistic children would be the topic for another blog post entirely, but I can summarize them with a short list of links:
    • Advocating a combination of chelation therapy and androgen blockade with Lupron (the same drug used for chemical castration) for autistic children (also here)
    • Diagnosing most autistic children with “precocious puberty” without proper diagnostic tests (an example bordering on diagnosing all autistic children with the same condition)
    • Subjecting children to excessive blood draws for no good reason
    • Running a front “institute” that allows them to constitute an IRB packed with cronies and friends to supervise his “clinical trials” (more here). As a clinical researcher, it boggles my mind that anyone can get away with such an unethical arrangement.
Kathleen Seidel has done an in-depth series about Dr. Geier, as well.
Reform is needed
Advocates for science-based medicine cannot help but be appalled at how easily physicians practicing modalities that are clearly far outside the standard of care can continue to do so with little or no interference by state medical boards. In essence, it takes particularly egregious offenses to motivate a board to act, be it substance abuse, non-science-based treatments resulting in the death or severe injury of a patient, or blatantly illegal behavior. Part of the problem is that the attitude among doctors seems to be that a medical license is a right, not an incredible privilege bestowed upon us by society that takes an equally incredible commitment and skill to be allowed to keep. Physicians who are on these boards are also often unpaid and reluctant (as they see it) to strip a fellow doctor of the means of his or her livelihood. There’s also a cultural tendency among physicians to stick together. We understand the difficulty of making decisions that can have profound consequences in our patients’ lives, and we tend to want to bend over backwards to give fellow doctors the benefit of the doubt. Our patients deserve better. The vast majority of physicians are competent and try their best to deliver the best evidence-based care they can to their patients. However, doctors who consistently do not practice according to the standard of care, be it because they are incompetent, dishonest, impaired by substance abuse, or because they have come to believe in blatantly unscientific treatments that do not help and not infrequently harm patients, do not deserve to be physicians. Examples such as Drs. Buttar, Kerry, and Geier show that our system is broken. If we as a profession do not find a way to do better, I fear that legislators will do it for us.

Ivermectin is now fast becoming the new MMS
A recent VICE story described a Telegram channel devoted to promoting veterinary ivermectin to treat autism. It has echoes of autism quackery going back at least to the use of MMS (a kind of bleach) to “cure” autism by eliminating “parasites.”
David Gorski on March 20, 2023
Link
If there’s one thing I’ve learned over the last couple of decades, it’s that there is one characteristic of a quack treatment that is almost immutable, that always, always comes to apply to it—and usually rather quickly after it is introduced as a “miracle cure” for something. Basically, sooner or later, that quack treatment will be—shall we say?—repurposed for other conditions, usually many other conditions (e.g., cancer). A corollary to this principle is that, sooner or later, the quack treatment will likely be applied to autism, especially if it’s ever been claimed as a “treatment” for “vaccine injury.” A further corollary (a sub-corollary, if you will) is that, if this treatment, whatever it is, causes significant side effects in the autistic children being subjected to it, instead of stopping the treatment the parents will “persevere” and continue to abuse their child with it. I was reminded of this and thought it worth discussing when I came across a story on VICE by David Gilbert, Inside the Private Group Where Parents Give Ivermectin to Kids With Autism. It gave me serious flashbacks to Miracle Mineral Solution (a.k.a. MMS), and it was that similarity that I wanted to explore.
First of all, times change, but the basics do not. For example, the private group promoting ivermectin is on Telegram, which is where all the COVID-19 quacks, cranks, and antivaxxers go now. Back in the day (namely, less than a year before the pandemic arrived), these sorts of groups dedicated to subjecting autistic children to quackery, all in the name of “recovering” them, were largely on Facebook. The reason is simple. Facebook, as poor a job as it has done in general in removing harmful content, is actually trying to remove harmful content, something that it has sporadic success with. Telegram, however, has close to zero guardrails; basically anyone can create groups about anything they want. Starting out as a messaging service dedicated to privacy and featuring end-to-end encryption, Telegram has evolved into a social media service as well, given the huge number of Telegram channels. It’s not that Telegram has no content moderation, but its content moderation is so lax as to be, in practice, homeopathic, except that as its content moderation is diluted to zero it most definitely does not become more powerful. As a result, it’s not difficult to find many Telegram channels dedicated to COVID-19 misinformation, antivaccine conspiracy theories, and, of course, “miracle cures” like ivermectin.
Another thing that does not change is the way that these groups are often only discovered and reported in the media when a mole lurks in them. The mole could be a reporter, activist, or interested citizen, but the end result is the same. The more horrifying aspects of what parents are doing to autistic children in the name of “curing” or “recovering” them are featured.
Ivermectin to treat autism: The MMS of the COVID-19 era
Regular readers (and those who might not be regular readers but have paid attention to quackery used to “treat” autism) the VICE story about parents treating their autistic children with ivermectin will immediately bring to mind pre-pandemic stories about “autism biomed” quackery, starting with the blurb:
“I have been applying Ivermectin liquid to my granddaughter’s feet, belly button, and swabbing her ears for six weeks now. She complains of sporadic blurry vision and sometimes headaches.”
Moreover, the grift is the grift, as I like to say, and the purpose of these groups is not truly to provide help and advice, regardless of how misguided that help and advice might be, but to promote the quack treatment under discussion:
In a private group on Telegram, parents whose children are living with a range of disabilities including autism, Asperger’s Syndrome, and Down Syndrome cheer each other on and provide support when discussing daily struggles.
But the channel’s main function isn’t actually support: It’s to promote the use of veterinary ivermectin as a treatment—and in some cases a cure—for these disabilities.
As I’ve written many times before, despite its ability to inhibit the replication of SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, in cell culture, well-designed randomized clinical trials have failed to find any efficacy for the drug. There’s a reason why I’ve referred to ivermectin as the the acupuncture of COVID-19 treatments because of its extreme implausibility based on basic science alone. The reason for that implausibility is that the concentration required to inhibit viral growth in vitro is 50- to 100-fold higher than what can be safely achieved in humans, meaning that, from strictly a pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics standpoint, ivermectin was always a highly implausible treatment for COVID-19. Let’s just say that the RCT results showing that it does not work were not a surprise to anyone who had actually read the original paper about its antiviral activity in cell culture.
Of course, what was being promoted on this group was not the human formulation of ivermectin, but the veterinary formulation, which is much more concentrated and a much higher dose:
The Telegram channel was established in July 2022 as an offshoot of the much larger pro-ivermectin group “Dirt Road Discussions,” which was set up in October 2021 by Danny Lemoi, who took veterinary ivermectin for almost a decade to, he said, treat Lyme disease. When ivermectin became hugely popular among anti-vaxxers as a treatment for COVID-19, Lemoi leveraged his experience with the drug.
More on Danny Lemoi later, as I’m sure that a number of our readers know that he died recently and that his death sounds as though it might have been due to ivermectin toxicity.
First, however, a bit of comparison. Equine ivermectin comes packaged in syringes with “1.87% ivermectin paste. 6.08 g syringe treats up to 1,250 lbs. Safe for horses of all ages, pregnant mares, breeding stallions.” Another formulation comes as a 1% solution to be given 1 ml/110 lbs of weight. Basically, in horses the dose of ivermectin can be up to 1.200 mg, while the human dose recommended is only around 3 mg. When ivermectin promoters state that ivermectin is “very safe” in humans, they are correct, but only at the dose recommended for humans. As with many drugs, toxicity increases with increasing dose, and when you take far more than the recommended dose your risk of serious side effects increases.
Not that any of this stopped the parents using ivermectin from giving them the horse paste:
The Learning to Fly channel, however, takes usage for children even further.
“It is for mom and dads with kids on the spectrum,” the founder of the channel wrote in a message describing the group last year. “My daughter is 30 yrs old with Asperger’s syndrome and my son is 28 yrs old with autism. We are all 3 on ivermectin and started mid February.”
Moreover, as is often the case with quackery, if your child suffers deterioration after starting the treatment, it is an indication that the treatment is working:
The channel also provides advice on how to explain the ivermectin usage to children:
“Best way to explain it is [the kids] have a cluster of parasites that are in a part of the brain that causes outbursts. When the parasites in that part of the brain get attacked [by ivermectin] the parasites panic and release their toxins as well as get active. Their death dance,” the channel guidelines state. “This will affect the kiddos and their behaviors.”
And when children experience side effects, the channel admins claim that it’s all because the ivermectin is driving out parasites. They call this “herxing,” which is a real term used to describe an adverse response that occurs in people who take antibiotics as a treatment for Lyme disease and a number of other illnesses.
“Herxing can be a big issue with our kids,” the channel admins wrote in a pinned message. “They have so much overloading them already, herxing adds more. Remember things will get worse before they get better. They will have days [when] it looks like their behaviors are getting worse but it is only temporary. This is the herxing.”
The term “herxing,” it should be noted, comes from Lyme disease quackery, because of course it does. Lyme disease is caused by a spirochete, a class of bacteria, and “herxing is short for the Jarisch-Herxheimer reaction, which has been observed in people when they start antibiotics to treat diseases caused by spirochetes, having first been observed in patients with syphilis well over a century ago:
Jarisch Herxheimer reaction (JHR) was first described in the literature by Adolf Jarisch (Austrian dermatologist) in the late 1800s when he noticed an exacerbation of skin lesions in a syphilis patient after starting treatment with a mercurial compound. In the early 1900s, a similar phenomenon was reported by Karl Herxheimer (German dermatologist).
JHR is a transient clinical phenomenon that occurs in patients infected by spirochetes who undergo antibiotic treatment. More specifically, the reaction occurs within 24 hours of antibiotic therapy for spirochetal infections, including syphilis, leptospirosis, Lyme disease, and relapsing fever. It usually manifests as fever, chills, rigors, nausea and vomiting, headache, tachycardia, hypotension, hyperventilation, flushing, myalgia, and exacerbation of skin lesions.[1][2] JHR is an acute, self-limiting condition and it is important to identify JHR and to distinguish it from allergic reactions and sepsis, which can be life-threatening.[3][4]
“Herxing” has, it appears, evolved into an almost all-purpose term used by quacks to describe when someone gets worse after a treatment that supposedly targets bacteria or any “parasite” as a way of explaining that you “have to get worse before you get better.” Steve Novella once wrote about the term while correctly noting that if the person using a treatment for “chronic Lyme disease” gets worse, “then that is evidence that the treatment is working and they are experiencing the JHR (or “herxing” as the community calls it),” while if nothing happens, then “they just need more treatment,” concluding that “no matter what happens or doesn’t happen, it’s chronic Lyme.” Substitute “parasites” for chronic Lyme disease here, and you get the idea. If your child starts getting worse, then it means that the treatment is “working” and eliminating the “parasites” that are supposedly the cause of the condition or disease being treated.
Chronic Lyme disease quacks even distinguish between “good herx” and “bad herx,” for instance, as Dr. Richard Horowitz has claimed:
Dr. Horowitz describes the difference between a “good” herx and a “bad” herx. Basically, with a good herx, the patient will have a reduction of symptoms and begin to feel better after the flare. With a bad herx, the patient will return to their prior baseline after the flare with no reduction in symptoms overall.
Unsurprisingly, there are treatments for “herxing” too that include “alkalinization”; “detox”; supplements, and more. It always amuses me to think of this whenever quacks accuse physicians of treating the side effects of pharmaceutical drugs with more pharmaceutical drugs. Apparently it’s good when quacks do the same thing, albeit with more woo, but bad when physicians do it?
Be that as it may, let’s see more of what parents are reporting in this group:
In the channel, parents even share stories about their children experiencing horrific side effects from the drug, including brain fog, severe headaches, nausea, muscle pain, and seizures—and are routinely dismissed by those running the channel, who claim it’s a normal part of the ‘healing’ process.
Actually, those of us who have followed such quackery know that “dismissed” is probably not quite the right word. Rather, they are “reassured” that such symptoms are to be expected and then encouraged to continue, for example:
A review of the chat’s eight-month history reveals parents complaining that their children suffer from a wide variety of side effects after taking the ivermectin paste, including: vomiting, change in complexion, seizures, lethargy, hyperactivity, agitation, and headaches.
“Major brain fog today after splitting headache yesterday,” one user wrote last month. Another wrote: “I have been applying Ivermectin liquid to my granddaughter’s feet, belly button, and swabbing her ears for six weeks now. She complains of sporadic blurry vision and sometimes headaches.”
“Bleeding or mucous or vomiting or diarrhea or acne or pealing or aches/pains or hot flashes & sweating are all good signs of clearing out your body,” another member wrote. “This is healing, keep going.”
Lest you judge these parents, you should recall how easy it is to fall into an echo chamber and, once in that echo chamber, how hard it is to listen to external voices. It’s even worse, given that the entire ethos of such communities tends to be along the lines of never, ever “giving up,” with abandoning treatment being viewed as surrender and the overall culture being geared towards trying increasingly radical quackery if the less radical quackery doesn’t work. Recall the story of Jim Laidler, who with his wife was drawn deeper and deeper into “autism biomed” quackery due to the much more primitive online venues that in the late 1990s and early 2000s, such as Internet forums and Usenet; that is, until a “Eureka!” moment rubbed Laidler’s face in the fact that all the quackery was not working to “recover” his autistic child, leading him to become an activist against autism and antivax quackery. He and his wife were both doctors, and they got sucked in by communities that weren’t nearly as large and were before the power of algorithmic social media, like FB, served to radicalize.
Let’s take a trip down memory lane to discuss MMS.
Autism “biomed” and MMS
I recall a 2015 article on the antivaccine website that has long promoted autism quackery, The Thinking Moms’ Revolution, entitled Why I Try “So Many” Protocols in Treating My Son with Autism that I once wrote about on my not-so-secret other blog, in particular this passage:
I refuse to look back in a decade and say “I really wish I had tried that when I first heard about it” or “I really wish I had pushed through that wall of herxing and gotten to the other side.” That is why we have tried so many protocols (and we’ve given them all true trial unless they caused our son to regress) and why I continue to go to conferences to hear new ideas and try new things. This is why I read medical literature over my lunch hour and why I bring new treatment ideas to my naturopath.
This is the entire philosophy and culture behind such groups, be they closed Facebook groups or, more recently, Telegram channel: Never question. Always keep searching. And, above all, never accept your autistic child for who he is. Also, remember that the autistic child is not your “real” child. Something stole your real child from you. Whether it was vaccines, parasites, “toxins,” something else, or—usually—a combination of at least a couple of these things, it was something external that robbed you of your “true” child. Don’t get me wrong, either. This is an entirely understandable human reaction to having your child change or be different from what you had expected or hoped for. It’s basically the changeling myth. (Echoes of this myth are undeniable in “gender critical” reactions to gender-affirming care for trans adolescents.)
I also note that “parasites” have long been an alternative medicine catch-all cause for almost everything, including cancer. Those who’ve been paying attention a really long time might recall Hulda Clark’s “Zapper,” an electrical device that supposedly killed a parasite (a liver fluke) that she had deemed the “cause of all cancers.” Ultimately, she claimed that it could also zap all viruses and therefore cure AIDS and then, eventually, the cure for all diseases, regardless of whether they were caused by “parasites,” infectious agents, or not. Quacks are nothing if not frequently grandiose.
Now let’s go a bit further back in time, to ten years ago, when I first encountered what I consider to be the most relevant parallel to this ivermectin group, the promotion of MMS as a cure-all, in particular for autism.
MMS: How “never give up” leads to horrifying anecdotes
Back in 2013, I encountered the blog of the mother of a boy named Jojo. His mother had been using a variety of “autism biomed” protocols for eight years before I encountered her blog, but had recently discovered MMS. First, a word about MMS. When you break down the chemistry, it is chlorine chlorite, which is a form of bleach. MMS promoters will do their damnedest to deny that MMS is, in fact, a bleaching chemical by pointing to how it is used, for example, as a water purification agent, but it is a form of bleach. Basically, MMS is a 28% solution of sodium chlorite, which when diluted in water—or, better yet, in a weak acid like lemon juice or vinegar—produces chlorine dioxide, the relevant bleaching agent. MMS, or so it is claimed, will kill the intestinal parasites that quacks blame for autism (and a variety of other conditions and diseases). They’ll even claim that you can see the parasites coming out in the stool! MMS for autism was, as far as I can ascertain, first popularized by a woman named Kerri Rivera, who was a regular fixture a decade ago as a speaker at Autism One, the premiere yearly autism and antivax quackery pseudo-medical conference, and recommended giving children MMS both orally and by enema. (Yes, by enema.)
Interestingly, MMS got its start as a miracle cure, thanks to a man named Jim Humble, who promoted it as part of his made-up religion, the Genesis II Church, using it as a profit center to support his “ministry.” The religious fervor behind MMS was unmistakable in the closed Facebook groups dedicated to it, and I sense a similar fervor, albeit not explicitly religous, in this Telegram group dedicated to ivermectin to treat autism.
But back to Jojo’s mother, who began to follow Kerri Rivera’s MMS protocol:
Jojo is given 1 oz of the mixture hourly, so effectively he is getting 1/8th of a drop each time. His first dose was given after school at 1 pm. He is now given 8 doses only although my reading tells me that it is a minimum. I suppose I could increase up to 9-12 doses a day but I’m kinda leery of the possible increase in die-off effects too.
Even as early as day 1, she noted Jojo running a low grade fever and coughing, which, of course, could simply have been a coincidence. Similarly, she also noted JoJo to have increased hyperactivity, which could very easily have been due to confirmation bias. By day 2, Jojo continued to have fever, and his cough got worse. Somehow, his mother came to believe that “coughing after taking MMS could be due to parasites in the lung dying,” as incredible as it might be that anyone would believe something like that. Later entries describe Jojo developing constipation, and, when that resolved, his mother thinking that parasites were coming out in his stool. It is a theme that continues through the rest of the blog, as Jojo develops diarrhea, languidness, and flareups of his chronic eczema (blamed on parasites, of course).
After a week, this mother escalated to MMS enemas, leading to a series of posts with some rather gross pictures. Now take a look at one such link and the picture contained therein. What’s shown are basically stringy bits of something that looks a little bit like a worm. Jojo’s mom asked her fellow denizens of the MMS Facebook group, all of whom were “pretty sure” it was a worm. It was not. Any surgeon or doctor who deals with GI problems will recognize it as a bit of mucus, possibly with a bit of colon mucosa (the lining of the colon). We see this sort of thing all the time, and it was definitely not a worm. Unfortunately, five years later (and the last time I wrote about this issue specifically) parents were still subjecting autistic children to MMS enemas to “cure” their autism, based on the claims that autism is caused by pathogens that include parasites, candida, bacteria, and viruses; “heavy metals”; and food allergies. The claim? According to Rivera, “MMS kills pathogens and neutralizes heavy metals, as well as reduces inflammation.” It took until 2019 before a “mole” exposed the MMS private FB groups in the same way David Gilbert exposed the ivermectin Telegram channel last week.
Ivermectin: MMS redux?
I don’t know if this is truly an immutable law, but it seems that way to me: Among quacks, the use of given quackery for any given condition will ultimately be expanded to be used for more conditions:
Members of the Learning to Fly channel believe that almost everything can be cured by taking ivermectin.
“Some say Down’s syndrome and such can’t be healed, I don’t believe it,” the channel founder wrote in a post earlier this year. Her daughter is also an active member of the group, and when another member asked about the efficacy of ivermectin, the daughter wrote that “everything from inherited multiple generation blood sugar disorders or autoimmune conditions to Cohen and Autism have been cured or made notable progress so far.”
Other parents have asked about a variety of diseases. “My youngest is 5 and was diagnosed with alopecia in January. It started right around Christmas time. Does anyone have any knowledge of ivermectin being beneficial for that?,” a user wrote last week.
In response, the channel founder wrote: “I haven’t heard anyone in here with it but I did find it on the list of things cured.”
See what I mean? This is very much like the way denizens of the private FB groups promoting MMS used to—shall we say?—expand the indications for MMS. Any condition that anyone asked about would be treatable by MMS, because of course it would be! A combinatino of the culture of the discussion group and the people actively promoting MMS, either for religion or profit (or both) made such an outcome inevitable.
Also very similar is the way that side effects are portrayed as evidence that it (be it ivermectin, MMS, or whatever quackery) is working, with doubters being urged to “press on through“:
“My daughter started having blurry vision on the ivermectin,” a member of the larger Dirt Road Discussions channel wrote. “She started with severe headaches alternating with stomach pain. Now her vision is very blurry. Any advice? She’s in the first grade. I don’t want her to miss out on all the learning that is so crucial at this age.”
In response, another parent wrote: “Press on through…It’s working.”
Even if:
And their advice to her is to keep doing it! pic.twitter.com/fzxqYYZsL4
— Wrath (@nmewrath) March 14, 2023
In the end, sometimes even the believers are the victims. Remember Danny Lemoi, who had been promoting ivermectin for COVID-19, cancer (for which he had also started recommending some seriously old school quackery like Laetrile), and autism? He died unexpectedly—or, dare I say?—died suddenly (sorry, couldn’t resist):
Just before 7 am on March 3, Danny Lemoi posted an update in his hugely popular pro-ivermectin Telegram group, Dirt Road Discussions: “HAPPY FRIDAY ALL YOU POISONOUS HORSE PASTE EATING SURVIVORS !!!”
Hours later, Lemoi was dead.
For the last decade, Lemoi had taken a daily dose of veterinary ivermectin, a dewormer designed to be used on large animals like horses and cows. In 2021, as ivermectin became a popular alternative COVID-19 treatment among anti-vaxxers, he launched what became one of the largest Telegram channels dedicated to promoting the use of it, including instructions on how to administer ivermectin to children.
While it is impossible to be sure of his cause of death, given the dearth of information surrounding it, it’s difficult not to wonder if the massive doses of ivermectin that he’d been taking for many months before had anything to do with it:
And according to the Missouri Poison Center, ingesting large doses of ivermectin formulated for animals has a long list of side effects, including seizures, coma, lung issues, and heart problems. Veterinary ivermectin is not a cure or effective treatment for COVID, the FDA has repeatedly warned, and is highly concentrated because it is designed for large animals like horses and cows. “Such high doses can be highly toxic in humans,” the FDA cautions.
Again, the human dose of ivermectin is indeed very safe—for humans. The horse dose? Not so much. Again, the dose makes the poison. Also, it appears that Lemoi had suffered from a bout of something close to congestive heart failure, attributed to Lyme disease, which administrators of the channel noted, “Danny was fully convinced that his heart had regenerated after his incident with Lyme disease that almost ended in congestive heart failure.” They also claimed that “a family history of heart disease and chronic stress” were why his heart had ultimately become engorged and that all “of his other organs were unremarkable, with his death being “a death by unfortunate natural causes.” None of this is possible to verify, because neither the administrators of the ivermectin Telegram group nor the family would respond to the reporter’s request for further comment.
Meanwhile, back in the group:
But a review of Lemoi’s Telegram channels shows that many of his followers who are taking his dosage recommendations, or “protocols,” for veterinary ivermectin are experiencing numerous known side effects of taking the drug.
“I’m 4 months now and all hell’s breaking loose, all pain has hit my waist down with sciatic, shin splints, restless leg syndrome, tight sore calves & it feels like some pain in the bones,” a member wrote on Friday.
Lemoi explained away the negative side effects of taking veterinary ivermectin by describing them as “herxing,” a real term to describe an adverse response that occurs in people who take antibiotics as a treatment for Lyme disease.
And:
“I am very new to this… I’ve been on Bimectin paste for 20 days,” one new member wrote on Friday morning, explaining that he too was suffering from Lyme disease. “I have severe chest pain. Costochondritis symptoms. Air hunger, internal tremors, brain fog, headaches on the back of my head, anxiety, depression, doom and gloominess.”
But don’t even just suggest that it might have been the ivermectin that killed Lemoi:
When some members of the group blamed Lemoi’s death on ivermectin, they were criticized in the Telegram channel; their fellow group members claimed they were spreading misinformation.
​​“No one can convince me that he died because of ivermectin,” one member wrote this week. “He ultimately died because of our failed western medicine which only cares about profits and not the cure.”
Same as it ever was. The drugs and quack treatments might change, as might the specific online forums where such quack treatments are promoted, but the psychology remains the same. Until we have better strategies and tools to address that, simply debunking treatments like MMS, the Zapper, and ivermectin for autism, although helpful to an extent, will not be enough.

Dubious stem cell trials for autism and the darker side of quackademic medicine
Despite a lack of evidence, Duke University is all-in on stem cells for autism, thanks to a billionaire benefactor and a highly dodgy for-profit Panama stem cell clinic. How did this come to be and what will be the outcome? Whatever the answers to these questions, it is clear that arrangements like the one between Duke University and The Stem Cell Institute are the dark(er) side of quackademic medicine.
David Gorski on November 2, 2020
Link

And now for something completely different…
Given how much I’ve been writing about COVID-19 science, pseudoscience, public health policy, and crankery, I feel as though I’ve been neglecting other issues relevant to science-based medicine. So this week, I’ll take a little break from the pandemic (don’t worry—I’m sure it’ll probably be back next week to look at another bit of COVID-19 grift), and revisit another form of grift, a particularly disturbing one. I’m referring to stem cell quackery. It’s a topic that I addressed initially on my not-so-secret other blog a couple of weeks ago, but that now has a major update, along with a paper, meaning that I can summarize what happened initially and, hopefully, update in a way to make a more complete story for this blog. It all started when I saw this Tweet:
Does Duke autism team partly have Panama stem cell clinic to thank for $10s of millions? https://t.co/W7d9tTlrDU
— Paul Knoepfler (@pknoepfler) October 13, 2020
We here at SBM have often bemoaned the infiltration of what I like to refer to as “quackademic medicine” in medical academia. It’s true that I did not coin the term “quackademic medicine” (Dr. R. W. Donnell did) but I did adopt it and popularize it to the point where many mistakenly think that I coined the phrase. In brief, quackademic medicine is a term to describe the increasing study and adoption of unscientific and pseudoscientific medicine in medical academia, mainly medical schools and academic medical centers. It’s gotten so bad that even my medical alma mater, the University of Michigan, the school where I proudly earned my MD, now features acupuncture, naturopathy, and even anthroposophic medicine. The Department of Family Medicine there even invited a prominent homeopath to give grand rounds on his field! It even indoctrinates residents into the quackery of “integrative medicine”. I pick on U. of M. because the embrace of quackery by some of its personnel pains me deeply, but I could easily rattle off at least a dozen other examples without even pausing to take a breath, and then there’s the NIH’s National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) (formerly known as the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine, or NCCAM), which is currently run by an acupuncture believer.
The dark(er) side of quackademic medicine: Teaming up with a quack clinic
As bad as the embrace of naturopathy, traditional Chinese medicine, and even reiki and homeopathy by academic medical institutions that would normally be expected to be bastions of science-based medicine is, I’ve discovered that there can be an even darker side to quackademic medicine. I’m referring to when researchers and universities team up with companies selling outright quackery, such as when St. Elizabeth Healthcare in Cincinnati took money from dōTERRA, a company selling essential oils, to start a center for “integrative oncology”. Unfortunately, what Dr. Knoepfler described a couple of weeks ago at Duke looks even worse than that:
There is a puzzle when it comes to the controversial idea of using cord blood for autism, because two of the strongest proponents are the autism cord blood program at Duke and for-profit, unproven stem cell clinics. On first glance it seemed like this was a bit of an odd couple to me.
The links between the Duke autism program and one particular Panamanian stem cell clinic called generically enough “The Stem Cell Institute” appear to go beyond just their enthusiasm about cord blood for autism.
Those apparent connections involve a mega-donor who has given a vast sum perhaps as high as $10s of millions to Duke’s autism cord blood group. Furthermore, The Stem Cell Institute says the donor and people in his circle have also been their customers. The clinic also makes another particularly startling claim I go into later in the past [sic].
As I’ve described more times than I can remember, bogus stem cell therapies are a particularly favorite form of autism quackery. Indeed, long time readers might remember the time twelve years ago that I wrote about Kent Heckenlively and how he took his severely autistic daughter to Costa Rica for “stem cell therapies” involving injecting “stem cells” directly into her cerebrospinal fluid and even borrowed $15,000 from her grandparents to do it. Indeed, I’ve even written about Duke University’s ethically dodgy “pay-to-play” clinical trials of cord blood stem cells for autism, noting that the Stem Cell Institute was the single largest recipient of money from patients who crowdfunded their treatments. (Northwestern University was another culprit doing, as Dr. Knoepfler described, the same sort of dubious things.)
Dr. Knoepfler also notes that investigators in Duke’s autism program, led by Dr. Joanne Kurtzberg, still share major enthusiasm for stem cell therapy using umbilical cord blood for autism, despite a negative phase II randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled clinical trial of umbilical cord blood for autism that showed no improvement in socialization skills or reduced autism symptoms. Other clinical trials also show no benefit. (Why anyone is doing these ethically problematic trials anymore is beyond me.) Despite that resoundingly negative study, these Duke researchers continue to want to bravely paddle up the river of pseudoscience, apparently rationalizing that they need to use more stem cells, rather than just cord blood:
Remarkably the Duke team has subsequently begun not one but two more new, related trials.
The first seems focused specifically on lab-amplified cord blood stem cells for kids with autism and the second is for young adults with autism.
How can they still be so enthusiastic?
I don’t know.
There always seems to be some rationalization to keep them going.
Things like this pop up, “If only we had designed our trial differently and excluded some patients, we would have seen benefit”, and so on. Maybe now they think that instead of cord blood it’ll be better to use lab-grown cord stem cells?
It feels to me like they just can’t let go of their idea that cord cells must help autism despite the data generally saying otherwise so far both from their own and other trials.
The Stem Cell Institute, located in Panama, is clearly a quack stem cell clinic, although that didn’t stop Duke University researchers from partnering with it. Indeed, the first trial opened to accrual on October 1; the second is expected to open this month. Its website advertises stem cells to treat autism, cerebral palsy, heart failure, multiple sclerosis, osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis, spinal cord injury, and autoimmune diseases, complete with very little actual science but a whole lot of testimonials. Its founder, Neil Riordan, has shown up with Mel Gibson on the Joe Rogan Experience (as has a Stem Cell Institute patient, welterweight champion Kamuru Usman) to tout his snake oil.
As an aside, in other marketing, Ozzie Osbourne also went to the Stem Cell Institute for treatment for Parkinson’s disease:
VIDEO: Kelly Osbourne discusses Ozzy's great progress after his recent stem cell therapy in Panama. https://t.co/2oDDisWXew #Ozzy #stemcells pic.twitter.com/viiWQPwPfc
— Stem Cell Institute (@Stemcellspanama) March 30, 2020
Now here’s where the connection I was talking about comes in:
As I’ve tried to learn more about all of this over the years, I found that the Panama stem cell clinic often kept popping up in a parallel way to the Duke Autism Program on the web with different searches. Some patients mention both.
More concretely, Duke has reportedly received more than USD $10 million (media reports range from $15 million to $26 million or even $40 million) for its autism research from a philanthropic organization called the Marcus Foundation, which also has connections to The Stem Cell Institute clinic in Panama, at least according to the clinic. The Marcus Foundation is led by Home Depot founder and billionaire, Bernie Marcus.
Bernie Marcus, besides being a billionaire, is a believer in stem cell treatments and has been a patient at the Stem Cell Institute. There’s even a story about it in the News section of the Stem Cell Institute’s website:
Bernie Marcus, cofounder of Home Depot and the company’s first CEO, suffered from bronchiectasis, a chronic lung condition that caused him to have difficulty, especially when public speaking. As a prominent businessman and active philanthropist, Bernie is a sought-after speaker. When his condition worsened and interfered with his speaking ability, he knew something had to be done. “I would get hoarse and cough ten to fifteen times every hour,” he said. “It was difficult to handle and progressively getting worse.” He went to the nation’s top respiratory hospital—National Jewish Health—where the doctors told him he would have to take antibiotics for two years to address the bacterial infection in his lungs. This treatment would do a number on his digestion, however, so he sought an alternative.
His physician recommended that he try stem cell treatment in Panama. Another good friend of Bernie’s had already been down to Panama to treat a stomach disorder that completely cleared up, so he felt comfortable with the recommendation.
Bernie was treated with stem cells and shortly thereafter stopped coughing and was able to return to his work. “I was able to go back to public speaking without embarrassing myself,” he said.
The story even claims that Marcus brought his wife, who has severe osteoarthritis of both knees and needs bilateral knee replacements, to Panama for stem cell treatments and claims that she is without pain now.
So we’ve established that the Marcus Foundation, which was founded by a billionaire who believes in unproven stem cell treatments that are basically quackery, has donated tens of millions of dollars to Duke to research cord blood and now stem cell treatments for autism. As Dr. Knoepfler notes, now that cord blood therapies have resoundingly failed in Duke’s phase II clinical trial, Duke researchers are moving on to treatments based on growing stem cells in a lab to infuse into patients, treatments much more like what the Stem Cell Institute claims that it is doing. (I always say “claims” with respect to what stem cell clinics like the Stem Cell Institute say they are doing, because in many cases it is not at all clear to me that they are actually correctly isolating and expanding the needed stem cell populations.) That’s bad enough. Although it’s certainly not illegal to seek donations from a foundation that clearly promotes dubious stem cell therapies, it should raise many red flags ethically to any researcher looking at science-based therapies based on stem cells. After all, the connection between Marcus and Riordan appears real, unless Riordan is lying about it, which seems unlikely, and the Stem Cell Institute is selling stem cell snake oil.
There is also this photo on the Stem Cell Institute’s Facebook page:
You never know who you might run into at the Stem Cell Institute in Panama. Dr. Neil Riordan with Bernie Marcus,…
Posted by The Stem Cell Institute on Monday, June 18, 2018
Here’s where it really gets dicey. As Dr. Knoepfler describes, it appears that Dr. Riordan is one of the scientific reviewers of grant applications to the Marcus Foundation and that he reviewed Duke University’s grant application. In a response to an article critical of Duke University’s stem cell trials for autism, Dr. Riordan himself did a sort of “Q&A” about the article and questions raised. I’m going to quote a bit more than what Dr. Knoepfler quoted:
13. Did you collaborate with any researchers from Duke when designing this study? Have you collaborated with researchers at Duke in any way?
I know Dr. Kurtzberg at Duke. Bernie Marcus, who funded the Duke trials, has been a patient in Panama (public information) and saw children with autism benefitting from treatment with umbilical MSCs first hand. I was asked to review the Duke proposal for the Marcus Foundation and was at the Foundation Board meeting that led to the funding.
So, basically, it sounds as though Dr. Riordan is basically bragging about having steered some of that sweet, sweet Marcus Foundation cash to Dr. Kurtzberg and Duke University. It goes beyond that, though:
14. Do you have plans for follow-up studies, and if so, what are the goals of those studies? If you have a specific study underway now, how many children do you plan to recruit?
There is currently no follow-up study in Panama underway. We do have plans for future studies in the U.S. but there is no timeline as of yet.
“We” have plans for future studies in the US? What does this mean? Whom does Dr. Riordan mean by “we”? It could be that he means the Riordan Medical Institute, located in Texas. Or does he mean Duke University? Or both? Inquiring minds want to know!
It also turns out, unsurprisingly, that Bernie Marcus is into more quackery than just stem cell quackery and has long been using his fortune to support and promote quackademic medicine. Here’s Marcus himself in an interview:
Yes. I have a particular doctor who is an integrative medicine doctor. He has used herbs. He has used massage. He has used chiropractic, and he has taken care of my family for well over 20 years. And I have watched the things that he does, and I have watched the fact that he could give us herbs instead of medicines—medicines where we always had a serious reaction, medicines that in fact could be dangerous in some situations. And instead of that, he gave us simple remedies that worked for us.
And I can tell you that some of them were exotic. Some of them were like umbilical cord stem cells, heavy doses of vitamin C, which he uses for cancer patients, that we know anecdotally alleviates some of the side effects of chemotherapy—losing the hair, the energy, the appetite, et cetera, et cetera. And it has been used by holistic medicine/integrative doctors for the last 15–20 years. And medicine turns its nose up at it, even though it is a vitamin and it goes in and out of the body, it is very, very hard to sell to anybody.
Fortunately, we now have some rigorous clinical trials going on at leading institutions, hopefully to prove this effect, and have the data available for others to use. That is what integrative medicine is. It is trying different, non-traditional ways of dealing with ailments that people have—you might call it different strokes for different folks.
And:
So I have experienced the value of integrative medicine myself, and I am a great believer in it. We helped open this clinic at Jefferson, and hopefully we are going to prove this. I think the other thing that will happen is that medical students are going to be exposed to it, which I think is very important—that they do not have blinders on their eyes that most medical doctors have when it comes to these kinds of nutrients. For most doctors, if it is not taught in medical school, it is not kosher. So I think it is going to have a very, very important effect on medicine in the future.
Unsurprisingly, rare is the actual rigorous clinical trial that actually shows benefit from these “alternative” and “integrative” treatments. Also, how is “stem cell therapy” in any way “integrative” or “alternative,” other than in the sense that it is unproven, except for a handful of indications, and that there are a huge number of quack clinics out there profiting from it?
Lack of evidence aside, there’s a center for “integrative medicine” named after him at Jefferson University, after the Marcus Foundation donated a $20 million grant to the university to form the first full department of “integrative medicine” in a major academic medical center, after having previously donated $25 million to integrative medicine projects including the creation of the Marcus Institute of Integrative Health, which offers “functional medicine“, a make-it-up-as-you-go-along “specialty” that relies on massive overtesting and overtreatment, high dose intravenous vitamin C, “restorative” micronutrients, and more. Meanwhile, at Duke, in 2018 a Marcus Foundation donation led to the founding of the Marcus Center for Cellular Cures (“cures”?), which is dedicated to—you guessed it!—stem cell-related treatments and “cures” for autism and other neurodevelopmental disorders.
This brings us to the latest on this arrangement, courtesy of Prof. Knoepfler and a new paper in Cytotherapy by Jeremy Snyder and Leigh Turner, who previously published about crowdfunding for unproven stem cell treatments and how it induces kind-hearted strangers to pay for quackery. In previous work Turner described how crowdfunding is abused by quack cancer clinics.
The dark side of quackademic medicine: Tainting science by consorting with quacks
Last week, Paul Knoepfler continued the story he had begun about the highly ethically questionable relationship between The Stem Cell Institute and Duke University, in particular Dr. Joanne Kurtzberg. Being a stem cell researcher himself Dr. Knoepfler mentions in his post how difficult it is for him to write an article like this, asking, quite reasonably, who “wants to take the risk to be critical of the practices of a team led by a fellow academic stem cell researcher?” and noting that, after his previous discussion of the same sort of setup at Northwestern University, leader Dr. Richard Burt pushed back with a piece in Science. I fully understand his reluctance. After all, given their prominence in the world of stem cell research, researchers like Drs. Burt and Kurtzberg that Knoeopfler criticized could well be the members of NIH study sections who will be evaluating his grant applications. Moreover, before drifting into studying dubious stem cell treatments for autism, these researchers had built their reputations with solid research. So Knoepfler answers his question about why he is writing posts like these:
Given all of that, why do a post like last week’s?
The well-being of pediatric patients and their families is the primary reason I decided to pull the trigger on this particular post.
I’m also very concerned more broadly about the practice of some universities requiring large fees for patients to receive unproven cellular therapy offerings, often in ways such as via off-study or compassionate use where the data from the patients often does not end up published. These arrangements may have less chance for benefit and more risks than are portrayed.
Some universities are at the same time hyping or exaggerating on-going clinical trials as though the cell therapy drug in question is already known to work.
He’s right, too. Duke, Northwestern, and some other universities are falling into hype that sounds very much like the hype of the for-profit stem cell clinics with which they’ve gotten into bed, while risking corrupting legitimate academic research:
This Duke-stem cell clinic situation is a prime example of muddy waters between a place overall doing robust clinical science and for-profit clinics. In terms of the actual biomedical science in this case, it seems to me like this is likely the realm of stem cell “magic” where one’s hopes and ideas prevail over actual data.
I’ve frequently said the very same thing, namely that, if you believe the advertising of for-profit stem cell clinics, stem cells are magic! They seem to think that they can just isolate any old stem cells, be they from amniotic fluid, mesenchyme, or wherever, inject them into the bloodstream, and expect that they will magically home in on wherever they need to go to fix whatever problem they’re being used to fix. This might make some sense in degenerative diseases involving chronic inflammation causing damage to a structure or organ, such as for various forms of arthritis, although I’d still say there was a huge assumption being made there. The same applies to damage from an acute injury, such as spinal cord injury or a stroke, although, again, it is a huge assumption to postulate that the cells will just magically “know” where to go and “know” how to fix the damage.
I said at the beginning of my post that this alliance between Duke University researchers and the Stem Cell Clinic represents the “dark side” of quackademic medicine. Basically, through its hard-to-find ties to the Stem Cell Institute Duke University has sullied its good name by getting into bed with stem cell quacks like Neil Riordan. It’s all fun and games (and easy to laugh at and off) when academic medical centers embrace, for example, the faith healing that is reiki. It’s not so funny anymore when they start taking money from believers in quackery to run scientifically dubious clinical trials of that quackery and even set up centers dedicated to dubious treatments. Real children could end up being hurt. Without robust preclinical evidence in cell culture and animal models of the disease being treated to show that the stem cells do what you claim they will do, it is not just a leap to test them in humans. By the Declaration of Helsinki, it is unethical. It’s arguably even more unethical to require patients (or their parents or other relatives) to pay huge sums of money to participate in these clinical trials.
This brings us to the paper by Snyder and Turner, “Crowdfunding, stem cell interventions and autism spectrum disorder: comparing campaigns related to an international “stem cell clinic” and US academic medical center“. In this paper, Snyder and Turner compare and contrast “crowdfunding campaigns, identifying an international stem cell clinic marketing a purported umbilical cord blood-derived stem cell treatment for autism spectrum disorder, with campaigns soliciting donations intended to help children with autism spectrum disorder either participate in clinical studies or obtain expanded access to stem cell products provided at an academic medical center in the US”. They begin by noting in the introduction that not all clinical trials of stem cell therapies come from for-profit direct-to-consumer clinics selling unapproved stem cell interventions:
However, not all crowdfunding campaigns related to purported cell therapies are confined to the direct-to-consumer marketplace for unapproved stem cell interventions. Some campaigns solicit donations that will help individuals access investigational stem cell products provided at academic institutions, either in the context of clinical trials or outside clinical studies on what in the US is known as an expanded access (EA) basis. For example, a study of crowdfunding campaigns for unproven stem cell interventions for neurological conditions identified campaigns for participation in clinical trials conducted at academic health centers or to utilize EA pathways at those facilities. In this study, although the top three destinations for purported stem cell treatments were clinics operating on a direct-to-consumer basis, the fourth most commonly named destination facility was Northwestern University. This location was named in crowdfunding campaigns seeking experimental stem cell interventions for multiple sclerosis. The site has reportedly ceased enrolling new participants in clinical studies. The fifth most frequently named destination facility was Duke University. These crowdfunding campaigns all sought experimental stem cell interventions for autism spectrum disorder (ASD).
Online crowdfunding activity identifying academic medical facilities as intended destinations for accessing experimental interventions has largely escaped scrutiny by scholars and journalists. This lacuna is striking because many investigational products are first tested in clinical trials conducted by researchers based at academic health centers. In particular, there has been little effort to compare and contrast crowdfunding campaigns for individuals seeking access to clinical studies or the EA regulatory pathway at academic health centers with crowdfunding campaigns for persons hoping to undergo unproven stem cell procedures at clinics operating on a direct-to-consumer commercial basis. Thus, the content of campaigns for participation in clinical trials and to access unproven treatments on an EA basis is largely unknown.
So what did Snyder and Turner do? They decided to compare the pitches made for clinical trials of stem cell treatments for autism by The Stem Cell Institute (SCI) in Panama and the Duke Center for Autism and Brain Development, noting that, although a phase 1 clinical trial of intravenous infusion of autologous umbilical cord blood cells was safe and resulted in significant improvements in behavior among children with ASD, a “more recent phase 2, randomized, double-blinded and placebo-controlled study by these same researchers found no improvement in ASD symptoms and socialization skills”.
The authors then did this:
The authors searched the GoFundMe crowdfunding platform for campaigns seeking funds to access stem cell interventions at these two sites. GoFundMe was selected for study, as it is by far the largest platform for medical crowdfunding campaigns worldwide. Searches took place using GoFundMe’s internal search engine and a search tool that scraped the GoFundMe site for crowdfunding campaigns seeking donations for ASD and specifying that the subject of the campaigns would travel to either Duke or SCI for stem cell intervention. Search terms used were “Duke” and “autis*” (to capture both “autism” and “autistic”) for campaigns with Duke University as a destination facility and “autis*” and “stem cell institute” or “autis*” and “stem cell” and “panama” for campaigns with SCI as a destination. This search took place on May 25, 2020, and returned 69 campaigns referencing Duke and 92 referencing SCI.
Snyder and Turner identified and analyzed ten campaigns to obtain access to stem cell interventions at Duke, with six to participate in a clinical trial, three to access stem cells on an expanded access basis, with one unclear as to which of these funds were being raised for. There were 76 campaigns for interventions at SCI. They then categorized statements about the perceived efficacy of stem cell interventions into “definitive statements that the intervention would work in all or some specific subset of cases (including specific percentages of positive outcomes or testimonials) and no definitive statements of efficacy”. To summarize the results, campaigns connected to both sites contained inaccurate claims, but campaigns identifying SCI as the intended destination for treatment made stronger claims about efficacy and included more testimonials than campaigns associated with Duke University. However, they also noted that press releases, clinical studies, and news stories about Duke’s program played an important role in “lending the perception of credibility to the putative stem cell treatments marketed by the international clinic”. In other words, news coverage of Duke’s trials and Duke press releases not only enticed parents of autistic children seeking stem cell treatments to want to enroll in Duke’s clinical trial, but that sheen rubbed off on SCI, where campaigns also cited Duke as evidence that SCI’s intervention was efficacious.
In addition, Snyder and Turner analyzed an additional eleven crowdfunding campaigns for children with ASD seeking to take the child to someplace other than Duke or SCI, which included for-profit stem cell clinics in the US, Russia, India, and Mexico. They observed that these campaigns “discussed inadequate numbers of umbilical blood stem cells for the procedure, cost, lack of availability in the US and lack of Food and Drug Administration approval as barriers to accessing this intervention at Duke” and “mentioned news coverage of the Duke trial to support the legitimacy of the intervention being sought”. They concluded that, although there were “meaningful differences” between the claims showing up in crowdfunding campaigns for treatment at SCI versus Duke, even so:
Acknowledging these important distinctions, there nonetheless are striking ways in which the clinical trials conducted at Duke help support and sustain a market for unproven and unapproved stem cell interventions provided at Panama’s SCI. For example, campaigns seeking donations for stem cell procedures conducted at SCI frequently refer or even link to information about clinical trials conducted at Duke. Campaigns reference these studies to bolster their claims that stem cells can now be used as safe and effective therapies to treat children with ASD. Some campaigns note that members of the philanthropic family supporting Duke University’s stem cell research in the area of ASD visited SCI and had stem cell procedures there. In other cases, campaigners referred to first seeking stem cell interventions at Duke University and then deciding to travel to SCI after being unable to access stem cell procedures at Duke. One campaigner claimed that they selected SCI as their preferred destination after being referred there by staff at Duke. Such claims might be inaccurate, but they suggest that the clinical research program at Duke propels significant interest in SCI’s products and bolsters confidence in their effectiveness.
Snyder and Turner conclude by urging universities to be more aware of how they’re being used:
The authors urge clinicians, institutional leaders and media relations or communications staff members at academic health centers and similar medical facilities to anticipate that their research can be used and, in some cases, abused in this manner.
And:
Researchers at academic institutions and comparable health care facilities cannot prevent representatives of businesses engaged in direct-to-consumer marketing of unlicensed and unproven stem cell interventions from making misleading or otherwise problematic promotional claims. However, they can play an important role in shaping how their own research is depicted in press releases and on institutional websites. Wherever and whenever feasible, stem cell researchers need to emphasize the preliminary nature of early-stage clinical studies and avoid making claims about efficacy until convincing evidence is available to support such assertions. Connections to direct-to-consumer sellers of unproven and unapproved stem cell products—no matter how fleeting—should also be avoided due to the documented propensity of these facilities to exploit these connections and of patients, their caregivers and their social networks to interpret these connections as endorsements.
From my perspective, the question boils down to: Are stem cell researchers at universities like Duke who consort with dubious for-profit stem cell clinics useful idiots for those quack clinics, or are they aware of what they’re doing? From my perspective, the two explanations are not mutually exclusive. There could be elements of both. Having observed quackademic medicine for nearly 16 years, I’ve come to realize that there really is an ivory tower, and many academics really are that naïve, although that doesn’t rule out an element of mutually beneficial grift. It’s basically impossible to say without a lot more in-depth knowledge of the arrangement and situation, although Knoepfler notes:
It is surprisingly easy to fall into the trap of viewing your favorite particular kind of stem cells as some kind of medical magic. I actively try to avoid this with one of my favorite types of stem cells, IPS cells. Over the years I’ve posted many times about limitations and even setbacks to clinical IPS cell research along with the milestones and stepwise successes.
Stem cells in a general sense are remarkable cells with unique qualities, but that doesn’t mean that any particular kind of stem cells can treat or cure a wide array of diseases.
These are wise words. Not only is it unlikely that stem cells, of whatever type, will be the panacea that quack stem cell clinics portray them as (and that even reputable stem cell researchers sometimes imply that they are), but scientists and physicians are human, too. They’re just as prone to all the cognitive biases and shortcomings hardwired by evolution into our primate brains. Scientists and physicians have a similar all-too-human tendency to become so enamored of their pet hypothesis or pet treatment that they have a hard time being objective about it and can sometimes, when sufficiently in love with their idea, rationalize getting help to study it from sources that they would normally dismiss as too tainted.
Is that what’s going on at Duke? Who knows? What I do know is that, from my perspective, SCI has all the hallmarks of a quack stem cell clinic. No reputable academic medical center or researcher at such a medical center should have anything to do with a clinic like SCI. While it may be amusing to see academic medical centers embrace, for example, the faith healing that is reiki, it’s not so funny any more when they start taking money from believers in quackery to run scientifically dubious clinical trials of that quackery and even set up centers dedicated to dubious treatments. Real children could end up being hurt.

CEASE therapy for autism: Homeopathic quackery and “self regulation” by naturopathic boards
Naturopathy is quackery. If you doubt this, consider that you can’t have naturopathy without homeopathy. What’s even worse is when naturopaths subject autistic children to quackery like CEASE therapy. Expecting any naturopathic regulatory board to investigate quackery in naturopathy is the proverbial fox guarding the henhouse.
David Gorski on May 28, 2018
Link

[Editor’s note: Today is a holiday in the US, and your humble managing editor spent much of it working on a grant, a book chapter, and, all day yesterday in Toledo on family business. As a result, I didn’t have time to produce one of my usual 5,000-word epics. I do, however, have a post that some of you might have seen before (and many probably have not) from my not-so-secret other blog, modified and repurposed for SBM. I’ll be back next week as usual. In the meantime, I’ll be holed up working on a grant and book chapter in my air-conditioned office, given that it’s supposed to go up to 96° F here in my neck of the woods. That’s too much heat for me to venture outside without a damned good reason.]
We here at SBM write about naturopathy a lot because, almost alone among alternative medicine “specialties,” naturopaths think of themselves as real physicians. They aren’t, of course. They are basically cosplaying real physicians, but they really do think that their education, training, and methodology are equal to that of MDs (and, in the US, DOs), even though it’s been discussed many times here and elsewhere why they are not, why naturopathic “accreditation” is a joke, and just how low standards are in naturopathic “medical” schools. I personally have discussed many incidents of naturopathic quackery that are, as much as naturopaths deny it, well within the accepted practice of naturopaths. I’m referring, of course, to treatments like the use of saliva from a rabid dog as an “approved” remedy to treat a variety of conditions, how naturopaths can make even Epsom salts fatal, the horror of what happens when a naturopath tries to treat pertussis “naturally,” or, thanks to lax regulations on compounding pharmacies, a clean kill by a naturopathic quack injecting curcumin intravenously. This latter incident, in particular, resulted not in naturopaths in California trying to clean up their acts but rather in their circling the wagons to defend their profession. It was also a very good illustration of why naturopathic licensure doesn’t protect patients from bad naturopaths because naturopathy is quackery by its very nature. “Licensed naturopaths” are no safer than any other naturopath.
Don’t even get me started on “stuff” naturopaths say when they think no non-naturopaths are listening, or the antivaccine quackery that is at the heart of naturopathy, such that the vast majority of naturopaths being antivaccine. Yes, I know that there are a few who are not (although I point out that even some of those, when tweaked, reveal antivaccine tendencies), but they are vastly outnumbered by the majority who range from moderately antivaccine to rabidly antivaccine. (Maybe that could be treated with a bit of homeopathic Lyssinum)
Given that naturopaths are making yet another effort to achieve licensure in my state of Michigan (and, sadly, having some success at it), I’m likely to be writing more than usual about naturopathic quackery (but I repeat myself) more than usual, the better to build an armamentarium of examples of why naturopathy is not medicine and why it endangers patients. So, when several people Tweeted this story at me, I took interest. So did Jann, who wrote about this legislative alchemy last week, but, since I live in the state, I figured it wouldn’t hurt to add my take on the story:
The College of Naturopathic Physicians is investigating a complaint launched against three B.C. practioners.
The registered naturopaths are said to be offering a treatment known as “CEASE” – Complete Elimination of Autism Spectrum Expression. The idea is largely based on the unscientific claim that Autism is caused primarily by vaccines.
In the treatment, children are “detoxified” using a highly diluted version of the causative agent, or toxin, in order to “purify” the body.
Who are the three naturopaths? Another news story reveals their names:
B.C. naturopaths Anke Zimmermann, Janice Potter and Margret Holland are all certified CEASE practitioners, and the college has acknowledged it is investigating the public complaint against them.
Anke Zimmerman? Hmmm. Where have we heard that name before? Oh, yes, I remember. She’s the naturopath who loves to use homeopathy about whose use of a homeopathic remedy supposedly derived from the saliva of a rabid dog to treat a boy with behavioral issues I wrote about last month. She also uses a homeopathic remedy supposedly derived from gonorrhea. (I swear, you can’t make stuff like this up. At least, I can’t.)
So what is CEASE therapy?
First, for those not familiar with homeopathy, I do need to do a little primer again. (I know, I know, there probably aren’t that many readers not familiar with The One Quackery To Rule Them All, but I do occasionally get new readers, and I don’t want to force them to click a link to learn what homeopathy is.) As I like to say, homeopathy doesn’t really qualify even as pseudoscience given that there’s nothing scientific about it and that in reality it shows far more similarity to sympathetic magic than anything else. In other words, there isn’t even enough of patina of science slathered over the quackery to qualify as pseudoscience. It’s magical thinking, pure and simple, in which homeopaths believe that diluting a remedy makes it stronger, but only if it is shaken vigorously (succussed) between each serial dilution step. Even more magically, they believe that it is possible for a compound that has been diluted many orders of magnitude more than Avagadro’s number, such that it’s exceedingly unlikely that even a single molecule of active substance remains, to have a therapeutic effect. They justify this by claiming that water has “memory” and retains some sort of “imprint” of the substance that it’s been in contact with. Never mind that there’s no evidence that water has “memory” beyond an extraordinarily brief period of time. Homeopaths are impervious to reason.
So CEASE therapy involves homeopathy, which is more than enough to make it quackery. That’s not all, though. It also involves the belief that vaccines are the cause of autism, which they are not. So let’s take a look at CEASE therapy again. It’s an invention/delusion of an actual MD (unfortunately) named Tinus Smits, who “discovered” CEASE:
Dr. Smits discovered in his practice with over 300 cases the foundation of CEASE therapy and came to his hypothisis [sic] of what causes autism. In his experience autism is an accumulation of different causes and about 70% is due to vaccines, 25% to toxic medication and other toxic substances, 5% to some diseases. With isotherapy (see below), a form of homeopathy using the causative substances themselves in homeopathic preparation, the toxic imprints can be erased.
He continues:
The treatment of autistic children and even adults has matured through 300 cases over the last three years and is called CEASE Therapy, which stands for Complete Elimination of Autistic Spectrum Expression. Step by step all asumed [sic] causative factors (vaccines, regular medication, environmental toxic exposures, effects of illness, etc.) are detoxified with the homeopathically prepared, that is diluted and potentized substances that were administered prior to the onset of autism. Currently we use the 30C, 200C, 1M and 10M potencies to clear out the energetic field of the patient from the imprint of toxic substances or diseases.
Of course, a 30C dilution means 30 serial 100-fold dilutions, or a 1060-fold dilution. A 200C dilution means 200 serial 100-fold dilutions, or a 10400-fold dilution. 1M means 1,000C, or a 102,000-fold dilution. You get the idea. Indeed, one can’t help in these situations to point out that Avagadro’s number is approximately 6 x 1023. That means if you dilute a one molar solution of something by approximately 12C (1024), then the solution is highly unlikely to have more than one or two molecules of the substance left. Take the dilution up to 30C, 100C, and beyond, and the odds rapidly become vanishingly small that a single molecule will remain. How small? Well, for a comparison that I frequently use when I’m giving talks that include a section on homeopathy, there are only estimated to be approximately 1080 atoms in the observable universe. Also remember, when Smits says that he’s using these different potencies, what he’s doing is increasing the “potency” at each step by using a more diluted remedy:
The duration of a remedy course depends on the severity of the problems and the reactions of the patient and can vary from 2 weeks to 2 months. Potencies should be repeated until no further improvement is seen before passsing [sic] to the next poetency [sic]. After each course a 1 or 2 week break is applied. The administration is carried out by letting 2 granules melt in the mouth.
So basically Smits is deluded into thinking that he’s using increasingly strong medicine to treat his patients.
What, however, is “isotherapy”? Smits is happy to explain:
Using the causative substances as a homeopathic remedy, their profound toxic effects can be witnessed as the children begin to react to the remedies. The reactions on the isopathic remedies are so characteristic, that there can be no doubt about the existence of a link between the toxins as the cause and the development of Autism as its effects although this is not considered as scientific proof. In this way Dr. Smits discovered, step by step, why autism and other behavioral problems, with their specific developmental problems, have so dramatically increased over the last ten to twenty years. It also became clear that autistic children do not suffer from one single cause but from an accumulation of different causes.
Do tell. So it sounds as though Smits uses vaccines and other “toxins” as the basis for his homeopathic “detoxification.” Of course, inquiring minds want to know: How much of each vaccine is in the starting material? Does he replicate the CDC vaccination schedule and then use some of that as his starting tincture for his homeopathic dilutions? This is about as close to an explanation as Smits comes:
The homeopathic method as applied in the treatment of vaccination damage consists of administering four successive remedies of the suspected vaccine.
I’m guessing Smits must use a lot of MMR. Actually, no he doesn’t. After all, if he’s making such diluted solutions of vaccine he could buy one vial and then use it for decades. Later, he claims:
All autistic children should be detoxified using the homeopathically diluted remedies of the vaccines that have been administered to the child.
And:
Autistic children should never again be vaccinated!
One more time. Vaccines do not, as far as science has been able to tell, cause autism. Many have been the epidemiological studies, and none of the large, well-designed ones have found a hint of a whisper of an association between vaccination and an increased risk of autism. By urging that autistic children never be vaccinated again, he is placing them in danger of infectious disease and turning them into vectors to spread infection.
Of course, homeopathy isn’t the only quackery in CEASE. As any good quack is, Dr. Smits is very much into high dose vitamin C, claiming that it “seems to play an essential role in protecting children against the adverse effects of vaccinations or other stress inducing events.” Whether vitamin C plays a role in protecting against stress-inducing events is still up for discussion, but it surely doesn’t prevent, treat, or cure autism.
Let’s conclude by getting to training. The three naturopaths being investigated are listed as being “certified CEASE practitioners.” Apparently, it means undergoing “training” by one of a few CEASE practitioners who appear to be acolytes of Dr. Smits, such as Kim Kalina. There’s a CEASE Facebook page showing various training sessions, such as:
You get the idea. Show up at a CEASE course, and get a certificate that’s not worth the paper it’s printed on. But what do these courses cover? Here’s one by Kim Kalina herself given last summer:
The course will cover
    • how to individualise, evaluate the need for and accurately apply each of the core components of CEASE – Isotherapy Remedies, Orthomolecular Supplements and the ‘Saturday’ Remedies
    • how to recognise which cases are best suited to CEASE vs Classical Homeopathy
    • the additional case-taking skills, questions and information needed in a CEASE case
    • the key ‘ Saturday’ remedies, potencies and posology indicated in autism cases, as well as other frequently indicated remedies in general CEASE cases – including specific Inspiring Homeopathy, Matridonal and Sarcode remedies.
    • the key Orthomolecular supports needed to support cellular detoxification in various types of CEASE cases, including supplements, vitamins, baths, etc.
    • how to apply and adjust the Isotherapy components of CEASE, including resources for info about drugs, vaccines etc. and extensive vaccine charts Kim has personally developed to enable practitioners to quickly identify which vaccine may need to be cleared based on unique characteristic symptoms of each
    • how to manage CEASE cases – this is perhaps the single most important aspect of the training, and Kim uses several of her own cases (not just autism cases), as well as FAQ’s from clients and practitioners, to take participants through many follow-ups, crises, etc. so that practitioners can learn how to handle the many case management issues that can arise and how to correctly interpret and manage each one
    • how to manage herxheimer reactions – don’t know what these are? This is essential info if you want to use CEASE safely and appropriately!
    • other supports and therapies that are very beneficial in CEASE cases, particularly in the management of these complex cases – specific cell salts, bowel nosodes, flower essences and additional therapies to consider that can help the healing process to unfold much more gently and easily
Such a lot of quackery. I note that, elsewhere, it is revealed that Smits died in 2010 and Kalina is carrying on his “legacy,” such as it is. She is also described as “one of the five approved instructors for the CEASE Organization (the others being in the Netherlands, Germany and Sweden), and brings extensive experience in both teaching and clinical case management to the CEASE community.” Kalina also misuses the concept of the Herxheimer reaction, which is sometimes seen after the initiation of antibacterials for tick-borne relapsing fever due to the release of endotoxin-like products by microorganisms as they die off during antibiotic treatment. It was first described as a reaction to the treatment of syphilis with penicillin and is also seen after treatment of other diseases caused by spirochetes, such as Lyme disease and leptospirosis. Yes, basically, Kalina is claiming that CEASE therapy can cause a “healing crisis” in which the patient gets worse before getting better. This is a common claim among quacks.
So what will happen? It’s noted in one story:
College bylaws prohibit false and misleading advertising, including marketing “likely to create in the mind of the recipient or intended recipient an unjustified expectation about the results which the registrant can achieve.”
The college also forbids naturopaths from advising against vaccination unless there is a “sound, and properly documented, medical rationale for doing so.”
I expect that nothing will come of this complaint against these three naturopaths. After all, if any “board” of naturopathy were actually to enforce standards like the ones above, it would have to take away the license of pretty much every naturopath under its regulatory authority.
Michigan legislators, take note. This is what naturopaths want for Michigan, and, if you pass a naturopathic licensure bill into law, this is what they will get.

“Dr. Amy” Yasko’s Autism Protocol: Unproven, Complicated and Expensive
“Dr. Amy” Yasko isn’t a real doctor and her autism protocol is unproven, complicated, and expensive. Her claims of success are contradicted by autism, nutrition, and genetics experts.
Jann Bellamy on April 26, 2018
Link

World Autism Awareness Day is celebrated each year on April 2nd. Unfortunately, we here at SBM are all too aware that Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) has been exploited by those profiting from unproven and expensive treatments like few other conditions: Restrictive diets, bogus diagnostic and treatment devices, chelation therapy, bleach therapy, hyperbaric oxygen therapy, homeopathy, herbs, vitamins, naturopathy, and chemical castration, among others. Purveyors of these false hopes sometimes align themselves with fellow promoters of pseudoscience: Antivaxxers, who flog the thoroughly discredited notion that vaccines cause autism. The victims are often children, whose parents are desperate to try anything that might help for a condition with no cure and not a lot of effective interventions.
Today we take a look at Amy Yasko, or “Dr. Amy,” as she calls herself, an unlicensed Maine naturopath who claims, in her self-published book, Autism: Pathways to Recovery:
considerable success in halting and in many cases reversing the effects of debilitating conditions, including ALS, MS, Parkinson’s disease, Alzheimer’s disease, Systemic Lupus Erythematosus (SLE), Myasthenia gravis, and autism.
Developed while she was in private practice as an unlicensed naturopath, she now offers the “Yasko protocol” to all comers through her websites and other media under the auspices of the “Neurological Research Institute,” a for-profit consulting company solely owned by Yasko. We’ll return to her protocol in a moment, but first let’s get to know “Dr. Amy.”
Despite calling herself “Dr. Amy,” and despite her use of diagnostic testing and prescribing therapeutic agents to treat autism and other medical conditions, Yasko is not a licensed medical doctor or naturopathic doctor (in fact, she’s ineligible for licensing) or on the faculty of any university. Nor is she an autism researcher, at least as that term would be understood among actual autism researchers.
According to her resume, Yasko has a Ph.D. in Microbiology/Immunology & Infectious Diseases from Albany State Medical College. In the 1980s through the early 2000s, she did research and published in respectable journals. She helped start two companies involved in the development of drugs and DNA synthesizers and holds several patents. But, sometime in the early 2000s, things seem to have gone off the rails. She veered from respectable science to naturopathy and pseudoscience, even though she knows better.
After working as a researcher and businesswoman, Yasko graduated from Clayton College of Natural Health (CCNH), an unaccredited naturopathic school that taught all manner of quackery and has since ceased operations. (I can’t imagine the cognitive dissonance required for someone with her background to stomach courses in, say, homeopathy.) According to Quackwatch, “the nature of CCNH’s teachings is also reflected in the brazen claims of its graduates,” listing Yakso’s declaration of her ability to “reverse” diseases with no known cure, like autism, as an example.
The Yasko Protocol
So, how does “Dr. Amy” “halt” and “reverse” autism and other diseases which medicine and science have concluded, apparently mistakenly in her view, are presently incurable?
The Yasko protocol starts with her “DNA Nutrigenomic Test,” which she developed. She claims the test can uncover genetic “weaknesses,” or mutations, in the form single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), in a particular nutritional pathway in your body, the methylation cycle. She describes this methylation cycle as “a biochemical pathway that manages or contributes to a wide range of crucial bodily functions, like immune function, mood balancing and controlling inflammation.” Lowered methylation function, says Yasko, “may” contribute to many major chronic conditions, including autism. According to her, autism is “a multifactorial condition, with genetic, infectious, and environmental contributors” and the methylation cycle is “unique” and “critical for health” because it “can” have an impact on all of these factors. Invoking epigenetics, Yasko says that it also is “the system the body uses to edit and correct problems with other genes” and “regulat[es] all other genes in your body” and “having your Methylation Cycle in balance gives you the tools you need to help turn on or off those other genes.”
While she may be solid, as one would expect, on some of the basics of genetics (she likes to impress readers with complicated diagrams and descriptions of gene functions), and her “Nutrigenomic Test” may actually uncover SNPs, it’s what she does with the results that veers from solid science into the wilds of pseudoscience: She runs the test results through a proprietary program, the details of which are apparently secret, generating a long list of dietary supplements which, she claims, address the genetic “weaknesses” uncovered by the test. Once the dietary supplement regimen is instituted per her instructions, regular lab testing is performed, supposedly to monitor and tweak the regimen. (You can find a sample test result and supplement recommendations here.)
Her protocol and its putative rationale are explained in a series of self-published books Yasko authored, including Feel Good Neutrigenomics: Your Roadmap to Health (which I read) and Autism: Pathways to Recovery (which I also read a good bit of), as well as DVDs, workbooks, lectures, and other websites, including CH3nutrigenomics, an “over 18,000 members strong” chat group she runs.
All of these – the genetic test, the supplements, the follow-up testing, as well as her books and DVDs — are sold by an “allied” (her description) company, Holistic Health International, which is solely owned and run by Yasko’s husband and linked to Yasko’s website under the “Our Products” tab. (Some materials are also available for free download.) Holistic Health also owns the copyright to “Dr. Amy’s” website. While the genetic and follow-up tests are purchased from Holistic Health, they are actually processed by two labs known for their unconventional laboratory-developed tests, Doctor’s Data and Genova. Doctor’s Data runs the “Nutrigenomic Test” and, as mandated by the FDA, Doctor’s Data requires a physician requisition for the test. Because the test is ordered directly by the consumer from the Holistic Health website, it is unclear how a physician’s requisition is obtained in the process.
According to Yasko, she has worked with almost 10,000 families worldwide. She also claims she has 71,000 people on her Facebook page, along with the thousands in her chat group.
Autistic children whose families choose to follow the protocol, which can cost thousands of dollars a year and last for years, may down dozens of dietary supplements a day, resulting in doses of micronutrients far exceeding the Recommended Daily Allowances. Their caretakers must regularly collect their urine, stool, and hair and send them in for lab testing, ordered via Holistic Health.
“Dr. Amy” was brought to my attention by a correspondent and I was made privy to an autistic child’s “Comprehensive Methylation Panel with Methylation Pathway Analysis,” the product of the child’s “Nutrigenomic Test,” processed through Yasko’s proprietary program. True to form, the “Analysis,” which bears the name and logo of the Neurological Research Institute, claims to have uncovered genetic “weaknesses” in the child which could be “bypassed” with “proper supplementation.” The results are given in a chart, listing gene names (e.g., “COMT”), the variation identified (e.g., “V158M”), whether there is a mutation, and its call (e.g., “Hetero”).
Based on the genetic test results and their processing through “Dr. Amy’s” proprietary program, recommendations include what Yasko calls “Step One Supplements,” which everyone should take as “nutritional groundwork” for her protocol, including “Basic Methylation Support,” as well as supplements supposedly tailored to mutations uncovered by the “Nutrigenomic Test.” For example, under “COMT V158M (COMT H62H) +/- VDR/Taq Tt” we find recommended two “Mutation Specific Formula RNA” supplements (here and here), 3 different B12 supplements (spray, drops, and tablets), Vitamin D, and “Methyl Max” (which also contains B12 and Vitamin D, along with, among other things, curcumin, ginkgo leaf extract, and an ingredient that comes from pigs).
By my count, Yasko recommended 75 different supplements for this child, plus B12 gum and B12 injections. For most, one or more doses are given per day. I added up the initial investment in these products if ordered from Holistic Health at current pricing and, not counting a few I couldn’t find, came up with a little over $3,500. In addition, the “Neutrigenomic Test” costs $495, plus regular follow up lab testing, which normally includes a hair analysis test ($95), comprehensive stool analysis ($345), and urine toxic and essentials elements test ($208). While Yasko maintains that all products need not be ordered from her husband’s company, many of the recommendations are Holistic Health-labeled products (e.g., “mutation specific” RNA, at $85). Some are Holistic Health formulations she created specifically for the protocol and not available elsewhere.
Yasko’s “Analysis” for this child included over 7 pages of citations from medical and scientific journals and other sources but, tellingly, she never cross-references these citations to her discussion, nor does she otherwise attempt to explain how they support her protocol.
In addition to her penchant for massive doses of dietary supplements, Yasko invokes other CAM tropes in her autism protocol: vaccination and heavy metal fear-mongering, the need to “detoxify,” and complicated diets. One of the purposes of the regular lab testing is to identify the presence and excretion of heavy metals via hair tests, “a cardinal sign of quackery,” according to Quackwatch, as well as urine and fecal tests. According to her book, Autism: Pathways to Recovery, common foods like mayonnaise, mustard, skim milk, croutons, and chocolate should be avoided because they “damage the nerves.” But we’ll have to leave these issues for another time. Today, we focus on the linchpin of Yasko’s autism protocol: her claim that using the right supplements can control how your genes act, in effect bypassing genetic mutations to optimize methylation cycle function, and, from that, positively affect the course of autism.
Experts and evidence belie “Dr. Amy’s” claims
Despite succeeding (if she is to be believed) where the entire scientific and medical community has failed, she has yet to publish a single paper in a respected peer-reviewed journal explaining just exactly how she achieves her miraculous results, no doubt preferring to keep her methods free from critique by those most qualified to evaluate them.
Since she won’t proffer her evidence to the scientific community, let’s compare her claims to what experts say about the evidence regarding genetics and nutrition and their relevance to the treatment of autism. Is there competent and reliable scientific evidence to support her claims?
First, while there are ways to help minimize the symptoms and maximize abilities, there is no cure for autism known to science. Thus, in asserting that her protocol achieves “considerable success in halting and in many cases reversing the effects of” autism, Yasko is claiming progress that has eluded the entire corps of autism researchers for decades. That alone makes her autism protocol lack credibility, to say the least. In fact, as we’ll see below, her assertion that her complicated protocol affects the course of autism in any way, even short of “reversal” or “halting,” isn’t credible either, based on the current state of our knowledge.
Second, the field of nutritional genomics is largely unregulated, with no defined standards. Until standards are developed, commercial firms purporting to give dietary advice based on genetic testing, like “Dr. Amy’s,” should be regarded with extreme caution. In her book, Autism: Pathways to Recovery, Yasko claims:
Once the molecular pathways are detected by specific SNPs are known, Nutrigenomics uses combinations of nutrients, foods, and natural ribonucleic acids to bypass these mutations and restore proper pathway function.
But, according to respected experts in the fields of nutritional genomics, this is simply not possible based on our current understanding of the interplay between genetics and nutrition.
In 2014, the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics issued a position statement:
The knowledge gained from nutritional genomics requires an evidence-based approach to validate that personalized recommendations result in health benefits to individuals and do not cause harm. Whether or not the knowledge gained from nutritional genomics can be integrated into the everyday lives of consumers is yet unknown. [Emphasis added.]
According to the Federal Trade Commission:
The FDA and CDC say they don’t know of any valid scientific studies showing that genetic tests can be used safely or effectively to recommend nutritional choices or to genetically customize dietary supplements . . .
In 2010, the Governmental Accounting Office issued a report following its investigation of companies offering dietary supplement recommendations based on genetic testing to treat diseases. According to the GAO:
there is no scientific basis for suggesting that supplements, diet, or exercise can be customized to DNA.
As to one company’s suggestion that dietary supplements could address the supposedly subpar performance of certain genes, the GAO’s experts called such claims “nonsensical:”
We have no idea of (a) whether the reduced activity has any real health implications and (b) what one would reasonably do about it if so.
Deficiencies in Yasko’s understanding of the clinical usefulness of genetic tests are evident in a review of her “Nutrigenomic Test” analysis for two autistic children by the medical director of the Autism Speaks Autism Treatment Network, developmental pediatrician Daniel Coury, in an interview by Bloomberg News reporters:
there is no scientific evidence that the recommendations would combat autism. . . Many genetic mutations examined in the these are also found in healthy people and there is no good evidence they cause autism . . . The mutations, while they are real genetic variant, haven’t been linked to nutritional deficiencies in autism patients . . . It sounds scientific, but the connection to autism isn’t there . . . I don’t see any evidence that it is useful.
Third, whether supposedly “customized” based on a genetic test or not, researchers question whether autistic children need dietary supplements at all. A systematic review of dietary interventions studies published in Pediatrics concluded that:
There is little evidence to support the use of nutritional supplements or dietary therapies for children with ASD.
Likewise, a cross-sectional study examining dietary supplement use and micronutrient intake in children with ASD likewise concluded that:
Few children with ASD need most of the micronutrients they are commonly given as supplements, which often leads to excess intake.
Speaking of “excess intake,” just one of the several B12-containing supplements recommended by Yasko, Holistic Health’s “Hydroxy B12 Mega Drops,” is given up to three times a day at 1,000 mcg per one-drop dose. According to a pharmacist I consulted, that’s up to 983% of an eight-year-old’s RDA! Even if not dangerous, it’s a tremendous waste of money.
Of course, excessive dosing is not an issue with Holistic Health’s Yasko-recommended “mutation-specific” RNA. That’s because, as SBM’s own David Gorski, who works with RNA, pointed out, RNA is incredibly unstable and unlikely to make it past your mouth. (Yet, she claims in Autism: Pathways to Recovery, that she has “devised a format in which the RNA stays intact in order to have a positive effect on the body,” although this is another secret method she won’t reveal.) When interviewed by Bloomberg News reporters about Yasko’s protocol, physician James Laidler, whose own son is autistic, called the whole concept of RNA supplements to treat specific gene variants “just laughable.”
And that’s not the only pharmacokinetics problem with Yasko’s dietary supplements. If you want to read more on the daunting prospect of any supplement getting absorbed and distributed to a particular point in the body, where it must be present in sufficient quantity, and for an adequate duration, to have an effect, read Scott Gavura’s excellent SBM post on the subject: “Where science meets supplements.”
Fourth, not only is nutritional genomics in its infancy, the utility of genetic testing in general in providing clinically relevant information is in its infancy. While the “Nutrigenomic Test” may accurately find SNPs (in other words, it may be analytically valid), neither its clinical validity (how well the genetic variant being analyzed is related to the presence, absence, or risk of a specific disease) or its clinical utility (whether the test can provide information about diagnosis, treatment, management, or prevention of a disease) has been established. That’s not just for selecting dietary supplements. That’s true of all genetic testing for most treatment decisions for any disease or condition, including autism. In particular, the genetic components of autism simply aren’t understood well enough for genetic testing to aid in treatment decisions.
Fifth, Yasko recommends that individuals work with their own health care professional, but does not require it. (Of course, what self-respecting physician would sign off her pediatric patient downing dozens of supplements a day and undergoing regular unnecessary lab testing?) This falls far short of the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics recommendation that a certified medical geneticist or genetics counselor be available to help the consumer determine whether a genetic test should be performed, which test should be performed, and how to interpret the results in light of personal and family history. Yasko’s cookie-cutter approach to genetic testing does none of this.
In sum, not only are Yasko’s claims of “reversing” or “halting” autism not credible, the idea that her supplement protocol could have any beneficial effect on autism is not credible:
    • According to experts in genetics and autism, genetic tests, like the “Nutrigenomic Test,” are not useful in guiding treatment decisions in general and dietary supplement recommendations in particular for autism. We simply don’t know enough about the interaction between genes and environmental factors, like nutrition, to make valid treatment decisions for autistic children.
    • Autistic children usually don’t need to take dietary supplements anyway.
    • If you’re thinking of submitting yourself or your child to a genetic test to guide healthcare decisions, you should do so under the guidance of a properly-credentialed genetics practitioner, who should consider not only the test itself, but also personal and family history.
The Yasko autism protocol ignores all of this, at the same time imposing an incredibly intrusive regimen and great financial cost on already-stressed families of autistic children. On top of that, recommending that patients purchase supplements and tests she recommends through her husband’s company presents a significant conflict of interest.
Yasko apparently sees the testimonials on her website and in her book as “proof” that her protocol “works.” But she was a researcher herself and she knows that’s not how competent scientists go about doing good science. She knows that only a well-designed, well-conducted clinical trial can show whether her protocol is effective. She knows that reputable scientists from the fields of autism, genetics, and nutrition have concluded we don’t have sufficient evidence to claim what she claims. (Far from it!) That makes it especially reprehensible that she is selling this complicated, unproven and expensive regimen to parents desperate to improve their autistic children’s lives.
Notes:For good information on evidence-based treatments and how to evaluate marketers’ claims, consult the Association for Science in Autism Treatment website.
For science-backed information on genetic testing and its limitations, see the National Library of Medicine: Genetic Testing.

Bleaching away what ails you
In an attempt to cure autism, some parents have taken to using Miracle Medical Solution (MMS), a “supplement” that is in reality a form of powerful bleach. They’re even giving autistic children bleach enemas. I wish I were kidding, but I’m dead serious.
David Gorski on May 28, 2012
Link
I’ve been at this blogging thing for over seven years, over four of which I’ve been honored to be a part of this particular group blog dedicated to promoting science as a basis for rational medical therapies. For three or four years before that seven year period began, I had honed my chops on Usenet in a group known as misc.health.alternative (m.h.a.). So, although I haven’t been at this as long as Steve Novella, I’ve been at it plenty long, which led me to think I had seen just about everything when it comes to pseudoscience and quackery.
As usual whenever I think I’ve seen it all, I was wrong.
I’m referring to something that has been mentioned once before on this blog, namely something called “Miracle Mineral Solution” (MMS). I must admit that after a brief reaction of “WTF?” I basically forgot about it. I shouldn’t have; I should have looked into it in more detail at the time. Fortunately, being a blogger means never having to say you’re sorry (at least about not having caught a form of quackery the first time it made big news), and fortunately MMS was brought to my attention in the context of an area of quackery that I frequently blog about. You’ll see what I mean in a minute.
What happened is that MMS was brought to my attention again by a couple of readers and, not remembering it other than vaguely, I did what I always do when confronted with these situations. I Googled, and I found what I needed to know. Basically, MMS is 28% sodium chlorite in distilled water. In essence, MMS is equivalent to industrial strength bleach. Proponents recommend diluting MMS in either water or a food acid, such as lemon juice, which results in the formation of chlorine dioxide.
MMS was originally sold by a man named Jim Humble, who claims that MMS can be used to successfully treat AIDS, hepatitis A,B and C, malaria, herpes, TB, most cancer and many more of mankind’s worse diseases. He even goes so far as to claim that 5,000,000 people have used MMS and that “hundreds of thousands” of lives have been saved. Unfortunately, it appears that for this function Jim Humble uses more concentrated MMS—a lot more concentrated. More horrifically, Humble bestows his “blessings” on poor people in Third World countries like Haiti, treating them like this:
We gotta give him just enough [industrial bleaching agent] that he don’t get sick but he’s on the edge of getting sick! So we’ve got to keep him just on the very edge and therefore it’s pretty intense for cancer, he needs to take it 4/5 times a day, small amounts instead of a big batch.
In fact, MMS is actually really nasty stuff, with some of its users suffering serious complications. Humble also teaches his disciples his quackery:
When people leave here they really know how to use MMS for all things, skin diseases of all kinds, colon problems, how to regenerate the liver, how to treat brain cancers, how to treat babies and pregnant women, and how to treat animals from mice to elephants. You will be personally taking MMS while here, spraying your skin with powerful solutions of MMS (but won’t hurt you), spraying others’ skin and hair. You will learn to use sprays, baths, IV solutions, MMS gas, soak the feet, and most importantly, the new protocols that in the country of Malawi have cured more than 800 people of HIV plus 40 cancer cases, 50 of feet and leg numbness, 3 heart disease cases, 13 diabetes cases, and many other diseases and problems.
Yes, you read it right. Jim Humble likes to go down to Haiti and the Dominican Republic and subject the poor there to his industrial bleach miracle cure. Unfortunately, he’s not alone in subjecting vulnerable populations to this “miracle cure.”
I learned that because it’s that time of year again.
Regular readers know what I’m talking about. Or, at least, they will know if I tell them I’m referring to a major meeting of the antivaccine movement. They know that sometime around the Memorial Day weekend every year, usually beginning a couple of days before the extended weekend and into the weekend itself, there lands in the Chicago area a quackfest of such unrelenting quackitude that it has to be seen to be believed. Basically, it’s the antivaccine and autism “biomed” movement Woodstock, except that it happens every year. Any and every quack and die-hard antivaccinationist who still believes believes against all evidence that vaccines cause autism is usually there. Anyone who’s anyone in the antivaccine movement was almost certainly there over this Memorial Day weekend (at least that part of the antivaccine movement that aligns itself with Generation Rescue/Age of Autism, anyway).
This quackfest is known as Autism One, and I’ve written about it before.
This year, as the Memorial Day weekend approached, and the Autism One conference started up, I wondered whether or not I should bother with it. I have, after all, been covering it every year for several years. It’s become predictable. Every year, I know that there will be quackery. There will likely be one or more skeptics trying to attend and, if they are recognized, getting kicked out to minimize the chances that a science-based or skeptical viewpoint about what goes on at Autism One will be published or posted anywhere. I didn’t know if anyone had planned on showing up at Autism One this year (although I do hope that someone did). Then it was pointed out to me that MMS would feature prominently at Autism One this year, and so it did. Yes, as one of my readers pointed out, MMS was featured in a talk at Autism One yesterday by a woman named Kerri Rivera, who boasts of 38 Children Recovered in 20 months:
This presentation will outline the approach Kerri has used successfully to help recover 38 children from a diagnosis of Autism. She will explain how MMS (chlorine dioxide) has become the “missing piece” to the autism puzzle for so many of the families that she works with. MMS is available worldwide, and is extremely cost effective, bringing recovery in reach of all families, despite economic or geographic limitations. This presentation seeks to prove that Autism truly is curable.
So let me emphasize this once again. Autism One, whose organizers claim that their conference is “all about the science,” featured a talk by a woman whose preferred form of therapy, besides hyperbaric oxygen, is to subject autistic children to industrial bleach in the deluded belief that she can “recover” autism with it. Rivera runs a clinic in Puerto Vallarta, Mexico that she calls AutismO2 Clinica Hyperbarica. If her website is any indication, Rivera gives autistic children MMS by mouth and by enema. (Yes, she subjects autistic children to bleach enemas.) Here’s the protocol:
Enema:10-15 drops MMS enabled and 500 mL waterIn the colon for 12 – 30 minutesUse pipette and syringeIs applied 2 or 3 times per week
Elsewhere, we see this:
Kerri will be discussing recent protocol developments around MMS and Autism, such as loading the dose, the baby bottle, the baking soda mix, enemas, baths, and how to handle a fever.
So let’s see. From my reading, it appears to me that proponents of MMS not only give MMS to autistic children orally, but bathe them in it and gives them enemas with it. Early on, as I was researching this post, I couldn’t find video of the actual Autism One presentation. So I went for the next “best” (if you can call it that) thing. A little Googling led me to this webinar about using MMS to treat autism. It features Jim Humble (the originator of MMS quackery) himself! Predictably, it starts with a “medical disclaimer” (i.e., quack Miranda warning) and then devolves from there:
Video streaming by Ustream
And here, as part of the same webinar, we see Rivera explaining how to administer the MMS by continually upping the dose:
Video streaming by Ustream
The latter video is utterly appalling. There really is no better way to describe it. In it, Rivera describes how, as you up the dose, you’ll see the autistic child do more stimming, which makes me wonder whether it’s because the child is feeling ill, leading him to show more autistic behaviors. Rivera, apparently believing in MMSHerxheimer reaction, which is sometimes seen after the initiation of antibacterials for tick borne relapsing fever. It was first describe as a reaction to the treatment of syphilis with penicillin and is also seen after treatment of other diseases caused by spirochetes, such as Lyme disease and leptospirosis. She talks about the “72-2” protocol, which, if you look at the website, involves giving MMS every two hours for 72 hours. She also recommends “fever therapy” and argues that it’s a good thing that MMS can cause fevers because it’s “waking up the immune system” which realizes that there’s “autism in the house.” She also exults about how she “loves the enemas” so much for autism.
Somehow, I doubt that autistic children love them as much as Rivera does. Maybe Rivera should try giving herself a bleach enema if she thinks it’s so great.
Next, take a gander at the handout that accompanies Rivera’s talk at Autism One. After the predictable Shopenhauer quote about truth “passing through three stages” (whose use is to me one of the surest signs I’m dealing with a quack or crank) her presentation includes a lot of the same nonsense that is touted in the video about bleach being safe and effective. There’s more stuff about “fever therapy” and a lot of stuff about getting rid of parasites, which, if you believe Rivera, MMS does in conjunction with all the other pseudoscience she promotes. She even promotes in essence giving a hot bleach bath (“to tolerance,” as she puts it) along with her fever therapy. Biologists in particular will laugh (or cry) at her misunderstanding of electrochemistry. It’s madness. And what’s her evidence? What do you think it is? It’s nothing more than unconvincing anecdotes.
Finally, let’s look at the actual presentation at Autism One itself. I was able to locate the presentation after it was pointed out to me that the videos from the live stream were being saved and were still accessible online. Here is the video for Rivera’s presentation. Her talk doesn’t start until approximately 4:20:

And part 2:

And part 3:

And part 4:

From the video, we learn that Kerri Rivera was trained as a DAN! (Defeat Autism Now!) practitioner (even though she is not a doctor) and charged by Bernie Rimland herself to translate DAN! protocols into Spanish and spread them throughout Latin America, like a preacher of woo. She’s also the director of a “clinic” even though she is apparently not a doctor or health care professional. Amusingly, during her presentation, when she talks about the “three stages” of truth in the quote attributed (likely mistakenly) to Schopenhauer, she opines that she’s still waiting for MMS to reach stage 3 (being accepted as self-evident). Apparently it never occurred to her that quackery never makes it to stage 3. It usually gets stuck at stage 1 or stage 2—and rightly so! Thus, MMS will always be stuck at stages 1 and 2 because MMS is rank quackery. But I digress…
One claim that stands out is this:
0.95 volts cannot harm body tissue. Human tissue has a voltage that can withstand greater than 1.28 volts (the oxidation potential of oxygen), thus .95 volts of chlorine dioxide.
This is silly in the extreme. Parasites, viruses, and bacteria, which chlorine dioxide suppresses, are made of the same organic molecules (protein, lipids, carbohydrates, nucleic acids, etc.) that human tissues are made of:
How does disinfection by chlorine dioxide work?
Substances of organic nature in bacterial cells react with chlorine dioxide, causing several cellular processes to be interrupted. Chlorine dioxide reacts directly with amino acids and the RNA in the cell. It is not clear whether chlorine dioxide attacks the cell structure or the acids inside the cell. The production of proteins is prevented. Chlorine dioxide affects the cell membrane by changing membrane proteins and fats and by prevention of inhalation.
When bacteria are eliminated, the cell wall is penetrated by chlorine dioxide. Viruses are eliminated in a different way; chlorine dioxide reacts with peptone, a water-soluble substance that originates from hydrolisis of proteins to amino acids. Chlorine dioxide kills viruses by prevention of protein formation. Chlorine dioxide is more effective against viruses than chlorine or ozone.
And:
Of the oxidizing biocides, chlorine dioxide is the most selective oxidant. Both ozone and chlorine are much more reactive than chlorine dioxide, and they will be consumed by most organic compounds. Chlorine dioxide however, reacts only with reduced sulphur compounds, secondary and tertiary amines, and some other highly reduced and reactive organics. This allows much lower dosages of chlorine dioxide to achieve a more stable residual than either chlorine or ozone. Chlorine dioxide, generated properly (all chlorine dioxide is not created equal), can be effectively used in much higher organic loading than either ozone or chlorine because of its selectivity.
As usual, it’s a matter of the dose making the poison. For example, the EPA sets the oral RfD (reference dose) for chlorine dioxide at 3 x 10-2 mg kg-1 d-1, which, for the average prototypical 70 kg man would be 2.1 mg per day. Rivera cites FDA regulations (21 CFR 173.300) regarding allowable levels of chlorine dioxide in food but neglects to point out what those allowed levels are:
The additive may be used as an antimicrobial agent in water used to wash fruits and vegetables that are not raw agricultural commodities in an amount not to exceed 3 ppm residual chlorine dioxide as determined by Method 4500-ClO2 E, referenced in paragraph (a)(2) of this section, or an equivalent method. Treatment of the fruits and vegetables with chlorine dioxide shall be followed by a potable water rinse or by blanching, cooking, or canning.
In other words, the amount that is permissible to use is low, and the fruit and the FDA requires that the food be rinsed with water afterwards or cooked so that the ClO2 goes away. This is a different situation than taking increasing concentrations of MMS based on adding drops of 28% solution of sodium hypochlorite designed to generate ClO2.
Elswwhere I have seen claims that the target concentration for MMS is 1 ppm and that tap water can have up to 0.8 ppm chlorine dioxide. If that were the case, then way bother with MMS? Just give your kid tap water to cure autism! Of course, it’s not the case. All one has to do is to look at Rivera’s protocol. Given that chlorine dioxide is approved in drinking water up to a maximum concentration of 0.8 ppm (or 0.8 mg/L), if a child took in 1-2 L per day of water (the amount depends on weight), then that would be around 0.8 to 1.6 mg of chlorine dioxide per day. Rivera’s recommended protocol involves working the dose up to 8 to 24 drops per day (1 to 3 drops administered 8 times a day), depending on the child’s weight. Now, a drop of MMS contains roughly 10 mg of sodium chlorite, which generates around 8 mg of chlorine dioxide. This means giving children between 64 and 192 mg of chlorine dioxide per day, depending on the child’s weight. That’s up to 120 times what even an older child could reasonably expect to be exposed to through drinking tap water. And, of course, this neglects the fact that most children don’t drink just tap water; usually they drink other things and don’t drink nearly 1 to 2 liters of tap water in a day. Under real world conditions, the math would work out even worse than what I’ve estimated. Also don’t forget that Rivera recommends giving MMS as an enema. To a child—any child—receiving an enema is likely to be a traumatic experience. For a child with autism, who tends to be more sensitive to various stimuli than neurotypical children, it could be sheer torture, even if there was nothing other than water in the enema.
Particularly amusing to me is the segment where Rivera writes that MMS is not snake oil. Her reasoning? Snake oil doesn’t recover children from autism in 21 months. Of course, she didn’t actually provide any actual evidence that she “recovered” even a single child from autism. She does however, claim that autism is “made up of pathogens,” including viruses, bacteria, parasites, candida, heavy metals, inflammation, and food allergies. Of course, heavy metals, inflammation, and food allergies are not pathogens, but then clearly biology and biochemistry are not Rivera’s strong suits. In any case, she claims that “40 more” children “lost their diagnosis” in the last 21 months. No control group. No solid evidence that these children were actually autistic to begin with, no evidence that MMS had anything to do with their progress, if progress it was.
In retrospect, I should have figured that, if there’s any form of quackery out there, someone, somewhere will be using it on autistic children. MMS is, of course, no different. Two days later, I’m also still amazed that I didn’t know more about MMS. After all, I’ve been looking at quackery of various sorts for over a decade now. I guess that just means there’s always something new to learn and some new woo to hear about—unfortunately. True, many of them are variations on a theme, basically the same old nonsense with a fresh coat of paint slapped on it to make it attractive to the unwary. True, each new generation of quacks appropriates old ideas and tarts them up with the newest science-y sounding terminology of the era in which they operate.
This is also the second time that I’ve seen autism quacks subjecting autistic children to what is, in essence, potentially nasty industrial chemicals. A couple of years ago, disgraced chemistry professor and mercury warrior Boyd Haley pumped autistic children full of an industrial chelator, claiming it was a “supplement.” Ultimately, Haley drew the attention of the FDA, which shut him down. Now, we’re seeing quacks douse autistic children in bleach, pump their colons full of it, and feed it to them until they start to have fevers and diarrhea, believing that the diarrhea and fever are evidence that the bleach is working to reverse autism. The diarrhea and fever might well be working to do something, but reversing autism is not part of that something. Making children sick is. Here’s a typical anecdote:
My 14YO son has autism. I’ve been treating him with a parasite cleanse system for 1.5 years (5 days on, 2 days off). He’s made some remarkable improvements, but every time I try to wean him off the cleanse, the parasite symptoms flare up. He is nonverbal and fairly low-functioning, so I don’t get any feedback from him as to how he is feeling. Last week, I started him on 1 drop of MMS then upped the dose to 1 drop, 2x a day this week. After about 4 days at 2 drops/day, he vomited once and had diarrhea all day. I am assuming it is the MMS. I decided to drop down to 1 drop/day again until he gets beyond this. He tends to have loose stools anyway, which I am guessing is related to this ongoing battle with the parasites. His gut tends to be very sensitive to anything I give him, so I have to go very carefully with anything new like the MMS. I am still giving him the other parasite cleanse (Systemic Formulas VRM 1-4). I would love to hear anyone’s ideas or insight into this. I am working with a homeopath who has done extensive research into parasite cleanses, but she has not researched MMS. I’m looking to get my son beyond these parasites once and for all. My homeopath and her colleagues are autism experts and do consults with parents from around the world. They have found that the children with autism who are considered “tough nuts” tend to also be parasite kids. With their compromised immune systems, it is difficult to eradicate parasites.
There’s only one word for this: appalling. Actually, there’s another word for it, too: Quackery. Pure quackery.

Premature Claims for Neurotrophic Factors
Steven Novella on November 9, 2011
Link
Scientific medicine is not easy. By this point we have largely picked the low hanging fruit, and continued improvements are mostly incremental and hard won. In order to get the most out of our limited research dollars, and optimize medical practice with the safest and most effective treatments, we need to use all available scientific evidence in the proper way. That is the essence of SBM.
There are those, however, that misuse or abuse the scientific evidence — whether to promote an ideology, out of innocent ignorance, or for nefarious purposes. In order to be truly science-based a medical intervention should be plausible, or at least not implausible, based upon basic science evidence, and it should actually be safe and effective when tested in people. Therefore, medical practices can fail to be scientific for one of two broad reasons: they can be scientifically implausible, or they can lack proper clinical evidence for safety and efficacy (or even have evidence for lack of efficacy). Some modalities (like homeopathy) fail on both counts.
The more pernicious medical claims are those that seem highly plausible, that can be extrapolated from basic science, but simply lack adequate clinical evidence. Stem cell clinics are an example — they can easily dazzle desperate patients with scientific descriptions of how stem cells work, and even cite published basic-science papers showing the potential of this technology. But what they cannot do is provide clinical evidence that the specific intervention they are offering is safe and effective for the specific disease or condition they are treating.
I recently came across another example of this type of failure — the promotion of neurotrophic factors for autism and other neurodevelopmental disorders. One center, the Neurorecovery Center Edelfo, specializes in this claim.
Neurotrophic factors are generally proteins that bind to cells and cause them to grow, proliferate, or just maintain their functionality. Some nervous system cells would die without a steady supply of the needed neurotrophic factors. The discovery of neurotrophic factors and their role in nervous system function was certainly very important to our understanding of neurological diseases. This knowledge has also led to a great deal of speculation about the potential of neurotrophic factors in treating neurological diseases.
After a couple decades of clinical research, however, the reality has not lived up to the promise. As is often the case, highly plausible ideas do not pan out in clinical research. Several neurotrophic factors, for example have been studied in diseases like ALS without any measurable clinical benefit. They are just another reminder that the body is complex, and even when we have a very compelling picture of why a treatment should work, that picture is almost certainly incomplete. We cannot know what the net effect will be of a treatment until we do rigorous clinical trials.
Another way to look at this is that the body has evolved complex mechanisms of self-regulation. It is not easy to push or pull on one piece of this complex system and predict the net effect. There are many reasons why a treatment that we predict should work, doesn’t.
Edelfo is doing what many similar clinics or supplement marketers do — making simplistic extrapolations from the basic science to clinical claims, without supporting those claims with clinical evidence. They cite basic science research to give the false impression they are science-based. For example, they write on their website:
BDNF has shown to have a neurotrophic effect in serotoninergic and dopaminergic neurons, but also in glutamatergic neurons of the hippocampus and the sensory regions like pain, touch and hearing. BDNF also contributes to the maturation of GABAergic neurons, so it can also be useful in bipolar disorders, schizophrenia, ADD, memory, neuronal deficits that affect audition, sensitivity, etc.GDNF has shown a specific effect in dopaminergic neurons and secondly in motor neurons, so it can be very useful in ADD, where a hypo development of the dopaminergic circuit has been shown, although there are other types of ADD that are generated by alterations in other regions like the frontal lobe, basal ganglia, etc. GDNF can also be useful in Parkinson’s, where there is a severe loss of the dopaminergic neurons of the substantia nigra and in motor problems, where experimental studies performed in rodents with motor damage have shown that the GDNF favors the axonal growth of motor neurons and improves the functional recovery.
Edelfo uses a diagnostic method based upon EEG to then design a nutritional supplement for their specific customers. The claims above are an excellent example of the type of pseudoscientific deception I am describing.  There is indeed a great deal of interest in GDNF for Parkinson’s disease. Animals studies have shown promise, but human studies have been negative. The problem is probably due to getting the GDNF to the target tissue.
GDNF is a protein. If you eat a protein it will be broken down into amino acids and used as food — it will not get into the bloodstream unaltered. This is why protein-based drugs typically need to be given intravenously, to bypass the stomach. GDNF has even more difficulty, however, since it also needs to cross the blood brain barrier — a protective barrier around blood vessels in the brain evolved to specifically regulate what gets into the brain. To overcome this issue researchers have used one of two methods — they either use gene therapy to insert GDNF producing genes into brain cells, or they use a continuous infusion of GDNF into the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF).
There are rather extreme methods of introducing a drug to the body, but they are necessary. And even still, researchers speculate that the CSF infusions used in human trials were not sufficient to get GDNF to the cells in the brain that are the target of treatment.
It is with these types of issues that pseudoscientific treatments often fail — bioavailability and pharmacokinetics. Does the substance get into the body, and what happens to it once it does? Basing claims for a nutritional supplement on the activity of BDNF is highly deceptive. It certainly can sound compelling to a non-expert, but the claims utterly fail when closely examined. The same, by the way, can be said for BDNF, which is also a protein.
Edelfo’s use of EEG (electroencephalogram), visual and auditory evoked potentials (VEP, AEP) is also questionable. These modalities are all legitimate methods of research and diagnosis, but they need to be specifically validated for each specific clinical use. They are therefore ripe for exploitation — they can be used inappropriately to give the impression of high-tech diagnostic procedure without the evidence to support the specific application.
The published research in this area is complex and mixed. In autism, for example, studies do show that there is a statistical difference in AEPs between autistic and typical children. This does not mean, however, that the test has specificity or sensitivity in the diagnosis of an individual. This is a common misuse of scientific evidence: using group comparisons and applying them to the individual. A different kind of study is necessary to see what predictive value the test has when applied to an individual. There are therefore many diagnostic modalities that are useful for research, but are not used clinically for this reason.
To further bolster their claims Edelfo does publish a few in-house studies. The quality of these studies is so low, however, that they are useless for anything but marketing. In a study of another neurotrophic factor, FGF2, in autism, the study was published in Defeat Autism Now (DAN), which is a dubious site dedicated to biological treatments for autism and notorious for making pseudoscientific claims. That aside, the study itself is fatally flawed in numerous ways, including using very low subject numbers and not describing any blinding. These types of studies are almost guaranteed to generate false positive results — again, useful for marketing, but not doing good science.
Conclusion
The public needs to be aware of the types of misleading claims that are made by clinics, centers, and marketers of health products that can seem very scientific when they are not. The use of pre-clinical evidence to make clinical claims, the use of research methods for clinical diagnosis, and the use of supplements without any consideration of bioavailability are chief among them. Patients and their families are cautioned to be skeptical of any clinic or center that claims to offer a unique service. Further, any clinical claims being made should be backed by well-designed clinical trials of the specific claims published in respected peer-reviewed journals.
Anything less than this is likely to be selling false hope, not a legitimate treatment.

Luc Montagnier and the Nobel Disease
David Gorski on June 4, 2012
Link
Few awards in anything have the cachet and respect the Nobel Prizes in various disciplines possess. In my specialty, medicine, the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine is quite properly viewed as the height of achievement. In terms of prestige, particularly in the world of science, the Nobel Prize is without peer. To win the Nobel Prize in Medicine or another scientific field, a scientist must have made a discovery considered fundamentally important to the point that it changes the way we think about one aspect of science or medicine. Winning the Nobel Prize in a scientific field instantly elevates a scientist from whatever he or she was before to the upper echelons of world science.
So how, one might ask, is it that seemingly so frequently Nobel Laureates embrace crankery or pseudoscience in their later years? They call it the Nobel Disease, and, indeed, it’s a term listed in the Skeptics’ Dictionary (where the term is attributed to me based on this post about Linus Pauling from four years ago, but I can’t claim credit for coining the term; it existed before I wrote that post) and Rational Wiki, complete with examples. What inspired me to take on this topic, dusting off some old knowledge and writings, is that we apparently have a new victim of the Nobel Disease. Well, perhaps “new” is not the right word, but he is the most recent example. I’m referring to Luc Montagnier, who with Françoise Barré-Sinoussi was awarded the Nobel Prize in Medicine for the discovery of HIV in 2008.
Unfortunately, it didn’t take Montagnier very long to devolve into crankery. Until 2009, to be precise. Since then, Montagnier has embraced concepts like DNA teleportation and ideas very much like homeopathy. And then, just last month, his journey to the dark side was complete. Yes, Luc Montagnier presented at the yearly quackfest I discussed last week, the one in which there was much enthusiasm among the attendees for a treatment that involves administering bleach enemas to autistic children. He presented at Autism One, a coup that caused much rejoicing in the antivaccine movement.
The Nobel Disease and me
Given my interest in skepticism, science-based medicine, and pseudoscience, it’s always interested me how scientists and doctors become cranks. Even more interesting is how people who have achieved the pinnacle of scientific glory, people whom one would reasonable expect to be about as immune to pseudoscience and crankery as anyone on this planet, manage to fail so spectacularly into quackery. Of course, Linus Pauling is the prototypical example, which is why I’ve written about him before multiple times, both here on SBM and elsewhere. A brilliant chemist who won two Nobel Prizes, one for chemistry and the Nobel Peace Prize, in his later years Pauling became convinced that high dose vitamin C was a highly effective treatment for cancer and the common cold and, expanding upon that, came to believe in the quackery that is orthomolecular medicine. As a result, Pauling’s reputation was tainted for all time, and he became known more for his crankery than his successes. Since his death, Pauling’s successors have continued to chase his dream with no real success because even massive doses of vitamin C have little or no effect on cancer and may even interfere with some chemotherapy regimens. I haven’t checked up on the latest research on vitamin C and cancer (perhaps that would be a subject for another post), but I have no doubt that Pauling’s acolytes are still out there, still trying to prove that giving multi-gram quantities of ascorbate can cure cancer.
Unfortunately, Pauling is not alone in becoming a crank. Linus Pauling might have been my first experience with the Nobel Disease, but it was not a personal experience. A few years ago, I actually got to confront the Nobel Disease, up close and personal so to speak, at a surgical meeting. The keynote speaker was Louis J. Ignarro, who was awarded the Nobel Prize in 1998 along with Robert F. Furchgott and Ferid Murad for their discovery that nitric oxide is a signaling molecule (a discovery, which, by the way, is far more important than just its role in providing a mechanism of action for Viagra and all those other related drugs now used to treat erectile dysfunction, as one of our regular commenters will happily tell you).
Unfortunately, Ignarro didn’t even wait until his later years to descend into the swamp of dubious science. In 2006, I saw Ignarro give an ostensibly scientific talk at the Academic Surgical Congress in San Diego, a talk whose second half was dominated by a discussion of arginine supplementation as a heart disease cure-all. Ignarro started by weaving a fascinating story of the experiments, reasoning, and evidence that led to the discovery of nitric oxide and its importance as a signaling molecule. He is a captivating speaker, and I was enjoying the talk immensely. As his talk progressed, I thought he was a great speaker for the American Association for Academic Surgery, one of the two surgical societies sponsoring the Academic Surgical Congress. (The Society of University Surgeons is the other). The AAS is an organization dedicated to encouraging academic and research careers in young surgeons. Indeed, one can only be an active voting member for 10 years after taking one’s first faculty position or until age 45, whichever is longer. After that, AAS members are required to superannuate (become “emeritus” non-voting members). Consequently, at the yearly conferences, one of the goals is to invite scientists of some renown to talk good science and fire up the troops, and usually one of these is a basic scientist rather than a surgeon. Dr. Ignarro seemed to be doing an admirable job.
And then there was a change.
With about 10 or 15 minutes to go in his talk, he changed gears abruptly, and it was like the grinding of metal on metal — to me at least. I saw a few looks of puzzlement among the young surgeons sitting around me, but for the most part everyone took this change without any evidence that it bothered them.
What happened is that Dr. Ignarro started delving into what sounded to me like woo about diet and heart disease, discussing evidence that he had developed that arginine supplementation increases nitric oxide levels and protects against heart disease. It was somewhat interesting, and he might have been on to something. However, he was clearly vastly overselling it, indeed outright advocating that everyone should be taking arginine supplementation because it would greatly reduce the risk of developing heart disease through its generation of nitric oxide. I might not have thought about it much again, but then he did something that I’ve never seen a scientific speaker do before at an invited scientific talk at a conference. He started discussing (hawking, actually) a diet book he had written called No More Heart Disease: How Nitric Oxide Can Prevent — Even Reverse — Heart Disease And Stroke. In a single — if you’ll excuse the term — stroke during the last 15 or 20 minutes of his talk, Ignarro turned what should have been an inspiring talk given to a bunch of young surgeon-scientists to fire them up to want to be great researchers and push the boundaries of surgical science into little more than an infomercial for his book and a forum to pontificate about his dubious ideas regarding nutrition. Even if his work on arginine ever panned out (which to my knowledge it has not yet in the 6 years since the meeting), when he gave his talk it was clearly not ready for prime-time, and it’s not as though various alternative medicine practitioners hadn’t been pushing arginine supplementation and various other nutritional “treatments” for a long time already. Ignarro gave them a seemingly scientific basis for these claims. He might turn out to be right, but even if he is, he had no business making the claims that he did based on the evidence that he had.
I was greatly disturbed and quite disappointed, as I sensed another Linus Pauling in the making. This concern was further amplified when I later heard about his inventing and promoting a dubious dietary supplement with HerbaLife and publishing a PNAS article touting arginine supplementation in which he failed to disclose his financial interest with HerbaLife. At the time, I was worried at the effect his talk might have on a bunch of idealistic young surgeons who are desperately trying to do good science, even in the face of having to maintain a clinical practice in surgery. Worse, as I found later when discussing the talk with colleagues, many of them didn’t recognize the dubiousness of the last part of the talk. They were a bit taken aback by his peddling of his book, but seemed willing to accept the whole package, including the last part of the talk. The Nobel Prize halo is strong indeed. I still remember how betrayed I felt as his talk progressed and wondered if the meeting organizers felt a similar sense of betrayal or whether they were too in awe of the Nobel aura to notice.
I couldn’t help but compare Ignarro to Nikolaas Tinbergen, whose adoption of the “refrigerator mother” hypothesis as the cause of autism in his actual Nobel lecture led Prometheus to quip that Tinbergen’s Nobel acceptance speech represented a “nearly unbeatable record for shortest time between receiving the Nobel Prize and saying something really stupid about a field in which the recipient had little experience.” Unfortunately, these days, Ignarro has teamed up with a naturopath named Andrew Myers to promote his practice. Myers, it turns out, is the President and Chief Science officer of NutraGenetics, a company Ignarro founded to sell his arginine supplements. Ignarro is even blogging on Myers’ blog and promoting a book they wrote together, Health Is Wealth: Performance Nutrition, complete with Myers on the cover, lab coat, stethoscope, and all, trying to look like a real doctor. From my perspective, if you’re a Nobel laureate whose scientific acumen has fallen to the point where you think it’s a good idea to appoint a naturopath as the chief science officer of your company, the Nobel committee should consider revoking your prize. In my opinion, of course.
It took Ignarro only a few years to go from Nobel Laureate to borderline, if not outright, crank. Sadly, took Montagnier only a year, if even that.
The Nobel Disease strikes Luc Montagnier
Luc Montagnier shared the Nobel Prize in 2008 for his discovery of the human immunodeficiency with Harald zur Hausen, who discovered the link between the human papilloma virus and cervical cancer, an event that Steve Novella took note of when Montagnier received the award. Then, earlier this summer, Montagnier appeared to endorse homeopathy:
French virologist Luc Montagnier stunned his colleagues at a prestigious international conference when he presented a new method for detecting viral infections that bore close parallels to the basic tenets of homeopathy.
Although fellow Nobel prize winners — who view homeopathy as quackery — were left openly shaking their heads, Montagnier’s comments were rapidly embraced by homeopaths eager for greater credibility.
Montagnier told the conference last week that solutions containing the DNA of pathogenic bacteria and viruses, including HIV, “could emit low frequency radio waves” that induced surrounding water molecules to become arranged into “nanostructures”. These water molecules, he said, could also emit radio waves
He suggested water could retain such properties even after the original solutions were massively diluted, to the point where the original DNA had effectively vanished. In this way, he suggested, water could retain the “memory” of substances with which it had been in contact — and doctors could use the emissions to detect disease.
Our very own Harriet Hall commented on one of Montagnier’s studies that was embraced by homeopaths as “proof” that homeopathy “works.” Montagnier may not beat Tinbergen’s record for shortest time to descend into pseudoscience after winning the Nobel Prize, but he’s definitely in contention. As if drifting into concepts that resemble those of homeopathy weren’t enough, Montagnier has also made a name for himself, such as it is, by appearing in the HIV/AIDS denialist film House of Numbers stating that HIV can be cleared naturally through nutrition and supplements:
Meanwhile, Montagnier patented a device to detect these fantastical radiowaves allegedly emitted by bacterial and viral DNA in water. This he did after publishing a paper in a journal that for which himself is the editor after a mere three days between submission and acceptance, which prompted Le Canard Noir to nominate him for an Ignobel Prize. So, as of around 2010, Luc Montagnier had already racked up an impressive list of crankery in a very short time after winning his Nobel Prize.
He wasn’t done, however.
Montagnier, autism quackery, and the antivaccine movement
Upon learning that Montagnier was going to present at Autism One, I decided that I would try to find his talk and then blog about it, given that AO usually posts video of all the talks. After all, I had no trouble last week finding the video for Kerri Rivera’s talk at AO about using bleach enemas to cure autism, and Mark and David Geier’s talk is posted. Now, a week later, links to saved streams of pretty much every talk appears to be posted at the Autism One website. Even Jenny McCarthy’s keynote speech is there.
Unfortunately, thus far I have not been able to find the video for Montagnier’s keynote talk. However, take a look at the description of his talk, entitled, The Microbial Track (an extended version of the abstract is here):
Our group of researchers and physicians from European countries, Chronimed, is studying chronic diseases. Our recent observations may lead to new approaches of treatment and prevention. These observations are of two types: biological and clinical. There is in the blood of most autistic children — but not in healthy children — DNA sequences that emit, in certain conditions, electromagnetic waves. The analysis by molecular biology techniques allows us to identify these electromagnetic waves as coming from already known bacterial species. This correlation, which is based on more than one hundred children of European origin, naturally does not prove a causal relationship. However, a therapy first started by a group of independent clinicians and now performed in conjunction with laboratory observations reinforces the idea that systemic bacterial infections play a role in the genesis of symptoms of autism.
Our GPs have observed that a long-term therapy consisting of successive antibiotic treatments with accompanying medications induced in 60% of cases a significant improvement — sometimes even a complete resolution of symptoms. These children can now lead a normal school and family life. In conjunction with these treatments resulting in amelioration of symptoms is the disappearance of electromagnetic signals associated with the plasma bacterial DNA.
Our working hypothesis is that immune dysfunction associated with inflammation of the intestinal mucosa leads to the introduction of bacterial components, including neurotoxins, into the bloodstream, creating oxidative stress as well as microvascularities, especially affecting meningeal vessels and finally specific neuronal damage.
Of course, much research is still needed to strengthen this hypothesis, but our goal here is to have the medical community and the parents be aware of these opportunities for immediate treatment that can improve or cure more than half of autistic children. It is expected that, in the future, similar approaches will be applied to other serious chronic conditions of children and adults, including rheumatological disorders.
Montagnier also posted this on his website. Elsewhere, on the Chronimed website, it is claimed that 70% of children improve “dramatically” and that the other 30% improve more slowly.
So let me get this straight: Montagnier is now claiming that there exist in the blood of autistic children DNA sequences that emit radio waves that come from bacteria? Based on this, he is treating autistic children with long term antibiotics? Really?
I also note that he also claims that the same sequences are found in the blood of patients with Alzheimer’s disease, Parkinson’s disease, multiple sclerosis, various neuropathies, chronic Lyme syndrome, and rheumatoid arthritis. Never mind that the results of Montagnier’s experiments suggesting that DNA emits radio waves are far more likely to be due to contaminants in his PCR reactions than they are to be due to anything else. In any case, since I can’t evaluate the talk itself (perhaps I will once the video finally surfaces, as I have no doubt that it will), I will go back in time to when the clinical trial Montagnier proposed was first hitting the news. I first learned about it from Gimpy and Anthony Cox. Unfortunately, the pseudoscience that Montagnier appears to have embraced with respect to autism was combined with a highly unethical study in a manner that would put Andrew Wakefield to shame.
The trial was sponsored by the Autism Treatment Trust (ATT) and the Autism Research Institute (ARI), both institutions that are — shall we say? — not exactly known for their scientific rigor. Montagnier teamed up with a Dr. Corinne Skorupka, who is a DAN! practitioner from France, and a Dr. Lorene Amet, who is described as a neuroscientist but is a PhD and not an MD (i.e., not a clinician). The study that, together, the Nobel Prize winner and quacks propose is described thusly:
We are finally in a position to run some very exciting investigations/interventions with the support of Professor Montagnier, Nobel Prize winner for Medicine (for the discovery of HIV) and Dr. C. Skorupka a DAN! practitioner from Paris and long time friend. The project proposes to look at potential bacterial and viral chronic infections in autism. Prof Montagnier is of the view that some abnormalities in autism as well as in a whole range of neurological conditions, such as chronic fatigue and multiple sclerosis may be caused by potential infective agents. These would be difficult to the immune system to track down and would affect cell function thereby contributing to the development of the pathologies. He has developed a new technique that detects, by resonance, the genetic material of these potential infective agents. Additionally, using a very sensitive PCR assay, he can screen for a range of gram positive and gram negative bacteria as well as mycoplasma and Borrelia (Lyme disease). He can also look at viruses (PCR assays under development). We are not alone in believing that this approach can help develop our understanding of the causes of autism and enable it to be treated more effectively. The proposed treatment combines a succession of antibiotics with basic biomedical supplements and probiotics. These antibiotics block cell division rather than kill bacteria, thereby avoiding potential side effects. Unfortunately, at the moment, there is no funding available to cover the costs of this project, but we are hoping to use the data collected to help us obtain funding for future research.
One reason I’m quoting liberally and am not directly linking to the web pages for these quotes is because the original links are dead, and they do not appear to exist in the Wayback Machine. It rather makes you wonder, doesn’t it? You’ll see why I say this in a minute. In the meantime, before I discuss the “study” itself, let me just say one thing here. Whenever you see an “investigator” charge patients to undergo an experimental protocol, be very, very afraid. In general, with very few exceptions, reputable medical researchers do not ask patients to pay to undergo experimental protocols; their studies are funded with grants from the government, private foundations, or pharmaceutical companies. Yet here we have Montagnier and colleagues charging the parents of autistic children (also summarized here):
We offer your child the opportunity to be part of this project and to access to the Montagnier Infection Screen protocol. There will be medical follow up from Dr. Skorupka. The details of the project are outlined below. The total cost per child is likely to be around £1800, spread over a six-month period (details below). The antibiotic treatment is not included and may cost some £30- £60 a month, depending of the particular antibiotic selected. Every two months each child’s progress will be reviewed by Dr. Skorupka and Dr. Amet at ATT with interim progress reviews carried out by phone.
It would appear to be the results of this “clinical trial” that Montagnier reported at Autism One. Because the original sources describing the trial appear to have been thrown down the memory hole, I rely on people like Anthony Cox to show just how badly designed this experimental protocol is. Here are its specific aims:
    • Investigate the possibility that some cases of autism are associated with a range of bacterial infections, based on laboratory testing and clinical examination conducted by Dr. C. Skorupka in Edinburgh.
    • Assess the ASD children for the presence of nanobacteria following Prof Luc Montagnier’s protocol of investigations. The protocol would require a blood draw conducted at the clinic with the help of our nurse. The blood normally has to be centrifuged immediately and the supernatant extracted, then frozen to -80C and shipped on carboice to France.
    • Evaluate the efficacy of antibiotic intervention as well as behavioural evaluations (ATEC and ADOS). This would involve meeting with Dr Skopurpka and Dr. Amet every 2 months and reviewing progress over the phone in the interim month.
    • Report outcomes.
How is this study unethical? Let me count the ways. First, as I mentioned, it charges the patient for an experimental protocol. More importantly, it tests a hypothesis that is highly implausible from a biological standpoint. That bacterial or viral infection might cause or contribute to autism does not reach homeopathy-level implausibility, but it also doesn’t reach the level of plausibility where it can be considered ethical to subject human subjects to a prolonged regimen of antibiotic treatment based on it. One reason is that there are no convincing preclinical data to support the idea that bacterial or viral infections either cause or contribute to autism. Quite the opposite, in fact. Of course, where scientists note that there is no relationship between specific infections and autism, no doubt Montagnier would claim that any old bacterial infection will do. After all, his magic device, at least according to him, detects any bacterial or viral DNA, even after it’s been diluted to nonexistence and the water filtered so that no DNA could be left behind.
But it gets even worse than that.
Based on an unsupported hypothesis that bacterial infections cause autism, Montagnier has subjected autistic children to blood draws and prolonged treatment with antibiotics. The former cause unnecessary pain and suffering, and the latter has the potential to cause well-known complications. These include antibiotic-induced diarrhea and even C. difficile colitis, as well as a variety of other problems that can be caused when a child’s normal bacterial flora are killed off with antibiotics. Even if children avoid that problem, there is the issue of selecting for resistant bacteria, leaving the child’s bacterial flora altered to contain a higher proportion of bacteria resistant to antibiotics. Since there is no reason to suspect that these children have any sort of clinical infection that needs treatment, giving them antibiotics for several months is all risk, no potential benefit. It’s completely unethical.
But it gets even worse than that.
The study proposed was poorly designed even for a pilot study. There was no control group, for one thing. Unless Montagnier radically changed the protocol, the children got the regimen, and the parents paid the practitioners to administer it. Moreover, because the selection criteria for the study were not specified, there is no way of knowing how much selection bias might have been operative, given that Montagnier now apparently claims that 60% of his subjects improved almost completely on long term antibiotics. Apparently he has also greatly expanded his study, which was originally supposed to be of only 12 subjects. However, now he reports that he’s helped over 200 children. I’d really love to see the evidence he uses to support that claim. Hopefully the video will show up at Autism One soon.
While I’m waiting, though, I want to know how quacks like this can get away with doing such unethical clinical trials. In the U.S., we have Mark and David Geier, who created an Institutional Review Board at their own “research institute” with cronies. The likely reason they could get away with it was because their research wasn’t federally funded, nor did their “research institute” receive federal funds. Thus they could skirt the Common Rule, which applies only to research being carried out at institutions receiving federal funds or research being used to support an application for FDA approval, although many states require any human subjects research carried within their borders to adhere to the Common Rule regardless of funding source. I’m not sufficiently familiar with the U.K. to know exactly how its ethical oversight of human subjects research works, but fortunately Gimpy was there to explain. Given that Montagnier’s trial used medicinal compounds (antibiotics), it clearly required oversight from an ethics board. Did it get it? What ethics board oversaw this trial? In the UK, clinical trials are regulated by the Medicines and Health Care products Regulatory Agency (MHRA), which enforces regulations that dictate that clinical trials of medicinal products in human subjects requires authorization by the MHRA and authorization by an ethics committee much like IRBs in the United States. Not only is there no indication that this trial has obtained the necessary approvals from the MHRA and an applicable ethics committee. In other words, it’s bad science and bad ethics, all rolled into one.
The Nobel Disease redux
I’ve wondered how some Nobel Laureates, after having achieved so much, proving themselves at the highest levels by making fundamental contributions to our understanding of science that they rate the highest honors, somehow end up embracing dubious science (Ignarro) or even outright pseudoscience (Pauling or Montagnier). Does the fame go to their head? Do they come to think themselves so much more creative than other scientists that their fantastical ideas become plausible to them? Does winning the Nobel Prize lead some scientists to think that the genius they showed in their own area of expertise that allowed them to win such an exalted prize also applies to other areas of science outside their area of expertise? Who knows? What I do know is that Montagnier has become the latest Nobel Laureate to become a crank. He even has the requisite persecution complex, as demonstrated in this post on his own blog from April entitled To autistic children, in which he complains about criticism and then, in essence, says, “They thought me mad — mad, I tell you! — but I’ll show them!” (Well, actually, he laments how the “country of Claude Bernard and Louis Pasteur” has become the “land of Diafoirus in an intellectual dictatorship that sterilizes any medical advance that upsets the establishment.” Then comes the prediction:
This work was not born today. It follows from patient observations made over the years by doctors, who dared not to follow mainstream antibiotic use. The very rapid progress resulting from careful use of antibiotics in these autistic children exceeded the expectations of both the doctors and the parents, attested by numerous videos and testimonials.
Of course this approach does not always work. We must confirm this breakthrough by controlled double blind clinical trials, but within the rules of medical ethics.
I support this approach even more as it coincides with another breakthrough, the science that I am developing, supported by an international network of physicists and biologists : detection with biophysical methods of latent infections by viruses and bacteria. These very infections are identified in autistic children, and also in neurodegenerative diseases, joint diseases, and certain cancers. Early detection will allow new approaches to prevention of these diseases so very prevalent in our population.
I really do need to see Montagnier’s Autism One video.
Through his work in isolating and identifying the human immunodeficiency virus, Luc Montagnier contributed to a major advance in science that ultimately led to effective treatments for AIDS and chronic HIV infection. He deserved his Nobel Prize. That’s why it makes me very sad to see him fall so far so fast. Presenting at Autism One is almost the bottom of the barrel as far as science goes. After palling around and sharing the podium with the likes of Andrew Wakefield, Mark and David Geier, Kerri Rivera, Mark Blaxill, Dan Olmsted, and the like, the only way Montagnier could fall lower would be if he were to take up a writing gig on NaturalNews.com.
I really hope I don’t see that next year, but, sadly, it wouldn’t surprise me if I did.

For-profit stem cell clinics, universities, and “pay-to-play” clinical trials for autism
Stem cell therapies show great promise, but as yet the vast majority of that promise has not been validated in rigorous clinical trials. Unfortunately, for-profit stem cell clinics are running clinical trials that require patients to pay to be part of it. These trials are not rigorous. Even more unfortunately, it appears that some universities are also running “pay-to-play” clinical trials that bear an uncomfortable resemblance to those run by for-profit clinics.
David Gorski on July 29, 2019
Link

There is little doubt that stem cell therapy has considerable promise to treat a wide variety of degenerative diseases. Unfortunately, little of that promise has been realized yet, and, even more unfortunately, the promise of stem cell therapy has attracted scammers and quacks like the proverbial flies to honey. Dubious stem cell clinics try to attract customers using a combination of high pressure sales techniques akin to those used by time share salespeople, providing free products to celebrities in order to gain publicity and testimonials, and even using dubious clinical trials and ClinicalTrials.gov as advertising tools. It’s for that reason that I have said on multiple occasions, every for-profit stem cell clinic is a predatory quack clinic. At least, if there’s an exception to that rule of thumb, I haven’t found it yet, and I’ve been looking for years. Unfortunately, these clinics have proliferated all over the world, including the US, without any strong scientific evidence that the stem cell treatments used are effective.
With that background in mind, I came across an article in Spectrum:
Hyperbaric chambers. Dietary supplements. Special diets. Dorinda Weeks’ son Aaron had tried them all. Ever since Aaron was diagnosed with autism at age 4, Weeks had resisted medication and behavioral therapies supported by science in favor of alternative approaches.
Aaron had repetitive behaviors such as hand-flapping, persistent gastrointestinal distress, hyperactivity and sensory sensitivities to food. And none of these treatments helped.
In 2014, when Aaron was 9, Weeks decided to try a more invasive therapy. “I was at a point in my life where I just had to do something for [him],” Weeks recalls.
She enrolled Aaron in a clinical trial led by a for-profit company called the Stem Cell Institute in Panama City, Panama. During four visits to Panama over nine months, Aaron received infusions of stem cells harvested from tissue that lined donated umbilical cords; using stem cells from donated umbilical cord tissue is illegal in the United States. The institute charged $1,800 for each of Aaron’s visits, according to his mother.
Of course, charging a patient to be part of a clinical trial is, from an ethical standpoint, highly dubious, particularly when it’s a for-profit clinic doing the trial and even more so when the trial itself isn’t particularly rigorous. We’ll get back to that. This trial, such as it was, was published last month in Stem Cells Translational Medicine. It’s a single-arm (meaning that there was no control group) trial of 20 subjects with autism spectrum disorder. The treatment was mesenchymal stem cells derived from umbilical cord tissue (UC-MSCs).
Like most stem cell treatments for most diseases hawked by clinics like the Stem Cell Institute, the biological rationale for the treatment consists of a bunch of handwaving:
Mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) have immune‐modulatory and anti‐inflammatory properties and have been safely used in the treatment of a variety of neurological and autoimmune conditions15, 26-33. In particular, MSCs derived from the Wharton’s jelly of umbilical cord tissue (UC‐MSCs) may possess greater immune‐modulatory activity34 and proliferative capacity compared with other MSCs35, 36. The rationale for MSC therapy to treat ASD has been discussed over the past decade37, 38; our group proposed the use of stem cell therapy to treat ASD in 200739. Some studies to date have demonstrated the safety of treatment that included MSCs40: of note, the results of a study by Sharma et al. showed that the majority (96%) of children with ASD treated with bone marrow‐derived cells including MSCs showed global improvements including behavior patterns (66%), social relationships (90.6%), and speech, language, and communication (78%)41.
Translation: There are some immune abnormalities associated with autism that no one really understands, and MSCs can have immunomodulatory activity; so stem cells should help. Basically, the biological rationale is: Stem cells are magic! So they’ll magically help autistic children. Because stem cells.
The follow-up of the subjects of the trial was as follows:
During the first visit, in week 1, participants were evaluated for safety and efficacy baseline values, and received 36 million UC‐MSCs intravenously over the course of 1 week, in four intravenous infusions of 9 million viable UC‐MSCs in each infusion. Twelve weeks later, at week 13, the subjects received the same dose of UC‐MSCs and were evaluated for safety and efficacy endpoints. This procedure was repeated at week 25 and week 37 after the start of treatment. The total dose received over the course of treatment was 144 million UC‐MSCs (4 × 36 million). In the follow‐up phase, visits occurred at week 49 (12 months after the start of treatment, 3 months after the last dose) and week 89 (21 months after the start of treatment, 12 months after the last dose).
The primary endpoint was safety, which was assessed at six different time points during the study using complete psychiatric and medical evaluations, laboratory exams, and occurrence of adverse events. Now here’s where the scientific value of the study falls to near zero:
Signals of efficacy were evaluated by parent‐reported outcomes via the CARS and ATEC tools44, in collaboration with the study pediatric psychiatrist, who evaluated the appearance, behavior, mood, speech, and intellectual functioning of the subjects to supplement parental
Parent reported outcomes with no controls? Even worse, the ATEC is the Autism Treatment Evaluation Checklist. It’s a dubious “tool” to measure the severity of autistic behaviors and symptoms used by autism quacks to “evaluate” treatment efficacy. Specifically, it was invented by Bernard Rimland and Stephen M. Edelson of the Autism Research Institute, and it was favored by autism quacks like Mark and David Geier.
Another issue is that this trial had no control group. Of course, it was a phase I/II trial; so it didn’t have to have a control group. Single arm designs are acceptable in this type of study because safety, not efficacy, is the primary endpoint and biomarkers and behavioral markers are the secondary endpoints. Unfortunately, what this means is that this trial cannot demonstrate efficacy. There are exceptions in which such a trial could demonstrate efficacy, but they are rare; specifically, if the effect size is so huge that it’s clear that there is efficacy. One example was the phase I clinical trial for Gleevec, in which the drug caused cancer to disappear in the majority of patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia (CML) that were in the early, or chronic, phase of the disease. Five years later, 98% of patients from the trial were still in remission. It is true that sometimes you can find signals of efficacy in a single arm phase I/II clinical trial, hints that the treatment being tested is having a therapeutic effect, but such signals need to be validated in a randomized trial.
This is not such a trial to me. The decreases in various cytokine levels reported were not impressive, and the changes in the ATEC and CARS scores was similarly unimpressive at twelve months and returned nearly to baseline by 21 months. In other words, I am singularly underwhelmed by the results of this study. Interestingly, there was considerable dropout as time went on such that only 14 of the subjects were evaluated at the 21-month time point. Moreover, only eight subjects showed a decrease in their ATEC and CARS scores, only five showing concomitant decrease in cytokine levels. It’s all pretty thin gruel.
As for the Stem Cell Institute, a perusal of its website reveals very quickly that it’s just another for-profit stem cell clinic, and you know what I think of for-profit stem cell clinics. Stem Cell Institute claims to be able to treat autism, cerebral palsy, heart failure, multiple sclerosis, osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis, spinal cord injury, and autoimmune diseases, among others. The website is full of testimonials, like this one:
And this one:
NEW VIDEO – Stem Cell Therapy for Autism: Reese Reese's dad discusses his improvements after stem cell therapy in Panama. https://t.co/ExBYJO1sxB #stemcells #autism pic.twitter.com/68LeXpgflS
— Stem Cell Institute (@Stemcellspanama) June 18, 2019
Neil Riordan, founder, chairman and chief science officer of the Stem Cell Institute, is even appeared on Joe Rogan’s podcast with Mel Gibson, which real stem cell scientist Paul Knoepfler characterized thusly:
In it Rogan is very upbeat about stem cells and doesn’t probe much as an interviewer. He also mentions his own perceived positive experiences with stem cells. To me he seems too cheery about stem cells, and I’m a big fan of stem cells.
Gibson talks about how he believes stem cells from Riordan were transformative for his elderly father. When Gibson talks about his dad, it is powerful, but that doesn’t mean this stuff really works. Gibson has also himself gotten stem cells.
Riordan makes a number of medical claims about what his institution can achieve with stem cells for a whole rainbow of conditions. It is mentioned that there are published papers on this specific stuff, but from what I’ve seen there isn’t much scientific rigor there in my opinion. Mostly we hear very big, unsupported claims about outsized positive outcomes for almost any medical problem. Does it sound too good to be true? I’m highly skeptical of the safe and effective use of these cells at this time in aging and especially in autism. Injecting laboratory-cultured stem cells into kids also invokes more bioethical considerations and there could be unique long-term risks that we do not understand.
Overall, to me this video again feels like an informercial that has likely greatly benefited Riordan.
No doubt it has, given that it’s had over 2.6 million views in the year and a half since the podcast first hit YouTube.
But what about the science? It is, as Dr. Knoepfler described it, not particularly scientifically rigorous. There are some preclinical studies in cell culture and animals, some speculative articles discussing the rationale for the use of stem cell treatments in various diseases, biomarker studies after stem cell infusions, and this rather uninformative phase I/II study of MSCs in autism.
This study, of course, is monstrously unethical. There was no plausible biological rationale for using MSCs to treat autism, and the treatment, although safe, is not without risk. In this trial, although there were no severe or life-threatening adverse events, there were a number of mild to moderate severity ones, including weight loss, inflammation at the site of infusion, headache, fever, and an increase in tics, hyperactivity and aggression, irritability, and obsessive-compulsive behaviors. There was, of course, also the risk of infection, blood-borne diseases, and other potential complications of any infusion of human blood- or tissue-based products, all without compelling evidence that the treatment is likely to work. To make it even more unethical, the patients’ families paid to be part of the clinical trial.
Of course, subjects in clinical trials often bear costs of being in the trial, specifically travel, time off work, and the like. Patients’ health insurance usually covers all their care not directly related to the clinical trial, such as other treatments and drugs, routine laboratory values and tests that would have been ordered anyway if not for the clinical trial, and the like. However, in general, the sponsor of the clinical trial provides experimental drug or treatment for free and bears the costs of the clinical trial itself, including the costs of the offices needed for randomization, data collection, and other expenses related to the clinical trial. However, it is generally considered at best ethically problematic to charge patients to be subjects in a clinical trial, usually in the form of making them pay for the experimental intervention, in this case stem cells. Arguments for this “pay-to-play” funding mechanism generally boil down to five, such as enhancing informed consent because the patient actually pays. There’s also an argument that pay-to-play is no different than taking part in expanded access programs, in which patients are often expected to pay for the experimental drug. Then, of course, clinics like this often claim that studies like the Stem Cell Institute study would never be done otherwise. (I, of course, would counter: Good. Studies like the Stem Cell Institute’s study shouldn’t be done.) Then, of course, there’s the “because freedom” argument.
On the other hand, there are a number of arguments against pay-to-play clinical trials, which were well enumerated in this article from 2015. To me, the most powerful argument against pay-to-play clinical trials is that they are exploitative, the psychological exploitation of individuals desperate to do anything to save their own or a loved one’s life. Desperate patients (or parents of patients) often feel tremendous pressure to raise funds. We’ve seen this many times before discussed on this very blog for dubious cancer therapies. Such patients go to great lengths to raise funds. They often take out large loans, raid their retirement savings, or even sell their house. They launch GoFundMe efforts and relentlessly fundraise on social media.
Also:
Paying for research participation might actually undermine social value and scientific validity by skewing research priorities or encouraging methodologically inferior research. Whatever its limitations, one of the critical functions of peer review is the comparative assessment of the worthiness and methodological rigor of alternative research projects. Peer reviewers can evaluate the potential social benefit of research and prioritize longer-term but more beneficial projects. Pay-to-play funding would prioritize research needs of the wealthy and their ailments. These priorities are unlikely to align with research that might be worthy but afflict individuals without the means to pay, such as interventions for lead poisoning, tuberculosis, or schistosomiasis. If successful, pay-to-play research could also skew researchers and research institutions to pursue lucrative studies that are not necessarily socially valuable. This might lead to a brain and facilities drain. Last, pay-to-play funding might enable studies that ask important questions but lack the methodological rigor to survive traditional peer review. At the extreme, pay-to-play arrangements might enable charlatans to pursue—and profit from—flawed trials that offer no, or even negative, social value (4–6).
And:
Pay-to-play arrangements also create challenges for the ethical implementation of a research study. Having a participant pay could lead to the bending of inclusion criteria, pressure on investigators not to remove participants from a study, and even inappropriate influences on decisions to terminate a study. For instance, it is not hard to imagine a pay-to-play participant pressuring a researcher to grant an exception to inclusion criteria and a researcher agreeing to do so because of the additional financial support. Similarly, patients with limited therapeutic options sometimes demand access to drugs even after studies have proven them to be ineffective. Finally, the paying participants might be reluctant to fully disclose symptoms and side effects. Having invested substantial sums, participants may not want to acknowledge problems that might result in their exclusion or removal from a study.
We can see this in this study by the Stem Cell Institute. A far more methodologically rigorous clinical trial would have been to do a randomized, double-blind, controlled clinical trial. Who would pay to be part of that study, though, given that there would be a 50-50 chance of winding up in the placebo control group? So the Stem Cell Institute did a less rigorous phase I/II study of patients who would have paid to travel to Panama and get the stem cell treatments anyway. To the Stem Cell Institute, this wasn’t a clinical trial. It was advertising. Riordan claims that “$7,200 the institute charged parents was ‘to defray costs outside of the treatment. The actual treatments were provided free of charge.'” One of the patients’ parents claimed that her expenses totaled over $20,000. Even if Riordan did defray some of the costs of the clinical trial, I’d conclude that it was an investment in advertising, to give the appearance of scientific rigor.
Then, I came across this:
This clinic was the largest recipient of crowdfunding $, including for stem cell 'treatments' for autism, in the recent study @LeighGTurner and I published. Duke and Northwestern showed up too. https://t.co/3Slbo3PzVh
— Jeremy Snyder (@jeremycsnyder) July 25, 2019
So the Stem Cell Institute was the largest recipient of money from patients who crowd-funded their stem cell treatments. Also, given that Duke came up on the list, this implies that there is a “pay-to-play” or “pay-to-participate” component to its stem cell trials, including a stem cell trial for autism:
For families interested in receiving this treatment (who are not in the trial) they can pay Duke for the treatment through Expanded Access Protocol, but Kurtzberg said some families are frustrated because there’s a long waiting list to get in.
To me, this is disturbingly similar to what the Stem Cell Institute is doing, as was the phase I clinical trial run by Duke to show safety published in 2017. It was an open label study; so huge placebo effects were, of course, possible.
Paul Knoepfler also did a disturbing series of posts about a stem cell trial run by Richard Burt of Northwestern University that required patients to pony up $100,000 to be part of the trial, while marketing “cure-like” outcomes, thus raising (to me more than him, in fairness) uncomfortable parallels to predatory trials by for-profit stem cell clinics like the Stem Cell Institute in Panama.
Stem cells definitely show enormous promise for a number of conditions, but all too often they are treated like magic, as though just infusing them, whatever type of cells, will lead to the cells magically homing in where they are needed and magically doing what they need to do. However, testing these therapies in any sort of “pay-to-play” model is an ethical minefield that universities enter at their peril. Bioethicist Alison Bateman-House noted that there is going to be a conference at the Department of Health and Human Services that will address pay-to-play clinical trials as one of its topics:
Setting aside everything else, I have serious concerns about any pay to play “trial.” That’s 1 of the topics to be discussed at this upcoming meeting (https://t.co/xqmeOhR1iD). There’s a webcast
— Dr. Alison Bateman-House (@ABatemanHouse) July 25, 2019
The Secretary’s Advisory Committee on Human Research Protections (SACHRP) is a committee that provides expert advice and recommendations to the Secretary of HHS on issues pertaining to the protection of human subjects in research. I’ll be interested in what it ends up saying about pay-to-play research of any kind, but in particular in stem cell trials, which seem to be particularly highly represented in requiring patients to pay.

Facilitated Communication Rears Its Ugly Head Again
Facilitated communication is pure pseudoscience that was debunked almost 30 years ago, but it keeps coming back, creating new victims.
Steven NovellaonMarch 14, 2018
Link

Imagine police coming to your home with a warrant for your arrest. The charges are that you sexually assaulted a family member. You are completely innocent and everyone is shocked at the accusation, which seemed to come out of nowhere. Then, it turns out that the accusations were based on a psychic’s vision.
Eventually the charges are dropped, but not until after your family is shattered and your life disrupted by spending over a month in jail.
This may seem like an absurd scenario, but it has happened many times, most recently to Jose Cordero, who was accused of molesting his 7 year-old autistic son. The “psychic vision”, however, is something equally pseudoscientific – facilitated communication.
This technique was developed in the late 1980s and was popular through the early 1990s. It consists basically of supporting the hand of a client who has impaired communication, helping them to type out or point to letters in order to communicate. The premise is that there are some people who have more of an ability to communicate than is apparent because of physical limitations. By helping them get over their motor deficits, untapped communication potential is revealed.
This was never a very plausible premise. It is mainly wishful thinking. For most communication-impaired individuals, especially children in the special-needs community, the problem is not purely motor. They have intellectual limitations. Holding their hand is not going to suddenly make them literate.
Still, the technique took the community by storm, unfortunately getting way ahead of any scientific validation. Red flags were immediately apparent, however. Children who were apparently severely intellectually limited were suddenly writing poems. They not only had mysteriously acquired the ability to read and write, they were advanced beyond their age. Some children had the impossible ability to touch type without even looking at the keyboard.
It also did not take long before children were accusing their parents or caregivers (never their facilitator, however) of abusing them.
When the research was finally done it was convincingly demonstrated that the facilitators were doing all the communication. They were not just supporting the arm of their clients, they were directing them to the letters. This was probably mostly subconscious, a form of the ideomotor effect (subtle subconscious movements based on expectation). Essentially the facilitators were “dowsing” the letter boards.
Reviews were published, official statements were made, and facilitated communication became a cautionary tale about adopting new techniques before they are scientifically validated. But that is unfortunately not the end of the story.
Belief in facilitated communication was already deeply embedded in the special needs community, like a fungus, and it was hard to eradicate. Just when you think it’s gone, it comes back with a vengeance.
Now, a quarter century after its thorough debunking, a new generation is encountering the remnants of facilitated communication and, unaware of its history, are falling for it all over again.
In this case the child’s elementary special-education teacher, Saul Fumero, had learned a technique he called “hand over hand” (facilitated communication by another name) and used it to “help” his students communicate. It was through this technique that the sexual assault allegations came out.
Fumero admitted he had no formal training, but that would not really have made any difference. The school also claims they did not sanction the technique, but I find their excuse inadequate.
It is also incredible to me that the police took the accusations seriously enough for Cordero to spend 35 days in jail and be separated from his family for months. The moment they learned the accusations were made through facilitated communication, they should have investigated Fumero, not Cordero.
The lessons here are clear. There is a reason we advocate for high standards of scientific validity in medicine, which includes mental health and psychological services. Medicine is hard, and there are many possibilities for self-deception and error. Rigorous scientific methods are necessary to avoid becoming nothing more than a witch doctor and snake oil salesman.
There is also great potential harm in practicing pseudoscience. Any professional has the responsibility of due diligence, to make sure they are using valid techniques, and to avoid harming their clients, those connected to them, and society, with pseudoscience.
The deeper lesson for the professional community is the harm that is done from adopting even promising methods too soon. What tends to happen is that they become embedded in the infrastructure. Before long there are institutes dedicated to the technique, seminars, specialists, even continuing education credits. The trappings of legitimacy can be acquired very quickly.
A new generation trained in the technique, and convinced by confirmation bias and their own anecdotes, may find it difficult to abandon the technique later.
To their credit, many language specialists did abandon facilitated communication when the science came out against it. But enough continued to support it that it was allowed to endure.
There are also many soft apologists for facilitated communication who argue that, even if studies do not confirm it, there are individual cases in which clients trained with the technique later learn to read and write independently.
These anecdotes, however, cannot be used to support facilitated communication. We don’t know where these clients would be without the technique. They likely just improved as they matured, or any nurturing interaction would have been sufficient for them to improve. It is wrong and dangerous to use non-specific effects, or uncontrolled anecdotes, to support claims of specific efficacy for a specific intervention. This is the foot in the door for pseudoscience.
The broadest lesson of all this is that professionals need to learn not only about their science, but about related pseudosciences. We need to learn what isn’t true, and how we know.
Every educator, or anyone who works with special needs children, should learn about facilitated communication and why it is complete pseudoscience. Police also need to learn about various techniques that might be presented to them as valid evidence.
Schools and other institutions also should police themselves for pseudoscience, as a basic component of quality control and professionalism.
In this case, everyone failed. Fumero failed by using an invalid technique he learned on his own on the children with whom he was entrusted. The special needs community failed by allowing this pseudoscience to simmer within their profession. The school failed to do even basic quality control in letting this happen. And the police failed by arresting a man based upon “spectral evidence.”
Every couple years we have to write about facilitated communication again, like applying ointment to that rash that just won’t seem to go completely away.

NYT Article on Rapid Prompting Method
Steven Novella on July 8, 2026
Link

This is one of those stories that will not go away, and a recent NYT article is fresh evidence of that. The title is: An Autism Breakthrough, or an Illusion? The Fight Over Assisted Spelling.” I always approach such articles cautiously, bracing myself for the cringing experience of reading a non-expert butcher such topics in depressingly predictable ways. This article was not as bad as some, but still ultimately failed to correctly cover the topic. The tagline gives away the core problem: “Popular communication methods for nonspeaking autistic people have ignited a fierce debate over what counts as evidence of hidden cognitive abilities.” Has it really?
The authors summary of the two sides is reasonably fair. We have covered this topic a fair amount as well. The quick back story begins in 1989 with the introduction of facilitated communication (FC). The idea is that some children thought to have profound intellectual disability, including many in the minimally or non-verbal autism community, really have only a motor disability. They cannot control their speech or their physical movements sufficiently to communicate, but inside they may be intellectually intact, even brilliant. FC, therefore, uses a facilitator to hold the arm of the non-verbal client to help them spell out responses on a letter board. The technique seemed like a revolution, to the delight of many language therapists and parents.
But there was a problem – a question of authorship. Who is ultimately controlling the output, the client or the facilitator? There are many clues that should have been obvious to any objective person (but of course, the people involved were highly invested). Children who were never taught to read could suddenly write at an advanced level. They seem to have just absorbed reading and spelling without being taught, in some cases even foreign languages. And not only were many of them intellectually intact, they were advanced beyond their age.
In fact facilitator often feel as if the child is “reading their mind”, because they are spelling what they are thinking. This lead to The Telepathy Tapes, a popular podcast that claims these children are literally psychic.
Perhaps most devastatingly, if you watch videos of FC in action, in many cases the children are not even looking at the letter board (spelling by pointing at a letter board without looking is literally an impossible feat).
This all raised the serious question of authorship, which was eventually studied, and it was conclusively found that the facilitator are doing the communication. A 2014 systematic review concluded:
“Results indicated unequivocal evidence for facilitator control: messages generated through FC are authored by the facilitators rather than the individuals with disabilities. Hence, FC is a technique that has no validity.”
And that should have been that. But it wasn’t. FC continues, and further it was rebranded to similar techniques, such as the rapid prompting method and others, collectively referred to as spelling. They are all just variations of FC. In RPM, for example, the facilitator hold the letter board rather than the client’s hand. The ideomotor effect works in both cases, however. All the methods have one thing in common – there is a facilitator in the loop who is capable of influencing (and even completely controlling) the output. If it were true that these children just needed motor help, then why couldn’t a simply metal arm hold the letter board? Why does it have to be a person?
Getting back to the NYT article, the author does give a fair if quick overview of the scientific position. She doesn’t really bring it home, however, with the only firm conclusion that an objective person can make. Instead she frames it as a genuine dilemma. She doubles down on this narrative in the lead comment: “But at the core of the story is a persistent tension over what counts as strong evidence: rigorous studies or personal experience.”
I guess “tension” is a sufficiently vague word to give her cover, but combined with the “fierce debate” language used in the tagline it gives the impression there is actual scientific debate on this issue. There isn’t. This “tension” has been resolved for at least a century, and back by countless examples. Rigorous studies give us reliable information on which we can base conclusions and practice. Personal experience is overwhelmed with bias and illusion and cannot be the basis of reliable conclusion. At best they can generate a hypothesis to be tested – but they cannot test hypotheses.
So when it comes to “rigorous studies or personal experience” – rigorous studies win. No question, no debate, no genuine tension. The people who tout the superiority of personal experience simply do not like the answer that rigorous studies provide. It is that simple.
Back in May the NYT published another article on this issue, which gets it right, this one by Dr. Lutz, a historian of medicine and mother of an autistic child. She actually cites the rigorous evidence and the unavoidable conclusion – FC and all its subtypes do not work. Even worse than not working – they steal the voice from a very vulnerable population.
First, she correctly points out that resources used to back pseudoscience are directed away from methods backed by actual evidence (even if they are not the miraculous cures that parents want). But worse, facilitator are communicating in the name of these non-verbal people, even to the point that what the facilitator spells out is treated preferentially to what the child communicates in other ways. Imagine the frustration of trying to communicate a basic need, while someone else is falsely claiming who want something else.
There are other victims as well. The parents are victims because their process of dealing with the difficult situation as it truly is becomes short circuited by a dangerous fantasy. There are also many cases of adults being accuse, via FC, of abuse, some even being convicted and spending time in prison.
The stakes here are actually quite high, and we have a clear and unequivocal answer – these methods do not work, the facilitator is the true author, and the children these methods claims to help and just being abused. Such methods are terrible for everyone involved.
The wishy-washy false balance of this NYT article will expand this harm. The net effect of such articles are always to drive desperate parents in search of the false hope being presented. It is profoundly frustrating that even when rigorous science provides us a clear answer, we cannot fully put such nonsense to bed.


The Telepathy Tapes – More FC Pseudoscience
Steven Novella on February 5, 2025
Link
Documentaries can be powerful. They can use the mature art-form of cinema in order to convey a specific narrative. The viewer can get drawn into that narrative, unaware they are being exposed to a very one-sided or limited take on a complex topic. I recently, for example, participated in a fun review of the Earthing Movie which was basically propaganda for the absolute nonsense that is earthing.
The Telepathy Tapes, which is primarily a podcast, suffers from the same problems as the Earthing Movie. In each case, the documentarians are not scientists, and they themselves get sucked into a world of pseudoscience that they are not equipped to properly evaluate. They become true believers, and then they turn their documentary skills toward promoting dangerous nonsense.
In this case, the header picture tells the entire tale, but let’s dive into the details. The core claim being promoted by this podcast is that non-speakers with autism or other neurological conditions actually have a rich inner intellectual life, they are simply not able to communicate their thoughts because of physical (but not intellectual) limitations. However, using various techniques, their communication can be facilitated, revealing their rich thoughts. If all this sounds familiar that’s because it is – this is 100% facilitated communication (FC), which was utterly disproved by the early 1990s.
The Telepathy Tapes takes FC one step further. Not only do these non-speakers have vastly more intellectual capability than is apparent, but they are also psychic. They can read minds, and even tap into a cosmic library of information, and spiritually communicate with other telepathic non-speakers. Let’s quickly review what FC is (although I do recommend reading some of the linked articles above for more background) and you will see why this outcome was likely inevitable.
In FC a facilitator allegedly helps their client to communicate in one of two basic methods. They can hold the arm of the client to “help” them either type or point to letters on a board. For those clients who have the ability to raise an arm, the facilitator can also hold a letter board up in front of them so that they can point. In each case the facilitator is capable of influencing, and in fact completely controlling, the output. They are moving the client’s arm, or they are moving the letter board, to get to the “right” answer.
Even if you have not heard of FC before you are likely thinking that there is an easy way to test the question of who is doing the communicating, the client or the facilitator, and you would be completely correct. Just blind the facilitator to the target information and see if the client can still communicate it. Show the client but not the facilitator a simple object and then have them name what they just saw. When this basic control is put into place, the client’s illusory ability to communicate vanishes.
FC had a brief moment in the mainstream of speech therapy but once the scientific evidence showed it was entirely bogus, responsible professionals abandoned it. But of course FC did not go away. It persists among true believers, some of whom have rebranded it as Spelling to Communicate or some other branding.
Within the pseudoscientific world of FC, however, there is a complete disconnect between what is actually happening inside the minds of the clients and what is being communicated in their name. This is horribly damaging and exploitative (even if well-intentioned). Because of this disconnect the claims made for FC clients can get increasingly extreme. At first it was thought that even non-speakers could engage in basic communication. But then FC was used to show that they can read (despite never being taught to read), and even read way above their age level. Some can apparently speak foreign languages they were never taught, while others attend college and are awarded degrees (all through FC).
The Telepathy Tapes, therefore, is just the next perhaps inevitable step in this sequence —autistic non-speakers, through FC, appear to also be psychic and transcendent. I can certainly see how this might be a comforting fantasy for parents who care for their children who cannot otherwise communicate. This creates a powerful emotional motivation to accept FC pseudoscience.
The documentarians did not do their due diligence. It does not appear that they consulted with appropriate experts, or wrap their heads around what FC is and why it is pseudoscience. Instead they did their own “tests”. As they say:
“The tests in The Telepathy Tapes library were conducted by director Ky Dickens and a small film crew in the homes of non-speakers and their families. These proof-of-concept sessions aimed to authenticate telepathic claims and assess the viability of a documentary. Their results underscore the need for deeper exploration and rigorous scientific study with tighter controls.”
So they went back in time almost four decades to do pilot testing of FC (as if it were a new technique) and then concluded that more study is needed. This seems blissfully unaware of the fact that those rigorous scientific studies with tighter controls have already been done, and FC failed those tests which conclusively demonstrate that the facilitators, not the clients, are doing the communication. They then bypassed any academic or scholarly review and went straight for public promotion. At least they got a successful podcast out of it.
This is not benign entertainment. The Telepathy Tapes project explicitly promotes versions of FC, and explains away the lack of rigorous scientific evidence (in ways familiar to promoters of alternative medicine), further contributing to the watering down of scientific and academic standards in our society. This further alienates the public from those pesky “experts” with their fancy research. It’s much more satisfying to just believe these kids are psychic.
And let’s also not forget that FC gets to many very dark places. Not only do these apparent savants dispense made-up medical advice, but under FC caregivers have been falsely accused of abuse. There are multiple cases of individuals being charged with felonies, undergoing long expensive trials, and losing their jobs because of bogus allegations made entirely using FC. There is also the notorious case of Anna Stubblefield who sexually abused a male client and claimed that he had given consent using FC. FC is like the “spectral evidence” of the medieval witch trials.
The Telepathy Tapes is simply abusing another generation of non-speakers, and convincing another generation of listeners that FC is something other than the completely discredited pseudoscience that it is. 

Preying on the Vulnerable: Electrodiagnostics, Bach Flower Remedies, and Sound Therapy for Autism, ADHD, and Learning Problems
Karyne Jeanne Richardson offers a ridiculous program of electrodiagnosis, flower remedies, and fractal sound to treat autism and other disorders. There are science-based autism programs that work; it is unfortunate when parents subject their autistic children to onerous, expensive, time-consuming, useless treatments based on pseudoscientific claims and false promises.
Harriet Hall on October 10, 2017
Link

When children are diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, or learning problems, parents naturally want to do everything possible to help them. If they are lucky, they will find reliable information. For autism, they may discover a website that offers real science and real hope for autism: The Association for Science in Autism Treatment. More likely, they will come across unreliable websites that offer pseudoscientific explanations, impressive testimonials, lots of hype, and false hope. And they will embark on programs with no evidence of effectiveness, programs that can be very time-consuming and very expensive. They will put their children on onerous special diets and submit them to all kinds of futile exercises. Some of them will continue useless treatments even after seeing evidence from controlled studies that they are indistinguishable from placebo.
Perhaps the most egregious of these untested programs is Karyne Jeanne Richardson’s elaborate mixture of electrodiagnostic testing, Bach flower remedies, and fractal sound therapy. Her website and her writings show that she believes in everything from ayurveda to Deepak Chopra to homeopathy to energy medicine. She says, “It must be known that true healing can be accomplished only when the spiritual nature of the human being is recognized as divine.”
SpectraVision/Bodyscan
SpectraVision supposedly represents the latest knowledge in the field of energy medicine. It will supposedly help you “rediscover your true nature, thereby eliminating the underlying imbalances that can manifest as physical disease.” Richardson also attributes many “conditions of ill health” in children with autism to Environmental Toxicology Overload (ETO). Toxins are identified by the scan, and modalities such as Epsom salt baths and massage of the head and feet are utilized to increase release of toxins from the body.
An explanation of Quantum SpectraVision Technology can be found here. It’s a pseudoscientific tour de force that you might find amusing. (Example: “all matter is just a form of energy, only the vibration rate is much slower.”) It says the machine can identify toxins, food issues, acid alkaline balance, spinal misalignments, etc. and will then recommend remedies in the form of things like orthomolecular nutrition, chiropractic or craniosacral adjustments, and homeopathic remedies.
SpectraVision is just another in a long list of quack electrodiagnostic devices derived from EAV (Electroacupuncture of Voll). The FDA has banned importation of these devices and has confiscated some of them. And there have been criminal prosecutions of marketers and users of the devices.
Flower essences
The SpectraVision scan presents 100 flower essences to the body and the body gives a numbered response. “The soul of the person chooses” the flower essences it wants. The chosen essences are administered at bedtime along with reading about the essences to invite that thought process into your dreams. She tells us there can be negative dreams at first, but they dissipate very quickly. “For some children, using the flower essences is the first time the soul wants to stay in the body.”
She says the foundational flower essences support the soul of the child: California wild rose, trumpet vine, Indian paintbrush, and five-flower formula. California pitcher plant essence is said to aid healthy digestion and absorption of nutrients for a healthy brain. When Indian paintbrush comes up on the scan, she says that means the child is ready to move from the phase of removing toxins to a new phase of creativity and coming into the body. They can do artwork during the hour and a half of listening to sounds to train the brain.
Bach flower therapy is a fanciful offshoot of homeopathy; proponents claim that flowers have a soul with affinity to the human soul. Their claims for clinical effectiveness have been tested. Edzard Ernst reviewed the published evidence and concluded: “The hypothesis that flower remedies are associated with effects beyond a placebo response is not supported by data from rigorous clinical trials.” I have written about Bach flower remedies before.
Fractal sounds
Richardson presents pretty pictures to show that fractal sounds on water sort of look like flowers. Wow! Who knew? That must mean something, right?
The SetiSMART patented software is the “sound codex” to the brain. It delivers a prescription sound program that synchronizes the heartbeat, the breath rate, and the brain waves. This supposedly balances the autonomic nervous system, reducing stress and the level of stress hormones, reducing inflammation, and allowing the brain to organize into functional neurological pathways. CCBT software uses Fractal Sonic Sounds (along with flower essences) to quiet and still the body’s hyperactivities and facilitate neurogenesis. The harmony supposedly affects epigenetics, switching genes on and off to restore balance, improve the immune system, and promote emotional bonding between parent and child.
Entrainment is a phenomenon where the vibrations of one object will change the vibrations of another object, synchronizing them. There have been reports of brain wave synchronization with repetitive sounds and beneficial effects of listening to music, but I don’t understand “fractal sounds” or what they are hoping to accomplish. And if entrainment occurs, I can’t imagine why synchronizing heart rate, breathing, and brain waves would be expected to have all the widespread effects Richardson describes (switching genes on, promoting emotional bonding?). And I can’t imagine the basis for prescribing an individual sound program. It doesn’t make sense to me, and I suspect that is because it doesn’t make sense. And of course there are no controlled research studies to validate Richardson’s program. She claims to have seen striking results, but these could be explained by natural development over time, relaxation, attention, suggestion, and other factors.
Richardson attempts to explain:
Sound organizes all matter in the Universe around us. Sound can organize our brain into coherent whole brain function.
When the body is not stressed, it does not produce cortisol and histamines, therefore inflammatory issues in the brain and body are reduced. Since stress can cause the stomach to shut down, the relaxation response in the body during the CCBT sound therapy invites better digestion. There is also deep sleep and deeper breathing, which provide the right balance of oxygen and carbon dioxide in the brain. With the appropriate flower essence, the whole spirit in the child feels safe, feels she/he can finally be at home on earth and want to stay inside the body. Then, as a result, good physical and emotional markers begin to improve on an ongoing basis.
I’m not buying this.
Who is promoting this?
Karyne Jeanne Richardson, BEP, APP, is the founding director of the Institute for Sound Health and Integrative Medicine and Director of PNI Graduate Studies Psycho-Neuro Immunology. I don’t know what BEP and APP stand for, but I’m pretty sure they aren’t degrees in any medical or scientific field. She has a degree in Theatre and Cinematic Arts and was an elementary school teacher, singer, and cast member of “Up with People.” She bills herself as:
    • Neuro Scientist, Researcher, Clinician, Author
    • Environmental Toxicologist
    • Certified Chopra Ayurvedic Instructor since 2004
    • Speech Pathologist & Balance Therapist
    • PMA Pastoral Medical
        ◦ Diplomat of Pastoral Science
        ◦ D.PSc. Ordained 2003
    • Ortho Molecular Nutritionist
    • Bio-Medical and Quantum Energy Medicine
    • Homeopathic Allergist
    • Brain Fitness Specialist—Autism through Dementia Spectrum
    • Stress Management personalized training
It could be argued that she is practicing medicine without a license.
Conclusion: Just too silly
I’m not going to bother to critique this in more detail: it’s just too silly. It’s a veritable cornucopia of woo woo. If you know anything about science and have read the debunking of claims for energy medicine, electrodiagnosis, flower remedies, homeopathy, etc. I won’t need to point out what is wrong with her claims. If you don’t accept science as the only reliable “way of knowing” and if you believe in the soul and believe that flower essences can persuade the soul to stay in the body, you wouldn’t listen to anything I might have to say anyway.

GcMAF and the life and death of an autism quack
David Gorski on July 19, 2015
Link

[Editor’s note: This is an extra bonus post that has appeared elsewhere. This week’s post will appear in several hours.]
A mysterious apparent suicide and conspiracy theories
Three weeks ago, those of us who combat the antivaccine movement noted the then-very recent death of an autism quack and antivaccinationist (but I repeat myself) who’s been big in the “autism biomed” movement for a long time and was a regular fixture at autism quackfests like Autism ONE for many years. I’m referring, of course, to Jeff Bradstreet, whose body was found in a river on June 19, dead from a gunshot wound to the chest that appeared to have been self-inflicted. It didn’t take long (less than a week) for the antivaccine movement to start speculating about conspiracies in which Bradstreet had been “bumped off” by big pharma, as represented by comments like these:
    • “It’s obvious that he was deliberately killed off because he spoke out against federal deceit, CDC, etc and was a life-saver for many like myself.”
    • “He did NOT kill himself! He was murdered for who he was speaking against, what he knew, and what he was doing about it. He was brilliant kind compassionate doctor with amazing abilities to heal. He was taken. Stopped. Silenced.”
    • “If this does not stink to high heaven I don’t know what does. A fisherman finds his body with a gunshot wound that appears to be a self inflicted. Just how the hell would they know that. Amazingly they happen to find the gun in the river. Wow that is some amazing detective work.”
    • “What a tragic loss of a beloved doctor. I pray the authorities get to the bottom of this story…it seems highly unlikely that a Christian man would shoot himself in thy chest and conveniently fall into a river.”
You get the idea. Meanwhile, others insinuated the existence of, basically, pharma hit squads. Not long afterward, Bradstreet’s family started a GoFundMe page to “find the truth.”
Let me just say one thing. I understand, to some extent, what the Bradstreet family is going through. My family has not escaped without having had one of its members commit suicide. Although it was someone I wasn’t particularly close to, he was very close to family members I am close to. So I understand better than most the pain they are going through. They do have my sympathy. I’ve been there.
That being said, it appears that more information is coming out about what happened in the days leading to Bradstreet’s death. It’s even started to filter out to major media outlets, as in this story published yesterday in the Washington Post, “The mysterious death of a doctor who peddled autism ‘cures’ to thousands“:
James Jeffrey Bradstreet was one of the world’s most famous — or infamous — physicians. He believed vaccines caused autism. He even testified so before Congress. Twice.
But he didn’t just rail against Big Pharma. He also tried to beat it.
Bradstreet offered thousands of autism patients around the globe controversial treatments. He claimed he could effectively cure kids of their autism, cancer and other maladies simply by injecting them with protein shots.
When Bradstreet’s body was found last month in the Rocky Broad River in mountainous North Carolina with a bullet wound to the chest, therefore, friends, family members and patients pointed fingers at drug corporations. The FDA. Anyone but Bradstreet.
“He did not kill himself!” one patient’s parent wrote online.
“May God have vengeance quickly on the evil doers who murdered him!” wrote another.
From this story, we also learn that Bradstreet’s family had quickly raised $33,000 to investigate his death and had used the money to hire private investigators. I rather suspect that, like John F. Kennedy, the assassination conspiracy theories surrounding his death will never die, although they will only be known to the dark underbelly of the antivaccine movement and autism quackery.
What really happened? The FDA was closing in.
Conspiracy theories aside, we’re finally learning what appears to be the event that might have pushed Bradstreet to kill himself. It turns out that the day before he apparently killed himself, his office was the target of a federal search warrant in relation to his use of an unapproved drug to treat autism, GcMAF. Readers were kind enough to supply me with a copy of the search warrant. Basically, the warrant gave permission to search the Bradstreet Wellness Center in Buford, GA for “records, documents and items” related to:
    • All Globulin component Macrophage Activating Factor (GCMAF), GC-Globulin, and/or any other products or component substances thereof that constitute misbranded drugs under the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act.
    • All records, in whatever form, associated with or pertaining to the acquisition, possession, distribution of unapproved drugs, prescriptions, and/or health care products. The records to be seized include those related to the brokering, ordering, purchasing, shipping, sale, and distribution of any drugs, including business journals and ledgers; tax records, and related work papers; purchase and sales records; communications; bank and financial records; shipment/transport records; supplier and customer records; regulatory compliance records and communications with federal, state, and local authorities; and any unopened mail addressed to or from the companies mentioned therein.
The warrant also authorized authorities to search for “all books, records, and documents” identifying current and former employees, any and all electronic, digital, and paper records relating to GcMAF, computers and peripherals, financial records, and more. You get the idea. As the news story I referenced above put it, whether or not any doubt remains over whether Bradstreet did indeed commit suicide, it’s clear that his use of dubious autism treatments had finally caught up with him after all these years. He was definitely in the FDA’s sights for his autism quackery. Strangely enough (to me) and frustratingly, it was not all his previous quackery that finally led to what one could only have hoped, had Bradstreet not killed himself, the beginning of the end of his empire of quackery and his taking up residence in a federal penitentiary. Remember, this is a guy who peddled hyperbaric oxygen chambers, chelation therapy, bogus stem cell treatments, hormone injections, secretin, and just about every sort of “autism biomed” quackery you can imagine, and then some. Let’s just put it this way. Bradstreet has in the past advocated exorcism to treat autism, although in the Autism Omnibus hearing, where he appeared as an expert witness for the complainants, he denied ever having performed exorcisms for autism. Yet it was GcMAF that finally led to the federal government taking substantive action.
GcMAF: A “miracle cure” for everything from cancer to autism
So what is GcMAF? It’s a protein that is normally found in the blood of healthy people. It is an immunomodulatory protein, in that its activity affects the function of the immune system. The glycoprotein (a protein with sugar molecules attached) GcMAF results from sequential deglycosylation of the vitamin D-binding protein (the Gc protein), and the resulting protein is felt to be a macrophage activating factor (MAF). MAFs are a class of protein known as a lymphokine, and they regulate the expression of antigens on the surface of macrophages. One of their functions is to “activate” macrophages, which can under the proper circumstances attack cancer cells. Of note, the production of GcMAF can be blocked by an enzyme called Nagalase (alpha-N-acetylgalactosaminidase), produced by many cancers, which led to its first incarnation in quackery as a “cure” for many cancers by Bill Sardi (remember him?) and Timothy Hubbell, based on dubious science and a clinical trial that didn’t show what its proponents claimed it did and was later retracted.
Bradstreet was a true believer in GcMAF as a cure for autism. For instance, check out this video of him promoting GcMAF as a cure for autism at the Treating Autism Conference at Brunel University in 2012:
He starts out as saying he’s been studying HIV and that’s what connected him up with GcMAF, claiming that he noted elevated Nagalase activity in autistic children, which presumably results in lowered GcMAF levels. This resulted in a paper based on 40 autistic children that he published in Autism Insights in which he claimed to have found elevated Nagalase levels in autistic children that were reduced by injecting GcMAF. While it is possible that GcMAF injections could decrease Nagalase levels if they were pathologically elevated it just doesn’t seem particularly plausible. What GcMAF injections could theoretically do is simply bypass the activity of Nagalase (which, remember, blocks the production of GcMAF) and lead to increased GcMAF levels. And ultimately Bradstreet also claimed improvement in autistic symptoms. Of course, this was a single-arm uncontrolled study, so it’s not particularly compelling evidence. It was also published in what was, before it was discontinued, in essence a vanity journal whose editorial board was packed with autism quacks, including Andrew Wakefield, Bryan Jepson, and Arthur Krigsman.
Another study with which Bradstreet was involved, claimed that GcMAF could normalize abnormal gene expression in the endocannabinoid system of autistic children, which, of course, links his work with claims made by some in the “autism biomed” movement that medical marijuana treats autism. Of course, this was an unrandomized, unblinded study (other than one person carrying out a lab test, specifically Ki67-ir profiles).
Based on highly dubious science and clinical data, Bradstreet was an enthusiastic backer of GcMAF, working with David Noakes, the head of Immuno Biotech:
During the same U.K. trip, Bradstreet and Noakes made what was essentially a promotional video for Immuno Biotech and its brand of GcMAF, called First Immune.
“I’m here with Dr. Jeffrey Bradstreet from the U.S.A., the autism expert in the First Immune GcMAF laboratories,” Noakes said on camera. “Dr. Bradstreet has been using our GcMAF for 18 months and we’d like to thank you for, I think you’ve treated 900 children now?”
“Not just children,” Bradstreet boasted. “So the spectrum of my patients with autism ranges from somewhere around 18 months to goodness, somewhere around close to 40. So we’ve treated many adults with autism as well as chronic fatigue patients, cancer patients. So we’ve found application for a fairly broad number of disorders for the product.”
And:
“Dr. Jeffrey Bradstreet has now treated over 2,000 autistic children with GcMAF and the results are well established,” according to one of Noakes’s Web sites. “85% improve, if only a little, and of them 15% have their autism eradicated. In all 3,000 children have been treated with GcMAF with similar results.”
Internet chatrooms reveal how desperate parents were drawn to these promises like moths to a flame.
The discussion forum on Autism Web shows hundreds of parents of autistic children seeking out alternative methods of treating, or even “curing,” their kids.
“We are doing GcMAF injections through Bradstreet,” began one thread in August of 2011. “It has been 5 weeks. Each shot is $90 so I’m hoping we will see something big soon. I would love to hear from anyone else that has been doing the treatment for longer than us.”
Dozens responded. The replies varied from wary to ecstatic.
Of course, lots of quack treatments for autism and other conditions have enthusiastic testimonials to back them up. What are less commonly seen are the negative testimonials, and Bradstreet has those:
“We have completed 20 shots of GcMAF so far. I am still waiting for the wow that everyone talks about,” one person wrote. Even worse, they described side effects including “crying and pains in his chest and stomach at least for first 3 days after the shot.”
“We are doing GcMAF injections. I have not seen any gains at all,” another person wrote. “I have seen the worse behaviors and tantrums. So after spending $1,300 for no gains and living in hell I am done with this.”
Others described nasty viral or bacterial infections which flared up after starting their kids on GcMAF.
“It came to a point where we couldn’t tolerate it any more,” an angry parent wrote.
These negative testimonials ultimately got the British health authorities’ attention.
The end of a quack empire
The problems with Bradstreet’s quackery led an Irish woman named Fiona O’Leary to begin investigating First Immune and complaining to UK health authorities. Her efforts led the authorities to act. The First Immune GcMAF production facility in the UK was raided by British health authorities earlier this year. They found that the facility did not meet Good Manufacturing Practice (GMP) standards and expressed concerns over the sterility of the medicine being produced and the equipment being used, leading to further concerns that the product could well be contaminated. More than 10,000 vials of GcMAF were seized and production was halted.
After O’Leary had complained to the FDA as well, four months later on June 18, the day before Bradstreet killed himself, the feds showed up at Bradstreet’s Buford, GA clinic, search warrant in hand. Had he been convicted Bradstreet could have faced up to 20 years in prison. Of course, we all know from a previous autism quackery conviction that Bradstreet would probably never have been jailed that long, given that sentences in these discussions are usually the maximum possible and seldom actually given under federal sentencing guidelines, but to see him in jail would have been sweet indeed, even if it were only for a couple of years. Antivaccinationists know that, which is why O’Leary has become a target of their wrath, with accusations of “murder” and not having a soul.
In any case, Bradstreet left, apparently fleeing to North Carolina, and drove three hours northeast to Lake Lure, NC, where he checked into a hotel. There he learned that a First Immune clinic run by Noakes had been shut down in an investigation of five deaths associated with GcMAF treatments. In fairness, it’s not clear whether the deaths were due to GcMAF or just terminal patients dying, but Swiss officials were on the trail as well. Hours after learning of this, Bradford disappeared. He wasn’t seen alive again. Although the investigation is not complete, authorities are satisfied that Bradstreet had committed suicide.
Yet the conspiracy theories continue:
“I know it was murder,” the Immuno Biotech CEO said. “Dr. Bradstreet stated what we all know: that the MMR vaccine causes autism,” repeating a claim often wielded by anti-vaccine activists that’s been totally debunked. “And he was an expert witness in many court cases in the U.S.A. providing testimony to that effect. MMR is a multibillion dollar vaccine and this [GcMFA] hurts the profits of the MMR drug companies and that is why he was killed.”
In a half-hour phone interview, Noakes told The Post that he was convinced a vaccine company killed Bradstreet to protect its profits from the wonder “cure” that is GcMFA.
“He was raided by the FDA the day before his murder so the murder is now dressed up to look like suicide,” Noakes claimed.
“Why would a doctor use a gun?” he continued. “A doctor wouldn’t use a gun at all. He’d use barbiturates or a cocktail of drugs which are easily available to him and take no effort.”
While it’s true that doctors who kill themselves are indeed more than twice as likely to use self-poisoning with drugs or other substances than the general population, they’re actually just as likely to use firearms, even in a population that doesn’t have many guns. In the gun-rich US, firearms are the most common method of physician suicide, being the method used for nearly half of physician suicides, only slightly less common than in the general population. So all the incredulous dismissals of the conclusion that Bradstreet killed himself, based on the belief that Bradstreet couldn’t have possibly killed himself with a gun because he’s a doctor and doctors don’t kill themselves that way, are complete nonsense based on misinformation about physician suicide. To cast doubt on suicide as a cause of Bradstreet’s death will require a lot more than a mistaken belief that doctors don’t kill themselves with firearms, because they do.
In reality, it’s clear that Jeff Bradstreet’s many years of applying his quackery to autistic children had finally—finally—caught up with him. I’m actually sorry that he killed himself, both for the pain it caused his family, but also because it means that Bradstreet ultimately escaped justice. It means he will never face a judge and jury for the many years he victimized autistic children with a wide variety of quackery. That saddens me, but I can still hope that Bradstreet’s co-conspirators face the justice he eluded.

Medical marijuana as the new herbalism, part 4: Cannabis for autism
Medical marijuana. It’s promoted as a seeming panacea that can cure whatever ails you. While there are potentially useful medicinal compounds in marijuana, in general the medical marijuana movement vastly oversells the promise. Nowhere is this more true than for cancer and autism, where there is no compelling evidence that cannabis cures cancer. Worse, parents are subjecting autistic children to cannabis with no evidence and even persuading state governments to list autism as a condition for which medical marijuana is appropriate.
David Gorski on August 3, 2015
Tweet

When I first started writing about the claims made for medical marijuana and the cannabis oil derived from it, it didn’t take long for me to characterize medical claims for cannabis as the “new herbalism,” as opposed to pharmacognosy, the branch of pharmacology devoted to the study of natural products. The reason is simple. Although I support legalization of marijuana for recreational use, when I look at how medical marijuana has been promoted as a “foot-in-the-door” prelude to legalization, I see testimonials and flimsy evidence ruling over all. I see all the hallmarks of alternative medicine herbalism and none of the hallmarks of pharmacology. Here’s what I mean. Pharmacognosy examines an herb, plant, or other natural product and seeks to identify the chemicals within it that have pharmacological activity against a condition or a disease, the better to purify and isolate those chemicals and turn them into drugs. Herbalism, on the other hand, emphasizes the use of whole plants or extracts from plants, rather than the isolation of the most active compounds. Thus, herbal remedies often contain hundreds, or even thousands, of different compounds, of which only one or a few are active. Even extracts, such as cannabis oil, contain many compounds.
In contrast to pharmacognosy, herbalists make the claim that whole herbs and plant components possess a synergy that is missing from the purified active constituents and/or that the mixture is safer than the pure components because one compound can reduce the side effects of another without reducing therapeutic efficacy. When looked at closely neither claim stands up to scrutiny. Synergism between plant constituents is rare and very difficult to demonstrate, for example. In essence, herbalism turns back the clock 200 years to a time before scientists had developed the techniques and abilities to isolate active ingredients with pharmaceutical activity. Moreover, herbalism, in contrast to pharmacognosy, emphasizes anecdotes over scientific evidence.
Indeed, in my previous posts in this series on medical marijuana, one theme has emerged, which is that cannabis—specifically, a class of active chemicals in marijuana known as cannabinoids—has potential for some diseases but is not the panacea claimed by its proponents. It does not cure cancer, for instance, contrary to glowing testimonials promoted by people like Rick Simpson. For other conditions, the evidence is either not particularly compelling or only mildly promising.
So I reacted with considerable dismay on Friday night when I saw this news report on the 11 o’clock news, “Michigan panel recommends allowing marijuana for autism“:
video platformvideo managementvideo solutionsvideo player
And, indeed, there have been stories all over the local news in Michigan like the one above and this one:
Note all the hearty cheering from the audience when the vote tally was read.
Here’s what happened:
Michigan would become the first state to allow medical marijuana for children with severe autism if a senior official follows the recommendation made Friday by an advisory panel.
The state’s Medical Marijuana Review Panel voted 4-2 to recommend autism as a condition that qualifies for the drug.
Supporters say oil extracted from marijuana has been effective in controlling extreme physical behavior by kids with severe autism. Pot wouldn’t be smoked.
The panel was influenced by comments received earlier from some Detroit-area doctors, especially the head of pediatric neurology at Children’s Hospital of Michigan, and parents desperate for relief. Many of the three dozen spectators cheered and applauded after the vote.
This is an utterly horrible idea, but it looks as though our state is nonetheless about to take the plunge into the Brave New World of treating autism with cannabis oil. Indeed, Michael Komorn, the President of the Michigan Medical Marijuana Association and the attorney who brought the petition before the board, basically admitted in the first news clip above that there was no science behind the board’s recommendations when he said: “It’s a no-brainer. And you heard the testimony of these people. They just want a little hope. That’s all they’re asking for.” Notice the distinct lack of any mention of strong science as a rationale for adding autism to the list of qualifying conditions. Komorn even went so far as to tout how the parents “are responsible for growing the plants or acquiring the cannabis, and they are in charge of dosing, frequency of use, and method of ingestion.”
Think about this for a moment. Is there another regulated drug for which this is the case? The board didn’t even provide, along with its recommendation for approving autism as a qualifying condition for treatment with cannabis oil, anything resembling recommendations for dosing, method of ingestion, and frequency of use, something very basic that is required by the FDA for even over-the-counter medications. Yet, here, in the fantasy world of medical marijuana, apparently parents are as knowledgeable as physicians and no guidelines for use are needed. The lack of dosing recommendations is another powerful indication that there is no science behind this recommendation, because if there was science behind it we’d know the optimal dose and method of administration to use cannabis oil to treat autism. Clearly, emotion, not science, ruled the day on Friday. Indeed, how Dr. Harry T. Chugani, the head of pediatric neurology at an institution as respected as Children’s Hospital could testify in favor of this is beyond me, but apparently he did:
“It seems to work. … Wouldn’t that be better than giving them all these psychiatric drugs?” Chugani said. “Not every autistic kid would take this, but if your behavior is wild and you have to be institutionalized, I as a physician would prefer to try medical marijuana. I have at least 50 patients on multiple drugs and still their behaviors are not controlled.”
Notice that Dr. Chugani, too, didn’t cite anything other than anecdotal evidence. How, for instance, did he know that the child isn’t calmer because he’s high on cannabis? And if we’re going to drug autistic children to make them behave, why not use opioids or other sedatives as well?
In any event, if you want evidence that medical marijuana is far more akin to herbalism than pharmacology, we need look no further than my state’s dubious position of becoming a “pioneer” in something that no state should be a pioneer in. That’s why I’ll first examine how the Medical Marijuana Review Panel got to where it is now, then the general claim that cannabis is a useful treatment for autism. Finally, I’ll evaluate the existing scientific evidence, which is pretty thin.
Autism biomed quackery embraces medical marijuana
As has been the case with virtually all uses of medical marijuana sanctioned by states, the road to the Michigan Medical Marijuana Review Panel recommending approval of cannabis for autism began not with doctors and scientists clamoring for it based on evidence, but with parents becoming politically active to lobby for it based on emotional anecdotes. Such was the case in Michigan, and, if you’ve been paying attention to the “autism biomed” movement, this quote will sound very familiar:
The review panel voted 4-2 in favor of a petition submitted by Lisa Smith, a Michigan mother who has said cannabis oil has helped improve her severely autistic 6-year-old son’s behavior, sleep patterns and eating schedule.
“The parents I’ve talked to are passionate and adamant that this represents a dramatic improvement in the quality of life for them and their affected children,” said David Crocker, a medical marijuana doctor and member of the panel.
What other treatments for autism have we heard the same claims for? Let me think… Oh, yes. We’ve heard them for quite a few “autism biomed” treatments, with parents being just as passionate. Unfortunately, the vast majority of “autism biomed” is rank quackery. Examples include “Miracle Mineral Solution” (MMS, a.k.a a form of bleach fed to autistic children and administered as enemas for which miraculous results are claimed), chemical castration with Lupron, chelation therapy, GcMAF, and many, many other pseudoscientific “treatments” featured at quackfests like Autism One. I’ve even seen glowing testimonials touting homeopathy for autism and the IonCleanse® “foot detox” bath. As regular readers know, homeopathy is, as I like to say, The One Quackery To Rule Them All, and “foot detox” baths are a scam.
Not surprisingly, segments of the autism biomed movement have embraced medical marijuana. For example, one prominent website advocating autism biomed quackery, the “Thinking Moms’ Revolution” (TMR), has numerous posts on its blog extolling the alleged virtues of medical marijuana for treating autism and advocating “freedom of choice.” If you doubt the increasing embrace of medical marijuana by the autism biomed quackery movement, look no further than this ad for an Medical Marijuana for Children with Autism eConference, sponsored in part by TMR. Indeed, Jeff Bradstreet, the longtime antivaccine autism biomed “practitioner” who committed suicide a month and a half ago after the FDA raided his clinic, was a speaker! So was a key supporter of medical marijuana for autism in Michigan, Lester Grinspoon.
Does this striking resemblance between autism biomed rhetoric and medical marijuana rhetoric mean that cannabis is useless for autism? Not necessarily, but it raises red flags. In any event, it would be more accurate to say that we don’t really know whether cannabis oil is efficacious for treating autism. I mention this similarity between the autism biomed movement and medical marijuana movement to emphasize how anecdotal evidence is incredibly unreliable, particularly for a complex condition like autism spectrum disorder (ASD). If you don’t believe me, consider this. Equally glowing testimonials for the rank quackery that is homeopathy to treat autism are not difficult to come by, which is one reason why testimonials are insufficient evidence upon which to base public policy; yet, that’s just what is happening in Michigan—and has been since medical marijuana was first approved. Remember, autism is a condition of developmental delay, not stasis, and autistic children frequently improve as they get older. Some even improve sufficiently to lose the ASD diagnosis.
Misguided activism advances cannabis for autism in Michigan
I understand (at least as much as someone who hasn’t actually experienced having a child with special needs can) how parents would be desperate to do everything they can for their children, but personal experience and anecdotes, contrary to what is claimed, can be extremely misleading, as we’ve described here many times before. That’s why anecdotes are not enough, and carefully controlled randomized clinical trials are needed, which, contrary to the claims of advocates, don’t really exist. Indeed, the science cited in the petition, as we will see in the final section of this post, is inadequate to make such a major policy change, consisting as it does of mainly preclinical evidence and case reports.
With that in mind, it’s useful to note that the road to this “victory” began years ago and actually represents a rebound from a defeat two years ago. In 2013, the Michigan Medical Marihuana Review Panel voted against adding autism to the list of indications for medical marijuana by a 7-2 vote:
Jenny Allen, whose 6-year-old son was diagnosed with autism several years ago, has tried giving him “mind-bending” medications, signed him up for behavior therapy and changed his diet. But his problems, including self-destructive behavior and biting, continue.
Now the 32-year-old Lansing mom wants to try giving him part of a brownie — a pot brownie — but was brought to tears Tuesday when the Michigan Medical Marihuana Review Panel rejected a petition that would have given her the legal means to do so.
The panel, in a 7-2 vote, gave a final recommendation against adding autism to a list of debilitating conditions suitable for treatment under Michigan’s voter-approved medical marijuana law.
“I’m incredibly disappointed,” Allen told MLive after the hearing, going on to question whether all panelists had thoroughly researched the topic. “I’m pretty shocked, actually, that nobody even brought up what the base condition is. It’s rather appalling.”
The panel made this decision in 2013 based on a correct assessment of the state of the evidence, which is that there is “not much quality, peer-reviewed research exploring marijuana as a treatment for autism,” that the case for adding autism to the list of approved conditions for which medical marijuana can be prescribed consists almost entirely of anecdotes and testimonials, and that not enough is known about the effects of long term use of cannabis on the developing brain. This assessment was correct in 2013, and nothing has happened in terms of the existing science during the intervening two years to change that assessment. So what really happened to reopen the case?
Not surprisingly, it was litigation that forced the Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs to submit a new petition for autism to the Medical Marihuana Review Panel. It was submitted on behalf of a woman named Lisa Smith for her son Noah, who has severe autism:
Lisa Smith says her son’s behavior was dangerous: hair pulling, kicks, punches, all related to a severe form of autism. But it began to change more than a year ago when he was given daily oral doses of oil extracted from marijuana.
“That’s all stopped. He’s more focused, he’s calmer,” Smith said of 6-year-old Noah. “He sleeps better through the night. He has a better appetite. You can tell he’s growing, gaining weight.”
Another parent who features in several of the news stories about this issue is Dwight Zahringer:
Dwight and Ixchel Zahringer’s son Brunello is going on 4 but has yet to speak. Last fall, his parents heard the chilling diagnosis — autism.
“We’ve had a hard, fast education in this for the last nine months,” Dwight Zahringer said. “Think of it like always being at a rock concert — everything really loud — and then you’re trying to have conversations or focus on things but you can’t because everything is overwhelming,” he said.
The dealings with health professionals form a familiar tale — advice to use powerful prescription drugs that are costly and may have worrisome side effects, the failure to see that those drugs are helping and the decision to stop them.
The Zahringers have thus far been disappointed with the progress their son Brunello has made with conventional therapy, such as Applied Behavioral Analysis. Seeking faster progress, they found medical marijuana and latched on to it for hope:
“We’ve been watching a lot of videos, a lot of documentaries, and we’ve seen proof that it can help,” said Ixchel Zahringer.
“One family had a kid who was very severe” with autism symptoms, “and they started giving him some of that (cannabis) oil, and they saw the child calming down.”
Dwight Zahringer came to his belief that he needs medical marijuana for his Brunello the same way that many in the autism biomed movement come to the conclusion that their child needs, for example, MMS. He pored over Internet sites and marijuana-themed literature, which convinced him that he needed to try cannabis on his son ASAP. He started using hemp oil, which apparently gets around the state’s current ban on treating autism with marijuana, but really wants the real thing. Parents like the Zahringers and Lisa Smith are clearly loving parents who want the best for their children, just as most parents who fall for “autism biomed” quackery love their children and want the best for them. Unfortunately, as we have seen and will see, the pro-cannabis literature and websites that tout cannabis as a treatment for autism provide a very biased and cherry-picked view of the medical literature.
Cannabis for autism: The evidence (or, more correctly, the lack thereof)
Perusing the news reports on the vote of the Michigan Medical Marijuana Review Panel, one point I’ve seen is that the reason why this vote came down in favor of adding severe autism to the list of qualifying conditions and the vote in 2013 did not is because the science was so much better described in the petition this time around. Indeed, advocates tout having bolstered the petition with “over 75 peer reviewed articles with over 800 pages of research on the issue of cannabis as a viable option for the treatment of autism” in addition to the “nineteen families, as well as physicians from MI and around the country.” Apparently, two advocates had a major hand in picking these articles:
The individuals who navigated the deepest into the science behind Autism’s riddling labyrinth of theories are without doubt Joe Stone and Dr. Christian Bogner. They were able to provide peer reviewed evidence that cannabis not only has the potential to provide palliative relief of symptoms related to autism, but may also have the potential to target the underlying causes of autism itself.
Note that nowhere in this report is mentioned evidence from well-designed clinical trials. In any event, I could not find the exact petition text, but there is a MoveOn.org petition to add autism to the list of qualifying conditions for medical marijuana in Michigan posted by Joe Stone and signed by Dr. Christian Bogner, Chad Carr, Dr. Harry Chugani, M.D., Dr. Lester Grinspoon, Michael A. Komorn, and Joe Stone. At the end, it lists links to research, specifically a paper written by Stone and Bogner that, one notes, was published online on the Cannabis for Autism blog rather than in a peer-reviewed medical journal, entitled “The Endocannabinoid System as it Relates to Autism“. This paper is also available on Scribd, with a complete list of references. It is clear to me that this discussion, along with its references, was the basis of the science presented to the panel.
Before I address this paper, which appears to be the best evidence advocates can put forward, let me just refer you to a good solid analysis of the state of the evidence for cannabis for neurological disorders by Skeptical Raptor. You can read the whole thing if interested, but the point I want to emphasize is that there is weak evidence that cannabis could be useful for epilepsy, as I discussed in my first post on this topic, but that a Cochrane review concluded that high quality evidence was insufficient to recommend it. There is also some evidence for the use of medical marijuana for spasticity and pain. The reason that this is relevant is because advocates for using medical marijuana for autism frequently point to cases where cannabis is used to control seizures, which many autistic children suffer from. This is a separate issue than whether cannabis is specifically therapeutic in autism, but the two issues are often conflated.
Sadly, Stone and Bogner’s “paper” is one of the most blatant examples of cherry-picked research I’ve seen in a long time, and that’s saying something. Indeed, plowing through the list and looking up key papers was a tediously predictable endeavor. Basically, Stone and Bogner take papers that look at some aspect of cannabinoid function, whether it’s about autism or not, and extrapolate to autism. Let’s take a look at their most convincing piece of evidence first (to me, at least). In this case, by “most convincing,” I mean least unconvincing:
“Rare mutations in neuroligins and nerexins predispose to autism” (Földy 2013). Neuroligin-3 is the only known protein required for tonic secretion of endocannabinoids that include AEA and 2-AG (Földy 2013). Neuroligin-3 mutations have been shown to inhibit tonic endocannabinoid secretion (Földy 2013). These alterations in endocannabinoid signaling may contribute to autism pathophysiology (Földy 2013, Krueger 2013, Onaivi 2011, Siniscalco 2013). These finding have in part prompted researchers to apply to conduct research with nonhuman primates in order to further elucidate this link (Malcher-Lopes 2013).
Endocannabinoid system deficiencies are suggested to be involved in the pathophysiology of a growing number of diseases (Marco 2012, Russo 2003). Pacher and Pertwee both cover the endocannabinoid system in detail (Pacher 2006, Pertwee 2010). The number of functions that endocannabinoid signaling regulate in the human body is extensive and beyond the scope of this paper (Pertwee 2010). For sake of brevity only a few potentially relevant aspects will be listed:
So what are these elements? Basically, Stone and Bogner cite a whole bunch of papers supporting the conclusions that endocannabinoids:
Modulate synaptic function
Regulate GI functions
Suppress proliferation and cytokine release in the central nervous system (CNS)
Regulate stress responses
Increase cerebral blood flow
Modulate neural and glial cell function
…you get the idea. So, yes, cannabinoids are important molecules in the CNS and elsewhere. No one argues against that. It’s also true that it was recently shown that mutations in neuroligins and nerexins appear to predispose children to autism and that neuroligin-3 mutations inhibit endocannabinoid secretion, suggesting that bolstering endocannabinoid secretion might antagonize or reverse the abnormalities associated with such mutations. (A decent overview of this research suitable for a lay person can be found here, and the original paper is here.) Let’s just put it this way. This is a rodent model, and right there it’s a question of how relevant it is to real, human ASDs. This is very preclinical evidence, meaning that it might or might not turn out to be relevant to human ASDs. At best, it justifies further study. Moreover, the primate model referenced in Stone and Bogner’s paper appears to be merely a proposal presented to a conference in Qatar. This is thin gruel indeed, as a recent review article on medical marijuana published in the Journal of Developmental & Behavioral Pediatrics by Hadland et al. points out:
Many advocates cite scientific literature regarding benefits of cannabis for the treatment of pediatric behavioral conditions, but often, data cited are from animal model-based research that does not yet have translation to human subjects. For example, a 2013 study 80 from Stanford University showed that mice with a specific and rare gene mutation linked to autism showed altered endocannabinoid signaling in the central nervous system. These data were then cited by online and print media supporters of medical marijuana (e.g., the High Times 81) as evidence that cannabis could be used as a treatment for autism. As another example, when another recent study 72 based on a mouse model of Fragile X syndrome (described earlier in this review) showed alterations in endocannabinoid signaling pathways, these data were referenced (in this case, by more mainstream media outlets, such as the Huffington Post 8 and Fox News 82) as evidence for a promising role for cannabis as treatment. Although these and other high-impact studies share important insights into the pathogenesis of autism spectrum disorders (ASD) and Fragile X syndrome, based on their results alone, it is erroneous and potentially harmful to conclude that cannabis should be used as treatment for either of these disorders at this time.
Indeed. Not surprisingly, Stone and Bogner’s article references that very same study on Fragile X syndrome as well. Much of the rest of their article boils down to the list I enumerated above plus other correlations, their arguments reduced to, in essence, this:
The endocannabinoid system is important in [insert important CNS function or signaling pathway here] in preclinical cell culture and animal models.
Autism and ASDs involve abnormalities of this important CNS function or signaling pathway.
Ergo, cannabinoids can be used to treat autism and ASDs.
Q.E.D.
In other words, there’s a whole lot of confusing correlation with causation and assuming pathogenesis when what is being observed might just be an epiphenomenon. There might be a direct role for these correlations in causing autism, and some of the signaling pathways might even represent promising targets, including the endocannabinoid pathway or a subset of it. Stone and Bogner go wrong by assuming all of these studies indicate a critical role for endocannabinoids in autism, such as elevated cytokine levels. For instance, take a look at this list of effects of cannabidiol (CBD):
CB1/CB2 agonist blocker (can inhibit overstimulation of CB1 by THC)
FAAH inhibition increases endocannabinoid levels (including AEA, 2-AG)
AEA reuptake inhibitor
5-HT1a agonist
Suppressor of tryptophan degradation
PPAR alpha and gamma agonist Positive allosteric modulator at glycine receptors
TRPV1 and TRPV2 agonist
Adenosine uptake competitive inhibitor
Antagonist at abnormal-CBD receptor
Regulator of intracellular Ca 2+ T-type Ca 2+ channel inhibitor (Izzo 2009)
This is a wide range of effects, some of which could be relevant to autism/ASD. The problem, of course, is that we don’t know which ones are the most relevant and which ones actually involve promising therapeutic targets for intervention.
Extrapolate, extrapolate, extrapolate!
Whenever writing a research paper that is basic science that could potentially be translated into a treatment for a disease, it is generally considered mandatory to speculate at the end just how this could come about. For instance, when scientists write about cannabinoids in the context of models of neurodevelopmental disorders, after all the basic science, cell culture, and animal model work, naturally they try to describe how their results could be pursued so that they translate into a clinical treatment. It’s known as showing clinical relevance to your findings, no matter how basic science they are. Stone and Bogner quote several of these sorts of speculative statements in the discussion or introduction of papers as though they were Gospel truth, then conclude:
Given the known role of the endocannabinoid system in ASD it seems entirely possible, if not likely, that cannabinoid rich botanical extracts from cannabis can be utilized as useful agents targeting the pathophysiology of ASD, as well as the many debilitating symptoms and conditions associated with it. The wealth of options that cannabis has to offer those that suffer from ASD in MI is not currently legally permitted. We believe that needs to change.
As I said before, Q.E.D. (Yes, that’s sarcasm.)
Where’s the beef (i.e., the clinical evidence)?
What all these 75 references really mean is that there is some correlative evidence that the endocannabinoid system is abnormal in autism. However, it’s not at all clear whether these abnormalities are causative or downstream effects from the true cause or causes, whatever they might be. What this evidence means is that it’s probably worthwhile to study the endocannibinoid system in autism and whether modulating its activity can have an effect on autistic symptoms. What it most definitely isn’t is compelling evidence to authorize any doctor in the state who wants to do so to use cannabis oil to treat autism. Yes, because the law states two doctors have to sign off for use of medical marijuana in children, parents will have to find two doctors, but, really, does anyone think that will be very difficult?
To recommend a treatment for general use, we need high quality clinical evidence. Is there any such evidence for cannabis oil for autism? The answer is a resounding and unequivocal no. Indeed, an excellent indication of the paucity of evidence regarding cannabis oil and autism is the way Stone and Bogner dance around the issue by citing anecdotal reports about the use of cannabis oil and cannabinoids to treat epilepsy:
How can combinations of cannabinoids be put into practical use by individual families? For our purposes let’s review the anecdotal reports of cannabinoid based treatments currently being utilized in MI (and around the world) for pediatric epilepsy. I think this is a good comparison due to the range and complexity of both conditions. CBD continues to prove its effectiveness in treating many types of epilepsy, but not all (Porter 2013). Anecdotal reports provided in online groups with families that share dosing and other related information to cannabinoid based pediatric epilepsy treatments reveal that in many cases parents (and physicians) find that an increased ratio of THC is required to increase the efficacy of treatment. The range seems to vary significantly from 24:1 to 1:1 (CBD:THC). Some partial explanations for this might include the ability of THC to increase GABAergic transmissions via CB1 activation, its modulation of ion channels, and that it’s a PPAR gamma agonist which is neuroprotective in epilepsy (Stone 2014).
Due to the range of ASD it seems possible that, similar to cannabinoid based epilepsy treatments, varying ratios of cannabinoids (specifically CBD:THC) will prove to have a greater efficacy overall when compared to individual cannabinoid based treatments (like Dronobinal). This concept has been further supported by the research and clinical use of Sativex, a 1:1 (CBD:THC) botanical extract marketed for use in a range of treatments throughout the world (Hazekamp 2013, Russo 2006). The ability to specifically tailor cannabinoid ratios in botanical extracts from cannabis in a case specific manner may prove an even greater efficacy.
This is nothing more than handwaving, comparing two different conditions and assuming that what is observed in one condition will apply to another condition. Worse, as Skeptical Raptor reminds us, despite these anecdotal reports of benefit due to cannabinoids or cannabis oil in epilepsy, a recent Cochrane Review concludes that “no reliable conclusions can be drawn at present regarding the efficacy of cannabinoids as a treatment for epilepsy.” In other words, there’s no high quality evidence that cannabinoids are efficacious in treating epilepsy. There’s even less evidence that cannabinoids can be used to treat autism. Indeed, as the aforementioned review by Hadland et al. notes:
Regarding human data on use of cannabis for developmental and behavioral conditions, to the best of our knowledge, the only available data are from small case series or single studies. For example, one 6-year-old boy with autism was treated with daily dronabinol for 6 months and was noted to have improvement in hyperactivity, irritability, lethargy, stereotyped behaviors, and speech, as measured by the Aberrant Behavior Checklist.83 This single case study was uncontrolled and unblinded. In another single case study 84 of a cannabis-using adult male with attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) off stimulants, the subject’s driving skills in a simulated test during a time of abstinence improved after smoking marijuana (What is unclear is whether this subject may have actually been experiencing cannabis withdrawal from his abstinence, with alleviation of his symptoms through subsequent use of marijuana.85). Another small case series 86 showed an improvement in self-injurious behaviors among adolescents after dronabinol therapy, but to date, the study has not been published, leaving protocol details scarce. In sum, none of these studies provides sufficient, high-quality data to suggest that cannabis should be recommended for treatment of ASD or ADHD at this time.
And neither does Stone and Bogner’s analysis, which was the basis of the evidence submitted with the petition to the Michigan Medical Marijuana Review Board to add autism as a qualifying condition for medical marijuana treatment. Their analysis is the very definition of cherry picking studies and extrapolating wildly from preclinical cell culture and animal studies and studies that address other conditions to conclude that cannabinoids are efficacious treating autism, while ignoring the dearth of evidence that counts: Actual clinical trial evidence. As the Cochrane review I cited pointed out, there were four randomized trials including a total of 48 patients using cannabinoids to treat autism. One report was just an abstract; another a letter to the editor. None of the trials provided randomization details, and there was no description of whether the control and treatment groups were equivalent. The studies were thus of incredibly low quality. All there are, are a handful of uninformative single patient case reports like this one.
Yet, when this this incredibly thin gruel was combined with emotional testimonials of distraught parents of severely autistic children, it was the emotional testimonials of distraught parents that won out. There isn’t another drug for which the FDA or a state would give doctors the go-ahead to use to treat humans for conditions like autism or cancer based on such slim to nonexistent evidence.
Approving the use of cannabis oil for autism: “Premature” doesn’t even begin to describe it
There is no doubt that the approval of medical marijuana for various medical conditions is driven far more by politics than science or clinical observations. For no condition is that more true than autism, for which even the anecdotal evidence is weaker than it is for other qualifying conditions such as chemotherapy-induced nausea, chronic pain, and epilepsy. Moreover, in this case, the Michigan Medical Marijuana Review Panel abdicated its responsibility to interpret existing science with respect to medical marijuana and autism. It is a travesty that the panel could take the cherry picked list of studies annotated with unjustified extrapolation of preclinical studies and conclude that there was a compelling case for adding autism to the list of qualifying conditions. The panel failed even to require that only relevant specialists, such as pediatric neurologists, be allowed to prescribe cannabis oil for autism and instead let any licensed physician (OK, two licensed physicians) do it. Worse, these physicians don’t even have to monitor how often or how much is given to an autistic child for whom they prescribe medical marijuana. They can leave it all up to the parents, the vast majority of whom have no medical training.
This lack of oversight is a big deal because, contrary to what medical marijuana advocates claim, science still doesn’t have a good understanding of what the long term effects of chronic daily cannabis use are on the developing brain. We do know that teenagers who were found to be dependent on marijuana before age 18 and continued using it into adulthood lose IQ points. One can argue that IQ is a poor surrogate for intelligence, but nonetheless such findings are worrisome. We do know that marijuana use is associated with abnormalities in the brain in young users in an exposure-dependent manner. There are other potential adverse health effects as well. In any decision to use a drug, there is a risk-benefit analysis, and thus far in autism there’s almost no evidence for benefit and troubling evidence of risk when cannabis is used long term in children.
Fortunately, the recommendation of the Michigan Medical Marijuana Review Board is not binding. That recommendation will now go to Mike Zimmer, director of the Michigan Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs. He will have the final say over whether autism is added to the list of qualifying conditions. We in Michigan can only hope he realizes what a massive mistake the review board made and overrules their recommendation. Although new evidence might change this in the future, at present, medical marijuana for autism is unscientific herbalism, not pharmacognosy, and has no place in science-based medicine or state policy.

A journey to alternative and integrative medicine apostasy
WIRED posted a story about Jim Laidler recently discussing his movement away from autism biomed and back to science. It’s a good story, that deserves sharing, and explores many of the motivations people have for embracing alternative medicine.
David Gorski on May 4, 2015
Link


I’ve been blogging for over a decade now, a fact that I find really hard to believe looking back on it right now. I’ve told the story before, but it’s worth briefly recounting again because doing so will explain why the story I’m about to discuss caught my attention. My “gateway drug,” if you will, into skepticism was discovering Holocaust denial in the late 1990s on Usenet, a vast and sprawling conglomeration of thousands of discussion forums that began to fade away at the turn of the century with the rise of web-based forums and Google providing an interface to it to make it Google Groups. The forum where I first discovered Holocaust denial and learned to combat it, alt.revisionism, still exists, but long ago degenerated into a cesspool of racism, spam, and trolling. A couple of years later, around 2000 or so, I discovered quackery and the antivaccine movement, thanks to a Usenet newsgroup known as misc.health.alternative, which is where I honed my early skills applying science to medical claims. It’s also where I first encountered Peter Moran, a regular commenter here who greatly inspired me back then with his full-throated criticism of cancer quackery and his website that taught me reasons why cancer quackery could appear to work even when it did nothing to impact the progression of the cancer.
In December 2004, intrigued by all the news stories about blogging and having discovered a number of good blogs, I decided on one dark, gray Saturday afternoon to dip my toe in the blogosphere. On the spur of the moment I created the first iteration of my not-so-super-secret other blog on—what else?—Blogger. Much to my own amazement, over the course of a year I got my little hobby noticed, to the point where I was invited to join a blog collective; by late 2007 I had become prominent enough to be invited by Steve Novella to join this very blog at its founding, where I have remained for seven years, with no plans to move on any time soon. During my early days, though, there was one person who also inspired me, helping me to learn about the pseudoscience that undergirds the antivaccine movement and, in particular, the quackery making up what is known these days as the “autism biomed” movement. His name is James Laidler, and he was one of the ones who introduced me to this topic which I’ve written about many times both at my not-so-super-secret other blog and, of course, right here on SBM. In doing so, over the years I’ve catalogued why “autism biomed” seems compelling to many parents with children with autism, how antivaccine groups use fake “medical conferences” to sell autism biomed by giving a patina of medical respectability to rank quackery like bleach enemas, and providing a place where those selling unscientific treatments can find willing customers and where disreputable discredited “scientists” like Andrew Wakefield and Mark Geier can find adoring fans who believe their quackery.
I bring this up because last week WIRED published an excellent article about Jim Laidler, “An Alternative-Medicine Believer’s Journey Back to Science.” Appropriately enough, it’s by Alan Levinovitz, an assistant professor of religion at James Madison University. I say “appropriately enough” because, as has been noted here on a number of occasions, there are many religion-like aspects to alternative medicine in general but to the autism biomed movement in particular. Indeed, the two are often tied together, with the motivation for some alt-med being explicitly religious and belief in alt-med sharing some major characteristics with religion, particularly belief in miracles against evidence, charismatic leaders (like Andrew Wakefield) who can do no wrong, and mutually-supportive communities of believers who reinforce each others’ beliefs and ward off skepticism. Add to that the magical thinking, and it’s not for nothing that I’ve referred to the central dogma of alternative medicine as being that wishing makes it so. Indeed, it’s for good reason that I frequently point out that most “energy medicine” (particularly reiki) is basically faith healing that substitutes Eastern mysticism for Judeo-Christian religious beliefs.
In Levinovitz’s profile of Jim Laidler, we see a lot of this, and I learned some details that I didn’t know about Laidler before. Levinovitz also grasps the religion-like nature of alt-med by starting the article bluntly saying:
Jim and Louise Laidler lost their faith on a trip to Disneyland in 2002, while having breakfast in Goofy’s Kitchen.
Jim Laidler and his wife Louise are both doctors, and two of their sons, Ben and David, were diagnosed with autism. In the late 1990s until what happened in 2002, the Laidlers were very much true believers in autism biomed. I knew this back in the day, because I had read Jim Laidler’s writing extensively before; indeed, it was his recounting of his experiences treating his sons with autism biomed quackery that helped me to understand how confirmation bias, regression to the mean, placebo effects, and observer effects could lead parents to believe that pseudoscientific treatments were working to “recover” their children from autism when they were doing nothing to impact the course of the condition. He was the first one to teach me that, contrary to the myth that leads parents to attribute any improvement in autistic children to whatever quackery du jour they are using, autism spectrum disorders are conditions that result in neurodevelopmental delay, not neurodevelopmental stasis. In fact, autistic children can and do recover to the point where they “lose the ASD diagnosis” in anywhere from 3% to 25% of cases. (Yes, the literature is a variable on this point.)
So, there they were, the Laidlers, treating Ben and David with a wide variety of quackery to “recover” them from autism, as recounted by Levinovitz:
For several years, on the advice of doctors and parents, the Laidlers treated their children with a wide range of alternative medicine techniques designed to stem or even reverse autistic symptoms. They gave their boys regular supplements of vitamin B12, magnesium, and dimethylglycine. They kept David’s diet free of gluten and casein, heeding the advice of experts who warned that even the smallest bit of gluten would cause severe regression. They administered intravenous infusions of secretin, said to have astonishing therapeutic effects for a high percentage of autistic children.
Using substances known as chelating agents, the Laidlers also worked to rid Ben and David of heavy metals thought to be accumulated through vaccines and environmental pollutants. With a PhD in biology as well as his MD, Jim Laidler had become an expert on chelation, speaking nationally and internationally about it at conferences dedicated to autism and alternative approaches.
I’ve discussed such treatments many times before here at SBM, particularly chelation therapy, which has no basis in science for treating autism and whose rationale is predicated on the belief that the mercury in the thimerosal preservative that used to be used in many childhood vaccines causes autism. It’s a dangerous treatment that has caused at least one death. Autism biomed in general can be viewed as uncontrolled and unethical experimentation on a vulnerable population, autistic children. It’s definitely worth pointing out that, with an MD and a PhD—just as I have!—Laidler had the intellectual and scientific background to recognize that what he was doing was without a basis in science and medicine. Yet he didn’t, at least not for several years. Indeed, he helped promote chelation therapy and “spread the good news,” so to speak. How did this come about?
The journey to belief
In Levinovitz’s account, the Laidlers’ journey began after their eldest son, Ben, was born. He didn’t hit his milestones on time, such as rolling over, crawling, and walking. By the time he was three and a half years old, his speech consisted largely of echoing, and the Laidlers could no longer attribute his developmental delays to being at the low end of the bell-shaped curve for normal variation in development. In fact, by this time, Laidler was beginning to suspect, based on Ben’s lack of eye contact and other behaviors, what was probably going on, recounting it thusly, “I knew what this looked like. But I didn’t want to bring it up, not even to Louise. You get superstitious, like if you say something it’ll come true.”
Their son David was born three years after Ben, and initially he hit all his developmental milestones early. The family moved to Portland, and the Laidlers discovered what then made up the autism biomed movement on the Internet, mainly online forums where parents traded success stories. Remember, this was 1997, long before the many, many antivaccine, pro-autism biomed websites that exist now, such as Age of Autism, The Thinking Moms’ Revolution, and the like. Andrew Wakefield’s infamous and now retracted Lancet case series wouldn’t arrive until next year, and the full fear mongering over mercury in vaccines was still a few years away. For example, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. didn’t publish “Deadly Immunity” until 2005. Jenny McCarthy’s antivaccine activism wouldn’t begin until a decade later. To bring it back around to how I started this post, there was Usenet, and there were private discussion forums, and that was about it. And, yes, I do recall reading Laidler’s description of how those forums were used mainly for parents to share “success stories” that, when he later looked at them critically, were not. No quackery was too outrageous, and all had validity.
Unfortunately, after hitting his milestones early for a while, David regressed. It was not long after that before he was diagnosed with autism as well. It was at this point, not surprisingly and in a very human reaction, the Laidlers fell into a depression.
And then:
Then another parent told Louise about Defeat Autism Now! She decided to attend.
The conference was a festival of alternative medicine, a campground of tents and booths and speakers offering attendees everything from cutting-edge supplements to dolphin therapy. Everyone—parents and presenters alike—swore by their preferred treatment, and countless stories circulated about severely autistic children who instantly turned around on the right protocol.
Louise returned filled with new hopes. At first, Jim was skeptical—”I hadn’t been there. I hadn’t felt the excitement”—but soon, he was hopeful too. They decided to put David and Ben on more supplements. They tried secretin infusions. They attended another DAN! conference. They came to believe in many other alternative therapies.
DAN!, as you might recall, consisted of a large number of practitioners offering all manner of quackery under the rubric of “autism biomed.” These doctors were listed on the registry of the antivaccine autism biomed group known as the “Autism Research Institute” an organization founded by Dr. Bernard Rimland in 1967. DAN! physicians generally became DAN! physicians by undergoing training through the ARI, which held yearly DAN! conferences to discuss the latest autism biomed quackery. Interestingly enough, in either an apparent attempt to become more “legitimate” or in response to lawsuits against DAN! doctors, ARI stopped maintaining its DAN! registry at the end of 2011. Back in the late 1990s through much of the first decade of the 21st century, though, if you wanted to find an autism biomed doc, the DAN! list was the first place to go. Unfortunately, many parents, like the Laidlers, did just that.
The Laidlers, however, eventually realized their mistake. Many parents, such as those who populate the antivaccine crank blog Age of Autism as bloggers or the inappropriately named “Thinking Moms” of The Thinking Moms’ Revolution never do. So what “converted” the Laidlers back to science? To understand this, we have to go back to what happened in Goofy’s Kitchen thirteen years ago.

The deconversion
So what, exactly, happened in Goofy’s Kitchen at Disneyland? It’s something that to most people would seem relatively minor but to the Laidlers immediately took on outsized significance. However, it’s also a good example of how a believer’s mind needs to be “primed” before an incident like this can tip him or her back towards skepticism. Before this event, Jim Laidler had started to doubt the whole DAN! subculture and what it was preaching. Levinovitz recounts how Laidler had begun to cringe when he heard of other parents mortgaging their homes to pay for expensive unproven autism biomed treatments and how “alarms went off” when parents and doctors would advocate dangerous protocols, such as extreme forms of chelation. So he spoke out against the more dangerous and extreme treatments being promoted and offered by DAN! doctors. That’s when he started to learn that skepticism is not appreciated in movements like DAN! Indeed, a prominent conference organizer took him to task for such criticisms, warning him “never to criticize anyone’s approach, no matter how crazy or dangerous it seemed.” We see a less extreme form of this same attitude in the seemingly more “reasonable” world of “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) or “integrative medicine,” where, seemingly, every hypothesis and treatment is potentially valid, even homeopathy, and CAM advocates are loathe ever to dismiss any treatment, even when it’s magical faith healing like reiki or sympathetic magic like homeopathy. More on that later.
First, let’s see what happened at Goofy’s Kitchen:
It was in the grip of these doubts when, inside Goofy’s Kitchen, Jim and Louise returned to their table from the buffet and noticed 6-year-old David hadn’t come with them. They saw him standing at the buffet, devouring a waffle. The Laidlers feared the worst. “We’d been told that the slightest smidgen of gluten would crash him,” Jim says. “It was absolutely devastating to watch.” But by the end of the vacation, they realized David was fine. Nothing happened.
When they returned home, the Laidlers took David off his restrictive diet, and he continued to improve—rapidly. Louise stopped Ben’s supplement regimen—without telling Jim—and Ben’s behavior remained the same. Then, after months of soul-searching, Jim Laider took to the internet to announce his “de-conversion” from alternative medicine—a kind of penance, but also a warning to others. “I had this guilt to expunge,” Jim says. “I helped to promote this nonsense, and I didn’t want other people to fall for it like I did.”
Jim Laidler had become an alt-med apostate. As anyone who’s studied religion knows, in general believers detest apostates far more than unbelievers. After all, unbelievers might still be made into believers and might just be ignorant of the belief system of the religion. Apostates, on the other hand, were once believers who were fully invested in belief but then actively decided to reject the religion. In this, he is like Britt Hermes, who was a naturopath but abandoned the faith after recognizing the pseudoscience at its heart, or Sam Homola, a chiropractor who rejected chiropractic’s more outlandish claims for the same reasons, or Paul Ingraham, a former registered massage therapist who couldn’t bear the pseudoscience anymore. After he announced his deconversion, Laidler suffered the usual fate of the apostate, shunning and attacks:
When Jim Laidler became an alt-medicine apostate, proponents of the treatments he criticized went on the attack. He received death threats from parents. It’s an intellectually and emotionally bruising battle no matter which side you’re on, one that today pits not just doctor against layperson, but also doctor against doctor. And as the Laidlers demonstrate, it can pit well-trained doctors against their own psyche. “I was happier because we felt like we were doing something right,” Jim Laidler says of the treatments he gave his sons over the course of so many years. “That’s how the madness begins. You want to believe that it’s working, so you force yourself to see results, and silence the scientific part of your brain.”
I know that Laidlers put up with such attacks for years. He had been fairly quiet over the last few years, which makes me wonder why he agreed to be the subject of a story published on a major website today, given that no doubt the reminder of his apostasy, correctly described as apostasy, will attract the attention of the autism biomed believers with whom he used to worship at the church of chelation. Whatever his reasons, I’m glad he did agree. I only wish Levinovitz had contacted me, because one thing that’s lacking in his piece is an understanding of just how influential Jim Laidler has been to a generation of skeptics (including myself) trying to counter the misinformation of the antivaccine movement and how useful his writings have been to us.
It has been said that alt-med appeals to some unmet need that scientific medicine either does not meet or does a poor job of handling. Whether that is a need for hope when there is little or none or the feeling that “something” is being done, that is perhaps true in many cases. However, unmet psychological needs are not a justification for the acceptance of pseudoscience creeping into conventional medicine, something we at SBM have been warning about for over seven years now. The story of the Laidlers shows how even doctors and scientists can be ensnared as patients and parents of patients, but what about the providers?
The return of David Katz and his “more fluid concept of evidence”
Four weeks ago, I discussed the unfortunate case of Dr. David Katz, who happens to be faculty at Yale along with our very own Dr. Steve Novella. Dr. Katz, you might recall, first found himself on the radar of skeptics when he advocated a “more fluid concept of evidence” with respect to medicine back in a now infamous 2008 talk. His message has been correctly characterized as, “Don’t abandon patients; abandon science instead.” Well who to my wondering eyes should appear in Levinovitz’s story but Dr. “More Fluid Concept of Evidence” himself? His message is very revealing, albeit perhaps inadvertently. After noting quite correctly that twenty years ago, when the Laidlers’ journey into alternative medicine began, what they sought for their sons was clearly outside the medical mainstream, “largely separate from mainstream hospitals and medical schools,” as he put it, Levinovitz notes that, thanks to what is now known as “integrative medicine,” such is no longer the case:
At Yale, physician and prominent health advocate David Katz practices integrative medicine, aiming to combine acceptance of alternative treatments with scientific rigor and regulation. Katz opposes chelation, along with all non-standard protocols proven to be physically harmful, but he supports being open-minded about many other alternative techniques, including acupuncture, homeopathy, and reiki.
Such open-mindedness, he says, offers a badly needed corrective to a broken medical system. “With internal medicine, once I’ve tried everything the textbooks tell me, I’m done,” he says. “But with integrative medicine, I always have something to try. I never run out of options.”
This argument is atrociously dumb, even by David Katz standards. Yes, it might be true that with integrative medicine a physician “never runs out of options,” but if those options are fantasy and fairy dust, they do the patient no more good than “throwing up one’s hands” and saying there’s nothing that can be done. Let’s put it this way. If magic like homeopathy and reiki (which, recall, is nothing more than “faith healing”) are “options,” then where does it end? How far outside the realm of well-established science does a proposed treatment have to be before Katz will reject it as not worth considering as an “option”? That he has embraced homeopathy and reiki tells me that there is probably no treatment so outrageously ridiculous that he won’t consider it.
It’s also not true that “once you’ve tried everything in the textbooks,” you’re done. If that’s the limit of your thinking, such that it either has to be in the textbook, or you’ll start considering fairy dust, then it’s your thinking that is limited, not that of skeptics. Just ask Mark Crislip, who just provided us suggestions for what to do when the evidence runs thin. In medicine, unfortunately, sometimes all the options are bad, and it’s a matter of picking the “least bad” option. Some things can’t be cured, but they can almost always at least be palliated. As is pointed out elsewhere in the WIRED article, expectation management is an important part of medicine, and it is there that medicine frequently falls down. Integrative medicine lets doctors off the hook. They no longer have to manage expectations, or at least they can give patients hope that they wouldn’t otherwise be able to give. It doesn’t always matter if it’s false hope:
And false hope isn’t just for patients. Doctors—traditional and integrative alike—also can become dependent. No doctor wants to be hope’s executioner, especially when they don’t know how to do it properly. The vast majority of doctors receive no formal training in how to deliver catastrophic news. Most hospitals don’t provide a social worker to take over once parents find out their child has autism. Instead of thinking about what to do when there are no options for a cure, it’s easier, as Katz puts it, to never run out of options.
No doctor wants to be hope’s executioner. How true. I’ve had to tell patients’ families in the past of dire circumstances with little or no hope. I’ve had to help families come to a decision to withdraw support. I’ve even had to be the one to withdraw support. I’ve had to tell patients and their families that there was nothing more that could be done to save their life. Yes, these were all a long time ago, before I hyperspecialized in breast cancer surgery, where, fortunately, such conversations are now fairly rare, but I remember such incidents clearly because of how hard they were, mentally, intellectually, and emotionally. They were painful. But they were part of my job, my profession. Giving patients the hard news was my duty. How much easier it would have been if I could have come up with “options” that would prevent me from having to present just the cold, hard, facts and prognosis to patients and their families.
As our fearless leader, Steve Novella, who was quoted in Levinovitz’s story, relates:
When confronted with the possibility of a troubling diagnosis, people often prefer to avoid hard truths. Novella tells a gut-wrenching story about one of his patients, who had ALS. After the initial diagnosis, the man left the office, unable to cope with the fact that he had an incurable degenerative disease, likely to kill him within five years. He chose to visit a naturopath instead, who had redemptive news: conventional, narrow-minded medicine had misdiagnosed him. It wasn’t ALS, the naturopath said, but rather chronic Lyme disease, which could be treated with holistic, all-natural supplements.
Nearly a year later, badly degenerated, the man was back in Novella’s office. He’d wasted countless hours and thousands of dollars on false hope. Now, he was willing to listen, but with far less time to prepare for the reality of what lay ahead, and a spirit broken by disappointment. Research suggests this is no mere anecdote. Studies out of Norway, Japan, and Korea have reported higher mortality rates and lower quality of life for cancer patients who pursue complementary and alternative medicine.
Whether he knows it or not, perhaps Dr. Katz has inadvertently revealed the probable primary motivation for the “integration” of quackery into conventional medicine, although not quite in the way he thinks he did. Reading this line of argument, I can’t help but conclude that the embrace of more “options” in integrative medicine is not so much about the patient, Katz’s protestations otherwise. Think about it. Katz argues that integrative medicine means “never running out of options.” While there’s no doubt that options can be a good thing when they are options not based on fairy dust that might actually do something, by embracing prescientific, pseudoscientific, and outright magical “options,” integrative medicine helps doctors avoid making the hard choices that their patients need them to make, or at least helps them put off those choices, often for long periods of time. That’s what it’s really about, not doing whatever it takes to make patients feel better. All that this requires is for physicians to be so open-minded that their brains are allowed to fall out.
Yes, there are problems with conventional medicine. Doctors often spend too little time with patients because the reimbursement system requires that they see lots of patients to be able to make a living. The medical system often doesn’t deal with terminal illnesses or chronic illnesses as well as it should. However, to paraphrase Ben Goldacre, just because there are problems with aircraft design, that doesn’t mean magic carpets really fly, and just because there are problems in our medical system does not mean that the solution is to embrace pseudoscience and magic. Jim Laidler was one of my early skeptical influences who helped teach me that. Ironically, David Katz is also teaching me the same thing, but mainly as a negative example.
The road to apostasy, as Jim Laidler shows us, is hard. That’s why it’s important to do what we can to prevent conversion to pseudoscience in the first place. Unfortunately, that is often not possible. Even more unfortunately, David Katz and other advocates of integrating quackery with medicine show that deconverting doctors who have embraced integrative medicine will likely be just as difficult. At least Dr. Laidler shows us that it can happen. Can it happen with doctors like David Katz? I hope so.

Stem Cell Therapy for Autism
Steven Novella on June 17, 2026
Link

If you are a parent of a young child with autism (especially level 2 or 3, requiring significant support), the promise of a cure or even an effective treatment is irresistible. This is exactly why there needs to be science-based regulatory standards – to protect vulnerable patients and their loved-ones. RFK Jr., however, wants to weaken these protections – even removing from the FDA website common-sense warnings for parents who are likely to be exploited (the HHS claims the removal was a routine cleanup of their website, a claim that does not pass the smell test).
We have also been covering dubious stem cell clinics here for two decades – the hype surrounding stem cells is perfect for predatory clinics. Stem cell treatments sound like cutting edge science. There is a lot of legitimate research and advances going on, and some therapies are in late stage clinical trials. Treatments often involve injections or infusions, with all the trappings of modern advanced medicine. And such treatments can cost tens of thousands of dollars. It’s a potential cash cow.
Unproven therapies also benefit from what I consider the weaknesses of “evidence based” medicine. EBM itself has some virtues, but it does not go far enough and relies upon a flawed approach to evidence (hence the need for science-based medicine). In practice this makes it vulnerable to exploitation, and what we see is that almost every dubious treatment calls itself “evidence based”, even when the evidence clearly shows it is ineffective.
What, then, is the science-based assessment of stem cell therapies for autism? First let’s address the plausibility – what are these treatments and how are they supposed to work? Right now the most common stem cell treatment offered for autism is intravenous infusions of cord blood. Sometimes stem cells from the cord blood can be cultured and purified. What do these stem cells do?
It is unclear if there is any significant migration of these stem cells into the brain. If any cells do get into the brain, it has not been established that they do anything there, or that what they do addresses any component of the underlying causes of autism. In the periphery they cannot directly affect brain function, but the speculation is they might reduce autoimmunity, or support mitochondrial function or angiogenesis (increasing blood flow), or perhaps have an anti-oxidant effect.
These speculations are all extremely familiar – they are among the most common hand-wavy explanations for how many dubious treatments are supposed to work. In my opinion, they are essentially worthless, because you can say them about almost anything. They have become almost the equivalent of saying “it’s magic”. Seriously – from a scientific perspective, the justification for IV infusions of stem cells to treat autism is as solid as giving someone a magical elixir in the hopes that it will somehow do something.
I don’t think these putative mechanisms are even enough to justify clinical trials, but we have had some clinical trials anyway. Regular readers here likely suspect what’s coming – a 2022 systematic review and metaanalysis found that:
“The results of this meta-analysis suggested that stem cell therapy for children with autism might be safe and effective. However, the evidence was compromised by the limitations in current study size, lacking standardized injection routes and doses of stem cells, as well as shortages in diagnostic tools and long period follow-up studies. Hence, it calls for more studies to systematically confirm the efficacy and safety of stem cell therapy for children with autism spectrum disorders.”
This is so common it’s a cliche – essentially the studies are all crap, in this case the results are essentially uninterpretable, so we need more studies (do we, really?). Being charitable, what this means is that stem cells for autism should not be offered outside of a regulated clinical trial, patients should not be charged for the treatment, and no clinic should market the treatment with any claims of effectiveness.
But there’s more, because there was further research, and a high quality one at that. Duke Health conducted the best study to date on this treatment, a Phase II study with 180 subjects, placebo controlled and double blind. They used a primary outcome and many secondary outcomes and reasonable follow up. What did the study show – dead negative. Every single outcome measure showed no difference between treatment and control, not even close. No p-values even flirted with significance. It’s as negative a study as you can imagine.
Phase II studies are often used to determine if it is worth proceeding to Phase III studies, the kind needed to get FDA approval. Such a negative study should be the death of this treatment, but the Duke researchers somehow found the results “encouraging”. What? How do they justify that? They conducted a post-hoc analysis and found that if you limited the analysis to just children without intellectual disability there was a trend toward benefit (not even statistical significance). Finding a trend in a post-hoc subgroup analysis is a classic maneuver for trying to rescue something positive from a negative study. It’s essentially nonsense. It would be amazing if you couldn’t find a subgroup with a trend.
It’s understandable that researchers are invested in their treatment working. We would all love to have an effective biological treatment option for ASD. So some motivated reasoning is expected. But there may be another layer here as well. According to MSN:
“More recently, Duke’s partnership with Cryo-Cell International, a company that banks cord cells and licensed Duke’s intellectual property to pursue autism infusion clinics, has collapsed – a signal that even commercial interest in the science has waned.”
If they were also pinning their hopes on a cash cow stem cell clinic, their motivated reasoning becomes more clear.
The best summary of the current situation is that:
    • Stem cells for autism do not have a clear or established mechanism of action
    • The treatment is expensive and invasive with demonstrable risks, and therefore caution is appropriate
    • Existing clinical evidence is a combination of low-quality studies and one high-quality study that is completely negative – most consistent with the conclusion that stem cell infusions are ineffective as a treatment for autism.
    • Parents should remain extremely cautious before pursuing such treatments, especially since there are many predatory stem cell clinics out there waiting to take their money. I personally would not recommend the treatment – those health care dollars are better spent on established interventions.
Given all this, I do not think that further clinical research is warranted. If someone believes there is still potential here, then what is required is to do further basic science research to establish a potential mechanism, a way of identifying subjects that might respond, or a method of treatment with a plausible chance of working better than cord blood. In short, clinical research should stop unless or until further basic science research provides a new justification for it.
Further – regulatory agencies like the FDA should crack down on dubious stem cell clinics offering cord blood or similar treatments for autism. They have cracked down in the past, with good results, but when they pause their crackdown, stem cell treatments for autism explode. There is simply too much money to be made here from desperate parents.
Meanwhile, the opposite appears to be happening. RFK feels he has personally benefited from stem cell treatments for his spasmodic dysphonia, and he apparently thinks this is enough justification to make it easier for Americans to get experimental, speculative, and even dubious stem cell treatments without having to travel abroad. Evidence be damned.
    • 

   Autism, Vaccines and the Media

   The Media and Vaccines
Steven Novella 
Link
As the name of this blog makes clear, the authors believe that the public is best served when the institutions of medicine and health care are science-based. The basis of medicine has many levels and institutions in our society. They include not only the practitioners of medicine, but hospitals, medical schools and other academic institutions, government and regulatory agencies, industry, insurance companies, the legal system, media, and (last but not least) the public. Defending science-based medicine requires advocacy at every level.
Arguably, the acceptance of science-based medicine at all levels is influenced greatly by public opinion (too much, in my opinion, as a profession, almost by definition, should rise above the lowest common denominator of public opinion), and public opinion is influenced greatly by the mainstream media. There is one issue, however, for which public opinion has a direct and measurable effect on the efficacy of a medical intervention and that is the vaccination program. Therefore we pay particular interest to how the media deals with the issue of vaccines, especially the recent false controversy over an alleged link between vaccines and autism.
It is my observation (and also supported by a recent study) that the quality of mainstream science reporting has been generally low, attributed to the scaling back of dedicated science journalists. On this issue I have found the reporting to be mixed, with both good and bad examples, but with the highest quality outlets generally getting the story right. This week Time magazine’s cover story is The Truth About Vaccines by Alice Park. The article is excellent – it covers the controversy without pandering and without pretending that there is more of a scientific controversy than there is. She states quite succinctly that the evidence has been evaluated by scientific organizations and there simply is no credible evidence for a link between autism and vaccines.
She hits many of the highlights of the important points against the antivaccinationist claims. For example:
- Proponents of a vaccine-autism link claimed that the mercury-based preservative in some vaccines, thimerosal, was responsible for the link to autism. However, thimerosal was removed from all routine childhood vaccines in the US by 2002 (with only trace amounts in some flu vaccines, which are optional). After the removal of thimerosal autism cases continued to rise unabated, obliterating any claim to a significant link.
- Vaccine critics say the increased vaccine schedule overwhelms the immature immune systems of young children. However, while the number of vaccines has increased, they are more targeted due to improved technology and scientific knowledge. Today’s vaccine schedule contains about 150 antigens (immune stimulating proteins), which is less than the 200 proteins that older vaccines contained.
- Widespread compliance is critical for “herd immunity” to be effective. This is critical because some people cannot get vaccines for medical reasons and they depend on the rest of us to be vaccinated. Voluntary refusal of vaccination has led to outbreaks of diseases like measles that vaccines effectively protect against.
- Vaccines partly suffer from their own success. Parents today never had to live through polio or small pox epidemics.
Overall an excellent article. There are still more points that are critical to the debate that she did not cover, but it is difficult to capture them all in a single article (I assume there were length limitations). For example:
- The “autism epidemic” is likely not real but an artifact of increased surveillance and a broadening of the definition of autism, which is now called “autism spectrum disorder.”
- While parents may first notice the symptoms of autism around the time that vaccines are being given, new studies show that signs are present much earlier, perhaps as early as 4-6 months. If the signs of autism are present before the vaccines are even given, that, of course, falsifies the vaccine-autism hypothesis.
- Evidence is increasingly pointing in the direction that autism is predominantly a genetic disorder or group of disorders. This does not rule out environmental influences entirely, but is argues against autism being primarily due to a toxin.
The scientific debate has largely been fought and resolved – there is no credible and significant link between vaccines and autism. But the public relations battle still rages, and the anti-vaccine side has been doing remarkably well recently. They have a good slogan (green our vaccines) and have been very energetic. In the battle between science and propaganda, propaganda has the short term advantage. While I think science has the long term advantage (because in the end legitimate science is more likely to be correct), a great deal of harm can be done in the meantime.
Park’s article in Time does a good job of pointing that out – irrationally rejecting vaccines causes harm, not only to your own children but to others. It is critical that we continue to point that out to the public. This is not just an abstract battle over how to interpret arcane medical data. Medicine is an applied science and the science behind vaccines has direct public health implications. The subtitle on the cover of Time puts it very succinctly:
Worried about autism, many parents are opting out of immunizations. How they’re putting the rest of us at risk.

   When “investigative reporting” becomes anti-vaccine propaganda
David Gorski
Link
Introduction: The following is the text of a letter that I mailed to Bob Sliva, General Manager of WXYZ-TV in Detroit in response to arguably the most biased and incompetent “investigative report” about mercury, vaccines, or autism that I have ever seen. I sent the letter by snail mail, because I was always taught that that gets a station manager’s attention far better than e-mail. My plan was to allow the three days until today for the letter to arrive and then to publish the text of my letter here on SBM as an open letter. After I mailed my letter, I worried that no one would bother to look at links that they had to type in themselves, which is why I wanted to post this as an open letter whose link I could then e-mail to the station.
I also worried that maybe I had been insufficiently polite and persuasive, given that one is always urged not to be too insulting or strident when writing to a media outlet. After all, if I were too strident, Mr. Sliva would find it easy to write me off as a biased crank. I also worried that maybe I should have e-mailed Mr. Wilson first. On the other hand, Mr. Wilson is a serial offender. In 2003 and 2004, he did a series on mercury, vaccines, and autism that credulously parroted all the pseudoscience, distortions, and misinformation that we’ve come to expect from the anti-vaccine movement. About two weeks before the “Green Our Vaccines” rally, my routine monitoring of the anti-vaccine underground turned up references to a story that Wilson was working on about the rally and the thimerosal issue. Believers in the myth that vaccines cause autism described Wilson and his earlier report in glowing terms, which sent up huge red flags to me. The original links no longer function, but, thanks to the Wayback Machine, I was able to find the transcripts of the original reports (1, 2, 3, 4, 5). This “reporting” (if you can call it that) somehow garnered an Emmy Award, showing that an award, even a normally prestigious one, is no guarantee of anything resembling scientific accuracy in reporting.
However, it was Mr. Wilson’s comments and behavior after a post by a friend of mine, Dr. Peter Lipson, that made me realize that dealing directly with Wilson was a waste of time and that I was right to go straight to the General Manager. I’ll show why in an addendum and will also add references to sources that refute Wilson’s one-sided and credulous reporting. It’s funny how such a pit pull of an “investigative journalist” who goes after politicians and others with such tenacity can’t find it in himself to ask even a mildly probing question when interviewing “luminaries” such as Boyd Haley or parents with no scientific background repeating anti-vaccine talking points. In any case, here follows the text of the letter that I sent to Bob Sliva, the Vice President and General Manager of WXYZ-TV:
July 9,2008Bob Sliva
Vice President/General Manager
WXYZ-TV
20777 West Ten Mile Road
Southfield, MI 48037
Dear Mr. Silva:
I am writing in regard to Steve Wilson’s report aired on the 11 PM news on July 8 entitled Some vaccines still contain mercury. As a cancer surgeon and native Detroiter who recently returned to southeast Michigan after living elsewhere for 20 years I was shocked and appalled both at how one-sided his report was and at the sheer level of misinformation Mr. Wilson managed to cram into such a brief segment. That WXYZ would air such an execrably researched and biased segment is the height of irresponsible journalism. Mr. Wilson clearly does not understand even the basics of evaluating scientific, clinical, and epidemiological evidence, and his story reflected that. It wasn’t even close to being fair and even-handed, containing numerous blatant and inexcusable inaccuracies, all on the side of stoking fear among parents that vaccines somehow cause autism. The scientific, clinical, and epidemiological evidence is quite strong that neither the mercury in thimerosal-containing vaccines nor vaccines themselves cause autism.
Arguably the most egregious example of how biased and downright deceptive this report was came when Mr. Wilson referred to Dr. Boyd Haley as a “pioneer in the study of this issue.” Is Mr. Wilson aware that Haley is viewed by most scientists in the autism community as a pseudoscientist; that is, when he is even considered at all? Is he aware that Haley once referred to autism as “mad child disease” and that he once marketed a chelator for cats? Oddly enough, none of this unsavory background was mentioned. I am not pointing this out solely to impugn Dr. Haley but rather to point out that for Mr. Wilson to refer to him as a “pioneer” is deceptive in that it leaves out another very big side of the story and presents Dr. Haley as an “expert” whose opinion the audience should trust.
Worse, Dr. Haley cited a number of dubious sources of his own unchallenged, and Mr. Wilson duly listed them with no context. For example, he cited a study of monkeys that allegedly found that vaccinated primates showed increased neurological disorders and non-social behavior similar to autism. This study was exceedingly shoddy in design and execution, so much so that I consider it downright unethical. Not only did it not include even close to equal numbers of animals in the control and experimental groups, but it was published by Andrew Wakefield, whose litigation- and money-driven “research” ten years ago sparked a scare over the MMR vaccine that led to a decrease in vaccination and a resurgence of the measles and mumps in the U.K. Moreover, its lead investigator Laura Hewiston not only is married to the IT director for Dr. Wakefield’s clinic but has an autistic son and is a plaintiff in the Autism Omnibus case, in which thousands of parents are trying to obtain compensation for alleged vaccine injury from the now being heard. If that’s not a major conflict of interest, I don’t know what is. If Mr. Wilson had found a conflict of interest that blatant with, for example, the head of the American Academy of Pediatrics, you know he would be all over it.
Other equally dubious studies are mentioned. For example, it is stated, “A study of vaccination records which seems to match increased Autism with increased vaccinations containing mercury.” It turns out that “seems” is a good word, because I presume that the study to which Mr. Wilson refers is a recent study by Mark and David Geier, a father-and-son team of true believers in the mercury hypothesis who not only use chelation therapy on autistic children with no evidence to back it up but have developed the “Lupron protocol,” in which autistic children are claimed to have “precocious puberty” and then are treated with a powerful anti-androgen agent normally used to treat prostate cancer or to chemically castrate sex offenders. The study itself is also very poorly designed, as an epidemiologist showed quite clearly (Part 1, Part 2, Part 3). I would also point out that Dr. Mark Geier has also in the past served as an expert witness in vaccine litigation; that is, until enough judges so severely criticized him that he was not even called to testify for the plaintiffs during the Autism Omnibus.
Then we get to “facts” mentioned in Mr. Wilson’s report that are not even studies. For example, he cites the antivaccinationist canard that the Amish in Pennsylvania don’t vaccinate and they don’t get autism. That is false. The Amish do vaccinate, and they do get autism. This myth originated with Dan Olmsted, a former UPI reporter who is no longer with UPI but is now Editor of the Age of Autism, a website dedicated to promoting the belief that vaccines cause autism. It’s unfortunate that Mr. Wilson did not see fit to cite his source. Indeed, it is rather amazing that Mr. Olmsted neglected even to interview Dr. Strauss, a physician who treats special needs Amish children at the cryptically-named Clinic for Special Children in Strasburg, PA. Also cited throughout is a three year old “expose” written by environmental activist Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.; however, Mr. Kennedy’s article was also riddled with misinformation and distortions. Indeed, Kennedy is not an objective source; rather, he is a true believer in the myth that thimerosal causes autism.
The most egregiously deceptive part of the report, however, was where Wilson stated: “She’s talking about a mercury-based vaccine preservative called Thimerosal…and the truth is there’s still as much as ever in 11 vaccines including most flu vaccines injected into pregnant women and kids, and some of them younger than 9 get two doses in a season. And also high levels of mercury from Thimerosal in tetanus shots and the boosters routinely injected into 11-year-olds…and also in some meningitis and diphtheria-tetanus formulas, too.”
Why is this deceptive? For one thing, even if vaccines actually did cause autism, they wouldn’t do so in a nine year old child. Yet Wilson includes the entire childhood immunization schedule in his list, all the way up to teens. Autism is usually diagnosed before age 3-5 these days, and often earlier. Indeed, it can sometimes be diagnosed as early as at one year of age. Moreover the “hypothesis” behind vaccine causation is that the mercury somehow damages a developing brain; earlier exposures matter, later exposures, not so much. So let’s look at the vaccination schedule and see what a typical child under six would get. I crosschecked the list with the list of vaccines and their thimerosal content. None of the vaccines routinely given to children under six contain thimerosal, other than the flu vaccine, and this is what the CDC says about the flu vaccine for children under two: “For the 2007-08 season, there is one product licensed for 6-23 month old children (the product is thimerosal-free).”
The bottom line is that thimerosal exposure in children is lower than it has been any time since the 1980s. So I ask Wilson: Why haven’t autism rates fallen, now that thimerosal has been out of nearly all childhood vaccines for over six years now? Every time this question is asked, supporters of the thimerosal myth handwave and shift the goalposts.
I conclude by making an observation. Back in February, your competitor WDIV-TV aired an incredibly credulous and bad story about “orbs,” in which it was speculated that these orbs were in fact ghosts or spirits. I had thought that that was the low point in journalism on Detroit television. I now change my assessement. At least stories about orbs are not likely to give a false impression that vaccines are not safe and thereby contribute to the resurgence of vaccine-preventable disease, as has happened in the U.K.
Sincerely,
David H. Gorski, MD, PhD, FACS
ADDENDUM:
As I alluded in the introduction to the letter above, Mr. Wilson showed up in the comments of my friend’s blog. If you have any doubts that he’s either a true believer or a cynical reporter who sees a hot story and doesn’t particularly care whether it’s true or not, read on. Mr. Wilson’s comments are sarcastic, belligerent, and on the whole virtually fact-free. Wilson even cites the antivaccination website Generation Rescue as a source! Here are some examples:
Boy, you folks are awefully fired up about a report based on a CDC list of vaccines that still contain mercury while it is widely (and falsely) reported that the the heavy metal was altogether removed years ago.
Some of you more-vitriolic folks remind me of those who SWORE there was, and could not be, any link between tobacco and cancer. Have you seen some of the ads with docs in white coats saying something like: “Yeah, I recommend my patients have a smoke. It relaxes them!”
Surely we can agree on this:
1. Nobody knows what causes Autism and no study has ever proved or disproved to an accepted scientific certainty that mercury is a trigger in some cases;
2. Mercury, like lead, is a heavy metal that is toxic to humans and should be avoided at all costs;
3. 11 vaccines that can be injected into children (and pregnant women) still contain mercury despite the call nearly 10 years ago from the AAP, government and independent experts for it to be altogether removed;
4. Thimerosal does nothing to increase the efficacy of the vaccine. It exists only for the benefit–financial and otherwise–of those who make it, sell it and ultimately inject it.
So can one of you geniuses explain to me why in the world anybody in their right mind would want to inject the second-most toxic heavy metal known into the body of a baby? This seems like a good idea to some of you???
All of Wilson’s assertions were refuted by subsequent commenters, and his invocation of smoking is a favorite denialist technique known as the “science was wrong before” gambit (the implication being that the crank is right). Did getting thoroughly slapped down by multiple commenters stop him? Au contraire:
I could spend all day refuting the claims and assertions here, not to mention the personal attacks which wouldn’t be necessary at all, would it, if the facts were unequivocally in support of your position?
Say what you will, the science here is just not conclusive on either side. Even the head of the American Academy of Pediatrics has agreed with that.
Yes, HCN listed a bunch of studies, most of which have been seriously questioned by others. And lest anybody think all the science is one sided, those visiting here with an open mind may wish to visit here:
http://generationrescue.org/studies.html
And please don’t waste more bandwidth arguing the weaknesses you see in those studies. As I already conceded, the science is not conclusive on either side–and I’m not the first, nor last, to mention the emperor without his clothes here. (I thought I’d try to work in a little sex just to spice up all this ranting from those who are taking themselves entirely too seriously.)
In other words, Mr. Wilson doesn’t want to be bothered with any inconvenient facts that get in the way of the story he wants to tell; so he instead relies on the logical fallacy known as argumentum ad ignorantiam. (Also, the science is pretty darned conclusive.) It’s also necessary to point out that Generation Rescue is hardly a reliable source for information about vaccines–or anything else for that matter. Remember, it’s the group that ran the highly deceptive advertisement in USA Today a few months ago to peddle toxic myths about vaccines.
When all else fails, Mr. Wilson changes the topic and equates two unrelated stories to make it seem as though questioning him is equivalent to agreeing with a bone-headed statement from a politician and then, like Brave Sir Robin, bravely runs away:
Now I’ve got to go help Phil Gramm spread the word to people losing their jobs, their homes, and their retirement savings that they’re just experiencing a mental recession. Like any suspicions about mercury in vaccines, all economic conditions some people are whining about are just in their heads! Some of you posters here with too much time on your hands need to shift over and share your genius with THOSE “maroons” who obviously just need your guidance to see The Truth.
With all due respect, I’m leaving you folks to continue to just talk amongst yourselves now.
I submit to Mr. Sliva that it is hardly professional behavior for a journalist to dismiss criticism this way, and it shows me that not bothering with Wilson was the correct thing to do. Moreover, Mr. Wilson demonstrated himself to be utterly unable to use evidence to defend a single one of his assertions. I have to wonder if he’s become so convinced of his rightness through his other work championing the “little guy” that he just automatically dismisses even valid criticisms of his reports as being just because his targets don’t like his reporting or because of ideology. He doesn’t seem capable of even considering the concept that the “little guy” isn’t always correct. When it comes to the anti-vaccination movement, that is surely true, and Wilson’s inability to dig up sources more reliable than Generation Rescue to defend himself from criticism shows it.
Investigative journalism is very important in a democracy for uncovering wrongdoing and malfeasance. However, in the hands of reporters with an agenda and no understanding of how science works, it can do enormous harm. Indeed, that’s what happened in the U.K., where measles, once conquered, has now become endemic again because of low vaccination rates in the wake of credulous reporting of Andrew Wakefield’s shoddy study linking the MMR vaccine to autism. Meanwhile, here in the U.S. we seem to be on the same trajectory, just a few years behind.
And, although there is plenty of blame to go around, irresponsible reporters like Steve Wilson deserve a significant share of the blame for doing “investigative reports” that are in reality nothing more than thinly disguised anti-vaccine propaganda.

   Steven Higgs: Another antivaccine reporter like Dan Olmsted in the making?
David Gorski
Link
April is National Autism Awareness Month, and as of today April is nearly half over. Do you notice anything different compared to the last couple of years? I do. Can you guess what it is?
The anti-vaccine movement’s usual suspects haven’t been all over the mainstream media, as they usually are this time every year, often as early as April 1 or even March 31. In fact, over the last couple of years I had come to dread April 1, not because it’s April Fools’ Day (although the things that made me dread that particular day were often indistinguishable from an April Fools’ Day prank, so full of idiocy were they), but rather the expected carpet bombing of the media by the likes of Jenny McCarthy, J. B. Handley, and their ilk, some or all of whom would show up on various talk shows to spread their propaganda that vaccines cause autism. For instance, last year Jenny McCarthy and her former boyfriend Jim Carrey showed up on Larry King Live! with Dr. Jerry Kartzinel (her co-author on her latest book of autism quackery) and J. B. Handley, the last of whom even contributed a guest post on Larry King’s blog, in which he touted an incredibly bad, pseudoscientific “study” commissioned by Generation Rescue. The “study” (and calling it a “study” is way too generous) was no more than cherry-picked random bits of data twisted together into a pretzel of nonsense, as I described. Around the same time, Jenny McCarthy was interviewed by TIME Magazine, an interview in which she uttered these infamous words:
I do believe sadly it’s going to take some diseases coming back to realize that we need to change and develop vaccines that are safe. If the vaccine companies are not listening to us, it’s their fucking fault that the diseases are coming back. They’re making a product that’s shit. If you give us a safe vaccine, we’ll use it. It shouldn’t be polio versus autism.
Soon after, Generation Rescue created a website called Fourteen Studies, which they promoted hither, thither, and yon. The idea of the website was to attack the main studies that failed to find a link between vaccines and autism and to promote the pseudoscientific studies that anti-vaccinationists like. In 2008, it was pretty much the same — well, worse, even. When she appeared on Larry King Live! with our old “friend,” anti-vaccine pediatrician to the stars, Dr. Jay Gordon, McCarthy shouted down real experts by yelling, “Bullshit!” (behavior trumpeted by Rachel Sklar of the Huffington Post).
This year? Oddly enough (and to me unexpectedly), there’s been almost nothing. J.B. Handley seems to be the man who wasn’t there. Well, not quite. It turns out that J. B. Handley has managed to get a little bit of fawning media attention, but just a little bit, in the form of an interview in The Bloomington Alternative entitled J. B. Handley: It’s unequivocal; vaccines hurt some kids. Apparently Mr. Handley has come down quite a bit in the world. Where’s his appearance with Jenny on Larry King Live! this year? Maybe it’s coming in the second half of the month. Or maybe the mainstream media, in the wake of the fall of Andrew Wakefield, have finally figured out how disreputable Generation Rescue is when it comes to vaccines. In the meantime Steven Higgs will have to do as a new mouthpiece for the anti-vaccine movement.
J.B. Handley: Anti-vaccine warrior that Steven Higgs loves
Regular readers of this blog will be able to spot the misinformation and anti-vaccine propaganda spewed by J.B. Handley in this article. There’s no doubt that Mr. Higgs is very impressed by J.B. from the very beginning of his article, which contains these characterizations of Mr. Handley:
    • It’s not like Handley doesn’t understand the vitriol regularly aimed at him by what he routinely calls “the other side.” He is a pointed, straight-talking pain in their asses.
    • McCarthy’s presence, Handley said, allows him to “hang out in the cheap seats and opine and write my own stuff and challenge people.” And in that regard, his style doesn’t earn him any props with the vaccines-are-sacrosanct crowd — the AAP, the pharmaceutical companies, and the government officials and researchers they financially support. He’s described their positions as “atomic stupidity” in articles he has written. Moron is a term he uses often, in print and in conversation.
    • Even over the telephone from two-thirds of a continent away, J.B. Handley exudes a large personality and supreme confidence in his experiences and conclusions about his son’s autism.
“Atomic stupidity” describes a lot of what Mr. Handley says on a routine basis when it comes to vaccines and autism, although those of us who’ve butted heads with him in the past tend to refer to it as “burning stupid.” My sarcasm and intense dislike for Mr. Handley aside, given that most of the article consists of typical, run-of-the-mill Generation Rescue anti-vaccine nonsense that I and several of my co-bloggers have refuted time and time again, Mr. Higgs’ little opus might hardly have been worth my notice, much less blogging about, were it not for this passage, in which Higgs swallows whole J.B. Handley’s premature gloating about a post that Steve Novella wrote for SBM in February:
“Dr. Novella’s piece details a recent study published in the Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry titled ‘A Prospective Study of the Emergence of Early Behavioral Signs of Autism’ that tried to figure out when signs of autism first emerge in babies,” Handley wrote. “Ironically, the study Novella references is quite supportive of the theory that autism is caused by the environment and most notably vaccines.”
The March 2010 study compared two groups of children, one at high risk for autism and one at low risk, and noted the onset of symptoms in children who developed autism. It found no difference in the frequency of visual contact, shared smiles and vocalizations at 6 months. The differences, however, “were significant by 12 months of age on most variables.”
In a blog post on the Web site Science-Based Medicine, Novella wrote, “What these results indicate is that clear signs of autism emerge between 6 and 12 months of age.”
Novella concluded that the study disproved a link between autism and vaccines. “Many children are diagnosed between the age of 2 and 3, during the height of the childhood vaccine schedule. This lends itself to the assumption of correlation and causation on the part of some parents.”
In an addendum to the blog, Novella acknowledged that he erred when he wrote that line, but he insisted, “Many parents blame their children’s autism on vaccines they received after the true onset of symptoms.”
While Handley didn’t comment on the addendum in his Age of Autism counterpost, he said the original line made him “shout and laugh at the same time.” Children have received 19 shots by 6 months — 52 percent of the total vaccination schedule — when the study says early symptoms of autism begin to appear.
Of course, Mr. Handley didn’t comment on (nor did Higgs link to) Steve’s followup post in his Age of Autism post, because Steve showed very clearly that Handley was, as usual, so wrong that he wasn’t even wrong. In essence, J.B. thought he had found a “gotcha” moment and that one erroneous statement that Steve made in his post was in fact an admission by mistake that the anti-vaccine movement is correct to point out a correlation between the peak ages of autistic regression and the height of the vaccine schedule. Steve admitted his error and then went on to describe clearly why his mistake was not evidence in favor of Mr. Handley’s position.
What was particularly interesting about Mr. Handley’s response was how much it showed that Mr. Handley has been changing his story and shifting the goalposts over the years. In particular, I noticed this paragraph in which J.B. stated:
More importantly, autism is not an event, it’s a process. It is exceptionally rare that I hear the story, “my son was 100% fine, and at 2 years old after one vaccine appointment he lost everything.” I have heard that story, but very rarely.
If Mr. Higgs had dug a little deeper, he might have realized that that’s exactly the sort of story I see time and time again presented by anti-vaccine believers, J.B. included, as “evidence” that vaccines cause autism.” Is this the same J.B. Handley who has touted at least since 2005 how common stories of children declining right after vaccines are? Let’s see, a couple of years ago he complained to the AAP:
Ms. Martin, let me give you a little insight into my world. If I wanted to find parents who had autistic children and who believed their child’s autism was impacted by vaccines, I wouldn’t need to email the nation’s pediatricians hoping I might find one or two. I could just open my window and yell, because these parents are everywhere in my neighborhood and town! Worse, our numbers continue to grow.
You see, not a day goes by without Generation Rescue receiving an email from a new parent who watched their child decline following a vaccination appointment with their pediatrician. While you search for the handful of parents with autistic children who may support immunizations, we can’t respond to emails fast enough from the thousands we hear from who feel vaccines contributed to their child’s autism.
“Not a day goes by …”? To me that sounded very much as though Handley was arguing that regression after vaccination is very common. Let’s look a bit more, say, from a post J.B. wrote before going on Larry King Live! last April:
Finally, we have tens of thousands of case reports of parents reporting that their child developmentally regressed, stopped talking, and was later diagnosed with autism after a vaccine appointment. The number of vaccines have risen along with autism rates, vaccines are known to cause brain damage, and parents report regression and later autism after getting them. Is it really so hard to believe we think vaccines are a trigger?
Wow. Tens of thousands of case reports! It appears to me that in his response to Steve there was more than a little bit of goalpost shifting. After all, the “stereotypical” (or “prototypical”) story of the anti-vaccine movement is of the child between the ages of 1 and 3 who is brought to the pediatrician, receives vaccines. Shortly thereafter, or so the anecdote goes, the child loses language and social skills and develops regressive autism. Never mind that, given the number of children who are vaccinated every year and the number of children who develop regressive autism, there are bound to be overlaps such that by random chance alone there will be many children who regress in reasonably close temporal proximity to vaccination. Never mind that no one has ever shown that this regression occurs more frequently in vaccinated children. Anecdotes like the ones J.B. was touting up until (apparently) now are the very “evidence” that the anti-vaccine movement uses to blame vaccination for autism. And, in all fairness, in a single child not studied in the context of populations, such an event can look all the world as though the vaccine caused the regression even when it did not. Even so, the point is that parents who believe vaccines caused their children’s autism don’t blame a process. They blame vaccines, often specific vaccines like the MMR.
In response to this article, I wrote Mr. Higgs an e-mail. I’ll admit that my tone was a bit peeved. However, it does bother me whenever a journalist give credence to the words of a man who, in addition to having a six or seven year history of spreading pseudoscience fueled by his unrelenting hostility towards vaccines, quite recently publicly gloated that he and his anti-vaccine movement were “early to middle stages of bringing the U.S. vaccine program to its knees.” My e-mail ultimately led to a three-way e-mail exchange between Mr. Higgs, Steve, and myself, and this led me to the definite conclusion that we have a budding Dan Olmsted on our hands.
Who is Dan Olmsted and why doesn’t any legitimate reporter want to be like him? Olmsted is currently the editor of Generation Rescue‘s anti-vaccine propaganda blog Age of Autism. What people who haven’t been following this issue a long time is that Olmsted used to be an investigative reporter and senior editor for United Press International (UPI). Between January 2005 and July 2007, he wrote a series of “investigative” reports in a series that he called Age of Autism (his first installment predating the Age of Autism blog by nearly three years). In the series, he totally bought into vaccine-autism pseudoscience and presented the conspiracy theory through a combination of the same logical fallacies and bad science that undergirds the anti-vaccine movement, including confusing correlation with causation to blame thimerosal in vaccines or vaccines themselves for autism.
Olmsted’s most infamous gaffe was to be, as far as I can tell, the man who originated the myth that the Amish don’t vaccinate and that as a consequence they don’t get autism, a fallacy that Olmsted first reported in a two-part story entitled The Amish Anomaly (Part 2 here) and revisited time and time again. Of course, the Amish do vaccinate, and there are autistic Amish. In fact, Olmsted even missed a clinic in the heart of Amish country that treats autistic Amish children. Unfortunately, facts didn’t stand in the way of a good myth, which has only grown in the five years since Olmsted first imagined it.
Ultimately, Dan Olmsted left UPI (whether he resigned or was fired, only he and UPI know) and is now the editor of the anti-vaccine crank blog Age of Autism, where he can “report” to his heart’s content, free of any pesky concerns about editors insisting on actual facts and science. Steven Higgs looks as though he’s ready to join him.
An anti-vaccine reporter
Unfortunately, when it comes to autism and vaccines, it’s not that uncommon for reporters to fall for the myth. The reasons aren’t hard to understand. If there’s one way for a reporter to establish a name for himself, it’s to uncover a big story, the bigger the better. One category of story that is particularly seductive is the huge health scare, particularly if it’s something seemingly benign that is causing it.
Something like vaccines.
Higgs certainly isn’t the first. After all, David Kirby was seduced by the idea that mercury in the thimerosal preservative that used to be in vaccines was the cause of autism. After he published Evidence of Harm: Mercury in Vaccines and the Autism Epidemic: A Medical Controversy in 2004, whatever remained of his journalistic career went into the crapper, leaving him to blog for The Huffington Post and, of course, Age of Autism. Then there’s a local connection, Steve Wilson, who up until recently was an investigative reporter for a local television station here in Detroit and who also bought into the myth that mercury in vaccines causes autism, a report that I duly criticized him for, even though I did it with some trepidation. My cancer center has a good relationship with the TV station that Wilson used to work for, and I was concerned that I would catch some flak for criticizing his report, which was nothing more than a rehash of the standard anti-vaccine mercury fear mongering. The sad thing is that Wilson did some absolutely outstanding work uncovering the malfeasance of our former mayor Kwame Kilpatrick. Unfortunately, his skepticism when it came to vaccines was in reality a pseudoskepticism, showing that even good investigative reporters can be crappy science and medical reporters.
Whether Higgs has any redeeming qualities in terms of investigative reporting skills, I don’t know. What I do know is that he has thoroughly drunk the Kool Aid, as demonstrated in spades in a story he published a month ago entitled Do Vaccines Cause Autism? In it, he tries to refute a contention by Dr. Phil Landrigan in a recent paper in which Dr. Landrigan stated bluntly (and correctly): “There is no credible evidence that vaccines cause autism.” In the article, Higgs repeated a number of common anti-vaccine tropes, tropes so common that I don’t feel obligated to answer them all, given that virtually all of them have been discussed before right here on this very blog. Some of them are talking points straight from Generation Rescue. For example:
Higgs confuses correlation with causation when it comes to thimerosal. Unfortunately, there is a lot of evidence showing no correlation between thimerosal-containing vaccines and autism. The idea that thimerosal in vaccines cause autism is a failed hypothesis. It’s been tested scientifically and failed.
Higgs buys the Generation Rescue line that nations with higher vaccination rates have higher autism rates and that vaccination does not correlate with lower childhood mortality. This is about as bogus a study as I can imagine, incompetently performed using cherry-picked data and not even peer-reviewed.
Higgs cherry picks conclusions from a study of thimerosal-containing vaccines and neurodevelopmental disorders other than autism. That particular study produced results that were entirely consistent with random chance correlations from multiple comparisons. Indeed, if Higgs takes the negative correlations seriously, one wonders why he didn’t mention the positive correlations, where children receiving thimerosal-containing vaccines actually had better measurements of neurodevelopmental outcomes. In essence, Higgs cherry picks the bad results and ignores the good results when a careful reading of the study shows that, overall, the effects were consistent with random chance.
I could go on, citing more articles by Mr. Higgs and more refutations of the anti-vaccine talking points that he parrots, but I think you get the idea. If you don’t, I’ll cite Mr. Higgs’ own words:
I’ve spent most of the past 28 years journalistically investigating conflicts between environmental victims and experts in the relevant fields. And, I can say without qualification, the victims have been right and the experts wrong in every significant story I’ve covered. I can’t think of a single exception.
And with respect to vaccines and autism, I say again, without reservation, parents like J.B. Handley and grandparents like Dan Burton are right about vaccines and autism. The experts are wrong, and their behaviors — their vitriolic attacks upon those who disagree, their underhanded political tactics — suggest they know they were wrong.
Although Mr. Higgs denied this interpretation in his e-mails, both Steve and I interpreted this as an accusation of lying. Like Mr. Handley, Mr. Higgs seems incapable of considering the possibility that we have looked at the evidence and honestly come to a different conclusion. I don’t even think he realizes he is doing it, because he seemed surprised when we pointed out that this passage appears to be accusing us and every scientist who point out that science doesn’t support the idea that vaccines cause autism of not just being mistaken but dishonest. As for “vitriol,” I had to wonder if Mr. Higgs had actually seen some of J.B.’s antics, such as his misogynistic attacks on Amy Wallace, his attacks on Steve Novella, and, of course, me. Although J.B. was apparently not responsible for it, the most infamous of all was Generation Rescue’s portrayal on its propaganda blog Age of Autism of Steve Novella and Paul Offit, along with journalists Amy Wallace and Trine Tsouderos (both of whom had written exposes of the antivaccine movement in 2009) as baby-eating cannibals sitting down to a Thanksgiving feast of baby, an image so vile that it disgusted a fair number of Age of Autism’s regular readers and the criticism led to the image and post being thrown down the memory hole.
When it comes to vitriol, as “insolent” as I can be at times, Steve and I remain rank amateurs compared to the anti-vaccine movement, in particular J. B. Handley and his merry band of antivaccine propagandists at Age of Autism.
A closed mind
In my correspondence with Mr. Higgs, to which Steve Novella contributed, I came to the distinct impression that Mr. Higgs had come to view himself as a crusader and, based on his experience, has simplified environmental issues to viewing that experts are always wrong. His experience with previous environmental catastrophes and the reactions of companies responsible for them have led him to the point where he cannot imagine even the possibility that the claim that thimerosal in vaccines causes autism can possibly be wrong or that the experts who point out that science doesn’t support such a link might actually be correct this time. That’s how anti-expert and anti-intellectual Mr. Higgs has he become. Indeed, Steve Novella even called Higgs out on his anti-intellectualism, and, incredibly, Higgs’ response was that had lived in a college town for many years around intellectuals and therefore couldn’t possibly be anti-science or anti-intellectual.
But he is. His writings leave no doubt of that.
As a final example, I will mention two things Higgs cited. First, he cited this video as “the most persuasive evidence I have found thus far,” the one moment in time when he came to believe that vaccine cause autism:
Watch CBS News Videos Online
Yes, that’s Bernadine Healy, former director of the NIH, and Mr. Higgs is quite enamored with her. Unfortunately, in recent years, she’s been flirting with the anti-vaccine movement, blaming the American Academy of Pediatrics, the CDC, and other health organizations and “just asking questions” about whether there is a connection between vaccines and autism. She’s also been promoting the idea of a “vaccinated versus unvaccinated” study, apparently not realizing the inherent difficulties involved in such a study. In essence, Dr. Healy, despite her previous position as NIH director (a position she was arguably unqualified for), is not an authority on vaccines. In fact, if you want an idea of how far down the rabbit hole of anti-vaccine lunacy Dr. Healy’s gone, consider that she was named as Age of Autism’s Person of the Year for 2008. If there’s one virtually completely reliable indication that a scientist or physician is well on the way to becoming an antivaccine crank (or has already become one), it’s being named Person of the Year by Age of Autism. It’s like the Nobel Prize, Oscars, Pulitzer Prizes, and Congressional Medal of Freedom for antivaccine crankery and autism quackery all rolled into one.
Finally, Mr. Higgs cited an article entitled Educating the Ohio Valley’s special kids. The interesting thing is that nothing in this article mentions vaccines as a cause of autism. Rather, the entire focus of the article appears to be on mercury and industrial pollution, the argument being that it is that that is correlated with the steadily increasing special education rolls in Evansville, IN. However, in his penultimate e-mail to me, Higgs cited this article and the leveling off of special ed enrollment in 2007 and 2008 as potential evidence for the thimerosal hypothesis, given that thimerosal was removed from most childhood vaccines by early 2002 and a 3 to 5 year delay would be expected after that happened before autism diagnoses would fall if thimerosal-containing vaccines were etiologically linked with autism. In his e-mail, Higgs asked, “I understand that two years does not constitute a long-term trend, but what other constant do you think every child in Indiana may have experienced in 2002 and 2003, other than vaccines?” Of course, as has been found in several studies in multiple locations and countries, there has been no convincing evidence of a leveling off or decrease in autism diagnoses five years after thimerosal was removed from vaccines in various countries, and there has been no convincing evidence of a leveling off or decrease in autism in California. The idea that thimerosal in vaccines causes autism led to a testable hypothesis. Every time this hypothesis has been tested, it has failed.
Curious about Mr. Higgs’ graph, I decided to look at the numbers anyway. In this task I was assisted by some blog buddies of mine, including Liz Ditz, who pointed out that a large number of factors could account for such an increase in special ed numbers and a leveling off in 2007, including the starting of campaigns to identify learning disabilities and their eventual leveling off and the effect of funding incentives on special ed enrollment. Multiple people pointed out to me that this leveling off of special ed cases appears to be occurring among all age cohorts. If thimerosal had anything to do with a leveling off in special ed case loads, it should have a far more profound effect in the youngest groups. It didn’t.
Meanwhile, Joseph was kind enough to provide me with a spreadsheet based on actual data, with special education counts for Indiana coming from here and whole-population enrollment counts coming from the National Center for Education Statistics here. He produced for me four graphs.
The first graph shows all disabilities for children aged 6 to 21:
Not much of a change over the period covered, is there? Next, we have a graph of all disabilities in the age group that would be most likely to be affected; that is, if thimerosal had anything to do with developmental disabilities requiring special ed:
Then we have a the same graph for the age group between ages 12 and 17.
Note how it looks very similar to the graph for ages 3-5. If thimerosal had anything to do with diagnoses leading to enrollment in special ed programs, you would expect to see a huge difference between the 3-5 year age cohort and the teenage cohort.
Finally, let’s look at the graph for diagnoses of autism at age 6:
Nope. No sign of a decrease in autism diagnoses in 2006 or later, which is what would be expected if thimerosal, which was removed from most childhood vaccines in late 2001, were a major etiological factor in autism. We can conclude from these graphs that Mr. Higgs is either very naive when it comes to data analysis or he saw what he wanted to see and stopped looking. His rush to judgment also belies one of his claims in his e-mails, namely that the science and epidemiology aren’t that hard to understand or do. That is, of course, just plain wrong. They are hard to understand and even harder to do. If they weren’t, then anyone could do them. Unintentionally, Mr. Higgs demonstrated himself that something that looks simple is not, and his looking at it simply led him to make an obvious rookie mistake that led him to the wrong conclusion.
Another Dan Olmsted?
Although admittedly I started out trying to address Mr. Higgs with a bit more “insolence” than might have been advisable, I had a hard time restraining myself, given his swallowing of everything that J. B. Handley lays down and his falling for everything Handley says about Dr. Novella. In any case, I tried to be less “insolent” as the correspondence continued. It nonetheless became clear in our correspondence that Mr. Higgs is a true believer, who really does think that Andrew Wakefield has been unjustly abused by the medical establishement and, amazingly, that J. B. Handley knows what he is talking about. I tried to plant a seed by providing him with a number of links, both from SBM and elsewhere, that refuted key points of the anti-vaccine movement. He said point blank that he wasn’t going to read them, at least at first. Also, in his responses he pointedly called me “Mr.” Gorski, even though after the first e-mail he clearly must have known I am a physician, an intentional bit of disrespect that amuses me far more than offends me, given how often I’ve seen anti-vaccine advocates and alt-med practitioners use it against me. In that, if anything, Mr. Higgs appears less polite than the journalist whose path he seems to be following, Dan Olmsted, or maybe David Kirby, given his fawning three part series interviewing Kirby.
But why?
In Mr. Higgs’ case, I rather suspect that it is really a case of being a true believer. According to him, every environmental health threat he’s seen was accompanied by industry denials and coverups. That may well be true. However, that history has apparently led Mr. Higgs to be so distrustful of what the government and medical authorities say, so suspicious of what “experts” say, that he can’t even consider the possibility that, in the case of vaccines, the experts are actually correct. There is no link between vaccines and autism that science has been able to detect. As passionate as Mr. Higgs may be about environmental pollution, he is, quite simply, on the wrong side of this particular issue and well on the way to becoming another Dan Olmsted supporting the quackery that is DAN!.
Indiana deserves better.
ADDENDUM: Steve Novella has also blogged about this, and he has shown that I might be wrong. It’s not Dan Olmsted whom Mr. Higgs is emulating. It’s Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.

   Mothering magazine: Peddling dangerous health misinformation to new mothers
David Gorski
Link
Last week, the British Medical Journal (BMJ) published an expose by investigative journalist Brian Deer that enumerated in detail the specifics of how a British gastroenterologist turned hero of the anti-vaccine movement had committed scientific fraud by falsifying key aspects of case reports that he used as the basis of his now infamous 1998 Lancet article suggesting a link between the MMR vaccine and a syndrome consisting of regressive autism and enterocolitis. Indeed, Deer even went so far as to describe Wakefield’s fraud as “Piltdown medicine,” comparing it explicitly to the infamous “Piltdown man” hoax, and in an accompanying editorial the editors of the BMJ agreed. These revelations were not by any means new. Scientists had suspected that something wasn’t quite right about Wakefield’s work almost as soon as it had been published, and by 2004 Brian Deer had uncovered clear evidence of major undisclosed conflicts of interest on Wakefield’s part. Unfortunately, by that time the proverbial cat was out of the proverbial bag, and Wakefield’s fraudulent research, aided and abetted by his flair for self-promotion in the media and some truly execrable, credulous, and sensationalistic coverage by the British press, had ignited a major scare over the MMR vaccine. MMR uptake rates plummeted below levels necessary for herd immunity, and measles came roaring back with a vengeance in the U.K. By the time the British General Medical Council finally ruled about a year ago that Wakefield had committed research fraud and violated research ethics in the work reported in his 1998 Lancet article and recommended that he be “struck off” (i.e., have his license to practice medicine in the U.K. revoked), the damage had been done.
As important as Wakefield is to the genesis of the modern anti-vaccine movement, however, there is another force that acts far more “where the rubber hits the road,” so to speak. This force comes in the form of publications and online discussion forums that cater to new mothers, offering all manner of advice and support. Some of these are very good, but all too many of them are hotbeds of anti-vaccine pseudoscience, confidently proclaimed by “elder statesman” members of these forums and included in articles published in glossy, attractive magazines. As a rather ironic coincidence, just as news of Andrew Wakefield’s latest humiliation was finding its way out into multiple news outlets last week, the first issue of 2011 of just such a glossy publication hit the shelves. I’m referring to Mothering, whose tagline is “Inspiring Natural Families Since 1976.” In reality, it should read: “Inspiring quackery and anti-vaccine views since 1976.” Of course, in the world of “alt-med,” the two often go hand-in-hand. In any case, one of our readers sent me a link to the latest issue of Mothering. Unfortunately, I can’t supply you with that link, because it’s for subscribers. I will, however, describe and quote articles and passages that demonstrate just what a wretched hive of scum and quackery Mothering is, particularly with respect to vaccines but not limited to vaccines. Taking into account its large and vigorous online forums, Mothering is major force for the promotion of anti-vaccine views and quackery among new mothers.
Mothering says: Don’t worry, be happy about pertussis
The cover of the January/February 2011 issue of Mothering asks, Whooping Cough: Is Your Family At Risk? Should You Vaccinate?, complete with the mandatory cute photo of a cherubic infant to drive home the point of how important these questions are. Now, it’s very tempting for me to cite the science-based answers and emphasize that the answers are yes and YES!, but, as you might imagine, that’s not exactly what Mothering advocates. Far from it.
The article is by a physician named Lauren Feder, MD and entitled “Straight Talk on the 100 Day Cough: What are the Symptoms of Pertussis? Who’s at Risk? And Is the Vaccine Right for Your Family?” Again, the answers to the last two questions should be “Everybody, particularly the unvaccinated” and “Yes, unless your child has a medical contraindication to being vaccinated.” But that’s not what Dr. Feder says. In fact, her article is a mix of science and pseudoscience, which is not surprising because it turns out that Dr. Feder is a homeopath:
Lauren Feder, MD, specializes in homeopathy, pediatrics, and primary-care medicine. Known for her holistically minded approach, Dr. Feder is a frequent lecturer to parents and professionals. She is the author of Natural Baby and Childcare and The Parents’ Concise Guide to Childhood Vaccinations. Her website is www.drfeder.com.
One can’t help but notice how Dr. Feder says she specializes in “homeopathy” and then “pediatrics,” not the other way around, implying that she views herself as a homeopath first and pediatrician second. Perusing her website, I found that the Mothering article appeared to be very similar to this article on Dr. Feder’s website. In it, after the disclaimer urging parents who suspect their child has whooping cough to take the child to a physician because whooping cough can be life-threatening. Then she recommends various homeopathic remedies for whooping cough. I kid you not. Here are a couple of examples:
Drosera for violent coughing spells ending in choking, gagging, or vomiting. Sometimes these coughs are so strong that the child can hardly catch her breath. Drosera is indicated for barking coughs, whooping cough, croup, and coughs that are worse after midnight, commonly accompanied by a bloody nose and a hoarse voice.
Spongia tosta for dry coughs that sound like a saw going through wood; often used for croup. Useful for croupy coughs that are worse before midnight, accompanied by a dry, barking cough that can sound like a seal.
The text for this section is very similar both on Dr. Feder’s website and in her Mothering article. Added to the sidebar of her Mothering article, Dr. Feder proclaims in addition, “Holistic medicine and homeopathy may shorten the course and severity of the illness.” There is, of course, no evidence presented (probably because there is no good scientific evidence to support such an assertion) that homeopathy can shorten the course of pertussis (or the course of any disease, for that matter), and to suggest as much is irresponsible in the extreme. Homeopathy is, after all, water. In the meantime, Dr. Feder makes exaggerated assertions about the whole cell pertussis vaccine that has largely been replaced by the acellular pertussis because of concerns that it caused a lot of neurological complications. Early reports in the 1980s suggested a high rate of neurological complications due to the whole cell pertussis vaccine, but more recent studies, as described by Steve Novella last year and by Paul Offit in his recently released book Deadly Choices: How the Anti-vaccine Movement Threatens Us All, have failed to confirm a link between seizures, neurological damage, and the whole cell pertussis vaccine. Perhaps the most telling aspect of Dr. Feder’s article is that nowhere does she state that all children without a medical contraindication to being vaccinated should be vaccinated against pertussis. Rather, she plays the game of saying “if you choose to vaccinate,” and then recommending this program of woo around the times of vaccinations:
In an attempt to use a more natural preventive approach, I prefer a different course of action. With any vaccination, I recommend administering the following vitamin and herbal remedy seven days before and after the shot, to generally strengthen the body. They may also help reduce any side effects of the vaccine.
Remember, your child should not receive a vaccination if she is cranky or ill. At our office, we prefer that, when possible, people take only one vaccine at a time. Contact your practitioner if unusual symptoms occur following the shot. You can use this protocol in conjunction with any other medications you give your child.
Each day, for seven days before and after the shot, give your child the following:
Briar Rose This gemmotherapy herb is a general immune strengthener.
Vitamin C Less than two years old, 100 milligrams, twice daily; two years and older, 250 mg twice daily.
She also recommends five homeopathic remedies be given before and after the shots, depending upon which remedy. Hilariously, she recommends giving three pellets of homeopathic DTaP 30C once a week for three weeks, beginning the day of the vaccination. She recommends the same thing for the Hib vaccine, homeopathic Hib given the same way. One wonders why Dr. Feder would even acquiesce to giving the vaccine if homeopathy is so great.
It occurs to me that, if Dr. Feder really believes in giving only one vaccine at a time and that parents should engage in all this woo before each vaccine, it would be a wonder if any parent manages to get through the entire vaccination schedule anywhere near on time in Dr. Feder’s practice. Maybe that’s the point. Also, such a regimen would require a whole lot of visits to the pediatrician, way more than the current vaccine schedule does, not to mention the purchase of a whole lot of homeopathic remedies to be given before and after the vaccines. Maybe that’s the point, too. Be that as it may, perhaps the most disturbing part of Dr. Feder’s article is how, after actually conceding that pertussis is dangerous and can even kill, she then tries to downplay the danger of pertussis by citing her own anecdotal experience, much as our “old friend” Dr. Jay Gordon likes to do:
Thus far, the worst case of pertussis I’ve seen was in an eight-month-old girl who was hospitalized for a few days despite having had two DTaP shots. Following the hospitalization, the patient and her family came to my office for homeopathic treatment to expedite her healing. Now she is fine.
Note the implications. First is the implication that, because this child got two DTaP doses and still caught pertussis, the vaccine doesn’t work. Next, the implication is that homeopathy works. Testimonials aren’t just for cancer, apparently. After all, this child was treated with standard of care in a hospital for a severe case of pertussis. Her parents also gave her homeopathic remedies prescribed by Dr. Feder. Obviously, it must have been the homeopathy that cured her, or at least completed her healing! Worse, Dr. Feder appears to be implying, “Don’t worry so much about pertussis. I’ve never seen a child die of it; so it must not be so bad, and homeopathy can take care of it anyway. So you don’t really need those nasty vaccines.”
Unfortunately, Dr. Feder’s article is not all that this issue of Mothering has in store for mothers. First, Dr. Feder’s article contains a link to an article by anti-vaccine-sympathetic pediatrician Dr. Jay Gordon, who has been featured on more than one occasion right here on SBM for speaking at Jenny McCarthy’s anti-vaccine rally, downplaying the severity of pertussis and launching ad hominems at Dr. Paul Offit, arguing that vaccination against H1N1 is not necessary and the flu isn’t so bad, becoming indignant at arguments that parents who refuse to vaccinate shouldn’t be held legally liable if their child infects another, and for arguing on The Doctors that vaccines cause autism. It’s not for nothing that both Steve Novella and I have concluded that Dr. Gordon, if not anti-vaccine, is at the very least an apologist for the anti-vaccine movement. His article for Mothering, entitled “Behind the Scenes with Dr. Jay,” is in the same vein as much of his other parroting of anti-vaccine views. Indeed, he makes nonsensical claims such as, “If vaccines work—and I believe they do—then vaccinated children are not endangered by unvaccinated children.” Apparently Dr. Jay has forgotten that no vaccine is 100% effective and that highly contagious diseases, such as the measles, can infect a subset of vaccinated children who didn’t respond to the vaccine sufficiently to achieve immunity. He then devolves into his usual pharma conspiracy mongering, replete with evidence- and data-free assertions such as this:
The pharmaceutical industry has not earned my trust. They have promoted ineffective drugs and other medicines that they knew had dangerous side effects. They have paid many physicians to ghost-write “in-house” research, and then to speak and write about the benefits of these same medications. Even if I believed that vaccines were the greatest invention in medical care—and I do not—I would still argue that the way they’re manufactured and given to children is not anywhere near as safe as it could be.
Evidence that the way vaccines are manufactured and given to children is not anywhere near as safe as it could be? None is presented by Dr. Jay. As I’ve said before, Dr. Jay clearly holds many anti-vaccine views, as defined thusly.
Also featured in the Jan./Feb. 2011 issue of Mothering is an article by — holy crap! — Barbara Loe Fisher, the Founder and President of the anti-vaccine group the National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC). Arguably, BLF is the grande dame of the current iteration of the anti-vaccine movement, having started her activism in the 1980s. In it, she regurgitates the same sorts of arguments that we’ve heard time and time again. In particular, she is upset that recent pertussis outbreaks have been linked to the unvaccinated, pointing out that rates of vaccination for pertussis are very high. That’s true when one looks at the overall population, but BLF neglects to note that there are pockets with high numbers of unvaccinated children that provide a nidus for outbreaks to occur because herd immunity has broken down, as Joe Albietz, Mark Crislip, and Steve Novella have discussed, while Dr. Albietz has discussed the complexities of the recent whooping cough epidemic in California. While it is not clear how much of the current outbreaks in California are due to low vaccine uptake rates versus other factors, it is clear that vaccination against pertussis is safe and effective, the attempts of Dr. Feder, Dr. Gordon, and BLF to paint it otherwise notwithstanding.
Mothering, HIV/AIDS, vaccines, and other quackery
Mothering magazine has been a hotbed of anti-vaccine rhetoric as long as I’ve been aware of it, which has been around six years now. Worse, as I pointed out earlier in a post from two years ago about the death of HIV/AIDS denialist Christine Maggiore of what appears all the world to look like a case of terminal AIDS, Mothering has supported HIV/AIDS denialism. Indeed, Maggiore was featured on the cover of an issue of Mothering several years ago when she was pregnant, her pregnant belly emblazoned with the word “AZT” in a circle with a slash through it. The issue featured Maggiore in an article entitled Safe and Sound Underground: HIV-Positive Women Birthing Outside the System. Other articles published in Mothering about AIDS include Molecular Miscarriage: Is the HIV Theory a Tragic Mistake?, AZT Roulette: The Impossible Choices Facing HIV-Positive Women, HIV and Breastfeeding: The Fear. The Misconceptions. The Facts. (of which only one out of three was correct, namely the fear), and AZT in Babies: Terrible Risk, Zero Benefit. So, in addition to irresponsible and non-science-based recommendations about vaccines, Mothering promotes irresponsible and non-science-based recommendations about HIV very similar to the misinformation that led Christine Maggiore and her daughter to their deaths. Hundreds of thousands of people in South Africa have died following this sort of advice.
Then there’s vaccination.
If you Google for information on vaccination safety, after science-based sites like the CDC and CHOP and non-science-based sites like the NVIC, it doesn’t take long to find one’s way to the Mothering.com forums on vaccination, particularly if you Google “vaccine safety discussion.” If you then head to the Mothering.com Vaccination Forum, right at the top, you’ll find two discussions, Selective & Delayed Vaccination and I’m Not Vaccinating. The rules for the forums are stated thusly:
For I’m Not Vaccinating:
Posting to this forum will not be restricted only to members who do not vaccinate. However, we will actively restrict conversations in favor of mandatory vaccination or other topics that would be inappropriate for the forum. This is not a place for debate or discussions on the merits of vaccines or the dangers of not vaccinating, it is also not a place to argue against vaccines or selective and delayed vaccination schedules. Such discussions are already hosted in the main Vaccinations forum and posts in that vein are most welcome and appropriate there.
For Selective & Delayed Vaccination:
This forum is not a place to argue against selective or delayed vaccination or debate vaccination in general. Such discussions are already hosted in the main Vaccinations forum and posts in that vein are most welcome and appropriate there. Our purpose for this forum is to provide information that is helpful for parents who have made the decision to vaccinate and are not seeking discussion against their decision but rather support and information to help them proceed in the best manner. Please respect this and post at all times with this in mind.
In other words, don’t intrude on the comfy, self-reinforcing, supportive vibe. But what about the main vaccination forums, where, supposedly, in contrast to these two forums, it’s OK to debate the merits of vaccinating versus not vaccinating? Well, it doesn’t sound so friendly to anyone who wants to have a science-based discussion of vaccination, as evidenced by this notice about updated guidelines for the vaccination forum:
MotheringDotCommune is a community forum geared toward parents interested in Natural Family Living. On the issues of vaccinations we believe in informed consent. This means we look at both sides of the vaccine issue. However, one of our objectives, and for which members and guests come to our forum, is to bring to light the information that is not mainstream and readily available.
Recently, we have seen several members join MDC who seem to have an agenda to promote vaccinations. Though Mothering does not take a pro or anti stand on vaccinations, we will not host threads on the merits of mandatory vaccine, or a purely pro vaccination view point as this is not conducive to the learning process.
We will be contacting several members to discuss their sincerity on MDC. In the meantime, we are asking our members not to quote from this notice or address members within a thread as this is strictly prohibited. Instead, contact a forum moderator or administrator if you are concerned about a post and we will take appropriate action if need be.
And, from the guidelines themselves:
We embrace all parents, regardless of their choice. We uphold the Vaccinations forum as a place where they can come and discuss all aspects of all vaccinations, and find support in their desire to make an informed decision to not vaccinate, to vaccinate, to selectively vaccinate, or to delay vaccinations.
[...]
We expect and insist that all members post here with an open mind and a willingness to learn — even from the new member. There should be an understanding that a large number of Mothering community members are against vaccinations so when you do come here to post to ask your questions, and you have an intention to vaccinate, members here will feel a need to inform you of the concerns about vaccinations. While no one should be labeled as irresponsible or uninformed for deciding to vaccinate, neither should parents here who have chosen to not vaccinate be accused of irresponsibility, not caring for their child, or presenting a threat to others.
Elsewhere in the guidelines, it is spelled out:
That said, we will not tolerate new members who come to this forum with a focused agenda.
That “focused agenda” being, apparently, supporting vaccines and countering pseudoscientific arguments against them, which will get you booted off the MotheringDOTCommunity (MDC) discussion boards really fast if you persist after being warned. We don’t want to harsh the buzz of all those crunchy moms clucking about how vaccines are “unnatural” and “unnecessary.” Particularly revealing is this thread entitled Problem with ‘The Purpose of this Forum.’ One mother even asked, “Why does Mothering.com have to be so PC by stating Vaccinations Forum is neither pro-vax or anti-vax in policy??” Another mother wondered if the reason the MDC forum moderators don’t want to own up to being “anti-vax” is due to liability concerns. If you want to get a flavor of the discussions on these boards, though, check out the reaction to Andrew Wakefield. For example, macha10 writes:
Here’s how this issue boils down for me. In the grand scheme of things, I don’t care if this Wakefield guy falsified data. I don’t care if the study was good. I don’t even care if vaccines contribute to autism or not. I STILL will not vaccinate my children, for plenty of other reasons. Autism is not my only reason. And I am so sick of the media and the so-called “experts” out there telling the public that we crazy non-vac parents don’t vaccinate only because of autism. And now that the study is false, we can all just vaccinate our kids again. And everything will be great. UGGGG.
In other words, don’t bother me with facts and science. In fact, if you want to get a flavor of the entire attitude of the MDC towards vaccines, you can’t do better than a conversation I monitored about five and a half years ago, specifically, this disturbing challenge about vaccines posted by someone using the ‘nym Jen123:
Mercury seems to be getting tons of coverage. When that deal is settled and we win, we need to go after another ingredient. We’ll dismantle the vaccine industry ingredient by stupid ingredient if we have to.
Who is with me?
Oh, no! It’s the toxins gambit coupled with mercury fear mongering! Although this was written in a semi-facetious tone, subsequent discussion demonstrated that this woman was serious. To her, it’s not just about mercury. It’s about vaccines. Here is a sampling of the depressing replies:
Actually I believe that the chickenpox vax does have fetal tissues in it.**
Eh, every time we win on one though, they’ll just throw another creepy ingredient in.
Yeah, what about aluminum? Formaldehyde is a carcinogenic. It boggles my mind that some people are ONLY worried about mercury when even without mercury they still contain carcinogenics and nuero/blood toxins (oh and antibiotics in some.) Yummy.
In another 50 years or so, they’ll make the connecting b/w vaxxes and alzheimers, soon teenagers will be getting it with all the aluminium they are being injected with. I really believe our life span is going to be decreasing — everyone will have some sort of cancer, and will be dieing at a younger age. But no one agrees with me irl
This is the sort of the sort of antivaccination rhetoric that “vaccine safety proponents” try to hide from view. These mothers claim they are not “anti-vaccination,” and probably most of them honestly believe that they aren’t. However, right beneath the surface of all their attacks on mercury, just out of sight to the casual observer, full-blown antivaccination paranoia and conspiracy theories lurk, and certainly their “anti-mercury” advocacy provides aid and comfort to those who have more global problems with vaccination. The bottom line is that MDC is anti-vaccine to the core.The few brave souls who try to post science-based information will rapidly find themselves under attack from a swarm of anti-vaccinationist cyber sisters. If they persist after being “informed” of the forum’s guidelines or “counseled,” they will be rapidly banned by the forum moderators.
Misinformed consent on MotheringDotCommunity
Mothering and Mothering.com claim to be all about “informed consent” when it comes to vaccination, alternative medicine, “alternative” childbirth practices such as the various forms of “natural” childbirth, and even homeopathy. They are in reality about misinformed consent in that the risks of vaccination are grossly exaggerated, while the severity and danger of the diseases vaccines protect against are minimized, as are the ability of vaccines to protect against these diseases. Thrown into the mix are articles like Dr. Feder’s, which “informs” readers that, while pertussis is bad it’s really not that bad, that the vaccine isn’t so good, and that homeopathy can be used to treat pertussis. In other articles, readers are “informed” that there is doubt over whether HIV causes AIDS, whether AZT can decrease the transmission rate of the virus between HIV-positive mothers and their children, and whether antiretrovirals can prevent the progression of HIV to AIDS. In still other articles, parents are told that they can manage colds, asthma, the flu, earaches, and lots of other conditions with homeopathy.
Perhaps the best example of “misinformed consent” found in Mothering.com can be found at this link to Vaccine Safety Awareness. Right there is a “Physician’s Warranty of Vaccine Safety” that plays the “toxin” gambit and demands in essence absolute safety from vaccines. Elsewhere, prominently featured is a link to the monthly VAERS Report. Never mind that VAERS is a database to which anyone can report an adverse event after vaccination, whether the event is related to vaccination or not. Worse, VAERS is highly subject to publicity. Indeed, trial lawyers have in the past gamed the database by encouraging their clients to report that vaccines caused their children’s autism. Amusingly, a parent by the name of Jim Laidler entered a report into VAERS that a vaccine turned him into the Incredible Hulk, and Kev Leitch did the same in a report claiming that the flu vaccine turned his daughter into Wonder Woman. The point is that anyone can enter a report, and there is no verification that the adverse event reported is actually due to vaccination. VAERS has the potential to be useful as a sensitive “early warning” system that could alert health officials to a problem, but it is useless for estimating actual rates of vaccine injury, and the ease with which it is gamed diminishes its usefulness even as an early warning system.
In fact, the entire Vaccines section of Mothering.com is full of dangerous misinformation. For example, chicken pox parties are recommended, even though as a result of the party described one child had the “worst case his doctor had ever seen,” with “hundreds of lesions, even in his mouth and down his throat.” Another article, entitled Poison in our vaccines, played the toxin gambit in huge, bold letters.
Mothering and MDC represent themselves as places to obtain accurate information about child care, health care, and childbirth. Because the magazine’s circulation is healthy and the community is very large, links to these sites all too often appear high in Google searches, leading young mothers to fonts of misinformation that leads to misinformed consent. Andrew Wakefield and his fellow travelers promoting unscientific information about vaccines are definitely to blame for providing the raw material for the anti-vaccine movement, but it’s communities like MDC and magazines like Mothering that spread the message to the masses, all in the name of protecting “freedom of conscience.” Unfortunately, freedom isn’t free when it’s based on misinformation, pseudoscience, and quackery

   Anti-vaccine propaganda from Sharyl Attkisson of CBS News
David Gorski 
Link
I’m not infrequently asked why the myth that vaccines cause autism and other anti-vaccine myths are so stubbornly resistant to the science that time and time again fails to support them. Certainly useful celebrity idiots like Jenny McCarthy are one reason. So, too, are anti-vaccine propaganda websites and blogs such as Age of Autism and anti-vaccine organizations like Generation Rescue, the National Vaccine Information Center, and SafeMinds and the organizations that publish them. However, these are clearly not the only reason. Alone, these people and organizations are in general quite rightly viewed as fringe, although they are very popular among the anti-vaccine movement. It is when such groups find a willing conduit for their pseudoscience in the “mainstream media” that they see the opportunity to attain a degree of seeming respectability that they can’t achieve on their own based on science. Worse, when mainstream news organizations or reporters fall for the pseudoscience claiming that vaccines cause autism, they contribute to the persistence of this myth outside the activist core of the anti-vaccine movement in the public at large.
In the past, anti-vaccine activists tried to accomplish this with the help of formerly respectable journalists such as David Kirby and Dan Olmsted, the former of whom wrote Evidence of Harm: Mercury in Vaccines and the Autism Epidemic: A Medical Mystery and the latter of whom wrote and promoted the Age of Autism series when he was an editor at UPI. However, although Kirby was never really that prominent or trusted, Olmsted was an editor of UPI. Now that he’s given up his UPI gig to become full time editor of AoA and to team up with Mark Blaxill to write a book (Age of Autism: Mercury, Medicine and a Manmade Epidemic) that regurgitated all the old misinformation about thimerosal and autism in a way that’s so 2005, Olmsted’s lost all credibility as a serious reporter. That’s a good thing.
The bad thing is that he has a replacement. Or at least so it would appear.
THERE’S A NEW ANTI-VACCINE REPORTER IN TOWN, AND SHE’S PUSHING SOME PSEUDOSCIENCE
Unfortunately, at CBS News, there now appears to be a woman who was willing to take over the role of mainstream media propagandist for the anti-vaccine movement. Her name is Sharyl Attkisson, and, oops, she did it again just this Thursday with an article entitled Vaccines and autism: a new scientific review, in which she pimps a truly horrible “review” of the evidence base regarding whether vaccines cause or predispose to autism. Interestingly, she’s quite late. AoA was promoting this article two months ago. On the other hand, April is Autism Awareness Month, and I can always count on the anti-vaccine movement to lay down some vaccine pseudoscience on or around April 1 every year (I leave it to the reader to judge the appropriateness of that date); so perhaps this latest from Attkisson is the opening salvo for this year’s campaign. Her article opens:
For all those who’ve declared the autism-vaccine debate over – a new scientific review begs to differ. It considers a host of peer-reviewed, published theories that show possible connections between vaccines and autism.
The article in the Journal of Immunotoxicology is entitled “Theoretical aspects of autism: Causes–A review.” The author is Helen Ratajczak, surprisingly herself a former senior scientist at a pharmaceutical firm. Ratajczak did what nobody else apparently has bothered to do: she reviewed the body of published science since autism was first described in 1943. Not just one theory suggested by research such as the role of MMR shots, or the mercury preservative thimerosal; but all of them.
Ratajczak’s article states, in part, that “Documented causes of autism include genetic mutations and/or deletions, viral infections, and encephalitis [brain damage] following vaccination [emphasis added]. Therefore, autism is the result of genetic defects and/or inflammation of the brain.”
Note the classic crank technique of trying to convince the reader that the “debate is not over,” that the hypothesis that vaccines cause autism is, in fact, “pining for the fjords” when in fact, on a strictly scientific basis, the hypothesis is at least as dead as that famous parrot, with Attkisson playing the role of the shopkeeper trying to convince his customer that “‘E’s resting” while raving about the parrot’s “beautiful plumage.”
Attkisson then goes on to write:
Ratajczak also looks at a factor that hasn’t been widely discussed: human DNA contained in vaccines. That’s right, human DNA. Ratajczak reports that about the same time vaccine makers took most thimerosal out of most vaccines (with the exception of flu shots which still widely contain thimerosal), they began making some vaccines using human tissue. Ratajczak says human tissue is currently used in 23 vaccines. She discusses the increase in autism incidences corresponding with the introduction of human DNA to MMR vaccine, and suggests the two could be linked. Ratajczak also says an additional increased spike in autism occurred in 1995 when chicken pox vaccine was grown in human fetal tissue.
Why could human DNA potentially cause brain damage? The way Ratajczak explained it to me: “Because it’s human DNA and recipients are humans, there’s homologous recombinaltion tiniker. That DNA is incorporated into the host DNA. Now it’s changed, altered self and body kills it. Where is this most expressed? The neurons of the brain. Now you have body killing the brain cells and it’s an ongoing inflammation. It doesn’t stop, it continues through the life of that individual.”
Dear readers, I apologize to those of you who don’t like my “tone” (well, no I don’t, at least not in this case), but those two paragraphs almost made me spit the iced tea I was drinking as I composed this all over the keyboard of my precious MacBook Air. The reason is that I have experience with working with DNA, human, mouse, and otherwise, including injecting it into tissues and trying to get it to express the protein for which it encodes. This is not a trivial matter. Think of it this way. If it were, gene therapy would be an almost trivial matter. But it’s not. In general, it’s difficult to induce human cells to take up foreign DNA in tissue. Even with viral vectors, it’s hard to get more than a small percentage of cells not only to take up the DNA but to express detectable levels of protein. Muscle is one tissue that can take up naked plasmid DNA and actually express it. Indeed, this technique has been used to generate cancer vaccines, where plasmid DNA is injected into the muscle in order to cause it to make a certain protein, which then provokes an immune response. But doing this is not easy, and the DNA is not detectably incorporated into the DNA of the muscle cells. Its gene expression is extranuclear (outside the nucleus).
But that’s not all. Even human cells that can take up random bits of extracellular DNA at very low efficiency (like muscle) do not integrate that DNA into their genome. Even if the DNA did reach the nucleus, recombination into the host genome would be both random and rare. Each cell would incorporate different bits of DNA into different locations in its genome. Does Dr. Ratajczak even know basic molecular biology?
But that’s still not all.
Dr. Ratajczak states that the DNA from vaccines is human DNA. Even if that human DNA did undergo homologous recombination, it would still be human DNA making human proteins. Yet Dr. Ratajczak claims that homologous recombination turns that cell into “altered self.” However, the body recognizes a cell as foreign or “altered” through the expression of its cell surface proteins. Consequently, the only likely currently known mechanism by which homologous recombination of human DNA from vaccines might conceivably result in such an autoimmunity phenomenon would be if the DNA from the vaccine somehow resulted in the expression of a foreign or altered protein on the cell surface that the immune system could recognize as foreign. That would mean either integrating into the gene for a cell surface protein or producing a cell surface protein itself. While not impossible, that’s pretty darned unlikely to happen on a scale that would affect more than a single cell, a few at most. To recap: To do what Dr. Ratajczak claims, human DNA from vaccines would have to:
    • Find its way to the brain in significant quantities.
    • Make it into the neurons in the brain in significant quantities.
    • Make it into the nucleus of the neurons in significant quantities.
    • Undergo homologous recombination at a detectable level, resulting in either the alteration of a cell surface protein or the expression of a foreign cell surface protein that the immune system can recognize.
    • Undergo homologous recombination in many neurons in such a way that results in the neurons having cell surface protein(s) altered sufficiently to be recognized as foreign.
That’s leaving aside the issue of whether autoimmunity in the brain or chronic brain inflammation is even a cause of autism, which is by no means settled by any stretch of the imagination. In fact, quite the opposite. It’s not at all clear whether the markers of inflammation sometimes reported in the brains of autistic children are a cause, a consequence, or merely an epiphenomenon of autism.
In other words, Dr. Ratajczak’s hypothesis is incredibly implausible on the basis of what we know about molecular biology and human biology. It’s not quite homeopathy-level implausible, but nonetheless quite implausible. Even so, I’m willing to have my mind changed for me, but there’s only one thing that can possibly do that: Scientific data. Experiments. Clinical trials. Good ones. So I “went to the source,” so to speak, and actually looked at Dr. Ratajczak’s review article being touted by Attkisson to see what she actually said about homologous recombination of human DNA in vaccines as one cause of autism. Here is the sum total of what she said:
Data from a worldwide composite of studies show that an increase in cumulative incidence began about 1988–1990 (McDonald and Paul, 2010). The new version of the measles, mumps, rubella vaccine (i.e., MMR II) that did not contain Thimerosal was introduced in 1979. By 1983, only the new version was available. Autism in the United States spiked dramatically between 1983 and 1990 from 4–5/10,000 to 1/500. In 1988, two doses of MMR II were recommended to immunize those individuals who did not respond to the first injection. A spike of incidence of autism accompanied the addition of the second dose of MMR II. Also, in 1988, MMR II was used in the United Kingdom, which reported a dramatic increase in prevalence of autism to 1/64 (noted above). Canada, Denmark, and Japan also reported dramatic increases in prevalence of autism. It is important to note that unlike the former MMR, the rubella component of MMR II was propagated in a human cell line derived from embryonic lung tissue (Merck and Co., Inc., 2010). The MMR II vaccine is contaminated with human DNA from the cell line. This human DNA could be the cause of the spikes in incidence. An additional increased spike in incidence of autism occurred in 1995 when the chicken pox vaccine was grown in human fetal tissue (Merck and Co., Inc., 2001; Breuer, 2003). The current incidence of autism in the United States, noted above, is approximately 1/100.
The human DNA from the vaccine can be randomly inserted into the recipient’s genes by homologous recombination, a process that occurs spontaneously only within a species. Hot spots for DNA insertion are found on the X chromosome in eight autism-associated genes involved in nerve cell synapse formation, central nervous system development, and mitochondrial function (Deisher, 2010). This could provide some explanation of why autism is predominantly a disease of boys. Taken together, these data support the hypothesis that residual human DNA in some vaccines might cause autism.
Later, she writes:
Other reports have also used prevalence data that support an association of the MMR vaccine with an increased prevalence of autism. Furthermore, an examination of the continuing increase in prevalence in autism in the context of the dates of spikes in increase in prevalence which point to the MMR II vaccine (which did not contain Thimerosal) suggests that something “new” caused the increase in incidence of autism. Changes in vaccine schedule occurred over the years such as changes in the age at which vaccines were given (Ramsay et al., 1991). These changes could contribute to the increases in incidence of autism. Another change was how some vaccines were propagated. The “new” component could be the human DNA from the preparation of the rubella component of the MMR II vaccine and the chicken pox vaccine. See “Changes in Rates of Autism Incidence” above. The United States Government and Dr. Geberding, Director of Vaccines at Merck & Co., Inc. say that autistic conditions can result from encephalopathy following vaccination (Child Health Safety, 2010).
I’m the sort of guy who’s data-driven. If there were scientific data that convincingly suggested a hypothesis, even one as implausible as the one above, I’d think about it and possibly even conclude that this is an area worthy of investigation. There were no data presented. There weren’t even studies cited that convincingly supported Ratajczak’s assertions. That’s it? I was thinking as I read her article. That’s all she’s got? Seriously? I thought it was a joke; so I read the entire article again. Yes, that is all that she has got: Implying that correlation equals causation, combined with an observation that there are “hot spots” for DNA insertion in the X chromosome in some autism-associated genes. From that, she concludes that the existing data support the hypothesis that human DNA in MMR II could be at least responsible for the “autism epidemic” through homologous recombination in the brain resulting in autoimmunity and chronic inflammation? And she cites the anti-vaccine blog Child Health Safety as one of her references? The date of the CHS entry cited is June 30, 2010. All I could find was this entry, which purports to argue that both Merck’s Director of Vaccines and the U.S. government have admitted that vaccines cause autism all based on the long known science showing that a maternal case of rubella while carrying a fetus can result in autism in the child, something that’s been known for several decades and is in fact one reason why vaccination against rubella is so important. How on earth did this get through peer review. Obviously, the peer reviewers of Dr. Ratajczak’s article were either completely ignorant of the background science (and therefore unqualified) or asleep at the switch.
The rest of Dr. Ratajczak’s article is a greatest hits collection of anti-vaccine hypotheses, speculations, ideas, and brain farts mixed with the occasional–and I do mean occasional–grain of scientifically supportable hypotheses regarding autism. The vast majority of what is discussed, however, is pure vaccine pseudoscience. The scientifically unsupported idea that mercury in vaccines causes autism? It’s there. The work of the tag team of Geier père et fils, the same team who came up with the idea of chemical castration as a treatment of autism that “works” because according to them testosterone binds mercury, making it easier to chelate? Copiously cited. True, Ratajczak doesn’t specifically cite the Geiers’ unethical clinical trial testing Lupron as a treatment for “precocious puberty” and autism, but she does cite the “scientific” basis that the Geiers used to justify that trial, as well as a lot of the Geiers’ usual execrable studies linking mercury in vaccines with autism. Mitochondrial dysfunction, which has been co-opted by the anti-vaccine movement as an “explanation” for how vaccines supposedly cause autism? It’s there too. She even cites David Ayoub, who is known for thinking that black helicopters are watching him. In other words, her review is 95% pseudoscientific garbage, maybe 5% reasonable science. On second thought, I’m clearly being generous.
Remember that Sharyl Attkisson is taking advantage of the start of National Autism Awareness Month to promote this nonsense.
SHARYL ATTKISSON: THE ANTI-VACCINE REPORTER FOR CBS NEWS
This is not the first time that Sharyl Attkisson has demonstrated herself to be biased in favor of the anti-vaccine movement. Indeed, I’ve known about her activities in this regard going back nearly four years. One particularly prominent example that sticks out in my mind is an article she published on the CBS News website back in 2007 entitled Autism: Why the debate rages, in which she made assertions and arguments of these sorts:
Science has been wrong before. She used Vioxx and Thalidomide as examples. Never mind that Thalidomide was never approved in the U.S. at the time of all the birth defects (it’s approved now to treat multiple myeloma), and in fact was an example of the FDA doing its job. In classic crank fashion, Attkisson used these examples to argue that science must be wrong now about thimerosal in vaccines. She even pulls out the hoary “refrigerator mother” gambit, implying that because there was a time that scientists speculated that cold, uncaring mothers contributed to or triggered autism and were clearly wrong about that, they must be wrong about vaccines now.
The classic “pharma shill gambit.” Attkisson ranted on about how scientists do research for vaccine companies, linking the pro-vaccine group Every Child By Two to pharmaceutical companies.
Science doesn’t know everything. Sample quote: “There is no definitive research proving a link between vaccines and autism or ADD, but there is also no definitive research ruling it out.” Well, there is no definitive research ruling out a link between autism and pixies, either.
Because scientists don’t know what is causing the “autism epidemic,” vaccines are a plausible cause.
Truly, Attkisson’s 2007 article was a crank trifecta plus one!
Then, in 2008, Sharyl Attkisson appeared to have been caught almost red-handed taking a letter of protest from a pro-vaccine group called Voices for Vaccines complaining about her reporting to the anti-vaccine group blog Age of Autism, an incident that led Liz Ditz to ask, “How much of Attkisson’s “investigating” consists of rewriting and rewording statements from principals at the advocacy–even propaganda–organization, Age of Autism?” I don’t know the answer to that question, but I do know that Attkisson’s reporting on vaccines is nearly indistinguishable from the message put forth by anti-vaccine groups like Generation Rescue, SafeMinds, and the NVIC. Attkisson even falls for bad science in other areas, such as breast cancer research. In fact, you could say that her science reporting when it comes to breast cancer causation is of the same quality as her reporting on vaccines and autism, and I don’t mean that as a compliment.
Nor do I mean it as a compliment when I say that, in the wake of Wakefield’s infamous “monkey business study” in 2009, Attkisson inserted her nose farther up Andrew Wakefield’s posterior than even the crew at AoA has yet managed:
Watch CBS News Videos Online
After all of Attkisson’s pandering to the anti-vaccine movement and promoting its message, one huge question remains. Why does CBS News tolerate Attkisson’s horrible reporting on vaccines and other scientific issues? I can’t speak about her other reporting, but when it comes to science, Sharyl Attkisson is a crank par excellence. She has an agenda; and she tortures the evidence to make it seem to agree with her biases. All of this wouldn’t matter so much if she weren’t a national correspondent for CBS. Unfortunately, there her crank magnetism allows her to engage in fear mongering on a national level.
I also wonder how long it will be before Attkisson joins Dan Olmsted as a writer for AoA. My only surprise is that, nearly four years since I first noticed her, she hasn’t made that move already. I suppose I can always hope that CBS News wises up to the anti-vaccine propagandist working as one of its correspondents and forces Attkisson finally to make that mov

   Jenny McCarthy, Jim Carrey, and “Green Our Vaccines”: Anti-vaccine, not “pro-safe vaccine” 
David Gorski
Link
Last week, there was a rally in Washington, D.C. How many people actually attended the rally is uncertain. The organizers themselves claim that 8,500 people attended, while more objective estimates from people not associated with the march put the number at probably less than 1,000. Of course, such wide variations in estimates for the attendance at such events are not uncommon. For my purposes it is irrelevant whether 500 or 8,000 attended because even if the lowest estimate is closer to the true number this march represented the largest march on Washington ever for this particular cause, the previous largest having occurred three years ago.
Fortunately for public health interests, the organizers’ timing was very bad (for them, at least) in that they marched last Wednesday, the very day after Barack Obama clinched the Democratic nomination. The media were rife with coverage of the history-making nomination of the first African-American as a nominee of a major party, as well as speculation about when and whether Hillary Clinton would concede and endorse Obama. Drowning out most other news, Obama’s nomination led to almost nonexistent news coverage of the rally, aside from a handful of television appearances by one of its celebrity organizers. Its relative lack of success notwithstanding, however, all who support science- and evidence-based medicine should nonetheless remain concerned about this rally, because it was a dagger aimed at the heart of the most effective public health innovation ever conceived by the human mind, an intervention that has arguably saved more lives over the course of human history than every other medical intervention combined. That this dagger turned out to be a toothpick is fortunate indeed but by no means a reason to dismiss the movement that spawned it as irrelevant.
I’m referring, of course, to the antivaccinationist movement, and the rally was known as the “Green Our Vaccines” rally, led by the celebrity couple Jenny McCarthy and Jim Carrey and organized and funded by Talk About Curing Autism (TACA), Generation Rescue (upon whose board McCarthy now sits), and a panoply of other groups that promulgate the myth that either vaccines containing mercury in the form of their thimerosal preservative or vaccines themselves cause autism.
“Green Our Vaccines”: Anti-vaccine, not “pro-safe vaccine”
The first thing that becomes apparent to any neutral observer is that the organizers themselves clearly went to great lengths to deny that they are “anti-vaccine.” Indeed, the overall mantra of the march appeared to be “I’m not anti-vaccine; I’m pro-safe vaccine,” a mantra that was to be waved in front of the press during the time before, during, and after the march like a talisman to ward off skeptics. Indeed, a couple of days before the rally David Kirby, chief apologist for the “mercury causes autism” movement, ex-travel writer for the New York Times and author of a book (Evidence of Harm: Mercury in Vaccines and the Autism Epidemic, A Medical Controversy) that arguably did as much to promote the claim that mercury in vaccines causes autism as Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s execrable bit of fear-mongering that appeared in Salon.com and Rolling Stone almost exactly three years ago did, tried unconvincingly to argue that he isn’t anti-vaccine. Meanwhile Jenny McCarthy herself has been frequently quoted as saying:
What I really am is “anti-toxins” in the vaccines. I do believe that there is a correlation between vaccinations and autism. I don’t think it’s the sole cause, but I think they’re triggering–it’s triggering–autism in these kids. A really great example is…is, sometimes obesity can trigger diabetes. I do believe that vaccines can trigger autism…It’s so much more than just mercury. That is one ingredient in the recipe of autism…People don’t realize that there is aluminum, ether, antifreeze, still mercury, in the shots.
I’ve referred to this before in the context of the Generation Rescue ad that first introduced the “Green Our Vaccines” slogan to the world. Indeed, I doff my hat to the organizers at this march they’ve framed the issue with such a wonderfully Orwellian slogan that’s brilliant because of how difficult it is for rational scientists to counter. After all, who doesn’t want “safer” vaccines? No one, of course! Not even the the man who is to antivaccinationists the Devil incarnate, vaccine scientist and defender Paul Offit, would say that he doesn’t want safer vaccines, too. Indeed, he’s spent his career trying to do just that: Develop more effective and safer vaccines. Certainly I can’t argue with making vaccines as safe as possible. They happen to be, by any reasonable measure, remarkably safe right now, but there’s always room for improvement. What the press and others at whom this crunchy eco-friendly message of reassurance and seeming reason that fits right in with the current mood of the country is aimed don’t realize is just one thing. After all, if there are indeed all sorts of horrible toxins in vaccines, shouldn’t we get rid of them? It all sounds so measured, so reasonable, and so conservative.
Too bad it’s about as disingenuous as it gets. Like Steve Novella, I have no doubt that Jenny McCarthy and Jim Carrey mean well, but I agree that it’s not enough to mean well. There’s a famous saying that the road to hell is paved with good intentions. My usually corollary to this saying is that good intentions coupled with misinformation and self-righteousness are the straightest and surest route to hell that I can think of, and among the best examples of this corollary are parents who have been misled by the pseudoscience of the cottage industry of autism quackery that depends on the belief that vaccines cause autism for its profitability. Couple that with the arrogance of ignorance, which Jenny McCarthy exhibits in abundance and which apparently drives her to conclude that attending the University of Google qualifies her to shout down doctors and scientists on Larry King’s show, and you have a truly toxic brew of self-righteously misdirected anger.
Nowhere was the utter disingenuousness of the “Green Our Vaccines” strategy more apparent than from the “toxin” gambit, which reared its ugly head on all the official literature, T-shirts, and signs for the march. “Toxins” are the new bogey man that has replaced the previous bogey man (thimerosal) in vaccines. The reason, of course, is that even zealots are coming to realize that science is failing utterly to support the hypothesis that the mercury in thimerosal-containing vaccines is linked with autism. Take a look at this emblem, which appeared on the back of every officially sold “Green Our Vaccines” T-shirt worn by almost every marcher in the rally:
Yes, the dreaded “toxin” gambit beloved of antivaccinationists was writ large in green and white all over Washington, a variation of which Jenny McCarthy had been parroting beforehand and that I presciently deconstructed a while back when Age of Autism contributor Kent Heckenlively produced such an over-the-top, jaw-droppingly silly invocation of this particular canard that I had a hard time believing anyone could write something so ill-informed. Not only was Heckenlively’s version of this gambit wrong, but it was so extravagantly and outrageously wrong that he even–incredibly–raised concerns about the sucrose in vaccines on the basis that excessive sucrose intake can lead to obesity, tooth decay, and type II diabetes. It’s as though he thinks that babies are being fed copious quantities of vaccine and are in danger of rotten teeth and obesity from it. Truly, you just can’t make stuff like this up.
Given that I’ve already dealt with this myth in detail before, I don’t see the need to do it again, other than to make a couple of additional points. I think that I can best illustrate why the “toxin” gambit is in fact an antivaccine gambit by going back to a conversation that I encountered on the Mothering.com discussion boards a few years ago, where the prevailing opinion is pro-woo and anti-vaccine. This attitude was perhaps best encapsulated by a comment by a woman using the ‘nym Jen123:
Mercury seems to be getting tons of coverage. When that deal is settled and we win, we need to go after another ingredient. We’ll dismantle the vaccine industry ingredient by stupid ingredient if we have to.
Who is with me?
Suffice it to say that apparently no one wasn’t with her. I will give Jen123 kudos, though. She perfectly and succinctly stated the true purpose of the “toxin” gambit. The “Green Our Vaccines” movement is nothing more than the very same sentiment wrapped up in a nice, friendly slogan that on the surface sounds so very, very reasonable, particularly when antivaccinationists mention all those really scary-sounding ingredients, unconcerned with getting the actual niceties of the chemistry right. For example, they either ignorantly or willfully confuse ethylene glycol (antifreeze, which is not in vaccines) with polyethylene glycol (a polymer of ethylene glycol, a chemically different compound which is in some vaccines and is also in a number of skin creams, toothpaste, and medications, including laxatives) or ethyl ether (a flammable liquid that was one of the first anaesthetics but has long since been supplanted by much safer agents) with polyethylene glycol pisooctylphenyl ether (Triton X-100, a kind of soap/detergent). They even go so far as to act horrified about the caustic properties hydrochloric acid, which is used to titrate the pH of vaccines to neutral, as though vaccines contained 12 M HCl! They’ll also rant on and on about formaldehyde, neglecting the fact that most people are exposed in a single day to more formaldehyde from plastics, plywood, furniture and furniture finishes, and a variety of other household products and objects in every house than babies are exposed to from their entire vaccine schedule. Moving away from chemistry to misunderstandings of biology, there’s also a love of harping on “aborted fetuses,” as though vaccines were somehow made from aborted fetal tissue. The reality is far less dramatic. For some vaccines, viruses are grown in a cell line derived from an aborted fetus nearly 45 years ago and maintained continuously in cell culture since. (Some antivaccinationists do know this, but they like to try to tap into religious objections to abortion by playing this gambit.) The whole bit about “monkey cells” is a similar gambit. Some viruses are indeed grown in monkey kidney cells, but it’s not as though these cells are retained in the vaccine, and antivaccinationists will play into this as though it somehow makes vaccines “dirty” sometimes even invoking the spectre of HIV. The seem to forget about a little step called “purification.” Viral particles are isolated and the cells are eliminated, just as the human fetal cells are. Maybe they believe in a homeopathic theory of vaccination, in which the vaccines somehow retain a memory of the monkey cells with which they have been in contact but that have been removed from the final product.
Boiling it all down, the “toxin” gambit represents nothing more than moving the goalposts, a tried-and-true technique beloved of all varieties of cranks. Now that thimerosal is increasingly being vindicated by clinical and epidemiological studies that have failed to find a link between its presence in vaccines and autism, antivaccinationists, convinced that it absolutely, positively has to be the vaccines that cause autism and all sort of other problems, have moved on to other ingredients. They will continue to do so as long as there are vaccines, and the “Green Our Vaccines” slogan is just a far more media-savvy manifestation of this goalpost-shifting that has always been part and parcel of the anti-vaccine movement. It’s also a clever co-optation of the environmental movement, although the demand that vacines be “green” has resulted in statements that are so rife with misinderstanding that it’s hard to figure out how to counter them. For example:
But Mason, who has two autistic children, warns that autism is on the rise, and that something has to change. “ideally the legislators would enact legislation that would force companies to use natural ingredients”, she argues. “Not what they’re using now.”
Apparently, Mrs. Mason wants manufacturers to use “all natural” ingredients in vaccines, as though she were getting her vaccines from Whole Foods. I can’t help but wonder if she knows that polio, the measles, mumps, influenza, smallpox, and every other vaccine-preventable disease are “all natural.” In any case, it should be apparent that the “Green Our Vaccines” slogan is nothing more than putting an eco-friendly face on antiscientific fearmongering in the cause of opposition to vaccines. Indeed, if anyone has any doubts that this march was primarily an antivaccination march, please peruse the slogans seen on signs photographed by Ginger Taylor, the text of which was convieniently catalogued for your perusal by none other than another apologist for the anti-vaccine movement Dan Olmsted. The marchers weren’t ashamed of their antivaccinationist element; indeed, they were proud of it:
There was also video presentation, complete with sappy music, showing these signs:
Another amateur video that gives you the flavor of the rally can be found here:
And, of course, here’s the real purpose of the march:
Organizers of the “Green Our Vaccines” rally tried very hard to hide that it is in reality an antivaccination rally, but they clearly failed, as has been pointed out before. It would be a surprise to expect otherwise. After all, Jenny McCarthy herself has said on numerous occasions that if she ever has another child, she “wouldn’t vaccinate at all, never, ever,” or, as she said on CNN:
I am surely not going to tell anyone to vaccinate. But if I had another child, there’s no way in hell…….for my next kid—which I’m never going to have—there’s no way.
Tell me again how this march was not “anti-vaccine” to its very core. If marchers are going to make an argument that requirements by the states that children be vaccinated before they attend public school or be allowed into day care represent an unacceptable infringement upon freedom, then let them make that argument explicitly and plainly, rather than wrapping it in deceptive pseudoscientific claims that vaccines are full of horrific “toxins” or that children are getting “too many, too soon.”
“Too Many, Too Soon”: More moving of the goalposts
Ever since there have been vaccines, there have been antivaccination movements. Indeed, it was not long after Edward Jenner discovered how to use the weaker cowpox virus to induce long-lasting immunity to smallpox that resistance to the concept of vaccination appeared, a resistance that continues to this very day. Reasons for this resistance started out primarily religious, with clergy arguing that people who became ill did so because it was God’s will and that vaccines were an arrogant attempt by Man to thwart that will. They then evolved to more modern fears of injecting “unnatural” substances into the body or simple resistance to the government telling people what to do, the latter of which particularly resonates in the U.S. Many fear even the infitessimally small risk that vaccines pose for the benefit of resistance to disease far more than they fear the diseases themselves, a result of the very success of modern vaccines. Of course, vaccines, like any other medical intervention, are not without risks, making it easy for them to jump on any hint of harm done by vaccines, whether real or imagined, even though vaccines are among the very safest of treatments.
This brings us to the other major slogan of the rally, namely “Too Many, Too Soon.” This, too, is a conveniently vague but oh-so-reasonable-sounding slogan. It, like “Green Our Vaccines,” is also another strategy to move the goalposts. The concept is based on the expansion of the number of recommended vaccines since 1983. Confusing correlation with causation yet again, anti-vaccine activists make the observation that the prevalence of autism has increased markedly since 1983, when the number of vaccines recommended for infants and small children was ten, to now, when the recommended number is 36. Indeed, this was a huge component of Generation Rescue’s deceptive full-page advertisement in USA Today that appeared back in February. The concept is simple. It is postulated that the increasing number of vaccines somehow “overwhelms” the immune system or causes some sort of “aggregate” toxicity that is responsible not just for autism, but a variety of chronic diseases, such as obesity and type II diabetes, asthma, and autoimmune diseases. That there is no even mildly compelling scientific or epidemiological evidence to support these claims doesn’t matter. Antivaccinationists have thus far successfully wrapped themselves in the mantle of caution that to most parents without a background in science or epidemiology seems eminently reasonable. It also sounds, on the surface at least, eminently reasonable when antivaccination activists claim that it’s the combination of vaccines that cause all these neurodevelopmental problems like autism. It’s also a conveniently difficult to falsify claim. Clearly activists have learned from their mistake with mercury never to make a hypothesis that makes a relatively easily testable prediction. The thimerosal hypothesis made the prediction that if thimerosal in vaccines were removed autism prevalence should fall rather rapidly within 5-7 years, given that the age range when most autism is diagnosed is from 3 to 5. Autism prevalence hasn’t fallen; it’s still rising. Even those who claimed that “it’s the mercury, stupid” and that “autism is a misdiagnosis for mercury poisoning” now realize that neither of these statements is true. The most that can be said from current data is that maybe, just maybe, a very small number of susceptible children could have a reaction that might manifest itself as autistic symptoms–hence the moving on to other “toxins.” In contrast, the “Too Many, Too Soon” hypothesis is much vaguer and difficult to extract easily testable hypotheses from, which is the whole point of it.
Of course, no scientific evidence is ever presented that rises above the level of Dr. Laura Hewitson’s badly designed monkey study, Generation Rescue’s even more poorly designed “telephone survey” of vaccinated and unvaccinated children, or Dan Olmsted’s easily falsified claim that the Amish do not vaccinate and do not get autism to support their contention that the current vaccine schedule is harmful. Moreover, when the GOV movement claims that current vaccines haven’t been tested in combinations, it’s just plain wrong. All new vaccines are tested in clinical trials against the background of the current vaccine schedule. In other words, if it’s a new vaccine not currently recommended, in clinical trials it’s merely added to the current schedule. If the vaccine is for the same disease as a currently used vaccine, then the trial looks at the new vaccine versus the old vaccine, all other vaccines in the schedule remaining the same. The reason we don’t do serial “one-at-a-time” trials is simple, but nonetheless antivaccinationists never seem able to grasp the concept: It would be extremely unethical to withhold protective vaccines from children in order to test them against no vaccines because it would leave the no vaccine group of children vulnerable to vaccine-preventable diseases. In reality, this is yet another thinly-disguised attempt to move the goalposts. More savvy antivaccinationists know that the kind of testing they demand is unethical, prohibitively expensive, and impractical, but demanding it allows them to claim (falsely) that there is no science supporting the safety of the current vaccine schedule and provide a complaint that sounds as though it has merit to those without a background in medicine and clinical trials. Moreover, contrary to the claims that the current vaccine schedule “overloads the immune system,” there are actually fewer antigens now in more vaccines, thanks to better vaccine design. Like the “Green Our Vaccines” slogan, the “Too many, too soon” slogan is also nothing more than a fairly clever strategy of preemptively moving the goalposts. Conveniently, the GOV folks never quite tell us which vaccines should be delayed and why or what the tradeoff would be in terms of exposing children to vaccine-preventable disease for a longer period of time before they are vaccinated. That’s not the point. Casting doubt on the safety and efficacy of vaccines is.
Conspiracy theories and paranoia
Like all movements based on pseudoscience, the “Green Our Vaccines” movement is full of paranoia and conspiracy-mongering. The most frequent targets are pharmaceutical companies, which, it is said, profit enormously from vaccines (they don’t; in fact thanks to liability issues fueled by just such activists it’s getting increasingly difficult to persuade vaccine manufacturers to keep making them), or the government. A lovely example of this was Jim Carrey’s speech to the marchers, which was recorded in an edited version by CNN and a more complete version posted on YouTube:
I have no way of knowing if Carrey had conspiracy theorist tendencies before he ever met Jenny McCarthy. Guessing from the level of paranoia in his speech, I’d guess there was a pre-existing affinity coupled with little or no knowledge of how science works. After all, it’s pretty hard to go from completely rational to this level of paranois in a mere year or so. For instance, note how his statement that he is “not against all vaccines” and that “vaccines can do a lot of good” was immediately followed by this:
…but many of us believe that in the last few decades corporate influence has turned the vaccine program into more of a profit engine than a means of prevention. It’s time to make the people who make them, the people who insist that we take them, know once and for all that it’s too many, too soon.
Yes, it’s just standard-issue antivaccinationist big pharma conspiracy-mongering, but then Carrey goes on to an unbelievable analogy:
If on the way to a burning building a fire engine ran people over, we wouldn’t stop using fire engines. We would just ask them to slow down a bit. Well it’s time to tell the CDC and the AAP that it’s time to slow the fire engine down. People are getting hurt on the way to the fire.
I’m still undecided whether this is the worst analogy ever or the best, albeit unintentionally. On the one hand, consider this: A fire engine is going to save people’s lives and put out fires; if it hits someone on the way to its destination it would by definition be hitting someone who was not its intended target. For that analogy to hold with vaccines, the shots would somehow have to be killing or injuring kids who never got them. They’re not. They’re not even, as far as science can tell, causing autism. So Carrey’s analogy is quite specious. On the other hand, the analogy is unintentionally spot on. After all, if we “slow down” fire engines, as he suggests, it would take them longer to get to fires. Some people who might have been saved if the fire engine arrived faster would then be likely to die because the firefighters and rescue teams arrive too late. If we slowed down the vaccination schedule, as Carrey suggests, that would leave more children vulnerable to vaccine-preventable diseases for a longer period of time, meaning that more children would certainly become ill and more might well die.
As hard as it is to believe, though, Jim Carrey then actually “topped” himself:
It’s time to tell them that we want real independent studies done on the effects of these vaccines. We are fed up with them trying to tell us that legitimate scientific research, court settlements that have been awarded for vaccine damage, and the overwhelming anecdotal evidence of thousands and thousands of parents and doctors do not constitute real science and don’t warrant their attention. I believe that history will prove that the moms and dads were right about autism. The sea of evidence and testimony can no longer be ignored, and those who refuse to acknowledge it now will take their place with the many learned men of the past who insisted that the earth was flat.
And I certainly wouldn’t trust the drug companies to regulate themselves. God knows they’re far too busy fighting the terrible scourge of restless leg syndrome–also known as “lazy ass” disease.
One can’t help but note the contempt that Jim Carrey apparently has for sufferers of restless leg syndrome, which, as Steve Novella pointed out, is a real entity. I have to ask: Don’t sufferers of restless leg syndrome deserve good treatments for their condition too? Jenny McCarthy took the persecution gambit even further with this claim:
Pediatricians, you know, take an oath, by the way, when they graduate from medical school. They really do. They take an oath to do no harm. Well harm has been done. If you take a look at the history of medicine, this lie has been told before. Do you remember when smoking was actually good for our health? Do you remember when autism was blamed on lazy mothers? We were known as refrigerator mothers, cold and uncaring to our children. Well take a look around. I believe science was wrong yet again.
Yes, the Jen and Jim show are delivering exactly what you think: It’s the infamous “science was wrong before” gambit, beloved of cranks of all stripes, be they quacks or cranks. Naturally, the implication of the “science has been wrong before” gambit is that Jenny and Jim’s “science” is correct and the present scientific consensus is radically wrong. In other words, it’s also an implied Galileo gambit. Although Jenny’s makes a good point about the now discredited “refrigerator mother” hypothesis regarding the cause of autism and I can’t blame mothers for being royally ticked off at being blamed for their children’s autism in that way in the past, McCarthy is so incredibly, extravagantly, outrageously wrong in comparing the prior lack of concern about cigarette smoking to the science showing no correlation between vaccines and autism. Indeed, it’s impossible not to point out that the same epidemiological science that demonstrated a bulletproof link between smoking and lung cancer and that smoking was associated with a number of other diseases is the very same sort of epidemiological science that has, despite trying in multiple large studies, failed to find a link between vaccines and autism.
Of course big pharma is suppressing the evidence. At least that’s what Jim Carrey and Jenny McCarthy (not to mention Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., who also spoke at the rally) believe. Whatever sins of big pharma and the government, it strains credulity to the breaking point every bit as much as 9/11 Truthers do when they claim that the government was involved in the 9/11 attacks to postulate such a huge conspiracy to cover up evidence that vaccines cause autism. For one thing, the government and big pharma are just not that competent at keeping explosive secrets secret for very long.
If you want to get a flavor of more of the paranoia that drives these marchers, I suggest viewing this, in which a marcher spouts bad science and conspiracy theories, not the least of which is that the press “always gets it wrong”:
The perfect solution fallacy
One of the common claims I heard from parents suspicious of vaccines leading up to the “Green Our Vaccines” rally goes something along these lines:
I believe in vaccines, but I don’t believe they are 100% safe. Until they prove it to me, my child is having no more.
Indeed, over and over I hear the demand for “100% safety” before parents will vaccinate. In fact, the “Green Our Vaccines” is nothing if not a clever manifestation of this demand. Most parents whom I’ve encountered who demand that standard for vaccines curiously selective about what they apply this standard to. One of my responses is to ask them a series of questions and point out a series of observations that takes a form something like this:
Do you drive your kids around in a car? How can you do that? It’s by no means “100% safe”! Do you know how many children die or suffer permanent brain injury in car crashes every year? Thousands! By your standards, then, shouldn’t you should be demanding “100%” safety from your auto before driving your children anywhere in it? Do you let your children swim? How can you be so irresponsible? 5,000 children a year are hospitalized for drowning or near-drowning. 20% die, and 15% suffer permanent neurological injury. (It’s true.) Do you have a child who plays baseball or softball? Don’t you know that 4-5 children a year in the U.S. die of injuries suffered playing baseball or softball. But deaths are only the worst injuries. Among children ages 5-14, well over 100,000 children are taken to the emergency room for injuries suffered playing baseball each and every year. These include sprains, contusions, fractures, dental injuries, head injuries and concussions, and internal injuries. In fact, although its overall rate of injury is fairly low, baseball has the highest child fatality rate of any sport. I really hope your children don’t like sports, especially baseball.
Clearly you, by your demand for 100% safety must not allow them to participate in any of these activities, nor must you allow them to cross the street or go to school. All these activities are far more dangerous than any vaccine. Indeed, one can’t help but note that if you applied the same standard to daily activities as you do to vaccines, your children would have to live in a hermetically sealed bubble, never venturing out. Oh, wait. That wouldn’t be “100% safe” either. Life isn’t “100% safe.” Nothing is.
The “100% safety” gambit is a variant of what is known as the “perfect solution” or “Nirvana” fallacy. It is an excuse for not doing something to fix or prevent a problem based on the assertion that the solution isn’t perfect. By any measure, vaccines are incredibly safe interventions, with a very low risk of complications. The risk, however, is not and never will be zero. Nothing is absolutely, positively 100% safe, including vaccines. However, they are certainly far safer than allowing children to be vulnerable to the diseases they prevent.
Conclusion
No one–and I mean no one–is arguing against safer vaccines. That’s a straw man argument that the the “Green Our Vaccine” movement finds useful as a rebuttal when the scientific vacuousness of its position is pointed out. In fact, a lot of money and effort are put into trying to make our vaccines as safe as possible, and that’s a good thing. Nor do I (or anyone else I’m aware of) argue that the parents in the rally don’t care about their children or aren’t trying to do what they believe to be best for them. What I do argue, as does Steve Novella, is that for all their good intentions these activists are, alas, spectacularly mistaken about the science that they believe to support their beliefs. Indeed, the entire “Green Our Vaccines” is based on a toxic mix of bad science, emotion, and misinformation about “toxins” that ignores chemistry, pharmacology, and even common sense, all tied together with the fallacy of the perfect solution. That’s no basis for public policy, and the “Green Our Vaccines” movement has the potential to do real harm to public health.
But maybe I’m mistaken. If that’s the case, then I ask anyone supporting the “Green Our Vaccine” movement who may read this to answer a few simple questions: How safe is safe enough for vaccines? Please be specific and remember that 100% safety is a completely unrealistic and unobtainable goal for any human activity, including vaccination. Show me why, in the case of vaccines, my view that it’s nothing more than a transparent excuse for not vaccinating, no matter what is wrong. With that in mind, what, specifically, would it take for you to agree to vaccinate your child? Remember also that vague platitudes about removing “ALL the toxins” from vaccines don’t count, because such a standard is impossible to achieve and therefore meaningless in terms of medicine and public policy. There will always be trace amounts of scary-sounding chemicals in vaccines, just as there are in every food that we eat and virtually every product to which we expose ourselves. There will always be proteins from viruses and bacteria, because it’s those proteins that contain the antigens that provoke the preemptive immune response that vaccines are designed to produce. The question to you is: Which specific toxins need to be removed and why? Please go back and read this before answering, though, because answers based on a misunderstanding of chemistry, pharmacology, and toxicology or on misinformation about what’s in vaccines don’t help clarify what “greening our vaccines” means, either. If you’re truly going to “green our vaccines,” you need to explain exactly what that means in scientific terms; otherwise it’s an impossible task. Scientists are funny that way. They need specifics.
We all want our vaccines to be as safe as humanly possible, but no matter what we do they will never, ever be absolutely, 100% safe. That’s an impossible standard. The reasonable and obtainable standard to which we strive is that vaccines should be far, far safer than the diseases against which they protect us, and they already meet this standard admirably. That is not to say that there isn’t always room for improvement. There is. However, there is also a point of diminishing returns, where each incremental increase in safety comes at an increasing cost. That’s the real world, and balancing relative risks and costs of the vaccination program or any medical screening or intervention program is what must be done in the real world. The demand for “100% safety” is a utopian ideal whose real, albeit unacknowledged, purpose is an excuse for not vaccinating at all. If we are to avoid a return to the bad old days, when epidemics of vaccine-preventable diseases wreaked suffering and death upon our populace, the misinformation and exaggerated claims of “toxicity” and harm due to vaccines must be countered with science-based information of the true benefits and risks of vaccination.

   In Jenny McCarthy’s own words
David Gorski
Link
Jenny McCarthy, regular readers of SBM know, has been a frequent target of criticism here. The reasons, of course, are very simple. She has become the most famous public face of the antivaccine movement, releasing a book every year or so since 2007 about how her son Evan has been “cured” of autism through the dubious biomedical treatments she’s given him and how it was vaccines that supposedly caused her son’s autism. Most recently, she’s releasing a paean to antivaccine views and autism quackery entitled Healing and Preventing Autism: A Complete Guide, co-authored by Dr. Jerry Kartzinel. Dr. Kartzinel, some may recall, wrote the foreword to Jenny McCarthy’s very first paean to autism quackery back in 2007 and was properly lambasted by Autism Diva and Kevin Leitch for writing
things like:
Autism, as I see it, steals the soul from a child; then, if allowed, relentlessly sucks life’s marrow out of the family members, one by one…”
Sometimes, in order to appreciate just how wrong antivaccinationist are, it’s best to let them speak in their own words. Nowhere recently have I seen a better example of this than in an interview with Jenny McCarthy published on the TIME Magazine website. In it, along with the usual invocation of the “toxins gambit” and appeals to anecdotal evidence over science, Jenny reveals that she clearly thinks it’s regrettable but acceptable that infectious diseases will return because of the efforts of her and her fellow antivaccine activists:
TIME: Your collaborator recommends that parents accept only the haemophilus influenzae type B (HIB) and tetanus vaccine for newborns and then think about the rest. Not polio? What about the polio clusters in unvaccinated communities like the Amish in the U.S.? What about the 2004 outbreak that swept across Africa and Southeast Asia after a single province in northern Nigeria banned vaccines?
JM: I do believe sadly it’s going to take some diseases coming back to realize that we need to change and develop vaccines that are safe. If the vaccine companies are not listening to us, it’s their fucking fault that the diseases are coming back. They’re making a product that’s shit. If you give us a safe vaccine, we’ll use it. It shouldn’t be polio versus autism.
Words fail me. Rare, I know, but the above statement is just too much. That’s right. Jenny accepts zero culpability for her role in frightening parents about vaccines and thus driving down the vaccination rate. In Jenny’s warped world, your children are acceptable collateral damage in the cause of promoting her unscientific belief that vaccines cause autism.
Here’s a hint for you, Jenny: We already do have vaccines that are safe. The government is listening to you and your fellow antivaccine activists far more than your pseudoscientific nonsense deserves and even though you are a scientific illiterate. They do it because you and your fellow antivaccine activists whose public face you have become are endangering public health on the basis of no good science, and they are trying to prevent that. Indeed, scientists continue to waste millions of dollars studying over and over again the question of whether vaccines are associated with autism and keep finding the same answer: They aren’t. It’s a no-lose situation for you. No matter how many studies exonerate vaccines as a cause of autism, you can simply say you don’t believe them. You can blithely dismiss them as “unconvincing” or as manipulated by big pharma even though you can’t understand them and have no scientific basis to dismiss them. Then you can repeat your tired demand for more studies, which in turn inevitably find the same result, after which you dismiss them again and ask for still more studies. If vaccine-preventable diseases come roaring back because your movement has frightened parents into not vaccinating, you can simply blame the government and pharmaceutical companies because they haven’t produced a vaccine to your imagined and unattainable standard of safety (i.e., absolutely 100% safe), rather than taking responsibility for own actions dissuading parents from vaccinating and accepting your share of the responsibility.
In fact, you are being completely disingenuous when you say that “if you give us a safe vaccine we’ll use it.” The reason is that you have made it very clear that no vaccine will ever be safe enough for you and that no amount of evidence will separate you from your antivaccine pseudoscience. Regardless of how much evidence is presented, how many times studies are repeated only to find the same result, to you your Google University “education” spent reading from the dark underbelly of antivaccinationist websites and blogs will always trump science. Always. Because of the arrogance of ignorance, you and your puppetmasters always find a way to move the goalposts back yet again and always will. Clearly, you no longer even care how much of a body count your activities may rack up.
Neither does TIME Magazine, apparently.
One last thing. Jenny describes her son Evan as having been handed to her “pre-vaccinated with a bandaid on his foot.” No vaccine that I’m aware of is given in the foot. The Band Aid® on Evan’s foot was almost certainly from routine blood tests done on all newborns via heel stick, like PKU screening. I think that quote alone shows you all you need to know about Jenny’s medical knowledge.

   Welcome back, my friends, to the show that never ends: The Jenny and Jim antivaccine propaganda tour has begun
David Gorski
Link
As hard as it is to believe, 2009 started out very promising from the perspective of actually countering the misinformation of the antivaccine movement. Antivaccine hero Andrew Wakefield, who with the help of the credulous and sensationalistic media started the entire MMR-autism scare in the U.K. a decade ago, was revealed as not just having been in the pocket of trial lawyers suing vaccine manufacturers and having been an incompetent scientist but as a scientific fraud, thanks to the investigative tenacity of Brian Deer. Thanks to Wakfield, the measles, once declared conquered in the U.K. in the mid-1990s, has come roaring back to the point where it has been declared endemic again by the ealth Protection Agency (HPA), the public health body of England and Wales. This was rapidly followed by the rejection by the Special Masters of the Vaccine Court of the claims of all the test cases in the Autism Omnibus case. It was a one-two body blow to the antivaccine movement.
Unfortunately, the antivaccine movement is nothing if not resilient. After all, the science has consistently been against each of its favorite claims, namely that the mercury in the thimerosal used as a preservative in vaccines or that the MMR vaccine causes autism. They simply move the goalposts and pivoted effortlessly to much harder to falsify ideas, such as blaming “toxins” in vaccines or proclaiming that our current vaccine schedule is “too many too soon.” After scientific setback after scientific setback that have revealed the antivaccine movement to be nothing more than the 2009 equivalent of creationists or the flat Earth movement, why would it matter to them that Andrew Wakefield has been thoroughly discredited and their signature legal action, the Autism Omnibus, has gone donw in flames? It doesn’t. Certainly it didn’t stop David Kirby from duping Keith Olbermann into chastising Brian Deer for nonexistent conflicts of interest; a group proclaiming loudly “We Support Dr. Andrew Wakefield” with a petition; David Kirby, Generation Rescue, and Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. from trying to distract attention from the defeat of the antivaccine movement in the Autism Omnibus ruling; or Andrew Wakefield himself from “complaining” to a press board about Brian Deer’s alleged misbehavior and errors. After all, science doesn’t matter to the antivaccine movement.
So, right on schedule to coincide with the start of Autism Awareness Month, as it has done every year since at least 2007 the antivaccine movement has begun a propaganda tour in order to coopt the term “autism awareness” for its own purpose of blaming vaccines for autism and proclaiming that various forms of quackery can “cure” autism. Indeed, this movement clearly wants to corrupt the term “autism awareness” to mean “antivaccine awareness,” and unfortunately it appears to be succeeding. Key to this effort in 2009 is a brand spankin’ new book by Jenny McCarthy and her “biomedical” guru Dr. Jerry Kartzinel, entitled Healing and Preventing Autism: A Complete Guide. The media blitz started even before Autism Awareness Month began, and I’ve already alluded to the despicable new message that appears to have become Jenny’s mantra (and thus that of the antivaccine movement for which she is the spokesmodel), namely, “It’s not my fault if vaccine-preventable diseases come back; it’s the pharmaceutical companies’ fault for not making ‘safer’ vaccines. Oh, and, by the way, we decide what’s ‘safe.’” Never mind that what makes vaccines “unsafe” to Jenny is based on a discredited idea that scientific study after scientific study has roundly refuted, namely that they cause autism.
Unfortunately, that isn’t all. As the U.K. media aided and abetted the MMR scare in the late 1990s until today, the U.S. media is aiding and abetting the antivaccine scare being promoted by Generation Rescue through its celebrity spokespersons Jenny McCarthy and Jim Carrey. The TIME Magazine interview to which I referred was just the beginning. Get a load of her on Larry King Live last Friday, along with Dr. Kartzinel and J.B. Handley, the same venue where almost exactly a year ago, in her arrogance of ignorance, McCarthy shouted down vaccine scientists on the air, yelling “bullshit!” at them three times. Truly, Larry King is as credulous as they come. The transcript is here, and J.B. Handley wrote a guest post for the Larry King Live blog, entitled Autism is Preventable and Reversible.
There is so much misinformation in the interview and in J.B. Handley’s blog post that it’s hard to know where to start. In fact, I could write a whole series of blog posts, like co-blogger Kimball Atwood, on just this interview and the new misinformation added to the old misinformation being peddled by the antivaccine movement; instead, I’ll be more selective, and readers should feel free to chime in with anything I’ve missed. Now, let’s start with two of the antivaccine movement’s favorite propaganda points:
KING: But you had a major effect, big story in the “L.A. Times” last week, the number of kids not being vaccinated in the public schools in Los Angeles. However at the same time, doctor friend told me today. Mumps are up and measles are up.
CARREY: We are not saying don’t vaccinate. That’s the thing we want to get really clear right now with …
KING: Let’s make it clear.
MCCARTHY: Yeah, we’re not.
CARREY: This is the thing. There’s a lot of misdirection going on. We hear the Campbell Browns and people like this that are saying, you can’t not vaccinate. No one has ever suggested not vaccinating.
MCCARTHY: Go back to 1989 schedule when shots were only 10 and the MMR was on that list. I don’t know what happened in 1990, there was no plague that was killing children that we had to triple the amount of vaccines.
CARREY: What happened back in 1989 that warranted 26 more vaccines?
MCCARTHY: Greed.
CARREY: Are all of them absolutely necessary?
KING: Because they want to make money?
MCCARTHY: Of course.
The first antivaccine propaganda point is the claim that Generation Rescue, Jenny McCarthy, Jim Carrey, and J.B. Handley (and by association, the entire antivaccine movement) are not “antivaccine.” That is easily demonstrated to be false (1, 2, 3). Another thread arguing for the disingenuousness of Jenny and Jim in proclaiming themselves to be “not antivaccine” is how the mouthpiece of Generation Rescue (excuse me, “Jenny McCarthy and Jim Carrey’s Autism Organization“), the Age of Autism blog, has such a major, unrelenting focus on vaccines. Indeed, Age of Autism blogger Kim Stagliano recently rejoiced on that very blog that vaccination rates are falling in other parts of the world, crowing that “an educated consumer may be a vaccine company’s worst customer.” (More like a miseducated consumer is the antivaccine movement’s best dupe.) In a similar vein, another Age of Autism blogger, Kent Heckenlively, today asks “Are We Winning the Vaccine-Autism War?” and concludes that the antivaccine movement is winning, as he, like Stagliano, rejoices that the pockets of high levels of vaccine resistance recently reported in Sonoma and Marin counties in California occur in areas where the population is educated and aflluent. Both he and Stagliano seem to labor under the common delusion that education and affluence somehow guarantee an understanding of science; sadly, they do not. They also seem blissfully unaware that the Bay Area is a hotbed of New Age woo and that credulous acceptance of “alternative medicine” appears to be highly correlated with antivaccine views. Even more notably, in his discussion Heckenlively doesn’t even bother to repeat the usual Age of Autism/Generation Rescue mantra that “we are not antivaccine”; rather, he appears to embrace his inner antivaccinationist, in essence equating antivaccine views with the educated and affluent..
Finally, there’s the old “big pharma greed” gambit. No one here at SBM, arguably least of all me, believes that big pharma is on the side of angels, but I can’t help but make one observation. If vaccines are such a huge profit source, then one wonders why the number of pharmaceutical companies manufacturing vaccines has fallen so precipitously over the last two decades. It couldn’t be the low profit margins and fear of litigation, could it, a large part of that fear having been fueled by the antivaccine movent? Perish the thought! And if vaccination rates fall, big pharma is a convenient scapegoat. Perish forbid that anyone would blame the falling vaccination rates in parts of the country on the efforts of Jenny and her merry band of antivaccinationists:
KING: Isn’t the problem here, Jenny, that people sometimes listen with one ear are going to panic. And not vaccine at all?
MCCARTHY: Probably. But guess what? It’s not my fault. The reason why they’re not vaccinating is because the vaccines are not safe. Make a better product and then parents will vaccinate.
CARREY: We’re not the problem. The problem is the problem.
“The problem is the problem”? How Zen of Carrey.
Actually, the problem is Mr. Carrey and Ms. McCarthy, who are both so full of the arrogance of ignorance that they think they understand the science and medicine of autism and vaccines after studying at Google University; indeed, they seem to think they understand it better than scientists who have spent their entire adult life studying such questions. They’re also completely unwilling to take responsibility for their actions.
Clearly, we’re going to be hearing a lot more of this, as this appears to be the standard Generation Rescue talking point for Jenny to parrot whenever anyone asks her if she feels any responsibility for declining vaccination rates, which in California has produced pockets of vaccine noncompliance that are poised to result in huge outbreaks of vaccine-preventable disease. That’s why this is a mantra that needs to be rebutted at every opportunity. To a large extent, the declining vaccination rate is Jenny’s fault, and J.B. Handley’s fault and Jim Carrey’s fault and Andrew Wakefield’s fault and that of every other antivaccine activist who uses misinformation, pseudoscience, and logical fallacies to frighten parents into thinking that vaccines cause autism. The only reason they try to deny that it is is because they are finally realizing that their actions have consequences and that one of those consequences will be to be seen as the cause of the return of vaccine-preventable disease. Truly, renaming the antivaccine movement to the pro-disease movement sounds more and more appropriate to me.
The most important revelation on JJJ’s appearance (Jenny, Jim, and JB’s appearance) on Larry King Live is that Generation Rescue has come up with one more brand new antivaccine propaganda tool. Before I discuss it, I’d like to take a trip down memory lane to an ad that Generation Rescue placed in USA Today in 2008. The ad showed the vaccine schedule in 1983 and compared it to that of 2008, while making the claim that the increase from 10 vaccines to 36 is the cause of the “autism epidemic. My “friend” Orac had something to say about this claim:
A lot of other things have happened since 1983 as well. For example, in the early 1990s, the diagnostic criteria for autism were broadened, and campaigns for greater awareness were begun. Diagnoses of autism in 1983 were made using the DSM-III, where the criteria for an autism diagnosis were much more restrictive than those in the DSM-IV, released in the early 1990s. Moreover, in 1983, categories of Asperger’s and pervasive developmental disorder-not otherwise specified, both of which are lumped into the 1 in 150 figure for 2008, weren’t recognized in the DSM-III. Of course, if I wanted to be snarky (and perish forbid that I would ever be snarky), I could point out that 1981 was the year that the IBM PC was released, followed by the Apple Macintosh in 1984, both of which led to the exponential growth of households owning and using personal computers. That’s it! It must be computer use that led to the increase in autism in the 25 years since 1983! Wait, what about the compact disc? It just so happens that 1983 is the year that the CD was first released in the American market. Ergo, it must be CDs that cause autism.
I could go on, but you get my point. A lot of other things have happened since 1983, but to Jenny McCarthy, J. B. Handley, and their assorted antivax fanatics it has to be those evil vaccines. It just has to be.
I consider Generation Rescue’s new gambit to be simply a cleverer version of the very same fallacy, with a heaping helping of the “correlation equals causation” fallacy thrown in for good measure:
MCCARTHY: The vaccine schedule is too bloated right now. Thirty six shots right now. Back in 1989, the shot schedule was 10 shots given.
CARREY: Ten shots given.
KING: When I was a kid, what did we get, three?
CARREY: It’s twice as many as anywhere else in 30 countries in the Western World. We give twice as many shots as any of those countries. Why is that?
This point is made in more detail in J.B. Handley’s guest post:
Few parents appreciate that American kids are the most vaccinated on the planet. Generation Rescue just released a study called “Autism and Vaccines Around the World” which will surprise many. We looked at the vaccine schedules of 30 other first world countries to compare how many doses of vaccines children receive. What did we find? Compared to our 36, the average for the rest of the first world is 18, or half of the U.S. schedule. Perhaps more shocking, we looked at countries with the lowest rates of mortality for children under 5 (the U.S. ranks a disappointing 34th, behind Cuba and Slovenia). How many vaccines do the 5 countries with the lowest under 5 mortality rates give? Well, Iceland, Sweden, Singapore, Japan, and Norway give 11, 11, 13, 11, and 13 vaccines respectively – all less than 1/3 the number of vaccines the U.S. mandates!
How do autism rates compare in some of these other countries? Iceland’s rate is 1 in 1,000, Finland’s 1 in 700, and Sweden’s 1 in 800. These countries give 1/3 the vaccines we do and have autism rates that are as little as one-tenth of ours? Something isn’t right.
Indeed, this is the very theme of a “study” posted on the Age of Autism blog entitled Autism and Vaccines Around The World: Vaccine Schedules, Autism Rates and Under 5 Mortality. If you look at the actual PDF containing the report, you’ll see that it’s obviously intentionally designed to look very much like an actual research report. The type, the format, and the style very closely mimic that of a real research paper. Of course, it is not anything of the sort, and if it were submitted to any halfway decent peer-reviewed journal of psychiatry or–even more so–of epidemiology it would find its way into the cylindrical file, possibly even before being sent out for peer review. It’s nothing more than the logical fallacy of confusing correlation with causation taken to a ridiculous extreme and then prettied up with all sorts of “science-y”-sounding jargon in an attempt to put the proverbial lipstick on the proverbial pig. Whoever put this “study” together at Generation Rescue clearly has no clue how to write such a study up, much less how to do one.
The first thing that struck me about this “study” was how poorly written it was. It looked slapped together, and, although it states that a “full publication and literature review was completed to determine vaccine schedules and under 5 mortality rates for 30 countries. What, exactly, does that mean? If you read any meta-analysis or serious review, you’ll see a careful and precise description of the criteria used to choose studies to include. No such description is given here. One is left with the distinct impression that a bit of cherry picking is going on here.
The second thing that leapt out at me is that there was absolutely no attempt to control for confounders. Indeed, one commenter on Age of Autism, responding to another commenter who pointed out that zero controlling for confounders was even attempted said:
Confounding factors? Since when is that ever a consideration? Perhaps you watch too much television and, based on dispropotionately biased coverage, think every parent in America whacks their kids on the head then stuffs them in the trunk.
These are babies under five.
Against such ignorance, the gods themselves contend in vain. The very reason it’s so easy to confuse correlation with causation, even in epidemiological studies that are testing a hypothesis rather than trying to support a preordained conclusion, is because of confounders, and, yes, it is completely irrelevant that these children are under five.
The reasons why the U.S. ranks 34th in childhood mortality is a topic of some controversy and considerable study and discussion. Of course, one wonders why Generation Rescue used the UN World Population Prospects The 2006 Revision when the 2008 Revision is easily available. (Apparently Generation Rescue can’t Google). (It couldn’t be because the under-five mortality rate in the U.S. fell from 7.8/1,000 live births to 7.3 between 2006 and 2008, could it?) Be that as it may, while the Generation Rescue “study” appears to be claiming that vaccines don’t have any relationship to overall childhood mortality, that’s completely the wrong question to be asking because vaccines do not prevent anything other than infectious disease. If we take a look, for example, the 2008 State of the World’s Mothers Report issued by Save the Children, we find some very interesting things, among which is the effect of disparities in health care among the poor, mostly black and Native American, and the better off sustaining our high child mortality compared to that of other developed nations. That’s one huge confounder. Another huge confounder is access to health care; many of the nations mentioned in the Generation Rescue report are nations with universal health care. Whether that drives the difference is a matter of controversy (given the politically charged nature of the discussions of universal health care, how coudl it be otherwise?) but it is yet another huge potential confounder. Of course, the biggest confounder of all is that childhood mortality has been falling in the U.S. for the last two decades. Add to that gun violence and other causes of childhood mortality that are elevated in the U.S. compared to other industrialized nations, and there are so many confounders as to make any inference from these raw numbers utterly meaningless. Again, vaccines only prevent death from infectious disease.
There is also at least one curious omission in the last table (Table 3), which was pointed out, surprisingly enough, by a commenter on Age of Autism. (And when a commenter in the antivaccine echo chamber that it Age of Autism points out a glaring hole in a Generation Rescue propaganda release, you know it’s a really huge hole! This commenter also pointed out that there was not even the most rudimentary attempt to control for counfounders. Truly, this propaganda stinkpile of a “study” is too stinky for any but the most brainwashed of Generation Rescue’s adherents.) Specifically, the U.K. was left out, which is listed as requiring 20 vaccines. That is close to France, which is listed as requiring 17 vaccines. One wonders if this omission is because the U.K. has an autism prevalence comparable to that of the U.S., possibly even higher. I wonder why Generation Rescue left the U.K. out of its last table, purporting to show the relationship between the number of vaccines a nation mandates and its autism rate. After all, the paper claims that it picked countries based on “materially lower levels of mandated vaccines and published autism prevalence data.” I could see where it might be hard to find publications with estimates of autism prevalence in, for example, Cuba, but it’s not as though recent estimates of autism prevalence in the U.K. aren’t readily available. Some “complete” literature search! Given the blatant “forgetting” of an example that most definitely does not support the “hypothesis” of the Generation Rescue paper, I also now wonder why only eight out of the 30 countries examined were chosen for inclusion in Table 3. You don’t think that Generation Rescue left the U.K. out of Table 3 because it didn’t fit with its hypothesis, do you? Unfortunately, I didn’t have time to go searching for all the prevalence data for the countries left out, but it wouldn’t surprise me at all if there were a few more U.K.’s in there.
Even curiouser (well, not really) are the sources used for all the prevalence data. Specifically, the dates of the studies are what stood out to me. Many of them are from the 1990s, and most are from before 2001. Given the increases in awareness, the broadening of the diagnostic criteria that occurred in the 1900s, using these prevalence estimates is meaningless. I could also point out that in the 1990s, the U.S. had a vaccination schedules with considerably fewer vaccines. Table 1 shows that! It would appear that Generation Rescue can’t even keep its story straight in its own study. In any case, comparing a vaccine schedule in 2006 (which is what Generation Rescue did in all cases) with prevalence rates from 5 to 10 years earlier taken from a period of time shortly after the diagnostic criteria had been changed is clueless at best and intellectually dishonest at worst, particularly when it’s done in the context of no effort to control for confounders, no statistical analysis, in essence nothing that any scientist or epidemiologist taking a serious look at the question would consider a minimum effort. In essence, because whoever at Generation Rescue passionately believes that (1) vaccines aren’t nearly as protective as we know them to be and (2) vaccines cause autism, this report ignores all other possible explanations for the numbers and, in fact, doesn’t even pick the right numbers to answer the question. I suppose that if these numbers had been properly picked for valid comparisons one might be able to view them as hypothesis-generating, but so many other studies have specifically looked at the question of whether vaccines cause autism using sufficient numbers to have the power to detect even a weak association and the correct epidemiologial and statistical techniques to analyze the data that throwing this sort of whole population data out as though it were “proof” of anything shows nothing more than how completely ignorant of science whoever wrote it is.
Of course, Generation Rescue isn’t really interested in accurate estimates of autism prevalence, as Sullivan has pointed out:
One of the problems with the vaccines-cause-autism groups is that they really don’t advocate for people with autism. They have abandoned entirely people of low income and minorities (except where they can be used for political gain).
It isn’t just that groups like SafeMinds, Generation Rescue and the rest can’t be bothered to spend the time worrying about minorities or adults. It’s the fact that the data those groups use to support the “epidemic” makes ZERO sense when you consider minorities.
Consider this: the “rate” of autism is 0.3 per 1,000 for Hispanics in Wisconsin, but 10.6 for Whites in New Jersey.
Why isn’t Generation Rescue calling for an investigating the Hispanics of Wisconsin? Shouldn’t they want to know what is “protecting” that subgroup from autism?
They don’t care, they don’t want to bring attention to the Hispanics in Wisconsin (or the under represented minorities across the nation), because it blows a big hole in the “epidemic”. Obviously we still aren’t counting all the people with autism in our prevalence estimates. How can we rely on the historical data that shows an “epidemic” if we aren’t doing a good job even now?
The Generation Rescue “study” is another instance of this very phenomenon, except that it even ignored a wealthy nation (the U.K.) because its autism prevalence data didn’t fit in with its conclusion that vaccines cause autism and that nations with lower numbers of mandated vaccines should therefore have lower autism prevalence. The study also completely ignored the far more likely reason why the United States has such an embarrassing level of childhood mortality: Poverty and disparities in care. That’s because, as Sullivan points out, groups like Generation Rescue are not interested in the poor or minorities, except when they are useful to their cause (Somali immigrants in Minnesota, for instance). All they are interested in is proving that vaccines cause autism. Whenever an antivaccinationist finds differences in autism prevalence, he ignores any other possible cause aside from the vaccines. That’s because, to J.B. Handley, Jenny McCarthy, Jim Carrey, and the rest of the antivaccine movement, first and foremost, it’s still all about the vaccines. It’s always been all about the vaccines. It always will be all about the vaccines. Always.
And when their efforts drive down the vaccination rate leading to outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases that cause children to suffer and even sometimes die, antivaccinationists will blame it on the pharmaceutical companies and governments for not having indulged their delusions to their satisfaction.
ADDENDUM: A reader was kind enough to point out to me that Bernadine Healy herself pointed out a lot of reasons why comparing childhood mortality in the U.S. with that in various European countries is fraught with confounders, making head-to-head comparisons of dubious value in many cases. The irony! I guess she must have forgotten her Newsweek article from two and a half years ago.

   The anti-vaccine movement strikes back against Dr. Paul Offit
David Gorski
Link
In my five years in the blogosphere, two years blogging for SBM, and over a decade in Internet discussion forums about medicine and “alternative” medicine, I’ve learned a few things. One thing that I’ve learned is that one of the biggest differences between those whose world view is based on science and who therefore promote science-based medicine and those promoting pseudoscience, quackery, and anti-science is that science inculcates in its adherents a culture of free, open, and vigorous debate. Indeed, to outsiders, this debate can seem (and sometimes is) vicious. In other words, if you’re going to be a scientist, you need to have a thick skin because you will have to defend your hypotheses and conclusions, sometimes against some very hostile other scientists. That same attitude of a Darwinian struggle between scientific ideas, with only those best supported by evidence and with the most explanatory power surviving, is a world view that those not steeped in science have a hard time understanding.
Among those who don’t understand science, few have a harder time with the rough-and-tumble debate over evidence and science that routinely goes on among scientists than those advocating pseudoscience. Indeed, in marked contrast to scientists, they tend to cultivate cultures of the echo chamber. Examples abound and include discussion forums devoted to “alternative” medicine like CureZone, where never is heard a discouraging word — because anyone expressing too much skepticism about the prevailing view on such forums invariably finds himself first shunned by other members of the discussion forums and then, if he persists, booted from the forum by the moderators. In marked contrast, on skeptical forums, most of the time almost anything goes. True, the occasional supporter of woo who finds his way onto a skeptical forum will face a lot of criticism, some of it brutal. However, rarely will such a person be banned, unless he commits offenses unrelated to his questioning of scientific dogma, such as insulting or abusive behavior towards other forum participants or trolling. Such people may annoy the heck out of us skeptics sometimes, but on the other hand, they do actually from time to time challenge us to defend our science and prevent us from becoming too complacent. Indeed, that’s what I like about skeptics and being a scientist. Nothing or no one is sacred.
In marked contrast, supporters of pseudoscience are very much characterized by their aversion to scientific debate. The reason is obvious. They don’t have the goods. (If they did, what they’re advocating wouldn’t be pseudoscience.) They can’t win on science, reason, and evidence. The result is that they often end up forming communities that exist more to support their pseudoscience than to discover what does and does not actually work. Indeed, Prometheus describes this phenomenon well as he’s seen it in “autism biomed” discussion forums.
The same sort of group dynamics occurs in forums like CureZone and many others. Those who try to apply science and skepticism to the prevailing dogma of the group usually end up banned or give up in disgust. Indeed, at the anti-vaccine crank blog Age of Autism, comments are ruthlessly censored, and anyone who disagrees too strongly with the prevailing “wisdom” that vaccines cause autism will soon find himself or herself permanently banned. One consequence of this can be that the adherents of such views become progressively less able to defend their views in an evidence- and science-based argument, because they simply aren’t used to having them challenged based on evidence and science. Indeed some no longer even know how to react to criticism other than by lashing out. We’ve seen this before on this very blog, where anti-vaccine activist J.B. Handley lashed out at Steve Novella, while from time to time various anti-vaccine activists, J.B. Handley included, and promoters of pseudoscience and quackery periodically launch prolonged ad hominem attacks on me1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10.
Another consequence is that promoters of unscientific and anti-scientific “medical” modalities have a tendency to be lawsuit-happy. We at SBM have written about this time and time again, both here and on individual bloggers’ blogs. The most recent and famous victim of this tendency is Simon Singh, who is being sued by the British Chiropractic Association for pointing out that there is no evidence behind their claims to be able to treat allergies and colic and quite correctly characterized such claims as “bogus.” Thanks to Britain’s notoriously plaintiff-friendly libel laws, Singh is fighting an uphill battle, too, and may very well lose. Fortunately, his case has become a cause célèbre, and Sense About Science has rallied public opinion in his favor and, more importantly, of reforming the U.K.’s antiquated anti-free speech libel laws — please sign the petition. However, Singh’s case is simply the most famous current example of how promoters of pseudoscience try to suppress criticism with legal threats or action. There have been several others before, including Andy Lewis of Quackometer, whose ISP caved in to legal threats from the highly dubious Dr. Joseph Chikelue Obi (who bills himself as the “world’s top expert in nutritional immunomudulation“). This came on hot on the heels of legal thuggery directed against him by the Society of Homeopaths. In both of these cases, the attempted legal action backfired spectacularly, as dozens, perhaps hundreds, of bloggers republished the posts verbatim that the Society of Homeopaths and “Dr.” Obi had successfully suppressed. Another example includes Kathleen Seidel, who was subject to a frivolous and punitive subpoena by lawyer Clifford Shoemaker, who is well known for bringing lawsuits based on the pseudoscience that vaccines cause autism. Fortunately, Shoemaker overreached and was forced to retreat in shame.
And I haven’t even mentioned über-quack Matthias Rath trying to silence Ben Goldacre through litigation
The most recent flavor of anti-science groups using the law to silence critics seems to be anti-vaccine activists. And, I’m sad to report that this time around it is Barbara Loe Fisher of the organization with the most Orwellian name, the National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC), who is suing Dr. Paul Offit; Amy Wallace, who quoted him in her excellent article published in WIRED Magazine in October (for which J.B. Handley launched misogynistic attacks on her); and Condé Naste, WIRED’s publisher. Here is the legal complaint (scrubbed of home addresses of the private parties involved).
This is not the first time an anti-vaccine activist has sued Dr. Offit. Just last year, Handley sued Dr. Paul Offit for a passage in his 2008 book Autism’s False Prophets, which included highly unflattering portraits (and, in my opinion, justifiably so) of anti-vaccinationists like Mr. Handley, including a discussion of a threatening post by Handley posted to an anti-vaccine mailing list, in which he said to the “neurodiverse folks monitoring this list”:
We will bring the full resources of myself and Generation Rescue to stop this. We will sue you for libel and we will go after your homes and assets. My lawyers live to investigate and sue people like you.
This, of course, sums up the attitude of all too many anti-science activists. They can’t win on the science; so they try to suppress criticism through legal action. Sadly, it’s their most potent weapon, certainly far more potent than any scientific argument they can come up with, given that even in the relatively defendant-friendly U.S. libel suits can be so intimidating that they will effectively silence criticism.
I don’t know enough of the details of the suit to determine whether Handley’s case had any merit or not, and I’m not a lawyer anyway. I tend to doubt that it did. Regardless of the merit of his suit (or, more probably, the lack thereof), I am pretty sure I have deduced Handley’s intent, as his e-mail and postings on AoA certainly leave no doubt as to his attitude. I also know that it’s very interesting that, as Squillo points out, Handley’s lawsuit was not filed on the basis of libel, but rather on “false light invasion of privacy” rather than for libel (a form of defamation), probably because false light is less well-defined than libel and easier to prevail on, perhaps as a result of Dr. Offit’s lawyer’s response. Whatever the case, Dr. Offit and his lawyers decided to settle rather than fight, with the settlement being an apology, an agreement to correct the passage in dispute, and a $5,000 donation to one of Jenny McCarthy’s favored autism charities, all of which to me sounds very much like a token settlement. I may be totally wrong about this, but my guess is that Dr. Offit just didn’t want to go through the pain of a full trial, which is, of course, the point of such legal actions; being sued is painful for anyone, and many decide it’s easier to cave than to fight, even when they have a strong case. My second guess is that Handley may have had just enough of a case plus a set of pockets deep enough to make a lot of trouble but probably not a good enough case to have had a high likelihood of prevailing if it had gone to trial. Otherwise, given his visceral hatred of Dr. Offit, I highly doubt that Handley would have agreed to such a tiny token settlement. (Another possibility to be considered is that Handley didn’t really want Generation Rescue and himself to be subject to discovery regarding the incidents at the heart of the disputed passage had the legal case moved forward.) On the other hand, Offit’s settling is a huge propaganda victory for Handley, which he has been trumpeting on his blog.
Unfortunately, Handley’s apparent success appears to have emboldened other anti-vaccine activists, and this, I suspect, is why Barbara Loe Fisher likely decided that she might be able to cause Dr. Offit some trouble. So cause him trouble she did by suing over this passage from Amy Wallace’s article:
Paul Offit has a slightly nasal voice and a forceful delivery that conspire to make him sound remarkably like Hawkeye Pierce, the cantankerous doctor played by Alan Alda on the TV series M*A*S*H. As a young man, Offit was a big fan of the show (though he felt then, and does now, that Hawkeye was “much cooler than me”). Offit is quick-witted, funny, and — despite a generally mild-mannered mien — sometimes so assertive as to seem brash. “Scientists, bound only by reason, are society’s true anarchists,” he has written — and he clearly sees himself as one. “Kaflooey theories” make him crazy, especially if they catch on. Fisher, who has long been the media’s go-to interview for what some in the autism arena call “parents rights,” makes him particularly nuts, as in “You just want to scream.” The reason? “She lies,” he says flatly.
“Barbara Loe Fisher inflames people against me. And wrongly. I’m in this for the same reason she is. I care about kids. Does she think Merck is paying me to speak about vaccines? Is that the logic?” he asks, exasperated. (Merck is doing no such thing). But when it comes to mandating vaccinations, Offit says, Fisher is right about him: He is an adamant supporter.
Regular readers may have noticed that I almost never accuse anyone of lying. The reason is that I tend to believe that most anti-vaccine activists really and truly believe in their pseudoscience. Consequently, when they spread misinformation and outright nonsense, they are not technically lying, at least not most of the time, because they have no clue that what they are saying is false. Indeed, although I do not know the specifics upon which Dr. Offit based his claim that Loe Fisher “lies” (although having read some of the vitriolic attacks on Dr. Offit by members of the anti-vaccine movement I can certainly understand why he might come to that conclusion), I do know that she is profoundly wrong about the science of vaccines and, utterly impervious to any science contradicting her viewpoint, spreads misinformation, so much so that whether Loe Fisher believes what she says or knows it to be false almost becomes a moot point when so much egregious misinformation and pseudoscience is spread against the backdrop of mountains of evidence showing that they are not scientifically valid. The end effect is more or less the same in a practical sense, although whether it is in a legal sense I do not know.
Even so, in her complaint Loe Fisher takes takes Jenny McCarthy’s disingenuous claim that she is “not anti-vaccine, but pro-safe vaccine” to whole new heights of bizarre contortion. I’ve written about this technique before. Fisher is very clever and couches her views in rhetoric of freedom and “informed consent.” Yet, it is very clear from the NVIC website what its true agenda is. For instance, there is a “memorial” for “vaccine victims,” which states:
They are the men, women, and children who have died or been injured by vaccines in nations around the world for the past 200 years. This is a virtual Memorial dedicated to those whose lives have been forever changed by vaccines they were often required by law to use.
And concludes:
Our hope is that, by honoring those who are casualties of mass vaccination policies, there will be greater public awareness of the need to value and care as much about those who are harmed by the complications of vaccines as we care about those who are harmed by the complications of infectious diseases. This International Memorial for Vaccine Victims is offered to the world as testimony of the need to protect the biological integrity of life on this planet.
The NVIC also runs a website called Stand Up! Be Counted!, which states: “No Forced Vaccination. Not in America.” It also uses common anti-vaccine tropes, such as confusing correlation with causation for the “autism epidemic.” Meanwhile the NVIC page about the H1N1 vaccine cites dubious studies on mercury in vaccines, in particular the discredited Hewitson study that I blogged about here and here. Then there’s the Vaccine Law Firm Directory she maintains of lawyers ready to sue for vaccine injury. But perhaps most telling of all is the recent NVIC conference, in which luminaries of the anti-vaccine fringe presented their views and “data,” and in which the man who started the fear that the MMR vaccine causes autism based on the shoddiest of science and whom Barbara Loe Fisher herself has vociferously defended, namely Andrew Wakefield, was given NVIC’s Humanitarian Award. The conference also included total cranks such as Gary Null, who is anti-vaccine to the core, an HIV/AIDS denialist, coffee enema advocate, and supporter of cancer quackery, and David Ayoub, whose claim to fame is that he thinks that mass vaccination programs are a plot by the Illuminati, complete with black helicopters. Quite frankly, from my point of view, if Barbara Loe Fisher isn’t anti-vaccine, she sure has an amazingly odd way of showing it. It would be very interesting to ask her whether there is anything or any evidence that could ever persuade her that vaccination is far safer than the diseases vaccinated against. I tend to doubt it, although I have no doubt, given her silver tongue, that she’d dance around the question quite skillfully, move the goal posts, or propose impossible-to-meet (in the real world, at least) standard of evidence.
My guess is that Loe Fisher’s lawsuit has very little to do with her reputation. After all, among real scientists knowledgeable about vaccination (as opposed to anti-vaccine “scientists” like Andrew Wakefield) her reputation is that of a promoter of pseudoscience; in other words, her only scientific reputation is a bad one. Moreover, among Loe Fisher’s core constituency, I highly doubt that Dr. Offit’s saying “she lies” about her would have any effect whatsoever on its opinion of her veracity, other than, perhaps, to make her fans love and believe her all the more. After all, in the circles that she travels, Dr. Offit is viewed as practically akin to Satan himself and routinely castigated as “Dr. Proffit.” However, having her veracity called into doubt by a real vaccine scientist could potentially hurt Loe Fisher in her efforts to win mainstream acceptance, and that is probably the real concern driving the lawsuit.
Another reason that Fisher’s frequent, impassioned, indignant denials that she is anti-vaccine are hard to believe is that she is very one-sided in her application of her appeals to freedom. She states over and over again that she is for “informed consent” and the right of parents to express “philosophical exemptions.” No doubt a libertarian argument could be made on political and philosophical grounds to support such a position. But, as PalMD shows, when a private institution decides that it will require that students be fully vaccinated according to the recommended schedule before they can attend school, suddenly Fisher isn’t so supportive of the whole freedom thing anymore. For example, when a Jewish school in Pittsburgh decided that it would not accept philosphical exemptions, would require that its students, other than those with legtimate medical exemptions, be fully vaccinated, and would not accept a letter from anyone other than a child’s primary care physician in order to grant a medical exemption, Fisher was most displeased:
According to Loe Fisher, the federal vaccine injury compensation program, established by the National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act of 1986, has paid more than $2 billion to families of children who have been injured or died as a result of vaccination.
“Vaccination should not be separated out from the informed consent paradigm,” she said.
Since the establishment of the CDC and American Academy of Pediatrics recommendations regarding vaccination requirements, Loe Fisher continued, families seeking medical exemption from vaccination have found it rough going.
Because it’s hard for a family to find a physician to provide a medical exemption, Loe Fisher said, many must rely on the religious or philosophical exemption, available in almost all states, to avoid vaccination.
She is not in favor of a private school refusing to accept those exemptions which are provided for by state law.
“It is questionable for a school to narrow those exemptions and not allow a parent who believes a child is at risk to take an exemption,” Loe Fisher said.
In other words, Fisher is against the government’s mandating vaccination before a child can attend school, public or private, but if the administration of a private school voluntarily decides without any government laws or pressure that it is going to require vaccination of its students before admission and not accept philosphical exemptions, she thinks that the government should have the power to enforce philosophical vaccine exemptions on it. Her advocacy of freedom with respect to vaccination is rather one-sided, don’t you think? After all, I bet Loe Fisher supports the right of private schools, such as Waldorf Schools, that do not require vaccination, often have high percentages of unvaccinated children, and, of late, have become incubators for outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases, not to require that their students be vaccinated. Thus, Loe Fisher’s support for “vaccine choice” except when it is the choice of a private institution to mandate vaccines casts her assertion in her complaint that she “does not seek to prohibit or advise against vaccination but to ensure that vaccination is voluntary and that it proceeds following fully informed consent” in a rather dubious light and contributes to the overall impression that she is in reality not a “vaccine safety” activist, but an anti-vaccine activist.
He’s also a flaming hypocrite. In my opinion, of course.
After having read her website and seen her quoted in many interviews, my bottom line opinion is that Barbara Loe Fisher is anti-vaccine. True, she’s good at cloaking what I consider to be her anti-vaccine views in rhetoric of “freedom” and “informed consent,” but whenever push comes to shove, she’s against vaccines and clearly thinks that they do more harm than good. Nowhere have I ever seen her say that she supports a single vaccination as routine. Not one. Her entire organization supports the scientifically discredited notion that vaccines cause autism and holds conferences with anti-vaccine speakers. It prominently has a web page linked to from its main page whose purpose is to provide a memorial for “vaccine victims.” It’s hard not to conclude from this that she is anti-vaccine.
Moreover, Barbara Loe Fisher is one to talk about libel, after what she said about Dr. Offit the very article by Amy Wallace over which she is suing:
Against this backdrop, Fisher, a skilled debater who often faces down articulate, well-informed scientists on live TV, mentioned Offit frequently. She called him the leading “pro-forced-vaccination proponent” and cast him as a man who walks in lockstep with the pharmaceutical companies and demonizes caring parents.
Maybe Dr. Offit should countersue for libel. It sounds as though he may have a case. After all, on the NVIC website, there is this little tidbit as well:
Offit’s attempt to exonerate DPT is part of a larger effort to convince the public – and drug company stockholders – that most vaccines, including his own, have no risks whatsoever.
I’d love to see Loe Fisher present evidence that Dr. Offit has ever said that most vaccines, including his own, have no risks whatsoever. But attacking Dr. Offit in such terms is not enough for Loe Fisher. As Kim Wombles points out, Loe Fisher sees her fight against vaccine mandates in apocalyptic terms, as she describes on the NVIC website:
The discrimination begins, always, with the majority in a society pointing the finger at a minority for somehow endangering the public health and welfare. Individuals in the minority group are singled out as different – ethnically, biologically, spiritually, morally – from the majority. The human impulse to fear, judge, marginalize or eliminate those different from the rest has left a blood soaked trail winding throughout the entire history of man from the Great Inquisition to the Holocaust; from the killing fields of Cambodia to Rwanda, Serbia and Tibet; while the persecution of those with leprosy, TB, AIDS, mental illness, and handicaps continues in every society.
Later in the same article, I found this quote by Loe Fisher likening Andrew Wakefield to a victim of the Inquisition:
I thought of the persecution of Andrew Wakefield, M.D., who is being punished by his British colleagues for daring to report an association between the MMR (measles-mumps-rubella) vaccine and neuroimmune dysfunction, including inflammatory bowel disease and autism. Like when the heads of heretics were impaled upon stakes on the Tower of London as a warning for all to see, the Wakefield inquisition is a spectacle designed to persuade all doctors contemplating questioning the safety of current mass vaccination policies to remain silent.
And this allusion to the Holocaust:
Holocaust survivor Elie Weisel has said “When you take an idea or a concept and turn it into an abstraction, that opens the way to take human beings and turn them, also, into abstractions.”
Individuals harmed by vaccines are not abstractions. They are human beings who deserve to be spared a lifetime of suffering rather than being thrown under the bus to prop up forced mass vaccination policies that fail to acknowledge biodiversity within the family of man.
When Barbara Loe Fisher likens the supporters of vaccination programs who correctly criticize her and those holding views similar to hers as “anti-vaccine” to Nazis or the Inquisition and their criticism to what the Nazis did to the Jews during the Holocaust or the Inquisition did to heretics, when she likens criticism of her stance on vaccines to the genocides in Cambodia and Rwanda, she shouldn’t be too surprised when a lot of people conclude that she is anti-vaccine, not pro-safe vaccine.
Just like those of the Society of Homeopaths, “Dr.” Obi, the British Chiropractors Association against Simon Singh, or Matthias Rath against Ben Goldacre, Loe Fisher’s lawsuit is also likely more about shutting up critics than it is about protecting her reputation. Clearly, Wallace’s article hurt the anti-vaccine movement. Moreover, if there’s one good thing about 2009, it’s that more and more mainstream media outlets stopped portraying the anti-vaccine movement as poor, persecuted parents and more and more portrayed it as a threat to public health based on pseudoscience, which it is. Yes, it’s true that individual stories from the movement can be very sad and compelling; many of these parents and their children have had a horribly rough time. However, we do not have to downplay their difficulties or insult them personally to point out that they are profoundly wrong based on science when they blame vaccines for their children’s autism and that their activities do represent a serious threat to public health. More and more reporters, like Trine Tsouderos and Amy Wallace, have come to realize that. Such reporters represent a threat. Moreover, demonizing these journalists online, as the anti-vaccine movement tried to do with Amy Wallace and Trine Tsouderos (the latter of whom was included in a Photoshopped collage with Steve Novella preparing to make a Thanksgiving feast of a baby), doesn’t work very well. That leaves lawsuits to intimidate those who would speak out and discourage other media outlets from writing similar stories.
I wonder. Sense About Science did a fantastic job of publicizing the Simon Singh libel case and using it to promote the need for reforming the U.K.’s libel laws. I wonder if it’s time for a similar movement right here in the U.S. to prevent promoters of pseudoscience from using the law to intimidate and harass defenders of science-based medicine. Although Dr. Offit probably has the financial means to defend himself, there are a lot of writers and bloggers who do not, should someone with deep pockets decide to try to silence them with a frivolous lawsuit. We definitely have a problem here, and I predict it’s going to get worse as pseudoscience movements like the anti-vaccine movement rightly become more and more marginalized.

   Autism’s false prophets revealed
David Gorski 
Link
In the brief time that Science-Based Medicine has existed, I’ve become known as the vaccine blogger of the group. True, Steve Novella sometimes posts about antivaccine pseudoscience and fear-mongering (unlike me, he’s even been directly attacked by David Kirby) and both Mark Crislip and Harriet Hall have each done one post about it, but, at least this far, hands down I’ve done more posts about the misinformation, pseudoscience, and outright quackery spread by antivaccine activists such as J. B. Handley’s Generation Rescue and his recently recruited empty-headed celebrity spokesperson Jenny McCarthy, not to mention a number of others who promote the resurgence of infectious disease by sowing doubts about the safety of the most effective weapon the mind of humans have ever devised against it. Truly, few uses of “alternative” medicine bother me as much as the antivaccine orientation of so much of the movement supporting it, a movement that has also led to all manner of “biomedical” treatments (quackery).
What you might not know is how I developed my interest in this particular area of dangerous pseudoscience. After all, I’m a cancer surgeon and an NIH-funded cancer investigator, not a pediatrician, immunologist, or neurologist. As hard as it is for me to believe, given that it seems today that I’ve always been refuting this nonsense, I only first discovered the antivaccine movement about three and a half years ago. True, I had been a regular on certain Usenet newsgroups for at least four or five years before that and had encountered antivaccinationists there before, but my contact with them online had been sporadic, and they seemed “out there” even in comparison to the usual run-of-the-mill alt-med maven. But then in the spring of 2005 I started to notice in a big way the cadre of pseudoscientists, parents of autistic children, and others who pushed the myth that thimerosal-containing vaccines or vaccines in general cause autism. Oddly enough, it started out with the Huffington Post, of all places. In May 2005, Arianna Huffington started a large group blog, chock full of famous pundits and celebrities writing blog posts. Within three weeks of its formation, I had noticed a very disturbing aspect of the Huffington Post, and that was that it appeared to be providing a major soapbox for antivaccinationists, including a post by Janet Grilo of Cure Autism Now, two posts by that propagandist of antivaccinationists David Kirby (with whom our fearless leader Steve Novella has managed to get into a bit of a tussle), and posts by that Santa Monica pediatrician to the children of the stars, Dr. Jay Gordon, a man who assiduously denies being “antivaccine” but parrots the most blatantly obvious talking points of the antivaccine movement and is currently best known as being the pediatrician for Jenny McCarthy’s son Evan. At the very least, Dr. Gordon is an apologist for the antivaccination movement, and he has become one of the “go-to” guys for the media looking for physicians who are “vaccine skeptics,” making numerous radio and TV appearances to promote his “skepticism.”
The next phase of my “awakening” to just how pervasive antivaccine fearmongering and pseudoscience were came when Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. wrote an incredibly dishonest and deceptive screed that got wide coverage in the summer of 2005. His article, called, charmingly enough, Deadly Immunity was a rehash of all the misinformation about thimerosal in vaccines and autism wrapped up with in a bow of conspiracy-mongering worthy of a 9/11 Truther with a penchant for quote-mining that would make a creationist blush. The article appeared simultaneously on Salon.com (which normally doesn’t publish such nonsense) and Rolling Stone, a magazine that really should stay away from science and stick to covering entertainment and politics. It was followed by a media blitz by RFK Jr. and antivaccine propagandist David Kirby, best known for his credulous treatment of the thimerosal/autism link, Evidence of Harm: Mercury in Vaccines and the Autism Epidemic: A Medical Controversy, published a few months before RFK, Jr.’s article, and his subsequent activities posting antivaccine nonsense on Huffington Post and, more recently, on the quackery-promoting antivaccine blog Age of Autism.
I’ve alluded to the fact before that I have quite a bit of blogging experience under another guise. Indeed, I’m sure many of the readers here know what that guise is. Suffice it to say that at the time I prefaced a post about RFK, Jr.’s article by saying that Salon.com had “flushed its credibility down the toilet” and referred to the article itself as the “the biggest, steamingest, drippiest turd Salon.com has ever published.” Clearly (and fortunately), I use much less–shall we say?–colorful language on this blog, but I bring this up so that the reader knows where I am coming from. Indeed, since that time in the summer of 2005, I’ve been wondering when scientists, public health officials, and physicians supporting science-based medicine would finally wake up and start to push back against this tide of antivaccine nonsense, which is starting to result in the resurgence of measles and other vaccine-preventable diseases. This year, I’ve seen some hopeful signs, including organizations like Voices for Vaccines and Every Child By Two, as well as other signs of push-back against the antivaccine movement, which, I hate to admit, has been clearly winning the P.R. war. What there hasn’t been yet is a book written from a scientific viewpoint that directly addresses the history of the recent resurgence of the antivaccine movement and refutes the pseudoscience that it promotes.
Until now, that is.
Released earlier this month is a direct shot across the bow of the antivaccine movement in the form of a book by vaccine scientist and physician Dr. Paul Offit of the University of Pennsylvania’s Childen’s Hospital of Philadelphia, a man whom the antivaccine movement views as an unholy combination of Hitler, Stalin, Mao, Darth Vader, and Satan Incarnate because of his staunch advocacy of vaccines and his willingness to stand up to the antivaccine movement. The book is entitled Autism’s False Prophets: Bad Science, Risky Medicine, and the Search for a Cure. Overall it is an excellent primer on the subject and should be required reading for anyone curious about how the antivaccine movement became so pervasive and powerful.
The book begins with a rather interesting choice for a quote:
When religion was strong and science weak, men mistook magic for medicine. Now, when science is strong and religion weak, men mistake medicine for magic.
– Tomas Szasz
Actually, I would quibble about whether religion is actually weak these days. In this country, at least, fundamentalist religion, in particular fundamentalist Christianity, seems stronger than ever, permeating society so thoroughly that it is unthinkable that an atheist President will be elected in my lifetime. Elsewhere, fundamentalist Islam and other religions hold sway. Later in the book Dr. Offit makes the connection between religion and the antivaccine movement, which strikes me as a bit incongruous with this quote. However, the quote does characterize quite succinctly that what we are dealing with in the antivaccine movement is not science. Rather it is more akin to religion, because scientific evidence exonerating vaccines as a cause of autism rarely changes the minds of adherents to the antivaccine faith.
One thing I was not aware of is just how much Dr. Offit has been harassed by antivaccine zealots because of his advocacy for vaccination. He lays it all out right from the very first passage in the book:
I get a lot of hate mail.
Every week people send letters and e-mails calling me “stupid,” “callous,” an “SOB,” or “a prostitute.” People ask, “how in the world can you put money before the health of someone’s baby?” or “How can you sleep at night?” or “Why did you sell your soul to the devil?” They say “I don’t have a conscience,” am “directly responsible for the death and damage of hundreds of children,” and “have blood on [my] hands.” They “pray that the love of Christ will one day flood [my] darkened heart.” They warn that my “day of reckoning is coming.”
Dr. Offit then describes how he became interested in pediatrics and vaccines and the path that led him to become an infectious disease specialist studying vaccines, describing in moving terms one child he took care of who died of a rotavirus infection and how that led him into his current work. Fairly conventional stuff, but it’s necessary to understand where Dr. Offit’s coming from. He then goes on to describe how he became an advocate for vaccines in the 1990s and how that led to his daily vilification. (Just search Age of Autism if you want to get a flavor of the sort of stuff Dr. Offit is subjected to day in and day out by his enemies.) As part of this campaign, Dr, Offit has even been subject to death threats and calls in which implied threats were made against his family and children. Indeed, after he had casually mentioned his children’s names during Congressional testimony in front of quackery-supporting antivaccinationist Congressman Dan Burton’s committee, in which he answered a question by Representative John Tierney about whether he vaccinated his own children, a concerned member Tierney’s staff warned him, “Never, never mention the names of your own children in front of a group like this.” Some of these threats were credible enough that the University of Pennsylvania routinely checks his mail for suspicious letters and packages and he has periodically required an armed guard.
Personally, I find Dr. Offit’s story quite credible. Indeed, I’ve occasionally been at the receiving end of but a small fraction of the vitriol directed at him. True, I have never been physically threatened (although one time I met someone whom I mistakenly thought–just for an instant–was a particularly persistent antivaccinationist who detested me and it momentarily frightened me), but antivaccinationists have certainly done their best to destroy my Google reputation. Usually, the attacks take the form of slander and ad hominem attacks. For example, not only have I been personally attacked by J.B. Handley of Generation Rescue himself on Age of Autism in a prolonged screed, the comments after which mocked my appearance and questioned my manhood, but one particularly deranged antivaccine advocate, who has in the past shown up at least once in the comments on this blog and is so off the deep end that even antivaccinationists are embarrassed by him, has written posts accusing me of “sodomizing autistic children” and of being a “member of NAMBLA.” (Google it if you don’t know what the acronym means.) He bases his accusations on a list circulated on Usenet by Holocaust deniers back around 2000 designed to smear those of us involved in the fight against online Holocaust denial as pedophiles. The list is so obviously a pile of lies (for instance, it has me living and working in both New Jersey and Chicago seemingly simultaneously), but that didn’t stop him and it doesn’t stop other cranks from periodically resurrecting this zombie and setting it loose to try to eat the brains of those who see it. Indeed, this same blogger/commenter has even tried to link Kathleen Seidel to NAMBLA as well. (More on her later, as she is a major player in the book.) Now I’m just a rather insignificant blogger, not a vaccine researcher who has been on national television and testified in front of Congress about vaccine safety, and I’ve experienced a bit of this vitriol. That’s why I’m not surprised that Dr. Offit has been subjected to much worse.
After describing his stake in this debate, Dr. Offit dives right in, beginning with a brief history of vaccines and then of the condition known as autism, serving as a background, including some earlier forms of autism “treatments” such as facilitated communication, a now discredited technique that led to false accusations of rape and child abuse against parents based on nothing more than suggestibility and the ideomotor effect. He then proceeds to describe how Andrew Wakefield’s litigation-funded research published in The Lancet in 1998 led to a scare over the MMR vaccine that has not abated even a decade later and has also led to measles again becoming endemic in the U.K. That’s just the warmup. I have to admit that this is the first book I’ve ever read about a topic that I had been following in detail and writing about myself periodically. Consequently, my review is filtered through that prism. It may also be the reason why I found how Dr. Offit structured the first part of his story particularly jarring. He begins the thimerosal story with a chapter entitled “Mercury Rising.” This chapter is a fairly straightforward and relatively uncritical recitation of the “science” used by antivaccinationists to show that mercury causes autism. From my perspective, having read and analyzed many of these studies and knowing that they are at best irrelevant and at worst rank pseudoscience, I found this chapter especially disturbing. I think I know what Dr. Offit was trying to do: To show how the steady drumbeat of such studies can give the impression that there is scientific legitimacy to the question fo whether vaccines cause autism, but it was hard to swallow. True, Dr. Offit immediately follows the chapter with “Mercury Falling,” in which he demolishes over and over again the “science” claiming to show that mercury in vaccines causes autism, but the overall effect disturbed me. Of course, that’s just me. I’d be curious to hear what others who have read the book thought of this structure.
One person who comes in for criticism is Dr. Neal Halsey, who in 1999 was head of the American Academy of Pediatrics’ vaccine advisory committee and was also instrumental in persuading the CDC to recommend the removal of thimerosal from vaccines even though there wasn’t any real science to show it to be dangerous. Two interesting points come out of this chapter that I hadn’t been aware of. First was the dynamic of how this came about. Many of the meetings held to discuss the matter were done by conference calls often dominated by Dr. Halsey. Indeed, the CDC committee was initially not at all enthusiastic about Dr. Halsey’s recommendations because they didn’t see any science compelling enough to warrant urgency. However, through force of will during several conference calls Dr. Halsey ultimately won the day. What seems to have happened is that, absent sitting in a room with all the players, members of the CDC got the impression that a “snowball” was growing in favor of doing something. Members later said that they were extremely skeptical but that with Dr. Halsey dominating the conversations and the inability to see the body language of other members of the committee, they didn’t realize that they were not alone in their extreme skepticism about the advisability of “doing something now.” The second point is that the banning of thimerosal absent compelling evidence that it caused harm was a fantastic example of the “precautionary principle” run amok, in which a ban was recommended “just in case.” That decision more than any other, argues Dr. Offit, was responsible for the subsequent nine years of antivaccinationist fearmongering over mercury in vaccines. After all, parents not unreasonably think, if the CDC and AAP recommended removing thimerosal from vaccines, there must have been a reason. Maybe there was something wrong that is now being hidden! Reassurances by the CDC that the recommendation was “just as a precautionary measure” designed to “make vaccines even safer” were not particularly convincing in comparison. Actions speak louder than words, after all. In other words, although antivaccine advocates were agitating about thimerosal in the late 1990s and likely would have continued to do so, the ultimate magnitude of the thimerosal scare in the U.S. was largely a self-inflicted wound on the part of the CDC and AAP.
One face familiar to me was featured prominently in this book, a woman named Kathleen Seidel, who created the Neurodiversity website and blog. She has been a thorn in the side of antivaccinationists for several years now. Arguably her biggest contribution is how she has revealed the sordid details of the conflicts of interest and pseudoscience “Behind the Mercury Curtain,” so to speak (the title of the chapter in Autism’s False Prophets featuring Seidel). She was the first to uncover how Dr. Mark Geier and his son David formed a dubious and “elusive” institute and packed an institutional review board of that institute with their cronies to rubberstamp their unethical “clinical trials” using chelation therapy and the powerful anti-androgenic and -estrogenic drug Lupron under the guise of treating “precocious puberty.” Indeed, my learning about the Geiers and their highly unethical research behavior back in 2006 was the second “awakening” I had about the antivaccine movement. Also interviewed for the book is another online friend, Camille Clark, also known as the Autism Diva, as well as others with autistic children who do not buy into antivaccine pseudoscience.
Through the latter part of the book, Dr. Offit reviews all the other major players in the antivaccine movement. They’re almost all there: J.B. Handley of Generation Rescue (now apparently known as “Jenny McCarthy’s Autism Organization”) and Age of Autism; Jenny McCarthy and her “Green Our Vaccines” nonsense; aging shock-jock Don Imus; chemistry professor-turned-antivaccinationist Boyd Haley; Mady Hornig; Richard Deth; David Kirby; and, of course, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. None of them are spared, nor should they be. For someone as interested as I, there wasn’t much there that I didn’t already know, although I was surprised to learn just how tightly RFK, Jr. is affiliated with trial lawyers (I had always thought he was idealistic but seriously misguided on the question of vaccines) and how David Kirby apparently used to bluster and bully that he was “with the New York Times” to try to obtain interviews when in fact he was never anything more than a freelancer who was occasionally published in the Gray Lady. However, to those who aren’t familiar with these characters, it is potentially eye-opening. Unfortunately, one aspect of this story that is missing is how antivaccine activists have coopted the case of Hannah Poling to serve their propaganda. True, the case didn’t really explode onto the scene until March. Perhaps it was too late to include it in the hardcover book, and I hope that Dr. Offit will write an update for the paperback edition. Indeed, the manipulation of the Hannah Poling case and the way that antivaccinationists latched on it as “evidence” that rare mitochondrial disorders are allegedly a factor predisposing to “vaccine injury” causing autism warrant a complete chapter in and of themselves.
The closing third of the book deals with how science is handled in the courts and in society. There is an extensive discussion of the Autism Omnibus and how weak the plaintiff’s case was in the first “test case.” More importantly, Dr. Offit echoes a lament that I have made time and time again about how science is so frequently misrepresented and abused in the media, describing specific examples. One point he makes is that scientists always tend to qualify their remarks and be very careful about stating conclusions. That’s nothing but good science (remember, science can never absolutely prove that there is no correlation between vaccines and autism, only suggest just how very, very unlikely it is that there is one), but such “weasel words,” which are normal qualifications of the uncertainty inherent in scientific conclusions, leave the average layperson thinking that there really is a major controversy among scientists. In the case of whether vaccines cause autism, there is not. Dr. Offit also compares the P.R. techniques used by the antivaccine movement to discount the science exonerating thimerosal-containing vaccines or vaccines in general as a cause of or contributor to autism to how the tactics tobacco companies used back in the 1950s and 1960s to try to convince people that there was still a scientific controversy over whether cigarette smoking causes lung cancer. He also points out how, in this age of science, belief in magic and the paranormal remain very common, making the connection between the lack of critical thinking skills that allow such superstition to continue to flourish and how easily pseudoscience can become accepted as “fact”–a point I have made many times before, although not so much on this blog.
Of course, no review would be complete if I didn’t briefly mention two things that bugged me about this book. No book is perfect, and Dr. Offit’s is no exception. Don’t get me wrong, though. Overall Autism’s False Prophets is an excellent book that I recommend highly. Nonetheless, I do have two minor nits to pick. The first is that Dr. Offit approvingly quotes Steven Milloy twice and Michael Fumento once, both of whom are well known corporate shills, apologists for conservative politics, antienvironmentalists, and anthropogenic climate change “skeptics.” (Indeed, Steve Milloy is known for his famous and dubious “Ultimate Global Warming Challenge.”) Moreover, both have been accused of ties to the very tobacco companies to which Dr. Offit compared antivaccinationists to, and both have conflicts of interest in the form of ties to and/or funding from the industries whose interests they virtually always champion, be it big oil, big pharma, or big tobacco. That they happen to be correct in condemning the antivaccination movement is not a good enough reason to cite them, and Dr. Offit could have made his points just as well without including quotes from such tainted sources. Even though the quotes themselves argue Dr. Offit’s case about science and society and the law, anyone who has skeptically examined the rhetoric of Milloy or Fumento will know that neither of them is a credible spokesman for science-based medicine.
The second nit is that Dr. Offit comes off as a bit credulous about the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM). Indeed, at one point he states:
But what worried many scientists and physicians about NCCAM was that alternative medicines would be exempt from the scientific method. Fortunately, that hasn’t happened.
Actually, I (and all of my cobloggers here, I daresay) would argue that that is exactly what has happened with the rise of NCCAM. Dr. Offit then goes on to argue that NCCAM has tested “several alternative medicines” and concluded that they didn’t work, mentioning laetrile. Actually laetrile was tested and found to be ineffective back in the 1980s, several years before the office that was the precursor to NCCCAM was ever established in the NIH. In any case, if he sees this review, I invite Dr. Offit to read articles by Wally Sampson, Steve Novella, Kimball Atwood, and me that argue otherwise and that NCCAM is a corrosive force against science-based medicine and for the accelerating infiltration of pseudoscience into academic medicine.
Be assured, however, that from my point of view the two nits I just picked are inconsequential compared to what is good and accurate about Autism’s False Prophets. Indeed, that I noticed them at all is probably a consequence of my having been active in the skeptical movement a long time (i.e., I “know too much”). After the virtually nonstop barrage of antivaccine propaganda and pseudoscience that has permeated the national zeitgeist, especially since Jenny McCarthy became a convert to antivaccinationism a little more than a year ago, Dr. Offit has provided a refreshing, science-based change of pace on the topic of vaccines and autism that pulls no punches. Every parent who has concerns about vaccines should read it to learn just how weak and without basis in science the claims of antivaccine “scientists” and advocates are and just how riddled with conflicts of interest every bit as bad as any attributed to big pharma so many of the luminaries of the antivaccine movement are. Even better, those out there who might be worried that Dr. Offit will be profiting from sales of his book can take comfort in the fact that Dr. Offit will not receive any money from it. He has promised to donate all royalties from sales of Autism’s False Prophets to autism research. Of course, it won’t be the type of autism “research” funded by Generation Rescue or performed by the likes of Boyd Haley, the Geiers père et fils, Andrew Wakefield, Laura Hewitson, Raymond Palmer or other false prophets of autism. It will go to real scientists doing real research on the science of autism and treatments designed to help autistic children, rather than subjecting them to a mind-dizzying panoply of “biomedical” interventions that are not only expensive but useless and potentially dangerous.
Education and contributing to science-based medicine, what more could one ask for? Buy and read Autism’s False Prophets instead of Jenny McCarthy’s new book Mother Warriors. Your brain will thank you.

   The effective wordsmithing of Amy Wallace
David J Kroll
Link
One of the most engaging and clearly-written pieces of science journalism over the last year or so was published in Wired magazine last week. Now in the midst of a firestorm of attention, Amy Wallace’s, “An Epidemic of Fear: How Panicked Parents Skipping Shots Endangers Us All,” is part interview with rotavirus vaccine developer, pediatric infectious disease physician and immunologist, Dr Paul Offit, and description of the anti-vaccination movement in the United States.
Wallace’s work is the centerpiece of a masterful collection of smaller articles providing science-based information about vaccination that also refuts common anti-vaccination myths including “How To Win An Argument About Vaccines” and “The Misinformants: Prominent Voices in the Anti-Vaccine Crusade”.
Wired’s follow-up discussion of the issue includes, “A Short History of Vaccine Panic,” for those of us who “have a day job” and not enough time to read Paul Offit’s 2008 book, “Autism’s False Prophets.”
On a personal note, I have to admit that it wasn’t until I began blogging four years ago that I realized just how vocal the anti-vaccination movement was in the United States. I come from a time (just on the tail end of the Baby Boom) where I still have relatives who were afflicted with polio and other now-preventable infectious diseases. From my hometown of Wallington, NJ – a stone’s throw from New York City – Bill Michalski writes in “Poland On The Passaic” how the fear of polio spread through town during the 1930s and 40s, with white flags hung out on front porches to warn away visitors. The devastation of these childhood illnesses makes the risks (yes, I agree there are some risks) of vaccination itself inconsequential.
Vaccination is a risk-benefit proposition but one where someone else’s view affects us all. Lack of vaccination compromises “herd immunity” that keeps us all safe, for example, from diseases like smallpox that have been eliminated from the face of the earth. Your vaccination is also important to others who may be immunosuppressed from cancer drugs, HIV/AIDS, or, in the case of someone close to me, immunosuppressant drugs to prevent organ transplant rejection.
Others have commented widely on Wallace’s article for its scientific and medical accuracy. However, I wanted to focus more so on the effectiveness of the writing as a scientific communication tool because much of the article gives the reader a concise view of issues and psychology that often take typical bloggers thousands of words to express (and still less effectively!).
Why is Paul Offit Perceived as Evil?
Wallace does a terrific job of showing us just how scary life is for Paul Offit and his family (with death threats reminiscent of those by animal rights and anti-abortion activists). He is a doc at the Children’s Hospital in Philadelphia and, as mentioned earlier, is one of the developers of a vaccine for rotavirus sold commercially as RotaTeq®. While not particularly deadly (although the parents of the 20-60 dead US infants and toddlers annually may beg to differ – as well as those of the half million worldwide), rotavirus causes a severe form of acute diarrhea in several hundred thousand US children annually under age 5. If you’ve had a kid with it, you wish they didn’t have to endure it if a vaccine would prevent the infection and sequelae.
Wallace also describes how Offit was in the hospital with kids suffering from polio in the mid-1950s. Hence, unlike many of today’s anti-vaccination advocates, Offit was influenced deeply and early by witnessing firsthand the devastation of now-preventable infectious diseases. That’s the world in which my parents and grandparents lived.
“It was a pretty lonely, isolating experience,” Offit says. “But what was even worse was looking at these other children who were just horribly crippled and disfigured by polio.” That memory, he says, was the first thing that drove him toward a career in pediatric infectious diseases.
Wallace goes on to describe a case in 1977 where, as an intern, Offit observed the death of a child from rotavirus, being surprised that the disease still killed kids. I’d say that many of us in science and medicine were influenced similarly by watershed events in our lives that led to pursuit of our respective career tracks.
Anti-vaccination advocates often criticize Offit for being in the pocket of Big Pharma (whatever that really means) because he made $50 million from the development of the RotaTeq vaccine. Offit admits to it being several million – a much more realistic number given what I know about deals made by institutions vs. remaining payouts to individual scientists – and he has every right to benefit from the intellectual property he has developed from his hard work. Offit has a four-bedroom house with his wife (who is also a pediatrician) and they each drive a Toyota Camry. He does not appear to have an extravagant lifestyle and, to be honest, why should we begrudge him if he did?
Offit acknowledges that he received a payout — “several million dollars, a lot of money” — when his hospital sold its stake in RotaTeq last year for $182 million. He continues to collect a royalty each year. It’s a fluke, he says — an unexpected outcome. “I’m not embarrassed about it,” he says. “It was the product of a lot of work, although it wasn’t why I did the work, nor was it, frankly, the reward for the work.”
There are plenty of us who have our kids vaccinated for rotavirus and I’m perfectly happy for Offit to collect a royalty. (I’d even encourage him to buy a more comfortable vehicle because I know how unnerving the Philadelphia commute can be.). Does this make him evil? In fact, last week the CDC published that the vaccine is already responsible for reducing cases and hospitalizations for rotavirus. If that’s the definition of evil then I aspire to be evil.
Wallace also notes indirectly that the anti-vaccination movement is doing just what they accuse Offit of doing: making money off of the situation:
At this year’s Autism One conference in Chicago, I flashed more than once on Carl Sagan’s idea of the power of an “unsatisfied medical need.” Because a massive research effort has yet to reveal the precise causes of autism, pseudo-science has stepped aggressively into the void. In the hallways of the Westin O’Hare hotel, helpful salespeople strove to catch my eye as I walked past a long line of booths pitching everything from vitamins and supplements to gluten-free cookies (some believe a gluten-free diet alleviates the symptoms of autism), hyperbaric chambers, and neuro-feedback machines.
Yes, where the science is not yet complete, pseudoscience (and the attendant hucksters and vultures) seem to fill the void. The difference between them and Offit: the product Offit developed has extensive scientific data to back up its effectiveness.
Efficiency of Words
But getting back to what impressed me most about Wallace’s article was how concisely she presented her content. Here, she sums up one of my discussion points above:
Today, because the looming risk of childhood death is out of sight, it is also largely out of mind, leading a growing number of Americans to worry about what is in fact a much lesser risk: the ill effects of vaccines.
To describe the hypocrisy of an Offit opponent:
Hence the death threats against Paul Offit. Curt Linderman Sr., the host of “Linderman Live!” on AutismOne Radio and the editor of a blog called the Autism File, recently wrote online that it would “be nice” if Offit “was dead.”
I’d met Linderman at Autism One. He’d given his card to me as we stood outside the Westin O’Hare talking about his autistic son. “We live in a very toxic world,” he’d told me, puffing on a cigarette.
To describe the logical trapping of pseudoscience believers:
. . .the astronomer Carl Sagan reached a similar conclusion: Science loses ground to pseudo-science because the latter seems to offer more comfort. “A great many of these belief systems address real human needs that are not being met by our society,” Sagan wrote of certain Americans’ embrace of reincarnation, channeling, and extraterrestrials. “There are unsatisfied medical needs, spiritual needs, and needs for communion with the rest of the human community.”
Looking back over human history, rationality has been the anomaly. Being rational takes work, education, and a sober determination to avoid making hasty inferences, even when they appear to make perfect sense. Much like infectious diseases themselves — beaten back by decades of effort to vaccinate the populace — the irrational lingers just below the surface, waiting for us to let down our guard.
To describe how people evaluate, incorrectly, perceived vs. actual risks:
Perceived risk — our changing relationship to it and our increasing intolerance of it — is at the crux of vaccine safety concerns, not to mention related fears of pesticides, genetically modified food, and cloning. Sharon Kaufman, a medical anthropologist at UC San Francisco, observes that our concept of risk has evolved from an external threat that’s out of our control (think: statistical probability of a plane crash) to something that can be managed and controlled if we just make the right decisions (eat less fat and you’ll live longer).
We scientists can do well to be students of Ms. Wallace’s efficiency with words.
Most recently, Wired demonstrates that, like the rest of us who employ the scientific method to evaluate data, it’s okay to admit (as well as the responsible thing to do) when one makes a mistake and then describe the consequences, or lack thereof, of the misstatement. For example, Wallace’s article did mistakenly state that vaccines no longer contain thimerosal (ethylmercury), an anti-microbial preservative that has proven safe in over a dozen studies:
An earlier version of this story suggested that no childhood vaccines contain thimerosal; in fact some versions of the influenza vaccine, which is not typically mandated for children’s admission to school, does contain the preservative. Go here for a further explanation.
Amy Wallace the Journalist
Finally, what I think also impresses me is Amy Wallace herself and her approach to this article. Wallace is not your typical science journalist. The majority of her portfolio is comprised of works on Hollywood and the entertainment industry. She is not a lobbyist or otherwise a representative of the pharmaceutical industry – as you might guess, she is already being accused of being such by anti-vax advocates, In fact, Wired has published a follow-up on Ms. Wallace’s background in response to a misinformation campaign about her that has already developed. (Nor this hasn’t stopped the anti-vax commenters from stating that the entire Wired feature is a paid hit job for the pharmaceutical industry.)
When the facts don’t support an opponent’s view on a pharmaceutical or therapeutic issue, the tendency is an intellectually lazy cry of “Pharma Shill.”
Wallace’s approach to Offit himself is, I think, so effective because she is supremely experienced at writing about personalities, their inner workings, and how they are viewed by the public. As an entertainment writer, she also has to delve into the truths behind the motivations of people and get past appearances and hype. She went above and beyond in giving time and publicity to anti-vaccination advocates, and their websites, and pretty much gave the reader all they need to make up their own minds about the issue.
But most importantly, all of scientists with whom I communicate on blogs and Twitter have agreed that the science reported in Wallace’s article is almost entirely valid and supported by solid, published data. Dr. Gorski has, for example, registered his support here at SBM back on October 20th.
But the combination of scientific validity, her engaging writing style, and historical/psychological commentary on pseudoscience comes together to create an example of what science journalism can and should be.
The record-setting pageviews for Wired and froth in the comments from anti-vaccination activists tells us all we need to know about how influential Ms. Wallace’s article is already – and will continue to be.
I encourage SBM readers to follow Ms. Wallace on her Twitter feed @msamywallace. Beginning last evening, she began writing about the e-mail she has received, both hateful and supportive, regarding her story. She notes that in 25 years of professional journalism (NYT, LATimes, etc.), she has never received such volume and vitriol of communications on any other topic.

.B. Handley versus vaccine science. Again. Not surprisingly, J.B. loses.
Our old friend anti antivaccine activist J. B. Handley invokes the “vaccines didn’t save us” gambit. It doesn’t go well for him.
David Gorski on August 13, 2018
Link

Regular readers of my not-so-secret other blog are probably aware that a week and a half ago I went undercover, into the belly of the beast so to speak, to an antivaccine panel discussion held by a local candidate for Congress and featuring my state representative, Jeff Noble. They also know that last week antivaxers were trying to entice me into appearing on a panel with antivaxers as the token pro-science skeptic. (I declined, but did get a fun blog post out of it.) These two recent events got me to thinking—or perhaps I should say “thinking again”—about the tactics and tropes favored by the antivaccine movement. This thinking came into relief when I came across this not so little gem of antivaccine misdirection by an old “friend” of mine, J.B. Handley.
J.B. Handley and I go back a long way. He first appeared on my not-so-secret other blog as a commenter sometime in 2005, if I recall correctly, but quickly disappeared when he realized that his antivaccine pseudoscience wasn’t persuading anyone, least of all me. You might recall that Handley and his wife founded the antivaccine group Generation Rescue, which later became Jenny McCarthy’s antivaccine group when she became its president. (She’s still on the group’s board of directors.) Generation Rescue began primarily as a flagbearer for what I used to like to call the “mercury militia,” a branch of the antivaccine movement whose central belief was that the mercury in the thimerosal preservative that was in some childhood vaccines until 2002 was the primary cause of the so-called “autism epidemic.” However, as it became clearer and clearer after the removal of thimerosal from childhood vaccines that autism rates were not declining, meaning that there was no link between mercury in vaccines and autism, Handley pivoted to claiming that autism and other neurodevelopmental disorders are caused by “an overload of heavy metals, live viruses, and bacteria,” and that the primary causes of the alleged autism epidemic “[included] the tripling of vaccines given to children in the last 15 years (mercury, aluminum and live viruses); maternal toxic load and prenatal vaccines; heavy metals like mercury in our air, water, and food; and the overuse of antibiotics.” In other words, he switched from a hypothesis that was rapidly being falsified to one that is damned near unfalsifiable.
Since then, I’ve mentioned Handley’s activities from time to time, such as when he gloated over the decline in confidence in vaccines among parents, in essence taking credit for it; attacked Steve Novella; launched a misogynistic attack on a female journalist who had written a pro-vaccine article; and in general demonstrating a high level of Dunning-Kruger effect.
This time around, he reminded me of one of the two main tactics of antivaxers, a tactic that isn’t covered enough. Basically, there are two central tenets of antivaccine pseudoscience. The first, of course, is that vaccines are harmful because they’re chock full of toxins and cause all sorts of horrific health problems. Skeptics refute this type of misinformation quite well. However, the second tenet of antivaccine pseudoscience is that vaccines don’t work (or don’t work very well) and as a result are not nearly as beneficial as vaccine advocates claim. One variety of this “vaccines don’t work” trope is what I like to refer to as the “vaccines didn’t save us” gambit, which is essentially the claim that vaccines had little to do with the decline in infectious disease over the last century. You can tell that’s the trope by the title of Handley’s blog post, “Did vaccines save humanity?” I will give Handley credit for one thing. This is a wrinkle on this hoary old bit of antivaccine intellectual dishonesty that I haven’t seen before.
Handley attacks a massive strawman
You know Handley’s argument is going to be dicey right from the opening passage of his blog post:
Since 1900, the mortality rate in America has declined by roughly 74%, creating a dramatic improvement in quality of life and life expectancy for Americans. The simple question is, “Why?”
Why did the mortality rate decline so precipitously? If you listen to vaccine promoters, the answer is simple: vaccines saved us. What’s crazy about this narrative is how easy it is to disprove, the data is hiding in plain sight. The fact that this easily-proven-false narrative persists, however, tells us a lot about the world we live in, and I hope will encourage parents to reconsider the veracity of many of the narratives they’ve been fed about vaccines.
Can you spot the straw man? It should be fairly easy for SBM readers. Basically, no scientist I know of is claiming that vaccines are responsible for all or most of the 74% decline in mortality observed over the 73 year period that Handley references in his post. Basically, what he’s doing is what we call inflating the denominator, which means making the denominator as huge as he can in order to make the percentage that he gets when he divides the numerator by it as small as possible. Of course, you know what the numerator is going to be. That’s right, deaths prevented by vaccines.
But does Handley have a point? Not really, as you will see. Rather, what he does is to cherry pick and misinterpret a handful of studies, take some not unreasonable cautioning by some scientists in the past, and mixing them together to make the deceptive claim that vaccines do very little good.
Edward Kass in 1970
The first piece of evidence that Handley cites is a speech by Edward Kass, MD, who at the time was President of the Infectious Diseases Society of America. Now, Mr. Handley might be forgiven if he doesn’t realize that speeches that the outgoing President of a medical society give are not the same as peer-reviewed evidence. I’ve been to a lot of these speeches, and one thing I’ve realized over the years is that there is a subset of them in which the society’s president is trying to tweak his membership, to challenge them with a controversial viewpoint. Dr. Kass’ speech, which was published in The Journal of Infectious Diseases in January 1971, strikes me as just that variety of presidential speech. In it, he cautioned his fellow infectious disease doctors and researchers that what they do didn’t have as large an influence as they like to think on mortality. Indeed, the title of the speech is telling, “Infectious Diseases and Social Change“. Using Kass’s speech, Handley invokes the “vaccines didn’t save us” gambit based on the observation that the mortality from various infectious diseases had been declining for decades before the vaccines were introduced for them and how mortality from scarlet fever (for which there has never been a widely used vaccine) was also in decline.
Handley again beats the straw man:
At the time, Dr. Kass was actually the President of the organization, which made the things he had to say about vaccines and their impact on the reduction in American mortality rates even more shocking, at least by today’s standards. Forty-eight years after Dr. Kass’ speech, vaccines have taken on a mythological status in many corners of our world, hyped up by the people who benefit the most from their use. Of course vaccines saved the world. Of course every child should get every vaccine. If you don’t vaccinate, you will enable the return of deadly childhood diseases. If you don’t vaccinate, your child will die. If you question vaccines, even a little, you’re an “anti-vaxxer” who should be shunned and dismissed!
Reading over Dr. Kass’s actual speech, I noted right away that it was not an antivaccine speech. Far from it. Handley opines that Kass “never referred to vaccines as “mankind’s greatest invention” or one of the other many hyperbolic ways vaccines are described all the time by vaccine promoters in the press today”, but, then, why would he have? His speech wasn’t about vaccines. Handley, of course, is very impressed by this particular quote from Kass:
…we had accepted some half truths and had stopped searching for the whole truths. The principal half truths were that medical research had stamped out the great killers of the past —tuberculosis, diphtheria, pneumonia, puerperal sepsis, etc. —and that medical research and our superior system of medical care were major factors extending life expectancy, thus providing the American people with the highest level of health available in the world. That these are half truths is known but is perhaps not as well known as it should be.
Of course, I can’t help but point out that, even if you accept the premise that these are “half truths,” that doesn’t mean medicine doesn’t work, and it doesn’t mean that vaccines weren’t important. Quite simply, Dr. Kass was pointing out that a lot of the improvement in our health has been due to improved socio-economic conditions and then went on to speculate about potential mechanisms. Handley quotes the first, but not the second, part of this passage. Here’s what Handley quoted:
This decline in rates of certain disorders, correlated roughly with socioeconomic circumstances, is merely the most important happening in the history of the health of man, yet we have only the vaguest and most general notions about how it happened and by what mechanisms socioeconomic improvement and decreased rates of certain diseases run in parallel.
Which is true but incomplete. Here’s what Kass said next:
We know that for many infectious diseases, such as poliomyelitis and perhaps infectious hepatitis, the trend is opposite, and for some there is little or no socioeconomic status.
So the relationship, while common, is not absolute. He also noted that there is little evidence that nutritional improvements account for the decline in mortality from common infections. So what does account for the differences? Kass speculated:
What other explanations are there for the effects of being poor? One explanation was developed in England more than 40 years ago (figure 6). It was shown that rates of rheumatic heart disease were almost linearly related to crowding at home. This is understandable since spread by droplet infection is greatest in a narrow radius around an infected source and the home is, particularly for children the place in which most prolonged contact will occur.
Kass also cited data from World War I that showed that when beds in barracks were placed too close together rates of meningococcal infection among troops rose abruptly and a study from Baltimore that showed in African-American children that attack rates for rheumatic behavior were not related to low income or lower educational attainment, but were directly related to the number of people per bedroom.
Of course, what Kass was really showing was that there are more ways to prevent disease than just vaccines, and this is hardly a message that anyone in public health would dispute. Nor is it a message that shows that vaccines don’t work. I’ll elaborate more as I discuss the next reference cherry picked by Mr. Handley.
“McKinlay & McKinlay”, or: Look how J.B. Handley had to go back 40 years to find a paper supporting him
Mr. Handley refers to his next piece of evidence as the “the most famous study you’ve never heard of”. I wouldn’t quite say that. For one thing, it’s not a study, but rather an opinion piece that reads like a book chapter more than anything else. Naturally, as I always do, I read all 23 pages of the article, entitled “The Questionable Contribution of Medical Measures to the Decline of Mortality in the United States in the Twentieth Century“. Unlike Mr. Handley, I didn’t find it a difficult read at all, although I did think that at points John and Sonja McKinlay (the authors were a husband-and-wife team of epidemiologists) overstate their case. Certainly, whenever I see a paper start with a subsection title of “Introducing a Medical Heresy”, my skeptical antennae start twitching a bit. I also couldn’t help but think “Grandiose, much?” when I read the first paragraph:
The modern “heresy” that medical care (as it is traditionally conceived) is generally unrelated to improvements in the health of populations (as distinct from individuals) is still dismissed as thinkable in much the same way as the so-called heresies of former times. And this is despite a long history of support in popular and scientific writings as well as from able minds in a variety of disciplines. History is replete with examples of how, understandably enough, self-interested individuals and groups denounced customs and beliefs which appeared to threaten their own domains of practice, thereby rendering them heresies (for example physicians’ denunciation of midwives as witches, during the Middle Ages). We also know that vast institutional resources have often been deployed to neutralize challenges to the assumptions upon which everyday organizational activities were founded and legitimated (for example, the Spanish Inquisition).
Because nobody expects…the Spanish Inquisition!
Sorry, I couldn’t resist. However, I must say that my skeptical antennae started twitching so mightily when I saw McKinlay and McKinlay invoke the Spanish Inquisition as an appropriate comparison to medical orthodoxy. Comparing medicine to religion, no wonder Handley liked this article so much:
The study clearly proved, with data, something that the McKinlay’s acknowledged might be viewed by some as medical “heresy.” Namely:
…that the introduction of specific medical measures and/or the expansion of medical services are generally not responsible for most of the modern decline in mortality.
By “medical measures,” the McKinlay’s really meant ANYTHING modern medicine had come up with, whether that was antibiotics, vaccines, new prescription drugs, whatever. The McKinlay’s 23-page study really should be read cover to cover, but in a nutshell the McKinlay’s sought to analyze how much of an impact medical interventions (antibiotics, surgery, vaccines) had on this massive decline in mortality rates between 1900 and 1970:
And here’s the graph:
So, yes, there was a remarkable decline in mortality from 1900-1973. Of course, once again, this is inflating the denominator, because this is all mortality, not just mortality from vaccine-preventable diseases or childhood mortality. In a later graph, he looks at what proportion of the total mortality reduction was represented by various infectious diseases, finding that only the declines in tuberculosis and pneumonia mortality were fairly large percentages of the overall decline 1973 (16.5% and 11.7%, respectively) and that the percent of the total decline in mortality from the other eight conditions examined (scarlet fever, diphtheria, influenza, whooping cough, measles, smallpox, polio, and typhoid) combined was less than 12%.
This leads McKinlay and McKinlay to conclude:
Even if it were assumed that this change was entirely due to the vaccines, then only about one percent of the decline following interventions for the diseases considered here could be attributed to medical measures. Rather more conservatively, if we attribute some of the subsequent fall in the death rates for pneumonia, influenza, whooping cough, and diphtheria to medical measures, then perhaps 3.5 percent of the fall in the overall death rate can be explained through medical intervention in the major infectious diseases considered here. Indeed, given that it is precisely for these diseases that medicine claims most success in lowering mortality, 3.5 percent probably represents a reasonable upper-limit estimate of the total contribution of medical measures to the decline in mortality in the United States since 1900.
Of course, I can’t help but point out that, even if this pessimistic estimate were accurate, that would still be millions of lives saved over that 73 year period. There’s also another problem, and McKinlay and McKinlay themselves note it. Mortality statistics over such a long time period are fraught with difficulties. For instance, there were changes in registration areas in the US in the early 20th century. Also, often no single disease, but a combination of conditions, is responsible for death. Moreover, studies show considerable inaccuracies in reporting the cause of death, and, just as relevant, there are changes over time in what is fashionable to diagnose. Add to that how some conditions cause immediate death, while others don’t. For example, consider scarlet fever. Untreated, it can result in rheumatic heart disease, but that usually doesn’t kill for decades. Indeed, my grandmother was an example. She had rheumatic heart disease after having had scarlet fever as a child. Eventually she needed a valve replacement. So if someone dies of rheumatic heart disease at age 60, is the cause of death heart disease or scarlet fever? Also, there are a lot of conditions that are debilitating but don’t cause immediate death. It’s true that over the last 50 years reporting has become a lot more standardized, but if you’re looking at statistics going back into the 19th century, you have to wonder how accurate they are.
Here’s another issue. Everybody dies. I like to say that life is a sexually transmitted terminal disease. If you don’t die of an infectious disease, you’ll die of something else eventually. That’s just the way it is. Heck, even McKinlay and McKinlay show that in this article with a graph showing the decreasing percentage of people dying of infectious disease being compensated for by the increasing percentage of people dying of chronic diseases and diseases of aging. In other words, it’s complex.
Of course, as I said the last time I discussed the “vaccines didn’t save us” gambit, there’s another problem with the use of mortality statistics über alles. They completely ignore incidence of the disease being prevented by vaccines. For instance, yes, mortality from measles was falling long before the vaccine—decades in fact. However, incidence, albeit fluctuating yearly, remained roughly the same until the measles vaccine was introduced, after which the incidence fell precipitously. And that’s the problem. Consideration of mortality alone as the be-all and end-all of whether a vaccine works completely ignores all the morbidity, all the suffering caused by infectious disease. By this analysis (and to J.B. Handley), none of that matters.
Vital statistics abused
The next paper used and abused by Handley is a paper published in 2000 by epidemiologists from both Johns Hopkins and the Centers for Disease Control entitled “Annual Summary of Vital Statistics: Trends in the Health of Americans During the 20th Century“. You can see why from the selective quote he chooses to highlight:
Thus vaccination does not account for the impressive declines in mortality seen in the first half of the century…nearly 90% of the decline in infectious disease mortality among US children occurred before 1940, when few antibiotics or vaccine were available.
No one ever said that vaccination did account for the impressive declines in mortality seen in the first half of the 20th century. Antivaxers like Handley like to make that claim, either explicitly or implicitly, but that doesn’t make it so. In fact, what’s interesting about this paper is that it actually explains the likely reason why mortality due to infectious diseases declined in the first half of the 20th century:
The major declines in child mortality that occurred in the first third of the 20th century have been attributed to a combination of improved socioeconomic conditions in this country and the public health strategies to protect the health of Americans. These public health measures included the establishment of local health departments in nearly all of the states. State and local health departments implemented these public health measures, including water treatment, food safety, organized solid waste disposal, and public education about hygienic practices. These improvements in water and food safety and purity are linked to the major decline in diarrheal diseases seen in the early years of the century. Similarly, improvements in housing and decreased crowding in US cities are linked to the reductions in mortality from tuberculosis and other diseases attributable to person-to-person airborne transmission.
The paper also notes:
Thus, vaccination does not account for the impressive declines in mortality seen in the first half of the century. The reductions in vaccine-preventable diseases, however, are impressive. In the early 1920s, diphtheria accounted for 175,000 cases annually and pertussis for nearly 150,000 cases; measles accounted for about half a million annual cases before the introduction of vaccine in the 1960s. Deaths from these diseases have been virtually eliminated, as have deaths from Haemophilus influenzae, tetanus, and poliomyelitis.
In other words, socioeconomic changes decreased mortality from vaccine-preventable diseases before the actual vaccines were developed, but the vaccines were important and remain important in preventing diseases and the morbidity and mortality from those diseases. Funny how J.B. Handley neglected to mention this part of the paper.
The Aaby Study
The hits keep coming from J.B. Handley, as anyone who knows him would expect. Next up:
Published in the peer-reviewed journal EBioMedicine in 2017, the study is titled, “The Introduction of Diphtheria-Tetanus-Pertussis and Oral Polio Vaccine Among Young Infants in an Urban African Community: A Natural Experiment.” Researchers from the Research Center for Vitamins and Vaccines, Statens Serum Institut (Denmark), and Bandim Health Project looked closely at data from the West African nation of Guinea-Bissau. The scientists in this study closely explored the concept of NSEs, “nonspecific effects” of vaccines, which is a fancy way of saying vaccines may make a child more susceptible to other infections. They found that the data for African children who had been vaccinated with the DTP vaccine:
was associated with 5-fold higher mortality than being unvaccinated. No prospective study has shown beneficial survival effects of DTP. . . . DTP is the most widely used vaccine. . . . All currently available evidence suggests that DTP vaccine may kill more children from other causes than it saves from diphtheria, tetanus, or pertussis. Though a vaccine protects children against the target disease, it may simultaneously increase susceptibility to unrelated infections.
Wow. Sounds damning.
Not surprisingly, it’s not. As Skeptical Raptor noted, the study was tiny, and the number of deaths studied was even tinier. Also, the deaths were not categorized. Basically, this was a typical small study with questionable results.
What J.B. Handley missed.
I could go on and on and on about how Handley has weaponized the Dunning-Kruger effect to cherry pick articles that he can spin to make it seem as though vaccines are not effective. More recent studies show that vaccination does indeed save lives. For example:
Childhood vaccination, and in particular measles and tetanus vaccination, is associated with substantial reductions in childhood mortality. We estimated that children in clusters with complete vaccination coverage have a relative risk of mortality that is 0.73 (95% confidence interval: 0.68, 0.77) times that of children in a cluster with no vaccinations. Although widely used, basic vaccines still have coverage rates well below 100% in many countries, and our results emphasize the effectiveness of increasing coverage rates in order to reduce child mortality.
Meanwhile, the dreaded CDC notes:
Strategic vaccination campaigns have virtually eliminated diseases that previously were common in the United States, including diphtheria, tetanus, poliomyelitis, smallpox, measles, mumps, rubella, and Haemophilus influenzae type b meningitis (8). With the licensure of the combined diphtheria and tetanus toxoids and pertussis vaccine in 1949, state and local health departments instituted vaccination programs, aimed primarily at poor children. In 1955, the introduction of the Salk poliovirus vaccine led to federal funding of state and local childhood vaccination programs. In 1962, a federally coordinated vaccination program was established through the passage of the Vaccination Assistance Act–landmark legislation that has been renewed continuously and now supports the purchase and administration of a full range of childhood vaccines.
Precisely.
The use of mortality as the be-all and end-all of vaccine efficacy is an intentional strategy of the antivaccine movement. This strategy completely ignores the morbidity and suffering due to vaccine-preventable diseases.
J.B. Handley, on the other hand, thinks this (if you can call it thinking):
So am I saying no one should vaccinate? No, I’m not. Vaccines provide temporary protection from certain acute illnesses. Some matter more than others. I think we give way too many vaccines, and I think the risk/benefit equation of each vaccine is never properly revealed to parents. Worse, the lie that vaccines saved humanity in the twentieth century has turned many vaccine promoters into zealots, even though their narratives are simply not supported by the facts.
As a counter-point:
A greater than 92% decline in cases and a 99% or greater decline in deaths due to diseases prevented by vaccines recommended before 1980 were shown for diphtheria, mumps, pertussis, and tetanus. Endemic transmission of poliovirus and measles and rubella viruses has been eliminated in the United States; smallpox has been eradicated worldwide. Declines were 80% or greater for cases and deaths of most vaccine-preventable diseases targeted since 1980 including hepatitis A, acute hepatitis B, Hib, and varicella. Declines in cases and deaths of invasive S pneumoniae were 34% and 25%, respectively.
And, from the World Health Organization:
Ehreth estimates that vaccines annually prevent almost 6 million deaths worldwide. In the USA, there has been a 99% decrease in incidence for the nine diseases for which vaccines have been recommended for decades, accompanied by a similar decline in mortality and disease sequelae.
No, the only one spreading lies here is Mr. Handley, who is also attacking an obvious straw man. Vaccines work.
The bottom line is that vaccines are safe, effective, and prevent disease. Yes, sanitation and public health measures decreased mortality from infectious diseases before vaccines for them were developed, but that doesn’t mean that they don’t work or aren’t important. The “vaccines didn’t save us” gambit, as demonstrated by J.B. Handley, remains intellectually dishonest.

   J.B. Handley of the anti-vaccine group Generation Rescue: Misogynistic attacks on journalists who champion science
David Gorski
Link
There’s been something I’ve been meaning to write about all week, but only just got around to it. There were lots of other things going on at my other online locale, and this topic is such old hat for so many that I really wasn’t sure if it was worth bothering with. My reluctance may also be, sadly, because I’ve become a bit jaded at the nastiness that anti-vaccine groups such as Generation Rescue (i.e., “Jenny McCarthy and Jim Carrey’s Autism Organization”–at least these days) and its erstwile founder J.B. Handley routinely lay down when someone points out that the emperor has no clothes, that vaccines do not cause autism. I’m referring, of course, to Amy Wallace, who wrote what is the best example of an article in the mainstream media about the anti-vaccine movement that “gets it.” The article was called An Epidemic of Fear: How Panicked Parents Skipping Shots Endangers Us All and appeared in WIRED Magazine.
It was a thing of beauty. There was no false “balance” that puts cranks pushing dangerous pseudoscience on the same plane as real scientists like Paul Offit. There was even a section calling out purveyors of vaccine misinformation. Several luminaries of the the anti-vaccine movement were there, including ones discussed frequently on this blog, like Jenny McCarthy and Jim Carrey, and Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. But that wasn’t all! There was even a section on how to debunk anti-vaccine canards. What more could an advocate of science-based medicine ask for?
When I first read Wallace’s article, I knew she was going to be in for a rough time. The anti-vaccine movement doesn’t take kindly to criticism. Indeed, I even warned the publicist who had e-mailed a bunch of bloggers, including me, about the article that I hoped she was ready for a “shitstorm” (the exact word I used). After all, I’ve been the target of J.B. Handley’s wrath on more than one occasion. He’s particularly fond of trying to poison my Google reputation when I annoy him sufficiently, and one time either he or someone inspired by one of his attacks on me actually e-mailed my cancer center director a link to his screed. In fact, it wouldn’t surprise me if J.B. posts another similar smear after this post.
In any case, the publicist said she and Wallace were ready. Well, as an interview on NPR with Wallace has shown, the “shitstorm” has arrived, and it is just as disgusting and vile as the term implies, complete with misogyny and sexism. Fellow SBM blogger David Kroll pointed out how effective Wallace’s article was, and now a list of attacks on Wallace has been compiled from Wallace’s Twitter feed:
I’ve been called stupid, greedy, a whore, a prostitute, and a “fking lib.” I’ve been called the author of “heinous tripe.”
J.B. Handley, the founder of Generation Rescue, the anti-vaccine group that actress Jenny McCarthy helps promote, sent an essay title” “Paul Offit Rapes (intellectually) Amy Wallace and Wired Magazine.” In it, he implied that Offit had slipped me a date rape drug. “The roofie cocktails at Paul Offit’s house must be damn good,” he wrote. Later, he sent a revised version that omitted rape and replaced it with the image of me drinking Offit’s Kool-aid. That one was later posted at the anti-vaccine blog Age of Autism. You can read that blog here
Stay classy, J.B. Stay classy.
That’s exactly the behavior from Mr. Handley that we’ve come to know and despise. Indeed, J.B. recently smeared our very own Steve Novella. This is the sort of behavior that we expect from the anti-vaccine movement:
I’ve been told I’ll think differently “if you live to grow up.” I’ve been warned that “this article will haunt you for a long time.” Just now, I got an email so sexually explicit that I can’t paraphrase it here. Except to say it contained the c-word and a reference to dead fish.
I’ve already discussed how Paul Offit has suffered from attempted intimidation and death threats from the anti-vaccine movement. In this, the anti-vaccine is very much like the Animal Liberation Front or other animal rights groups, wielding intimidation to keep scientists from speaking out. Their level of understanding science is about at the same level, as well. But it’s not just Paul Offit. I’m currently reading Michael Specter’s new book Denialism: How Irrational Thinking Hinders Scientific Progress, Harms the Planet, and Threatens Our Lives. (Why is it that books like this always require such a long and unwieldy subtitle? Heck, even Suzanne Somers’ book is called Knockout: Interviews with Doctors Who Are Curing Cancer–And How to Prevent Getting It in the First Place. Word to publishers: Stop it! But I digress.) In Denialism, Specter includes a solid chapter about the anti-vaccine movement, Vaccines and the Great Denial, and in that chapter he describes how Marie McCormick, who led the Institute of Medicine panel that produced a seminal report in 2004 scientifically exonerating vaccines as a cause of autism suffered from similar harassment. She now has a guard posted near her office.
It’s the M.O. of the anti-vaccine movement. Unable to win on science, they try to win through intimidation and smears. As a result, scientists are reluctant to go into autism research, because they quite understandably don’t want the hassle of dealing with the attacks. Ditto vaccine science. After all, all one has to do is to look at the examples of Paul Offit and Marie McCormick to understand why public health officials shy away from getting involved and especially from speaking out in defense of science and against fear mongering. The same is also true of journalists. Indeed, the reaction of the anti-vaccine movement to Wallace’s piece makes me wonder if part of the reason for so much of the false balance and the apparent reluctance of journalists to call out Jenny McCarthy and put her on the spot in an interview has anything to do with the fear. It’s a possibility.
I do have to admit that I was quite amused by J.B.’s attack on Wallace in the anti-vaccine crank blog Age of Autism, though. It was full of whining and bits that show such a complete lack of self-awareness on J.B.’s part that it was truly hilarious to behold. Here is a sampling:
    • “Ms. Wallace appears to have gone exclusively to Google University to research her feeble attempt at describing a very complex topic.” I just about spit out my coffee all over my lovely MacBook Pro when I read this. Given that the “spokesperson” for Generation Rescue, Jenny McCarthy, is perhaps the best known user and abuser of the University of Google, a use and abuse that have led her to make gut-bustingly funny manglings of science like this, J.B.’s statement took my irony meter and fried that sucker into a puddle of molten metal and rubber, and even that was quivering in fear of another assault.
    • “I grow so weary of pointing out the same logical fallacies, misstatements, and outright factual errors that many journalists make when covering this debate, it’s going to be a struggle for my stamina to analyze her tripe in detail.” This is one of the rare areas where I’m in agreement with J.B., just not in the way he thinks. In fact, I think I’ve used that very sentence, or a variation thereof, when beginning more than one post about some nonsense published on J.B.’s anti-vaccine blog Age of Autism, because I do get tired of pointing out the same logical fallacies, misstatements, and outright factual errors that each and every blogger at AoA–nay, every anti-vaccine zealot I’ve ever encountered!–routinely parrots. J.B. is no exception; in fact, he spews more than usual, for instance his monumentally not-even-wrong project “Fourteen Studies.” But I keep doing it, because, well, it’s become my duty. In fact, I’m going to have to exercise some of that patience and stamina right here because J.B once again serves up a huge heapin’ helpin’ of logical fallacies, misstatements, and outright factual errors. As usual.
    • “The main targets of our movement are the CDC, AAP, and vaccine makers. Offit is an annoying sideshow, nothing more. He’s annoying because of articles like yours. He didn’t cause my son’s autism, and he has nothing to do with my son’s recovery.” For Dr. Offit’s supposedly being someone that J.B. doesn’t consider very important, who is an “annoying sideshow,” J.B.’s blog and organization sure do expend a lot of verbiage attacking him. In fact, a quick Google search for “Paul Offit” in the domain ageofautism.com pulled up over 1,000 hits. Just this week, J.B. launched a hilariously off-base attack entitled Dr. Paul Offit, The Autism Expert. Doesn’t See Patients with Autism? So hilariously self-unaware was J.B. in that post that earlier this week I seriously thought of doing a parody of it substituting Andrew Wakefield for Paul Offit. After all, Wakefield doesn’t see children with autism either. He’s been a “researcher” (and a truly incompetent, compromised, and likely fraudulent one at that) ever since he finished his training. These days, Wakefield lends his anti-vaccine cred to Thoughtful House, where he can’t see patients because of that pesky problem of having decided to flee the consequences of his large part in the promotion of the myth that the MMR vaccine causes autism, resulting in a plunge in vaccination rates and the resurgence of measles in the U.K. over the last decade, and not having a medical license. Sadly, other things got in my way. Or maybe not so sadly. I’m better at humor and sarcasm than parody.
    • “Offit actually has proven to be quite helpful – he’s the poster boy for the other side, which means his faults become the other side’s faults.” Project much, J.B.? Actually, it’s J.B. and his ilk who try to make Offit the poster boy for all the imagined and exaggerated faults fo the “other side.” Besides, every conspiracy movement needs a villain. For 9/11 Truther’s it’s the U.S. government (and sometimes the Mossad). For creationists, it’s Richard Dawkins. For the anti-vaccine movement, it’s Paul Offit, for much the same reason that Richard Dawkins is made into the villain by creationists and fundamentalists. They both dare to speak out against popular pseudoscience and don’t back down.
In his post, it’s also hard not to point out that J.B. does inadvertently demonstrate why any reasonable person should consider him anti-vaccine:
Why are you boring readers with misguided psychobabble? You could have used this time to read some of the science on our side of the fence which is also peer-reviewed! Clean water, toilets, and refrigerators eradicated disease, or at least 98% of it, I’ll give vaccines credit for the final 2% — and a whole lotta’ autism, allergies, and other demylenating illnesses.
Wow. Just wow. I’d really like to see what “peer-reviewed” evidence from “his side” that J.B. has that shows that it was not vaccines but rather clean water, toilets, and refrigerators that eradicated “98%” of infectious disease or that vaccines cause a “whole lotta autism allergies, and other demyelinating diseases.” Here’s hint one for J.B.: Peer-reviewed doesn’t mean it’s necessarily good research. It’s a minimum standard, and the “research” that J.B. cites has, without an exception that I’ve ever seen, been uniformly awful. (Monkey business, anyone?) As I pointed out with the most recent assault on science by the anti-vaccine movement, namely the execrable monkey study being touted as evidence that thimerosal in the hepatitis B vaccine causes “neurological damage” (an anti-vaccine code word in its “research” for “autism”), peer reviewers are routinely mislead by various studies by anti-vaccine cranks because they don’t know the subtext for these studies.
Here’s another thing that J.B.’s comment makes me wonder about. He gets very indignant when he is called anti-vaccine. He inevitably whines that he is not “anti-vaccine” but “pro-safe vaccine” or some variant thereof. I have to wonder, though. If J.B. really thinks that vaccines are only responsible for a mere 2% of the elimination of infectious disease–I mean, really, really believes it right down to the depths of his soul–why doesn’t he just come right out and admit that he’s anti-vaccine? After all, if he believes that vaccines cause an “epidemic” of autism, demyelinating diseases, and allergies, all for the benefit of a mere 2% when it comes to infectious diseases, then why not just say he is against vaccines because they don’t do any good and do a lot of harm? That’s what he just said, and I have no reason to believe he’s lying. Let’s put it this way. If I believed as J.B. apparently does, if I believed that vaccines were responsible for at most 2% of the elimination of infectious diseases and at the same time caused an “epidemic” of autism, demyelinating diseases, and other severe consequences, you can bet that I’d come out and say I was against vaccination. It would be a reasonable stance based on unreasonable beliefs about the dangers of vaccines. But I don’t believe anything of the sort. The scientific evidence simply doesn’t support J.B.’s assertions. I also suspect that, deep down J.B. doesn’t entirely believe these things either. If he truly does believe that vaccines do so little good and cause so much harm, his self-delusion would have to exceed even his obnoxiousness. Maybe it does.
After all, the evidence that vaccines played a major role in the elimination of diseases is incontrovertible. Smallpox was not eliminated by better sanitation and refrigeration. It was eliminated by a vaccine. The incidence of measles didn’t plunge dramatically primarily because of better sanitation or refrigeration; it plunged because of the introduction of an effective vaccine. (Unfortunately, this progress is being endangered by the misinformation being spread by the likes of J.B. Handley and the pseudoscience of quacks like Andrew Wakefield.) The incidence of invasive Haemophilus influenzae type B (Hib) disease didn’t plunge in the early 1990s because of better sanitation or refrigeration. Sanitation and refrigeration were just fine in the late 1980s. The incidence of severe Hib plunged because of a vaccine–indeed, to the point where younger pediatricians have never even seen a case of HiB. This is a good thing, although I’m not so sure J.B. would agree. Either that, or he’d try to claim that it wasn’t the vaccine, which is nonsense.
J.B. also can’t stand strong, principled disagreement with him. Like all people, he doesn’t like to be told he is wrong. The difference is that he reacts to criticism by attacking the person doing the criticism, not by refuting him with evidence. That’s because he can’t use evidence; his position is unsupportable by science. J.B. also has a huge amount of what appears to me to be a mixture of envy and contempt for the scientists who tell him he doesn’t know what he’s talking about. Indeed, this is what he’s written:
I’m not intellectually intimidated by any of these jokers. Their degrees mean zippo to me, because I knew plenty of knuckleheads in college who went on to be doctors, and they’re still knuckleheads (I also knew plenty of great, smart guys who went on to be doctors and they’re still great, smart guys).
I chose a different path and went into the business world. In the business world, having a degree from a great college or business school gets you your first job, and not much else. There are plenty of Harvard Business School grads who have bankrupted companies and gone to jail, and plenty of high school drop-outs who are multi-millionaires. Brains and street-smarts win, not degrees, arrogance, or entitlement.
In other words, as I said before, to J.B., it’s all about “elitism.” He honestly seems to believe that the reason the scientific community doesn’t accept his wild beliefs that vaccines cause autism is because of elitism and groupthink, not because the scientific evidence doesn’t support that belief. Unlike the case for scientists, it never occurs to him that maybe–just maybe–he might be wrong. It never occurs to him that the reason he is viewed with such disdain among scientists is because, well, he is wrong. But not just wrong, spectacularly, dangerously, and arrogantly wrong about the science. Truly, he is full of the arrogance of ignorance, and thinks that his success in the business world (or, as he puts it, his “brains and street smarts”) means that he can figure vaccines out. He can’t. Brains and street smarts count for little in science without a background understanding of science and acceptance of the scientific method, neither of which J.B. has.
One thing Amy Wallace gets completely right is described in her interview with NPR :
Wallace calls part of the discourse that has followed her article “a bullying tactic.” She points to JB Handley, founder of Generation Rescue — which contends that too many vaccines are given too soon and blames autism on vaccines — for many attacks against her in the blogosphere. She says such tactics dissuade many scientists from taking a stand in the debate. It is important to speak out against those tactics, she says, adding that she has been commenting regularly about the issue on Twitter.
Indeed it is important to stand up to bullies, and Wallace has done just that.
At this stage, I have to wonder if the anti-vaccine movement is becoming its own worst enemy. As the science keeps marching in that shows no connection between vaccines and autism and lends no support to the concept that vaccines are ineffective and dangerous promoted by the anti-vaccine movement, groups like Generation Rescue are becoming more shrill and even more quacktastic than ever. In doing so, they further marginalize themselves. Quite correctly, their behavior leads reasonable and scientific people to dismiss them more and more. Unfortunately, when that happens, all that leaves is abuse and bullying as tactics to intimidate those who speak out against them.

   J.B. Handley, Generation Rescue, and attacks on critics
David Gorski
Link
I am writing this because a colleague of mine has been attacked, specifically, our fearless leader Steve Novella. J.B. Handley, Founder of “Jenny McCarthy and Jim Carrey’s Autism Organization – Generation Rescue” (whose usurpation by Jenny and Jim was apparently done in an opportunistic fashion but has had a consequence that must be galling to J.B., namely that some interviewers apparently think that Jenny McCarthy and Jim Carrey, not J.B. and his wife, are the true founders of Generation Rescue), did not like something that Steve wrote and in his characteristic fashion, has responded with a vicious ad hominem attack. Normally I wouldn’t feel obligated to put my two cents in, as Steve is more than capable of taking care of himself in a scientific argument and quite able to refute anything J.B. can throw at him. Moreover, whenever J.B. Handley attacks someone in a fashion this nasty, it is an excellent indication that the person he is attacking has scored some serious points against him. Indeed, I have twice been on the receiving end of J.B.’s tirades on the Generation Propaganda blog Age of Autism. On one occasion, he referred to me as the “worldwide wanker of woo,” and on another occasion seemed to think that I criticized Generation Rescue so harshly because I “don’t like full page ads,” rather than because I hate pseudoscience and anti-vaccine nonsense. When criticism really hits a nerve with J.B. Handley, he lashes out in a characteristic fashion. Clearly Steve’s reasoned, level-headed criticism of the latest Generation Rescue anti-vaccine propaganda initiative did just that.
In this case, however, I feel some explanation is in order because I feel a bit responsible for having brought J.B.’s wrath down upon Steve. First, a little history (albeit recent history) is in order. As I described in detail last week and the week before, Generation Rescue, with Jenny McCarthy and Jim Carrey at the fore, sometimes with J.B. himself, has mounted an impressive anti-vaccine propaganda effort. It started with a media tour promoting her most recent paean to anti-vaccine pseudoscience and autism quackery written with “co-author” Dr. Jerry Kartzinel. The book is entitled Healing and Preventing Autism: A Complete Guide, and three weeks ago Jenny McCarthy and her boyfriend Jim Carrey showed up on Larry King Live to tout a truly incompetent and intellectually dishonest “study” that purported to find that U.S. children are the “most highly vaccinated children in the world” and that that’s correlated with our higher autism rates. I would have none of it. Next, Generation Rescue introduced its equally intellectually dishonest “Fourteen Studies” website, which launched dubious attacks from pseudoexperts on fourteen of the major studies that failed to find a correlation between vaccines and autism or thimerosal-containing vaccines and autism. I wrote a lengthy post for SBM describing the utter intellectual and scientific bankruptcy of the entire enterprise.
Now, to go back a little further, J.B. and I have a bit of a history dating all the way back to when I first became interested in the antivaccine movement in 2005. This history, however, had played out entirely on my other blog, where as many readers here know, I blog under a pseudonym. Handley consistently thought that by “outing” me (as cranks as varied as antivaccinationists and creationists had done before) he would somehow frighten me into silence. My persistence over four years shows how well that worked. In any case, we at SBM had discussed divvying up both the studies that Generation Rescue hated (the fourteen studies) and the highly dubious studies they liked, several of which I’ve discussed in detail, showing why they were so bad. As a part of this, Steve did a followup post on one specific study, the one that is often referred to in the literature as the “Danish study,” that failed to find a correlation between mercury in vaccines and autism. Characteristically, Steve did an excellent job.
Here’s where the story gets interesting. One week after I posted my deconstruction of J.B. Handley’s “Fourteen Studies,” I reposted a modified version of the same post on my other blog. I explicitly did this as an experiment whose hypothesis was that J.B. would only attack my pseudonymous persona and would not attack me under my own name, because doing so would rob him of his ability to whine about my blogging under a pseudonym. Never mind that my pseudonym is perhaps the worst-kept secret in the medical/scientific blogosphere. (It also didn’t hurt that I was away at the AACR Meeting in Denver and needed some easy material because I didn’t have time to blog.) As predicted, J.B. didn’t bite at the first version. Also as predicted, he did show up in the other version, saying:
What the hell is wrong with your brain? Why is this such a hard concept for you to grasp? How did you get to be so stupid?
To which I replied:
As I predicted when I posted this, JB was a no show elsewhere but a show here. I wonder why. I also wonder why he didn’t also show up at Steve Novella’s takedown or the takedown published by a “friend” of the blog a week ago.
Thank you, JB, for confirming my hypothesis, though. I do appreciate it, and you are always welcome to comment here and on my “friend’s” blog.
The next day, J.B. Handley launched a nasty personal attack on Steve on Age of Autism, the antivaccine propaganda blog, which appears to be a wholly owned subsidiary of Generation Rescue where J.B., along with his merry band of antivaccine zealots including David Kirby, Dan Olmsted, Kim Stagliano, and others, regularly blogs.
Now do you see why I feel a bit responsible? I suspect that my amused tweaking of J.B. led to his shifting his frustration to Steve, who is far nicer and more civil than I usually am when dealing with nonsense on the order of what Age of Autism and Generation Rescue regularly serve up.
Certainly, though, I’m not worried that Steve couldn’t handle himself against a booster of pseudoscience like J.B. Steve was more than able to write a devastating response to J.B.’s attack that eviscerated his every point, and I can’t wait to see what the skeptical rogues on The Skeptics’ Guide to the Universe will say about this. However, having had a bit more–shall we say?–history with J.B., certain aspects of his attack caught my attention.
First, this:
I don’t know Dr. Novella and I certainly having nothing against him personally, but I was stunned by the utter lack of knowledge and critical thinking that went into his critique of our new site.
I find it amusing that apparently J.B. doesn’t read his own blog because last July Age of Autism published a response by Hannah Poling’s father Dr. Jon Poling to Steve’s discussion of the Hannah Poling case, to which Steve responded. It was actually a pretty big deal. Here’s a little hint to J.B. that I learned long ago blogging: Search your own blog for any person or topic you’re thinking of writing about to make see if you’ve addressed the topic or person before, and, if you did, what you or your coblogger said. Most amusing about this misstep, J.B.’s self-absorption is showing. Apparently if he hasn’t heard of someone (or has but forgot about him), that person is insignificant. Be that as it may, this passage, more than any other, boils down J.B.’s mindset. It’s pathognomonic of him and explain much about why he hates us “pointy-headed” scientists so much:
I’m not intellectually intimidated by any of these jokers. Their degrees mean zippo to me, because I knew plenty of knuckleheads in college who went on to be doctors, and they’re still knuckleheads (I also knew plenty of great, smart guys who went on to be doctors and they’re still great, smart guys).
�
I chose a different path and went into the business world. In the business world, having a degree from a great college or business school gets you your first job, and not much else. There are plenty of Harvard Business School grads who have bankrupted companies and gone to jail, and plenty of high school drop-outs who are multi-millionaires. Brains and street-smarts win, not degrees, arrogance, or entitlement.
In other words, to J.B., it’s all about “elitism.” He honestly seems to believe that the reason the scientific community doesn’t accept his wild beliefs that vaccines cause autism is because of elitism and groupthink, not because the scientific evidence doesn’t support that belief. Unlike the case for scientists, it never occurs to him that he might be wrong or that the reason he is viewed with such disdain among scientists is because, well, he is wrong. But not just wrong, spectacularly and arrogantly wrong about the science. As both Steve and I have pointed out, it is the arrogance of ignorance.
J.B. also clearly doesn’t understand the nature of academic medicine and science. He seems to think it’s some sort of cushy ivory tower where a Ph.D. guarantees one a career. He’s so wrong on this one that he is, as they say, “not even wrong.” However, as I am in a benevolent mood, I’ll educate J.B. a bit on what it takes to be a academic faculty at a major university. First off, a Ph.D. (or an M.D.) doesn’t guarantee anything. Making a parallel to the business world, sure, it helps to have a Ph.D. from a good school. It’ll help to get a good postdoctoral position. However, once you’re in your postdoc, no one really gives a rodent’s posterior where you went to school, and, if you’re an M.D., once you’re in your residency, no one cares anymore where you graduated from medical school. They really don’t. All they care about is how well you do where you are now.
In fact, science is every bit as Darwinian a career as business, with the exception that the rewards are not financial, nor is a scientists’s worth measured by money, which appears to be the be-all and end-all for how J.B. views success, given his remark about millionaires. After fighting to get into a good Ph.D. program, a freshly minted scientist needs to fight to get a good postdoc. Once there, he has to produce. He has to demonstrate his worth by doing good science and publishing in good journals. Then, because obtaining an entry-level faculty position has become intensely competitive, a new Ph.D. often needs to do two or even three two- to three-year postdocs in order to amass enough of a track record to entice a university to take a chance on him with a lab and a startup package. Finally, once a new scientist has a faculty position, he has in general around three or four years to obtain independent research funding to cover at least 50% of his salary as a condition of tenure, or he will be fired and have to start all over again looking for a new faculty position, which will be harder to find after having failed to gain tenure at one institution. Worse, over the last few years, getting that initial grant has become harder than ever. In the past, scientists who failed to gain tenure often ended up working for pharma, but in the current climate pharma has been downsizing. There now exists an underclass of underemployed Ph.D. scientists, who may be poorly paid adjunct professors with no hope of any permanent work.
So let’s see: Get funded in three or four years or get fired to face a highly uncertain fate. That sounds pretty hardcore to me. I will admit that it’s easier for academic physicians in that they can always return to practicing medicine if they fail, but will no longer have a lab. I will grant that, once a scientist obtains tenure, things are easier in that he can’t be easily fired, but, trust me, if a scientist doesn’t produce and loses funding, he will find himself in a world of hurt. Schools have ways of making such faculty’s lives so miserable that they end up quitting.
J.B. also doesn’t understand the culture of science at the faculty level, either. Once someone becomes a full scientist and obtains an academic position, no one cares where he or she went to school, where he did his postdoc, or where he did his residency. Really. No one does. All they care about is whether that person does good science, publishes good science, and can get his or her science funded. In this, science and medicine are a lot like the business world that J.B. waxes so rhapsodic about. J.B. is also wrong to think that “street smarts” should win in science. They don’t necessarily, because what matters is doing good science. The scientific method is a systematized method of minimizing human bias and error, whereas “street smarts” are, all too often, all about hunches. Hunches can be valuable in science, but only as a first step. If a hunch isn’t supported by scientific evidence, it is worthless, and scientists will discard it. It may not happen as fast as we like; it may be messier than we like; but eventually it will happen. That’s the difference between scientists and J.B. Handley. No matter how cherished our hunches are, we do consider the possibility that they may be wrong, and eventually we can be persuaded that they are wrong if the evidence is strong enough. Indeed, this is perhaps the most ignorant thing J.B. said in his attack:
I have been astonished by the culture of arrogance and elitism that medical schools appear to breed in their doctors and scientists. The culture tends to produce an “us vs. them” mentality, where doctors collectively back each other up on controversial issues, typically without understanding the issue for themselves.
J.B. really hasn’t seen how cut-throat scientific arguments can be. Moreover, science actually does reward overthrowing the existing paradigm. Look at the list of Nobel Prize winners. You won’t find anyone there who won that prize because he or she simply confirmed pre-existing scientific dogma. Believe me, if a scientists provided compelling scientific evidence that vaccines or mercury in vaccines do cause autism and could show how they do it, that scientist would be instantly famous and a serious contender for a Nobel Prize. In any case, clearly the accusation of “arrogance” against J.B. really stings him. However, what else should we call it when someone, without any knowledge or training, blithely rejects the findings of science and labels them all a vast conspiracy to “hide the truth”? Or when someone thinks his “street smarts” trumps the accumulated knowledge of science thus far? Arrogance doesn’t begin to describe such an attitude, and only a lack of understanding of science could have produced this comment:
On of the most fascinating aspects of the autism epidemic is how the mainstream health community seems to get away with a stunning paradox: they are so damn smart that they are certain as to what doesn’t cause autism, but they haven’t a clue as to what does. How can that be? Why aren’t the smarts being applied to finding the cause?
This is nothing more than the classic logical fallacy of an appeal to ignorance. In other words, to J.B. because scientists don’t really know what does cause autism, then his pet view that vaccines cause autism must be plausible.
After my having dealt with J.B. online on and off for four years, one thing that’s become clear to me is that he does not understand science. He thinks he does, but he does not. He has made up his mind about vaccines and autism and is not open to evidence falsifying his belief. That is inimical to the culture of science, which is always testing scientific dogma versus reality and discarding what doesn’t line up with the evidence. With few exceptions, even the most dogmatic of scientists can be persuaded if the evidence is strong enough. In contrast, Mr. Handley clearly views science as a tool to support his conclusions and an enemy when it does not. Moreover, viewing the vaccine-autism pseudoscience through the prism of a businessman’s viewpoint, rather than a scientist’s viewpoint, to him it’s a propaganda battle to win, not a scientific question to answer. Like any good businessman, he has a product to sell, and sell it he does, using all the tools of Madison Avenue pitch men at his disposal. It doesn’t matter to him if the product is a lemon; he needs to sell it.
Moreover, the entire culture at the Age of Autism is an increasingly paranoid echo chamber. Just look at some of the comments there:
Dr. Novella buries his nose in literature, but he fails to recognize the political backstories that skewed the studies. And he hasn’t had face time — or G.I. time — with any kids on the autism spectrum. His selective ignorance is not only arrogant, it’s life-threatening. (Nancy Hokkanen)
Novella is part of the HealthFraud crowd, started by Barrett who was the cover for the AMA when its dirty tricks dept had to go underground.
To see what sort of operation is going on it would help to study the COINTRELPRO operation of the FBI.
His comment “including the Centers for Disease Control, the American Academy of Pediatrics, The American Medical Association, the Institute of Medicine, and the March of Dimes.”
is just the old authority ploy, or ‘lying with the truth’. Blair was the master, of course. (john)
And, my favorite:
Novella, I believe, is one of the members of the “Quackwatch,” along with Gorski (aka Orac, aka Dirtbag, aka whoever knows how many other aliases he hides behind), Probert (aka TheProbe, aka Freespeaker), Kevin Leitch, and numerous others. I find it deliciously ironic that they claim to be a group of people concerned about quackery in all of its forms (and, they even have the cute little “superhero” names to prove it), and they are the biggest quacks of them all! (Craig Willoughby, who has abandoned any prior pretense of rationality.)
I love the adoration of my fans, much as, I suspect, Steve does. Word to Craig: I don’t have any other aliases than the two you know about. I’m also terribly, terribly hurt that you consider me a “dirtbag.”
I presented these examples to show just how inimical to science the entire Age of Autism crew is. If science doesn’t jibe with their beliefs, then everyone who criticizes them is part of some huge conspiracy by The Man (in the form of the CDC, AAP, big pharma, and the government) to suppress The Truth. Personally, I often joke that I wish there were such a conspiracy, because I want in on some of that filthy big pharma lucre for doing what I would do anyway: Writing about pseudoscience and quackery. Maybe I could even quit my day job and sit around in my shorts all day blogging. Alas, it is not to be, and I have to blog in my spare time.
In the end, I feel rather sorry for J.B. Sure, he’s rich. Sure, he gets to pal around with celebrities these days. However, he labors under the delusion that vaccines caused his child’s autism and that various forms of “biomedical therapy” (a.k.a. autism quackery) will cure it. He may never believe me when I say this, but it would actually be fantastic if scientists could find so obvious and simple a cause of autism as vaccines; if that were the case, doctors could change their practice to correct the problem. That’s what we do when we find out that a treatment is causing harm. Moreover, if all the dubious “biomedical” interventions actually worked, it would mean that scientists would have a huge leg up in figuring out what the cause of autism is; they do not, and so scientists do not, and doctors still have only limited options of relatively weak efficacy for treating autistic children. Worse, J.B. is in the position to do so much good for autistic children, but instead he chooses to use his wealth and business savvy to promote pseudoscience that is not just harmful to autistic children, but potentially harmful to all children through its discouragement of vaccination and the increasing risk of outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases that follow from his antivaccine activism.
But more telling is J.B. reaction to criticism. In the case of Steve he relies primarily on ad hominems and distortions. In the case of me, he’s utterly ignored my criticisms of his “Fourteen Studies” website, at least not those written under my own name. Whether it’s because he doesn’t want to give me the satisfaction of responding or because he’s embarrassed at realizing that he’s behaved exactly as I had publicly predicted, I don’t know. In any case, rather than addressing actual substantive criticisms, he routinely chooses to lash out at critics when they score direct hits on his nonsense, digging any dirt he can at the University of Google and slinging the mud far and wide. That should tell you all you need to know.

   2009: Shaping up to be a really bad year for antivaccinationists
David Gorski
Link
I will begin this post with a bit of an explanation. Between one and two weeks ago, there appeared two momentous news about the manufactroversy regarding vaccines and autism. No doubt, many SBM readers were expecting that I, as the resident maven of this particular bit of pseudoscience, would have been here last week to give you, our readers, the skinny on all of this. Unfortunately, as some know, my wife’s mother died, coincidentally enough, on the 200th anniversary of Darwin’s birthday and a day when one of those two momentous bits of news was released to the public, which is why I used one of my handful of posts written and then held in reserve. I’m back now, though, and I don’t think it’s too late to comment on these bits of news because now that over a week has gone by what I’ve seen has led me to draw some conclusions that I might not have been able to do, had I done my usual bit and been first off the mark (at least among SBM bloggers) discussing the story.
2008: The Best of Years for the Antivaccine Movement
But first, let’s take a look at last year. In 2008, Jenny McCarthy was the new and fresh celebrity face of the movement that believes that autism and all manner of other neurodevelopmental disorders are caused by vaccines and that the government and big pharma are suppressing The Truth. She had emerged in the fall of 2007 after having tried to erase from the Internet her previous involvement in the “Indigo Child” movement in preparation for becoming an “autism advocate” who could write a book that could land her on Oprah’s show. Thanks to her and, perhaps even more so to the star power of her boyfriend Jim Carrey, who is just as wrong about vaccines and medicine as Jenny is, the antivaccine movement came roaring into prominence in a way that it had never managed to pull off before. After all, let’s face it, a former Playboy Playmate of the Year and a famous comedian are far more “interesting” public figures for various media outlets to interview than previous celebrities who spearheaded the vaccine manufactroversy, such as Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. or Don Imus and his wife Deirdre.
Indeed, Jenny’s combination of good looks and utter obnoxiousness led to her showing up all over the media in 2008. For example, on April 1 (appropriately enough), she appeared on Larry King Live! and shouted down physicians who had the temerity to tell her that her Google University knowledge was just plain wrong. The pinnacle of her influence came during the summer, when, having now supplanted J.B. Handley as the public face of the antivaccine group Generation Rescue and transforming GR into “Jenny McCarthy’s autism charity,” she led the “Green Our Vaccines” rally in Washington, DC. True, at most there were several hundred people there, but it got wide news attention, and Jenny was all over the news. She rapidly followed it up by releasing a second book Mother Warriors: A Nation of Parents Healing Autism Against All Odds and appearing on The Oprah Winfrey Show yet again.
When Amanda Peet joined the fray on the pro-vaccine side, it let the media to portray the vaccine issue as a celebrity cat fight. Meanwhile, thanks to Jenny’s ties with the Playboy organization and her celebrity friends, she was able to fill Generation Rescue’s coffers with the proceeds of celebrity “autism” events where luminaries such as Britney Spears, Charlie Sheen, and Hugh Hefner would show up. Add to that her promotion of Celebrities Against Autism and her partnering with professional wrestling and celebrity poker events with Lance Armstrong, and that’s a chunk of change that’s allowed GR and the equally antivaccine and quackery-friendly TACA to rebrand themselves in the eyes of the public as respectable autism charities, rather than crank organizations pushing a scientifically discredited idea and thereby endangering public health.
Then there was the Hannah Poling case, which has been extensively discussed here, both by me and Steve Novella. In brief, the government awarded compensation for vaccine injury through the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program to the family of a girl named Hannah Poling, manifested a regressive encephalopathy with features of autism spectrum disorder after a “catch up” vaccination session. It was later determined that Hannah suffers from a highly unusual mitochondrial disorder, which rendered her susceptible to neurologic injury from high fevers. She had high fevers after the vaccine, but she had also had a series of ear infections. The antivaccine movement has done its best to make Hannah its poster child as “smoking gun proof” that the government had admitted that vaccines can cause autism in susceptible children, when it had done nothing of the kind. Because the science is difficult, and because mitochondrial disorders are so uncommon, though, David Kirby and his fellow mouthpieces at Age of Autism had a field day twisting the scientific evidence and, as Mark Crislip likes to say, making therapeutic (or, in this case causative) mountains out of clinical molehills.
Truly 2008 was the high water mark of the antivaccine movement.
Still, not all was positive for the the disease promotion movement, even in 2008. For example, the second half of the year, after at least four years of no activity there was actual pushback against it. Amanda Peet spearheaded the Every Child By Two initiative, which was designed to encourage parents to have their children vaccinated. Not long after, Dr. Paul Offit, to antivaccinationists the Dark Lord of Vaccines, a veritable Darth Vader, Lord Sauron, and Satan Incarnate himself, released his excellent book telling in clear, easily accessible language, exactly why scientists conclude that vaccines do not cause autism and why the various “biomedical treatments” recommended for “vaccine injury” in the form of autism are virtually all quackery. Finally, as the year wound to a close, a group of scientists from Cornell tried to replicate the results of one of the godfathers of the antivaccine movement, Andrew Wakefield. Wakefield’s studies, starting in 1998 in The Lancet, had concluded that the measles virus in the MMR vaccine somehow invaded the gut and caused a syndrome that led to regressive autism and inflammatory bowel disease–and found no correlation between MMR vaccination and any such syndrome. Andrew Wakefield, as you recall, is the man who, more than anyone else, caused the anti-MMR scare in the U.K. and Europe that has resulted in the resurgence of measles. Indeed, he is a hero of the antivaccine movement, so much so that the antivaccine propaganda blog Age of Autism gave him the “Galileo Award” for 2008, completely ignoring the fact that, for a “maverick scientist,” it is not sufficient to be reviled. One must also be right, which Wakefield was most assuredly not.
Because one of the two body blows to the antivaccine movement that have already occurred in 2009 involves Andrew Wakefield, this is the perfect place to segue from the best of years for antivaccinationists to (thus far) the worst of years.
2009: The Worst of Years, thanks to Andrew Wakefield
As 2009 dawned, the antivaccine movement seemed strong and getting stronger. Having successfully framed themselves as “pro-safe vaccine, not antivaccine” and popularized the cleverly Orwellian slogans “Green Our Vaccines” and “Too Many Too Soon,” they had stoked fear of vaccination on both sides of the Atlantic, to the point where vaccination rates had begun to fall below the level necessary for herd immunity, and outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases were becoming apparent. In the U.K., thanks to Andrew Wakefield and the antivaccine movement his work had spawned, over the last decade, MMR vaccination rates had fallen below 80% (and in some parts of London, below 60%), leading a disease once considered defeated to come roaring back to the point where last year U.K. health authorities had to admit that it is once again endemic. Meanwhile in the U.S., outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseaseas were occurring among unvaccinated populations, such as in Minnesota, while measles was also making a comeback.
One thing I could never understand about Andrew Wakefield is why so many believed him. The British press ate his bad science up and were complicit in contributing to the decline in vaccination rates that endanger public health now. I, for one, was not at all surprised at the first blow to the antivaccine movement that occurred in 2009, namely Brian Deer’s revelations that Andrew Wakefield had almost certainly falsified data used in his original 1998 Lancet paper. Specifically, and in brief, this is what Wakefield was found to have done:
However, our investigation, confirmed by evidence presented to the General Medical Council (GMC), reveals that: In most of the 12 cases, the children’s ailments as described in The Lancet were different from their hospital and GP records. Although the research paper claimed that problems came on within days of the jab, in only one case did medical records suggest this was true, and in many of the cases medical concerns had been raised before the children were vaccinated. Hospital pathologists, looking for inflammatory bowel disease, reported in the majority of cases that the gut was normal. This was then reviewed and the Lancet paper showed them as abnormal.
A detailed account by investigative journalist Brian Deer (whom I met during his visit to the University of Michigan two weeks ago) can be found here, as can an account of how the MMR scare led to a return of the measles.
It’s not as though this revelation should have come as a surprise. After all, the signs had all been there right from the beginning that something was not right, indeed at least as early as 2002. Indeed, advocates of science-based medicine everywhere owe Brian Deer a huge debt of gratitude for having pursued this case for so long, as this is what he found out about Wakefield and his work. Moreover, it’s not as though warning signs weren’t there in the very paper. As Brian Deer described at the University of Michigan a couple of weeks ago, something didn’t smell right in the Lancet paper. What he meant was that the results looked too good to be true.
The original 1998 Lancet paper made two key claims based on its findings studying twelve children, which, according to the Wakefield, had been, “consecutively referred to the pediatric gastroenterology unit at the Royal Free Hospital and School of Medicine in London. First, it claimed that eight of the twelve children studied had manifested developmental regression within two weeks of the MMR vaccine, and one had developed regression after a measles infection, the clear implication being that there was a close temporal relationship between MMR vaccination and the onset of regression in 75% of the children. The second claim was that all 12 of the children demonstrated “intestinal abnormalities, ranging from lymphoid nodular hyperplasia to aphthoid ulceration.” Although the paper stated that the authors “did not prove an association between measles, mumps, and rubella vaccine and the syndrome described” and that “virological studies are underway that may help to resolve this issue,” Wakefield at his press conference to announce the findings stated that he had preliminary virological evidence showing measles virus in the gut. It took him four years to follow up these results with a paper in Molecular Pathology that reported measles virus in 75/91 children with ileal inflammation and children with developmental disorders. Although Wakefield was careful not to use the word autism in the actual text of the paper–or even the word vaccine–the implication of the paper was plain, and, if it wasn’t to some, Wakefield made sure to drive home what he thought the implication was: That the MMR is associated with a syndrome of developmental disorders, including autism, and inflammatory bowel disease.
Unfortunately for Wakefield, Deer’s instincts ultimately proved to be correct. The first shoe to drop was Deer’s 2004 Channel 4 documentary exposing Wakefield’s incompetence and conflicts of interest. As it turned out, Wakefield did not have the viral data in 1998. Indeed, a young investigator named Nicholas Chadwick had been unable to detect measles virus in any of the samples from the 12 children and had told Wakefield. Wakefield kept that data out of the original Lancet paper because it did not support his hypothesis. How, then, to explain Wakefield’s subsequent paper in 2002 that reported the detection of measles virus sequences in a large proportion of the ileal biopsy specimens of children with “autistic enterocolitis”? In 2007, during the beginning of the proceedings for the test cases in the Autism Omnibus case (more on that in the next section), Stephen Bustin, arguably the preeminent expert in the use of the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) to detect DNA sequences, testified for the government about the methods used in the laboratory that did the PCR analysis for Andrew Wakefield. Suffice it to say that this had to be about the sloppiest laboratory I’ve ever seen. Also suffice it to say that the negative controls were amplifying measles sequence, meaning that it was impossible to tell a signal was a true signal or a false positive. In fact, Bustin’s investigation concluded that what Wakefield was reporting was almost certainly all contamination from plasmids made in an adjacent laboratory. Ironically, this was the same laboratory that participated in the 2008 attempt to replicate Wakefield’s results. Clearly, it had cleaned up its act by then.
The other problem revealed in the 2004 documentary was that Andrew Wakefield had a massive conflict of interest. Teamed up with antivaccination crank extraordinaire Hugh Fudenberg, he had come up with a combination single agent vaccine/therapeutic (which he characterized as a “cure for autism“) agent based on the quack favorite “transfer factor.” Not only this, but he had filed patent applications for this concoction. In other words, Wakefield stood to profit handsomely if the MMR was discredited as being safe. Not long after these revelations, ten of the thirteen authors of the original 1998 Lancet report renounced its conclusions and asked to have their names removed from the paper.
But it was even worse than that.
At the end of 2006, the second shoe dropped. It turned out that Wakefield’s conflict of interest was even worse than that. In fact, it turned out that Wakefield had been paid by lawyers seeking to sue vaccine manufacturers for “injury” due to the MMR. In fact, his services had been bought and paid for to the tune of paid £435,643 in fees, plus £3,910 expenses. Neither this conflict of interest nor the conflict of interest inherent in having an alternative vaccine for measles, a single vaccine, with its patent pending were reported in the Lancet paper. It was these revelations that triggered an investigation by the General Medical Council in the U.K. into research malfeasance and ethic violations.
But it was even worse than that. Unfortunately, it took two more years to find out just how bad.
Two weeks ago, Brian Deer reported in the Sunday Times that, not only had Andrew Wakefield had massive conflicts of interest, but he had falsified data in his original paper. Indeed, consistent with the revelations that there had never been any detectable measles viral sequences, Deer reported that one father had taken his child’s specimen to be tested by a different laboratory and that that laboratory had failed to find any trace of measles virus. More importantly, however, none of the children studied for the Lancet paper actually even came from the Royal Free Hospital’s catchment area of North London; indeed, none of them even came from London. In fact, they were not “consecutively referred,” either. Rather, they had been recruited through the anti-MMR antivaccine underground and 11/12 of them were involved in anti-MMR litigation. Thus, they were a highly selected group. In addition, ccording to Deer’s account of the records examined by the GMC, in most of these children autistic features were present before they had received their MMR vaccination and in others such features only became apparent after a much longer interval than a few days after MMR. In other words, what was reported in the Lancet paper in 1998 and what was found in the children’s medical records differed significantly.
In other words, one of two things happened, neither of which is flattering to Wakefield. Either he took the history only from parents, who were litigants in vaccine injury cases and for whom confirmation bias could easily have led to remembering incorrectly that their child’s behavioral changes were noted shortly after the MMR rather than before it or months later. If this was the case, Wakefield was incompetent for not having examined the medical records. Alternatively, Wakefield did examine the medical records and lied about them in the Lancet paper. If this is the case, he is dishonest.
In fact, I might have been willing to give Wakefield somewhat of the benefit of the doubt, viewing the discrepancies between the medical records and what he reported in the Lancet paper as being yet more evidence of his incompetence and his resultant shoddy research methodology rather than dishonesty, were it not for the major discrepancies between what Wakefield said about the histology of the biopsy specimens in the paper. What was reported in the paper does not jibe with what the pathologists who first examined the specimens saw, where, in all 12 cases, no abnormalities had been reported on the initial examination of the specimens. Yet Wakefield reported a distinctive pattern of gut inflammation, specifically “colitis and ileal-lymphoid-nodular hyperplasia.” The Lancet paper had pointed out the “uniformity” of the pathological changes. What had happened?
Not happy with the readings of the pathologists, apparently Wakefield’s research team met for a “research review” of the biopsy specimens. This in and of itself is not unusual. However, it is unusual that the research team overturned the original readings of so many of the specimens. It is even more unusual (i.e., suspicious) that the reinterpretations of the original readings all went in the same direction: towards a reading of inflammation consistent with Wakefield’s hypothesis that the measles virus from the MMR was somehow involved in causing gut abnormalities and autistic regression. Even if I wanted to attribute Wakefield’s problems to incompetence, it’s pretty hard to do, given the confluence of evidence from multiple sources pointing to malfeasance.
2009: The Worst of Years, as the Special Masters Weigh In
If the revelations about Andrew Wakefield’s research fraud were the only event thus far, 2009 would already be shaping up to be a bad year for antivaccinationists. However, less than a week after Deer’s revelations were reported, the long-awaited ruling in a huge legal action made up of approximately 5,000 parents who are convinced that vaccines caused their children’s autism. I’m referring to the Autism Omnibus proceedings.
In the U.S., because of rising litigation that jeopardized the vaccine program and threatened to drive pharmaceutical companies out of the vaccine business, Congress passed the National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act of 1986 (Public Law 99-660), which created the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (VICP). The idea was to create an alternative to the tort system through which people injured by vaccines could be efficiently compensated. Vaccine litigants, if denied compensation, could still sue in conventional courts, but all claims for compensation had to go first through the VICP. Moreover, the standards of evidence in the Vaccine Court of the VICP are arguably markedly lower than in conventional federal courts. For example, Daubert rules for scientific evidence do not apply. Indeed, all that is necessary is a scientifically plausible-sounding mechanism by which a plaintiff might have been injured by vaccines, and compensation can be awarded. In essence, lowering the Daubert standard and allowing “science” that has not yet been peer reviewed makes meeting the standard of evidence showing a 51% or greater chance that the plaintiff was injured by the vaccine in question easier because it opened the door to an antivaccinationist version of the Gish Gallup, forcing the defense to answer and refute all sorts of bad science.
Be that as it may, as the number of litigants claiming that vaccines caused their children’s autism ballooned to close to 5,000, threatening to bankrupt the VICP unless massive infusions of new money from Congress were provided, it was decided that the proceedings should be bundled into one massive legal action known as the Autism Omnibus. As part of this proceeding, litigants were to choose what they considered to be the best cases representing their hypothesis of causation by which vaccines could produce autism and other neurodevelopmental disorders. The court would hear these cases, make a rulings, and then these rulings would be used as the basis for all similar cases as follows:
The Petitioners’ Steering Committee (PSC) has advanced three different theories of “general causation,” i.e., how the vaccines involved can cause autism, in the Omnibus Autism Proceeding. The Office of Special Masters (OSM) has assigned three Special Masters to resolve the autism cases. The OSM instructed the PSC to designate three “test cases” for each of the three theories, a total of nine test cases. The three theories of “general causation” are: (1) the theory that MMR vaccines and thimerosal-containing vaccines can combine to cause autism; (2) the theory that thimerosal-containing vaccines can cause autism; and, (3) the theory that MMR vaccines, without regard to any thimerosal additive, can cause autism.
After more than a year and a half after the proceedings began, on February 12, the Special Masters released its decisions on the first three test cases, Cedillo v. HHS (Case No. 98-916V), Hazlehurst v. HHS (Case No. 03-654V) and Snyder v. HHS (Case No. 01-162V). In all three cases, despite the “best” that the antivaccine contingent could throw at the courts, the Special Masters decisively rejected all three hypotheses of causation. Indeed, the results surprised me, as I had expected, given the extremely low bar for evidence, that there would have been a little bit of wiggle room in the decisions that would leave the door open for the antivaccine fringe to claim that there was a possibility that further causation cases would be entertained. No such wiggle room was granted. Since the decisions together run hundreds of pages, this article has become quite long, and other bloggers have posted excerpts, I will be judicious in selecting key quotes.
First, from the ruling on Cedillo v. HHS, written by Special Master George L. Hastings, Jr., we have these:
    • “This case, however, is not a close case. The overall weight of the evidence is overwhelmingly contrary to the petitioners’ causation theories. The result of this case would be the same even if I totally ignored the epidemiologic evidence, declined to consider the video evidence, and/or excluded the testimony of Dr. Bustin. The result would be the same if I restricted my consideration to the evidence originally filed into the record of this Cedillo case, disregarding the general causation evidence from the Hazlehurst and Snyder cases. The petitioners’ evidence has been unpersuasive on many different points, concerning virtually all aspects of their causation theories, each such deficiency having been discussed in detail above. The petitioners have failed to persuade me that there is validity to any of their general causation arguments, and have also failed to persuade me that there is any substantial likelihood that Michelle’s MMR vaccination contributed in any way to the causation of any of Michelle’s own disorders.”
    • “Nor do I doubt that Michelle’s parents and relatives are sincere in their belief that the MMR vaccine played a role in causing Michelle’s devastating disorders. Certainly, the mere fact that Michelle’s autistic symptoms first became evident to her family during the months after her MMR vaccination might make them wonder about a possible causal connection. Further, the Cedillos have read about physicians who profess to believe in a causal connection between the MMR vaccine and both autism and chronic gastrointestinal problems. They have visited at least one physician, Dr. Krigsman, who has explicitly opined that Michelle’s own chronic gastrointestinal symptoms are MMR-caused. And they have even been told that a medical laboratory has positively identified the presence of the persisting vaccine-strain measles virus in Michelle’s body, years after her vaccination. After studying the extensive evidence in this case for many months, I am convinced that the reports and advice given to the Cedillos by Dr. Krigsman and some other physicians, advising the Cedillos that there is a causal connection between Michelle’s MMR vaccination and her chronic conditions, have been very wrong. Unfortunately, the Cedillos have been misled by physicians who are guilty, in my view, of gross medical misjudgment. Nevertheless, I can understand why the Cedillos found such reports and advice to be believable under the circumstances. I conclude that the Cedillos filed this Program claim in good faith.”
Next, from the second case, Hazlehurst v. HHS, Special Master Patricia Campbell-Smith concluded:
Having carefully and fully considered the evidence, the undersigned concludes that the combination of the thimerosal-containing vaccines and the MMR vaccine are not causal factors in the development of autism and therefore, could not have contributed to the development of Yates’ autism. The weight of the presented evidence that is scientifically reliable and methodologically sound does not support petitioners’ claim. Petitioners have failed to establish entitlement to compensation under the Vaccine Act.
Finally, from the third case, Snyder v. HHS, Special Master Denise Vowell wrote:
To conclude that Colten’s condition was the result of his MMR vaccine, an objective observer would have to emulate Lewis Carroll’s White Queen and be able to believe six impossible (or, at least, highly improbable) things before breakfast. The families of children with ASD and the court have waited in vain for adequate evidence to support the autism-MMR hypothesis. Although I have the deepest sympathy for families like Colten’s, struggling emotionally and financially to find answers about ASD’s causes, and reliable therapies to treat ASD’s symptoms, I must decide Colten’s case based on the evidence before me. That evidence does not establish an adequate factual basis from which to conclude that Colten’s condition was caused by his vaccines.
Petitioners have not demonstrated by a preponderance of the evidence that Colten’s condition was either caused or significantly aggravated by his vaccinations Thus, they have failed to establish entitlement to compensation and the petition for compensation is therefore DENIED.
Ow. That last one’s going to leave a mark.
A more emphatic refutation is hard to imagine. Even better, Special Master Hastings recognized one of the main drivers of the scare over the MMR and vaccines in general as a “cause” of autism: Money. Indeed, a veritable cottage industry of “biomedical” quackery, dubious therapies, and pseudoscience depends upon keeping the idea that vaccines cause autism alive. “Luminaries” of this cottage industry include the aforementioned Andrew Wakefield, who has now infested the United States (the State of Texas, specifically) with his brand of quackery at Thoughtful House, now that the U.K. is investigating him. Also included are Mark and David Geier, who have been touting the use of a powerful anti-sex steroid medication to treat autistic children, and, until recently, Dr. Rashid Buttar, who is now facing sanctions by the North Carolina Board of Medical Examiners and has been banned from treating children. Add to that ambulance-chasing lawyers like Clifford Shoemaker, who have been raking in money hand over fist, thanks to the fact that the VICP actually pays the petitioners’ attorney fees regardless of whether the petition results in compensation, and it is easy to see why this industry won’t easily let parents be disabused of the fears over vaccines that it has stoked. (Indeed, Shoemaker even tried to abuse the subpoena process in order to quash reports of how much money he was making representing VICP litigants, an action for which he was sanctioned by the courts.) In the case of Andrew Wakefield, attorneys looking for big payouts from the pharmaceutical industry have even paid for research. Meanwhile, as documented on this blog before, some researchers producing reports implicating vaccines in autism are actually petitioners in the Autism Omnibus, for example, Laura Hewitson, whose husband works for Wakefield, while compounding pharmacies advertise their supplements and other dubious “remedies” right on the Age of Autism.
Those of us who support science- and evidence-based medicine were quite heartened by the revelations about Andrew Wakefield and the ruling in the Autism Omnibus. True, we wondered why it took 11 years for the revelations about Wakefield’s incompetence and outright fraud to see the light of day, but we were glad that they finally had. One reason is that, to the vast majority of lay people who are parents, the science is hard to understand, and the antivaccine movement had, more or less successfully, framed the issue as big pharma protecting its interests and a conflict between “brave maverick” doctors against government and pharma experts. However, fraud is something that people understand all too well. Demonstrating that Wakefield’s results were riddled not just with conflicts of interest but with outright scientific fraud made the issue very clear, driving home that there was no scientific basis to suspect that the MMR had anything to do with autism or other neurodevelopmental disorders. Similarly, the ruling of the Vaccine Court on the first three test cases surprised me. As I mentioned earlier, I had expected some wiggle room and was heartened to see that, contrary to what I had expected, science won unequivocally and resoundingly in court, at least in this case.
Antivaccinationists circle the wagons
The reaction of the antivaccine fringe to the rulings of the Special Masters and the revelations about Andrew Wakefield’s scientific fraud are instructive. Let’s examine the reaction to the Wakefield revelations first.
I don’t know about you, but if I passionatedly believed that the MMR vaccine causes autism or, even worse, caused autism in my child, I would be feeling very betrayed right now. In fact, I’d turn on Wakefield like a wild boar. But that’s just me. Apparently, that’s not the reaction of most of the antivaccine fringe. Indeed, the antivaccine propaganda blog Age of Autism and David Kirby, along with other antivaccine groups, immediately orchestrated a smear campaign against Brian Deer based on the flimsiest of pretenses. For example, in response to Keith Olbermann’s having correctly picked Andrew Wakefield as his “worst person in the world” for February 10, 2009, David Kirby cleverly played upon Olbermann’s hatred of Rupert Murdoch, pointing out that The Times of London is a Murdoch paper. This allowed Kirby to brag before the February 11 “Worst Person in the World” segment that he had persuaded Olbermann to name Brian Deer as one of the “worst persons in the world,” even publishing the script. Truly, Olbermann had been played for a fool by the antivaccine movement. The specious claim? That somehow Deer had a huge conflict of interest because he made the complaint to the GMC about Wakefield, a meme started by the British version of David Kirby, Melanie Phillips. It’s also a claim that, even if true, would mean nothing, as it does absolutely nothing to refute the findings in Deer’s reporting or the results thus far of the GMC’s investigation. Indeed, the ad hominems went beyond that. For example, Jane Bryant of OneClick Group has tried to paint Brian Deer as “out of control,” during which she couldn’t seem to resist trying homophobia on for size, stating:
By all accounts a gay man and therefore unlikely ever to have to face the multiple vaccine risk agonised over by parents from around the world in relation to their children, Brian Deer has made it his business to portray the parents of these autistic vaccine damaged children as deluded mendacious chancers.
I find this particularly ironic and despicable, given that chief antivaccine propagandist David Kirby is almost certainly also gay and that his previous jobs have included reporting for Outweek and The Advocate. One’s sexual orientation is completely irrelevant to one’s arguments. Only data, evidence, reason, and science should matter.
Finally, when all else fails, the antivaccine movement plays the conspiracy card, as John Stone of the British antivaccine group Cry Shame did on–where else?–Age of Autism:
And yet the medical and political establishment has been constructing its case against Wakefield on Deer’s reporting for the last five years. It was on the back of his first report that Wakefield was held to be “discredited” and the world was brow-beaten into believing it was so. UK National Health Service websites link up to Deer’s website, and the longest medical disciplinary hearing in British history was launched on the basis of his complaint. It is a game in which everybody hides behind everybody else, pretending they can’t be seen – but actually they are all standing there, and their trousers are down.
Never once does it occur to Stone or, for instance, any of the pro-Wakefield commenters here that the reason Wakefield is in such trouble is because he is a dishonest, incompetent, and unethical scientist. This, of course, is a perfect segue into the reaction to the Autism Omnibus rulings, which cranked the antivaccine fringe into ever more histrionic fits of conspiracy mongering. Indeed, leave it to our “old friend” J.B. Handley to connect the two by insinuating that the U.S. Department of Justice had tipped off Brian Deer somehow, so that his revelations could be published in close temporal proximity to the announcement of the first Autism Omnibus rulings:
That said, I found it rather odd that Brian Deer torpedoed Andy over the weekend with a seemingly made-up outrage piece, only days before the judges ruled in the Vaccine Court. The timing struck me as odd.
Meanwhile, the ever-reliable antivaccine advocate Kent Heckenlively, whose understanding of science is astonishingly bad, posted “analyses” of each decision. Some tidbits follow.
Regarding the Cedillo decision:
In his closing remarks he notes that the decision was not even close, and that the Cedillos have been misled by physicians who saw an opportunity to take advantage of a family who thought their child had been injured by a vaccine.
As much as those of who have children with autism and choose to help them are under great stress, I just viscerally respond to this attack against those physicians who are doing their best to help our children. They choose to enter this fight, knowing they will be attacked, but strengthened by the conviction they can help some of our children. To many of them, we owe our children’s future. And when they have not been able to find the answer, they continue to fight.
It is apparent to anybody who looks at this unfolding tragedy that the pharmaceutical companies have no interest in helping us, the medical universities and research facilities can offer us no help, and now we know we have no friends in the vaccine court.
Regarding the Hazlehurst decision:
The sad truth of the matter is that we are massively out-gunned in terms of research dollars. The medical personnel who undertake our cause do it knowing full well there will be many defeats. Judges will be dazzled by experts who claim to know so much, except for the question of what causes autism.
And, finally, regarding the Snyder decision:
I’ve tried to figure out how to explain this decision, and the best I can come up with is an example from the book, “Blink” by Malcom Gladwell. In the book Gladwell recounts the difficulty female musicians had in being hired by professional orchestras, particularly for the wind instruments. They were thought to lack the lung capacity of men. But when the auditions began to use screens, so the conductors couldn’t see the gender of the person playing, the number of women hired by professional orchestras increased five-fold.
Now the conductors would probably have sworn they were free of sexism, and may have truly believed it, but something else was clearly at work. Although the claim was made that they were simply listening to the music and picking the best people, the different results obtained after the use of the screens showed a significantly different mental process going on.
I can only conclude that something similar is at work in the minds of the Special Masters, and perhaps many people who will look at what we allege. Despite their efforts to carefully weigh the evidence, something else is tipping the scales. I don’t believe it’s money, at least in the crudest sense of the word. It’s money in the sense that it’s built the entire edifice and world-view in which the Special Masters are looking at these claims.
Or, to translate: The pharmaceutical companies paid for the verdict, and the judges were unconsciously biased against all those “brave maverick doctors” testifying for the plaintiffs.
But perhaps clearest, most blatant “it was fixed” argument comes from Dr. Jay “Don’t Call Me Antivaccine” Gordon in two posts he wrote for that repository for antivaccine posturing, The Huffington Post, entitled “There Is No Proof that Cigarettes Cause Cancer” and The Vaccine Court Was Wrong. Let’s take a look at his first bit of idiocy:
It took fifty years before the courts finally acknowledged that cigarette smoking causes cancer.
There were billions of dollars at stake.
The dozens of court decisions that there “was no proof” were supported by physicians, expert witnesses of all types and hundreds of millions of dollars spent on attorneys.
Experts and doctors alike stated over and over again that we need not continue studying this issue because there was just no proof.
Let me state very simply, vaccines can cause autism.
No real scientist would encourage us to stop studying this possibility.
Note the blatant straw man argument (“No real scientist would encourage us to stop studying this possibility”). Note the specious and false comparison that antivaccine advocates love to use: Comparing tobacco research to vaccine research. No matter how easy it is to demonstrate how wrong they are, they think it’s a slam dunk comparison that bolsters their paranoid, conspiracy mongering world view. After all, decades ago, scientists kept finding scientific and epidemiological evidence that tobacco smoking causes lung cancer and all manner of other health problems. Tobacco companies funded a well-financed denialist campaign of lies, bad science, and outright pseudoscience to try to convince the public that there was no link between smoking and cancer in order to protect their profits and forestall the regulation or banning of cigarettes by the government. So to antivaccinationists, it seems perfectly reasonable to claim that claiming that vaccines cause autism is the same thing, except with the evil big pharma vaccine manufacturers suppressing the “truth” to protect their profits and keep themselves safe from lawsuits.
Note another thing. Note the absolute certainty with which Dr. Jay states unequivocally that “vaccines can cause autism.” He even uses boldface and italics in the font, but that isn’t even enough to convey his level of certainty. He has to underline it too! (I congratulate him for his restraint in not using all caps as well.) Note that Dr. Jay’s certainty comes with no scientific evidence presented whatsoever to support it. None. Zero. Zip. Nada. This is very consistent with his past behavior, in which he apparently believes that simply asserting something is the same as proving it. It isn’t; argument by assertion is the lamest form of argument. In any case, apparently, just like the antivaccine movement for which he is an apologist, Dr. Jay just knows that vaccines cause autism, science be damned. Indeed, he demonstrates this utter belief–not science, belief–that the “proof” will someday be found:
The proof is not there yet. It will be found. Let’s hope it doesn’t take another fifty years and hundreds of court cases to convince the government and the public. Private industry is once again duping the FDA, doctors and the public. The conflicts of interest are obscene and illegal.
The diseases against which we vaccinate are still dangerous and still present in other countries and in America but simple risk/benefit analysis would show that the risks from the way vaccines are manufactured and administered far outweighs the risks of harm from these relatively rare illnesses.
Sure thing, Dr. Jay, and The Truth Is Out There. Fox Mulder and Dana Scully have taught us this, and Dr. Jay wants to believe. Oh, does he ever want to believe!
And that’s why these two victories for science will not, as many hope, put a damper on the antivaccine movement. They just won’t. To those who cling to the scientifically discredited idea that vaccines cause autism against the mountains of evidence that do not support it, as Kev points out, it is not about science. It is about winning and convincing people that they are right. It is about finding someone or something to “blame” for their children’s autism. To them, doctors have no authority. Scientists have no authority. The Special Masters have no authority. The scientific method means nothing. Only their personal experiences and the conclusions they draw from them, no matter how fallible humans are at drawing inferences from them, matter. To them, as Dr. Jay Gordon made explicit when he spoke to the “Green Our Vaccines” rally last summer, and said that his die hard belief that vaccines cause autism is based on states that he bases his conclusions that vaccines probably cause more harm than good on “over 30 years” of his own experience and above all (emphasis mine) “listening to you,” meaning the parents who believe vaccines “injured” their children.
That’s because the battle between parents who believe that vaccines cause autism and scientists is a battle about, more than anything else, two world views. Scientists, knowing how easily humans fool themselves into confusing correlation with causation when drawing conclusions from personal experience and anecdotes, rely on epidemiology and the scientific method to answer the question of whether vaccination is associated with autism. In contrast, the believers cannot accept that they can be fooled. Dr. Rahul K. Parikh described this conflict well in a recent article on the Omnibus decision:
Among those expressing shock and disappointment was Rebecca Estepp, the mother of an autistic child, who is one of the claimants and the national manager of the advocacy group Talk About Curing Autism. “It’s tough when you’re taking parent support calls and you hear the same story day after day,” she told the Wall Street Journal. “When does anecdotal evidence become enough?”
Her question isn’t a new one, especially in a society where belief, emotion and science so often conflict. For scientists, the answer to Estepp’s question is never. Developing a hypothesis from anecdotes or observations (whether one or a hundred of them) is merely the first step in a longer process. Next comes the hard part: testing that hypothesis to see if you can back it up with hard data, and then sharing the data with others to see if they can reproduce the findings, often multiple times.
Even more accurately, Dr. Parikh states:
Now, read that headline again: “Vaccines Didn’t Cause Autism, Court Rules.” It doesn’t say, “Vaccines Didn’t Cause Autism, a Decade’s Worth of Rigorously Conducted and Verified Medical Research Rules.” That may not be as sexy as the recent headline, but it is the truth. The scientific community disproved the vaccine-autism connection long ago, multiple times.
Which is true (except that it’s well over a decade’s worth of research), and to which I would add: The scientific community only continues to study the vaccine-autism connection, churning out negative study after negative study because it hopes to convince those who are unconvinceable by science. Indeed, just how unconvinceable they are is summed up in this poem by Rolf Hazelhurst, the father of one of the three complainants:
If we win, we keep going.
If we lose, we keep going.
If we win, the going will be easier.
If we lose, the going will be more difficult.
However, the Court rules, we will keep going.
That is a religious, cultish attitude. A little thing like a news report revealing the hero of the antivaccine movement to be a scientific fraud or a court ruling that, even under the most favorable standards of evidence imaginable, vaccines do not cause autism will not change the mind of someone like this, nor will it make the antivaccine movement have second thoughts about its cultish beliefs. The only hope that we who support science-based medicine can have is that these two body blows to the antivaccine movement will finally–finally!–drive home the message to the media that, when it comes to the claim that vaccines cause autism, there’s no there there, as they say. We can also hope that the fence-sitters, those parents who may have heard Jenny McCarthy ranting about how vaccines caused her son Evan’s autism and how she cured him with various biomedical interventions may see these two repudiations of the myth that vaccines cause autism and be reassured.
A guy can hope, can’t he?

   Anti-vaccine warriors vs. research ethics
David Gorski
Link
Three weeks ago, the anti-vaccine movement took a swing for the fences and, as usual, made a mighty whiff that produced a breeze easily felt in the bleachers. In brief, a crew of anti-vaccine lawyers headed by Mary Holland, co-author of Vaccine Epidemic: How Corporate Greed, Biased Science, and Coercive Government Threaten Our Human Rights, Our Health, and Our Children, published a highly touted (by Generation Rescue and other anti-vaccine groups, that is) “study” claiming to “prove” that the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (VICP) had actually compensated children for autism. As is typical with such “studies” generated by the anti-vaccine movement, it was bad science, bad law, and just plain bad all around. The authors intentionally conflated “autism-like” symptoms with autism, trying to claim that children with neurological injury with “autism-like” symptoms actually have autism. Never mind that there are specific diagnostic criteria for autism and that, if the children actually had autism, many of them would have been given a diagnosis of autism. Never mind that what they were doing was akin to claiming that all patients with “Parkinson’s-like symptoms” have Parkinson’s disease. (Hint: They don’t.) Never mind that all they did was to demonstrate a prevalence of autism spectrum disorders among the VICP-compensated children that was clearly within the range of what would be anticipated if there were no relationship between vaccines and autism. Never mind all that. This was Holland’s big chance, but it went over like the proverbial lead balloon. No one bit, other than FOX News.
The study rapidly faded into the obscurity it so richly deserves, in spite of mighty efforts by Generation Rescue, SafeMinds, and the likes of Ginger Taylor to keep it alive and use it as a rallying point to persuade legislators to pass anti-vaccine-friendly legislation. You could feel the frustration in its backers as Holland’s study, into which groups like Generation Rescue had apparently poured their hopes of being vindicated, crashed and burned.
However, there’s one aspect of this study that I didn’t discuss. In fact, I thought of it as I read it, but I wasn’t sure. What I (and others) have noticed is that there was no statement in the article that approval had been obtained from the relevant institutional review boards (IRBs) to do human subjects research. For those not familiar with what an IRB is, an IRB is a committee that oversees all human subject research for an institution. It is the IRB’s responsibility to make sure that all studies are ethical in design and that they conform to all federal regulations. Basically, IRBs are charged with weighing the risks and benefits of proposed human subject research and making sure that
     1.  risks are minimized and that the risk:benefit ratio, at least as well as it can be estimated, is very favorable;
     2.  to minimize any pain, suffering or distress that might come about because of the experimental therapy; and
     3.  to make sure that researchers obtain truly informed consent.
During the course of a study, regular reports must be made to the IRB, which can shut down any study in its institution if it has concerns about patient welfare.
Of course, I know this all because I happen to be involved in human subjects research. It’s part of what I do while doing research in breast cancer. Clinical trials are obviously human subjects research. After all, their very purpose is to test a new drug or treatment on human subjects in order to determine if it works. However, human subjects research encompasses a lot more than just clinical trials; in fact, it encompasses almost any research study that involves either human subjects or human subjects’ protected health information (i.e., medical charts). Basically, any human subject experimentation requires approval by a properly constituted IRB. There is no documentation in Holland et al that IRB approval had been obtained, either from the for NYU (given that Mary Holland is a research scholar at the NYU School of Law) and/or Pace University, given that Pace Law School is cited as having “provided significant research support for this study” in the footnotes of the paper:
Mary Holland, Research Scholar and Director of the Graduate Legal Skills Program, NYU School of Law; Louis Conte, independent investigator; and Robert Krakow and Lisa Colin, attorneys in private practice. Pace Law School provided significant research support for this study.
Autism News Beat and Sullivan are already all over this issue, but I thought I’d throw in a bit from my perspective, given that I actually have to work with IRBs and, before my career is over, will probably be roped into serving on an IRB. In any case, as is true of any researcher who is involved in human subjects research, I had to undergo specific training regarding the “rules of the road,” so to speak, as a requirement of being an investigator on any study involving human subjects research.
How is human subjects research defined? According to 32 CFR 219.102(d), research means “a systematic investigation, including research development, testing, and evaluation, designed to develop or contribute to generalizable knowledge,” and according to 32 CFR 219.102(f) a human subject is defined as ” living individual about whom an investigator (whether professional or student) conducting research obtains data through intervention or interaction with the individual, or identifiable private information.”
Under these criteria, I believe that the Pace study clearly qualifies as human subjects research. First of all, as poorly designed as the study was, it was clearly intended as a systematic investigation designed to contribute to generalizable knowledge and testing a hypothesis, namely that autism is associated with vaccine-induced brain injury. The authors claim to have found data in the VICP-compensated cases indicating that there is a higher incidence of autism in these children. Never mind that they found nothing of the sort, they set out to test that hypothesis and their methods were designed to support it. Moreover, as Autism News Beat pointed out, members of the Elizabeth Birt Center for Autism and Legal Advocacy (EBCALA) administered the Social Communication Questionnaire (SCQ) to the parents or caregivers of 22 children. This clearly makes the parents who answered the questionnaire (and their children) human subjects, as identifiable protected health information about the children is being solicited and used to test their hypothesis.
To be fair, I have to point out that there are types of studies that are exempt from full IRB approval. In fact, there are six categories of so-called “exempt” studies. I frequently use category four, which involves the use of already existing clinical information that has been de-identified. I also note that this particular exemption involves research that does not involve interacting with living humans about their health information; rather, these sorts of studies tend to involve chart reviews or the examination of human tissue specimens that have already been collected. Be that as it may, there is one potential exemption that EBCALA might claim. First, number two:
Research involving the use of educational tests (cognitive, diagnostic, aptitude, achievement), survey procedures, interview procedures or observation of public behavior, unless:
     1.  information obtained is recorded in such a manner that human subjects can be identified, directly or through identifiers linked to the subjects; and
     2.  any disclosure of the human subjects responses outside the research could reasonably place the subjects at risk of criminal or civil liability or be damaging to the subjects financial standing, employability, or reputation.
Unfortunately for Holland et al, the first “unless” probably kills this exemption. The information they obtained was obtained in a manner such that the human subjects can be identified. The second “unless” might or might not kill the exemption; I note that both criteria are used to decide whether an exemption is not permissible. However, even if this research could potentially be considered exempt – and I highly doubt that a reputable IRB operating within the law and the Common Rule would find it exempt, particularly since IRBs are charged with taking special care to protect human subjects considered to be vulnerable, such as children, and that the survey is in fact a screening/diagnostic tool, making the results protected health information – it should also be noted it is not the investigators who get to decide whether a protocol is exempt or not and therefore whether a protocol requires IRB evaluation and approval. Period. Investigators do not have the power to determine whether their research falls under one of these exempt categories; only the IRB can make that determination, usually in an expedited review that determines whether a potentially exempt protocol meets the standards of one of the categories that are exempt from full IRB approval. It’s right there in the rules:
Only the IRB may determine which activities qualify for an exempt review. Investigators do not have the authority to make an independent determination that research involving human subjects is exempt and must contact the IRB concerning the status of proposed research or changes in ongoing research.
Also note that the research cannot begin until after IRB approval is obtained.
Personally, unlike the case with the Geiers, my guess is that as lawyers Holland et al were simply ignorant that what they were doing constituted human subjects research and that’s why they didn’t bother with a little thing (to them) like obtaining IRB approval before doing their study. Indeed, when Autism News Beat inquired at Pace Law School about whether the EBCALA study had IRB approval, this is what he was told:
When asked if the Pace study had IRB approval, Pace Law spokesperson Lauren Rubenstein referred the question to the study’s co-author, Louis Conte. In an email, Rubenstein wrote “Louis Conte has told me that there was no human subjects research in this study.
Which reveals Conte’s utter cluelessness about human subjects research. Investigators interacted with the parents of these children, administering a questionnaire to them for purposes of looking for data to support their hypothesis. It’s human subjects research until judged otherwise–by an IRB, not by Conte, Holland, or any of the other of the merry band of anti-vaccine lawyers who put this travesty of a study together. Not surprisingly, attempts to get Conte to respond to e-mails regarding IRB approval of the study were not returned.
Of course, ignorance of the law is no excuse; as lawyers the authors of Holland et al should know. I also find it rather hard to believe, whether or not they were ignorant of federal law and regulations regarding human subjects research, that at some point either Holland and her coauthors weren’t made aware somehow by someone that what they were doing constituted human subjects research under federal law. Surely someone must have realized this, given that questionnaires about protected health information were being administered to living human beings. If they did not, then, quite frankly, I find the level of incompetence and lack of concern about basic ethical standards that every investigator in the U.S. who engages in human subjects research knows as basic information because they are required to know them and abide by them as part of ethics and the law.
This lack of concern about such niceties of the ethical treatment of human subjects is nothing new in anti-vaccine studies. Andrew Wakefield demonstrated it with his callous treatment of children at a party, whom he basically bribed for blood samples and whose fear he made light of. The Geiers père et fils demonstrated it when they created an IRB to oversee their own research, sat on that IRB themselves with Dr. Geier himself chairing the committee (a massive conflict of interest), and packed it with their anti-vaccine cronies.
There’s one more “out” that Holland et al might try for, and that’s to say that their research was not federally funded and is therefore not covered by the Common Rule. However, most universities that accept federal funding for research agree to be bound by the Common Rule for all research carried out by their faculty, students, and trainees. Even if Holland et al tried to justify their failure to obtain IRB approval this way and argue that they are not legally bound to follow the Common Rule, their failure to obtain IRB approval for their study and submit to IRB oversight is a massive ethical failing. I characterized Holland et al as evidence that when the anti-vaccine movement can’t win on science, it will appeal to the law. It also appears that when it can’t win on ethics, it will appeal to the law as well.
While Holland et al tout “unanswered” questions about autism and the VICP, the only question I have is: Will Pace University and NYU will investigate how such a study could be performed without its investigators obtaining the requisite IRB approval? Or will they sweep this massive ethical (and possibly legal) breach under the rug and hope it goes away?

Trust in science and vaccines continues to decline. Why?
Recent evidence shows that public trust in science and vaccines has declined markedly since the pandemic. Why is this, and is there anything we can do about it?
David Gorski on November 27, 2023
Link

As we are approaching the end of the fourth year of the COVID-19 pandemic, which has killed close to 7 million people worldwide and 1.2 million in just the US alone, both estimates being almost certainly significant undercounts of the true toll, I was depressed to see yet more evidence indicating significantly declining trust in science and science-based interventions to combat disease, such as vaccines. For example, earlier this month the Pew Research Center published survey results noting that Americans’ Trust in Scientists, Positive Views of Science Continue to Decline, with the blurb, “Among both Democrats and Republicans, trust in scientists is lower than before the pandemic.” Not long before that, there was a spate of articles about how exemptions to school vaccine requirements are now at an all-time high and COVID-19 and influenza vaccine uptake among children is very low, based on a recent MMWR study Coverage with Selected Vaccines and Exemption from School Vaccine Requirements Among Children in Kindergarten — United States, 2022–23 School Year. The news is indeed depressing for science and vaccine advocates, as has been recent news about how vaccination rates among healthcare workers for influenza and COVID-19 have been declining, based on two studies also published in MMWR, Influenza and Up-to-Date COVID-19 Vaccination Coverage Among Health Care Personnel — National Healthcare Safety Network, United States, 2022–23 Influenza Season and Declines in Influenza Vaccination Coverage Among Health Care Personnel in Acute Care Hospitals During the COVID-19 Pandemic — United States, 2017–2023. As someone who, since skipping a year around 15 years ago and getting laid up for a week with the worst case of flu I had ever had, has always gotten his yearly flu vaccine and who is also up-to-date on COVID-19 boosters, including the most recent, I nonetheless admit to little surprise at these data. After all, I’ve been writing about vaccine hesitancy and antivaccine pseudoscience and conspiracy theories for nearly 20 years.
Before I discuss why this is happening, which is, of course, a bit sarcastic, as regular readers will recognize immediately, particularly given Jonathan Howard’s post over the weekend about a certain oncologist, but I do think it’s worth unpacking. First, let’s start with the Pew Research Center survey.
Trust in science has declined since the pandemic
The Pew survey examined a number of areas related to what Americans think of science and scientists:
    • Impact of science on society
    • Trust in scientists
    • How scientists compare to other groups
    • Differences in trust in scientists based on political orientation
The survey methodology involved polling a sample of 8,842 U.S. adults from Sept. 25 to Oct. 1, 2023 taken from the Center’s American Trends Panel (ATP), an online survey panel that is recruited through national, random sampling of residential addresses. The survey was weighted to be representative of the U.S. adult population by gender, race, ethnicity, partisan affiliation, education and other categories. In addition:
Data in this report is drawn from ATP Wave 135, conducted from Sept. 25 to Oct. 1, 2023, and includes an oversample of Hispanic men, non-Hispanic Black men and non-Hispanic Asian adults in order to provide more precise estimates of the opinions and experiences of these smaller demographic subgroups. These oversampled groups are weighted back to reflect their correct proportions in the population.
A total of 8,842 panelists responded out of 9,577 who were sampled, for a response rate of 92%. The cumulative response rate accounting for nonresponse to the recruitment surveys and attrition is 3%. The break-off rate among panelists who logged on to the survey and completed at least one item is 1%. The margin of sampling error for the full sample of 8,842 respondents is plus or minus 1.6 percentage points
Unfortunately, the results of that the issue examined above are painfully predictable, as you will see, but first let’s look at the first three topics. While the vast majority of Americans agree that science has had a mostly positive effect on society, the percentage of Americans who say this has declined markedly since January 2019:
Overall, 57% of Americans say science has had a mostly positive effect on society. This share is down 8 percentage points since November 2021 and down 16 points since before the start of the coronavirus outbreak.
About a third (34%) now say the impact of science on society has been equally positive as negative. A small share (8%) think science has had a mostly negative impact on society.
Are you surprised that it’s so low? To be honest, I was a bit surprised that it was only 73% in January 2019; I would have guessed higher. To me, it’s instructive to look at the graph of the distribution of answers since 2018:

You could look at this chart and say that the percentage of Americans who think that science has had a “mostly negative” affect on society is still small, only 8%. However, it has doubled since 2019, and, although on an absolute basis, that is a relatively small increase, on a relative basis it’s huge. Think about it: The percentage of people who think science has been mostly harmful has doubled in less than five years. Also of interest is how the number who think that science has had an equal positive and negative impact, after having remained pretty stable for four years, has over the last two years increased on a relative basis by over 21%, a change reflected in the number of Americans who say that science has had a mostly positive impact, again after four years of relative stability (aside from a bit of an outlier high value in 2019), plunged by 11%.
This increasing distrust is mirrored by the next result of the survey:
When it comes to the standing of scientists, 73% of U.S. adults have a great deal or fair amount of confidence in scientists to act in the public’s best interests. But trust in scientists is 14 points lower than it was at the early stages of the pandemic.
The share expressing the strongest level of trust in scientists – saying they have a great deal of confidence in them – has fallen from 39% in 2020 to 23% today.
As trust in scientists has fallen, distrust has grown: Roughly a quarter of Americans (27%) now say they have not too much or no confidence in scientists to act in the public’s best interests, up from 12% in April 2020.
Again, the percentage of Americans who have little or no confidence in scientists to act in the publics best interests has more than doubled in less than four years. Let’s take a look at how these numbers compare to doctors, medical scientists, and other authority figures:
As you can see, there have been declines in trust in most areas, but trust in some seems more stable than others, such as the military and religious leaders. Similar to the case with scientists in general, the percentage with little or no confidence that medical scientists (which include physicians) act in the best interests of society has also roughly doubled, with a concomitant decline in the other categories.
What is, perhaps, most depressing about this study is that the decline in trust in science and scientists was not uniform. Rather, there are certain groups for which the decline was much greater than other groups. First, though, as you might expect, trust in science tends to correlate with educational attainment:
Americans with higher levels of education are especially likely to say science has had a mostly positive effect on society. About eight-in-ten adults with a postgraduate degree say this, as do 72% of those with a bachelor’s degree.
A smaller majority of Americans with some college education say science has had a mostly positive effect on society (56%). And fewer than half of those with a high school diploma or less education hold this view (42%).
The graph of the data shows this phenomenon rather starkly:
The above result is not unexpected, nor is it new. It is also somewhat reassuring in that the number of very highly educated COVID-19 minimizers and antivaxxers are clearly an incredibly tiny minority of highly educated people with PhDs and professional degrees. On the other hand, because of their advanced degrees, such physicians, scientists, and other PhDs have an outsized influence when they promote pseudoscience and conspiracy theories because of the letters after their names, particularly among people who, unlike those of us who have pointed out for a long time that an advanced degree does not inoculate against irrational beliefs, assume that those with an advanced degree, particularly in medicine or medical science, must know what they’re talking about.
The result that is particularly worrisome to me should come as no surprise to our readers, namely that trust (or, more specifically, lack of trust) in science has become very much politicized, with a huge partisan difference in trust in science and scientists. Although trust in science has also declined among Democrats, it’s most striking among Republicans:
Fewer than half of Republicans (47%) now say that science has had a mostly positive effect on society. In 2019, 70% of Republicans said this.
Read the full report here: https://t.co/qpldfH0zjs pic.twitter.com/MVtwZLS4XN
— Pew Research Science (@pewscience) November 15, 2023
As you can see from the chart above, belief that science has had a net positive effect on society has only declined slightly among Democrats and those who lean Democratic; it’s barely lower than it was in 2016, although it had increased to an even higher level between 2019 and 2021. In contrast, among those who are Republican or lean Republican, there has been a massive decline, consistent with what I’ve been discussing all along regarding, for example, the antivaccine movement.
Although the numbers are small, even among Democrats with a bachelor’s degree, there has been a marked decline in trust in science. It’s much worse among Republicans because Republicans started from a much higher baseline distrust of science, but the percentage of those expressing little or no confidence that scientists act in the best interests of society increased by more than three-fold among both political orientations, although the magnitude of the change was less among those with some college or less:
As you might recall, antivaccine beliefs used to be more or less evenly distributed between the left and the right (although when I first started writing about the antivaccine movement in 2004 there existed an exaggerated if not outright false stereotype that antivaxxers tended to be hippy-dippy crunchy lefties, particularly suburban moms, in liberal enclaves like Marin County or Manhattan). However, beginning around the time of the Tea Party wave in 2010 or somewhat earlier, the political center of gravity of the antivaccine movement began to shift rightward, a process that accelerated in 2015 with the resistance to California SB 277 (which eliminated nonmedical exemptions to school vaccine mandates), picked up more steam with the rise of Donald Trump and his victory in the 2016 Presidential election, and then was turbocharged by the pandemic, to the point where it is now very much further to the right than it ever was.
Of course, vaccine science is not the only science. I only mention it so prominently here because the antivaccine movement is the science denial movement with which I am most familiar. I also note that evolution denial (a.k.a. creationism or “intelligent design” creationism) has, due to its tight association with conservative and evangelical religions whose adherents believe in a more literal interpretation of the Bible, always also been associated far more with the political right than the left. I also can’t help but wonder whether the main drivers of the decreasing trust in science and scientists documented by this survey are vaccines and COVID-19 mitigations.
Also disturbing are the racial disparities in trust in science documented in this survey:
These results are unsurprising, given the long history of racial disparities in medicine and the legacy of abuses like the Tuskegee syphilis experiment, all of which those promoting distrust in physicians and scientists—the whole medical and scientific endeavor, actually—have been unceasingly reminding the public about in order to encourage racial minorities not to trust medicine and science.
The overall picture painted by the Pew survey is a depressing one for science advocates. Trust in science has declined since the pandemic hit, and that decline shows no signs of leveling off yet. It should not be too surprising, then, that there have been consequences to this decline in trust.
Vaccines
Going along with this general decline in trust in science and scientists, vaccination rates have not recovered to their prepandemic levels:
Vaccination rates among U.S. kindergartners for routine childhood shots have still not returned to pre-pandemic levels, according to new federal data published Thursday.
Researchers from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) looked at how many children met school requirements for the measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine; the diphtheria, tetanus and acellular pertussis (DTaP) vaccine; the poliovirus (polio) vaccine; and the varicella (chickenpox) vaccine.
For the 2022-23 school year, about 93% of children in kindergarten had met the vaccination requirements. That’s about the same number that was seen the previous school year, but lower than the 94% seen in 2020-21 and the 95% seen in 2019-20, prior to the COVID-19 pandemic. The latter percentage had been the standard for about 10 years.
At the same time, rates of exemption to vaccines required for school have increased:
Now, I know what some readers might be thinking. A decline of 2% in the vaccination rates of kindergarteners sure doesn’t sound like much. “Only” 2% sounds like a small decline, and it is on an absolute basis although on a relative basis going from 95% to 93% coverage represents a 40% increase in the number of unvaccinated children. Remember, also, that for the most transmissible vaccine-preventable diseases, the percentage of immune people necessary to achieve herd immunity is 95% or higher, meaning that vaccination rates need to be 95%—or preferably higher.
As the CDC report on vaccine exemptions notes in its conclusion:
The overall percentage of children with an exemption increased from 2.6% during the 2021–22 school year to 3.0% during the 2022–23 school year, the highest exemption rate ever reported in the United States (2). The percentage of children with an exemption increased in 40 states and DC. To achieve the Healthy People 2030 target of 95% MMR coverage, exemptions cannot exceed 5%. State-level exemption rates in excess of 5% prevent 10 states from potentially achieving ≥95% MMR coverage even if all nonexempt kindergartners in 2022–23 were vaccinated, up from four states in 2021–22. National MMR coverage of 93.1% during the 2022–23 school year translates to approximately 250,000 kindergartners who are at risk for measles infection.
As we’ve discussed here many times before going back to the very earliest years of this blog, what happens when overall vaccination coverage declines is that it tends to do so unevenly, with pockets of children with vaccine uptake much lower than that needed for herd immunity. You can see that from how exemption rates are now over 5% in 10 states. When that happens, we start to see outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases, usually starting with the most contagious of vaccine-preventable childhood diseases, measles, as happened earlier this year in Ohio where there was an outbreak that sickened 85 children, the vast majority of whom were unvaccinated.
Some states have really high exemption rates, too. For instance, Idaho has an exemption rate of over 12%, with uptake ranging from 80.7% and 81.8% for four key childhood vaccines (MMR, DTaP, polio, and varicella). That’s really low, far below what is needed for herd immunity, especially for measles. Other states with high exemption rates include Arizona (7.4%), Oregon (8.1%), Utah (8.1%), and Wisconsin (7.2%), among others. States with very low exemption rates include California (0.2%), Mississippi (0.2%), West Virginia (<0.1%), and New York (0.1%), all states that do not allow nonmedical “personal belief” exemptions to school vaccine mandates and whose exemption rates are consistent with the percentage of children who would have valid medical exemptions. Basically, restricting nonmedical exemptions to school vaccine mandates works.
Unsurprisingly, as I have pointed out before this latest CDC report was published, antivaxxers have crowed and gloated over the decline in childhood vaccination rates and the increase in nonmedical vaccine exemptions that has taken place since the pandemic. Similarly, COVID-19 contrarians in the name of unthinking fealty to evidence-based medicine precepts to the point of echoing longstanding antivaccine tropes that has led them to undermine not just confidence in COVID-19 vaccines but confidence in the entire childhood vaccine schedule, tut-tut and gloat, “I told you so,” never acknowledging their role in promoting distrust of vaccines and public health science.
Meanwhile, online, antivaxxers have seamlessly repurposed antivax rhetoric and conspiracy theories about MMR and other childhood vaccines to COVID-19 vaccines and back again:
“No no no. Avoid them all,” one person says. “Once they’re injected into the bloodstream, the metals and toxins have access to the brain and every organ!” she claims falsely. “Arm yourself with information to decline because they will pressure you.”
Others share stories of children they claim have been damaged by the MMR vaccine. Some advise the parents to “just ignore” communications from the NHS. “I keep getting letters for all my kids. It’s scaremongering. I’ve threatened my surgery with harassment if they don’t stop sending me letters,” another person says.
And:
Part of the problem, said Selvarajah, is that there is a “massive overhang” from the days of Andrew Wakefield, who in the late 1990s pushed the debunked theory that the MMR vaccine causes autism – leading uptake to plummet. Those false claims still circulate in some parent circles, he added. General scepticism about vaccines has also risen post-pandemic: “Since Covid we’ve seen a lot more hesitancy. Theories about the MMR and Covid vaccines have merged.”
As I’ve long been saying, this was always going to happen. There are only a limited number of antivaccine narratives, and they are endlessly repurposed and tweaked for new vaccines as they arise. We’ve long pointed out how doctors who voice suspicion of COVID-19 vaccines seem inevitably drawn towards the very same antivaccine narratives that have been applied to childhood vaccines since time immemorial (or at least since long before I started paying serious attention two decades ago), narrative such as claims that the disease is “harmless” (applied to both measles and COVID-19 in children, even though before the measles vaccine measles used to kill around the same number of children adjusted for population increases, as COVID-19 kills now), that “natural immunity” is better, and that vaccines haven’t been adequately tested. That last one is a favorite of Dr. Vinay Prasad, whose EBM fundamentalism led him to start parroting misleading antivaccine rhetoric about childhood vaccines having never been tested in “saline controlled” randomized clinical trials and even repeating almost word-for-word antivax “do not comply” rhetoric.
It’s not just childhood vaccines, either, nor is it just lay people. As I cited above, the CDC recently reported that vaccination rates for COVID-19 and influenza are declining among US healthcare workers. The rates are truly appalling, too, as a news story summarized:
For the first study, researchers pulled data from the CDC’s National Healthcare Safety Network (NHSN) for January to June 2023.
They found that flu vaccine coverage was 81% among health care employees at hospitals and 47.1% at nursing homes.
In terms of COVID vaccine coverage for medical workers, it was at just 7.2% at hospitals and 22.8% at nursing homes.
Again, these are appallingly low numbers, and the trend is not good either:
In a second study, the CDC researchers analyzed the same data to determine the level of flu vaccination among health care personnel.
Prior to the COVID pandemic, flu vaccine coverage rose from 88.6% in 2017-2018 to 90.7% in 2019-2020.
However, the rate declined to 85.9% in the 2020-2021 season and dropped again to 81.1% in 2022-2023.
When you can’t even get healthcare personnel to do the right thing with respect to their own health and that of their patients, you know there’s a problem.
So what’s going on?
Public health and science advocates are understandably somewhat puzzled and unhappy about these results. Of course, antivaxxers and COVID-19 minimizers (like Dr. Prasad) are quick to blame scientists and the public health apparatus exclusively. Of course, no science advocate that I’m aware of denies that part of this growth in distrust is, in part, a self-inflicted wound. The CDC’s performance very early in the pandemic, particularly with respect to testing, masking recommendations, and personal protective equipment, was not very good. The difference is that science advocates will admit this and suggest ways to do better, just as we have always criticized the FDA and CDC when they suffered lapses.
In contrast, you’ll notice how those most responsible for intentionally stoking this distrust completely ignore their role in, well, stoking this distrust since 2021 (at least). As Dr. Howard so well put it, when “reputable” doctors lecture science advocates about how it’s “entirely predictable” that parents would become suspicious of routine chlldhood vaccines, his conclusion is correct but not for the reasons he claims. Surely his incessant arguments that COVID-19 isn’t dangerous to children, like this one, had nothing to do with it:
Covid-19 is less deadly to children than many other risks we accept as a matter of course, including drowning, vehicle accidents, and even cardiovascular disease.
This was exactly how antivaxxers used to minimize the severity of measles. Indeed, this is nothing more than the Brady Bunch gambit, in which antivaxxers used to point to a 1969 episode of The Brady Bunch and other old sitcoms that played measles for laughs as evidence that measles wasn’t considered dangerous then, updated for COVID-19.
There are, of course, a number of other forces promoting distrust of science and vaccines. As Katrine Wallace, an epidemiologist and anti-misinformation advocate at the University of Illinois Chicago, notes:
Wallace attributes the rise of scientific mistrust to what she described as an “infodemic” about Covid-19: an influx of conflicting information and opinions about the virus and prevention measures.
“It led to a lot of public chaos, bewilderment, message fatigue and people just kind of checking out,” Wallace told CNN. “It just causes a lot of confusion because we have different people with big platforms saying different things.”
“Infodemic” is a term that was coined 20 years ago about the tsunami of information, in which scientifically valid information is mixed together with pseudoscience and conspiracy theories in such a way that it is almost impossible for a lay person to tell which is which, which is then amplified by the algorithms of social media that feed us what causes the most “engagement”:
In the absence of high-quality information about the Covid-19 virus, “information voids” for public health topics filled social media platforms with speculation,supplements and untested cures, she added.
In Wallace’s eyes, the system amplified disinformation and cultivated growing scientific mistrust among groups.
“Everyone was at home on social media and interacting in these echo chambers filtering out any information they didn’t want to see,” Wallace said. “Different groups come to different conclusions because they’re interacting with different information.”
Of course, much of that misinformation was, in fact, disinformation in that it was not erroneous or incorrect misinformation innocently shared, but rather the product of groups seeking to promote their own ideologically based narrative:
And often, experts say, that flood of false information was intentional and malicious — attacking scientific voices in favor of inaccurate content.
Dr. Peter Hotez, the dean of the National School of Tropical Medicine at Baylor College of Medicine, said a “revisionist history” popped up as the pandemic emerged, blaming scientists for seeding mistrust and exacerbating the harms of Covid-19.
“There was a predatory, targeted, deliberate movement from the far right trying to discredit science and scientists,” Hotez said. “The narrative that’s trying to be put out there is that the scientists did something wrong.”
Dr. Hotez is, of course, not wrong here. Far from it. All you have to do is to look at who appeared regularly on Fox News during the pandemic to promote doubt about nonpharmaceutical interventions against COVID-19 (e.g., masking, business closures, etc.) and about how dangerous the virus was in order to promote a “we want them infected” narrative pushing “natural herd immunity,” coupled with the promotion of quack cures like ivermectin and misinformation casting doubt on the safety and efficacy of COVID-19 vaccines. Unlike the way those blaming it all on scientists ignore their role in stoking distrust of science, Dr. Hotez acknowledges that we probably contributed to it:
Hotez said the scientific community can make some changes that will build trust.
“We need to up our game in terms of how we do science communication,” he said. “Stop with the old-fashioned idea of communication that we talk to the American people as if they’re in the sixth grade. Talk to them like adults.”
Universities, which Hotez believes are risk-averse, should encourage their scientists to speak out, he said.
That last part resonates with me, given the proclivity of antivaxxers and quacks dating back to long before the pandemic for trying to attack me through my employer by burying my department chair in complaints for my social media activity and trying to get me fired—or at least silenced by my job. Fortunately, there is a strong culture of academic freedom in universities that resists such efforts. Unfortunately, that same culture has protected academics promoting misinformation.
Be that as it may, just answering misinformation with good information and talking to the public “like adults” will never be sufficient. I like to cite Brandolini’s law, which states that the energy required to refute misinformation is an order of magnitude greater than the energy required to create it, and then observe that Brandolini was an optimist. My observation has been that it often takes at least two or three orders of magnitude to refute misinformation compared to what it takes to create it. We will always be at a huge disadvantage as long as we take only the approach of debunking. That’s why I’m a big fan now of “prebunking,” which involves recognizing the common narratives and conspiracy theories behind antiscience misinformation and preemptively teaching about them and trying to provide critical thinking skills that allow one to recognize new forms of old misinformation when one sees them.
In the meantime, science advocates, scientists, and physicians have their work cut out for them, as the trendiness suggest that we haven’t yet hit bottom in terms of distrust of science and medicine.

Sharyl Attkisson and CBS News: An epic fail in reporting on the murder of autistic teen Alex Spourdalakis
David Gorski on September 2, 2013
Link
An antivaccine reporter strikes again
The damaged done by the antivaccine movement is primarily in how it frightens parents out of vaccinating using classic denialist tactics of spreading fear, uncertainty and doubt (FUD). Indeed, as has been pointed out many times before, antivaccinationists are often proud of their success in discouraging parents from vaccinating, with one leader of the antivaccine movement even going so far as to characterize his antivaccine “community, held together with duct tape and bailing wire,” as being in the “early to middle stages of bringing the U.S. vaccine program to its knees.” Meanwhile, just last week Anne Dachel, “media editor” for the antivaccine crank blog Age of Autism, gloated about basically the same thing, how although overall vaccination rates remain high, vaccine exemption rates are up in many areas of the country and how her movement has provided plenty of information to “scare [parents] out of vaccinating.”
And it is the very same antivaccine propaganda blog, Age of Autism, that is promoting a different, more insidious message, specifically how the brutal murder of an autistic teen nearly three months ago “illumines the autism nightmare.” What do I mean by “insidious message”? It’s the hijacking of the autism advocacy movement, which tries to advocate for more services for autistic children and adults and more awareness and understanding of autism, by the antivaccine message that autistic people are somehow “damaged,” be it by vaccines or unnamed “toxins,” that the “real child” has been “stolen” by autism, and that any manner of biomedical quackery to “recover” autistics is justified by the horror of autism. Although Attkisson, the reporter for the story discussed below, never specifically mentions vaccines, if you know the background of the case, that message is quite obvious and not very far under the surface of her report on the murder of Alex Spourdalakis:
Not surprisingly, this story was reported by Sharyl Attkisson, who is CBS News’ resident antivaccine reporter. I’ve known her to promote antivaccine views in a manner that gave Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. a run for his money as far back as 2007. Since then, she’s smeared Paul Offit as a “pharma shill,” very likely fed information to someone at AoA to help them portray Lisa Randall at Voices for Vaccines as an “industry group,” done a puff piece about antivaccine physician and hero to the antivaccine movement Andrew Wakefield, and misreported the significance of the Hannah Poling case (which was really just the rebranding of autism). Most recently, Attkisson promoted a truly execrable “review article” summarizing the evidence relating vaccines to autism. The review article, by Helen Ratajczak, cited lots of pseudoscience from antivaccine literature in the service of supporting a truly dumb hypothesis, namely that DNA from vaccines could recombine in the brains of children to result in autism. Attkisson was quite smitten with the idea. As you might imagine, I was not. Along the way, Attkisson also indulged in promoting breast cancer misinformation. No wonder she is the perfect reporter to do this story promoting the viewpoint that autism is so horrible and the system provides so little help that we should understand why a mother like Alex’s might become so desperate that she would poison her son and then, when that failed to kill him, try to slash his wrist, and then, when that failed, stab him in the heart with a kitchen knife.
A feeling of utter revulsion welled up in me when I finally watched Attkisson’s video. On the one hand, I can only begin to imagine how hard it is to raise and care for a child like Alex Spourdalakis, who was nonverbal and, as he grew, was becoming very strong and difficult to manage and control. On the other hand, that is no excuse for murder. Those of you who haven’t read my original post about this murder, go now and read it. It provides the background, in particular how long before the murder the antivaccine movement had latched on to Alex’s story, blatantly used it to promote their viewpoint, and corrupted it. Not long before Alex’s murder, Andrew Wakefield even traveled to visit him and make this video:
That’s just a reminder that even minimal fact checking would have turned up the Wakefield connection, not to mention that shortly after this video an anonymous donor turned up to get Alex out of Lutheran General Hospital and to a “safe, secret place,” or how the antivaccine crank blog Age of Autism had a tight connection with Dorothy Spourdalakis that it touted nearly three months before Alex’s murder. Also note that Alex’s mother wrote a thank you note to AoA in which she states:
Vaccines have maimed too many already and there are many more to come. The CDC’s latest stats confirm that. We are not going away, nor are we giving up. My son Alex is just one of millions of children and adults who no longer will be silenced.
It is a sentiment that Sharyl Attkisson appears to agree with.
Lies of omission to exploit an autistic teen
I don’t think I am exaggerating when I say that I found Attkisson’s report to be exploitative and far more sympathetic to the mother and caregiver who murdered Alex Spourdalakis than to Alex himself. It’s sympathetic to the mother in that it spins a tale in which a mother, who was so kind and loving that she would wash her son’s feet, sleep on the floor by his bedside, and do everything in her power to find him help, finally despairs and decides that her son is suffering so much that he is better off dead. So she and Alex’s other caregiver Jolanta Agata Skordzka killed Alex and tried to commit suicide, but failed. The exploitation comes from the multiple images of Alex nearly naked and in four point restraints, images that show no respect for his dignity as a human being. Indeed, I would go further than calling this segment exploitative and slanted towards the mother and accuse Sharyl Attkisson of lying by omission in that so many relevant facts about the background of this story are omitted that a viewer unfamiliar with it would completely miss the context and have no idea who at least two of the people interviewed are. If Attkisson were to plead ignorance, she would reveal herself to be the hack reporter that I consider her to be. I don’t think she can plead ignorance anyway, because of her close connections with the antivaccine movement through bloggers at AoA and her long history of promoting antivaccine pseudoscience that goes back at least to 2007, which is when I first noticed her, and probably beyond. Why CBS News continues to indulge Attkisson’s penchant for vaccine pseudoscience I don’t know, but this piece clearly represents a failure of her producers to do even minimal checking of her reporting, as you will see.
The first lie of omission comes from what is not mentioned about the footage of Alex used by Attkisson in her report. Notice the source of the video: The Autism Media Channel (AMC). What is not revealed by Attkisson is that the Autism Media Channel is an antivaccine propaganda network designed to promote the idea that autism is caused by vaccines. Don’t believe me? Then consider this. The Director of the Autism Media Channel is Andrew Wakefield. It’s somehow been mysteriously scrubbed from the site, where you will find little mention of Andrew Wakefield anymore, but the antivaccine crank blog Age of Autism refers to Wakefield as the Director of AMC (for example, here) and it is in various news outlets that he is the Director of the AMC (for example, this Guardian story, which lists him as the “director of a company called Medical Interventions for Autism and another called the Autism Media Channel”). Meanwhile, the AMC still features a couple of videos by Wakefield, for example, this video in which he challenges Dr. David Salisbury, Director of Immunisation at the Department of Health in London, the official responsible for overseeing the nation’s immunization program in the UK, to a debate over the death of a child thought by his parents to have been caused by the MMR vaccine. Then there’s this video (the second one on the page), where Wakefield is interviewing Dr. Arthur Krigsman, who, not coincidentally, is featured in Attkisson’s report as the only doctor who could help Alex Spourdalakis when Loyola University Medical Center and other hospitals could not. He is also on the staff of AMC. As the Guardian article put it:
The Autism Media Channel website contains videos with titles such as Not Born With It – a reference to the belief that autism is far from genetic, which leads it to advocate biomedical interventions such as nutritional supplements as well as gluten- and casein-free diets (one video is entitled How To Afford A Gluten And Casein Free Diet). Other videos recommend that parents of autistic children cook food using stainless-steel or ceramic pots so metals don’t “leach into the food and give more toxic overload to your kid”.
The lies of omission are many-fold and just keep coming. For example, Attkisson doesn’t mention the ongoing connection between Andrew Wakefield and the AMC, which is not, as it is represented, just a web channel designed to promote the vaccine-autism hypothesis that was started by Andrew Wakefield and Polly Tommey. Instead, Attkisson presents the AMC as a “website with a mission of helping those living with autism.” Very benign-sounding. Who could argue with that? It’s also the AMC’s self-professed mission. However, any halfway-decent reporter would have at least mentioned in passing the AMC’s connection with Wakefield. Another omission is that Tommey is quite a familiar presence to British skeptics, being a well-known antivaccine activist and supporter of Andrew Wakefield. (She even has her own approving Whale.to page.) Indeed, Tommey once maintained a Facebook Campaign known as Mothers Supporting Andrew Wakefield’s Work. A few years ago, she launched a billboard campaign to try to score a meeting with then-Prime Minister Gordon Brown. British physician Dr. Michael Fitzpatrick pointed out at the time, in a response he called An Open Letter to Gordon Brown:
In her campaign posters, Mrs Tommey, whose 12-year-old son Billy is autistic, offers to save the UK government £500 million a year by helping people with autism to get jobs. But it is not clear from the posters how she thinks this can be achieved. However, The Autism File, the magazine she edits, focuses on two issues: supporting the campaign led by the former Royal Free Hospital researcher Andrew Wakefield against the MMR vaccine and promoting ‘unorthodox biomedical’ treatments for children with autism.
The current issue of The Autism File contains a 15-page feature providing a detailed account of the case presented by Dr Wakefield to the General Medical Council, where he is currently facing charges of professional misconduct. The recent judgments in the US Omnibus Autism Proceedings revealed the consensus among experts that Wakefield’s research was scientifically flawed and probably fraudulent. Yet this research has proved damaging to thousands of parents – on both sides of the Atlantic – who were drawn into futile litigation. The resulting decline in confidence in MMR has contributed to renewed outbreaks of measles. It is regrettable that The Autism File should continue to uphold pseudoscience to the detriment of children’s health.
The Autism File promotes a range of ‘unorthodox biomedical’ treatments for autism. These include exclusion diets, vitamins and supplements, anti-fungal and anti-viral medications, and ‘detoxification’ regimes, such as ‘chelation therapy’, which purport to remove ‘heavy metal’ toxins from the body. Practitioners providing these treatments also offer a wide range of unvalidated investigations. Polly Tommey’s husband Jonathan, who is closely involved in The Autism File, also runs a private clinic providing biomedical tests and treatments (though he has no medical qualifications).
And, from the Guardian article:
The presenter of many of the Autism Media Channel videos is Polly Tommey, who is also registered with the Texas secretary of state as a co-director of the company, along with Wakefield. Tommey, who recently moved to Austin from the UK with her husband, Jonathan, and their three children, first appeared on the autism radar in 1999 when she and Jonathan were guests on Tonight With Trevor McDonald. That evening they announced that they had given their autistic son, Billy, an infusion of the hormone secretin, extracted from pig intestines, which stimulates digestive fluids in the pancreas, produces pepsin in the stomach and bile in the liver and, they said, resulted in “excellent progress”.
And:
Meanwhile, Jonathan, Tommey’s husband, who has a sports science degree and a foundation degree in nutritional therapy, set up the Autism Clinic in Berkshire to offer “specialist autism treatment”, including “diagnostic tests” and an array of supplements and vitamins that he prescribes and makes available from his online shop. He also features in some of the programmes on the Autism Media Channel’s YouTube page. In one of those films, Jonathan Tommey – The Biomedical Imbalances In Autism, he recommends “supplementary intervention” such as “vitamins and herbs” for children with autism. In the same film he discusses chelation therapy. “As nutritionists, we can’t use chelating agents. They are prescriptive medications,” he says, adding, “They are available on the web. My suggestion is you’ve got to be very careful doing this without professional guidance, and unfortunately in this country there are not many practitioners that do chelation.” But, he adds, “Chelation has been used to a good level of success.”
So what we have here is a woman who, while she does advocate for families with autism, also promotes the pseudoscientific and dangerous idea that the MMR and other vaccines cause autism, as well as a variety of quackery designed to treat the “toxic insults” that in her mind cause autism. Indeed, a quick perusal of The Autism File website, which is a repository for the magazine, confirms Dr. Fitzpatrick’s assessment quite nicely and confirms the Guardian‘s reporting. For instance the treatment section features articles on enzymes, reiki, homeopathy (complete with at least one testimonial), and many other forms of quackery, “biomedical” and otherwise. There are articles claiming that heavy metals in vaccines cause autism or that vaccines in general cause autism. If you don’t believe that Polly Tommey is firmly entrenched within the antivaccine camp, look no further than to yesterday’s Age of Autism, in which her latest issue of The Autism File is prominently promoted as featuring two articles from AoA contributors, Lisa Goes and Cathy Jameson and featuring a monthly column by AoA’s managing editor, Dan Olmsted. If you take a look at the table of contents of the latest issue, you’ll see that the author list reads like a Who’s Who of the antivaccine movement, including a column by Kim Stagliano (another AoA contributor), Deirdre Imus, Erik Nanstiel, Anju Usman, and, yes, Andrew Wakefield himself, who penned a piece called Reflections: The Painful Truth Behind Recent Tragedy. Not surprisingly, Wakefield attacks those who try to counter the message of people like Attkisson, Tommey and Wakefield that the mother was a long-suffering saint who finally cracked because there was no help for her son.
Here’s an excerpt:
Clearly of the same assured if mistaken mindset, the Autism Self-Advocacy Network (ASAN), in calling for Spourdalakis and Skrodzka to be charged with a “hate crime,” claims that:
In truth, Alex’s murder is about a repulsive ideology all too common within our society that preaches that it is better to be dead than disabled.
Really? Were these organizations—NCD and ASAN—there for Alex at any stage during the unfolding tragedy? Did they have access to his medical records or interview his carers? Did they warn from Alex’s bedside, as did Jill Rubolino and Jeanna Reed from Autism Is Medical (AIM) of their grave concerns for Alex’s life in the absence of medical care? Did they make spontaneous offers of help, or seek to offset in any way the chance that their “hate crime” was imminent?
This is typical Wakefield, as disingenuous as it gets. Remember that Wakefield wrote in the introduction of his book Callous Disregard a fictional vignette about a mother who loved her autistic child so much that she climbed the Hounds Ghyll viaduct with him and jumped off with him. The view, clearly, was that autism can be such a burden that, when it gets too hard, the greatest act of love is a murder-suicide, which is the way to “keep him safe.” The echoes from this resonate in the Alex Spourdalakis case.
As I pointed out before, it is very likely that Dorothy Spourdalakis was subjecting Alex to “autism biomed” quackery and came to know Rubolino and Reed through that. At the time, I was making an educated guess based on what I could find on AoA and elsewhere on the web. I wasn’t sure that this was true, hence my qualifying my statements with terms like “apparently” or “probably.” There is clear evidence that the Spourdalakis family was offered help, both from the Illinois Department of Children and Family Services and from the local Autism Society. She refused help from the former, and was put in contact with an attorney by the latter. Dorothy Spourdalakis appears to have refused it because that help consisted of standard conventional treatments for autism. If Alex were transferred to a psychiatric hospital’s long-term care ward he would no longer receive the autism biomed treatments. At the time, I also noted that AoA contributor Lisa Goes portrayed Jeanna Reed as ranting and haranguing Alex’s doctors with pleas to read quack studies and claims that “many of these children present with bowel disease and mitochondrial dysfunction. He could have GERD, duodenitis, esophagitis, ulcers in the small intestines, colitis. How can we know if we don’t test?” As I pointed out at the time, this was pure autism biomed rhetoric, leavened with the arrogance of ignorance. When one of the doctors referred to autism as a “mystery,” Goes actually completely lost it, yelling, “No! No! It’s not. It’s a medical illness that causes bad behavior. All you have to do IS READ*!” Add to this Andrew Wakefield’s grandstanding visit to Alex in his hospital bed last spring, and the connection is clear. Most likely, AIM never “spontaneously” offered help, but rather Dorothy Spourdalakis probably reached out to Reed and/or Rubolino as “autism biomed” advocates. Most likely the NCD and ASAN knew nothing of Alex’s case until after his murder because the only way they would have heard of it is if they were monitoring antivaccine websites, as I do. It wasn’t in the news then.
Unwittingly, Sharyl Attkisson has confirmed my worst suspicions. In her segment, an interview with Polly Tommey is featured prominently but her background is not mentioned. She is presented as nothing more than a concerned parent and autism advocate, rather than the antivaccine activist that she is. Nor are her close ties with Andrew Wakefield ever mentioned. Tommey opines that “His [Alex’s] death didn’t need to be. It was because there wasn’t anything in place for him.” However, that is not true, as I explained above. This leads us to Arthur Krigsman, which was the kind of help Dorothy Spourdalakis apparently did want.
Also featured prominently in Attkisson’s segment is footage shot of Alex Spourdalakis undergoing endoscopy by Arthur Krigsman for his GI issues. Footage of Alex becoming violent is featured, with Attkisson’s voice-over stating that Alex’s mother blamed the fits of violence on severe GI distress, saying, “Dorothy believed that Alex’s violent outbursts were triggered by severe gastric pain, but nobody seemed to know what to do with him.” We’re then told that a “glimmer of hope came” when “autism advocates” connected Alex’s family with a GI specialist. Yes, that GI specialist was Dr. Krigsman, who (it is not mentioned) used to be Andrew Wakefield’s partner at Thoughtful House when Wakefield was still the medical director there; that is, before Wakefield was fired by the board of directors in the wake of being struck off by the British General Medical Council (GMC), which found him guilty of several counts of egregious research misconduct, referred to him as “irresponsible and dishonest,” and had his infamous 1998 Lancet article retracted. Not coincidentally, Krigsman has been a coauthor with Wakefield on three articles.
Given that Wakefield and Krigsman were two of the most vocal promoters of the concept of “autistic enterocolitis” (in reality a nonexistent entity), it is not at all surprising that Dr. Krigsman immediately diagnosed stomach ulcers. To be honest, the images on the screen were there so briefly that I couldn’t tell if this looked reasonable or not, but I’d sure like to see a pathology report of gastric biopsies. Maybe one of my gastroenterologist colleagues could comment. In the meantime, it’s interesting to note that, testifying for the plaintiffs at the Autism Omnibus hearings, Dr. Krigsman stated that he sued a hospital because he claimed it restricted his privileges to do endoscopies because it was “concerned that the colonoscopies that were being performed on these children did not have proper indications of colonoscopy.” He has also been fined by the Texas Medical Board. In the wake of Wakefield’s disgrace, after having left Thoughful House not long after Wakefield did, Krigsman soldiers on promoting the same idea, the same “autism biomedical” quackery that Wakefield promoted and still promotes, just no longer at Thoughtful House. Indeed, Dr. Krigsman even presented at the Autism One quackfest last spring, as he frequently does.
CBS News: Epic fail
I could go on and on about how irresponsible and wrong Sharyl Attkisson is in promoting an idea that tries to absolve Dorothy Spourdalakis and Jolanta Agata Skordzka of guilt for the murder of Alex Spourdalakis just because he was autistic, large, and very difficult to handle, as have Matt Carey, Skeptical Raptor, Paula Durbin-Westby, the Poxes Blog, Science Mom, Liz Ditz, Todd W., and Scott Gavura have. I could go on and on again, as other skeptical bloggers and I have before, about how Attkisson has abused her trust as a journalist to promote quackery. (It is not for nothing that she has won a hallowed place in the Encyclopedia of American Loons.) I could go on and on, as Matt Carey has, about how, through this story, Attkisson has whitewashed the brutal murder of an autistic teen in order to hide the involvement of Andrew Wakefield and other “autism biomed” advocates and, worse, to promote in a not-so-subtle way their message that it is better to be dead than severely autistic. But why bother? Attkisson appears to be beyond redemption, given her long-documented history of antivaccine sympathies and promoting autism biomed quackery.
It is CBS News that bears ultimate responsibility for airing Attkisson’s irresponsible and deceptive whitewashing of the Alex Spourdalakis case, presenting who opportunistically latched on to it as legitimate “autism advocates” and lying by omission about critical parts of the story. Producers obviously failed to do even minimal fact checking, even the most superficial of which would have immediately revealed the obvious connections between the Autism Media Channel and Andrew Wakefield, between Polly Tommey and the antivaccine movement, and between Arthur Krigsman and Andrew Wakefield. Fact checking would also have rapidly uncovered how Tommey and Wakefield had been collecting this footage most likely to be used in a reality TV show that they were developing, The Autism Team, whose trailer features autistic children screaming, hitting themselves and throwing tantrums, and featuring—you guessed it!—a team of “autism experts” including Dr. Krigsman as the only people who can help:
It sure looks to me as though the idea behind this show was to have parents with children with severe autism who are at their wits’ end call for help, and—whoosh!—The Autism Team swoops in, gives the child all sorts of biomedical quackery, and rapidly makes things better. It’s the classic reality show format, in which there is a problem and the reality show host comes in and almost miraculously fixes the problem, the way, for example, Caesar Millan corrects the behavior of unruly dogs in The Dog Whisperer or the way Stacy London and Clinton Kelley fix the fashion-challenged in What Not To Wear. Yes, it is just that crass and blatant, which is why I chose these two examples to illustrate my point, even at the risk of offending. Look at the video if you don’t believe me—if you can stand it. As Carey points out:
That video shows autistic children in meltdowns, being self-injurious. One specific child is flown from the U.K. to New York to see Arthur Krigsman (just as Mr. Spourdalakis was taken from Chicago to New York to see Krigsman). In the trailer, after visiting Krigsman the child was shown happy, playing, and the parents were shown grateful. As we know, this was not the conclusion of the Alex Spourdalakis story. Whatever Mr. Wakefield and Ms. Tommey had planned for the video they had taken, the “treat bowel disease and everyone is happy” story was not to be. Instead, he has produced a video of the “medical establishment fails family, leading to tragedy” theme. I do wonder how he managed to work that theme around the facts that the tragedy (aka brutal murder at the hands of his mother) came to pass after Mr. Spourdalakis was seen by Mr. Krigsman.
Matt Carey is correct. As I’ve pointed out before, the entire narrative of the autism biomed movement is that autism “stole” the parents’ “real child” away from them. Since the idea that vaccines cause autism is basically holy writ for the autism biomed movement, that means vaccines “stole” the real child away by making him autistic. Parents who try to “recover” that “real” child are thus viewed as heroic, rather than abusive, because they’re willing to do whatever it takes to defeat the scourge of autism (and vaccines) in order to rescue the “real” child within. Dorothy Spourdalakis, having valiantly struggled against the demon autism, is thus to many a tragic and heroic figure, who strove, failed, and decided that life was no longer worth living for either Alex or herself. Worse, a disturbing number of people seem all too willing to accept that narrative, that “autism made her do it.” If the narrative that “autism biomed” can cure didn’t work out for the footage that Wakefield and Tommey shot of Alex and his mother, then another, more tragic narrative, of a mother so overburdened by autism, with no person or organization to help her, became so distraught that she killed her child, is to them a tragic but understandable outcome. Never mind that it’s a lie in that Dorothy Spourdalakis was offered help at least twice but turned it down, and having a disabled child who is difficult to handle does not justify killing him brutally.
CBS News failed in that its producers took at face value the claims of Polly Tommey and Dorothy Spourdalakis, as related by Sharyl Attkisson, that no help was offered to her. They failed in how they allowed Attkisson to frame this story so sympathetically to the plight of the mother, letting her surrogates, such as Polly Tommey, state virtually unchallenged the view that “autism drove her to it” and that if only Spourdalakis had had adequate “support” (what kind of “support” is not mentioned), then maybe she wouldn’t have murdered Alex. That the producers at CBS News This Morning allowed Attkisson to juxtapose a voice-over about the AMC movie project calling it “a rare visual prelude to murder” with carefully-selected footage designed to portray Dorothy Spourdalakis as downright saintly and only driven to murder by circumstances beyond her control is a journalistic failing of the highest order. Sure, there’s the obligatory interview with someone like Ari Ne’eman who quite correctly points out that it is a dangerous ideology that views those with severe developmental issues as less than human that was behind Alex’s death, but the overall message of the segment is loud and clear. After all, right after the interview with Ne’eman, Attkisson shows Dorothy’s suicide note, from which she quotes thusly, “‘Alex will no longer be treated like an animal or subjected to restraints,’ indicating she thought they both were better off dead.” Attkisson then concludes with a survey that claims that doctors aren’t sure what treatments are appropriate for autistic children and by stating that advocates hope that the case of Alex Spourdalakis will result in change.
I, too, hope that the case of Alex Spourdalakis will result in change. I hope that the way CBS News permitted Sharyl Attkisson to exploit it proves so embarrassing that there is change—at CBS News, where change is desperately needed, starting with preventing Sharyl Attkisson from ever reporting on autism or vaccines again. What CBS News has done is to do a story that is nothing more than a press release for Andrew Wakefield and Polly Tommey’s vision. It was beyond an epic fail on the part of CBS News. It was journalistic malpractice. Alex Spourdalakis demands justice.
ADDENDUM: If you think I’m exaggerating about how the antivaccine movement is reacting to this and how it is trying to do its best to absolve the mother of guilt for her crime, just read the comments after this post at AoA over the weekend. One example is this comment from someone named Sheila Tzorfas:
WHO really killed Alex? …The Doctors WHO shot him with Aluminum, thimerosal (Mercury) embalming fluid, fetal cells, rats brains, parts of cows, pigs, caterpillars, ether and more in the name of health. The SCHOOL system that did not send viable home services or place him a nurturing, caring environment, the Medical Staff that did not DETOXIFY him; the Spiritual Community too buy to help, the ER doctors whose training in Autism was close to nonexistent, the Neighbors who hid their eyes, the Insurance Companies that waged a battle, the MEDIA, that hides the increase of illnesses from the viewers as 1 in every 6 children have been afflicted with Developmental Disabilities starting in 1991 when all newborn babies get a shot for a sexually transmitted disease that they CANNOT get,the Psychiatrists that did not give him relief, and the surrounding communities which include all…. Shell of,”Recovering Autism, ADHD, & Special Needs.”
Notice that there’s no mention of the mother on the list of “who really killed Alex.” Apparently she isn’t the one who “really” killed him.

Bad Documentary Review: Family Shots
Amazon removed a number of anti-vax documentaries in March but a few still remain unfortunately. Family Shots is a anti-vax propaganda film pretending to be a documentary about a father trying to find out if vaccines are safe. It also got government funding to be made. Yeah…
Braden MacBeth on July 15, 2019
Tweet

[Editor’s note: With Dr. Gorski extremely busy this week, we have a post from frequent guest contributor Braden MacBeth to fill in.]
I found myself in that weird part of Amazon again, a part of Amazon that has gotten markedly smaller after a round of anti-vax documentary removals in early March. Family Shots was created and directed by David Sieveking and released in September of 2018. Barring the scientific illiteracy in every frame, it is a competently made film compared to many other quack documentaries I’ve reviewed. The camera work, audio production, and general flow of the film is much better than what I’m used to seeing. I imagine the fact that Sieveking received a grant from the German government played no small part in the improved production. For the first twenty minutes of the film, I didn’t think it was going to go down the anti-vax rabbit hole as far as it did. Needless to say I was very disappointed.
Neonatal tetanus, do mothers need the shot?
Family Shots begins with Sieveking’s wife meeting with her obstetrician. Her obstetrician recommended that she get the TDaP vaccine to protect her baby against tetanus, diphtheria, and pertussis. She felt that it wasn’t necessary and could potentially harm her as she felt she was “very sensitive with a baby inside her”. Ultimately Jessica decides to get TDaP vaccine, going against her gut feeling. According to Sieveking, she fell very ill the day after receiving the vaccine and she was confined to bed for weeks. He also claims she suffered from premature contractions. Of course he believes that this was due to the vaccine:
Neither her gynecologist, nor the family doctor linked it with the vaccination. They assumed it was the flu or gastroenteritis.
That would be because the TDaP vaccine is an inactivated vaccine so you can’t get sick from it. The most common adverse effects from the TDaP vaccine are pain or swelling near the injection site and a moderate fever. I’m unable to find any evidence that the TDaP vaccine can cause the problems she claims to have experienced. Despite two doctors telling them that the TDaP vaccine didn’t cause any of her symptoms they both firmly believe that it did. The film immediately cuts to a conversation between Jessica and her midwife:
It’s not necessary to vaccinate a pregnant woman. Of course if you’re sensitive to it , you may react with premature contractions. As for the risk of tetanus, I’ve worked in the health system for a long time and I’ve never encountered neonatal tetanus, nor have any of my colleagues.
First things first: midwives aren’t doctors. There’s been a lot of research investigating if the TDaP vaccine can cause premature contractions, or preterm births; they don’t. One study published in the Journal of Human Vaccines & Immunotherapeutics tracked the outcomes of 1,758 women in Texas and found that there was no statistically significant difference in the number of preterm births between the women who received the TDaP vaccine, and those who did not. Another study published in The BMJ Open tracked the outcomes of women in two regions of Sweden, and no adverse reactions such as premature contractions were associated with the TDaP vaccine. The TDaP vaccine is perfectly safe, but is it necessary for mothers to get it to protect their newborns?
The TDaP vaccine protects against tetanus, pertussis, and diphtheria, and it’s recommended that all expecting mothers receive the vaccine when they are between 27 and 36 weeks pregnant by every medical organization ever. Receiving the vaccine during this period is crucial because it allows for the greatest number of antibodies to be transferred to the infant during pregnancy. Pertussis was responsible for at least 1,500 hospitalizations and 9 deaths of infants in 2017 in the United States. Tetanus is incredibly rare, and only 29 cases and 2 deaths were reported in 2015 in the US. One reason why the number of cases is so low is that it’s very hard to get tetanus, as it requires the spores to enter through breaks in the skin. The other reason is that you can’t walk into an ER with a paper cut without being asked if your tetanus vaccine is up to date or being offered a tetanus booster at least ten times. However, tetanus is very scary and in a 2011 report by the CDC the per case death rate was estimated to be 13.2%. Newborns are particularly at risk because the umbilical stump can become infected. It’s important that mothers get the TDaP vaccination during the recommended time period to protect their newborns from potentially deadly illnesses; the risks of getting vaccinated are virtually non-existent.
I don’t believe that man’s ever been to medical school
Around 20 minutes in Sieveking begins his quest to find out if his wife’s “skepticism” surrounding vaccines is well-founded or not. He starts by visiting a clinic where a “physician” is lecturing a room full of expecting parents about the necessity of vaccination. The “physician” starts by stating:
Vaccination is one of the most powerful manipulative interventions possible…We’re not in favor of the current vaccine inflation.
Babies receive a large number of vaccines to prevent a large number of serious illnesses that could seriously harm or kill them. I would think a physician would be in favor of getting newborns vaccinated to protect them from these illnesses as soon as possible. However, Sieveking mentioned at the start of the segment that he was visiting an anthroposophical medical clinic. I thought anthroposophical medicine was just a different form of medical training in Germany, similar to osteopathic medicine in the US, but it turns out anthroposophical medicine is just another form of alternative medicine quackery based around the beliefs of Rudolf Steiner. Long story short: it’s a combination of naturopathy, homeopathy, and schizotypal personality disorder. Sieveking even has the audacity to state: “The lecture sounds rather ideological, but at least the speaker is a qualified physician”. I was unable to find out who the “physician” in this segment actually is, but their advice should be disregarded because it’s insane:
The official recommendation is to start vaccinating at nine weeks. In one day the child receives over 20 vaccines; all at the same time. The earlier I start to vaccinate, the higher the dosage has to be. As the immune system is still so underdeveloped it doesn’t know what to do with it. And, irritatingly if I vaccinate at one year, I need far fewer doses than if I start to vaccinate at nine weeks. Once the child is walking, the immune and nervous systems have both reached an initial level of maturity. So for us, as anthroposophical doctors, that is the perfect time to vaccinate.
There’s so much wrong here I don’t know where to begin. At no point will a child receive over 20 vaccines at the same time. The highest number of vaccines a child would receive simultaneously during the CDC’s recommended vaccine schedule I could come up with is seven vaccines for the following: hepatitis B, tetanus, diphtheria, pertussis, haemophilus influenzae type b, pneumococcal, and rotavirus. While some of these vaccines protect against a number of strains of the same virus totaling over 20, to say that’s the same thing as receiving over 20 vaccines is a stretch. Furthermore, I have no idea where he got this “the lower the age, the higher the dosage” idea is from; the dosage is the same for most vaccines no matter what age the person is. Furthermore, why should the dosage of the vaccine matter? Vaccines are safe at whatever dosage they’re approved to be given at. The most glaring problem with his proposal is that beginning vaccination at 1 year as opposed to 9 weeks leaves the child vulnerable to vaccine-preventable illnesses during that span of time.
Adjuvant lies
Every antivax documentary tries to argue that the adjuvants in vaccines are dangerous despite the fact these arguments have debunked thousands of times by people who are much more qualified and well-mannered than myself. Sieveking focuses on the “dangers” of the amount of aluminum in the vaccines. To learn more about the safety of the aluminum adjuvants in vaccines, Sieveking had the opportunity to sit down with Dr. Klaus Cichutek, the president of the Paul Ehrlich Institute. The Paul Ehrlich Institute is a federal agency under the German Federal Ministry of Health and is responsible for the researching and testing vaccines and medicines. Dr. Cichutek explained to him that aluminum adjuvants are a necessary component in vaccines, decades of research proven that they are safe, and that vaccines are necessary to prevent the spread of dangerous diseases. Surely Sieveking would be satisfied with this answer? Of course not. This is an antivax documentary!
Sieveking decides to visit an international symposium on the “link” between vaccines and auto-immune diseases to “find out whether these adjuvants can be dangerous”. Potential links between specific vaccines and autoimmune diseases have been investigated and it’s been shown repeatedly that there is no link between vaccines and auto-immune diseases. Sieveking shows footage of multiple known antivaxxers giving talks starting with Cristopher Exley:
You are seeing now for the first time, some fundamental science underlining the possibility that aluminium adjuvants can produce toxicity from the injection site. The question then arises, do we need to be more cautious? Are there other toxic events associated with aluminium adjuvants and vaccination?
He shows a slide of brain scans of people with Mild Cognitive Impairment and Alzheimer’s disease, implying that aluminum adjuvants could cause those conditions. There is no evidence that the aluminum adjuvants in vaccines is the cause of those conditions despite Exley trying so desperately to prove it. Exley has published at least one paper in a low-quality journal proposing that there is a link between aluminum in brain tissue, and autism. Dr. Gorski published a post in RetractionWatch criticizing the poor methods, questionable data, and the fact that it was funded by the Children’s Medical Safety Research Institute, a known anti-vaccine group. Despite the shoddy research, many anti-vaccine groups cling to it as if it is indisputable evidence that the aluminum adjuvants in vaccines are harmful. The amount of aluminum in vaccines is negligible and is not readily absorbed by the body.
The symposium segment of Family Shots really shows you what this film is all about: it is a hardcore antivax film masquerading as being about a concerned parent investigating “real” risks of vaccines. It ends with this speech from a speaker whom I was unable to identify:
So again, I’m not saying do not vaccinate your children. I’m only saying that we don’t have a grasp of the actual risk, because the objective research has never been done. It should be done with people who don’t have ties with the pharma. We have to have an independent body that will conduct the trial.
Except…you are telling people not to vaccinate their children? The only thing being shown at this symposium are misrepresentations of the risks and research surrounding vaccines. Vaccines have been shown to be safe and effective, and have saved millions of lives. The objective research on vaccines has been done, you’ve just chosen to ignore it all. The research has been conducted by independent bodies that have no ties to pharmaceutical companies. Sieveking even talked to the president of one such body not 10 minutes earlier. The Paul Ehrlich Institute, the CDC, and the NHS, are all independent bodies that have researched vaccines and all have concluded that they are safe and effective.
Hexavac horror story
Following the talks at the symposium, Sieveking decides to sit down with a former employee of the Paul Ehrlich Institute, Klaus Hartmann. Hartman seems to have had a successful career as an expert witness in vaccine injury cases after leaving the Paul Ehrlich institute about 10 years ago. Hartman states that he chose to leave the institute because “there was a tendency to not want to hear about reported side effects or anything negative about vaccines”. Hartmann claims that there were reported deaths following vaccination with a hexavalent vaccine for infants, Hexavac. Hexavac received marketing approval in the European Union in 2000, but this approval was revoked in December of 2005. The reason for revoking Hexavac’s marketing approval was concerns about it not providing long-term protection against hepatitis B. There doesn’t seem to be any evidence that Hexavac, nor any other hexavalent vaccine, has been associated with sudden infant death syndrome or any other cause of premature death.
Hartman claims that the he evaluated these cases and came to the conclusion that a link seemed possible, and he’s not the only doctor Sieveking interviews that makes such a claim. Sieveking also interviewed Dr. Rudolph Penning, a forensic pathologist at the Munich Institute of Forensic Medicine, who claims he observed unusual infant deaths after they received the Hexavac vaccine. Penning contacted the Paul Ehrlich institute too see if there were any reports of similar cases but his concerns were dismissed. The European Medicines Agency’s Committee for Proprietary Medicinal Products concluded in 2003 that while it appeared there was a possible statistical association, no plausible biological cause for such an association could be identified. Penning was a coauthor on a letter to the editor titled “Unexplained cases of sudden infant death shortly after hexavalent vaccination“, and in the conclusion they state: “So far there is no way to proof [sic] that these infant deaths are caused by vaccination”. This paper has been held up by antivaxxers as airtight proof that hexavalent vaccines can cause sudden infant death syndrome, despite numerous issues with their findings and how they were presented. In follow-up letter to the editor, Dr. Wolfgang Maurer points out numerous issues with the original letter. The original letter was accepted the day it was received because it was the journal’s policy not to review letters to the editor. There was no information in the letter regarding other findings that should’ve been reported if they were following a standard autopsy protocol. The authors also claimed that “mast cell tryptase was slightly above normal” in one child, but they state a few lines later that “there are no reference values available regarding mast cell-tryptase plasma concentrations in this age group.”. They basically did everything wrong, which you can read more about in Maurer’s full response letter. Hexavac was pulled from the market because it did not provide long-term immunity against hepatitis B, not because it was causing deaths and the German government was trying to cover it up. Research has shown that there is no association between vaccination and sudden infant death syndrome.
Now That’s What I Call Oblivious™
Family Shots really gives a close-up of the mindset of parents against vaccination; they’re oblivious to the real threat of vaccine-preventable diseases returning and how dangerous those diseases are. The film is centered around Sieveking’s newborn daughter and follows her as she grows up. Sieveking decides multiple times throughout the film to ignore the advice of medical professionals, public health officials, and other parents, and put his child’s health at risk by not vaccinating her and making other boneheaded decisions. The first of these instances begins about 25 minutes in when talking with his child’s pediatrician about the risk of hepatitis B. The pediatrician says there have been multiple cases of hepatitis B acquired from the needles of drug users. Sieveking takes this to mean that his daughter doesn’t need the hepatitis B vaccine and that he can just sweep playground for used needles. Of course, this simply isn’t the case. Children are at risk from contracting hepatitis B if their mother has hepatitis B, or by coming into contact with bodily fluids infected with hepatitis B. The latter is particularly concerning considering there could be bodily fluids anywhere and young children put their mouths on everything. While hepatitis B isn’t something that parents should have to worry about too much, that’s because of very successful vaccination programs. There are still an estimated 257 million people infected with Hepatitis B worldwide.
The second of these instances begins with an announcement over the radio reporting that there was no end in sight to a measles outbreak in Berlin. Sieveking and his wife discuss getting their daughter the MMR vaccine:
Well, should you do what’s best for everyone else? Or what’s best for your own child? I think it would be better if we don’t vaccinate. Not right now.
Getting vaccinating against measles, mumps, and rubella as soon as possible is in every child’s best interest. Measles is highly contagious, and killed over 100,000 people in 2017 alone. There is almost no risk to getting the measles vaccine, but the risk of getting measles in an industrialized country has never been higher thanks to anti-vaxxers. Measles is not just a fever and a rash, 1 in 5 children who get measles will have to be hospitalized, it can cause ear infections that cause permanent hearing loss, 1 in 20 will get pneumonia, and measles can cause encephalitis that can lead to permanent brain damage and so much more. Fortunately, those that get measles and survive, hopefully without any permanent effects, will have immunity for life and won’t have to be worried about potentially deadly complications from measles any longer. Sorry, I left out the part where measles can cause subacute sclerosing panencephalitis 6-10 years after a measles infection and results in incurable chronic brain inflammation and death in about 1 in 10,000 people who get measles. I don’t know how a parent could ever refuse a vaccination that would entirely mitigate the risk of their children contracting this disease. In addition, some children, such as those who are immunocompromised, rely on herd immunity to protect them from vaccine preventable diseases that have a very high chance of killing them.
In the end, not only did they decide not to vaccinate their daughter against measles, they thought it would be a good idea to ignore the advice of public health officials and take their unvaccinated daughter to a party in Berlin during an active measles outbreak. He also puts on a hazmat suit to take his daughter to the party to mock the fear people have of a very real threat. Classy.
Fortunately, their daughter didn’t catch measles from the party. Unfortunately, shortly after the party his daughter did get sick, and he expresses worry that she might have caught the measles. She ended up diagnosed with pneumonia, likely because she did not get the pneumococcal vaccine. More than 900,000 people got pneumococcal pneumonia each year in the US and more than 3,500 died in 2013 from pneumococcal meningitis. It is entirely possible that his daughter got sick for absolutely no reason. Did this event give them some drastic change of heart, to get them to see that not vaccinating their daughter could seriously harm her? Of course not! Sieveking even states later in the film that they decided to get a nanny instead of sending their daughter to nursery school due to the risk of infection. Now I’m not a doctor, but I am almost certain that there is a way to prevent kids from getting highly contagious and potentially deadly diseases so that would be much less of a concern for him. It’ll come to me I’m sure…
Conclusion: I can’t believe you’ve done this
In the grand scheme of things, Family Shots is nothing new. It’s the German version of VAXXED presenting the same antivaxxer tropes we’ve seen thousands of times along with a curve ball or two. Documentaries like VAXXED and Family Shots play a huge part in sucking people into the pseudoscience cyberspace. The removal of VAXXED and other anti-vax documentaries from Amazon Prime in March was a big win, but as Dr. Gorski explains: there’s still way too many on these services. So let’s start there. I’d also encourage you to report the film as inappropriate using Amazon’s reporting system. There’s enough of a precedent that there’s a solid chance the film will be removed and that would go a long way in disrupting anti-vaccination groups’ recruitment.
As it stands there have been more than 1,000 confirmed cases of measles in the United States as of July, 2019, the highest in over 25 years. Measles was declared eliminated in the US because we had such an effective vaccination program. Not only are we about to lose out measles elimination status in the US, thousands of young children too young to be vaccinated and people who are immunocompromised are being put in danger for absolutely no reason. This film exists to peddle nothing but ignorance and fear to parents; it has no business existing. Vaccines have been proven to be safe and effective and they prevent millions of deaths from vaccine preventable diseases because we have an effective vaccination program for the most part. As it’s been shown after the past couple of years, even a slightly lower than ideal vaccination rate can lead to massive outbreaks, resulting in expensive hospitalizations, permanent complications, and tons of unnecessary suffering.
Antivax is the weirdest form of quackery to me. I can easily empathize with people who fall into other forms of quackery. Wouldn’t it be great if curing cancer only required a simple vitamin infusion or by cutting out sugar from your diet? But vaccines are what quack treatments wish they were. Vaccines are cheap, very safe, and highly effective. Why would someone want to prove that they are dangerous so badly that they will ignore the mountain of scientific evidence supporting the safety and efficacy of vaccination, and instead listen to cranks who have published research so fraudulent they lost their medical license? At least in the case of the major antivaxxers, such as Del BigTree, because it makes them buckets full of cash.
This review isn’t going to change an anti-vaxxers mind; that’s not the point. As Dr. Novella explains in his post “How to Respond to Anti-Vaxxers“, research has shown there is no clear winning strategy to get parents to change their mind about vaccinating. Films like this feed into new parents’ fear of everything, and have no business being on Amazon Prime. It’s no question that internet misinformation on social media and documentaries like Family Shots have contributed to declining vaccination rates and the return of measles. As a result of that, we’re likely going to lose our measles elimination status in the US soon. It’s time to start talking about what we have to do to get it back.

Move over, Christopher Shaw, there’s a new antivaccine scientist in town
Move over, Christopher Shaw, there’s a new antivaccine scientist dedicated to demonizing aluminum adjuvants in town. His name is Christopher Exley. He’s got a fluorescence microscope, and he’s not afraid to use it.
David Gorski on December 4, 2017
Link

If there’s one thing about antivaccine activists, it’s that they rely on bad science (and the shameless misinterpretation of valid science) to give the impression that there is solid scientific evidence behind their pseudoscientific claims. I’ve discussed examples—and deconstructed them, explaining why they didn’t show what the investigators claim they showed—more times than I can remember, most recently when Christopher Shaw and Lucija Tomljenovic tortured yet more mice in the name of autism pseudoscience to produce a paper that was ultimately retracted because of readers on PubPeer who found images that reeked of manipulation. Of course, most antivaccine “research” is never revealed to have suffered from scientific fraud, but it’s basically all bad. I long ago lost track of the number of truly atrocious studies I’ve evaluated over the years published by antivaccine “scientists” dating all the way back to Andrew Wakefield and the father-son duo of pseudoscientists, Mark and David Geier.
Speaking of Mark and David Geier and bad antivaccine autism science, I encountered yet another example yesterday when I came across an article written by our old friend J.B. Handley for Medium entitled “New study: Massive Aluminum levels in Autism brains, is this the smoking gun for vaccines?” Spoilers: The answer is no. However, in this case, the voyage to that answer is important; so I had to look through the study. First, however, let’s take a look at how JB does what JB does best: Gloat prematurely whenever he thinks he’s found “smoking gun” evidence supporting his belief in the discredited idea that vaccines cause autism and win friends and influence people. Of course, J.B. Handley and his wife founded Generation Rescue, a group originally devoted to the belief that mercury due to the thimerosal preservative in vaccines is the primary cause of the “autism epidemic.” However, moving with the times and the shifting milieu in the antivaccine movement in which aluminum (atomic symbol: Al) is the new mercury, a milieu that shifted because of how, 15 years after mercury was removed from childhood vaccines, autism prevalence hasn’t fallen, Handley has now latched on to aluminum in vaccines as the cause of autism. It’s hip, it’s happening, and, above all, to Handley it’s always about the vaccines, as it is for all antivaccine zealots.
After citing the usual litany of bad antivaccine science about aluminum, Handley gloats:
The one thing missing from all the work done to date about aluminum and its possible role in autism? Actual brain tissue of people with autism. All the studies published that appeared to be demonstrating strong biological certainty of how the aluminum in vaccines could trigger autism were done with MICE, and Professor Exley and his colleagues’ new research studied the actual brains of people with autism. The conclusions should make you gasp.
The aluminium content of brain tissues from donors with a diagnosis of ASD [Autism] was extremely high…the mean aluminium content for each lobe across all 5 individuals was towards the higher end of all previous (historical) measurements of brain aluminium content, including iatrogenic disorders such as dialysis encephalopathy …We recorded some of the highest values for brain aluminium content ever measured in healthy or diseased tissues in these male ASD donors…Why, for example would a 15 year old boy have such a high content of aluminium in their brain tissues?
Actually, the only thing that makes me gasp is the unjustified conclusions being made from this paper, “Aluminium in brain tissue in autism,” coauthored by Matthew Mold, Dorcas Umar, Andrew King, and Christopher Exley and published in the Journal of Trace Elements in Medicine and Biology. I’ve encountered Exley before elsewhere, and his track record is not—shall we say?—encouraging. The first time, he had published a truly execrable paper in which he measured aluminum content in mastectomy specimens taken from 17 women with breast cancer in which he tried to link aluminum from antiperspirants to breast cancer. He also wrote a review article trying to make the same argument. In both cases, he failed to make anything resembling a compelling scientific case for aluminum from antiperspirants as a cause of breast cancer. The second time, I noted that he’s one of a group of scientists funded by the Child Medical Safety Research Institute (CMSRI), which is a group funded by Claire and Al Dwoskin, who are as rabidly antivaccine as anyone I’ve seen, including even Mike Adams. Among that group of antivaccine “scientists” funded by CMSRI? Anthony Mawson, Christopher Shaw, Lucija Tomljenovic, and Yehuda Shoenfeld, antivaccine crank “scientists” all. And guess what? This study was funded by CMSRI, too. Fair’s fair. If antivaxers can go wild when a study is funded by a pharmaceutical company and reject it out of hand, I can point out that a study funded by an antivaccine “foundation” is deserving of more scrutiny and skepticism.
A study must rise or fall on its own, however, regardless of who funded it or what obnoxious antivaxer is promoting it. So let’s dig in. One thing that stood out to me reading the manuscript is just how fast it was accepted for publication. It was submitted on October 26, resubmitted in revised form on November 21, and accepted on November 23. It was then published online on November 26. That’s amazingly fast for a paper to be reviewed, revised, accepted, and published. This sends up a number of red flags, implying that the review was rushed (and thus suboptimal, to put it kindly). The journal is not known to be a predatory one or a “pay to play one.” It has a halfway decent impact factor (3.225). So what’s going on here? Well, Exley is on the editorial board of the journal. Whenever I see a paper by someone on the editorial board of a journal published in that journal I tend to raise an eyebrow and wonder about how objective the peer review was.
The introduction also gives away the game:
Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is a group of neurodevelopmental conditions of unknown cause. It is highly likely that both genetic [1] and environmental [2] factors are associated with the onset and progress of ASD while the mechanisms underlying its aetiology are expected to be multifactorial [3-6]. Human exposure to aluminium has been implicated in ASD with conclusions being equivocal [7-10]. To-date the majority of studies have used hair as their indicator of human exposure to aluminium while aluminium in blood and urine have also been used to a much more limited extent. Paediatric vaccines that include an aluminium adjuvant are an indirect measure of infant exposure to aluminium and their burgeoning use has been directly correlated with increasing prevalence of ASD [11]. Animal models of ASD continue to support a connection with aluminium and to aluminium adjuvants used in human vaccinations in particular [12]. Hitherto there are no previous reports of aluminium in brain tissue from donors who died with a diagnosis of ASD. We have measured aluminium in brain tissue in autism and identified the location of aluminium in these tissues.
First off, no, aluminum has only been “linked” with ASD by antivaccine cranks. There is really no good evidence that aluminum in vaccines causes ASDs, try as as antivaxers might to try to “prove” that there is. Particularly telling is that Exley cites papers by Tomljenovic and Shaw, who are well known for their proclivity to publish papers chock full of bad (and fraudulent) science purporting to link aluminum adjuvants to autism and other conditions. Any citation of one of their papers is a good indication of bad science. If you don’t believe me, then check out this deconstruction of one of the papers.
So, right off the bat, the scientific justification for this study is highly dubious, but it was done anyway; so we have to deal with the results. What did Exley’s team do? They obtained brain tissue samples from autistic people from the Oxford Brain Bank, which is hosted in the Department of Neuropathology of the Oxford University Hospitals NHS Trust and the Academic Unit of Neuropathology of the Nuffield Department of Clinical Neurosciences of Oxford University. The bank stores sample and clinical data relevant for research into neurological diseases. From this bank, it appears that Exley received five specimens of frozen brain tissue (four males, one female, age range 15-50), consisting of samples from tissue from temporal, frontal, parietal and occipital lobes and hippocampus of each individual. Aluminum levels were measured using transversely heated atomic absorption spectroscopy.
Also, the authors received frontal, parietal, occipital, temporal and hippocampal tissue from ten donors (three females and seven males) with a diagnosis of ASD was supplied by the Oxford Brain Bank as three 5 μm thick serial paraffin-embedded brain tissue sections per lobe for each donor. These were subjected to staining with the fluorescent probe lumogallion, which is purported to be a selective stain for aluminum in cells and was first used to localize aluminum in plant roots. It’s sold, however, by Santa Cruz Biotechnology as a stain for aluminum, gallium, and other metals. The stained sections were then subjected to fluorescence microscopy to visualize where the lumogallion binds to aluminum in the tissue.
I could see a number of problems with the methods used. First, there are no controls. Certainly, if Exley were accessing the Oxford Brain Bank to obtain tissue from autistic people, then why couldn’t he have also obtained brain tissue from age-matched normal controls? If the bank doesn’t have such tissue, then it should have been justified. Either way, the relevance of these measurements are suspect, given that we have nothing to compare them to. There’s also an extreme paucity of clinical information about the samples used. There are no dietary histories, no medical histories, and all with a very small sample size. While dietary history might be hard to come by in a typical database associated with a tissue bank, there’s no excuse for not including medical histories, given that the Oxford Brain Bank definitely includes clinical information about the patient from which each sample came from.
There’s another thing. The raw aluminum levels measured by atomic absorption spectroscopy are reported as ranging from 0.01 (the limit of quantitation) to 22.11 μg/g dry weight. The authors go further to report that the aluminum content of all tissues ranged from 0.01 (the limit of quantitation) to 22.11μg/g dry wt. and that the aluminum content for whole brains (n=4 or 5 depending upon the availability of hippocampus tissue) ranged from 1.20±1.06) μg/g dry weight.to 4.77±4.79 μg/g dry weight. Exley then cites a previous study of his, which he refers to as “our 60 brain study,” that has “allowed us to define loose categories of brain aluminium content beginning with ≤1.00 μg/g dry wt. as pathologically benign (as opposed to ‘normal’).” I looked up the study, reference 15, and was puzzled. In it Exley reported measuring aluminum levels in the brain of one man, a 69-year-old who had died of Alzheimer’s disease. Either Exley screwed up the reference, or he hoped that no one noticed that he had referred to a reference that doesn’t describe what he claims it described. The first would just be sloppy. The second would be dishonest. Fortunately for Exley, in this case, it looks as though he was just sloppy.
I suspect that Exley meant this study, although I’m not sure. In that study, he found that the median aluminum content in 713 samples was 1 µg/g dry tissue and that 75% of the measurements were less than 2 µg/g dry tissue. Some things to note. First, these were all brains from elderly people. Second, Exley basically says that 75% of all values were less than 2 µg/g dry tissue. Looking at Table 1 of the present paper, I note that the vast majority of aluminum concentrations were below 2 μg/g dry weight, too. I also notice some rather extreme variability in measurements. For instance, the sample replicates for one specimen were 1.71, 1.64, and 17.10 μg/g dry weight. For those not familiar with scientific terminology, “replicate” means repeated measurements performed on the same sample, although in this case the replicates the samples were divided into three, and each portion subjected to the same procedure to measure aluminum. The replicates were then averaged and a standard deviation calculated. There were other replicates as questionable. For example, for another sample the replicates measured 2.44, 1.66, and 22.11 μg/g dry weight. For still another sample, replicates were 0.01, 0.64, and 18.57 μg/g dry weight. Remember, again, these are replicate measurements of the same samples. True, there could be “clustering” of aluminum in different parts of the sample, but even allowing for that possibility, these values do not give me a lot of confidence in the reproducibility of Exley’s methodology. So what does Exley do with such widely variable results? He reports the average of the three values for these specimens, which is—surprise! surprise!—hugely dominated by the spuriously high value in each case, thus falsely inflating the value for each of those specimens. Of course, even in Exley’s “60 brain study,” he shows no evidence that aluminum content greater than 2.0 or 2.0 μg/g dry weight is even pathological! He even notes “how difficult it might be to use statistical measures of brain Al content as reliable indicators of potential neurotoxicity.”
Also, if only we had an idea of the aluminum concentration in normal brain tissue. If only…
Oh, wait, we do. It’s between 1.4 to 2.5 µg/g dry tissue, as measured in a study that compared aluminum concentration in the brains of patients with Alzheimer’s disease. Oops! That’s not very different from the values that Exley found, and if you take into account the huge variability in some of his sample replicates, I have a hard time thinking there’s anything particularly alarming in these values. Heck, even compared to Exley’s “60 brain paper” I have a hard time being alarmed by the numbers in this new study.
I also can’t help but notice another issue. In his “60 brain” paper, Exley noted that the values he measured for aluminum didn’t follow a normal distribution. We see the same thing here, with these widely varying values in his replicates. As a result, it would have been more appropriate to use the median rather than the mean, which is what he did in his “60 brains” paper. (It also doesn’t help that the standard deviations are larger than the actual values for multiple samples.) Yet in this paper, for some reason, he uses mean values. Of course, mean values result in seemingly larger values for aluminum content. Gee, that couldn’t have had anything to do with why Exley chose to use them, could it?
When it comes to fluorescent staining of tissue samples, I must admit that I’m not an expert, although I have done some fluorescence microscopy work in the past, including some confocal microscopy. So I’m not completely without knowledge here. I know some of the pitfalls, and I know that certain controls are very, very important. I also know that counterstains are usually necessary if you’re going to make assertions about which cells whatever it is that you’re looking for is localizing in. In this paper, Exley makes a number of conclusions, such as that aluminum located in inflammatory cells associated with the vasculature, in round and amoeboid glial cell bodies, neurones and glia-like cells, and other areas. I looked at the figures for which these claims were made, and my reaction was: WTF? Maybe. Maybe not. I can’t tell. Here’s the thing, though. There are specific stains for such cells and structures. If you really want to know where the aluminum is localized, you stain with both the stain for aluminum and a different stain with a different colored fluorescent molecule attached, and then you can tell. Yes, I know it’s more complex than that, and that there are a lot more pitfalls of dual fluorescence staining with different probes, but, seriously. Scientists are getting good at this. It should be doable.
Fortunately, when it comes to the fluorescence microscopy, The Blood-Brain Barrier Scientist knows a lot more than I do, and blogged about this study. This analysis is a lot more technical than mine, particularly for the fluorescence microcopy. The discussion gets into such minutiae as how different sections are superimposed, and a lot of it overlaps what I found troubling as well, but it’s certainly worth reading if you’re more technically inclined. Bottom line: The fluorescence microscopy is dodgy, and it is vastly overinterpreted. That doesn’t even take into account the nonexistent to weak statistics in the paper.
Nowhere is this overinterpretation more evident than in Exley’s discussion:
This implies that aluminium somehow had crossed the blood-brain barrier and was taken up by a native cell namely the microglial cell. Interestingly, the presence of occasional aluminum-laden inflammatory cells in the vasculature and the leptomeninges opens the possibility of a separate mode of entry of aluminium into the brain i.e. intracellularly. However, to allow this second scenario to be of significance one would expect some type of intracerebral insult to occur to allow egress of lymphocytes and monocytes from the vasculature. The identification herein of non-neuronal cells including inflammatory cells, glial cells and microglia loaded with aluminium is a standout observation for ASD. For example, the majority of aluminium deposits identified in brain tissue in fAD were extracellular and nearly always associated with grey matter [19]. Aluminium is cytotoxic [21] and its association herein with inflammatory cells in the vasculature, meninges and central nervous system is unlikely to be benign. Microglia heavily loaded with aluminium while potentially remaining viable, at least for some time, will inevitably be compromised and dysfunctional microglia are thought to be involved in the aetiology of ASD [22], for example in disrupting synaptic pruning [23]. In addition the suggestion from the data herein that aluminium entry into the brain via immune cells circulating in the blood and lymph is expedited in ASD might begin to explain the earlier posed question of why there was so much aluminium in the brain of a 15 year old boy with an ASD.
This is speculation on steroids. More important, though, is the subtext. Where, I wonder, does Exley think this evil aluminum is coming from? He specifically mentions immune cells bringing aluminum into the brain as an explanation for “so much aluminum” in the brain of a 15 year old boy. Hmmm. He couldn’t mean…vaccines…could he? Oh, let’s cut the crap. Of course he means vaccines. Exley thinks aluminum adjuvants cause autism, and this study was looking for a way to “prove” that they do. This is, like most studies funded and carried out by antivaxers, horrible science. No wonder J.B. Handley is so impressed by it.
Finally, there’s aspect of this study that angers me greatly. Brain tissue is a precious resource. Tissue from autistic brains is an even more precious resource. This poorly designed, poorly executed, poorly analyzed study squandered some of that precious resource in the service of a study that tells us nothing scientifically useful about autism that could lead to a deeper understanding of the abnormalities of the autistic brain and the pathogenesis of this neurodevelopmental disorder. Such a waste of precious tissue borders on the criminal.

Anti-anti-vax: Getting to the gist
Scott Gavura on March 29, 2012
Link
I’m currently putting the finishing touches on a presentation for the The Ontario Public Health Convention next week, where I’ll be speaking, with occupational therapist Kim Hébert, about the anti-vaccine movement and social media (SM): how antivaccine advocates use it, and the challenges and opportunities for public health advocates. I’m pleased to see Seth Mnookin, author of The Panic Virus and someone whose work is likely known to many SBM readers, is one of the keynote speakers – his perspective will be valuable for the public health crowd which has traditionally relied on fairly static “key messages” for disseminating information on vaccine safety and effectiveness. The panel discussion of which I am a part will be an examination of challenges and opportunities presented to public health advocacy, and particularly vaccine advocacy, in a Web 2.o environment. What seems clear is that the old public health channels don’t cut it anymore: these methods are distant and insufficient to address the wide and rapid spread of misinformation in an era of social media. We all remember the anxiety over H1N1 just a few years ago – and judging by the poor uptake of the vaccine, it seemed the anti-vaccine movement had some success in propagating fear, uncertainty, and doubt. I’d almost forgotten about this chestnut from the Health Ranger himself:
In about two minutes, Mike neatly compiles most of the still-common anti-vaccine gambits in use. It’s not keyboard cat popular, but almost 200,000 views is likely greater than any pro-vaccine video produced. But is it effective? I looked to the medical literature for any current articles on the tactics of the antivaccine movement. In contrast to the wealth of information online, particularly here at SBM, there is a much smaller set of papers in print. A friend of the blog covered one recent paper back in January, Anna Kata’s Anti-vaccine activists, Web 2.0, and the postmodern paradigm – An overview of tactics and tropes used online by the anti-vaccination movement. Kata neatly categorizes the disingenuous tactics and messaging used by the antivaccine movement. Tactics include:
    • Skewering the science of vaccine safety and efficacy, while trying to create legitimacy for unfounded or discredited theories of harm.
    • Shifting the hypotheses and the villain, from MMR, to thimerosal, to other “toxins”, and more recently, “too many, too soon”.
    • Censoring criticism, whether it’s at Age of Autism, Mothering.com, or other antivaccine sites that delete comments or restrict access to their events.
    • Attacking the opposition, whether it’s our own David Gorski or lawsuits against Paul Offit or Amy Wallace.
And then there are the tropes, known to SBM readers as they’ve all been covered in some form before:
    • “I’m not anti-vaccine, I’m pro-safe vaccine”
    • “Vaccines are toxic!”
    • “Vaccines should be 100% safe”
    • “You can’t prove vaccines are safe”
    • “Vaccines didn’t save us”
    • “Vaccines are unnatural”
    • “Choosing between diseases and vaccine injuries”
    • “Galileo was persecuted too”
    • “Science was wrong before”
    • “So many people can’t all be wrong”
    • “Skeptics believe…”
    • “You’re in the pocket of Big Pharma”
    • “I don’t believe in coincidences”
    • “I’m an expert on my own child”
I’m sure there are more than a few missing, as the spin continues despite the overwhelming evidence that vaccines, on balance, are safe and highly effective. Kata points out that the anti-vaccine movement has been around as long as there are vaccines: It exists despite the evidence, so no amount of evidence will ever cause it to disappear. She summarizes with a list of some potential solutions to arresting the propagation of this misinformation, noting the potential opportunities for social media campaigns to “immunize” against misinformation.
And that’s where a second article picks up, a more detailed examination of “Web 2.0” as the newest battlefield for both the antivaccine movement and for public health advocates. From Betsch et al, it’s entitled Opportunities and challenges of Web 2.0 for vaccination decisions and was published earlier this year in the journal Vaccine. The paper is a summary of a conference on vaccination decisions held in 2011. As someone who discusses vaccines directly with patients, but also via the interwebs, I found the paper discussed some of my personal questions about vaccine advocacy:
    • What is the most effective way for me, as a health professional, to identify and address antivaccine sentiment among my patients?
    • What is the most effective way I can use social media to present science-based information in a way that maximizes its usefulness to the largest audience?
The paper focuses on the impact of impact of Web 2.0, a term which may sound trivial to those who already contribute on a blog, as you’re already in a 2.0 environment. Briefly, any technology that facilitates user-to-user interaction can be thought of as Web 2.0. Social media (e.g., Facebook, Twitter, etc.) is any 2.0 technology that facilitates sharing, adapting, and crowd-sourcing material. Compared to the static websites of several years ago, most of the internet is now squarely 2.0. The key feature relevant to vaccines and web 2.0 is the ability to add a personal narrative to data. That is, users can adapt, promote, support and personally contextualize internet content easily now – sharing this article to your own Facebook feed, perhaps prefaced with your own comment on its merits, is one click away.
The emerging consequence of social media as it relates to vaccination decisions is the ability to attach a personal narrative to vaccine information.
Vaccination decisions
Betsch summarizes the considerations that go into vaccination decisions, which include recommendations from health professionals, social norms, previous experiences with, and beliefs about, vaccines, trusted individual and organizations, and related background knowledge. The key drivers of the decision are believed to be those that have an effect on risk perception – that is, the perceived risks and benefits of vaccinating, and also of not vaccinating. Both the frequency or likelihood of an event, and the severity of that event, may be considered.
And here’s where it gets interesting with Web 2.0. As I’ve noted before, it takes only a few minutes of reading anti-vaccine information to shift perceptions of relative risk and benefit, and to lower vaccination intentions. And social media makes it that much easier – by effectively using the power of a simple narrative. And narrative is among the most potent tactics of the antivaccinationist.
The narrative
I take great pains as a health professional to give the proper context for my recommendations. If questioned about MMR vaccines and autism, I might provide a response like, “Numerous studies have demonstrated that there’s no relationship between the MMR vaccine and neurodevelopmental disorders”. While that may be accurate, it may not be most effective way to address the underlying uncertainty. The individual benefit of vaccination may be hard to see (though it’s easier when there are outbreaks to point to.) The harms, whether real (injection pain) or just attributed to vaccines, may be more tangible. The antivaccine response, while wrong, is far simpler: “MMR has been linked to autism. The vaccine is dangerous.” The ability to link a personal, emotional narrative to an antivaccine trope is facilitated by Web 2.0 technologies – it can personalize impersonal information. Emotional appeals can push the actual evidence into the background. The producers of the Greater Good movie used this approach to deliver their antivaccine message: Three narratives of harm attributed to vaccines, around which all of the antivaccine tropes described above were packaged and delivered.
Betsch points out how the narrative, or anecdote, is a powerful communication device. It’s easily understood, concrete, seemingly credible, and emotional. Whether or not they’re causally linked to the vaccine isn’t relevant – narratives increase the perception of harm and of the resultant risk of vaccination. While there have been some attempts to compile narratives of consequences of vaccine avoidance (What’s the Harm? comes to mind), on balance, negative personal narratives on vaccines seem far more prevalent.
The gist
So the challenge for public health advocates in a Web 2.0 environment is twofold: We must be accurate and effective. Accuracy may mean more complexity and nuance to our messaging. Plus we need to be able to rapidly respond to emerging concerns, ideally in a way that facilitates dissemination and sharing via social media to the same recipients of antivaccine messages. And here’s where we come to the third paper, one which explores theories of risk perception and decision-making: fuzzy-trace theory. It’s examined in detail in a 2011 publication by Valerie Reyna, Risk perception and communication in vaccination decisions: A fuzzy-trace theory approach. According to this theory, we integrate information in two distinct ways:
     1.  Verbatim memories: the precise details of the facts
     2.  Gist memories: the essential meaning of the facts
Based on this theory, gist memories are derived not from verbatim facts, but are developed in parallel with verbatim memories. Because they’re subjective, they incorporate existing biases and understandings. Reyna argues that gist memories are relevant to reasoning and decision-making – and that gist is in fact preferred when exact answers are not required. Importantly, meaning is at the core of gist memories. She argues that traditional public health messaging, designed to warn and persuade, doesn’t provide the necessary meaning to support the development of a pro-vaccine gist. From this perspective, anti-vaccine messages can create strong gist memories: they provide meaning to adverse events related to vaccinations – even where no true relationship exists. The narrative is coherent, even if it’s not rational. Positive vaccine communication needs to do the same, appealing to values, such as how vaccinating protects those that cannot be vaccinated. Emotional resonance counts, too – messages can be resonant while remaining accurate and distilling risk perceptions in ways that support positive gist interpretations.
Conclusion
Social media has changed the way we share information on the internet, presenting challenges and opportunities to public health advocates. The ability to attach a personal narrative to vaccine communication has the potential to shift risk perception about vaccines. While research on best practices continues to evolve, it seems safe to conclude the following: Make the gist of your pro-vaccine message easy to extract, and make it memorable.
References
Betsch, C., Brewer, N., Brocard, P., Davies, P., Gaissmaier, W., Haase, N., Leask, J., Renkewitz, F., Renner, B., Reyna, V., Rossmann, C., Sachse, K., Schachinger, A., Siegrist, M., & Stryk, M. (2012). Opportunities and challenges of Web 2.0 for vaccination decisions Vaccine DOI: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2012.02.025
Kata, A. (2011). Anti-vaccine activists, Web 2.0, and the postmodern paradigm – An overview of tactics and tropes used online by the anti-vaccination movement Vaccine DOI: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2011.11.112
Reyna, V. (2011). Risk perception and communication in vaccination decisions: A fuzzy-trace theory approach Vaccine DOI: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2011.11.070
